02.02.2013 Views

Australia's last great whale haven.pdf - Ningaloo Atlas

Australia's last great whale haven.pdf - Ningaloo Atlas

Australia's last great whale haven.pdf - Ningaloo Atlas

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

November 2011 Discussion<br />

29<br />

Discussion<br />

Cetaceans and the Bioregional Plan<br />

Cetaceans that frequent the NW Marine Region are poorly protected<br />

under the Australian Government’s proposed Bioregional Plan and the<br />

accompanying proposed marine reserve network does little to adequately<br />

protect areas of known importance for most cetacean species. The Plan<br />

focuses on four species of cetaceans: the three species of inshore dolphin<br />

and humpback <strong>whale</strong>s. Concerns arise over two major points: firstly, the<br />

plan effectively ignores the other species known or expected to occur in<br />

the region. Secondly, the plan does little to protect even these four species.<br />

The majority of the proposed reserves are IUCN category VI, the lowest level<br />

of protection available, allowing multiple use or, in other words, “business<br />

as usual”. Most of the highly protected areas (IUCN category II) are relegated<br />

to oceanic waters underlain by abyssal plains. There is only one highly<br />

protected area, within the Kimberley Marine Reserve, placed specifically<br />

to protect the humpback <strong>whale</strong> calving grounds; however, the boundary<br />

proposed does not reflect the extent of the biologically important area for<br />

this species indicated by the Jenner 97 survey.<br />

The proposed highly protected reserves stand<br />

out as avoiding areas that are currently under<br />

or proposed to be under petroleum leases (Figure 5).<br />

No additional protection is proposed for areas<br />

surrounding the existing small Commonwealth<br />

marine reserves in the region, such as around<br />

<strong>Ningaloo</strong> Reef, Mermaid Reef, Ashmore Reef National<br />

Nature Reserve and Cartier Island Marine Reserve.<br />

The areas where multiple human uses intersect,<br />

especially the oil and gas industry, fisheries and<br />

shipping, are not destined for further protection.<br />

The plan identifies 23 regional priorities for the<br />

NW Marine Region, including 12 conservation<br />

features and 11 pressures on the environment.<br />

The conservation feature regional priorities include<br />

the three inshore dolphins and humpback <strong>whale</strong>s,<br />

as well as other ecological features and the existing<br />

Commonwealth Reserves. The 11 pressures identified<br />

are all relevant to cetaceans in the region, and<br />

include climate change, noise pollution, physical<br />

habitat modification, human presence at sensitive<br />

sites, marine debris, invasive species, light pollution,<br />

the extraction of living resources, bycatch in fisheries,<br />

collision with vessels and changes to hydrological<br />

regimes 63 . The priorities exclude all offshore<br />

cetaceans and habitats which have been found<br />

to be important to them, such as the Browse Basin.<br />

It may be that the plan only acknowledges the three<br />

inshore dolphins and humpback <strong>whale</strong>s because<br />

they are the most studied species, and threats to their<br />

populations can be determined with more certainty<br />

than for other species. Many of the threatening<br />

processes are concentrated around coastal areas<br />

where these species are commonly found. The fact<br />

that inshore dolphins are resident in small areas<br />

puts increased pressure on them compared with<br />

species that move more widely. However, offshore<br />

species may also display high site fidelity, as shown<br />

for rough-toothed dolphins in Hawaii 13 ; impacts on<br />

these habitats may also damage local populations.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!