The sports pages - Cranbrook School
The sports pages - Cranbrook School
The sports pages - Cranbrook School
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Debating<br />
Report<br />
CAS Debating 2012<br />
Team Rd 4 Win Loss<br />
1st III L 2 1<br />
2nd III L 2 1<br />
3rd III W 3 1<br />
10A W 2 2<br />
10B L 2 2<br />
9A L 1 3<br />
9B L 2 2<br />
8A W 2 2<br />
8B W 3 1<br />
7A L 1 3<br />
7B W 2 2<br />
Total 22 20<br />
CAS Round 4 – <strong>Cranbrook</strong> vs. St Aloysius’<br />
(home)<br />
7s topic: That we should make outdoor<br />
physical activities compulsory in schools<br />
7A team (negative): Louis Shapiro, Jasper<br />
Stockley and Tim Bassett<br />
7B team (affirmative): Charlie Fine, Alexander<br />
Nettleton and Ben Harvey<br />
Our last home debate for 2012 was very<br />
exciting! Negating the night’s topic, the 7As<br />
attacked St Aloysius’ arguments as fiercely<br />
as possible. Despite shredding the first<br />
opposing speaker’s claims and putting up<br />
strong subsequent rebuttals the debate<br />
unfortunately went to our visitors due to<br />
their strong model.<br />
Jasper Stockley<br />
<strong>The</strong> 7Bs had a successful debate. Ben Harvey<br />
spoke about how sport prevents obesity<br />
in students, and Alexander Nettleton<br />
and Charlie Fine spoke about Olympic<br />
champions – like our very own Steve<br />
Solomon – ultimately coming from schools<br />
that actively support compulsory sport. <strong>The</strong><br />
strength of these arguments ensured our<br />
win. It was a great team effort!<br />
Philip Arndt<br />
8s topic: That schools should have the<br />
right to access their students’ social media<br />
accounts<br />
8A team (Negative) Sam Feitelberg, Hugo<br />
Hughes and Richard Frost.<br />
8B team (Affirmative) Robert McNamara, Ben<br />
Clarke and Ben Little.<br />
4 Term 3 Week 5<br />
From top: THOMAS MAHONY, STEPHEN CHRISTODOULOU AND CHARLIE DONALD IN BRIEFING WITH COACH,<br />
NATHAN ADLER; SENIOR BOYS COME TO SUPPORT THE 1ST III<br />
9s topic: That schools should have the<br />
right to access their students’ social media<br />
accounts<br />
9A team (negative): Hal Crichton-Standish,<br />
Jack Fagan and Nicholas Lamens<br />
9B team (affirmative): Laurence Nettleton,<br />
Sam Atkinson and Matthew Chard<br />
Forget your petty Friday night teenage<br />
gatherings; CAS debating is the real deal!<br />
Fervently negating the topic, first speaker<br />
Jack Fagan outlined the negative impacts<br />
on invading privacy. Hal Crichton-Standish<br />
attacked from a moral standpoint and<br />
Nicholas Lamens surveyed the potential<br />
personal and social damage caused by such<br />
a policy. Despite an unfortunate loss, the 9As<br />
fought their hardest all season and left the<br />
battlefield better-equipped for Round 5.<br />
Hal Crichton-Standish<br />
10s topic: That prisoners have too many<br />
privileges<br />
10A team (negative): Tom Mills, Matthew<br />
<strong>The</strong>ophile and Jake Widjaya<br />
10B team (affirmative): Stephen<br />
Christoloudou, Charlie Donald and Tom<br />
Gibson<br />
<strong>The</strong> 10As put on a fantastic debate. Going<br />
into the debate we were keen to win.<br />
<strong>The</strong> home advantage to us motivated us<br />
throughout the night. <strong>The</strong> topic was a tough<br />
one to debate but we were able to attack<br />
the opposition’s model, where they failed to<br />
establish what prisoner privileges actually<br />
exist. After much battering of their case<br />
we emerged the winners of the debate.<br />
However, the adjudicator suggested we<br />
need to improve the defence of our own<br />
arguments.<br />
Jake Widjaya<br />
3rd III topic: That Western countries<br />
should not deliver aid through faithbased<br />
charities<br />
Team (affirmative): Luke Ditchfield, Lewis<br />
Cooksley and Josh Barry