ENVSEC Progress Report 2006.pdf
ENVSEC Progress Report 2006.pdf
ENVSEC Progress Report 2006.pdf
- TAGS
- envsec
- www.envsec.org
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
CONTENTS<br />
Executive Summary<br />
<strong>Progress</strong> <strong>Report</strong> 2006<br />
News from the regions 6<br />
South-Eastern Europe 6<br />
Eastern Europe 8<br />
Southern Caucasus 10<br />
Central Asia 12<br />
Cross-regional activities<br />
News from the Secretariat 17<br />
Annexes<br />
2<br />
16<br />
1 Main meetings attended and organized in 2006<br />
2 Planned, on-going and completed projects<br />
3 National focal points and contacts<br />
4 <strong>ENVSEC</strong> contact directory
Executive Summary<br />
During 2006, the Environment and Security Initiative (<strong>ENVSEC</strong>) continued to implement sub-regional<br />
projects in the Southern Caucasus, Central Asia and South Eastern and Eastern Europe. At the request<br />
of Belarus, Moldova and Ukraine, the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> partners initiated an environment and security<br />
risk assessment in this Eastern European sub-region. In addition to the continuing environmental consequences<br />
of the Chernobyl disaster, the issues identified for urgent attention by <strong>ENVSEC</strong> included<br />
wastes, stocks of rocket fuel and obsolete pesticides from Soviet times, and shared waters.<br />
In Central Asia, preliminary environment and security risk assessment reports were prepared to pave<br />
the way for the Eastern Caspian and Amu Darya sub-regional programmes. The first Tajikistan-<br />
Afghanistan meeting of heads of environmental agencies highlighted the need for closer cross-border<br />
cooperation on issues related to nature conservation and resource management. The assessment of<br />
environmental and health risks at industrial hot spots in the Ferghana valley shared by Kyrgyzstan and<br />
Tajikistan was completed. Suggestions were made for a series of immediate measures for minimizing<br />
the identified risks and for cleaning up the polluted areas.<br />
In South Eastern Europe, the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> partners continue to promote environmentally sound mining<br />
practices through training, assessment and rehabilitation projects. The consortium is implementing<br />
several demonstration projects for rehabilitating mining legacies and building local capacities both in<br />
governance (mining regulators) and technical fields. <strong>ENVSEC</strong> is also promoting cross-border cooperation<br />
on nature protection through the establishment of protected areas and parks. The addition of the<br />
REC as a partner has meant inclusion of ongoing projects such as the Multilateral Environment<br />
Agreements implementation, and the Adriatic Sea Partnership.<br />
Among its peace-building efforts in 2006, <strong>ENVSEC</strong> provided a core contribution to the OSCE-led Environmental<br />
Assessment Mission to fire-affected territories in and around the Nagorno-Karabakh region<br />
in the Southern Caucasus. During the Mission, local and international wild land fire experts assessed<br />
the short- and long-term impact of the fires on the environment and recommended measures to counteract<br />
any detrimental impacts. The Mission recommended a series of joint capacity-building and training<br />
activities in fire management, fire prevention and preparedness and fire suppression. It also urged<br />
enhanced regional co-operation on both fire and water management issues in the context of relevant<br />
regional and international frameworks. In the light of the ongoing conflict, the Mission served as an important<br />
confidence-building measure by bringing the parties together on a critical environmental issue.<br />
Activities conducted under the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> Initiative show that environment can act as a bridge for crossboundary<br />
cooperation. Joint assessments and information exchanges have identified common interests,<br />
improved mutual understanding, and built foundations for agreements on trans-boundary environmental<br />
management. The partnership approach on which <strong>ENVSEC</strong> is based brings explicit benefits<br />
of improved coordination and a cost-effective comprehensive approach to regional cooperation as well<br />
as enhanced synergies and coherence with other donor initiatives at the country and sub-region level.<br />
A mid-term assessment requested by CIDA and conducted by an independent consultant concluded<br />
that “<strong>ENVSEC</strong> is a rare upshot of the implementation of the February 2005 Paris Declaration with regard<br />
to donor harmonization and local ownership”.<br />
Thanks to funds provided to-date by Austria, Belgium Canada, the Czech Republic, Finland, Germany,<br />
Hungary, Italy, the Netherlands, Norway, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland and the USA, 4,686,000 million<br />
were made available for activities in 2003 -2006. The <strong>ENVSEC</strong> partners added USD 912, 000 through<br />
these years, and NATO as an associated organization aligned its activities amounting to USD<br />
7,456,000. A work programme including over 70 projects stemming from region-specific priorities related<br />
to need of further assessments, policy development, institution and capacity building as well as<br />
technical cooperation has been elaborated for the period 2007-2009.<br />
3
Contact <strong>ENVSEC</strong><br />
Chairman of the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> Management Board<br />
Ben Slay, Director<br />
UNDP RBEC Bratislava Regional Centre<br />
Grosslingova 35, 811 09 Bratislava, Slovak Republic<br />
+421 2 59337 444<br />
ben.slay@undp.org<br />
<strong>ENVSEC</strong> Secretariat:<br />
Marika Palosaari, Coordination Officer<br />
UNEP Regional Office for Europe<br />
11-13 Chemin des Anémones, CH-1219 Châtelaine, Geneva<br />
+41 22 917 8483, fax +41 22 797 3420<br />
marika.palosaari@unep.ch<br />
Peter Svedberg, Administrative Unit Officer<br />
UNDP RBEC Bratislava Regional Centre<br />
Grosslingova 35, 811 09 Bratislava, Slovak Republic<br />
+421 2 59337 219, fax: +421 (2) 59337 450<br />
peter.svedberg@undp.org<br />
Jelena Beronja, Regional Desk Officer for South Eastern Europe<br />
UNEP Vienna - ISCC<br />
Vienna International Center, PO Box 500, A 1400 Vienna, Austria<br />
+43 1 260 60 44 21, fax +43 1 260 60 6730<br />
jelena.beronja@unvienna.org<br />
Nickolai Denisov, Regional Desk Officer for Eastern Europe<br />
UNEP Regional Office for Europe<br />
11-13 Chemin des Anémones, CH-1219 Châtelaine, Geneva<br />
+41 22 917 8281, fax +41 22 797 3420<br />
nickolai.denisov@unep.ch<br />
Inkar Kadyrzhanova, Regional Desk Officer for Central Asia<br />
UNDP Kazakhstan<br />
Tole bi 67<br />
050000 Almaty, Kazakhstan<br />
+ 7 327 258 26 42, fax + 7 327 258 26 45<br />
inkar.kadyrzhanova@undp.org<br />
David Swalley, Regional Desk Officer for the Southern Caucasus<br />
Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe<br />
Office of the Co-ordinator of OSCE Economic and Environmental Activities<br />
Kaerntner Ring 5-7, A1010 Vienna, Austria<br />
+43 1 514 36 913, fax: 43 1 51436 96<br />
david.swalley@osce.org<br />
Bo Libert, UNECE Focal Point<br />
UNECE Environment, Housing and Land Management Division<br />
Palais des Nations, CH-1211 Geneva 10, Switzerland<br />
+41-22-917 23 96, fax: +41-22-917 06 21<br />
bo.libert@unece.org<br />
4
Stephen Stec, REC Focal Point<br />
Regional Environmental Center for Central and Eastern Europe<br />
Ady Endre ut 9-11, 2000 Szentendre, Hungary<br />
+36 26 504 000, fax: +36 26 311 294<br />
sstec@rec.org<br />
Contacts within the Associated <strong>ENVSEC</strong> member NATO<br />
Susanne Michaelis and Walter Kaffenberger<br />
NATO Public Diplomacy Division<br />
Bd. Leopold III, B-1110 Brussels, Belgium<br />
+322 707 4520 Fax +32 2 707 4232<br />
michaelis.susanne@hq.nato.int<br />
kaffenberger.walter@ hq.nato.int<br />
More Information<br />
The <strong>ENVSEC</strong> website (www.envsec.org) includes information on all <strong>ENVSEC</strong> regions and projects, as<br />
well as the partner organisations, national focal points and other resources. All of the publications, including<br />
the assessment reports and maps, are available there as well. More details about concrete<br />
work under the Initiative are presented below and in the Annexes. <strong>ENVSEC</strong> partners will be grateful for<br />
any feedback and ideas with respect to both this report and the Initiative itself.<br />
5
NEWS FROM THE REGIONS<br />
Europe<br />
South-<br />
Eastern<br />
Managing and reducing trans-boundary risks of hazardous activities<br />
Managing and reducing the trans-boundary risks of hazardous activities has been recognized<br />
as one of the priority <strong>ENVSEC</strong> fields of action from the onset of the Initiative in South-<br />
Eastern Europe (SEE). The implementation of the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> SEE regional project “Improving<br />
regional cooperation for risk management from pollution hotspots as well as the transboundary<br />
management of shared natural resources” is financed by the Austrian Development<br />
Agency (ADA) and the Canadian International Development Agency (CIDA). A refined desk<br />
assessment of the region’s mining hotspots updated with local information was finalized in<br />
August 2006, based on the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> missions to Albania, Montenegro, Serbia and Bosnia<br />
and Herzegovina in April and May 2006.<br />
This targeted assessment of the transboundary environment and health risks of mining resulted<br />
in a list of pilot sites 1 where immediate follow up action should be catalyzed. Romania<br />
and Kosovo (the UN administered territory under UN Security Council resolution 1244) are<br />
not directly covered by the assessment, as considerable progress has already been achieved<br />
there for example by the activities of UNDP office in Kosovo*, which implements a feasibility<br />
study for the remediation of Stan Trg/Stanterg and Artana/Novo Brdo Mines. Also in Lojane<br />
Mine in Macedonia, a feasibility study is under implementation by UNDP Macedonia to determine<br />
the measures necessary to remediate the site. It is anticipated that this work will catalyse<br />
follow-up action in a larger scale at these two sites, in the framework of the UNDP Regional<br />
Hotspot Programme led by UNDP Montenegro. Preparations for a regional workshop<br />
on innovative techniques and technologies for contaminated mine waters assessment, management<br />
and remediation, to be held in Bor, Serbia in March 2007 are underway.<br />
The mining sites assessment will be followed by development of policy and technical options<br />
suitable for the region as well as implementation of pilot activities focusing on innovative, local<br />
and cost-efficient risk reduction and management measures. In 2007 regional capacity building<br />
activities will also be developed and implemented in accordance with the “Mining for Closure”<br />
principles.<br />
*Kosovo refers to the UN administered territory under UN Security Council resolution 1244<br />
1 Rubic & Rreshen, Kurbnesh, Fushe-Arrez, Kukes / Gjejan, Elbasan (Albania), Bor mines, Krupanj - Veliki Majdan,<br />
Majdanpek, Kolubara (Serbia), Vares, Srebrenica (Bosnia and Herzegovina), Suplja Stena, Mojkovac (Montenegro),<br />
Sasa, Lojane, Bucim, Probistip & Dobrevo (FYR Macedonia).<br />
6
Management of trans-boundary natural resources<br />
In 2006 a rapid assessment of management problems in transboundary protected areas -<br />
with emphasis on mountain ecosystems - was facilitated by the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> Initiative. The assessment<br />
is based on country surveys prepared by local experts in Albania, Bulgaria, Bosnia<br />
and Herzegovina, Kosovo*, Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia Montenegro, and Serbia.<br />
The results of the assessment were discussed at a regional workshop “Enhancing Transboundary<br />
Biodiversity Management in South Eastern Europe” held on 13-14 June 2006 in<br />
Podgorica, Montenegro. As a result, eight priority mountain areas 2 with potential for transboundary<br />
biodiversity protection were identified by the participants representing governments,<br />
NGOs and international organizations.<br />
Requested by the Ministry of Environment and Physical Planning of the Former Yugoslav Republic<br />
of Macedonia, a feasibility study for establishing the National Park in the Macedonian<br />
side of “Shara” Mountain was conducted by UNEP and finalized in September 2006. The following<br />
field visit to the Shara Mountain resulted in the establishment of a stakeholder group at<br />
the local level and a lobby group in the Parliament of the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia.<br />
In the Prokletije region, several stakeholder events were organized by the Balkan Peace Park<br />
Project. UNEP and the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> partners supported the Balkan Peace Park NGO meeting in<br />
Podgorica, which was organized back to back with the first biodiversity workshop and gathered<br />
civil society representatives from Kosovo*, Albania and Montenegro’s Prokletije area.<br />
Technical assistance was provided to UNMIK for the preparation of an advanced draft of the<br />
National Parks Law of Kosovo*.<br />
The Pelister Statement - adopted during the SEE Intergovernmental Consultation in May<br />
2006 in the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia - recognized that a legal framework for<br />
cooperation in SEE is feasible. An early draft of this document was developed by the Balkan<br />
Foundation for Sustainable Development and the EURAC in September 2006 and circulated<br />
to the National Focal Points and other partners. The first intergovernmental meeting on the<br />
Preparation of a legal framework for the Protection and Sustainable Development of Mountain<br />
Regions in South Eastern Europe was held in November 2006 in Bolzano, Italy.<br />
On management of transboundary waters further progress was made in development of Networks<br />
among local actors of the Sava river basin. A workshop organized in Croatia in September<br />
2006 gathered 70 participants from governmental institutions, local municipalities and<br />
NGO representatives from Bosnia-Herzegovina, Croatia and Serbia as well as international<br />
organisations. The workshop focused on promotion of co-operation on water resource management<br />
and information exchange as well as collaboration between Sava Commission and<br />
the local actors, as well as among local actors in the Sava river basin. As a result of the workshop<br />
it was proposed that an informal mechanism would be established in order to intensify<br />
the flow of information and contacts between local actors.<br />
The Adriatic Sea Partnership (ASP) was launched by some of the Adriatic Sea countries in<br />
Portoroz, Slovenia in June 2006. By the end of 2006 all littoral states had joined, as well as<br />
the Mediterranean Action Plan and several international organizations and NGOs. The ASP<br />
is an umbrella framework for more effective cooperation of all Adriatic Sea countries to meet<br />
existing and prospective commitments for protection and sustainable development of the re-<br />
* Kosovo refers to the UN administered territory under UN Security Council resolution 1244<br />
2 The Sharr/Sara mountains (Kosovo*/Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia), Bjeshket a Nemuna / Prokletije<br />
Mountains (Albania/Kosovo*/ Montenegro), Sutjeska – Durmitor – Tara river valley (BiH and Montenegro) and<br />
West Stara Planina (Serbia and Bulgaria).<br />
7
gion, including those under the Mediterranean Strategy for Sustainable Development and the<br />
EU Marine Strategy.<br />
The project “Reducing the Impact of Agriculture in the Prespa Park Region”, a strong link was<br />
established between agricultural associations, extension service, Regional Directorate of Agriculture,<br />
University of Korca and Regional Council. With the new agriculture season, farmers<br />
started to create or improve vineyards and cultivate medicinal plants, and in general there is a<br />
growing interest on agriculture as a very important income providing activity. This is a result of<br />
professional training on association’s development, networking and dissemination of information,<br />
global trends on agricultural marketing, international standards, integrated pests management<br />
and environmentally friendly techniques delivered to extension service and agricultural<br />
associations. In Macedonia, the establishment of an agro-chemical laboratory and a<br />
pests and disease monitoring system, and the training of farmers to use it, has resulted in reduced<br />
use of pesticides and more efficient irrigation. This has also reduced the costs for<br />
farmers in their cultivation of the land, providing a better income source while reducing the<br />
use of unsustainable agriculture practices. The project supported the monitoring system together<br />
with the GEF Small Grants Programme, and the GEF full-size project on biodiversity<br />
management in Prespa Park will undoubtedly build further on the project results.<br />
Cross-cutting issues<br />
The Ministry of Environment of Albania formally opened the Aarhus/Public Environmental Information<br />
Centre in Tirana in December 2006. This effort was supported by OSCE and the<br />
<strong>ENVSEC</strong> partners and benefited from exchanging experiences with similar Centres in Georgia<br />
and Armenia.<br />
A draft background paper on the use of National Implementation Plans in South Eastern<br />
Europe was prepared under the Acceptance and Implementation of Multilateral Environment<br />
Agreements (AIMS) project. The 6th AIMS meeting adopted a set of conclusions regarding<br />
assistance needs in the region for implementation of Environment Agreements and the future<br />
of the AIMS network.<br />
Eastern<br />
Europe<br />
Assessment on environment and security issues and linkages in Eastern Europe<br />
One of <strong>ENVSEC</strong>’s main activities in Eastern Europe throughout 2006 has been a regional<br />
assessment of environment and security issues. Besides the analytical value that it aims to<br />
provide, the assessment process has facilitated collaboration between groups of interested<br />
agencies and organisations in Belarus, Moldova and Ukraine that are developing mechanisms<br />
for national implementation of <strong>ENVSEC</strong> project activities. Country consultations in<br />
8
May-June 2006 provided useful opportunities for exchanging views on priority problems and<br />
possible actions to address them.<br />
After being reviewed by the countries, the assessment will be finalised and launched in 2007.<br />
Concerns articulated by the countries through the process range from management of shared<br />
water basins and other natural resources (the Dniester, Pripyat, Neman-Daugava and Danube<br />
basins) to specific risks associated with pollution and waste. These include the still<br />
widespread consequences of Chernobyl, the need to address environmental aspect of security<br />
policies (in particular related to defence activities, the military legacy of the past, and the<br />
need for energy independence), environmental management in areas of instability and social<br />
stress, and overall development of capacities and institutions to address the environmentsecurity<br />
interface.<br />
The preliminary work programme formulated as one result of the assessment process includes<br />
some twenty projects to be gradually made ready for implementation as funds become<br />
available. The current project portfolio covers all elements of the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> agenda from assessment<br />
to policy development and risk mitigation, while focusing on strengthening country<br />
capacities to address various environment and security concerns in a variety of ways. All<br />
<strong>ENVSEC</strong> partner agencies have taken part in developing and furthering project ideas, including<br />
follow up discussions on the country level.<br />
On-going projects<br />
Among ongoing activities in Eastern Europe has been the Cooperation in the Dniester basin<br />
and disposal of obsolete pesticides in Moldova. Phase I of the UNECE- and OSCE-led Dniester<br />
basin cooperation project produced a comprehensive assessment of the situation in the<br />
basin. Phase II started in the late summer of 2006 and has focused on developing institutional<br />
and legal arrangements for joint project management. The aim is to develop an action programme<br />
for development of the transboundary water cooperation by early autumn 2007. At<br />
the same time, a feasibility study for improving water and environment information exchange<br />
will be completed with the help of UNEP/GRID-Arendal, building among other components on<br />
the ongoing support of NATO to water monitoring on the Dniester and Prut rivers. An important<br />
aspect of the work in the Dniester river basin is to involve the Transnistria region in the<br />
cooperation.<br />
The NATO-led Pesticide Disposal project in Moldova has achieved considerable progress.<br />
National capacities for analysing the composition of unidentified pesticides have been fully<br />
developed, and obsolete pesticide repackaging and relocation are under way. The formal inauguration<br />
of the Project took place in Chisinau on 7 November 2006 with the participation of<br />
the President of Moldova, Mr. Vladimir Voronin. The NATO Science for Peace and Security<br />
(SPS) Programme will provide additional analytical equipment that will allow the analysis of<br />
pesticide residues in agricultural products, thus contributing to food-chain security. OSCE<br />
supports the work by both soliciting additional support and resources, and looking at needs<br />
and possibilities to extend the work to the Transnistrian part of Moldova.<br />
The development of a national environmental security programme and action plan in Moldova<br />
has been supported by <strong>ENVSEC</strong> as part of the regional assessment and work programme<br />
preparation. The programme as approved by the National Security Council of Moldova covers<br />
a broad range of issues on the national and the local levels, with <strong>ENVSEC</strong> involvement aimed<br />
at ensuring linkages with its international processes and fostering inter-agency cooperation.<br />
9
Southern Caucasus<br />
During national consultations in 2004, governmental and civil society stakeholders from Armenia,<br />
Azerbaijan, and Georgia identified four major priority themes for <strong>ENVSEC</strong> work in the<br />
Southern Caucasus: environmental degradation in the frozen conflict zones, the irrational<br />
use of transboundary natural resources, rapid urbanization, and cross-cutting issues such as<br />
public awareness and environmental governance. Accordingly, <strong>ENVSEC</strong> activities in the<br />
Southern Caucasus during 2006 focused on conducting environmental assessments in frozen<br />
conflict zones, building institutional capacity for monitoring transboundary water resources,<br />
and facilitating civil society participation in environmental governance.<br />
Frozen conflict zones<br />
Despite the continued protracted conflicts in the frozen conflict zones in the Southern Caucasus,<br />
the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> Initiative achieved considerable success in assessing environment and security<br />
issues in areas witnessing frozen conflicts. During October, 2006, <strong>ENVSEC</strong> provided a<br />
core contribution to the OSCE-led Environmental Assessment Mission in fire-affected areas in<br />
and around Nagorno-Karabakh. Complemented by international experts as well as local experts<br />
from both sides of the line of contact, the Mission assessed the environmental impact of<br />
extensive wild land fires that occurred in the region during the summer period. The Mission<br />
made recommendations on how to rehabilitate the fire-affected areas and prevent the recurrence<br />
of such fires, thus presenting additional opportunities for regional cooperation and confidence<br />
building in regards to the conflict in the Nagorno-Karabakh region. In addition to the<br />
Environmental Assessment Mission, desk research began for upcoming environmental assessments,<br />
awareness raising, and capacity-building activities for environmental issues in<br />
Abkhazia and South Ossetia in 2007.<br />
Cooperation on shared rivers<br />
In 2006 <strong>ENVSEC</strong> has continued supporting the work on improving the management of transboundary<br />
waters in the Southern Caucasus. One of the challenges is to ensure that the quality<br />
and quantity of the water throughout the Kura-Aras/Araks river system meet the requirements<br />
of the communities using the river as well as ensuring optimal ecosystem functioning.<br />
In its 5 th year of monitoring activities, the NATO/OSCE South Caucasus River Monitoring project<br />
expanded its activities to include monitoring of pesticides in addition to heavy metal and<br />
radio-nuclide contaminants.<br />
10
In the framework of the UNDP/GEF project, Reducing Trans-boundary Degradation of the<br />
Kura-Aras/Araks River Basin, <strong>ENVSEC</strong> supported a complementary project to assess the<br />
condition of trans-boundary aquifers in the South Caucasus region. Moreover, <strong>ENVSEC</strong> has<br />
continued to support regional workshops gathering representatives from NGOs from the<br />
Southern Caucasus countries to share information and provide input into coordinated international<br />
water management programs throughout the region. In June, 2006, <strong>ENVSEC</strong> contributed<br />
to a meeting of the NGO Forum for Kura-Aras/Araks river basin that approved a Charter<br />
and appointed representatives to participate in the UNDP/GEF Steering Committee.<br />
In 2007, the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> Initiative will continue to build upon the existing cooperative relationships<br />
in the Southern Caucasus and catalyze both national and intergovernmental remediation<br />
activities for threats to trans-boundary natural resources. The <strong>ENVSEC</strong> partners will support<br />
the development of emergency response capacities for government officials and community<br />
groups in dealing with natural disasters such as flooding, orphaned mining sites, and<br />
defunct military-industrial complexes. In the three capital cities of Baku, Yerevan, and Tbilisi,<br />
<strong>ENVSEC</strong> will address environment and security risks resulting from the rapid urban population<br />
growth. This will be done through a series of projects to train and support governments<br />
and civil societies to address the issues of outpaced urban infrastructure capacity in terms of<br />
housing, waste management, water supply and transportation.<br />
Public awareness<br />
<strong>ENVSEC</strong> has also continued to promote public awareness of critical environmental issues<br />
through the creation of Public Environmental Information Centres (“Aarhus Centres”). In the<br />
course of 2006, new Aarhus centres were established in Georgia and Armenia and have increased<br />
public discussion and decision-making processes in environmental affairs. In addition,<br />
the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> partners facilitated a Regional Meeting of Aarhus Centres, which brought<br />
Aarhus centre managers to Georgia from existing centres in the Southern Caucasus and<br />
Central Asia to share best practices on activities and sustainability. Based on the conclusions<br />
of this meeting, <strong>ENVSEC</strong> plans additional activities in 2007 to promote the third pillar of the<br />
Aarhus Convention (access to justice) in the ongoing work of Aarhus Centres.<br />
The <strong>ENVSEC</strong> partners will continue to undertake projects to facilitate the ability of nongovernmental<br />
and media organizations to inform the public about environment and security<br />
issues. In 2007, special attention will be given to the 3 rd Pillar of the Aarhus Convention – Access<br />
to Justice – in order to promote environmental governance.<br />
In 2006, public awareness and its role in the planning and decision-making process has also<br />
been promoted through helping Armenia and Georgia in developing capacity to integrate environmental<br />
issues into the national development frameworks. The project on Strategic Environmental<br />
Assessment (SEA) has resulted in involving about 200 national stakeholders, including<br />
public, in the pilot SEA application to the Yerevan City Master Plan. In Georgia,<br />
awareness has been raised through development of national Resource Guidance for the SEA<br />
Protocol Implementation. Activities on both countries have also contributed to the interministerial<br />
dialogue required in SEA application. In terms of the results’ sustainability, in Armenia<br />
the national Strategy for Implementation of the SEA Protocol has been developed, setting<br />
the medium and short-term actions to be taken by the country.<br />
11
Central Asia<br />
In Central Asia the Initiative is expanding its initial focus from the Ferghana Valley to other<br />
priority regions such as the Eastern coast of the Caspian Sea and the Amu Darya river basin.<br />
Preliminary environment and security risk assessment reports were prepared in 2006 to pave<br />
the way for these sub-regional programmes.<br />
Ferghana Valley<br />
The current Ferghana Valley programme consists of nine regional and sub-regional projects<br />
that will be completed during 2007. Three projects were finalised in 2006: Rapid Environment<br />
and Health Risk Assessment, Support to Regional Environmental Festival in Central<br />
Asia, and Training on Investigative Journalism. Environmental and health risks at industrial<br />
hot spots have been analyzed by the Rapid Environment and Health Risk Assessment project<br />
implemented by UNEP with the assistance of OSCE and UNDP country offices and support<br />
by the Italian Ministry of Environment and Territorial Planning.<br />
In 2006 the national experts trained by the project completed the assessment of the environmental<br />
and health risks at four industrial hot spots. As a result, suggestions were made for a<br />
series of immediate measures for minimizing the identified risks as well as cleaning up the<br />
polluted areas. The prioritized sites 3 for further remedial action and support are in Kadamzhai,<br />
Kyrgyzstan and Kanibadam and Tajikistan. Both the Tajik and Kyrgyz authorities are now<br />
seeking support and resources for remediating the polluted sites. The risk assessment methodology<br />
demonstrated its applicability to the sites, although the lack of environmental monitoring<br />
data and maps impeded the implementation of risk assessment.<br />
The project on Uranium waste and tailing sites in the Ferghana Valley continues with the radiological<br />
assessment missions with participation of national and regional experts and was<br />
carried out according to the proposed work plan to the Uranium sites in Tajikistan, Uzbekistan,<br />
Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan. The Almaty-based Volkovgeologiya and Al-Farabi University<br />
provided an entire range of analytical services and delivered results from the field radiological<br />
assessment missions. The Partner Country Project Director and NATO Country Project<br />
Director participated in the International Atomic Energy Agency’s regional workshops in<br />
Tashkent and Bishkek, in March and September 2006. This resulted in better coordination of<br />
radiological protection programmes conducted by both organizations in the Central Asian region.<br />
A training on analytical methods and techniques for radioactivity measurements was<br />
completed in Almaty in July 2006 and continued with training on radon and advanced gamma<br />
3 The highest values of risks on waste including toxic effects and impacts on humans through water use and food<br />
chain were found on these sites.<br />
12
spectrometry in Ljubljana, February 2007. The training was organized by Al-Farabi University,<br />
Volkovgeologiya and Jozef Stefan Institute, and conducted by Russian, Kazakh, Polish and<br />
Slovenian experts. NATO experts in radon gas surveying and measurements participated in<br />
radiological assessment missions to Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan. Application of nuclear track<br />
detectors for radon measurements, primarily in the indoor environment in places suspected of<br />
the use of tailing/waste rock materials for construction purposes was made. The preliminary<br />
radon levels in the indoor environment showed relatively low values. Milestones for the future<br />
are completion of radiological assessment missions to the remaining sites in Kazakhstan and<br />
Uzbekistan as well as repeated assessment of the sites in Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan.<br />
In Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan an alternative method suitable for a Community Based Disaster<br />
Management approach to the production of hazard, risk, and vulnerability assessments and<br />
mapping was developed by the Natural disaster preparedness in high-risk communities project<br />
team. The new methodology will replace outdated technical solutions and promote the<br />
use of assessments and maps in risk, vulnerability and capacity analysis. At the same time,<br />
the official procedures and methodology for updating the risk assessments and maps will be<br />
revised by the Information Management and Analytical Centres in Ministries of Emergency<br />
Situations. Besides cooperation with the government agencies, the project built cooperation<br />
with the Assessment and Mapping team of the OSCE project on “Risk analysis, monitoring<br />
and awareness raising on radioactivity in Sugd” in Tajikistan.<br />
Community-level training work in risk, vulnerability and local capacity assessment enables the<br />
participants to do non-scientific assessments of risks of any given area and offers also suggestions<br />
on risk mitigation measures. Three hundred inhabitants of the affected communities<br />
have gained significant knowledge in disaster and risk assessment through training components<br />
such as games, disaster story exchange, discussions, observations, monitoring as well<br />
as working group discussions on disaster prevention, preparedness and respond.<br />
In Kyrgyzstan, six mitigation projects have been started in the pilot communities. They include<br />
constructing protective dams, planting trees against erosion, strengthening houses against<br />
earthquakes and winds, creating evacuation routes, cleaning aqueducts etc. In Tajikistan, as<br />
a result of the training for local communities and local governments, four specific mitigation<br />
projects were developed in Asht, Kanibodom and Isfara Districts. Information tools such as<br />
booklets were developed jointly with NGOs and the Oblast Departments for Emergency Situations<br />
and distributed in local languages for people living in risk areas. The project has supported<br />
also information exchange and cooperation between high-risk districts of Ferghana<br />
Valley by organizing a visit to the Crisis Management Centre in Bishkek and providing on-thejob<br />
training. Information about the project and its activities has been shared also through<br />
websites (www.untj.org and www.caresd.net).<br />
Other capacity building activities in the Ferghana Valley included training on Environmental<br />
issues in Early warning systems on methodology and indicator framework developed specifically<br />
for the Ferghana Valley. In Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan the project on Environmental<br />
Impact Assessment in a Transboundary Context started with the public hearings on the case<br />
of the planned gold and copper mine exploration on the Kyrgyz side of the border. In 2006 the<br />
Kyrgyz authorities submitted a notification, and the exchange of information between the two<br />
Governments and the company is well under way.<br />
Public awareness<br />
<strong>ENVSEC</strong> work in the field of public awareness continued in 2006 through the training of Kazakhstan<br />
journalists in Almaty and a study visit of the Regional festivals on environmental<br />
journalism to Khanty-Mansyisk, Russia. As a result of these trainings, the quality of local envi-<br />
13
onmental media products has improved in many ways; there is an increase in broadcast and<br />
newspaper media and other coverage of global, regional and local environmental issues; information<br />
exchange between countries of the region has been fostered; working relations between<br />
environmental NGOs, public authorities, national broadcasters, and newspaper publishers<br />
have become stronger, with increased media outreach and improved impact of environmental<br />
mass media on public awareness and understanding of environmental issues.<br />
Training on investigative journalism for journalists from local and regional Kazakhstan newspapers<br />
was organised in Almaty in November 2006. Facilitated by UNEP and supported by<br />
OSCE and UNDP, the training resulted in both a better understanding of water-environmentsecurity<br />
interactions by the participating media and in some twenty publications in the local<br />
and Almaty press.<br />
Among the 2006 outcomes on raising public awareness is the popular on-line ‘State of the<br />
Environment’ report for four provinces of the Ferghana Valley in Djalal-Abad, Batken and Osh<br />
Oblasts Kyrgyzstan and Sugd Oblast of Tajikistan. UNEP facilitated the cooperative production<br />
of these on-line reports, which have contributed to the increased transparency of environmental<br />
information, deepened regional cooperation and a new ground for further in-depth<br />
work. Promotion of public participation in environmental decision-making, particularly regarding<br />
the threats identified in <strong>ENVSEC</strong> assessments, has been continued by the Aarhus Public<br />
Information Centres in Osh and Khudjand with the support of the OSCE.<br />
Further priorities for the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> work in 2008-2010 in the Ferghana Valley will be defined<br />
by the participating countries and the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> partners during 2007.<br />
Amu-Darya River Basin<br />
In 2006, the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> partners started consultations on environment and security risks in the<br />
Amu-Darya river basin. The <strong>ENVSEC</strong> Initiative will undertake a detailed assessment of water<br />
management and quality situation in the upper Amu-Darya river and identify opportunities for<br />
strengthening basin-wide cooperation around common issues. The key goal for the future development<br />
of the Amu-Darya basin states is a more efficient use of shared water resources<br />
that are increasingly under pressure by rising demands for electrical power generation and<br />
irrigation and by potential impacts of climate change.<br />
The first Tajikistan - Afghanistan consultations held in Dushanbe in July 2006 identified a<br />
range of issues that need to be addressed. These include the lack of river basin resource<br />
management frameworks and poor management practices, trans-boundary water pollution,<br />
loss of and threats to shared nature areas, frequent natural disasters and an overall need to<br />
increase the monitoring and information exchange capacities. The main activities related to<br />
the assessment process of the Amu-Darya river basin are expected to kick off during the first<br />
quarter of 2007.<br />
Eastern Caspian Programme for Kazakhstan and Turkmenistan<br />
The main objective of the Eastern Caspian programme of the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> Initiative is to assess<br />
the environment and security situation in the Atyrau and Aktau oblasts of Kazakhstan and<br />
Balkan Velayat of Turkmenistan and develop a programme of work towards solution of priority<br />
problems. Consultations and field visits organized by the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> partners in Ashgabad and<br />
Turkmenbashi, Turkmenistan and Aktau, Kazakhstan in April 2006 came up with priorities related<br />
to the currently rapidly developing oil and gas sectors in the coastal areas and its impact<br />
on the local population and their lively hoods. Classical transboundary environmental issues,<br />
as identified by <strong>ENVSEC</strong> in the Ferghana Valley programme, seem to be almost absent in the<br />
14
East Caspian. Regional consultations and a launch of assessment the report are scheduled<br />
for the first half of 2007. In development of follow-up activities the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> partners will<br />
closely collaborate with the Caspian Convention and the Caspian Environmental Programme.<br />
In Kazakhstan the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> partners are assisting the Government of Kazakhstan in eliminating<br />
approximately 1,400 tons of Liquid Rocket Fuel Components, commonly referred as Mélange,<br />
by ensuring recycling or disposing of Mélange in an environmentally sound manner.<br />
After the completion of the Scoping study in Kazakhstan, an international tender process was<br />
launched to select a company that could dispose of Mélange stocks in an environmentally<br />
sound and cost effective manner. A pre-tender meeting was organized in Almaty and was attended<br />
by potential bidders from Germany, France, Russia, Poland and Kazakhstan. As part<br />
of the pre-tender meeting the participants visited two sites of Mélange storage - Saryozek and<br />
Kapchagay. At the same time, information meetings were organized in Vienna to request donor<br />
support with the participation of several OSCE delegations. As a result of the tender, a<br />
qualified company was selected to provide the services related to the elimination of Kazakhstan’s<br />
Mélange. Ultimately, the project seeks to curb environmental and safety threats posed<br />
by large quantities of Mélange stored in the vicinity of populated areas, thereby improving the<br />
environmental and security status in the country and, in particular, the concerned areas.<br />
The <strong>ENVSEC</strong> activities in Central Asia are closely coordinated with the partners’ other projects<br />
in the region, such as the ‘Chu-Talas River Commission’ in which UNECE and OSCE<br />
have been working together with the UN Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the<br />
Pacific. The project "Support for the creation of a transboundary water commission on Chu<br />
and Talas Rivers between Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan" (http://www.talaschu.org/) was concluded<br />
successfully in July 2006 with the inauguration of the bilateral commission. The Chu-<br />
Talas Commission addresses a common problem in Central Asia, the issue of water infrastructure<br />
that is situated in one country but is used by several countries. A new project to<br />
broaden the water cooperation between the two countries is presently discussed with the bilateral<br />
Commission. Another example of work implemented in cooperation with <strong>ENVSEC</strong> in<br />
Central Asia is the capacity building and sub-regional cooperation project on Dam Safety. It<br />
achieved three major outcomes in 2006: a draft law on safety of water facilities; a draft regional<br />
treaty 4 on hydro-technical installations safety in Central Asia; and a publication on dam<br />
safety in Central Asia giving an account of the situation in Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan,<br />
Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan as well as an updated list of major dams. The work will be continued<br />
in 2007 with negotiations on the regional treaty as well as development of national legislation<br />
on dam safety. (http://www.unece.org/env/water/damsafety.htm)<br />
4 The Proposed Regional Treaty would regulate the procedure of informing the countries on the safety situation of<br />
Interstate Significant Dams, and also deal with other related types of cooperation between the countries.<br />
15
Cross-regional activities<br />
Assistance to EECCA 5 and South Eastern European countries in implementing the Convention<br />
on the Transboundary Effects of Industrial Accidents (TEIA)<br />
A series of joint Transboundary Effects of Industrial Accidents-<strong>ENVSEC</strong> missions to selected<br />
signatory countries (Bulgaria, Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, Belarus, Moldova,<br />
Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan) was undertaken by expert teams comprising i.e. representatives of<br />
UNECE, UNEP and REC. The missions and comprehensive in-country discussions have<br />
helped to assess and clarify the status of industrial activities with potential transboundary environmental<br />
impact, and country capacities to address the potential risks. Findings from the<br />
assessment missions have been presented at the TEIA Conference of the Parties in Rome in<br />
November 2006, and will be followed by development specific capacity-building needs. The<br />
results will be presented in a visual format at the 2007 Environment for Europe conference in<br />
Belgrade.<br />
Environmental Diplomacy - Environment and Security Module<br />
In 2006 the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> partners started collaboration with the University of Peace on giving<br />
training on environment and security issues as a part of the Geneva Environmental Diplomacy<br />
Program 6 sponsored by Switzerland and developed by the University of Geneva, UNEP<br />
and UNITAR. The ‘Environment and Security’ Module gave the students an analysis of the<br />
relationship between environmental security and peace; the security implications of environmental<br />
changes; environmental stress and conflict; and the need for micro- and mesodiplomacy<br />
in areas such as South Eastern Europe and international river basins. The training<br />
was attended by present and future diplomats, policy and decision makers in governments,<br />
regional intergovernmental bodies, local authorities, the private sector, NGOs, and UN bodies<br />
(including participants from the Balkans and the Eastern Europe, Caucasus and Central Asia<br />
regions). 20 participants from countries with economies in transition were offered a scholarship<br />
for the course. The ‘Environment and Security’ Module received very positive feedback<br />
and as a result of an end-of-course evaluation it got a satisfaction rate 0.92, (the value of the<br />
overall satisfaction indicator was situated between 0-1; 1 indicated a high degree of satisfaction<br />
and inversely 0 meant that students were expressing dissatisfaction.), which was above<br />
the average of 0.9. Eight of the total 30 participants chose to write their final thesis of the Diplomacy<br />
course about Environment and Security related topic.<br />
5 Eastern Europe, the Caucasus and Central Asia<br />
6 The Environmental Diplomacy Program teaches the skills necessary to participate in global negotiations in<br />
environment, sustainable development and related fields. It covers the scientific understanding, political sensitivity<br />
and practical negotiating techniques relevant to the development and implementation of legal instruments and<br />
other types of agreements. In 2006 the course consisted of 10 different modules.<br />
16
NEWS FROM THE <strong>ENVSEC</strong> SECRETARIAT<br />
Advisory Board meeting: continued support and recommendations for future work<br />
At the end of October 2006, the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> Initiative organized its bi-annual Management<br />
Board meeting as well as its annual Advisory Board 7 meeting. At the Management Board<br />
meeting the members of the Secretariat were re-elected, Ben Slay from UNDP was appointed<br />
as the Chairman of the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> Management Board in 2007 and an agreement was reached<br />
on the new Memorandum of Understanding of the expanded partnership. The Advisory Board<br />
2006 gathered representatives from donor and recipient countries, academia and international<br />
organizations. The meeting had the objectives to review the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> process from a<br />
thematic as well as an institutional perspective, and receive recommendations from the participants<br />
on the way forward. The thematic aspects were reviewed and discussed in the different<br />
regional contexts. The institutional aspects of <strong>ENVSEC</strong> were reviewed in light of the<br />
Initiative’s new institutional set-up implemented during 2006, as well as results of the midterm<br />
independent evaluation requested by the Canadian International Development Agency.<br />
Recommendations were received by participants with regard to results based management<br />
and reporting; project prioritization and fundraising strategies; synergies with other constituencies<br />
as well as improvement of communication and visibility.<br />
Mid-term Assessment of the Partnership<br />
As mentioned above, a mid-term evaluation for 2004-2006 was conducted by an independent<br />
consultant. The assessment focused mainly on efficiency of the partnership approach. Results<br />
of the assessment were generally positive with the final report concluding that “<strong>ENVSEC</strong><br />
is a rare upshot of the implementation of the February 2005 Paris Declaration with regard to<br />
donor harmonization and local ownership. The Initiative follows these principles, and it provides<br />
a window for National Focal Points and other stakeholders to shape the program and<br />
ensure its responsiveness to local priorities in coordinated fashion.” The main recommendations<br />
for the further development of the Initiative included: strengthening the strategic management;<br />
sharpening the definition of the scope and strategic and regional objectives of the<br />
Initiative; building synergies and ensuring coherence with other donor initiatives at the country<br />
and sub-region level; developing further the Results-Based Management and reporting as<br />
well as improving the visibility of achievements. Many of the recommendations have already<br />
been addressed by the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> partners and plans have been made to meet majority of the<br />
recommendations by the end of 2007.<br />
Support to the Environment for Europe process<br />
The <strong>ENVSEC</strong> Initiative takes part in the relevant policy processes such as the Environment<br />
for Europe process (EfE) in which the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> Initiative has been involved since its beginning.<br />
In 2006 UNEP, on behalf of the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> partners, has helped the participating countries<br />
in preparing a background paper on “the need to recognize and reinforce the work on<br />
assessing and addressing environmental and security risks in the pan-European region” to<br />
facilitate the ministers’ discussions at the EfE Ministerial Conference in Belgrade in 2007.<br />
<strong>ENVSEC</strong> is also supporting preparation of the draft elements of South Eastern Europe Mountain<br />
Convention.<br />
7 An ad-hoc group comprised of donors, national focal points from recipient countries, environment and security<br />
experts and other stakeholders providing scientific and policy advice for the Initiative.<br />
17
ANNEX 1: Main meetings attended and organized in 2006<br />
When / Where What<br />
12 February The Radioactivity Environment Security Central Asia<br />
(RESCA) kick-off meeting<br />
13 February, Bishkek, Kyr- 3rd Regional Meeting of the Ferghana Valley Oblast Envigyzstanronmental<br />
Committees<br />
14 February, Bishkek, Kyr- Regional workshop on Natural disasters preparedness in<br />
gyzstan<br />
Ferghana Valley<br />
20-21 February, Kosovo* South Eastern Europe: Mission to Kosovo*<br />
14-15 March, Azerbaijan Caucasus Regional Desk Officer’s country visit: Azerbaijan<br />
3-5 April, Armenia and Geor- Caucasus Regional Desk Officer’s country visits: Georgia<br />
gia<br />
and Armenia<br />
6-7 April, Sisak, Croatia Sava river basin project workshop in Croatia<br />
19-26 April, Minsk – Kyiv, Chernobyl Commemoration events in Belarus and Ukraine<br />
Ukraine and Belarus<br />
20th Anniversary of the Chernobyl disaster<br />
12-13 May, National Park Pe- Cooperation for the Protection and Sustainable Developlister,<br />
Former Yugoslav Rement of Mountainous Regions in South Eastern Europe,<br />
public of Macedonia<br />
Intergovernmental consultation<br />
22-24 May, in Prague,Czech<br />
Republic.<br />
OSCE Economic Forum<br />
25-26 May, Chisinau,<br />
Moldova<br />
Eastern Europe assessment, country consultations<br />
29-30 May, Kyiv, Ukraine Eastern Europe assessment, country consultations<br />
1-2 June, Minsk, Belarus Eastern Europe assessment, country consultations<br />
13-14 June, Podgorica, Mon- Workshop on Enhancing Transboundary Biodiversity<br />
tenegro<br />
Management in South Eastern Europe<br />
11-12 July, Dushanbe, Tajiki- 4th Regional Meeting of the Oblast Environmental Comstanmittees<br />
in Ferghana Valley<br />
12-13 July, Dushanbe, Tajiki- Meeting on environmental cooperation<br />
stan<br />
Between Tajikistan and Afghanistan<br />
Environmental Authorities<br />
26 July, Bishkek, Kyrgyzstan Inauguration of the Chu-Talas water commission<br />
10-11 August, Kiev, Ukraine Meetings in the Dniester II-project (“Action Programme to<br />
improve transboundary cooperation and sustainable<br />
management of the Dniester River”)<br />
26 August -10 September, Training Course in Environmental Diplomacy<br />
Geneva, Switzerland<br />
11-12 September, Donja Regional Workshop "Network Development of Local Ac-<br />
Stubica, Croatia<br />
18-22 September, Tbilisi,<br />
Georgia<br />
22-23 September, Odessa,<br />
Ukraine<br />
tors in the Sava River Basin"<br />
Workshop on Capacity Building for Information Exchange<br />
on Forest Policies in Caucasus Region, orgnized by FAO,<br />
Georgian Ministry of Environment Protection and Natural<br />
Resources, and UNECE - Trade and Timber<br />
Meetings in the Dniester II-project (“Action Programme<br />
to improve transboundary cooperation and sustainable<br />
management of the Dniester River”)<br />
18
26-27 September, Tbilisi,<br />
Georgia<br />
Aarhus Convention meeting in Caucasus<br />
28-29 September, Belgrade, Acceptance and Implementation of Multilateral Environ-<br />
Serbia<br />
ment Agreements<br />
2-3 October, Helsinki, Finland Conference on Policy Coherence for Development ‘Call for<br />
Coherence’, working group on Security and Development<br />
3-13 October, Fire affected OSCE-led Environmental Assessment Mission to wildland<br />
territories in and around the fire affected territories in and around the Nagorno-<br />
Nagorno-Karabakh region Karabakh region.<br />
5-6 October, Osh, Kyrgyzstan Training on environmental indicators for social conflict for<br />
monitors working for NGOs in the Ferghana Valley on<br />
monitoring of social conflict indicators.<br />
6 October, Bishkek, Kyr- National meeting on Environment and Security Initiative,<br />
gyzstan<br />
discussion of year 2006 results and prospects for 2007<br />
26 October, Brussels, Bel- Conference on Greening Foreign and Security Policy: The<br />
gium<br />
Role of Europe, working group meeting on Preventing<br />
Conflict<br />
3-4 November, Bolzano, Italy Intergovernmental Meeting on the Preparation of the<br />
South Eastern Europe Mountain Convention<br />
16-17 November, the Hague, Institute for Environmental Security – Environmental Secu-<br />
Netherlands<br />
rity for Poverty Alleviation and UNEP-<strong>ENVSEC</strong> joint workshop<br />
on Environmental Security Methodologies<br />
20-25 November, Almaty, Ka- Media training on water-environment-security issues for<br />
zakhstan<br />
local and regional press journalists in Kazakhstan<br />
2 December, Dushanbe, Taji- National meeting on environment and security Initiative,<br />
kistan<br />
discussion of year 2006 results and prospects for 2007<br />
6-7 December, Brussels, Bel- Conference on Greening Foreign and Security Policy: The<br />
gium<br />
Role of Europe, working group meeting on Preventing<br />
Conflict<br />
8 December, Brussels, Bel- Preparatory meeting for <strong>ENVSEC</strong> projects within NATO<br />
gium<br />
‘Science for Peace and Security’ programme<br />
11 December, Minsk, Belarus NATO / Lithuania-facilitated round table on ecology and<br />
security in Belarus - Russia - Ukraine<br />
* Kosovo refers to the UN administered territory under UN Security Council resolution 1244<br />
19
ANNEX 2: <strong>ENVSEC</strong> Projects<br />
1. Ongoing and planned projects as of January 2007<br />
Project<br />
and<br />
Lead organisation<br />
SOUTH-EASTERN EUROPE<br />
Improving regional cooperation<br />
for risk management<br />
from pollution hotspots<br />
in South Eastern Europe<br />
UNEP<br />
Regional co-operation<br />
Demonstration project I: Feasibility<br />
Study for Lojane Mine<br />
Cleaning and Closure<br />
UNDP<br />
Region/Countries Description Status/<br />
Duration<br />
Albania, Bosnia and<br />
Herzegovina, Bulgaria,<br />
Croatia, the<br />
Former Yugoslav Republic<br />
of Macedonia,<br />
Romania, Serbia &<br />
Montenegro, Kos-<br />
ovo*, Moldova (will be<br />
involved as an in-kind<br />
contribution by<br />
<strong>ENVSEC</strong> Eastern<br />
Europe)<br />
Former Yugoslav Republic<br />
of Macedonia<br />
Aiming to reduce trans-boundary environmental and human safety risks<br />
posed by sub-standard mining operations in the SEE region, by providing<br />
a targeted in-depth assessment of trans-boundary environment and<br />
health risks resulting from mining designed for decision-makers and mining<br />
experts at the regional level; identifying potential “hot spots”; recommending<br />
priority measures of mitigation and for risk management. The<br />
project will develop policy and technical options suitable for the region<br />
and will take forward demonstration and pilot activities, in particular focusing<br />
on innovative, local and cost-efficient risk reduction and management<br />
measures.<br />
Carry out a comprehensive environmental investigation, and based on<br />
that to recommend a short-term risk reduction and long-term remediation<br />
and environmental protection measures for the Lojane mine. The proper<br />
conservation of the Mine will prevent further contamination of the area<br />
and the impact on the neighbouring country. It will also have a positive<br />
impact on the relations between the national/local governments and the<br />
local citizens from the affected area that is still declared as a crisis region.<br />
20<br />
January 2006 -<br />
Dec. 2008<br />
Funding<br />
Fully funded<br />
November.2005 Fully funded<br />
/May 2007
Regional co-operation<br />
Demonstration project II<br />
Feasibility study for Trepca<br />
complex: Support to Industrial<br />
“Hot Spot“ Remediation<br />
(SIHR) in Kosovo*:<br />
UNDP<br />
Regional co-operation<br />
Demonstration project III<br />
(Bor Project)<br />
UNDP<br />
Improving regional cooperation<br />
for the transboundary<br />
management of shared natu-<br />
ral resources in South Eastern<br />
Europe<br />
UNEP<br />
Capacity Building on Legal<br />
Instruments for the Protection<br />
Mountain regions in South<br />
Eastern Europe<br />
UNEP<br />
Reducing the impact of agriculture<br />
in the Prespa Park<br />
Region<br />
UNDP<br />
Kosovo* Environmental Assessment and Programme Development for Stan<br />
Trg/Stanterg and Artaana/Novo Brdo Mines. To set the foundation for a<br />
larger remediation programme by conducting a comprehensive assessment<br />
to determine the impact of mine production and processing on the<br />
environment from two mine sites.<br />
21<br />
Aug 2006-<br />
May.2007<br />
Serbia The project focus is to prepare a feasibility study of selected sites in the Under devel-<br />
Bor mine complex in order to determine the requirements of environmental<br />
remediation of pollution sources to water; and by bringing in the<br />
socio-political perspective into the study. It will thereby result in the outcome<br />
of recommendations taking a community participatory approach to<br />
remediation of environmental hot spots, which if no measures are taken,<br />
could constitute a trigger for national or trans-national conflicts.<br />
opment<br />
Albania, Bosnia and Assessment of the state of trans-boundary ecosystems, main threats<br />
Herzegovina, Bul- and current management practices; carry out feasibility study and pargaria,<br />
Croatia, the ticipative Peace Park Strategy, support ongoing initiatives of trans-<br />
Former Yugoslav Reboundary cooperation of biodiversity and protected areas management,<br />
public of Macedonia, and facilitate collaborative and consultative processes; support the es-<br />
Montenegro, Romatablishment of Networks of Protected Areas and build capacity on senia<br />
Serbia, Kosovo* lected topics at the sub-regional level.<br />
and the Former<br />
Yugoslav Republic of<br />
Macedonia<br />
Albania, Bosnia and<br />
Herzegovina, the<br />
Former Yugoslav Republic<br />
of Macedonia,<br />
Montenegro, Serbia,<br />
Kosovo*, Bulgaria<br />
and Greece<br />
The Former Yugoslav<br />
Republic of Macedonia,<br />
Albania<br />
Jan. 2006/ December<br />
2008<br />
Fully funded<br />
Not funded<br />
Fully funded<br />
Establishment of a functioning framework for co-operation between na- December Partly funded<br />
tional authorities that are facing similar problems in the field of protection 2005and<br />
sustainable development of the mountain regions in South Eastern<br />
Europe. The project aims at identifying needs and issues of regional cooperation<br />
for the protection of mountain areas of the South Eastern<br />
Europe region as well as available instruments of and possible options<br />
for strengthening the framework for cooperation between stakeholders.<br />
December 2006<br />
Promote integrated ecosystem management of the Trans-boundary<br />
Prespa Park by working with farmers groups and associations to minimize<br />
the impact of intensive agricultural production on the biodiversity,<br />
water quality and ecosystem function in the Prespa Region.<br />
Feb 2005/ Jun.<br />
2006<br />
Fully funded
Sustainable Management of<br />
the International Waters -<br />
Prespa Lake<br />
NATO/PDD/CP981116<br />
Adriatic Sea Partnership<br />
REC<br />
Transboundary Environmental<br />
Governance in SEE (TEGS)<br />
REC<br />
Acceptance and Implementation<br />
of Multilateral Environment<br />
Agreements in SEE<br />
(AIMS)<br />
REC<br />
Bi-/multilateral arrangements<br />
for prevention of transboundary<br />
environmental conflicts:<br />
the Timok River<br />
REC<br />
Albania, Greece and The aim is to understand the mechanisms behind the water loss in the Feb 2006/<br />
The Former Yugoslav Prespa Lake and to develop a model for the prediction of the effects of Feb 2009<br />
Republic of Mace- changes in quantity and quality of the lake's water. An automatic metedoniaorological<br />
station, water level recorder, equipment for the tracer injection<br />
experiment will be purchased and installed and local scientists will be<br />
trained. Recommendations for sustainable development will be presented<br />
to end-users at a final workshop.<br />
Albania, Bosnia and To facilitate project preparation and implementation aimed at protection February 2006<br />
Herzegovina, Croatia, and sustainable development of the Adriatic Sea region, through a com- – December<br />
Montenegro, prehensive umbrella partnership and a platform for joint action based on 2008<br />
(Slovenia, Italy) commitments by littoral states through appropriate institutional arrangements.<br />
Albania, Bosnia and<br />
Herzegovina, Croatia,<br />
the Former Yugoslav<br />
Republic of Macedonia,<br />
Montenegro,<br />
Serbia, Kosovo*<br />
Albania, Bosnia and<br />
Herzegovina,<br />
Bulgaria, Croatia, the<br />
Former Yugoslav<br />
Republic of<br />
Macedonia,<br />
Montenegro,<br />
Romania, Serbia<br />
To build regional capacity to develop recommendations for sustainable<br />
mining operations and site remediation and improve governance over<br />
foreign direct investment in hazardous activities by applying the<br />
Governance Principles for FDI in Hazardous Activities (GPs) in pilot<br />
projects.<br />
22<br />
April 2006 –<br />
March 2007<br />
Fully funded<br />
Partly funded<br />
Partly funded<br />
Contribute to improved implementation of Multilateral Environment<br />
Agreements (MEA) in SEE through the regional AIMS Network, sharing<br />
experiences to build up awareness of problems and solutions, conduct<br />
regional activities on practical implementation, in particular with refer-<br />
2001 - 2007 Partly funded<br />
ence to the use of National Implementation Plans (NIPs) and the UNECE<br />
and UNEP Guidelines.<br />
Bulgaria, Serbia The project aims to support development of agreements and other arrangements<br />
for increased cooperation on common environmental problems<br />
and management of shared natural resources, using recent examples<br />
from the wider region as models. The focus is on the Timok River<br />
between Bulgaria and Serbia & Montenegro.<br />
April 2007 – Partly funded<br />
December 2008
Walk on the Wild Side of Life: South Eastern Euro-<br />
Border Police explore the joint pean countries<br />
natural heritage of the Green<br />
Belt<br />
UNEP<br />
Bridging the Gaps: Enhancing<br />
Implementation of Multilateral<br />
Environmental Agreements in<br />
the Balkans<br />
UNEP<br />
EASTERN EUROPE<br />
Countries Albania,<br />
Bosnia Herzegovina,<br />
Former Yugoslav Republic<br />
of Macedonia,<br />
Serbia, Montenegro,<br />
Croatia, Kosovo*<br />
<strong>ENVSEC</strong> assessment of envi- Belarus, Ukraine and<br />
ronment and security issues in Moldova<br />
Belarus, Ukraine and Moldova<br />
UNEP<br />
Transboundary cooperation<br />
and sustainable management<br />
of the Dniester river<br />
OSCE, UNECE, UNEP<br />
Real time monitoring and decision<br />
support systems for<br />
international rivers: application<br />
to the Nistru and Prut rivers<br />
NATO/PDD/CP971918<br />
This project concept aims to improve transboundary biodiversity conservation<br />
in border areas by creating synergy through cooperation with<br />
stakeholders and multipliers in the military sector. The integration of the<br />
military sector in data collection and nature conservation gives way to a<br />
whole range of mutual benefits, be it in improving the image of stakeholders,<br />
joint use of infrastructure or the evaluation of observation data<br />
for public relations.<br />
23<br />
2007-2008 Not funded<br />
Building and improving national capacities for the development and im- 2006-2007 Not funded<br />
plementation of legislation for an enhanced and more effective national<br />
implementation of key global and regional Multilateral Environment<br />
Agreements (MEA), as well as integrating the EU environmental acquis –<br />
and streamlining reporting and information management systems in the<br />
Balkan region. The Project will significantly improve national capacities<br />
for the implementation of MEAs and the related EU acquis and that the<br />
outcomes will be replicated across the region.<br />
Based on the results of national consultations and desk work, an<br />
<strong>ENVSEC</strong> assessment report and work programme will be developed for<br />
Belarus, Ukraine and Moldova. The programme will include further indepth<br />
assessment and monitoring of issues at specific hot spots as well<br />
as direct interventions in terms capacity building and support to policy<br />
development.<br />
Ukraine and Moldova The objective of the project is to develop an Action Programme to im-<br />
Ukraine, Moldova,<br />
Romania<br />
Ongoing Fully funded<br />
Ongoing Fully funded<br />
prove the cooperative management of water and related resources of the<br />
Dniester River Basin. The target group for the project is authorities responsible<br />
for water management in Ukraine, Moldova and if possible the<br />
Transnistria region. The activities include drafting, negotiating and agreeing<br />
on Action Programme including a revised legal framework for the<br />
cooperation.<br />
The overall aim of this project is to enhance the development of a common<br />
framework for data exchange required for sustainable management<br />
of the rivers Prut and Nistru shared by Moldova, Romania, and Ukraine.<br />
With NATO support, four automatic water-monitoring stations were purchased<br />
and put into operation at the two rivers (sites Tudora, Sireuti,<br />
Naslavcea and Valea Mare.)<br />
Ongoing Fully funded
Harmonisation of seismic risk<br />
prevention<br />
NATO/PDD/CP980468<br />
Mitigating risks from stocks of<br />
obsolete pesticides<br />
in transboundary basins and<br />
near-border areas<br />
NATO – OSCE (Moldova)<br />
Cooperative flow and flood<br />
management in the upper<br />
Pripyat / Dnieper – Buh canal<br />
basin<br />
OSCE, UNEP, UNECE<br />
Cross-border assessment and<br />
management plan for the<br />
Drisviaty / Druksiai lake basin<br />
UNEP<br />
Joint research related to activities<br />
with transboundary<br />
impact in the Danube delta<br />
UNECE<br />
Moldova, Romania,<br />
Ukraine<br />
Moldova, Belarus,<br />
Ukraine<br />
The risk hazard maps of Moldova, Romania and Bulgaria will be harmo- Nov 2004/<br />
nised in order to allow realistic and consistent risk assessment of the Sep 2008<br />
seismic effects generated by the Vrancea zone. The project will deliver a<br />
joint hazard map in Eurocode 8 format.<br />
24<br />
Fully funded<br />
To assist the Moldovan government with the destruction of a stockpile of Ongoing Partly funded<br />
Pesticides and Hazardous Chemicals amounting 3500 tonnes. The project<br />
is implemented in three phases which will all be supported by<br />
<strong>ENVSEC</strong>: I. Repacking and Centralisation, II. Chemical Analysis<br />
III. Destruction. Phase II, the establishment of a laboratory and training<br />
of local experts, is being implemented by NATO. Phase I and III will be<br />
implemented jointly by NATO/NAMSA and OSCE through Trust Funds<br />
projects. NATO will also help investigate pesticide-related risks, needs<br />
and disposal options in selected near-border regions of Ukraine and Belarus.<br />
Belarus, Ukraine The project will a feasibility study to explore and detail needs and realistic<br />
options of cooperative flow management in the Ukrainian part of the<br />
Pripyat basin to improve flood control on both sides of the border, maintain<br />
navigational levels in the Dnieper – Buh canal, and support coordinated<br />
use of shared water resources in the basin. Activities will be<br />
closely coordinated with the starting EU-supported Trans-Boundary<br />
River Basin Management project, Phase II.<br />
Belarus, Lithuania,<br />
Latvia<br />
Ukraine, Romania,<br />
Moldova<br />
The project will start the preparation of an integrated basin management<br />
plan as well as environmental information management and exchange<br />
system for the Druksiai / Drisviaty lake catchment basin as building<br />
blocks for a transboundary resource management system (the lake is<br />
cooling reservoir for the Ignalina nuclear power station; it drains into the<br />
Daugava / Zakh. Dzvina river)<br />
2007-2009 Not funded<br />
2007-2009 Not funded<br />
The project will promote and strengthen information sharing and coop- 2007-2009 Not funded<br />
eration between the countries regarding the construction of the Bystroe<br />
canal and other projects with possible transboundary impact. The project<br />
is a follow-up to the work by the Inquiry Commission under the UNECE<br />
Convention on Environmental Impact Assessment in a Transboundary<br />
Context.
Development of capacities for<br />
application of the UNECE<br />
Espoo Convention on<br />
Environmental Impact Assessment<br />
in a Transboundary<br />
Context<br />
UNECE<br />
Mapping of radioactive pollution<br />
and flows of transuranic<br />
elements<br />
around the Chernobyl nuclear<br />
power plant<br />
NATO<br />
Strengthening national and Moldova, Ukraine,<br />
local capacities to assess and Romania<br />
prevent risks from transboundary<br />
accidents<br />
UNEP, UNECE<br />
Assessing environmental implications<br />
of energy development<br />
policies and trends<br />
UNEP, UNDP, OSEC,<br />
UNECE, REC<br />
Belarus, Ukraine Pilot project to clarify procedures and mechanisms and strengthen capacities<br />
in Belarus in relation to the implementation of the UNECE Convention<br />
on Environmental Impact Assessment in a Transboundary Context.<br />
The project will address the development of a chalk deposit at the<br />
Ukrainian border in the south-west of Belarus (Polesie region).<br />
Belarus, Ukraine The project will aim at obtaining comprehensive up-to-date information<br />
about current and projected radioactive contamination of the territory<br />
surrounding the Chernobyl nuclear power plant; to estimate radioecological<br />
consequences of the redistribution of radionuclides to the territory<br />
of Belarus and Ukraine as a result of extreme natural phenomena,<br />
fires and other transport mechanisms.<br />
Belarus, Moldova,<br />
Ukraine<br />
25<br />
2007-2009 Not funded<br />
2007-2009 Not funded<br />
The project will help assess and manage risks associated with the construction<br />
of an oil terminal and refinery at Giurgiulesti (Moldova) by training<br />
and increasing capacities of environmental authorities and the industry.<br />
Local activities will be preceded by a policy workshop for national<br />
authorities of the neighbouring countries. The project is linked to the capacity-building<br />
programme of the UNECE Convention on the Convention<br />
on the Transboundary Effects of Industrial Accidents.<br />
2007-2009 Not funded<br />
The project will promote consideration of environmental issues in energy<br />
related strategic decision-making, in particular to provide recommendation<br />
for optimization of governmental energy plans in Belarus and<br />
Ukraine and develop for environmental assessment of energy programmes<br />
and policies. On the regional level the project will analyse and<br />
visualise environmental implications of the region’s response to energy<br />
security challenges under current trends and various development scenarios.<br />
2007-2009 Not funded
Training, awareness raising<br />
and institutional support to<br />
address environmental effects<br />
of defence activities<br />
OSCE, NATO, UNEP, REC<br />
Disposal of stocks of rocket<br />
fuel toxic component (“mélange”)<br />
OSCE<br />
Needs assessment, institutional<br />
and legal strengthening<br />
of environmental cooperation<br />
with Transnistria<br />
OSCE, UNEP, REC<br />
Environmental assessment of<br />
development planning<br />
and environment-security<br />
monitoring in the Crimea<br />
UNDP, UNEP<br />
Assessment and capacitybuilding<br />
for managing environment<br />
and security risks<br />
in Donbas and Salihorsk regions<br />
UNEP<br />
Ukraine, Belarus,<br />
Moldova<br />
The project will provide facilities and programme for systematic training<br />
of MOD personnel in assessing and managing environmental risks; support<br />
production of information on environmental impacts of Ukrainian<br />
defence activities and infrastructure (database of areas and facilities at<br />
risks; public reports on environmental impacts of armed forces). In<br />
Ukraine it will help strengthen institutional basis for managing environmental<br />
risks by the Ukrainian armed forces (standards, practices, legislation).<br />
2007-2009 Partly funded<br />
Ukraine The project will help mobilise and utilise resources for the disposal of<br />
stocks of rocket fuel toxic component (melange) stored at 7 locations in<br />
Ukraine.<br />
Moldova The project will foster cooperation with Transnistria through needs assessment,<br />
institutional and legal support for addressing general and<br />
specific environmental issues<br />
26<br />
2007-2009 Partly funded<br />
2007-2009 Partly funded<br />
Ukraine The project will promote implementation of strategic environmental assessment<br />
in Crimea as a recognised tool for sustainable development<br />
and conflict prevention. Project will be linked to and support the implementation<br />
of the Crimea Integration and Development Programme of<br />
UNDP. The project will also develop and help implement a mechanism<br />
2007-2009 Not funded<br />
for monitoring environmental and natural resource aspects of conflict and<br />
security situations as an add-on to existing security monitoring by UNDP,<br />
with particular focus on land-related issues and conflicts.<br />
Belarus, Ukraine The project will support regional environmental management and governance<br />
as an element of stabilisation in regions of social stress and<br />
instability. In particular the project will assess and help mitigate environmental<br />
risks related to unsustainable mining practices and the closure of<br />
mines, and increase transparency over environmental issues and decisions.<br />
Work in Donbas will be linked to Sweden’s effort to strengthen<br />
integrated environmental permitting system in the region.<br />
2007-2009 Not funded
Enhancement of public par- Belarus The project will help increase public awareness and access to informa- 2007-2009 Not funded<br />
ticipation in decision-making<br />
tion for decision makers and the general public on the implications of the<br />
and exchange of information<br />
hydropower plants construction on rivers Neman / Nemunas and Zak-<br />
on hydropower development<br />
hadnaya Dzvina / Daugava<br />
on the Neman / Nemunas and<br />
Zakh. Dzvina / Daugava rivers<br />
UNEP<br />
Prevention of illegal cross- Ukraine, Belarus,<br />
border transport of hazardous Moldova<br />
waste: training of border, customs<br />
and environmental authorities<br />
OSCE (Ukraine), UNEP<br />
Support to development and<br />
implementation of Moldovan<br />
national environmental security<br />
programme<br />
UNEP, OSCE<br />
SOUTHERN CAUCASUS<br />
Transboundary river management<br />
in Kura-Aras/Araks<br />
river basin through public involvement<br />
in water governance;<br />
complemented by a regional<br />
study on underground<br />
waters<br />
UNDP<br />
The project will help strengthen capacities of the authorities to monitor<br />
and prevent illegal traffic of hazardous materials waste, i. a. with reference<br />
to international practices and legal instruments such as the Basel<br />
Convention on the Control of Transboundary Movements of Hazardous<br />
Wastes and their Disposal. Training will also produce recommendations<br />
on further capacity-building needs and actions.<br />
Moldova The project supports Moldova in developing and initiating a comprehensive<br />
Environmental Security programme and action plan on the national<br />
and the local levels i.a. reflecting upon and furthering issues and priorities<br />
raised through the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> assessment.<br />
Armenia, Azerbaijan,<br />
Georgia, Iran<br />
27<br />
2007-2008 Not funded<br />
Ongoing Fully funded<br />
The overall long-term objective is to ensure that the quality and quantity July 2004/ Feb Partly funded<br />
of the water (surface and underground water) throughout the Kura- 2006<br />
Aras/Araks river system meets the short and long-term requirements for March-Dec<br />
optimum ecosystem function as well as the needs of the communities 2006 for Aqui-<br />
using the river. Component for 2007: In coordination with the GEF Kura- fers component<br />
Aras/Araks River basin project, explore with the countries possible options<br />
for development and establishment of legal and institutional frameworks<br />
for the joint management of the natural resources of the basin.<br />
Specifically the project will assist the countries to develop a preliminary<br />
legal and institutional framework for coordination of regional action for<br />
the protection of the Kura-Aras/Araks basin environment. It is hoped that<br />
this project will provide the basis for future negotiations, supported by the<br />
GEF and other donors, for a lasting agreement and institution structure.
<strong>ENVSEC</strong> in-depth assess- Georgia, Armenia and As a follow up to the regional <strong>ENVSEC</strong> assessment, in-depth assessment<br />
of environmental degra- Azerbaijan<br />
ments of environmental degradation in frozen conflict zones (such as<br />
dation in frozen conflict zones<br />
Abkhazia, South Ossetia and Nagorny Karabakh) will be developed, if<br />
in the South Caucasus<br />
agreed by the parties to the conflicts, with the objective of providing reliable<br />
data therefore removing the uncertainty on the state of the environ-<br />
UNEP and OSCE<br />
ment from the issues of dispute. Desk assessments will be the first step<br />
in the project.<br />
Capacity Building on legal<br />
Instruments for the Protection<br />
Mountain regions in the Caucasus<br />
UNEP<br />
Training in investigative journalism<br />
with respect to environment<br />
and security issues<br />
UNEP<br />
Strategic Environmental Assessment<br />
in Spatial Planning<br />
UNDP<br />
Armenia, Azerbaijan,<br />
Georgia, Iran, Russian<br />
Federation, Turkey<br />
Georgia / Southern<br />
Caucasus<br />
Additional follow-up activities on identified priority issues in frozen conflict<br />
zones will be developed and implemented, if agreed by the parties to<br />
the conflicts.<br />
28<br />
Planned Partly funded<br />
Establishment of a functioning framework for co-operation between na- Nov. 2005/ Dec Fully funded<br />
tional authorities that are facing similar problems in the field of protection 2006<br />
and sustainable development of the mountain regions in Caucasus. The<br />
project aims at completing a multi sector analysis of existing instruments<br />
for the region, organising of a regional stakeholder meeting and drafting<br />
a provisional convention with which to begin negotiations.<br />
Provide hands-on training to practicing journalists from the countries on<br />
investigative and analytical approach to covering environmental and security<br />
issues and linkages in the print and electronic media. Training<br />
sessions will focus on priority issues defined in <strong>ENVSEC</strong> assessments.<br />
Planned Partly funded<br />
Azerbaijan, Armenia The project will focus on the evaluation of the current status of the capacity<br />
to implement SEA and assessment of current planning/decisionmaking<br />
processes in each country, the development and application of<br />
country-tailored SEA capacity building trainings for government representatives,<br />
experts, non-governmental stakeholders and UNDP staff in<br />
SEA concepts and methodology. It will support integration of SEA into<br />
the countries’ strategic and planning activities through pilot demonstra-<br />
Planned Partly funded<br />
tion of SEA application using a selected program/plan in each country (or<br />
other capacity building activity selected based on the initial capacity<br />
needs assessment result).
South Caucasus cooperative<br />
river monitoring<br />
NATO/PDD/CP977991<br />
Multi-disciplinary analysis of<br />
the Caspian Sea ecosystem<br />
NATO/PDD/CP981063<br />
Technical Workshop on Oil<br />
Spills Remediation in the<br />
Caspian Sea Region<br />
OSCE, NATO<br />
Reduction of flood risks for<br />
people living along the Kodori<br />
River in Abkhazia, Georgia<br />
UNDP<br />
Armenia, Azerbaijan,<br />
Georgia<br />
The project aims at the establishment of a transboundary river monitoring<br />
infrastructure system for the rivers Kura and Aras/Araks shared by<br />
Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia. In each of these countries, one central<br />
laboratory for water quality and quantity analysis and standardised operating<br />
procedures have been established, a watershed management system<br />
has been developed and a data and model sharing system accessible<br />
by internet has been created. One important component is the extensive<br />
joint training of young scientists from the three countries in NATO<br />
laboratories. The project is conducted in close collaboration with ministries,<br />
state committees and national departments concerned.<br />
29<br />
Oct 2002/<br />
Oct 2007<br />
Azerbaijan, Russia The project aims at investigating climatic and man-induced environ- Aug 2004/<br />
mental change in the Caspian Sea and developing circulation and eco- Apr 2008<br />
system models. The project facilitates training of local experts, transfer of<br />
technology and expertise and data exchange between riparian countries.<br />
It initiates coordinated scientific investigations and encourages the development<br />
of regional observation networks.<br />
The OSCE, in cooperation with NATO, will organize a technical workshop<br />
with the participation of OSCE/NATO partner countries and international<br />
experts. During the workshop the participants from the Caspian<br />
Sea littoral states (Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, Russia, Turkmenistan and<br />
Iran) and international experts will present national problems, international<br />
experience, lessons learned and exchange views on the best possible<br />
way forward in developing oil spills response program in the Caspian<br />
Sea region. The workshop could also result in identification of the<br />
best oil spills remediation technologies; work out “A Comprehensive Oil<br />
Spills Remediation Program for the Caspian Sea Region”; and set up a<br />
framework for co-operation between OSCE and NATO in implementing<br />
such a Program.<br />
Fully funded<br />
Fully funded<br />
Abkhazia, Georgia The overall goal of the project is to enhance the stability of local commu- Planned<br />
nities in the Lower Kodori River by strengthening their capacities in flood<br />
management and mitigation. To this end the project will rehabilitate the<br />
embankments of the Lower-Kodori River in order to stop the flooding of<br />
villages and agricultural land in Lower Kodori Valley, as well as support<br />
the capacity of the local population to maintain the riverbanks and other<br />
preventive measures, and build preparedness. Community groups will be<br />
established which initially will receive training in flood management, and<br />
then use that knowledge to rehabilitate the river embankments.<br />
Not funded
CENTRAL ASIA<br />
In-depth assessments of environment<br />
and security risks of<br />
the Amu-Darya river basin<br />
UNEP, UNDP<br />
In-depth assessment of environment<br />
& security hot-spots<br />
on the Eastern Caspian coast<br />
UNEP, UNDP<br />
Environmental conflict early<br />
warning system for Kyrgyzstan,<br />
Tajikistan and Uzbekistan<br />
UNDP<br />
Natural disaster preparedness<br />
and risk reduction for communities<br />
in high-risk districts in<br />
Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan<br />
UNDP<br />
Afghanistan, Tajiki-<br />
stan, Turkmenistan<br />
Uzbekistan<br />
Kazakhstan, Turkmenistan<br />
The project aims at assessing of environment and security issues in the<br />
upper Amu-Darya basin through a desk assessment and field missions.<br />
Besides the assessment the project activities will include various awareness<br />
raising and capacity building activities such as training of local authorities,<br />
researchers and NGOs.<br />
30<br />
Jan 2007/ Mar<br />
2008<br />
The project will assess in-depth environment & security hotspots on the Nov 2005 /<br />
Eastern Caspian coast following the preliminary identification of issues in March 2007<br />
<strong>ENVSEC</strong> 1st stage assessment for Central Asia, national consultations<br />
and on-going activities; plan concrete actions on the ground on the institutional,<br />
policy and community levels<br />
Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan Based on in-depth assessment and existing early warning systems, the<br />
and Uzbekistan <strong>ENVSEC</strong> will set up an environmental system of information collection<br />
and dissemination for tracking and analysis of potential conflicts arising<br />
Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan<br />
from competition over natural resources or from potential natural hazards<br />
between communities in three states of Ferghana Valley. It is also aimed<br />
at assessing the security- environment linkage more broadly and at placing<br />
environmental causes of conflict in the perspective of the wider security<br />
context. Such system of monitoring and early warning will produce<br />
substantial basis for adoption of responsible policies in maintaining secure<br />
environment.<br />
Based on in-depth assessment and existing UNDP programmes, the<br />
<strong>ENVSEC</strong> will design activities to prevent increasing social tension and<br />
conflicts by strengthening national capacities in natural disaster risk<br />
management to reduce losses and impacts of both natural and manmade<br />
disasters in high-risk regions. More specifically, to strengthen capacities<br />
of local authorities and communities in disaster risk management,<br />
to reduce vulnerability to disasters, and to pilot mechanisms for<br />
community involvement in disaster risk management.<br />
Ongoing<br />
Sep 2006 –<br />
Dec 2007<br />
Jan 2006/<br />
Dec 2007<br />
Funded<br />
Partly funded<br />
Partly funded<br />
Fully funded
Uranium Waste and tailings<br />
Sites in the Ferghana Valley<br />
NATO/PDD/CP981742<br />
Improved Land and Water<br />
Resource Management in the<br />
Upper Syr Darya Basin in the<br />
Context of Sustainable Development<br />
UNDP, Global Environment<br />
Facility MSP<br />
Ferghana valley web portal<br />
UNDP, UNEP<br />
Kyrgyzstan, Tajiki- The effective management of uranium industry wastes to prevent health Jan 2006/ July<br />
stan, Uzbekistan, Ka- and environmental detriment - characterization of source terms, determi- 2008<br />
zakhstannation<br />
of local contamination and migration of radionuclides, assessment<br />
of radiation doses to the population from external gamma-radiation, radon<br />
isotopes and from ingested/inhaled radionuclides, estimate of risk,<br />
proposal for mitigation/remediation, if any, comparison with international<br />
standards.<br />
Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan This project will address transboundary integrated land and water man-<br />
and Uzbekistan agement by preparing a transboundary diagnostic analysis that will assist<br />
in development of a set of eco-system quality objectives (EQOs)<br />
serving as the basis for the regional strategic action programme and the<br />
national action plans. The second part of this approach is the testing of<br />
these EQOs as instruments for sustainable use of land and water resources<br />
in the region. These EQOs will be scaleable for the whole region,<br />
down to small villages. Once these EQOs are established, two<br />
community level demonstration projects that emphasize issues of sustainable<br />
development in transboundary cooperation in resource utilization<br />
and economic development will be implemented to test their practicality.<br />
Kyrgyzstan,<br />
Tajikistan,<br />
Uzbekistan,<br />
Turkmenistan and<br />
Kazakhstan<br />
The aim of this project is to set up an information sharing process and<br />
create a network of information officers working on the local level in the<br />
target area of Ferghana Valley. The web portal will become a component<br />
of the existing Central Asia and Russia Environment and Sustainable<br />
Development Digital Network (CARESD) web portal. <strong>ENVSEC</strong>-<br />
Ferghana Information Officers will be connected to Environmental Information<br />
Network for Central Asia and Russia network (CARNet) of civil<br />
society organisations established in 2004 around CARESD. UNEP will<br />
work with <strong>ENVSEC</strong> counterparts in the Ferghana valley on the delivery<br />
on-line of substantive environment-security information, i.a. to ensure<br />
transparency in monitoring of <strong>ENVSEC</strong> issues and activities in the postassessment<br />
phase.<br />
31<br />
Under consideration<br />
March 2006/<br />
Dec 2006; extended<br />
till Dec<br />
2008<br />
Fully funded<br />
Not funded<br />
Not funded for<br />
2007 - 2008
Environmental Impact As- Kazakhstan, Kyrsessment<br />
in a Transboundary gyzstan<br />
Context: Pilot implementation<br />
project in Central Asia<br />
UNECE and OSCE<br />
Dam safety in Central Asia:<br />
capacity building and subregional<br />
cooperation<br />
UNECE, OSCE<br />
Enhancing regional exchange<br />
of water resource information<br />
(CAREWIB phase II)<br />
UNECE and UNEP<br />
The project will demonstrate the application of transboundary environmental<br />
impact assessment in Central Asia between the two countries<br />
Kyrgyzstan and Kazakhstan, both parties of the EIA Convention. The<br />
project will develop national implementation mechanisms in Kazakhstan<br />
and Kyrgyzstan. A full procedure of EIA in a transboundary context will<br />
further be applied to a specific planned project (production facility or similar)<br />
in Kyrgyzstan, with the involvement of Kazakhstan authorities and<br />
the public.<br />
Ongoing Fully funded<br />
Central Asia The project will assess needs to revise the existing legal provisions and<br />
to reform the established institutional modalities for dam safety; Provide<br />
technical support through advise and training; identify and support technically<br />
an institution in each participating county to serve as a national<br />
focal point to coordinate dam safety activities at the country level and<br />
represent that country in interrregional cooperation activities. On the regional<br />
level the project will facilitate the formulation of a concept of<br />
subregional cooperation for safe operation of dams and other hydraulic<br />
Ongoing Partly funded<br />
structures, especially those located on transboundary rivers, and support<br />
the development and start-up of a work programme.<br />
Central Asia The project will build upon Central Asia Regional Water Information Base<br />
(CAREWIB) information service of the Interstate Commission for Water<br />
Coordination towards further development of its contents and full integration<br />
of with other sources of regional water-related information, in order<br />
to facilitate a Central Asian water information exchange network for policy-makers<br />
and the general public.<br />
32<br />
Under consideration<br />
Not funded
Environmental Diplomacy<br />
Program for Young Diplomats<br />
from Central Asia<br />
UNDP, UNEP, OSCE<br />
Elimination of Kazakhstan’s<br />
Mélange (Liquid Rocket Fuel<br />
Component) Stockpiles: Implementation<br />
– Phase III<br />
OSCE<br />
SEMIRAD II - Investigation of<br />
the Radiological Situation in<br />
the Sarzhal Region of the<br />
Semipalatinsk Nuclear Test<br />
Site<br />
NATO/PDD/CP980906<br />
Study of Radioactive Waste<br />
Disposal Sites in Turkmenistan<br />
NATO/PDD/CP978439<br />
Central Asia The main objective of the project is to prepare and deliver an environ- Planned for<br />
mental diplomacy training programme in Central Asia for the junior and<br />
mid-level diplomats from the Ministries of Foreign Affairs. The project<br />
will rely on the training programme already organized in Geneva, in August<br />
2006. The specific project objectives are:<br />
2007 - 2008<br />
- to research and develop multidisciplinary training modules and related<br />
teaching materials for teaching and practicing environmental<br />
diplomacy in Central Asia in, initially, 10 areas<br />
- to identify and mobilize a suitable trainers and lecturers for areas<br />
mentioned above;<br />
- to form and develop a list of potential students and client networks<br />
- to train young diplomats from the Ministries of Foreign Affairs, and<br />
possibly other clients and client networks, producing a first group of<br />
about 40 negotiators trained in environmental diplomacy;<br />
- to evaluate the course and secure funding for a training programme<br />
for 2007 - 2008 in Bishkek or Almaty.<br />
33<br />
Not funded<br />
Kazakhstan The objective of the project is to assist the Government of Kazakhstan in Planned<br />
eliminating approximately 1,400 tons of Mélange by ensuring recycling or<br />
disposing of Mélange in an environmentally sound manner. Ultimately,<br />
the project seeks to curb environmental and safety threats posed by<br />
large quantities of Mélange stored in the vicinity of populated areas,<br />
thereby improving the environmental and security status in the country<br />
and, in particular, the concerned areas.<br />
Not funded<br />
Kazakhstan This project is a continuation of SEMIRAD I. The new site to be studied Aug 2004/ Aug<br />
for its radiological condition lies north of Ground Zero and southwest of<br />
Maize (Kazakhstan). Within the framework of the project areas, if present,<br />
which present radionuclide concentrations that are high enough to<br />
2007<br />
present a terrorism/defence threat will be identified. Results will allow the<br />
Kazakh Government, local authorities and their agencies to develop<br />
strategies for the rehabilitation and development of the area.<br />
Turkmenistan The project is assisting Turkmenistan in the safe handling of radioactive Jul 2001/ Au-<br />
waste, a side-product from iodine and bromine production facilities near gust 2008<br />
by the Caspian Sea. The project includes the implementation of a radiochemical<br />
laboratory in Ashgabat, the installation and operation of radioprotection<br />
equipment and the training of Turkmen teams. This will enable<br />
Turkmenistan in gaining scientific and technical autonomy in waste characterisation<br />
and radio protection.<br />
Fully funded<br />
Fully funded
Integrated Water Resources<br />
Management for Wetlands<br />
Restoration in the Aral Sea<br />
Basin (Northern part)<br />
NATO/PDD/CP980986<br />
Using Stable Isotopes, Passive<br />
Organic Samplers and<br />
Modelling to Assess Environmental<br />
Security in Khorezm,<br />
Uzbekistan<br />
NATO<br />
Biotechnological Exploitation<br />
of Uzbek Saline Water Reserves<br />
Using Halotolerant Microalgae<br />
NATO<br />
CROSS REGIONAL ACTIVITIES<br />
Establishment of and support<br />
to Public Environmental Information<br />
Centres (“Aarhus<br />
centers”)<br />
OSCE, UNECE<br />
Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan<br />
The overall objective of the project is to propose a system of models, Aug 2005/ Aug<br />
GIS and engineering tools for civil infrastructure and a pre-feasibility 2008<br />
study answering to the principal needs for integrated water resources<br />
management in the Syrdarya Delta. The results of the study should<br />
serve as a basis for internationally supported investment proposals. The<br />
participation of the local community and other stakeholders should add<br />
to the reality of the proposed measures and should support the creation<br />
of a "Committee for water resources management of the Syrdarya delta".<br />
Uzbekistan By applying innovative technologies the ecosystems of lakes in the Amu Jul 2006/ Dec<br />
Darya river basin will be better understood and a predictive model will be 2009<br />
established. This will improve the understanding of the impact of agricultural,<br />
industrial and urban activities on the ecosystems. The results will<br />
be transferred, among other authorities, to the State Committee for Nature<br />
Protection.<br />
Uzbekistan The Aral Sea and other major saline water reserves in the region will be Jul 2006/ Dec<br />
assessed for their potential use in the production of the algae Dunaliella 2009<br />
salina. This algae is a rich source for bioactive compounds and therefore<br />
a candidate for commercial production with application in agriculture and<br />
medicine. In the framework of the project a pilot plant will be developed<br />
and a techno-economical viability study will be performed.<br />
34<br />
Fully funded<br />
Fully funded<br />
Fully funded<br />
Albania, Armenia, Promoting the implementation of the Aarhus Convention and the second Ongoing Partly funded<br />
Azerbaijan, Georgia, component of Objective 6 of the EECCA Strategy by creating, or sup-<br />
Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan porting already existing, public information centres (Aarhus Centres);<br />
Using Aarhus Centres to raise awareness of environment and security<br />
linkages; promote public participation in environmental decision making<br />
and access to justice.<br />
For 2007, more emphasis will be placed on the 3 rd Pillar of the Aarhus<br />
Convention (Access to Justice) by conducting a regional training for<br />
Judges under the auspices of the Task Force on Access to Justice.
Training in investigative journalism<br />
with respect to Environment<br />
and Security issues<br />
and linkages<br />
UNEP<br />
Assistance to EECCA and<br />
South Eastern Europe countries<br />
in implementing the Convention<br />
on the Transboundary<br />
Effects of Industrial Accidents<br />
UNECE and UNEP<br />
Energy and Environmental<br />
Challenges to Security - A<br />
Seminar for Parliamentarians<br />
and others<br />
REC<br />
Towards a legal regime for<br />
flood management in UNECE<br />
region<br />
REC<br />
Central Asia, Caucasus<br />
EECCA and South<br />
Eastern Europe countries<br />
South Eastern<br />
Europe, Eastern<br />
Europe, possibly others<br />
Provide hands-on training to practicing journalists from the countries on<br />
investigative and analytical approach to covering environmental and security<br />
issues and linkages in the print and electronic media. Training will<br />
be held in the framework of annual regional festival of environmental<br />
journalism and focus on priority issues defined in <strong>ENVSEC</strong> assessments.<br />
35<br />
Jan. 2004/<br />
March 2006<br />
The project will help improve industrial safety, in particular at hazardous March 2006 /<br />
installations, through assessing readiness of and needs of the countries Nov 2007<br />
for the implementation of prevention measures, and tailoring capacitybuilding<br />
activities to foster preparedness and adequate response to industrial<br />
accidents. The outcome of the project (countries’ commitments,<br />
verification missions and reports, programme of needs-driven assistance<br />
activities) will contribute to the assistance programme adopted by the<br />
Conference of the Parties to the UNECE Convention on the Transboundary<br />
Effects of Industrial Accidents.<br />
Fully funded<br />
Fully funded<br />
The seminar on “Energy and Environmental Challenges to Security” is<br />
aimed at engaging political actors and key policymakers and stakeholders,<br />
including governmental authorities, journalists and members of<br />
civil society, to focus the international debate on these issues through a<br />
high-level conference. It provides an opportunity to promote on the basis<br />
of sound scientific knowledge understanding and raise awareness<br />
among critical players whose actions will have a major impact on the<br />
future course of development and on security-related matters, and to<br />
accomplish outreach to targeted groups from the international initiatives<br />
related to Environment and Security that have gathered the latest thinking<br />
on the subject.<br />
Planned Not funded<br />
UNECE region The goal of the project is to contribute to the development of an international<br />
legal regime for flood management in the UNECE region, or, alternatively,<br />
with respect to specific shared rivers and water bodies on a<br />
sub-regional level. The project envisions in-depth research, surveying<br />
and analyzing applicable international legal principles, relevant legal<br />
texts, articles and other resources, culminating in a detailed, commented<br />
Planned Not funded<br />
proposal for state-of-the-art rules. Alternative institutional arrangements,<br />
including commissions with various powers, will be examined, together<br />
with geographical and other considerations relevant to regime formation<br />
with particular application to river basins.
Prediction of Glacial Hazards<br />
and Disasters in the Central<br />
Caucasus, Russia<br />
NATO<br />
New Technologies of Seismic<br />
Resistant Construction<br />
NATO<br />
Russia One major aim is to improve the modelling techniques for catastrophic Jun 2006/<br />
slop instability and produce predictions and glacial hazard maps for the<br />
glaciers in Russian Central Caucasus. A short-, mid- and long-term forecast<br />
will be produced and potential disaster sites be identified. The results<br />
will be disseminated to local authorities dealing with emergency,<br />
disaster and infrastructure planning.<br />
Dec2009<br />
Azerbaijan and Kazakhstan<br />
* Kosovo refers to the UN administered territory under UN Security Council resolution 1244<br />
NB: project fiches exist for all planned / on-going project<br />
2. Completed <strong>ENVSEC</strong> projects as of January 2007<br />
Project<br />
and<br />
Lead organisation<br />
SOUTH EASTERN EUROPE<br />
The whole project is aimed at lowering the number of victims during high<br />
magnitude earthquakes and strong explosions based on Aseismic Construction<br />
Technology (ACT). The new ATC will result in simpler and<br />
cheaper small stable houses that could, for example, be used for constructing<br />
settlements of refugees.<br />
36<br />
Jun 2006/ Dec<br />
2009<br />
Fully funded<br />
Fully funded<br />
Region/Countries Description Year of<br />
completion<br />
In-depth assessment of Envi- South Eastern Europe One of the first assessments carried out by the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> team, and the result of 2003<br />
ronment and Security risks<br />
extensive desk studies, fieldwork and stakeholder meetings and workshops in<br />
and opportunities in South<br />
the region, this assessment is the basis of the work programme that is now being<br />
Eastern Europe<br />
implemented in the region. Publication of ‘Environment and Security transforming<br />
risks into cooperation, the case of Central Asia and South Eastern Europe’. Also<br />
UNEP<br />
available in Russian.
Rapid Environmental Assessment<br />
of the Tisza River<br />
Basin, including environment<br />
and security risks<br />
UNEP<br />
Network Development of local<br />
actors from the Sava River<br />
Basin on Water resource<br />
Management<br />
OSCE<br />
SOUTHERN CAUCASUS<br />
<strong>ENVSEC</strong> phase 1 assessment<br />
of environment and security<br />
risks and opportunities<br />
in the South Caucasus<br />
UNEP<br />
Hungary, Romania, Montenegro<br />
Serbia, Slovakia,<br />
Ukraine<br />
Bosnia & Herzegovina,<br />
Montenegro, Serbia, Croatia,<br />
Slovenia<br />
Armenia, Azerbaijan, Georgia<br />
Preliminary assessment of the overall environmental situation, environmental<br />
problems and security issues, plus identification of “hot spots” in the transboundary<br />
Tisza River basin of South-Eastern Europe<br />
The project aimed to promote regional co-operation in water resource management<br />
through establishing networks of local actors from the Sava River Basin,<br />
and by identifying the role of these local actors in river basin management. Further<br />
information is available on the project website: http://www.reccroatia.hr/eng/projects.php?id=78<br />
37<br />
2004<br />
2006<br />
Based on the results of national consultations and deskwork, an <strong>ENVSEC</strong> as- 2004<br />
sessment report and work programme has been developed for the Southern<br />
Caucasus. The programme includes further in-depth assessment and monitoring<br />
of issues at specific hot spots as well as direct interventions in terms capacity<br />
building and support to policy development. Publication “Environment and Security<br />
transforming risks into co-operation, the case of the Southern Caucasus”.<br />
Also available in Russian.<br />
Assessment and neutralisa- Armenia The assessment will be composed of the following elements: Quantity and char- 2004<br />
tion of hazardous chemicals<br />
acteristic of the melange; Processing technology available in the region and in-<br />
in abandoned military sites in<br />
ternationally; Local facilities and resources available in-country; Modalities for<br />
Armenia<br />
recycling/disposing of the melange; Cost and time frame for implementation of<br />
the recycling/disposal of the melange. Based on the findings and recommendations<br />
of the Experts, the Office will seek extra-budgetary contributions to implement<br />
the recycling\disposal of the toxic melange.
Special issue of the “Caucasus<br />
Environmental Magazine”<br />
OSCE<br />
Environment and Security in Armenia, Azerbaijan and<br />
the South Caucasus Triangle Georgia<br />
OSCE via GTZ<br />
Seismic Risk in large cities of<br />
the Caucasus, tools for risk<br />
management (SeRiCiCau)<br />
NATO/PDD/CP974320<br />
Strategic Environmental Assessment<br />
(SEA) – Promotion<br />
and Capacity Building<br />
CENTRAL ASIA<br />
<strong>ENVSEC</strong> Phase 1 assessment<br />
of Environment and security<br />
risks and opportunities<br />
in Central Asia<br />
UNEP, UNDP<br />
Support the production of a special issue of the CENN (Caucasus Environmental 2005<br />
NGOs Network) “Caucasus Environmental Magazine”, on environment and security<br />
in Russian and English. The aim was to contribute to an increasing awareness<br />
in the region of the relevance for security of environmental degradation and<br />
this project supports environmental journalism in the Caucasus. This special edition<br />
of the quarterly magazine was published in December 2005 and distributed<br />
to different stakeholders in the region.<br />
In cooperation with Deutsche Gesellschaft für Technische Zusammenarbeit<br />
(GTZ). Activities will combine awareness raising of environment and security issues<br />
through workshops and elaboration of information material; setting up (or<br />
supporting) local environmental information centres (local branches of the Aarhus<br />
Centres); implementation of small scale projects submitted by community<br />
associations based on the discussed ideas.<br />
2005<br />
Armenia, Azerbaijan, Geor- Updated GIS-based hazard, vulnerability and risk maps were compiled, scenar- 2006<br />
gia, Russia<br />
ios for disastrous events were developed and the knowledge was transferred to<br />
local authorities and ministries as the end-users. This will improve the preparedness<br />
of the authorities concerned and promote the value of sharing information<br />
among Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia. Databases on seismic activities were<br />
completed and are permanently updated. Electronic maps of seismic hazard of<br />
cities were prepared for the end users.<br />
Armenia, Georgia Project aimed to introduce application of SEA for integrating environment into<br />
countries’ development framework, thus support the process towards ratification<br />
of the UNECE SEA Protocol (signed by both countries in 2003). In Armenia, the<br />
pilot SEA of the Yerevan Master Plan was implemented, resulting in some SEA<br />
recommendations being incorporated in the master plan and in raising awareness<br />
and involving public in the master plan development and SEA process. In<br />
Georgia, the national Resource Guide to Implement the SEA Protocol has been<br />
developed, for raising awareness on the SEA Protocol requirements. In Armenia<br />
project has been finalized by the development of the National Strategy for Implementation<br />
of the SEA Protocol, which will undergo the inter-ministerial review<br />
process and is considered to be formally adopted.<br />
2006<br />
Central Asia One of the first assessments carried out by the <strong>ENVSEC</strong> team, and the result of 2003<br />
extensive desk studies, fieldwork and stakeholder meetings and workshops in<br />
the region, this assessment is the basis of the work programme that is now being<br />
implemented in the region. Publication of “Environment and Security transforming<br />
risks into cooperation. The case of Central Asia and South Eastern Europe”.<br />
Also available in Russian.<br />
38
In-depth field assessment of The Ferghana valley An in-depth (phase II) assessment of the region was initiated in May 2004 with 2005<br />
environment and security hot-<br />
the main objective to assess and communicate information on environment &<br />
spots in the Ferghana – Osh –<br />
security hotspots in the Ferghana-Osh-Khujand triangle with focus on trans-<br />
Khujand triangle and adjacent<br />
boundary risks from human activities, in particular industrial hot spots (hazardous<br />
areas<br />
waste, risks for accidents and spillages, including radioactive waste poorly stored<br />
or completely abandoned), pressure on natural resources (land degradation, de-<br />
UNEP, UNDP, OSCE<br />
forestation, ownership; water quality, usage and sharing) and cross-cutting issues<br />
such as natural disasters or the impacts of climate change on the region.<br />
Publication: “Environment and Security: Transforming risks into cooperation -<br />
Central Asia - Ferghana / Osh / Khujand area”. Also available in Russian.<br />
Assessment and Mitigation of Uzbekistan and Kyrgyzstan This project collected data on the seismological and geological characteristics of 2005<br />
Seismic Risk in Tashkent,<br />
the region, and seismic hazard maps and earthquake ground motion models for<br />
Uzbekistan and Bishkek, Kyr-<br />
Bishkek and Tashkent were developed. NATO support included the purchase<br />
gyzstan Republic<br />
and installation of GIS equipment and software as well as training of young scientists.<br />
The end-results were given to the state committees and ministries con-<br />
NATO<br />
cerned in Kyrgyz Republic and Uzbekistan.<br />
Sustainable Development of Uzbekistan With the aim to establish a remote sensing system for studying the Aral Sea eco- 2005<br />
Ecology and Land and Water<br />
system, a GIS Centre was equipped and put into operation at the Nukus State<br />
use through implementation of<br />
University, Karakalpakstan (Uzbekistan). With the help of Russian expertise, the<br />
a GIS and Remote Sensing<br />
centre developed forecast models for ecosystem changes and early crop-yield<br />
Centre in Karakalpakstan Uz-<br />
estimation models. Scientists were trained in this centre to ensure improvement<br />
bekistan<br />
of water management and agricultural planning. The results were transferred to<br />
the Interstate Coordination Water Management Commission as well as to state<br />
NATO<br />
committees and regional governments of Uzbekistan.<br />
SEMIRAD 1 – Investigation of Kazakhstan Within the framework of this project the radioactive contamination level at the 2005<br />
the radiological situation in the<br />
Tel’kem valley (Kazakhstan) was determined. Two-week field expeditions were<br />
Sarzhal region of the Semi-<br />
carried out on an annual basis and technical support to the National Nuclear<br />
palatinsk Nuclear Test Site<br />
Centre of Kazakhstan was provided. The results showed that the studied area<br />
was little more contaminated by radionuclides than would be expected from a<br />
NATO<br />
global fallout and thus presents little radiological hazard for farmers. The conclusions<br />
were reported to the Kazakh authorities concerned.<br />
39
Rapid environment and health<br />
risk assessment of industrial<br />
hotspots<br />
UNEP<br />
Training in investigative journalism<br />
with respect to Environment<br />
and Security issues<br />
and linkages<br />
UNEP<br />
Support to regional festival on<br />
environmental journalism in<br />
Central Asia<br />
UNDP<br />
EASTERN EUROPE<br />
Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan<br />
Carry out a rapid assessment of environment and health transboundary risks<br />
originated by industrial sites and hazardous waste dumps, located in the<br />
Ferghana valley area, with prioritisation of risks related to individual sites; carry<br />
out, for the selected sites, detailed assessment of risk, define provisional offsite<br />
contingency plans (OCPs) for the areas affected by the sites investigated, in<br />
compliance with European Directives and International Conventions (e.g.<br />
UNECE Convention on Industrial Accidents), and to carry out pre-feasibility studies<br />
for correction/ reconstruction measures necessary to prevent/ reduce the<br />
identified risks; contribute to the developing process of capacity building and to<br />
promote the public participation on the risk management.<br />
Central Asian countries Provide hands-on training to practicing journalists from the countries on investigative<br />
and analytical approach to covering environmental and security issues<br />
and linkages in the print and electronic media. Training will be held in the framework<br />
of annual regional festival of environmental journalism and focus on priority<br />
issues defined in <strong>ENVSEC</strong> assessments.<br />
Central Asian countries Organise national and regional competitions and festivals of environmental films, 2006<br />
TV and radio programmes, and newspaper articles. Build capacities of selected<br />
national journalists and environmental NGOs on organisation of the festivals and<br />
public environmental campaigns for awareness raising. Establish working<br />
mechanisms for dialogue with the Ministries of Environment on how to draw public<br />
attention to the critical national environmental and development priorities, and<br />
contribute to national environmental protection and peace building.<br />
Monitoring and Assessment of Moldova, Romania In order identify the main sources of pollution in the river Prut, the contamination 2005<br />
Heavy Metal Pollution in River<br />
levels of 4 heavy metals (Cd, Cu, Pb, Zn) were studied. The project allowed the<br />
Prut<br />
acquisition of analytical equipment in Moldova and Romania. Scientists from both<br />
countries were trained in NATO country laboratories to ensure sustainable qual-<br />
NATO<br />
ity analysis and monitoring of the river. Results were reported at international<br />
conferences as well as to the local authorities.<br />
40<br />
2006<br />
2006
Rocket fuel disposal workshop<br />
and assessment in<br />
Ukraine<br />
OSCE - NATO<br />
CROSS REGIONAL PROJECTS<br />
Postgraduate Course on Environment,<br />
Security and Diplomacy<br />
UNEP<br />
Ukraine NATO/OSCE organised a workshop to share national experiences and seek for 2005<br />
applicability of the best methods and technical options for secure, economically<br />
efficient and environmentally friendly methods of liquid rocket fuel component<br />
("mélange") disposal. The result of the assessment in Ukraine will provide technical<br />
and financial assistance for the implementation of melange recycling and<br />
facilitate the elaboration of an independent technical-economic assessment<br />
based on-site Needs Assessment Mission (NAM) of an international expert<br />
group.<br />
* Kosovo refers to the UN administered territory under UN Security Council resolution 1244<br />
The ‘Environment and Security’ Module gave the students an analysis of the re- 2006<br />
lationship between environmental security and peace; the security implications of<br />
environmental changes; environmental stress and conflict; and the need for micro-<br />
and meso-diplomacy in areas such as Central Asia and international river<br />
basins. The training was attended by present and future diplomats, policy and<br />
decision makers in governments, regional intergovernmental bodies, local authorities,<br />
the private sector, NGOs, and UN bodies (including participants from<br />
the Balkans and the Eastern Europe, Caucasus and Central Asia regions). 20<br />
participants from countries with economies in transition were offered a scholarship<br />
for the course.<br />
41
ANNEX 3: National focal points and contacts<br />
SOUTH-EASTERN EUROPE<br />
Albania<br />
Sajmir Hoxha<br />
Chief of Cabinet, Ministry of Environment<br />
Rruga e durreshit, Nr. 27 Tirana<br />
Tel. +355 4 270 621<br />
Fax +355 4 270 627<br />
E-mail sajmir@abissnet.com.al<br />
Lorenc Xhaferraj<br />
Desk Officer, UN Department<br />
Ministry of Foreign Affairs<br />
Gjergj Fishta – 6, Tirana<br />
Tel. +355 4 364 090 ext.142<br />
Fax +355 4 364 401<br />
E-mail lxhaferraj@mfa.gov.al<br />
Bosnia and Herzegovina<br />
Azra Rogovic<br />
Senior Advisor<br />
Ministry of Foreign Trade and Economic Relations<br />
Musala 9, Sarajevo<br />
Tel. +387 033 211 852<br />
Fax +387 033 211 852<br />
E-mail azrarogovic@yahoo.co.uk<br />
Bulgaria<br />
Detelina Peicheva<br />
Expert, International Cooperation Department<br />
Ministry of Environment and Water<br />
22 Maria Luiza Blvd, Sofia 1000<br />
Tel. +359 2 940 61 32<br />
Fax + 359 2 980 96 41<br />
E-mail dpeycheva@moew.government.bg<br />
Krasimir Petrov<br />
State Expert, OSCE Chairmanship Directorate<br />
Ministry of Foreign Affairs<br />
Alexander Zhendov Str. 2, Sofia 1040<br />
Tel. +359 2 948 24 51<br />
Mobile +359 887 464 445<br />
Fax +359 2 971 03 21<br />
E-mail kr.petrov@mfa.government.bg<br />
42<br />
Croatia<br />
Sandra Tucak-Zoric<br />
Environmental Impact Assessment Department<br />
Ministry for Environment Protection, Physical<br />
Planning and Construction, Expert Advisor<br />
Republike Austrije 16, Zagreb<br />
Tel. +385 1 3782 173<br />
Fax +385 1 3782 157<br />
E-mail Sandra.tucak-zoric@mzopu.hr<br />
Marina Vasilj<br />
Head of the Department for Co-operation with International<br />
Organisations<br />
Ministry of Foreign Affairs<br />
Trg. N.S. Zrinskog 7-8, 10 000 Zagreb<br />
Tel. +385 1 4569 839<br />
Fax +385 4597 416<br />
E-mail intl.institutions@mvp.hr<br />
The Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia<br />
Kosta Trajkovski<br />
Head of Unit for Project Preparation<br />
Ministry of Environment and Physical Planning<br />
Drezdenska-52, Skopje<br />
Tel. +389 2 3066 930 ext. 155<br />
Fax +389 2 3066 931<br />
E-mail k.trajkovski@moepp.gov.mk<br />
Jani Bogoevski<br />
Head of Department of Foreign Economic Policy<br />
Ministry of Foreign Affairs<br />
Dame Gruev br. 6, Skopje 1000<br />
Tel. +389 2 3123 044<br />
Fax +389 2 3115 790<br />
E-mail jani.bogoevski@mfa.gov.mk<br />
Romania<br />
Silviu Stoica<br />
General Director of the Authority for Implementation<br />
of the Structural and Cohesion Funds for Environmental<br />
Infrastructure Projects<br />
Ministry of Environment and Water Management<br />
12, Libertatii Blvd, 040129, Bucharest 5<br />
Tel. +40-21 3357172<br />
Fax +40 21 312 42 27<br />
E-mail silviu@mappm.ro<br />
Carmen BURLACU<br />
Director General<br />
General Directorate for OSCE and Council of Europe<br />
Ministry of Foreign Affairs<br />
14 Modrogan Street, District 1, Bucharest<br />
Tel: + 4021 230 75 79<br />
Fax: + 4021 231 81 15<br />
e-mail: ddo@mae.ro
Republic of Serbia<br />
Stevo Tubic<br />
Assistant Director for Sector for Environmental<br />
Protection from Pollution<br />
Ministry of Science and Environmental Protection<br />
of the Republic of Serbia<br />
Dr. Ivana Ribara 91, Novi Beograd<br />
Tel. +381 11 3132576<br />
Fax +381 11 2158 793<br />
E-mail Stevo.tubic@ekoserb.sr.gov.yu<br />
Republic of Montenegro<br />
Ministry of Tourism and Environment Protection<br />
Podgorica, Montenegro<br />
Tel: +381 81 482 313<br />
Kosovo (the UN administered territory under UN<br />
Security Council resolution 1244)<br />
Nezakete Hakaj (contact)<br />
Head of Environment Protection Division<br />
Ministry of Environment and Spatial Planning<br />
Rilindja Komplex, II office 218 Pristina<br />
Tel. + 381 38 211 718<br />
Mobile +377 44 213 963<br />
Fax + 381 38 211716<br />
E-mail nezakete.hakaj@gmail.com<br />
Ismail Hetemaj (contact)<br />
Head of Nature Protection Division<br />
Ministry of Environment and Spatial Planning<br />
"Rilindja" Komplexcont.III/212, Prishtina<br />
Tel. + 381 38 211 805<br />
Fax + 381 38 211 716<br />
E-mail ihetemaj@yahoo.com<br />
43<br />
EASTERN EUROPE<br />
Belarus<br />
Natalia Golovko<br />
International Cooperation Department<br />
Ministry of Natural Resources and Environmental<br />
Protection<br />
Kollektornaya ul. 10, Minsk 220048<br />
Tel. +375 17 200 4328/7454<br />
Fax +375 17 200 7454<br />
E-mail icd@minpriroda.by<br />
Moldova<br />
Violeta Ivanov<br />
Head of the Division Environmental Policy and<br />
European Integration<br />
Ministry of Ecology and Natural Resources<br />
9 Cosmonautilor Str., MD 2005 Chisinau<br />
Tel. +373 22 20 45 07<br />
Fax +373 22 22 68 58<br />
E-mail ecopolicy@mediu.moldova.md<br />
Andrei Galbur<br />
Director of the Multilateral Cooperation Department<br />
Ministry of Foreign Affairs and European Integration<br />
31 August str., 80. Chisinau MD2012<br />
Tel. +373 22 233 940<br />
Fax +373 22 232 302<br />
E-mail: andrei.galbur@mfa.md<br />
Ukraine<br />
Olga Marushevska<br />
Head of International Cooperation Department<br />
Ministry of Environmental Protection<br />
Uritskogo vul. 35, Kyiv 03035<br />
Tel./ Fax ++38 044 206 3110<br />
E-mail marushevska@menr.gov.ua<br />
Volodymyr Tolkach<br />
Head of the OSCE Division<br />
Department for UN and Other International Organizations<br />
Tel: +380 44 238 1640<br />
Fax: +380 44 272 2040<br />
E-mail: v.tolkach@mfa.gov.ua
SOUTHERN CAUCASUS<br />
Armenia<br />
Ms. Ruzanna Davtyan<br />
Head of International Cooperation Department<br />
Ministry of Nature Protection<br />
Government House 3, Republic Square, Yerevan<br />
375010<br />
Tel: +37410 58 53 49<br />
Fax: +37410 58 54 69<br />
interdpt@rambler.ru<br />
Ms. Nouneh Zastoukhova<br />
First Secretary<br />
International Organizations Department<br />
Ministry of Foreign Affairs<br />
Government House 2, Republic Square, Yerevan<br />
375010<br />
Tel: +37410 54 40 41/232<br />
Fax: +37 410 54 3925<br />
n.zastoukhova@mfa.am<br />
Azerbaijan<br />
Imran Abdulov<br />
Deputy Head of Department of Environmental and<br />
Nature Protection Policy<br />
Ministry of Ecology and Natural Resources<br />
B. Aghayev Str 100-A, 370073 Baku<br />
Tel. +99 412 438 85 13<br />
Fax +99 412 492 59 07<br />
E-mail imranabdulov@baku.az<br />
Kenan MURTUZOV<br />
Second Secretary<br />
Department of Economic Cooperation and Development<br />
Ministry of Foreign Affairs<br />
4 Shihali Gurbanov Str, Baku, 370009<br />
Tel. +994 12 492 96 92 ext.2079<br />
Fax. +994 12 492 68 25<br />
KMurtuzov@yahoo.com<br />
Georgia<br />
George Kolbin<br />
Head of Department of International Relations<br />
and Conventions<br />
Ministry of Environmental and Natural Resources<br />
Protection<br />
ul. Kostava 68a 380015<br />
Tbilisi - Republic of Georgia<br />
Tel: +995 32 23 06 64<br />
Fax: +995 32 33 39 52; 94 36 70<br />
E-mail: gmep@access.sanet.ge<br />
44<br />
CENTRAL ASIA<br />
Kyrgyzstan<br />
Omor Rustembekov<br />
Director of the Department of Ecology and Nature<br />
Use, State Agency for environmental protection<br />
142 Gorkiy Street, Bishkek 720053<br />
Tel. +996 312 54 74 52<br />
Fax +996 312 54 91 18<br />
E-mail demos@intranet.kg<br />
Zamira Tohtohodjaeva<br />
Counsellor, Ministry of Foreign Affairs<br />
59 Razzakova Street, Bishkek 720050<br />
Tel. +996 312 62 67 73<br />
Fax: +996 312 66 05 01<br />
E-mail dio@mfa.gov.kg<br />
Tajikistan<br />
Makhmadsharif Khakdodov<br />
Deputy Minister<br />
Ministry of Industry<br />
Rudaki ave. 80, Dushanbe<br />
Tel +992 372 21 55 94<br />
E-mail envsec.tj@mail.ru<br />
Luqmon Isomatov<br />
Head of UN Department<br />
Ministry of Foreign Affairs<br />
Rudaki ave. 42, Dushanbe 734051<br />
Tel. +992 372 21 07 34<br />
Fax +992 372 21 02 59<br />
E-mail luqmon@umomfa.tajik.net<br />
Uzbekistan<br />
Timur Tillyaev<br />
Head of Legal-Ecological Department<br />
State Committee for Nature Protection<br />
99, Amir Temur ave., Tashkent, 700084<br />
Tel: +998 71 135 78 64<br />
Fax: +998 71 135 16 65<br />
E-mail info@uznature.uz<br />
Ildar Shigabuddinov (contact)<br />
Head of Department of UN and international political<br />
organizations, Ministry of Foreign Affairs<br />
9, Uzbekistan ave., Tashkent<br />
Tel./Fax +998 71 139 18 05<br />
E-mail ildars@yahoo.com<br />
Kazakhstan<br />
Alexander Bragin<br />
Chief of department of legal policy and interna-
Mr. Ilia Imnadze<br />
Second Secretary<br />
Department of International Organizations<br />
4 Chitadze Str.<br />
Tbilisi 0118, Georgia<br />
Ministry of Foreign Affairs<br />
Tel: + 995 32284620<br />
Fax: +995 33284678<br />
iimnadze@mfa.gov.ge<br />
45<br />
tional cooperation<br />
Ministry for environmental protection<br />
Ministries house, Block A<br />
Astana, Kazakhstan<br />
Tel: + 7 3172 740839<br />
Fax: +7 3172 740818<br />
a_bragin@nature.kz<br />
Turkmenistan<br />
Timur Berkeliev<br />
Repina St. 8a, apt 12<br />
744005 Ashgabat Turkmenistan<br />
tel: +993 12 39 86 84<br />
mobile: +993 66 32 83 57<br />
email: berkeliev@gmail.com
ANNEX 4 <strong>ENVSEC</strong> contact directory<br />
OSCE, Office of the Co-ordinator of OSCE Economic and Environmental Activities, Kärntner<br />
Ring 5-7, A1010 Vienna, Austria, Telephone: +43-1 514 36 0 Fax: 43 1 51436 96<br />
Baltes, Marc +431 514 36 742 marc.baltes@osce.org<br />
Daussa, Raül +431 514 36 237 raul.daussa@osce.org<br />
Nordström, Saba +431 514 36 175 saba.nordstrom@osce.org<br />
Snoy , Bernard +431 514 36 525 bernard.snoy@osce.org<br />
Swalley, David +431 514 36 913 david.swalley@osce.org<br />
Country missions and offices: please see www.osce.org<br />
UNDP RBEC Bratislava Regional Centre, Grosslingova 35, 811 09 Bratislava, Slovak Republic,<br />
Telephone: +421 (2) 59337 111, Fax: +421 (2) 59337 450<br />
Kadyrzhanova, Inkar +7 327 258 26 42 inkar.kadyrzhanova@undp.org<br />
Martonakova, Henrieta<br />
+421 2 59337 411 henrieta.martonakova@undp.org<br />
Slay, Ben +421 2 59337 444 ben.slay@undp.org<br />
Svedberg, Peter +421 2 59337 219 peter.svedberg@undp.org<br />
Country missions: please see http://europeandcis.undp.org;<br />
http://www.undp.org/regions/europe/<br />
UNEP<br />
Regional Office for Europe, 15, chemin des Anémones, CH-1219 Châtelaine, Geneva,<br />
Telephone: +41229178279, Fax: +41 229178024<br />
Denisov, Nickolai +41 22 917 8281 nickolai.denisov@unep.ch<br />
Leone, Gaetano +41 22 917 8871 gaetano.leone@unep.ch<br />
Novikov, Viktor +47 3703 5707 viktor.novikov@grida.no<br />
Palosaari, Marika +41 22 917 8779 marika.palosaari@unep.ch<br />
Schlingemann, Frits +41 22 917 8291/8276 frits.schlingemann@unep.ch<br />
Simonett, Otto +41 22 917 78342 otto.simonett@unep.ch<br />
UNEP Vienna – ISCC, Room: JOE 25, Vienna International Center, PO Box 500, A 1400 Vienna,<br />
Austria, Telephone: + 431 26060 4545 Fax: +43 1 260 60 6730<br />
Beronja, Jelena +431 260 60 44 21 jelena.beronja@unvienna.org<br />
Egerer, Harald +431 260 60 4545 harald.egerer@unvienna.org<br />
Regional Environmental Center for Central and Eastern Europe, Ady Endre ut 9-11, 2000<br />
Szentendre, Hungary, Telephone: +36 26 504 000, Fax: +36 26 311 294<br />
Stec, Stephen +36 26 504 000 sstec@rec.org<br />
Szigeti Bonifert, Marta +36 26 504 000 mbonifert@rec.org<br />
Country offices please see: www.rec.org/REC/Introduction/CountryOffices<br />
UNECE Environment, Housing and Land Management Division, Palais des Nations<br />
CH-1211 Geneva 10, Switzerland, Telephone: +41-22-917 23 96, Fax: +41-22-917 06 21<br />
Barlund, Kaj +41 22 917 23 70 kaj.barlund@unece.org<br />
Libert, Bo +41 22-917 23 96 bo.libert@unece.org<br />
NATO Programme for Security Through Science, NATO Public Diplomacy Division, Bd. Leopold<br />
III, B-1110 Brussels, Belgium, Telephone: +322 707 4520, Fax +32 2 707 4232<br />
DeWispelaere, Chris +322 707 4620 chris.dewispelaere@hq.nato.int<br />
Kaffenberger, Walter +322 707 4520 kaffenberger.walter@ hq.nato.int<br />
Michaelis, Susanne +322 707 4520 michaelis.susanne@hq.nato.int<br />
46