11.01.2013 Views

Brushstrokes - October 2011 - Surface Coatings Association of New ...

Brushstrokes - October 2011 - Surface Coatings Association of New ...

Brushstrokes - October 2011 - Surface Coatings Association of New ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

www.scanz.org.nz<br />

OCTOBER <strong>2011</strong><br />

Crystals <strong>of</strong> Anatase Titanium Dioxide


For Your Specialty Chemical Needs<br />

Specialist <strong>of</strong><br />

Industrial Minerals<br />

Auckland 09 444 4650 Brett, Janine, Glenys, Rod<br />

Christchurch 03 338 8995 Mike, Jason<br />

www.chemcolour.co.nz info@chemcolour.co.nz<br />

ISO 9001:2000<br />

Need Innovation?<br />

ISM have the solution!<br />

Representing the leading brands in paint manufacture<br />

Additives<br />

Acrylic Microspheres<br />

AMP95 and VOX 1000<br />

Cellulosics<br />

Bentone Clays<br />

Biocides<br />

“Green” options<br />

Flow, levelling, defoamers<br />

Wetting agents<br />

Rheology Modifiers<br />

Dispersants<br />

Resins<br />

Acrylic polyols<br />

Alkyds<br />

Crosslinkers<br />

Epoxies<br />

Iso Free systems<br />

hydrocarbon resins<br />

Phenolics<br />

Silicones and Siloxanes<br />

Solution polymers<br />

Pigments<br />

AntiCorrosives<br />

Cuprous Oxide<br />

Flame Retardants<br />

Fluorescents<br />

Metallics<br />

Mixed Metallic Oxides<br />

Organic and Inorganics<br />

Pearls<br />

Titanium Dioxide<br />

Ultramarines<br />

ISM NEW ZEALAND LTD, 71C MONTGOMERIE ROAD,<br />

AIRPORT OAKS, MANUKAU CITY 2241, NEW ZEALAND<br />

TELEPhONE: +64 9 275 0745 FACSIMILE: +64 9 275 0746<br />

www.ismnz.com<br />

Liquid Coating Resins & Additives<br />

Bayferrox Iron Oxides<br />

Biocides & Performance Additives<br />

Mineral Fillers & Additives<br />

Surfactants & Enviro-friendly Solvents<br />

Nick Bray 09 306 6091 nick@alchemyagencies.co.nz<br />

Nigel Garland 09 306 6096 nigel@alchemyagencies.co.nz<br />

www.alchemyagencies.co.nz<br />

“Supplier for industrial solutions”<br />

DSM Neoresins; Arch Chemical biocides; BASF Emulsions & solvents; Celanese solvents & monomers;<br />

Extender pigments; Orica chlorinated paraffins; Degussa catalysts; Haltermann Oils & solvents;<br />

Huntsman Tioxide; Kukdo Epoxies; Noveon additives; Lucite monomers; Magruder flushes; Penreco oils;<br />

Rockwood Oxides; Johnson Matthey organic titanates; Wolstenholme metallic pigments and much more…<br />

Free phone 0800 22 22 77<br />

http://www.orica-chemicals.com


This edition was intended to have Titanium<br />

dioxide as its theme but as usual following<br />

the conference, there is some spill over in this<br />

issue and for the next. In this edition we have the full<br />

transcript <strong>of</strong> Adam Berry’s article kindly given to us by<br />

Nuplex Industries Ltd. Adam has joined Rocket Lab<br />

Ltd, a new Zealand based company that is developing<br />

niche technologies in electronics and propulsion<br />

system for rockets. Who would have believed that paint<br />

technology could lead to Rocket Science? Of course<br />

some would say that Rocket Science is no longer<br />

Rocket Science! NASA are planning to hand launch<br />

capability over to the private sector on the grounds<br />

that rocket science has become common science. I<br />

think there may be some pain ahead.<br />

Speaking <strong>of</strong> rocket science, we see from Peter’s<br />

painted memories, that early titanium dioxide started<br />

life as a coprecipitated anatase and barium sulphate<br />

and eventually to uncoated grades in the early 1940’s.<br />

Uncoated titanium dioxide has highly catalytic<br />

effect on any organic binding resins and must have<br />

produced some fierce chalking. The advent <strong>of</strong> surface<br />

treated grades greatly improved the performance as<br />

we see today. Couple that with the improvements in<br />

additives and titanium almost stirs straight into many<br />

paint formulations without the need for prolonged<br />

dispersion. When I started in the paint industry,<br />

everything was done in a ball mill, even laboratory<br />

samples. How many people even remember how to<br />

formulate for a ball mill?<br />

Throughout the time that I have been associated with<br />

the paint industry, the titanium dioxide producers<br />

have been threatening short supply and high prices as<br />

the cost <strong>of</strong> production and the market price squeezed<br />

pr<strong>of</strong>its, or so we were always lead to believe. We even<br />

had some Japanese suppliers use the <strong>New</strong> Zealand<br />

market to get established and then “turn <strong>of</strong>f the tap”<br />

so to speak. Titanium is probably better value in real<br />

dollar terms than it has ever been and with a rebound<br />

recession predicted, the paint industry will no doubt<br />

feel the effects very early in the cycle, resulting in less<br />

pressure on prices. Let’s hope our own paint industry<br />

will be in position to take advantage <strong>of</strong> it.<br />

<strong>Brushstrokes</strong><br />

Editorial<br />

The committee is in the advanced stages <strong>of</strong> planning<br />

for a seminar to be held in mid <strong>October</strong>, similar to the<br />

very successful one held back in 2004. The theme<br />

is basic paint technology, intended fort technicians,<br />

people in sales that think they know it all but <strong>of</strong>ten<br />

don’t, old hand like me that have forgotten it or have<br />

holes in their knowledge they don’t even know about,<br />

or anyone else that is interested to learn, or re learn,<br />

some <strong>of</strong> the fundamentals again. With the changes<br />

that have taken place in the last 10 years or so, there<br />

is always something new to be learnt. Look out for the<br />

notice later in the journal.<br />

In that regard, the <strong>Coatings</strong> and Polymer Science<br />

course is still available at the University <strong>of</strong> Auckland.<br />

It is administered by Neil Edmonds and run at<br />

Tamaki Campus in Glen Innes. The course has<br />

been amalgamated into the polymers and plastics<br />

program and run in conjunction between the School<br />

<strong>of</strong> Chemical Sciences and Engineering and Materials<br />

Science. More details next issue for those that would<br />

like to take their knowledge to a higher level with a<br />

recognised qualification.<br />

CJB.<br />

The theme <strong>of</strong> the next issue is<br />

Ro<strong>of</strong> <strong>Coatings</strong>.<br />

Any technical, historical or market oriented<br />

articles to do with the paint for ro<strong>of</strong>s, painting<br />

ro<strong>of</strong>s or the substrates that ro<strong>of</strong>s are made<br />

from, will be gratefully accepted.<br />

Please send any ideas, articles<br />

or suggestions to the editor.<br />

Email: cbolt@xtra.co.nz<br />

Phone: 021 897 844.<br />

or by mail to PO Box 1282, Pukekohe 2340<br />

Advertising enquires: Marina on<br />

021 781 968 or marina@apconz.co.nz<br />

Visit the SCANZ website<br />

www.scanz.org.nz<br />

SURFACE COATINGS ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 1


Painted Memories<br />

A selection <strong>of</strong> Historical Paint References compiled by Peter Walters<br />

Titanium Dioxide, the theme <strong>of</strong> this edition <strong>of</strong> <strong>Brushstrokes</strong>, is,<br />

in spite <strong>of</strong> its now almost universal use as the white opacifying<br />

pigment in most industries, a very recent addition to our<br />

formulating armoury. Titanium Dioxide has only been produced<br />

commercially since 1919, initially by two companies, sharing<br />

technology and development efforts, in Fredrikstad, Norway &<br />

Niagara Falls, USA.<br />

The first Titanium Dioxide products consisted <strong>of</strong> 25% anatase<br />

TiO2 co-precipitated with 75% barium or calcium sulphate.<br />

These pigments gave between three and four times as much<br />

hiding as the then commonly used white lead. This quantum<br />

leap in performance sounded the death knell <strong>of</strong> white lead as<br />

an effective opacifying pigment. However initial cost <strong>of</strong> these<br />

‘high performance’ pigments relegated their early use to quality<br />

and specialised paints, providing the white lead industry with<br />

breathing space.<br />

The crucial dates in the adoption <strong>of</strong> TiO2 as our preferred<br />

white opacifying pigment are 1920, the first commercial TiO2<br />

composite products became available for purchase, 1928,<br />

‘Pure’ anatase pigments, 1940, ‘Pure’ rutile pigments and 1951<br />

the first surface treated TiO2 products became commercially<br />

available. During the 1950’s TiO2 replaced most previous white<br />

opacifiers as the pigment <strong>of</strong> choice.<br />

This timeline is reflected in the historic texts in my personal<br />

library. The Certain-teed Paints Varnishes handbook <strong>of</strong> 1928<br />

mentions Titanox, a 30% titanium oxide co-precipitated<br />

with 70% barium sulphate, and Titanolith, a very new coprecipitated<br />

three component pigment consisting <strong>of</strong> 15%<br />

titanium oxide, 25% zinc sulphide and 60% barium sulphate.<br />

The handbook contains the comment “Titanium oxide itself<br />

is a very excellent pigment but it is so expensive that it could<br />

not be put to general use.” Even the article on Titanox states<br />

that “Its relatively high cost causes it to be replaced whenever<br />

possible by combinations <strong>of</strong> other pigments which possess<br />

equally good properties.”<br />

By 1935 The Modern Painter and Decorator stated, under an<br />

entry for Titanium Oxide, that it was a “comparatively new<br />

addition to the range <strong>of</strong> white pigments” that had the chief<br />

disadvantage <strong>of</strong> an “expense which has prevented it from being<br />

so widely employed as it deserves to be.”<br />

My extract for our theme is from von Fischer’s comprehensive<br />

textbook “Paint and Varnish Technology” published in 1948 by<br />

the Reinhold Publishing Company. I have chosen to reproduce<br />

the first part <strong>of</strong> Chapter 5 as it comprehensively contrasts and<br />

compares all white opacifying pigments used in the coatings<br />

2 SURFACE COATINGS ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND<br />

industry at a point in time when Titanium Dioxide was just<br />

coming to dominate this field. A coatings text, therefore, had to<br />

compare TiO2 with the existing technologies that the coatings<br />

technologists at the time would have been familiar with. This<br />

textbook was also published prior to the introduction <strong>of</strong> surface<br />

treated grades <strong>of</strong> TiO2 and at a time when anatase TiO2 was<br />

considered the appropriate choice for exterior white house<br />

paints because <strong>of</strong> the “self-cleaning” properties brought about<br />

by its free-chalking characteristics.<br />

White Hiding Pigments<br />

By W. H. Madson<br />

Pigments Department, E.I. duPont deNemours & Co., Inc.,<br />

Wilmington, Delaware<br />

In this chapter there will be a general consideration <strong>of</strong> the<br />

various white hiding pigments in common use. This subject<br />

is a very large one; therefore it will not be covered completely<br />

but only the more important points will be considered. There<br />

isn’t any good short definition <strong>of</strong> what we mean by a white<br />

hiding pigment. However, it may be defined as a material which<br />

“tends to color something white.”<br />

In order to clarify the topic under consideration it is best to list<br />

the white hiding pigments which will be taken up. The following<br />

are included:<br />

White lead (basic carbonate) Titanium dioxide (Rutile)<br />

White lead (basic sulfate) Titanated Lithopone<br />

Zinc oxide Zinc sulfide-barium<br />

Leaded zinc oxide Zinc sulfide-calcium<br />

Lithopone Zinc sulfide-magnesium<br />

Zinc sulfide Antimony Oxide<br />

Titanium-barium pigment Lead titanate<br />

Titanium-calcium pigment Basic lead silicate<br />

Titanium-magnesium pigment Zirconium oxide<br />

Titanium dioxide (Anatase) Lead tetra-phosphate<br />

Of these 20 white pigments, white lead is the oldest, while<br />

titanium dioxide (pure and extended) is the most important<br />

today. The last three are relatively new in the pigment field.<br />

Probably more will be learned about these in future years.<br />

Figures 2 and 3 summarize the production figures <strong>of</strong><br />

three important pigments. A study <strong>of</strong> these graphs reveals<br />

interesting information on the production <strong>of</strong> these materials.<br />

Attention is called to the effect <strong>of</strong> the depression years and<br />

how the introduction <strong>of</strong> a new pigment tends to affect one<br />

already in production.


Fig. 2 Some white pigment sales.<br />

Fig. 3<br />

As mentioned above White lead is the oldest white pigment<br />

in use today. It was known at least 400 B.C. The first plant<br />

in America was built in 1804 by Samuel Wetherill & Sons<br />

in Philadelphia. There have been recent advances in the<br />

improvement <strong>of</strong> manufacture which is enabling the industry<br />

to make better white lead pigment. It is manufactured by<br />

five different processes. These vary primarily in the type <strong>of</strong><br />

raw material used.<br />

The oldest process is probably the Dutch process, which<br />

uses refined metallic lead in the form <strong>of</strong> perforated discs. It<br />

takes about three months to make the white lead. The Carter<br />

process dates from 1885. It uses powdered lead in revolving<br />

wooden cylinders and takes only 12 days. The Euston process<br />

puts the refined lead in solution and precipitates the white<br />

lead. Feathered lead is used as the raw material, which is<br />

made by running molten lead into water. The Sperry process<br />

is the electric process using a lead anode and iron cathode.<br />

The electrolytes, sodium acetate and sodium carbonate, are<br />

separated by a membrane. The Thompson-Stewart process is<br />

a recent development similar to the Carter process in that lead<br />

oxide is formed. However, all the lead oxide is first formed;<br />

then carbon-dioxide is added and controlled to form a definite<br />

chemical compound: 4PbC03.2Pb(OH)2.PbO.<br />

Basic carbonate white lead has the ability to impart adhesion,<br />

toughness, elasticity, and durability to a paint. It is used in<br />

various types <strong>of</strong> paint, principally in exterior paints. Basic<br />

carbonate white lead is the only white pigment which will<br />

produce a durable exterior paint if used alone without other<br />

pigments. A large proportion <strong>of</strong> the total white-lead production<br />

is used in white-lead pastes, which are thinned to paint form<br />

by the painter or other consumer. The two types <strong>of</strong> commercial<br />

white-lead paste are heavy paste and s<strong>of</strong>t paste. The first is<br />

composed <strong>of</strong> about 91 per cent white lead and 9 per cent<br />

linseed oil, while the latter contains about 89 per cent white<br />

lead, 9 per cent linseed oil, and 2 per cent turpentine. The<br />

linseed oil used is refined oil with an acid number <strong>of</strong> 6 to 12.<br />

About 95 per cent <strong>of</strong> the total production <strong>of</strong> white lead is<br />

consumed by the paint industry, with a small amount used in<br />

putty and by the ceramic and other industries.<br />

Basic lead sulfate is quite widely used as a paint pigment.<br />

It is called white basic lead sulfate, basic sulfate white lead<br />

or “sublimed white lead.” White basic lead sulfate is a quite<br />

recent pigment in comparison to basic carbonate white lead.<br />

It was originated in 1855 by E. O. Bartlett. He was at that<br />

time making zinc oxide directly from zinc ores by the American<br />

process. Applying the same principles to the production <strong>of</strong> a<br />

lead pigment from lead ore, he found that it was possible to<br />

produce a white powder having pigment properties.<br />

The first plant was built in 1876 in Joplin, Missouri, where lead<br />

ore deposits were sufficiently free from other metals for the<br />

production <strong>of</strong> white basic lead sulfate. It is manufactured by two<br />

processes, called the fume process and the chemical process;<br />

these are self-explanatory as far as manufacturing is concerned.<br />

Almost the entire production <strong>of</strong> white basic lead sulfate goes into<br />

mixed-pigment exterior paints, either directly or as the basic lead<br />

sulfate portion <strong>of</strong> blended leaded zinc oxides.<br />

White basic lead sulfate, like basic carbonate white lead, has<br />

the ability to impart to paints adhesion, toughness, elasticity,<br />

and durability, but is not as effective in this respect as is the<br />

basic carbonate. In exterior mixed-pigment paints, it is used<br />

principally as a substitute for basic carbonate white lead.<br />

White basic lead sulfate may be used for the “white lead”<br />

content <strong>of</strong> many specification paints, such as Federal<br />

Specification paints TT-P-40 and TT-P-81. White basic lead<br />

sulfate is a less expensive pigment than basic carbonate<br />

white lead, and this has been an influencing factor in its<br />

use. White basic lead sulfate is not generally used for singlepigment<br />

paints or pastes but is used in conjunction with<br />

other pigments in ready-mixed exterior paints. Ninety-seven<br />

per cent <strong>of</strong> the total production <strong>of</strong> this material is used in<br />

the paint industry, the remaining 3 per cent being used in<br />

the rubber and other industries.<br />

Zinc oxide pigments are made primarily by either the American<br />

or French process. In both these processes the characteristics<br />

<strong>of</strong> the pigment are determined by:<br />

1. The temperature <strong>of</strong> the oxidation <strong>of</strong> the fume;<br />

2. The time the zinc oxide is held at a high temperature;<br />

3. The composition <strong>of</strong> the gases;<br />

4. The rate <strong>of</strong> cooling.<br />

SURFACE COATINGS ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 3


The French process uses purified metal which is melted and<br />

vaporized at 1650 to 1850°F under controlled conditions. The<br />

main difference in the American process is that this process<br />

uses ore instead <strong>of</strong> refined metal.<br />

However, the effects for which it is used in paints can be<br />

summarized, together with the known or suggested explanations<br />

for the results:<br />

“Use <strong>of</strong> Zinc Oxide in Paints (Nelson-Mattiello)<br />

To aid mixing and grinding - Consistency control - Penetration<br />

control and sealing - Drying - Hardening or solidifying the film<br />

Gloss and gloss retention - To minimize discoloration and<br />

yellowing - Reduced chalking - Color and tint retention<br />

Dirt shedding (self-cleansing), washability, and ease <strong>of</strong><br />

polishing - Mildew control - Resistance to moisture and to<br />

blistering under moist conditions - Neutralizing and inhibiting”<br />

Leaded zinc oxide was first introduced into the paint industry<br />

about 1896 as a result <strong>of</strong> developments on smelting Colorado<br />

complex zinc and lead ores. With improvements in the<br />

manufacturing process the product was standardized. Several<br />

grades were developed containing 5, 20 and 35 per cent lead<br />

sulfate and basic lead sulfate, the remainder being zinc oxide.<br />

The more recent developments have been the introduction <strong>of</strong><br />

a 50 per cent grade <strong>of</strong> leaded zinc and the manufacture <strong>of</strong><br />

leaded zinc oxides by blending white basic lead sulfate and<br />

lead-free zinc oxide. A considerable portion <strong>of</strong> the leaded zinc<br />

oxide on the market today is entirely or in part a mechanical<br />

mixture. Practically the entire production <strong>of</strong> leaded zinc oxide<br />

is used by the paint industry. It is used in conjunction with<br />

other white pigments in exterior house paints. When leaded<br />

zinc oxide is used in a paint it usually furnishes the entire<br />

amount <strong>of</strong> zinc oxide required in the particular paint.<br />

Co-fumed leaded zinc is made in the same general manner as<br />

American process lead-free zinc oxide. Dry-mixing zinc oxide<br />

and basic lead sulfate in the proper proportions yields blended<br />

leaded zinc oxide.<br />

Lithopone was not very important for some time after its<br />

introduction. This is <strong>of</strong>ten characteristic, and some attribute this<br />

condition to the fact that people do not like to make changes.<br />

However, the fact that lithopone was not light-stable prior to<br />

about 1920 no doubt had a definite effect on its acceptance. The<br />

improvement in lithopone at this time was very marked and made<br />

it possible for the material to be used much more widely than<br />

previously. Lithopone is primarily used in paints, rubber, textiles,<br />

paper and printing inks. It is receiving very stiff competition from<br />

titanium dioxide and extended titanium dioxide.<br />

High strength lithopones are made by blending lithopone with<br />

zinc sulfide or titanium dioxide. The former are made in several<br />

“strengths,” the 50 to 55 per cent zinc sulfide grade being<br />

the most popular. This is also known as zinc sulfide-barium<br />

pigment. Blends with titanium dioxide are called “titanated<br />

lithopones,” and usually contain about 15 per cent <strong>of</strong> titanium<br />

dioxide. Also in this same class are the zinc sulfide-calcium<br />

and zinc sulfide-magnesium pigments; these are blends <strong>of</strong> zinc<br />

sulfide with calcium sulfate or magnesium silicate.<br />

4 SURFACE COATINGS ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND<br />

Zinc sulfide is a relatively high-strength pigment, but it has not<br />

been used as widely as the blends with lithopone or extenders.<br />

Extended titanium pigments were introduced shortly after World<br />

War I. First to be produced was titanium-barium pigment,<br />

consisting <strong>of</strong> 25 per cent titanium dioxide and 75 per cent<br />

barium sulfate. Later came titanium-calcium pigment, with 30<br />

per cent titanium dioxide, and a 30 per cent titanium-barium<br />

pigment. Relatively recently, titanium-magnesium pigment (30<br />

per cent titanium dioxide and 70 per cent magnesium silicate)<br />

was made for use in house paints.<br />

These pigments, particularly straight titanium dioxide, met<br />

great resistance because <strong>of</strong> their relatively high price per<br />

pound, and a long educational program was required to<br />

convince the pigment users that these prices were really low<br />

when considered on the basis <strong>of</strong> cost per unit <strong>of</strong> hiding power<br />

developed in the finished product.<br />

Fig. 4 Titanium dioxide pigment<br />

Titanium dioxide has the highest hiding power <strong>of</strong> any <strong>of</strong> the<br />

white pigments, but its manufacture is more complicated and<br />

more expensive than any <strong>of</strong> the other pigments which have been<br />

considered. Figure 4 shows the manufacture <strong>of</strong> titanium dioxide<br />

pigment. Examination <strong>of</strong> this flow sheet shows how complicated<br />

the manufacture <strong>of</strong> this pigment really is. In order to<br />

manufacture pigment <strong>of</strong> a high quality today, extreme care must<br />

be taken in all steps, and impurities controlled very accurately.<br />

Previously the subject <strong>of</strong> hiding power was mentioned. It is<br />

this quality <strong>of</strong> titanium dioxide that makes it very important in<br />

the paint field. The comparison <strong>of</strong> the hiding power <strong>of</strong> various<br />

pigments is given in Figure 5. There may be some disagreement<br />

in the actual values <strong>of</strong> hiding power. This disagreement is<br />

due primarily to the fact that different conditions are used in<br />

measuring it. However, in general, the order given in Figure 5<br />

will be found under usual conditions.<br />

Fig. 5 Comparison <strong>of</strong> hiding power <strong>of</strong> various pigments.


A Naturally Occurring Sub-Micron Titanium<br />

Dioxide Extender for Decorative Paints<br />

Introduction<br />

By Simon Bussell*, Technical Sales Manager, Sibelco Speciality Minerals Europe * Corresponding author<br />

Mart Verheijen, Application Development Manager, Sibelco Speciality Minerals Europe<br />

In the first quarter <strong>of</strong> 2009 the price <strong>of</strong> titanium dioxide (TiO2)<br />

stood at $2,400/tonne for the US and Asia. Since that time<br />

regular increases have seen the price increase dramatically<br />

to $2,750-2,950/tonne by the end <strong>of</strong> 2010. Prices are even<br />

higher in Europe at up to €2,780/tonne.‚ At the same time<br />

supply has been severely limited with manufacturers rationing<br />

deliveries to customers. There are several causes for this,<br />

shortages <strong>of</strong> titanium ores such as ilmenite and rutile as well<br />

as other raw materials such as sulphuric acid, increased energy<br />

costs, increased demand from Asia and capacity reduction by<br />

suppliers. This situation has forced formulators to look again<br />

at the level <strong>of</strong> TiO2 in their coatings and consider options for<br />

reducing the quantities used. One such option is a complex<br />

carbonate extender produced by the Sibelco Group company<br />

Ankerpoort based a mixture <strong>of</strong> calcium and magnesium<br />

carbonates and hydrated carbonates. The material is marketed<br />

by Sibelco Speciality Minerals Europe (SSME) a new<br />

commercial group focused on the supply <strong>of</strong> functional fillers for<br />

coatings, polymers and adhesives. This work will show that the<br />

mixture, which occurs naturally as sub-micron, platy crystals,<br />

is an ideal TiO2 extender, maintaining and improving brightness<br />

and hiding power in comparison to other ultrafine extenders.<br />

Experimental<br />

Titanium Dioxide is responsible for two principle features <strong>of</strong><br />

paints and coatings, whiteness and opacity. TiO2 is the best<br />

pigment for these properties because <strong>of</strong> its high refractive<br />

index (2.75). This gives the highest level <strong>of</strong> scattering when<br />

light crosses the boundary between binder and TiO2 particle or<br />

air and TiO2 particle. Reduction <strong>of</strong> TiO2 content is a balancing<br />

act between the need to reduce cost and the need to maintain<br />

quality. To be effective a TiO2 extender must allow TiO2 levels to<br />

be reduced while maintaining whiteness and opacity levels.<br />

In the 1970’s a wall paint could contain more than 18% TiO2 by<br />

volume. 3 This has been steadily reduced since that time, typically<br />

by improving the dispersion and separation <strong>of</strong> TiO2 particles in the<br />

film. Figure 1 shows diagrammatically how this can be done by<br />

reducing the average particle size <strong>of</strong> the filler material.<br />

There is a limit to how effective this method can be. Beyond<br />

a certain particle size suitable finely ground fillers may not be<br />

available, and if they are binder demand, dispersant levels and<br />

dispersion time would all be increased. An alternative method<br />

is to use ultrafine particles to space the TiO2 particles in the<br />

interstitial voids between large filler particles (figure 2). Typically<br />

Figure 1 – improved TiO2 distribution by reduction <strong>of</strong> filler particle size<br />

(not to scale).<br />

particles <strong>of</strong> around twice the diameter <strong>of</strong> TiO2 particles (0.5-<br />

0.6µm) are found to be most effective.<br />

The purpose <strong>of</strong> this work was<br />

to determine how effective this<br />

complex carbonate mineral<br />

is as a TiO2 extender. To do<br />

this it was compared with four<br />

other materials commonly<br />

used for TiO2 extension, finely<br />

ground calcite, precipitated<br />

calcium carbonate, fine<br />

hydrous kaolin and calcined<br />

kaolin at two different TiO2<br />

volume concentrations.<br />

Figure 2 - TiO2 spacing by ultrafine extender (not to scale)<br />

Materials<br />

This work was undertaken at the SSME paint lab in Maastricht<br />

using a formulation (table 1) based on a styrene-acrylic<br />

emulsion. Initially two coatings were prepared using 7% TiO2 by<br />

volume and 3.5% TiO2 by volume. Selected coatings from these<br />

trials were repeated using a higher binder level. With the PVC<br />

above critical and a low level <strong>of</strong> TiO2 these coatings were felt to<br />

represent a general use interior wall paint.<br />

Fillers<br />

The complex carbonate extender is a mixed alkaline earth<br />

carbonate with the general formula Mg3Ca(CO3)4. It is formed<br />

by the weathering <strong>of</strong> magnesite or dolomite and subsequent<br />

deposition. Ankerpoort mine and partially process the material<br />

in Greece (figure 3) where the raw material is screened and<br />

beneficiated to provide a reasonably pure feedstock for further<br />

processing. The material is then shipped to The Netherlands<br />

where Ankerpoort have developed proprietary processing<br />

SURFACE COATINGS ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 5


Table 1 – interior wall paint formulation<br />

techniques to achieve the optimum particle size distribution without<br />

affecting the unique morphology. The deposit is fine and white with<br />

a high carbonate content and an iron content <strong>of</strong> only 0.03%.<br />

Details <strong>of</strong> the morphology and physical properties can be seen in<br />

figure 1 and table 1. It occurs naturally as an aggregate <strong>of</strong> platy<br />

crystals with sides <strong>of</strong> ≈ 0.5 – 1.0µm and an aspect ratio <strong>of</strong> 10:1.<br />

The defining properties are the high brightness, low particle size<br />

and the high oil absorption/ surface area. The advantages <strong>of</strong><br />

these properties will be shown in the following work.<br />

The properties <strong>of</strong> the other test fillers (as measured by SSME)<br />

are summarised in table 3. Where quoted, the manufacturers<br />

D50 particle size is also given. Measurements were made using<br />

the Sedigraph technique which is useful for platy materials<br />

such as hydrous kaolin, but can give discrepancies for round<br />

or needle shaped particles such as PCC. A lower value would<br />

be expected for the calcined kaolin suggesting this sample was<br />

highly agglomerated.<br />

Methods<br />

7% TiO2<br />

7% TiO2<br />

+ 20%<br />

Binder<br />

3.5% TiO2<br />

Dispersion - All coatings were produced using a high speed<br />

disperser with a toothed blade. The water, dispersants, calcium<br />

scavenger, biocide, antifoam and thickener were dispersed at<br />

6 SURFACE COATINGS ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND<br />

3.5% TiO2<br />

+ 10%<br />

Binder<br />

Water 270 270 270 270<br />

Dispersant A 4 4 4 4<br />

Na HMP 1 1 1 1<br />

Dispersant B 1 1 1 1<br />

Biocide 3 3 3 3<br />

Antifoam 2 2 2 2<br />

Cellulose thickener 3 3 3 3<br />

TiO2 80 80 40 40<br />

5µm GCC 290 290 290 290<br />

Test extender 100 100 140 140<br />

Talc 80 80 80 80<br />

Styrene Acrylic<br />

binder<br />

160 192 160 176<br />

Thickener 3 3 3 3<br />

TiO2 PVC 7 6.7 3.5 3.4<br />

Total PVC 72.2 68.4 72.7 70.8<br />

Figure 3 Ankerpoort mine in Greece<br />

Figure 4 (left) - Morphology <strong>of</strong> complex carbonate extender<br />

Table 2 - Physical properties <strong>of</strong> complex carbonate extender<br />

Density 2.7g/cm3<br />

Mohs Hardness 2 - 3<br />

Refractive index 1.61 – 1.64<br />

D50 (Sedigraph) 0.56µm<br />

Oil Absn 55-60g/100g<br />

BET 18m2/g<br />

Brightness (Ry) 95<br />

Brightness (ISO) 92.3<br />

pH 10<br />

Table 3 – physical properties <strong>of</strong> competitive test extenders<br />

Fine GCC PCC<br />

low speed until fully dissolved. The pigment, fillers and extender<br />

were added and dispersed at high speed for 30 minutes until a<br />

grind <strong>of</strong> 5 or better was achieved. Following this the binder and<br />

thickener were added and dispersed at low speed for a further<br />

30 minutes until a uniform dispersion was achieved.<br />

Brightness and contrast ratio - The coatings were drawn<br />

down onto a Leneta No. 2 opacity chart using a bird type<br />

applicator to give a 150µm wet film thickness and allowed<br />

to dry for 7 days. Brightness was measured as L* using a<br />

spectrophotometer. Contrast ratio was measured as the ratio<br />

<strong>of</strong> reflected light from the coating over the black and white<br />

portions <strong>of</strong> the card (RB/RW) expressed as a percentage.<br />

Viscosity measurement - Viscosity was measured using a<br />

Brookfield viscometer fitted with spindle 5. High and low shear<br />

measurements were made at 100rpm and 10rpm.<br />

Results and discussion<br />

Hydrous<br />

Kaolin<br />

Calcined<br />

Kaolin<br />

Density 2.7 2.6 2.6 2.6<br />

D50 (Sedigraph) 1.1 1.38 0.62 6.6<br />

D50 (TDS) 0.2 - 0.3 0.7<br />

Oil Absn 30.5 37.5 42.0 74.5<br />

Brightness (ISO) 91.0 95.5 85.5 90.9<br />

The results for all test measurements are shown in table 4a and<br />

4b. There was no significant difference in the brightness measured<br />

for all formulations, being in the range 95.0 ± 0.6 although it<br />

should be mentioned that the highest brightness for each series


Table 4a – test results for 7% TiO2 formulation<br />

7% Titan<br />

7% Titan<br />

+ 20%<br />

Binder<br />

was given by the complex carbonate extender. As may be expected<br />

the brightness <strong>of</strong> the coatings containing 7% TiO2 was higher than<br />

those containing 3.5% TiO2, although in reality the difference was<br />

on average only half a point. Gloss measurements were also very<br />

similar for all samples ranging from 2.4 to 3.8. All coating would<br />

be suitable for low sheen applications.<br />

The variation in contrast ratio was far greater, ranging from<br />

a low <strong>of</strong> 90.1 to a high <strong>of</strong> 96.2. Once again the complex<br />

carbonate formulations had the highest value in all test series,<br />

in some cases by a significant margin, being at least two points<br />

above the average value for each series <strong>of</strong> tests. The results<br />

for the fine GCC and the PCC were very similar and it would be<br />

difficult to place one above the other in terms <strong>of</strong> contrast ratio.<br />

The lowest contrast ratio was given by the hydrous and calcined<br />

kaolins which were also very similar. In terms <strong>of</strong> particle size<br />

and shape the hydrous kaolin was closest in morphology to<br />

the complex carbonate, however the results show it is not as<br />

effective as the complex carbonate as a TiO2 extender.<br />

There was some variation between the contrast ratio <strong>of</strong> the<br />

higher and lower TiO2 contents. Increasing the level <strong>of</strong> extender<br />

and reducing the level <strong>of</strong> TiO2 gave a higher contrast ratio for<br />

the complex carbonate, fine GCC and hydrous kaolin while a<br />

lower value for PCC and calcined kaolin.<br />

The area which showed the greatest difference between the<br />

complex carbonate and the other extenders was viscosity.<br />

The GCC, PCC and hydrous kaolin give reasonably similar<br />

viscosities, however the complex carbonate gives a noticeably<br />

higher viscosity and the calcined kaolin a noticeably lower<br />

viscosity. The highly thixotropic nature <strong>of</strong> dispersions<br />

containing the complex carbonate can be an advantage in that<br />

settling is less pronounced and thickener levels can reduced. If<br />

lower viscosities are required then subsequent work has shown<br />

that alternative combinations <strong>of</strong> dispersant and thickener are<br />

Portafill H5 Fine GCC PCC Hydrous Kaolin Calcined Kaolin<br />

Brightness L* 95.8 95.0 95.4 94.9 95.4<br />

CR/% 96.4 92.4 92.5 92.4 90.1<br />

Gloss 85° 2.8 2.4 3.2 2.5 2.6<br />

Viscosity100rpm/cP 2640 1880 2040 1680 1240<br />

Viscosity10rpm/cP 14000 7200 7600 7200 4400<br />

Brightness L* 95.8 95.3<br />

CR/% 95.9 94.9<br />

Gloss 85° 2.6 2.7<br />

Table 4b – test results for 3.5% TiO2 formulation<br />

3.5% Titan<br />

3.5% Titan<br />

+ 10%<br />

Binder<br />

Portafill H5 Fine GCC PCC Hydrous Kaolin Calcined Kaolin<br />

Brightness L* 95.6 94.5 95.1 94.4 94.8<br />

CR/% 95.2 94.3 91.1 92.2 92.0<br />

Gloss 85° 3.6 3.4 3.8 2.9 2.9<br />

Viscosity100rpm/cP 3600 1880 1680 1920 1160<br />

Viscosity10rpm/cP 21200 7600 5600 9200 2000<br />

Brightness L* 93.2 94.4 94.4 94.1<br />

CR/% 94.5 92.0 90.3 91.5<br />

Gloss 85° 3.2 3.1 2.8 3.1<br />

effective in controlling the rheological behaviour.<br />

The relatively low viscosity <strong>of</strong> the mixes containing the calcined<br />

kaolin, despite the highest oil absorption, may be further<br />

evidence <strong>of</strong> the difficulty in deagglomerating the material and<br />

achieving a fine dispersion. This in turn would account for the<br />

poor performance in terms <strong>of</strong> contrast ratio.<br />

Conclusions<br />

SSME’s complex carbonate extender is an ultrafine, platy<br />

extender and has been compared in this series <strong>of</strong> tests against<br />

ultrafine carbonate extenders and ultrafine platy extenders.<br />

Overall the results show that it works well as a TiO2 extender,<br />

brightness in the test formulations was slightly better than<br />

the competitive materials however the most important result<br />

was contrast ratio. In formulations above critical PVC it is<br />

relatively easy to achieve a good brightness using white fillers<br />

but dry hiding power can be difficult to maintain as TiO2<br />

levels are reduced. This work shows that increasing the level<br />

<strong>of</strong> the complex carbonate extender in a formulation allows<br />

the TiO2 level to be reduced while actually increasing the<br />

dry hiding power to a level not achieved by other fillers. This<br />

has advantages both in terms <strong>of</strong> cost reduction and quality<br />

improvement. In addition the rheological behaviour makes this<br />

extender highly suitable for viscous materials such as sealants,<br />

underbody coatings and putties.<br />

References<br />

1. Titanium dioxide price pressure, Industrial Minerals, March 2009<br />

2. Titanium dioxide market most “buoyant” for a decade, Industrial<br />

Minerals, Jan <strong>2011</strong><br />

3. The Effect <strong>of</strong> Fine Particle Size Extenders and Entrapped Air on TiO2<br />

in Emulsion Paints, Paul F. Dietz, PCI Magazine, September 2003.<br />

Contact details<br />

Simon Bussell, Sibelco Europe, Brookside Hall, Sandbach,<br />

Cheshire, UK. Contact: Simon.bussell@sibelco.com,<br />

Ph: +44 1270 752914, +44 7889 057206<br />

SURFACE COATINGS ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 7


Formulating for the Future<br />

<strong>New</strong> open-time binder for the Australasian Market<br />

Summary<br />

By S.B. Browning and A. Berry - Nuplex Resins, Australasia<br />

In Australasia, the open time <strong>of</strong> current water borne enamels<br />

is limited by the binder system, which in gloss systems is<br />

about three minutes. Incremental gains in open time may be<br />

made from changing the rheological pr<strong>of</strong>ile and/or with certain<br />

additives, but the open time will still be significantly shorter<br />

than solvent borne systems. In addition these additives have<br />

the potential to compromise the chemical and mechanical<br />

properties <strong>of</strong> the coating and significantly reduce the coverage.<br />

Nuplex Industries acknowledges this fact and has developed an<br />

experimental binder using proprietary binder technology that<br />

gives coatings two and a half times the open time <strong>of</strong> commercial<br />

water borne trim enamels with improved early water resistance.<br />

Introduction<br />

Over the past 15 years, the trim enamel market has undergone<br />

a dramatic shift from solvent borne alkyds to waterborne<br />

acrylic systems. A number <strong>of</strong> reasons have been given for<br />

this including the perceived environmentally friendliness to<br />

hazard mitigation. This transformation has lead to a number <strong>of</strong><br />

advantages, such as water wash up and fast curing times.<br />

However, this transition has exposed the weaknesses<br />

<strong>of</strong> waterborne acrylic trim enamels. Due to their drying<br />

behaviour, the open time and gloss are poorer than the older<br />

solvent borne technologies, whilst their lower solids deliver<br />

poor telegraphing resistance.<br />

To resolve these deficiencies Nuplex Resins embarked on<br />

a project to understand the rheological parameters that<br />

determine open time with the intention <strong>of</strong> developing a series<br />

<strong>of</strong> binders with better application properties without increasing<br />

the concentrations <strong>of</strong> surfactants or solvents. This is important<br />

as the desired improvement in open time should not be at the<br />

expense <strong>of</strong> dry film properties.<br />

What is open time?<br />

Open time is many things to many people. However a good<br />

definition <strong>of</strong> this property was put forward by Reuvers in 1999:<br />

“the period <strong>of</strong> time during curing when small corrections can<br />

be made without leaving clearly visible brush strokes”<br />

This definition covers the time in which a painter can repair<br />

any deformations in the film (the repair time) and the time<br />

when painter can re-brush (the wet edge or lapping time.)<br />

One must bear in mind that this is not only the time when<br />

surface imperfections can flow out <strong>of</strong> the coating but also<br />

when sagging, slumping and runs can occur (Akkerman et al,<br />

8 SURFACE COATINGS ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND<br />

2009.) All <strong>of</strong> these properties are to do with flow and hence<br />

are related.<br />

Whilst it is generally acknowledged that the high shear viscosity<br />

will determine how much paint is applied and hence wet film<br />

thickness, Bosma et al. found by manipulation <strong>of</strong> the Orchard<br />

equation that a paint will cease flow, levelling and hence<br />

open time once it has reached a certain low shear viscosity<br />

and from this concluded that paints with a high degree <strong>of</strong><br />

pseudoplasticity will always have poor open times.<br />

The differences between solvent borne and<br />

water borne coatings.<br />

There are number <strong>of</strong> reasons why the open times <strong>of</strong> solvent<br />

borne coatings are superior to those <strong>of</strong> their water borne<br />

cousins, but the main reason is the relationship between<br />

fluidity (inverse viscosity) and solids content. Dispersions and<br />

waterborne dispersions in particular decrease their fluidity with<br />

increasing solids at a much faster rate than solutions regardless<br />

<strong>of</strong> solvent content. As a result water borne binders have<br />

virtually no flow above 50%, whilst solvent borne alkyds still<br />

have a degree <strong>of</strong> fluidity at 75% solids. This allows the painter<br />

significantly longer period to work with the coating, hence<br />

better open times, and thus better dry film appearance.<br />

This fluidity effect is exacerbated by the different levelling<br />

mechanisms between water borne and solvent borne coatings.<br />

In the initial phase <strong>of</strong> curing, the evaporate rate is constant<br />

regardless <strong>of</strong> local layer thickness. In solvent based paints<br />

this leads to an increase in surface tension in areas <strong>of</strong> low<br />

film build - as white spirits has a surface tension <strong>of</strong> 24 dynes/<br />

cm whilst the final coatings typically have a surface tension <strong>of</strong><br />

45 dynes/cm. As the surface tension tries to equilibrate, that<br />

is the surface area reduces, material is forced to flow from<br />

locations <strong>of</strong> low surface tension to areas where the surface<br />

tension is higher. This results in a surface tension gradient that<br />

promotes levelling, but this phenomena is opposite for water<br />

based coatings as water has a surface tension <strong>of</strong> 72 dynes/cm.<br />

This factor can be minimized by the addition <strong>of</strong> surfactants<br />

and solvents, but this has a negative effect on hardness<br />

development, water resistance and in the case <strong>of</strong> solvents, an<br />

increase in VOC.<br />

Another reason why waterborne coatings are observed to be<br />

inferior to solvent borne coatings is telegraphing resistance,<br />

the transmission <strong>of</strong> substrate defects from the substrate to the<br />

surface. In the absence <strong>of</strong> surface tension gradients (as occurs<br />

at initial application <strong>of</strong> the coating) the telegraphed amplitude<br />

only depends on the initial solids content (also known as


the shrinkage factor) and is thus irrespective <strong>of</strong> rheological<br />

properties, thickness, applied surface pr<strong>of</strong>ile or surface tension.<br />

The shrinkage factor can thus be modelled as:<br />

where ρ solids is density <strong>of</strong> solids and SC-0 is initial solids<br />

content. Using this formula we can ascertain that by either<br />

increasing the solids content or by decreasing the density <strong>of</strong><br />

the solid, the degree <strong>of</strong> shrinkage can be reduced (See graph<br />

below) In solvent borne coatings, both the solids content is<br />

higher, and due to the higher resin component, the density <strong>of</strong><br />

the solids is lower, hence much better telegraphing resistance.<br />

The Development <strong>of</strong> an Experimental Open<br />

Time Binder<br />

As we have seen, the application and appearance <strong>of</strong> self<br />

cross linking acrylics are inferior to their solvent borne alkyd<br />

predecessors. To try and minimize the shortfall in open-time,<br />

paint chemists commonly add humectants such as glycols or<br />

surfactants; with conventional logic being that these will hold<br />

back water and therefore extend open time.<br />

However propylene glycol does not form an azeotrope 1 with<br />

water, and it is the belief <strong>of</strong> the authors that propylene glycol<br />

only improves the wet edge <strong>of</strong> the paint and not the ability for<br />

a paint to flow out after brush/roller corrections. Significantly<br />

greater gains in open time have been found by slightly reducing<br />

the volume solids content rather than by increasing the<br />

surfactant and solvent concentrations, with only a minimal<br />

reduction in telegraphing resistance.<br />

1 An Azeotropic mixture is defined as a liquid mixture <strong>of</strong> two or more<br />

substances, that when mixed behave as a single species as the<br />

vapour produced from partial evaporation <strong>of</strong> the liquid has the same<br />

composition as the liquid (Turner, 1950.) Whilst propylene glycol is<br />

infinitely dissolvable in water, the resulting liquid exhibits two distinct<br />

boiling points.<br />

Even when the volume solids <strong>of</strong> a coating with a <strong>New</strong>tonian<br />

rheology pr<strong>of</strong>ile is around 35%, the open time using the Nuplex<br />

Cross Open Time (COT) method will be at best between three<br />

and four minutes. This is because the curing mechanism <strong>of</strong> the<br />

resin is the overriding factor in determining the open time in<br />

waterborne acrylic enamel systems.<br />

The self cross-linking acrylic polymers commonly used in the<br />

manufacture <strong>of</strong> trim enamels are classified as dispersions.<br />

In the wet state these resins exist as semi solid particles<br />

suspended in water, and film for through deformation or<br />

coalescence <strong>of</strong> these polymer particles. The dry film retains<br />

some <strong>of</strong> the structure <strong>of</strong> the polymer particles which reduces<br />

the gloss, particularly at 20°. In general the acrylic polymer<br />

particles are high molecular weight and cannot easily move<br />

past one another, so the viscosity increases rapidly on drying,<br />

hence the short open times. These polymers get the majority <strong>of</strong><br />

their performance properties from their high molecular weight<br />

and not from cross-linking, which is why they appear to cure<br />

at a much faster rate than alkyd systems. It is also why acrylic<br />

systems need to have higher glass transition temperatures than<br />

alkyd systems to get the same blocking resistance.<br />

There are two other waterborne technologies that are currently<br />

available for use in the waterborne trim enamel market; alkyd<br />

emulsions and solutions.<br />

Alkyd emulsions are supplied as alkyd droplets in water (an oil<br />

in water or o/w emulsion.) As water evaporates, the viscosity<br />

increases until the resin inverts from an oil in water emulsion to<br />

a water in oil (w/o) emulsion, and the viscosity decreases. The<br />

dry time <strong>of</strong> alkyd emulsions is similar to solvent borne alkyds,<br />

as they both require oxidative cross-linking for chemical and<br />

mechanical properties.<br />

Unlike acrylic dispersions, the resin droplets in alkyd emulsions<br />

are liquid, which gives these binders a higher degree <strong>of</strong> fluidity<br />

at the same solids content, and as alkyd emulsions do not<br />

coalesce, they do not require a coalescing solvent and they<br />

contain renewable (but yellowing) oils. This yellowing and the<br />

slow dry times are two reasons why this technology has fallen<br />

from favour in the Australasian trim market.<br />

Currently the only other technologies that can be utilised are<br />

water soluble polymers. Traditionally the trim market was<br />

dominated by (alkyd solvent borne) solutions, which have<br />

issues with odour, dry time VOCs and yellowing, but have good<br />

open time and telegraphing resistance (due to being able to<br />

flow above 70% volume solids.) Water soluble polymers also<br />

have excellent gloss and open time but perform very poorly<br />

when exposed to water, <strong>of</strong>ten re-dissolving within two minutes.<br />

They mostly have poor mechanical properties.<br />

The Experimental Binder EM8683<br />

These deficiencies in current resin technology have led Nuplex<br />

to develop EM8683, an experimental polymer designed to<br />

have much better open time than current technologies on the<br />

market. As we have already seen, the open time <strong>of</strong> the current<br />

waterborne self cross-linking acrylics is limited by the binder<br />

system. Nuplex have addressed this by developing a fast curing<br />

acrylic copolymer emulsion. Unlike traditional self cross-linking<br />

acrylics, this system is oil modified and oxidatively cross-links,<br />

hence the MFFT is significantly reduced without compromising<br />

mechanical properties.<br />

To ensure that the performance <strong>of</strong> this experimental polymer is<br />

SURFACE COATINGS ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 9


similar to current market standards, paints made on EM8683<br />

have been evaluated and compared to six commercially<br />

available paints; three high gloss solvent borne alkyd trim<br />

enamels, two high gloss waterborne trim enamels and a water<br />

based trim enamel based on an alkyd emulsion.<br />

The open time was tested using a standardised method very<br />

similar to ASTM D7488-10, and evaluated a number <strong>of</strong><br />

properties including how long the open time is in the wet (open<br />

time a’) and dry (open time b) films. It was found that the open<br />

time <strong>of</strong> EM8683 was nearly as long as the waterborne alkyd<br />

and 250% longer than a commercial waterborne acrylic market<br />

standards. Significantly, and unlike paints based on self crosslinking<br />

acrylics, the open time in the wet film was identical to<br />

that in the dry film.<br />

As previously mentioned, EM8683 utilises oxidative crosslinking<br />

technology. There have been a number <strong>of</strong> advantages<br />

in doing this, such as reducing the coalescent demand and<br />

improving the resistances to water and hydrophilic stains.<br />

To ensure that the coating did not suffer from loss <strong>of</strong> dry,<br />

it was placed in the oven at 60°C for seven and 42 days<br />

(1000 hours.) In this test it was found that EM8683 had dry<br />

times longer than acrylics but still shorter than solvent borne<br />

enamels. It was also found that the dry time <strong>of</strong> the heat aged<br />

samples was similar to the un-aged sample, unlike three<br />

commercial solvent borne standards.<br />

To observe the mechanical properties <strong>of</strong> the coatings; block<br />

resistance and pendulum (Koenig) hardness tests were<br />

undertaken. Block resistance was carried out using a method<br />

based upon ASTM D4946-89 (2003.) In this test EM8683<br />

had a block resistance within the solvent borne and waterborne<br />

market standards, even though the MFFT <strong>of</strong> EM8683 is much<br />

lower than the self cross-linking acrylics, and a pendulum<br />

hardness akin to the solvent borne alkyds.<br />

Finally the 20° gloss <strong>of</strong> the coating based in EM8683 was<br />

67%. This is a step improvement from the current technology<br />

as it places it roughly half way between the solvent borne<br />

<strong>Coatings</strong> that Michelman has successfully tested for repulpability<br />

and their applications include:<br />

VaporCoat® 330C – a wax replacement solution typically used on roll wrap, produce boxes, poultry boxes and<br />

anywhere packaged goods require protection from water and/or moisture vapor.<br />

Michem® Coat 40EAF - another wax replacement coating that is water resistant and also demonstrates some<br />

grease resistance. Typically used on fruit, vegetable and protein/meat boxes.<br />

Nomar 70AF - a water based, abrasion resistant coating, generally used to provide abrasion protection for gas<br />

flushed food packaging or small appliances.<br />

Coating X300AF - another waterborne coating that provides a high level <strong>of</strong> water resistance and good moisture<br />

resistance on kraft paper. It is used to protect food products from excessive moisture, freezer burn and sticking.<br />

MaxWhite 17 - a decorative white coating that provides excellent brightness before and after wax applications.<br />

10 SURFACE COATINGS ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND<br />

alkyds and the water borne self cross-linking acrylics.<br />

Conclusion<br />

With commercial pressures from the marketplace and our<br />

share holders, environmental pressures from legislators,<br />

specifiers and consumers and performance pressures from all<br />

<strong>of</strong> the above, we are all continually trying to formulate for the<br />

future. One <strong>of</strong> the last bastions <strong>of</strong> solvent borne technology<br />

in architectural coatings is gloss trim paints. To overcome the<br />

limitations <strong>of</strong> acrylic water borne enamels in both open time<br />

and telegraphing, Nuplex has developed a new binder resin.<br />

Whilst the ultimate parameters <strong>of</strong> this resin are currently being<br />

finalised, the results, thus far, look very promising.<br />

It is anticipated that this binder will be utilised in one <strong>of</strong> two<br />

ways, either in coatings with the same volume solids but much<br />

better open time; or in coatings with higher volume solids to<br />

minimise telegraphing. This second route may be a way <strong>of</strong><br />

reducing TiO2 demand as coverage will be better with the higher<br />

film build. Either way, the coalescent demand will be lower<br />

which may lead to lower formulation costs, reduced VOC’s and<br />

due to the low MFFT and hydrophobic nature <strong>of</strong> this resin, it is<br />

believed that it will be a good candidate for DTS applications as<br />

it is expected have good tannin bleed resistance.<br />

While this polymer is being commercialised we will still be<br />

formulating for the future – working on the next generation<br />

<strong>of</strong> polymers which will give even longer open times and emit<br />

even less VOC’s and having physical and chemical properties in<br />

advance <strong>of</strong> those already achieved.<br />

Acknowledgements:<br />

Nuplex Technical team in Australia and <strong>New</strong> Zealand<br />

Nuplex Technical Team in Holland and Adam Berry<br />

References:<br />

1. Akkerman, J. Bosma, M. Berry, A. Fallani, F. Adolphs, R. Mestach,<br />

D. “<strong>New</strong> developments op open time resins for waterborne<br />

decorative coatings” European <strong>Coatings</strong> Congress, 2009<br />

2. Turner (ed) “The Condensed Chemical Dictionary” Forth Edition,<br />

Reinhold Publishing Corporation, 1950


Bridging the gap in performance deficiency <strong>of</strong><br />

eco-friendly waterborne coatings by making use<br />

<strong>of</strong> a nanoparticle containing additive<br />

Eco-friendly waterborne paints and coatings already gained<br />

considerable interest and market shares compared to traditional<br />

solvent borne systems driven by stricter legislation as well as<br />

the general environmental awareness. Nevertheless waterbornes<br />

have well known limitation in overall performance compared to<br />

classical solvent borne systems.<br />

A innovative concept based on metal oxide nanoparticle<br />

technology potentially improving waterborne coatings will be<br />

introduced. With a chemo-mechanical milling process particles<br />

with tailored surface properties were generated. A overall good<br />

compatibility <strong>of</strong> the particles with a broad variety <strong>of</strong> binders<br />

was observed. Especially acrylic binders and copolymers with<br />

acrylic compartments are very well suited for the use with<br />

Oxylink. This also includes acrylic modified alkyds and PUDs.<br />

MEK double<br />

rubs<br />

[#]<br />

120<br />

80<br />

40<br />

0<br />

? = 85<br />

0.00 1.00 2.00<br />

wt.-% Oxylink 3101 (solids on solids)<br />

Figure 1: Concentration <strong>of</strong> Oxylink 3101 in transparent wood stain<br />

formulation based on Primal AC 337ER versus the<br />

MEK rub resistance<br />

The particles in the additive improve the overall coating<br />

performance due to direct particle-to-resin interaction. This<br />

effect closely depends on the high degree <strong>of</strong> dispersion as<br />

well as on the high surface area <strong>of</strong> the nanoparticles. We<br />

recommend a usage level <strong>of</strong> 1.0 % additive for first formulation<br />

experiments (see. Fig. 1).<br />

In particular the MEK rub stability, drying time, blocking<br />

resistance and stability against humidity will be improved.<br />

Detailed test results for a wood stain and a direct-to-metal<br />

By Marc Herold and Frank Tabellion<br />

Figure 2: Performance charts <strong>of</strong> a transparent Coating for wood based<br />

on Primal AC-337 ER (top) and a white DTM formulation based on<br />

Neocryl XK 86 (bottom).<br />

coating are depicted in Figure 2. The main performance benefit<br />

for the wood coating by the additive is a reduced drying time<br />

and a higher blocking resistance. The humidity resistance and<br />

the MEK-double rub resistance are the main effects for the<br />

direct-to-metal coating.<br />

The above shown results demonstrate that a nanoparticle<br />

based additive like Oxylink can significantly improve the overall<br />

properties <strong>of</strong> waterborne coatings. With steadily improving the<br />

properties <strong>of</strong> waterborne coatings, the gap between waterbornes<br />

and solvent borne coatings becomes narrower and the hurdles<br />

for using waterbornes become lower. As a consequence,<br />

nanotechnology can play an important role in bringing greener<br />

coatings forward.<br />

Bühler PARTEC GmbH<br />

Science Park 2<br />

66123 Saarbrücken<br />

Phone: +49 681 394 6550<br />

oxylink@buhlergroup.com<br />

SURFACE COATINGS ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 11


Introduction<br />

To brush or not to brush.<br />

Formulating hand applied waterborne high performance<br />

two pack polyurethane coatings<br />

By Adriaan Sanderse, Jan Goossen, Jaap Akkerman, Dirk Mestach - Nuplex Industries.<br />

Progress made over the last years in the design <strong>of</strong> waterborne<br />

acrylic polyols and polyisocyanates for two pack polyurethane<br />

coatings has enabled the coatings formulator to overcome<br />

the drawbacks that were associated with the first generation<br />

<strong>of</strong> water-borne polyurethanes. Consequently waterborne two<br />

pack (WB2K) technology has gained a strong foothold in the<br />

industrial coatings market, meeting all <strong>of</strong> the requirements to<br />

<strong>of</strong>fer a true alternative for solventborne coatings.<br />

In addition to <strong>of</strong>fering reduced emissions <strong>of</strong> volatile organic<br />

compounds (VOC) during application <strong>of</strong> the coating resulting<br />

in reduced exposure <strong>of</strong> the painter to organic vapours, these<br />

coatings reduce risk <strong>of</strong> fire and are easier to clean up (creating<br />

less hazardous waste to dispose <strong>of</strong>).<br />

Most WB2K coatings have been optimized for application by<br />

means <strong>of</strong> spraying, either airless or air assisted or electrostatic.<br />

Until now, not much work was done to develop formulation<br />

guideline for WB2K systems that can be hand applied, by<br />

roller or brush. However if it would be possible to hand apply<br />

WB2K systems with final aesthetical and film-properties that<br />

are equivalent to spray applied WB2K would open up a number<br />

<strong>of</strong> new end-use applications where properties such as high<br />

durability and excellent resistance properties are <strong>of</strong> prime<br />

importance. Typical examples <strong>of</strong> such end-use applications<br />

are highly durable clear and pigmented exterior woodcoatings,<br />

yacht coatings, site-applied flooring coatings and coatings to<br />

repair or refinish interior wood.<br />

Water-borne two component<br />

polyurethane technology<br />

As for all paint formulation work, the right selection <strong>of</strong> the base<br />

resin components is crucial to obtain a satisfactory end result.<br />

In a WB2K coating system for hand application, component<br />

A is a polyol binder, consisting <strong>of</strong> small colloidal polyol<br />

particles that are suspended in water. Because <strong>of</strong> the fact that<br />

most waterborne acrylic polyols can not sufficiently emulsify<br />

hydrophobic isocyanates to achieve proper homogeneous film<br />

formation 2,1 , component B is preferably a water dispersible<br />

polyisocyanate hardener. Water dispersible hydrophylic<br />

polyisocyanates can be prepared by reacting isocyanate<br />

trimers with mono-functional polyethers 2 . Most suitable<br />

polyisocyanate hardners for this application are based on<br />

hexamethylene diisocyanate (HDI) trimers, however in order to<br />

optimize properties such as hardness development, also water<br />

12 SURFACE COATINGS ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND<br />

dispersible polyisocyanates based on isophoronediisocyanate<br />

(IPDI) trimers can be used in combination with HDI-types.<br />

Just before application the polyol component is mixed with<br />

the polyisocyanate hardener. After application onto the<br />

substrate, the coating cures through the hydroxyl-isocyanate<br />

reaction resulting in the formation <strong>of</strong> urethane crosslinks. In<br />

waterborne systems a important side-reaction occurs when<br />

isocyanate reacts with water. Some <strong>of</strong> the polyisocyanate<br />

groups are sacrificed because <strong>of</strong> this reaction forming the<br />

unstable carbamic acid which immediately decomposes and<br />

releases CO2 gas and a primary amine. The amine can then<br />

react with the isocyanate forming polyurea. Because <strong>of</strong> the<br />

water side-reaction, the NCO:OH ratio will have a significant<br />

impact on the coating properties: dry times, sanding, pot<br />

life, hardness development and chemical resistance. The<br />

competition between urethane versus urea reaction is<br />

governed by a number <strong>of</strong> parameters such as the surface area/<br />

particle size <strong>of</strong> the polyisocyanate emulsion, the emulsion<br />

stabilization mechanism3 , neutralizing agents and the time<br />

between mixing components A and B and the application <strong>of</strong><br />

the coating. Publications by Urban et al. 4,5 discuss in great<br />

detail the mechanisms and the influence <strong>of</strong> the ratio between<br />

hydrophobic / hydrophilic isocyanates and the curing conditions<br />

such as relative humidity on film-properties.<br />

Binder selection<br />

Most waterborne polyol emulsions are stabilized by either<br />

anionic or non-ionic stabilizing groups or a combination there<strong>of</strong>.<br />

Anionic groups are required for fine particle size emulsions.<br />

Generally there is a relation between the acid value <strong>of</strong> the<br />

polyol and the particle size <strong>of</strong> the emulsion. Most commonly<br />

the anionic groups are introduced by the copolymerization<br />

with carboxylic acid functional (meth)acrylic monomers such<br />

as acrylic or methacrylic acid. The carboxylic acid groups are<br />

converted in the salts using a volatile amine before or during<br />

emulsification in water. The problem associated with the<br />

presence <strong>of</strong> amines in the coating system is the catalytic action<br />

towards the isocyanate-water reaction. In order to decouple the<br />

emulsion particle size with the negative catalytic influence <strong>of</strong><br />

the neutralizing amine, the resin chemists at Nuplex Resins<br />

developed a proprietary technology to replace part <strong>of</strong> the<br />

carboxyl acid groups in the polyol by sulfonate-functional<br />

groups. The advantage <strong>of</strong> the sulfonate functionality is the<br />

fact that these acid groups are neutralized with an inorganic<br />

base that has no unfavourable catalytic action. As a result the<br />

curing <strong>of</strong> the WB2K coating become more controllable and


the flow and levelling properties are positively influenced. Also<br />

the risk <strong>of</strong> CO2 bubbles getting trapped in the drying coating<br />

is reduced. In Table 1 the main properties <strong>of</strong> the waterborne<br />

acrylic polyol used in this study are given.<br />

Table 1. Resin properties.<br />

Hydroxyl value 4.2 % OH<br />

Solids content 47 %<br />

pH 8<br />

Acid value (on solids) 16 mg KOH g mixed<br />

carboxylic and sulfonic<br />

Particle size ± 100 nm<br />

Co-solvent Butyl glycol (approx. 2 %)<br />

Rheology <strong>of</strong> hand applied WB2K coatings<br />

The paint rheology is one <strong>of</strong> the most important parameters<br />

for brush or roller application. When comparing the flow-curve<br />

<strong>of</strong> a conventional solvent-borne 2K paint formulated for hand<br />

application (VOC <strong>of</strong> ± 500 g/l) with that <strong>of</strong> a WB2K system, the<br />

initial flow curves immediately after mixing are quite different<br />

(figure 1).<br />

Figure 1. Flow curve <strong>of</strong> SB 2K and WB 2K paints.<br />

The flow curves also change in a different way as a function <strong>of</strong><br />

the time after mixing (graph 2).<br />

Figure 2. Changes in rheology during the pot-life <strong>of</strong> WB and SB 2K<br />

formulations.<br />

At high shear the viscosity <strong>of</strong> WB2K paint is much lower,<br />

resulting in an initial brush resistance that is far too low.<br />

Furthermore the viscosity decreases during the pot-life, so<br />

application properties become worse after mixing <strong>of</strong> the paint.<br />

Under low shear on the other side, the viscosity is much higher,<br />

with relatively poor flow as a consequence. Because <strong>of</strong> this<br />

rheological behaviour defoaming <strong>of</strong> the paint after application<br />

also becomes difficult.<br />

In order to adjust the rheological behaviour <strong>of</strong> the WB2K paint<br />

a high shear a polyurethane thickener is used to increase<br />

the ICI viscosity to a level <strong>of</strong> 1.6 Poise, similar to that <strong>of</strong><br />

the solventborne paint. By adding the thickener the solids<br />

content <strong>of</strong> the paint could be lowered in order to reduce the<br />

low shear viscosity. This results in adequate brush resistance<br />

in combination with acceptable levelling, flow and defoaming<br />

properties. Most waterborne two pack systems still require the<br />

use <strong>of</strong> some co-solvent and the influence on the rheological<br />

pr<strong>of</strong>ile needs to be taken into account. With this specific polyol<br />

it was found that a mixture <strong>of</strong> butyl acetate, dipropylene glycol<br />

dimethyl ether and butyldiglycol acetate <strong>of</strong>fered the best<br />

results regarding the balance between gloss and levelling. The<br />

flow-curves as function <strong>of</strong> time after mixing for the adjusted<br />

formulation are given in figure 3.<br />

Figure 3. Time dependant flow-curves <strong>of</strong> adjusted formulations.<br />

Formulation parameters for clear and<br />

pigmented coatings<br />

A basic formulation for a hand applied WB2K formulation (both<br />

pigmented and clear) is given in Table 2. The white mill base<br />

used in the pigmented formulation was prepared by dispersing<br />

in a pearl mill 20.12 parts <strong>of</strong> titanium dioxide with 1.03 grams<br />

<strong>of</strong> a dispersant, 0.16 grams <strong>of</strong> thickener and 5.8 grams <strong>of</strong><br />

demineralized water until a Hegmann fineness <strong>of</strong> less than 10<br />

microns was obtained.<br />

During this work it was found that proper selection <strong>of</strong> the high<br />

shear thickener and defoamer is essential to formulate a paint<br />

with a good balance <strong>of</strong> aesthetical and performance properties.<br />

How to achieve proper defoaming<br />

When formulating without a defoamer, the paint, after brush<br />

or roller application will contain at lot <strong>of</strong> foam. After drying<br />

<strong>of</strong> the paint this will result in surface defects such as pinholes<br />

and foam. The selection <strong>of</strong> a defoamer however is<br />

not straight forward as it should ensure proper defoaming<br />

during application without affecting gloss, flow and levelling.<br />

Preferably the defoamer should be easily introduced into the<br />

base without excessive shear.<br />

SURFACE COATINGS ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 13


Table 2. WB2K formulations.<br />

Component Raw material Weight<br />

Clear varnish White paint<br />

Polyol<br />

emulsion<br />

51.41 36.37<br />

Wetting<br />

additives<br />

0.52 0.36<br />

Base<br />

High shear<br />

thickener<br />

2.70 1.91<br />

Defoamer variable variable<br />

Hardener<br />

Diluents<br />

Properties<br />

Demineralized<br />

water<br />

13.73 11.86<br />

Mill base<br />

HDI/IPDI<br />

- 27.11<br />

based<br />

hydrophilic<br />

isocyanate<br />

HDI based<br />

9.85 6.97<br />

hydrophilic<br />

isocyanate<br />

8.66 6.12<br />

Co-solvents* 5.82 4.12<br />

Demineralized<br />

water<br />

7.31 5.18<br />

Density (kg/l) 1.04 1.22<br />

Volume solids<br />

(%)<br />

38.9 38.9<br />

Weight solids<br />

(%)<br />

42.3 50.5<br />

VOC ready to<br />

use (g/l)<br />

87 73<br />

NCO/OH ratio 1.25 1.25<br />

* co-solvent mixture consisting <strong>of</strong> butyl acetate:dipropylene glycol<br />

dimethyl ether:butyldiglycol acetate in a ratio <strong>of</strong> 13/74/13.<br />

In the base for the clear varnish formulation given in table 2,<br />

a number <strong>of</strong> different defoamer types were added at different<br />

concentration levels.<br />

All varnish samples were subjected to a foam test that is<br />

carried out as follows: the coating is applied with a pipette to<br />

the white part <strong>of</strong> a black-white paper contrast chart. After that,<br />

Table 3. Results for the foam test in a clear varnish.<br />

14 SURFACE COATINGS ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND<br />

coating is applied to half <strong>of</strong> the black part <strong>of</strong> the chart using a<br />

brush. The varnish on the white chart is stipulated intensively<br />

with the brush to incorporate a lot <strong>of</strong> air. This varnish is then<br />

brushed over the second half <strong>of</strong> the black part <strong>of</strong> the chart. The<br />

amount <strong>of</strong> foam in the two black parts <strong>of</strong> the chart is judged<br />

after drying overnight according to a scale <strong>of</strong> one (bad) to five<br />

(good). Also the clarity <strong>of</strong> the varnish applied onto glass was<br />

judged after drying. The results are given in table 3.<br />

In the foaming test the defoamers based on a mixture <strong>of</strong><br />

hydrophobic solids and polysiloxanes and the polyether siloxane<br />

defoamer perform well both at high and low addition levels.<br />

However the first type does introduce a strong orange peel<br />

effect in the dried film, even at low concentrations. Also this<br />

defoamer has a negative influence on the clarity <strong>of</strong> the film.<br />

The polyether siloxane defoamer also introduces a slight orange<br />

peel effect, but at low concentrations this is judged to be<br />

acceptable. The defoamer based on the mixture <strong>of</strong> polymers<br />

and hydrophobic solids is somewhat less effective but has<br />

no effect on gloss and haze. At the lower addition level, no<br />

negative effect on the leveling properties was observed.<br />

In order to verify if these defoamers also worked in pigmented<br />

systems, additional tests were performed using the defoamers<br />

at the lowest addition level. Gloss and haze values were<br />

measured for both brush and roller application and are given in<br />

Defoamer Addition level Before After Orange peel Clarity on glass Gloss*<br />

(20°)<br />

None none 2 1 none OK 84 24<br />

Mixture <strong>of</strong> hydrophobic solids<br />

and polysiloxanes<br />

Mixture <strong>of</strong> polymers and<br />

hydrophobic solids<br />

Polyether siloxane copolymer<br />

* applied by brush low=0,17 wt%, high=0,34 wt%<br />

Figure 4. Gloss and haze values for different defoamer types.<br />

Haze*<br />

low 5 5 yes NOK 76 93<br />

high 5 5 yes NOK 82 39<br />

low 4 4 none OK 84 20<br />

high 5 4.5 none OK 83 28<br />

low 5 5 slight OK 84 22<br />

high 5 5 yes OK 84 24


figure 4. Based on these result a final selection was made for<br />

the defoamer based on the polyether siloxane copolymer.<br />

Additional tests have been performed on the final clear varnish<br />

and white paint formulations. The coatings were applied on<br />

glass panels at a wet film thickness <strong>of</strong> 120 microns and dried<br />

at 22 °C and 50% relative humidity: drying and hardness<br />

development were measured. Household chemical resistance<br />

according to the DIN 68861-1A (on oak veneered panels two<br />

coats <strong>of</strong> respectively 175 and 125 microns wet film thickness)<br />

and resistance against methyl ethyl ketone (MEK) were<br />

measured after 1 week <strong>of</strong> drying. Results are given in table 4.<br />

Results at a glance<br />

Waterborne acrylic polyols having mixed carboxylic and sulfonic<br />

stabilization can be used to formulate hand applied two pack<br />

varnishes and paint that show good esthetical properties (gloss,<br />

flow and levelling).<br />

Proper selection <strong>of</strong> the defoamer in the formulation is<br />

essential to get smooth, defect free coatings. Evaluation <strong>of</strong><br />

drying time, hardness build-up and resistance properties show<br />

that these are on the same level <strong>of</strong> conventional solventborne<br />

polyurethane coatings.<br />

These products open up a whole new range <strong>of</strong> end-use<br />

applications for environmentally friendly high performance<br />

coatings where previously only the use <strong>of</strong> high VOC-systems was<br />

a viable option.<br />

Email address: adriaan.sanderse@nuplexresins.com<br />

References<br />

1. M. Melchiors, C. Kobusch, K. Noble, M. Sonntag, H. Casselmann.<br />

‘Aqueous Two-Component Polyurethane (2C-PUR) <strong>Coatings</strong>: An<br />

Evolving Technology’, presented at the International Waterborne,<br />

High Solids and Powder <strong>Coatings</strong> Symposium, <strong>New</strong> Orleans, LA,<br />

February 10, 1999.<br />

2. R. Hombach, H. Reiff, M. Dollhausen, US4663377 to Bayer AG.<br />

3. J. Akkerman, R. Hall, D. Mestach and P. Vandevoorde, sixth<br />

Nürnberg Conference, 2001, 17.<br />

4. D. Otts, M. Urban, Polymer 46 (2005), 2699.<br />

5. D. Otts, K. Pereira, W. Jarret and M. Urban, Polymer 46 (2005),<br />

4600.<br />

Table 4. Testing <strong>of</strong> optimized clear varnish and white paint. Clear Varnish White Paint<br />

Persoz hardness (s) 1 day 107 105<br />

7 days 284 234<br />

BK drying (min) phase I 15 15<br />

phase II 195 210<br />

phase III 360 270<br />

phase IV 570 810<br />

MEK resistance double rubs 68 57<br />

Household chemical resistance (according to DIN 68861-1A) Exposure<br />

5 = no visual damage, 0 = severe damage<br />

ammonia (25 %) 16 h 3 5<br />

ammonia (25 %) 2 m 5 5<br />

50 % ethanol 16 h 5 5<br />

red wine 16 h 5 2<br />

c<strong>of</strong>fee 16 h 5 3<br />

water 16 h 5 5<br />

acetone 16 h 5 5<br />

olive oil 16 h 5 5<br />

mustard 16 h 5 3<br />

black ink 16 h 5 3<br />

cleaning solution 16 h 5 3<br />

SURFACE COATINGS ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 15


We invite papers that deliver new perspectives on<br />

· Smarter Manufacturing – Choosing The Right Equipment<br />

· Environmentally Sustainable Manufacturing In NZ<br />

· NZ Made Vs Imports – Keeping NZ Customers Loyal<br />

· The NZ Way – Specific Technical Demands For The NZ Market<br />

· Innovation In NZ<br />

· The Future Of Manufacturing In NZ<br />

· Challenges Of “Economy <strong>of</strong> Scale” And How To Overcome These<br />

· R & D Successful Studies<br />

· Freight Companies Challenges For Import/Export<br />

PAPERS<br />

Oral presentations will be scheduled to suit the final programme and will be delivered as<br />

presentations <strong>of</strong> 35 minutes with 5 minutes question time. There is also the opportunity<br />

for panel and combination presentations to provide a range <strong>of</strong> perspective on an issue<br />

or a cluster <strong>of</strong> related topics in a shorter format. All papers will be evaluated by the<br />

conference committee. Papers accepted will be published in the conference proceedings<br />

exactly as submitted. A short resumé and photo <strong>of</strong> the presenter is required to be sent<br />

with the abstract.<br />

CONDITIONS<br />

Speakers will be provided with registration for the day <strong>of</strong> their presentation allowing<br />

them to attend other sessions and network with the industry participants. Travel,<br />

accommodation and any additional registration costs associated with the<br />

conference are not included.<br />

ABSRACT FORMAT<br />

• An abstract must be no more than 300 words<br />

• The abstract must include the title <strong>of</strong> the presentation<br />

• Please include all authors <strong>of</strong> the submission, indicating the<br />

author presenting the paper<br />

• The abstract should not include graphics or tables<br />

• Papers should reflect the highest pr<strong>of</strong>essional standard<br />

• The use <strong>of</strong> trade names is discouraged<br />

CONTACT DETAILS<br />

If you would like to present an oral paper at the SCANZ<br />

conference 2012 please email your abstract, resumé and photo to:<br />

Sue Peck, SP Conference Management, Email: suepeck@xtra.co.nz,<br />

Phone: 64 6 3571466<br />

16 SURFACE COATINGS ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND<br />

SURFACE COATINGS ASSOCIATION NZ<br />

2012 CONFERENCE<br />

CALL FOR PAPERS<br />

In 2012 the <strong>Surface</strong> <strong>Coatings</strong> <strong>Association</strong><br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>New</strong> Zealand will be hosting ‘Made<br />

in NZ’ in Blenheim, <strong>New</strong> Zealand. This is<br />

<strong>New</strong> Zealand’s leading technical event for<br />

the surface coatings industry attracting key<br />

participants from established and emerging<br />

companies.<br />

19-21 July 2012<br />

Marlborough Convention<br />

Centre, Blenheim<br />

KEY DATES<br />

Expressions <strong>of</strong> interest by: 31 <strong>October</strong> <strong>2011</strong><br />

Closing Date for Abstracts: 29 February 2012<br />

Final Paper Closing date: 31 May 2012<br />

Final Presentation Closing date: 30 June 2012


FRANK JOSEPH AITKEN-SMITH<br />

One <strong>of</strong> the hardest tasks in life is to write an obituary for a<br />

friend whom one has known for a great many years. Frank was a<br />

workmate and friend whose principles and integrity were <strong>of</strong> the<br />

highest order and he will be missed by friends and colleagues alike.<br />

Franks career in the Paint Industry started in 1947 when,<br />

using his own words, “I had no idea as to what I should do for<br />

a living other than it had to be in a laboratory”. He obtained<br />

a job with Fleetwood Paints in Deptford, South London and<br />

was introduced to the industry by an elderly chemist who was<br />

making paint in an equally elderly edge-runner. Varnishes were<br />

cooked in large mobile pots over sunken gas rings in an open<br />

lean-to attached to the <strong>of</strong>fice building. In Winter the varnish<br />

makers dressed in overcoats and scarves were carefully watching<br />

the “string” from the paddle.<br />

From here he moved on to Sherwood Paints in Barking, Essex<br />

when a tram, ferry and bus ride eventually got him to work<br />

each morning. Work was a large barn with a concrete floor and<br />

long wooden benches with nowhere to sit. Frank remarked “ in<br />

winter, with snow on the ground, we stood at our bench wearing<br />

overcoats and scarves under our lab coats” They did not make<br />

their own mill-bases as a man made them all on triple and single<br />

roll mills. Sherwood made a range <strong>of</strong> good decorative paints and<br />

Frank admitted he learned a good deal <strong>of</strong> his knowledge there.<br />

In about 1950 he joined Pinchin Johnson & Associates<br />

in Silvertown, a large modern paint factory with various<br />

sections dealing with Development, Raw Material Testing and<br />

Government Specification Training. He eventually obtained his<br />

A.R.I.C. with PJA. Frank always said that, at that time, they<br />

were expected to call their superiors “Sir” and to wear a suit and<br />

tie under their lab coats. Frank was very happy working for PJA<br />

but in 1953, for various reasons, he transferred to Taubmans<br />

Paints in Miramar, Wellington.<br />

His move to Wellington was significant as it was here in 1954<br />

he met and married Valerie, his wife, a partnership which was<br />

to last 57 years. Frank’s workmates were Jock Mandeno ( Willie<br />

Mandeno’s Father) and Keith Furneaux who was Frank’s Best<br />

Man at the wedding.<br />

Frank joined the O.C.C.A. N.Z. Section in 1953 a couple <strong>of</strong><br />

weeks after he joined the Taubmans lab.<br />

Two years later Frank was transferred to the Taubmans plant<br />

in Auckland and worked there until it closed down in 1959. He<br />

then joined Hill & Plumber on Federal and Hobson Streets<br />

when, although they were only a paint distributor, they purpose<br />

built a laboratory for Frank on its premises. Noel Frykberg was<br />

the Representative and identified customer needs while Frank<br />

formulated the necessary paints and sent it to Wellington where<br />

the paint was manufactured.<br />

Frank was also a Founder member <strong>of</strong> the Auckland Branch<br />

<strong>of</strong> the O.C.C.A N.Z. Section., and has maintained his<br />

20TH February 1930 - 21st August <strong>2011</strong><br />

membership throughout his career, being a regular attendee at<br />

Technical evenings, Past Chairman’s Dinners and Conferences<br />

etc. (Frank was Chairman <strong>of</strong> the Auckland Section between<br />

1963 and 1965)<br />

Noel then bought a company in Penrose Auckland with a<br />

nominee shareholder in David Levene and changed its name to<br />

Oregon Paints. The writer was the company chemist and the<br />

company eventually became Levene Paint Manufacturing Ltd.<br />

In 1962 Frank moved to B.I.P and, in 1970, to Goldex Paints,<br />

subsequently bought out by Samson Paints. When James<br />

Hardie bought Samson Paints, Frank retired - for the first time.<br />

In 1983 Frank joined the D.S.I.R. and worked at the Naval<br />

Dockyards Laboratory for the Dept. <strong>of</strong> Defence.<br />

Frank then joined Levene Paint Manufacturing in 1985 in a<br />

part-time position, which is where the Writer got to know and<br />

respect more <strong>of</strong> Frank, who became a very valued member <strong>of</strong> the<br />

L.P.M. Lab. Staff.<br />

In 1994 Frank retired for the second time, devoting his time to<br />

his own company.<br />

Way back in 1974 Frank and Valerie had started a company<br />

<strong>of</strong> their own called Fine Arts Supplies Ltd and expanded it to<br />

a very successful supplier <strong>of</strong> art paints when Bruce Clegg and<br />

Peter Ellis became involved. Frank subsequently sold his share<br />

in F.A.S. and formed Multicraft Manufacturing where, right<br />

up until his death, he and his associates were supplying photosensitive<br />

and screen blocking lacquers for screen printing as well<br />

as fabric dyes and chemicals.<br />

Frank was a humble man and it was very easy to underestimate<br />

his capabilities, which were enormous. Certainly <strong>of</strong> strong will,<br />

stubborn and forthright, he did not display his knowledge in an<br />

arrogant manner, rather he would quietly go on learning and not<br />

making the same mistakes twice. Frank is survived by his wife<br />

Valerie, his children and there families and a large number <strong>of</strong><br />

friends and colleagues.<br />

Tom Hackney<br />

SURFACE COATINGS ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 17


SURFACE<br />

COATINGS<br />

ASSOCIATION<br />

NEW<br />

ZEALAND<br />

Seminar: 17th November <strong>2011</strong><br />

Venue: The University <strong>of</strong> Auckland, Tamaki Campus<br />

SCANZ is planning to run a full day seminar on basic paint parameters, similar<br />

to the very successful seminar a few years ago. This is aimed at new chemists<br />

and plant personnel with a penchant for understanding the chemistry behind<br />

their products. A degree in Chemistry is not essential.<br />

Provisional Program:<br />

• General introduction - what is paint ? Where and why it is used ?<br />

• HSNO – documentation, MSDS<br />

• Morning tea<br />

• Binders (resins / polymers)<br />

• Pigments<br />

• Solvents<br />

• Additives<br />

• Lunch<br />

• Paint Formulating<br />

• Rheology<br />

• Paint Production, processing<br />

• Afternoon tea<br />

• Quality / Paint Testing<br />

• Paint Defects / Trouble shooting<br />

Costs: These have not been finalised at print deadline but will be minimal to cover the<br />

overheads only. Further notice by email shortly.<br />

For more information or to express an interest, contact Phil Coveny on:<br />

Ph: 09 580 0851 Mob: 021 748 167 Email: philc@nuplex.co.nz.<br />

18 SURFACE COATINGS ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND<br />

Binders<br />

Rhodoline Defoamers<br />

Rhodoline Dispersants<br />

Extenders: Tixosil & Tixolex<br />

Upcoming Event<br />

The pr<strong>of</strong>essional body <strong>of</strong> chemists in the oil and chemical coatings industry<br />

Surfactants<br />

Water Repellents<br />

Wetting Agents<br />

Gensil Silicones<br />

<strong>New</strong> Zealand Manufacturer backed by Global Innovation<br />

For more information contact:<br />

Kevin Osten Ph (0274) 577 417 • kevin.osten@ap.rhodia.com • Customer Services: Ph (06) 368 9372 • Fax (06) 368 2071


Evonik Tego wins<br />

“Ringier Technology<br />

Innovation Award<br />

<strong>2011</strong> for <strong>Coatings</strong><br />

Industry”<br />

TEGO ® Twin 4100 is an innovative product that<br />

combines properties <strong>of</strong>ten seemingly contradicting<br />

in one molecule. This enables coating and ink<br />

customers to formulate environmentally friendly<br />

solutions by using an APE-free, solvent-free and<br />

isocyanate-free product. TEGO ® Twin 4100 is a good<br />

example <strong>of</strong> a product that Tego is utilizing based on<br />

its innovation technologies. This is exemplified not<br />

only by benchmarking existing technology but also<br />

by entering new chemical fields in the coatings and<br />

ink markets, especially in environmental friendly<br />

systems like water, UV and High Solids systems.<br />

Ringier Trade Media Ltd. is a leading B2B<br />

industrial information provider <strong>of</strong> technical<br />

information, solutions and applications for<br />

industrial leaders in China, Asia Pacific and the<br />

Middle East. The Ringier Technology Innovation<br />

Award is to recognize those who have made<br />

significant contributions for the advancement<br />

<strong>of</strong> the industry through technical innovation,<br />

productivity increase, economic efficiency and<br />

market opportunity creation. Ringier Technology<br />

Innovation Awards are regarded as one <strong>of</strong> the most<br />

important awards in China’s coating industry.<br />

David tells me that Twin 4100 ® is a Gemini<br />

surfactant that effectively lowers surface tension<br />

and improves wetting and flow even at very low<br />

concentrations. Its Gemini structure reduces<br />

foaming even in highly dynamic processes<br />

and application methods. The product’s good<br />

compatibility and long-term activity also impress<br />

in problematic binder systems. The solvent-free<br />

TEGO Twin 4100 ® has proven itself particularly in<br />

waterborne formulations for wood and industrial<br />

finishes as well as printing inks and lacquers …ED<br />

SITUATION WANTED<br />

Experienced coatings chemist seeks<br />

full time position at any coatings<br />

manufacturer in <strong>New</strong> Zealand.<br />

I am a qualified paint chemist from Zimbabwe with<br />

vast knowledge and technical expertise in paint<br />

systems, formulations and production mechanisms.<br />

I hold Bachelor’s degree (honours) in chemistry<br />

and South Africa Paint Technology course and have<br />

received four awards for being the best student.<br />

In 2010 I received the ‘Kekwick Award’ for being<br />

the most outstanding student during the Paint<br />

Technology course, presented to me by Brenda<br />

Peters the Oil & Colour Chemists <strong>Association</strong><br />

(OCCA) President <strong>of</strong> which I am a member <strong>of</strong>.<br />

I have 5 years experience in the coatings industry<br />

and have knowledge with domestic, industrial and<br />

automotive coatings. My duties and responsibilities<br />

involve the following:<br />

Research and development on new products,<br />

Formulation optimization, in process control <strong>of</strong><br />

unfinished and finished paint in production, Quality<br />

control <strong>of</strong> incoming raw materials, evaluating<br />

competitors’ products, Offering technical assistance<br />

to internal and external customers, customer<br />

complaints resolution.<br />

Contact: Patience Sameke Email: patiek8@gmail.com<br />

Cell: +263 772747301<br />

SURFACE COATINGS ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND 19


Random and Disordered Thoughts - By Jetsam<br />

Once again we are blessed with a wonderful article by Peter<br />

Walters tracing the history <strong>of</strong> perhaps our most important<br />

single paint ingredient, certainly our most important white<br />

pigment in the modern age.<br />

When you look back at things like white lead, one is able to<br />

imagine that white paint, or even orange paint, was a toxic<br />

nasty that could poison us and make us all sterile. A bit like the<br />

ancient Romans with their lead water pipes. Titanium dioxide<br />

is completely the opposite, a potential environmental life saver.<br />

We have even been sent an article that extols the virtues <strong>of</strong><br />

cleaning the atmosphere using nano-sized titanium dioxide.<br />

In this age <strong>of</strong> global warming and carbon tax, I note that<br />

the scientific community has determined that growing trees<br />

is contributing more to global warming because <strong>of</strong> the dark<br />

colour than the benefit from adsorbing carbon dioxide. Maybe<br />

our government could fund research into growing white trees.<br />

IMCD <strong>New</strong> Zealand Ltd is a leading supplier <strong>of</strong> specialty and commodity chemicals into the<br />

<strong>New</strong> Zealand <strong>Coatings</strong>, Inks, Construction, Adhesive and related markets.<br />

Some <strong>of</strong> our key agencies include…<br />

Dow Chemicals - Glycols, Epoxy resins, Glycol Ethers,<br />

Amines, PEGs, Surfactants and Water Treatment systems.<br />

Troy - Wet/Dry film Biocides and Additives.<br />

AkzoNobel - Organic Peroxides.<br />

Sasol - Surfactants and Olefins.<br />

20 SURFACE COATINGS ASSOCIATION OF NEW ZEALAND<br />

That raises the question <strong>of</strong> white houses with white ro<strong>of</strong>s. Some<br />

scientists worked out the positive contribution to climate cooling<br />

if every ro<strong>of</strong> was painted white.<br />

But there are a growing number <strong>of</strong> local bodies, or the<br />

remnants <strong>of</strong> them if you live in Auckland, that are specifying<br />

light reflectance values <strong>of</strong> no more than 55%, medium to<br />

dark coloured houses with, presumably, correspondingly dark<br />

coloured ro<strong>of</strong>s. With the huge potential <strong>of</strong> titanium dioxide to<br />

save the planet, or at least us from ourselves more likely, you<br />

have to wonder about the commitment or the intelligence <strong>of</strong><br />

the politicians that make up these rules, or are they just paying<br />

lip service to global warming? After all, carbon is easy to tax<br />

and as we all seem to have forgotten in the euphoria <strong>of</strong> the<br />

rugby world cup, so are people.<br />

I bet most <strong>of</strong> you did not realise how political titanium<br />

dioxide really is.<br />

DuPont - Capstone Fluoro-Additives and Micro Powders.<br />

Wacker - EVA Polymer Emulsions and Powders,<br />

Silicones, Silanes, Siloxanes and Fumed Silica.<br />

<strong>New</strong> Supplier: http://www.dow.com/ Eagle Chemicals - Solvent based<br />

resins (Alkyds, Polyester and Acrylics).<br />

RECREATE PMS<br />

Our contact details:<br />

Paul Armistead and Warren Strickett • 09 582 0250 • imcdcs@imcd.co.nz • www.imcd.co.nz<br />

Head Office<br />

5 Lockhart Place, Mt Wellington, Auckland 1060, <strong>New</strong> Zealand<br />

P.O. Box 62274, Mt Wellington, Auckland 1641, <strong>New</strong> Zealand<br />

Tel +64 9 914 7010 Fax +64 9 914 7014<br />

Email: sibelconz@sibelco.co.nz<br />

Nationwide Stockists <strong>of</strong>: Barytes, Calcite, Cement, Clay, Diatomaceous Earth,<br />

Feldspar, Gypsum, Iron Oxide Pigment, Magnesium Oxide, Mica, Miclay,<br />

Nepheline Syenite, Pumice, Pyrophyllite, Silica, Slate, Talc & Wollastonite<br />

www.sibelco.co.nz


Rohm and Haas <strong>New</strong> Zealand Ltd<br />

• Paraloid ® Thermoplastic/Thermosetting<br />

Acrylics<br />

• Primal ® Acrylic Copolymers<br />

• Acrysol ® , Orotan ® , Kathon ® , Ropaque ® ,<br />

Skane ® , Rocima ® , Additives<br />

• Acumer ® , Acusol® Dispersants/Detergent<br />

Polymers<br />

Rhodia<br />

• Rhodoline ® Defoamers, Dispersants, Wetting<br />

Agents<br />

• Abex ® , Alkamuls ® , Antarox ® , Geropon ® ,<br />

Igepal ® , Rhodasurf ® , Soprophor ® Surfactants<br />

“TECHNOLOGY AND COLOURS<br />

FOR COATINGS”<br />

• Organic /Inorganic Pigments (DIC, Sudarshan, Sun E.C. Pigments)<br />

• Fiesta Fluorescent Colours (Swada, NovaGlo, Glowbug)<br />

• Ultramarine Pigments<br />

• Gasil Matting Silicas, Silica gels, Freeflow (PQ Corp)<br />

• Pigment Dispersions (DIC Group)<br />

• Coating & Composite Resins (Reichhold & DIC Group)<br />

• Epoxy Curing Agents/Resins (Reichhold & DIC Group)<br />

• Polyisocyanates/Polyurethanes (Reichhold & DIC Group)<br />

• Aluminium Pastes/Powder (Benda Lutz)<br />

• Solvent Dyes (Rathi)<br />

DIC <strong>New</strong> Zealand<br />

PO Box 12-748, Penrose, Auckland 1642<br />

Telephone 09 636 2947 • Fax 09 636 5522<br />

email: penny.meads@dic.co.nz • website: www.dic.co.nz<br />

CONNELL BROS COMPANY AUSTRALASIA LIMITED<br />

(formerly Wilbur-Ellis Connell Bros)<br />

3rd Floor, 19 Great South Road, <strong>New</strong>market, Auckland<br />

PO Box 9956, <strong>New</strong>market, Auckland<br />

( +64 9 984 4700 7 +64 9 921 3391<br />

www.connellbros.com<br />

Aditya Birla Chemicals<br />

• Epotec ® Epoxy Resins, Reactive Diluents &<br />

Curatives<br />

Columbian Chemicals Company<br />

• Raven ® Carbon Black Pigments<br />

Dynasol<br />

• Calprene ® and Solprene ® Elastomers<br />

Huber Engineered Materials<br />

• Calcium carbonate, Silica/silicate, Kaolin<br />

clay, Alumina trihydrate, Barium sulphate,<br />

Engineered composites<br />

General Chemicals<br />

• Glycols, Coalescents, D-Limonene, EDTA, Iron<br />

Oxides, Surfactants, Hot Polymerised SBR<br />

Rubbers, Various Commodities<br />

AArbor International Corporation<br />

• Silverking ® Aluminium Pigment Pastes<br />

Alberdingk Boley Gmbh<br />

• Refined Linseed Oils<br />

Sherwin Williams Chemicals<br />

• Moly-White ® Corrosion Inhibitors<br />

Bayer <strong>New</strong> Zealand Ltd<br />

PO Box 2825<br />

Auckland<br />

Phone 64 9 441 8595<br />

www.lanxess.com


• Alkyd Resins<br />

• Polyester Polyols<br />

• Solution Acrylics<br />

• Polyester Gelcoats<br />

I N D U S T R<br />

I E S<br />

Manufacturers & Suppliers <strong>of</strong>:<br />

L I M I T E D<br />

• Aqueous Polymer<br />

Dispersions<br />

• Polyurethane Dispersions<br />

• M/C Urethanes<br />

Proud<br />

Supporters<br />

<strong>of</strong> SCANZ<br />

• Waterborne Alkyds<br />

• T RAcrylic/Alkyd<br />

I E S L I M I T E D Hybrid Resins<br />

• Speciality Resins<br />

• Acrylic Polyols<br />

P O Box 12-841, Penrose, Auckland. Phone: 0-9-579 2029. Fax: 0-9-571 0542. Toll Free: 0800 803 000<br />

T h e<br />

QC<br />

Building the Future Together<br />

W o r l d o f A d d i t i v e s<br />

Proud supporter <strong>of</strong> SCANZ<br />

Solution<br />

s for<br />

<strong>Coatings</strong><br />

and<br />

Plastics<br />

C o o k s C o m p o s i t e s<br />

Tronox Titanium Dioxide<br />

Nubiola anti-corrosives, ultramarine blue<br />

Shamrock micronised waxes<br />

Dynoadd coatings additives<br />

Microbeads surface modifiers<br />

Industrial Copolymers resins and Oxazolidines<br />

Jayant Oil Castor oil and derivatives<br />

Nippon Polyurethane<br />

Worlee Chemie resins<br />

Spolchemie Epoxies<br />

Silanes, chlorinated paraffins, zinc oxide<br />

Organic pigments and lead chrome replacements<br />

Iron oxide, talc, barium sulphate, silica flour, mica<br />

Metal powders and pastes, pigment preparations<br />

D-Limonene, methylene chloride, caustic soda<br />

Building Building the Future the Future Together Together<br />

T h e<br />

Contact: Heather Smith, Richard Calvin, Dave Perano, Steve Parlane,<br />

John Gilbert, Sean Winter, Michael Behr, Anne Day, Tracy Taylor,<br />

Taryn Rabie, Gray Gilbert<br />

Ph (09) 486 6637 • Fax (09) 486 6286<br />

www.rebain.com<br />

Offices in Auckland, Palmerston North, Melbourne, Barcelona, Rotterdam & Venezuela<br />

T h e W o r l d o f A d d i t i v e s<br />

W o r l d o f A d d i t i v e s<br />

QC<br />

Solution<br />

s for<br />

<strong>Coatings</strong><br />

and<br />

Plastics<br />

& P<br />

Q<br />

o<br />

C<br />

l<br />

S<br />

y<br />

o<br />

m<br />

lu<br />

e<br />

tio<br />

r<br />

n<br />

s<br />

s for<br />

<strong>Coatings</strong><br />

and<br />

Plastics<br />

Supplier <strong>of</strong> brand Titanium Dioxide<br />

I N D U S<br />

I N D U S T R I E S L I M I T E D<br />

C o o k s C o m p o s i t e s & P o l y m e r s<br />

C o o k s C o m p o s i t e s & P o l y m e r s<br />

PO Box 5175<br />

Rotorua West, Rotorua 3044<br />

Toll Free NZ only:<br />

0800 4 TIONA (0800 484 662)<br />

Phone +64 7 346 2225<br />

Fax +64 7 346 2224<br />

Mobile: 021 643 192<br />

www.cristalglobal.com

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!