25.04.2013 Views

Download this report as a 94-page PDF - USGS

Download this report as a 94-page PDF - USGS

Download this report as a 94-page PDF - USGS

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Tucson and may be archived at another location<br />

(most likely Western Archaeological Conservation<br />

Center, Tucson; Andy Hubbard, pers. comm.).<br />

This redundancy in data archiving is to ensure that<br />

these valuable data are never lost. Along with the<br />

archived data we will include copies of the<br />

original dat<strong>as</strong>heets and a guide to filling them out.<br />

This information, in conjunction with the text of<br />

<strong>this</strong> <strong>report</strong>, should enable future researchers to<br />

repeat our work.<br />

Verification and Assessment of Results<br />

Photographic Vouchers<br />

Whenever possible we documented vertebrate<br />

species with analog color photographs. Many of<br />

these photos show detail on coloration or other<br />

characteristics of visual appearance, and they may<br />

serve <strong>as</strong> educational tools for the park staff and<br />

visitors. Photographs will be archived with other<br />

data <strong>as</strong> described above.<br />

Specimen Vouchers<br />

With proper documentation, specimen vouchers<br />

are the most indisputable form of evidence of<br />

species occurrence. For plants, we searched the<br />

University of Arizona Herbarium for existing<br />

specimens from Fort Bowie NHS (see Appendix<br />

A for results), but we collected herbarium<br />

3<br />

specimens whenever flowers or fruit were present<br />

on plants in the field (Appendix A). All specimens<br />

that we collected were accessioned into the<br />

University of Arizona Herbarium. Although we did<br />

not collect specimen vouchers for vertebrates, we<br />

searched for existing vouchers from Fort Bowie<br />

NHS in records from 23 natural history museums<br />

(Table 1.1 see Appendix E for results).<br />

Assessing Inventory Completeness<br />

We evaluated inventory completeness by (1)<br />

examining the rate at which new species were<br />

recorded in successive surveys (i.e., species<br />

accumulation curves; Hayek and Buz<strong>as</strong> 1997) and<br />

(2) by comparing the list of species we recorded<br />

with a list of species likely to be present b<strong>as</strong>ed on<br />

previous research and/or expert opinion. For all<br />

species accumulation curves, we randomized the<br />

order of the sampling periods to break up clusters of<br />

new detections that resulted from temporal<br />

conditions (e.g., monsoon initiation) independent of<br />

cumulative effort. We used the computer program<br />

Species Richness and Diversity III (Pisces<br />

Conservation Ltd., IRC House, Pennington,<br />

Lymington, UK) to calculate species accumulation<br />

curves where the order of samples w<strong>as</strong> shuffled >10<br />

times and the average is plotted, thereby smoothing<br />

the curve.<br />

Table 1.1. Museums that were queried in 1998 for vertebrate specimen vouchers with “Arizona” and “Fort Bowie<br />

National Historic Site” in the collection location. Collections in bold-faced type had specimens from Fort Bowie NHS. See<br />

Appendix E for results.<br />

Collection Collection cont.<br />

Chicago Academy of Sciences Peabody Museum, Yale University<br />

Cincinnati Museum of Natural History & Science Saguaro National Park<br />

Cornell Vertebrate Collections, Cornell University Strecker Museum, Baylor University, Waco<br />

George M<strong>as</strong>on University (Fairfax, VA) Tex<strong>as</strong> Cooperative Wildlife Collection<br />

Marjorie Barrick Museum, University of Nevada-L<strong>as</strong> Veg<strong>as</strong> University of Arizona<br />

Michigan State University Museum (E<strong>as</strong>t Lansing) University of Tex<strong>as</strong>, Arlington<br />

Milwaukee Public Museum University of Illinois, Champaign-Urbana<br />

Museum of Tex<strong>as</strong> Tech University University of Colorado Museum<br />

Museum of Vertebrate Zoology, University of California, Berkeley Walnut Canyon National Monument, Arizona<br />

Museum of Life Sciences, Louisiana State University, Shreveport Western Archaeological and Conservation Center, Tucson<br />

North Carolina State Museum of Natural Sciences<br />

Oklahoma Museum of Natural History, Norman<br />

Wupatki National Monument, Arizona

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!