2012 Aboriginal Studies - UBC Press
2012 Aboriginal Studies - UBC Press
2012 Aboriginal Studies - UBC Press
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
politiCs & nAtion<br />
the perils of identity<br />
Group Rights and the Politics of Intragroup Difference<br />
Caroline Dick<br />
CARoLINe DICk is an assistant<br />
professor in the Department<br />
of Political Science at the<br />
University of Western Ontario.<br />
2011<br />
978-0-7748-2062-2 HC $90.00<br />
July 2 012<br />
978-0-7748-2063-9 Pb $29.95<br />
260 p ages, 6 x 9 "<br />
<strong>Aboriginal</strong> studies, Law &<br />
Politics , Political theory &<br />
Philosophy , Constitutional Law ,<br />
Canadian Courts & Constitution<br />
18 order online: www.ubcpress.ca<br />
The Perils of Identity lays out various philosophical<br />
treatments of identity, addresses their<br />
limitations, and then offers a means for judges<br />
to address group claims. The scholarship is very<br />
sound and the author is at the top of her game.<br />
– Christa Scholtz, author of Negotiating Claims:<br />
The Emergence of Indigenous Land Claim<br />
Negotiation Policies in Australia, Canada, New<br />
Zealand, and the United States<br />
Many liberal theorists consider group identity<br />
claims a necessary condition of equality in<br />
Canada, but do these claims do more harm than<br />
good? To answer this question, Caroline Dick<br />
examines the identity-driven theories of Charles<br />
Taylor, Will Kymlicka, and Avigail Eisenberg in the<br />
context of Sawridge Band v. Canada, a case which<br />
sets a First Nation’s right to self-determination<br />
against indigenous women’s right to equality. The<br />
concept of identity itself is not the problem, Dick<br />
argues, but rather the way in which prevailing<br />
conceptions of identity and group rights obscure<br />
intragroup differences. Her proposal for a new<br />
politics of intragroup difference has the power to<br />
transform rights discourse in Canada.<br />
CoNteNts<br />
Introduction<br />
1 Gender Discrimination within First Nations:<br />
The History and Nature of the Sawridge Dispute<br />
2 Group Rights and the Politics of Identity<br />
3 Taylor’s Theory of Identity Recognition<br />
4 Kymlicka’s Cultural Theory of Minority Rights<br />
5 Eisenberg’s Theory of Identity-Related Interests<br />
6 Culture, Identity, and the Constitutional Rights<br />
of <strong>Aboriginal</strong> Peoples<br />
7 The Politics of Intragroup Difference<br />
8 Sawridge Revisited<br />
Conclusion<br />
Notes; Bibliography; Index