26.10.2013 Views

Stop Copyists From Undercutting Your Innovation - Foley & Lardner ...

Stop Copyists From Undercutting Your Innovation - Foley & Lardner ...

Stop Copyists From Undercutting Your Innovation - Foley & Lardner ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Damages<br />

Chint (China) v. Schneider Electric (France)<br />

– Schneider brought a patent infringement lawsuit<br />

against Chint, to force Chint into an acquisition<br />

deal; Chint sued Schneider for infringement of its<br />

own utility model patent<br />

– $47M awarded to Chint in Sept. 2007<br />

– The parties settled at $23M in April, 2009<br />

– Wenzhou Intermediate Court (Zhejiang Province)<br />

©2009 <strong>Foley</strong> & <strong>Lardner</strong> LLP<br />

Damages (cont.)<br />

Holley Communications (China) v. Samsung<br />

Electronics (Korea)<br />

– Holleycomm sued Samsung for patent<br />

infringement<br />

– SIPO held the patent valid<br />

– $7.4M awarded to Holleycomm in Dec, 2008<br />

– On appeal now<br />

– Hangzhou Intermediate Court (Zhejiang Province)<br />

©2009 <strong>Foley</strong> & <strong>Lardner</strong> LLP<br />

37<br />

38<br />

19

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!