forum - Chillmatch.com
forum - Chillmatch.com
forum - Chillmatch.com
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
FORUM 1<br />
THE TRADE JOURNAL FOR REFRIGERATION TECHNOLOGY 2006<br />
www.kueba.<strong>com</strong><br />
Visit Küba at iKK 2006<br />
in Nuremberg from 18<br />
to 20 october 2006, Hall<br />
4, Stand 508<br />
Next ecoNomy liNe Cool play in the Allianz Arena<br />
Hotel & ReStAURANt iNDUStRy Cooling à la carte | meAt RetAil Healthy treats | RefRigeRANt co 2<br />
Best energy balance | AiR DiStRiBUtioN Customised cooling | KüBA iNSiDe Fresh breeze for wind power
02 | eDitoRiAl | coNteNtS | iNteRVieW | iNteRNAl | AcceSSoRieS | iNSiDe | RePoRt | eVeNtS | PRActice | SeRVice<br />
coNteNtS<br />
03 | iNteRVieW<br />
A perfect <strong>com</strong>plement. interview with new Küba sales<br />
manager Don van Wezel.<br />
04 | iNteRNAl<br />
Simple, reliable, fresh. An overview of the new green<br />
economy line and its features.<br />
06 | RePoRt<br />
cool play. Küba and its green economy line in the refrigeration<br />
line-up for the new Allianz Arena.<br />
10 | cooling à la carte. the right cooling solution for the<br />
Hotel Pfaffinger Hof.<br />
12 | meat that’s a treat. Healthy enjoyment of fine delicacies<br />
from Upper Austria’s ideally cooled meat market<br />
fleischhauerei Schuster.<br />
20 | Best energy balance. the environmentally-friendly refrigerant<br />
co 2 in Switzerland’s Aligro bulk supermarkets.<br />
15 | eVeNtS<br />
meet us at the iKK. All about the iKK and the new<br />
chillventa, which will open its doors in 2008.<br />
16 | iNSiDe<br />
A fresh breeze for wind power. top Küba cooling for<br />
wind turbine generators.<br />
18 | AcceSSoRieS<br />
Uniformly well cooled. the advantages of thermotex<br />
textile hoses at a glance.<br />
23 | fReQUeNtly ASKeD QUeStioNS<br />
the new elektrog. What refrigeration engineers need to<br />
know.<br />
StANDARDS<br />
02 | eDitoRiAl / coNteNtS<br />
02 | imPRiNt<br />
eDitoRiAl<br />
DeAR ReADeR,<br />
Europe’s prospects for the next six months may seem sobering:<br />
higher taxes, a strong Euro, high oil prices, expensive raw materials<br />
like copper or aluminium and a sluggish world economy.<br />
Nevertheless, we have no reason to be pessimistic.<br />
With an intelligent and bold product strategy we intend to master<br />
the downswing without side effects. For instance, with our new<br />
green economy line, and with our blue Classic Line we have<br />
tailored our product portfolio to precisely meet the needs of our<br />
customers. Ubiquitous cost pressure does not have to lead to a<br />
reduction in quality.<br />
As an experienced manufacturer of high-quality refrigeration<br />
<strong>com</strong>ponents, Küba believes that the optimal cost/benefit ratio of<br />
our products is the best basis for a mutually successful partnership<br />
with planners, engineering <strong>com</strong>panies and operators. At a<br />
time when other <strong>com</strong>panies are tempted to cut costs by reducing<br />
quality, our reaction is is to do just the opposite: We have an<br />
obligation to our partners in the market to strictly maintain and<br />
enhance our high quality standards in production, the materials<br />
used and in the way we do business. In this way, we aim to<br />
strengthen the bonds of our <strong>com</strong>mon success – quality unites<br />
and creates new opportunities.<br />
May you enjoy this issue,<br />
Don van Wezel<br />
imPRiNt<br />
FORUM The trade Journal for Refrigeration Technology<br />
PUBLISHER: Küba Kältetechnik GmbH, Oberdiller Straße 23, D-82065 Baierbrunn,<br />
Tel.: +49/(0)89/74473-264, Fax: +49/(0)89/74473-107 MANAGING EDITOR: Michael<br />
Münch (Küba Kältetechnik) CONTRIBUTORS TO THIS EDITION: Don van Wezel,<br />
Josef Irl, Eng. Peter Strauß, Oliver Memminger, Kai Krebs, Marcus Höpfl, Peter Rudolf<br />
Wohlmuth, Dr. Gabriele Lüke, Petra Sippel EDITING, LAYOUT & PRODUCTION:<br />
imprime – Dr. Lüke, Mai & Partner – Journalists & graphic designers, Perchtinger Str.<br />
8–10, 81379 Munich, Tel.: +49/(0)89/747344-73 and -74 PRINTING & SHIPPING: artconcept<br />
Werbeagentur GmbH, Martinsried/Munich<br />
Reproduction only by written permission from Küba Kältetechnik GmbH. Copyright reserved. We<br />
do not accept responsibility for unsolicited manuscripts, pictures and files.<br />
SeRVice | PRActice | eVeNtS | RePoRt | iNSiDe | AcceSSoRieS | iNteRNAl | iNteRVieW | coNteNtS | eDitoRiAl | 03<br />
Mr. van Wezel, the new Küba economy line has been on the<br />
market since January 2006. How are sales?<br />
We are very pleased about its successful start. We receive new<br />
enquiries on a daily basis from potential customers in Germany<br />
and abroad.<br />
This shows that Küba understands the needs of the market.<br />
Why is the new line so appropriate for the market?<br />
The new economy line is an efficient solution for standardised<br />
cooling tasks in the retail and service sectors – in other words,<br />
for non-sensitive refrigerated goods that just need a constant<br />
temperature. In this regard, the green economy line also perfectly<br />
<strong>com</strong>plements our blue Classic Line, which is designed<br />
for <strong>com</strong>plex or custom refrigeration in the manufacturing and<br />
processing industries.<br />
Does the standardised refrigeration you mentioned represent a<br />
growing market segment?<br />
The service and retail sectors need fast and intelligent solutions<br />
for standard cooling tasks. Supermarkets, grocery stores, filling<br />
stations, restaurants, catering services, or kiosks everywhere<br />
are confronted with the same challenge: They have to refrigerate<br />
packaged products, (products that leave the sales and work<br />
areas in the same condition in which they were brought in), for a<br />
relatively short period. During this period the products must be<br />
simply reliably fresh – nothing more and nothing less.<br />
Simple, reliable, fresh – that is also the motto for the new economy<br />
line.<br />
Exactly. Simple to install, absolutely reliable to operate: Thus,<br />
the cooled goods always stay fresh. And this means that our<br />
customers get a solution that perfectly meets their needs.<br />
A perfect <strong>com</strong>plement<br />
Don van Wezel has been managing sales at Küba since January<br />
1st, 2006. He explains to foRUm what sets the economy line Air<br />
cooler product line apart.<br />
This must make them happy.…<br />
That’s not all. We can deliver the units with short lead times.<br />
They are quickly and easily installed, and cleaning is quite simple<br />
– which naturally is an extremely important factor in the food<br />
industry. Of course the new unit line has also been priced attractively.<br />
And for <strong>com</strong>plex cooling tasks there is the Classic Line.<br />
The Classic Line always <strong>com</strong>es into play whenever more than<br />
just temperature is involved. This is the case, for example, when<br />
factors such as long-term storage, assurance of maturation<br />
processes, humidity, precise air distribution, hygiene, or corrosion<br />
protection in acidic environments play a crucial role. And<br />
this increases the <strong>com</strong>plexity of the units accordingly.<br />
Is that the essential distinction to the economy line?<br />
Exactly. The blue and the green worlds are <strong>com</strong>pletely <strong>com</strong>plementary.<br />
They only differ in their respective areas of implementation<br />
and thus their <strong>com</strong>plexity. This, of course, means that the<br />
new economy line delivers the proven Küba quality: high cooling<br />
capacity through the CAL® distributor effect, long service<br />
life, high level of installation safety, as well as the hygienic powder<br />
coating. From a technical perspective, what makes the new<br />
economy line an autonomous unit line is its equipment: This<br />
line satisfies the standardised requirements of the application<br />
scenarios. The buzzword here is “built to application”.<br />
This concept raises the bar for the <strong>com</strong>petition. Currently, none<br />
of them has such as offering.<br />
True. The new economy line was definitely the right decision for<br />
Küba. Now we can serve all market segments <strong>com</strong>prehensively,<br />
01/2006 FORUM
04 | eDitoRiAl | coNteNtS | iNteRVieW | iNteRNAl | AcceSSoRieS | iNSiDe | RePoRt | eVeNtS | PRActice | SeRVice<br />
Simple, reliable, fresh<br />
Küba has successfully positioned itself in line with market demands with its new green economy line: From<br />
standardised to <strong>com</strong>plex cooling tasks – Küba offers the right solution for any application.<br />
WitH itS NeW ecoNomy liNe Küba‘s developers have succeeded<br />
with an innovative, market-driven extension to the product<br />
line: The economy line’s state-of-the-art Air Coolers offer a<br />
solution that is designed especially for standardised cooling<br />
tasks in the retail and service industries. “With this new addition<br />
Küba now has a seamless portfolio of both <strong>com</strong>plex Air Coolers,<br />
as well as standardised Air Coolers,” explains managing direc-<br />
junior Df<br />
➡ Space-saving:<br />
Horizontal drain enabling a height reduction to 180 mm, including<br />
the 90° elbow<br />
➡ Best air guidance:<br />
Integrated air baffle plate projects the air along the cell ceiling<br />
and thus far into the room<br />
➡ for extreme applications:<br />
Installation of an additional heater is possible, for example, for<br />
use in deep-freeze rooms subject to frequent door opening<br />
➡ Simple installation:<br />
The unit can be easily screwed to the cell ceiling; removable<br />
fan plate<br />
tor Thies Hachfeld. Standard cooling tasks are handled by the<br />
green economy line, whereas the proven multi-variant Classic<br />
Line is designed for <strong>com</strong>plex or custom refrigeration installations,<br />
particularly in the processing and manufacturing industries.<br />
Such a differentiation makes sense: “Non-sensitive” packaged<br />
goods that leave the store in the same state in which they<br />
were delivered and which usually are stored for short periods<br />
<strong>com</strong>pact Df<br />
➡ Simple installation:<br />
Hinged fan plate, removable side piece<br />
➡ Space-saving:<br />
Drain vertical, height including drain 315 mm<br />
➡ Narrow width:<br />
Compact design, only 872/972 mm wide<br />
➡ Best air guidance:<br />
Integrated air baffle plate projects the air along the cell ceiling<br />
and thus far into the room<br />
at a constant temperature, do not need <strong>com</strong>plex Air Coolers. In<br />
this case temperature is the only significant refrigeration quality<br />
parameter. The goods must be simply and reliably fresh. And<br />
this is precisely what the new product line offers: The economy<br />
line is simple to install and clean, absolutely reliable to operate<br />
and it always keeps the refrigerated goods fresh. In other words,<br />
it is a market-oriented solution in proven Küba quality. The new<br />
product line has been priced attractively. In addition the units<br />
are always available with short lead-times.<br />
What makes these units into an autonomous product line from<br />
the technical perspective is primarily their equipment: This line<br />
perfectly satisfies the standardised requirements – “built to application”.<br />
The new line <strong>com</strong>prises differentiates four product<br />
series: junior DF, <strong>com</strong>pact DF, market plus SP and <strong>com</strong>fort DP.<br />
➡ expanded capacity range:<br />
Now up to 52 kW<br />
➡ incremental capacity steps:<br />
now with fan diameter 500 mm<br />
➡ increased air throw:<br />
Küba Air Jet as accessory<br />
➡ Quick cleaning:<br />
Hinged drain tray as accessory<br />
market plus SP <strong>com</strong>fort DP<br />
www.next-economy-line.de<br />
Each series has several design variants ranging from 0.5 and<br />
50 kW.<br />
By contrast, the Classic Line is designed to handle <strong>com</strong>plex<br />
cooling tasks for the manufacturing and processing industries,<br />
i.e. wherever more than just the temperature of cooled goods is<br />
essential. Here, factors such as long-term storage, assurance<br />
of maturation processes, humidity, air distribution precision, hygiene,<br />
or corrosion protection for acidic environments, play a<br />
crucial role, for example. Managing director Thies Hachfeld is<br />
pleased: “This differentiation makes it clear why the new economy<br />
line is the right decision for Küba: Now we can serve all market<br />
segments <strong>com</strong>prehensively, in line with demand and with<br />
the highest level of quality.”<br />
➡ expanded capacity range:<br />
Now up to 28 kW<br />
➡ Space-saving:<br />
Height 303 mm<br />
➡ Best air guidance:<br />
Integrated air baffle plate, low air speed (to 0.8 m/s projects the air<br />
along the ceiling of the cell and therefore far into the room<br />
➡ Virtually no draught:<br />
Low air speed in the cooling room through integrated air baffle<br />
plate, low-noise version integrated (standard with two-step<br />
fans), extremely quiet version in the third speed “S” with accessory<br />
(condenser)<br />
FORUM 01/2006 01/2006 FORUM
06 | eDitoRiAl | coNteNtS | iNteRVieW | iNteRNAl | AcceSSoRieS | iNSiDe | RePoRt | eVeNtS | PRActice | SeRVice<br />
cool Play<br />
www.next-economy-line.de<br />
The architecture and colourful lighting of<br />
new Allianz Arena in Munich are captivating<br />
to be sure. But that’s not all. It also<br />
has some real refrigeration engineering<br />
highlights to offer.<br />
footBAll mAKeS PeoPle HUNgRy and<br />
thirsty. Particularly the fans. Sharing the thrill<br />
also takes energy. The operators of the new Allianz<br />
Arena in Munich were justified in making<br />
sure that fans were well cared for. The stadium<br />
can ac<strong>com</strong>modate up to 70,000 people, and<br />
they want to eat and drink. They can get bratwurst,<br />
pizza, or French fries for snacks. In two<br />
Fan-Centres, Munich breweries, Hacker Pschorr<br />
and Paulaner, dispense their respective brands<br />
of beer to the fans. Arena à la Carte is a family<br />
restaurant whose bar and bistro offer a menu<br />
to fit the tastes of parents, children, VIPs and<br />
sponsors. During the off-season high-quality<br />
fare must also be ensured so that the stadium<br />
can be used as a location for events, conferences<br />
or symposia. Given these diverse catering<br />
scenarios ranging from mass to exclusive,<br />
intelligent and efficient solutions were required<br />
particularly from refrigeration engineers. The<br />
variety of cooled goods is every bit as varied<br />
FORUM 01/2006 01/2006 FORUM
08 | eDitoRiAl | coNteNtS | iNteRVieW | iNteRNAl | AcceSSoRieS | iNSiDe | RePoRt | eVeNtS | PRActice | SeRVice<br />
1<br />
as the individual tastes of the fans. The refrigeration technology<br />
had to meet the widest variety of requirements imposed by the<br />
goods that will be cooled. The number of people to be served<br />
was also a factor that could not be underestimated:<br />
• 2,200 sponsors,<br />
• 2,600 business seat owners,<br />
• 1,500 VIPs,<br />
• 1,300 visitors each at the two Fan-Treffs and<br />
• the queues that can be expected in front of the 28 kiosks.<br />
All these people not only want a wide variety of enough food<br />
and beverages from the two main kitchens; they also expect all<br />
products to be processed with perfect quality. By the way, most<br />
of the products offered <strong>com</strong>e from the region.<br />
Responsible for the overall catering concept was Arno Stuckert<br />
of Augsburg, a respected specialist planner for the food services<br />
industry. Muhr GmbH from Viechtach in Lower Bavaria and<br />
Kühlanlagenbau Süd-Ost GmbH from Dresden both oversaw<br />
the operative refrigeration engineering implementation. Muhr<br />
was responsible for the cooling systems for the two large kitchens,<br />
while Kühlanlagenbau Süd-Ost GmbH equipped the kiosks.<br />
Installation started in November 2004. In this process the<br />
refrigeration systems were installed first, followed by the insulation<br />
installations. As the prerequisite for the system’s function,<br />
a chiller system with condensing units was installed on each of<br />
the seven levels of the stadium. All of the condensers required<br />
2<br />
for food service applications were connected to this system.<br />
The water feed temperature is +8 °C, the return temperature is<br />
+40 °C, maximum. Relative to the water-cooled condensers that<br />
were used, the operators placed a primary value on extremely<br />
quiet operation; in this case the value of 35 dBA was not to be<br />
exceeded. Levels 3 and 4 are a good example of the specific<br />
refrigeration requirements:<br />
On level 3 in the family restaurant area<br />
• a cooling room for beverages (36 m 3 ),<br />
• a cooling room for dairy products (15 m 3 ),<br />
• a cooling room for vegetables (20 m 3 ),<br />
• a cooling room for meat (20 m 3 ),<br />
• eight refrigeration tables, refrigerated well buffets and walk-in<br />
coolers needed to be supplied.<br />
On level 4 in the main kitchen area<br />
• a cooling room for beverages (52 m 3 ),<br />
• a cooling room for dairy products (31 m 3 ),<br />
• a cooling room for vegetables (46 m 3 ),<br />
• a cooling room for meat (46 m 3 ),<br />
• a cooling room for finished goods 1 (42 m 3 ),<br />
• a cooling room for finished goods 2 (42 m 3 ),<br />
• a cooling room for tableware (31 m 3 ),<br />
• a cooling room for ice cubes (22.5 m 3 ),<br />
• cooling for the prep room (129.5 m 3 ) as well as<br />
• cooling for the equipment room (33 m 3 )<br />
were on the agenda.<br />
Küba Kältetechnik supplied the fan Air Coolers for implementation<br />
of the plan. The market plus SP series from the new green<br />
economy line and some SG evaporators with increased blow<br />
range, directed air flow and higher <strong>com</strong>pression were also used.<br />
Thus, Küba units are used in all areas: In the large-scale catering<br />
kitchens, in the prep rooms (here some units featured textile<br />
hose adapters), in the open cooling rooms, in the deep-freeze<br />
rooms, and in the kiosk areas. In line with the new dual division<br />
of the Küba world; the Küba Air Coolers offer solutions for both<br />
<strong>com</strong>plex cooling tasks, as well as standardised cooling tasks<br />
– such as those required in the kiosk area.<br />
Nevertheless, the refrigeration engineering challenge posed by<br />
the Allianz Arena with the number and variety of requirements<br />
associated with the different cooling tasks. The installation itself<br />
involved some special features. For example for stadium levels<br />
3 and 4 it was possible to connect all entities requiring refrigeration<br />
on these two levels to the cold water plumbing via two multi<strong>com</strong>pressor<br />
cooling systems; in other words it was possible<br />
to create an integrated solution. However such a construct was<br />
not possible for the other levels. Here 19 individual water-cooled<br />
condenser units were installed and connected individually to the<br />
cold water plumbing. These water-cooled condenser units were<br />
directly installed above the cooling rooms – between the cooling<br />
room ceiling and the rough ceiling. In addition all cooling ag-<br />
moRe iNfo<br />
FORUM 01/2006 01/2006 FORUM<br />
3<br />
5<br />
4<br />
6<br />
www.next-economy-line.de<br />
1 View of the stadium:<br />
A dream for every football<br />
fan – and refrigeration<br />
engineer<br />
2 Josef Köppel, supervising<br />
fitter for muhr gmbH<br />
– final mounting of an SP<br />
evaporator<br />
3 Universal market plus<br />
flexibility: in photo<br />
number 3 the frozen<br />
goods are kept in the<br />
deep freezing room at -35<br />
°c, packaged of course,<br />
and …<br />
4 … in photo 4 vegetables<br />
are cooled „simple,<br />
reliable, fresh“ in open<br />
containers.<br />
5 the junior Df fits into<br />
small, low-ceiling cooling<br />
cells with a big effect:<br />
here in one of the kiosk<br />
cooling cells<br />
6 it makes queuing worthwhile:<br />
Beverages and<br />
snacks await hungry and<br />
thirsty fans at<br />
gregates were fitted with a data interface. Thus, fault messages<br />
can be detected quickly and the faults can be resolved. The<br />
following areas are among those supplied individually:<br />
• Beverage cooling room level 3, sector 1 (97 m 3 room volume),<br />
• Wet waste cooling room level 0, sector 4 (43 m 3 ),<br />
• Deep freeze room level 0, sector 4 (70 m 3 ),<br />
• Beverage cooling room level 4, sector 3 (76 m 3 ),<br />
• Food cooling room level 5, sector 1 (49 m 3 ),<br />
• Shock cooler with 12.5 kW cooling capacity.<br />
Given this sophisticated planning and installation nothing can<br />
go wrong in the <strong>com</strong>petition for the German and International<br />
championships – as the World Cup has clearly shown. Cold<br />
beer, delicious bratwurst and a lot of goals – the football fan has<br />
every reason to be happy.<br />
there are 62 Air coolers from the blue and green Küba world in<br />
the Allianz Arena. together they represent total cooling capacity of<br />
158.15 kW. A list of aggregates, their respective areas of implementation<br />
and their cooling capacity is available at http://www.kueba.<br />
<strong>com</strong>/kueba/deutsch/nbsp/menu/what_146_s_new/aktuelles/<strong>forum</strong>/<br />
index.html
10 | eDitoRiAl | coNteNtS | iNteRVieW | iNteRNAl | AcceSSoRieS | iNSiDe | RePoRt | eVeNtS | PRActice | SeRVice<br />
FORUM 01/2006<br />
cooling à la carte<br />
An integrated <strong>com</strong>pressor solution and the junior DF ensure optimal and energysaving<br />
refrigeration at the Hotel Pfaffinger Hof.<br />
Sparkling clean and brilliant – like this kitchen in the Hotel Pfaffinger Hof – is what guests expect of a good kitchen in the hospitality industry.<br />
Adjacent is a view of the deep freeze cell: Here, vegetables and fruit deep frozen are kept fresh for processing at a room temperature of –20<br />
°c. Here, the junior Df from the green Küba economy line makes sure that temperatures are kept constant (photo far right).<br />
“gooD RefRigeRAtioN iS an absolute necessity in the hotel<br />
and restaurant business”, says Alois Bichler, owner of the<br />
Pfaffinger Hof hotel. It should <strong>com</strong>e as no surprise then that he<br />
had a very clear idea about the quality of the cooling systems<br />
that he needed for his new hotel. So, for refrigeration engineer<br />
Josef Irl, managing director of Irl Kältetechnik GmbH & Co. KG<br />
in the Bavarian town of Edling, there was only one solution. He<br />
ordered from Küba. “Only Küba supplies the high-quality demanded<br />
for a really good cooling system,” is Irl‘s conviction.<br />
The Pfaffinger Hof is a brand new hotel that was built in 2003 in<br />
Pfaf-fing am Inn, a town located located on the Inn river in the<br />
foothills of the Alps. “We <strong>com</strong>bine traditional Bavarian atmosphere<br />
with the <strong>com</strong>fort of a modern hotel”, is how hostess Luise<br />
Bichler describes her hotel’s philosophy. Regardless of whether<br />
guests are planning a tranquil private holiday, a relaxing business<br />
trip, or a family celebration – the Pfaffinger Hof always<br />
offers the right ambiance. First and foremost, however, Luise<br />
Bichler wants to spoil her guests with hearty regional cuisine.<br />
The kitchen‘s offerings range from cream aspic to roast venison.<br />
It is thus logical that refrigeration was of central significance for<br />
the Bichlers as they planned the new building.<br />
Altogether, 5 cooling rooms needed to be equipped: a deep<br />
freeze room, separate cooling cells for meat, beverages, and<br />
vegetables, and a kitchen cooling cell. Two special requirements<br />
were important for the design of overall solution. Firstly,<br />
Alois Bichler placed high priority on an energy-saving system.<br />
Secondly, because the cooling cells are quite small, high-quality<br />
units with minimum space requirements were needed. These<br />
were the interior dimensions in the specification (L x W x H).<br />
Deep freeze cell: 2,100 mm x 1,000 mm x 2,480 mm<br />
meat cooling cell: 2,140 mm x 1,000 mm x 2,380 mm<br />
Kitchen cooling cell: 2,140 mm x 1,700 mm x 2,380 mm<br />
Vegetable cooling cell: 2,140 mm x 1,000 mm x 2,380 mm<br />
Beverage cooling cell: 3,880 mm x 2,680 mm x 2,080 mm<br />
The solution, which was installed between January and October<br />
2003, was very elegant. On the <strong>com</strong>pressor side, Pfaffinger Hof<br />
opted for an integrated solution rather than one consisting of<br />
different individual systems. The specific advantages of this integrated<br />
system are explained at the end of the article. Küba evaporators<br />
were used to equip the cooling cells. Due to their limited<br />
space, Irl selected the slender junior DF from the new green<br />
Küba economy line. The cooling cells were not <strong>com</strong>pletely lined<br />
during installation. Instead, individual cooling cell panels were<br />
cut to size and mounted together. The condenser was installed<br />
in the attic storey.<br />
Now the necessary temperatures can be achieved effortlessly.<br />
In the deep freeze cell a temperature of –20 °C is ensured; the<br />
meat cooling cell is 0 to +2 °C, guaranteed; the standard temperature<br />
in the kitchen cooling cell is +3 °C; vegetables are refrigerated<br />
at +5 °C; and beverages are refrigerated at +6 to +8<br />
°C. Since the Küba units are easy to operate, defrosting and<br />
cleaning are also easy: Twice a day the cooling cells are automatically<br />
defrosted at a final defrosting temperature of +8 to<br />
+10 °C. The cells are cleaned as needed.<br />
Dixell regulators are used to control cooling cell temperature. A<br />
frequency converter is used to regulate the integrated system<br />
from the <strong>com</strong>pressor side.<br />
Moreover, the integrated solution cited proved to be the superior<br />
solution as far as saving energy was concerned. “If we had used<br />
individual systems then we would have had to install a separate<br />
aerating and venting system. That would have meant unnecessarily<br />
higher installation expenses and in addition it would have<br />
driven up the energy costs”, explains refrigeration engineer Irl.<br />
The integrated system saves the customer, as desired, energy<br />
and thus cash in hand. The system consumes between 20 and<br />
35 percent less energy than would have been consumed with<br />
implementation of individual systems.<br />
The integrated system, with heat recovery in <strong>com</strong>bination with<br />
Küba evaporators and the Küba condenser in the attic storey,<br />
controlled by frequency converters and Dixell regulators, thus<br />
enabled a customised, high-performance and in terms of energy,<br />
a highly economical system. Alois Bichler got precisely<br />
the solution that he desired: “The system functions well, to this<br />
point there have been no problems worth mentioning. I am very<br />
pleased”.<br />
irl Kältetechnik gmbH & co. Kg<br />
the <strong>com</strong>pany, headquartered in the Bavarian town of edling, was<br />
founded in 1966 and is now managed by Josef irl in the second generation.<br />
the <strong>com</strong>pany specialises in refrigeration, air-conditioning<br />
and heat pump technology for <strong>com</strong>mercial and industrial applications.<br />
their extensive offering consists of sales, planning, configuration,<br />
installation of new and used cooling systems, as well as heat<br />
pump systems, maintenance, customer service, and on-call duty,<br />
recycling and conversion of old cooling systems.<br />
more information at: www.irl-kaeltetechnik.de<br />
11<br />
01/2006 FORUM
12 | eDitoRiAl | coNteNtS | iNteRVieW | iNteRNAl | AcceSSoRieS | iNSiDe | RePoRt | eVeNtS | PRActice | SeRVice<br />
FORUM 01/2006<br />
Keeping meat a treat<br />
In order to offer its customers top quality, Fleischhauerei Schuster, a specialty meat market in<br />
Upper Austrian Ostermiething purchased a state-of-the-art cooling system.<br />
toDAy’S Pig is tomorrow’s ham is a saying that also applies<br />
in Ostermiething in Upper Austria. This is where the specialty<br />
meat market Fleischhauerei Schuster is headquartered. The<br />
family-owned <strong>com</strong>pany is known for fine hams and many other<br />
meat delicacies. In addition the firm offers party service, canteen<br />
management, wedding and event catering in all variations: from<br />
cold cuts, to finger food, to buffets, and from small gatherings<br />
to major functions. And to ensure that meat, ham and sausage<br />
arrive on the table in top quality, the Schuster family naturally<br />
optimises its refrigeration installations on a regular basis.<br />
The latest round of modernisation began in April 2003, when<br />
the Schusters had decided to build a new large meat processing<br />
facility with adjoining sales area and residential quarters.<br />
New construction had be<strong>com</strong>e necessary because the existing<br />
facilities were bursting at the seams and more space was urgently<br />
needed. In terms of the refrigeration technology this was<br />
an opportunity to make a major step forward. The previous solution,<br />
which consisted primarily of individual aggregates, was<br />
replaced with a sophisticated integrated solution with supplemental<br />
individual systems.<br />
Concept design and system implementation were handled by<br />
Strauß Kälte-Klimatechnik G.m.b.H. in Salzburg. As a longstanding<br />
business partner of the Schuster family Strauß was a<br />
natural choice for this job. The firm was able to individually and<br />
optimally satisfy the needs of the customer.<br />
The new installation, which represents the state of the art in<br />
terms of energy and hygiene, has been in operation for the fa-<br />
tecHNology: KüBA <strong>com</strong>PoNeNtS At A glANce<br />
the home of specialities: Butcher shop, party service, canteen management<br />
and refreshments, all in one.<br />
cility since March 2004. The cooling system had to satisfy the<br />
a number of demanding specifications. It had to offer optimal<br />
energy efficiency and be configurable for different temperature<br />
ranges. It also had to be suitable for different application scenarios,<br />
which meant that it must provide cooling as well as airconditioning<br />
control. This was the prerequisite for ensuring optimal<br />
conditions in each of the different areas. Temperature and<br />
humidity can be precisely matched to the needs of the rooms.<br />
Air speeds can also be adjusted. For instance, in rooms where<br />
Application / cooling room Quantity Air cooler type Room temperature in °c Dt1 Rel. humidity<br />
Ground floor<br />
Cutting 1 DPA 044-N +10 8<br />
Production 1 DPA 044-N +10 8<br />
Meat cooling room 1 SGAE 92 0 7 90– 95<br />
Curing room 1 SGAE 81 +2 7<br />
Acclimatised room 1 SGA 61 +10 10 60–70<br />
Deep-freeze room 1 SGBE 91 – 22 7<br />
Consignment cooling room 5 KVB 2928 0 8 90<br />
Packaging 1 DPA 044-N +10 8<br />
Loading 1 DPA 042-N +10 8<br />
Hallway 1 DPA 042-N +10 8<br />
Waste 1 SPA 042C +4 8<br />
KR kitchen 1 SGAE 81 0 7 90<br />
Sales cooling room 1 KVB 2923 0 8 90<br />
Basement<br />
Cooling room 1 SGAE 81 +4 7 90<br />
Deep-freeze room 1 SGBE 82 – 22 7<br />
www.next-economy-line.de<br />
01/2006 FORUM
14 | eDitoRiAl | coNteNtS | iNteRVieW | iNteRNAl | AcceSSoRieS | iNSiDe | RePoRt | eVeNtS | PRActice | SeRVice<br />
FORUM 01/2006<br />
Photo left: Refrigeration <strong>com</strong>petence prior to regulating the system: engineer Peter Strauß (l.) and franz Schuster. Photo right: <strong>com</strong>fortable<br />
working area: under the DPA044 ceiling Air cooler at maximum 0.8 m/s air speed in the cutting and processing area.<br />
employees are working all day, the air speeds must be kept as<br />
low as possible to avoid draughts.<br />
thus, the cooling system was organised as follows:<br />
• <strong>com</strong>pressor unit for cooling rooms<br />
• <strong>com</strong>pressor unit for cutting rooms and work rooms<br />
• <strong>com</strong>pressor unit for small cooling units in the sales area<br />
• individual systems for deep freeze rooms to<br />
optimise energy consumption and ensure operational reliability.<br />
mode of operation: the work process of a butcher‘s shop<br />
starts in the cutting room. in an area of approximately 75 m²<br />
meat products are precisely cut under a four-motor <strong>com</strong>fort<br />
DP ceiling Air cooler from the new green Küba economy<br />
Strauß Kälte-Klimatechnik g.m.b.H.<br />
Strauß Kälte-Klimatechnik g.m.b.H. in Salzburg-tahlgau can look<br />
back on over 40 years of refrigeration and air-conditioning engineering<br />
experience. Refrigeration and air-conditioning engineering for<br />
the food and beverage sector, food retail, supermarket, fresh produce<br />
warehouses, meat processing plants, as well as building climate<br />
control, are all part of the <strong>com</strong>pany‘s range of services. in these<br />
segments the <strong>com</strong>pany, which is also one of the five owners of Kältering<br />
Austria (a wholesaler serving food and beverage <strong>com</strong>panies),<br />
is one of the strongest family-owned <strong>com</strong>panies in Austria. engineer<br />
Rudolf Strauß, responsible for technology, and engineer Peter<br />
Strauß, responsible for sales, are driving the <strong>com</strong>pany’s expansion<br />
course. An important phase started for Strauß in 1998: the firm moved<br />
into its new building. the facility is approximately 5,500 m 2 and<br />
includes 1,300 m 2 of warehouse, production, office space.<br />
line. thanks to the low air speed of maximum 0.8 m/s, work<br />
under these Air coolers is quite pleasant.<br />
After fine cutting, the meat then goes to further processing<br />
and then onto smoking in the smoker systems, or cooking in<br />
the multi-cart cooking systems. the next step is to cure (preserve)<br />
the sausage and meat products. the curing chamber<br />
is maintained at a constant +2 °c by an electrically defrosted<br />
SgA81. connected to the curing chamber are a consignment<br />
cooling room (pre-picking cooling room) and a meat<br />
cooling room that are both equipped with static Air coolers.<br />
A packaging and loading area is next to the consignment<br />
cooling room. this is where a four-motor and a two-motor<br />
<strong>com</strong>fort DP ceiling Air cooler perform their labour. All DP<br />
units are equipped with speed switches to avoid draughts.<br />
“Our efforts were directed towards installing an economic and<br />
also a technically sophisticated, standard solution with multiple<br />
systems,” emphasises Rudolf Strauß, who designed the system.<br />
“Our principle is: Intelligent and synergetic solutions for<br />
the client‘s specific requirements.” Strauß opted for Küba units<br />
due to the broad product line. “Thus, we were able to avoid mixing<br />
different makes.” The customer, Fleischhauerei Schuster, is<br />
very pleased with the system, which has been working perfectly<br />
since operation began. And the end customers enjoy the fine<br />
products.<br />
SeRVice | PRActice | eVeNtS | RePoRt | iNSiDe | AcceSSoRieS | iNteRNAl | iNteRVieW | coNteNtS | eDitoRiAl | 15<br />
Wel<strong>com</strong>e! We will be presenting the new green economy line and two units from the classic line together with our group partners on our<br />
iKK trade show booth. Stop by and talk to us. We look forward to seeing you (Hall 4, Stand 508)!<br />
meet us at the iKK<br />
This year in Nuremberg the IKK will open its gates for the last time. It will be reborn in 2008 as<br />
Chillventa. Küba and the new economy line will be there, in 2006 and in 2008.<br />
WitHiN A VeRy SHoRt time the new green economy line has<br />
be<strong>com</strong>e an established concept among cooling experts. After a<br />
successful roadshow in the first quarter of this year and an inhouse<br />
show at Küba’s headquarters in Baierbrunn, the four new<br />
product lines will now be introduced to a larger public at IKK in<br />
Nuremberg. The economy line products will be supplemented<br />
in Nuremberg by two multi-variant units from the blue Classic<br />
Line, which are designed for the long-term storage of sensitive<br />
products in open containers. Dear reader, we invite you to visit<br />
our stand from the 18th to the 20th of October and talk to us.<br />
The history of this show will <strong>com</strong>e to an end with this year’s IKK.<br />
In July 2006, 26 <strong>com</strong>panies and 5 organisations in the air conditioning<br />
and refrigeration industry, including Küba Kältetechnik<br />
GmbH, founded the Chillventa exhibitor group. This group will<br />
form the basis of a new trade show, the Chillventa. It will open its<br />
gates in October 2008 and will take the place of the IKK.<br />
Why a new trade show? This development came about after discussions<br />
concerning the future of our industry trade fair with the<br />
German Refrigeration & Air-Conditioning Association (Verband<br />
Deutscher Kälte-Klima-Fachbetriebe (VDKF)), failed conclusively<br />
mid-year – despite the efforts on all sides. The VDKF wanted to<br />
continue holding the IKK annually in spite of the disappointment<br />
experienced at the Hanover Fair in 2005, where 50 percent fewer<br />
visitors attended. In addition the idea was to <strong>com</strong>bine the IKK in<br />
odd number years with the large ISH/Aircontec trade fair held in<br />
Frankfurt, which is carried primarily by the heating and sanitation<br />
industries and their industry associations. This would have <strong>com</strong>promised<br />
the conceptual clarity of the IKK. Moreover the VKDF<br />
had planned to give up the successful and internationally esteemed<br />
trade fair venue of Nuremberg.<br />
Many exhibitors did not agree with these proposals. Thus, the<br />
exhibitor group, Chillventa Nuremberg, was formed, which in<br />
the meantime has been extended by the addition of several major<br />
<strong>com</strong>panies and which also has been able to win the German<br />
Federal Guild, Association of the Cooling and Refrigeration<br />
Trade (Bundesinnungsverband des Deutschen Kälteanlagenbauerhandwerks<br />
(BIV). The BIV represents 19 state guilds and a<br />
total of 1,100 refrigeration and air-conditioning firms. Moreover,<br />
10 Italian industry <strong>com</strong>panies have declared their support for<br />
the new Chillventa.<br />
NürnbergMesse will organise the new trade fair. It will invest considerably<br />
in Chillventa. Among other things NürnbergMesse has<br />
agreed to reduce exhibitor rental rates by more than 10 percent,<br />
double the advertising budget and to appropriately <strong>com</strong>pensate<br />
the services of associations, organisations and institutions. With<br />
this modernised trade fair concept the Chillventa will continue<br />
the successful history of the IKK: under a new name at an esteemed<br />
trade fair venue.<br />
01/2006 FORUM
16 | eDitoRiAl | coNteNtS | iNteRVieW | iNteRNAl | AcceSSoRieS | iNSiDe | RePoRt | eVeNtS | PRActice | SeRVice<br />
FORUM 01/2006<br />
gooD NeWS foR tHe eNViRoNmeNt – AND tHe ecoNomy.<br />
Sustainable decentralised power generation is developing<br />
into a pronounced growth market. Soon wind energy will<br />
be<strong>com</strong>e the most significant source of regenerative energy and<br />
will replace hydropower in this category.<br />
Thus, future perspectives for the Nordex Group, one of the<br />
world‘s largest suppliers of wind turbines, could not be better.<br />
The same applies for its strategic partner, Winergy AG from<br />
Voerde on the lower Rhine. Winergy, a long-standing Küba customer<br />
is the leading provider of gear units and generators for<br />
wind turbines with locations in Voerde and Ruhstorf in Bavaria.<br />
The Voerde site produces the gear units, while Ruhstorf is responsible<br />
for the generators.<br />
Together with the Nordex Group, Winergy have implemented<br />
an outstanding reference project, in which Küba is also a participant:<br />
the Windpark Ketzin, currently the largest wind farm in<br />
Germany. Ketzin is located approximately 20 kilometres north<br />
A fresh breeze for wind<br />
power<br />
To optimally cool the wind turbine’s generators, Winergy AG relies on heat<br />
exchangers with maximised surface area.<br />
The contribution made by refrigeration technology: A wind turbine<br />
has approximately 18 different <strong>com</strong>ponents. For example,<br />
gear units, clutches or frequency converters. Moreover, there<br />
is also a generator with a capacity of up to 2,500 kW that is<br />
part of such a turbine. The generator must be cooled with water.<br />
Since a large share of the <strong>com</strong>ponents are delivered by Winergy<br />
AG, Küba‘s participation in this exciting project was a natural<br />
choice. A heat exchanger with the largest possible surface area,<br />
this means the greatest possible heat exchanging capacity was<br />
required to cool the generator. At the same time, this heat ex-<br />
Winergy Ag<br />
Winergy Ag (headquartered in Voerde) is the leading provider of gear<br />
units and generators for wind turbines. in recent years the <strong>com</strong>pany<br />
has extended its market share to more than 40 percent. in the wind<br />
turbine segment with more than one megawatt capacity, (the so-called<br />
megawatt class), Winergy even has a market share of more than<br />
50 percent. of the 49,000 wind turbines installed worldwide, 24,000<br />
of them are equipped with Winergy gear units. this corresponds to a<br />
market share of more than 45 percent. in addition Winergy is among<br />
the leading suppliers of generators for wind turbines with a world<br />
market share of approximately 16 percent.<br />
of Potsdam in an area on the Nauner plateau that is zoned for<br />
wind power generation. It was built in early 2005 by the Nordex-<br />
Winergy team for e.disnatur, a subsidiary of Fürstenwald-based<br />
E.DIS AG. The farm is equipped with eight N90 turbines and has<br />
a total installed capacity of 18.4 MW.<br />
The Ketzin wind farm is considered to be in a weak wind location.<br />
To obtain optimal energy yield at such a location the machines<br />
have been erected on tubular towers that are 100 metres<br />
high. At this hub height the annual measured mean wind speed<br />
is 6.3 m/s.<br />
The 2.3 MW turbines that were especially developed for the<br />
German market and installed here will generate approximately<br />
35 million kW of electricity annually. This corresponds to the<br />
annual power consumption of approximately 8,000 private<br />
households in Brandenburg. What’s more, generating this<br />
amount of electricity from wind prevents the emission of<br />
30,000 tons of CO 2 that is harmful to the climate.<br />
changer had to ensure the lowest possible<br />
loss of pressure on the air side. Based<br />
on the <strong>com</strong>pany‘s special expertise Küba<br />
developed a prototype to re-cool the cooling<br />
water.<br />
How is this performed? The air inside the wind<br />
turbine that is heated by generator losses is circulated<br />
exclusively by the turning rotor. After its exit<br />
from the stator package the air is forced through the<br />
heat exchanger. The inner air which is re-cooled in this<br />
manner is then rerouted into the areas of the two stator end<br />
connections into the rotor. Both cooling flows (air/water) are<br />
separate closed circuits. The warmed water and glycol mixture<br />
is re-cooled by the outside air. At full generator capacity total<br />
losses of up to 85 kW can occur on the generator. Additional<br />
ribbing to cool the generator is not required.<br />
Oliver Memminger, head design engineer for Winergy AG in Ruhstorf<br />
values the collaboration with Küba: “In <strong>com</strong>peting with other<br />
well-known manufacturers, Küba Kältetechnik came through<br />
as the winner due to their outstanding project work, high level of<br />
flexibility, their high quality standard and their exemplary<br />
documentation.” These prerequisites are mandatory<br />
for series production. In addition, short response times<br />
for all types of enquiries, the non-bureaucratic handling<br />
of prototype orders, as well as the short delivery times<br />
played an important role. “Küba‘s extensive know-how<br />
was another decisive factor. Because all <strong>com</strong>ponents<br />
<strong>com</strong>e from well-known certified manufacturers, we can<br />
also guarantee high quality,” explains Memminger<br />
with satisfaction.<br />
➊ ➊<br />
➊<br />
in addition to the Küba cooled generator there are<br />
17 different <strong>com</strong>ponents in a wind turbine<br />
17
18 | eDitoRiAl | coNteNtS | iNteRVieW | iNteRNAl | AcceSSoRieS | iNSiDe | RePoRt | eVeNtS | PRActice | SeRVice<br />
FORUM 01/2006<br />
Uniformly well cooled<br />
Room cooling can be easily and hygienically optimised with textile hoses from<br />
Thermotex: Air is distributed in the room right where it’s wanted.<br />
fReSH, cRiSP VegetABleS, tender steaks, or fine pastries<br />
are appealing and they are what customers want. However in<br />
the cooled work areas of the food industry one will frequently<br />
find wilted lettuce, tough meat or dried-out baked goods. The<br />
reason is usually non-uniform air distribution. This problem,<br />
however, can be quickly and easily solved with a system based<br />
on the textile hoses from Thermotex Luftleitsysteme GmbH in<br />
Moers and evaporators from Küba. Air can be uniformly distributed<br />
in the room with the hoses that are directly connected to<br />
the evaporators. “In cooled work areas textile hoses currently<br />
represent the state of the art”, confirms Rolf Otten, project engineer<br />
for Linde AG headquartered in Wiesbaden.<br />
This consistent use of textile hoses makes sense: All <strong>com</strong>panies<br />
that must cool their work areas for production require uniform,<br />
low-draft cooling. Heat nests must be avoided. The <strong>com</strong>bined<br />
Thermotex/Küba system makes this possible and also has a<br />
positive side effect: the working conditions for employees are<br />
improved, resulting in lower illness rates. Accordingly, the hose<br />
evaporator system has be<strong>com</strong>e a standard in the major logistics<br />
centres of the food retail industry – for example, for Edeka,<br />
Rewe or Tengelmann. Moreover, cooling the entire sales or work<br />
area with this solution, instead of storing the goods that need<br />
to be cooled in individual refrigerated shelves, is a solution that<br />
implemented more and more. “The latter is another ideal application<br />
for a system consisting of Küba evaporators and Thermotex<br />
textile hoses,” explains Claudio Steinman, refrigeration<br />
engineer TS at Frigo Consulting in Schlieren, Switzerland.<br />
How does the solution function specifically? Air leaving the Küba<br />
evaporator is channelled into Thermotex textile hoses and then<br />
distributed throughout the room. The hoses are made of polypropylene,<br />
a synthetic fabric that is characterised by its minimal<br />
water retention capacity. At the end the hose is not sown shut,<br />
rather it is stopped with a round end cap of the same diameter.<br />
This produces a closed pressure system. Air escapes over the<br />
entire surface of the hose at a speed of less than 0.2 m/sec. Water<br />
condensation does not occur, since due to the air-permeable<br />
fabric the temperature does not fall below the dew point. Compared<br />
to insulated sheet metal ducting with air grills, this form<br />
of air distribution is much easier and much more practical. It offers<br />
even more advantages: Lower <strong>com</strong>pression, lower weight,<br />
faster installation and last but not least, a lower price. Furthermore,<br />
the fact that the hoses can be cleaned and that they are<br />
resistant to aggressive cleaning agents and lyes, makes them<br />
an outstanding alternative to VA ducts.<br />
Thermotex primarily develops industry-specific and custom<br />
variants: “Our textile hoses are not off-the-shelf products; they<br />
are each manufactured to customer order,” explains managing<br />
director Jörg-Peter Krebs. Thus, the confectionary industry appreciates<br />
the following solution: Thanks to fabric with differing<br />
levels of permeability, the air escape direction can be guided<br />
as needed in one hose. The upper half (9 to 3 o’clock) consists<br />
of air-impermeable fabric; the lower half of the hose (3 to<br />
9 o’clock) consists of permeable fabric. Thus, the air only flows<br />
downward.<br />
Just how individual a solution can be is demonstrated by this<br />
actual case study: In the Tengelmann AG Logistics Centre in Viersen,<br />
outside of Düsseldorf, the challenge was that there were<br />
different ceiling heights in one room. In addition, due to the<br />
remodelling in the course of expanding the warehouse, there<br />
were main beams that ran in the air direction and shelving that<br />
reached almost to the ceiling. Heinrich Kreutzträger Kältetechnik<br />
GmbH & Co. KG, which has been relying on the Küba/Thermotex<br />
<strong>com</strong>bination for some time now, was <strong>com</strong>missioned to<br />
optimise these rooms in terms of refrigeration engineering. The<br />
experts sewed the textile hoses with height jumps and side<br />
jumps. Now the air is distributed to two or three textile hoses<br />
from one <strong>com</strong>pressor, as needed. An optimal solution.<br />
this is how it works (l. to r.): Hose adapter for <strong>com</strong>pensating the<br />
different heights (side view), hose piece at the transition point from<br />
two hoses to one; two-motor Air cooler with thermotex textile hoses.<br />
more information at: www.thermo-<br />
19<br />
01/2006 FORUM
20 | eDitoRiAl | coNteNtS | iNteRVieW | iNteRNAl | AcceSSoRieS | iNSiDe | RePoRt | eVeNtS | PRActice | SeRVice<br />
FORUM 01/2006<br />
Self-serve shelves in front of the fish sales area co 2 -SgA 051 at 0 = 0 °c, for cooling the fish sales area<br />
Best energy balance<br />
In the branches of Aligro bulk supermarket, CO 2 is used as the refrigerant and <strong>com</strong>es out with significantly better<br />
numbers than does the standard refrigerant R404A.<br />
foR 30 yeARS, Aligro has been the undisputed number one<br />
among the bulk supermarkets in French-speaking Switzerland.<br />
The reason is the well thought-out retail concept that Aligro<br />
founder Pierre Demaurex developed in the 1960‘s in Geneva and<br />
which he consistently improved. The family-owned <strong>com</strong>pany<br />
provides its customers, particularly restauranteurs and retailers,<br />
not only top quality products in the greatest variety, Aligro “Alimentation<br />
en gros” also features particularly customer-friendly<br />
opening times: Its doors open to customers at 6:00 a.m.<br />
Last fall, Dominique and Etienne Demaurex, sons and successors<br />
of Pierre Demaurex opened the third Aligro market in Sion.<br />
The typical Demaurex concept finds its successful implementation<br />
on an impressive 5,000 m 2 sales floor (out of total floor<br />
space of 12,500 m 2 ). Since freshness of the products is one of<br />
the crucial quality parameters for Aligro markets, in Sion refrigeration<br />
also played a decisive role. LKS KälteSchweiz AG/LKS<br />
FroidSuisse SA, headquartered in Prattlen near Basel was re-<br />
sponsible for planning and realisation of the overall refrigeration<br />
and control technology in the normal area and deep freeze area<br />
of the bulk supermarket. It is a subsidiary of the US firm, Carrier/Linde<br />
Refrigeration. It supplied three <strong>com</strong>pressor units, as<br />
well as the cooling display cases with a total sales length of 180<br />
m and equipped the nine walk-in cooling rooms with floor space<br />
of approximately 200 m 2 . Moreover, Carrier/Linde Refrigeration<br />
outfitted the five deep freeze cells with floor space of approximately<br />
90 m 2 .<br />
Technical details: For normal cooling, the new CO 2 <strong>com</strong>posite cooling<br />
system CO 2 OLtec by Linde Kältetechnik was used for the third<br />
time. Control and monitoring of these NC <strong>com</strong>pressor units, which<br />
also work in the transcritical area, is also handled by the newly<br />
developed Eckelmann VS3000C. All sales display case evaporators<br />
and cooling room evaporators are equipped with electronic<br />
expansion valves.<br />
The required overall cooling capacity for the normal cooling area<br />
is 322 kW. It is divided into two separate integrated refrigeration<br />
units each with identical cooling capacity. The deep-freeze area<br />
reaches a cooling capacity of 67 kW. Its heat is dissipated in<br />
cascade operation by CO 2 evaporating directly from the normal<br />
cooling systems. In the sales areas as well the direct expanding<br />
carbon dioxide ensures heat dissipation in the normal as well as<br />
in the deep-freeze area. A CO 2 gas cooler in V-block design is<br />
used for transferring the heat (2 x 236 kW) that needs to be dissipated<br />
to the ambient air. In the sales areas <strong>com</strong>mercial retail<br />
shoppers can find fresh and frozen goods in a variety of different<br />
cooled shelving, cooling counters, cooling islands and deepfreeze<br />
<strong>com</strong>binations from the Linde Evolution 5 series, as well<br />
as in a larger number of walk-in cooling rooms and deep freeze<br />
rooms. In these areas CO 2 Air Coolers from Küba are used exclusively.<br />
A listing is provided in the table on page 22. In addition<br />
heat recovery is integrated in the overall system concept. Thus,<br />
hot water for heating at 2 x 150 kW is available during the heating<br />
season and hot service water at 90 kW is available year round.<br />
Some details concerning system installation and process control<br />
for normal cooling: In the normal cooling system the <strong>com</strong>pressor<br />
unit system was divided into two pressure areas for<br />
the dimensioning of <strong>com</strong>ponents. The high-pressure area was<br />
configured at a maximum operating pressure of 115 bar. This<br />
area includes the pressure side of the <strong>com</strong>pressors, the heat<br />
recovery system, the hot gas and liquid line to the gas cooler,<br />
all refrigeration <strong>com</strong>ponents on the high-pressure stage, as well<br />
as a special high-pressure valve. The maximum operating pressure<br />
for the other system <strong>com</strong>ponents, for example the collector<br />
or the liquid and suction line, is only 40 bar. The evaporators<br />
in the normal cooling system are optimised on the refrigerant<br />
side for CO 2 for technical flow reasons and configured for the<br />
higher pressure loads. Thus, for the greater part of the systems,<br />
standardised <strong>com</strong>mercial refrigeration <strong>com</strong>ponents could be<br />
used that among other things can also be used in CO 2 deep<br />
freezing.<br />
Other important issues when operating a <strong>com</strong>pressor unit system<br />
are the expenses for electricity. The refrigerant used is of<br />
crucial relevance, particularly in this regard. If high outside temperatures<br />
are assumed, then the standard refrigerant R404A<br />
shows clear advantages in a superficial <strong>com</strong>parison of the refrigerants<br />
R404A and CO 2 relative to achievable performance.<br />
“However, if the favourable thermodynamic and technical thermal<br />
characteristics of CO 2 are taken into consideration, there is<br />
a different picture,” emphasises Marcus Höpfl, manager of the<br />
Buchser subsidiary and member of the management team of<br />
LKS KälteSchweiz AG. He explains:<br />
• Due to better heat transfer ensured by CO 2 , it is possible to<br />
operate refrigeration furniture or cooling room evaporators at an<br />
evaporation temperature that is two Kelvin higher <strong>com</strong>pared to<br />
R404A.<br />
• Due to the high pressure situation of CO 2 there is a saturation<br />
temperature loss in the suction line that is reduced by one<br />
Kelvin as <strong>com</strong>pared to R404A. Thus, the return transport of the<br />
oil to the condensers is further ensured in this process. The CO 2<br />
condensers in the normal cooling system can be operated with<br />
vacuum pressure, which corresponds in total relative to R404A<br />
to a saturation temperature that is three Kelvin higher.<br />
• The special characteristics of the transcritical process control<br />
and the good heat transfer characteristics of CO 2 in the gas<br />
cooler enable cooling of the pressure gas to nearly the air temperature.<br />
• At lower air temperatures a reduction of the condensing temperature<br />
to approximately +10 °C is possible when using CO 2 . The<br />
reason is that a sufficiently high differential pressure exists relative<br />
to the evaporation pressure due to the higher pressure level of CO 2<br />
even at these low temperatures.<br />
• The current energy consumption of NC/DF DX CO 2 systems<br />
is approximately 15 to 20 percent lower than <strong>com</strong>parable NC<br />
R404A-systems with refrigerant/re-cooling system and DF DX.<br />
The energy data are based on measurements that have been<br />
performed over a period of one to one and half years.<br />
• At the current state-of-the-art the investment costs of NC/DF<br />
DX CO 2 systems are equivalent to the cited <strong>com</strong>parable R404A.<br />
The prerequisite is that the NC system performance must be<br />
21<br />
01/2006 FORUM
22 | eDitoRiAl | coNteNtS | iNteRVieW | iNteRNAl | AcceSSoRieS | iNSiDe | RePoRt | eVeNtS | PRActice | SeRVice<br />
FORUM 01/2006<br />
co 2 -SAfety meASUReS: (l.) Bakery goods cooling cell with acoustic and visual signal if there is a co 2 alarm, as well as „Do not enter if<br />
there is a co 2 alarm“ warnning sticker. (r.) After failure or standstill, all systems automatically start up again, even if the safety valve (as<br />
shown in the photo) was active.<br />
more than 220 kW or the surface area of the supermarket must<br />
exceed 2,500 m 2 .<br />
For Marcus Höpfl, the summary is clear: “CO 2 should be looking<br />
at an exciting future as refrigerant. Currently its implementation<br />
in refrigeration applications is indeed somewhat more expensive<br />
because the necessary <strong>com</strong>ponents are not yet being produced<br />
in the same quantities as are produced for systems that<br />
work with fluorinated refrigerants. Currently this acts as somewhat<br />
of a brake on demand. In the future, however, there will<br />
not be a price difference even at lower system capacities. Even<br />
today, environmentally-oriented and energy-efficient <strong>com</strong>panies<br />
are converting to CO 2 and are setting positive examples. The<br />
leaders are found in the Scandinavian countries and countries<br />
like Switzerland, the Netherlands, Luxemburg, Saudi Arabia and<br />
Germany.“<br />
tHe tecHNology At A glANce<br />
cooling rooms with co 2 supercritical and deep freeze rooms with co 2 subcritical. equipped with Küba co 2 evaporators.<br />
Room Application evaporator capacity / kW t 0 /°c t R /°c P max bar<br />
Cooling room NC Dairy S-SGBE 091 10.2 –5 +3/+5 54<br />
Cooling room NC Unloading dock S-SGB 071 11.6 +3 +13/+15 54<br />
Cooling room NC Intermediate storage S-SGB 061 8.0 +3 +13/+15 54<br />
Cooling room NC Preparation S-SGB 041 2.9 0 +8/+10 54<br />
Cooling room NC Intermediate storage S-SGBE 081 7.3 –7 0/+12 54<br />
Cooling room NC Meat S-SGBE 061 4.0 –7 0/+2 54<br />
Cooling room NC Meat preparation S-SGA 041 2.5 0 +8/+10 54<br />
Cooling room NC Bakery S-SGBE 071 5.7 –7 0/+2 54<br />
Cooling room NC Fish preparation S-SGA 051 3.9 0 +8/+10 54<br />
Cooling room NC General S-SGBE 081 7.3 –7 0/+12 54<br />
Cooling room NC Fish preparation S-SGA 051 3.9 0 +8/+10 54<br />
Cooling room NC Fruits & vegetables S-SGB 091 10.2 –5 +3/+5 54<br />
Cooling room DF Deep-freeze room S-SGLE 082 C 10.5 –31 –22/–24 32<br />
Cooling room NC Deep-freeze room S-SGLE 082 C 10.5 –31 –22/–24 32<br />
SeRVice | PRActice | eVeNtS | RePoRt | iNSiDe | AcceSSoRieS | iNteRNAl | iNteRVieW | coNteNtS | eDitoRiAl | 23<br />
On March 16th 2005, the Act Governing the Sale, Return and Environmentally Sound Disposal of Electrical and Electronic Equipment<br />
(ElektroG) went into effect in Germany. Thus, two EC directives that are important for the refrigeration industry were also implemented<br />
in German national law: Directive 2002/96/EC concerning Waste of Electrical and Electronic Equipment (WEEE), as well<br />
as directive 2002/95/EC concerning the restriction of certain hazardous substances in electrical and electronic equipment (RoHS).<br />
To what extent is Küba affected by the new directives? Are Küba products subject to the new ElektroG and, if yes, which ones? Do<br />
cooling systems that are equipped with Küba heat exchangers fall under the ElektroG?<br />
tHe AReA of APPlicABility of the ElektroG includes large<br />
and small household appliances (e.g. refrigerators, mobile room<br />
air conditioners) that require electrical current or electromagnetic<br />
fields for their operation. On the other hand, the ElektroG does<br />
not apply to these units or <strong>com</strong>ponents if they are connected to<br />
units that are not themselves subject to the ElektroG (for example,<br />
room air conditioners that are permanently installed in the<br />
building, as the building is not subject to the ElektroG), or units<br />
that are only installed by specialised personnel (e.g. cooling systems).<br />
• Evaporators, Air Coolers, condensers and re-coolers, which<br />
are indeed equipped with fans, are not considered electrical<br />
equipment in terms of the ElektroG, because they are installed<br />
by specialised personnel in stationary cooling systems. The<br />
cooling system is permanently connected to the building.<br />
• Heat exchangers are not classified as electrical equipment<br />
subject to the ElektroG, rather they are considered to be<br />
<strong>com</strong>ponents. Only if these <strong>com</strong>ponents are installed in units<br />
which themselves are subject to the ElektroG, (e.g. coolers<br />
in large household appliances), must the ElektroG be taken<br />
into account relative to the restrictions on the use of certain<br />
hazardous substances such as lead, mercury, chrome or cadmium.<br />
Heat exchangers in permanently installed systems are<br />
not subject to the ElektroG.<br />
• Likewise, refrigeration or air-conditioning products such as<br />
are installed in vehicles or in refrigerated sales display cases<br />
do not fall under the ElektroG (see the ORGALIM manual for<br />
WEEE and RoHS).<br />
Küba heat exchangers and units are designed for permanent industrial<br />
cooling systems that are installed by specialised personnel<br />
and thus are not subject to the ElektroG. Nevertheless, for<br />
the materials, solder or welding additives and purchased parts<br />
used by Küba, certificates are available stating that these materials<br />
or parts are RoHS-<strong>com</strong>pliant. While Küba heat exchangers<br />
are not subject to the ElektroG, they nonetheless satisfy both<br />
RoHS and ElektroG requirements.<br />
moRe iNfo<br />
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS<br />
http://www.kueba.<strong>com</strong>/kueba/deutsch/nbsp/menu/what_146_s_<br />
new/aktuelles/aktuelle_vortraege/elektrog/index.html<br />
01/2006 FORUM