In The Student uniform Industry - RJ McCarthy
In The Student uniform Industry - RJ McCarthy
In The Student uniform Industry - RJ McCarthy
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
A bright new perspective on<br />
CSR Accountability<br />
in the student <strong>uniform</strong> industry<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>RJ</strong>M 2010 Accountability Report
<strong>The</strong> <strong>RJ</strong>M 2010 Accountability Report<br />
Table of Contents<br />
CEOs Open Letter on CSR<br />
Corporate Social Responsibility Strategy<br />
Key Performance <strong>In</strong>dicators<br />
Manufacturing Responsibility<br />
Greening our Operations<br />
<strong>In</strong>spiring our People<br />
Supporting our Communities<br />
Company Background<br />
Report Scope<br />
Appendix: Code of Conduct<br />
3<br />
10<br />
11<br />
12<br />
16<br />
19<br />
21<br />
23<br />
24<br />
25<br />
2
CEO’s Open Letter on CSR<br />
Reviewing our progress in 2009 on Corporate Social Responsibility<br />
One year ago, I started as the new CEO of R.J. <strong>McCarthy</strong> (“<strong>RJ</strong>M”) and pledged to make our company an industry leader<br />
in corporate social responsibility (“CSR”). <strong>RJ</strong>M had always been strong in CSR, but we wanted to go farther. As a<br />
company, we decided to get very serious about this new goal – so much so that we renewed our mission to state that our<br />
reason for being as an organization is to “create the world's highest quality school <strong>uniform</strong>s in a socially responsible way”.<br />
<strong>In</strong> the last year, I have travelled across our company<br />
speaking to our employees, across Canada speaking<br />
to our customers, and across the world speaking to<br />
our suppliers, to communicate our passion and focus<br />
around this new purpose. During these talks, I made a<br />
pledge that my tenure would start with new ideas<br />
around CSR, and quickly be followed by concrete<br />
actions. We have achieved that promise. <strong>The</strong> purpose<br />
of this letter is to demonstrate to our constituents how<br />
seriously we are taking this new mission and how<br />
much progress we have made against it in just one<br />
year. I'd also like to comment on some of the<br />
challenges we are facing and on where we are going<br />
“... I made a pledge<br />
that my tenure would<br />
start with bold new<br />
ideas around CSR, and<br />
quickly be followed<br />
by concrete actions. We<br />
have achieved that<br />
promise.”<br />
John Kelleher, President & CEO<br />
Background<br />
Director, Board of Directors of Covenant House<br />
(Canada’s largest youth homeless shelter)<br />
Former President & CEO, one of Canada’s top retailers<br />
(Black’s Photography)<br />
MBA, Harvard Business School<br />
MPA, Harvard School of Government<br />
from here.<br />
PART I – A Summary of our Progress in the Last Year<br />
As a company, we feel very proud of our progress to date. Two of our first actions were to give someone inside the company<br />
the role of Head of Social Responsibility and to create a new four part framework that would guide all of our thinking and<br />
work on CSR. Our new framework clarified our intentions to make progress in four key areas: (1) Manufacturing<br />
responsibly; (2) Greening our operations; (3) <strong>In</strong>spiring our people; and (4) Supporting our communities.<br />
I would like to lay out the achievements we've had in these four areas during this past year and comment on where we are<br />
going from here. We believe that we have already become the leader in our industry on CSR. At the same time, I would<br />
absolutely stress that we see everything we've done as a beginning and not an end. We are committed to a long-term outlook<br />
on CSR and will work to continually improve and expand how the company is performing on corporate social responsibility.<br />
3
1<br />
Manufacturing Responsibly<br />
4
1<br />
Manufacturing Responsibly<br />
<strong>The</strong> achievement I would most like to highlight in this section is the completion of third-party audits on<br />
every supplier that manufactures (cuts and sews) <strong>RJ</strong> <strong>McCarthy</strong>-branded products. This gives us the<br />
confidence that we have had qualified, independent experts look at these<br />
facilities to help us get a baseline of each facility's current standing on CSR.<br />
<strong>The</strong>se experts are confident that we do not currently have any Zero Tolerance<br />
violations (violations that we find completely unacceptable such as forced<br />
labour, child labour, etc.).<br />
Are we saying that no issues exist in these facilities? Absolutely not. Are we<br />
saying that no future problems will arise? Absolutely not. It would be difficult to say that about any<br />
manufacturing facility anywhere in the world. Of course there are issues that require improvement and<br />
remediation over time. We are saying that we have now gained an understanding of “our baseline” and that<br />
we are now working on addressing these problems.<br />
Furthermore, we've committed to a regular program<br />
of action (ourselves, our third-party auditors, and<br />
other independent groups with whom we've<br />
committed to collaborate) that should identify and<br />
correct issues in a very open and transparent way<br />
going forward. Through high standards, rigorous<br />
John Kelleher in <strong>RJ</strong>M’s Toronto Factory<br />
positive change over time.<br />
auditing, transparent discussion of successes and<br />
challenges, and serious follow up, we will make real<br />
I would also like to highlight that we are continuing to work with the Worker Rights Consortium (“WRC”)<br />
in Washington, D.C. I've personally traveled down to Washington on multiple occasions to meet with their<br />
Executive Director and to talk openly about our issues and challenges. At present, we are also continuing<br />
our policy of voluntarily disclosing our factory locations to this group and agreeing to cooperate with them<br />
on periodic evaluations of our facilities.<br />
5
2 Greening Our Operations 3<br />
<strong>In</strong>spiring Our People<br />
6
4<br />
Supporting Our Communities<br />
Heart to Heart Haiti<br />
Uniform<br />
Assistance<br />
Program<br />
7
PART II – A Summary of our Progress in the Last Year<br />
8
PART III – Where We Are<br />
Going From Here<br />
<strong>In</strong> addition to working on the challenges I described earlier, we are also thinking about the following<br />
longer-term opportunities in CSR for our company. Over the next five years, we will continue to explore<br />
these as a way of even further enhancing our leadership on CSR versus our competitors:<br />
1. Being more transparent about CSR challenges - I'm a huge believer in transparency and I think people<br />
will support you through almost any problem so long as you're open and candid about the challenge<br />
involved. <strong>The</strong> best companies on CSR speak extremely openly and candidly about both successes and<br />
failures. That is why I'm writing this report and this new spirit of transparency is what <strong>McCarthy</strong>'s is now<br />
all about. We have actually engaged a team of MBA students from the Richard Ivey School of Business to<br />
help us write this report - the student <strong>uniform</strong> industry's first accountability report. We have now published<br />
this report (and will do so every two years hereafter) as a part of our new commitment to transparency.<br />
2. Educating and inspiring parents about the importance of social responsibility – and exciting them about<br />
what <strong>RJ</strong>M is doing - to do this we can use our showrooms, our marketing materials, and our staff.<br />
3. “Cracking the code” on more environmentally and socially friendly products.<br />
4. Making the case to school boards that <strong>RJ</strong>M is delivering real benefits through its CSR investments –<br />
how to avoid having them choose competitors that don't focus on CSR to the same degree.<br />
5. Continually increasing, over time, our ability to manufacture more responsibly by:<br />
a. Looking at more sourced products, not only <strong>McCarthy</strong> - branded items<br />
b. Thinking through more aspects of our value chain - aiming to take our CSR efforts further<br />
into our supply chain over time<br />
c. Providing more and greater documentation of issues and follow up efforts<br />
We are very proud of what we have achieved at <strong>McCarthy</strong>'s on CSR in just one short year. We now lead<br />
our industry in this area by a wide margin.<br />
But again, I would like to end by repeating that we see everything we have done so far as a beginning and<br />
not an end. When it comes to CSR, a very long term sustained commitment is required and that's exactly<br />
what we intend to deliver.<br />
John Kelleher<br />
President and CEO<br />
R.J. <strong>McCarthy</strong> LP<br />
9
Corporate Social Responsibility<br />
R.J. <strong>McCarthy</strong> (hereafter <strong>RJ</strong>M) understands that as the leader in school <strong>uniform</strong>s in Canada, we must take the lead in social<br />
responsibility. As our customers are those who will be inheriting the world of tomorrow, we must be a company that looks to the<br />
future with a respect and understanding of how we impact this world, the environment and our own local communities.<br />
Our top management team and our Board of Directors have recently made the decision to reexamine everything our company is<br />
doing in order to see how we can become one of Canada's leading companies in sustainable practices.<br />
To achieve this goal, <strong>RJ</strong>M recently developed a comprehensive 4-part framework:<br />
1. Responsible<br />
Sourcing &<br />
Manufacturing<br />
2. Greening Our<br />
Operations<br />
3. <strong>In</strong>spiring Our<br />
People<br />
4. Supporting<br />
Our<br />
Communities<br />
At <strong>RJ</strong>M we are proud of the steps that we've<br />
taken so far, but we are truly excited about<br />
the new and more aggressive steps that we<br />
are planning around social responsibility in<br />
every part of our business. We believe that<br />
doing this is an essential part of driving<br />
towards our mission of creating the world's<br />
highest quality school <strong>uniform</strong>s in a socially<br />
responsible way.<br />
To continually monitor and improve our<br />
performance standards in social<br />
responsibility, <strong>RJ</strong>M uses a variety of tools<br />
and resources, including:<br />
1. <strong>In</strong>tertek Reports<br />
2. Carbonzero Report<br />
3. Quarterly Dashboards and<br />
Accountability Reports<br />
4. BFI Reports on waste management<br />
Ultimately we are responsible to a number<br />
of stakeholders: students, parents,<br />
employees, and the communities in which<br />
we operate. <strong>RJ</strong>M is committed to ensuring<br />
we are socially responsible throughout our<br />
operations to the satisfaction of each of our<br />
stakeholders.<br />
MANUFACTURING RESPONSIBLY<br />
OUR GOAL: TO EHNANCE OUR LONGSTANDING COMMITMENT TO PRODUCING<br />
MCCARTHY UNIFORMS USING MANUFACTURERS AND SUPPLIERS THAT<br />
ENSURE SAFE AND FAIR WORK ENVIRONMENTS<br />
What we are doing to achieve this:<br />
‘GREENING’ OUR OPERATIONS<br />
OUR GOAL: TO SIGNIFICANTLY REDUCE OUR ENVIRONMENTAL FOOTPRINT<br />
What we are doing to achieve this:<br />
INSPIRING OUR PEOPLE<br />
OUR GOAL: TO CREATE A CORPORATE CULTURE WITH A DEEP COMMITMENT TO<br />
SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY<br />
What we are doing to achieve this:<br />
SUPPORTING OUR COMMUNITIES<br />
OUR GOAL: TO CONTINUE OUR LONG STANDING COMMITMENT TO SUPPORTING<br />
OUR CANADIAN COMMUNITIES<br />
What we are doing to achieve this:<br />
10
Key Performance <strong>In</strong>dicators<br />
Issues<br />
Key Performance <strong>In</strong>dicators (KPI)<br />
<strong>In</strong>formation<br />
Source<br />
2009<br />
Results<br />
1. Manufacturing<br />
Responsibly<br />
Factory Audits <strong>In</strong>tertek Factory Audits (#)<br />
Aggregate Factory Audit Score (%)<br />
<strong>In</strong>tertek Report<br />
<strong>In</strong>tertek Report<br />
7 of 7<br />
91%<br />
Audit: ZT violations<br />
ZT Policy Compliance (%)<br />
ZT Violations (#)<br />
<strong>In</strong>tertek Report<br />
<strong>In</strong>tertek Report<br />
100%<br />
0<br />
Audit: UR violations<br />
UR Policy Compliance (%)<br />
UR Violations (#)<br />
<strong>In</strong>tertek Report<br />
<strong>In</strong>tertek Report<br />
89%<br />
68<br />
Audit: OP violations<br />
OP Policy Compliance (%)<br />
OP Violations (#)<br />
<strong>In</strong>tertek Report<br />
<strong>In</strong>tertek Report<br />
95%<br />
20<br />
Violation Resolution<br />
Progress<br />
Total Violations identified (#)<br />
Violations Resolved (#)<br />
Resolutions being explored (#)<br />
Commitment Letters Sent to Factories (#)<br />
Commitment Letters Received From<br />
Factories (#)<br />
Head of Purchasing<br />
Head of Purchasing<br />
Head of Purchasing<br />
Head of Purchasing<br />
Head of Purchasing<br />
88<br />
88<br />
0<br />
6<br />
6<br />
2. Greening<br />
Our Operations<br />
Carbon Neutrality Carbon Footprint (tCO2e) Carbonzero 1306<br />
Commuting Sales Fleet Composition (% of Hybrids) <strong>RJ</strong>M<br />
100<br />
Energy Conservation<br />
Electricity Consumption (kWh/sq.ft.)<br />
Electricity Emissions (tCO2e/sq.ft.)<br />
Natural Gas Consumption (m3/sq.ft.)<br />
Natural Gas Emissions (tCO2e/sq.ft.)<br />
Carbonzero<br />
Carbonzero<br />
Carbonzero<br />
Carbonzero<br />
8.7<br />
0.0015<br />
1.5<br />
0.0032<br />
Waste Management<br />
Total Waste Generated (kgs)<br />
BFI<br />
51120<br />
Shipping<br />
Emissions / Package (tCO2e/pckg)<br />
Carbonzero<br />
7.6<br />
Water Consumption<br />
Water Consumption (total m3)<br />
Hydro Bill<br />
n/a<br />
3. <strong>In</strong>spiring<br />
Our People<br />
Employee Satisfaction<br />
Employee Survey Score (%)<br />
Employee Surveys Completed (#)<br />
<strong>RJ</strong>M Employees<br />
Survey<br />
80<br />
3<br />
4. Supporting<br />
Our Communities<br />
Making Charitable<br />
Donations<br />
Number of School Recipients<br />
Uniform Assistance Program ($000)<br />
<strong>RJ</strong>M<br />
<strong>RJ</strong>M<br />
253<br />
200<br />
Primary Charitable Partner<br />
Scholarships<br />
Charitable <strong>In</strong>itiatives (#/year)<br />
Scholarships Provided ($000)<br />
<strong>RJ</strong>M<br />
<strong>RJ</strong>M<br />
8<br />
85<br />
5. Raising<br />
Awareness<br />
Parental Awareness<br />
Sustainability Satisfaction Score (%)<br />
Community Satisfaction Score (%)<br />
Responsible Sourcing Satisfaction Score (%)<br />
Parent Survey<br />
Parent Survey<br />
Parent Survey<br />
98%<br />
96%<br />
97%<br />
11
MANUFACTURING RESPONSIBLY<br />
Responsible sourcing and manufacturing is a major part of our business and one that we've tackled head-on. Beginning with<br />
setting clear and high standards, <strong>RJ</strong>M is committed to doing business only with those manufacturers who share our high<br />
standards and provide safe and fair work environments for their employees. Educating our suppliers about responsible<br />
manufacturing is the most critical thing we can do since ultimately it is only when our supply chain cares as much about<br />
these issues as we do that we will have truly had the impact that we desire.<br />
Once these standards have been communicated, we put in place new processes to monitor our supply chain against these<br />
standards and to make sure that our principles of social responsibility are being upheld. If changes are needed, we work<br />
closely with manufacturers to educate and help them to make the necessary adjustments to enact positive changes and to<br />
improve their working conditions.<br />
Finally, by communicating our progress and challenges in a transparent way, we ensure that all parties are well informed and<br />
are provided with ample opportunity to engage in our process.<br />
We are currently also exploring the opportunity to source and to retail more sustainable products made from recycled and<br />
biodegradable materials in our showrooms. Over time, we will strive to make this a more significant part of our business.<br />
Our customers care about these products and we must be responsive.<br />
Our goal is to enhance our longstanding commitment to producing <strong>RJ</strong>M <strong>uniform</strong>s using manufacturers and suppliers that<br />
ensure safe and fair work environments. To achieve this goal, we actively monitor our cut and sew factories through internal<br />
and external audits and frequent visits to facilities in China.<br />
Why is <strong>RJ</strong>M currently manufacturing in China?<br />
Our manufacturing facilities are currently located predominately in China, with six factories in that country and one in<br />
Canada. We work directly with these suppliers, who cut, sew and embroider our <strong>uniform</strong>s before they are shipped to Canada.<br />
Our manufacturing facility in Canada is located at our head office in Toronto.<br />
We source globally from<br />
China because of it’s . . .<br />
What this means. . .<br />
“Where Chinese companies<br />
[out perform rivals] is by<br />
offering a combination of a<br />
low-cost and, . . . a full<br />
package service, and stateof-the-art<br />
machinery<br />
including information and<br />
communication<br />
technology”<br />
-Report on ICTs in the Value Chain<br />
12
Highlight of <strong>In</strong>itiatives<br />
1. Developed and implemented a new Code of Conduct system for all of our suppliers<br />
2. Partnered with <strong>In</strong>tertek to provide formalized third-party auditing of our factories in China and Canada<br />
3. <strong>In</strong>troduced a three-tiered rating system to accurately measure the conditions of our factories<br />
1) Code of Conduct<br />
We made changes to our Code of Conduct this year to increase our focus and signal our commitment to CSR to our<br />
suppliers. Please refer to the Appendix for our Code of Conduct.<br />
While the principles of our code have remained the same, we have made significant progress in our ability to measure and<br />
benchmark the CSR initiatives at <strong>RJ</strong>M and our supply network.<br />
(Excerpt from the <strong>RJ</strong>M Responsible Manufacturing Guidebook)<br />
General Principle<br />
<strong>RJ</strong>M intends to conduct its business in a socially responsible manner and is determined to work with suppliers who<br />
endorse the standards and principles outlined in this document, the <strong>RJ</strong>M Responsible Manufacturing Guidebook &<br />
Checklist (hereafter Guidebook). <strong>RJ</strong>M will only partner with businesses that either meet the standards and principles<br />
outlined in the Guidebook or are committed to meeting these standards over a reasonable period of time.<br />
<strong>In</strong> general, when deviations from our standards are discovered by us or brought to our attention by others, our first<br />
choice will be to work proactively with the Supplier involved to drive positive change and to achieve the standard. As<br />
many labor rights groups have said, this is the best way to truly enact change. However if we determine that a<br />
management team at a factory is not genuinely addressing corrections in a timely manner, we will suspend or<br />
permanently bar the supplier in question. Suppliers may be given time to fix problems, but we will not abide with<br />
Suppliers who do not take these issues as seriously as we do.<br />
2) Formalized Audits<br />
<strong>RJ</strong>M follows a three-tiered manufacturing audit process that<br />
allows us to ensure our adherence to our Code of Conduct.<br />
This year we selected <strong>In</strong>tertek, a leading quality and safety partner<br />
for global businesses, as our responsible manufacturing partner.<br />
<strong>In</strong>tertek performed full audits of our six cut and sew factories in<br />
China and our Toronto headquarters in Canada, and created<br />
comprehensive audit reports.<br />
<strong>The</strong>se audit reports allow us to track policy violations and the<br />
initiatives under way to eliminate violations in the future. <strong>The</strong>y<br />
also allow us to ensure that our partners are focused on<br />
sustainability and committed to making improvements.<br />
<strong>RJ</strong>M Factory Audit Partner<br />
“<strong>RJ</strong>M is not a large multinational<br />
company, but is now setting<br />
standards and using CSR policies<br />
for its cut and sew operations that<br />
are as good as those from very large<br />
-Linda Wei,<br />
<strong>In</strong>tertek Representative<br />
13
Our three levels of audits:<br />
We monitor our suppliers<br />
through internal distance audits<br />
We send firm representatives to visit<br />
cut and sew operations overseas<br />
We have engaged independent 3rd-parties<br />
to perform targeted audits of our suppliers<br />
Why it is important<br />
What we do<br />
3) Rating System<br />
We developed a comprehensive three-tiered rating and point<br />
system to audit our cut and sew factories. Our rating system<br />
was developed in collaboration with <strong>In</strong>tertek, and ensures our<br />
high standards are conveyed through it. <strong>The</strong> rating system<br />
communicates our expectations about responsible<br />
manufacturing to our suppliers, and acts as a benchmark for<br />
year-over-year improvements.<br />
Third-party auditor<br />
Each item in our audits is assigned to one of three tiers – zero<br />
tolerance, urgent remediation, or ongoing progress. We take<br />
these matters seriously and will work with suppliers to ensure<br />
that they are committed to comply with our requirements<br />
prior to entering into a contract.<br />
Zero Tolerance (ZT) items include child labour, harassment,<br />
discrimination and other practices that are totally unacceptable. <strong>The</strong>se<br />
violations are usually illegal and fundamentally unethical. <strong>RJ</strong>M takes<br />
these matters very seriously and, prior to entering into a contract with a<br />
Supplier, will do everything possible to work with the Supplier to ensure<br />
that Suppliers do what is necessary to comply with <strong>RJ</strong>Ms requirements.<br />
Urgent Remediation (UR) items include unfair discipline practices,<br />
lack of employment benefits, certain health and safety concerns and<br />
other practices that are intolerable over a reasonable time period.<br />
Ongoing Progress (OP) items include keeping proper employment<br />
records, ensuring rules and regulations are clearly posted and legible,<br />
reconstructing exits to be more accessible, and other practices that,<br />
although important, do not require immediate attention.<br />
We plan to rigorously measure all our suppliers<br />
according to this three-tiered system<br />
<strong>The</strong>se ratings illustrate our view of the severity and<br />
time sensitivity of each item discussed<br />
This will help both factories and auditors quickly<br />
understand how we believe each item should be<br />
handled<br />
A point system has been devised to indicate the<br />
importance of each item, the expectations <strong>RJ</strong>M<br />
holds of its suppliers, and to track improvement over<br />
time<br />
We plan to continuously upgrade and improve our<br />
Code of Conduct over time<br />
14
Results<br />
Focus Key Performance <strong>In</strong>dicator (KPI)<br />
Goal 2009 Results Progress<br />
Factory<br />
Audits<br />
<strong>In</strong>tertek Factory Audits (#)<br />
Aggregate Factory Audit Score (%)<br />
Conduct one audit per year per factory<br />
Establish auditing baseline for future<br />
Audited all 7 factories<br />
Received score of 91.4%<br />
Minimizing<br />
UR violations<br />
UR Policy Compliance (%)<br />
UR Violations (#)<br />
Achieve 90% Compliance, or greater<br />
Establish auditing baseline for future<br />
Achieved 89% UR Compliance<br />
68 outstanding UR violations<br />
Minimizing<br />
OP violations<br />
OP Policy Compliance (%)<br />
OP Violations (#)<br />
Achieve 90% Compliance, or greater<br />
Establish auditing baseline for future<br />
Achieved 95% OP Compliance<br />
20 outstanding OP violations<br />
Eliminating<br />
ZT violations<br />
ZT Policy Compliance (%)<br />
ZT Violations (#)<br />
Achieve 100% Compliance<br />
Establish auditing baseline for future<br />
Achieved 100% ZT Compliance<br />
Achieved zero ZT violations<br />
Violation<br />
Resolution<br />
Progress<br />
Total Violations Outstanding (#) Establish auditing baseline for future <strong>In</strong>curred 88 violations<br />
Violation Resolution in Progress (#) <strong>In</strong>crease violation resolutions being explored 61 resolutions being explored<br />
Violations Resolved (#)<br />
<strong>In</strong>crease violation resolved<br />
27 violations resolved<br />
On target<br />
Within 10% of target<br />
Off target<br />
<strong>In</strong>sufficient data<br />
Actions for 2010<br />
Going forward, we are exploring other manufacturing/cut and sew locations that offer emerging capability and better<br />
quality/cost tradeoffs. Those include Bangladesh, Cambodia, and Vietnam (or others). We will provide an update on our<br />
progress in future reports.<br />
15
GREENING OUR OPERATIONS<br />
From our head office in Toronto to every <strong>RJ</strong>M showroom across Canada, we are focused on greening our operations.<br />
We are minimizing consumption and reducing waste by limiting materials packaging, using less paper in showrooms and in<br />
our head office, moving to double-sided copying, exploring e-billing, and by making a concerted shift to use more recycled<br />
post-consumer paper and materials in marketing products where possible. Furthermore, all of our locations recycle and have<br />
shifted to more environmentally friendly cleaning products.<br />
We have transitioned our light fixtures to use more energy efficient bulbs and have installed occupancy sensors in low-traffic<br />
areas to save energy. Over time, we will explore transitioning to more energy efficient and less pollution-emitting cooling<br />
and heating systems in all of our buildings.<br />
We have reduced the use of plastic shopping bags at all of our retail locations with the launch of our “plastic to enviro”<br />
shopping bag project.<br />
Highlight of <strong>In</strong>itiatives<br />
1. Partnered with Carbonzero to measure full GHG inventory; achieved carbon neutrality for all owned operations<br />
2. <strong>In</strong>troduced internal environmental improvements in operations; reduced plastic shopping bags, transitioned to hybrid<br />
vehicles<br />
3. <strong>In</strong>troduced recycling program, reducing standard waste by approximately 30%, and increasing company wide recycling of<br />
paper and plastics<br />
1) Carbonzero Partnership to achieve carbon neutrality<br />
in our headquarters and showrooms<br />
<strong>RJ</strong>M has implemented a full, multi-year greenhouse gas<br />
management strategy that will measure, reduce and<br />
neutralize greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from its<br />
business.<br />
<strong>RJ</strong>M has partnered with Canadian company Carbonzero to<br />
undertake a measured, phased approach to ensure that our<br />
full GHG inventory is properly and accurately accounted for<br />
and neutralized.<br />
<strong>The</strong> multi-year, complete approach used by Carbonzero<br />
ensures a true inventory of heating and cooling energy<br />
emissions, electricity consumption, and vehicle fleet energy<br />
consumption and emissions.<br />
October 2009<br />
Carbonzero consultants,<br />
Howie Chong and<br />
Elizabeth Koster, at<br />
<strong>McCarthy</strong>'s head office,<br />
carefully examining our<br />
documents and records.<br />
“We have been very impressed with the total<br />
organizational commitment <strong>McCarthy</strong>’s has shown to its<br />
new green strategy and towards achieving carbonneutrality”<br />
Howie Chong<br />
President, Carbonzero<br />
16
Why we chose to work with Carbonzero?<br />
Carbonzero is a Canadian company that helps<br />
organizations, governments and individuals manage<br />
and neutralize their greenhouse gas (GHG)<br />
emissions.<br />
Carbonzero is a leader in providing full service<br />
carbon management solutions for its clients including<br />
fully verifiable ISO-14064-1 compliant carbon<br />
footprint assessments and was recently ranked the<br />
highest provider of made-in-Canada offsets by the<br />
David Suzuki Foundation and the Pembina <strong>In</strong>stitute.<br />
Carbonzero has worked with other premium<br />
Canadian brands like the Liberal Party of Canada,<br />
<strong>The</strong> Canadian Union of Public Employees, and<br />
Vitamin Water (Coca-Cola Canada).<br />
We chose Carbonzero because of its industry leading,<br />
rigorous, auditable methodology for calculating<br />
carbon footprints.<br />
<strong>RJ</strong>M has achieved carbon neutrality for all of its owned<br />
operations (referred to as Scope 1 and Scope 2<br />
emissions).<br />
For these emissions, we have conducted a<br />
comprehensive internal project to reduce the emissions<br />
that could be reduced, and where we have not reduced,<br />
we have purchased offsetting donations (referred to as<br />
“offsets”) toward renewable energy projects to reduce<br />
our carbon-footprint to zero.<br />
We have provided our offsets to the Commission<br />
Scolaire Marguerite-Bourgeoy (CSMB) GHG Emissions<br />
Reduction, a project that consists of a series of energy<br />
efficiency measures across over 100 schools in the<br />
Greater Montreal area.<br />
Rigorous process and results<br />
Carbonzero spent nearly a month with us to assess the<br />
greenhouse gas emissions of our Canadian operations.<br />
<strong>The</strong>y use the GHG accounting process to calculate our<br />
emissions from:<br />
a. Heating, cooling and electricity<br />
from building operations<br />
b. Vehicle fuel<br />
c. Corporate travel<br />
d. Employee commuting<br />
e. All shipping within Canada<br />
We are proud to report that we have now offset our carbon<br />
footprint and are carbon neutral in the above areas.<br />
2) Transition to<br />
Hybrid Vehicles<br />
<strong>RJ</strong>M is proud to announce their transition to a fleet of<br />
energy-efficient vehicles for its sales force. Since<br />
September 1, 2009, all members of <strong>RJ</strong>M's school<br />
sales team have been driving the new Toyota Prius,<br />
one of the world's leading hybrid vehicles with a<br />
reputation for first rate fuel efficiency.<br />
This shift to a “greener” fleet is a critical part of<br />
<strong>RJ</strong>M's new detailed plan on social responsibility and<br />
another meaningful step towards achieving<br />
<strong>McCarthy</strong>'s renewed mission of “creating the world's<br />
highest quality school <strong>uniform</strong>s in a socially<br />
responsible way”.<br />
3) Waste Management<br />
Through our partnership with BFI waste management,<br />
we introduced recycling facilities across all showrooms<br />
in 2009, resulting in a reduction of waste by<br />
approximately 30%.<br />
17
Improved <strong>In</strong>ternal Operations<br />
<strong>RJ</strong>M is minimizing consumption and reducing waste by concurrently engaging in multiple internal initiatives that aim at<br />
reducing our environmental impact and greening our operations.<br />
Reduced<br />
energy use<br />
Reduced<br />
water consumption<br />
Decreased use of<br />
plastic<br />
Decreased use of<br />
paper and increase<br />
recycling<br />
Results<br />
Issue Key Performance <strong>In</strong>dicator (KPI)<br />
Goal 2009 Results Progress<br />
Carbon<br />
Neutrality<br />
Carbon Footprint (tCO2e) Establishing baseline for future Recorded 1306 tCO2e.<br />
Energy<br />
Conservation<br />
Electricity Consumption (kWh/sq. ft.<br />
Electricity Emissions (tCO2e/sq. ft.)<br />
Establishing baseline for future<br />
Establishing baseline for future<br />
Recorded 8.70 kWh/sq.ft<br />
Recorded 0.0015 tCO2e/sq.ft<br />
Natural Gas Consumption (m3/sq. ft.)<br />
Establishing baseline for future<br />
Recorded 1.50 m3/sq.ft<br />
Natural Gas Emissions (tCO2e/sq. ft.)<br />
Establishing baseline for future<br />
Recorded 0.0032 tCO2e/sq.ft<br />
Waste<br />
Management<br />
Total Waste Generated (kgs) Establishing baseline for future Generated 51120 kgs of waste<br />
Shipping Emissions / Package (tCO2e/pckg) Establishing baseline for future Recorded 7.61 tCO2e/pckg<br />
Commuting<br />
Sale Fleet Composition<br />
(% of Hybrids)<br />
Establishing baseline for future<br />
Replace old vehicles with hybrid<br />
vehicles<br />
Water<br />
Consumption<br />
Water Consumption (total m3) Establishing baseline for future No measurement obtained<br />
On target<br />
Within 10% of target<br />
Off target<br />
<strong>In</strong>sufficient data<br />
18
Greening Our Operations:<br />
Challenges<br />
1. Thinking through the relevance and feasibility of<br />
including offshore carbon emissions through suppliers<br />
Actions for 2010<br />
2. Identifying the life expectancy of key assets, so that<br />
eco-replacements can be considered (including<br />
machinery, furnaces, lighting, and leases)<br />
3. Behavioral/Awareness and training with staff to bring<br />
them up to speed on our plans and motivate them to<br />
take action<br />
INSPIRING OUR PEOPLE<br />
Social and environmental responsibility starts with awareness. By empowering each and every one of our employees with the<br />
knowledge and tools necessary to act in an environmentally conscious way not just at work but in their daily lives as well, we<br />
are creating a corporate culture that institutes, at its foundation, what it means to be green. We have recently implemented a<br />
series of ongoing workshops called the “lunch and learn series.” Among the critical topics that will be discussed with our<br />
employees is CSR education. To make sustainability a real part of our business we must truly engage employees in this<br />
discussion at every level of our company.<br />
Highlight of <strong>In</strong>itiatives<br />
1. Appointed a new Head of Social Responsibility<br />
2. Held first 'Lunch and Learn' workshops<br />
3. Held first town hall meetings to encourage and inspire employees to think about social responsibility<br />
4. <strong>In</strong>troduced employee satisfaction survey<br />
19
Head of Social Responsibilty<br />
“I am thrilled to have led <strong>McCarthy</strong>'s into a greener, more sustainable,<br />
and more responsible era of business in 2009. I am excited about our<br />
strategy and our plan, and am proud to have the full support of our<br />
new President, our Board of Directors, and the rest of the <strong>McCarthy</strong><br />
team. I am confident that, over time, the <strong>McCarthy</strong> brand will be<br />
synonymous with sustainability.”<br />
- Joanna Halligan,<br />
Head of Social Responsibility<br />
Do you love your job at <strong>McCarthy</strong>’s?<br />
80%<br />
80% of employees say<br />
“I love my job at <strong>McCarthy</strong>’s”<br />
Employee Satisfaction Survey<br />
We have recently introduced a quarterly survey that tracks employee<br />
satisfaction. <strong>The</strong> survey allows us to monitor our employee satisfaction<br />
and assess the impact of our initiatives.<br />
“I am excited about the changes I am seeing. . . we have built a<br />
great company with great employees.” - <strong>RJ</strong>M Employee<br />
Community Town Hall<br />
Meetings<br />
Our Town Hall Meetings, led by our President and CEO John<br />
Kelleher, introduced our new mission and vision for the<br />
future of <strong>McCarthy</strong>'s, addressed the results from our first ever<br />
employee survey, as well as all the work being done<br />
regarding responsible manufacturing in our supplier factories.<br />
Lunch and Learn<br />
<strong>In</strong> an effort to increase communication and awareness<br />
throughout the company, we introduced our Lunch and Learn<br />
Workshops. During these lunch hours, a member of our team<br />
makes a presentation on an issue that they are passionate<br />
about. Our Lunch and Learn Workshops have covered such<br />
topics on Sustainability, Health and Safety in the Workplace,<br />
Why Uniforms & Why <strong>McCarthy</strong>'s, and Responsible<br />
Manufacturing.<br />
Results<br />
Issues Key Performance <strong>In</strong>dicator (KPI)<br />
Goal 2009 Results Progress<br />
Employee<br />
Satisfaction<br />
Employee Survey Scores<br />
(% satisfied)<br />
<strong>In</strong>crease employee satisfaction score 80%<br />
Employee Survey Completed (#) <strong>In</strong>crease number of employee surveys completed 3<br />
On target<br />
Within 10% of target<br />
Off target<br />
<strong>In</strong>sufficient data<br />
20
<strong>In</strong>spiring Our People:<br />
Challenges<br />
Actions for 2010<br />
SUPPORTING OUR COMMUNITIES<br />
<strong>RJ</strong>M provides significant support to communities and families with the <strong>McCarthy</strong> Partnership Program. This program focuses on<br />
three major aspects of community involvement: school donations, scholarships, and the <strong>uniform</strong> assistance program.<br />
<strong>In</strong> all of the above, <strong>RJ</strong>M has been a leader in establishing these kinds of programs and in supporting our communities. Every one<br />
of our employees is very proud of the positive impact our business has made over the last 50+ years in this regard.<br />
Highlight of <strong>In</strong>itiatives<br />
Our goal is to continue our commitment to providing significant support to communities and families with the <strong>McCarthy</strong><br />
Partnership Program through school donations, scholarships, and <strong>uniform</strong> assistance, as well as Canadian charitable<br />
organizations and worthy causes beyond our borders.<br />
Our partnerships<br />
Covenant House<br />
At R.J. <strong>McCarthy</strong>, we are committed to helping charities in<br />
our community through the donation of products as well as<br />
charitable donations. <strong>In</strong> December 2009, we donated 240<br />
hooded sweatshirts, 100 baseball caps, and 30 backpacks to<br />
the Covenant House youth shelter as part of their Street<br />
Kids Christmas Gift Book campaign. We look to continue<br />
supporting Covenant House as part of our ongoing<br />
charitable partnerships in the future.<br />
Annual Fundraising & Charitable Donations<br />
We have formed fundraising partnerships with the<br />
Canadian Breast Cancer Foundation, Heart and Stroke, <strong>The</strong><br />
Angel Foundation for Learning, and Breakfast Clubs of<br />
Canada. We also worked with MSC Canada in raising<br />
$170,000 for their causes in 2009, and Heart to Heart Haiti<br />
to raise $33,300. Finally, we worked with Condoray, an<br />
organization in Peru that helps teach women and children<br />
proper hygiene, and basic language and printing skills.<br />
21
Our <strong>Student</strong>s<br />
We at <strong>RJ</strong>M believe in supporting our students in order to ensure that not only are they able to participate in the <strong>uniform</strong><br />
program at their school, but also, to ensure that their voices are heard.<br />
School Donations<br />
<strong>McCarthy</strong> partner schools benefit from our school donation program, which is intended to help<br />
schools improve the quality of education for all students. <strong>RJ</strong>M donated to a total of 253 schools<br />
in 2009.<br />
Scholarships<br />
Each year we award deserving students with a <strong>McCarthy</strong> Scholarship to help finance postsecondary<br />
opportunities. <strong>In</strong> 2009, we donated a total of $85,000 in scholarships.<br />
Uniform Assistance Program<br />
<strong>McCarthy</strong>'s works closely with partner schools to provide needy families with school <strong>uniform</strong>s to<br />
ensure that every child has a basic <strong>uniform</strong>, regardless of their family income. Last year we<br />
donated $200,000 in the form of <strong>uniform</strong> assistance to students in need. We will be working to<br />
increase our support of students, and tracking the amount of support that students are receiving.<br />
Results<br />
Issues Key Performance <strong>In</strong>dicator (KPI)<br />
Goal 2009 Results Progress<br />
Making<br />
Charitable<br />
Donations<br />
Primary<br />
Charitable<br />
Partner<br />
Total Charitable Donations ($) Establish baseline for future Donated $180,000<br />
Number of School Donation<br />
Recipients<br />
Uniform Assistance Program<br />
Donation ($)<br />
Establish baseline for future 253<br />
Establish baseline for future Donated $200,000<br />
Charitable <strong>In</strong>itiatives (#/year) Establish baseline for future Executed 8 charitable initiatives<br />
Scholarships Scholarships Provided ($) Establish baseline for future Awarded $85,000 in scholarships<br />
On target<br />
Within 10% of target<br />
Off target<br />
<strong>In</strong>sufficient data<br />
Supporting Our<br />
Communities: Challenges<br />
Actions for 2010<br />
22
Company Background<br />
Profile<br />
Established in 1956 by Robert J. <strong>McCarthy</strong>, <strong>McCarthy</strong>’s is Canada’s leading retailer of school<br />
<strong>uniform</strong>s. <strong>McCarthy</strong>’s has a network of 15 showrooms across Canada, a large base of loyal<br />
customers, and serves the <strong>uniform</strong> needs of thousands of students and families across the country.<br />
Over its proud 54-year history, <strong>McCarthy</strong>’s has earned a reputation for offering its school partners<br />
and customers the widest selection of high quality school <strong>uniform</strong>s along with the most<br />
convenient shopping options. <strong>McCarthy</strong>’s is committed to ensuring that – in addition to<br />
unsurpassed quality – corporate social responsibility and sustainability become the new<br />
foundation of its exciting new mission and strategy. For more information please visit<br />
www.rjmccarthy.com.<br />
A Rich History<br />
Martin <strong>McCarthy</strong> took<br />
over as President<br />
Set up international<br />
supplier<br />
relationships<br />
Senior management<br />
team members were<br />
hired from outside<br />
the family<br />
Assembled a Board<br />
of Directors with<br />
strong independent<br />
advisors to help us<br />
grow and develop<br />
1983<br />
1987 2000 2009<br />
1956 1998<br />
2003-07<br />
R.J. <strong>McCarthy</strong> Ltd.<br />
was founded by Bob<br />
<strong>McCarthy</strong><br />
<strong>In</strong>itiated expansion plan -<br />
opened first store outside<br />
of HQ<br />
Expansion continued,<br />
growing to 15 stores<br />
23
Report Scope<br />
Basis of the Report<br />
<strong>The</strong> R.J. <strong>McCarthy</strong> CSR Sustainability Report was developed following the Global Reporting <strong>In</strong>itiative's (GRI) G3<br />
Guidelines and Apparel and Footwear Sector Supplement (AFSS). Although at the present time <strong>RJ</strong>M has not applied for<br />
the GRI designation, we will continue to adhere to the G3 reporting guideline for subsequent reporting periods and will<br />
endeavor to receive the GRI designation in the near future.<br />
<strong>RJ</strong>M has attempted to create a complete and comprehensive report; however, several G3 and AFSS indicators are omitted<br />
from the report, either due to lack of internal data or irrelevance of the indicator on <strong>RJ</strong>M's current operations. Our future<br />
goal is to bridge the gap as we continue to improve on our methods of gathering key data metrics.<br />
For more information about the Global Reporting <strong>In</strong>itiative, see www.globalreporting.org<br />
Every data point in this report was verified internally. We continue to explore the viability of an external verification<br />
program.<br />
If you have any questions about this report, please direct them to:<br />
Head of Social Responsibility<br />
sustainability@rjmccarthy.com<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>McCarthy</strong> Building<br />
360 Evans Avenue<br />
Toronto, ON, M8Z 1K5<br />
1-800-668-8261<br />
24
Appendix: Manufacturers' Code of Conduct<br />
<strong>McCarthy</strong>'s has developed a manufacturers' code-of-conduct to ensure high working standards in our suppliers' factories<br />
1. General Principle<br />
<strong>RJ</strong>M intends to conduct its business in a socially responsible manner<br />
and is determined to work with Suppliers who endorse the standards<br />
and principles outlined in this document, the <strong>RJ</strong>M Responsible<br />
Manufacturing Guidebook & Checklist (hereafter “Guidebook”).<br />
<strong>RJ</strong>M will only partner with businesses that either meet the standards<br />
and principles outlined in the Guidebook or are committed to meeting<br />
these standards over a reasonable period of time.<br />
<strong>In</strong> general, when deviations from our standards are discovered by us<br />
or brought to our attention by others, our first choice will be to work<br />
proactively with the Supplier involved to drive positive change and to<br />
achieve the standard. As many labour rights groups including the<br />
Worker Rights<br />
Consortium (WRC) have said, this is the best way to truly enact<br />
change. However if we determine that a management team at a<br />
factory is not genuinely addressing corrections in a timely manner,<br />
we will suspend or permanently bar the supplier in question.<br />
Suppliers may be given time to fix problems, but we will not abide<br />
with Suppliers who do not take these issues as seriously as we do.<br />
2. Legal Expectations<br />
Business partners and their employees shall comply with all contract<br />
provisions, legal requirements and standards of their industry under<br />
applicable laws. Nothing in this Guidebook is to be construed as<br />
encouraging, authorizing or condoning any action by any company<br />
or individual that breaches any applicable law or regulation, directly<br />
or otherwise. By extension, the provisions of this Guidebook are not<br />
to be read as creating or implying meanings beyond those specifically<br />
explained in this document.<br />
3. Standards<br />
For the purpose of upholding this code, the Supplier Accountability<br />
Checklist corresponds to these standards.<br />
3a. Forced Labour, Harassment, and/or Abuse<br />
Suppliers shall treat workers with respect and dignity and maintain<br />
employment on a voluntary basis. Suppliers shall not use forced<br />
labour in any of their contracting, subcontracting or other<br />
relationships for the manufacture of their products. Suppliers shall<br />
respect each employee's right to decide to work or not to work, and<br />
shall not use corporal punishment, threats of violence, sexual<br />
harassment, verbal abuse, or any other form of physical or<br />
psychological coercion.<br />
3b. Child Labour<br />
Suppliers shall only employ workers who meet the applicable<br />
minimum legal age at which school has ended, or who are at least 15<br />
years of age (14 years of age if the law in the given country of<br />
manufacture allows), whichever is greater. <strong>The</strong> combined time spent<br />
in school, transportation and at work should not exceed 10 hours a<br />
day. Suppliers shall also comply with all other applicable child labour<br />
laws related to hiring, wages, hours worked, overtime, and working<br />
conditions.<br />
3c. Resolution of Disputes<br />
Suppliers shall incorporate a dispute resolution process as part of<br />
their management practices to allow employees to voice workplace<br />
grievances without fear of reprisal.<br />
3d. Discrimination<br />
Suppliers shall determine employment, salary, benefits,<br />
advancement, discipline, termination or retirement of workers on the<br />
basis of knowledge, skill, efficiency, and ability to do the job and<br />
meet its requirements, not on the basis of personal characteristics or<br />
beliefs. Personal characteristics and beliefs include but are not<br />
limited to: gender, race, religion, age (other than normal hiring or<br />
retirement limitations), disability, sexual orientation, nationality,<br />
political orientation, social or ethnic origin or membership in any<br />
legal organization.<br />
3e. Freedom of Association and Collective Bargaining<br />
Suppliers shall respect the right of employees to free association and<br />
collective bargaining where applicable.<br />
3f. Wages, Benefits<br />
Suppliers shall set working hours and overtime pay in compliance<br />
with applicable local laws. Workers shall be paid at least the<br />
minimum legal wage, and preferably a wage that meets local industry<br />
standards. Suppliers shall provide all benefits legally required by<br />
local labour laws.<br />
3g. Hours of Work<br />
Suppliers shall maintain reasonable employee work hours in<br />
compliance with local standards and applicable local laws. Suppliers<br />
shall compensate employees for overtime as required by local labour<br />
laws.<br />
3h. Health and Safety<br />
Suppliers shall provide safe and healthy work environments for their<br />
employees. Factories shall comply with all applicable local laws and<br />
regulations regarding working conditions. Suppliers shall provide<br />
well-lit and reasonably ventilated workstations, clean restrooms, fire<br />
exits, safety equipment, first aid supplies, proper storage and disposal<br />
units for hazardous materials, and shall ensure that all machinery and<br />
equipment is well maintained and in working condition. <strong>The</strong>se same<br />
conditions shall apply to worker housing when provided by the<br />
Supplier.<br />
3i. Environmental Requirements<br />
Suppliers shall adhere to all applicable local environmental laws and<br />
regulations.<br />
3k. Monitoring and Compliance Process<br />
Suppliers shall sign and agree to uphold this <strong>RJ</strong>M Code of Conduct.<br />
Suppliers shall cooperate with <strong>RJ</strong>M to provide reasonable<br />
opportunities for <strong>RJ</strong>M or its agents to verify that the principles in this<br />
document are being upheld. If <strong>RJ</strong>M learns that its standards are not<br />
being respected, it maintains the right to suspend or terminate its<br />
relationship with the Supplier altogether.<br />
3j. Transshipment<br />
Suppliers shall comply with applicable customs importing laws and,<br />
in particular, establish and maintain programs and documentation to<br />
support country-of-origin production verification to prevent the<br />
illegal transshipping of merchandise.<br />
4. Monitoring and Compliance Process<br />
Suppliers shall sign and agree to uphold this code of conduct.<br />
Suppliers shall cooperate with <strong>RJ</strong>M to provide reasonable<br />
opportunities for <strong>RJ</strong>M or its agents to verify that the principles in this<br />
document are being upheld. If <strong>RJ</strong>M learns that its standards are not<br />
being respected, it maintains the right to suspend or terminate its<br />
relationship with the Supplier altogether.<br />
25
Thank you<br />
We would like to thank the MBA team from the Richard Ivey School of Business<br />
who were instrumental in creating this report as part of their Ivey Consulting<br />
Project<br />
Avnish Babla<br />
Katie Daly<br />
Karamdeep Nijjar<br />
Chris O’Grady<br />
Navtej Sidhu<br />
Stuart Wilson<br />
We would also like to thank the following individuals for their contributions<br />
Joanna Halligan<br />
Steven Martins<br />
Matt Mayr<br />
Radhika Ray<br />
Aaron Shapiro<br />
26
R.J. <strong>McCarthy</strong><br />
360 Evans Avenue<br />
Toronto, ON, Canada<br />
M8Z1K5<br />
www.rjmccarthy.com<br />
27