15.08.2013 Views

Briefing - BVCA admin

Briefing - BVCA admin

Briefing - BVCA admin

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Pe and the<br />

Social Sector<br />

Autumn 2011<br />

<strong>Briefing</strong><br />

LP Outlook<br />

Q&A with<br />

Michelle Kathryn<br />

essomé<br />

CeO, AVCA<br />

Special international Edition<br />

Sponsored by


Canaccord Genuity is proud to sponsor<br />

The <strong>BVCA</strong> 2011 Year of Venture Campaign<br />

IDEAS ARE THE ENGINE OF OUR BUSINESS<br />

Canaccord Genuity is a leading independent financial services firm<br />

committed to fostering the entrepreneurial economy by bringing<br />

corporate and institutional clients a unique perspective on global<br />

investment opportunities.<br />

More information is available at www.canaccordgenuity.com<br />

Canaccord Genuity Inc., Member FINRA/SIPC.<br />

Canaccord Genuity Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Authority and is a member of the LSE<br />

Canaccord Genuity Corp. is a Member of CIPF and IIROC.


Autumn 2011<br />

Contributors<br />

Sir Ronald Cohen, Michael Queen,<br />

Sidney Chameh, Paul Perpère, Antony<br />

Collins, Sarah E Alexander, Dörte<br />

Höppner, Mahendra Swarup, Richard<br />

Roach, Toshihisa Adachi, Jeanette<br />

Lepper, Rory O’Sullivan, Sachin Date,<br />

Luis Antonio Marquez Heine, David<br />

Collinson, Edmund Tyler, William<br />

Holder, Neal Greer and Michelle<br />

Kathryn Essomè<br />

Contact us<br />

1st Floor North, Brettenham House<br />

Lancaster Place, London WC2E 7EN<br />

T: +44 (0)20 7420 1800<br />

F: +44 (0)20 7420 1801<br />

E: bvca@bvca.co.uk<br />

bvca.co.uk<br />

editor<br />

Tom Allchorne<br />

+44 (0)20 7420 1807<br />

research<br />

Colin Ellis<br />

+44 (0)20 7420 1830<br />

Commercial Opportunities<br />

Leon de Bono<br />

+44 (0)20 7420 1853<br />

events<br />

Kristina Gauzel<br />

+44 (0)20 7420 1824<br />

Training<br />

Lisa Simpson<br />

+44 (0)20 7420 1823<br />

Contents<br />

Special international edition<br />

Brazil 7<br />

france 9<br />

emerging markets 13<br />

europe 14<br />

india 15<br />

Japan 18<br />

MenA 19<br />

Mexico 23<br />

China 29<br />

Q&A with Michelle Kathryn essomé, CeO, AVCA 30<br />

editor’s note 3<br />

Private equity and the social sector 5<br />

A world of opportunity 5<br />

LP outlook 9<br />

Choosing the right funding partner 16<br />

Technology M&A in 2011 20<br />

exits and returns 21<br />

The pensions risk 24<br />

responsible investment 26<br />

The Takeover Code 28<br />

Private equity and the g20 32<br />

Public policy update 33<br />

Market statistics 34<br />

Transaction tracker 37<br />

reserve your copy of the next bvca<strong>Briefing</strong><br />

To guarantee you receive your copy of the next edition please email<br />

Rob Hammond, rhammond@bvca.co.uk<br />

To advertise in the next bvca<strong>Briefing</strong> please contact Leon de Bono,<br />

+44 (0)20 7420 1853 / ldebono@bvca.co.uk<br />

Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong> 1


More than 100 specialist private equity lawyers.<br />

Eleven offices around the world.<br />

Thirty years advising the industry on funds, deals and strategy.<br />

SJ Berwin is not just a supporter of private equity.<br />

We’re at its core.<br />

Get quick updates from SJ Berwin’s private equity<br />

team on Twitter @SJBerwinPE<br />

www.sjberwin.com<br />

Berlin Brussels Dubai Frankfurt Hong Kong London Madrid Milan Munich Paris Shanghai<br />

SJ Berwin LLP is a limited liability partnership registered in England no OC313176<br />

20660


editor<br />

Tom<br />

Allchorne<br />

Editor’s note<br />

Welcome to the Summit 2011 edition of the <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong>. With our<br />

flagship event taking on a distinctly international flavour this year, this<br />

Autumn issue follows suit, with articles from a number of our international<br />

association partners, from Brazil and France, to the Middle East & North<br />

Africa, Japan and India.<br />

Private equity and venture capital are today truly global industries. From being concentrated in<br />

Western Europe and North America, we are now seeing markets opening up across the world. The<br />

<strong>BVCA</strong> has developed extensive partnerships with our peers overseas providing <strong>BVCA</strong> members<br />

with access to their markets, and offering our own support and expertise as the global hub of<br />

private equity. Over the last 18 months the <strong>BVCA</strong> has signed Memoranda of Understandings with<br />

fellow associations across the world, and have dedicated programmes of activities with the USA,<br />

Russia, India, China, Brazil, Mexico, the MENA region, and, most recently Africa.<br />

In July the <strong>BVCA</strong>’s CEO Mark Florman was part of a business delegation to Africa organised by<br />

UK Trade & Investment (UKTI) and the UK Department of International Development (DFID).<br />

He joined the Prime Minister David Cameron, Trade Minister Lord Green and the International<br />

Development Secretary, Andrew Mitchell, on an historic visit to the continent, along with 20 other<br />

business leaders, including the CEOs of Virgin, Barclays, Standard Chartered, Diageo, Vodafone,<br />

Waitrose and more.<br />

As part of the trip, and at a ceremony attended by the Prime Minister, in Lagos, Nigeria, Mark signed<br />

a Memorandum of Understanding with Ms. Tokunboh Ishmael on behalf of the African Venture<br />

Capital Association (AVCA), where she is a board member. In this issue you will hear from the new<br />

CEO of AVCA, Michelle Kathryn Essomé, where she outlines her plans for the future and explores<br />

the changing nature of Africa, socially, economically and financially.<br />

You will also read about what investors think of private equity. With this being the last <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong><br />

of 2011, it is only fitting we ask some Limited Partners for their assessment of the year behind us<br />

and what 2012 and beyond holds in store. With difficult market conditions in light of the on-going<br />

Eurozone crisis and volatile capital and currency markets, competition is fierce on the fundraising<br />

trail, and the LPs are putting GPs under greater scrutiny.<br />

Of increasing importance to LPs is environment, social and corporate governance (ESG), and it<br />

is on this topic that the <strong>BVCA</strong> recently conducted a survey, asking <strong>BVCA</strong> members for their<br />

views on responsible investment. The survey found that 63% of respondents thought that active<br />

management of sustainability issues made a company more attractive to investors, and 55%<br />

reported that their LP had asked ESG specific questions over the past two years. See page 26 for a<br />

detailed breakdown of the findings.<br />

This is another example of the positive role private equity is playing in the global economy -<br />

building better, sustainable businesses, creating jobs, fostering innovation and delivering genuine<br />

value creation. With the global economic recovery continuing to stutter, such skills are needed<br />

more than ever.<br />

Tom Allchorne<br />

Editor<br />

tallchorne@bvca.co.uk<br />

Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong> 3


• Concluded every announced pension<br />

insurance buyout over £100 million:<br />

2009, 2010, 2011<br />

• The only insurer to have transacted<br />

a £1 billion pension insurance buyout<br />

Pension Insurance Corporation provides<br />

innovative, bespoke insurance to the trustees<br />

and sponsors of defined benefit pension funds.<br />

Pension Insurance Corporation has become the<br />

market leader by insuring more than 50,000<br />

pensioners from: Cadbury, Alliance Boots, the<br />

London Stock Exchange, Liberty International,<br />

Leyland DAF, Honda, Alitalia and many others.<br />

14 Cornhill, London EC3V 3ND. Telephone: +44 (0)20 7105 2000<br />

Pension Insurance Corporation is part of the Pension Corporation Group. Pension Corporation LLP is a limited partnership registered in England<br />

under registration number: OC316968. Our insurance solutions are provided through Pension Insurance Corporation Ltd, registered in England under<br />

registration number 05706720 which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Authority (FSA FRN: 454345). Both registered offices are<br />

at: 14 Cornhill, London EC3V 3ND.<br />

4 Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong><br />

For further information please contact:<br />

David Collinson or Jay Shah<br />

Co-Heads of Business Origination<br />

020 7105 2000<br />

www.pensioncorporation.com<br />

Risks<br />

transferred,<br />

pensions insured


Comment<br />

When the pioneers of private equity and venture capital set up shop<br />

in the UK in the 1970s and early 1980s, we were met with widespread<br />

scepticism. Venture capital, it was said, wasn’t needed here. The<br />

established industrial and commercial giants who were responsible<br />

for innovation and job creation were thought to be adequately<br />

provided with capital by the stock exchange and the High Street<br />

banks. There was no need for our proposed combination of patient,<br />

active investment and entrepreneurial flair.<br />

Well, we were right and conventional wisdom was wrong. Many of<br />

the commercial and industrial giants of thirty years ago have gone<br />

or survive in radically different and often much-reduced form. Their<br />

positions of eminence have been taken by hi-tech enterprises, many<br />

of them funded by private equity and venture capital.<br />

So when we talk today about introducing private equity and venture<br />

capital to support entrepreneurship in the social sector, we get a far<br />

more receptive hearing. There is no doubt about the opportunity: the<br />

social sector is vast and it is chronically undercapitalised. Once we have<br />

Comment<br />

3i is proud of its British roots. Up until the mid-1980s we invested<br />

almost entirely in UK business and had been doing exactly that since<br />

1945. However, as financial markets became more international, so<br />

did 3i. We saw some great opportunities for investment across the<br />

world and have expanded to take advantage of them. International<br />

growth has been a fundamental driver of our business in recent years<br />

and we now operate in 13 countries across four continents. Today<br />

over three quarters of our investments are outside the UK.<br />

Apart from the obvious benefits to investors in 3i, giving them<br />

access to international opportunities, there are other benefits to<br />

being an international investor. Having people on the ground in the<br />

countries in which we invest means we are much more attuned to<br />

the local market. We find this gives us an advantage, both in sourcing<br />

proprietary deals and during competitive processes, as well as during<br />

Transforming the<br />

social sector<br />

Sir Ronald Cohen<br />

established an environment that includes appropriate tax incentives<br />

and changes to the rules governing both the permitted investments<br />

of charitable trusts and foundations and prudent investment by<br />

institutions, private equity professionals can apply on a large scale<br />

the financial and managerial disciplines, and the unwavering focus<br />

on results, that we have honed over the last three decades. We will<br />

use innovative financing products that will link social outcomes to<br />

financial rewards and connect social entrepreneurs and the capital<br />

markets. One such product, the social impact bond, is already in use.<br />

Social entrepreneurs and social investors are already addressing social<br />

problems. Success is measured by a blend of quantifiable social and<br />

financial returns. The formation of Big Society Capital now gives our<br />

efforts a huge boost. My forecast is that impact capital will transform<br />

the social sector in just the same way that private equity and venture<br />

capital have transformed the commercial sector over the past three<br />

decades. Private equity and venture capital professionals have unique<br />

skills to make this happen. n<br />

A world of<br />

opportunity<br />

Michael Queen, 3i, CEO<br />

the asset management stage of the investment.<br />

Just as important is the international network that our portfolio<br />

companies gain access to. This is how we really drive value – by<br />

opening up markets that firms would otherwise not easily be able to<br />

reach. Take one of our recent realisations - Norma Group, the German<br />

engineering firm which we led to IPO this year - as an example. Over<br />

the period of our investment, international sales increased from 40%<br />

to almost 75% of the total, more than doubling the share that came<br />

from North America and Asia.<br />

Earlier this year we opened an office in Sao Paulo, Brazil. Not only<br />

are we already seeing some excellent opportunities and deal flow<br />

emerging from that office, it is also a great platform to help the<br />

expansion of our other portfolio companies into one of the world’s<br />

fastest growing markets. n<br />

Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong> 5


6 Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong><br />

Annual<br />

Gala Dinner<br />

25 years of celebrating in style...<br />

This December, the <strong>BVCA</strong>’s Annual Gala Dinner will return for its 25th successful year,<br />

bringing together the industry’s most prominent leaders for an exclusive evening of<br />

networking, socialising and entertainment in the heart of London.<br />

Join us as we celebrate the festive season and look forward to the 2012 Olympics<br />

with our distinguished guest speaker Sir Steve Redgrave.<br />

Programme:<br />

19.00 Cocktail reception<br />

20.00 Welcome address & dinner served<br />

22.00 Address by Sir Steve Redgrave CBE<br />

22.30 Complimentary post-dinner bar & entertainment<br />

Capacity for this exclusive occasion is strictly limited; advance booking is essential.<br />

Thursday 1 st December 2011<br />

7pm until late<br />

Dress code: Black tie<br />

The Lawrence Hall<br />

Royal Horticultural Halls<br />

Greycoat Street, London SW1P 2QD<br />

To book, visit www.bvca.co.uk/events<br />

or telephone Tommy Nguyen:<br />

+44 (0)20 7420 1852<br />

Sponsored by


Country<br />

Profile<br />

Brazil<br />

The destination for private equity<br />

and venture capital investments<br />

Sidney Chameh, Chairman of the Brazilian Private Equity and Venture Capital Association (A<strong>BVCA</strong>P)<br />

In the past few years the Brazilian private equity and venture<br />

industry has grown and most importantly maintained its<br />

attractiveness on the global scene. Local players are increasing in<br />

size and numbers and international players are setting up shops in<br />

the country.<br />

Fundraising in the region continues to have a positive outlook<br />

for the years ahead with estimates showing that Latin American<br />

private equity and venture capital could raise at least US$10bn in<br />

2012. According to the Latin American Venture Capital Association,<br />

private equity and venture capital fundraising in the region grew<br />

59% to US$4.9bn in the first half of this year compared to the<br />

same period in 2010, and Brazil accounts for the vast majority of it.<br />

In fact, in the first three quarters of 2011, more than US$6.2bn has<br />

been raised in Brazil alone. In spite of warnings over the possibility<br />

of overheating, investors have showed no signs of any decrease in<br />

their interest. The reasons for this continued interest vary but the<br />

country´s continued growth, especially with the difficult economic<br />

situation and fiscal adjustments taking place in the United States<br />

and Europe, has put Brazil in an advantageous position.<br />

Brazil is also enjoying a period of stable employment and a vibrant<br />

and robust domestic consumer market. From 2003 to 2011,<br />

more than 37 million people joined the middle class, which today<br />

represents approximately 54% of the entire population. Sound<br />

governmental policies, a solid legal and regulatory environment<br />

and almost two decades of political stability have also helped to<br />

consolidate Brazil´s position as an attractive destination for new<br />

private equity investments.<br />

According to the recent EMPEA/Coller Survey on the views of<br />

global limited partners on emerging markets private equity, Brazil<br />

has now leapfrogged China as the most attractive destination for<br />

new long-term investments. The PE/VC industry in Brazil not only<br />

has experienced an increase of interest from international limited<br />

partners, but also from its own local investor base. In spite of the<br />

low penetration of private equity and venture capital, which is<br />

about 0.2% of Brazil´s GDP, Brazil has a solid base of local investors<br />

which includes foundations and pension funds, corporate entities<br />

and family offices. With approximately US$300bn in assets<br />

under management (AUM), Brazil´s more than 350 pension<br />

funds play a major role in supporting private equity and venture<br />

capital investments in the local sphere. Around 20 local pension<br />

funds are active investors in the asset class, with the 10 largest<br />

controlling more than 60% of the total pension funds´ assets under<br />

management, or approximately US$180m.<br />

Alongside the many opportunities available, investors who come<br />

to Brazil will also find some constraints that warrant their close<br />

attention. Challenges faced by foreign investors include the lack of<br />

information on the local fund managers and investment specialists,<br />

and the difficulties of hedging for the long term a position in local<br />

currency (Reais) versus the foreigners’ own currency. The high cost<br />

of capital locally and short time horizons on hedging instruments<br />

makes it almost untenable to implement a fully hedged strategy<br />

in local currency, although this is improving as the level of real<br />

interest rates falls and the tenors for hedging instruments extend.<br />

Other burdens investors find in Brazil are the heavy bureaucratic<br />

and tax structures, the infrastructure bottlenecks and the lack of<br />

qualified labor. These and other upcoming challenges from global<br />

sporting events such as the Olympic Games and the World Cup<br />

need to be addressed and resolved for Brazil to benefit fully from<br />

the unique position it has assumed in the global private equity and<br />

venture capital industry. n<br />

Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong> 7


contact one of our advisors to tailor<br />

a bespoke Prestige hospitality programme<br />

for you on: 020 7516 1644 or at:<br />

chris.travers@prestigeticketing.london2012.com<br />

8 Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong><br />

London 2012 official hospitality<br />

IN THE SUMMER OF 2012 THE EYES OF THE WORLD WILL BE ON LONDON<br />

Who will be entertaining your best clients?<br />

To make sure it is you, contact Prestige.<br />

ExcEPTIONa L WORLD-cL a SS HOSPITa LITY<br />

THE BEST caTEg ORY SEaTS<br />

a ONc E - IN-a-LIFETIME E x PERIENc E<br />

THE ONLY HOSPITa LITY I N THE OLYMPIc Pa R k<br />

Prestige Hospitality Pavilion


Country<br />

Profile<br />

france<br />

Bouncing back from<br />

the downturn<br />

Paul Perpere, Managing Director of AFIC, the French private equity association<br />

France has a dynamic SME segment, a strong and sophisticated<br />

framework for private equity transactions and a well-established<br />

infrastructure to successfully achieve critical mass in all private equity<br />

activities. As a result, the French private equity industry today is the<br />

second largest in Europe and is doing well judging by the number of<br />

funds raised, the amounts invested and the number of companies it<br />

funded in 2010. On an annual average basis, 1,450 companies were<br />

funded by the French private equity industry between 2000 and<br />

2010; 80% of which were SMEs and over 30% innovative companies.<br />

Fundraising by French private equity firms in 2010 generated €5bn<br />

and the leading sources of capital were: private individuals and family<br />

offices (27%), government entities (19%), pension funds (12%),<br />

banks (10%) and insurance companies (8%). The majority of the new<br />

funds were French (73%), with 15% from European countries and<br />

12% from the rest of the world.<br />

Last year, investments by French-based private equity firms reached<br />

€6.5bn, almost 60% more than in 2009 (€4.1bn), of which 85% was<br />

invested locally and 15% abroad. The number of companies funded<br />

also grew to reach 1,685 compared to 1,469 in 2009 with 53% of the<br />

total amount invested by the French private equity industry directed<br />

into buyouts. Growth investments, the only category not impacted<br />

by the financial crisis, represented 34%, seed/start-up totalled 10%<br />

and turnaround 1.7%. The total portfolio volume amounted €80bn<br />

at the end of 2010 with the total number of firms in portfolios<br />

exceeding 5 000.<br />

However, due to the uncertain economic conditions throughout<br />

the Eurozone and tightened market conditions for loans to LBO<br />

transactions, which are 50% below 2007 transaction volumes, the<br />

2010 market activity was a far cry from the €10bn invested in 2008.<br />

The economic role of private equity has been heightened ever since<br />

the 2008 financial crisis which led to a credit crunch and drove up<br />

the demand for growth capital from French private equity firms. The<br />

new solvency capital requirements for banks (Basel III) and insurance<br />

companies (Solvency II), both key institutional providers of funds<br />

for private equity firms in Europe, are putting significant stress on<br />

the market and are threatening the financing of the industry as a<br />

whole despite the fact that credit tightening should be encouraging<br />

companies to strengthen their balance sheets. n<br />

Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong> 9


Investor<br />

Outlook<br />

10 Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong><br />

Listening<br />

to the LPs<br />

The uncertain economy has made Limited Partners more selective over their private equity<br />

managers. Antony Collins looks at the evolving expectations for General Partners going into 2012<br />

It was a troubling summer for investors - ratings agencies slashed<br />

national investment grades, capital and currency markets slumped<br />

and billion dollar country bail-outs were negotiated. Little surprise that<br />

Limited Partners (LPs) are now assessing closely where and with whom<br />

to put their much-sought after capital.<br />

“LPs on a macro level currently have concerns about the different<br />

economic situations,” says Mounir Guen, CEO of MVision Private<br />

Equity Advisers. “In the US there was the ratings downgrade while<br />

places like Switzerland, Brazil and Australia have experienced<br />

currency movement. In Europe there is, of course, anxiety over a<br />

number of member states. As such, investors are reflecting on what<br />

is going on, what countries to invest in and how they are positioned<br />

in the market.”<br />

Before the summer, things looked positive. Coller Capital’s Global<br />

Private Equity Barometer Summer 2011 report predicted a boom in<br />

activity. Almost two thirds (64%) of LPs were expecting “large growth”<br />

in private equity exits while only 12% intended to decrease allocations.<br />

The research, though, was undertaken in March and April 2011, long<br />

before the financial hiccups. Since then, LPs have swapped optimism<br />

for pragmatism.<br />

William Gilmore, head of private equity at Scottish Widows Investment<br />

Partnership (SWIP) asks: “Lots of LPs have enjoyed decent distributions<br />

this year but the markets are volatile so the question is how much of<br />

these distributions can be re-invested? The latest valuations were<br />

made in June, before the turmoil in the markets, so we may have to<br />

wait until the end of the year to see how valuations and allocations<br />

stand. At the moment, many LPs are somewhat in limbo.”<br />

natural selection<br />

In such uncertain times, LPs require stability, which means more<br />

pressure is being put on General Partners (GPs). Investors are now<br />

analysing managers’ performance closer than ever before deciding<br />

where and with whom to invest.<br />

“LPs are looking for GPs that are well established, experienced across<br />

cycles, and have generated cash on cash returns through a number of<br />

exits and part of a stable team,” explains Andrew Bentley, a partner at<br />

Campbell Lutyens. “LPs also expect GPs to demonstrate a thorough<br />

understanding of, and influence over, its companies that result in real<br />

value growth.”<br />

The prevalence of secondary buyouts (SBOs), which unquote claimed<br />

made up 52% of all European deals in the first half of 2011, is an<br />

example of what is making LPs more selective. Investors have started<br />

to find that one fund in which they are invested can end up selling an<br />

asset to another fund in which they also hold a stake.<br />

While the performance of SBOs is not necessarily worse than primary<br />

buyouts (most assets with a 10-year cycle offer plenty of opportunity<br />

for development), it does mean paying out fees and carried interest<br />

to hold the same asset at a higher valuation. John Gripton, head of<br />

investment management Europe at Capital Dynamics, states: “Often<br />

there is still plenty of mileage left for certain assets to be further<br />

developed and other GPs can see the remaining potential. Our concern<br />

is that managers who are only working on secondary deals may have<br />

limited sourcing capabilities.”<br />

As such, private equity managers need to prove strong sourcing<br />

capabilities and a decent portfolio. Choosing the right GPs has<br />

become more important which, in turn, has meant managers have to<br />

work harder to entice investors.<br />

“There is lots of talk among LPs about the need to focus down the<br />

number of GP firms they commit to,” adds Alan Mckay, CEO of<br />

Hermes GPE. “A significant number of major LPs consider their private<br />

equity programmes too diverse for the decade ahead and I think this<br />

will result in a greater concentration of capital into the best managers.”<br />

Gripton states that LPs are “digging a lot deeper into the track record<br />

of a manager”. He adds: “The performance of individual funds can be<br />

influenced if the investment phase commenced within six-to-nine<br />

months either side of the crisis. The overall performance for funds<br />

raised at this time will not always give a clear indication of the quality<br />

of a manager.”<br />

Indeed, management fees are becoming tighter too as GPs, especially<br />

in larger funds, offer discounts to attract interest. It was reported that<br />

BC Partners and Cinven issued reductions of 5% on fees for the first<br />

close of their recent, well-received fundraisings.<br />

invested development<br />

Robert Coke, team head of absolute return and buyouts at Wellcome<br />

Trust, believes that LP priorities are currently GPs who do not overuse<br />

leverage but seek top line growth: “That implies sector specific and<br />

emerging markets strategies, as well as more mid-market funds.”


LPs are looking for GPs that are well established, experienced<br />

across cycles, and have generated cash on cash returns<br />

through a number of exits and part of a stable team<br />

Peers agree. The desire amongst LPs is to target more managers<br />

in sub-regional or local funds to complement the more diverse<br />

portfolios offered by the bigger players.<br />

“I think the market is moving away from pan-regional funds,<br />

operating in the upper/mid-market, and towards more countryspecific<br />

funds targeting the lower mid-market,” says Mackay. “This<br />

is the case in Europe and Asia where investments by local funds can<br />

more easily secure financing from local banks.”<br />

Turkey is one jurisdiction high on the LPs’ agenda. A young<br />

population, stable political situation, strong economy and tight trade<br />

links with the EU means that dedicated expertise for the country<br />

provides a different angle than a pan-regional fund can offer. LPs are<br />

quick to stress it is not an “either or” option.<br />

“The larger European funds will still play a role in terms of helping to<br />

back larger deals so there will be a combined role,” William Gilmore<br />

comments.<br />

For emerging markets though, the pool of GPs is not as deep. The US,<br />

for instance, has about two and a half times more GPs than Europe<br />

and that figure is drastically smaller for less-developed private equity<br />

centres.<br />

“Capital Dynamics has always had country fund exposure but the<br />

general market is moving in that direction now as well,” Gripton<br />

concurs. “It is easy for an LP to find their way to an international<br />

large LBO fund, but finding a good fund in places such as Italy or<br />

Turkey can prove a lot harder.”<br />

The chances of accessing quality GPs become limited depending on<br />

which markets the LP is focusing on. This means providing a spread<br />

of investments than can balance the risk of less developed markets<br />

but also help deliver optimum distributions.<br />

“LPs consider balanced exposure,” Guen remarks. “They will want a<br />

couple of GPs at large, international funds, a couple in pan-European<br />

funds and then a selection of sub-regional or country-based GPs.”<br />

ethical call<br />

While these investment priorities hone in on GP performance, there is<br />

a separate issue affecting the selection process: environmental, social<br />

and governance (ESG) matters. ESG has been gaining importance<br />

– questionnaires are now often passed to managers as part of the<br />

investment process – but some LPs believe the concept of responsible<br />

investment is something GPs have been slow in understanding.<br />

“There is a growing desire – especially from LPs – not just for capital<br />

to be invested but for those investments to be in companies<br />

that operate with ethical, environmental and appropriate<br />

social responsibility,” Mackay says. “In the future, private equity<br />

managers will not just need to be good at understanding financial<br />

performance but also corporate responsibility.”<br />

For GPs, who have long been focused on economic and regional<br />

dynamics, it will be a fresh challenge. The growing expectation<br />

is to extend expertise into ethical standards. It would be folly to<br />

suggest ethics is not an existing consideration. Few managers<br />

knowingly invest in companies that deliberately flout international<br />

expectations, such as dumping toxic waste or acts of bribery, but<br />

in the current climate of corporate governance and corporate<br />

legislation, LPs are wary of negative exposure to perceived<br />

unethical practises.<br />

In addition, ethical criteria vary across markets, whether it is the<br />

US, Europe, Africa or Asia. The cultural differences – the school<br />

leaving age in Rwanda is 12, for example – means that accusations<br />

of child labour could be made by UK lobbyists while for local<br />

workers it would be a normal societal expectation.<br />

Gilmore believes that the ESG concept is still in its early stages and<br />

a lot of educating needs to be done, both for LPs and GPs. The<br />

concept is much better understood in listed companies whereas<br />

private equity investors still attempt to select the best managers<br />

based mainly on financial performance. The danger is, for LPs,<br />

that too much red tape or dictation could ultimately lead the GPs<br />

themselves being more selective about investors.<br />

“Even so, LPs like the freedom to invest so have to be careful about<br />

not being are too vocal about ESG to managers as it could prompt<br />

the GPs to source capital elsewhere,” Gilmore warns.<br />

Gripton says that EGS is a complex area and key issues differ with<br />

geography and investment style so LPs and GPs need to take a<br />

“sensible approach”.<br />

“It is a fine line though between tying the hands of GPs and allowing<br />

them the trust and freedom to make appropriate investment<br />

decisions. I am not certain that sending a 30-page questionnaire<br />

is really the best approach.”<br />

The mounting scrutiny – financial and ethical – may prove<br />

disheartening for some managers but LPs are still committed to<br />

private equity and conscious not overwhelm GPs to the point of<br />

souring the relationship.<br />

In future though, GPs may have to become accustomed to even<br />

more detailed inspection by LPs if they are to continue to attract<br />

the biggest investments. n<br />

Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong> 11


Investing in training,<br />

enhancing returns<br />

Training and Professional Development 2011–2012<br />

Advanced Evaluating Management Teams<br />

08–09 November 2011, 13–14 June 2012<br />

Advanced PA/EA<br />

07–08 February 2012, 23–24 October 2012<br />

Best Practice Financial Modelling<br />

28–29 November 2011, 18–19 April 2012, 17–18 September 2012<br />

Finance in Private Equity<br />

11–12 June 2012<br />

Foundation<br />

14–18 November 2011, 14–18 May 2012, 05–09 November 2012<br />

Introduction to Private Equity<br />

22–23 November 2011, 20–21 March 2012, 23–24 May 2012,<br />

18–19 September 2012, 12–13 November 2012<br />

Investment Foundation<br />

12–14 March 2012<br />

Investor Relations and Fundraising NEW<br />

23 November 2011<br />

Legal Agreements in Private Equity<br />

06–07 March 2012, 04–05 September 2012<br />

Non–Executive Directors<br />

22–23 May 2012, 30–31 October 2012<br />

Skills of Negotiating<br />

21–23 February 2012, 19–21 June 2012,<br />

11–13 September 2012, 20–22 November 2012<br />

Steering Value Creation<br />

30 April–01 May 2012<br />

12 Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong><br />

NEW Personal Development Portfolio<br />

Approaches to Cost Management & Reduction<br />

24 April 2012, 15 November 2012<br />

Assertiveness & Influencing Techniques<br />

26 April 2012, 27 November 2012<br />

Effective Forecasting and Budgeting<br />

8 March 2012, 19 September 2012<br />

Effective Leadership<br />

27 June 2012, 28 November 2012<br />

Finance for the Non-Financial Manager<br />

20–21 March 2012, 24–25 October 2012<br />

The Independent NED<br />

7–8 February 2012, 30–31 October 2012<br />

Pitch Perfect Presentations<br />

29 March 2012, 16 October 2012<br />

Professional Networking Masterclass<br />

3 July 2012, 4 December 2012<br />

The Newly Appointed Manager<br />

16–17 May 2012, 30–31 October 2012<br />

15%<br />

DISCouNT<br />

on all training<br />

courses booked<br />

before 21 December<br />

2011 when quoting<br />

‘SUM11’<br />

Visit www.bvca.co.uk/training to book<br />

or contact the <strong>BVCA</strong> Training team:<br />

training@bvca.co.uk +44 (0)20 7420 1800


Country<br />

Profile<br />

Looking for the<br />

growth markets<br />

of the future<br />

Sarah e. Alexander, President and CEO of the Emerging Markets Private Equity Association (EMPEA)<br />

Emerging markets private equity has become and will remain core<br />

to investor portfolios. Investors recognize the simple truth that<br />

faster-growing emerging markets hold greater return potential<br />

than developed markets.<br />

Improvements in fiscal and monetary policies, rapid economic<br />

growth, growing middle classes accustomed to rising standards<br />

of living, and the emergence of sophisticated local private<br />

equity fund managers have all contributed to emerging markets’<br />

ascendance within the PE landscape. From only 4% of total global<br />

PE fundraising in 2004, emerging markets’ share tripled to almost<br />

12% in 2010. EMPEA’s annual LP surveys indicate that emerging<br />

markets’ share of allocations will keep growing, with 2011 survey<br />

respondents predicting a rise from 11-15% today to 16-20% by<br />

2013. Fundraising for emerging markets-dedicated funds is likely<br />

to exceed US$40bn this year, a 75% increase over 2010, compared<br />

to a 15% projected rise year-on-year in the US.<br />

But not all emerging economies have benefited equally from the<br />

growing appetite for private equity in these markets. PE investment<br />

is increasingly concentrated in China, India and Brazil. In 2010,<br />

75% of the private equity capital invested in emerging economies<br />

went to these three countries, up from 50% in the years from<br />

2007-2009. China’s share in particular is swelling; China-dedicated<br />

funds represented 45% of all capital raised for emerging marketsfocused<br />

funds through mid-2011.<br />

Year after year, our annual survey of LPs points to investors’ desire<br />

for greater exposure to high-growth markets as the number one<br />

reason behind emerging markets’ rising share within allocations.<br />

While China, Brazil and India consistently sit atop our survey’s list<br />

of most attractive markets for near term GP investment, LPs also<br />

express growing interest in diversifying into Latin America beyond<br />

Brazil, Southeast Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa.<br />

Beyond the macroeconomic<br />

fundamentals, there is a subtle<br />

combination of both demand- and<br />

supply-side factors that work in concert<br />

to draw LP capital to certain markets<br />

Why, then, do such a small number of markets command so much<br />

of the capital?<br />

The reality is that no single country can claim the winning formula<br />

for building a PE market, and no single factor – growth rate,<br />

population size, past returns, number of managers, regulatory<br />

environment – determines LP decision-making. If growth rates were<br />

all that mattered, Qatar, Ghana and Mongolia would be the top<br />

three destinations for LP PE capital in 2011. If population size were<br />

the answer, then Indonesia, which boasts the world’s fourth largest<br />

population, would have drawn investor attention long before 2011.<br />

Pakistan, Nigeria, and Russia in sixth, eighth and ninth place in the<br />

population rankings respectively, would also be priorities.<br />

Instead, beyond the macroeconomic fundamentals, there is a<br />

subtle combination of both demand- and supply-side factors that<br />

work in concert to draw LP capital to certain markets. Enabling<br />

factors include the domestic regulatory architecture and legal<br />

system, the degree of participation from domestic sources<br />

of institutional capital as well as the existence of an active and<br />

organized domestic practitioner community.<br />

EMPEA works at all of these levels in our efforts to help develop the<br />

PE industry across all emerging and developing economies, without<br />

a bias toward destination. We do this at the local market level, for<br />

example, by engaging on regulatory issues – in both developed and<br />

emerging markets – in favor of policies that support the industry’s<br />

growth or at least do no material harm, and by supporting the<br />

local organization of the industry.<br />

We also produce analysis for the<br />

global investor and private equity<br />

community that goes beyond<br />

the headlines – not only putting<br />

China, India and Brazil into<br />

the global context, but also<br />

highlighting the dozens of other<br />

economies where private equity<br />

can play a uniquely valuable<br />

role in financing<br />

economic development<br />

while providing superior<br />

returns to investors<br />

that discover those<br />

opportunities. n<br />

Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong> 13


Country<br />

Profile<br />

14 Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong><br />

europe needs<br />

private equity<br />

Dörte Höppner, Secretary-General, European Private Equity and Venture Capital Association (EVCA)<br />

Our industry has come a long way in recent years. From modest<br />

beginnings in the 1980s, private equity and venture capital is now<br />

a major part of the corporate landscape, with 26,000 investee<br />

companies across Europe. We have also come a long way in<br />

terms of our engagement with stakeholders, our international coordination<br />

and an awareness of our civic duties.<br />

In terms of industry co-ordination, our industry’s Public Affairs<br />

Executive brings together the EVCA, the <strong>BVCA</strong> and other national<br />

associations to agree on the most important decisions affecting<br />

the whole industry at EU-level. This model has been a great<br />

success, affording flexibility to national associations to lobby on<br />

home turf and still be co-ordinated in our messaging in Brussels.<br />

There is also more informal co-operation, such as a joint project<br />

between the <strong>BVCA</strong> and EVCA to refine the language we use to<br />

describe the industry.<br />

Such co-ordination is essential at a time when we face a raft of<br />

new and proposed regulation. Much of it affects our investor<br />

base. There is a general trend for regulation aimed at institutional<br />

investors that encourages short-term investment behaviours, by<br />

prejudicing illiquid assets and pandering to the fetish for instant<br />

access and regular valuations. Pension funds and insurance<br />

companies in Europe have combined assets of some US$40trn,<br />

representing 10% of the financial system. Rules that change their<br />

behaviours will have a massive impact on Europe’s capital flows.<br />

A recent report by the Committee on the Global Financial System<br />

found that the combined impact of a raft of new rules “could<br />

make it more difficult for insurance companies and pension funds<br />

to play their traditional role as global providers of long-term risk<br />

capital and accelerate the shifting of risks to households”.<br />

For insurers, there is Solvency II that will introduce a risk-based<br />

approach to capital requirements that prejudices illiquid assets<br />

including private equity. A similar route may be taken by the<br />

forthcoming revisions to the Pension Fund Directive.<br />

This runs contrary to the broader political goals of increasing<br />

long-term investment in the European economy, eradicating<br />

systemic risk and supporting stable sources of finance for Europe’s<br />

economies and SMEs.<br />

We are working hard at EU level to air these concerns with<br />

policymakers in the same constructive manner that saw the AIFM<br />

Directive voted into law in far better shape than we once feared.<br />

I believe we face a major opportunity to position our industry as a<br />

constructive agent in building Europe’s future. After all, more than<br />

80% of these are SMEs. As such, we have a very important role to<br />

play in the revival of Europe’s fortunes.<br />

This cannot be achieved by trade bodies alone. It cannot be a<br />

top down approach. The whole industry must get engaged, with<br />

integrated stakeholder communications built into the fundraising<br />

and investment process.<br />

Nobody needs reminding of the terrible state Europe finds itself in.<br />

Europe needs political courage to get out of this mess. But after that<br />

it will need a strategy for the future: for growth, productivity and<br />

competitiveness. This won’t come from state bail-outs or hand-outs.<br />

It will come from entrepreneurial activity supported by sources of<br />

committed capital, such as private equity and venture capital.<br />

Parts of our industry didn’t have the greatest reputation going<br />

into the financial crisis, but if you look at our track record through<br />

the downturn, it is clear our model has been not just vindicated<br />

but passed with flying colours. The default rate for private equitybacked<br />

companies is running at around 2%, way below the 6% or<br />

more for the rest of the corporate world.<br />

We have a proven and stress tested investment model that has<br />

a huge amount to offer a Europe and a world in need. Now we<br />

need to spread that message even wider. We at EVCA look forward<br />

to working alongside the <strong>BVCA</strong> and other national private equity<br />

associations over the coming year to do just that. n


Country<br />

Profile<br />

The role of private<br />

equity in the economic<br />

development of india<br />

Mahendra Swarup, President of the Indian Venture Capital Association (IVCA)<br />

To measure the role of private equity (PE) and venture capital<br />

(VC) funds in driving economic development and fostering<br />

entrepreneurship, we need to first understand the avenues into<br />

which PE and VC firms invest. Deals in India can be broadly classified<br />

into the following six types: early/seed stage; growth stage; late stage;<br />

pre-IPO; investment in public companies (PIPE deals); and buyouts.<br />

Late stage and PIPE deals have predominantly accounted for almost<br />

half of the total deal value flowing into India. We are however<br />

seeing significant activity in the early and growth stage space, which<br />

indicate that investors are warming up to the idea of investing in<br />

businesses much earlier in the lifecycle than before and thus helping<br />

to strengthen the entrepreneurial framework in India.<br />

PE and VC funds have invested more than US$58bn into the<br />

economy over the last five years. While this amounts to less than<br />

1% of Indian GDP on average, the compounding effect that PE/VC<br />

capital has on businesses is unparalleled.<br />

Over 2,000 firms in India have benefited directly from PE/<br />

VC funding. Consider the listing of Makemytrip last August on<br />

NASDAQ for example. This was a landmark deal in India’s startup<br />

history and is touted as the game changer for online travel<br />

portals and e-commerce businesses in India. The capital invested<br />

in Makemytrip by SAIF Partners, Helion Venture Partners and Sierra<br />

Ventures has catapulted the company and Indian ecommerce<br />

portals onto the global arena.<br />

Bharti Airtel is an example from the previous decade where<br />

funding played a critical role in its success. In 1999, Warburg Pincus<br />

invested US$300m in Bharti and helped build it into India’s largest<br />

telecom player. There are numerous such success stories across<br />

businesses in India if you analyse the deal space over last ten years.<br />

In addition to monetary benefits, companies that receive PE/VC<br />

capital also see an improvement in their corporate governance,<br />

operational performance, financial decision making, strategy and<br />

growth thought process, adoption of best practices and access to<br />

marquee customers. The upward trend seen in PE/VC investments<br />

in India is an encouraging sign for businesses and entrepreneurs<br />

across the subcontinent.<br />

We are also seeing a gradual shift in the fundamental mindset<br />

of the average Indian with regard to entrepreneurship. India is<br />

moving away from an era where businesses were predominantly<br />

run by families over several generations. Today, first generation<br />

entrepreneurs, with little or no financial backing, are venturing<br />

out to implement business ideas. Even though only a few ideas<br />

manage to get funds from a VC, there is a stronger support system<br />

developing as a result of constant interaction between PE/VC and<br />

entrepreneur communities, and as a result we are seeing higher<br />

quality entrepreneurs and business ideas emerge.<br />

Large business houses that do not have access to low interest<br />

debt capital are also reaching out to PE firms to cover short-term<br />

and long-term fund requirements through late stage or expansion<br />

funding vehicles.<br />

All of the factors mentioned above directly affect the economic<br />

development of India. While there are no tangible yardsticks yet<br />

to measure direct economic contribution of PE/VC funds, the<br />

performance of PE/VC-backed firms and fund exits over the next<br />

decade will help us measure the value that these funds have been<br />

able to create in the Indian economy. n<br />

2006 2007 2008 2009 2010<br />

Indian GDP (in US$bn) 951 1242 1216 1377 1624<br />

PE VC Ivestments (in US$bn) 9 21 15 3 10<br />

PE VC Investments as % of GDP 0.9 1.7 1.2 0.2 0.6<br />

Source: World Bank, RBI<br />

January 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong> 15


Sponsored<br />

Article<br />

Private equity firms investing in businesses with global aspirations have a wider and more complex<br />

range of factors to consider when selecting funding and banking partners, according to richard<br />

roach, managing director of UK financial sponsors at RBS.<br />

With the speed and trajectory of economic recovery remaining<br />

uncertain, UK-based private equity investors are increasingly subjecting<br />

potential funding and banking partners to a greater degree of scrutiny<br />

than might have been the case prior to the financial crisis. The principles<br />

they apply typically broaden when the target company is already a<br />

global player, or if it has ambitious plans for international growth.<br />

This adds a new dimension to the selection procedure. Investors<br />

naturally want reassurance that finance will be made available on<br />

reasonable terms. But beyond that, many of those supporting<br />

buyouts of international organisations want a suite of ongoing<br />

banking services in place, wherever they do business. And they want<br />

access to the same range and quality of services they already receive<br />

in the UK. With new opportunities opening up at an accelerated<br />

pace in Asia Pacific and elsewhere, investors can’t afford to lose<br />

competitive advantage as a result of other private equity firms and<br />

their customers being quicker off the mark.<br />

Case in point: A-gas going (even more) global<br />

Earlier this year, RBS co-led a banking club, supporting a £70m buyout<br />

of A-Gas International by leading mid-market private equity house<br />

LDC, together with the A-Gas management team. The approach<br />

we took, together with our partners at LDC, amply demonstrates<br />

the advantages of a seamless connection between financing an<br />

initial transaction and supporting long-term strategic objectives with<br />

ongoing banking services.<br />

Based in Bristol, A-Gas distributes speciality gases and chemicals for<br />

industrial use in refrigeration, air conditioning, insulation, solvents,<br />

manufacturing and medical sectors, with each business unit enjoying<br />

a strong market position. Since launching in 1993, the company<br />

now has more than 120 staff, based in the UK, Australia and South<br />

Africa, with a growing presence in Asia Pacific and North America –<br />

an attractive proposition for private equity investors. For our part,<br />

A-Gas represented a business that had already been performing<br />

impressively, and looked well-placed for future growth, building on a<br />

well-invested asset base.<br />

16 Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong><br />

Beyond the horizon<br />

Security may be required. Product fees may apply.<br />

On the same page<br />

The RBS structured finance team has a strong track record of working<br />

with global businesses in the industrial and chemicals industries,<br />

something which appealed to Ian Podmore, investment director<br />

at LDC: “It was also a top priority for the deal to be structured in a<br />

way that aligned with our long-term objectives, and those of the<br />

management team at A-Gas,” he says. “Securing funding on this<br />

scale depends on much more than banks just grasping where a<br />

target business sits in its current market. It’s also critical that they can<br />

envisage the same future, and as far ahead as we can.”<br />

Continual changes to already tightening environmental and health<br />

and safety regulations mean businesses like A-Gas are poised to<br />

capitalise on a growing demand for their products and services,<br />

including a rapidly expanding service of reclamation and recycling of<br />

used product. It added up to a smart investment proposition for LDC,<br />

and one for which, having subsequently satisfied our due diligence<br />

criteria, we were happy to scope out debt funding.<br />

Asking the right questions<br />

For buyout transactions to take place smoothly and effectively, it’s<br />

essential for the parties involved to enjoy a relationship of absolute<br />

trust and confidence in each other’s field of expertise. RBS and A-Gas’s<br />

senior executives have a professional relationship that goes back<br />

some 10 years, during which we’ve developed a sound understanding<br />

of their business and the markets in which they operate. The<br />

knowledge we’ve built up over that time informed and underpinned<br />

our debt appetite, ultimately giving LDC and A-Gas management<br />

greater confidence that we’d be able to deliver for them.<br />

Depending on the nature of the business being targeted, investors<br />

at private equity firms might ask what experience potential finance<br />

providers have of:<br />

• Supporting PE-backed companies in similar industry sectors<br />

• Supporting companies of similar turnovers or volumes of business<br />

• Supporting companies operating in similar overseas locations<br />

Any PrOPerTy uSed AS SeCuriTy, whiCh MAy inCLude yOur hOMe, MAy Be rePOSSeSSed<br />

if yOu dO nOT KeeP uP rePAyMenTS On A MOrTgAge Or OTher deBT SeCured On iT.


• Managing cash in countries where the target company operates<br />

or trades<br />

• Leading or working in club deals with other banks on similar<br />

transactions<br />

Thinking long-range, there are often many considerations beyond<br />

any initial private equity-backed deal. In this case, A-Gas, whose<br />

executives have big plans for international expansion, required a<br />

platform for global cash management that would safeguard liquidity,<br />

even in countries with starkly contrasting banking systems.<br />

Successful structured finance deals largely depend on everyone<br />

asking the right questions from the outset, so that expectations can<br />

be managed. For RBS and LDC, we asked:<br />

• Does the company wish to grow organically or by acquisition,<br />

or both?<br />

• Looking even further ahead, what and when might senior<br />

management and LDC require by way of funded debt to exploit<br />

new opportunities?<br />

• Is there sufficient headroom in the facility we’ve provided?<br />

• How quickly can funds be drawn down?<br />

The nature of many private equity transactions – not to mention<br />

the personalities involved – means that businesses are obliged to hit<br />

the ground running, often driven by a reinvigorated management<br />

team, eager to implement plans they may have been nurturing<br />

for some time, and in no mood to be held back. In the case of<br />

A-Gas, it was crucial that leverage finance could be provided<br />

throughout the investment cycle, in parallel with an international<br />

cash management capability.<br />

deliverability is key<br />

As most private equity investment directors and investment managers<br />

will testify, every transaction has its own unique combination of<br />

influencing (and sometimes) game-changing factors. But what<br />

they all share is a relentless focus on deliverability. It’s typically the<br />

aspect of a deal that’s most likely to keep its stakeholders awake at<br />

night. Will finance ultimately come through? If it does, will it be as<br />

accommodating as I wanted, or as I’d been promised? Although<br />

deals are seldom permanently scuppered at the last minute, if some<br />

of the parties involved have few options at their disposal for rustling<br />

up more capital or giving up more equity, the consequences of<br />

deliverability hold-ups for the shape or timing of the transaction can<br />

be complex and drawn-out.<br />

In the present economic climate – and probably the months lying<br />

ahead – there’s an understandably heightened focus on deliverability<br />

risk amongst potential MBO teams and their private equity backers.<br />

That’s why what might occasionally appear to be unusually<br />

penetrating questions on the part of a bank represents a positive sign.<br />

It was critical for our colleagues at LDC to be reassured that, for A-Gas,<br />

they could rely on senior debt being delivered, on top of the addedvalue<br />

commercial and market intelligence they could safely assume<br />

we’d provide. Now, working closely with the A-Gas management<br />

team, LDC is set to embark on a global growth strategy, with a focus<br />

on Asia-Pacific and the Americas – and supported by the provision of<br />

funding by RBS.<br />

For further information, contact Richard Roach, Managing Director<br />

(Financial Sponsors UK), RBS. Email: richard.roach@rbs.com. n<br />

A cross-border checklist<br />

The increasingly global nature and reach of the UK’s private equity industry,<br />

and wider adoption of its investment model beyond its traditional UK and<br />

US heartlands, have served to underline the importance of integrated<br />

cross-border banking services for private equity investors.<br />

In readiness for a growing pipeline of international investment<br />

opportunities, a number of private equity houses are recognising that<br />

now is the time to re-evaluate their existing global cash management and<br />

trade finance arrangements:<br />

• Firms considering stakes in businesses whose future value rests largely<br />

on long-term global expansion strategies<br />

• Firms whose current investment portfolios include businesses which<br />

are set to make the move from trading with international customers<br />

to setting up sales units, operations or plant overseas<br />

• Firms backing companies which must shift more towards international<br />

supply chains for goods or components in order to stay competitive<br />

and retain their investment value for equity-holders<br />

The speed at which private equity firms (and the businesses they<br />

back) must frequently move requires a joined-up but flexible approach<br />

to banking, including the ability to overcome hurdles presented by<br />

time zones or local regulations governing repatriation of cash. A solid<br />

understanding of local and national idiosyncrasies within different<br />

countries’ banking systems may represent a reassuring added extra – but<br />

what can firms do to assess their current international banking facility?<br />

CFOs and heads of treasury might usefully ask themselves some of<br />

the following:<br />

1. How well-represented is our bank internationally – in the countries<br />

where we want to do business?<br />

2. How valuable are the insights our bank gives us on country-specific<br />

economic or industrial trends and trading conditions, especially where<br />

we’re only just starting out?<br />

3. Will our country managers have someone from the bank on the<br />

ground they can talk to when they need – just as we can here in the<br />

UK?<br />

4. If not, does our bank’s UK team have people available to talk to our<br />

people overseas – even outside core UK working hours?<br />

5. How can our people leverage our bankers’ connections with local<br />

businesses?<br />

6. How can a global bank ensure we maximise return on our cash –<br />

regardless of where it’s deposited – but without diminishing access?<br />

7. To what extent are the products and services offered by our bank in<br />

the UK also available in the countries where we operate or trade? What<br />

special or one-off arrangements might we need in specific countries<br />

from time to time – and how prepared is our bank to respond?<br />

8. How familiar will our bank’s overseas representatives – or their local<br />

partners – be with private equity investment models? Will they ‘get it’<br />

consistently across different countries?<br />

9. If we decided to move our main corporate global banking<br />

arrangements, what reassurance do we have that the process will be<br />

made as painless as possible?<br />

10. If geopolitical factors prompt us to immediately withdraw from a<br />

specific country, where do we stand if circumstances beyond our<br />

control – and our bank’s – prevent us accessing assets held in that<br />

country?<br />

January 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong> 17


Country<br />

Profile<br />

Toshihisa Adachi, Chairman of the Japan Venture Capital Association (JVCA)<br />

The Japan Venture Capital Association (JVCA) was established in<br />

2002 as Japan’s first and only organization with the specific aim<br />

of assisting venture capital firms and venture business supporters.<br />

JVCA’s mission is to promote the interests and development of its<br />

members while contributing to innovation in Japan and the global<br />

community. The association’s general partners total over 50, and<br />

the association is supplemented by a commensurate number<br />

from related areas such as accounting firms, legal counsel, and<br />

corporate venture capital.<br />

Over the past decade, and especially since the peak in 2006, both<br />

investment and exit through IPOs have been declining, and Japan’s<br />

venture capital houses are faced with a severely unfavorable market.<br />

As a result of the slump in the IPO market and the concurrent<br />

financial crisis, institutional investors are wary of investing in<br />

VC funds which has made fundraising difficult. Under such an<br />

environment, some general partners have been forced to close<br />

their funds. The drop in IPOs and sluggish markets have also<br />

caused a lowering in the valuation and return expectations for<br />

existing portfolios managed by both general and limited partners.<br />

Entrepreneurs are also faced with challenging situations that<br />

include not only the invisible exit through IPOs but also costly<br />

listing requirements. The recent movement towards strengthening<br />

compliance and regulations will likely increase the burden on<br />

entrepreneurs and start-up companies which thrive on a high<br />

speed of activity yet do not have sufficient management resources.<br />

As a result of this recent trend, an increasing number of<br />

entrepreneurs are starting companies with the aim of setting them<br />

up as joint ventures with, or selling them to, attractive alliance<br />

partners, rather than aiming to be public companies.<br />

There is some good news however. The sluggish economy could<br />

be creating favorable opportunities. Past recessions have given<br />

birth to a number of entrepreneurs and new companies, many of<br />

which are successful today. Japan historically lacks labour mobility,<br />

but severe economic conditions may force liquidity in human<br />

resources, and that is a good chance for venture companies to<br />

hire talented individuals.<br />

Some public blue chip companies, from the electronics,<br />

telecommunications, pharmaceutical and chemical industries<br />

for example, have developed internal venture capital capabilities<br />

in order to acquire synergies and complementary technologies<br />

18 Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong><br />

Japan<br />

Waiting for the sunrise<br />

and services. Those corporate venture capital units are expected<br />

to play an important role in the VC market and could solve<br />

many problems. For such companies, the most attractive sector<br />

currently is clean-tech, especially in the areas of energy-saving.<br />

They are quite irreplaceable technologies particularly after the<br />

3.11 disaster. Other areas of interest include telecommunication<br />

components, next generation internet platforms, and life sciences,<br />

with a particular emphasis on preventive healthcare technologies<br />

for Japan’s aging society.<br />

With the absence of an exit market in Japan, venture capital<br />

houses and their investee companies have been developing<br />

businesses and exploring markets that lend themselves to crossborder<br />

partnerships. Japan is historically a nation of technologies<br />

and recently has developed a reputation for services. Investments<br />

into businesses with a competitive edge on a global scale are in<br />

great demand.<br />

Entrepreneurs and venture capital firms need to develop a global<br />

point of view. The same goes for venture capital associations.<br />

Collaborations and enlightenments within associations are<br />

expected as never before. For the JVCA, an alliance with<br />

neighboring Asian societies is important, but there must also be an<br />

alliance with the UK, Europe and the US who preceded the JVCA<br />

in the history of associations. These relationships are essential for<br />

the future of the VC industry in Japan. The night has fallen after the<br />

sunset, but the Sun will rise again for sure. n


Country<br />

Profile<br />

Jeanette Lepper, Manager at the MENA Private Equity Association<br />

Private equity in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) has<br />

begun to emerge from the global financial crisis and the Arab<br />

Spring as a leaner, more focused and determined industry. Fund<br />

managers that <strong>admin</strong>istered multi-billion dollar vehicles during the<br />

peak years of 2007 and 2008 are reevaluating their investment<br />

models. Many GPs are going back to basics – focusing on growth<br />

plays and portfolio company development. Venture capital and<br />

SME investing have surfaced as the new stars, offering more<br />

opportunity, better valuations, and a chance for PE investors to<br />

fuel the job creation and economic growth needed to stabilise<br />

MENA’s dynamic social and political scene.<br />

“Today you see fund managers focusing on SMEs, which is<br />

the majority of the private economy in the region,” says Imad<br />

Ghandour, founder and managing partner at CedarBridge<br />

Partners. “It is where people need the money, where the lucrative<br />

opportunities are, and where the growth is.”<br />

Following the global crisis, large MENA-focused buyout funds have<br />

struggled to deploy capital, with deal sizes shrinking significantly.<br />

Transactions for 2010 totalled US$692m, down from US$895m in<br />

2009. While fundraising was up in 2010, it remains far below precrisis<br />

levels. The decline in activity comes largely due to waning<br />

liquidity, weakened public markets that have limited IPO prospects,<br />

longer lead times for deal origination, and mismatched buyer-seller<br />

expectations. Although the large cap segment of the market will<br />

continue to be challenging for most, there is an increasing sense<br />

that deal flow can be generated by managers with existing track<br />

records focusing on SME and venture capital opportunities.<br />

MENA’s venture capital and SME space presents a relatively exciting<br />

picture. Valuations are reasonable, quality targets are increasing,<br />

growth is high, and GPs face little competition from other lenders.<br />

The number of VC deals closed in MENA for 2009-2010 was nearly<br />

treble the total for the two years prior. This growth is expected<br />

to continue apace. In support of this positive trend, the recently<br />

founded MENA Private Equity Association has focused its early<br />

MenA<br />

Building a sustainable market<br />

efforts on VC promotion. The Association offers a free online VC<br />

directory and guide to the industry for companies in search of<br />

early stage funding. Venture capitalists have also used the group as<br />

a platform to discuss ideas and interact with industry stakeholders.<br />

Mid-market growth will also be supported by governments keen<br />

to spur job creation and improve social infrastructure. “We are<br />

primarily looking at growth sectors that benefit from the positive<br />

demographic trends that this region is facing,” says Faisal Al Hamad,<br />

executive director at NBK Capital’s Alternative Investment Group.<br />

“With effective government support, the youth bulge in the region<br />

will continue to drive activity in sectors related to discretionary<br />

consumer spending, in addition to defensive growth sectors such<br />

as education, healthcare, and infrastructure services, all of which<br />

are sectors that should see increased PE activity.”<br />

Going forward, observers can expect to see mid-sized funds in<br />

the US$100-350m range, many with a sector focus on healthcare,<br />

power, and other non-cyclical growth areas. Fundraising will<br />

be difficult from both local and international sources, and GPs<br />

may have to consider creative deal-by-deal solutions. Private<br />

fundraising and investment activity in the near term will focus<br />

on the Gulf, as countries in North Africa and the Levant continue<br />

to sort out their domestic politics. The UAE and Saudi Arabia<br />

will remain top attractions. Governments in these countries and<br />

Qatar will continue to push for better business and fund-friendly<br />

regulations, despite short-term distractions posed by turmoil in<br />

neighbouring states. And while the IPO craze is over, exits will still<br />

be possible for high quality assets through the public markets, as<br />

well as strategic sales.<br />

PE professionals may be excused for feeling slightly deflated by the<br />

steep fall in fundraising and investment totals. However, MENA’s is<br />

a young industry that grew up perhaps too quickly. Its new face<br />

– sober, streamlined, building on more significant track records –<br />

will certainly be more sustainable, and more in tune with regional<br />

economic needs. n<br />

Venture capital and SME investing have surfaced as the new stars, offering<br />

more opportunity, better valuations, and a chance for PE investors to fuel<br />

the job creation and economic growth needed to stabilise MENA’s dynamic<br />

social and political scene<br />

Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong> 19


Sponsored<br />

Article<br />

rory O’Sullivan, head of European M&A at <strong>BVCA</strong> Year of Venture campaign sponsor Canaccord<br />

Genuity, reflects on the technology M&A environment and drivers for the future<br />

As we enter the final quarter of 2011, we can find some solace in<br />

these uncertain economic times in the healthy M&A environment<br />

surrounding the European technology sector. Deal drivers continue to<br />

support activity across a variety of segments. Some of these drivers<br />

include robust corporate cash balance sheets and tax considerations<br />

around repatriation of this cash for US acquirers in particular.<br />

More important in supporting deal activity, in our view, are the<br />

twin drivers of entrepreneurial activity and the accelerating<br />

pace of product and business model innovation. European<br />

entrepreneurship and innovation continues to generate<br />

considerable value for their venture and other investors on both<br />

these counts.<br />

Having reined in their research and development, cut costs and<br />

restructured, ICT companies are coming out of the recession with<br />

more cash on their balance sheets and are seeking acquisitions for<br />

growth. As at Q2 2011, the sector’s top 25 companies grew their<br />

cash pile to US$591bn representing an 18% year-on-year increase<br />

from US$499bn at the end of Q2 2010.<br />

Transformations of technology companies are fuelling multibilliondollar<br />

mergers and acquisitions and divestitures, as the industry<br />

consolidates and develops new businesses to compete for<br />

corporate IT budgets. Google’s US$12.5bn purchase of Motorola<br />

Mobility, and Hewlett-Packard’s decision to acquire UK software<br />

maker Autonomy for US$10.3bn, and considering to divest their<br />

PC business, are the latest examples of the change in products<br />

and services that are reshaping the industry. Additionally, major<br />

private equity funds that raised capital before the recession still<br />

have substantial resources for acquisition, made evident by the<br />

large number of PE-backed deals in Q2.<br />

While value creation and business model disruption continue<br />

apace online, and an ever growing and increasingly engaged online<br />

audience drives advertising and commerce revenues for many<br />

leaders, it may be instructive to refresh some of the other trends<br />

which give us at Canaccord Genuity confidence in continued<br />

secular activity in European technology M&A.<br />

The emergence of cloud computing, together with the growing<br />

adoption of SaaS/on demand services, virtualisation and open<br />

20 Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong><br />

Checking the scorecard<br />

for technology M&A<br />

in 2011<br />

source software continue to disrupt the previous, established<br />

ecosystem. Mobility is a tremendous driver which is having a<br />

profound impact on the technology landscape and food chain,<br />

while the increasing degree of vertical integration in the mobile<br />

sector, amongst others, is another recent trend still having an<br />

impact on consolidation in the sector.<br />

The broad reach of these trends in terms of deal drivers is<br />

evidenced by the breadth of some of our M&A activity in 2011<br />

to date. Canaccord Genuity has announced or completed in the<br />

last three quarters transactions in sectors spanning enterprise<br />

software, IP licensing, local advertising, mobile marketing, online<br />

video, price comparison, security software, power electronics,<br />

semiconductors, and solar power.<br />

While economic uncertainty and stock market volatility is clearly<br />

impacting boardroom confidence in bold, transformational deals,<br />

we do see continued and robust activity at the growth-driven,<br />

incremental/bolt-on acquisition level that represents the bread<br />

and butter of technology M&A.<br />

While any pretense at crystal ball gazing in the current volatile<br />

economic environment should be treated with caution, the broad<br />

and deep roots of these technology M&A drivers do fill us with<br />

optimism in our outlook for 2012. n


Sponsored<br />

Article<br />

Operational improvement remains key driver of value creation, writes Sachin Date, EMEIA Private<br />

Equity Leader at Ernst & Young<br />

Our latest annual study, How do private equity investors create<br />

value?, is an exploration of 2010 exits showing that private equity<br />

(PE) exit activity returned in 2010. PE proved itself far better able<br />

to weather the storm than anyone had anticipated back in 2008<br />

and, for the last five years of our analysis, has outperformed public<br />

company benchmarks.<br />

However, despite the robustness of the PE model, the absence of<br />

corporates from the M&A market presents a formidable challenge<br />

to the PE market recovery. Given the importance of trade sales as an<br />

exit route, the market will not completely recover until corporates<br />

return in full force. Even though exit activity has improved, the<br />

uncertainty in the economy — with threats of a double-dip<br />

recession and volatility in the public markets — challenges whether<br />

this increase in activity can continue.<br />

The recovery in exits was evident in 2010. There were 57 exits in<br />

Europe, a sharp rise from the lows of 2008 and 2009, when just over<br />

30 exits were completed each year. UK exit activity, representing 32%<br />

of the overall European portfolio, continued to improve as PE buyers<br />

returned with confidence to the market. The UK has continued to<br />

deliver returns level with the European average, despite the downturn<br />

and greater maturity of the PE market.<br />

The return of initial public offerings (IPOs) was one of the most notable<br />

drivers of exit activity, as a total of 11 portfolio companies exited via<br />

IPO across Europe – the highest number since 2006. Exits via IPO also<br />

accounted for some of the largest companies in PE portfolios by entry<br />

enterprise value (EV): 19% of exits by number were by IPO, while 56%<br />

by entry EV were by IPO. Contrary to the rest of Europe, there were no<br />

UK IPOs of PE-backed businesses of any size.<br />

The average entry EV for exits by IPO in 2010, at over €2.5b in Europe,<br />

is almost double the previous high of 2007. This demonstrates that<br />

the public markets have been a key route to realizing large portfolio<br />

companies, with 2010 a particularly strong year for this.<br />

Exits and returns<br />

up in 2010<br />

However, despite the improvement in 2010, the difficult conditions<br />

over the past three years have resulted in a further aging of portfolios<br />

(4.2 years in December 2010).<br />

For European exits, 2010 returns were positive, with EBITDA (earnings<br />

before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization) growth through<br />

operational improvement remaining the most important driver of<br />

PE’s value creation, rather than multiple expansion and leverage.<br />

The most striking finding is that, within operational improvement,<br />

organic revenue growth is proportionally the largest contributor. This<br />

accounts for 46% of profit growth across the period. Cost reduction<br />

also drove a significant amount of the value created in PE portfolios<br />

over the long and short term.<br />

PE houses have proven their capabilities by working more closely with<br />

their portfolio companies and management for the best returns.<br />

Based on exits achieved during the study period, the report found<br />

that replacing management during the investment adds up to 1.6<br />

years to the average holding period, and reduces returns by 40%.<br />

Failing to have the right team at the beginning of a deal can prove<br />

costly to businesses, especially during these difficult economic times.<br />

Our research also found that PE has increased the use of operating<br />

partners to work with management teams to drive additional<br />

business improvement.<br />

Even though exit activity has improved, the uncertainty in<br />

the economy challenges whether this increase in activity can<br />

continue. Corporates have not staged a major comeback on the<br />

M&A market, despite having built up significant cash reserves and,<br />

until confidence in the market reappears, a return to normalized<br />

conditions will be difficult.<br />

The PE model remains robust and will continue to evolve despite the<br />

current challenging conditions. While a return to the boom years is<br />

on hold for now, there is no doubt that PE will continue to thrive. n<br />

PE houses have proven their capabilities by working more<br />

closely with their portfolio companies and management<br />

for the best returns.<br />

Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong> 21


new<br />

Expert training solutions,<br />

for Portfolio Companies<br />

In Spring 2012, the <strong>BVCA</strong> is launching an innovative portfolio of specialised training courses, specifically<br />

designed for private equity and venture capital–backed companies. Help your Portfolio Company<br />

management teams develop the skills and leadership potential they need for next stage investment and<br />

sustainable, long–term growth.<br />

forthcoming 2012 courses:<br />

Approaches to Cost Management & reduction 24 April 2012, 15 November 2012<br />

Assertivess & influencing Techniques 26 April 2012, 27 November 2012<br />

effective forecasting & Budgeting 8 March 2012, 19 September 2012<br />

effective Leadership 27 June 2012, 28 November 2012<br />

finance for the non–financial Manager 20–21 March 2012, 24–25 October 2012<br />

Pitch Perfect Presentations 29 March 2012, 16 October 2012<br />

Professional networking Masterclass 3 July 2012, 4 December 2012<br />

Skills of negotiating 21–23 February 2012, 19–21 June 2012<br />

The independent ned 7–8 February 2012, 30–31 October 2012<br />

The newly Appointed Manager 16–17 May 2012, 30–31 October 2012<br />

Visit www.bvca.co.uk/training to book<br />

or contact the <strong>BVCA</strong> Training team:<br />

training@bvca.co.uk<br />

+44 (0)20 7420 1800<br />

22 Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong>


Country<br />

Profile<br />

Luis Antonio Marquez Heine, Director General of Amexcap, the Mexican private equity association<br />

The private equity market in Mexico has been in continuous<br />

growth since its formal beginning one decade ago and still holds<br />

great potential. With a stable economy, a robust legal framework,<br />

little competition from other funds and a lot of companies to<br />

invest in, several private equity houses are taking advantage of<br />

the conditions.<br />

There are currently 50 GPs investing in Mexico - 40% domestic and<br />

60% international. According to a Deloitte study it is estimated<br />

that the combined resources of private equity funds in Mexico will<br />

increase from US$5.8bn dollars in 2010 to US$6.5bn in 2011, an<br />

increase of 14%. Additionally, the amount invested will grow from<br />

US$789m to US$1.6bn, an increase of 104%.<br />

Private equity funds directed their investment to the following<br />

sectors in 2010:<br />

• Financial services: 36%<br />

• Real estate: 31%<br />

• Agriculture: 14%<br />

• Automotive, health and telecommunications: 3% each<br />

• Consumer goods, hotels, manufacturing, information<br />

technology and others: 2% each.<br />

By stage:<br />

• Start-ups: 6%<br />

• Early stage: 20%<br />

• Growth stage: 57%<br />

• Mature stage: 17%<br />

According to the last economic census, there are more than 5<br />

million companies in Mexico, with 220,000 classed as small, more<br />

than 15,000 medium and more than 10,000 large, and the rest<br />

microenterprises. Clearly there is much opportunity for investors with<br />

many niches to be exploited across a range of industry sectors and<br />

at all stages of a company’s life. In the start up and early-stage space<br />

for example federal and local governments have extensive programs<br />

designed to drive the development of innovative, technology and<br />

exporting industries. And whilst the Mexican Stock Market isn´t yet<br />

the most feasible exit for the great majority of companies, there is a<br />

dynamic merger and acquisition pipeline.<br />

Several international investors, both GPs and LPs, are already<br />

invested in Mexico. Indeed, international LPs are responsible for<br />

approximately 83% of all capital raised by Mexican focused private<br />

equity funds, 42% of which came from the US and Canada, 20%<br />

Private equity in<br />

Mexico<br />

from Europe and the rest from Asia, Latin America and other<br />

regions like the Middle East.<br />

Turning to legal matters, although the Mexican environment is not<br />

perfect, it works properly. Limited partnerships are allowed under<br />

Mexican law, and, since 2009, Mexican pension funds, named<br />

Afores, can invest in private capital vehicles, thus accelerating the<br />

development of the sector. To date, Afores have invested more<br />

than US$2bn in private equity funds, including real state and<br />

infrastructure.<br />

In relation to the economic environment, several private analysts in<br />

their most recent forecasts have estimated that the GDP in Mexico<br />

will grow at a rate of 3.6% during 2012, retaining its status as the<br />

second biggest economy in Latin America. Other facts speak for<br />

themselves, like rising from 62nd to 35th as the best place in the world<br />

to do business according to Doing Business, putting Mexico above<br />

all of the BRICs and Latin America countries. Mexican universities<br />

produce 90,000 more engineers and specialized technicians than<br />

Brazil in areas such as aerospace, renewable energies and automotive<br />

industries, and there are more than 90 million cell phones, covering<br />

85% of the population. Mexico has proven resilient in the face of<br />

the global economic and financial crisis, which is largely due to<br />

appropriate public finances and macroeconomic management that<br />

will surely prevail in the long run. n<br />

Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong> 23


Sponsored<br />

Article<br />

Private equity needs to better understand the changing nature of pension funds at their investee<br />

companies, writes David Collinson, co-head of business origination at Pension Corporation<br />

Pricing a new acquisition takes many operational assumptions into<br />

account, both at company level and market level. Increasingly,<br />

pricing will look much more closely at any associated defined<br />

benefit pension fund. Yet as pension funds move into run off, as they<br />

are closed to new members and future accrual, it is vital that GPs<br />

really understand the changing dynamics and size of the plentiful,<br />

potential pension black holes that can open up. If pension risks are<br />

not carefully analysed, that assumed IRR of 25% over four years<br />

could very well be wiped out.<br />

The obvious costs, which are generally factored into price<br />

calculations, are the ongoing contributions employers are obliged to<br />

make, as well as ongoing <strong>admin</strong>istration expenses. Over the lifetime<br />

of a typical pension fund the management expenses could represent<br />

over 15% of the liabilities.<br />

Yet perhaps less well understood are a raft of additional expenses<br />

and costs, which in recent years have made up the bulk of the<br />

ongoing burden on the employer of a defined benefit pension plan.<br />

These include the costs of legislation, funding poor investment<br />

performance, and the opportunity cost of being responsible for a<br />

pension plan. And I’m not sure that prior to an acquisition many GP’s<br />

factor into their assumptions that the trustees of a defined benefit<br />

pension plan effectively hold a long term equity put option that they<br />

can exercise against the GP’s portfolio company, a put option that<br />

could potentially wipe out some or all of the GP’s assumed 25% IRR.<br />

Take, for example, a portfolio company a GP is looking to acquire<br />

which, for the sake of argument, is unlevered and has a free cash<br />

flow of £30m per annum. The Net Present Value (NPV) of the cash<br />

flow over the next 15 years, at a Weighted Average Cost of Capital<br />

(WACC) of 10%, is £230m.<br />

However, this portfolio company happens to be the sponsor of a<br />

defined benefit pension plan.<br />

Prudent assumptions<br />

The associated pension fund has liabilities of £180m, at a discount<br />

rate of 6%, with only £130m of assets with an expected return of 7%<br />

– leaving a deficit of £50m and no chance of making good the hole<br />

by themselves. The trustees and employer have therefore agreed a<br />

standard 10-year recovery plan, which will see the employer injecting<br />

an additional £5.2m contribution per annum, with an assumed<br />

investment return of 7%.<br />

24 Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong><br />

The pensions risk<br />

According to the Pensions Regulator, the standard actuarial valuation<br />

of the pension fund, known as Technical Provisions (TPs), should be<br />

“based on prudent assumptions, in relation to their assessment of<br />

the employer covenant”.<br />

However, “prudent assumptions” are entirely subjective and depend<br />

very much on the relative strength of the employer.<br />

The four year time horizon the GP is looking at for its IRR will<br />

almost certainly conflict one way or the other with the timescale<br />

the trustees work to. They will generally have a long-term horizon,<br />

at least as long as their employer is healthy and solvent, which in this<br />

case it appears to be.<br />

However, if the employer weakens significantly or becomes insolvent,<br />

their timescale considerably shortens. In the latter scenario they<br />

become forced sellers of equities and risk assets (probably at the<br />

bottom of the market, as this is when insolvencies occur) and forced<br />

buyers of insurance/interest rates and inflation rates (either to the<br />

PPF or to the insurance market). The trustees are therefore highly<br />

suspicious of anything which can weaken the corporate covenant,<br />

as we shall see.<br />

Strategic investment<br />

Partly based on the existing recovery plan, the GP decides to move<br />

ahead and acquire the company. At this point, management decides<br />

on a new strategic investment – intended to generate a 15% return,<br />

to be financed through the raising of £100m of senior debt, secured<br />

and financed by the Opco, at a cost of 7% per annum.<br />

Post-strategic investment, the Opco throws off £23m per annum –<br />

the original £30m minus the £7m required to pay the yield on the<br />

senior debt – plus the additional £15m per annum generated by the<br />

investment, giving a total of £38m per annum. The new 15 year NPV<br />

therefore (at the same WACC) is £290m, up from £230m before<br />

restructuring.<br />

On the face of it this is a strong investment, placing the Opco at<br />

the forefront of its industry and with options for future growth. All<br />

of which one might have thought would strengthen the corporate<br />

covenant and put the pension plan on a more secure footing.<br />

However, the trustees, relying on “prudent assumptions”, don’t like<br />

the £100m of senior debt, which in their view weakens the covenant.<br />

They therefore switch out of equities and into gilts.


Yet this investment strategy generates a lower return and the<br />

trustees are now only able to count on a return of 4%. In turn, this<br />

pushes out liabilities, under TPs, from £180m to £230m.<br />

Given that, in their view, the corporate covenant has weakened, the<br />

trustees now want to shorten the duration of the recovery plan and<br />

extract maximum value. This means that company contributions<br />

shoot up to £22m over five years, rather than the relatively<br />

manageable £5m for 10 years.<br />

The trustees have had a huge, unforeseen, impact on the assumed<br />

25% IRR.<br />

If the impact of the trustee’s view of Opco leverage and change<br />

in investment strategy had been taken into account prior to<br />

acquisition, then it is possible that the GP would have taken the<br />

strategic decision not to acquire the Opco in the first place, precisely<br />

to avoid this ramping up of essentially open-ended pension<br />

contributions. Alternatively, prior to taking on the leverage, the<br />

GP might have looked at its options and passed the pension fund<br />

to a third party, usually an FSA authorised and regulated insurance<br />

company, through a pension insurance buyout or buy-in.<br />

If they retain the pension fund, the bad news for management<br />

is that they could face even higher contribution rates at the next<br />

valuation – as will many of the sponsors of the c.40% of pension<br />

funds which had their triennial valuation in March 2009, with the<br />

next one due in March 2012.<br />

In 2010, over £29bn in contributions were paid by the private sector<br />

to defined benefit pension funds and a recent survey of trustees<br />

carried out by Pension Corporation found that 55% of them expect<br />

employer contributions to go up by more than 10% after the next<br />

valuation.<br />

So post the restructuring and the pension plan renegotiation, the<br />

GP now receives £6m per annum for five years from the existing<br />

business, increasing to £28m from year six onwards. At the same<br />

WACC, the NPV of company’s cash flow is now only £235m.<br />

Without the burden of the pension plan, the GP at this point would<br />

have been better off to the tune of £55m.<br />

Legislation risk<br />

There can be no doubt that defined benefit pensions funds have<br />

been steadily rising in terms of cost of management time, running<br />

expenses, and increasingly in the need to make good deficits.<br />

Deficits have increased due to several factors, including<br />

underperformance of risk assets, increased liabilities that have not<br />

been matched by hedging assets such as bonds and swaps, benefit<br />

uplifts granted in the 1980s and 1990s - such as enhanced early<br />

retirement - and of course ever-increasing longevity, something<br />

which has only lately been recognised by pension fund actuaries.<br />

There has however been another factor at work, which has<br />

significantly increased costs: legislation. In fact, we estimate that<br />

four pieces of legislation alone have added approximately 44%<br />

to the cost of running a pension fund over the past 30-40 years:<br />

making pension increases guaranteed rather than an intention<br />

added 12% to the cost of running a pension fund; requiring the<br />

prefunding of technical provisions with a prudent margin added<br />

8%; the removal of ACT for equity dividends added 12%; and<br />

the PPF levy and compliance with the Pensions Act 1995 added<br />

another 12%.<br />

These additional costs have all been borne by the employer, and in<br />

the case of private equity, the GP, heavily impacting IRRs.<br />

Relative to the costs of securing the pension liabilities with an<br />

insurance company pension fund investments are in general<br />

significantly misaligned.<br />

Pension funds have been hit again and again by the double whammy<br />

of stock market crashes reducing asset levels, whilst collapsing gilt<br />

yields push up liabilities. During July and August 2011 alone we<br />

estimate that UK private sector pension funds collectively lost in<br />

excess of £200bn relative to their liabilities.<br />

When they were less mature, pension funds had good reason to<br />

invest in equities. From 1974-2000 the average annual real return<br />

on UK equities was 13%. Given the high returns experienced in<br />

the equity markets, and the tax incentives of operating defined<br />

benefit pension funds, operating a pension plan was historically cost<br />

efficient for the employer.<br />

However, as pension funds move to run off, this position has in<br />

many cases changed.<br />

Take for example for a pension fund with £100m of assets and<br />

£130m of liabilities, which, under its existing recovery plan, is to<br />

invest 100% in equities. If the trustees don’t hedge the interest rate/<br />

inflation exposures, which most do not, there are some potentially<br />

severe consequences for the employer. In effect, the employer has<br />

granted a put option to the Trustee on 10 year equity performance<br />

and real interest rates at durations in excess of 10 years; the<br />

employer is therefore liable to meet the underperformance of the<br />

equities against the projected returns – in this case the extent to<br />

which £100m of equities fails to grow to £197m over 10 years.<br />

If the pension fund assets outperform, the outperformance will be<br />

of little value to the employer; surplus generated will be used by the<br />

trustees to de-risk or be held in the fund as a buffer. The equity risk<br />

is one way for the employer.<br />

The trustees therefore effectively have a 10 year put option on<br />

equity market performance which starts off £97m in the money. The<br />

cost of the same put option, if it were to be bought in the market,<br />

would be £63m.<br />

Given the complexity of a pension fund and the power the trustees<br />

can wield, it is unsurprising that increasing numbers of GPs have<br />

been transferring these substantial, open-ended risks to insurance<br />

companies. The employer benefits by divesting itself of any future<br />

responsibility, financial or otherwise, for a known and pre-agreed<br />

amount paid as premium. The pension fund members benefit as<br />

the insurance regulatory regime ensures their benefits are secure,<br />

backed by shareholder capital. In effect, this is a demonstrable<br />

strengthening of the covenant supporting the liabilities and can be a<br />

considerably cheaper option for the employer. n<br />

Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong> 25


Research<br />

Colin ellis, the <strong>BVCA</strong>’s Chief Economist, looks at the changing views of private equity to<br />

responsible investing<br />

With the scars from the financial crisis taking a long time to heal<br />

in developed economies, the role that business plays in influencing<br />

broader social developments, as opposed to just economic progress,<br />

has remained firmly in the spotlight. But while the huge negative<br />

banking externalities – most notably high unemployment and weak<br />

wage growth for those still in work – are still at the forefront of many<br />

people’s minds, the broader agenda of sustainability is an important<br />

issue for all companies. This is particularly true in the case of private<br />

equity, where a past lack of transparency and often large deal values<br />

mean that the industry needs to tackle sustainability head-on.<br />

Sustainability, in this context, implies businesses actively addressing<br />

and managing environmental, social and governance (ESG) issues, in<br />

particular to ensure that meeting present demands does not limit the<br />

ability of others to meet their own needs in the future. Sustainable<br />

growth and development must take into account long-term issues<br />

and risks as well as short-term pressures. Businesses must address<br />

potential negative environmental and social impacts, while at the<br />

same time also meeting their shareholders’ requirements.<br />

Private equity and venture capital should be uniquely well-placed<br />

in managing these long-term issues. While public entities can be<br />

distracted by frequent reporting requirements and short-term<br />

share price movements, fund managers in our industry deliver their<br />

best returns by genuinely maximising the enterprise value of their<br />

investee companies. And that enterprise value, in turn, reflects not<br />

just the profits or cost savings that company managers and General<br />

Partners (GPs) can deliver this year, but expected profits over the<br />

lifetime of the investee company: a share or equity stake in a firm is<br />

a claim on all future profits as well as today’s bottom line.<br />

The active management model of PE/VC lends itself very well<br />

to this sort of long-term transformational approach, with funds<br />

often investing substantial additional capital, over and above the<br />

acquisition funding, in order to modernise, expand or improve an<br />

investee company’s production process.<br />

At the same time, this long-term focus means that the brands and<br />

reputations of investee companies really matter. If a company’s<br />

activities prove unpalatable to its current or potential customers –<br />

for instance, a production plant pollutes the local environment or<br />

working conditions in overseas factories are deemed unacceptable<br />

– then its brand will be damaged, and future revenues and economic<br />

value may be permanently lower as a result.<br />

26 Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong><br />

Sustainability<br />

matters<br />

Surveying the land<br />

All told, the theoretical structures suggest that sustainability should<br />

be a key issue for GPs. But what happens in practice?<br />

In order to gauge <strong>BVCA</strong> members’ attitudes to sustainability, the<br />

<strong>BVCA</strong> Responsible Investment Advisory Board (RIAB) commissioned<br />

a survey of members back in 2009, and the results were subsequently<br />

published online. With two years having passed since that initial<br />

exercise, the RIAB decided to conduct a similar survey in August<br />

2011, to see if attitudes had changed.<br />

The 2011 survey garnered a total of 80 responses from <strong>BVCA</strong><br />

members, broadly comparable with the previous 2009 exercise. And,<br />

overall, the new results suggest that there is a growing awareness of the<br />

role and importance of sustainability within the private equity (PE) and<br />

venture capital (VC) community. As with the 2009 survey, a minority<br />

of respondents did not think that sustainability (as defined above) was<br />

appropriate for the PE/VC community. However, that minority shrank<br />

from 39% in 2009 to just 24% in the most recent survey.<br />

At the same time, the importance of sustainability for potential and<br />

current investee companies is also more widely recognised. Sixty<br />

four percent of respondents thought that active management of<br />

sustainability issues made a company more attractive to investors,<br />

compared with just 44% in 2009. Seventy seven percent of<br />

respondents thought that actively managing sustainability issues<br />

demonstrated that a company was adopting a long-term strategy,<br />

compared with just 46% two years ago. And in terms of the cost<br />

of sustainability, just 10% of respondents thought that companies<br />

managing these issues were incurring unnecessary costs, down from<br />

19% in the previous survey (Chart 1). The growing recognition of the<br />

importance of sustainability was also evident in the extent to which<br />

PE/VC firms consider ESG risks in managing investee companies,<br />

and the general importance respondents place on those companies<br />

acting in a sustainable manner.<br />

investor interest<br />

In part, the growing awareness of sustainability issues appears to<br />

have been driven by investors as well as fund managers. Fifty-six<br />

percent of respondents reported that their firm had been asked<br />

to respond to investor questions that were focused specifically<br />

on sustainability or ESG issues in the past two years. Where PE/<br />

VC firms invest in emerging market economies, sustainability is


often a key priority, not least because the investors in those funds<br />

can be important public entities such as the World Bank. In many<br />

developing markets in particular, established PE investors from<br />

abroad can lead best practice in the area of sustainability. But with<br />

companies also increasingly concerned with how they manage their<br />

pension funds and financial assets, sustainability is also important for<br />

PE/VC investors in established markets.<br />

However, there also appears to be a growing realisation that<br />

sustainability matters not just because of its potential direct<br />

reputational impact, but also how that can then affect company<br />

performance and ultimately fund returns. Fifty-four percent of<br />

survey respondents agreed that sustainability management would<br />

generate greater shareholder value over the long term, up nine<br />

percentage points (ppts) from the 2009 survey (Chart 2). And 45%<br />

of respondents said that sustainability management did impact on<br />

their investment decisions, an increase of 7ppts from two years ago.<br />

There are also signs that company managers themselves are taking<br />

more of a lead in this area, with around half of respondents agreeing<br />

that management teams are increasingly interested in sustainability<br />

issues as a means to reduce risks and create additional value; fewer<br />

than 20% of respondents disagreed.<br />

Perhaps the biggest change in the past two years, however, has been<br />

the widespread implementation of institutional measures to embed<br />

sustainability into PE/VC processes. Fully 63% of those survey noted<br />

that their firm already had a policy or set of principles setting out the<br />

firm’s approach to sustainability issues in place, up from just 24% in<br />

2009. And only a fifth of respondents had no plan to implement such<br />

a policy in the future, down from 51% two years ago. Yet while GPs<br />

genuinely do seem to be addressing these issues internally, much<br />

ChArT 1 ChArT 2<br />

% of respondents<br />

70<br />

60<br />

50<br />

40<br />

30<br />

20<br />

10<br />

0<br />

Companies managing<br />

sustainability are incurring<br />

unnecessary costs<br />

19<br />

10<br />

37<br />

64<br />

Agree Disagree Neither/don’t know<br />

44<br />

2011<br />

26 2009<br />

more remains to be done. Just 20% of GPs acknowledged regular<br />

formal reporting or communication of their firm’s sustainability<br />

activities internally, with 44% having no plans to implement any such<br />

communication going forwards. While that is an improvement on<br />

two years ago (when just 12% of GPs had internal reporting), it also<br />

represents a missed opportunity. By ensuring that all staff are aware<br />

of the high profile and importance of managing sustainability issues,<br />

PE/VC firms can really take up the mantle of responsible investors<br />

and lead best practice across the corporate sector as a whole.<br />

While GPs do genuinely seem to be devoting more time to these<br />

important issues – and 71% of respondents expected their firm to<br />

do more to incorporate sustainability risks and opportunities into<br />

investment strategies over the next two to three years – all too often<br />

the good work that they already do is left unacknowledged. One of<br />

our goals at the <strong>BVCA</strong> is to put private equity and venture capital<br />

firmly in the economic mainstream, to make them a regular part of<br />

business and industrial life.<br />

Our members have numerous examples of long-term value creation<br />

through sustainable engagement on issues such as energy efficiency,<br />

focus on supply chains, and reducing waste and carbon impact. We<br />

would like these to become more widespread, and to be used as<br />

industry benchmarks, to help change the outdated perceptions<br />

and fears around the industry. At their best, PE/VC managers and<br />

their investee companies can be outstanding corporate citizens. By<br />

continuing to concentrate and on these important long-term issues,<br />

not only can GPs genuinely maximise the value of their investments,<br />

they can also show the outside world that private equity and venture<br />

capital genuinely seek to build better and sustainable businesses that<br />

endure for the long term. n<br />

% of respondents<br />

60<br />

50<br />

40<br />

30<br />

20<br />

10<br />

0<br />

45<br />

54<br />

Sustainability management<br />

generates greater long-term<br />

shareholder value<br />

14<br />

11<br />

Agree Disagree Neither/don’t know<br />

40<br />

2011<br />

35 2009<br />

Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong> 27


Sponsored<br />

Article<br />

edmund Tyler and William Holder, partners in SJ Berwin’s corporate practice, look at changes to the<br />

UK Takeover Code<br />

Last month the Takeover Panel - the body that regulates offers for<br />

publicly quoted companies in the UK - made wide-ranging reforms<br />

to the Takeover Code. Despite reassuring noises from the Panel<br />

that the changes are not aimed at the private equity industry, their<br />

effect may be felt most keenly by financial bidders.<br />

For private equity and other financial bidders, the changes that<br />

are likely to have the most impact are those relating to the bid<br />

timetable and process, and the prohibition on “break fees” and<br />

deal protection measures.<br />

The key change to bid timetables is that all potential bidders must<br />

now be named if a target makes an announcement that a bid<br />

is in prospect, and there are just four weeks from that date for<br />

each named bidder to “put up or shut up”. If a prospective bidder<br />

chooses to “shut up” – i.e., to announce that it is not proceeding<br />

with its bid – it cannot bid for the target again for another six<br />

months (unless, for example, there is another bid, or the target<br />

consents).<br />

A target must usually make an announcement if there is a leak<br />

that it is in talks about a possible bid. However, bidders were<br />

rarely identified in these announcements in the past, and financial<br />

bidders in particular may have reputational concerns with being<br />

identified with a series of bids that do not proceed because they<br />

are made public prematurely. To address these concerns, the Panel<br />

may allow a potential bidder to withdraw before it is identified, but<br />

a prospective bidder who chooses this option will not be permitted<br />

to re-approach the target for another six months (except in limited<br />

circumstances – e.g., if another bidder emerges).<br />

For the financial bidder who intends instead to “put up” and<br />

proceed with its bid, but has yet to secure its bid finance, four<br />

Despite reassuring noises from<br />

the Panel that the changes are<br />

not aimed at the private equity<br />

industry, their effect may be felt<br />

most keenly by financial bidders<br />

28 Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong><br />

Strengthening<br />

the target’s hand<br />

weeks will rarely be enough. Although the Panel has the discretion<br />

to grant an extension to the four week period, it will usually only do<br />

so if the target is willing to seek the extension (so getting the target<br />

board on side at an early stage is critical). The Panel will only give its<br />

decision whether or not to grant an extension shortly before the<br />

four week deadline is due to expire, causing further uncertainty for<br />

any bidder.<br />

To avoid these new timetable pressures, bidders will be heavily<br />

reliant on bid confidentiality being maintained by all parties during<br />

the due diligence and bid financing negotiations. Where this can<br />

be achieved – see for example HG Capital’s bid for Group NBT<br />

plc announced shortly after the new rules came in – the bidder’s<br />

position is much improved.<br />

The other major change that is likely to impact particularly on<br />

private equity firms is the ban on inducement (break) fees, work<br />

fees and all other deal protection measures provided by the target,<br />

with only very limited carve-outs. In the past, these arrangements<br />

provided an element of protection for a prospective bidder where<br />

a competing bid materialised. Their abolition makes bids more<br />

risky for a financial bidder, even in cases where an approach is<br />

actively encouraged by the target. Bidders will need to consider<br />

other ways to protect themselves from the costs of failure, such<br />

as stake-building.<br />

On top of these changes, bidders will have to publicly disclose<br />

more detailed information on debt finance terms and the full<br />

content of financing documentation (although details of the<br />

equity structure will not usually need to be disclosed). Bidders must<br />

also give a complete breakdown of offer-related fees, more detail<br />

on the bidder’s intentions for the target company (and bidders will<br />

be held to their stated intentions for at least a year, if they don’t<br />

specify a timeframe), and provide more opportunity for employee<br />

representatives to make their views known.<br />

How far all this will impact on the ability of private equity houses to<br />

do deals still remains to be seen. The Panel has said (acknowledging<br />

the significance of the changes) that, depending on levels of<br />

bid activity, it plans to review the amended rules at least a year<br />

after implementation, so industry participants should use this<br />

opportunity to feed back their experiences of how the changes<br />

are operating in practice. n


Country<br />

Profile<br />

As global private equity investment in China continues to grow, neal greer speaks to those who<br />

have taken the plunge and operate in this intriguing emerging market<br />

Rarely has a country captivated the collective economic consciousness<br />

of so many people as China does at present. To some, the Chinese are<br />

potential white-knights delivering much needed financing to many<br />

struggling European companies starved of capital. It seems no matter<br />

where you go, what you read or who you ask, there is commentary<br />

and opinion keenly debating when the “C” part of the BRIC’s buoyant<br />

economy will leave the Western world for dust.<br />

Clearly the country has also become a destination for private<br />

equity investment. According to Thomson Reuters, the first half of<br />

the year saw £2.6bn of global private equity investment into China,<br />

encompassing 57 deals. This represents a considerable increase in<br />

terms of deal value of 265% and an increase of 23 deals on the<br />

same period in 2010.<br />

This growth can be partially attributed to the lure of such an<br />

exciting emerging market as traditionally pan-European and<br />

US-focussed firms look beyond their conventional investment<br />

strategy. Apax Partners certainly fall into that category. The Jermyn<br />

Street-based outfit opened an office in Hong Kong in 2005 and set<br />

up another office in Shanghai four years later.<br />

As they close in on their third transaction in China, partner Richard<br />

Zhang spoke candidly about the firm’s evolving strategy. He said:<br />

“We continue to see a wide range of investment opportunities<br />

across Europe and the US and are committed to these markets.<br />

There are also huge opportunities to combine this proven<br />

investment strategy and global sector expertise with a dedicated<br />

local presence in the rapidly growing markets of Asia. As the<br />

sectors in which Apax invests become increasingly global in nature,<br />

so it is that the source of long term supportive capital should also<br />

become global. There are clearly opportunities for a firm such as<br />

Apax with a deep knowledge of sector expertise to assist Western<br />

companies as they expand into China and vice versa.”<br />

For those not familiar with the territory, the notion of investing<br />

in China is something not to take lightly as Shanghai-based<br />

Ben Wootliff, Head of Corporate Investigation at Control Risks,<br />

explained. “There are fantastic opportunities in China,” he said.<br />

“But investors often don’t realise that it is also a highly opaque<br />

environment, with a relatively high level of corruption”. Control<br />

Risks work on the ground in China advising potential investors<br />

of the considerable risks. Colleague and senior consultant Will<br />

The Chinese<br />

challenge<br />

Tang added: “Limited access to reliable information and a weak<br />

contractual enforcement process make it a place where deals<br />

can easily go wrong and where problems can’t be easily resolved<br />

through the courts. Foreign arbitral awards are also rarely enforced<br />

in China so firms have little recourse when it comes to dispute<br />

resolution. Unlike in the US and UK, investors cannot always rely<br />

on the representations made by target companies; rather foreign<br />

investors need to understand how the personal relationships of<br />

business partners may increase the risk of fraud and corruption<br />

and violation of the FCPA and UKBA.”<br />

UK entrepreneur Matt Slater wholly echoed Wootliff’s and<br />

Tang’s guarded approach. Mechanical engineer Slater founded a<br />

consultancy ‘Senlinx’ in Shanghai earlier this year. He said: “Doing<br />

business in China is a somewhat daunting task that regularly tests<br />

your patience and commitment, it is no small undertaking, so<br />

understand what you are getting yourself into first.”<br />

“The lack of clarity from the regulatory and bureaucratic system<br />

makes seeking good advice of key importance - small decisions<br />

which seem inconsequential at the time, can often come back to<br />

haunt you”. Slater continued. “Local knowledge is critical in order<br />

to get things done efficiently - language and cultural differences<br />

are always challenges when doing business overseas, but in China<br />

these differences are amplified.”<br />

Despite the risks, which are part and parcel of any investment<br />

in any geography, Zhang was pleased with how things have<br />

progressed so far. “We will invest in China again when we see the<br />

right opportunities. Operationally we have had no problems at<br />

all. Our team in China is now well established within China while<br />

enjoying very strong connectivity with the global firm, especially<br />

the sector teams. The seamless operation between our sectors<br />

and our geographies is a core strength of Apax, which has enabled<br />

successful and innovative deals to be completed in emerging<br />

markets like China”.<br />

No one really knows when China will become the world’s leading<br />

superpower, nor does anyone indeed really know what the future<br />

holds for both current and prospective private equity investments<br />

in the country. What is certain however, is that China offers a<br />

myriad of opportunity for private equity. A chance of unlimited<br />

reward but balanced with considerable risk. n<br />

Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong> 29


Q&A<br />

As the new CeO of AVCA, what are your immediate/<br />

short-term priorities?<br />

AVCA aims to become the principal knowledge centre and service<br />

provider for the African private equity and venture capital industry.<br />

In time, we will be known as the pre-eminent advocate for the<br />

industry and a catalyst for private sector growth on the continent.<br />

As CEO, my number one priority is to deliver for our members<br />

through advocacy, training, conferences, research, industry news<br />

and seminars on topical events.<br />

In the short term, my first task is to revitalise the association and<br />

build it to become a successful and self-sustaining organisation. This<br />

process includes a number of key initiatives:<br />

• Building on the recent restructuring of our leadership and<br />

governance structure to rebuild our membership base and<br />

establish AVCA as the leading source of quality information on<br />

all matters related to private equity in Africa. Our board was<br />

recently strengthened with two high level appointments: Runa<br />

Alam (founding partner and CEO for Development Partners<br />

International) as Co-Chair and Simon Walker (Director-General<br />

for the Institute of Directors and ex-CEO of the <strong>BVCA</strong>) as Special<br />

Advisor. Runa and Simon are invaluable contributors to AVCA,<br />

bringing a wealth of experience in private equity and corporate<br />

reorganisation, deep connections in Africa and a demonstrated<br />

commitment to Africa’s private sector growth.<br />

• Establishing an affiliate of the Secretariat in London, giving<br />

AVCA greater connectivity with London-based African GPs who<br />

currently represent more than 50% of funds under management<br />

across the continent.<br />

• Developing peer-to-peer networks and negotiating collaboration<br />

agreements with international, regional and national associations<br />

such as EMPEA, SAVCA and others. We have recently signed a<br />

Memorandum of Understanding in Lagos, Nigeria with the <strong>BVCA</strong><br />

which will provide <strong>admin</strong>istrative support for the Secretariat,<br />

assistance in event organisation and training, as well as guidance<br />

on governance, amongst other areas of cooperation.<br />

• Embarking on a major recapitalisation initiative to ensure that<br />

AVCA can adequately deliver on its goals.<br />

• Communicating with our members, informing them of our new<br />

leadership structure, our goals and projects, and generally what<br />

we’re planning to do to better support them. Incidentally, I want<br />

to take this opportunity to announce that on 22-24 of April 2012,<br />

AVCA will hold its first annual conference in Accra, Ghana after a<br />

two-year hiatus.<br />

30 Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong><br />

with<br />

Michelle Kathryn Essomé<br />

CEO, African Private equity & Venture Capital<br />

Association (AVCA)<br />

And what about the longer term plans for the<br />

organisation?<br />

We are hearing from our members that there’s a need for greater<br />

Africa-specific data. In our first year, AVCA has already begun<br />

to undertake an investment activity report, launching the first<br />

performance benchmarks for Africa and will roll-out Africa-specific<br />

case studies for our training programmes, developmental impact<br />

and ESG studies.<br />

we have had two large funds targeting Africa raised this<br />

year from Carlyle and helios, but why now? what makes<br />

Africa an attractive investment destination?<br />

Quite simply, LPs are constantly seeking greater diversification,<br />

minimal positive correlation and attractive returns over traditional<br />

assets. Africa private equity is a new asset class that can deliver high<br />

returns, particularly in a very low interest rate environment such as<br />

the one prevailing today.<br />

In the 2011 Coller Capital/EMPEA survey, about 45% of LPs surveyed<br />

now viewed Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) as an attractive market,<br />

compared to 21% of respondents last year.<br />

African countries have experienced average growth rates of 4.9%,<br />

positioning the continent as one of the fastest growing regions in<br />

the world. Six of the world’s ten fastest-growing economies were in<br />

SSA over the past decade according to the Economist.<br />

We also are now seeing strong growth rates in companies operating<br />

in the financial services, agriculture and manufacturing sectors<br />

whereas historically Africa was largely a commodities play.<br />

In addition, Africa has a population of approximately 1 billion people,<br />

many of whom are becoming a burgeoning middle-class consumer<br />

base.<br />

When you look at all of these facts, Africa definitely needs to be a<br />

part of an emerging market portfolio. It is natural that global buyout<br />

firms are now looking to Africa with new eyes.<br />

what sort of impact has private equity had so far on<br />

African companies and economies?<br />

The role of impact investing - which seeks to make an impact be<br />

that social or environmental ‘beyond a positive financial return’<br />

– has been and continues to be a way that private investors and<br />

foundations such as Heirs Holdings, the Rockefeller Foundation just<br />

to name a few, can effect catalytic changes in African economies.<br />

AVCA is actively working to partner on these initiatives.


what countries and industry sectors offer the best<br />

opportunities for private equity investors?<br />

I think each GP would give you a different answer to this question!<br />

I personally would say Nigeria, Ghana, Kenya, Uganda and most of<br />

southern Africa would feature highly on the list.<br />

African GPs are looking for companies with strong management<br />

teams which can develop to become key regional players, as well as<br />

established companies with a leadership position in their market and<br />

are in need for funding for expansion.<br />

what are the main challenges to private equity<br />

investment in Africa?<br />

For global LPs, I would say the biggest challenge is the gap between<br />

perception and reality. Promoting successful portfolio companies<br />

will definitely go a long way to correcting these views.<br />

For GPs, many portfolio companies may not necessarily be attuned<br />

to the level of management reporting required by private investors, a<br />

dearth of industry data as cited earlier and limited exit opportunities.<br />

Patience is essential.<br />

is there such a thing as ‘African private equity’ or can the<br />

market be broken down into specific countries/regions?<br />

Definitely, although the African private equity market is still relatively<br />

young, in addition to pan-African funds, we’re also seeing regional<br />

and country-specific funds and sector plays - financial services,<br />

healthcare, fmcg, infrastructure, agriculture, telecommunications<br />

and natural resources, to name a few.<br />

Key to the growth of any private equity market is the<br />

involvement of domestic LPs. Are we seeing an increased<br />

appetite from local players across Africa?<br />

London<br />

10 November<br />

2011<br />

British Library<br />

Conference Centre<br />

Kings Cross St Pancras<br />

Sponsored by<br />

The only technical private equity and venture<br />

capital conference to be devised, delivered<br />

and hosted by industry experts.<br />

Over the past year, AVCA has held a series of private equity<br />

pension fund roundtables in conjunction with the Commonwealth<br />

Secretariat in Accra, Nairobi, Lagos and Gaborone with the express<br />

goal of educating local LPs.<br />

These investors can play vital role as they have local knowledge and<br />

a more intimate understanding of domestic firms. In addition, it’s<br />

important for global investors to see domestic commitment. In<br />

addition, there may be co-investment opportunities and, in some<br />

countries, regulations are supporting greater investment in private<br />

equity. Local LPs play a key role in the development of African<br />

private equity.<br />

if you had just one minute to explain the benefits of<br />

private equity, what would you say?<br />

There are huge advantages to private equity investment: an extensive<br />

due diligence process, a facility to stress test management’s business<br />

plan and forecast, an ability to exercise significant influence on<br />

management and a company’s strategy, interests are aligned, a<br />

optimal level of gearing can be achieved and a knowledge exchange<br />

which can enable companies to grow. n<br />

Biography<br />

Michelle Kathryn Essomé is the new CEO for the African Private Equity & Venture<br />

Capital Association.<br />

She has nearly 20 years of investment banking experience covering a wide range<br />

of marketing and origination roles in equities, fixed income and investment<br />

management with Merrill Lynch, Goldman Sachs, JPMorgan, Lehman Brothers<br />

and Nomura.<br />

Michelle has an MBA in Finance from Columbia Business School, where she was<br />

a Robert F. Toigo fellow, and a BBA in Finance from Howard University. She has<br />

worked in the US, UK and France and is fluent in French. In addition, she has lived<br />

in Niger, travelled throughout Africa and is married to a Cameroonian financier.<br />

TAX, Legal and<br />

Regulatory Conference<br />

For further information Please contact Tommy Nguyen at tnguyen@bvca.co.uk T: 020 7420 1852<br />

TLR-half ad Jul11.indd 1 04/10/2011 14:26<br />

Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong> 31


Comment<br />

On the eve of the next G20 Summit in France, shadow banking is set to be high on the agenda.<br />

Simon Horner looks how private equity can make its voice heard<br />

In October 1973, Syria and Egypt launched a surprise attack on<br />

Israel. The US, determined to protect a fledgling democracy,<br />

appropriated US$2bn in arms and aid. OPEC responded in turn with<br />

an oil embargo, and crisis and global recession followed. World<br />

leaders began regular gatherings in 1974 in the library of the White<br />

House to agree a response. In 1975, French President Valéry Giscard<br />

d’Estaing suggested a more formal, annual arrangement and the G6<br />

was born, comprising the UK, US, France, Italy, Germany and Japan.<br />

A year later, Canada joined to make the G7 and finally Russia in 1997<br />

to make the G8. During that time the group had proved an effective<br />

forum on anything from global conflict to international aid.<br />

But come the financial crisis in 2008, the G8 had lost its lustre.<br />

That it was the banks of the US and Europe that had brought the<br />

world economy to its knees meant the G8 was not in a position to<br />

dictate solutions for themselves or the rest of the world. In one<br />

fell swoop the G8 became the G20, admitting the BRICs and other<br />

strong emerging market powers.<br />

The G20 actually first met in 1999 as a group of finance ministers,<br />

but 2008 was the first time they came together as world leaders.<br />

This group was de facto charged with responding to the financial<br />

maelstrom that was fast gathering pace. The London Summit of<br />

2009 was the peak of activity with billions of new money made<br />

available for IMF bailouts and plans for global rebalancing laid out.<br />

In that febrile context, the sight of global leaders coming together<br />

and agreeing to pull in the same direction was a far cry from 1930s<br />

style beggar-thy-neighbour protectionism. But outside of global<br />

emergency what has become of the G20, what lies ahead and<br />

what does it mean for private equity and venture capital?<br />

Firstly, the G20 is here to stay. The system of rotating presidencies<br />

gives it a sense of perpetual motion with each new country<br />

determined to make its mark – indeed current holders France even<br />

have a special Eiffel Tower themed G20 logo. In terms of content<br />

we can be sure that whilst it will be steered to some extent by the<br />

whims of the presidency, it will be financial in focus (we already<br />

have the UN to stop wars and disease).<br />

Thus far, banks have copped most of the flak, just as they have<br />

domestically and in Europe. But there are clear signs that attention<br />

is drifting the way of alternative asset management, driven in<br />

part by the urging of bankers themselves. Shadow banking, a<br />

32 Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong><br />

Private equity<br />

and the g20<br />

somewhat emotive term, will be the subject of much discussion<br />

at this Autumn’s meeting. This is where private equity must sit up<br />

and listen.<br />

To some, notably in Brussels, shadow banking means anything<br />

financial that is not a bank. Thankfully to others, in particular the<br />

Financial Stability Board (FSB, effectively serving as the G20’s<br />

financial brain) it means something more nuanced. In April they<br />

released a scoping document that talked of credit intermediation<br />

and maturity and liquidity transformation – in other words, banking.<br />

We have long campaigned that private equity is not systemically<br />

risky, we do not leverage at the level of the fund and our portfolios<br />

are not cross-collateralised. Where private equity houses do invest<br />

in debt it is not originated by us and as there are no redemption<br />

rights for investors, there can be no maturity mismatch. Our case<br />

is clear but the pertinent question remains how do we present it<br />

and to whom?<br />

The G20 has no permanent secretariat and so the challenge<br />

is to identify the key players in the rotating presidency, in this<br />

case, France. The FSB does have a secretariat but its workings are<br />

relatively opaque. They are conceiving of workstreams as we speak<br />

that will determine the nature and content of discussions at this<br />

Autumn’s meeting.<br />

Tactically we are well placed to plug our arguments into this<br />

process, however ephemeral the protagonists may seem. But<br />

what is really required is a new global strategy to match up to the<br />

regulatory infrastructure that has sprung up around us. This means<br />

a new global public affairs council that matches the reach and the<br />

legitimacy of the G20 itself. Private equity has a huge footprint<br />

in China, Brazil, Mexico, India and increasingly Africa , but world<br />

finance ministers need reminding.<br />

We need to use such a forum to demonstrate the global worth<br />

of our sector and its importance to all G20 member nations. The<br />

<strong>BVCA</strong> has already signed MOUs with many of these countries,<br />

including Mexico who hold the next presidency. We are building a<br />

coalition to match that of the G20. Whether we need a secretariat<br />

ourselves remains to be seen. But what is clear is that as regulation<br />

goes global, our response must speak to that same constituency.<br />

Private equity is no longer the exclusive preserve of the G6, times<br />

have changed and so must we. n


Public<br />

Policy<br />

update<br />

AifM directive update<br />

The AIFM Directive is currently midway through the Level 2<br />

implementation phase. ESMA, the pan-European regulator,<br />

consulted on the advice that it will provide to the Commission<br />

on implementation measures over the Summer, and the <strong>BVCA</strong><br />

responded to this both in its own capacity as well as feeding<br />

into the pan-European industry response. ESMA will now<br />

review the consultation responses and produce a revised set of<br />

implementation advice to the Commission by 16 November. We<br />

will be engaging the Commission over the coming months to<br />

ensure that their final implementation measures are appropriate<br />

and workable for private equity.<br />

The consultation process has taken several months, and there are<br />

a number of areas – such as the requirements as to the type of<br />

professional indemnity insurance (PII) which fund managers will<br />

have to hold – where the <strong>BVCA</strong>’s input has helped to produce a set<br />

of advice that is workable for private equity and venture capital.<br />

Nevertheless, there remain a number of key areas of concern in<br />

the draft advice, and the Directive will have a significant impact<br />

on the industry.<br />

Key areas that we are still pressing on include:<br />

• The role of depositaries in monitoring the transactions of<br />

the fund – private equity funds will be required to appoint a<br />

depositary, which will have duties including the monitoring of<br />

the cash flows of the fund. Our response makes clear that this<br />

monitoring should be on an ex-post basis, and there should<br />

be no potential for the depositary to exercise ex-ante control<br />

over the fund. We have also argued that the depositary regime<br />

should introduce as few burdens as possible, to avoid onerous<br />

cost burdens on the industry.<br />

• The use of professional indemnity insurance or additional<br />

own capital – the Directive requires funds to hold PII cover or<br />

an additional amount of its own capital to protect investors<br />

against professional negligence. We have worked with ESMA<br />

to ensure that the level of cover to be held is placeable in the<br />

market, whilst still offering the appropriate protection.<br />

• The extent to which leverage undertaken at portfolio company<br />

or SPV can be excluded when calculating restrictions on a fund’s<br />

leverage. We have argued strongly that leverage at the portfolio<br />

company or SPV level should be excluded from any restrictions<br />

of leverage, as per the agreements reached at Level 1.<br />

Corporate governance<br />

Over the Summer, the <strong>BVCA</strong>’s Legal & Technical Committee<br />

responded to a Green Paper issued by the European Commission<br />

on corporate governance. Our response emphasised the strength<br />

of corporate governance and shareholder engagement in the<br />

private equity sector. A copy of the <strong>BVCA</strong> response is available here:<br />

http://bit.ly/prP0EL.<br />

Pre-pack sales<br />

Following its recent consultation, to which the <strong>BVCA</strong> responded,<br />

the Insolvency Service is reconsidering its proposals for changes<br />

to the pre-pack sales rules. Those contained in its proposal met<br />

with some resistance from interested parties and the proposed<br />

implementation date was pushed back to April 2012 at the earliest.<br />

A copy of the <strong>BVCA</strong> response is available here: http://bit.ly/p4FIo8.<br />

Takeover Code changes<br />

The Takeover Panel published its response statement to the<br />

proposed Code amendments set out in its March consultation<br />

paper on 21 July 2011. The amendments to the Code which were<br />

proposed in PCP 2011/1 were substantially adopted by the Code<br />

Committee. The Takeover Panel published a revised version of the<br />

City Code on 5 September 2011 and the amendments came into<br />

force on 19 September 2011.<br />

european contract law<br />

The <strong>BVCA</strong> is engaging with a number of interested parties and<br />

government departments on the latest consultation paper issued<br />

by the EU Commission. The proposals for a new pan-European<br />

contract law raise a number of concerns and the <strong>BVCA</strong> continues<br />

to monitor developments closely. A copy of the green paper can be<br />

found here: http://bit.ly/ql2XWU.<br />

financial reform<br />

HM Treasury published a consultation in June entitled “A new<br />

Approach to the Regulatory System: a blueprint for reform”. This<br />

is the third consultation HM Treasury have published in relation<br />

to proposed regulatory reform and it includes a summary of<br />

responses to its previous papers. It also sets out the draft text of<br />

the Financial Services Bill which makes amendments to existing<br />

legislation – in particular the Financial Services and Markets Act<br />

2000. The <strong>BVCA</strong> Regulatory Committee has submitted a response<br />

to this consultation focussing on proposals allowing the regulator to<br />

publish warning notices and to impose requirements on unregulated<br />

parent entities of FSA Regulated firms.<br />

Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong> 33


Market<br />

Statistics<br />

Despite a strong start<br />

to 2011, fundraising<br />

in the UK trailed off in<br />

Q3, with £2.1bn raised<br />

compared to more<br />

than £4bn raised in<br />

each of the previous<br />

quarters, according<br />

to data by Thomson<br />

Reuters. It was a similar<br />

picture globally where<br />

just over £25bn was<br />

accumulated, down on<br />

the £38bn+ Q1 and Q2<br />

each racked up.<br />

34 Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong><br />

fundrAiSing<br />

uK Quarterly Pe fundraising<br />

Amount raised (£bn)<br />

global Quarterly Pe fundraising<br />

Amount raised (£bn)<br />

16<br />

14<br />

12<br />

10<br />

8<br />

6<br />

4<br />

2<br />

0<br />

90<br />

80<br />

70<br />

60<br />

50<br />

40<br />

30<br />

20<br />

10<br />

0<br />

7.3<br />

Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3<br />

2007 2007 2007 2007 2008 2008 2008 2008 2009 2009 2009 2009 2010 2010 2010 2010 2011 2011 2011<br />

55.6<br />

9.1<br />

66.6<br />

5.0<br />

52.6<br />

11.7<br />

79.4<br />

14.1<br />

85.7<br />

3.0<br />

69.7<br />

3.6<br />

59.3<br />

6.3<br />

49.2<br />

2.8<br />

36.9<br />

1.2<br />

29.2<br />

Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3<br />

2007 2007 2007 2007 2008 2008 2008 2008 2009 2009 2009 2009 2010 2010 2010 2010 2011 2011 2011<br />

0.2<br />

16.9<br />

0.4<br />

10.7<br />

2.2<br />

32.5<br />

1.0<br />

28.7<br />

1.2<br />

25.8<br />

1.6<br />

27.3<br />

4.0<br />

38.8<br />

4.1<br />

38.9<br />

2.1<br />

Source: Thomson Reuters ThomsonOne<br />

25.7<br />

Source: Thomson Reuters ThomsonOne


2011 Q1–Q3 global Pe fundraising by Stage focus<br />

Net period amount raised (£m)<br />

50,000<br />

45,000<br />

40,000<br />

35,000<br />

30,000<br />

25,000<br />

20,000<br />

15,000<br />

10,000<br />

5,000<br />

0<br />

147<br />

44,696<br />

Buyouts Opportunistic Early Energy Generalist Fund of Later<br />

Secondary Turn- Value Core Other Seed<br />

stage<br />

funds stage<br />

funds around/ add<br />

private equity/ stage<br />

Distressed debt<br />

Special situations<br />

Mezzanine<br />

Balanced<br />

stage<br />

stage<br />

inVeSTMenTS<br />

145<br />

14,288<br />

45<br />

7,302<br />

Trends in uK VC investment<br />

Amount invested (£m)<br />

500<br />

400<br />

300<br />

200<br />

100<br />

0<br />

137<br />

316<br />

Q1<br />

2007<br />

455<br />

Q2<br />

2007<br />

135<br />

329<br />

Q3<br />

2007<br />

126<br />

376<br />

Q4<br />

2007<br />

81<br />

5,967<br />

113<br />

446<br />

Q1<br />

2008<br />

109<br />

17<br />

192<br />

5,520<br />

Q2<br />

2008<br />

40<br />

5,129<br />

69<br />

5,102<br />

89 89 90<br />

212<br />

Q3<br />

2008<br />

225<br />

Q4<br />

2008<br />

206<br />

Q1<br />

2009<br />

36<br />

4,466<br />

80<br />

62<br />

173<br />

Q2<br />

2009<br />

38<br />

4,175<br />

247<br />

75<br />

Q3<br />

2009<br />

Net period amount raised (£m) Number of funds<br />

3,320<br />

38<br />

17<br />

79 83<br />

207<br />

Q4<br />

2009<br />

2,741<br />

25<br />

2,349<br />

1,263<br />

12<br />

7<br />

830<br />

200<br />

180<br />

160<br />

140<br />

120<br />

100<br />

80<br />

60<br />

40<br />

20<br />

Source: Thomson Reuters ThomsonOne<br />

Amount invested (£m) Number of deals<br />

323<br />

Q1<br />

2010<br />

360<br />

80<br />

Q2<br />

2010<br />

73<br />

179<br />

Q3<br />

2010<br />

223<br />

Q4<br />

2010<br />

414<br />

Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong> 35<br />

29<br />

484<br />

64 67<br />

52<br />

Q1<br />

2011<br />

223<br />

Q2<br />

2011<br />

0<br />

160<br />

140<br />

120<br />

100<br />

80<br />

60<br />

40<br />

20<br />

0<br />

Number of funds<br />

Number of deals<br />

Source: Dow Jones VentureSource


<strong>BVCA</strong> launches bespoke<br />

personal insurance facility<br />

with Chubb Insurance<br />

<strong>BVCA</strong> Insurance Services is delighted to announce the launch of a bespoke personal<br />

insurance facility with Chubb Insurance supported by leading personal lines broker,<br />

Quantum Underwriting Solutions Plc. Chubb have recently been voted “Personal Lines<br />

Insurer of the Year 2010” in the Insurance Times Awards, for the eighth time in eleven<br />

years. Their market-leading Masterpiece policy covers any number of houses, cars and<br />

possessions under one policy, with one renewal date serviced by a dedicated personal<br />

account manager at Quantum.<br />

Individuals within <strong>BVCA</strong> Member firms can benefit from a free personal consultation, either at home or at work,<br />

to review whether their current insurance arrangements meet their needs and if not, find a better solution.<br />

<strong>BVCA</strong> Members are also offered the exclusive benefit of interest free credit, regardless of premium amount.<br />

Explaining the reasons behind this initiative Andrew Graham, COO of the <strong>BVCA</strong>, commented: “Following<br />

the development of <strong>BVCA</strong> Insurance Services we continue to explore new partnerships with insurance<br />

providers to deliver exclusive benefits to our Members. After carrying out extensive market research and<br />

<strong>BVCA</strong> Member assisted due diligence, we chose Quantum due to their unwavering commitment to an<br />

advice and service-led proposition.”<br />

Simon Mobey, Chubb European Personal Lines Manager, added: “Chubb Insurance is proud to be partnering<br />

with the <strong>BVCA</strong> and Quantum on this initiative. Like Quantum, we specialise in serving the insurance needs of<br />

those with more to protect, and for whom standard products are simply inadequate. Chubb’s service has won<br />

an unparalleled number of awards, and therefore our product will be the perfect match for the <strong>BVCA</strong> members<br />

who rightly demand a bespoke service.”<br />

Quantum was founded in 2004 and deals only with personal insurance for individuals with more to protect.<br />

Quantum are Chubb’s largest privately owned niche broker insuring over 1,500 clients covering collective assets<br />

in excess of £1.5Bn. Quantum is headquartered in Solihull with offices in London and Farnborough. Founding<br />

director, James Wasdell commented: “We are delighted to partner with the <strong>BVCA</strong> to offer market leading<br />

insurance products from a highly rated insurer”. He added: “We have been meeting new clients for six years and<br />

continue to see wholly inappropriate insurance cover that does not match the client’s lifestyle or asset-base.”<br />

For more information you can visit www.quantumplc.com/bvca.<br />

To book your personal consultation you can email bvca@quantumplc.com<br />

or call Quantum on 0870 402 1900.<br />

Alternatively contact Nathan Sewell, nsewell@bvca.co.uk<br />

36 Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong><br />

<strong>BVCA</strong> Insurance Services is authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Authority


The <strong>BVCA</strong> Transaction Tracker is (a) a list of venture capital and private equity deals involving<br />

UK targets and (b) a record of non-UK deals completed by UK-headquartered firms.<br />

The investments listed below took place between 9 July 2011 and 23 September 2011.<br />

Data provided by Thomson reuters.<br />

uK private equity deals<br />

Company name Location investment<br />

date<br />

Transaction<br />

tracker<br />

Business description investor(s)<br />

Guardian Assurance Lytham St. Annes 16/08/2011 Guardian Assurance is a financial and insurance services provider. Cinven<br />

Eaton Towers London 20/09/2011 Eaton Towers provides telecommunication services. Capital International<br />

Lexicon Partners London 19/08/2011 Lexicon Partners is an investment banking advisory services provider. Evercore Partners<br />

Nexeon Abingdon 03/08/2011 Nexeon is a United Kingdom-based silicon anodes developer. Imperial Innovations<br />

Wireless Logic Marlow 16/08/2011 Wireless Logic is a connectivity aggregator provider. ECI Partners<br />

Dreams High Wycombe 06/08/2011 Dreams is a United Kingdom-based bed retailer and manufacturer. Exponent Private Equity<br />

Brasserie Bar Co. Blisworth 09/09/2011 Brasserie Bar Co. operates within the premium casual drinking in UK. Core Capital<br />

Atlas Genetics Bristol 20/07/2011 Atlas Genetics is a point-of-care diagnostic tests developer. Bellevue Asset Management,Johnson & Johnson Development<br />

Corporation,Life Sciences Partners,Novartis Venture Funds,<br />

Laidlaw Interiors Group Willenhall 26/07/2011 Laidlaw Interiors Group is an interior products supplier and<br />

manufacturer.<br />

Blue Sphere Corporation London 23/08/2011 Blue Sphere Corporation develops Emission Reduction Project<br />

Integrator.<br />

WRG Creative<br />

Communications<br />

Manchester 14/08/2011 WRG Creative Communications is a marketing and events company. LDC<br />

Rutland Partners<br />

Centurion Venture Partners<br />

Horizon Discovery Cambridge 15/09/2011 Horizon Discovery is a personalized medicines developer. DFJ Esprit ,F. Hoffmann-La Roche AG,MVM Life Science Partners<br />

Autifony Therapeutics London 22/08/2011 Autifony Therapeutics is a biotechnology company. Imperial Innovations,SV Life Sciences Advisers<br />

ECO Plastics Hemswell 19/07/2011 ECO Plastics is a plastic bottle recycler. Ludgate Investments,<br />

WorldStores Twickenham 17/07/2011 WorldStores is an online home and garden products retailer. Advent Venture Partners,Balderton Capital Management<br />

Kalvista Pharmaceuticals Southampton 23/08/2011 Kalvista Pharmaceuticals is an ophthalmology company. Novo A/S,SV Life Sciences Advisers<br />

Advanced Plasma Power Swindon 12/09/2011 Advanced Plasma Power is a waste technology developer. Leveraged Green Energy<br />

MISSION Therapeutics Cambridge 25/08/2011 MISSION Therapeutics operates as a pharmaceutical company. F. Hoffmann-La Roche AG,Imperial Innovations,Smith Kline Beecham<br />

Corporation,Sofinnova Partners<br />

Beacon Endoscopic, Inc. Newton 01/08/2011 Beacon Endoscopic, Inc. is a medical device company. MVM Life Science Partners<br />

Stanmore Implants<br />

Worldwide<br />

Elstree 20/07/2011 Stanmore Implants Worldwide engages in the manufacture of<br />

implants.<br />

Imperial Innovations<br />

MediaSift Reading 11/07/2011 MediaSift develops social media tools and platforms. GRP Partners,IA Ventures<br />

Applied Superconductor Blyth 19/07/2011 Applied Superconductor is an electrical networks developer. IP Group,Ocas Ventures BVBA,Octopus Ventures<br />

Base79 London 15/09/2011 Base79 operates as a digital rights management company. MMC Ventures<br />

SupersonicAds London 19/07/2011 SupersonicAds develops social in-game advertising platform. Greylock Partners<br />

NewVoiceMedia Basingstoke 28/07/2011 NewVoiceMedia is a contact center services provider. Eden Ventures,Notion Capital Partners<br />

Hubdub Edinburgh 07/09/2011 Hubdub develops and operates skill games. Pentech Ventures,Scottish Investment Bank<br />

Twin Pines Creations London 20/09/2011 Twin Pines Creations develops website for the latest Top10 news. Accel Partners,Founder Collective,Idealab<br />

Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong> 37


Transaction tracker: uK private equity deals<br />

Company name Location investment<br />

date<br />

38 Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong><br />

Business description investor(s)<br />

Taptu Cambridge 08/09/2011 Taptu provides search and services for mobile devices. DFJ Esprit,Sofinnova Partners<br />

Lumicity London 19/08/2011 Lumicity owns and operates solar photovoltaic (PV) projects. Ludgate Investments,Novusmodus<br />

PneumaCare Cambridge 02/08/2011 PneumaCare is a United Kingdom-based imaging technology<br />

developer.<br />

Ardenham Energy Aylesbury 12/09/2011 Ardenham Energy is a renewable energy projects developer. Bridges Ventures<br />

Cambridge Angels,Cambridge Capital Group<br />

Atraverda Abertillery 24/08/2011 Atraverda is a power supply technology developer. Espirito Santo Ventures,Finance Wales ,OnPoint Technologies<br />

Seedcamp Investments London 08/09/2011 Seedcamp Investments is a United Kingdom-based fund incubator<br />

company.<br />

Burcote Wind Dunfermline 25/07/2011 Burcote Wind operates as a renewable energy company. Hotbed<br />

Wholebake Corwen 18/08/2011 Wholebake is a United Kingdom-based snack bars manufacturer. Finance Wales<br />

ACT Venture Capital,Bertelsmann Capital,GIMV N.V.,HENQ Invest,Reed<br />

Elsevier Ventures<br />

Endomagnetics London 05/08/2011 Endomagnetics operates as a medical device company. Bloomsbury Bioseed Fund,Sussex Place Ventures<br />

PolyTherics London 07/09/2011 PolyTherics is a United Kingdom-based biopharmaceutical company. Beringea,Longbow Capital,YFM Equity Partners<br />

Lanyrd London 06/09/2011 Lanyrd is a social conference directory provider. Index Ventures,PROfounders Capital<br />

KickSport Peterborough 20/07/2011 KickSport operates as a martial arts equipment retailer. Catapult Venture Managers<br />

Oxford Photovoltaics Yarnton 19/07/2011 Oxford Photovoltaics is a solar cell technology developer. MTI Partners<br />

Gekko Technology Kenilworth 24/08/2011 Gekko Technology is a lighting products manufacturer. Midven<br />

Shire Foods Leamington Spa 29/07/2011 Shire Foods is a United Kingdom-based pastry manufacturer. Dawnay Day Lander<br />

Oxtexs Oxford 01/08/2011 Oxtexs is a United Kingdom-based tissue expanders manufacturer. Isis Innovation<br />

Design LED Products Livingston 19/08/2011 Design LED Products is a light guide structures manufacturer. Braveheart Ventures,Highland Venture Capital,Scottish Investment<br />

Bank<br />

CamStent Cambridge 02/08/2011 CamStent is a United Kingdom-based polymer coatings developer. Undisclosed investor<br />

4i Security Blackburn 14/07/2011 4i Security is a United Kingdom-based security systems provider. Undisclosed investor<br />

wireWAX London 19/07/2011 wireWAX is a United Kingdom-based taggable video tool provider. Passion Capital Investments<br />

Continuous Retorts Newcastle Upon Tyne 26/07/2011 Continuous Retorts is a United Kingdom-based machinery<br />

manufacturer.<br />

Top Technology Ventures<br />

Rock Networks Warrington 20/07/2011 Rock Networks is a communication services provider. Undisclosed investor<br />

Whatusersdo Ashington 30/08/2011 Operates as an online user experience research service. North East Finance<br />

Anvil Semiconductors Coventry 09/07/2011 Anvil Semiconductors is a power converter devices developer. Midven<br />

Scour Prevention Systems Lowestoft 03/08/2011 Scour Prevention Systems is an erosion prevention services provider. London Business Angels<br />

Audacious Middlesbrough 12/07/2011 Audacious develops an application for the Internet. North East Finance<br />

Marchtown Associates Chester-le-Street 04/08/2011 n Associates is a search engine optimization software developer. North East Finance<br />

Future Medical Technologies Manchester 03/08/2011 Future Medical Technologies is a polymeric hydrogels developer. Undisclosed investor<br />

Alchemy Healthcare West Bradford 03/08/2011 Alchemy Healthcare is a drug delivery platforms developer. Undisclosed investor<br />

Med ePad Liverpool 24/08/2011 Med ePad is a United Kingdom-based mobile Internet device<br />

developer.<br />

Undisclosed investor<br />

Lifeways Community Care London 08/09/2011 Lifeways Community Care is a specialist care services provider. August Equity<br />

Logic Group Holdings, The Fleet 14/07/2011 Logic Group Holdings, The, is a transactions service provider. Susquehanna Growth Equity<br />

MeetingZone Thame 01/08/2011 MeetingZone provides automated conferencing services. GMT Communications Partners<br />

Motorclean Basildon 11/07/2011 Motorclean is a United Kingdom-based car valeting service provider. Matrix Private Equity Partners<br />

MSD Cranes & Equipment Darlington 25/07/2011 MSD Cranes & Equipment is a crane services provider. Undisclosed investor<br />

ParkatmyHouse.com - 14/07/2011 ParkatmyHouse.com is an online parking marketplace provider. BMW i Ventures<br />

Pattonair Derby 01/08/2011 Pattonair is a United Kingdom-based outsourcing services provider. Exponent Private Equity<br />

Original Additions (Beauty<br />

Products)<br />

Gas Measurement<br />

Instruments<br />

Hampson Industries - Shim<br />

Business<br />

Hayes 19/07/2011 Original Additions (Beauty Products) distributes beauty products. LDC<br />

Renfrew 03/08/2011 Gas Measurement Instruments is a detection instruments<br />

manufacturer.<br />

London 26/08/2011 Hampson Industries - Shim Business is a shim components<br />

manufacturer.<br />

Battery Ventures<br />

Bridgepoint Capital<br />

HB International London 24/08/2011 HB International operates as a global executive search company. Hamilton Bradshaw<br />

Evgen Liverpool 13/09/2011 Evgen is a United Kingdom-based cancer therapeutics developer. Enterprise Ventures,SPARK Venture Management<br />

Fairline Boats Oundle 12/07/2011 Fairline Boats is a United Kingdom-based powerboats manufacturer. Better Capital<br />

Fishawack Communications Knutsford 20/07/2011 Fishawack Communications operates group of healthcare companies. YFM Equity Partners


Transaction tracker: uK private equity deals<br />

Company name Location investment<br />

date<br />

Flexspace Industrial<br />

Buildings<br />

Business description investor(s)<br />

London 17/08/2011 Owns and operates industrial buildings. Europa Capital Partners<br />

Funeral Services Partnership Nottingham 14/09/2011 Funeral Services Partnership provides funeral services. August Equity<br />

Kent Solar Plant (4.9MW) Sevenoaks 16/08/2011 Kent Solar Plant (4.9MW) operates as a photovoltaic power plant. Foresight Group<br />

Indicus Advisors London 08/08/2011 Indicus Advisors is an alternative investment manager. Ares Management<br />

Inpartnership Manchester 15/08/2011 Inpartnership is an asset management and advisory services provider. Sigma Capital Group<br />

Amor Group Renfrew 11/07/2011 Amor Group provides information technology support. Growth Capital Partners<br />

Angel Springs Wolverhampton 20/07/2011 Angel Springs is a United Kingdom-based water cooler company. LDC<br />

ACHICA Cheltenham 30/07/2011 ACHICA is a United Kingdom-based online shopping store. Balderton Capital Management<br />

Advanced Childcare Stockport 01/09/2011 Advanced Childcare is a United Kingdom-based care services provider. Global Innovation Partners<br />

Ark Home Healthcare London 20/09/2011 Ark Home Healthcare provides home healthcare services. Core Capital,Core Capital Partners<br />

Attenda Staines 24/08/2011 Attenda is a United Kingdom-based managed services provider. Darwin Private Equity<br />

Azullo Lancaster 01/08/2011 Azullo is an online advertising platform developer and provider. AXM Venture Capital<br />

BACTEC International Rochester 17/08/2011 BACTEC International is an explosive ordnance disposal company. Perusa<br />

Bagel Nash Leeds 03/08/2011 Bagel Nash is a bagel fast food chain of restaurants. YFM Equity Partners<br />

BBC Magazines London 16/08/2011 BBC Magazines is a print and online publishing company. Exponent Private Equity<br />

Edge Public Solutions Sale 19/07/2011 Edge Public Solutions is a transformation services provider. Undisclosed investor<br />

CapQuest Group London 17/08/2011 CapQuest Group provides financial services. TowerBrook Capital Partners<br />

Card Factory Wakefield 14/07/2011 Card Factory owns and operates greeting card and gift stores Charterhouse Capital Partners<br />

City & County Healthcare Wembley 14/07/2011 City and County Healthcare provides social care services. Sovereign Capital<br />

Climate Energy Witham 29/07/2011 Climate Energy is a United Kingdom-based energy advice provider. Climate Change Capital<br />

By Design UK London 11/09/2011 By Design UK is an interior design aggregation Website provider. eVenture Capital Partners<br />

Cambridge Semiconductor Cambridge 21/07/2011 Cambridge Semiconductor is a power management developer and<br />

supplier.<br />

Clydesdale Bank<br />

Brintons Kidderminster 08/08/2011 Brintons is a United Kingdom-based carpet manufacturer. Carlyle Group, The<br />

Beepl London 20/07/2011 Beepl helps users seek opinions and product recommendations. Credo Ventures as<br />

Benchmark Scaffolding London 27/07/2011 Benchmark Scaffolding is a modular system and hoists provider. RCapital Partners<br />

Bezier London 22/08/2011 Bezier is a United Kingdom-based retail media provider. H.I.G. Capital<br />

RedKite Financial Markets London 26/07/2011 RedKite Financial Markets is a surveillance services provider. DFJ Esprit<br />

SeeSaw Online London 14/07/2011 SeeSaw Online is an online video content provider. Undisclosed investor<br />

Select Living Options Gloucester 14/07/2011 Select Living Options provides support living services. Sovereign Capital<br />

Teaching Personnel Welwyn Garden City 15/08/2011 Teaching Personnel is a personnel recruitment services provider. Graphite Capital Management<br />

Tinopolis Group Llanelli 09/08/2011 Tinopolis Group is a media production services provider. Vitruvian Partners<br />

Verdant Leisure Dunbar 25/07/2011 Dunham Leisure owns and operates holiday home parks. RJD Partners<br />

Vickers Electronics - 22/07/2011 Vickers Electronics manufactures energy management system. Enterprise Ventures,PHD Equity Partners<br />

Virgin Active Central Milton Keynes 20/08/2011 Virgin Active owns and operates a chain of health and fitness centres. CVC Capital Partners<br />

we7 Oxford 26/07/2011 we7 operates an online music website. Eden Ventures,Pentech Ventures,Qualcomm Ventures<br />

WTG Technologies London 22/08/2011 WTG Technologies is an applications platform developer. Undisclosed investor<br />

Zulu Beauty London 04/08/2011 Zulu Beauty is a United Kingdom-based online cosmetics retailer. Undisclosed investor<br />

Community Pharmacy London 06/09/2011 Community Pharmacy operates as a chain of pharmacies. Beringea<br />

Pro Bono Bio Reading 12/09/2011 Pro Bono Bio operates as a healthcare company. GK Rossiyskaya Korporatsiya Nanotekhnologiy, OAO<br />

Unipart Automotive Oxford 16/09/2011 Unipart Automotive is a United Kingdom-based car parts supplier. H2 Equity Partners<br />

Ark Home Healthcare London 20/09/2011 Ark Home Healthcare is a domiciliary care services provider. Core Capital<br />

Spa Future Thinking Oxford 22/09/2011 Spa Future Thinking is a market research company. Next Wave Partners<br />

beJig London 12/09/2011 beJig is a United Kingdom-based social gaming platform provider. Undisclosed investor<br />

City Inn London 16/09/2011 City Inn offers modern luxury hotels. Blackstone Group<br />

Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong> 39


non-uK private equity deals by uK firms<br />

Company name Location investment<br />

date<br />

40 Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong><br />

Business description investor(s)<br />

Garmz Austria 06/08/2011 Garmz is an Austria-based fashion portal operator. Eden Ventures,Kima Ventures<br />

Wilkinson Steel and Metals Canada 07/08/2011 Wilkinson Steel and Metals is a steel and metal distributor. HarbourVest Partners ,Headway Capital Partners ,HSBC Capital<br />

(Canada),Morgan Stanley Alternative Investment Partners,Nova<br />

Capital Management,Parish Capital Advisors<br />

National Concrete<br />

Accessories<br />

Canada 07/08/2011 National Concrete Accessories is a hardware manufacturer and<br />

distributor.<br />

HarbourVest Partners ,Headway Capital Partners ,HSBC Capital<br />

(Canada),Morgan Stanley Alternative Investment Partners,Nova<br />

Capital Management,Parish Capital Advisors<br />

Debro Chemicals Canada 07/08/2011 Debro Chemicals, Inc. is a Specialty Chemical Distribution company. HarbourVest Partners ,Headway Capital Partners ,HSBC Capital<br />

(Canada),Morgan Stanley Alternative Investment Partners,Nova<br />

Capital Management,Parish Capital Advisors<br />

Exchanger Industries Canada 07/08/2011 Exchanger Industries designs and manufactures heat transfer<br />

equipment.<br />

HarbourVest Partners ,Headway Capital Partners ,HSBC Capital<br />

(Canada),Morgan Stanley Alternative Investment Partners,Nova<br />

Capital Management,Parish Capital Advisors<br />

Golden Jaguar Group China 26/07/2011 Golden Jaguar Group operates buffet restaurant chains. Apax Partners Worldwide<br />

Qosmos France 08/09/2011 Develops and sells Network Intelligence/DPI technology solutions. Alven Capital Partners SA,DFJ Esprit<br />

Orege France 12/07/2011 Orege SA is active in the environmental sector. Climate Change Capital<br />

PhotoBox France 25/07/2011 Photobox SAS provides online digital photography services. Greenspring Associates,HarbourVest Partners ,Highland Capital<br />

Partners ,Index Ventures,Insight Venture Partners,Quilvest Capital<br />

Ateliers LR Etanco SAS France 05/09/2011 Manufactures and distributes building fasteners and fixing systems. 3i Group<br />

Foncia Groupe France 26/07/2011 Provides property management services. Bridgepoint Capital,EURAZEO<br />

Losberger Germany 06/09/2011 Losberger provides solution for construction of tents and halls. H.I.G. Capital<br />

Novem Car Interior Design Germany 18/08/2011 Manufactures automobile interior trim components. Bregal Capital<br />

tausendkind Germany 23/08/2011 tausendkind operates an online store with products for children. Gatcombe Park Ventures,IBB Beteiligungsgesellschaft<br />

Green Building Group Germany 21/07/2011 Green Building Group manufactures prefabricated construction. H.I.G. Capital,Solidus Partners<br />

EyeEm Mobile Germany 04/08/2011 Offers photo sharing application for computers. Passion Capital Investments,Wellington Partners<br />

IN tIME Express Logistik Germany 12/08/2011 IN tIME Express Logistik provides freight transportation services. Barclays Private Equity<br />

PYI Corporation Hong Kong 21/08/2011 PYI Corporation, Ltd manufactures and installs marble and granite<br />

products.<br />

AID Partners Capital<br />

Brandtone Ireland 21/08/2011 Brandtone is an Ireland-based mobile marketing company. Enterprise Ireland,Unilever Ventures,Verlinvest ,Vision Capital<br />

Igobubble Ireland 20/09/2011 Igobubble provides a mobile application. Black Pearl Capital<br />

Mintigo Israel 19/09/2011 Serves as an automated acquisition solution. Giza Venture Capital,Sequoia Capital<br />

Mentor Development<br />

Partners<br />

Kenya 22/08/2011 Offers consulting services in the area of real estate development Actis Capital<br />

Rift Valley Railways Kenya 11/09/2011 Rift Valley Railways provides railway transportation services. BIO,International Finance Corporation,KfW,Netherlands Development<br />

Finance Company<br />

Raet Holding Netherlands 24/08/2011 Raet Holding BV provides services for payroll and personnel<br />

<strong>admin</strong>istration.<br />

CVC Capital Partners<br />

Doedijns International Netherlands 10/08/2011 Doedijns International BV is an engineering services provider. IK Investment Partners<br />

Bureau van Dijk Electronic<br />

Publishing<br />

Rizal Commercial Banking<br />

Corporation<br />

Emerging Markets<br />

Payments Holdings<br />

Netherlands 22/07/2011 Bureau van Dijk Electronic Publishing B.V. publishes business<br />

information.<br />

Charterhouse Capital Partners<br />

Philippines 15/07/2011 Rizal Commercial Banking Corporation operates as a commercial bank. CVC Capital Partners<br />

South Africa 16/08/2011 Emerging Markets Payments Holdings is a payment services provider. Actis Capital<br />

Com Hem Sweden 21/07/2011 Com Hem AB provides television, telephone and Internet services. BC Partners<br />

Docu Group Deutsche<br />

Holding<br />

Switzerland 09/08/2011 Docu Group Deutsche Holding provides information services. GMT Communications Partners<br />

Infront Sports & Media Switzerland 02/09/2011 Infront Sports & Media provides marketing services and sport services. Bridgepoint Capital<br />

Kinetic Concepts United States 13/07/2011 Kinetic Concepts, Inc. is a medical technology company. Apax Partners Worldwide<br />

BakerCorp United States 31/07/2011 Supplies containment rental equipment in the United States. Permira Advisers<br />

Valeritas United States 12/09/2011 Valeritas, Inc. operates as a medical technology company. Abingworth Management,Advanced Technology Ventures,CHL<br />

Medical Partners,HLM Venture Partners,Kaiser Permanente<br />

Ventures,MPM Capital,ONSET Ventures,Pitango Venture Capital,Welsh,<br />

Carson, Anderson & Stowe<br />

TouchTunes Music<br />

Corporation<br />

United States 17/08/2011 TouchTunes Interactive Networks provides entertainment services. 3i Group,VantagePoint Capital Partners<br />

AccuVein United States 28/07/2011 Manufactures and sales medical devices for health care industry. Bessemer Venture Partners,MVM Life Science Partners<br />

Quid United States 25/07/2011 Quid, Inc. develops data collection software. Atomico Ventures,Endeavour Vision,Founders Fund, Infocomm<br />

Investments<br />

Beacon Endoscopic United States 01/08/2011 Beacon Endoscopic, Inc. is a medical device company. MVM Life Science Partners<br />

Advanced Cardiac United States 08/09/2011 Advanced Cardiac Therapeutics, Inc. develops cardiac ablation NBGI Private Equity<br />

Therapeutics<br />

catheters.<br />

Personalis United States 12/08/2011 Personalis, Inc. operates as a biotechnolgy company. Abingworth Management,Lightspeed Venture Partners,Mohr Davidow<br />

Ventures<br />

Covestor United States 31/08/2011 Covestor, Inc. provides online portfolio-sharing services. Amadeus Capital Partners,Episode-1 Partners,Spark Capital,Union<br />

Square Ventures<br />

Fingerprint Digital United States 08/09/2011 Operates as a kid's learning and entertainment platform. Reed Elsevier Ventures,Undisclosed Investor<br />

M86 Security United States 28/07/2011 Develops security solutions for Internet-based communication HarbourVest Partners ,Kelso Place Asset Management ,Updata<br />

streams.<br />

Partners,Vora Ventures<br />

Echoecho Media United States 08/09/2011 Echoecho Media, Inc. provides mobile software. Google Ventures,PROfounders Capital<br />

UTEC Survey United States 22/07/2011 UTEC Survey, Inc. provides survey and geotechnical services. Kelso Place Asset Management ,Lime Rock Partners<br />

Peregrine Midstream United States 03/08/2011 Peregrine Midstream Partners operates as oil and natural gas EQT<br />

Partners<br />

company.<br />

BNY ConvergEx Group United States 20/07/2011 BNY ConvergEx Group provides investment technology solutions. CVC Capital Partners<br />

Dealer.com United States 25/08/2011 Dealer.com, Inc. provides online marketing solutions services. Accel Partners,Apax Partners Worldwide<br />

Martini Media Network United States 11/07/2011 Martini Media Network operates online content and advertising<br />

networks.<br />

Granite Ventures ,Reed Elsevier Ventures,Venrock Associates<br />

HUB International United States 18/07/2011 HUB International provides insurance services. Apax Partners Worldwide ,Morgan Stanley Private Equity


© 2011 EYGM Limited. All Rights Reserved.<br />

Information tells.<br />

Insight reveals.<br />

For the latest insights<br />

into how private equity<br />

investors created value<br />

during 2010 visit<br />

www.ey.com/privateequity<br />

See More | Insight<br />

Autumn 2011 <strong>BVCA</strong> <strong>Briefing</strong> 41


The leading industry body for venture<br />

capital and private equity worldwide.<br />

we lead and represent our industry.<br />

we are a bridge between our industry and investors.<br />

we demonstrate our industry’s positive economic and social impact.<br />

We help you access:<br />

A global network of industry leaders and opportunities<br />

• Over 200 prominent industry figures serve as committee and advisory board members<br />

• More than 480 members, including General Partners, Limited Partners and<br />

professional advisers<br />

• Entrepreneurs and portfolio companies to facilitate deal flow<br />

• Exclusive preferential rates for more than 40 high-profile networking events<br />

Cutting-edge industry intelligence and training<br />

• Extensive library of proprietary research materials developed in-house<br />

• Estimated £10m of expert advice provided to our tax, legal and regulatory committees<br />

• Specialist training programmes devised and led by industry experts<br />

effective representation and influence in policy making<br />

• Representing members’ interests in Whitehall, Brussels and the wider international arena<br />

• Developing regulatory and legislative recommendations to support enterprise and growth<br />

• Liaising with senior media representatives to ensure our industry is at the forefront<br />

we support your objectives and drive innovation and growth.<br />

For further information<br />

contact the <strong>BVCA</strong><br />

1st Floor North, Brettenham House<br />

Lancaster Place, London WC2E 7EN<br />

T: +44 (0)20 7420 1800<br />

F: +44 (0)20 7420 1801<br />

E: bvca@bvca.co.uk<br />

bvca.co.uk

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!