Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Q1 2020
THE BUSINESS OF
TEXAS
SPORTS
TILMAN
TELLS IT
LIKE IT IS
No-Nonsense Business Lessons
from the “Billion Dollar Buyer”
COWORKING
WITH THE
COWBOYS
A Chat with Jerry Jones Jr.
CATCHING
UP WITH
MARK CUBAN
7 Questions for the Legend
THE
RELAUNCH
ISSUE
Warren is cleaning up Texas–
and KEEPING IT SAFE.
Warren Paynes | Lead Residential Driver | Texas Disposal Systems, Inc.
Warren Paynes doesn’t just make Texas a cleaner place — he makes it a safer place. As a driver for Texas Disposal Systems, he knows that driving safe
protects him, his route partner and everyone around them. He stays focused, performs inspections on his vehicle and puts his cell phone away.
Warren takes his driver safety training seriously, and that’s why Texas Mutual is proud to support him and all the Texans who make the road their
workplace. Texas Mutual is changing the way workers’ comp works for you. See Warren ON THE JOB at WorkSafeTexas.com/OnTheJob.
© 2019 Texas Mutual Insurance Company
Letter from the
OWNER
Great CEOs create great jobs. And meaningful work is something
almost everyone craves. That’s why I have always felt that building a
business is a noble cause. By creating and running great businesses, we
satisfy our need to help others even as we provide for our own needs.
This dynamic is, in large part, why we are excited to relaunch Texas
CEO Magazine with the mission of helping CEOs across Texas grow
their businesses and master their role as head of the organization.
Whether that organization is public or private, for-profit or nonprofit,
large or small, we all face similar challenges. We hope that Texas
CEO Magazine can become your best and most trusted source for
information on the CEO role and the state of business in Texas—and
become a part of your personal CEO journey too. We intend to do
this not only through ideas and insights in the magazine but through
events, podcasts, and newsletters that allow you to access our content
in whatever way is most convenient for you.
Texas is one of the great states for sports, and that’s one reason we
chose sports as the theme of our relaunch issue. Here, football is king:
We’re the state of Friday Night Lights, epic college football rivalries,
and the Dallas Cowboys (the world’s most valuable sports team, worth
an estimated $5 billion). But that’s only part of the Texas sports story.
Whether it’s our forthcoming third Major League Soccer team or our
growing esports scene, Texans love sport of all kinds—and spend a lot
of money on it. There’s also an even deeper connection between sport
and business. Great coaches and great athletes hold lessons for every
CEO, about leadership, strategy, endurance, and so much more. We will
explore a few of those lessons throughout this issue.
WE WOULD LIKE
TO INCLUDE YOU IN
THE CONVERSATION. DON’T
HESITATE TO REACH OUT
IF YOU HAVE STORY IDEAS,
CEOS YOU THINK WE SHOULD
PROFILE, OR CEO ISSUES YOU
WANT US TO COVER.
As Texas CEO Magazine moves forward, we would like to include you
in the conversation. Don’t hesitate to reach out if you have story ideas,
CEOs you think we should profile, or CEO issues you want us to cover.
Get in touch anytime at info@texasceomagazine.com.
Leading an organization is a challenging endeavor, and we look forward
to being alongside you in your journey to becoming the most effective
CEO possible.
TexasCEOMagazine.com
3
INSIDE Features
Q1 2020
Publisher
Lauren Daugherty
Editor
Aaron Hierholzer
Operations
Tamara Trammell
Graphic Design
Michele Rodriguez
86
LISTEN TO TILMAN!
A Conversation with Tilman Fertitta, Landry’s CEO,
Houston Rockets Owner, and the “Billion Dollar Buyer”
8
LEADERSHIP LESSONS
FROM A TEXAS RANGER
A Conversation with Hank Whitman,
Former Chief of the Texas Rangers
18
THE EYES OF TEXAS
ARE UPON US
A Conversation with Chris Del Conte,
Athletics Director at the University of Texas
22
WHAT CEOS
CAN LEARN FROM
EXCEPTIONAL
COACHES
John Thornton, PhD
24
STARTUP SUCCESS:
HOW MUCH SHOULD WE RAISE?
Gordon Daugherty
28
7 QUICK QUESTIONS
WITH MARK CUBAN
A Lightning Round with the Legend
30
WANT TO WORK
FROM COWBOYS HQ?
HERE’S YOUR CHANCE.
A Conversation with Jerry Jones Jr.
35
CEO ACTIVISM
AND THE CLOAK
OF SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY
Bill Simon and Blaine McCormick, PhD
Contributors
Wade H. Allen
Akira Asada, PhD
Craig Casselberry
Ed Curtis
Gordon Daugherty
Tasha Eurich, PhD
J. Michael Godfrey, PhD
Lisa Jaster
Blaine McCormick, PhD
Gary Oden, PhD
Timothy J. Quigley, PhD
Bill Simon
Tony Streeter
John Thornton, PhD
Kirk Wakefield, PhD
To subscribe to the print or digital edition of
Texas CEO Magazine, please visit our website:
www.texasceomagazine.com
and click subscribe.
POSTMASTER
Please send address changes to:
The American CEO, LLC
dba Texas CEO Magazine
8012 Bee Caves Road
Austin, TX 78746
© 2019 The American CEO, LLC dba Texas
CEO Magazine. All rights reserved. The
Content in this issue may not be reproduced,
distributed, or otherwise used without the prior
written consent of the American CEO, LLC.
The various contributors own their respective
Content that is published in this magazine.
The beliefs, content, comments, opinions,
statements and viewpoints (collectively, the
“Content”) published in this issue are those
of the respective contributors and we do not
necessarily agree, endorse, support or verify
such Content. The Content presented in this
issue is for informational purposes only and is
not advice of any kind.
Your use of the Content is at your own risk. The
Content is provided on an “AS IS” basis, without
any warranties of any kind, either express
or implied. Neither The American CEO, LLC
nor any person associated with us makes any
warranty or representation with respect to the
completeness, reliability, quality, or accuracy
of the Content. Without limiting the foregoing,
The American CEO, LLC does not represent
or warrant that the Content will be accurate,
reliable, error-free, that errors will be corrected,
or that the Content will otherwise meet your
needs or expectations. The American CEO, LLC
disclaims all warranties of any kind, whether
express or implied, statutory or otherwise,
including but not limited to any warranties of
merchantability, non-infringement and fitness
for particular purpose. The foregoing does not
affect any warranties which cannot be excluded
or limited under applicable law.
4 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
INSIDE Departments
6 [MANAGEMENT]
OUTSIDER CEOS
GENERATE MORE
EXTREME RESULTS
Timothy J. Quigley, PhD
14
THE BODYGUARD
A Conversation with Mike Ramirez,
Personal Protection Expert
29 [ENTREPRENEURSHIP]
THESE
ENTREPRENEURS
ARE MAKING
SAN ANTONIO SAFER
Showcasing Safety Innovation
in Alamo City
41 [PERFORMANCE]
DESIGNING AN
EFFECTIVE SALES
PROMOTION:
LESSONS FROM TEAM
SPORTS MARKETING
Kirk Wakefield, PhD
43 [SELF-AWARENESS]
THE NEGLECTED
KEY TO STRESS
MANAGEMENT
J. Michael Godfrey, PhD
47 [SELF-AWARENESS]
SELF-AWARENESS
AND THE CEO
Tasha Eurich, PhD
51
WHAT’S MY CMO
TALKING ABOUT?
Tony Streeter
53
THE SPORT OF
RELOCATION
Ed Curtis
56
LEGISLATIVE
FOOTBALL,
TEXAS-STYLE
Craig Casselberry
60
BUILDING A
BRIGHTER FUTURE
FOR CENTRAL TEXAS KIDS
A Conversation with Richard Tagle,
CEO of the Andy Roddick Foundation
65
WHAT HAS ANDY
RODDICK LEARNED
SINCE STARTING
HIS FOUNDATION?
68
BUILDING
THE ESPORTS
SKYSCRAPER
A Conversation with Jason Lake,
Founder and CEO of Complexity Gaming
72 [RESOURCES]
CRAFTING
THE BLUEPRINT
FOR A SUCCESSFUL
EXECUTIVE SEARCH
Wade H. Allen
74
TICKET TO
THE LIMIT
A Conversation with Randy Cohen,
Founder and CEO of TicketCity
77
CATCHING THE
PERFECT PASS
A Conversation with S. C. Gwynne,
Best-Selling Author of The Perfect Pass
80 [CULTURE]
IS YOUR
EMPLOYEE WELLNESS
PROGRAM WORKING?
Gary Oden, PhD
84 [PERFORMANCE]
UNITY VS. UNIQUENESS
IN SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING—
WHICH IS MORE EFFECTIVE?
Akira Asada, PhD
90 [LEADERSHIP]
MISSION, PRIDE,
PEOPLE:
3 KEYS TO MILITARY AND
CORPORATE SUCCESS
Lisa Jaster
94
BRINGING
A RENEGADE
SPIRIT TO XFL 2.0
A Conversation with Grady Raskin,
President of the Dallas Renegades
96
THE BUSINESS OF
COLLEGE ATHLETICS
A Conversation with Judy MacLeod,
Commissioner of Conference USA
TexasCEOMagazine.com
5
[MANAGEMENT]
CEO SUCCESSION RESEARCH
OUTSIDER CEOS
GENERATE MORE
EXTREME RESULTS
Timothy J. Quigley, PhD
When a firm replaces a CEO, everyone involved typically
goes through a period of high stress. The board faces a highly
consequential decision, the organization faces uncertainty,
and the newly appointed CEO faces a fresh challenge—all
under the watchful eye of shareholders and the market.
One of the most frequently studied factors in CEO succession
is whether the new CEO is promoted from within or appointed
from without. After dozens of attempts, researchers have come
up with little conclusive evidence that either of these profiles, the
insider or the outsider, typically outperforms the other. Absent
in much of the literature is the acknowledgment that each type of
candidate has its pros and cons. While insiders are familiar with
the firm’s current state and resources, they are also more likely
to preserve the status quo. Outsiders, on the other hand, bring
fresh blood to the top of the organization and are usually more
willing to rock the boat, but they also may have blind spots and
incorrect assumptions about the firm, which can lead to errors. 1
Nevertheless, CEO succession remains a worthy subject of
study, not least because of the “CEO effect”—the measurable
effect a particular CEO has on performance. 2 We know that,
generally, the CEO accounts for around 25 percent of variance
in a firm’s performance. That may not be as large a number as
you expect, but it is clearly significant enough to warrant the
board’s careful consideration of CEO candidates. We also know
that, while most CEO appointments are inconsequential (with
no major effect on firm performance upward or downward), a
minority are quite consequential—either negatively or positively.
Rather than revisit the issue of whether insider or outsider
candidates are “better,” I, along with my coauthors Donald
Hambrick, Vilmos Misangyi, and Alessandra Rizzi, recently
set out to give the issue of insider-outsider CEO succession a
new frame: that of risk-taking (see “CEO Selection as Risk-
Taking,” Strategic Management Journal). Instead of asking
the usual question of which type of CEO delivers better
results, we hypothesized that outsider CEOs were more
likely to deliver more extreme results, whether positive or
negative, as compared to the more neutral results delivered
by an insider CEO. That meant that boards, making the call
between an insider or outsider candidate, actually faced a
risk-taking problem. Would they prefer to bet on an outsider
in the hopes of outsize performance, with the concomitant risk
of large losses, or play it safer with an internal candidate?
Testing Our Prediction
To test our expectation that outsider CEOs delivered more
variable performance, we examined 1,027 CEO successions of
small, midsize, and large public companies in the United States.
Of these successors, 43 percent were outsiders. We wanted to
see how much the firm’s performance (measured, like most
succession studies, by return on assets) changed relative to its
previous performance and to industry-wide performance.
Multiple analyses revealed that our prediction was correct. The
insider CEOs were generally safer bets, while outsider CEOs
were risker, producing either higher or lower results than
inside hires overall. The figure below shows the post-succession
performance-change scores for the full sample of incoming
6 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
CEOs; as you can see, the outsiders’ scores are distributed
more widely across the spectrum, signifying a broader range of
outcomes, while the insiders tend to cluster toward the middle.
Distributions of performance-change scores for insider and outsider successors
To prevent the possibility of other factors, such as recent
performance, skewing this comparison, we performed several
other analyses. One involved finding “matched pairs” of
similar firms in the same industry who hired outsider or
insider CEOs in the same time period. For these “lookalike”
comparison firms, we found the same results: there was more
variance (up or down) when the successor was hired from
outside. We also used another form of matching that compared
firms with similar pre-succession probabilities of hiring an
outsider CEO against each other. Again we found the same
trend: When these firms chose an insider CEO, there was a
greater chance of neutral performance changes. If they chose
an outsider CEO, on the other hand, variance in performance
was more likely to be more extreme in either direction.
Why Are Outsider CEOs a Riskier Choice?
There are several reasons why outsider CEOs tend to generate
more extreme results—and thus represent the riskier choice for
a board of directors. First, outside appointments are somewhat
more common when the company is in distress and needs a
fresh perspective, while inside promotions are more common
when company performance is stable and healthy. Clearly, if the
company is already unstable, extreme outcomes are more likely.
(Our analysis took this into account and found that outsiders
are still riskier, showing that this is not the sole factor.) A
second and related cause is the fact that outside CEOs may be
less constrained by their history with the firm and more likely
to take bigger and bolder action than someone promoted from
within, thereby causing more extreme outcomes, up or down. 3
Third, there is always “information asymmetry” when a
board seeks to hire an outside successor to the CEO. In other
words, while the board is likely to be familiar with an internal
candidate currently serving as COO or president within the
firm, they will likely know very little about a candidate who is
new to the company. Outsider CEO candidates also know much
more about themselves than the board knows about them—
and the candidate has an incentive to misrepresent or inflate
their capabilities during the hiring process. Because of this
information differential, the board may make errors in judgment
regarding the successor. When a board chooses an outsider,
they often use the logic that they want a world-class executive to
lead the company—and what are the chances that that executive
is currently employed there? But in the process, they may
overestimate the outside candidate’s capabilities, cultural fit,
and other factors, leading to lower-than-expected performance.
Or they may miss a significantly beneficial characteristic
of the CEO, leading to unexpectedly high performance.
When we combine these factors—considering that outsiders
are more likely to take the helm in times of crisis, more likely
to make sweeping, decisive moves, and may not be as capable
(or may be more capable) than the board expected—it’s not
surprising that a CEO plucked from outside the company is
more likely to cause larger swings in firm performance.
The Takeaway
Understanding that outsider CEOs are more likely to
deliver extreme results does not necessarily make the
board’s job of overseeing succession any easier. On the
other hand, it can help if boards consider the succession
decision and source of the new CEO in the frame of risktaking,
much like any other important strategic decision.
Understanding this dynamic, the board can consider follow-on
questions such as: “What is our tolerance for surprises right
now, whether welcome or unwelcome?” “Is the company in
a state that we need to take the relative risk of an outsider?”
and “What attributes, capabilities, and experiences may
we be overlooking in this outsider candidate?” And with
internal candidates: “Are there impediments the board can
remove to ensure they are able to see and take appropriate
risks?” Because the CEO role is so unique, it will remain
difficult to predict how any one candidate will fare. But,
viewing the insider-outsider choice through the frame of
risk-taking is one way to empower the board of directors to
make more informed and confident succession decisions.
Timothy J. Quigley is an associate professor at the University of
Georgia’s Terry College of Business. His research is focused on CEOs, top
executives, and managerial discretion. More specifically, Dr. Quigley’s
interests lie in understanding how and when CEOs and other top
executives impact organizational outcomes, the causes and outcomes of
CEO succession, and how these have changed over the course of time.
Dr. Quigley received his PhD in Strategic Management from Penn State
University and is on the editorial board of Strategic Management Journal.
1
A. W. Gouldner, Patterns of Industrial Bureaucracy (Glencoe, IL: Free Press, 1954); R. H.
Guest, “Managerial Succession in Complex Organizations,” American Journal of Sociology,
68(1), 47–54 (1962); W. Shen & A. A. Cannella, “Revisiting the Performance Consequences of
CEO Succession,” Academy of Management Journal, 45(4), 717–733 (2002).
2
Timothy J. Quigley, Donald C. Hambrick, Vilmos F. Misangyi, and G. Alessandra Rizzi, “CEO
Selection as Risk-Taking,” Strategic Management Journal, 40, 1453–1470 (2019).
3
D. L. Helmich and W. B. Brown, “Successor Type and Organizational Change in Corporate
Enterprise,” Administrative Science Quarterly, 17(3), 371–381 (1972); A. Karaevli and E.
J. Zajac, “When Do Outsider CEOs Generate Strategic Change?,” Journal of Management
Studies, 50(7), 1267–1294 (2013).
TexasCEOMagazine.com
7
Leadership Lessons
Tintype of Chief Hank Whitman
by Brigham and Jenna Mayfield
FROM A
TEXAS RANGER
Former Texas Rangers
chief Hank Whitman
on his transition from law
enforcement to head of the Texas
Department of Family and
Protective Services
In his long career, Hank Whitman
not only spent eleven years with the
Texas Rangers, rising to become
chief of the agency. He also, most
recently, held what he describes as
an even tougher job: overseeing
the Texas Department of Family
and Protective Services. When
Whitman retired from DFPS
last June, Governor Greg
Abbott recognized his service,
saying he’d “helped create a
safer future for Texas.”
We spoke with Whitman
about his time as a Ranger,
the leadership challenges he
encountered at DFPS, and
the fulfillment of his role in,
as he describes it, protecting
the unprotected.
Feature
Did you know when you were small that you wanted to be a
Texas Ranger? No, I didn’t. I’ll tell you that I didn’t have a real
long career with the Texas Rangers. I only did 11 years. I don’t
think anybody’s ever made it to chief that quick, but things
happen quickly within our division. I was a police officer in Corpus
Christi for ten years before I came to DPS, where I was later
promoted into the Criminal Intelligence Division. I completed my
graduate degree and was promoted into the Rangers in 2001.
Before the governor asked me to be the commissioner of
the Texas Department of Family and Protective Services, I
thought being the chief of the Texas Rangers would be the
pinnacle of my career. But this whole new family [DFPS] that
I took on for the last three years really captured my heart.
It’s two different worlds. The Rangers are completely apolitical.
They do a lot of public corruption work and investigate mostly
high felony crimes. Public corruption cases are a huge part
of their daily work and are often referred to the Rangers by a
district attorney or a law enforcement agency head. Those cases
are sensitive and sometimes controversial and, understandably,
should not be investigated by the local law enforcement agency.
On any given month, we’re also working 40 to 60 homicides
around the state. But this latest job [with DFPS], I went from
overseeing a $22 million Ranger budget and a $20 million
border budget to an almost $3 billion budget. A large increase
in personnel too. DFPS has 12,250 employees while the Rangers
now have 150. There really aren’t that many Rangers. When
I came on to the Rangers, there were a little over 100.
Wow. That’s not many for a big state like Texas. That is true!
But I had to learn how to deal with politics in the new job
at DFPS. Something that I didn’t have to do in my previous
position. Lawmakers would either be hugging each other
from both sides of the aisle or arguing. It was tough and that
is a big understatement. I met with lawmakers on a regular
basis. A lot of them were fantastic to work with. Many I
consider personal friends. Obviously, I didn’t see eye to eye
with all of them, and likewise they didn’t with me at times.
But I don’t think I left that capitol with any enemies. We all
respected each other. They too have a very tough job.
It was difficult to see our caseworkers get pounded on a daily
basis, when they’re doing the best job they can with very
limited resources and funding. If a legislator would start
yelling at me in a hearing, I would think, “Well, I’m going to
yell back too. I may be an appointed commissioner but I’m a
citizen of this state too.” Fortunately, I had nothing to lose—I
didn’t apply for the job. So, I thought, “Well, I’m going to
yell back. Fire me! I don’t care. I’ll go home right now.”
I was mindful of not crossing the line too far and knew
I had to maintain a professional demeanor for my
employees. It wasn’t about me. It was about them and to
this day, I say they have the hardest, most thankless job in
government service. I’m proud to have been their leader for
those three years. They have saved so many children and
elderly people from abuse, neglect, and exploitation.
What were some of the first challenges you faced when you
took on the commissioner job at DFPS? One of the things I
asked the governor was, “Will you allow me to build my own
executive team?” He said, “Absolutely.” There was no influence
from above. There was no “Hey, you need to do this or that
or consider this person or that person.” We were allowed to
develop sound policy that was proven, develop an effective,
dedicated executive team, and challenge the status quo.
The generals underneath the executives were a different challenge.
About half of them were engaged, and the other half were like,
“We’ve seen cowboys ride in here, but eventually they ride off
into the sunset. We’ll watch this guy ride off into the sunset
like the rest.” That attitude did not sit good with me at all.
When I called all the field leaders in for a face-to-face meeting,
I could tell which ones despised me even being there. And I
understand that. Here’s a guy coming into their world who
doesn’t even have an inkling of knowledge about child welfare
or adult protection services. I respected that wholeheartedly.
I’m not a caseworker. I’m not a social worker. I was a cop
and I didn’t want them to think I was arrogant and not
respectful of what they do. But I do know public administration
and I have a solid understanding of human behavior.
One of the things I noticed was that there was a lot of complacency
in upper and middle management—middle management being
the hub of a successful agency. They weren’t the ones getting
yelled at by the lawmakers, so they saw no need for change.
How did you handle that situation? I said, “Accountability
is big to me, and no more are we going to blame the
caseworkers when you, as their supervisors, oversee the cases
yourself.” We’re supposed to be leaders and mentors, not
just people filling leadership roles. Two different things.
Boy, did that change the agency immediately. I picked up six
new enthusiastic regional directors, and the other six would
not return. Those six great new leaders were like, “Put me in,
coach. I’ve been sitting on the bench waiting for this.” Some
people still saw me as an outsider, but I wasn’t the enemy. “We’re
going to be bold,” I told them. No more status quo. “We’re going
to change, and we are going to change big.” Surprisingly, the
changes we made proved to turn the ship in a big way. DFPS is
like a huge aircraft carrier—you can’t turn it on a dime. But it
turned, and it turned in the right direction. It still needs lots of
improvements, as any agency does, but it turned for the better
because of its dedicated employees and a new direction.
TexasCEOMagazine.com
9
Tintype of Chief Hank Whitman and Mike Ramirez
by Brigham and Jenna Mayfield.
Read Ramirez’s story starting on page 14.
I would make each of my executive
team members take over in each weekly
executive meeting. I wanted to watch how
they made decisions. In this manner, I
was able to build a succession plan and
they got to know how I operate. One
thing they noticed was that I didn’t talk
a lot. I listened. A lot of CEOs need to
do more of that, especially when they
have good experts. Sometimes they
would even forget I was sitting there.
Did it help that your leaders at DFPS
were presumably drawn to the work of
helping these kids and families? Yes. We
were all affected by that. On any given
day, the state of Texas has 30,000 kids
in our conservatorship. Thirty thousand.
It was horrifying for me to even see
10 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
those numbers. It was also tough and
heartbreaking to see kids who age out of
foster care without being adopted. Our
biggest push was to get them into college
or vocational school. Every foster child
in the state of Texas can go to any state
college or vocational school tuition free. No
school loans to worry about. Unfortunately,
fewer than 7 percent take advantage of it.
Wow. We’ve raised that number now. They
often don’t take advantage of it because
they’re mad and don’t trust the system. We
as a community, not just DFPS, weren’t
doing a good job of mentoring those kids.
Because that’s all they need—someone
to be there for them. These kids have
never lived a normal life, and we want
them to have that life of normalcy.
It made my job as chief of the Rangers
seem like a cakewalk. The normal
life expectancy in the position of
commissioner is 18 months, so I
surpassed that, with three years and
two grueling legislative sessions.
There was one commissioner who
completed four years, but it’s not a
position people hold for a long time.
What did you tell your successor on
your way out? What did you learn? As I
told the governor’s staff when I decided
to retire, “I want the next person to
do ten times better than what we did.”
And they’re going to want the next
person to do that. I’m confident that
will happen. When I retired, I got a lot
of good feedback on the changes we
Feature
implemented. People told me, “It worked.
We didn’t like it. But we understand now
that it worked.”
What were some of those changes you
made? One thing my crew learned quickly
was that I hold people accountable. I take
notes. I don’t forget. When I first came
in, there was a lot of what I call “slow
rolling.” Every project was estimated
to take six months or a year. “Really?”
I’d say, “I think that’ll take three weeks.
I’ll give y’all one month.” Well, hell,
they’d have it done in two weeks.
I also noticed in executive meetings that
we had these employees lined up all
around the walls. They were “subjectmatter
experts.” They attended the
executive meetings in case one of the
executives needed them. As far as I
recall, they never talked at all. After
the first couple of meetings, I asked if
they really needed to be there. I found
out they were doing it that way because
they’d always done it that way. And
they all dreaded it. So, I told them to
go back to work and we’d call them if
needed. It saved everyone time, and for
us productivity was critical. Of course,
we did call them in when we needed to
hear from them. Those subject-matter
experts are your successors. You’re
mentoring them to move them up.
There’s a saying I learned when I went
through Police Staff and Command
School many years ago: “Either move
them up or manage them out.” At first,
I found that to be very distasteful, but
the goals and objectives of a department
like DFPS must be met or children and
elderly suffer or possibly die. If they’re
good, you promote them and continue
to mentor them. And if they’re not
making it after all attempts are made to
make them good, productive employees,
then you have to manage them out.
How did you know who to manage up
and who to manage out? One thing was,
I did a lot of ride-alongs. I’d say, “Okay
team, I’m heading to the field to do
some ride-alongs with the caseworkers.”
“Well, Commissioner, where are you
going?” people would ask. I wouldn’t tell
them. Because if I did, they might want
to call the field: “Hey, Commissioner’s
out. Make sure you clean up the place.”
The first time I did it, I did tell them I
was going to San Antonio. Well, hell, it
was like a reception when I got there.
Everything but the flowers. But those
ride-alongs were important. They let
the field know that I wasn’t the Wizard
of Oz in a big tall white building
behind a curtain. They knew even the
top guy was willing to come out and
work with them from time to time.
I encouraged my executives to do ridealongs
too. I made it part of their annual
evaluation. I told them they were required
to ride along twice a year. Each one of
them got a profound appreciation for
what a caseworker does on a daily basis. I
recalled that my CFO had never been on a
ride-along. After completing his first one
he told me, “Now I know why they keep
asking for the funding they need. I get it.”
We did a lot of things right, and
sometimes we didn’t. When we fell
through, we’d work with the Office of
Consumer Affairs to look at what went
wrong and how not to make the same
mistake again. When we saw that a case
wasn’t handled correctly, I’d look at that
person’s annual evaluation. Sometimes
it would say they were great, and then
I’d know the evaluation wasn’t being
used correctly. So I’d have that talk
with the supervisor and let them know
how critical the annual evaluation is to
their success as an effective leader.
Eventually they understood that
everybody’s accountable, including me.
I take full responsibility for everything
they do. But everybody’s going to be
accountable for themselves too. That
was a whole different concept to them.
If I’m going to fight for you, I told them,
then I have to know you will take care
of our children and vulnerable adults.
And I didn’t run the Ranger division
any different when I was chief there.
What were some differences between
leading the Rangers and leading the
DFPS? With the Rangers, I had seven
commanders, and they were proven
leaders of their own command. But
the biggest difference is the nature
of the work. At the Rangers, we lived
in a very intense investigative world.
Most of the cases we dealt with were
homicides. But we didn’t have to worry
about keeping kids safe, healthy, and
away from harm. That’s a tougher job!
So there’s a lot more urgency at DFPS.
On any given day—seven days a week,
365 days a year—our 7,000 caseworkers
are having to lay eyes on children within
24 hours. It’s not like the Rangers, where
we can start working once we get there—
unless there’s a shootout, of course.
It’s two different levels of stress. The
Rangers live in a stressful world too, of
course. Rangers work independently.
They do not have an assigned partner.
You can only imagine the Ranger who
walked into the scene at the church in
Sutherland Springs [site of the 2017 mass
shooting in Wilson County that killed
26 and wounded 20 more]. One of the
first ones who walked in there goes, “I’m
going to need a lot of help.” Even those
guys had difficulties seeing that gruesome
scene because of the children and the
elderly who were shot and killed in there.
Just because you’re wearing a Ranger
badge, it doesn’t mean that all of a
sudden you have no emotions. You do,
and they too go through PTSD like other
first responders. Every police officer
does, and so do my caseworkers.
I bet. They suffer from an extreme
amount of PTSD. A lot of them mask
it, but that’s one of the things we
implemented: a peer group to keep an eye
on those who lose a child on their case.
That’s almost a career killer for them,
not in that they’re going to be dismissed
necessarily. More often they just say,
“I quit. This baby just died under my
care and case supervision.” Well, true
in a sense, but they were usually doing
TexasCEOMagazine.com
11
everything they could. Society forgets
that caseworkers are human and they,
like police officers, cannot predict what
a person will do with a child despite
having followed all the directions of
the court and despite the services
they provide the parent or parents.
When critical incidents of that magnitude
happen, I would personally call them:
“Are you okay? You doing all right?”
It helps. But I also knew when it was
time to get them mental health services.
These houses they’re going into, they’re
not mansions. You’re looking at some
very difficult situations. They’re going
into homes I wouldn’t go into as a cop
unless I had backup with me. And
they’re doing it with no weapon. They
often have no sense of fear. They just
do it. They get called all kinds of names.
At times assaulted, threatened, and
stalked. It’s awful. It’s the hardest job in
government service without a doubt.
Some of these caseworkers, they’ll be
sitting in a client’s home, have a roach
fall on their shirt or watch a rat run by,
and they’ll just go back to talking to mom
or dad. It’s like, “They don’t scare me.”
I’m sure some people would start and
then immediately say, “This isn’t for me.”
My predecessor, Judge [John] Specia,
was instrumental in redeveloping the
academy’s training process for new
incoming caseworkers. He started
putting trainees in the field right off
the bat. Instead of doing three months
in the classroom before they went out
to the field, they now go two weeks in
the classroom, one week in the field,
three weeks in the classroom, and so
on. I wish the colleges that teach social
work would start doing that. Let them
intern with us, so that they can get that
fear factor out of the way. Now, if we’re
going to lose them, we’re going to lose
them real quick, and then we don’t spend
tens of thousands of dollars training
them just to have them walk out.
I also overhauled how we promote
supervisors and that helped with turnover
too. Before, it was the fellow supervisors
and program directors who selected
upcoming supervisors. I brought everyone
in and had them explain the process to
me. And I said to them: “Truly, it’s the
‘good ole boys’ system, right?” They
all looked at me like, “Well, yeah.”
I knew we needed to stop that
immediately. Supervisors were picking
their favorite person, and it wasn’t always
a person who had leadership qualities.
The other unit members saw that—and it
was destructive to the entire unit. I called
all my training people in and said, “I
want your team to develop a 120-question
test for every role of supervision in
this department, with 1,000 questions
in a computer bank. I want it to cover
everything from leadership to the job
itself to the family code.” For those who
desired to become a supervisor, they were
required to take the exam and make at
least an 80 percent score. To my surprise,
we had a one-in-three failure rate.
Wow! That would have been a third of
personnel who were not prepared to lead.
Second, I told them that we were going
to put together a promotion board.
The candidates would be required to
answer a series of critical questions
pertaining to their field of supervision.
The board would not consist of anyone
they would directly work for.
Their faces were turning white listening
to this. I said, “There’s going to be
a proctor in the room, too. They’re
going to take the score sheets from the
interviewers and put them in a sealed
envelope.” I didn’t want people looking
at each other during the process or
knowing how the other evaluators were
scoring. I wanted it to be a fair process.
When we implemented that, my
supervisor turnover went from 28 percent
to 7 percent. That 7 percent was due to
normal retirement turnover. Caseworkers
in the field were happy because they knew
their supervisors were now competent
and went through a fair process—it wasn’t
just the ‘good ole boys’ system anymore.
Of course, that didn’t go over real well
with the existing supervisors—“Oh, God,
I have to take this test,” they said. But
I once sat in a room with 700 of them
at a conference, and I said, “Can I see a
show of hands of how many of you got
promoted under the new system?” Threequarters
of them raised their hand.
Not one out of them in that category
have I ever had to demote or dismiss.
Where did you learn to hire and train
like that? DPS. That’s the way we did
it in DPS. It’s a fair system. If your
middle management isn’t working,
that’s like the engine of a huge truck
freezing up. That’s what was happening.
The previous promotion process
was gumming things up, and our
engine was running very sluggish.
I take being promoted very seriously.
On the last Tuesday of every third
month, every person who is a newly
promoted supervisor comes to Austin
with his or her family and attends
a formal promotion ceremony. Our
promotion ceremony is broadcast
throughout the state on our intranet,
so all employees can watch from
their phone or office computer. We’d
have a guest speaker and the new
supervisors would take pictures with
their families, friends, and coworkers.
They went home with a feeling of, “I’ve
accomplished something. I’m a leader.”
After we implemented that, morale
just kept going straight up. Then I
implemented the commissioner’s award
of excellence. It’s the highest award
that can be bestowed on an employee or
outside stakeholder. In the three years
I was there, I awarded 70. The award
ceremony was televised, and again, we’d
have the recipient up with their whole
family. I’d invite them up to see my
office and visit with the executive team.
Their kids really enjoyed it as well.
These caseworkers save lives daily. It
didn’t cost anything to recognize them
and bring their morale up. An employee
wants to be told when they’re doing good.
Pay is good, but that recognition is more
important. Every CEO needs to know that.
12 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
P O D C A S T
Each week on Ask a CEO, veteran tech CEO Joel Trammell explores a challenge
of one of the least understood jobs in business—that of the CEO.
Some topics we’ve covered:
• TAKING A COMPANY PUBLIC
• MASTERING WORK-LIFE BALANCE
• THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN
MANAGEMENT AND LEADERSHIP
• BEST PRACTICES FOR
COMPENSATION
Do you have a topic you’d like to
hear discussed? Or a question
about an issue you’re facing?
Let us know at
ask@texasceomagazine.com.
SUBSCRIBE NOW on Apple
Podcasts or Google Podcasts.
SPONSORED BY:
THE
BODYGUARD
In 2020, personal and diplomatic security protection isn’t just for heads of state. Increasingly,
businesspeople are enlisting the help and services of professionals like Mike Ramirez, who provide personal
and executive security protection in dangerous situations and places, whether at a conference abroad or in
a warzone. We asked Ramirez to tell us about his job—and what business leaders should know about it.
How did you get into the profession of personal protection?
I grew up about an hour southeast of San Antonio in a small
town called Kenedy, Texas. From a young age I always knew
that I wanted to be a Marine. In my senior year of high
school, I contacted a recruiter who then came to talk to me
about the Marine Corps at my parents’ house. After about
an hour of the recruiter telling me all about what the Marine
Corps had to offer and all the places I would get to travel
to, I signed my contract, and the path to where I am today
began. I spent the next four years as an Infantry Marine and
a Security Force Marine. In the mid-1990s, I got my first
taste of military personal protection while on a special duty
assignment providing armed protection for a high-ranking
officer. At that time, it wasn’t called “personal protection”—
you were just a military enlisted man assigned to an officer
because their rank warranted protection by a Marine.
After four years in the Marine Corps, I came back to Texas
and went to work for the Texas Department of Corrections.
I worked in a maximum-security state penitentiary in my
hometown of Kenedy. My first year, I worked in administrative
segregation, where offenders are locked up 23 hours a day
because of hostile behavior or because they had threats
on their lives. You’re worried about your own personal
protection at that point. Needless to say, it was not a very
cordial environment, but I learned a lot in my first year at
the penitentiary. For one, I learned how to read people very
quickly and that no two situations are ever the same. Nothing
is what it appears to be when you walk into a cell block.
After my first year in administrative segregation, I took
another position as a correctional field officer. As a CFO,
you ride on horseback every day and take offenders
to work out in the fields. The penitentiary I worked at
sat on a large amount of land, so the prison used the
offenders to do the labor and farm the land. We would
take a squad of anywhere from 25 to 50 offenders per field
officer and have them plant seeds and harvest crops.
Later, I was promoted to K-9 sergeant. My job was primarily
breeding, raising, and training dogs to track humans. If
an offender tried to escape from our prison or any other
prison, we would deploy our human-tracking dogs to
track and capture them. We also assisted local and state
police with our K-9s. If they conducted a traffic stop and
someone bailed on them, they would call us, and we’d
take our dogs out and assist in capturing the suspect.
That sounds a little more pleasant than administrative
segregation. It was! It was one of the most rewarding
jobs and if I ever win the Lotto, I would go back and
do it for free. Getting to ride horses all day and work
with dogs was a very rewarding experience.
Around 2003, the war in Afghanistan had been going for
a couple of years and the war in Iraq had started, I was
still working for the penitentiary. I kept in touch with
guys I had been in the Marines with. When I shared with
them that I was working at a penitentiary, they would say,
“Man, that sounds like a dangerous job for not very much
14 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
money.” They went on to share with me about private
military contracting. They informed me that the US
government was paying former military guys, like myself,
good money for the skills the Marine Corps taught us.
I thought, “Well, I’ll go give it a year, save that money,
and come back and decide what I want to do next.” I went
through the extreme vetting and grueling selection process,
then headed to Iraq. Before I could blink, I’d been there 10
years. My first clients that I provided personal protection
for were US civilian contractors who were rebuilding
the infrastructure, water-treatment facilities, and power
plants that had been damaged in the bombings during the
beginning of the Iraq War. From there I went on to providing
diplomatic protection for US ambassadors, secretaries of
state, diplomats, senators, congresspeople, and many other
government officials traveling in, to, and around Iraq.
We also provided 24/7 protection for the US ambassador
assigned out of the embassy in Iraq. We conducted the
advance surveys and risk assessments, coordinated the routes
we’d be taking, put together evacuation and emergency
plans should we come under attack, which we did on many
occasions. When the war in Iraq kicked off, there became
a need for former military guys like me with special skills
to provide protection for designated government officials
because our military was doing the offensive missions,
tracking down terrorists and fighting the war on terror.
Looking for the bad guys wasn’t our job. Our job was to
protect those who we were assigned to. We weren’t looking
for an engagement. Our job was to get the person we were
assigned to protect to their meetings safely, keep them out
of harm’s way and return them back to a secure location.
When it comes to diplomatic protection, we figured out
over time that in some cases, depending on the mission
and the location we would be traveling to, that it was better
to have the diplomat travel without the four or five black
Suburbans and two helicopters—“little birds”—flying above.
It’s kind of announcing the target. Yes, you could say that.
In the beginning, the thought process was to overwhelm our
attackers with our physical presence, sirens and lights and men
with superior firepower. With time, we realized that wasn’t
enough. The would-be attackers were getting braver and their
tactics were changing. They started identifying our Suburban
motorcades and using IEDs [improvised explosive devices] on
the sides of the roads or in dead animals. We had to adjust our
tactics and ways of moving our clients around the country.
The decision was made at the higher level that a new method
of transporting clients needed to be developed. My team and
I were tasked with that adjustment. We implemented using
vehicles commonly used in that area so we would blend in
more. We started dressing like the locals and concealing
our weapons when out in public. It proved to work well.
This method is still used to this day in many different
countries as a way of transporting diplomats around cities
in combat zones and hostile areas in a low-profile status.
During that time, I was recruited and switched gears from
diplomatic protection to intelligence and counterintelligence
work. This work took me in a whole new direction. After about
10 years of doing private military contracts, both diplomatic
protection and intelligence, I was ready to slow down and
returned home to the US.
I was fortunate enough to bring those security and personal
protection and intelligence skill sets back with me from all
my years in combat zones and hostile areas and put them to
use in corporate America. In this day and age, the need for
personal protection here in America and abroad is in much
greater demand than when I started in this business. Many
more private families, business professionals, and company
leaders are seeking professional protection services.
It’s very rewarding work, whether it’s a businessperson or a
family, making sure they can go about their business and not
have to be concerned for their security.
What causes somebody to say, “I need to hire professional
protection”? There are many reasons for an individual or
a company to decide that security and personal protection
is needed. A lot of times the requests come if there’s been
a direct threat against themselves or to their business.
If a company’s executives must travel, they may want
protection, especially if it’s a speech or event in a public
forum and there may be protesters or activists who could
potentially cause them harm. It could even be simply so
the protected person does not have to travel alone.
Other times, there is no specific threat, but if they’re traveling
for example in Mexico or South America, danger can arise
at any time. Kidnapping for ransom and maintaining a
positive public image are a big concern in those areas.
It could even be something like the client wanting some private
time or to avoid business pitches while traveling abroad. If
someone recognizes him or her and starts doing a pitch or
asking to borrow money, it’s easier for me to be there and
step in to handle the situation. Beforehand, we would have
already established our code words and signals, so they can
signal that they want out of the situation and I can intervene.
What makes a good client? Someone who’s open-minded
and willing to listen to our recommendations instead of
putting themselves in bad situations. That happens in some
industries more than others, especially when you compare
people in the business world to those in the entertainment
world. When people are willing to listen to our advice and
expertise, it allows us to do a better job for the client.
16 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
When you get a new client, how do you assess their needs?
We start by scheduling a conference call or a sit-down,
where I ask questions so I can have a better understanding
of what the person’s needs and concerns are: What is
the purpose for the travel? Is this business or personal?
Who do you plan to meet? How long are you going to be
there? Are there known threats against you? Why are you
requesting security? Are you being proactive, just wanting
to travel safely, or has something recently happened?
Once I get the information, I can start devising a security
plan specific to their needs and begin reaching out to my
network of security professionals. I have a large network
in this industry that I utilize for real-time intelligence and
security information in just about any part of the world.
If it is multiple people traveling that require security, I
will put together a team of security professionals to travel
with the clients. If requested or warranted, I will send
someone ahead of time to conduct an advance of the area
and places that we will be taking the client to. One person
cannot provide adequate security for multiple people.
Is there anywhere people don’t use security where you
think they should? Many Americans go to Mexico and
think, “Oh, Mexico is okay.” Honestly, Mexico is one of the
most dangerous countries in the world today. People just
don’t realize it. Americans can be targeted for kidnapping,
extortion, or just plain robbery. The cartels have been
jockeying for control over different parts of Mexico for
years and it has caused so much turmoil. You can be at the
wrong place at the wrong time and get caught up in a bad
situation with the continuous fighting among the cartels.
If they’re traveling in Mexico or anywhere in Central and
South America, I recommend that CEOs and companies take
the time and spend the money to ensure the security and
safety of their personnel. It’s much better to have a security
plan and team in place and not need it than to need it and
not have it. The cost will be a lot less than it would be to
pay a ransom. A lot of times it comes down to dollars, but
when it’s time to save money, it shouldn’t come from your
security. Businesspeople shouldn’t have to be concerned
with their security and safety when traveling. They should be
focusing on the business and representing their company.
Do you see yourself doing this for 20 more years? Whether it
be on the physical side of protection or overseeing operations
and passing my knowledge to the next generation, I will
continue bringing an undeniable passion and great value
to the table for many years to come. I’m very thankful to
have had all these years doing this work operationally.
At some point I’m probably going to have to step back
and allow the younger men to keep doing the handson
work, and I’ll take more of a management role and
continue to pass on the knowledge to the younger men. I
will squeeze a few more years out of the operational side
by continuing to stay in shape physically and mentally,
training on a regular basis, and keeping my network going.
How do you handle privacy issues? Do people worry about
having some guy standing a foot away every time they go
down to the beach on their vacation? That comes up a lot,
whether the security is for a family or corporation. People
struggle with losing their sense of privacy and personal
space. And it’s understandable. No one wants to have private
conversations with some stranger hovering around. I try
to make it clear to potential clients that there are several
ways of conducting personal protection and security.
We go over this in client assessments. It’s always tailored
to the client’s needs. There’s the up-close-and-personal
protection where I’m dressed in a suit walking a foot
away from the client, always by their side, opening the
door to let him in and out of the vehicle, and there’s
no doubt that I am there to protect that person.
There’s also what’s called low-profile protection, where
security is going to dress down and blend in more with the
people of that area. We will travel a little more low-key,
probably utilizing the same types of vehicles everyone else is
driving in that area. When we get to where we’re going, the
client will open their own door. I may have another security
person already at the location. Once you exit the vehicle, I’m
going to hand you off to the security member already at the
location. Security will give the client plenty of space depending
on the circumstances and have little to no contact with the
client unless the situation requires it, or the client requests it.
And then there’s what we call shadow security or protection,
where we never have contact with the client in public unless
the situation calls for it. This way of protection requires
multiple security team members in order to have men prestaged
in the locations the client will be traveling to as well
as to provide several security personnel to follow the client in
separate vehicles. The client drives themselves in their own
vehicle and we follow in different vehicles. Another example
of shadow security—let’s say you’re on vacation in Cabo
San Lucas with your family. We’ll have established where
you’re staying, how you’re traveling, and security will have
men on the ground before you get there. Security will be in
place around the house and they’ll look like locals from the
area. If a client is hanging out on the beach, a security team
member or members might be getting sun, wearing shorts
and hanging out like everyone else just a short distance away,
and unless security identifies a threat or we get the code word
or signal from the client, we’ll give them some room so they
don’t feel like they have lost their personal space. So, as you
can see, there are several ways to provide security and still
maintain the client’s sense of personal space and freedom.
TexasCEOMagazine.com
17
The Eyes
18 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
Feature
OF
TEXAS
ARE
UPON
US
University of Texas
athletics director Chris
Del Conte on servant
leadership, the future
of collegiate sports, and
what it takes to run an
institution representing
nearly 30 million Texans.
By most accounts, Chris Del Conte has revitalized Longhorn athletics.
Since his hire in December 2017 as vice president and athletics
director at the University of Texas, he’s not only overseen a recordbreaking
$219 million in annual revenue—he’s also led the charge
on building new sports facilities, amped up game day with a festival
concept on Bevo Boulevard, and found time to run one of the most
responsive Twitter accounts out there. (Seriously, try tweeting at
him. He’ll probably respond.) We recently spoke to Del Conte about
leading an organization that entertains millions of spectators even
as it prepares its student-athletes for success—on and off the field.
To start off, can you give us an idea of the scope of UT Athletics?
We’ve got about 400 full-time employees, 2,000 part-time
employees, 523 student-athletes, and a budget of $225 million.
We’re the front porch of an institution that has 52,000 students
and about 500,000 living alumni. Plus, there’s about 30
million people in the state of Texas that the University of Texas
represents on a daily basis. The eyes of Texas are upon us!
You ran smaller operations before you got to the University of Texas.
What were the big differences moving to a larger institution? I’ll
go back to the movie Hoosiers for a moment. When I was director
of athletics at Rice, it was a lot like the town of Hickory, Indiana,
in Hoosiers. It was a small town, 3,000 students, and you have
basically 30,000 living alumni and an $11 million budget. You
know who your constituents are. When I moved to TCU, it was
like the sectionals in Hoosiers. It was a bigger stage, where you
have 8,000 students and 50,000 living alumni. And now I’m at the
University of Texas, with a lot more than that. But at the end of the
day, the fundamentals of the game are the same. It’s still a 10-foot
rim, it’s still a 15-foot free throw, and it’s still a 94-foot court.
At the end of Hoosiers, they take the whole team into that big
gymnasium and they’re all looking around at the size and scope of
the place. But the dimensions of the court are the same as anywhere
else. In the same way, the football field is the same at Rice as it is
at TCU as it is at the University of Texas. It’s just the size and scope
of the operation that’s bigger. With that comes all the challenges
of a larger organization, but the basic footprint is the same. And in
all three institutions, we’re educating young people, helping them
get a degree through their interests on the playing field. It’s just
the size and scope of who you represent and the complexities of the
institution that are magnified when you move to a larger institution.
Photos courtesy of Texas Athletics
Finding good jobs for your student-athletes is a key priority of yours.
What do you want Texas CEOs to know about your student-athletes?
When they come to our school, every one of our student-athletes believes
that they’re going to be a pro athlete in whatever sport they participate
in. But there’s always that “aha” moment where they realize it’s about
more than that. Our job is to say, “A sport is what you do—it’s not who
you are.” When you come to college, we’re going to find and accentuate
who you are. Every one of our kids has tremendous grit. They are driven
to be the very best. They have put their entire efforts into athletics and
they know what time management is, they know what hard work is.
TexasCEOMagazine.com
19
THERE’S A
SAYING IN OUR
WEIGHT ROOM: “THE
WINNING TRADITION
OF THE UNIVERSITY
OF TEXAS SHALL NOT
BE ENTRUSTED TO
THE TIMID NOR THE
WEAK.” TELL ME WHAT
EMPLOYERS WOULD NOT
WANT TO HIRE SOMEONE
WHO’S BEEN TRAINED
UNDER THAT MOTTO?
The American dream of bettering one’s life
is always predicated on education. That’s
exactly the opportunity we’re offering at
the University of Texas. We’re getting
young people to come change the world.
That’s what we say here: “What starts here
changes the world.” We truly believe that.
When you get a degree from the University
of Texas, from the finest faculty the land
has to offer, you are then prepared to
change the dynamics of any institution
you go work for based on that educational
background at the University of Texas.
So, an employer getting a student-athlete
from the University of Texas can be sure
that person has been tested under the
eyes of Texas. The pressure of being a
student-athlete is not for the faint of heart.
There’s a saying in our weight room:
“The pride and winning tradition of the
Texas Longhorns will not be entrusted
to the weak nor the timid.” Tell me what
employers would not want to hire someone
who’s been trained under that motto?
The athletics director position has a lot
of similarities to the CEO position. One
unusual aspect of it is that you are often
not the face of the organization. It’s
often the coaches who are most visible,
and the success of the institution might
be externally judged on their success.
How do you deal with that? I think of
my role as one of servant leadership. It
should be about our coaches and our
student-athletes. My job is to be the
wind beneath their wings, whether it
be our coaches, our student-athletes, or
our constituents at large. When you put
them before you, that’s the greatest form
of leadership—serving your community.
That’s what team sports are all about.
It’s a collective group that makes your
team successful, not an individual.
As athletics director, I’m running an
economic enterprise based on people’s
passion. No one has to buy a season ticket.
No one has to buy a T-shirt. No one has
to come to the games. We’re providing
an opportunity for people to form a sense
of community around the University of
Texas. We invite 100,000 people to come
back to campus to celebrate the University
of Texas through the eyes of sport. That
makes us the front porch, like I said, but
the most important thing is the house—the
university. The house has transformed
lives and bettered the community through
education. Then Texas Exes is the back
porch, where we invite people to the
barbecue to relive the glory days.
When you’re running an enterprise
based on passion, whether it’s the
passion of the kids on the field or the
coaches or our donors or our students
or the state of Texas as a whole, you’d
better have a servant mind and heart.
You will not be successful if you think
it’s about you. It is always about the
University of Texas first and foremost.
You had a “lemons into lemonade”
situation this year, where you had to
20 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
replace a coach in the middle of the
year. The team rallied and then ended up
winning a national championship. How
do you handle a situation like that? You
always put the student-athletes first. Kids
are resilient. That particular issue was
difficult to deal with, but the kids knew
they wore that burnt orange and white
across their chest and were going to rally
around each other and the university. We
were already having a successful season,
so that was a bump in the road. But it was
an opportunity for them to realize that
together they can do something special.
As you look five, ten years down the
road at collegiate athletics, do you see
any big changes? Do you see the esports
craze getting folded into intercollegiate
athletics? Are you worried about the
struggles people are having with football
injuries? It’s ever-changing every day.
The enterprise has always gone through
big shifts since it was established over a
century ago. The football program here was
established in 1893, but college athletics
in its current form really took hold in the
early 1900s. One thing that we’ve always
had is change, whether it be changes in
conferences or rules or affiliations. You just
have to be able to adapt to the changes.
As far as the two trends you just
mentioned, some of those are politically
motivated. I don’t know if esports will
ever take hold in the South. But it’s
happening in other cities and states,
so you have to be aware of that. And
the safety of the game has always been
paramount. Hell, that was paramount
when Teddy Roosevelt was president.
You’re always going to have these dynamic
topics. They’re always going to be there.
My job is not to be rigid in thought but
to be malleable for the betterment of
the institution and our program.
WHEN YOU’RE
RUNNING AN
ENTERPRISE BASED
ON PASSION, YOU’D
BETTER HAVE A
SERVANT MIND AND
HEART. YOU WILL NOT
BE SUCCESSFUL IF YOU
THINK IT’S ABOUT YOU.
What do you tell people about what it’s
like to work for you? I expect you to do the
job! You’re the expert in your particular
field, so do your job. As a leader, I don’t
need to be a jack of all trades—I hire
experts to do their job. It’s like in football,
where you’ve got 11 people on the field and
if each of them does their job, the team will
be successful. You’ve got to hire the right
people, give them the tools necessary to be
successful, then stand back and let them
work. That’s what a leader should do. If
you’re manipulating every little thing as a
leader, then you’re not allowing people to
grow. If you hire someone to run an area of
your organization, let them run that area.
At the University of Texas, our goal is to be
a top-10 team in every one of our sports,
so collectively we give our staff and our
coaches all the tools necessary to be great
and then we let them do it. And we hold
them accountable to that standard. Period.
If I worked for you, what stories would
I hear? What has influenced you
throughout your career? I have mentors
I constantly work with, but probably my
biggest mentor was my dad. Growing up,
he always told us: Be humble, be honest,
and serve people. If you do those three
things well, you will be successful. But
if you don’t do one of those three things
well, then life will be difficult for you.
Those three things are important to me
and I always carry them with me. And my
dad and mom lived those things. When I
was a kid, they started a children’s home
in New Mexico, where they helped look
after over a hundred and fifty foster kids.
Did you know that athletics director
was a job you wanted at a young age, or
did you stumble into it? It wasn’t one of
those things I knew from the beginning.
When I was in college, a house parent at
the ranch I was at became a team doctor
at Washington State, and he gave me
a job in the maintenance department.
I worked my way up from there. But I
always knew that I wanted to be around
an organization that was giving something
good to humanity. Outside of the GI Bill,
more kids go to college for free through
athletic scholarships than anything else.
It doesn’t matter where you’re from or
your socioeconomic background—through
sport you can change your paradigm
because you got a free education.
Feature
But to me it’s always been about being
humble, being honest, and serving others—
those three traits my father instilled in
me. Those are always going to be with
me. I was always going to do that type
of work. Sport just happened to be the
arena that galvanized my interest.
TexasCEOMagazine.com
21
WHAT CEOS
Can Learn from
EXCEPTIONAL
COACHES
John Thornton, PhD
I have always been fascinated by the coaches who have “it”—that
X-factor that separates exceptional coaches from the also-rans.
What do they do differently as they put together a staff, organize
practice, recruit talent, and manage high-stakes games? While a
favorable bounce here and there helps out, it’s become obvious over
my forty-plus years in athletics that consistent winning happens
by design. In some form or fashion, the exceptional coaches all
had a system, a routine that worked for them. John Wooden, Pat
Summitt, and Paul “Bear” Bryant—with their respective Pyramid of
Success, Definite Dozen, and Junction Boys—are the stuff of legend.
Each is absolutely authentic. Each put in the vast amount of time,
expertise, and effort it takes to achieve success.
My interest in great coaching runs through my entire career, from
my early involvement in high school coaching to my experiences
with intercollegiate coaching and administration, ending with
my time as interim athletics director at Texas A&M University.
It continues through today in my role as executive professor and
director of the Texas A&M Coaching Academy, where I deal with
the complexities of directorship over intercollegiate athletics
programs. If I have learned anything, it’s that the job of building
a successful athletic program is not for the faint of heart. As the
homespun Coach Bum Phillips once said, “There are two kinds of
coaches: those that are fired and those that are going to be fired.”
The exceptional men and women who succeed in this highpressure
role have my utmost respect. They must channel their
players’ competitiveness, please their donors, and persist through
public scrutiny and the incessant chatter of social media gurus.
And as my mentor Coach Shelby Metcalf—hall of famer and the
winningest coach in the Southwest Conference—was fond of
saying, they do all this with “a scoreboard tied to their ass.”
Does that sound familiar? Perhaps a little like the CEO role?
Indeed, coaching within a Tier One athletic program like Texas
A&M—with its seven-figure revenue and nearly 600 studentathletes—is
a lot like leading in corporate America. Leaders in both
settings face the same pressure to perform, the same responsibility
to deliver wins through other people. And I believe that each role
has much to learn from the other.
Here are five characteristics of the exceptional coaches I have
known, each of which translates to consistent winning in the
business realm.
1. Exceptional coaches define and embrace their
uniqueness. Exceptional coaches are special: They stand
out in some way, whether you call it their style, their persona,
or something else. They might be folksy, hard-ass, nononsense,
or mystical, but whatever they are, they are totally
themselves. They find the authentic core of themselves, share
it with their teams, and use it to separate themselves from
the merely average coaches. This authenticity fosters the
kind of trust and loyalty that—to again quote Coach Metcalf—
prevents fans “from naming a street after you one year and
running you out of town on it the next.”
2. Exceptional coaches are consumed with their
profession. For better or worse, exceptional coaches live
their job every day. They have an unrelenting, laser-like
focus. They constantly fight for what they and their teams
need to win. As an administrator, dealing with these passionfilled
firebrands could get tiresome at times, but I had to
realize that this was a part of what made them good. They
take no days off. They are always striving for excellence.
22 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
Feature
3. Exceptional coaches are competitors. The best
coaches I know hate to lose more than they enjoy winning.
They attract players with that same competitive drive, which
can be a curse or blessing depending on your perspective.
Recruiting, developing talent, and scheming up the x’s and o’s
all contribute to game-day success, but as Coach Metcalf also
says, “talent that doesn’t compete gets you fired.” Coaches
that recruit competitors—and develop the competitive nature
of their teams—are the ones who win consistently.
4. Exceptional coaches develop a culture you can
feel. Just as exceptional coaches have their own unique
style, they also build a unique team identity. They make
players feel like they are part of something special. Whatever
the specifics of that culture are, players are motivated by the
sense of belonging and shared identity. They know that their
coach and their teammates have their back.
5. Exceptional coaches surround themselves with
talent. Great coaches don’t just focus on the one or two
superstars—they make sure they have talent in every role.
That goes for the MVP, the “glue guy” (who holds the team
together), and everyone in between. They are not afraid
to tinker with the process to ensure that talent is properly
utilized. And they do not have a problem making the tough
call and benching the underachievers.
In my time at Texas A&M, I have seen exceptional coaches perform
incredible feats. One coach inherited a team that hadn’t won
a game in conference play the entire year before—but after six
months of preparation, he helped the team qualify for postseason
play and set the stage for six straight NCAA appearances.
Other coaches recently led Texas A&M teams to three national
championships, a feat this institution had not achieved since
1939. These exceptional coaches, to a one, displayed the five
characteristics I have outlined, which is why I strive daily to impart
them to future and current coaches.
I also believe that these characteristics are not confined to the
world of athletics. Like exceptional coaches, exceptional CEOs do
all of the above: They find their authenticity as a leader, build their
passion for the business, harness their competitive spirit, build a
strong culture, and surround themselves with top-level talent. It is
no surprise to me that so many business leaders draw inspiration
from the world of sport. At the heart of leading, coaching, and
winning lie many of the same principles—principles that can
inspire us to higher performance, whether we are pursuing a
national championship or building a world-class business.
John Thornton is the inaugural director of the Texas A&M Coaching
Academy. He earned his doctorate degree from Texas A&M in 1997 and
received the 1998 Academic Inspiration Award by a vote of the Texas A&M
Scholar-Athletes of the Year. Previously, he served as Senior Associate
Athletics Director and Interim Athletics Director at Texas A&M.
TexasCEOMagazine.com
23
STARTUP SUCCESS:
A STARTUP FUNDRAISING SERIES
HOW MUCH
Should We Raise?
Gordon Daugherty
For most startups, the decision to raise
money is made out of necessity. The
entrepreneur needs more funding to
continue pursuing their dream, whether
the money will be used just to survive
a while longer or truly shift a gear and
move into the next stage of evolution.
Other startups pursue funding out of
want more than need. Usually, this is
because they either want to get more
aggressive in their growth or because
there’s some opportunity they want
to exploit sooner than when they
might otherwise organically. These
startups are in the fortunate position
of turning down the funding if the
terms, timing, or amount isn’t right.
But regardless of whether the
entrepreneur is pursuing funding out
of necessity or desire, they still face a
difficult decision: how much to raise.
Not only is the decision critical to the
startup’s own planning and forecasting,
but investors will want to understand
why the entrepreneur has chosen to
raise the stated amount of money.
The ability to demonstrate that they
determined the right amount of funding
for the company at its particular stage
is important for establishing credibility
with the investor. The entrepreneur
will essentially become the steward of
the investor’s money through multiple
rounds of funding, until they eventually
exit and the investor gets a return. Thus,
the investor needs to see a cohesive
fundraising strategy that doesn’t just let
the startup survive for a while longer but
rather allows them to reach future key
milestones for continuing to get funded
and eventually grow a great company.
Investors typically get a lot of unacceptable
responses when they ask why the desired
amount of funding is the right amount,
such as “Most other startups at our stage
seem to raise that amount,” “It’s the
most we think we will be able to raise,”
“It only dilutes us 25 percent,” and “It
gives us one year of runway.” These
responses might be true, but they are
all also terrible. This article provides a
framework for determining how much
24 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
a startup should raise and how they
should describe that to investors.
The basic formula
For startups seeking growth, the figure
below summarizes the first major steps for
deciding how much to raise. As you can
see, the amount of money raised affords
the startup a combination of time and
resources. And with time and resources,
they can accomplish things (outcomes).
The basic concept is simple. And since
we are trying to solve for the right
amount of funding to raise, let’s analyze
the other variables a little further.
Time and resources
When I say time, I actually mean an
amount of time the money will last, or
what is often referred to as runway.
The amount of runway needed varies
widely for each venture but usually
gets longer with subsequent rounds of
funding and later stages of evolution.
The most obvious type of resource is
the one every founder obsesses about,
additional headcount—regardless of
whether they are part-time or full-time.
“If we only had two more developers, we
would be in great shape.” In the same
category as headcount are contractors,
consultants, and various service
professionals like lawyers and accountants.
What many early-stage startups don’t
think about are things like increased
spending for marketing programs,
specialty tools, and software systems.
These are usually important resources that
are also needed to advance the business.
For startups, time and resources are in
competition with each other. In other
words, a startup could use all of the new
funding to gain time, but that means
not adding headcount to the team,
not adding more contractors, and not
spending more on programs, tools, and
the like. Instead, they could use all of
the new funding to aggressively dial
up headcount and spending, but that
means they’ll almost immediately have
to raise more money. Part of the trick
is dialing in the optimal combination of
extra time and extra resources in order
to achieve the desired outcomes.
Figuring out the best combination involves
creating a financial forecast model that
allows experimenting with various
assumptions and alternatives. For a preseed
or seed round of funding, the startup
will have lots of assumptions that have
no support from prior results. Because
of this, the investors will really want to
understand any information or insights the
startup has to support their assumptions.
Later, the prior track record will serve
as a basis for many of the projections.
Outcomes
Outcomes are discretely identifiable results
the startup hopes to achieve with their
newly raised funds. How about acquiring a
certain number of new customers to reach
the next meaningful revenue milestone,
or significantly reducing your average cost
to acquire a new customer? How about
securing a strategic partnership that will
provide significant leverage, or getting final
approval on a patent filing? What about
launching a new product or entering a new
market? These are outcomes that reduce
the investor’s risk or increase their upside
potential when the startup eventually exits.
The best way to understand the formula
is the way it is diagramed above, left to
right. But the best way to actually go
about the exercise of figuring out how
much money to raise is to work backward,
starting with the desired outcomes. It is
those future outcomes that the investors
want the company to achieve and,
therefore, the things they want to fund.
Once the desired future outcomes are
determined, the startup simply needs
to use their financial forecast model to
determine the best combination of time
and resources needed to generate the
outcomes. With this, they can determine
how much funding is needed for that
combination of time and resources.
Feature
There are pretty dramatic differences
in the outcomes Silicon Valley investors
expect and the outcomes investors in most
other places in the country expect. A set
of projected outcomes that are exciting
to an investor in Memphis, Tennessee,
or Denver, Colorado, could easily seem
way too safe and conservative to a Silicon
Valley investor. There is much more of
a swing-for-the-fences, build-a-unicorn,
global-world-domination mentality in
Silicon Valley, and fundraising startups
should understand this philosophical
difference in risk tolerance as they go
about setting their desired outcomes.
Time for the first
check and balance
Why not just raise enough money to last
a long time, like three or four years?
Well, ignoring whether the startup could
be successful raising that much, the
answer relates to the valuation they’re
able to negotiate with investors.
Let’s assume $10 million would fund a
particular venture for four years. The
question is, What sort of valuation can
the company earn at the time they raise
that money? As you can see in the figure
below, today’s valuation is mostly based
on the state of the business today. If
investors will only agree to a $5 million
valuation, for example, the company
will experience significant dilution and
immediately give control to the investors
due to the amount of equity they will get.
The amount of money raised compared
to the valuation they’re able to negotiate
provides a check and balance.
Because of this, the process of figuring
out how much money to raise is often
iterative. First, an uncontested look into
the crystal ball allows the startup to figure
TexasCEOMagazine.com
25
out how much to raise in order to accomplish a desired set of
outcomes. Next, a test-drive with investors helps inform whether
the valuation they’ll be able to negotiate derives reasonable
dilution or if they’ll need to adjust the amount, either up or
down. If they adjust the amount down, the significance of the
projected outcomes will also be adjusted down. That might cause
the round of funding to seem less exciting for investors, and an
adjustment may be necessary. These iterations continue until
the startup finds the right balance of outcomes and valuation.
Multiple rounds over time
Now that you understand the basic formula and framework,
let’s project forward to see how multiple funding rounds tie
together. As you can see in the figure below, with each round of
funding, the projected outcomes eventually become the state of
the business in the future. That is what the company uses to gain
the desired step-up in valuation for the next round of funding.
This cycle continues again and again until the company is either
self-sustaining or experiences an exit (acquisition or IPO).
Evolving from a bootstrapped startup to a funded one is a big
and important transition. A startup might end up as a funded
one out of need or want. If they don’t need funding, then
they have alternatives. Most startups eventually need outside
funding and, once that happens, many things change. One of
those things is they get to accomplish more and grow faster,
assuming they have a scalable business. But they will also
experience a change in accountability. No longer are they only
accountable to the founding team and other team members;
they suddenly have to answer to their new investors, who
might have different interests, beliefs, and motivations than
they do. The more investors they take on over time, the more
varied those interests, beliefs, and motivations will be, and the
more they’ll have to accommodate or negotiate with them.
Like many things in business, up-front time and effort spent
on fundraising strategy can pay huge dividends later. It
translates to increased odds of raising the right amount of
money to reach the next significant milestone for making
another want-versus-need decision and generally controlling
their destiny. Surely, they know things won’t play out exactly
as planned, but that doesn’t relieve them from the obligation
to start with a strategy. After that, they can do what every
great entrepreneur does—adjust and adapt as necessary.
Iterations to fundraising strategy may also happen as you
test-drive ideas and assumptions with investors before
actually launching the fundraising campaign. That takes place
during the planning phase of fundraising—and is the topic
of my article in the next issue of Texas CEO Magazine.
Gordon Daugherty is a seasoned business executive, entrepreneur, startup advisor, investor, and the best-selling author of Startup Success: Funding the Early Stages of Your
Venture. A proud native Texan, Daugherty graduated from Baylor University. He has vast experience with early-stage fundraising from both sides of the table, making more
than 200 investments and raising more than $80 million in growth and venture capital as a company executive, fund manager, board director, and active advisor.
SUBSCRIBE TO Texas CEO Magazine at texasceomagazine.com/subscribe.
WANT TO SEND THIS MAGAZINE TO YOUR CLIENTS?
For information on bulk discounts, email us at info@texasceomagazine.com.
WANT TO STAY INFORMED ON OUR EVENTS, PODCAST, AND MORE?
Sign up for our weekly e-newsletter at texasceomagazine.com/news.
26 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
Improve Your
PROFIT MARGIN Via...
• Process Automation
• Platform Standardization
• Digital Transformation
• Data Analytics & Governance
Case studies on the aforementioned can be found at:
ylconsulting.com/tx
7
WITH
Feature
Mark Cuban
Quick Questions
We don’t need to introduce Mark Cuban, do we? Entrepreneur,
investor, author, Texan, Dallas Mavericks owner, Shark Tank
star—you know the drill. We threw seven quick questions to
Cuban. Let’s see what he had to say.
1. YOU HAVE THE RESOURCES TO LOCATE ANYWHERE
IN THE WORLD. WHAT KEEPS YOU IN TEXAS? The people.
The energy. The business climate. And of course my favorite
basketball team.
2. WHAT DO YOU THINK CAUSED YOU TO GO DOWN THE
ENTREPRENEURIAL PATH? My parents always encouraged me
to try new things, and more importantly, they were insistent that
if I wanted something, I had to find a way to earn the money
for it. That pushed me in the direction of selling everything and
anything a little kid could.
3. WHAT WERE THE FORMATIVE EXPERIENCES THAT
DEVELOPED YOUR MANAGEMENT APPROACH? Lots of
mistakes. Recognizing that if my vision wasn't aligned with
those of my employees and customers, nothing works.
I have to add that management is a skill that requires constant
developing. Managers have to be adaptive to what is happening—
not just in their marketplace but also culturally. And they have to
always learn from their mistakes.
4. WHILE THE MAVERICKS ARE A PRIVATE BUSINESS, THEY
OPERATE VERY PUBLICLY. WHAT ADVICE DO YOU HAVE FOR
CEOS WHO FIND THEMSELVES MOVING INTO THE PUBLIC
LIMELIGHT? There is nothing like running a sports team. For
any other CEO that finds themselves moving into the limelight—
or wishing to move into the limelight—develop relationships
with any and all media that impacts your industry. It could be a
blogger and Instagram influencer or it could be a magazine.
Don’t wait for them to come to you. Go to them and let them
know that your knowledge can help them create content and
make them look better at their job.
5. YOU LOOK AT A LOT OF DEALS AND VISIT WITH A
LOT OF ENTREPRENEURS. WHAT ARE YOU LOOKING FOR
TO MAKE YOU THINK THEY WILL BE SUCCESSFUL? I want
to see deals where my first reaction is “Why didn't I think of
that?” I want entrepreneurs who are agile. Always willing to
learn. Always willing to sell. Always willing to connect with
people and be nice. Nice is a very underrated skill.
6. IS THERE A PART OF BUSINESS YOU WISH YOU HAD
SPENT MORE TIME LEARNING ABOUT EARLY IN YOUR
CAREER? Video editing. It would be fun to be able to whip up any
video anytime, so I don't have to wait on others to get things done.
7. IS THERE A NEXT ACT FOR MARK CUBAN, AND WHAT
MIGHT IT BE? I haven’t had my first act yet. Stay tuned.
Kathy Hutchins / Shutterstock.com
28 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
Josh Ramos, Rick Narpaul, John Adams, and Beto Altamirano
[ENTREPRENEURSHIP]
THESE
ENTREPRENEURS
ARE MAKING
SAN ANTONIO
SAFER
Plenty of innovators have made our
lives more convenient, productive, and
connected—but for some, the primary
concern is making our lives safer.
Each of these four San Antonio
entrepreneurs developed a new way to
keep people safe from preventable harm,
at home, at work, or on the road. The
world may still be a dangerous place, but
these Texans are making it a little less so.
Rick Narpaul
Founder & CEO, Mach1 Services
Ever been stranded on the side of the road
thanks to a blown tire, a drained battery,
or an empty gas tank? Even if you have a
membership to AAA or other insurance,
you still have to wait for someone to
dispatch help from a call center, which
seemingly takes forever. When you’re in
that stressful situation with cars and trucks
speeding past you, you want help as soon
as possible.
The Solution:
Rick Narpaul describes Mach1 Services
as “the Uber of roadside service.” With
the Mach1 app you can access roadside
assistance dispatched automatically,
connecting you to the closest service
provider that can help. This cuts down
your wait time and lets you track the help
that’s on the way in real time. The process
is simple for service providers too: Receive
the request, follow turn-by-turn directions,
and arrive at the driver in need. The service
is currently available in San Antonio,
Austin, Houston, Dallas/Fort Worth, and
Corpus Christi.
Next up for Mach1 is expansion across the
US and into more automotive services.
Users will soon be able to use the app
to order a mobile mechanic to do oil
changes, trip inspections, and lots more,
right at their home or workplace.
www.mach1services.com
Download the iOS or Android app
Josh Ramos
Founder & CEO, RMS Innovations
Josh Ramos usually begins his elevator
pitch with a number: eight. As of 2019,
Ramos explains, eight children in the US
are shot in their own home accidentally
every single day. Gunlocks may seem
the obvious solution, but they have their
flaws. Many can be easily unlocked
with the universal keys available at any
Home Depot or Walmart. Some guns
can still be discharged with the lock
in place. And the traditional key or
combination dial mechanism can prevent
the firearm owner from quickly using
the gun in an emergency situation.
The Solution: Ramos’ solution is twofold.
First, biometrics allow the owner to unlock
the spring-loaded mechanism in less than
half a second by pressing their finger on
the sensor. Second, the RMS gunlock uses
a dual-rod blocking mechanism, which
ensures that accidental firing doesn’t
happen while the lock is engaged (setting
it apart from dangerous single-rod trigger
gunlock). When Ramos’ gunlock hits the
market soon, it will fit about 80 percent of
rifles, shotguns, and handguns.
John Adams
Founder & CEO, RubrixAiD
For 60 years, since the inception of the
modern EMS and 911 phone system,
citizens have only had one major response
to crisis in their homes or in the street:
call and wait. Most people—even trained
ones—are not always mentally ready or
equipped to deal with injury as it happens.
EMS is not readily available on every street
corner, so time is a factor. Seconds count,
so proper and immediate aid could make
the difference in saving limbs or life.
The Solution: For the first time in human
history, RubrixAiD has developed and
manufactured an automated first-aid
kit that helps users with medical care,
anytime, anywhere. RubrixAiD walks
the user through emergency non-critical
first-aid care, whether it’s minimizing
blood loss, stimulating breathing, or
mending wounds. The interface is visual
and intuitive, meaning that even a preteen
can offer on-the-spot, potentially
life-saving assistance. RubrixAiD uses
the latest and greatest technology on the
market, including artificial intelligence
and machine learning, to accomplish this
feat in real time across any geographical
location. As it works to offer safety and
care to the public, the company has
garnered significant attention, including
strategic partnerships and working
relationships with companies such as
Google, T-Mobile, and Twilio.
www.rubrixaid.com
Beto Altamirano
Cofounder & CEO, Cityflag
Let’s say you see a pothole, an abandoned
car, vandalism, or any other unsafe area
in your neighborhood. What’s your best
option for getting it fixed? Most likely,
it’s calling 311, having a drawn-out phone
conversation, and simply hoping that your
local government is able to follow through.
The Solution: As cofounder and CEO of
Cityflag (and one of Forbes’ “30 Under 30
Social Entrepreneurs”), Beto Altamirano
is using mobile technology to open up
the lines of communication between
citizens and government—and get issues
resolved quickly and more efficiently. With
Cityflag’s 311SA mobile app, San Antonians
can instantly report issues in their
neighborhood to the city. It’s a 15-second
task rather than a 20-minute call. The app
has already drawn 20,000 users, who have
generated over 40,000 requests. Bringing
the agility of the tech world to bureaucratic
and risk-averse government may not have
been easy for Cityflag, but it’s now paying
off in saved time, saved taxpayer dollars,
and increased civic involvement.
www.cityflag.co
TexasCEOMagazine.com
29
Want to Work
from
COWBOYS HQ?
HERE’S YOUR CHANCE
Feature
A CONVERSATION
WITH JERRY JONES JR.
The Dallas Cowboys have the most loyal fans in the NFL. We
didn’t just make that up—an Emory University poll from last
July proved it. In the 30-plus years since Jerry Jones bought the
legendary franchise, he and his family have grown it into the
most valuable sports property in the world.
Recently, we had the great privilege of chatting with Jerry Jones Jr.,
who serves as the Cowboys’ executive vice president and chief
sales and marketing officer. He told us how his operation
capitalizes on Cowboys fans’ legendary enthusiasm,
especially through Formation, a new collaborative workspace
in the team’s world headquarters. Formation opened its doors
this past summer, offering open workspaces, dedicated desks,
and private offices to individuals and entrepreneurs. Get a seat
at Formation and you’ll not only hitch your business to the
excitement of the Dallas Cowboys—you might find yourself in
the lunch line next to an NFL legend.
The Dallas Cowboys World Headquarters at The Star has been open for a
couple of years now. What was the process of building the headquarters
like? When we built our stadium [AT&T Stadium in Arlington, Texas,
completed in 2009], we were all asked what our biggest challenge was.
In our minds, that challenge was meeting the expectations of our fans for
what the home of the Dallas Cowboys should be. That was the approach
that we took to build AT&T Stadium and create an experience for our fans.
Five years ago, when we got the opportunity with the City of Frisco
to build The Star as the future headquarters of the Dallas Cowboys—
business operations, training and practice facility, and a lot more—
we wanted to create yet another way our fans could experience
the Dallas Cowboys in ways they hadn’t before. We sat there
really whiteboarding different ideas of what that might mean and
how we could take advantage of the Dallas Cowboys brand.
Photos courtesy of Formation
At the time, we had more than 25 years of experience to draw
from, things we had done with our sponsors, their customers, and
our fans. It’s from those conversations that The Star evolved and
became what it is today. The things we have done there are things we
believe in 100 percent, things like the Omni Hotel, Cowboys Fit [the
health and fitness center at The Star], Cowboys Club, and work we’ve
done with Baylor Scott & White on health protection and injury
prevention. Those ideas were all whiteboarded long before they came
to fruition, using the concept of leveraging the Cowboys brand.
TexasCEOMagazine.com
31
Our approach, starting with Jerry
Sr., has always been to leverage the
passion and excitement of the Dallas
Cowboys. We’ve found we can use that
tradition, history, and brand affinity to
help sponsors like Pepsi, Ford, or the
Miller Brewing Company. By leveraging
the association with the Dallas Cowboys,
you really create an uneven playing
field, and that’s what we’ve done here
with Formation [the new collaborative
workspace]. Our family has always been
passionate about entrepreneurship and
business and now, with Formation, we
have the chance to help foster success
with everyone from entrepreneurs to
CEOs of up-and-coming businesses.
My understanding is that
Formation is already highly utilized,
even though it’s only been open since
last August. How did that business come
about? It really grew out of our focus
on the culture and environment at The
Star. As we were collecting ideas for
what we wanted our headquarters at
The Star to be, we weren’t looking
32 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
at sports training facilities like we
did when we were building the
stadium. We looked for ideas all over
the place. We studied corporations and
their headquarters, places like Apple and
Google. We went and saw what some of
our sponsors, like Ford Motor Company,
were doing. In looking at those places,
we wanted to see how they treated
corporate environment and culture.
In building The Star, we focused
on the atmosphere, the look and feel of
everything from the players’ cafeteria
to business operations. We had to think
WE REALLY
DIDN’T LOOK
AT IT AS COWORKING
AS MUCH AS WE
LOOKED AT IT AS AN
ENTREPRENEURIAL
MEMBERSHIP CLUB.
about not only what the experience for
our fans was like, but how we could
ensure that our employees and our
football team had a great experience
as well. What setting could we give
them that would make them thrive?
That really bled to the idea
of a coworking space, which then led
into the development of Formation. The
concept was picking up steam and a lot
of people were jumping into that industry,
but we really didn’t look at it as coworking
as much as we looked at it as an
entrepreneurial membership club. What
does that mean? It means you have an
opportunity to leverage the Cowboys the
very way that our family does. Formation
really lets people tap into the history,
the passion, and the excitement of the
Cowboys brand as well as the dynamic
of a family-run operation. With
Formation, we had a chance to let
people access those amenities and
take part in that very excitement of
being a part of the Cowboys family.
That’s what Formation represents.
Feature
TO THINK
THAT YOU’RE
GOING TO LUNCH AND
RIGHT NEXT TO YOU IN
LINE IS DAK PRESCOTT
OR JAYLON SMITH?
THAT IS PRICELESS.
What is the appeal for individuals or
companies that take advantage of
Formation? Leveraging the Cowboys
brand makes a big difference. It lets the
guard down in a business dynamic. We’ve
done that very thing for the last 30 years
by giving our business partners access
to the brand. To me, that’s what we’re
emphasizing with Formation. It’s why
Formation is more of an entrepreneurial
club than a typical coworking space.
Its connection to the Dallas Cowboys,
The Star, and our family has allowed
it to stand out from similar spaces and
provide a unique edge in business.
Our headquarters at The Star is 400,000
square feet. The Dallas Cowboys are only
in 70,000 of that square feet. What’s
going on in the other 330,000? Those
are companies like FM Global, Bank
of America, Merrill Lynch. And we
just announced Keurig Dr Pepper’s
new 350,000-square-foot Texas
headquarters adjacent to our building,
on another side of the practice field.
When those companies invite a client
to come to have a discussion, they
walk through the main entryway of the
Dallas Cowboys headquarters. There
are five Super Bowl trophies sitting
there, five Super Bowl rings, a tribute to
the Cowboys Ring of Honor. They feel
like they’re visiting the Cowboys even
though they’re going over to have
a meeting at Merrill Lynch. Those
companies have seen what a brand
association with the Dallas Cowboys
does for their business.
Now, with Formation, smaller operations
can get in on that and really benefit in
the networking and relationship-building
space—whether you’re an entrepreneur
just starting out on your own or a CEO
of a newly launched corporation. In fact,
our open workspaces are designed for
maximum flexibility and connectivity with
others. We also provide many ongoing
opportunities for relationship-building
like weekly happy hours, monthly network
huddles, a monthly series called “The
Cowboys Way,” in which our front office
executives share professional insights, and
periodic keynote addresses for members.
That’s the opportunity Formation
gives. If I were starting up a company
and my name wasn’t Jerry Jones Jr.,
that’s where I’d be officing. It’d be the
best chance to get that uneven playing
field that I’ve been fortunate enough to
have throughout my business career.
Another topic that’s come up a lot lately
is esports. I know you’ve done some
partnering in that arena. Where do you
see that going? It’s a really interesting
industry, especially with Complexity
Gaming now headquartered here on our
campus. I’d say that right now it’s a really
broad-strokes term. When someone
says “esports,” they’re often being too
general. Which part of esports are you
talking about? What video game is it?
But there are still a lot of uncharted
waters out there. We’ve had discussions
with high schools, with UILs, with
school districts about this becoming a
high school sport and a college sport
that’s no different from rowing or
lacrosse. We’re certainly staying
educated on it, we see the opportunity,
and we’re putting a chip on the table if
you will, seeing what will transpire.
The younger generations are following
it closely. When we first started
discussing esports, my boy was 11 and
he definitely knew more about it than my
brother and I did—how you could watch
and how influencers worked related to
esports. It was a good education for us.
Your brand is obviously associated with
the Dallas metro area. What do you see
happening there that has you excited
about business going forward? We all
know the great environment that the state
of Texas creates for corporations, not just
in sport but in any industry. You see big
corporations moving to Austin, you see
them moving into Dallas, you see them
moving to North Dallas especially. Back
in 2013, we had to make the decision to
make a huge financial commitment here.
As we sit today, we have over $1.5 billion
TexasCEOMagazine.com
33
invested into The Star development,
and that’s with only two-thirds of it
being developed. We still have 30-
plus acres of the 90 acres to go.
But you get comfort in seeing the growth
of North Texas and Texas overall. There’s
no better place to do business right
now. We felt that Frisco really was the
heartbeat of all that when we made the
commitment to bring The Star here,
and now we’re doing the same with
Formation. We’ve created an uneven
playing field with the Dallas Cowboys
name and fostered an energy there
that has allowed businesses to thrive.
We’ve also found that several of our
members see Formation as the perfect
way to extend their business into the
growing north corridor of Dallas.
With growth often come challenges. Are
there any major challenges in the DFW
area or Texas in general you think we
should be leery of as we continue to
experience this significant growth? Well,
I can tell you one thing you see when
there’s growth everywhere, especially as
we look at North Texas and the DFW area:
In the development phase, construction
costs usually go a little higher than you
had budgeted for, because there’s that
kind of demand for contractors. When you
have growth throughout, that becomes
a real issue. But it’s also a good problem
to have, because it creates a stimulus
in that area for thriving economics.
These high costs for new construction are
yet another reason why coworking is often
a good option for businesses. Formation,
for example, offers an elevated level of
hospitality and aesthetic that is truly
unmatched in this market. We’ve also
seen firsthand how our workspaces are
well-liked by any level of professional—
from an entrepreneur to a seasoned CEO.
And, better yet, Frisco is the ideal place to
be, as one of the fastest-growing suburbs
in Texas and in the US overall. When
you combine this with The Star campus
and Dallas Cowboys organization, there’s
truly no better place to do business.
The workforce is probably the numberone
concern we hear from CEOs. How are
we going to keep filling the pipeline with
workers? They’re hard to come by.
At Formation, one of the lures of the
workplace is how closely it is tied to
the Dallas Cowboys organization. To
think that you’re going to lunch and
right next to you in line is Dak Prescott
or Jaylon Smith? That is priceless.
It’s also all about the amenities.
Formation is located next to more than
30 restaurants and just steps from
fitness, entertainment, and business
innovations. Members also have special
access to presales for select AT&T
Stadium and Ford Center events, and
unique members-only events created by
Dallas Cowboys staff with opportunities
to hear from in-house experts. There
are many other particularly unique
membership perks, like professional
headshots from a team photographer,
an on-site barista, notary services, lunch
delivery from the team chef, and more.
And secondly, as big as we have
grown, between my brother,
my sister, myself, and of course
Jerry Sr., we’re still a family-run,
hands-on operation. In today’s
workplace, the more you look at your
colleagues and employees as family
members, not just as tools to a bottom
line, the better culture you’ll have.
Because you ask—how would you
manage them if they were your own
children, your own siblings, your own
parents? If you take that approach
of trying to invest in them and take
satisfaction in their growth and success—
even if it ultimately means they leave for
a bigger opportunity somewhere else—
you ought to take pride in that. That’s
our approach, and so far it’s working well.
34 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
CEO
Activism
& THE
CLOAK OF
Social
Responsibility
Bill Simon & Blaine McCormick, PhD
In August 2005, when Hurricane Katrina ravaged Florida
and the Gulf Coast, leaving unprecedented destruction and
human misery in its wake, Walmart was one of the first
companies on the scene. Springing into action, the company
used its emergency management team and renowned logistics
capabilities to bring relief efforts to ravaged parts of New
Orleans and Mississippi. Walmart representatives arrived on
the scene long before most government agencies could react.
In an October 2005 speech entitled “Twenty First Century
Leadership,” then-Walmart CEO Lee Scott asked of his
company, “What would it take for Walmart to be that company,
at our best, all the time? What if we used our size and resources
to make this country and this earth an even better place for
all of us: customers, associates, our children, and generations
unborn? What would that mean? Could we do it? Is this
consistent with our business model? What if the very things
that many people criticize us for—our size and reach—became
a trusted friend and ally to all, just as it did in Katrina?”
Using the experience with Katrina as a springboard, Lee
Scott led Walmart to take an active role in the environmental
sustainability movement. Walmart, by most measures, has had
a significant impact in moving sustainability to the mainstream
consciousness of the consumer.
Taking a stand on something like Katrina, or even the
TexasCEOMagazine.com
35
environment, still allows a company to avoid some measure
of controversy. After all, who is opposed to hurricane relief?
Further, the sustainability movement is seen favorably by most
Americans. However, since Lee Scott moved Walmart into
sustainability in 2005, CEOs have increasingly taken more
controversial positions on issues that historically have been off
limits. We have seen Target take a position on gender identity
and bathrooms, CVS on cigarettes, and more recently, Walmart
and Dick’s Sporting Goods on guns.
Though the issues may be new, American business leaders have
been engaging in social issues for well over a century. In 1914, Ford
Motor Company announced that it would pay a minimum wage of
$5 per day—more than double the industry wage at the time—and
later reduced the workday from nine-hour shifts to eight-hour
shifts. Contemporaries praised founder Henry Ford as a great
humanitarian, but Ford claimed that humanitarianism had nothing
to do with it. He was setting policies to attract and keep the best
possible workforce he could—and refused to frame his business
decisions as socially responsible. In his memoir, My Life and Work,
he explains, “The payment of high wages fortunately contributes
to the low costs because the men become steadily more efficient on
account of being relieved of outside worries. The payment of five
dollars a day for an eight-hour day was one of the finest cost-cutting
moves we ever made, and the six-dollar day wage is cheaper than
the five. How far this will go, we do not know.” In 1915, however,
Ford would start taking controversial activist stances on how to end
World War I, would run unsuccessfully for Senate in 1918, and in
the 1920s would publish anti-Semitic material in his newspaper,
The Dearborn Independent.
CEOs are not the only activists in the business community,
though. Author Jeff Gramm contends that shareholder activism
has been alive and well in the United States since Benjamin
Graham clashed with Northern Pipeline in 1927, pressuring
the company to distribute excess cash to shareholders. Gramm
chronicles that history in his recent book, Dear Chairman.
Shareholder activists can be very pro-shareholder like Benjamin
Graham or more pro-consumer like Ralph Nader, who grew
toward shareholder activism in his later years. Milton Friedman
captured some of the history between activist shareholders
and activist CEOs in his now 50-year-old essay, “The Social
Responsibility of Business Is to Increase Its Profits.” Specifically,
he noticed how corporate executives would raise wages “to be
a socially responsible business” when it was clearly in their
self-interest to raise wages to attract better talent and reduce
shrinkage or sabotage. He also observed that, more blatantly,
executives frame corporate donations as efforts to improve their
36 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
Feature
A convoy of Walmart trucks waited to enter New Orleans on Sept. 1, 2005,
after the city was battered by Hurricane Katrina. Government agencies said the
massive storm taught them that big-box retailers need to be an integral part of
hurricane preparation and relief efforts.
Nicholas Kamm/AFP/Getty Images
communities rather than as self-interested gifts that maximize
their tax deductions. In his essay, Friedman coined the term “the
cloak of social responsibility” to describe how CEOs transform
self-interested actions into exercises in social consciousness.
So, CEOs taking positions on social issues and committing
corporate resources to support these positions is nothing
new. The relationship between CEO and shareholders took
its most recent turn on August 19, 2019, when 181 CEOs
signed the Business Roundtable’s “Statement on the Purpose
of a Corporation.” The statement posits that a company has
stakeholders beyond its shareholders and that profit and return
is not its only objective. This is an extreme departure from the
historical objective of a company: it has long been held that
fiduciary duty to the shareholder is the driving factor in the
strategic objectives of a company. Some even argue that acting
on behalf of “stakeholders” who are not shareholders may
violate that fiduciary responsibility. Yet at least one signatory
of the agreement has doubled down on its commitment to
social responsibility. Almost two months after the release of the
“Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation,” Amazon created
a webpage outlining “Our Positions” on a wide variety of social
issues, including the minimum wage, climate change, and
immigration.
What would motivate CEOs and their respective companies to
take controversial positions? Companies, especially publicly
traded companies, live and die on quarterly and annual results.
A few percentage points on the top or bottom line can mean the
creation or destruction of billions of dollars of value. Many of the
controversial issues that are in the public eye today reflect the
split that exists in our country. The split is not only political—that
is, Democratic or Republican—but also geographical: the two
coasts versus the vast middle. We see a bifurcation in our cities
versus our rural areas, in our age demographics, and in our racial
makeup. Against this backdrop, taking a position on an issue
could have a massive impact on a company. Companies taking
positions on political issues (or politicians) can find themselves
on the wrong side very quickly. Since World War II, the majority
party in Congress has changed seven times (even more if you count
only one party controlling either the House or the Senate) and the
presidency has changed parties nine times. If you are going to take
a position, be sure it is one that you can stand on, because recent
history has shown that political cycles are much shorter than
business cycles.
Across two centuries of American business history and
thousands of executives, CEO activism remains a relatively rare
activity, with only a handful of CEOs—public or private—ever
TexasCEOMagazine.com
37
5 Things
TO CONSIDER BEFORE TAKING AN ACTIVIST STANCE
Before jumping into the activist role, here are
some things you should consider:
1. CEO activism remains a rare phenomenon. Despite lots
of press to the contrary, CEO activism remains an exceptional
activity. In 2018, researchers at the Stanford Graduate School
of Business surveyed 3,544 CEOs and found that the vast
majority never go on the record regarding social or political issues
in a meaningful way. Only 12 percent of S&P 1500 company
CEOs engage in activism, and much of this activity was less
controversial (i.e., surprisingly mainstream) than headlines such
as “The New CEO Activism” might suggest. And the Stanford
researchers surveyed only publicly traded companies, not the far
more numerous group of private businesses, where CEOs can
more easily avoid publicity. So, if you’re not receiving outside
pressure to engage in CEO activism, don’t let your internal team
talk you into it without clear and compelling reasons.
2. Potential backlash requires preparation. Activist executives
go at least as far back in American history as Thomas McKenney
and John Jacob Astor’s differing views on Native Americans and
the fur trade of the early 1800s. The difference today is the speed
at which social pressure can be brought to bear. Social media and
the 24-hour news cycle have changed the model. CEOs almost
immediately know when something has gone viral as tweets and
retweets begin to rain down in indescribable quantities. Protests,
email campaigns, and boycotts can organize in an instant and
have an impact not only on business but on organizational morale
and dynamics. Several years ago, Target responded to internal
and external pressure and made an activist decision regarding the
use of restrooms by transgender individuals. A boycott followed
swiftly and Target would spend $20 million to install private
bathrooms in stores. Thankfully, CEO statements and company
positions can also be disseminated in seconds, changing the
narrative instantly. Being prepared is key. The blade of corporate
activism swings in both directions, but the speed at which it does
can be dizzying.
3. CEOs can advocate for state or national economic issues
instead. CEO activism is framed as a political activity, even
though it is far removed from the political decisions made by
executive, legislative, and judicial players in Texas or Washington,
DC. In fact, the Stanford survey intentionally disregarded CEO
advocacy on matters such as trade negotiations, tariffs, and
corporate tax rates. Yet these are the very things that CEOs can
address far more effectively than political actors can. It’s almost
like asking CEOs to do the job of Congress and vice versa. Who is
speaking out to create economic environments where businesses
can flourish? Texas is such a place at present, but so was
Michigan at one time. Rather than becoming embroiled in social
issues, you might consider speaking out on an economic issue
that’s important to you or your business. Be mindful, however,
that even seemingly benign topics can be met with resistance.
Walmart’s recent efforts to encourage US manufacturing have
been a contributor to the resurgence of US-based production.
Surprisingly, some critics accused Walmart of trying to minimize
its reliance on Chinese imports. Others said that those were not
the kind of jobs we wanted back in the US. Even when you think
everyone will be on board, activism will often result in criticism.
4. Private ownership affords special freedoms. Founded in
1972, Hobby Lobby had almost 200 stores when it initiated its
policy of closing on Sundays in 1998. The company later noted
that it estimated $100 million in lost sales when it made the
decision. Company leadership could have put on the “cloak of
social responsibility” and stated that they did this for the sake
of climate change (reduced energy usage and less car travel to
their stores) or to take a stance against war (by promoting peace
and mindfulness among its workforce). But, largely because it
is a privately owned company, Hobby Lobby’s leadership felt
comfortable clearly communicating that they implemented this
policy for religious reasons—the least favorably regarded category
of corporate activism according to the Stanford survey. Similarly,
Chick-fil-A’s religion-based decision to stay closed on Sunday
would be very difficult if it were a public company. As a private
company, Chick-fil-A can make the decision to forgo its Sunday
earnings without pressure from shareholders.
5. The cloak of social responsibility increases the risk of
political capture. The objective of any CEO activism should be
to take a position that benefits the corporation as well as society
as a whole. As Friedman pointed out, CEOs often don the cloak
of social responsibility to earn public goodwill for decisions
that ultimately serve the interests of the business. These two
things can be very difficult to separate. Friedman would argue
that when CEOs allow “social responsibility” to dominate
their decision making, the result is to “extend the scope of the
political mechanism to every human activity”—meaning that the
corporation becomes a tool for certain social interests and can
thus open itself to political influence. Why, for example, would
legislatures pass potentially controversial gun control legislation
when they could pressure CEOs to take their preferred stances
instead? CEOs can minimize the risk of political capture by using
the cloak sparingly and being up front about the benefits of this
activity to their companies.
38 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
Feature
announcing a public position on a political matter. Though some
headlines claim that CEOs are “breaking with tradition” and
taking stances on social issues, ours are not the first corporate
executives to assume the cloak of social responsibility.
For years, Harry Potter was forced to live in a cupboard under
the stairs while his hosts blamed him for all manner of their
unhappiness. Along the way, he goes to wizarding school,
hones some of his powers, and is given a Cloak of Invisibility.
Ultimately, he realizes that he’s a very powerful wizard who
doesn’t really need a Cloak of Invisibility to succeed—though that
cloak certainly proved useful on several occasions. Somewhat
like Harry Potter, US corporations live in a cupboard under
the stairs, are blamed for all manner of societal evils, and are
often reminded of their status as guests. Note that the Business
Roundtable’s “Statement on the Purpose of a Corporation”
starts and ends with the hosts: “Americans” and “our country,”
respectively. Like Harry Potter’s invisibility cloak, the cloak of
social responsibility might prove useful from time to time when
troubles come—so use it as you must. However, our hope is
that US corporations remember that their true power remains
in generating long-term value for shareholders. The ultimate
statement a CEO can make is staying in business.
Bill Simon is the former President and CEO of Walmart, US. He is currently a Senior Advisor with KKR and Executive in Residence at Baylor University.
Blaine McCormick is Chair of the Department of Management at the Hankamer School of Business at Baylor University.
4 APPROACHES TO CEO ACTIVISM
PUBLIC
COMPANY
PRIVATE
COMPANY
ACTIVISM-INCLINED
The Cloak of Social
Responsibility
(e.g., the 2019 Business
Roundtable statement)
Engagement Strategy
(e.g., Patagonia and
environmental activism)
ACTIVISM-DISINCLINED
Maximize Long-Term
Shareholder Value
(e.g., Apple during Steve
Jobs’ 1997–2011 tenure)
Separation Strategy
(e.g., Chick-fil-A and
LGBTQ+ issues)
Imagine a product that has an 18-month lifecycle and is constructed
with many rare-earth (or “conflict”) metals. The product is not
easy to recycle given the complexity of its construction, and
the company continues to raise the price of newly introduced
models. Further, the product’s company gives virtually no money
to charitable causes. Its leadership states that it is the company’s
product, not tax-deductible donations, that will make a difference
in the world. You’ve probably guessed by now that this is Apple
Computer and the iPhone during Steve Jobs’ tenure. During that
time, Apple created billions upon billions of dollars of value for
shareholders by focusing on two fundamentals: making insanely
great products and delighting customers. At his best, Ford took
a very similar approach, stating, “Most certainly business and
charity cannot be combined; the purpose of a factory is to
produce, and it ill serves the community in general unless it does
produce to the utmost of its capacity.” These are both examples
of one approach to the issue of CEO activism: focus squarely on
maximizing long-term shareholder value while taking no substantive
positions. This is just one of four places a CEO might find himor
herself on the above matrix. Let’s explore the other three:
Separation Strategy: After navigating a period of intense criticism
centered on founder S. Truett Cathy’s support for “traditional
marriage,” Chick-fil-A released this statement in July of 2012:
“We are a restaurant company focused on food, service, and
hospitality; our intent is to leave the policy debate over samesex
marriage to the government and political arena.” As a private
company, they clearly showed that they will separate business
and political issues and not allow others to force their integration.
Though Cathy did dip his toe into activism, the company has
since modeled the Separation Strategy to distance itself from
criticism. At present, they have pretty much stayed focused
on “food, service, and hospitality,” even as protests roiled
restaurant openings throughout their expansion into Canada.
Engagement Strategy: For decades, Patagonia has leveraged its
position as a private company to say and do things important
to its founder, Yvon Chouinard. The company is clearer than
ever that “we’re in business to save our home planet.” In a
recent interview, Chouinard even noted that when it comes
down to two candidates for a job, they hire the person most
committed to saving the planet. Fully engaging in social
activism has associated costs and benefits, but Patagonia
works hard to align company activities with its core values.
The Cloak of Social Responsibility: The 2019 Business Roundtable
statement is a good recent example of the “cloak of social
responsibility,” often worn to relieve political pressures or
to transform self-interested activities into something that
seems less shareholder-focused. CEOs of public companies
can and have used the cloak in tough situations. CEOs might
find that it promotes both brand loyalty and employee loyalty
but increases the risk of being captured by political actors.
TexasCEOMagazine.com
39
HOW BUSINESSES EXPERIENCE TEXAS
ATTEND
SPONSOR
GET INVOLVED
OMNI FRISCO HOTEL AT THE STAR | SEPTEMBER 24, 2020
PRESENTING SPONSOR
FOR TICKETS, ROOMS, AND MORE INFORMATION VISIT:
YTEXAS.COM/SUMMIT
[PERFORMANCE]
DESIGNING
AN EFFECTIVE
SALES
PROMOTION
Kirk Wakefield, PhD
LESSONS FROM
TEAM SPORTS
MARKETING
When a fan buys a ticket to a professional sporting event, they
have learned to expect some form of promotion. This trend
reflects a larger shift in the sports world, as promoters work to
make the experience more entertaining rather than relying solely
upon team performance to attract fans. Today, promoters are
on a continual search for the next big promotional idea and, so
far, the most effective appears to be . . . bobbleheads. Seriously.
Past and current research on the effects of single-game
promotions in Major League Baseball finds that the following
have the strongest effects on attendance (in order):
• Bobbleheads
• Combination of giveaway and special event
• Combination of two or more special events
• Giveaway valued at $5 or more
• Giveaway valued at less than $5
• Price discounts
• Single special event 1
What is the common denominator here? All but one of the items
in this list (price discounts) add value to the experience.
Bobbleheads, for example, give fans the opportunity to exhibit
the passion they have for the team when they put them on
display at the office or at home. Giveaways can add value
to the experience as well. Fans prefer giveaways that are in
some way related to the event (e.g., bats, gloves, and caps for
baseball) 2 —this fuels the fantasy and feelings they associate
with the experience. Special events like concerts or celebrity
appearances, especially when combined with giveaways
or another event (e.g., a pre-game concert and post-game
fireworks), also have great impact on the experience.
The idea is to make promotional events truly memorable
experiences that excite fans rather than just offering another
forgettable promotion. Assuming a brand sponsors the promotion,
the extent to which the experience provokes strong internal
(sensations, feelings, and thoughts) and behavioral responses
determines the benefit to the brand. 3 Not surprisingly, again, price
discounts come near last in the previous list, as the price cut offers
only economic and no direct emotional or experiential benefits.
TexasCEOMagazine.com
41
The Characteristics of a Well-Designed Promotion
Adding value is important to think about in designing any sales
promotion, whether for a sports event or not. But it’s only one of
the factors to think about. Well-designed sales promotions have five
characteristics, which you can remember with the acronym CASES:
Clear target and objective
Adds value
Simple
Experiential
Sponsored
The best way to see how this plays out is to look at an example.
Lexus hits all the above points with a promotion offering Lexus
owners complimentary valet parking at Globe Life Park in
Arlington for all Texas Rangers home games. This promotion:
• has a clear target and objective; in this
case to reinforce loyalty to its brand among
Lexus owners who attend Rangers games.
• adds value by offering a service perceived to be
worth the $30 charged all other car owners (but
does nothing to reduce perceived ticket value).
• is simple to understand: “I give them my car
before the game and I pick it up after the game.”
• is experiential: “Wow, I can drop myself off
at the gate and walk right into the game.”
• is clearly sponsored with prominent signage and
Lexus uniformed attendants at drop-off and pickup.
Over the years since initiating this popular promotion, Lexus
has improved the process by requesting mobile phone numbers
via text and generating social media engagement, as well as
connecting the promotion directly to the local Lexus dealer.
Ideally, a well-designed promotion should also include data
capture. While it’s always desirable to collect customer contact
information (cell phones, emails, or social media), it is not
always feasible. There may be a trade-off between offering a
simple service and adding a complicating factor that aids data
capture. Proper positioning of the data capture request can
assist in the process. For example, attendants could inquire
among new visitors, including non-Lexus owners who pay for
the valet, “May we exchange mobile phone numbers to make
certain we provide you with the best service possible? Here is
our number at the valet station. Check the box on the form if
you want to hear about other great service offers from Lexus.”
Adding Real Value
As you design your own sales promotions, remember that adding
value—the A in CASES—does not mean reducing prices. That said,
the perception of value is in the eye of the beholder. Focus groups
or online panels can help you gauge fan or customer reactions
before you spend valuable resources on ineffective promotions.
Sometimes sponsors and corporate salespeople come up with
ideas that might have made sense on the golf course or at dinner
with perhaps one too many drinks, but ultimately don’t add value
to the experience. Too often these “creative” promotions have
poor perceived value due to a variety of reasons, including low
payout odds and associated low payoff value. Take the time the
Detroit Pistons partnered with Arby’s. The promotion involved
giving away small curly fries if (1) a player scored a tripledouble,
(2) fans printed out the box score from the paper, and
(3) then went to Arby’s to redeem. Fans waited over nine years
until Greg “Curly Fries” Monroe recorded a triple-double. The
point is that marketers must develop promotions that deliver
certainty of positive outcomes and experiences at the event.
Crazy promotions such as this may add some entertainment value,
but they do less to reinforce loyalty to the team and organization.
The promotions that add real value are typically experiential. Shirt
giveaways for a “color-out,” with all fans wearing the home-team
colors, add value to the experience at the event. So do promotions
where sponsoring retailers offer tickets to team practices held
at outside facilities (e.g., WNBA teams practicing at a college to
generate interest), which add value in an experience all its own.
The primary thing to remember about the sales promotion—
and the lesson every CEO can take from sports promotions—is
that the strongest offers add value to the experience. You
want to help your customers create lasting memories they
associate with your brand, not just give them a chance to pocket
the money from a discount and forget about it forever.
Kirk Wakefield is the Edwin W. Streetman Professor of Retail Marketing and executive director of Sports Sponsorship & Sales at Baylor’s
Hankamer School of Business. His research in retailing, covering more than two decades, focuses primarily upon sports psychology, team sports
marketing, entertainment marketing, and fan and consumer response to pricing and promotional tools. He has conducted fan research in almost
every venue in sports, including the NBA, NFL, MLB, MLS, NHL, and NASCAR. Wakefield is the author of Team Sports Marketing, now widely
used in universities nationwide and available online at www.teamsportsmarketing.com.
1
Thomas C. Boyd and Timothy C. Krehbiel (2006), “An Analysis of the Effects of Specific Promotion Types on Attendance at Major League Baseball Games,” Mid-American
Journal of Business, 21 (2), 21–32.
2
Kirk L. Wakefield and Victoria Bush (1998), “Promoting Leisure Services: Economic and Emotional Aspects of Consumer Response,” Journal of Services Marketing, 12 (3),
209–222.
3
Zarontonello & Schmitt (2013), “The Impact of Event Marketing on Brand Equity,” International Journal of Advertising, 32 (May), 255–280.
42 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
THE
NEGLECTED
[SELF-AWARENESS]
KEY
TO STRESS
MANAGEMENT
J. Michael Godfrey, PhD
Meet Nathaniel. Nate wants to be successful and respected
at work but not lose himself, his family, or other things
he values in the process. He’s hardworking and was very
successful in his job. As a result, the board promoted him
to CEO, which seemed glamorous to Nate, and he was sure
it would bring money, prestige, power, and recognition.
He looked forward to greater happiness and success.
IF YOU WANT TO
MANAGE STRESS TO
YOUR ADVANTAGE, ESTABLISH
A SOLID FOUNDATION OF
GROWING SELF-AWARENESS.
Very soon, Nate found himself facing the realities of the job.
He was paying less attention to his self-care and his family.
He struggled to get everything done. After about 16 months
in the new position, Nate was depressed, having panic
attacks, and showing all the signs of burnout. He was irritable
and impatient with his family, and angry more often than
usual. He had headaches often, wasn’t sleeping, and had a
cold he couldn’t shake. He had more trouble concentrating
and paying attention than usual and he frequently lost
track of important things. He came to tears more quickly
than typical for him. Disenchanted, he was not sure why
it had to be this way. There ought to be a better way.
How Has It Been for You?
How has being CEO been for you? Challenging and fulfilling?
Stressful?
TexasCEOMagazine.com
43
Who gave you the heads-up on the unrelenting stress of the
CEO job—the demands of global business, the requirement
to be “always on,” and the travel involved? How about the
frequent frustration, disappointment, irritation, overwhelm,
isolation, loneliness, and the effects of all this on your health
and well-being? How about the pressure on your family life?
to pay undivided attention to what you are experiencing in the
moment, in the various aspects of your being—as objectively as
possible—and being open to new experiences of growth. Such
attentiveness is a disciplined process that one must learn. As
awareness grows, you can take time to understand the source(s)
of these experiences as well as their present and potential effect.
Do you recognize stress when it shows up in you? Do you
know the essentials of managing the stress of the job?
To Manage Stress, Increase Self-Awareness
If you want to manage stress to your advantage, establish a
solid foundation of growing self-awareness. All other stress
management efforts are built on this foundation. Yet, many stress
management techniques skip over self-awareness and treat only
symptoms. As a result, they do not yield long-term results.
I work with people like Nate (and like you) in coaching
relationships to
support their growth
in self-awareness
and help them
manage the stress of
the CEO job. They
learn to increase
their self-awareness,
critically examine
their situation, and
implement stress management strategies and techniques that help
them put stress to work for their advantage. They come out on
the other side with a clearer focus, a better pace of life, increasing
quality in their relationships, and ultimately, greater success.
Pay Attention to Your Whole Being
The term self-awareness is most commonly used to refer to a
person’s awareness of their inner states and how those states
express themselves, which is very important in leadership
and life. Some have suggested that self-awareness is “both a
tool and a goal” and I agree that it is just that important and
beneficial. 1 “The ability to reflect on and accurately assess one’s
own behaviors and skills as they are manifested in workplace
interactions” is a characteristic of high-performing managers,
according to the organizational psychologist Allan Church. 2 And
self-awareness can improve your overall sense of well-being. 3
Here, I am using a broader idea of self-awareness, one that
involves your whole being—physical, emotional, mental,
spiritual. This type of self-awareness is foundational
for the management of your stress, for improving your
persistence in distress, 4 and for living and relating well.
Helpful self-awareness is not neurotic rumination about an
issue or getting stuck in the negative; that dynamic can lead
to greater anxiety and depression. 5 Helpful self-awareness
involves getting to know yourself more deeply by taking time
A growing self-awareness can help you learn to recognize
signals of stress and appreciate them for what they are.
Then you can choose a positive, helpful path of action.
If you are not self-aware, you can miss these signals. Then, stress
can become unhealthy, leading to burnout, ineffectiveness, and
depression with accompanying low energy. If allowed to continue
unmanaged, the stress can wreck your health and even kill you.
If you have been in the red zone of stress for a while now, you have
likely come to accept it as a “new normal.” You may not be aware
of how far you have driven yourself up the distress ladder until it
seriously affects your
health, relationships,
and work
effectiveness. Most
people wait until the
train is completely
off the tracks
before thinking
of getting help.
A GROWING SELF-AWARENESS
CAN HELP YOU LEARN TO
RECOGNIZE SIGNALS OF STRESS AND
APPRECIATE THEM FOR WHAT THEY ARE.
Stress Is Natural and Normal
Stress is a natural and normal part of being human. You
need a little stress all the time to assist you in meeting the
demands of life and work. But you can get too much of a
good thing. Your brain does countless things without your
conscious knowledge, and one of these is to trigger the
stress reaction based on your unique version of reality. 6
Your brain is always on alert, rapidly scanning the environment,
checking to see if you are safe or in danger and working to
minimize danger and maximize reward. Five times per second,
life events trigger nonconscious emotions. 7 As it scans your
surroundings, the brain may predict that danger is present
and “throw a switch,” so to speak, to prepare you to fight, run,
or hide. All of this happens outside your consciousness.
When your brain throws the switch, your first awareness will
be a feeling. Physically, you will feel it in your gut and your
chest, and through physical symptoms such as rapid heart rate
and elevated blood pressure. Emotionally, you will feel it as
anger, fear, or frustration. These experiences can range from a
little discomfort to a full fight, flight, or freeze reaction. 8 Once
you have this conscious feeling, which is about half a second 9
after the brain “throws the switch,” you are in a position to
choose how you will behave. You can let the fight-flight-freeze
reaction run its course, or you can choose another behavior.
44 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
The brain sometimes makes good predictions that are helpful
and even lifesaving. In cases of physical threat, the fight-flightfreeze
reaction is essential and must run its course if you are
to react fast enough to escape danger. But the brain often
makes bad predictions and erroneously prepares our bodies to
fight, run, or hide. Bad predictions can occur in interpersonal
relationships, in various social settings and situations, and
in response to other issues such as schedules, deadlines,
disagreements, and personality or style differences. In these
cases, the fight-flight-freeze reaction is not necessary, productive,
or helpful. It is better to engage your problem-solving abilities
to make a different choice than fighting, running, or hiding.
Stress Is Like Fever
Just as you don’t choose to have a fever, you don’t choose
to have stress. Your body produces it automatically when
needed. It’s a signal, a symptom, showing that something
unusual is present—a perceived threat, something unfamiliar,
something that pushes the limits of your capacity.
As with fever, once you recognize your stress as a symptom,
you don’t panic every time it happens. Instead, you can use this
self-awareness to manage the situation with problem-solving
skills, trying to get back to “normal.” In the future, you can avoid
whatever precipitated your stress and hopefully prevent it.
But if your stress remains unchecked, it can become contagious,
affecting not only you but also those around you—your
spouse, children, colleagues, and others. Your stress can
create distress for them as they witness your misery, dodge
your defensive behavior, or catch the brunt of your fury.
Cognitive Impairment and Stress
When you are in a stressed, defensive posture (feeling
the urge to fight, run, or hide, which for some of us
is most of the time), your brain is channeling your
mental and bodily resources away from critical thought,
problem solving, and self-management. As a result:
• Your ability to concentrate, learn, think, hear,
communicate, and see problems clearly declines
dramatically.
• A demand for certainty replaces curiosity and creativity.
• Your perspective narrows. You tend to
oversimplify, minimize, and neutralize problems,
and you lose the big picture as a result.
• You look for a scapegoat to blame when things go wrong.
Imagine how these things can affect your leadership, especially
in times of crisis. Fortunately, if you are growing in selfawareness,
you will learn to recognize these symptoms
of stress and choose better, more rational responses.
How to Improve Your Self-Awareness
• Practice mindfulness. To be mindful is to pay deep,
intentional attention to what’s going on in the moment,
inside and around you. It means paying attention to
what’s going on in your mind (not just your brain) 10 —
to your thoughts, motives, defenses, emotions, physical
states, and how all of this might affect you and others.
Increased reflection results in increased self-development.
TexasCEOMagazine.com
45
• Use reflection questions.
o Reflect on your practice. At various times during
the day, especially at the end, take time to think back
through your interactions. Examine the beliefs you
espouse compared to beliefs you act out, your thoughts,
sensations, reactions, and emotions. Ask “what” and
“how” questions to understand how these played out.
o Reflect in your practice. Monitor the above aspects
of your being while you are working and interacting
in real time. Present-tense versions of your endof-day
questions work well to guide real-time
reflection. Find questions for reflection here:
https://discoveryourtruecourse.com/
resources/questions_for_reflection.
• Exercise discipline.
o Throughout the day, take breaks and replace thoughts
of work with positive thoughts about something
or someone you appreciate. Be grateful for them.
o Stay present during interactions with others. Pay
attention to what others say without judging them,
letting your biases distort the message, or having
an inner side conversation with yourself. Avoid
jumping to quick conclusions, correcting, or
trying to fix. Stay curious. Be open to new
and unfamiliar ideas and ways of doing things.
o Practice behavioral agility, which is the ability
to modulate your behavior, especially stress
behavior, to best serve a particular situation.
• Learn how others see you.
o Have conversations with others you trust to
see if your beliefs about yourself are accurate.
You may not feel comfortable opening up to your
coworkers, your board, or even at home. If so,
get a coach, a counselor, or a trusted advisor.
o If you think others may be guarded in their
opinion, engage a third party to facilitate
a qualitative 360° interview process.
• Be courageously honest with yourself, even
if it’s painful. Celebrate the good. Correct
thoughts and actions as required.
• Try keeping a journal of your thoughts and reflections.
A FEW OF MY FAVORITE
REFLECTION QUESTIONS
In any specific situation:
• How else could I look at this?
• What were my clear expectations?
• What impact did my inner conversations have on
my effectiveness?
• How open am I to learning?
• How stuck am I in my way of thinking?
• How true am I to my values?
• What triggered the emotions I experienced?
• What positive impact did I have?
The CEO job is stressful, but that doesn’t mean you have
to be constantly miserable. You don’t have to give up your
sense of self, your family, or the other things you value.
Any solution for stress management, as I have outlined
above, always starts with self-awareness. As you build
your self-awareness and lower your stress, remember
that few of us, if any, can grow our self-awareness on our
own. Once you find that trusted person or people to be
your partner in building self-awareness—and to hold you
accountable for sticking to the process—you have taken the
critical first step to managing stress in the long term.
J. Michael Godfrey, DMin, PhD, PCC, is the founder and president of True Course. He supports leaders to be more, see more, and achieve
more that matters in their personal lives and professional lives, and helps them posture themselves to finish without regret. True Course
supports executives as they lead their organizations to become places where people love to work, serve, and be customers. He is the author
of Without Regret: Be More, See More, Achieve More that Matters and Put Stress to Work: Turning Headaches into Advantages. For more
information visit DiscoverYourTrueCourse.com. Contact Dr. Godfrey at discover@discoveryourtruecourse.com.
1
Fenigstein, A., Scheier, M. F., & Buss, A. H. (1975). “Public and Private Self-Consciousness:
Assessment and Theory.” Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 43(4), 522–527. http://
dx.doi.org/10.1037/h0076760
2
Church, A. H. (1997). “Managerial Self-Awareness in High-Performing Individuals in
Organizations.” Journal of Applied Psychology, 82(2), 281–292. http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/0021–
9010.82.2.281
3
Kelly Richards, C. Campenni, and Janet Muse-Burke (2010) “Self-Care and Well-Being in Mental
Health Professionals: The Mediating Effects of Self-Awareness and Mindfulness.” Journal of
Mental Health Counseling: July 2010, Vol. 32, No. 3, pp. 247–264. https://doi.org/10.17744/
mehc.32.3.0n31v88304423806
4
Feldman, G., Dunn, E., Stemke, C., Bell, K., & Greeson, J. (2014). “Mindfulness and Rumination
as Predictors of Persistence with a Distress Tolerance Task.” Personality and individual
differences, 56, 10.1016/j.paid.2013.08.040. doi:10.1016/j.paid.2013.08.040
5
Trapnell, P. D., & Campbell, J. D. (1999). “Private Self-Consciousness and the Five-Factor Model
of Personality: Distinguishing Rumination from Reflection.” Journal of Personality and Social
Psychology, 76, 284–304. http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.76.2.284
6
Barrett, L.F. (2017). How emotions are made: The secret life of the brain. New York: Houghton
Mifflin Harcourt Publishing, p. 25–29 (Kindle Version).
7
Gordon, E. (2016). The Brain Revolution: Know and Train New Brain Habits. Indianapolis: Dog
Ear Publishing, p. 11–12.
8
For more on stress symptoms see Godfrey, J. M. (2016). Put Stress to Work: Turning Headaches to
advantages. Willmington, DE: Thomas Noble, chapter 3: How Stress Shows Up to Work, pp. 23—32.
9
Gordon, pp. 11–12.
10
Lisa Feldman Barrett suggests that the “mind” is “a computational moment within your
constantly predicting brain.” Barrett, L.F. (2017). How Emotions are Made: The Secret Life of the
Brain. New York: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt Publishing, p. 280 (Kindle Version).
46 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
SELF-AWARENESS
[SELF-AWARENESS]
AND THE CEO
How do we gain insight about ourselves
when people are reluctant to tell us the truth?
A stranger approaching you in the street will in a second’s glance
see you whole, size you up, place you in a way in which you cannot
and never will, even though you have spent a lifetime with yourself . . .
Tasha Eurich, PhD
and therefore ought to know yourself best of all.
—Walker Percy
The saying that “feedback is a gift” is such a painful cliché that
we often forget how true it really is. As leaders, we need not only
the self-awareness that comes from looking inward—we also need
what I call “external self-awareness.” That comes from turning
our gaze outward to understand how we are seen. And no matter
how hard we try, we simply cannot do this on our own. We need
that gift of feedback from the people around us, whether it’s an
employee, a board member, a CEO at a different organization,
or even a total stranger. Unfortunately, though, learning how
others see us is usually thwarted by one simple fact: even the
people we’re closest to are reluctant to share such information.
We all need the “gift of feedback” for one simple reason: other
people generally see us more objectively than we see ourselves.
Psychologist Timothy Smith and his colleagues powerfully
demonstrated this in a study with 300 married couples in which
both partners were being tested for heart disease. They asked
each participant to rate both their own and their partner’s levels
of anger, hostility, and argumentativeness—all strong predictors
of the illness—and found that people’s self-ratings were infinitely
less accurate than those of their spouses. Another study asked
more than 150 Navy officers and their subordinates to rate the
officers’ leadership style, and found that only the subordinates could
accurately assess their bosses’ performance and promotability.
WHETHER OR NOT WE RUN
A MULTIBILLION-DOLLAR
COMPANY, PROTECTING OUR FRAGILE
EGOS BY DECIDING WE ARE RIGHT AND
OTHERS ARE WRONG CAN BE RISKY.
TexasCEOMagazine.com
47
Three Actionable Strategies
for Building Self-Awareness
360º
FEEDBACK
THE RIGHT
FEEDBACK
PROCESS
THE DINNER
OF TRUTH
nearly instantaneously he noticed that something was different.
Casual chatter had a habit of going silent whenever he entered the
room. He was getting mostly good news and hardly any bad news.
And his team was no longer inviting him to their social gatherings.
The most popular and
well-known method
for soliciting feedback
in the business world—
and worth every CEO’s
time as a tool for
understanding how
they are perceived.
It’s not the “be-all,
end-all,” though: the
numeric outputs can
sometimes be difficult
to interpret and put
into action.
All feedback is not
created equal: we have
to choose the RIGHT
people, ask them the
RIGHT questions,
and use the RIGHT
process to get valuable
information.
Find the “loving critics”
in your life—the people
who care about you but
are willing to be brutally
honest—and then ask
them specific questions
to solicit real insight.
Josh Misner, a professor
and a prominent member
of the Good Men
Project, recommends
a practice for gaining
self-awareness in our
personal lives.
Invite a friend, family
member, or mentor to a
meal, and ask them the
thing that bugs them
most about you. Tell
them that anything is fair
game—and that you will
listen with openness, not
get defensive.
Catmull didn’t like this very much. He didn’t feel like a different
person than University of Utah Ed or New York Tech Ed. But he
realized that his new role as The Boss, coupled with his increasing
prominence in the academic community, had changed the way
people perceived him. He told me, “I recognized that, okay, this
is the way it is, and it will probably get worse over time.” The
reluctance to speak up was presenting a giant obstacle not just in
his own performance, but to the collective self-awareness of his
team. Since then, Catmull has made it a top-tier priority to combat
this reluctance and seek the honest truth, not just about himself
as a leader, but about the challenges and issues his company is
facing. And it has made quite a difference. He now says that one
of his core tenets is what he calls “leading by being self-aware.”
Developing external self-awareness becomes particularly critical,
yet infinitely more difficult, when you’re the boss, and especially
when you’re the CEO. Studies show that self-aware leaders are
more successful and promotable, and some research has even
shown that self-awareness is the single greatest predictor of
leadership success. The problem is, the higher up you are on the
corporate food chain, the less likely you are to be self-aware, an
affliction that’s been labeled “CEO Disease.” After all, who really
wants to tell the boss that his management style is alienating
people, or that her latest staffing choices are causing friction,
or that his clients find him controlling? Complicating matters,
the overconfidence that results from past successes can make it
challenging for leaders to hear and accept difficult feedback—
and thus make their employees more reluctant to give it.
Pixar president Ed Catmull has witnessed this reluctance to speak
truth to power firsthand. Years before he co-founded his company
and became president of Disney Animation Studios, he was a young
PhD student at the University of Utah’s nascent computer graphics
program. He adored the comradery he had with his professors and
fellow graduate students—there were no strict hierarchies, they worked
independently, and everyone generally got along. Catmull liked this
environment so much that he created a similar structure in his first
job out of school. As the head of a small computer animation research
team at the New York Institute of Technology, he hired smart people,
treated them as equals, and let them do their thing. As a result, they
told him pretty much everything that was going on. He was involved
in social activities and was basically one of the guys—it felt good.
But when Catmull was hired to lead Lucasfilm’s brand-new computer
division, he realized that he’d need to rethink how he managed people.
His new team would be bigger, better resourced, and have a much
higher profile. To achieve George Lucas’s ambitious vision of bringing
computer technology to Hollywood, Catmull reasoned, he would need
to adopt a more formal, hierarchical structure with a manager running
each of the graphics, video, and audio groups. And when he did that,
Whether or not we run a multibillion-dollar company, protecting
our fragile egos by deciding we are right and others are wrong can
be risky. Nevertheless, we fall back on the same old excuses. We tell
ourselves we’re doing fine and don’t really need the feedback. Or we
tell ourselves that asking for feedback would be weak. Or, perhaps
most understandable of all, we rely on the excuse that we just don’t
want to ask for feedback. After all, it’s scary and uncomfortable.
The good news is that we can decide to pull our heads out of the sand
and recognize that others’ opinions are just as important for insight
as our own. The best leaders push through their fear, defensiveness,
and vulnerability and go for it anyway. As U.S. President Franklin
Delano Roosevelt once opined, “Courage is not the absence of fear,
but rather the assessment that something else is more important
than fear.” In our case, that “something else” is insight.
Take the Insight Quiz
Looking to get a high-level snapshot of your own
self-awareness—and how it matches up with
how others see you? Take this 5-minute quiz, and
choose a friend to fill out the same survey for you.
You’ll get the results when both sets of data are in!
Access the quiz at www.Insight-Quiz.com.
This article is adapted from Dr. Tasha Eurich’s book, Insight: The
Surprising Truth About How Others See Us, How We See Ourselves,
and Why the Answers Matter More Than We Think (Currency). An
organizational psychologist and sought-after keynote speaker, Eurich
gives leaders around the world the tools they need to succeed in an everchanging
world. Visit www.TashaEurich.com to learn more about her.
48 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
Early bird registration (until Jan 31, 2020): $299
Regular registration (after Jan 31, 2020): $399
Registration fee includes the reception
Friday evening and lunch on Saturday.
Baylor University Executive MBA Program - Dallas
Louise Herrington School of Nursing – Academic Building
333 N. Washington Ave, Dallas, TX 75246
Have questions?
Email us at info@texasceomagazine.com and we’ll respond promptly.
To register, visit texasceomagazine.com/mar20
DO YOU ASPIRE TO BECOME A CEO?
THIS ROLE IS VERY DIFFERENT FROM EVERY OTHER C-SUITE
POSITION AND YOU NEED TO PREPARE DIFFERENTLY FOR IT.
DALLAS
Aspiring CEOs Seminar
FRIDAY, MARCH 20: 6:30 PM TO 8 PM, RECEPTION AND INTRODUCTION
SATURDAY, MARCH 21: 9 AM TO 4 PM, SEMINAR
To help aspiring chief executives, seasoned tech CEO Joel Trammell has taken his CEO training course and adapted it specifically for them.
Joel’s leadership as CEO has resulted in successful nine-figure acquisitions by two Fortune 500 companies. As CEO of network
management software firm NetQoS, he delivered 31 consecutive quarters of double-digit revenue growth and a $200 million valuation.
CA Technologies acquired the company in 2009, generating more than 10x return on capital to its private equity investors. In 2010, he
cofounded Cache IQ, a storage software company that NetApp acquired two years later.
Joel is committed to using his experience to help current and aspiring CEOs. Join us for this crash course in excelling in the CEO role—
and learn valuable lessons that will advance your career.
TESTIMONIALS:
“Joel Trammell’s CEO seminar is a must, especially for any first-time CEOs. You will learn what to expect as a CEO and the ins and outs of building a powerful
team through Joel’s real-life experience and candid feedback. You will also hear from and network with some of the more successful executive leaders in
Austin. I pull from this experience with every challenge I face—especially the ones I never expected. Go do this!”
—Denver Fredenberg, owner, Harvest Rain; former CEO, Hyperwear
“The CEO seminar was a great experience because it gives you a chance to step back from your day-to-day and think strategically with the help of Joel
Trammell. I learned tactics that I now put into action every day.”
—Chuck Gordon, CEO, Storable; former CEO, SpareFoot
“The CEO seminar was not only insightful and thought provoking on leadership styles and successful business constructs; it also afforded a unique opportunity
to interact with my peers across a variety of companies. I learned lessons I still refer to today in managing people and the culture of an organization.”
—Melanie Kalemba, former CEO, Movero Technology
HOSTED BY:
SAVE THE DATE!
October 3, 2020 • 1 pm
Come shoot clay pigeons with Texas Rangers at a private club in Austin, Texas.
This event will benefit the Texas Ranger Hall of Fame and Museum in Waco, Texas.
To put your name on the waitlist for tickets, or to inquire about sponsorships,
email us at info@texasceomagazine.com.
WHAT’S MY CMO
TALKING ABOUT?
Tony Streeter
As head of the entire organization, the CEO is expected to have a working
knowledge of each functional area of the business. But as technology
evolves at dizzying speeds, it’s not always easy to keep up. You may have
thought, for example, that you understood marketing nomenclature, but
now noticed that it’s getting harder to differentiate between a conversation
with your CMO and your CIO. Let’s take a brief tour of some of the words and
phrases your CMO is probably using these days—so you can
have an informed conversation about how the marketing
department fits into the strategic plan of your organization.
Martech (1) is the buzzword created to describe the combination
of marketing activities with technology. Although traditional
methods of advertising and marketing (billboards, ads, radio,
TV, sponsorships, direct mail, etc.) are still effective, the digital
boom has paved the way for the development of a number of
sophisticated digital tools that provide a depth of insight for the
savvy marketer. Mass marketing via standard approaches has
now been surpassed by digital marketing practices that allow for
highly targeted campaigns and detailed effectiveness reporting.
Integrating data analytics (2) with your internal customer data—
typically held in a customer relationship management (CRM)
(3)
database—and third-party data now gives you the ability to
(1) get a profile of your customer (what they buy, when they
buy, how much they are willing to pay) and (2) understand
who is buying (demographics such as age, gender, income,
and education level); where they are buying from (geolocation),
and what motivated them to buy (discount, incentive,
bundle, online content, testimonials/endorsements, etc.).
In the past, marketers relied on laborious multivariate
testing (MVT) (4) to gauge prospective customers’ reactions
to different offers, different content, and so on. Now, with
prescriptive analytics (5) , market testing has largely been
automated. Prescriptive analytics uses both descriptive
analytics (data about the past) and predictive analytics
(modeling and forecasting of what may happen in the future)
to arrive at recommended courses of action, especially
when combined with sophisticated propensity models (6) .
Machine learning (ML) (7) can also be used to automate
multivariate testing by first performing a cluster analysis that
groups variables before placing them into a multinomial logistic
regression—essentially, a method of predicting probable outcomes
given a certain set of variables. So instead of waiting weeks or
months to see what actual customers do, the proper data analytics
techniques can tell you what they are most likely to do in minutes
or seconds. Of course, the accuracy of the recommendations
depends heavily on the accuracy of your internal data and
the stringency of your data governance (8) practices.
Here are some other digital tools your CMO may be talking about:
IP Address Hyper-Targeting
Here’s a neat little development that came out around the 2016
election: IP address hyper-targeting. Every household that has
an Internet connection has a unique IP address. The digital
advertising tactic known as IP address hyper-targeting delivers
personalized content to a website user’s mobile device or desktop
based upon its physical location. IP targeting is better than
traditional geo-fencing (9) in that it targets specific households or
businesses. So, for example, a political message can be directed
TexasCEOMagazine.com
51
toward a target audience’s IP addresses (based upon voter
addresses in a database) while avoiding those who don’t wish to
see or hear it. It works by converting physical addresses into IP
addresses and then messaging to mobile devices and desktops
that use those IP addresses. Let’s say you run a B2B business
and are trying to win favor with a particular company; you can
determine their IP address and put your message in front of every
employee registered at that IP address when they go online. (For
more about how this works, take a look at www.eltoro.com.)
Converting Analytics into Directional Leads
Google Analytics can tell you a lot about how your
website is received by the general public. It can tell you
the number of sessions you’ve had, the number of unique
visitors, your bounce rate, your most popular pages, the
average time spent on your website, etc. However, this
information doesn’t directly convert into leads.
There are online sales intelligence tools that will allow you
to uncover more about your anonymous website visitors and
can help you turn Google information into directional leads.
Tools like Leadfeeder integrate with both Google and LinkedIn
and take in IP address information to provide a customized
dashboard that furnishes insights on who’s visiting your site.
The lead dashboard will show you the names of the companies
associated with the IP addresses that are visiting your website
(important for B2B companies). And, although it can’t tell you
the exact individual who visited, it can tell you what they looked
at, how long they looked, and on what date. Software can also
provide, via integration with LinkedIn, a list of the company’s
employees, their titles, and their email addresses. So, let’s say
someone from Company X spent six minutes looking at one
of your services. You could infer that Company X may have a
need for that service. Next, you would go through the list of
company contacts and select the individual or department that
would most benefit from your service, then reach out to them.
GLOSSARY
(1) Martech - A portmanteau of marketing
and technology, most often used to
describe projects and campaigns that use
technology to achieve marketing goals.
(2) Data analytics – The practice of examining
raw data sets with the objective of identifying
patterns and arriving at conclusions.
(3) Customer relationship management
(CRM) – Customer relationship
management (CRM) tools offer companies
a system of record for storing data about
and interactions with their future and
current customers.
(4) Multivariate testing (MVT) - A
technique for testing how prospects and
customers react to different combinations
52 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
of multiple variables. Similar to A/B
testing, but uses more than one variable to
arrive at the best combination of variables.
(5) Prescriptive analytics – A form of
analytics that makes prescriptions or
recommendations for future actions. While
predictive analytics can model possible
future outcomes based on historical data,
prescriptive analytics advises organizations
on the best path to take.
(6) Propensity models – A tool for
forecasting customer behavior, involving
scoring likely future customer behaviors
numerically. A higher number means the
customer is more likely to engage in the
behavior in question.
Competitor Monitoring
Competitor monitoring and analysis can be an arduous
undertaking. In the past, sporadic information would
come in from a number of sources. Sales may have known
something about a competitor’s pricing. Marketing may
have snagged a competitor’s brochure at a trade show.
Whatever was culled together told a patchy story at best.
Today, with most of a company’s information online, competitive
data can be gathered, organized, and presented more easily.
Software platforms like WatchMyCompetitor.com can now pull
product information (pricing changes, launches, availability,
retiring products), marketing information (promotions, events,
website layout changes, banner changes, online ads), social
media information (impactful posts and videos), and company
information (personnel changes, restructuring, financial results,
investor updates, new partners, new locations) and put all
of it into a concise, personalized dashboard. In addition, the
information is consistently updated, and you can set alerts for
strategic changes. You no longer have to be caught unaware.
It’s worth every CEO’s time to learn the basic language,
approaches, and tools of the modern CMO. Once you have a
working knowledge of the latest developments in marketing
technology, your conversations with your head of marketing
will be a lot less confusing—and significantly more productive.
Tony Streeter is the Chief Marketing Officer, SVP, at Y&L Consulting
Inc. in San Antonio, Texas. He has led new product development,
ecommerce marketing, and integrated platform marketing initiatives
for major companies such as Harland Clarke, Deluxe Corporation,
and RR Donnelley. Currently, Streeter leads marketing and branding
initiatives for Y&L Consulting, a comprehensive IT services and
solutions company specializing in IT development, data analytics,
emerging technologies, and help desk services.
(7) Machine learning (ML) – A subset
of artificial intelligence dealing with
computers’ ability to learn from data,
recognize patterns, and adapt to new
situations without human intervention.
(8) Data governance – The management of
an enterprise’s data, including its integrity,
security, and the various rules that govern
how it is handled.
(9) Geo-fencing – The practice of using
GPS or radio frequency identification
(RFID) to create a boundary around a
geographic area, then trigger responses
when a device enters that area.
THE SPORT OF
RELOCATION
Ed Curtis
Anyone doing business in Texas knows that the competitive landscape is changing. Out-of-state-based
businesses, from a wide array of industries, are looking to set up shop in Texas. According to the YTexas
Relo Tracker, 2018 and 2019 brought over 50 corporate headquarter relocations into the Lone Star State. If
you were to include corporate expansions, the number is well into the hundreds. Leading industries include
technology, advanced manufacturing, consumer packaged goods, and professional service firms.
In recent years, another industry has emerged in the world of corporate relocation and expansion. It’s the
sports industry. Here are six sports-related relocation and expansion projects that will shape the future
of the Lone Star State.
PGA of America — You would think Palm Beach
Gardens, Florida, would be the home of all things golf. Not so
anymore. While still maintaining a presence in South Florida,
the PGA of America is relocating its corporate headquarters
to Frisco, Texas, after more than a half century of operation.
That’s only the tip of the iceberg. The HQ will be part of a 600-
acre mixed-used development that is projected to include two
championship golf courses, a short course, Class AA office space,
and a 500-room Omni resort, to include a 127,000-squarefoot
conference center and a whole lot more. Rumor has it
there is a possibility that the PGA will bring a future Ryder Cup
to Texas. Meanwhile, the PGA Championship is slated to be
played at PGA Frisco in 2027 and 2034. Since the area hasn’t
hosted a PGA Championship since 1963, that is a big deal. This
relocation will create a ripple effect on the economy, creating
a market ripe for vendors, suppliers, players, and residents
close to the game of golf. The project will reside near US 380
and the Dallas North Tollway. When will we see this? Believe
it or not, not in the too distant future. Could be as early as
2022—with the hotel and convention center not far behind.
“PGA Frisco is destined to become the future home of American
golf,” said PGA chief operating officer Darrell Crall. “We are
working collaboratively on every step, on roads and design, making
sure we are all committing to the community and executing in a
way that everyone can be proud of. Frisco is a perfect match for
our corporate culture. The PGA of America is thrilled to bring
our headquarters and championship golf to Northern Texas.”
TexasCEOMagazine.com
53
Austin FC — In 2021, Major League Soccer
(MLS) will have a home in Austin. The Austin FC
team will be the first top-division major sports
team in the Austin area. Anthony Precourt, previous
owner of the Columbus Crew, brought Austin’s first
major league team to the city in January of 2019,
when he sealed a deal with the City of Austin to bring
the 27th MLS club to the state capital. The club is building
a new state-of-the-art soccer park and multi-use stadium
for the team in a public/private partnership with the city at
McKalla Place, near the Domain mixed-use development. The
club will also build a $45 million training facility called St.
David’s Performance Center in Northeast Austin, which will
have four full-size soccer fields and first-class amenities for the
club’s first team and academy teams. Both the stadium and St.
David’s Performance Center are scheduled to open in 2021. For
a town that falls short of a professional sports franchise, this
is huge for Austin. Season tickets can still be reserved with a
$50 refundable deposit at austinfc.com. Go get ’em.
Envy Gaming — Look no further than Dallas,
Texas, for the next wave of esports teams sweeping
the nation. Envy Gaming, which moved to Dallas
from Charlotte, North Carolina, in 2017, was recently
named the eighth most valuable esports organization
in the world. Envy acquired the Dallas Overwatch
League franchise spot in 2018, launching its Dallas Fuel
franchise. In 2019, Envy Gaming raised an additional
$20 million in VC funding and also acquired the Dallas
Call of Duty League team spot, which will debut the Dallas
Empire team in the 2020 competitive season. Esports has
exploded in popularity in recent years, with fans filling arenas to
watch players square off in popular multiplayer video game
competitions. Envy Gaming will host seven home weekends of
live esports competition in various stadiums across North Texas
in 2020. It is estimated that there are over 50 million registered
players of popular video games in the US, which creates a market
for tremendous growth. For more information, visit Envy.gg.
United States Tennis Association Texas
— If you’re a tennis fan in Texas, and that would include
me, then get ready to make some trips to Central Texas.
The United States Tennis Association (USTA) Texas is
planning to relocate its headquarters to Cedar Park, Texas.
The development project will bring around 40 outdoor and
six to eight indoor courts and be part of a 150-acre mixeduse
development. The new HQ will anchor a multibilliondollar
project (Indigo Ridge) that will encompass over five
million square feet of mixed-use development, including
dining, retail, and entertainment. The facility will be in
earshot of the major Apple expansion and will be an added
draw for more corporate relocations to the area. If this will look
anything like the USTA HQ in Florida, we’re in for a real treat.
54 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
Perfect Game — Nestled in the Austin suburb of Hutto,
Texas, will be the largest baseball development the state has
ever seen. Iowa-based scouting organization Perfect Game
is partnering with the city and other investors to anchor an
$800 million development in the City of Hutto. In addition
to the baseball facilities, the new development will feature a
200,000-square-foot indoor sports and events center designed
to seat 13,000, and a convention hotel. The organization is already
talking with major sports franchises and universities about
expanding opportunities for children to advance in the sport.
Yes, the Field of Dreams will still remain in Iowa, but about 24
baseball fields used to train students of the game will soon be here
in Central Texas. When will it be done? Some say as early as 2021.
Dallas Renegades and Houston
Roughnecks — If you are wondering if there is
any more room for football in Texas, the answer is an
astounding yes. The XFL, financed by the chairman and
CEO of the WWE, Vince McMahon, chose two of the eight
markets to launch in Texas. The two Texas teams join
Seattle, Los Angeles, New York, St. Louis, Tampa Bay,
and Washington, DC, as the league’s inaugural cities.
Texas nemesis and former OU head coach Bob Stoops
is head coach for the Dallas Renegades, with much of
the leadership coming from other Texas sports franchises,
including the Dallas Stars and Texas Rangers. The team will play
its home games at Globe Life Park in Arlington, which is being
repurposed as a football venue after its previous tenant, Major
League Baseball’s Texas Rangers, relocates to the newly built
Globe Life Field. The Houston Roughnecks will be led by former
SMU coach June Jones, with their games being held at TDECU
stadium on the University of Houston campus. The opening
season, beginning on February 9, will have a 10-week season,
with each team hosting five home-field games. What’s interesting
is that the game will feature a few new, tested rules for a faster
pace that should complete in under three hours. The league will
draw from former college and NFL players, many of whom have
talent to show the world. My analysis—the talent level will be top
notch. Season tickets start as low as $20 per seat, and premium
seats can be purchased for less than $100 at xflrenegades.com
and xflroughnecks.com. You’ll definitely be seeing me at one of
these games.
Sports bring a healthy sense of competition to our neighborhoods
and build strong communities. With a growing population, ripe
with future talent and a fan base eager for entertainment, sports
will continue to expand in our great state. Will there be a new
NFL team making it to Texas? Well, that may be a longshot. Only
time will tell.
Ed Curtis is the founder and CEO of YTEXAS. He launched YTEXAS after 20
years in banking and private sector business, where he held various positions
such as Market CEO, Chief Lending Officer, and Chief Executive Officer.
TexasCEOMagazine.com
55
LEGISLATIVE
FOOTBALL,
TEXAS-STYLE
Craig Casselberry
56 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
There’s an adage in football, now America’s favorite sport (at least
if you believe the TV ratings), that winning comes down to the
fundamentals. If you block and tackle properly, success will follow.
Members of the 86th Texas Legislature certainly did a lot of
blocking and tackling. They filed more than 7,300 bills in 2019 and
enacted over 1,400 into law, addressing some difficult issues and
coming away with some big wins.
The “Big Three” in Texas state government—Governor Greg Abbott,
Lt. Governor Dan Patrick, and House Speaker Dennis Bonnen, all
Republicans—focused their legislative energies on fundamental
policy issues like property tax relief and school finance reform, and
largely avoided the more divisive social issues.
Why the newfound synergy? Look no further than the November
2018 elections; Republicans lost 12 House seats, two incumbent
senators, and two incumbent congressmen, and other statewide
elected officials survived closer-than-expected elections.
It was apparently enough to scare Republicans straight. What
resulted was a more “moderated” leadership team and a Legislature
that focused more on issues like taxes and education reform and
less on social issues, as they had previously done with the so-called
“bathroom bill.”
While it was pragmatic politics, let’s also give credit where credit
is due—the 86th Legislature solved some longstanding, thorny
issues. And, importantly to our state’s CEOs, they didn’t tread on
the nation’s leading economy, which continues to create jobs in
record numbers.
Highlights
State Budget. House Bill 1 establishes a two-year balanced
state budget (as required by the Texas Constitution) with $250.7
billion in overall spending. This is an increase of more than 16
percent over the prior biennium, made possible by a healthy Texas
economy and growth in the energy sector.
Much of the new spending went to the top legislative priorities:
$6.5 billion for public schools and $5.1 billion to “buy down”
Texans’ property tax bills (more on that in a moment).
TexasCEOMagazine.com
57
The Legislature also authorized a record-breaking $6.1 billion
withdrawal from the Economic Stabilization Fund (or “Rainy
Day Fund”) for large-scale infrastructure projects and Hurricane
Harvey recovery.
Economic Incentives. The Texas Enterprise Fund—the
governor’s “deal-closing” fund to attract large companies and their
jobs—received a whopping $535 million boost. Texas Enterprise
Fund projects are centered largely in the big cities. Some will
argue that rural Texas needs and deserves similar attention.
The Texas Film Incentive program, which had languished
and lost pace with other states for the past several years, was
increased to $50 million dollars.
Property Tax Reform. The Legislature (via Senate Bill 2)
barred cities, counties, and special districts from increasing
property tax collections more than 3.5 percent in any year
without a vote of the public; school districts are capped at 2.5
percent, a major reduction from the current cap of 8 percent.
School Finance Reform. The Legislature accomplished
something many insiders thought impossible—enacting
wholesale school finance reform without a court mandate.
The legislation provides a total of $11.6 billion in new state
funding for public education:
(i)
(ii)
$4.5 billion for a 20 percent general increase in
per-student baseline funding, and targeted funding
increases for pre-kindergarten programs, third-grade
reading proficiency, and dyslexia;
$2 billion for an average salary increase of $4,000 for
teachers, librarians, nurses, and counselors; and
(iii) over $5 billion for “buying down” school districts’
maintenance and operation tax rates to provide
taxpayer relief (an average of 8 cents per $100
property valuation in 2020 and an additional 5 cents
per $100 property valuation in 2021).
House Bill 3 will also provide future school tax relief by limiting
local school property tax growth to 2.5 percent per year (absent
voter approval). And because state government is increasing
its share of public education funding from 38 percent to 45
percent, it is decreasing the “Robin Hood” recapture payments
required from wealthy districts by $3.6 billion per biennium, or
47 percent overall.
Even with the passage SB 2 and HB 3, Texans are unlikely to see
their property tax bills fall in absolute terms, as increasing home
values will continue to drive those bills upward. But the reform
package should prevent the dramatic increases Texans have been
seeing in high-growth areas.
State vs. Local Control. The revenue limitations in SB 2 and
HB 3 are fairly extreme examples of state preemption over local
control. On the other hand, cities were successful in defeating
legislation that would have removed their ability to enact local
ordinances requiring employers to provide paid sick leave or
regulating short-term rental companies like Airbnb.
In November, Texans went to the polls and passed Proposition 6
to fund the Cancer Prevention and Research Institute of Texas
(CPRIT) for another decade. Not only has CPRIT played a
role in reducing cancer-related mortality; it has also spawned
companies that create innovative technologies and related jobs.
Propositions 1 and 7 to fund infrastructure projects in areas
impacted by Hurricane Harvey were also approved by voters.
Legislative Interim
Soon, Texas legislative interim committees will begin hearings
on issues expected to be debated in the 87th Legislature,
including the impact of business taxes on job creation and the
nation-leading Texas economy.
For example, the Senate Finance Committee will be examining
business personal property taxes, among 20 total issues with
varying impact on the business community. Where and how to
tax distribution of online purchases will also be examined.
Chapter 313 of the Texas Economic Development Code—which
allows for local property tax abatements to attract jobs—will also
be scrutinized in the interim year.
What’s Next?
The 2020 elections will determine who controls the redrawing of
legislative district lines (a.k.a. redistricting) when the 87th Texas
Legislature convenes in January 2021, so every competitive race
will be hotly contested. Those elections will also influence the
approach to a variety of issues important to the Texas business
community.
If the economy continues to flourish and property tax bills stay
at least level, expect the Legislature to stay close to its current
composition. But the state’s demographics are changing rapidly,
with a growing Hispanic population and in-migration from more
liberal states that could change our politics—and our policy—
faster than anticipated.
Either way, these once-a-decade redistricting sessions have
always included fireworks. 2021 will be no exception.
Craig Casselberry is founder and CEO of Quorum Public Affairs Inc. and
a 30-year veteran of Texas policy and politics. He is a former aide to two
Texas governors and has provided government and public affairs services
to companies, issue coalitions, and economic developers since 1994.
58 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
GLOBAL FORECASTING
LUNCH
featuring Dr. George Friedman
DATE AND TIME
Tue, February 11, 2020
11:30 AM – 1:00 PM CST
LOCATION
Baylor University’s
Executive MBA Campus
3107 Oak Creek Drive
Austin, TX 78727
ONE OF THE MOST IMPORTANT TASKS FOR
A CEO IS PREDICTING THE FUTURE. JOIN US
FOR A LUNCH WITH EXPERT FORECASTER
DR. GEORGE FRIEDMAN.
ABOUT THIS EVENT
What global and domestic events will affect markets that impact your
business? How will you be prepared for these? How will you maneuver
to help your business survive and thrive?
Your ability to predict the future and plan for it greatly impacts your
business. To help you get the insights you need for success, Texas CEO
Magazine and YTexas are hosting this exclusive lunch with Dr. George
Friedman. We invite you to join us as he forecasts the future and
answers your questions.
EVENT DETAILS
This event will be held at the Baylor Executive MBA campus in north Austin.
Parking is free and convenient, right outside the building.
A gourmet lunch will be provided.
Space is very limited, so book your tickets early!
ABOUT DR. FRIEDMAN
Dr. George Friedman is an internationally
recognized geopolitical forecaster
and strategist on international
affairs and the founder and chairman
of Geopolitical Futures.
Dr. Friedman is a New York Times bestselling
author. His most popular book,
The Next 100 Years, is kept alive by the
prescience of its predictions. Other bestselling
books include Flashpoints: The
Emerging Crisis in Europe, The Next Decade,
America’s Secret War, The Future of War, and
The Intelligence Edge. His books have been
translated into more than 20 languages.
Dr. Friedman has briefed numerous
military and government organizations
in the United States and overseas
and appears regularly as an expert on
international affairs, foreign policy,
and intelligence in major media.
For almost 20 years before resigning
in May 2015, Dr. Friedman was
CEO and then chairman of Stratfor,
a company he founded in 1996.
Friedman received his bachelor’s
degree from the City College of the
City University of New York and
holds a doctorate in government
from Cornell University.
TO GET YOUR TICKETS, VISIT TEXASCEOMAGAZINE.COM/FEB11
HOSTED BY:
SPONSORED BY:
BUILDING
A BRIGHTER FUTURE
FOR CENTRAL TEXAS KIDS
A CONVERSATION WITH RICHARD TAGLE,
CEO OF THE ANDY RODDICK FOUNDATION
For 20 years, the Andy Roddick Foundation has worked to give youth in low-income communities across
Central Texas access to education and learning opportunities. Richard Tagle was born and raised in Manila
and built his career in DC, but he’d only been to Texas twice when he accepted the job as the Andy Roddick
Foundation’s CEO. Richard talked to us about his DC-to-Texas transition, the unique challenges of the
nonprofit CEO, and how his passion for data gives him an edge—and, sometimes, gets him in trouble.
WHETHER YOU’RE
A DEMOCRAT OR
REPUBLICAN IN AUSTIN,
YOU’RE STILL OPEN-MINDED
ABOUT THINGS. YOU STILL
CARE ABOUT WHAT HAPPENS
IN YOUR NEIGHBORHOOD
AND COMMUNITY.
How did you get into this interesting position as a nonprofit
CEO? I was born and raised in the Philippines, in Manila. I
was groomed to be an investment banker because most of my
aunts and uncles were in investment banking. But at 16, I left
the Philippines. I basically ran away. I love my family, but it
was “This is the college to go to, this is the right course to take,
this is the right girl to date.” Those expectations weren’t what I
wanted for myself. I was ready to get out and go see the world.
So I counted my Christmas money and my money from my
summer job and got a one-way ticket from Manila to Hawaii
to see my grandmother. I asked her if I could stay there. She
said, “You can’t run away from home and live with me. Dignify
it. If you really want to see the world, then see the world.”
So I moved to San Francisco. Later, in graduate school in
Washington, DC, I shifted gears from finance to public
administration, then later on to social policy. I became more
and more curious about how nonprofit organizations work and
how communities change. Up until then, I had no idea what a
nonprofit organization was or the role it played in civil society.
For my first foray in nonprofit work, I worked for the
United States Conference of Mayors. I was 22, and I
had to go to 88 of the poorest towns in the South to
oversee the grants that USCM forwarded to them.
60 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
IF WE CAN MAKE OUT-OF-SCHOOL
LEARNING A POSITIVE EXPERIENCE
FOR YOUNG PEOPLE, THAT’S GOING TO BE
COPIED BY THE REST OF THE COUNTRY.
When the Andy Roddick Foundation
contacted me many years later, I had
lived in Washington, DC, for 27 years,
doing educational lobbying, running a
middle school academic program, and
doing nonprofit consulting. I’d only been
to Austin twice prior to coming here
for this job. It was March 2013 when
they showed me around. I remember
it because everything was so green.
Right—you were probably picturing
West Texas and tumbleweeds. That’s
right. When I met with the staff and
the board, I was really impressed—with
them, with Andy, with the city. I said I
could move in summer, which probably
was the wrong thing to say. When I
left the airport, it was 106 degrees.
We have a lot of companies moving to
Texas. As someone who came here from
DC, what would you tell somebody who’s
thinking about relocating to Texas? I
was surprised by the open-mindedness
here. Prior to moving to Texas, I’d
always had this understanding that
Texas is conservative and Republican.
Having lived in DC for 27 years, a town
that’s 98 percent Democrat, I really had
hesitation. “Am I going to fit in there?”
But the number-one thing that surprised
me is, whether you’re a Democrat or
Republican in Austin, you’re still openminded
about things. You still care about
what happens in your neighborhood
and community. People really want
their schools to be great. They have
different ideas of what level of investment
there should be, and how to make that
investment, but at the core of it, they
really care about the children and the
community. It’s the same for health,
education, workforce development. I
thought everybody here was like, “No
government spending. No taxes. Nothing.”
The second thing that surprised me was
the level of diversity. Everybody was
telling me, “Oh, it’s not diverse. As a
Filipino, you’re going to stand out.” But
in my neighborhood, I live across from
an Indian couple, two doors down is a
Chinese family, next door is a Korean
family. It’s become more diverse in the
past decade. I still go to places where
I’m the only person of color. That still
happens. But the diversity is becoming
more pronounced, especially in more
affordable pockets of Central Texas.
As we address housing affordability
and as more companies move here, I
think that the diversity will increase.
Are there any special challenges working
in nonprofit education in Texas? The
burden on Texas is that we are actually
more diverse in some key ways. California
may have more kids—they have eight
million—but we have a bigger ruralurban
divide, and our kids are speaking
more languages. Thanks to our size,
whatever we do in this state is going to
be the barometer of what the country has
appetite for. So if we can make out-ofschool
learning a positive experience
for young people, that’s going to be
copied by the rest of the country. We’re
beginning to convene all of these folks
and explore how we make sure that
there is learning support for the 5.4
million kids in our schools. We have
the second-largest school population in
the country. One of every 10 students
in the country attend a Texas school.
When you talk to donors, how do you
convince them that making a donation
to the Andy Roddick Foundation is
worthwhile? There’s a lot of good
nonprofit organizations out there. But
I can tell you three things the Andy
Roddick Foundation is set up to do.
The first is that we pay close attention
to where the need is. It’s not about what
we want to do; it’s about what we need
to do. I’ll tell you a story. Andre Agassi,
Andy’s mentor, built a foundation focused
on charter schools, and Andy wanted
to do the same thing. During that first
board meeting I attended, Andy was
talking about this charter school. It just
so happened that KIPP was right next
door to our donated space. I said, “Andy,
just look outside the window. There’s
a charter school right there. Why build
something when you can just give money
to that one?” I used my newness as the
chip. I told them I didn’t know Austin, but
that we should explore opportunities like
that. For the rest of 2013, we did nothing
but talk to families and other foundations
about their needs and where the gaps
were. That’s when we found out summer
learning was a great need, especially
in East Austin, and why we designed
our own summer learning program.
For afterschool, rather than just
duplicate programs, we spend hundreds
of thousands supporting other
organizations that are aligned with us.
That’s how we scale kids’ opportunity
to be exposed to high-quality programs.
We bring these partners into the fold
and expand our reach that way.
The second thing is that we know how we
are making a difference. I’m the research
guy. I want data. I want to see that the
needle is moving. We count everything
from the level of family engagement in
our programs to how often the kids come
to our program on a daily basis. We can
tell you our six-week retention rate during
the summer, our daily attendance rates,
the academic skills we start with and
the academic skills we end up with. We
publish an annual report showing how our
kids are doing in schools participating
in our program in comparison to kids
who have the same profile but don’t
participate in our programs. The
school district helps us with that.
I was the same way when I was running
Higher Achievement. I raised $3.2
62 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
million for a six-year randomized study
that compared 500 kids who went into
our program and 500 who couldn’t get
into our program. Half the parents in DC
loved me because their kids got in, but
the other half hated me. But now we have
data to tell you that the program produces
results. The US Department of Education
uses that as the flagship research for
the value of academic programs after
school. Those parents are probably still
mad at me, but seven million other
kids will benefit from that research.
The third thing would be our commitment
to continuous improvement. We use
the data to improve: We do one thing
in the first school, learn how we can
make that more efficient in the second
school, then even more so in the third
school. If people share their resources
with us, they can trust it will address
real needs, that we will track the data,
and that we will use it to continue
our efficiency and effectiveness.
What were some of your aha moments on
this journey as a nonprofit leader? Well,
one is that a lot of people throughout
Texas still don’t see the value of highquality
out-of-school programs. There’s
a notion that schools can do everything.
But children spend just 20 percent of
their waking day in school, and the data
shows that children who have extra
learning support outside school do
better. Yet a lot of people are hesitant
to invest in afterschool programs.
“Why are we having reading mentors
come at three o’clock? Shouldn’t we
have done that during school time?”
We want to change that way of thinking.
One teacher in a class of 28 students
can’t respond to 28 different learning
styles, so you do need community
resources outside of school to facilitate
that kind of learning support. Now, I’m
not saying that out-of-school time should
replace schools, but many students
need that personalized attention.
Schools can’t have volunteer teachers,
but our program can have volunteer
mentors to work with those kids.
The other counterintuitive thing I learned
is that operations doesn’t necessarily
get cheaper the more you grow. That’s
probably true with McDonald’s and
Coca-Cola, when you have the same
product to manufacture, but as we
grow as a nonprofit, there is also more
personalized attention and time we’re
adding. At my previous job, at Higher
Achievement, we thought things would
be cheaper if we went to multiple cities
as fast as we could. We wouldn’t have
to hire another CEO to run Nashville,
another CEO to run Richmond. But I
learned that if I’m based in Washington,
DC, I couldn’t go to Nashville and raise
money there. We needed to build the
infrastructure that would facilitate
relationships. You’re always seen as the
DC guy coming here raising money for
his program. The relationship aspect
of this work is what makes it effective.
Once a kid realizes I forgot his or her
name, that breaks down that relationship.
So you have to grow smartly.
What do you think about the role of
technology in learning? Obviously, there
was great hype around technology in
education a while back. Then we went
through what Gartner calls the Trough of
Disillusionment. Then we came out the
other end with things like Khan Academy.
Technology is never a silver bullet, but
there are times when technology attracts
students’ curiosity. You can use that when
it’s appropriate. A teacher can use a video
to attract students’ attention and curiosity
as they learn coding, for example. And
you can have a laptop in front of you
to follow the instructions right there.
When you’re talking about art and
creativity, you can use technology, but
sometimes a kid banging an African
drum is just as important. So to me,
the key to technology is knowing
when it’s the most appropriate and
when it will spark curiosity.
I know you’ve focused on East Austin, but
what do you see the foundation’s scope
being like in five years? We started with
East Austin because of the opportunity
gap that still exists there. But we’re in
the middle of a strategic plan to double
the number of students we serve directly.
I want to see all 11,800 kids in East
TexasCEOMagazine.com
63
I OFTEN HAVE MEETINGS WITH
HIM WHERE I SAY, “WHAT DO
YOU THINK?” HE LOOKS AT ME AND SAYS,
“YOU’RE THE CEO—YOU TELL ME.”
Austin thinking about going to college
or being ready for college regardless of
their family’s income or background.
the West Side and two on the East Side.
Everyone was going where it was easiest,
not necessarily where it was needed.
The second week we had a chef from
Hilton teach the kids how to make
sushi. This time Raul starts thinking
he might want to be a chef. He asks me
if chefs make a lot of money, and if he
can be an architect and a chef. “The
world’s your oyster,” I told him. Then
the third week we built solar-powered
cars out of matchboxes and reflectors.
Now Raul wants to design cars.
For the past 20 years, the foundation
has been a philanthropic grant-making
institution. When I started, Andy told
me he wanted the foundation to really
be embedded into the community, so
people know we’re not going away.
People were always telling us that
they didn’t like working with outside
organizations because they would
leave when they ran out of money. The
principals would have to explain to
the kids, “Oh, you’re not going to have
that reading program anymore.” Andy
told me he wanted to assure kids that
we will be there for the long haul.
That’s a great goal. Besides taking
fundraising to the next level, what are
the other bottlenecks to your growth
and success? It’s very hard to find staff.
I have a great team, but as we grow,
it’s harder to find the combination of
passion and brains and wit and ability
to relate to people. It’s tough to entice
those great people to work in the
nonprofit sector rather than the forprofit
sector with its higher salaries
and sometimes greater benefits.
I think the other challenge is how
competitive the nonprofit sector is. And
I say this as a sharer of resources with
other nonprofits. In Central Texas, I
think there’s a nonprofit for every seven
people. It’s seen as a zero-sum game.
My number-one pet peeve is when
organizations don’t collaborate. Not
just in sharing resources but also in
addressing challenges, and strategies that
can overcome those challenges. When
we don’t all work together to figure out
how to serve these kids, we end up, as
we did in 2013, with 127 programs on
Most athletes wait until the end of their
career to start a foundation. But Andy
started very early in his career. He and I
have talked about this several times. He
had a conversation with Andre Agassi
that I think really opened his eyes to how
much time he’d need to figure things
out. Andy is very much the keeper of the
vision, but I often have meetings with
him where I say, “What do you think?”
He looks at me and says, “You’re the
CEO—you tell me.” One of the things he’s
learned is to ask the right questions.
I also give Andy a lot of credit for creating
an inquisitive board that doesn’t just
rubber-stamp everything. They ask the
right questions: “Why is that the strategy
to get us there as opposed to alternatives?”
“Why this school and not this school?”
It’s a lot of very smart people, including
our staff, asking questions of each other.
I could probably write a case study on
every board discussion we’ve ever had.
How big is the board? The board is 15
people. We just recruited three new
board members. Now half are women
and 30 percent are people of color.
We have very broad perspectives,
different business backgrounds.
Do you ever work directly with the
kids? What’s that like? I do. In 2015, I
mentored four second-grade boys. One
boy, Raul, didn’t know what he wanted
to be when he grew up. The first week
we had architects come and teach them
how to build the wonders of the world in
Asia—Taj Mahal, Great Wall of China. As
we were cutting cardboard and learning
proportion, Raul goes, “Mr. Richard,
I think I want to be an architect.”
I said, “You know, you can be
anything—you just need to focus. What
are your math grades right now?”
He said, “Oh man, I hate that subject.”
I told him, “If you want to be an architect,
you need math. If you want to be a chef,
you need math. You need to know the
difference between two ounces and two
and a half ounces. All these people, they
have high-paying jobs because they did
their math homework and all that stuff.”
Raul’s family certainly couldn’t afford
a math tutor. But we actually funded
an afterschool STEM program in his
school, so he started in that. That kind of
interaction with that second grader to me
is why I do this. Raul and I were able to
explore different futures, different worlds,
different things that he would never
have imagined, especially in a subject he
hated so much. Now he’s embracing it.
If that kind of curiosity is being sparked
in each and every one of these kids in
East Austin, it’s going to be one of the
most promising neighborhoods. A lot
of people think you need to move away
from your neighborhood in order to
get a bright future. When I first spoke
with the board, I said, “This is one of
those things I want to demystify,” this
idea that you have to move out of a
poor community to have a better life.
I want them to experience growing up
in East Austin as something positive,
as a community that gave them all
the tools they needed. Then they
might stick around and, in that same
community, raise their family.
64 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
WHAT HAS
ANDY RODDICK LEARNED
SINCE STARTING HIS FOUNDATION?
Andy Roddick founded his namesake foundation at a remarkably young age—when he was just 18 years
old. Today, the foundation gives low-income children in Central Texas opportunities to discover their
passion—whether it’s sports, solar power, or sushi—by maximizing their out-of-school time. We asked
Roddick a few questions about what it was like to start and grow this one-of-a-kind charitable endeavor.
What moved you to start the Andy Roddick Foundation so
early in your career? On a plane ride beside Andre Agassi, I
asked him what his biggest regret was, and he told that he
should have started his foundation sooner. That got me into
thinking about how I wanted to make a difference. It also
got me thinking about setting up my foundation so I didn’t
say the same thing when I was asked the same question.
What’s the primary way ARF is changing kids’ lives today?
We look at the time when kids are not in school and we
use that to make a difference. We provide high-quality
out-of-school-time learning programs and opportunities.
The lack of access to these opportunities contributes
a great deal to the achievement gap between affluent
students and students in low-income communities. Poor
students often lag behind because of the absence of quality
out-of-school-time support or lack of access to it.
What kinds of activities do kids do in ARF programs? We
expose them to a variety of learning activities—academics,
STEM, arts, enrichment, sports, and fitness. Our idea is
that you present young people with a variety of programs
and activities so they can discover what they are passionate
about. They code, they learn cricket, they build solar-powered
cars, they write their own comic books and draw their own
superheroes, they learn how to make sushi from a five-star
chef, they learn about opera, 3-D printing, African drumming—
and all of these activities are provided in a learning-centered,
engaging way, so they get to discover what excites them.
What is your current involvement with the foundation
like? I chair the board and I make sure we have a dynamic
board that guides my thinking. We have an excellent staff
that oversees the operations and the programs on a daily
basis, but I ask a lot of questions. One good thing I did
TexasCEOMagazine.com
65
was to surround myself with people smarter than me about
operations, programs, and running a nonprofit. Our board
is very strategic in its thinking, and our staff knows the best
practices out there. We did win the Excellence in Summer
Learning Award from the New York Life Foundation and the
National Summer Learning Association this year, after all.
How has the foundation changed in the years since you founded
it? What surprised you most about its evolution? When we first
started, we did a lot of good things in a bad way, meaning all we
did was act as a pass-through. We raised money and distributed it
to a lot of worthy causes. But beyond that, little impact was seen.
Now, we piloted our program in 2014 with 78 students in one
school and we really focused on providing quality programming,
being strict about what outcomes we wanted to generate, and
how we generate them. We wanted to be intentional about the
results we wanted them. Almost six years later, in 2019, we
had benefited over 7,000 students through our own programs
and other programs we supported with funding and quality
assistance. We see the impact. We are becoming one of the go-to
leaders in the field when it comes to quality, and as such we are
helping other programs also reach that level of high quality.
Have you found that any skills translate from the tennis court
to successfully overseeing a charitable organization? Just
like playing tennis, running the foundation requires focus.
I can’t just do it by ear or by winging it. It requires strategy,
assessment, calculations for improvement. It needs to be very
intentional. In tennis though, when I do it right, I win. When
the foundation does it right, a whole community wins.
Any advice for people who are considering starting their
own foundation? No matter what the cause or mission is,
you have to be focused on what kind of difference you want
to make. There are many ways to get there, but if you don’t
know what your North Star is, it will be difficult to reach it.
66 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
ON SALE
NOW!
Available wherever books are sold online.
Funding the
Early Stages
of Your
Venture.
If you’re new to the fundraising game, fear of the unknown might be keeping
you awake at night. This book will help you navigate the fundraising journey
while also helping make sense of the chaos and frustrations you will likely face
during the process. The long list of valuable insights and genuine aha moments
you’ll discover should dramatically improve your odds of fundraising success.
bk5gunoajn5etyhnlntacm4c0wqx 2,048×1,365 pixels.pdf
Saved to Dropbox • Dec 3, 2019 at 8J57 AM
BUILDING
THE
ESPORTS
SKYSCRAPER
JASON LAKE,
FOUNDER AND CEO
OF COMPLEXITY
GAMING, ON THE
EXPONENTIAL
GROWTH AND
SKY-HIGH FUTURE
OF COMPETITIVE
VIDEO GAMING
Think esports is just a bunch of kids playing video games? Think
again. In 2020, competitive video gaming is a billion-dollar
industry, and Jason Lake of Complexity Gaming is in the vanguard.
Complexity, founded in 2003, was acquired by Jerry Jones and
John Goff in 2017 and since then has relocated to Cowboys HQ and
rebranded to align with the franchise.
Lake likes to describe his work in the esports industry as “building
skyscrapers,” edifices that take considerable time and effort to build,
but that generate returns for generations. If you’re unfamiliar with
the whole “esports thing,” read on for a crash course—and to find out
why every business leader should be paying attention.
68 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
THE ESPORTS
INDUSTRY IS VALUED
AT ABOUT $1.1 BILLION
WITH EXPECTATIONS OF IT
REACHING PROBABLY $1.8
OR $2 BILLION BY 2022.
How did you get into esports to start with? I grew up as a
football player who was also a video game player. Back in the
1980s, that was kind of a unique thing. You were either a jock
or a nerd. But I was a bit of both. I discovered esports around
2002 and saw that competitive video gaming was a thing, and it
was the perfect synergy for me. I founded Complexity 16 years
ago, in 2003, so I’ve been in esports since the beginning.
How do you think about esports? How do you see it fitting into
the current landscape? Esports is essentially competitive video
gaming. It takes the form of organized multiplayer video game
competitions between professional players. All esports are video
games but not all video games are esports. So the age-old debate
has been: “Is this activity a sport?” Personally, I’m not really
super interested in that debate. Any time there’s an activity that
billions of people around the world enjoy, there’s going to be a
certain percentage of those people who like to watch excellence
in that activity. Esports is no different. Video games have
become ubiquitous to virtually all cultures around the world, so
watching excellence in those games is the natural progression.
I think a lot of our CEOs would be surprised about the size
and scope of the esports market and the amount of money
involved. Esports is growing quite rapidly. Currently, it’s
estimated there’s over 450 million active global fans of
esports. Seventy-nine percent of those are under the age of
35. Some estimates have that number ballooning to over 600
million globally in the next couple of years. As far as dollar
signs, the esports industry is valued at about $1.1 billion
with expectations of it reaching probably $1.8 or $2 billion
by 2022. It’s becoming quite mainstream in the digital era,
due to the evolution of technology and the growing consumer
preference toward new forms of competitive events.
We see traditional rock stars like Post Malone doing different
activations with esports teams. You see a cross-collaboration
with a lot of notable athletes who all grew up playing
video games and admire their professional counterparts
in the esports world. You see influencers like Ninja going
on Jimmy Fallon regularly. I think esports is becoming
ingrained into the sports and media and entertainment
culture all around the world. It’s fascinating to be a part of.
Is the US the leading esports market or are there bigger ones?
Esports was originally founded in the Korean market, then
caught fire in Europe before it really started to grow in the US.
If you had to pick one market that’s probably going to be the
world’s largest over the next decade, that would be China.
You’ve recently associated with a major sports franchise in the
Dallas Cowboys. Tell me what that’s been like. It’s been fantastic.
Complexity was acquired by Jerry Jones and John Goff in
2017. We’re really one of the first ever esports teams to truly be
integrated with a sister traditional sports team. Both Complexity
and the Cowboys are headquartered at The Star in Frisco,
Texas, and that enables us to have seamless coordination and
integration with that organization. We work with the legal team,
the marketing team, the accountants, the social media team, the
coaches, the health and welfare departments, and the charity
departments of the Cowboys. We’re really quite integrated across
the operations. We have a gaming zone in AT&T Stadium. We set
up a gaming trailer at training camp out in Oxnard, California,
for the players. Players come through our new headquarters
quite often and pick up a hoodie and play video games with us.
So I think we’re by far the esports team that’s most integrated
with a traditional sports franchise anywhere in the world.
Obviously we’ve had esports for a long time, as you mentioned.
What do you think is driving the dramatic growth in the last few
years? Great question. The exponential growth really started
with the rise of Twitch, which is a streaming platform that
enabled anyone to turn on their mobile device or computer
and watch these events live from anywhere in the world. Once
that took off and the viewership data was filtering in, we saw
an influx of investor cash, which really propelled the industry
to a much larger level than it was just five years ago. That
exponential growth makes this sector one of the more interesting
of any sports entertainment product anywhere in the world.
As the world changes and young people become more
sophisticated with what ads they want to consume and what
activities they’ve chosen to spend their discretionary income
on, gaming time and time again tops those lists. As advertisers
and marketers have a harder and harder time reaching new
generations through traditional methods of marketing, many of
them have found esports to be a quite compelling way to do that.
Is there anything particular about Texas that is hot for esports?
Definitely. Dallas is arguably the second-hottest city for
esports in North America next to Los Angeles. For us, the
partnership with the Cowboys makes Texas the perfect place.
There’s so many synergies. Complexity is able to leverage the
existing brand partnerships of the Cowboys and to create a
mutually beneficial relationship. We’ve signed top endemic
brands [which sell products used directly in esports, such
as gaming equipment and energy drinks] and non-endemic
brands like MillerCoors, GameStop, Baylor Scott & White,
Mamba Sports Academy, and others—and we couldn’t have
done that as quickly without the support of the Dallas Cowboys
across the street. There are other organizations that have
TexasCEOMagazine.com
69
ANYONE WHO
OVERLOOKS ESPORTS
OR DERIDES IT AS SILLY VIDEO
GAMES FOR YOUNG PEOPLE
IS REALLY MISSING THE
TRAJECTORY OF THE FUTURE.
relocated to Dallas as well, and there’s an esports stadium
out in Arlington. I think Texas is going to continue to be a
very critical place as American esports start to grow out.
Not a whole lot of people necessarily remember this, but
Western esports was actually born in Dallas back in the early
2000s. There were a couple of events a year, QuakeCon and
CPL, and gamers from all around the world would fly to Dallas
and compete. That was in a way the birth of Western esports.
So it’s pretty appropriate that all these years later, Dallas is
once again a leading center for esports growth in America.
Most of us who have kids, we’ve learned the traditional
sports ritual—the twice-a-week practices, the games on
Saturday, etc. Is the same sort of thing developing in esports?
Are there local clubs that kids get involved in? There are.
First of all, esports is really an umbrella term. Complexity,
for example, fields gamers in ten different games right now.
Where the Dallas Cowboys play just football, Complexity is
in multiple games [such as Counter-Strike: Global Offensive,
Call of Duty, Madden, and Fortnite], similar to how a
university is in multiple sports year-round. Each game has
its own ecosystem, with its own fan base and player base.
Generally speaking, one of the more interesting things
we’ve seen over the past 24 months is the rise of collegiate
esports and scholarships, which has then filtered down
to high school esports programs because of course if
you can qualify for a scholarship via any activity, high
schools are interested in that for their students.
So whereas traditional sports started at the grassroots level
and then grew up to the pro level, esports grew backwards.
We started at the pro level and just now we’re establishing
our root system down into college and high school esports.
All the major universities around Texas, to the best of my
knowledge, are exploring or have already started esports
programs, many of which include scholarships.
What’s the future of esports? We’re creating multigenerational
billion-dollar sports properties for teams like Complexity. The
phrase I use is “We’re building skyscrapers,” and skyscrapers
take time and money to build, but then they return revenue
for generations. Once they’re built out, the top esports
franchises like Complexity are going to experience similar
fandom and international stardom to the Dallas Cowboys,
the Los Angeles Lakers, the New York Yankees. It’s a digital
sport for a digital era. As we look around ourselves, we have
supercomputers in our pockets and electric cars that drive
themselves. Esports are part of that transformation.
I think anyone who overlooks esports or derides it as silly video
games for young people is really missing the trajectory of the
future. I like to say, like Gretzky, that you want to skate to where
the puck is going, not to where the puck is. If you’re taking a
good look, in the entertainment and sports worlds, it’s pretty
obvious to all observers that the puck is moving toward esports.
Is the biggest misconception about esports that it’s just a bunch
of kids playing video games? Yeah. The age-old perception by
people who don’t educate themselves is that all esports players
and fans are 25-year-old boys living in their parents’ basements,
with very unhealthy lifestyles and no social lives. Nothing
could be further from the truth. Many of our professionals
were all-state sports athletes when they were in high school.
Our entire narrative and mission moving forward is centered
around the health and welfare and performance of our gamers.
Our gamers live in luxury apartments about a mile from
where I’m sitting. They have breakfast and lunch five days
a week at the Dallas Cowboys training table, which is the
same place the players get their nutrition. They have free
memberships to the Cowboys Fit gym here on the property.
They have physicals and preventative medical care at the
Baylor Scott & White sports therapy hospital, also on the
property. Then they have the opportunity to come over and
train in what is probably the world’s best headquarters.
When most people come to visit us, I think they expect to walk
into a room with a lot of computers and some neon lights.
But we’ve built out a next-generation esports infrastructure
system that closely mimics traditional sports, including how
they care for the whole well-being of their athletes. We call this
esports 3.0. We’re really proud to be at the forefront of it.
Is there a Super Bowl of esports in the United States that people
should be aware of? Since esports is an umbrella term that
encompasses multiple games, each gaming title for the most part
has its own system. Some are franchise systems where there’s an
upfront cost of up to $40 million to own a franchise, and some
are open ecosystems. So each game has its own structure and its
own “Super Bowl.” League of Legends is generally considered
the world’s largest esport, and they host their world finals at
different locations around the planet each year. Millions of
people at home also tune in and watch. It’s a very interesting
space to be in because it’s really 24/7/365. And since different
cultures celebrate different holidays, I generally work a bit on
Christmas Day. It’s nonstop. It’s very global. We spend a lot of
time on airplanes. It’s a very exciting space to be a CEO in.
70 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
The thing I find with older folks who start investigating our
space is they don’t understand the attraction of going to a
stadium to watch people play video games. I say, “Well, you like
to play basketball and you drive to a stadium and drink a beer
and watch Luka Dončić play. It’s basically the same thing.”
At its core, video gaming—and this is what a lot of people
don’t understand—is a very social and communitybased
activity. When my son gets home from school,
he doesn’t hop on a computer and play by himself.
He hops on a computer to play with his friends from
around America. This is where they socialize, where
they learn teamwork, where they learn leadership.
When you have a large stadium event, it’s a really unique
opportunity to go out and meet all these other people who
are passionate about the same game, the same tournament
you are—and maybe have some nachos and a bottled water
and enjoy the event. These events can pack out 10-, 20-,
30-, 40-, or 50,000 people at cities around the world.
Where would I go to find an event like this in Texas? We typically
have three to four midsize events here in Dallas a year. Since
we have the Ford Center here at The Star that seats up to
16,000 people, I’m always speaking with event organizers,
looking to bring more esports to the great state of Texas.
From an advertising perspective, what should a CEO interested
in reaching your market do? Esports fan engagement is
massive, both online and offline. As I said, the global esports
audience is projected to grow to upwards of 600 million in
the next year. Brands recognize that large audience. It’s an
audience that’s very difficult to reach via traditional means,
because they’re not sitting down and watching traditional
sports like they used to. They’re computer savvy, generally
college educated, generally middle class, and they also use
ad blockers because they don’t like to be bothered by ads.
The question as a savvy advertiser or marketer is “How do
I reach this generation before they start developing brand
loyalties?” Esports is definitely a viable vehicle for that.
You can meet the community and these new consumers
in an area they’re passionate about. A lot of companies
that have done so early have reaped great benefits.
We’re seeing a virtual who’s who of blue-chip corporate
America getting involved at some level at this point.
This is not a virtual sport in the sense that people are all
congregated in the same location for the event, correct? Yes,
absolutely. The teams or the players go to the location, say
a stadium. The fans buy tickets and concessions just like a
traditional sporting event. There are giant screens where you
can watch the players play, and that is also broadcast around
the world on Twitch or YouTube or other streaming platforms.
Any parting advice for CEOs? My advice to any leader who
looks at the esports space and rolls their eyes or would
like to ignore it is to have an open mind. The world is
changing very quickly, and it’s only a matter of time until
esports intersect with your business in some way, shape, or
form. Have at least a cursory understanding of the space.
That’s just common due diligence for a leader today.
TexasCEOMagazine.com
71
[RESOURCES]
CRAFTING
THE BLUEPRINT
FOR A SUCCESSFUL
EXECUTIVE SEARCH
Wade H. Allen
Great organizations do not happen by blind luck. Greatness
depends on alignment within the organization, from culture
to chemistry, from values to purpose, from skills to beliefs.
When you embark on a search for a new executive
leader, it’s vital to ensure that this internal alignment is
already in place. Unless you have proactively built a great
organization, you will struggle to attract executive talent—
or to even know what to look for in the first place.
Just as in building a home, the project of building a great
organization requires a blueprint. A home’s blueprint
must include plans for the foundation, the framework,
and the buildout. All are required, and there is an order
in which they must be executed, even though you can
work on different pieces independently before they’re
assembled if you adhere to the specifications.
As you build and align the organization, all of this remains
true. Let’s see how it works, starting with the foundation.
The Foundation: Culture
In a home or a business, the foundation supports everything
else. In building a home, whether you are starting from
scratch or modifying an existing dwelling, the foundation
drives what can and can’t be done. In building a business,
your foundation is the culture—the set of values that
guide how people interact, work, socialize, and feel
at home, like this is their place and their people.
Clearly, culture is not the physical facility or amenities—it is
a sense of belonging, team, and unity. It’s something you feel
rather than touch. Values define culture, and the behavioral
norms you expect from your employees must be consistent with
those values. Hiring starts with culture, too, or at least a vision
of it. A common fallacy is that hiring great talent starts with a
job description or knowing someone who can probably handle
the job. The real starting place should be a strong culture,
communicated simply and clearly in a way that attracts talented
people. Yet too often little time is spent here.
To get the most from your payroll expense, every employee
must fit the culture. There is an exponential return on
cultural alignment for individuals up the ladder, who may
now lead 100 or 1,000 people and set the strategy for a
whole team, group, or company. Ensuring culture fit does
not mean building a company of clones, though—you
need different talents and skills, as well as diversity and
inclusion, to truly meet the needs of your chosen market.
The CEO is always responsible for creating, articulating, and
maintaining the corporate culture, the foundation of the
business. This is not something to be handed off to the head of
Human Resources; it is your job to make sure it happens. The
way you act and work must be consistent with that message—no
exceptions. Let’s be blunt—the buck starts and stops with you!
The Framework: Leadership
The framework of a home defines its structure and layout
and guides everything that goes within the building. This is
much like the leadership capability within your company.
Good leadership clarifies everyone’s job responsibilities
and eliminates unnecessary busywork. It offers the
essential framework for what happens day to day.
A cabinet that’s 4’1” wide just won’t fit on a 4’ bathroom
wall—even though it’s pretty close. On the other hand,
a 2’ cabinet will look out of place on the same wall and
72 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
won’t maximize the storage space. This is why getting
the framework—the leadership—of your business right
matters so much. Your leadership determines what fits
and what doesn’t in the workings of the organization.
It’s not just the CEO’s leadership that defines the framework.
The leadership of your executives and managers matters as
well. While the CEO provides the structure and layout for
the entire home, other leaders are essential to providing
the framework for each of the rooms. These leaders must
help their teams understand why they are there and the
reason for working hard. They must foster the unity that
motivates a team to win together. This takes time, planning,
asking, and listening. It takes serious, dedicated effort.
Developing people who have potential to be good leaders, next
year or three years out and beyond, requires time and money,
but you will pay for it now or later. If you already have people
with the required leadership potential in-house, then by all
means grow and promote from within. However, If you don’t
have the right leaders to support your current business needs,
don’t just promote someone to quickly fill the slot so you can
concentrate on other urgent things—this will undoubtedly
come back to haunt you. The same goes for hiring your CFO’s
cousin or an old college roommate just to fill a position.
Yes, providing the leadership framework takes time—something
that’s in short supply for the CEO every day. But again,
offloading this responsibility isn’t an option. You understand best
which leaders are needed, and it’s your job to make sure you get
them in place. To be blunt again—the buck still stops with you!
The Buildout: Talent
Once you have the foundation (culture) and the framework
(leadership) in place, it’s time for the buildout—so you can
start to see what the finished product, your home, will look
like. Many different skilled workers are needed to complete this
buildout. In other words, this is where talent comes into play.
In the buildout phase, talent must be carefully coordinated.
Electricians need to run the wiring before the Sheetrock is
installed; nice wooden floors will be ruined if big industrial
equipment still needs to be hauled across them. Define what
is needed for the long term so you hire appropriately up front.
Don’t replace floors that were damaged because you cut corners.
The buildout requires finding the right talent and
ensuring that they understand the framework to follow.
And like it or not—the buck still stops with you!
Success Requires Planning
Apple’s product marketing teams spend a significant amount of
time and money trying to determine what products customers
want—often before their customers even realize they want them.
Before the iPod was introduced, people had no idea that they
absolutely had to have one. This is planning—understanding
what is needed to get ahead of the game and succeed long-term.
As CEO, this is a good model to follow in your search for executive
talent. It’s up to you to identify what the organization needs long
before the need is pressing. The problem is the tyranny of the
urgent. Too often, the planning stage looks like this:
“We need a VP of sales now! Grab a job description
off the Internet and start looking. I want to see candidates
next week. Of course we know what we’re looking for!”
As leaders within the same company, we often take alignment
for granted because we’re around each other so much. But
is everyone else on your team on the same page? For 25-
plus years, we’ve seen at least one such internal disconnect
on almost every executive search we’ve performed.
Maximizing ROI requires maximizing alignment.
Your sales, marketing, finance, and strategy departments
should plan like Apple design does, anticipating the future
needs of the organization. You must understand what skills,
experiences, and background are truly required versus
simply preferred, as well as what is needed in the next six
to 18 months to remain successful. Does the candidate fit
the requirements? Does the candidate fit the culture? A no
to either of these is a decision made: pass and move on.
During an executive search, it’s also important to surround
yourself with great leaders who can provide insight into your
own potential blind spots. Planning requires candid, open
discussions so that you end up with the right hire—and with
honesty about your own abilities and potential. In this spirit,
you should also be open to replacing yourself. If you determine
that one of your key employees can’t take the company to the
next level, then the same rules should apply to you. If you want
and require the best talent, then you must lead by example.
Passing the buck on an executive search is so enticing.
Don’t! Make sure there is a clear vision of a great culture
that attracts people who want to be part of a long-term
endeavor. You need great leadership, starting with
yourself, to establish that culture and the supporting
initiatives that motivate people to succeed. Now you
are in a perfect position to hire and retain talent.
So we see it’s all about talent, leadership, and culture—
what we affectionately call TLC. Time to get moving!
Wade H. Allen has been president and CEO at the executive placement
firm Cendea for over 25 years. Since 1994, Cendea has provided seniorlevel
executive search solutions for businesses that have high goals and
require impact leaders who can take them to the next level. You can
reach Cendea at TxCEOMagazine@Cendea.com.
TexasCEOMagazine.com
73
TICKET
TO THE
LIMIT
If you ask Randy Cohen, founder of the Austin-based
ticket broker and online marketplace TicketCity, the
letters “CEO” mean something different.
For decades, Cohen has referred to himself as
TicketCity’s Chief Energizing Officer. Within seconds
of meeting him, you see that the moniker fits. In our
fast-talking chat, he explains what it means to be the
chief energizer, how his endless energy helped him
conquer countless challenges—from police chases to
livid ticket buyers—and how he built TicketCity into
a trusted fixture of the industry.
Tell us a little about your early days in the ticket business.
How did you get started? It started in the late eighties, when
I took my life savings of $1,200 and bought 200 seats for
the big Texas vs. Arkansas basketball game at $6 a piece.
I thought for sure the game would sell out. Arkansas was
number one in the country, and Texas was number three—this
was during the “BMW” years of Blanks, Mays, and Wright.
And . . . it didn’t sell out. So I go down to the stadium with
200 seats in my hand—couldn’t believe I was about to lose my
life savings. Then, all of a sudden, sure enough, from the box
office comes the news: It did sell out. And there I was, saying,
“Hello everybody! Stand back, nonbelievers! Here you go!” I
sold all the $6 seats for $15 a piece. That’s $1,800 profit.
And you decided the ticket business was for you? It beat
waiting tables! Not that the next time went so well. I took
that profit and bought a bunch of seats for the Sweet
Sixteen tournament in Dallas. Sure enough, same thing:
It didn’t sell out. So I’m down there selling tickets on the
street when somebody comes up and says, “Hey, what
you got going on?” I told him I was selling tickets.
74 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
He pulls out his badge and goes, “Well, you can’t do that.”
I’m like, “Why not? They’re my tickets!”
But he took my money and my tickets. I had a few seconds to
make a decision then, and I made the wrong one. I took the
money and tickets back and ran out of there. I knew I could
beat the cop on foot. But then all of a sudden I hear, “We’ve
got a runner! We’ve got a runner!” I came to a corner as they’re
chasing me, and if I would’ve made the right turn, I would’ve
been home free. I made the left, and my feet came out from under
me. Money and tickets everywhere. I spent the night in jail. I
thought that was ridiculous. I should be able to sell tickets I own.
That taught me a real lesson: Make sure you know the rules
and ordinances. From there, things slowly started to happen,
and when I started TicketCity full time in 1990, I’d learned the
rules. Later, we’d put together associations like the Texas Ticket
Brokers Association. There’s a lot of scammers out there in the
ticket world, but it’s trust that has made TicketCity so successful,
as a reputable ticket company that’s been around for 30 years.
So how did you get from being chased by cops to a reputable
business? It’s been a heck of a journey. I was doing the ticket
business on the side while I had a sales job, selling labels and
ribbons and mailers for a commercial printing company. But
in 1990 we were doing enough business that I could quit my
day job. And sure enough we started getting some traction.
By the mid-nineties, the Internet was really going. We
were one of the first companies out there to put together a
secondary-market software and real-time ticketing. We did
have trouble getting everybody to jump on that software
at the time—“Cohen’s going to steal my information.”
But I started buying tickets to all the college football teams around
the country, all the NFL teams, all the NBA teams, all the MLB
teams. I had so much inventory grandfathered in. And I still have
a lot of that today, even though it’s a different ballgame. We’re still
able to make a lot of money off having the right to buy, say, UT
tickets or tickets to ACL or the US Open or the Kentucky Derby.
What’s the process of managing your ticket inventory like?
At TicketCity, I like to say, “It’s not sold out until we say it’s
sold out.” Because we have access and relationships, so we’re
able to get seats even though something might be sold out.
In today’s day and age, all the tickets are online, obviously.
Today it’s all about eyeballs, so I’m putting my inventory
not just on the TicketCity site—I’m putting it on StubHub,
I’m putting it on Vivid Seats. We don’t care who sells them.
I just want to get them sold and maximize my margin.
But for the individual, the question is, What do you value
more? “Do I have more money or do I have more time?
What’s my stress level worth?” Many times you can get
a better deal waiting until the last second, but then one
out of 10 times it will blow up and really be sold out.
When do sellers typically drop those last tickets? Well, today,
the market stays higher for longer. I’m in control of my inventory,
so I can decide whether to lower the price or be the last man
standing. If I have World Series tickets and the game is in a few
hours, I can still sell them up until game time and just transfer
them to your phone. But usually the last six hours before a
game or event—that’s where the best potential deals are.
We like to have, say, a hundred tickets or less on the day of the
game. That’s the inventory we can play with. But in general
you make more margin by selling early. At the end of the
day, it’s supply and demand on the game. You might have a
bunch of LSU fans who bought season tickets from UT just
to make sure they had a ticket to the game—well, now they
might be selling their tickets themselves. We do the best we
can to keep the market up. We’re the market makers for some
events, like the US Open. We have a lot of tickets there every
year. But we’re not the market makers for everything.
If I’m trying to buy tickets, how do I recognize a scam? There are
a lot of shams out there in the ticket world, and the shammers
are smart. It gets tricky. I’d say that a deal too good to be true,
is. Recently, you had people walking hundreds of kids into ACL
for 50 bucks. Those guys ended up getting thrown in jail.
There are plenty of people on Craigslist who offer sham
deals. I see tears at these events all the time from people
who don’t get in. At the end of the day, it’s about whether
it’s worth the stress to get a good deal. That’s what makes
TicketCity so successful: We’re a reputable company that’s
been around for 30 years. We’ve earned people’s trust. If
there’s an issue, we’re going to handle that issue right away.
You’ve been to just about every major sporting event that
exists in the world. If you had a year to live, what are you going
to make sure to catch? Man, the World Cup is amazing. The
Ryder Cup is tremendous. The Davis Cup is tremendous. The
opening ceremonies of the Olympics too. In fact, the Olympics
are where I got one of my big epiphanies. I got a call on opening
day of the 1996 Summer Olympics in Atlanta. We’d set up an
office there. We’d been preparing for years. Now this lady is
asking, “Hey, do you have any opening ceremonies tickets?”
“Yeah, we have great seats,” I tell her. “How many do you need?”
She says, “Well, I just need one. But the thing is I don’t have a
ride.” That was a big moment. I’m thinking to myself, “Randy,
you’ve got to do this. This is what you talk about—doing the
right thing long after the feeling of doing it leaves you.” So I
said, “Ma’am, it’s your lucky day. I’m coming to get you.”
I went and rented a black Lincoln Continental and I picked up this
75-year-old grandmother about an hour and a half outside the city,
TexasCEOMagazine.com
75
and we drove to the Olympics. She was so excited. She couldn’t
believe she was going to check something like this off her bucket
list. She was sparkling and delightful and excited. We walked in
and watched Muhammad Ali light the cauldron, we saw all the
Olympians walk in with all their colors. She had such a good time.
The next day, back in the office, word starts spreading
around. “Did you hear what Cohen did? He blew off his
plans and took a grandmother to the Olympics.” And the
rest of the team starts following suit, going above and
beyond for our customers. It trickles down from the top.
That was a big epiphany on being customer-centric.
What sports are popular these days? Where is demand going
up or down? Esports is coming on strong. There’s definitely a
market. A lot of money’s being spent. We’ll sell tickets there
if we see an event that we think is going to sell out. Wrestling
is still in there too. People like WWE and cage stuff.
How involved is TicketCity in the ticket-buyer’s whole
experience? Do you offer other services? Some people want to
rent a nice house or get a great parking spot, so we have a lot of
that contracted. So we do some hospitality. But times are changing.
You have to have your specific laser-like focus on what you want to
be good at. If you try to do parking, hospitality, hotels, and tickets
. . . it’s a lot. Our focus is still on acquiring and selling tickets.
The business is changing at the speed of light, though.
They don’t sell nearly as many season tickets anymore. You
have big companies that try to aggregate all the inventory
and then keep the market high. But I think the pendulum
will swing back the other way and season ticket holders
will start to buy packages again. History repeats itself.
Ever since I’ve known you, you call yourself the Chief
Energizing Officer, not the chief executive officer. Why is
that? One of my big roles has been to put together a great
team, rally the troops, be the marketing guy. I have a lot of
energy. When I come in, I’m high-fiving and chest-bumping
my people. I’m there for them any time they need me. They do
the heavy lifting, and I’m there as a Chief Energizing Officer
in case of emergencies. I’m almost like an insurance policy.
I’ll give you an example. At the Seattle Super Bowl, people had
ordered a bunch of seats from people who put spec inventory on
our site. Some of those had sold at $3,000 but the day of the game
comes and the market is at $10,000. So now we get the call: “I’m
sorry, Randy, our tickets didn’t come through. We can’t deliver.”
“What?”
As TicketCity, I’m still responsible for all these tickets. One guy
was like, “You don’t understand. I sold these to a drug dealer in
Costa Rica and he’s going to kill me.” And that guy was sitting there
at our office in Phoenix for three days, crying, hoping to get his
seats. And we were able to get him his tickets. But there are tons
of stories where we just didn’t have the inventory, from people
wanting to propose at a game to people fulfilling lifelong dreams.
As Chief Energizing Officer, I don’t run from those problems.
You’ve got to meet with every customer head-on. And, at that
Super Bowl, we ended up giving everyone all their money back,
plus an additional $2,000 a person, per ticket. And I threw a
big party out there for them. All the food and booze included.
So they didn’t get to go to the game, but I was there, they were
able to lash out at me and yell at me. It was overwhelming. It
was the best-worst experience of my life. But we got everybody
taken care of. Sometimes it takes extra energy to go, “Woo,
woo! Stand back, nonbelievers. Let’s make this happen!”
So that’s a bad day at work. What’s a good day at work at
TicketCity? What gets you up in the morning? I still love what
I do. We make dreams come true. We put a lot of smiles on
people’s faces. We show up and help make sure people get the best
experience they can, with the right seats that fit their needs. We
even coach them, help them get exactly what works best for them.
What about from the employee perspective? Is it easy to hire
people into the ticket industry? I’ve been really lucky. The
average TicketCity management employee has been with us
twenty-something years. They’re still here. They’re still fighting
the good fight. We have some legends in the ticket industry. And
I’m considered one of the godfathers of the ticket business now.
Is the legal landscape pretty stable right now for the ticket
business? There’s always battles, man. It’s yin and yang.
After calling us the scalpers of the world for a long time, now
it’s more like “If you can’t beat ’em, join ’em.” But there’s
always legislative battles. We fought things from Texas to
Canada. But the law in Texas is pretty wide open. You can
sell a ticket for whatever here. It’s not like in New York,
where you could only sell 20 percent over at one point.
People aren’t selling from the street anymore. There’s
a lot of companies out there, Gametime or SeatGeek,
where you’re able to actually sell tickets online.
Companies have basically taken the street scalper out of
the loop. They’re still out there, but not as much.
Since you’re probably one of the world experts on UT athletics,
how do you feel about where the program is headed? I’ll steal
a phrase from our athletics director, Chris Del Conte: “Ladies
and gentlemen, the bar is open.” People are excited. You can feel
the energy. And the money’s flowing into that program.
Any final thoughts? I tell people all the time, “Love what you do.
Do it well. And keep on doing it.” I’m still showing up and fighting
the fight and trying to get 1 percent better every day. That’s what
we preach around here. How do you get your company getting 1
percent better every day? How do you be the best you can be?
76 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
CATCHING
THE PERFECT PASS
Innovation often springs from the unlikeliest of places. Take the unnoticed football program of Iowa
Wesleyan in 1989, where head coach Hal Mumme and assistant coach Mike Leach developed an
offensive strategy that would change the sport forever. New York Times best-selling author and Pulitzer
finalist S. C. Gwynne tells that story in The Perfect Pass, delivering a portrait of two unconventional
minds at work. Gwynne spoke with us about why the story of Hal and Mike caught his attention and
what management lessons may lie in their reinvention of offensive strategy. Gwynne’s latest book,
Hymns of the Republic: The Story of the Final Year of the American Civil War, is available now.
You’re known as a historian. How did you happen on this story
about football? It started with a Texas Monthly article that I
wrote about Mike Leach, who had his great run at the national
championship in 2008 with Texas Tech. That game against
Texas in Lubbock, the Crabtree catch, that was the greatest single
game in the history of Texas Tech. Period. Everybody at Tech
can tell you what happened in that game second by second.
I went out to cover Mike and the team with the idea that we
would put him on the cover, as we did. We put him on the
cover in September 2009 with a pirate patch on his eye. I was
hanging out, reporting the story, talking to Mike, the coaches,
and everybody. I wanted to understand the offense, because I
didn’t. And I knew hardly anybody else did, either. Mike would
routinely put up large numbers of points against you, and you
couldn’t figure out how he was doing it. And you couldn’t stop it.
Before that, there had only been one significant article written
about Mike Leach. Michael Lewis, one of my absolute favorite
writers, had written a cover story about Leach in the New
York Times Magazine, “The Most Offensive Mind in Football.”
Lewis did a lot of things in that article, but he hadn’t gotten
into where the Air Raid offense came from. And so I asked.
Mike starts telling me about Iowa Wesleyan back in the
eighties and this guy Hal Mumme who I’d never heard of. The
thing that really caught my ear was when he said: “In the off
season, Hal and I would get into this old car and we’d drive
TexasCEOMagazine.com
77
across the frozen wastes of the Midwest, talking to high school
coaches, JUCO coaches, CFL coaches, World Football League
coaches—anybody who would tell us about the pass.” They
ended up in Lindy Infante’s office in Green Bay. They ended
up in Dennis Erickson’s office in Miami. Any high school or
junior college where someone was throwing, they went.
I thought, wow, this sounds like a buddy movie, like the Lord
of the Rings—going out in search of the perfect pass. And
they found it. Iowa Wesleyan did unprecedented things. And
because they were a tiny college in the middle of nowhere,
nobody had any idea that they had done it. Mumme and Leach
then proceeded to do the same thing at Valdosta State, which
earned Hal the head coaching job at an SEC school, Kentucky.
I wanted to tell that story of Hal and Mike, but I also needed to
know how Air Raid worked. I knew I was going to depart from
most football books. I was going to do x’s and o’s, show people
how their plays actually work. One in particular, called “mesh.”
Because if you know how mesh works, you understand Air Raid.
I spent so many hours with Hal. I had a dry-erase board and a
camera setup. I would go through and ask Hal to tell me how
different passes worked. He’d draw them out, arrows here and
arrows there. I couldn’t keep up. I made him break it down
second by second. I did probably a hundred total interviews
for the book, many focused on how the black magic worked.
In order to tell their story, I also had to go back into the history of
football, and America’s weird relationship with the forward pass.
You show in the book that Hal Mumme didn’t invent anything
per se. He just integrated other things. Nobody ever invents
anything. Ever. No such thing. Not even Walter Camp [the
“Father of American Football,” who developed the system of
downs and the line of scrimmage]. And as soon as you say that,
eight people raise their hands and go, “Oh no, actually, in Abilene
in 1922 they were doing that.” Hal was a great synthesizer, as are
all great coaches. And some of his stuff was absolutely radical.
That’s often the case in business as well. It’s the integration
of different ideas, packaged up in a certain way, that’s
where the “aha” is. In this case, spacing the linemen wasn’t
revolutionary, for example. Yes. I would argue, however, that
nobody had done “hurry-up, no-huddle” since the nineteenth
century. Boomer Esiason doing a no-huddle—he was just trying
to make the defense unable to substitute. In the twentieth
century, nobody did hurry-up, no-huddle until Hal did, which
I think is a pretty significant innovation. The nineteenth
century is a long way away. Nobody knew how they did that.
They didn’t have tape back then. And they didn’t huddle,
because there was no such thing as huddle. But yes, everybody
repackages. When Emory Bellard invented the triple option,
versions of that had been around going back to the nineteenth
century. On the other hand, it was a hell of a great offense.
One of the things about this type of innovation—and this transfers
to business—is they didn’t accept the premises of the game that
everybody else did: that in a game your offense typically has
65 plays, or that the line of scrimmage is a certain prescribed
length, or that three is the number of plays you get to make a
first down before having to punt or kick. Hal and Mike didn’t
accept that the power centers of the field would be concentrated
in the middle linebacker. They spread out the power vortexes.
The time and space of the game were completely different.
For a lot of coaches, the goal of the game was time of possession.
If you controlled it, you would win. Hal and Mike didn’t care
how long they controlled the ball. They thought the concept was
irrelevant. They would score 65 points on you with 20 minutes
of possession and have fun with the rest. They had short, lighthitting
practices. No one was doing any such thing back then.
Before, there was this idea that you ran a specific play that
was mapped out precisely beforehand. It turned out that if
you have people who can adapt to what the defense shows
you, you have a huge advantage. That’s exactly true. In a lot of
ways, the most radical thing they were doing was option offense.
That meant teaching your players how to read the field on the
fly. Opposing teams did not understand this at first. A receiver
would be trained to read coverage and react in different ways,
and the quarterback was trained in the same way. Which meant
that even the offense did not know exactly what was going to
happen. Mike Leach’s great receiver at Texas Tech Wes Welker is
a perfect example of an option receiver that no one could cover.
The other management lesson here is that Hal came up
with an idea of radical simplicity in a world that was getting
phenomenally complex. Hal’s world was so simple. In a world
of telephone-directory-sized playbooks, he did not have one.
At times his teams had less than 10 plays, designed in such
a way that they looked complex. From his opponents’ point
of view, it looks like they’ve got 18 angry hornets coming at
them. Their offensive linemen had exactly two coverages. In
that era, Paul Brown was famous for his 500-page playbook.
It was a badge of honor. It was supposed to take years to
understand the complexity of the NFL, and all you ever did was
go to clinics and pick up plays. All the options were thought
out. The other teams were living in this enormously complex
world. But for Hal’s guys, the world was extremely simple.
And this was a constant fight. Several different times, the Air
Raid started to get too complex. Hal would sit down with his
coaches and just ruthlessly go through and cut out plays.
If there’s one single overriding lesson, it’s this: If
you can be simple in a complex world, you win.
It’s a great point. A key talent of the best CEOs is simplifying
the business for the team. The team’s in the middle of
the details every day and they can get lost. You have to
say, “These are the three objectives we’re chasing, not
78 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
the thousand other things we could be chasing.” It’s like
SpaceX. Talk about simplicity. They have one goal: “We’re
going to Mars.” It’s utter simplicity. Everybody there has
the light in their eyes. They all know why they’re there.
Besides developing the Air Raid offense, what other factors
were part of Mike and Hal’s success as coaches? One of the
things they were best at was spotting talent. I have written about
recruitment in the business world and I have to say that the
Air Raid guys are some of the best at it I have ever seen. Most
coaches want that typical quarterback, a six-foot-five, 230-pound
guy with a big strong arm. But Leach says you probably don’t
want that guy. He’s looking for two things in a quarterback right
away. One is extreme accuracy. The assumption is usually that
if you find the big strong guy you can teach him accuracy. Leach
says no: If he isn’t accurate in high school, he’s never going to
be. That’s completely against what everybody else thought. The
second thing was a great release. Have you seen the ball come
out of Pat Mahomes’ hand? That’s an Air Raid quarterback.
That’s what Leach is looking for. Extreme accuracy and a release
like that. Nobody else was looking at that. His quarterback this
year at Washington State, Anthony Gordon, was a junior college
quarterback no one wanted. He’s leading the nation in passing.
Leach has been able to spot quarterbacks like nobody’s
business. When Bob Stoops hired him as a coordinator in 1999
at Oklahoma, everyone was really skeptical. Then Leach goes
up to Snow Junior College and gets this guy who had been a
washout at Weber State and has a sore arm. Not only that,
Leach says, “We’re going to throw the ball 60 times a game”—
and we’re doing it with this guy from Snow Junior College
who was a washout at Weber State and has a sore arm.
This is Josh Heupel. Leach takes the offense from 111th to fifth
in one year. It’s so brilliant that Tech hires Leach. And the
next year, running the Air Raid with Heupel as quarterback,
Bob Stoops wins his only national championship. Leach
saw Heupel. Nobody else saw Heupel. He pulled him out of
nowhere, and he keeps doing that over and over again.
In the business world, people often look more for experience
than talent, even though it may be experience in being
mediocre. They’ll take the person who’s done the job
for 10 years and shown no exceptionalism. It’s the same
principle as hiring the six-five quarterback. You can’t be
blamed if he fails. He looked the part. One of the reasons
I love Moneyball so much is they said, “Wait, look at his
on-base percentage,” which people weren’t doing.
How much is classic Air Raid still used today? Mike
Leach is still running the Iowa Wesleyan offense.
Nobody else is doing that. They’re all mucking with
it. But you can see its influence everywhere.
But it took a long time to get there. The resistance to what
Mike and Hal were doing was just unbelievable. They fired
Hal at Iowa Wesleyan. I would argue that the only reason
anybody ever hired him was he went to work for the worst
college in America with the worst facilities and the worst
football team. There was resistance every step of the way. It
was like, “You can’t do that.” But Mike and Hal aren’t in any
box. They’re not thinking outside the box. There is no box.
TexasCEOMagazine.com
79
[CULTURE]
IS YOUR
EMPLOYEE
WELLNESS PROGRAM
WORKING?
Employee wellness isn’t just about fitness. Use these six tips to create a holistic wellness program that
improves your bottom line, no matter how large or small your firm is.
Gary Oden, PhD
Over thirty years ago, I took a headfirst dive into the world
of employee wellness programs. I was working on my PhD in
Applied Exercise Physiology at Texas A&M when the director
of our lab came to me with a question: Was I interested in
working on an evaluation of the wellness program at the
big Westinghouse plant down the road in College Station?
This plant, employing over 2,000 people to create radar
components for fighter planes, had recently launched the
program, with a beautiful new fitness center as its centerpiece.
“Sure,” I said.
Thus began my eight-year involvement with Westinghouse,
measuring the profitability and effectiveness of their employee
wellness program and consulting them on improvements.
And thus began a career that would later see me consulting
on several other large-scale employee wellness programs,
from Norwegian shipbuilders to the State of Texas.
If you lead an organization of more than 200 employees,
it’s likely you already have some sort of employee wellness
program (around 90 percent of US businesses above this
size offer one). But all wellness programs are not created
equal, not by a long shot. You may also lead a smaller
company and wonder how you can get one started without
blowing your budget. Either way, it’s worth assessing how
your organization supports employee wellness. Especially
today, a smart, well-run wellness program can be a major
asset, improving everything from your healthcare spend to
employee engagement to your appeal to talented job seekers.
Here are my top six tips for optimizing your employee
wellness program, gathered over three decades of
work evaluating and consulting on them.
1. The CEO must be on board.
For any wellness program to be successful, the CEO has got to
take an interest. This is obvious from a financial standpoint.
The day will come when decisions must be made about
whether certain resources are allocated toward the program
or not. If the CEO is unwilling to devote any resources
(even if it’s just employee time), the program will fail.
But, more importantly, the CEO and the executive team are
also critical in setting an example when it comes to prioritizing
wellness and participating in the program. For example,
when I first came to Sam Houston State University, where
I still teach, the health and kinesiology center was seldom
used by faculty. Across the whole campus, there were maybe
half a dozen people who you’d see in the faculty locker room
consistently. But then we got a new president. He was a big
advocate of fitness, and he visited the health center no fewer
than three days a week. Suddenly, the faculty locker room
was bustling with people working out and being active. The
president’s participation was contagious, and faculty wanted
him to see that they shared his enthusiasm for fitness.
The same will be true at your business. If the CEO and
executive team don’t have buy-in and involvement in
the program, if they never talk about it and aren’t seen
participating themselves, it is likely to come across like an
HR afterthought. And you will see limited benefit from it.
80 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
2. It’s not just about fitness.
Probably the most common mistake I see when I’m brought in
to evaluate an employee wellness program—especially at larger
companies—is the mindset that “employee wellness” equals
“fitness.” Many leaders are narrowly focused on the construction
of a fitness center or the purchase of workout equipment.
I myself am a big advocate of fitness, but there’s much more
to a holistic employee wellness program. In fact, fitness is just
one of three pillars, the other two being nutrition and stress
reduction. These other two carry just as much weight as fitness
when it comes to delivering the outcomes we care about.
We’ve known since the time of Hippocrates that we should let
food be our medicine, and more than ever, stress is reaching
epidemic levels in terms of the impact on employee health. A
great wellness program recognizes each of the three pillars.
Fortunately, implementing the stress and nutrition components
usually gives you a much bigger bang for your buck—costing
significantly less than purchasing fitness equipment and building
exercise facilities. In fact, if a board came to me today and asked
where they can get the most value from a wellness program, I’d
point them immediately toward stress-reduction programs.
3. Partner with the community.
As I mentioned, you don’t have to lay out a ton of money to put
together a great employee wellness program. If you lead a smaller
company and don’t have budget for wellness staff or facilities,
there’s still plenty you can do, especially by drawing upon the
resources already in your company and your community.
First, find a person (or small group of people) in the
company who is already wellness-minded. See if they are
interested in spearheading your wellness program. Once
you find your internal point person, relieve them of some
of their regular duties to make room for this initiative.
The next step is to help your point person seek out health
resources in the local community they can plug your organization
into. You would probably be surprised by how many organizations
are willing to do health screenings and educational programming
at your company for a nominal fee, whether it’s the American
Heart Association, the American Cancer Society, or even local
hospitals and health systems. Any time these organizations
can get their name in front of a decent-sized group of people,
they will usually be eager to do so. That’s something you and
your wellness point person can take advantage of as you put
together a low-cost program. It’s a win-win for both parties.
4. Measure success.
When I was at Westinghouse in the 1980s, we had the advantage
of working in a highly regimented plant environment where we
could measure productivity in a fairly objective way. As employees
produced parts for fighter planes, they logged their progress
in a computer system, so I could see a wealth of productivity
data for each person. I could see that Joe Smith, for example,
completed X number of boards from August until January with
THREE COMPONENTS
OF EMPLOYEE WELLNESS
• ACCESS TO EXERCISE FACILITIES
AND EQUIPMENT
• GYM MEMBERSHIP PROGRAM
• ON-SITE CLASSES (YOGA, ETC.)
• COMPANY-SPONSORED SPORTS
LEAGUE PARTICIPATION
• STANDING DESKS
FITNESS
• ON-SITE SCREENINGS
(BLOOD PRESSURE, BLOOD LIPIDS, ETC.)
NUTRITION
• LUNCHTIME SPEAKING SERIES
FROM NUTRITION EXPERTS
• HEALTHY SNACKS AVAILABLE IN
OFFICE
• CHOOSE HEALTHY OPTIONS FOR
COMPANY-SPONSORED LUNCHES
• HEALTHY-RECIPE-SHARING
PROGRAM
STRESS REDUCTION
• TEACHING RELAXATION
TECHNIQUES (MEDITATION, MUSCLE
RELAXATION, ETC.)
• COURSES IN STRESS MANAGEMENT,
TIME MANAGEMENT, AND MONEY
MANAGEMENT
• INCREASED WORK-FROM-HOME
OPTIONS
• MANAGERS TRAINED IN THE
IMPORTANCE OF WORK-LIFE
BALANCE
82 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
a Y percent rejection rate, and I had tremendous access to all
the granular underlying data. And I could see whether Joe’s
productivity went up, down, or stayed the same as he attended
the fitness center and took part in other health initiatives.
In the decades since, a lot has changed in the corporate world.
Today, it’s very rare to find an objective measure of productivity.
Employees are increasingly doing knowledge work, and their
productivity often comes down to their supervisor’s subjective
opinion. But there are plenty of other things you can still track.
Far and away, controlling healthcare costs is the metric most
leaders care about when they implement a wellness program.
Tracking these costs is indeed an effective way to measure
how a wellness program is doing (even though many other
factors, of course, affect healthcare cost). I recommend
having a system that shows how a certain employee or
cohort of employees’ participation in the wellness program
correlates to their healthcare cost over the long term.
Beyond healthcare cost, I also recommend tracking
metrics like absenteeism, employee engagement (via
survey responses), employee turnover, and percent of
employment offers accepted—all of which can be positively
affected by a great employee wellness program.
Any efforts you make to support employee wellness will
almost certainly have a positive effect, even if it’s small and
hard to measure. But it is important to track the outcomes
you care about most to determine how your wellness
program is performing and how it might be improved.
5. Incentivize participation.
In a perfect world, your staff would be intrinsically
drawn to participate in your wellness program. But in
reality, you’ll get the best results from kick-starting
participation by strategic use of incentives.
Fortunately, you don’t have to drop a lot of money. At several
companies, we gamified the process through a points system.
Once employees rack up a certain amount of points, they
get special recognition and small prizes like a water bottle
or T-shirt. Don’t underestimate the usefulness of these
measures. It’s shocking what people will do for a T-shirt. At
other companies, we saw significant traction from allowing
people to earn paid time off through participation.
But there’s one other incentive that I’ve found to be the
most significant. Which leads us to the final tip . . .
6. If you have wellness staff,
they need to be excellent.
In larger companies that have full- or part-time wellness
staff—whether it’s nutritionists, trainers, wellness directors,
or otherwise—the quality of these individuals is probably the
biggest factor in employee participation and the overall success
of the program. If these people aren’t well-trained professionals
that employees actually want to be around, the program is not
going to be successful. Period. I’m currently working with the
Texas Department of Criminal Justice as they hire, train, and
certify a new team of wellness professionals, and getting great
people with a personal touch is at the forefront of our minds.
Ultimately, it’s up to you, the CEO—in partnership
with your executive team, HR team, and/or appointed
wellness point person—to create a wellness program
that fits your organization’s culture, work environment,
budget, and goals. But keeping these six tips in mind
will help you avoid the pitfalls I’ve seen many times.
One final word for the CEO: Don’t forget about your own
wellness. You have a tremendous amount of stress placed on
you. Being able to handle that stress—whether it’s by running
three miles a day or going to a progressive muscle relaxation
class—is critical not only for modeling wellness for your
workforce but for keeping yourself at the very top of your game.
Gary Oden is a professor in the Department of Kinesiology at Sam Houston
State University. In addition to serving as Corporate Wellness Director for
Westinghouse Corporation, Dr. Oden has served as a wellness-program
consultant for MetLife, Aker Kvaerner, Memorial Hermann Health System,
and the State of Texas. His current research focus is speed and agility
training techniques, and he is currently conducting research comparing
speed and agility training equipment.
TexasCEOMagazine.com
83
[PERFORMANCE]
MARKETING RESEARCH
UNITY VS. UNIQUENESS
IN SOCIAL MEDIA MESSAGING—
WHICH IS MORE EFFECTIVE?
Akira Asada, PhD
Dr. Akira Asada tested social media marketing strategies for two MLB teams.
The results have implications for any brand, sporting or otherwise.
84 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
When people love a brand, they often form a community around
that brand. People who love Harley-Davidson may form groups to
ride motorcycles on weekends, for example, and people who love
Apple may create an online forum to discuss the new iPhone.
The concept of brand community is not new in the sports world.
For many decades, sports fans have boasted about their favorite
teams, shared unique fan experiences, and developed a sense of
belonging. People’s attachment to these sports fan communities
often has a significant influence on their behaviors. In fact,
research published in the Journal of Sport Management found
that a person’s attachment to a sports fan community is a better
predictor of consistent game attendance than attachment to the
team itself. 1 Therefore, to develop a sustainable fan base, sports
teams should create strong connections among their fans.
Social media is, of course, one of the most effective tools for
strengthening connections among fans of a team (or any
brand). Sports teams often post pictures and videos depicting
their fans wearing team jerseys and cheering together. These
images make fans feel closer to other fans and promote unity.
Sports teams also use hashtags to increase bonding among fans.
For example, the Detroit Lions use the hashtag #OnePride,
which fans use to share their pride in being part of the Lions
community. Fans who learn about other fans’ personal stories
with the team feel a stronger attachment to the community.
However, this approach may ignore one important market:
potential fans. When existing fans create a strong bond, it
may create a boundary that alienates potential fans. But
if a sports team wants to build a strong fan base, it has
to engage both markets, using social media not only for
engaging existing fans but also for attracting potential fans.
I was curious about which social media strategies are most
effective for speaking to these two groups, so I conducted
an experiment in which I tested two approaches. In the first
approach, a team emphasizes unity among its fans by showing
the fans wearing team apparel and cheering for the team
together. In the second approach, a team emphasizes the
uniqueness of each fan by showing individual fans enjoying
games in various ways.
I tested the effectiveness of these two approaches for two
Major League Baseball teams: the Tampa Bay Rays and the
St. Louis Cardinals. The Rays are one of the least popular
MLB teams, ranking 29th among 30 teams in average
home game attendance, whereas the Cardinals are among
the most popular, ranking second place in average home
game attendance. 2 I recruited 206 US residents on Amazon
Mechanical Turk. Each of the research participants was
randomly exposed to one of four types of social media posts:
1. Rays posts emphasizing high unity among the fans
2. Rays posts emphasizing high uniqueness of each fan
3. Cardinals posts emphasizing high unity among the fans
4. Cardinals posts emphasizing high uniqueness of each fan
After seeing the posts, the participants indicated their intention
to support the team using a 7-point scale from 1 (very unlikely)
to 7 (very likely).
The findings revealed an interesting difference. For the
less-popular Tampa Bay Rays, the uniqueness approach
resulted in greater support intentions (M = 4.12) than the
unity approach (M = 3.30). When a team is not very popular,
potential fans psychologically put themselves in a different
category than the team’s existing fans: “They support the
team because they are fans. I am not a fan, so I do not
support the team.” In this case, unity among the fans makes
that distinction more overt, so potential fans would be more
hesitant to support the team when seeing “unity” messages.
By contrast, social media posts emphasizing the uniqueness of
individual fans of a team like the Rays were more effective.
For the very popular St. Louis Cardinals, I found that the
opposite also holds true. For this team, the unity approach
resulted in greater support intentions (M = 5.75) than the
uniqueness approach (M = 4.87). Why? When a team is very
popular, potential fans think that supporting the team is
something common in their community of residence, and
they perceive supporting the team to be part of social norms
shared by residents: “They support the team because they
live here. I also live here, so I should support the team.”
In this case, unity among fans clarifies and emphasizes
the social norm and creates greater social pressure to
support the team—resulting in a more effective social media
strategy than emphasizing the uniqueness of each fan.
These findings have unique implications for non-sports
businesses as well, because many businesses, like sports
teams, run social media accounts that speak to a broader
brand community. If you own a relatively new company that
needs a wider customer base, you may want to take the Rays
approach, showing how the company’s product satisfies various
individual customers in various ways. By contrast, if you own a
large company that focuses on maintaining existing customers,
more like the Cardinals, you may want to show how customers
share similar experiences and enjoy a sense of belonging.
The bottom line: Unity and uniqueness are both effective
social media messages for fostering brand support. But
to harness them most effectively, choose the message
that best fits the current stage of your brand.
Akira Asada is an assistant professor in the Department of Kinesiology and
Sport Management at Texas Tech University. He conducts quantitative
social research with a focus on sport consumer behavior, particularly
within the areas of word-of-mouth and sport consumer socialization.
1
Yoshida, M., Heere, B., & Gordon, B. (2015). “Predicting Behavioral Loyalty Through Community:
Why Other Fans Are More Important Than Our Own Intentions, Our Satisfaction, and the Team
Itself.” Journal of Sport Management, 29, 318–333.
2
ESPN, MLB attendance report, 2019. Retrieved from http://www.espn.com/mlb/attendance.
TexasCEOMagazine.com
85
Listen
In his recent book, Shut Up and Listen!, Tilman Fertitta lays out hard-hitting business advice like only the
Billion Dollar Buyer could. In addition to starring in his own CNBC reality show, Tilman is a Houston native,
“the richest restaurateur in the world” according to Forbes, and sole owner of Fertitta Entertainment, which
owns Landry’s, the Golden Nugget Casinos and Hotels, and the NBA’s Houston Rockets.
What’s Tilman’s best advice for Texas CEOs? We asked him that—and a lot more.
You came out with a book late last year. How was that process for you? It’s harder
than a lot of people think, and very different from being an entrepreneur. It was
from a great process. It was interesting how HarperCollins approached it. They
said, “Hey, we don’t want a life story. We want you to take this part of your world
and put it in a silo.” We stuck it into about 170 pages. HarperCollins told me and
my team that we were more involved in the book than they’ve ever seen.
You were one of those people who knew at a very early age you wanted to be an
entrepreneur, correct? One hundred percent. I say this in the book: I think God
gives a gift to everybody and you’ve got to find out what that gift is. A lot of people
don’t take time to realize what their gift is. Some people have a great music ear,
some people are great artists, some people are great athletes—you’ve got to figure
out what it is. I feel that he gave me a business mind and an entrepreneurial
brain, so I took that and ran with it.
Do you think a lot of people are still drawn to entrepreneurship and business?
Everybody wants to be a businessperson. It’s funny. I’ve had the opportunity to
meet so many people, from television stars to movie stars to professional athletes,
and they start making money on other things and then realize, “God, I want to be
a businessperson too.” And there’s as much respect out there for the entrepreneur
and the businessperson as there is for anybody.
86 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
Feature
TO TILMAN!
Photos courtesy of Fertitta Entertainment
TexasCEOMagazine.com
87
You’ve realized your dream of owning a sports franchise, the
Houston Rockets. That’s got to be a unique challenge. There’s two
scoreboards there: the business scoreboard and the scoreboard
of how the Rockets are playing. It’s definitely a balance. The
two do go together in the sense that if you’re a successful team,
you’re going to have more sponsors and more butts in the seats.
And you’re going to make more money. The number-one goal is
to always have a very competitive team, but at the same time you
want to be careful about the business and make sure the other
aspects you go into are successful.
With your position in restaurants, in casinos, in the NBA, I would
think you get a good pulse on the economy. What are you seeing
right now? Things seem to be strong, but everybody seems to be
worried at the same time. We’ve been waiting for the economy to
blow up now since around 2015 or 2016, since it runs in eight- to
10-year cycles. But we’ve had a great run here for 12 years. At
some point, the consumer does get full. They’re not going to buy
any more houses or cars or TVs. But we continue to build condos
and cars and TVs until we’ve overbuilt everything. That’s what
really causes a consumer recession. So we’re just going to have
to watch and see. That day is coming. We just all hope it doesn’t
come next year—or the year after.
But you’re seeing nothing in your businesses today that has you
worried about the near term? I see a little bit, but it’s also the
labor inflation that’s happening. I’m in a business with 60,000
employees. With these cities passing crazy minimum wages, it’s
tough. And at the same time, I’m in a business that everybody
wants to be in and that everybody thinks they can do. But all
businesses are tough. Every business is competitive. The strong
survive and the weak don’t.
You mentioned having 60,000 employees. How do you find good
people? I bet you’ve got a lot of jobs to hire every month. Two
things really help: having a strong HR department and being the
type of company that people want to go work for.
You’ve leveraged debt throughout your career. Some people
are very anti-debt, some people pro-debt. What are your
recommendations for CEOs to use debt in a responsible, effective
way? You have to know your business and what kind of debt
you can handle. A lot of people don’t do that research to see
what they can handle and what they can’t. I have no fear of debt.
I look at the amount of money I’ve borrowed as my greatest
accomplishment, because I have the credibility to go to Wall
Street and borrow that amount of money. It doesn’t bother me. I
wouldn’t be where I am if I didn’t believe in debt.
88 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
Feature
Doing Billion Dollar Buyer had to be an interesting experience,
especially seeing so many different types of businesses. What
did you learn from seeing such a wide swath? There are so many
young entrepreneurs out there today, and they all think they
have a product better than everybody else’s. And they don’t
necessarily. It’s important to be a realist and know if you have
something special or if you don’t have something special. That’s
something that entrepreneurs and even CEOs need to always
remember. Just because it’s yours, that doesn’t mean it’s special.
You write in the book about the 95:5 Rule, which is about paying
attention to the 5 percent that makes the real difference in the
business. In your restaurants, that can be tiny details like a drink
served without a napkin or fans running at different speeds. Do
you find you can teach that in your employees, or do some people
have it and some people don’t? You can absolutely teach it. I’ve
taught it at this company. Most of my people are homegrown,
and it’s a culture that I’ve developed in the company. The best
way is leading by example. When people see you do things as the
CEO, then they do it.
“Be plappy” is one of the phrases in the book I hadn’t heard
before. Could you explain what that means? It means to “play
happy.” It’s something I heard 35 years ago when we were doing
a premeeting for waiters. One of them was unhappy, and you
could just see it on their face. We said, “Hey, everybody has
issues and everybody has problems. But sometimes you’ve got to
come to work and be plappy”—just “play happy.” The customer
doesn’t care that your dog chewed up your wallet or that your
wife or husband is mad at you. In the hospitality business, the
customer experience is all that matters.
You mentioned having a lot of people who work with you for a
long time. What’s your secret for getting people to stick around?
I think I’m very fair. You always know where you stand with me.
I think if you talk to most people, they’d tell you I’m very difficult
to work for, but they wouldn’t want to work for anybody else.
Everybody knows that we’re going to “be the bulls,” as I say. When
times are tough, we’re going to be the acquirer. We’re not going to
be the one being acquired. That’s just the way we operate.
Any parting advice for fellow Texas CEOs? Don’t count on
your CFO to know your numbers. You need to know your own
liquidity. Great companies fail all the time because leaders are
expecting somebody else to understand the liquidity of their
company. Just because you’re the boss, that doesn’t mean you
don’t need to focus on the numbers yourself.
A FEW SAMPLE TILMANISMS
“Tilmanisms” are the phrases and ideas Tilman says over
and over. Find a lot more in Shut Up and Listen!
• There are no spare customers.
• Never put your lifestyle ahead of the growth of your business.
• Consultants can consult you straight out of a business.
• No matter the circumstance, be the bull.
• And of course . . . shut up and listen!
TexasCEOMagazine.com
89
[LEADERSHIP]
MISSION, PRIDE, PEOPLE
3 KEYS TO MILITARY
AND CORPORATE SUCCESS
Military lessons don’t always translate to the corporate world. Here are three that do.
Lisa Jaster
Every few months, a former servicemember writes a new
leadership book and the general public eats it up. Many of us
in the military are baffled by the popularity of these books.
When every military leadership book that rolls off the press is
a best seller, I think what we’re really looking at is the lack of
meaningful leadership exposure the civilian sector receives.
To their credit, these books can be exciting reads. What’s better
than gritty tales of tough situations and leadership challenges
in combat? After a few stories, these books typically take
combat successes and then reverse-engineer them. Here the
reader gets a behind-the-curtain view of how military training
yielded teamwork, blind trust, and confidence in commanders—
presumably so they can apply these lessons in their own lives.
Unfortunately, you can’t just read Extreme Ownership over the
weekend and expect people to follow you on Monday like you’re
Jocko Willink. Number one: You’re not Jocko. Number two:
Your 40-year-old mother-of-two coworker may not be ready for
a Jocko around the office. As alluring as it sounds, you’re just
not going to take the leadership lessons learned in Al Anbar
and walk that straight into the corporate world. Those worlds
are just too far apart. The military pay structure is rigid and
standardized. There’s no such thing as a 40-hour workweek, and
90 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
there’s no overtime. Most members of the Armed Forces join for
specific reasons and hold similar values. Whatever differences
we start off with get marched out of us in our initial schools.
Another dynamic specific to the military is direct authority.
There are plenty of opportunities to leverage indirect authority
in the military, but when influencing skills fail, the soldier,
sailor, airman, or Marine leader can always fall back on
“because I said so.” In the military, there’s the potential
for severe penalty for not doing what your boss says.
All that said, it is possible to leverage military leadership
techniques in the civilian world, but they need a bit of massaging
to fit the corporate environment. A great place to start are
three factors that successful military units and successful
corporate enterprises already have in common: a shared
mission, pride in their unit, and a “people first” mentality.
Shared Mission
Shared mission is simple in the military. It’s part of our oath
of office and the second paragraph of every military order.
Every US Army soldier, officers and enlisted, raises their right
hand and states, “I, [their name], do solemnly swear (or affirm)
that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United
States against all enemies, foreign and domestic.” The oath
continues to talk about allegiance, obligation, and duty. The
second paragraph of a military operations order, which is the
standard mode of tactical communications in the US Department
of Defense and most other military forces, is actually called
the “Mission” paragraph. It includes the task that needs to
be accomplished by the unit and the purpose for doing it.
Simulating that in corporate America is possible if the company’s
leadership has built the organization around a shared “why”
that they can articulate and motivate their employees to adopt.
documents and organization, allowing for a “cowboy”
mentality that feels good. That freedom can remain within the
boundaries of a standardized system of communication. In fact,
the format often increases free thought and brainstorming,
as long as you allow for flexibility in the “how” within the
confines of the “what” (purpose) and “why” (intent).
This brings us to the second point: The mission must include
a purpose and intent that is clear enough to communicate the
end state but open-ended enough to allow people flexibility to
figure out how they will achieve it. I currently work at a rapidly
growing engineering firm that has doubled in size every five
years over the last 20 years. The owners enjoy the growth but
want the customer to continue to feel like they are working with
a small, community-based company. Our “what” (purpose) is
to be a full-service engineering firm providing a one-stop shop
for customers in the Hill Country and surrounding areas. Our
“why” (intent) is to create relationships with each client that
allow them to feel comfortable calling us for a wide variety
of needs—and that make them want their family and friends
to call us as well. That purpose and intent leads me, as the
Director of Civil Engineering, to build a “how” around our
company leadership’s guidance that differs slightly by each
technical division, branch office, and type of client. I am allowed
to be more creative because I have some solid guidance.
Third, the company needs to live and breathe that mission
in all they do. This is truer for the highest and lowest levels
of employees than mid-level management. The junior-most
employee has the most contact with the customer, so their
behavior directly impacts client relationships and influences
the organization’s reputation. The highest level of leadership
Two key components of every military mission statement are
purpose and intent. What is the goal and why is that our goal?
There are plenty of companies out there that just sell a product
in order to make money. That’s okay, and that alone might pay
the bills, but it is not the foundation for building a brand and a
cohesive employee base that wants to drive the company to the
next level of success. The employees may even believe in the
product, but without a mission, they can’t have a vision. Without
a vision, they cannot operate independently. Each soldier, after
receiving their operations order brief, knows what they need to
do to prepare for the next phase of the operation and begins their
preparation accordingly. This way of operating is so ingrained in
the military mindset that even the most junior officer in the office
of the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff uses the same format.
If a CEO wants to leverage this hard-won military knowledge,
they need to make a few critical decisions and stick with them.
First, identify the form of communication that works for the
company and includes all critical topics and subtopics. Make sure
this new standard is scalable so it can be used at every level of
the organization. Many companies shy away from standardized
TexasCEOMagazine.com
91
cannot profess a mission and expect those below to follow
it without seeing the example. Professional appearance is
an excellent example of this, both in and out of uniform.
It takes practice and consistency to communicate a mission
that (1) includes enough detail to drive behaviors, (2) includes
few enough details to allow for free thought and creative
solutions, and (3) is understandable at the lowest possible
level. But it is possible, especially if the leader him- or herself
lives the mission through their actions. Leadership through
penmanship does not work. Words on a website do not drive
behaviors. Leaders must uphold the standards themselves.
Unit Pride
I think it’s safe to assume that everyone who joins the military
has a bit of a patriotic streak, which gives uniformed leadership
a surefire motivator from the onset. As I mentioned, individuals
raise their right hand and pledge to support and defend the
Constitution of the United States against all enemies on their
first day of work. That’s a bit extreme to expect someone to do
for most jobs. It’s critical to turn that job into a career for that
employee and help them find what they can be proud of at the
smallest level—be it a team, an office, a department, or even just
a project group. What product or service does that small section
provide that the employee can brag about to their friends?
Soldiers in the US Army wear a patch on our left shoulder to
demonstrate what major command we belong to. And inside
each major command, we have mascots and team names for
every military subgroup, down to a squad or team. We paint
our symbol on trucks, put it on memos, and decorate our work
areas with it, just as corporate America does with logos. We have
coins, stickers, hats, and T-shirts to demonstrate our esprit de
corps. But the military takes it one step further: We encourage
individuals to see that the mission of their small team makes the
larger team’s mission possible. Without me, the squad couldn’t
succeed. Without the squad, the platoon, company, battalion,
all the way up to the military as a whole, wouldn’t succeed.
A manager must instill a similar unit pride in employees by
showing people that their individual actions are somehow
adding to the whole. At my current company, where we
want to be a full-service engineering firm, it is imperative
that we ask our clients about items outside our direct scope.
This way, we help the client solve their overarching problem
rather than just putting a Band-Aid on the immediate
issue. We build trust and a lasting relationship. Doing
that together, across the team, grows our unit pride.
“People First” Mentality
One advantage civilian organizations have over military
organizations is in the people department. Although I believe
that soldiers, sailors, airmen, and Marines are some of the
best humans alive, they are also assigned—they are rarely
chosen. Usually, the available person fills a military job and
then learns what they need to do through on-the-job training.
In a business, you have an opportunity to interview each
employee and chose your teams based on capabilities and fit.
But no matter how good or bad the staff might be, a group
of bitter, isolated people will never succeed. That’s why it’s
critical in either environment to have a “people first” mentality,
placing relationships between humans front and center.
At West Point, we took PL300, a class in military leadership from
the Behavioral Sciences and Leadership department. The big joke
back in 1998 was that the correct answer for any unit-cohesion
issue was to hold a mandatory barbeque. Oddly enough, that
lesson was truer than my 21-year-old brain could comprehend. A
person spends one-third to one-half of their waking hours with
their coworkers. If the individuals can’t socialize at the lowest
level—at lunches, coffee-pot and water-cooler discussions, and
so on—then they will never be able to work as a team. Making
sure that someone is a character fit for the company or team
isn’t enough. Each employee must feel like they are getting
something back for the time they spend away from their personal
life. I have found that there are three major drivers of work
happiness: money, location, and job satisfaction. I am finding out
as I get older that job satisfaction, which prominently includes
my relationships with my coworkers, has now replaced money
as my top priority. Knowing that your employees likely feel the
same, and helping them develop positive relationships with
each other, will keep your turnover low and productivity high.
One thing “people first” doesn’t mean is that you must treat
everyone exactly the same. I learned a hard lesson in Ranger
School: There are a lot of amazing soldiers who just aren’t
meant for certain types of missions. Since corporate America
has the right to hire and fire people, find those who fit within the
company and nurture them, but let go of those who aren’t driving
toward the same end state or aren’t motivated by the company’s
“why.” That way, both you and that employee can find a better fit.
In Conclusion
Military leadership offers plenty of lessons for corporate America,
but those lessons must be taken with a grain of salt. The base of
the organization—people—is significantly different in military and
civilian environments. But regardless of which type of group you
stand in front of, there are three critical drivers of success. Each
organization must have a clear mission, a sense of unit pride, and
a “people first” mentality. Build these three in your team and you
will see success, whether it’s on the battlefield or at the office.
Lisa Jaster is the Director of Civil Engineering for M&S Engineering and
a lieutenant colonel in the US Army Reserve. After graduating from West
Point in 2000, she was commissioned as an engineer officer and served on
active duty until February 2007. During her time in the military, Jaster
deployed to Afghanistan and Iraq, earning two Bronze Star Medals, two
Meritorious Service Medals, and a Combat Action Badge, to name a few
of her awards. She is also one of three women to earn the army’s coveted
Ranger Tab out of the initial integrated Ranger School in 2015.
92 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
AUSTIN
DO YOU ASPIRE TO BECOME A CEO?
THIS ROLE IS VERY DIFFERENT FROM EVERY OTHER C-SUITE
POSITION AND YOU NEED TO PREPARE DIFFERENTLY FOR IT.
Aspiring CEOs Seminar
FRIDAY, FEBRUARY 21: 6:30 PM TO 8 PM, RECEPTION AND INTRODUCTION
SATURDAY, FEBRUARY 22: 9 AM TO 4 PM, SEMINAR
To help aspiring chief executives, seasoned tech CEO Joel Trammell has taken his CEO training course and adapted it specifically for them.
Joel’s leadership as CEO has resulted in successful nine-figure acquisitions by two Fortune 500 companies. As CEO of network
management software firm NetQoS, he delivered 31 consecutive quarters of double-digit revenue growth and a $200 million valuation.
CA Technologies acquired the company in 2009, generating more than 10x return on capital to its private equity investors. In 2010, he
cofounded Cache IQ, a storage software company that NetApp acquired two years later.
Joel is committed to using his experience to help current and aspiring CEOs. Join us for this crash course in excelling in the CEO role—
and learn valuable lessons that will advance your career.
TESTIMONIALS:
“Joel Trammell’s CEO seminar is a must, especially for any first-time
CEOs. You will learn what to expect as a CEO and the ins and outs
of building a powerful team through Joel’s real-life experience and
candid feedback. You will also hear from and network with some
of the more successful executive leaders in Austin. I pull from this
experience with every challenge I face—especially the ones I never
expected. Go do this!”
—Denver Fredenberg, owner, Harvest Rain; former CEO, Hyperwear
“The CEO seminar was a great experience because it gives you a
chance to step back from your day-to-day and think strategically
with the help of Joel Trammell. I learned tactics that I now put into
action every day.”
—Chuck Gordon, CEO, Storable; former CEO, SpareFoot
Early bird registration (until Jan 31, 2020): $299
Regular registration (after Jan 31, 2020): $399
Registration fee includes the reception
Friday evening and lunch on Saturday.
Baylor University Executive MBA Program - Austin
3107 Oak Creek Drive, Austin, TX 78727
Have questions?
Email us at info@texasceomagazine.com and we’ll respond promptly.
To register, visit texasceomagazine.com/feb21
“The CEO seminar was not only insightful and thought provoking on
leadership styles and successful business constructs; it also afforded
a unique opportunity to interact with my peers across a variety of
companies. I learned lessons I still refer to today in managing people
and the culture of an organization.”
—Melanie Kalemba, former CEO, Movero Technology
HOSTED BY:
BRINGING A
RENEGADE SPIRIT
TO XFL 2.0
Dallas Renegades president Grady Raskin on staffing an office, drafting a football team, and appreciating
all that North Texas has to offer.
Did you know you wanted a career in sports from an early
age? From an early age, sports were my life. Whether I was
watching with my father or playing with my friends, sports
was always the center point in my life. It wasn’t really until
college that I realized I could have a career in the area I
loved so much. Timing and opportunity came together in
several instances, and I like to think I took advantage of it.
How did you land the role as Renegades president? What was the
process like? As in many high-level sports opportunities, recruiters
played a huge role. Over my career, I made sure to connect with
as many recruiters as possible. When approached about the role,
the recruiter encouraged me to speak with the XFL league staff
and allow them to show me what XFL 2.0 would be all about. All
conversations with the XFL were direct and honest. Everyone from
the HR team to Oliver Luck and Jeffrey Pollack were amazingly
passionate and made me want to jump on board. I was humbled
to be considered for the role and excited to get the ball rolling.
How would you define your role as president of the Renegades?
What were your priorities going in? Initially, my role was
recruiting a front office staff. We are nothing without good
people. Since we are a lean staff, I had to make sure we had
strong directors in all areas and that they have the proper
support staff. I am happy to say that we staffed up pretty
quickly and each hire is proving to be a home run. Now, I
do all I can to provide support and relay information from
the league. Ticket sales and brand awareness are our top
priority, so all activity focuses on these two crucial areas.
As you put together that front office, what were you looking for in
people? My approach was to find genuine, selfless individuals who
truly understood what it might take to create a football team in a
new professional football league. I wanted confident, not cocky.
Since we have such a lean staff, everyone will need to focus on their
own particular areas but will also be called to collaborate in other
areas. We need to take advantage of the intelligence and experience
of the entire staff and everyone needs to be open to suggestions.
Lastly, with the short timetable and enormous amount of
work to be done, an electric energy and positive attitude
was a must. We may not always agree on a thought or
direction, but we will deal with each other positively
and respectfully. No time to be anything else.
What, to you, is the most exciting aspect of the new iteration
of the XFL? So many exciting aspects of XFL 2.0. In fact, the
only similarities between what was done in 2001 is the name and
ownership. This go-around, it is all “for the love of football.”
So much research has been done to find out what people would
want out of a new professional football league. We surveyed fans,
officials, coaches, and others. It was clear that the overriding
theme was to make the football fast, fun, and affordable. Less stall
and more ball. Low on gimmicks and high on genuine football.
It will look and feel like the current football that Americans love
to watch on Saturdays and/or Sundays but will have some subtle
tweaks to help speed up play and create amazing new experiences.
What was the draft process like? Over the summer, each
market conducted showcases where invited players came out to
show their skills. From those Summer Showcases, we created
a pool of players who were eligible for our draft. Each player
received a non-binding commissioner’s invite to participate
in the draft. Over two days, each team drafted 71 players.
94 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
Remember, we’re drafting entire teams, not just filling in
a few holes. The experience was amazing, and I have to
give props to our football operations team, who did their
homework, were amazingly prepared, and stayed incredibly
upbeat and positive for every single pick. It was a long two
days and every team should be proud of their efforts.
I would also note that we had a supplemental draft in
November to capture any unique talent that had come on
the market. Like any professional league, our rosters will
constantly evolve, and we are doing everything we can to
have the best players available playing in the XFL.
Why the Renegades as a name? The XFL combined their
internal brainpower with an outside agency to come up with
all the names and logos of each team. They created a short
film to show where the inspiration came from. Our short film
shows the eclectic, diverse nature of North Texas, including
visuals of cowboys, a graffiti artist, motorcycle enthusiasts,
and more. While we see the voice of the Renegade to be
unconventional, courageous, relentless, and a trailblazer, it
will truly be defined by what our team does on the field and
the traditions created by our fans in the years to come.
You’re a born and raised Dallasite. What keeps you in North
Texas? Why would I want to leave North Texas? It’s just a
wonderful part of the country with hardworking, positive
people. The corporate climate is extremely strong, and the
cost of living provides people the opportunity to experience
all the sports and entertainment that this area provides.
It also helps that my entire family is here. I married another
Dallasite, so her parents, as well as my parents and my
sister and her family all live nearby. We are fortunate
to be able to get together for all holidays. I never take
for granted how fortunate I am to be able to do this.
What’s the number-one lesson you’ve learned over your
leadership career? What would you tell someone looking
to get into a leadership role today? I believe that everything
begins with honesty and humility. If you hold yourself
accountable for the same things you ask of your team,
it is hard to go wrong. Something will surely go wrong
at some point, but dealing with the issues directly and
honestly seems to always get the best result. I am a very
direct person and appreciate this being reciprocated.
This may be redundant, but I would add to always
deal with things in a timely manner. Holding off on
tough decisions or conversations will only add to
the difficult nature of what needs to be done.
What are you looking forward to most this season? I am looking
forward to watching football in February, March, and April. I’m
excited about watching a fast-paced form of familiar football that
many will enjoy. I can’t wait to provide some amazing access to
our fans at Globe Life Park and to our viewers on FOX, FS1, ABC,
and ESPN. All of this done with extremely affordable pricing
to allow everyone in North Texas the opportunity to watch
professional football and create new memories of their own.
TexasCEOMagazine.com
95
THE BUSINESS OF
COLLEGE ATHLETICS
A CONVERSATION WITH
CONFERENCE USA COMMISSIONER JUDY MACLEOD
When Judy MacLeod became the third commissioner of Conference USA in 2015, her appointment was
historic: She is the first and only female commissioner of a Football Bowl Subdivision athletics conference.
She came to the Dallas-headquartered conference in 2005 after 15 years at the University of Tulsa,
including 10 as athletics director. We talked to MacLeod about her backstory, the financial side of collegiate
athletics, and what’s exciting at the four Texas schools representing Conference USA.
Your career began in athletics and you’re still there. Did
you know at an early age that you wanted to be in the
business? I did not. I played basketball in college and
actually was planning on going into the finance industry. I
didn’t even realize I could have this kind of a career. I got
offered an assistant coaching job right out of college and
I thought, “If I ever want to do it, I should try it now.”
I decided to get into administration when I took a job with
the Goodwill Games in Seattle. I ran a couple of sports in
the 1990 Goodwill Games. When I tell young people that
now, they look at me like I
have two heads. “What’s a
Goodwill Game?” I’m like,
“Oh, I am old, aren’t I?”
After that, I had to make
a decision: Do I want
to pursue coaching or
administration? I thought
I might be better suited for
administration. So I decided
to go back to grad school
and moved to Oklahoma
for a graduate assistantship at the University of Tulsa.
A little change there from Seattle. Had you ever even been
to Tulsa? No. My friends and family might’ve thought I’d lost
it, but I was like, “It’s two years. You can do anything for two
years.” After a year, they hired me full-time. I was still finishing
up my master’s. Five years after I arrived, I became the athletics
director. People are like, “This isn’t a real story.” And sometimes
it doesn’t even sound real when I tell it, but it happens.
96 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
So you were young and inexperienced when you took that
job. Tulsa’s not a Division III school. They could have done a
nationwide search. Why do you think they took a chance on
a young person? A lot of it was the circumstances. They made
me interim AD first. When they later hired Dr. Bob Lawless
from Texas Tech [as university president] and introduced
me to him as interim AD, he probably looked at me like,
“Are you kidding me?” And to his credit, he spent about 10
months evaluating me. Those 10 months under Dr. Lawless,
every day was a test. And I guess I eventually passed.
WE SAID, “IT’S GREAT IF
YOU’RE AN OKLAHOMA
STATE FAN, BUT IF YOU LIVE IN
TULSA, AND OKLAHOMA STATE’S
NOT PLAYING TULSA, WE NEED
YOU TO BE A TULSA FAN.”
When he offered me the job,
I thought, “Well, I’m already
doing it. Tons of people work
their whole careers to be an
AD. Why would I not?” So, I
took it. He was the best boss
I could ever ask for. Just
incredibly supportive, helped
me grow so much. I consider
him and his wife friends to
this day. It’s unbelievable,
really, to get that opportunity
at 31 years old.
The AD position has some similarities to the CEO role,
but it’s not the highest paid or most well-known position,
especially compared to some of the coaches. How did
that work? Honestly, that dynamic was perfectly fine
for me and my personality. I would prefer to not be
the one in the spotlight. It’s about the young men and
women who are putting in the work, and the coaches.
Those are the people who deserve the recognition.
As an AD I’m there to lead, but also to
serve those people and give our coaches
what they need to do their jobs and
create a great experience for the studentathletes.
It was never an issue. Obviously,
I had coaches and administrators who
were older than me, who made more
money than me, but we were all pulling
on the same rope. The more basketball
was excelling at Tulsa during those
times, and the more credit they got, the
better I was, as far as I’m concerned.
There’s a certain challenge to not being
the preeminent, best-known university
in a particular state or region. How did
you deal with that? Tulsa is a small
private school. Within a two-hour drive,
we had Oklahoma, Oklahoma State, and
Arkansas. There were more alums from
those places in the city of
Tulsa than from University
of Tulsa. It was always a
challenge, but we did our
best to be Tulsa’s team. We
said, “It’s great if you’re an
Oklahoma State fan, but if you
live in Tulsa, and Oklahoma
State’s not playing Tulsa, we
need you to be a Tulsa fan.”
The success obviously helped.
We finally got football going. We’d been
to a couple Sweet Sixteens and an Elite
Eight in men’s basketball. So things
were moving pretty well, but it was still
a challenge. We didn’t even have the
challenge we do today, where people can
watch every game on TV from their couch.
How does the revenue break out at
smaller schools—not just at Tulsa but
in Conference USA overall? All of our
schools’ athletic programs receive
funding from their university, whether
it’s an allocation or driven by student
fees. That’s one of the misconceptions,
that there’s so much money flowing. Our
schools do not bring in enough revenue
to support their expenses, so they’re
subsidized by our universities. That’s
a choice the institutions have made,
because athletics are important and
bring many things to campus—alumni
engagement, publicity, exposure. But
it’s not like there’s so much money that
we don’t know what to build next.
Or that you have all this money to pay
every student-athlete a living wage. How
do you see that issue developing? For
a long time we’ve all said, “This is too
hard. How would it work?” And it is hard,
but that can’t be the excuse not to try to
figure it out. Whatever we do, it’s got to
be uniform. We can’t have different laws
in different states. We need guidelines.
We’re working on it diligently—I say
“we” because the NCAA is a membership
organization. I can’t tell you that the
answers are easy or that everyone’s going
to like them, but it’s something we have
to figure out. We have to move with the
culture and the modernization of things.
YOU CAN HAVE A GREAT
EXPERIENCE AT OUR
GAMES FOR A LESS EXPENSIVE
PRICE AND WITH MORE
CONVENIENCE.
For a while in college athletics, it felt
like you had to get the new list of
who’s in the conference every year. For
the last three or four years, it seems
like we’ve steadied. Do you see that
staying in place, or is there going to be
another big upheaval? I do think things
have stabilized. In some of the larger
conferences, the individual schools have
signed over television rights and other
media contracts. With that stabilized at
the top, it’s a domino thing. It eventually
affects everyone, though I would never
say it’s never going to happen again.
For some of us, high school and college
sports were a big part of growing
up. Now many kids would rather
play Fortnite than go to a football or
basketball game. Are we going to see
video gaming within the NCAA umbrella
down the road? They’ve talked about it
and studied it for a while. We’ve talked
about it within our conference. We
haven’t gotten to that point of having a
league championship in esports. I don’t
know if it fits under an NCAA umbrella
or not. But I definitely think it’s not
going away. It’s remarkable, some of the
facilities that have been built for esports.
You’ve got four Texas schools
representing Conference USA—North
Texas, Rice, UTSA, UTEP. What are
the exciting things happening at those
schools? The overarching thing I
would say is the leadership at all four
schools. From the presidents to the
ADs, they’ve been very aggressive in
marketing and improving things.
All four of them have exciting things
going. North Texas has gone through
an explosion of growth with
their football facility and
indoor practice facility, used
by football, track, softball,
soccer, and other sports
when there’s inclement
weather. Their women’s
soccer team won their third
consecutive conference
tournament championship
and play in a brand new
soccer stadium, and they
recently announced a new golf facility.
At Rice, especially on their women’s side,
they’ve had tremendous success. Last
year, their women’s basketball team went
undefeated in the league and captured
both the regular season and conference
tournament championships, and
participated in the NCAA tournament.
And they should be very good again.
Their volleyball team is nationally
ranked, defeated Texas in the regular
season, and participated in the NCAA
tournament. Under second-year head
coach Mike Bloomgren, the football
program showed dramatic improvement
this season. The football team was one
of only seven programs to be honored
by the AFCA for recording a perfect
APR for 2017–18. The men’s basketball
program is in its third year under
Scott Pera and is currently 6–3 with
some good wins in the early going.
TexasCEOMagazine.com
97
At UTSA, their AD is in her
second year and doing some
great things down there.
Their football program
is still relatively young,
but there’s tremendous
potential if they can get it
going. The interest is there.
When they first started
football, they had quite a
few people coming to the
Alamodome, and it was a
great atmosphere. They
were picked second in the
preseason poll for men’s
basketball. Steve Henson’s done a really
nice job. They’ve got a couple of players
who are on our preseason all-conference
team. They recently hired a new baseball
coach in Patrick Hallmark, who brings
an excellent pedigree to their program.
UTEP’s still rebuilding in football, but
they are another team that’s continuing
to play hard. They have a brand new
president and a fairly new AD and are
continuing to upgrade their facilities.
I would watch out for their men’s
basketball team. Coach [Rodney] Terry
is in his second year and they’ve already
had wins against New Mexico State and
New Mexico, both of whom were very
highly regarded going into the season.
I think we’re going to see some noise
from them on the men’s basketball side.
Conference USA seems to have an
advantage when it comes to the
game-day experience. When you go
see a UT football game, it’s a daylong
commitment, with getting there and
parking and all that. Your fans’ ability to
park right at the stadium, sit in a good
seat, without a lot of fanfare—that’s
appealing to people, right? Our ADs
have made a concerted effort to think
about the experience, from the time
somebody leaves their house to when
they return to their house—how do we
make it the easiest and best? Granted,
we’re not dealing with 100,000 people,
so inherently it’s going to be easier.
But we still work to make it a great
98 Texas CEO Magazine Q1 2020
YOU DON’T HAVE
TO BE AN ALUM OR
AFFILIATED WITH ONE OF OUR
SCHOOLS TO COME OUT AND
ENJOY HIGH-LEVEL COLLEGE
BASKETBALL IN A FAMILY-
FRIENDLY ENVIRONMENT AT AN
ECONOMICAL PRICE.
experience, and you are going to see
a good football or basketball game,
because we have really talented young
men and women in our programs.
So you can have a great experience
at our games for a less expensive
price and with more convenience.
Figuring out where all your schools go
during bowl season has to be one of
the most challenging duties you have.
How does that process work? That’s
one of the more interesting processes
we go through. It doesn’t change day
to day—it changes every five minutes,
from one phone call to the next. We’ve
been really successful though. Last
year, Conference USA won the trophy
for the highest winning percentage in
bowls. The year before last, we had 10
bowl-eligible teams and were fortunate
enough to find places for nine of them.
I wish we could have found 10, but the
system is constrained. There’s a limit.
We work with our bowl partners.
We talk with our ADs. At the end of
the day, it’s really the bowl’s choice.
But number one, we try to create
match-ups that are appealing. If we
have a 10–2 team, we don’t want to
match them up with a 6–6 team.
We also work really hard to make the
games make sense geographically. Now,
that’s not going to happen 100 percent of
the time. But we’ve done a really nice job
of having bowls in great locations. We
play in Hawaii sometimes.
We play in the Bahamas
every year. We play in
Florida, obviously, in the
Metroplex. It’s just a puzzle,
putting it all together.
You can’t make 100 percent
of teams or fans happy, but
we try to do the best we
can. I think our coaches and
ADs realize that any bowl
is a good bowl. You get to
spend extra time with your
kids, and your fan base and
community gets excited.
Conference USA is making moves
locally with the conference basketball
tournament here in Texas at The Star
in Frisco for the third consecutive year.
How has that helped your league’s
profile? Please give us some insight on
how y’all are approaching this event.
We partnered with the City of Frisco,
Visit Frisco, the Dallas Cowboys and
Baylor Scott & White to bring one of
our premier events to Frisco. We have
four days of tremendous basketball
with 12 men’s and 12 women’s
teams competing for an automatic
bid to the NCAA tournament.
The unique setting, playing two games
under one roof simultaneously, the
Fan Fest we have created on the plaza,
and the surrounding restaurants,
hotels, and retail have combined
for a great experience not only for
our teams, but also for the fans.
Similar to what we talked about earlier,
you don’t have to be an alum or affiliated
with one of our schools to come out
and enjoy high-level college basketball
in a family-friendly environment
at an economical price. With the
help of our local vendors, corporate
sponsors and the other contributors
already mentioned, we have created
a great tournament atmosphere,
while delivering substantial economic
impact back to the surrounding area.
www.itsonmessage.com/align