House of Representatives
House of Representatives
House of Representatives
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Monday, 3 June 2013 HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES 11<br />
an education union case as being 'not that <strong>of</strong> an<br />
intervener, but that <strong>of</strong> a partisan'.<br />
The interaction between labour costs and job growth<br />
is something that the Fair Work Commission is<br />
required to consider under Labor's laws but, even the<br />
member for Batman, in his former capacity as the<br />
Minister for Tourism, publicly observed that penalty<br />
rates were a major obstacle for the industry in these<br />
difficult times, when he said:<br />
I hope the bench <strong>of</strong> Fair Work Australia has given proper<br />
regard to the input <strong>of</strong> the tourism industry in this context<br />
because I understand that is the key issue to industry at this<br />
point in time.<br />
This is about fairness and sustainability and, as the<br />
Treasurer noted, talking about supporting jobs and<br />
growth, you cannot have a job if the employer shuts the<br />
shop because the cost for that particular business<br />
owner are too high. Onerous workplace conditions<br />
impose great burdens on businesses, particularly in<br />
regional Australia.<br />
Small towns have beautified their streetscapes,<br />
thanks to considerable investment by local councils,<br />
and they encourage weekend visitors, but, the way we<br />
are going, it is getting harder and harder to get a cup <strong>of</strong><br />
c<strong>of</strong>fee or a meal on a Saturday or Sunday or indeed a<br />
weekday night because <strong>of</strong> onerous workplace wages<br />
and conditions forcing the owners to work seven days<br />
and seven nights a week rather than employing people<br />
as they would have done in the past. If they go down<br />
that path, they are going to be working many, many<br />
hours. Their families miss out—because a lot <strong>of</strong> them<br />
have children—but, if they employ people and have to<br />
pay the higher and higher penalty rates, they simply<br />
cannot make a pr<strong>of</strong>it. Therefore what is the point <strong>of</strong><br />
working for so many hours and paying the higher<br />
electricity bills due to the carbon tax and higher fuel<br />
costs—depending what business they own—due to the<br />
carbon tax, with all the other burdens that are being<br />
forced on them and prices which are going up and up<br />
under this Labor government?<br />
This is about jobs and growth, and certainly nothing<br />
this government has done has ever helped those two<br />
important aspects <strong>of</strong> the economy: jobs and growth.<br />
We need to be very mindful <strong>of</strong> this particular<br />
resolution because what we need is fairness and equity<br />
and businesses to stay open. (Time expired)<br />
Mr LAURIE FERGUSON (Werriwa) (10:51):<br />
Whilst the actual resolution deals with penalty rates,<br />
the previous speaker had recourse to significant<br />
bombast and rhetoric about the state <strong>of</strong> the overall<br />
economy. Therefore it is necessary to put on the public<br />
record a few realities. In fact, unemployment in this<br />
country, for instance, at 5.6 per cent, is strongly at<br />
variance with the Europe-wide average <strong>of</strong> 12 per cent<br />
and the United States rate <strong>of</strong> 7.6. He talked about<br />
inflation in this country and the pressures that is<br />
CHAMBER<br />
creating. He did not seem too concerned when the rate<br />
<strong>of</strong> inflation under the Howard government was 6.75<br />
per cent, in contrast to the 2.75 per cent today. He did<br />
not say that the economy is 13 times larger than it was<br />
overall when this government came to power. He did<br />
not refer to the reality that the overall tax impost in this<br />
country is 22.2 per cent <strong>of</strong> GDP, as opposed to 24 per<br />
cent under Howard. Those are a few realities out there.<br />
But the main axiom he came against was the<br />
question <strong>of</strong> the carbon tax, trying to somehow imply<br />
that the thing that really does affect people in this<br />
country, energy cost increases, is something<br />
overwhelmingly to do with the carbon tax. The fact <strong>of</strong><br />
political life, the truth, is that the reason that energy<br />
prices are moving significantly in this country is that<br />
state governments, Labor and Liberal, disregarded the<br />
need to build infrastructure for decades, pretending to<br />
the Australian people that cheap energy could occur<br />
forever. Unfortunately, it has come home to roost.<br />
Infrastructure has to be renewed, it has to be replaced,<br />
and it is costing people a significant amount <strong>of</strong> money<br />
these days.<br />
But the resolution before us today deals with the<br />
question <strong>of</strong> penalty rates. When I go to the Liverpool<br />
Titans football games or go to the South-West Sydney<br />
Tigers Aussie rules or the Campbelltown City rugby<br />
league games, I see a reality <strong>of</strong> this society: people<br />
working on weekends to keep society going, to keep<br />
the community having the option for people to play<br />
sports. When I go to the Country Women's<br />
Association, I see organisations that are struggling. In<br />
regard to RSL service organisations, Rotary and Lions<br />
around this country, we all know the truth that they are<br />
struggling because people have no confidence that each<br />
week they will be available, that they will be able to be<br />
there, that they will not be on call 24 hours a day for<br />
work and that they will not be required to work every<br />
weekend. That is a reality.<br />
Penalty rates are about compensating people for the<br />
loss <strong>of</strong> family life, the fact that they cannot be with<br />
their children going to sport on Saturdays and Sundays,<br />
that they cannot be sure that they can do those<br />
sidelines, that they cannot be referees and umpires and<br />
people on the grounds, that they cannot help the ethnic<br />
school on the weekend at the local public school, that<br />
they cannot be involved in community radio because <strong>of</strong><br />
the impact <strong>of</strong> the workforce changes in this country.<br />
That is what penalty rates are about. They are about<br />
compensating people for the loss <strong>of</strong> family life, for the<br />
loss <strong>of</strong> networks with their friends, their community,<br />
their society, their suburb.<br />
And for those opposite, quite frankly, despite the<br />
attempt to be a small target before the next election, to<br />
pretend that nothing is going to change, the reality is as<br />
we have seen in Queensland. They came to power<br />
against an unpopular government that people wanted to