View associated PDF document - United Nations Volunteers
View associated PDF document - United Nations Volunteers
View associated PDF document - United Nations Volunteers
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
CARING CITIES<br />
VOLUNTEERISM IN URBAN DEVELOPMENT<br />
AND THE ROLE OF THE UNITED NATIONS<br />
VOLUNTEER PROGRAMME
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
TABLE OF CONTENTS<br />
Page 2<br />
Introduction 4<br />
PART I<br />
URBAN DEVELOPMENT AND VOLUNTEERISM 6<br />
1. The Challenges of Urbanization 6<br />
1.1. Urban Poverty 7<br />
1.2. Urban Opportunities 9<br />
2. Meanings and Typology of Volunteerism 10<br />
2.1. Meanings and Definitions 11<br />
2.2. A Typology of Volunteering 13<br />
3. The Importance of Volunteerism in Urban Development 16<br />
3.1. Economic Benefits 16<br />
3.2. Grassroots Work/Organizations 17<br />
3.3. Social Cohesion and Capital 18<br />
3.4. Cultural Heritage and Local Pride 23<br />
3.5. Benefits to the Volunteer 24<br />
PART II<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME 26<br />
1. Introduction to UNV 26<br />
2. The international response to the urban problematique<br />
of developing countries and UNV’s role 28<br />
3. UNV’s niche in urban work 30<br />
3.1. Promotion and support to volunteerism 30<br />
3.2. The Mobilization of UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> 31<br />
4. Thematic view and illustrations 40<br />
4.1. The political & institutional domain 40<br />
4.2. The social domain 48<br />
4.3. The economic domain 54<br />
4.4. The physical domain 59<br />
4.5. The cultural domain 61<br />
4.6. An integrated approach 63<br />
Conclusion 64<br />
References 66<br />
Colophon 68
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper ‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
INTRODUCTION<br />
Page 4<br />
Page 5<br />
We are living in an era dominated by the private market ethos;<br />
this trend tends to overshadow the value of voluntary actions.<br />
However, volunteerism continues to play a crucial role even in a<br />
market-oriented society. Equally, volunteerism plays a vital role<br />
in human settlements, which constitute a microcosm of society.<br />
This publication analyses the importance of volunteer work in<br />
the development of cities and towns, and presents the urban<br />
agenda of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> <strong>Volunteers</strong> Programme (UNV).<br />
UNV promotes and supports volunteerism through different<br />
means and also fields teams of UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> in developing<br />
and transitional countries. UNV has devoted particular attention<br />
to urban areas and this has evolved over a period of 30 years,<br />
from scattered activities to systemic programming, culminating<br />
in making urban development one of the priorities for its<br />
Strategy 2000. Rather than overlapping with other development<br />
agencies, UNV has been able to offer a distinct value-added<br />
and to complement efforts.<br />
The publication is divided into two main parts: volunteerism and<br />
UNV. The first part focuses on the importance of volunteerism<br />
in urban development. It starts with an introduction to urban<br />
problems, followed by a detailed analysis of volunteerism in this<br />
context. The second part begins with an introduction to UNV,<br />
followed by the general features of its urban operations.<br />
Subsequently it provides a detailed view of the UNV response<br />
to urban problems, with illustrations. The publication concludes<br />
with thoughts on the achievements of UNV, and on the<br />
consolidation of its urban agenda.<br />
UNV’s Strategy 2000 came into being shortly after the<br />
‘Istanbul Meeting’ in 1996 (the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong>’ Summit<br />
Conference on Human Settlements ‘Habitat II’). Coincidentally,<br />
Year 2001 is the first year after the conclusion of UNV’s<br />
Strategy 2000 and the year of ‘Istanbul + 5’ (the Special<br />
Session of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> General Assembly for an Overall<br />
Review and Appraisal of the Implementation of the Habitat<br />
Agenda). This means that UNV’s Strategy 2000 was<br />
implemented during the period between ‘Istanbul’ and ‘Istanbul<br />
+ 5’, and produced the urban agenda which is presented in<br />
this publication.<br />
‘Istanbul + 5’ will review global achievements in the field of<br />
human settlements since the ‘Istanbul’ meeting and will also<br />
discuss future actions. Therefore, this publication has come in<br />
time because it takes stock of what UNV has achieved<br />
throughout this period, and also discusses the future.<br />
The present publication is also well-timed because 2001 has<br />
been chosen by the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> as the International Year of<br />
the <strong>Volunteers</strong> with UNV being the institutional focal point. This<br />
publication is part of UNV efforts to provide information about<br />
volunteerism in general and about its programme in particular.
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART I – URBAN DEVELOPMENT<br />
AND VOLUNTEERISM<br />
Page 6<br />
Page 7<br />
1. The Challenges of Urbanization<br />
Urbanization is an overwhelming phenomenon throughout the<br />
whole world, and there is ample and widespread evidence<br />
about its occurrence and effects. There is no need, therefore,<br />
for this publication to re-confirm this state of affairs in great<br />
detail (for more information on the subject see, for instance,<br />
UNCHS 1996). However, this section presents some basic<br />
facts about urbanization, with special attention to poverty. The<br />
focus on the urban poor is justified by the fact that this group<br />
bears the brunt of urban problems.<br />
The urban population of the world has been drastically expanding,<br />
both in absolute and in relative terms and this growth is<br />
mainly concentrated in developing countries. According to data<br />
compiled by UNDP (1999), in 1970 the ratio of city dwellers in<br />
developing as opposed to industrialized countries was one to<br />
one. Today this ratio is nearly two to one. It will be three to one<br />
by the year 2015, and will approach four to one by 2025.<br />
Since 1970, 1.23 billion urban residents have been added<br />
to the world population, of which 84% have been in lessdeveloped<br />
regions. In the words of a recent report of the World<br />
Bank (1999: 1):<br />
‘At the threshold of the 21st century, cities and towns are<br />
forming the front line in the development campaign. Within a<br />
generation, the majority of the developing world’s population<br />
will live in urban areas. The number of residents in developing<br />
countries will increase by 2.5 billion – the current urban<br />
population of the entire world. The scale of this urbanization,<br />
with its implications for meeting the needs of individuals at<br />
relatively low levels of national income, is unprecedented.’<br />
The process of urbanization has been accompanied by a<br />
plethora of problems of varying nature (and type) e.g. social,<br />
economic, environmental, etc. It is outside the scope of this<br />
publication to elaborate on evidence about such problems<br />
(there is already an enormous literature on such issues). However,<br />
it is worth noting the alarming magnitude of urban poverty<br />
– because being poor in a city or town entails facing its multiple<br />
problems on a day-to-day basis. According to UNDP (1999),<br />
approximately half of the poor in the world live in urban areas,<br />
and this figure continues to go up, both in absolute and relative<br />
terms.<br />
1.1. Urban Poverty<br />
The absolute numbers of urban poor may suffice to demonstrate<br />
the existence and magnitude of the problem, hence the<br />
importance of combating it. This can be reinforced by comparisons<br />
with rural poverty. There is an argument among<br />
development academics and practitioners that poverty in rural<br />
areas is more prominent – and therefore deserves more<br />
resources – than poverty in urban areas. Although it is beyond<br />
the scope of this publication to provide ultimate evidence about<br />
the significance of urban versus rural poverty, it is important<br />
here to show that such relative significance has often been<br />
underestimated. The following points illustrate the relative<br />
importance of urban poverty:<br />
– Higher living costs. As noted by UNCHS (1996), in most<br />
developing countries urban residents face higher living<br />
costs, because many items that have to be bought in urban<br />
areas are free or cheaper in rural areas as they grow or are<br />
produced locally – e.g. fuel, food, fresh water, traditional<br />
building materials, and housing itself.<br />
– New/extra needs. In addition to the higher costs of basic<br />
needs, urban living also entails new or additional needs, a<br />
fact which requires extra expenditure. For example, long<br />
distance daily commuting is an ordinary feature of urban<br />
living, which means that public transport (and <strong>associated</strong><br />
costs) becomes an indispensable need. Also, urban living<br />
generally involve more complex and costly recreational<br />
habits (cinemas, shows, night life), which are important in<br />
a milieu that lacks the appropriate space, time and cultural<br />
bonds often necessary for rural types of recreation (encountered<br />
in nature, in extensive village celebrations, etc.).<br />
There is also a much higher pressure for consumption in<br />
general (of non-basic goods) in urban areas, due to a much<br />
more aggressive marketing milieu, and to the constant<br />
day-to-day exposure of the poor to people who ostentatiously<br />
show their expensive goods. (It is often argued that access<br />
to a wider range of goods and services constitutes an<br />
advantage of urban settlements over rural areas. While this<br />
may be true for those who can actually purchase such<br />
goods and services, the reality for the masses of urban<br />
poor is different – they often sacrifice basic needs in order<br />
to be able to purchase non-basic goods and services).
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper ‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART I –<br />
URBAN DEVELOPMENT AND VOLUNTEERISM<br />
The Challenges of Urbanization<br />
PART I –<br />
URBAN DEVELOPMENT AND VOLUNTEERISM<br />
The Challenges of Urbanization<br />
Page 8<br />
– Greater vulnerability to changes in income: Urban dwellers<br />
often have a greater dependence on cash incomes, which<br />
means greater vulnerability to price rises and falls in income.<br />
This problem is minimized in rural areas due to subsistence<br />
production and foraging (see UNCHS, 1996).<br />
– Socio-cultural bonds: Support networks based in family,<br />
kinship and/or ethnic-cultural background are generally<br />
stronger in rural areas, and prove to be fundamental in many<br />
episodes of crisis and emergencies. Socio-cultural bonds<br />
and derived support networks tend to be weaker in urban<br />
areas, due to the pressures of urban living, <strong>associated</strong><br />
psycho social stresses, and ethnic-cultural mixtures. For<br />
instance, the widespread phenomenon of street children is<br />
a clear and sad evidence of this problem.<br />
– Greater health risks: The urban poor face the ‘worst of both<br />
worlds’: while they still suffer problems common to rural<br />
areas (such as infectious diseases and malnutrition), they<br />
also suffer problems which are particular to urban areas<br />
(chronic and psycho social diseases) (Harpham, 1987).<br />
The above reasoning does not deny the significance of rural<br />
poverty (and therefore of the need to combat it). The point is<br />
that, independently of (or in addition to) combating rural poverty,<br />
it is essential to combat urban poverty. There is a widespread<br />
belief among many development thinkers and practitioners that<br />
urban poverty will ‘naturally’ disappear solely by combating<br />
rural poverty. They believe that the urban poor are basically<br />
rural migrants running away from poverty in their regions of<br />
origin. Therefore, the argument goes, if rural poverty is removed,<br />
no more poor people would migrate to cities and towns, and<br />
the poor who are already living in such urban settlements<br />
would migrate back to the (now economically better) rural<br />
areas.<br />
Page 9<br />
as homelessness, crime, pollution, unemployment, overcrowding<br />
(squatters), and psycho social conditions <strong>associated</strong> with<br />
urbanization.<br />
1.2. Urban Opportunities<br />
Whether one likes it or not, urbanization is a global phenomenon.<br />
The majority of urban dwellers in all corners of the planet just<br />
do not want to move to rural areas. They prefer to work in<br />
typically urban occupations (e.g. services) rather than in farming,<br />
or they may prefer urban socio-cultural habits to rural ones.<br />
The fact that there is widespread poverty in urban areas does<br />
not automatically means that urbanization is evil – the same<br />
way that the widespread existence of poverty in rural areas<br />
should not lead to similar conclusions regarding rural settings.<br />
Cities and towns are also loci of many opportunities. No matter<br />
how challenging, it is more opportune and at the same time<br />
more realistic to fight urban poverty within cities and towns<br />
themselves, and to allow the poor to benefit from the<br />
opportunities offered by such settlements, than to think about<br />
an idyllic urban exodus.<br />
Solutions to the problems of urban areas in general and of the<br />
urban poor in particular are often complex, and require a wide<br />
set of interrelated activities. At any rate, volunteerism plays a<br />
significant role as part of such solutions.<br />
Removal of poverty and the creation of opportunities in rural<br />
areas might perhaps attract a number of urban dwellers. Yet,<br />
there is no evidence whatsoever that it would constitute a<br />
comprehensive solution to urban poverty. The example of many<br />
Western European countries reinforces this point. Rural poverty<br />
in absolute terms (i.e. acute deficiency or deprivation of basic<br />
needs) in this region of the world is rare. Yet, many dwellers of<br />
Western European cities still face harsh living conditions, such
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART I –<br />
URBAN DEVELOPMENT AND VOLUNTEERISM<br />
PART I –<br />
URBAN DEVELOPMENT AND VOLUNTEERISM<br />
Meanings and Typology of Volunteerism<br />
Page 10<br />
2. Meanings and Typology of Volunteerism<br />
Before the paper focusing on the importance of volunteerism in<br />
urban development, this section will provide information about<br />
meanings and definitions as well as about a typology of<br />
volunteerism, as a background to comprehend the subsequent<br />
text.<br />
2.1. Meanings and Definitions<br />
Volunteering means different things to different people. A recent<br />
study (Cnaan et al, 1998) found widespread differences<br />
between countries in public perceptions of what constitutes a<br />
voluntary activity. In some countries giving blood was seen as<br />
volunteering, in others being involved in a political party or<br />
trade union was counted. For some people the defining<br />
characteristic of volunteering was the absence of financial<br />
reward; for others lack of coercion was the main identifier.<br />
Volunteering takes on different forms and meanings in different<br />
settings. It is strongly influenced by the history, politics, religion<br />
and culture of a region. What may be seen as volunteering in<br />
one country may be dismissed as low paid or labour intensive<br />
work (or even forced labour) in another. However, despite the<br />
wide variety of understandings it is possible to identify some<br />
core characteristics of what constitutes a voluntary activity. In<br />
fact it is essential that we attempt to define volunteering. It is<br />
necessary because without some shared understanding of the<br />
common elements of volunteering the term would be meaningless<br />
and would nullify the attempts by governments to promote<br />
it. Although it is clearly not possible to come up with a hard<br />
and fast definition of volunteering that will take into account the<br />
variety of contexts in which it operates, we can construct a<br />
broad conceptual framework which will allow for significant<br />
differences in interpretation within clearly delineated boundaries.<br />
There are five key elements to this framework. First the notion<br />
of reward. Some definitions argue that only purely altruistic<br />
behaviour should be counted as volunteering. Others contend<br />
that there is no such thing as pure altruism and that all<br />
volunteering contains an element of exchange and reciprocity.<br />
Thus some definitions would allow for volunteers to be<br />
rewarded in some way, either non-materially through the<br />
provision of training or accreditation, or materially through the<br />
reimbursement of expenses or the payment of an honorarium.<br />
Page 11<br />
The key cut-off point in drawing the distinction between<br />
volunteering and paid employment is that the volunteer should<br />
not be undertaking the activity primarily for financial gain and<br />
that any financial reimbursement should be less than the value<br />
of the work provided.<br />
The second element concerns the notion of free will. Most<br />
definitions concede that volunteering and compulsion are<br />
incompatible. Thus schemes which run counter to the ILO<br />
Conventions on forced labour would clearly not qualify as<br />
volunteering. But as with the notion of reward, there are grey<br />
areas <strong>associated</strong> with concept of free will. For example, how<br />
should we view school community service schemes which<br />
encourage, and sometimes require, students to get involved in<br />
voluntary work? Food for Work programmes, where there is an<br />
explicit exchange between community involvement and food<br />
assistance? Or citizen service schemes which offer people a<br />
community service alternative to military service? The broad<br />
conceptual framework accepts that it may be difficult to uphold<br />
the pure notion of free will in any volunteering interaction<br />
people’s motivation to volunteer will perhaps always include a<br />
mix of reasons, including peer pressure and social obligation.<br />
But it would also exclude any overt attempt by government to<br />
force people to participate.<br />
The third element relates to the nature of the benefit. To<br />
differentiate volunteering from a purely voluntary leisure activity<br />
requires there to be a beneficiary other than (or in addition to)<br />
the volunteer. But where the line should be drawn is open to<br />
question. Some would argue that the beneficiary has to be a<br />
stranger to the volunteer; others would allow neighbours to be<br />
included, and even friends and extended relations. Still others<br />
would include the notion of self-help or mutual aid where the<br />
dividing line between personal and third party benefit is<br />
especially blurred. Whilst allowing for a variety of interpretations<br />
the broad conceptual framework demands that there be an<br />
identifiable beneficiary or group of beneficiaries (which might<br />
include such abstract notions as the environment or society<br />
itself) other than (or in addition to) the volunteer’s immediate<br />
family or friends. This would allow for self-help and mutual aid<br />
to be included but would rule out caring for dependent relatives.<br />
Fourthly, there is the issue of organizational setting. Some<br />
definitions insist that volunteering must be carried out through
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART I –<br />
URBAN DEVELOPMENT AND VOLUNTEERISM<br />
Meanings and Typology of Volunteerism<br />
PART I –<br />
URBAN DEVELOPMENT AND VOLUNTEERISM<br />
Meanings and Typology of Volunteerism<br />
Page 12<br />
Page 13<br />
a formal, non-profit or voluntary organization of some sort.<br />
Others keep to the organizational requirement but include<br />
activity undertaken within the public or corporate sector. Others<br />
relax the organizational requirement and accept activities carried<br />
out informally, either on a one-to-one basis such as helping out<br />
a neighbour, or in isolation through such civic-minded activities<br />
as picking up litter. The broad framework put forward here<br />
allows for both formal (organized) and informal (one-to-one)<br />
volunteering to be included and for volunteering carried out<br />
both in the public and corporate sectors.<br />
The final element is the level of commitment. Some definitions<br />
allow for one-off voluntary activities to be included; others<br />
demand a certain level of commitment and exclude occasional<br />
acts. The broad conceptual framework enables us to<br />
encompass a range of different levels of activity from high<br />
commitment to sporadic involvement, although it seems fair<br />
to assume that most volunteering would carry with it some<br />
degree of sustained commitment.<br />
Given the differing interpretations of what constitutes a<br />
voluntary activity it is not surprising that there is disagreement<br />
over terms. Some people favour the term volunteering, others<br />
voluntary activity, voluntary work or voluntary action. In some<br />
countries distinctions are drawn between more traditional<br />
forms of charitable activity and more modern forms of citizen<br />
involvement and participation. Whilst recognizing that different<br />
terms often have very different meanings in different settings<br />
this publication will use volunteering and voluntary activity as<br />
interchangeable terms to describe the broad range of activities<br />
which fall within the broad conceptual framework outlined<br />
above. Similar terminological difficulties arise in relation to the<br />
organizations through which most volunteering takes place.<br />
Voluntary organizations, community groups, civil society organizations,<br />
third sector associations, non-governmental and nonprofit<br />
organizations are all terms which are used to describe<br />
the rich variety of organizational structures which occupy the<br />
space outside the state and the market. As with the terms to<br />
describe individual voluntary activity all have subtle, or not so<br />
subtle, differences of meaning. But for the purpose of this<br />
publication we will choose the term voluntary and community<br />
organizations to encompass this wide variety of organizational<br />
forms.<br />
In West and Central Africa there<br />
is a tradition of Tontine. This is a<br />
self-help group of citizens established<br />
to provide a rotating credit<br />
system for members. Each<br />
member makes a regular financial<br />
contribution and each has a turn<br />
in drawing from the funds.<br />
Women take a leading role as<br />
members and fund-managers.<br />
In Slovakia the Multiple Sclerosis<br />
2.2. A Typology of Volunteering<br />
It is possible to identify at least four different types of volunteer<br />
activity, delineated according to a final outcome or final purpose<br />
criterion: mutual aid or self-help, philanthropy or service<br />
to others, participation and advocacy or campaigning. Each of<br />
these types occurs in all parts of the world, and both in urban<br />
and non-urban areas. However, the form each type takes and<br />
the balance or mix between different types differs markedly<br />
from place to place. Factors influencing the nature of<br />
volunteering will include the economic, social and political<br />
make-up of the country/region/city and its stage of development.<br />
As a broad rule of thumb the less economically<br />
developed the locality the less formal its volunteering structures<br />
are likely to be, and the greater the emphasis on informal<br />
support systems and networks of mutual aid and self-help.<br />
In contrast, industrialized countries/regions/cities typically will<br />
exhibit more formal volunteering structures with a greater<br />
emphasis on philanthropic forms of activity. This is not to imply<br />
that the developed world is richer in volunteering than the<br />
developing world. Rather that the form volunteering takes is<br />
conditioned by the society in which it is based. Of course there<br />
are parts of the world where volunteering is stronger than<br />
others – in certain countries the political system works against<br />
the free association and participation of its citizens. But even in<br />
countries most hostile to its development, volunteering can be<br />
found. The four categories of volunteering are not mutually<br />
exclusive. There is clear overlap between them. So, for<br />
example, volunteers involved with a philanthropic or service<br />
delivery agency may also very well be involved in advocacy and<br />
campaigning. Likewise, mutual aid may benefit others apart<br />
from members.<br />
Mutual Aid or Self-Help<br />
Anthropologists have noted the existence of mutual<br />
associations (or sodalities from the Latin word sodalis meaning<br />
close friend) as far back as the neolithic period and the role of<br />
mutual aid associations in primitive cultures has been well<br />
<strong>document</strong>ed.<br />
In many parts of the world today mutual aid provides the main<br />
system of social and economic support for a majority of the<br />
population. From the small informal kinship and clan groupings<br />
to the more formal rotating credit associations and welfare<br />
groups, volunteering as an expression of self-help or mutual aid
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART I –<br />
URBAN DEVELOPMENT AND VOLUNTEERISM<br />
Meanings and Typology of Volunteerism<br />
PART I –<br />
URBAN DEVELOPMENT AND VOLUNTEERISM<br />
Meanings and Typology of Volunteerism<br />
Page 14<br />
Page 15<br />
plays a primary role in the welfare of communities. In Kenya, for<br />
example, the tradition of Harambee plays a vital role in the<br />
provision of health, water and educational facilities. In Senegal<br />
mutual aid is organized around Mbootaay groups (meaning to<br />
nurture), while in Java such activity goes under the name of<br />
Arisan. In Mexico there is a thriving mutual aid tradition of<br />
Confianza and in the Gulf States the practice of Murfazaa is<br />
long-established. Self-help also plays an important role in<br />
countries of the industrialized North, particularly in the health<br />
and social welfare field, where numerous organizations have<br />
been established to provide support and assistance to those in<br />
need, often organized around a particular disease or illness.<br />
Philanthropy or Service to Others<br />
Perhaps more a feature of developed societies (especially in its<br />
organized form), philanthropic volunteering can nevertheless be<br />
found in all regions of the world. It is distinguished from selfhelp<br />
activity in that the primary recipient of the volunteering is<br />
not the member of the group him or herself, but an external<br />
third party, although most people would acknowledge that<br />
there is an element of self-interest in such philanthropic activity.<br />
Much of this type of volunteering takes place within voluntary<br />
or community organizations, although in certain countries there<br />
is a strong tradition of volunteering within the public sector and<br />
interest is growing in volunteering in the corporate sector. In<br />
some countries sophisticated networks have been established<br />
to recruit and place volunteers with the most appropriate<br />
organization. These include both national and local volunteer<br />
centres, which have been established with support from<br />
government. There is also a long-standing tradition of<br />
volunteers being sent from one country to another to offer<br />
developmental and humanitarian assistance, both North to<br />
South and South to South and, to a far lesser extent, South to<br />
North.<br />
Participation<br />
This refers to the role played by individuals in the governance<br />
process, from representation on government consultative<br />
bodies to user-involvement in local development projects. As a<br />
form of volunteering it is found in all countries, although it is<br />
most developed in advanced democracies and those countries<br />
with a strong tradition of citizen participation. Participation was<br />
recognized as an essential component of good governance at<br />
the Copenhagen Summit and has become the watchword of<br />
Slovak Union is a voluntary selfhelp<br />
organization which<br />
developed out of a grassroots<br />
initiative in 1990. It brings<br />
together citizens affected with<br />
multiple sclerosis and their<br />
families, as well as other people<br />
willing to provide assistance. In<br />
addition to providing a range of<br />
practical support to members,<br />
the Union campaigns and<br />
advocates on behalf of people<br />
with multiple sclerosis. It<br />
receives some state funding<br />
and is one of the most active<br />
and visible expressions of selfhelp<br />
in Slovakia.<br />
In the 1990s in Brazil the Citizens’<br />
Action Against Hunger and For<br />
Life campaign was launched by<br />
leaders of various civic groups.<br />
There was a massive public<br />
response and within three months<br />
over 3,000 volunteer committees<br />
had been set up across the<br />
country to look for ways of combating<br />
hunger and poverty. It is<br />
estimated that an astonishing<br />
38% of the Brazilian population<br />
participated directly in the<br />
campaign, either through making<br />
a donation or by volunteering.<br />
In Maharashtra in India in 1998 a<br />
group of concerned citizens<br />
came together to form an action<br />
campaign to save children’s lives<br />
in Melghat. The group called<br />
itself Melghat Mitra (Friends of<br />
Melghat) and determined to<br />
prevent the death of children<br />
caused by malnourishment in<br />
seven settlements during the<br />
monsoon period. A number of<br />
daily newspapers published the<br />
appeal, resulting in a response<br />
from over 3,000 people, who<br />
made donations of money and<br />
time. Two hundred volunteers<br />
agreed to give 10 days of their<br />
time to the project over a period<br />
of 92 days. Having achieved<br />
these goals Melghat Mitra is now<br />
tackling the long-term development<br />
needs of the settlements.<br />
development in recent years, although there is a forceful<br />
critique which argues that much of what has passed for<br />
participation has been little more than token involvement and a<br />
means of legitimising outsiders’ decisions.<br />
Advocacy or Campaigning<br />
The fourth type of volunteering is advocacy or campaigning,<br />
be it lobbying government for a change in legislation affecting<br />
the rights of disabled people or pushing for a worldwide ban<br />
on landmines. <strong>Volunteers</strong> have paved the way for the introduction<br />
of new welfare services in the field of HIV and AIDS,<br />
have raised public consciousness about abuses of human<br />
rights and environmental destruction, and have been active in<br />
the women’s movement and in democracy campaigns in many<br />
parts of the world. Some campaigns are very localized others<br />
are global in their reach. The anti-landmine campaign, for<br />
example, is estimated to have involved more than 300 million<br />
volunteers from over 100 countries. By its very nature such<br />
campaigning activity has the capacity to bring volunteers into<br />
conflict with the state. Some governments have sought to<br />
clamp down on these activities. Others have accepted that<br />
volunteering has a legitimate role to play in campaigning for<br />
change and acting as a check on the executive.
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART I –<br />
URBAN DEVELOPMENT AND VOLUNTEERISM<br />
PART I –<br />
URBAN DEVELOPMENT AND VOLUNTEERISM<br />
The Importance of Volunteerism in Urban Development<br />
Page 16<br />
Page 17<br />
3. The Importance of Volunteerism in Urban<br />
3. Development<br />
This section highlights five sets of impacts and benefits: (i)<br />
overall economic benefits, (ii) grassroots work and organizations,<br />
(iii) social cohesion and capital, (iv) local pride, (v)<br />
benefits to the volunteers.<br />
3.1. Economic Benefits<br />
Volunteering makes an important economic contribution to<br />
urban settlements in particular and to society as a whole.<br />
Activities undertaken by volunteers would otherwise have to<br />
be funded by the state or by private capital. Volunteering adds<br />
to the overall economic output and reduces the burden on<br />
government spending. The existing studies point to the magnitude<br />
of its contribution. For example, a survey of volunteering in the<br />
UK in 1997 suggested that half the adult population took part<br />
in voluntary work, contributing a notional £40 billion to the<br />
economy (Smith, 1998); while a recent survey in Canada<br />
suggested that over five million adults volunteered, adding<br />
some $16 billion to Gross Domestic Product. Two large crossnational<br />
surveys in recent years also point to the importance of<br />
volunteering. A survey in eight European countries in 1994<br />
found an average participation rate in volunteering across the<br />
continent of 23% (Gaskin and Smith, 1995); while the 22-<br />
nation study reported by the Johns Hopkins Institute in 1998<br />
found volunteer involvement running at an average of 28%,<br />
equivalent to almost 10.5 million full-time employees (Salamon<br />
and Anheier, 1998).<br />
A joint study between the Johns Hopkins University and the<br />
<strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Development Programme (UNDP) is developing<br />
a framework for measuring the economic contribution of<br />
voluntary and community organizations (including the value of<br />
volunteering) for use in satellite accounting. UNDP also aims to<br />
include measures of governance and participation in its 2001<br />
Human Development Report. CIVICUS, the world alliance for<br />
citizen participation, is meanwhile developing its own civil society<br />
index, which includes a measure of the level of involvement in<br />
the formulation and implementation of public policy.<br />
So far there is little and disaggregate data available on the<br />
quantitative contribution of volunteerism, specifically in urban<br />
The South Asian Poverty<br />
Alleviation Programme (SAPAP)<br />
Pilot programme started in<br />
1996 supporting the poverty<br />
reduction efforts of 6 countries:<br />
Bangladesh, India, Maldives,<br />
Nepal, Pakistan and Sri Lanka.<br />
Since the start of the<br />
programme around 80,000<br />
households have formed themselves<br />
into 3,500 community<br />
organizations which have helped<br />
launch thousands of individual<br />
and family income-earning<br />
activities and built up numerous<br />
community assets from irrigation<br />
systems to roads.<br />
areas. Nevertheless, there is strong evidence that volunteer<br />
work – for example, all the self-help activities at the community<br />
level – accounts for a sizeable share of the urban economy. At<br />
the same time, urban areas account for a sizeable share –<br />
often the largest part – of the economy of countries as a whole.<br />
3.2. Grassroots Work /Organizations<br />
The past few decades have witnessed the rise of an approach<br />
to urban development commonly called the ‘community-based’<br />
approach – which is fundamentally based on the volunteer<br />
contributions of the members of grassroots communities. Its<br />
widespread recognition in development circles constitutes one<br />
set of evidence about the importance of volunteer work at the<br />
urban grassroots at least for three reasons: survival, filling in a<br />
structural void between the private and the public sectors, and<br />
building the political basis of communities. In addition, the<br />
current burgeoning attention to governance further underlines<br />
its importance. Each of these issues will be analysed in turn.<br />
– Survival: firstly, the ‘survival’ argument notes that in most<br />
circumstances, the public and the private sectors have not<br />
managed adequately to provide all the basic needs of the<br />
urban poor in developing countries (either because of<br />
deficiencies in the system of supply or high costs). This<br />
means that the urban poor just have to engage themselves<br />
voluntarily in the direct production of basic needs (e.g.<br />
housing, water, sewerage, solid waste, drainage, etc.) in<br />
order to survive and to live decently. Whenever such<br />
circumstances arise, there is a rationale for urban development<br />
projects to empower and strengthen grassroots<br />
communities to enhance their survival mechanisms.<br />
– Structural niche for volunteer technical work. the second<br />
argument is more radical than the previous one, it contends<br />
that mutual voluntary/self-help production is structural in (at<br />
least some) societies, and that there will always be a void<br />
between public and private production (which has to be<br />
filled by the community itself). Consequently, there is a need<br />
for urban development projects to empower and strengthen<br />
grassroots communities not only in emergency/survival<br />
situations, but always.
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART I –<br />
URBAN DEVELOPMENT AND VOLUNTEERISM<br />
The Importance of Volunteerism in Urban Development<br />
PART I –<br />
URBAN DEVELOPMENT AND VOLUNTEERISM<br />
The Importance of Volunteerism in Urban Development<br />
Page 18<br />
Page 19<br />
– Political pressure: the third argument focuses on participation,<br />
which is one type of volunteerism, as noted before.<br />
Communities also have certain needs and rights vis-à-vis<br />
the state. Due to the uneven balance of power in cities –<br />
and in societies – low-income communities tend to have<br />
such needs fulfilled and rights respected only if they are<br />
able to organize themselves and exert concerted pressure<br />
on the public system.<br />
– Governance: fourthly, the current worldwide attention on<br />
(urban) governance also stresses politics, but in a different<br />
way. That is, participation is important not necessarily for<br />
the community to exert ‘pressure’ on the public system, but<br />
to build a more definite relationship. Under such circumstances,<br />
communities need not only the skills to ‘fight’ for<br />
their interests, as above, but also to build alliances and<br />
work together with different stakeholders. This further<br />
reinforces the importance of volunteerism at the urban<br />
grassroots.<br />
Participation has long been seen as an essential element<br />
of good governance and effective development. Numerous<br />
studies have attested to the link between user involvement<br />
and the success of water, sanitation and environmental<br />
projects in many different parts of the world (See, for example,<br />
Kahkonen, 1999). The UNDP Poverty Report for 1998<br />
concluded that: ‘UNDP’s experience suggests that<br />
community anti-poverty programmes should be firmly based<br />
on ‘social mobilization’ (UNDP, 1998), ‘Poor people may<br />
be relatively powerless as individuals, but not when they<br />
mobilize themselves together in communities’.<br />
3.3. Social Cohesion and Capital<br />
Physical proximity among a number of people facilitates, or may<br />
actually be a fundamental pre-condition, for the construction of<br />
social cohesion and capital among such people. In this respect,<br />
cities and towns are strategic, as they constitute spatial entities<br />
where people congregate.<br />
Volunteerism is closely related to the formation of social cohesion<br />
and capital. It fosters trust between citizens and helps develop<br />
norms of solidarity and reciprocity which are essential to stable<br />
communities. By building trust and reciprocity between citizens<br />
In her study in Tanzania,<br />
Narayan, looked for evidence<br />
of social capital by measuring<br />
involvement in associations and<br />
trust in institutions amongst<br />
750 households. The settlement<br />
chosen for the study was found<br />
to be rich in voluntary and<br />
community groups, ranging from<br />
rotating credit associations and<br />
burial societies to clubs for youth<br />
and elders. Involvement was<br />
high, with over 70% of the<br />
population belonging to at least<br />
one group and an average<br />
membership of 1.5 groups per<br />
person. By matching up data<br />
on associational involvement<br />
and household income the<br />
study concluded that there was<br />
a positive link between social<br />
capital and household welfare.<br />
volunteering contributes both to a more cohesive, stable society<br />
and to a more economically prosperous one. In his classic<br />
study of regional government in Italy, Putnam (1993) concludes<br />
that differences in performance between regions can be<br />
accounted for largely by differences in levels of social capital.<br />
This he defined as ‘features of social organization, such as<br />
trust, norms and networks, that can improve the efficiency of<br />
society by facilitating coordinated actions’. One of Putnam’s<br />
key measures of social capital was participation in voluntary<br />
associations, or horizontal ‘networks of civic engagement’.<br />
Several recent studies have pointed to a link between social<br />
capital and economic advance in developing countries. Krishna<br />
and Uphoff (1999), for example, found a positive relationship<br />
between levels of social capital (as measured by informal<br />
networks and mutual support) and performance of settlements<br />
with a watershed conservation and development programme in<br />
India; while Narayan (1997) found a link between involvement<br />
in voluntary associations and household welfare in Tanzania.<br />
Just how social capital performs this function is not clear from<br />
the literature but three main ways have been suggested: by<br />
facilitating the sharing of information among members of groups;<br />
by increasing cooperation; and by facilitating collective decisionmaking.<br />
In a separate study Narayan (1999) draws a distinction<br />
between ‘bonding’ social capital developed within groups and<br />
‘bridging’ social capital arising from the interaction between<br />
groups. For social capital to contribute to social integration<br />
there needs to be not only high levels of associational activity<br />
but a dense network of cross-cutting ties among groups. The<br />
point is powerfully illustrated by Varshney (1998) in a study of<br />
communal riots in India. In seeking to explain why some towns<br />
with a mix of Hindu and Muslim populations remain free from<br />
conflict while others with a similar population profile erupt into<br />
ethnic violence, Varshney looks at the role played by voluntary<br />
associations and informal community networks in building<br />
social capital. He concludes that those areas with low levels<br />
of communal strife are characterized not simply by high levels<br />
of associational activity but by high levels of cross-cutting<br />
engagement between the Hindu and Muslim populations.<br />
Bazan and Schmitz (1997), in their turn, carried out an in-depth<br />
study in the town of Dois Irmaos in Southern Brazil, which
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART I –<br />
URBAN DEVELOPMENT AND VOLUNTEERISM<br />
The Importance of Volunteerism in Urban Development<br />
PART I –<br />
URBAN DEVELOPMENT AND VOLUNTEERISM<br />
The Importance of Volunteerism in Urban Development<br />
Page 20<br />
highlighted a strong association between the development of<br />
the local industrial community and their stock of social capital.<br />
In the specific case of Dois Irmaos, the strong social cohesion<br />
– and correlated high stock of social capital – stemmed from<br />
the ties between migrants, formed along ethnic and cultural<br />
lines:<br />
‘In terms of social relations, Dois Irmaos represented a highly<br />
integrated community during the first stage of its economic<br />
development. Like many other Brazilian-German settlements,<br />
solidarity and involvement in community affairs were commonplace.<br />
For many years, community members acted in close<br />
cooperation to build up their churches, to establish and keep<br />
their own community schools, to found mutual-self help societies,<br />
and to create various leisure associations as diverse as<br />
bowling clubs, shooting clubs and choral societies… people<br />
participated in all types of associations. This corresponds to<br />
what Gluckman (1967) has termed ‘multiplex relations’; a<br />
situation in which members of a community belong to more<br />
than one association. There were also many examples of<br />
associations in the economic field… The number of cooperative<br />
practices suggests a high degree of trust amongst members of<br />
the pre-industrial community. This was an important aspect of<br />
the social capital generated in Dois Irmaos during this period.’<br />
(Bazan and Schimtz, 1997: 14–16)<br />
As a result of the aforementioned practices, Dois Irmaos<br />
accumulated a vast stock of social capital, which, according<br />
to Bazan and Schmitz (1997), positively influenced the industrial<br />
development of the town (heavily concentrated in the shoe<br />
industry) through the quality of the relationships within the group<br />
of entrepreneurs, and between entrepreneurs and labourers.<br />
Co-operation within the group of entrepreneurs helped them<br />
to mobilize resources and to overcome barriers to the effective<br />
use of resources. This was carried out through practices such<br />
as exchanging technical knowledge and information, and the<br />
borrowing materials and tools. In a later stage, new forms of<br />
cooperation emerged, such as a number of industrial organizations<br />
concerned with promoting or defending the collective<br />
interests of the shoe producers.<br />
Co-operation between entrepreneurs and labourers, in its turn,<br />
has been described as follows:<br />
Page 21<br />
‘Reciprocity and cooperation in intra-firms relations took the<br />
form of a dense market of economic and social exchanges<br />
between entrepreneurs and workers, in which the payment for<br />
an exchange did not have to be made with the same coin in<br />
which it had been received. The type of exchange varied<br />
according to individuals’ particular demands or assets. Workers,<br />
for example, felt that they received from entrepreneurs the<br />
opportunity to maintain their contact with the land, or at least<br />
the opportunities for their families to do so (Schneider, 1994).<br />
Some workers would try to start their own enterprises and<br />
were often helped by their employers; most of the new firms<br />
that were emerging in this period were owned by ex-employees<br />
of shoe manufacturers. In addition, workers received economic<br />
and social support from entrepreneurs ranging from loans to<br />
build up their houses to providing mediation in family conflicts.<br />
In return, workers were highly committed to their jobs, and<br />
entrepreneurs benefited in a number of ways as a result of<br />
workers’ loyalty. For example, workers were understanding<br />
when there were payment delays; they were prepared to work<br />
overtime so that delivery times could be met; and absenteeism<br />
was low.’ (Bazan and Schmitz, 1997: 27)<br />
The period of high social cohesion in Dois Irmaos eventually<br />
evaded, with corresponding consequences to the local economy.<br />
However, after the period in which the initial spontaneously<br />
constructed stock of social capital eroded, there have been<br />
conscious efforts from the local entrepreneurs to rebuild it<br />
through dialogue. Inter-firm forums have been organised to<br />
discuss problems between shoe makers and suppliers, and<br />
intra-firm courses or meetings have been initiated at which<br />
managers discuss a broad range of issues with the labourers.<br />
Health and well-being<br />
There is also evidence about the importance of social cohesion<br />
in the realm of health as evidenced, for example, by the work<br />
of Wilkinson (1996). One illustration is the town of Roseto<br />
(Pennsylvania, USA). This town attracted the attention of<br />
researchers because its population had death rates – particularly<br />
from heart attacks – much lower than neighbouring and<br />
similar towns from the mid – 1930s.<br />
The population of Roseto, USA, consisted mainly of descendants<br />
of migrants from Italy, who arrived in the USA in the 1880s.<br />
After failing to explain the health differentials on the basis of the
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART I –<br />
URBAN DEVELOPMENT AND VOLUNTEERISM<br />
The Importance of Volunteerism in Urban Development<br />
PART I –<br />
URBAN DEVELOPMENT AND VOLUNTEERISM<br />
The Importance of Volunteerism in Urban Development<br />
Page 22<br />
usual risk factors, researchers on the subject began to draw<br />
explanations related to social cohesion. For instance:<br />
‘From the beginning the sense of common purpose and the<br />
camaraderie among the Italians precluded ostentation or<br />
embarrassment to the less affluent, and the concern for<br />
neighbors ensured that no one was ever abandoned. This<br />
pattern of remarkable social cohesion, in which the family, as<br />
the hub and bulwark of life, provided a kind of security and<br />
insurance against any catastrophe… Throughout the years of<br />
study of this community the indicators were that the strength<br />
of unconditional interpersonal support and family and community<br />
cohesiveness had served to counteract the effects of life<br />
stress… The data obtained over a span of twenty years in the<br />
Italian-American community of Roseto, when compared with<br />
those of neighbouring communities, strongly suggests that the<br />
cultural characteristics – the qualities of a social organization –<br />
affect in some way individual susceptibility to myocardial<br />
infarction and sudden death. The implication is that an<br />
emotionally supportive social environment is protective and<br />
that, by contrast, the absence of family and community support<br />
and the lack of a well-defined role in society are risk factors.’<br />
(Bruhn and Wolf, 1979: 134, after Wilkinson, 1996: 117–118)<br />
The Construction of Social Cohesion and Capital<br />
The reasoning developed above notes the pivotal importance<br />
of social cohesion for development. The construction of social<br />
cohesion in urban areas – particularly in the larger centres – is<br />
an important task. On one hand, as already noted, cities and<br />
towns are strategic for the formation of social capital as they<br />
constitute spatial entities where people congregate. On the<br />
other hand, they constitute a challenge, especially the largest<br />
cities, considering that heterogeneity is a hallmark of urban<br />
communities. Such communities lack the spontaneous stock of<br />
social capital which is generally available in places where the<br />
inhabitants share the same ethnic-cultural background. A<br />
straightforward policy implication would be the need to invest<br />
in the construction of social cohesion. Governments have a<br />
role to play in investing in social capital, in supporting the<br />
voluntary and community organizations which nurture it. As<br />
Putnam (1993) has put it: ‘For political stability, for government<br />
effectiveness, and even for economic progress social capital<br />
may be even more important than physical or human capital’.<br />
Page 23<br />
3.4. Cultural Heritage and Local Pride<br />
The preservation/reinstatement of the cultural values of a<br />
society has a significant impact on development. Deterioration<br />
of historically important material cultural assets – structures,<br />
sites, objects, books and archives – results in loss of heritage<br />
and identity, as does the disappearance of cultural expression<br />
– music, language, folklore and crafts. A given community<br />
tends to have a greater stake in a development initiative when it<br />
relates to – or at least respects – the community’s cultural<br />
foundations. Cultural heritage also plays a very important role in<br />
reinforcing the pride of a community vis-à-vis the place where it<br />
lives. There is a social identification with a given city/town as a<br />
place (geographical entity): everybody within a local population<br />
belongs to the same place. Therefore, urban conservation<br />
enhances the social identification of the population with its city.<br />
On the contrary, many initiatives are wasted precisely because<br />
they overlook cultural foundations – exemplified by cases of<br />
vandalism in public infrastructure and buildings and the lack of<br />
use of public facilities. Therefore, it is imperative to preserve<br />
and reinstate the cultural dimension of the settlements, and to<br />
reinforce the sentiment of pride that the citizens feel towards<br />
their built milieu.<br />
The preservation of culture largely depends upon voluntary<br />
actions of individuals and groups – e.g. preservation within<br />
one’s private property; care of public spaces and buildings;<br />
collective efforts to restore endangered monuments and<br />
intangible assets, etc. These are attitudes which cannot be<br />
‘bought and sold’ in the private market; they are fundamentally<br />
based in voluntary/free will.<br />
The relationship between volunteerism and cultural heritage/local<br />
pride, if supported, provides the opportunity for the establishment<br />
of a virtuous cycle. This includes the preservation of the<br />
local culture; enhancement of the local pride increases people’s<br />
motivation to further invest in their settlement (i.e. increased<br />
propensity to do volunteer work). This additional investment in<br />
their place will generate further impact on the cultural heritage,<br />
local pride and so forth.
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART I –<br />
URBAN DEVELOPMENT AND VOLUNTEERISM<br />
The Importance of Volunteerism in Urban Development<br />
PART I –<br />
URBAN DEVELOPMENT AND VOLUNTEERISM<br />
The Importance of Volunteerism in Urban Development<br />
Page 24<br />
3.5. Benefits to the Volunteer<br />
Volunteering also brings benefits to the volunteer. In many parts<br />
of the world mutual support provides the essentials of life –<br />
food, clean water, health care, education – i.e. self-help schemes,<br />
as already noted. Volunteering is bound into the very fabric of<br />
life and is indivisible from the struggle for survival. In other parts<br />
of the world volunteering serves a very different function. Here<br />
volunteering is much more a life-style choice. People can chose<br />
whether or not to spend part of their free-time in a voluntary<br />
activity. Many millions do so and attest to the benefits of<br />
participation. Volunteering enables people to meet new friends;<br />
learn new skills; gain in confidence and self-respect. Perhaps<br />
above all, volunteering brings personal satisfaction. In one<br />
study in the UK volunteering was identified as the second<br />
greatest source of joy after dancing (Argyle, 1996).<br />
Page 25<br />
employment and the daily struggle for survival leaves little<br />
time or energy for voluntary work. There is a forceful critique<br />
of volunteering, particularly in the developing world, which<br />
dismisses volunteering as a ‘tax’ on the poor, in particular on<br />
poor women, already shouldering much of the burden of family<br />
care and (increasingly) of economic survival. But there is an<br />
alternative viewpoint: by shifting the focus away from service<br />
to others and emphasizing the personal benefits of involvement<br />
– broadening of networks, acquiring of skills and experience,<br />
help with finding paid employment – volunteering can be seen<br />
as a powerful empowering strategy for those suffering from<br />
economic and social disadvantage. For volunteering to<br />
contribute most effectively to social integration it is essential<br />
that opportunities for greater involvement be opened up to<br />
people from excluded groups.<br />
Volunteering brings particular benefits to those suffering from<br />
social exclusion, bearing in mind the extent of this problem in<br />
the settlements throughout the developing world. For people<br />
with disabilities participating in volunteering can aid social<br />
integration and challenge negative stereotypes of disabled<br />
people as passive recipients of care. For unemployed people<br />
volunteering can improve employability by providing essential<br />
work-experience and opportunities for skills development and<br />
training. For young people volunteering offers opportunities<br />
for self-development and risk-taking and provides a valuable<br />
grounding in the practice of citizenship. For older people<br />
volunteering has a positive contribution to make to the process<br />
of ‘active ageing’ by helping the newly retired adjust to life<br />
without the structure of the workplace, by providing<br />
opportunities for life-long learning and by improving physical<br />
and mental well-being. In addition to age-specific benefits,<br />
volunteering can help to ease tensions between age groups<br />
and foster notions of intergenerational solidarity through such<br />
mentoring initiatives as Foster Grandparent schemes.<br />
And yet in many countries there is an inverse relationship<br />
between volunteering and social exclusion. The most<br />
marginalized groups in society are the least likely to participate.<br />
The barriers to participation are well <strong>document</strong>ed: poverty,<br />
unemployment, youth alienation, poor organizational practice<br />
etc. One should be wary of trying to foist volunteering on those<br />
at the margins of society. For many people the search for paid
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART II – THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS<br />
PROGRAMME<br />
Page 26<br />
Page 27<br />
1. Introduction to UNV<br />
Set up as a UN subsidiary organ in 1970, the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong><br />
<strong>Volunteers</strong> (UNV) Programme is administered under the<br />
auspices of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Development Programme<br />
(UNDP). Its headquarters was moved from Geneva to Bonn<br />
in 1996.<br />
UNV’s urban agenda is built upon this agency’s overall<br />
framework of action, outlined above. That will be elaborated<br />
after a brief discussion on the general context of international<br />
assistance to urban development.<br />
UNV’s framework of action can be divided into two broad<br />
components: (i) promotion and support of the different types<br />
of volunteerism, and (ii) mobilization of UN <strong>Volunteers</strong>. In<br />
practice these two components are often – although not<br />
always – linked together. For the sake of better understanding,<br />
each component will be outlined separately.<br />
The promotion and support activities of UNV target all four<br />
types of volunteerism analysed in the first part of this paper<br />
(self-help, service to others, participation and advocacy). In<br />
many circumstances and places, local volunteers – be they<br />
institutions or individuals – have problems of their own. They<br />
may not be able to provide alone the volunteer response<br />
necessary for a given development problem. In such cases,<br />
UNV complements the local response and also builds local<br />
volunteer capacity, securing sustainability.<br />
In its turn, the mobilization of UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> fits within the<br />
volunteerism category of ‘service to others’. The UN <strong>Volunteers</strong><br />
are professionals who work in support of a wide range of<br />
development initiatives of governments, civil society organizations,<br />
private sector and international organizations. They are<br />
recruited on the basis of specific needs and post descriptions<br />
in the light of the blend of qualifications, skills and experience<br />
sought. UNV has a set of characteristics, which distinguishes it<br />
from other development actors (whether international or local).<br />
The role of a UN Volunteer in a given development project is<br />
different from that of a local volunteer. The UN Volunteer is<br />
able to tap immediately into the informational and technical<br />
apparatus of the UN system and to bring fresh and quick<br />
responses to emerging problems in the field. Furthermore, the<br />
neutrality of UNV helps in reducing the vulnerability level of a<br />
programme to internal political pressures, and in mediating<br />
between local stakeholders in a given project.
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
The international response to the urban problems of developing countries and UNV’s role<br />
Page 28<br />
2. The international response to the urban problems of<br />
2. developing countries and UNV’s role<br />
The importance of volunteerism in urban development, highlighted<br />
in the first part of this paper, has been recognized by<br />
many international agencies. Such agencies have offered<br />
promotion and support to volunteerism in specific sectors<br />
within their respective frameworks of action. For instance,<br />
WHO has supported volunteer contributions to improve urban<br />
health; UNICEF has supported similar contributions in fields<br />
of action related to children living in cities, UNESCO has done<br />
the same in the field of cultural heritage, etc.<br />
UNV’s framework of action, in its turn, includes volunteerism<br />
in general, that is, cutting across the various sectors of urban<br />
development. This has an important added-value, considering<br />
that urban development is by definition multisectoral. UNV has<br />
been catalysing the synergies and complementarity between<br />
the volunteer contributions in the different sectors of the<br />
development of a given city or town. UNV has also promoted<br />
and supported volunteer co-operation between different cities<br />
and towns.<br />
UNV also provides an added-value through the specific work<br />
of the UN <strong>Volunteers</strong>. By and large, the international agencies<br />
have responded to the urban problems of developing countries<br />
through macro-level initiatives. For example, there are many<br />
international initiatives of support for local/urban activities such<br />
as awareness-raising campaigns, processes of partnership<br />
building among the different urban stakeholders, and/or<br />
assistance to policy-making (see, for instance, Werna, 1996,<br />
2000, for reviews). At any rate, in order to be effective and<br />
sustainable, urban development initiatives need to be solidly<br />
anchored with the local stakeholders. This process requires<br />
labour-intensive, in-depth, long-term work. This is where the<br />
forte of the UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> exists.<br />
Page 29<br />
dation of the process with the stakeholders at the local level.<br />
However, the anchoring of development processes (especially<br />
those which are externally induced) at the local level is often<br />
not simple, and there are many examples of initiatives which<br />
have not fully succeeded. Therefore, UNV is well placed to<br />
secure the establishment of such initiatives, especially at the<br />
grassroots, through the extensive day-to-day, face-to-face, work<br />
of the UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> with the local stakeholders.<br />
In other cases, activities of international agencies do reach the<br />
local level, often via allied local organizations which operate in<br />
the field on a day-to-day long term basis. UNV also has a<br />
contribution to offer in such cases. Firstly, the work of the UN<br />
<strong>Volunteers</strong> in the field can help to expand the reach of international<br />
initiatives. In addition, the UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> can work with<br />
and within the very local organizations which are responsible<br />
for the implementation of these initiatives. Such organizations<br />
often face difficulties and have problems of their own, which<br />
UNV can help to address – e.g. through capacity building,<br />
technical assistance, institutional strengthening and other<br />
activities which again require the type of intervention that<br />
characterise the work of the UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> – e.g. labourintensive,<br />
in-depth, long-term work. Such interventions strengthen<br />
the implementation process through the local organizations.<br />
In some instances, the aforementioned urban actions of international<br />
agencies remain at the macro level (for example,<br />
workshops with city stakeholders, consultancy missions, fast<br />
campaigns to motivate local stakeholders to build synergies<br />
or/and to carry out specific tasks, etc.). It is expected that such<br />
short-term and intensive tasks would constitute the trigger or<br />
lay the necessary seeds for the replication and final consoli-
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper ‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
UNV’s niche in urban work<br />
Page 30<br />
3. UNV’s niche in urban work<br />
Following UNV’s overall framework of action, and its specific<br />
role as partner in international assistance for urban development,<br />
its urban agenda can be divided into two broad components:<br />
(i) promotion and support to the different types of volunteerism,<br />
and (ii) the mobilization of UN <strong>Volunteers</strong>.<br />
3.1. Promotion and support to volunteerism<br />
– Isolated initiatives: Each city or town comprises several<br />
volunteer organizations as well as individuals which<br />
contribute to the various sectors of its development. For<br />
example: grassroots (self-help) groups; solidarity groups<br />
with specific purposes, corporate volunteerism (e.g. private<br />
enterprises supporting communities), among others. UNV<br />
strives to strengthen existing initiatives, to support the<br />
creation of new ones in strategic areas, and to catalyse<br />
complementarity between them.<br />
– Collective attitudes and behaviours: volunteerism does not<br />
consist only of calculated and focused actions of organized<br />
groups (important as they are). Collective attitudes and<br />
behaviours such as the respect of human rights, the<br />
preservation of culture and of the environment largely depend<br />
upon voluntary actions. That is, they cannot be ‘bought and<br />
sold’ in the market place, rather they are fundamentally<br />
based on free will. Such collective attitudes and behaviours<br />
strengthen the social foundations of urban development,<br />
they therefore also have UNV’s support.<br />
– City-wide approach: UNV also promotes the establishment<br />
of mechanisms to put together in a systematic way all the<br />
volunteer activities in a given city or town. One way to do<br />
this is via the local government, the political authority which<br />
represents the city or town as a whole. Another way is the<br />
creation of a city-wide volunteer centre.<br />
– Inter-city volunteerism: this is important not only to support<br />
the development of poorer settlements, but also to create<br />
a broader sense of solidarity among people who live in<br />
different localities. UNV has promoted schemes of<br />
co-operation between local authorities, as well as inter-city<br />
corporate volunteerism.<br />
Page 31<br />
– New forms of volunteerism: UNV also strives to keep abreast<br />
with innovations in the field of volunteerism. One recent<br />
example is corporate volunteerism, which challenges the<br />
traditional view that volunteerism happens only via civil<br />
society organizations. Another example is the use of<br />
information technology (on-line volunteering). Further forms<br />
of volunteering are also taking shape. One of the most<br />
interesting is service credit, or time-dollar schemes, in<br />
which people who take part in voluntary activity are ‘paid’ in<br />
time donated by other volunteers. Advocates for such<br />
schemes point to their value in building social capital and in<br />
challenging traditional stereotypes of volunteering as charity<br />
by the explicit emphasis on exchange and reciprocity. All<br />
these forms of volunteerism have a role to play in urban<br />
development.<br />
The aforementioned actions are carried out through different<br />
means. In some cases, they take place directly via support from<br />
UNV Headquarters and in others via UNV Programme Officers<br />
stationed in the field. Some examples of such actions are:<br />
building partnerships, linking donors and local volunteer groups,<br />
connecting two different groups which want to establish an<br />
alliance based on voluntary exchanges, disseminating<br />
information about volunteerism, conducting awareness raising<br />
campaigns, etc.<br />
In other cases, the activities included in this first component of<br />
UNV’s urban agenda are often linked to the second component<br />
(based on the work of the UN <strong>Volunteers</strong>). For example, UN<br />
<strong>Volunteers</strong> directly build the capacity of and provide technical<br />
assistance to volunteer organizations in the field. In such cases,<br />
the outputs are enhanced because such initiatives benefit from<br />
the increased synergy accruing from volunteer-to-volunteer cooperation.<br />
A detailed view of the work of the UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> is<br />
presented below.<br />
3.2. The Mobilization of UN <strong>Volunteers</strong><br />
The second component of UNV’s urban agenda is based on<br />
the ‘service to others’ type of volunteerism. It entails the use of<br />
the comparative advantage of the UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> providing an<br />
added value in international co-operation for urban development.<br />
Such ‘service to others’ work of the UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> has been<br />
instrumental not only in supporting ‘pure’ volunteer activities
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
UNV’s niche in urban work<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
UNV’s niche in urban work<br />
Page 32<br />
(explained above), but also in providing volunteer component<br />
of broader initiatives, for instance, in supporting government<br />
gencies and the development of the private sector in the South.<br />
Selected attributes of the UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> to carry out urbanrelated<br />
work<br />
– Outreach work at the urban grassroots: human resources,<br />
labour-intensity, long term presence: overall, grassroots<br />
work is highly labour-intensive – as it entails long-term, dayto-day,<br />
face-to-face activities. According to Moser (1993),<br />
who studied and wrote widely on urban community work,<br />
the key component in such work is professionally trained<br />
staff to assist the communities in developing their own<br />
projects. According to her, ‘resources (other than human)<br />
to start these projects are often of secondary importance –<br />
especially because many of such projects, initiated or<br />
supported by civil society organizations, recognize the need<br />
to encourage self-reliant development without dependency.<br />
Consequently, project funds were most frequently spent<br />
not on physical infrastructural materials, but on the fielding<br />
of professionally-trained staff to assist the community in<br />
developing their projects.’ This clearly highlights the<br />
relevance of UNV’s contribution.<br />
Within the UN System, UNV is becoming known as an<br />
‘outreach’ agency, since the UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> often work<br />
directly with communities, fostering local participatory<br />
approaches to sustainable development. This ‘field<br />
perspective’ shapes the character of UNV’s work,<br />
emphasizing the kind of projects/programmes that can<br />
show direct impact down to the community level. At times,<br />
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> also live in the communities with which they<br />
work, thus experiencing their problems first-hand as well<br />
as identifying strengths and mobilizing indigenous resources.<br />
UNV is able to carry out outreach activities during extensive<br />
periods of time (considering, for instance, the extent of the<br />
assignments of the UN <strong>Volunteers</strong>); thus ensuring an in-depth<br />
contribution to the communities.<br />
– Broad scope of action and flexibility: problems and needs<br />
vary widely from city to city, and within cities. Therefore,<br />
broad scope of action and flexibility allow UNV to offer<br />
tailor-made responses to each specific situation and to<br />
adapt to many different circumstances. Universality in<br />
Page 33<br />
selection and placement is a distinguishing characteristic of<br />
the programme. For instance, during the period 1971–2001,<br />
more than 16,000 UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> from some 140 nations<br />
have worked in an equal number of countries. Such a<br />
diversity allows UNV to support a broad scope of initiatives<br />
in many different sectors of activity and geographic regions.<br />
The UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> are recruited on the basis of specific<br />
needs and post descriptions in the light of the blend of<br />
qualifications, skills and experience sought. They are people<br />
from different age groups, from mid-20s to over 60 years<br />
old. The average age of the UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> is 39. They are<br />
recruited from both developing and industrialized countries.<br />
There are more than 4,000 candidates on the UNV roster,<br />
in some 110 professional categories.<br />
There is also a variety of types of UN <strong>Volunteers</strong>. A given<br />
project can be supported by the most appropriate<br />
combination of profiles of UN <strong>Volunteers</strong>, including:<br />
- International and national UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Specialists: They<br />
are university graduates with considerable professional<br />
experience in many different fields. Also, the use of<br />
national volunteers has the added advantage of building<br />
local capacity through on-the-job training.<br />
- International and national UNV Field Workers: Majority<br />
of them drawn from local communities for their active<br />
leadership profiles. They contribute as UN <strong>Volunteers</strong><br />
through their inside/personal knowledge of grassroots<br />
communities.<br />
- UNV advisors recruited under two special programmes,<br />
TOKTEN (returning professionals to serve on short-term<br />
assignments) and UNISTAR (short-term advisory services,<br />
mainly in business development activities), as well as<br />
short-term specialists (especially in situations of conflict).<br />
- On-line services: In addition to mobilizing people to work<br />
directly in the field (‘on-site’ UN <strong>Volunteers</strong>), UNV is now<br />
also mobilizing volunteers who cannot travel to the field<br />
but can work from home using information and<br />
communication technology.
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
UNV’s niche in urban work<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
UNV’s niche in urban work<br />
Page 34<br />
- Mixed teams: often different types of UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> work<br />
together in one project. This mixed team approach provides<br />
the necessary combination of skills in a given project, and<br />
allows the UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> to learn from each other and to<br />
enhance the effectiveness of the project.<br />
- Special characteristics: UNV makes a continuous effort to<br />
design and provide innovative approaches. One illustration<br />
is the use of what could be called ‘mirror volunteers’,<br />
volunteers who have experienced a problem/need similar<br />
to that of the target population of a given project. For<br />
example, the use of local government volunteers. UNV<br />
offers its administrative apparatus to facilitate the fielding<br />
of public officers from the local government of a given city<br />
to travel to another city to provide assistance to their<br />
counterparts there.<br />
Mirror volunteers may also be used to empower excluded<br />
groups. For example, the use of disabled UN <strong>Volunteers</strong><br />
in a project which aims to increase the socio-economic<br />
opportunities of a group of disabled people. Another<br />
initiative of UNV in this front is the use of HIV-infected<br />
patients as UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> in a project targeting HIV-AIDS.<br />
The use of mirror volunteers in a given project provides a<br />
unique added-value that can only be achieved through the<br />
personal interaction between people who have<br />
experienced the same problem or need. In addition, the<br />
granting of UNV status to people such as the disabled<br />
and HIV-AIDS patients conveys a powerful symbolic<br />
message, i.e. that the U.N. recognizes the capacity of<br />
people that society often excludes.<br />
– Neutrality/impartiality: The existence of internal differences<br />
within and between urban communities and between<br />
different urban stakeholders often lead to conflicts. This<br />
highlights the value of another attribute of UNV. Being part<br />
of the UN system, UNV operates under the principles of<br />
both neutrality and impartiality in situations of conflict and<br />
of potential conflict among stakeholders. This helps in<br />
reducing a programme’s vulnerability to internal political<br />
pressures and in mediating between stakeholders in a<br />
given project/programme.<br />
Page 35<br />
– Speed of technical response: emergency situations<br />
constitute a sad and constant feature of many cities and<br />
towns in developing countries – taking into consideration<br />
that the urban poor live in precarious conditions (housing<br />
built with deficient materials and in hazardous settings, lack<br />
of food security, rise in urban violence, etc). When grassroots<br />
organizations need help from international agencies, the<br />
existence of intermediaries between the two often delays<br />
the process. Bearing this in mind, the unique combination<br />
of working at the grassroots level while being directly linked<br />
to the international system allows UNV to tap directly and<br />
constantly from the informational and technical apparatus of<br />
the UN, hence delivering fresh and quick technical<br />
responses to emerging problems in the field, whenever<br />
required.<br />
– Voluntary ethos: the UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> are able to use the above<br />
attributes in association with their voluntary ethos, which,<br />
as noted throughout in this paper, brings benefits of its own.<br />
– Human resources (volunteers) management: UNV can<br />
relieve other organizations from the complex process of<br />
managing human resources, i.e identifying, contracting,<br />
placing, administering and monitoring volunteers anywhere<br />
in the world. There are some 70 UNV Programme Officers<br />
in more than 60 countries, dedicated to managing the work<br />
of the volunteers in the field, and identifying opportunities<br />
for UNV. Over the years UNV has developed stable, proven<br />
procedures (including standard ‘Conditions of Service’) to<br />
manage and co-ordinate volunteer operations globally.<br />
A case for sustainability<br />
As in the case of any other form of external/international<br />
assistance, attention should be paid to the sustainability of<br />
the actions of the UN <strong>Volunteers</strong>. Therefore, their interventions<br />
are designed with such a concern in mind. In this regard, it is<br />
important to note that it is not only possible to achieve this<br />
objective, but in many cases the very work of the UN <strong>Volunteers</strong><br />
becomes the agent of sustainability. Because, in many circumstances,<br />
the sustainability of development projects is consolidated<br />
through long-term work at the grassroots, i.e. exactly the type<br />
of work carried out by the UN <strong>Volunteers</strong>. The next section will<br />
present a selected number of concrete activities of UNV,<br />
through which the aforementioned attributes are realized.
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
UNV’s niche in urban work<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
UNV’s niche in urban work<br />
Page 36<br />
Selected types of contributions of UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> in urban<br />
related work<br />
– Organisational/institutional strengthening: as noted in a<br />
previous publication produced by UNV (1995: 45): ‘In<br />
most cases… external catalysing agents play an important<br />
role in initiating and consolidating the development process<br />
[of communities], or accelerating what otherwise would<br />
have taken much longer to evolve’. An important part of<br />
such work concerns the strengthening of grassroots<br />
organizations, such as CBOs (community-based organiza<br />
tions). These organizations have played a crucial role in the<br />
development of urban communities – e.g. by constituting a<br />
forum for each community to get together, organize itself<br />
and strengthen its social cohesion/capital; by representing<br />
the whole community vis-à-vis the government and other<br />
external actors, by catalysing external support, etc.<br />
However, such organizations have problems of their<br />
own. While they are generally spontaneously formed,<br />
without technical planning or managerial backing, they often<br />
end up carrying out significant institutional tasks. A large<br />
number of urban communities have thousands of members,<br />
sometimes even hundreds of thousands (such as the Tondo<br />
in Manila, Rocinha in Rio, among others). In such cases, the<br />
tasks – and challenges – of urban grassroots organizations<br />
are often closer to those of local government – at least in<br />
terms of being a representative of the local population,<br />
fighting for them along with other stakeholders and bringing<br />
in external resources. The difference is that local governmental<br />
institutions are planned from the outset, and receive<br />
managerial and technical support of various types and<br />
sources. However, in order to be maximally effective, these<br />
urban grassroots organizations often need support of<br />
varying nature. Like other types of sizeable organizations,<br />
they need a proper institutional design, and a plan of action<br />
for proper institutional functioning. The role played and tasks<br />
undertaken by the CBO’s directly benefit from the interactive<br />
attributes of UN <strong>Volunteers</strong>, such as: (i) ability to do<br />
labour-intensive work, (ii) long term involvement, (iii) broad<br />
scope of action (to address the range of institutional needs<br />
throughout the world), (iv) flexibility (to address the<br />
differences within and between grassroots organizations),<br />
(v) neutrality (to deal with heterogeneous communities) and<br />
(vi) volunteerism (to enhance the voluntary ethos of such<br />
Page 37<br />
organizations). Beside CBOs, other organizations such as<br />
local NGOs and even local government authorities often<br />
need the same type of support, and therefore may benefit<br />
from UNV’s inputs.<br />
– Managerial capacity-building: the aforementioned institutions<br />
often lack managerial skills to deal with many day-to-day<br />
hurdles or to incorporate the institutional changes noted<br />
above. Capacity-building constitutes another type of task<br />
which would gain from the unified effect of some of the<br />
characteristics of the UN <strong>Volunteers</strong>, i.e. (i) labour-intensive,<br />
(ii) long term work, (iii) flexibility (to address differences<br />
within and between organizations); (iv) volunteerism (to<br />
secure more intense interpersonal connection and synergism,<br />
especially in the case of voluntary organizations). Another<br />
route to capacity-building is the substantive involvement of<br />
national UN <strong>Volunteers</strong>, who learn through on-the-job<br />
training during the execution of the project(s).<br />
– Technical capacity-building: the aforementioned institutions<br />
also have deficiencies in technical staff (accountants, information<br />
agents, fund-raisers, among many others), therefore<br />
require training schemes. Also, many urban communities<br />
have a considerable number of people working in the same<br />
professional field (e.g. fishermen, bricklayers, rickshaw<br />
drivers, domestic servants, etc.), a fact which could justify<br />
the establishment of a training scheme in such a field. This<br />
type of task is similar to the previous one, therefore would<br />
also benefit from UNV’s inputs.<br />
– Community animation/orientation: most urban community<br />
members are not aware of their rights and opportunities in<br />
the city – due to illiteracy and/or recent migration – therefore<br />
do not benefit from them. In addition, newcomers are often<br />
not aware of the risks and challenges of urban life. Such a<br />
situation reveals the importance of a professional who raises<br />
the awareness, among the community members, of their<br />
rights and orients them in respect of the risks and challenges<br />
as well as the opportunities and the benefits of urban living.<br />
This constitutes another type of assignment which matches<br />
UNV’s forte, as it has to be carried out within the communities<br />
on a day-to-day, face-to-face basis over extensive periods of<br />
time. The field worker (Section 1) is one type of UN<br />
Volunteer that would be particularly appropriate for such an
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
UNV’s niche in urban work<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
UNV’s niche in urban work<br />
Page 38<br />
assignment. Field workers are community members themselves,<br />
who could therefore well convey their experience in<br />
the city to their less knowledgeable/prepared counterparts.<br />
– Participatory work: the utmost importance of social<br />
cohesion/capital has already been noted in this publication.<br />
It suffices to say that participatory work is at the heart of<br />
the process of construction of social cohesion/capital.<br />
External support to carry out this type of work is of utmost<br />
importance because: (i) participatory processes are often<br />
more difficult to build in cities due to the hurdles of urban<br />
life (less time to do the ground work necessary to start the<br />
process) and due to the heterogeneity of the communities<br />
(lack of a common ethnic-cultural background); (ii)<br />
community participation was (sometimes still is) politically<br />
repressed in a number of countries; (iii) some cultures do<br />
not have a strong tradition of participatory work. The role<br />
and importance of UNV in the construction of social<br />
cohesion/capital was noted before in this paper. The same<br />
applies, by association, to participatory work.<br />
– Mediation between local stakeholders: the current worldwide<br />
attention on (urban) governance has already been noted.<br />
Urban governance concerns the relationship between local<br />
authorities and civil society, entailing negotiations and joint<br />
ventures between different local stakeholders. It may be<br />
seen as a participatory process at the city level. Therefore,<br />
it would benefit from the type of work described above. It is<br />
also worth noting that the neutrality/impartiality of the UN<br />
<strong>Volunteers</strong> may be particularly valuable in such a context of<br />
mediation. There are of course qualitative differences<br />
between the construction of a participatory process within<br />
a community, and the construction of a governance process<br />
within a city. The type of professional required for each task<br />
is therefore different.<br />
Page 39<br />
from professionals who could establish the initial links and<br />
start up the whole process.<br />
– Technical assistance: although external technical assistance<br />
has been criticized for not being sustainable, it is still vital<br />
particularly in least developed countries and/or in situations<br />
of emergency. Under such circumstances, technical<br />
assistance may be pivotal for development and many times<br />
(such as in emergencies) even a matter of life and death.<br />
There is a wide range of technical activities – especially at<br />
the grassroots – which would benefit from the interactiveness<br />
of the attributes of the UN <strong>Volunteers</strong>, as they are labourintensive,<br />
volunteer-oriented, long term activities (for example,<br />
the whole range of mutual self-help construction work). Also,<br />
technical assistance can indeed be combined with capacitybuilding,<br />
a fact which would reinforce the sustainability of<br />
the activities.<br />
In short, this section has presented selected types of contributions<br />
of UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> to urban development – without<br />
pretending to have exhausted all possibilities. Rather than overlapping<br />
with or duplicating efforts of other development agencies,<br />
UNV is able to offer a unique contribution. Next, UNV’s<br />
specific contribution in the different sectors of urban development<br />
will be elaborated, with concrete examples.<br />
– Mobilization of resources: in several instances, urban projects<br />
require external resources, as cities and their communities<br />
are often not self-sufficient in everything – especially in such<br />
globalized times of increasing interdependence. However, it<br />
is precisely the most resourceful cities and communities<br />
which have the means (skills, contacts, communication<br />
technology, etc.) to obtain further resources. The poorest<br />
settlements lack such means. Therefore, they would benefit
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
Thematic view and illustrations<br />
Page 40<br />
Page 41<br />
4. Thematic view and illustrations<br />
There are different ways to disaggregate the complex and<br />
multisectoral field of urban development. In this paper, this field<br />
will be divided into five broad domains (which are not mutually<br />
exclusive): political & institutional, social, economic, physical<br />
and cultural.<br />
UNV has acted in all these domains through the two components<br />
of its urban agenda i.e. promotion and support to the different<br />
types of volunteerism, and the mobilisation of UN <strong>Volunteers</strong>.<br />
4.1. The political & institutional domain<br />
Municipal management<br />
The roles of local and municipal authorities in developing<br />
countries are changing fast, due to several facts which may<br />
occur independently or concomitantly in a given city or town,<br />
for instance:<br />
– The process of privatisation of public services in the urban<br />
areas: it is wrong to say that this process entails only a<br />
transfer of activities and responsibilities from the public to<br />
the private sector (which could lead to the conclusion that<br />
the role of the public sector would become ‘easier’). This<br />
process entails a change of roles in the public sector, and<br />
some of the new roles may be much more complex and<br />
difficult than the previous ones, for example the public<br />
regulation of an expanding number of private enterprises,<br />
new systems of a public-private mix (subcontracting,<br />
bidding, franchising, etc.).<br />
– The process of democratisation, which includes community<br />
participation and governance building: this process also<br />
entails roles for local authorities (vis-à-vis the civil society)<br />
which are very different from traditional roles such as<br />
paternalistic administration, clientelism, let alone non-democratic<br />
administration (e.g. unelected mayors ).<br />
– The process of political-administrative devolution, which<br />
transfers roles and responsibilities from upper layers of the<br />
government to the local authorities.<br />
A --------------------------------------------<br />
Volunteer support to the<br />
Municipalities’ Association of<br />
Nepal<br />
----------------------------------------------<br />
MuAN (Municipalities Association<br />
of Nepal) is an umbrella<br />
organisation, which represents<br />
all the municipalities in the<br />
country. Its current and planned<br />
duties include advocacy, facilitation,<br />
resource mobilisation, and<br />
technical assistance in specific<br />
fields. The UNV role in this<br />
project is to strengthen MuAN’s<br />
capacity.<br />
Support to address MuAN’s<br />
constraints requires activities<br />
which match UNV’s strengths.<br />
These activities include institutional<br />
re-organisation, managerial<br />
and technical capacity building,<br />
and mediation between stakeholders.<br />
Such activities fit into<br />
the UNV preferred pattern of<br />
labour-intensive, outreach, longterm<br />
work, and neutrality/impartiality.<br />
Also, the fact that the<br />
project is linked to an umbrella<br />
organisation responsible for all<br />
municipalities provides a unique<br />
opportunity for the UN <strong>Volunteers</strong><br />
to promote and strengthen<br />
volunteerism at the urban level<br />
throughout the whole country<br />
through (I) advice to policymaking,<br />
(II) direct contacts with<br />
local authorities, and (III) demonstration<br />
activities in partnership<br />
with civil society organisations.<br />
The project was formulated in<br />
partnership with MuAN, UNDP<br />
Nepal and GTZ. The project<br />
lasts for 3 years, and concludes<br />
with a ‘phasing-out’ period during<br />
which the UNV team will just be<br />
monitoring the activities of the<br />
local staff, who will be in full<br />
control of the day-to-day operations,<br />
and will also be involved<br />
in the formulation of activities to<br />
be implemented after the end of<br />
the project. This will ensure<br />
sustainability. The local partners<br />
also will contribute in kind and/or<br />
in cash for the execution of the<br />
demonstration activities included<br />
in the project. In addition, all<br />
local authorities already contribute<br />
to MuAN. These facts not only<br />
guarantee the commitment of<br />
such partners, but also illustrate<br />
evidence of the existence of<br />
local resources — which can be<br />
used after the termination of the<br />
project. Finally, the project is<br />
designed in such a way that<br />
MuAN takes full ownership of it.<br />
The leadership of MuAN will be<br />
supported and strengthened by<br />
the project.<br />
– The process of globalisation: local authorities increasingly<br />
need to adapt themselves to respond to changes and<br />
challenges accruing from the rapidly moving international<br />
milieu, which affect the local level.<br />
A large number of local governments in developing countries<br />
face strong difficulties in coping with such an overwhelming<br />
wave of changes, and would benefit from types of UNV<br />
assistance noted in the previous section, such as institutional<br />
strengthening, capacity building, resource mobilisation and<br />
technical assistance. UNV has a growing portfolio of projects<br />
in this area in different parts of the world. One example is the<br />
on-going project in Nepal, illustrated in text A.
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
Thematic view and illustrations<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
Thematic view and illustrations<br />
Page 42<br />
Page 43<br />
City-to-city co-operation<br />
UNV is also supporting municipal management by way of cityto-city<br />
co-operation.<br />
A large number of cities from industrialised countries have<br />
established programmes of direct assistance to cities from<br />
developing countries. A number of cities in the developing<br />
world itself are also engaged in similar activities to support<br />
their counterparts in need. Such co-operation between cities<br />
is already a noticeable fact, with hundreds of ‘donor’ cities at<br />
work. This has been increasingly noted in the technical as well<br />
as academic literature on development, which already coined<br />
terms to refer to this widespread phenomenon: ‘city-to-city cooperation’,<br />
‘local level co-operation’ or ‘decentralised co-operation’.<br />
In addition, considering the widespread global trend of politicaladministrative<br />
devolution of power, municipal governments are<br />
likely to gain even more autonomy from central governments.<br />
This means that city-to-city co-operation is likely to grow even<br />
more.<br />
City-to-city support is significant to a large number of local<br />
authorities. The roles of such authorities throughout developing<br />
and transitional countries are changing fast, due to several facts<br />
already described in this paper. These changes have imposed<br />
extra burdens on municipalities.<br />
International assistance to municipalities has not been able to<br />
address their limitations and accommodate the changes properly.<br />
One difficulty — widely heralded by local stakeholders – is that<br />
multilateral or bilateral aid often (or forcibly) comes via central<br />
government authorities. This fact delays or severely cuts down<br />
the aid to the targeted municipalities. This is due to inefficient<br />
administration of central government staff, malfeasance and/or<br />
boycott (e.g. when a local authority is from an opposition party).<br />
In this context, city-to-city co-operation plays a significant role,<br />
as it can provide direct support to local governments.<br />
There is also an alternative argument justifying the inefficiency<br />
of international assistance to municipalities. It does not focus<br />
on the possible problems of central government authorities, but<br />
on the simple fact that the needs of municipalities are just<br />
enormous, vis-à-vis the limited resources of the multilateral and<br />
bilateral agencies. Also, in this alternate scenario, the importance<br />
of city-to-city co-operation surfaces. The resources of donor<br />
B --------------------------------------------<br />
Enhancing volunteerism in cityto-city<br />
co-operation in different<br />
parts of the world<br />
-----------------------------------------------<br />
UNV has an on-going project<br />
with IULA (International Union of<br />
Local Authorities), which includes<br />
two components. The first<br />
component consists of support<br />
to two IULA regional offices for<br />
the establishment of a campaign<br />
to mobilise donor cities, and the<br />
establishment of a database to<br />
match supply and demand for<br />
city-to-city cooperation. The<br />
second component focuses on<br />
the support to a number of<br />
individual initiatives of city-tocity<br />
co-operation in different<br />
parts of the world (the initiatives<br />
are selected by IULA). Overall,<br />
the project promotes and<br />
fosters solidarity between local<br />
governments.<br />
C --------------------------------------------<br />
Volunteer support to urban<br />
governance in Port Harcourt<br />
(Nigeria) with a focus on children<br />
-----------------------------------------------<br />
UNV has provided support to the<br />
implementation of the Child<br />
Friendly Cities Initiative in Port<br />
Harcourt, Nigeria. Child Friendly<br />
Cities is a global initiative of<br />
UNICEF, and is currently being<br />
launched in a number of<br />
countries. It is based on an<br />
integrated approach to urban<br />
development where all local<br />
stakeholders are encouraged to<br />
form partnerships to defend the<br />
rights and address the needs of<br />
the urban children, especially<br />
cities are often independent of those of other international<br />
donors, which means that they constitute an added-value in<br />
such a context.<br />
City-to-city co-operation is related to UNV’s framework of action<br />
because it entails volunteerism and solidarity among local<br />
governments. It includes the work of experts funded by and<br />
sent from one city to another. Therefore, it constitutes an innovative<br />
type of volunteerism: ‘local government volunteers’.<br />
The importance of UNV’s support to city-to-city co-operation<br />
comes from the fact that the missions of the experts from the<br />
donor cities often represent an extra burden to their local<br />
governments. This is because they entail many procedures,<br />
which are not part of the day-to-day business of local authorities:<br />
that is, administrating the trip and taking care of experts overseas.<br />
These procedures are part of UNV’s day-to-day business.<br />
Therefore, UNV’s support in this field increases the efficiency<br />
of the programmes of the cities which already send their experts,<br />
and, at the same time, provides an opportunity for new cities<br />
which do not have the means to do it on their own. UNV is<br />
open to work with individual cities, and at the same time, it has<br />
developed a broader initiative with IULA (International Union of<br />
Local Authorities) (see text B).<br />
Urban governance<br />
The growing importance of urban governance has been noted<br />
in this publication. In many instances, local stakeholders do not<br />
have the collective skills to start such a process naturally, due<br />
to lack of tradition or due to a history of repression. Also, in<br />
many circumstances, the construction of links between local<br />
stakeholders is pre-empted by conflicting interests. These facts<br />
underline the importance of UNV mediators at least in the initial<br />
stages of the process, plus participatory work.<br />
It is also important to recall the role that volunteerism plays in<br />
the formation of social cohesion, already mentioned.<br />
Considering that governance entails relationships between<br />
public authorities and civil society, it greatly depends upon the<br />
establishment of strong cohesion between the stakeholders.<br />
UNV has implemented a number of projects, which relate to<br />
urban governance in different ways. Some of them concentrate<br />
on specific problems or needs, and build a governance process
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
Thematic view and illustrations<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
Thematic view and illustrations<br />
Page 44<br />
between local authorities and local communities with a focus<br />
on addressing their problems and needs. Examples include the<br />
support to urban environment improvement in N’djamena (Chad)<br />
and Dakar (Senegal), public services to markets in Tema (Ghana)<br />
and children’s issues in Port Harcourt (Nigeria). Other projects<br />
include an urban component as part of a broader governance<br />
initiative (e.g. in Kyrgyzstan, Burkina Faso and The Gambia).<br />
Text C and text D illustrations given below briefly describe the<br />
projects which build processes of urban governance around<br />
the solution of specific needs, i.e. children’s issues in Port<br />
Harcourt, and municipal taxes in Tema. Text D also illustrates<br />
more explicitly the connection between volunteerism and social<br />
cohesion. Text E illustrates one project in which urban<br />
governance is part of a broader initiative, i.e. decentralisation in<br />
Kyrgyzstan.<br />
the poor and most disadvantaged.<br />
The efforts of all local stakeholders<br />
are centred on an axis<br />
linking community-based organisations<br />
and local government<br />
authorities. The specific activities<br />
of the initiative to be implemented<br />
in a given city are designed and<br />
gathered under the framework<br />
of a Local Plan of Action.<br />
The UNV project aims to anchor<br />
the Child Friendly Cities Initiative<br />
with the key local partners in<br />
the municipality of Port Harcourt,<br />
Nigeria. UNV has fielded a team<br />
constituted by two specialists<br />
and ten field workers. The UN<br />
Volunteer specialists have trained<br />
the staff of the governmental<br />
agencies on the Child Friendly<br />
Cities concept, reinforced the<br />
connections between the local<br />
government and the local<br />
communities, and co-ordinated<br />
at the local level the implementation<br />
of the Plan of Action. The<br />
field workers have strengthened<br />
the participation of the community<br />
in the implementation of the<br />
Plan of Action.<br />
The project has also started to<br />
produce concrete benefits for<br />
the communities targeted such<br />
as improved sanitary facilities<br />
and a health centre that have<br />
been made possible through the<br />
participation of the UN <strong>Volunteers</strong>.<br />
Water sources have also been<br />
improved by applying modern<br />
and durable building methods.<br />
This ensures that the communities<br />
are able to draw water from<br />
Page 45<br />
safe and sanitary sources thus<br />
ensuring better health conditions<br />
among the inhabitants. A particular<br />
area of great advantage is<br />
the building of a staircase in the<br />
Enugu Waterfront Community. It<br />
appears that before the staircase<br />
was constructed, many of the<br />
children and elderly were constantly<br />
hurt and displayed broken<br />
limbs as a result of having to<br />
jump from one side to the other.<br />
However, since its construction,<br />
the injuries have been greatly<br />
reduced to almost none.<br />
D --------------------------------------------<br />
Social cohesion and volunteering:<br />
the construction of a process of<br />
governance involving taxpayers<br />
and local authorities in Tema<br />
(Ghana).<br />
-----------------------------------------------<br />
The project addresses causes<br />
of the shortcomings in the municipal<br />
system of collection and<br />
management of taxes. These<br />
shortcomings constitute a serious<br />
and recurring problem in Tema<br />
and in many other cities. They<br />
have a direct effect on the<br />
capability of the local governments<br />
to provide the urban infrastructure<br />
and services, and,<br />
consequently, to foster the local<br />
economy and to guarantee a<br />
minimum standard of living for<br />
the urban populations. There is<br />
widespread non payment of<br />
taxes, a problem which is fundamentally<br />
related to lack of social<br />
cohesion and confidence. Taxpayers<br />
do not trust local authorities<br />
regarding the management<br />
of the taxes collected.<br />
In this project, UNV therefore<br />
works with taxpayers and the<br />
local authorities to bring about<br />
a civic process to build trust<br />
and strengthen cohesion. The<br />
project also builds technical<br />
capacity within the local government.<br />
The project is based on<br />
the specific attributes of the UN<br />
<strong>Volunteers</strong> – outreach and grassroots<br />
work. Their neutrality, trustworthiness<br />
and solidarity are<br />
fundamental to brokering between<br />
stakeholders and to building<br />
their mutual confidence. The<br />
project is being implemented in<br />
partnership with the UMP<br />
(Urban Management Programme).<br />
The UMP contributes with<br />
technical supervision and backstopping<br />
of the UN <strong>Volunteers</strong><br />
and with specific studies of<br />
municipal revenue systems.<br />
E --------------------------------------------<br />
Volunteer support to<br />
decentralisation in Kyrgystan<br />
-----------------------------------------------<br />
This project is under the directive<br />
of UNDP. UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> in the<br />
country live in small urban settlements<br />
and in rural districts to<br />
assist communities in planning<br />
and carrying out development<br />
projects. The project reaches<br />
1,000,000 inhabitants.<br />
Mixed teams of 20 international<br />
and national UN <strong>Volunteers</strong><br />
working as regional advisors,<br />
local development officials and<br />
fieldworkers form the outreach<br />
arm of the project. They get the<br />
people involved through local<br />
organisations to improve access<br />
to information and drum up<br />
funds for community projects. In<br />
one small municipality, for<br />
example, UNVs helped form 21<br />
organisations.<br />
Responses from three separate<br />
districts report that the benefits<br />
of such UNV intervention are<br />
manifest in the areas of capacity<br />
building, providing training skills<br />
through participatory methods,<br />
involving women in leadership<br />
and decentralisation.
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
Thematic view and illustrations<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
Thematic view and illustrations<br />
Page 46<br />
Volunteer organisations<br />
Volunteer organisations are surely of major importance in UNV’s<br />
urban agenda. A large part of the first component of this agenda<br />
– support and promotion of the different forms of volunteerism<br />
– is realised through working with such organisations, e.g. selfhelp<br />
groups, advocacy groups, service-to-other groups and<br />
others. The work of many UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> (second component<br />
of the agenda) also entails support to such types of groups.<br />
This publication highlighted that volunteer organisations based<br />
in urban areas have problems of their own, therefore benefiting<br />
from UNV support in areas such as institutional strengthening,<br />
capacity building, resource mobilisation and technical assistance.<br />
The outputs of the activities are enhanced because they<br />
benefit from the increased synergy accruing from volunteer-tovolunteer<br />
co-operation.<br />
Text F, G and H below exemplify different types of projects. In<br />
the first one UNV supports urban grassroots communities to<br />
strengthen their skills in the self-help and participation types<br />
of volunteerism. Text G describes a project in which UNV<br />
supports the creation of a university volunteer scheme<br />
to work on the reconstruction of settlements. Text H illustrates<br />
the assistance to volunteer groups which are formally involved<br />
in local government.<br />
F --------------------------------------------<br />
Volunteer support to strengthen<br />
urban communities in Costa<br />
Rica and Honduras<br />
-----------------------------------------------<br />
This project entails supporting<br />
the implementation of urban<br />
community centres which were<br />
established with the support of<br />
UNCHS (Habitat). The centres<br />
are owned and managed by a<br />
local community-based organization,<br />
and aim at providing lowincome<br />
people better access to<br />
services/resources such as<br />
advice to local businesses, promotion<br />
of local products, job<br />
information, community loans.<br />
The implementation of the<br />
centres entails in-depth and<br />
long-term work with and within<br />
local communities. This implies<br />
not only co-ordinating the<br />
activities, but also setting in<br />
motion a process of capacity<br />
building and community<br />
strengthening, which ultimately<br />
guarantees the sustainability of<br />
the actions. Consequently the<br />
need for establishing the<br />
centres has been identified as<br />
an appropriate niche for UNV to<br />
intervene. UNV is constituted in<br />
such a way as to be able to<br />
carry out in-depth, outreach and<br />
capacity-building activities at<br />
the grassroots level, working<br />
with(in) local communities for<br />
long periods of time.<br />
G --------------------------------------------<br />
The establishment of a<br />
university volunteers service to<br />
Page 47<br />
support the reconstruction of<br />
settlements in Nicaragua<br />
-----------------------------------------------<br />
This project is linked to a<br />
UNDP/UNCHS (Habitat)<br />
programme, which supports the<br />
development of outreach settlements<br />
in the aftermath of Hurricane<br />
Mitch. The UNV project<br />
contributes to anchoring the<br />
overall programme at the local<br />
level.<br />
The project builds upon the cooperation<br />
between UNV and<br />
two national universities in the<br />
context of a University Volunteer<br />
Service (UVS). Nicaraguan<br />
graduates support the field<br />
activities of the aforementioned<br />
programme and therefore not<br />
only contribute to the development<br />
of outreach settlements<br />
but also receive practical training.<br />
Their experiences are<br />
<strong>document</strong>ed and used as learning<br />
material in the universities.<br />
In order to strengthen and<br />
formalise existing experiments<br />
of university volunteering, one<br />
UN Volunteer works directly<br />
with the universities, thus ensuring<br />
the sustainable design of the<br />
scheme.<br />
Altogether, the project promotes<br />
volunteerism among recently<br />
graduated professionals and<br />
community members in<br />
Nicaragua through activities<br />
related to urban areas. Ultimately,<br />
the inhabitants of the selected<br />
outreach settlements will<br />
benefit from this initiative and at<br />
the same time, the new<br />
professionals will profit from it<br />
in terms of personal and<br />
professional development.<br />
H --------------------------------------------<br />
Volunteerism as a pillar of urban<br />
management in Bhutan<br />
-----------------------------------------------<br />
Starting in June 2000, a<br />
Volunteer Action Group (VAG)<br />
in each ward of Phuentsholing<br />
City in Bhutan meets at least<br />
once a month. Composed of<br />
residents and business owners<br />
interested in the welfare of their<br />
community and dedicated to<br />
improving overall life in<br />
Phuentsholing, the VAG can<br />
bring up any issue, from parking<br />
problems to waste disposal,<br />
with the PCC (Phuentsholing<br />
City Council). By creating<br />
pressure groups out of<br />
volunteers, PCC hopes to make<br />
its operations more accountable<br />
and responsive. The VAG<br />
depends on concerned residents<br />
who receive no compensation,<br />
yet are willing to give up their<br />
time for the welfare of their<br />
community. The scheme is supported<br />
by UNV and by VSO<br />
(the British volunteer-sending<br />
agency).<br />
Using a map devised by the<br />
surveyors, PCC has divided<br />
Phuentsholing into 15 wards,<br />
each of which has a VAG<br />
composed of 5–10 community<br />
volunteers nominated by the<br />
Ward Community.<br />
The volunteers, according to<br />
PCC VAG Guidelines, ‘should<br />
be driven by the desire to<br />
improve the environment of the<br />
Community as a whole. ‘ A<br />
PCC employee in each ward<br />
serves as a Ward in Charge, a<br />
liaison between the ward and<br />
PCC. The Ward-in-Charge<br />
relays the concerns brought up<br />
in the VAG meetings to PCC<br />
and ensures that PCC responds<br />
with some type of action. For<br />
example, the VAG may complain<br />
that residents repeatedly litter<br />
the community areas. The Ward<br />
in Charge informs PCC, which<br />
decides to authorize the VAG to<br />
issue fines to persistent litterbugs.<br />
Or the VAG may decide<br />
to act on its own and initiate an<br />
anti-littering campaign. Or PCC<br />
may decide to empty rubbish<br />
pits more often. The options are<br />
unlimited. The immediate purpose<br />
is communication and<br />
participation, mainly regarding<br />
sanitation, but the VAG can<br />
bring up any issue they like.<br />
School crossings, safety, and<br />
security – there’s no limit. By<br />
encouraging volunteers throughout<br />
Phuentsholing to participate<br />
in city planning, the VAG will<br />
give every resident and business<br />
a stake in the future of the city.<br />
The forging of a communal spirit<br />
can also improve the social<br />
cohesion of Phuentsholing.
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
Thematic view and illustrations<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
Thematic view and illustrations<br />
Page 48<br />
Page 49<br />
4.2. The social domain<br />
There is a whole set of social problems, which occur predominantly<br />
in urban areas. Largely they are derived from stressors<br />
related to urbanisation such as overcrowding, pollution, longdistance<br />
commuting in precarious circumstances, lack of sociocultural<br />
bonds, lack of access to basic services, etc. A selected<br />
number of social problems related to urbanization are discussed<br />
below.<br />
Abandoned children<br />
While this is an overwhelming – and continuously expanding –<br />
problem in urban settlements throughout the developing world,<br />
it seldom happens in rural areas. It is clearly connected to the<br />
urbanization process, and often takes place due to the breakdown<br />
of family bonds (<strong>associated</strong> with the loss of ethniccultural<br />
bonds in cities and/or to other effects of the pressures<br />
of urban living). Even when (low-income) families do not fall<br />
apart, the adults cannot frequently take proper care of the<br />
children — again due to urban pressures: stress and/or need to<br />
stay away from home to make a living (e.g. Werna et al., 1999).<br />
Solving this problem clearly requires preventive action, which<br />
in turn entails direct, long-term work with low-income families<br />
and communities, and with children at risk. This shows the<br />
advantages of UNV’s roles in tasks such as community animation<br />
and orientation, participatory work, income generation and<br />
grassroots technical assistance (psychologists, councillors and<br />
social assistants).<br />
In parallel to the above, curative actions are also necessary to<br />
assist the large numbers of children who are already on the<br />
streets. Again, direct, long-term work — in this case with the<br />
abandoned children themselves — is absolutely required to help<br />
this particular group which consists of often psychologically<br />
traumatized individuals, who are exposed to problems such as<br />
discrimination, homelessness, malnutrition, drug-taking, infections<br />
diseases, prostitution, crime and violence. Thus, UNV’s grassroots<br />
technical assistance is of primary importance (i.e.<br />
professionals working directly with the children). It is worth<br />
re-emphasising the importance of UNV’s volunteer ethos. The<br />
spirit of solidarity transmitted through voluntary work is crucial<br />
to build trust and confidence in such children in especially<br />
difficult circumstances.<br />
I --------------------------------------------<br />
Volunteer support to street<br />
children in Latin America<br />
-----------------------------------------------<br />
Street children in Tegucigalpa,<br />
Honduras and Managua,<br />
Nicaragua have been piloting<br />
their own solutions to problems<br />
of exclusion, glue-sniffing and<br />
precarious income earning for<br />
themselves and their families<br />
with the help of UN <strong>Volunteers</strong><br />
whose assignments were<br />
funded by the Government of<br />
Belgium.<br />
In other countries such as<br />
Ecuador and Brazil, UN<br />
<strong>Volunteers</strong> helped street children<br />
by providing training in handicrafts,<br />
introducing teenagers to<br />
potential employers and teaching<br />
language skills.<br />
In addition to the above ‘handson’<br />
activities, street children in<br />
Latin America have also been<br />
supported through broader<br />
initiatives. For example, UNV is<br />
currently supporting the governments<br />
of Central American<br />
countries to address issues<br />
about sexual exploitation, child<br />
labour and unemployment.<br />
Since early 1999, 21 UN <strong>Volunteers</strong><br />
have been working on<br />
such regional activities, focusing<br />
their efforts mainly at the legislative<br />
level. The UN <strong>Volunteers</strong><br />
have helped to draft laws and<br />
train judges, lawyers and government<br />
officials on how to apply<br />
the Convention on the Rights of<br />
the Child.<br />
J --------------------------------------------<br />
Volunteer support to<br />
adolescents involved in law<br />
violations in Central America<br />
-----------------------------------------------<br />
It is a known fact that many<br />
adolescents who commit minor<br />
offences are brutally treated by<br />
law enforcement officers. This<br />
often contributes not to prevent<br />
them from repeating the offences,<br />
but actually force them to climb<br />
the crime-ladder – as the<br />
youngsters feel mistreated by<br />
the official system, and feel that<br />
the only option is to immerse<br />
themselves in crime. Considering<br />
this, within the framework of the<br />
project related to the Convention<br />
on the Rights of the Child (see<br />
text I), UNV has provided<br />
support to youngsters in trouble<br />
with the law.<br />
In parallel, in El Salvador and in<br />
other Central American countries,<br />
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> go to detention<br />
centers and meet with hardened<br />
teenage criminals who have<br />
been denied their childhood.<br />
They bring with them their<br />
UNV can also use the ‘mirror volunteer’ approach to enhance<br />
the effectiveness of the curative actions. This means using<br />
ex-street children as UN <strong>Volunteers</strong>. As highlighted before, this<br />
approach provides a unique added value that can only be<br />
achieved through the personal interaction between people<br />
who have experienced the same problem or need.<br />
UNV is currently implementing a Child-friendly Cities initiative in<br />
Port Harcourt, Nigeria (presented in text J). It also implemented<br />
a similar activity in the Palestine. In addition, UNV has supported<br />
street children through other types of projects. Text I provides<br />
examples from Latin America.<br />
Violence and crime<br />
High rates of violence already constitute a crucial problem in<br />
many urban areas in developing countries, and the problem is<br />
continuously spreading to other cities and towns. The specific<br />
condition of urban violence is <strong>associated</strong> with urban features<br />
such as:<br />
– Intra-urban differentials: cities and towns are relatively small<br />
geographical areas, which concentrate high disparities in<br />
income and standard of living. There is a growing body of<br />
research which shows how the day-to-day/constant cognitive<br />
perception of the poor as worse-off than other members of<br />
society generate behaviour patters which lead to violence<br />
and crime (see, for instance, Wilkinson 1996 for a review).<br />
– Lack of social-cultural/family bonds: this already noted<br />
problem also has an effect on violence and crime (e.g.<br />
adolescents and young adults who grow up without proper<br />
family and communitarian support).<br />
– Anonymity and lack of social control: the fact that everyone<br />
virtually knows everyone else in a given rural village constitutes<br />
a deterrent to violent and criminal behaviour, as the<br />
culprit is easily identifiable. This is not the case in urban<br />
settlements, due to their much larger populations.<br />
– Economic vulnerability: as noted before, the urban poor are<br />
often extremely vulnerable to high prices and changes in<br />
income; and they do not have the option to fall back to an<br />
agrarian support system. Therefore, even when a given lowincome<br />
individual (or group) is not affected by the above
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
Thematic view and illustrations<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
Thematic view and illustrations<br />
Page 50<br />
Page 51<br />
factors, she/he (they) may resort to crime and violence to<br />
make a living.<br />
In order to be effective, projects which address the problems<br />
of urban violence and crime should include preventive measures<br />
at the community level. This is where/how social problems may<br />
be prevented, through bottom-up changes in people’s attitudes<br />
and responses – which is much more effective than top-down<br />
repression. This is exactly where UNV’s strength lies (i.e. outreach/grassroots<br />
work), and therefore UNV’s intervention in<br />
this area may make a considerable impact.<br />
UNV’s approach is to work with grassroots organisations to<br />
design preventive activities such as support to groups at risk<br />
of becoming criminals (children and adolescents in especially<br />
difficult circumstances); organisation of neighbourhood watch<br />
schemes (non-violent; community-based deterrents to violence);<br />
community/social reinsertion of minor offenders (before they<br />
escalate the crime-ladder); income-generation alternatives to<br />
criminal practices. Again, the ‘mirror volunteer’ approach (excriminals<br />
as UN <strong>Volunteers</strong>) is highly valuable. Text J provides<br />
some illustrations of UNV’s activities in Central America.<br />
Drug-abuse<br />
Cities and towns concentrate the majority of drug-related<br />
problems in developing countries, and the connection with<br />
urbanisation derives from the following:<br />
– Behavioural pre-conditions for drug-taking in sizeable shares<br />
of the urban population due to lack of socio-cultural/family<br />
bonds and livelihood pressures (noted before);<br />
– Large supply of drugs induced by the existence of concentration<br />
of people and therefore of large potential<br />
markets – broader/easier access to drug supply;<br />
– Anonymity and lack of social control – which makes things<br />
easier both for the drug dealers and takers.<br />
UNV has joint activities with UNDCP (<strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Drug<br />
Control Programme) in different countries and regions (East<br />
Africa, Southeast Asia). Text K below illustrates a recently<br />
completed project in the Caribbean.<br />
Actions which are crucial and at the same time match UNV’s<br />
message to the affected adolescents<br />
and help them come to<br />
grips with the emptiness and<br />
despair caused by neglect.<br />
K --------------------------------------------<br />
Volunteer support to reduction<br />
of drug consumption in the<br />
Caribbean<br />
-----------------------------------------------<br />
This project was conceptualised<br />
in the context of the Barbados<br />
Plan of Action, adopted at the<br />
Regional Meeting on Drug<br />
Control Co-operation and Coordination<br />
in the Caribbean,<br />
Barbados, 1996. The Plan<br />
comprised 87 recommendations<br />
in six thematic areas. UNV’s<br />
project with UNDCP concentrated<br />
on drug demand reduction<br />
with national and international<br />
partners. This choice of focus<br />
was well in keeping with UNV’s<br />
mandate, and was in tune with<br />
a change in international atti-<br />
tudes towards the drugs issue,<br />
as reflected in the resolutions of<br />
a special session of the UN<br />
General Assembly held 8–10<br />
June 1998, devoted to the fight<br />
against illicit drugs. The<br />
Session developed a forwardlooking<br />
strategy for the 21st<br />
Century. It gave high priority to<br />
‘drug demand reduction’, and<br />
recognised the significance of<br />
the need to address fundamental<br />
issues such as poverty, community<br />
participation, advocacy.<br />
In St. Vincent, for example, the<br />
project provided a UN Volunteer<br />
counsellor to assist an NGO<br />
(Marion House) in its role as the<br />
main organisation in the country<br />
involved in drug demand reduction<br />
and rehabilitation work. This<br />
UN Volunteer has provided<br />
support to prevention work with<br />
children and the youth at Marion<br />
House, counselling for the<br />
mentally ill at a psychiatric<br />
hospital and rehabilitation work<br />
with prisoners. The project also<br />
included other components in<br />
Barbados, Dominican Republic<br />
and Trinidad and Tobago.<br />
L --------------------------------------------<br />
Volunteer support to sex<br />
workers in Madagascar<br />
-----------------------------------------------<br />
The government of Madagascar<br />
decided to embark on a crusade<br />
to improve the living standards<br />
of women. The issues were<br />
poverty alleviation, HIV-AIDS as<br />
well as other sexually transmitted<br />
diseases (STD). UNV has<br />
comparative advantages include:<br />
– Prevention: direct, long-term work with families and<br />
communities (awareness raising, strengthening of social<br />
and family cohesion, etc) and with individuals at risk.<br />
– Rehabilitation of drug users: again, direct long-term work –<br />
this time with the drug users themselves – is utterly necessary<br />
(e.g. psychologists, councillors, social assistants). It is also<br />
worth re-emphasising the significance of the solidarity<br />
transmitted via voluntary work to help heal this traumatised<br />
group of individuals. The use of mirror volunteers (ex-drug<br />
addicts) can also be highly effective.<br />
Prostitution<br />
Although many of those who face this problem do not come<br />
from cities or towns (i.e. they are amongst the rural poor), the<br />
setting of prostitution is often urban. Because of the socially<br />
disreputable character of this practice, the anonymity and lack<br />
of social control prevalent in urban areas is very convenient, for<br />
both prostitutes and clients. Cities and towns also have larger<br />
potential markets.<br />
Preventive actions need to be closely <strong>associated</strong> with<br />
programmes to combat poverty (both in urban and rural areas).
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
Thematic view and illustrations<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
Thematic view and illustrations<br />
Page 52<br />
Page 53<br />
They require direct long-term work with families and communities,<br />
therefore would benefit from UNV’s specific attributes.<br />
Curative actions with prostitutes also need to be face-to-face,<br />
labour intensive. Text L shows an example of such curative<br />
work in Madagascar. Again, the transmission of solidarity via<br />
voluntary work and the use of mirror volunteers (ex-prostitutes)<br />
can also add value.<br />
Health conditions<br />
There are specific health conditions <strong>associated</strong> with urban<br />
areas. Firstly, many infectious diseases, incidence of intoxication<br />
and accidents derive directly from physical features of<br />
the urban milieu alone or in association with poverty – e.g. overcrowding,<br />
particular sources of pollution, heavy traffic, lack of<br />
proper drainage systems, housing built in hazardous areas.<br />
Further health conditions derive from psycho-social behaviours<br />
<strong>associated</strong> with urban sources of stress. Several mental health<br />
conditions constitute examples (e.g. Harpham and Blue, 1995).<br />
The health problems of children derived from lack of proper<br />
care as a result of lack/loss of socio-cultural bonds constitute<br />
another illustration (Werna et al. 1999). Infectious diseases<br />
such as HIV-AIDS are also <strong>associated</strong> with lifestyles/behaviours<br />
that are more prevalent in urban areas (e.g. hypodermic use of<br />
drugs, prostitution, and multiple sexual partners).<br />
The improvement of health conditions <strong>associated</strong> with the<br />
physical features of urban areas requires direct action in such<br />
a milieu. This will be presented later on (section on ‘the<br />
physical domain’). In their turn, preventive actions for health<br />
conditions <strong>associated</strong> with behaviour require direct, long-term<br />
work with individuals, families and communities, therefore<br />
benefiting from UNV’s specific attributes noted in previous<br />
items. Curative actions also include face-to-face, labour intensive<br />
work (e.g. treatment of mental patients). Again, solidarity<br />
transmitted via voluntary work adds significant value to the<br />
joined in the crusade under the<br />
umbrella of ILO and UNFPA. A<br />
UN Volunteer nurse has<br />
provided training and education<br />
for the prevention of HIV-<br />
AIDS/STD and pregnancy. Of<br />
equal importance, UNV’s involvement<br />
also tries to give prostitutes<br />
an income-generation alternative,<br />
by providing training skills in<br />
various areas that would allow<br />
them to escape poverty and<br />
therefore avoid resorting to<br />
prostitution as a means to<br />
obtaining an earning.<br />
M --------------------------------------------<br />
‘Mirror volunteers’: people living<br />
with HIV-AIDS in Africa and the<br />
Caribbean<br />
-----------------------------------------------<br />
UNV has lent much-needed<br />
support for HIV/AIDS-stricken<br />
communities in African and<br />
Caribbean countries. Because<br />
most of the UN <strong>Volunteers</strong><br />
come from these regions, and<br />
some are themselves infected<br />
with the HIV virus, they<br />
understand what is needed and<br />
can deliver culturally sensitive<br />
assistance at the local level.<br />
One of the goals is to limit the<br />
spread of the disease by<br />
dissemination of information. In<br />
this respect, awareness<br />
campaigns are used to reach<br />
out to target groups through<br />
peer educators, especially<br />
working with young population.<br />
Second, UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> help<br />
create networks and support<br />
groups that can provide<br />
The fight against illiteracy in urban areas requires specific<br />
technical solutions. Firstly, the teaching programmes of elemencounselling,<br />
food and homebased<br />
care for those who are<br />
suffering. Third, they help survivors<br />
whose resources have been<br />
depleted by the loss of a family<br />
member. In some places, UN<br />
<strong>Volunteers</strong> have helped establish<br />
small chicken and pig farms,<br />
procured seeds and tools for<br />
vegetable gardens, etc. In other<br />
communities, UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> are<br />
teaching carpentry skills to<br />
orphans, so that they can begin<br />
to earn a living.<br />
This project involving UN<br />
<strong>Volunteers</strong> living with AIDS has<br />
targeted Malawi, Zambia,<br />
Jamaica, Dominican Republic,<br />
Cuba, Trinidad and Tobago,<br />
Haiti and Guyana. Similar<br />
initiatives will soon expand to<br />
Cambodia, India and French<br />
speaking African countries.<br />
N --------------------------------------------<br />
‘Mirror volunteers’: the disabled<br />
in Phnom Pen, Cambodia<br />
-----------------------------------------------<br />
One in every 250 Cambodians<br />
has lost a limb to a landmine;<br />
countless others have been<br />
disabled by malnutrition and<br />
disease. Together they constitute<br />
one of the most economically<br />
deprived and socially isolated<br />
groups in the country. From her<br />
wheelchair, one energetic UN<br />
Volunteer has been a dynamic<br />
force behind the transformation<br />
of an abandoned building in<br />
Phnom Penh into a place where<br />
the disabled can get back to<br />
work, in spite of physical<br />
treatment of traumatised people (e.g. mental health patients,<br />
HIV-AIDS patients.).<br />
In addition, the existence of a correlation between social<br />
cohesion and health (explained in the first part of this publication),<br />
demonstrates further contributions of volunteerism<br />
to health – i.e. via its role in supporting the establishment or<br />
reinforcement of networks of social cohesion.<br />
Text M below depicts one project, which addresses a serious<br />
health problem that affects urban areas, i.e. HIV-AIDS. This<br />
project includes the use of mirror volunteers.<br />
Social Exclusion<br />
There are many excluded people living in cities and towns in<br />
developing countries, i.e. the poor in general, or specific groups<br />
such as the disabled, informal sector workers, street children,<br />
HIV-AIDS patients, among others.<br />
One way to support the excluded population is through projects<br />
which address structural causes of the problem such as illiteracy.<br />
Although illiteracy is not specifically urban, it has specific and<br />
harmful effects in urban areas. To say the least, the access of<br />
the rural poor to basic needs is less dependent on one’s ability<br />
to read and write – especially in subsistence societies. However,<br />
it is very difficult and sometimes even impossible for<br />
illiterate people to live in urban areas, because of the complexity<br />
of urban production and consumption patterns.
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
Thematic view and illustrations<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
Thematic view and illustrations<br />
Page 54<br />
Page 55<br />
tary education often focus on aspects of the daily life of the<br />
students – therefore preparing them to deal with such aspects<br />
better. Consequently, there should be an urban specificity in<br />
such programmes. Secondly, the teaching programmes also<br />
have to be adequate themselves to address the requirements<br />
of the time- and space-compressed pace of urban living.<br />
As noted earlier in this publication, one of the main areas of<br />
activity which match UNV’s attributes is capacity-building (thus<br />
including teaching), which in turn constitutes the core activity<br />
of educational programmes. Similar to the case of the other<br />
issues, UNV’s intervention can be either direct with the target<br />
beneficiaries or/and through local institutions.<br />
Other projects which address the causes of the problem include<br />
confidence building, the generation of income to the excluded<br />
group, and awareness-raising campaigns to change the discriminatory<br />
perception about specific groups by the population<br />
in general .<br />
The aforementioned types of project can be implemented on<br />
their own or together with initiatives tailor-made to specific<br />
groups. Previous side text have included examples with street<br />
children, HIV-AIDS patients and prostitutes. Text N illustrates<br />
a case with the disabled. The next section of this publication<br />
contains an illustration focusing on the informal sector.<br />
4.3. The economic domain<br />
Urban settlements include specific types of economic activities.<br />
Therefore, support to such activities requires particular technical<br />
solutions. At the same time that the urban economy requires<br />
macro-level support and policies of integration with the national<br />
and international systems, it also requires intervention at the<br />
grassroots. For instance, the urban poor need support in at<br />
least three main areas: processes of production, regulatory<br />
framework, and credit.<br />
Processes of production<br />
Some industrialized countries are witnessing a certain level of<br />
economic fusion (and therefore lack of differentiation) between<br />
urban and rural areas - e.g. people based in the rural areas but<br />
providing services in cities (telecommuting), factories moving to<br />
challenges. With its lively café,<br />
arts and crafts shop and traditional<br />
massage services offered<br />
by blind professionals, the<br />
National Centre for Disabled<br />
Persons has become a popular<br />
tourist destination. It is also a<br />
place where the disabled can<br />
reclaim their lives, through training<br />
and employment opportunities<br />
and by belonging fully to a<br />
community.<br />
O --------------------------------------------<br />
Support to urban enterprises in<br />
developing countries through<br />
corporate volunteerism<br />
-----------------------------------------------<br />
Corporate volunteerism is a<br />
growing trend in the private<br />
sector. It constitutes a type of<br />
activity directly linked to UNV’s<br />
mandate and to its objective of<br />
promoting volunteerism. So far,<br />
corporate volunteerism has<br />
progressed mostly in companies<br />
based in industrialised countries<br />
(although a limited number of<br />
cases in developing countries<br />
also exist). Corporate volunteerism<br />
has focused mainly on<br />
employees working with nearby<br />
communities. At the same time,<br />
one of the specialisms of UNV<br />
is to administer individuals or<br />
teams of volunteer experts<br />
working in outreach projects.<br />
UNV provides the travel arrangements,<br />
and supports the experts<br />
in the countries where they<br />
would work. Therefore, UNV’s<br />
strategy for partnership in the<br />
field of corporate volunteerism<br />
is to offer its added value to<br />
expand the current employeecommunity<br />
relations beyond the<br />
local realm:<br />
- To support companies from<br />
industrialised countries to move<br />
beyond projects in their home<br />
countries – hence to send their<br />
employees for projects in<br />
developing countries.<br />
- To support companies from<br />
developing countries to move<br />
beyond local projects – hence<br />
to send their employees for<br />
projects in outreach areas in<br />
the country and in other<br />
countries.<br />
This initiative includes the<br />
benefits of ‘mirror volunteers’ –<br />
the countryside, etc. However, in most of the developing world<br />
(and indeed in many other parts of the industrialized world)<br />
there is still a sharp division between urban and rural processes<br />
of production. Cities concentrate services and/or industrial<br />
production; therefore, the skills required for the urban economy<br />
are specific.<br />
Technical assistance and capacity building are fundamental<br />
in fostering the urban processes of production in developing<br />
countries: in particular to help the poor establish and develop<br />
a productive niche in the urban economy. As already noted in<br />
this paper, UNV has comparative advantages for carrying out<br />
such activities. Besides the fact that these activities are based<br />
on labour-intensive, extensive work, they also benefit from other<br />
attributes of UNV such as flexibility, broad scope of action and<br />
speed of response. These attributes are especially important in<br />
addressing the fast pace and constant shifts and challenges of<br />
the urban economy (e.g. abrupt changes in demand). UNV<br />
administers a volunteer programme (UNISTAR) through which<br />
international executives and technical experts offer their expertise<br />
in developing countries and promote corporate volunteerism<br />
worldwide (see text O).<br />
Finally, the correlation between social cohesion and economic<br />
development (explained before) demonstrate further contributions<br />
of volunteerism in the economic realm – i.e. via its role in<br />
building or strengthening social cohesion.
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
Thematic view and illustrations<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
Thematic view and illustrations<br />
Page 56<br />
Page 57<br />
Regulatory framework<br />
Many units of production in developing countries are part of<br />
the informal sector, which means that such firms operate<br />
outside the regulatory framework of the government. There is<br />
ample evidence that the urban informal sector plays a very<br />
important role in the economy of developing countries. It has<br />
also had a particular impact on the alleviation of urban poverty.<br />
The advantages of this sector to the poor and less skilled<br />
producers include less or no need for paperwork, for formal<br />
training and for initial capital (ease of entry). The proportion<br />
of the labour force engaged in urban informal production in<br />
developing countries ranges from 20 to 70 percent. As for<br />
consumption, many goods supplied by the informal sector would<br />
otherwise not be accessible to poor people – because formal/<br />
larger-scale firms lack the interest to cater for them or because<br />
their prices are higher (e.g. UNDP, 1991; Werna, 1997).<br />
Although the informal sector is not exclusive to urban areas, it<br />
has particular features in such areas, which therefore require<br />
specific technical answers. Firstly, each process of production<br />
has specific regulatory aspects - and, as noted before, there<br />
are processes of production which are specific to urban areas.<br />
Secondly, because informal producers operate outside government<br />
control, they are susceptible to coercion, which may<br />
disrupt their business. Informal producers in rural areas often<br />
escape control, because they work in a subsistence economy<br />
(which needs no economic regulation), and live in isolation or<br />
in remote regions. Urban informal producers, in their turn, are<br />
directly exposed to coercion on a daily basis. They work faceto-face<br />
with the police and with sectors of the population who<br />
are unhappy with their presence for different reasons (e.g.<br />
informal producers represent unfair competition vis-à-vis formal<br />
producers; they overcrowd the streets; they cater mainly for<br />
the poor and therefore ‘attract poverty’).<br />
Although there has been growing recognition of the need to<br />
support the informal sector, in many countries informal producers<br />
are still harassed and even prevented from working. The solui.e.<br />
private sector employees<br />
supporting their counterparts<br />
in other countries. The initiative<br />
targets both urban- and rural<br />
based enterprises alike.<br />
P --------------------------------------------<br />
Volunteer support to the<br />
informal sector in Zanzibar,<br />
Tanzania<br />
-----------------------------------------------<br />
UNVs’ initiative to combat<br />
poverty among women in<br />
Zanzibar, Tanzania takes the<br />
form of entrepreneurial training.<br />
A UN Volunteer gave training to<br />
business extension workers,<br />
helped women organise<br />
themselves into groups to<br />
exchange problems and<br />
solutions, and conducted a<br />
market survey of microbusiness<br />
opportunities. She also<br />
facilitated the groups in<br />
acquiring legal status and<br />
access to formal banking<br />
services.<br />
Q --------------------------------------------<br />
Volunteer support to the urban<br />
economy in Liberia through<br />
micro-credit schemes<br />
-----------------------------------------------<br />
UNV is actively involved in<br />
Liberia in the UNDP/UNV-<br />
Trickle UP collaboration Project<br />
‘Promotion and Support for<br />
Income Generating Activities<br />
Among Vulnerable Groups In<br />
Liberia’. This tripartite initiative<br />
started in 1995 with UNV as<br />
the executing agency. The project<br />
follows the Trickle UP grants<br />
approach and beneficiaries are<br />
the most vulnerable groups<br />
such as ex-militants, single<br />
headed female households and<br />
youths disabled during the<br />
internal conflict. The project<br />
targets the poorest 30% of the<br />
population providing them a<br />
grant of US $100, paid in two<br />
installments of US $50. The<br />
tion is definitely not to evict informal producers from cities and<br />
towns and to prevent them from carrying out their business.<br />
This would only increase the ranks of the unemployed, with its<br />
multiplier effects (poverty, violence, etc.). Moreover, considering<br />
that the informal sector is the supplier of particular services/<br />
goods for the urban poor, suppression of informal production<br />
would also exacerbate the needs of this part of the population.<br />
Solutions to the problems of the informal sector require intense<br />
negotiations between the different urban stakeholders (e.g.<br />
local authorities, representatives of the formal private sector,<br />
the informal producers). Such negotiations fall within the broad<br />
framework of ‘urban governance’, already analysed in this paper.<br />
Consequently, this shows the role of UNV as mediators at least<br />
in the initial stages of the process. In addition, the process of<br />
gradual ‘formalisation’ of informal producers requires labourintensive<br />
training on issues such as paperwork and other<br />
bureaucratic procedures.<br />
Finance<br />
The urban economy is often more monetarized than its rural<br />
counterpart, therefore exposing urban producers to a greater<br />
need for credit. At the same time, urban financial schemes also<br />
entail qualitative changes. To give a well-known example: the<br />
successful experience in micro-financing of the Grameen Bank<br />
started in Bangladesh and is being replicated in many countries<br />
worldwide. This experience has focused mainly in rural areas,<br />
and its success is strongly based on the social and solidarity<br />
bonds between community members (which prevent each<br />
member from defaulting on payment). However, as emphasised<br />
throughout this paper, such social/solidarity bonds in urban<br />
areas are often much weaker. Consequently, the counterpart<br />
urban micro-finance schemes have to be qualitatively different:<br />
they have either to build/strengthen such bonds, or to use an<br />
alternative approach, which does not rely on them. Either way,<br />
such equivalent schemes can take advantage of UNV’s attributes,<br />
as they need day-to-day intensive work directly with local<br />
communities. Text Q below provides the illustration of a project<br />
in Liberia.
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
Thematic view and illustrations<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
Thematic view and illustrations<br />
Page 58<br />
Page 59<br />
project was implemented in the<br />
city of Monrovia and surrounding<br />
areas and later expanded to<br />
other localities in the country.<br />
Through businesses that have<br />
been established by grants provided<br />
by the project, it has provided<br />
sustainable livelihood for<br />
approximately 9,132 beneficiaries<br />
of the program and their families.<br />
They have been able to provide<br />
food security, healthcare and<br />
education for their families.<br />
Fifteen NGOs participated in<br />
the final phase.<br />
The beneficiaries have demonstrated<br />
good business acumen and<br />
innovations in their trade. One<br />
innovative person started with<br />
selling dry goods but quickly<br />
moved to textile printing. Another<br />
young entrepreneur<br />
started a soap making business,<br />
now he sells to bulk buyers.<br />
A further very good example of<br />
working with little means is a<br />
cutlery-making workshop. This<br />
skilled worker runs a pottery<br />
business. He makes moulds out<br />
of sand or clay for household<br />
utensils and pours melted metal<br />
recovered from used cans and<br />
bottles in that mould. Finally he<br />
scours the rough edges of the<br />
spoons and pans and sells them.<br />
This business also has an environmental<br />
component, as it recycles<br />
waste by utilizing scrap metal<br />
found in the streets as raw<br />
material for their products.<br />
R --------------------------------------------<br />
Volunteer support to housing<br />
provision and inner city<br />
renovation – cases from<br />
Namibia and Poland<br />
-----------------------------------------------<br />
A small team of UN <strong>Volunteers</strong><br />
– an urban planner, a community<br />
worker and a building<br />
engineer – worked with<br />
Namibia’s Ministry of Local<br />
Government and Housing,<br />
the National Housing Enterprise<br />
and local authorities. They<br />
analysed constraints in housing<br />
delivery, helped prepare a<br />
national shelter strategy, organised<br />
implementation of self-help<br />
housing at community level,<br />
surveyed lands and allocated<br />
plots, and gave training in lowcost<br />
building. This Namibia Build<br />
Together programme won the<br />
Best Practices Award at the<br />
1995 Dubai International Conference<br />
on Best Practices in<br />
Improving the Living Environment.<br />
Another award-winning UNVassisted<br />
initiative is the<br />
Renovation Strategy for the<br />
Inner City Area of Szczecin in<br />
Poland. Wide public consultation,<br />
together with balanced application<br />
of social, environmental and<br />
commercial criteria, ensures<br />
investment is attracted while<br />
existing housing is upgraded,<br />
additional accommodation<br />
provided and an architecturally<br />
historic area is preserved.<br />
4.4. The physical domain<br />
This domain is the ‘hardcore’ of urban development, and includes<br />
housing and the provision of physical infrastructure and<br />
engineering-related urban services, such as: transport, water,<br />
sewerage, drainage, garbage collection, roads, etc.<br />
The urban poor often live in neighbourhoods – such as shanty<br />
areas, squatter settlements and slums - which are substantially<br />
different from the central areas of cities, and therefore require a<br />
specific type of solution for their problems. In a previous section,<br />
this paper analysed the community-based approach in urban<br />
development, and highlighted the role of mutual, voluntary and<br />
self-help processes throughout the developing world. This<br />
certainly encompasses the elements of the physical domain, as<br />
many low-income urban settlements are literally built entirely, or<br />
at least with a large amount of input, from its own residents.<br />
Consequently, there is a need to support grassroots communities<br />
to carry out these tasks, therefore making the most of<br />
UNV’s specific abilities to work with grassroots communities<br />
Depending on the circumstances, housing and the other physical<br />
elements of urban development are provided by other urban<br />
agents. In such cases, UNV may also be of value, through the<br />
types of support that it can provide to local authorities, NGOs<br />
and to the private sector, as described elsewhere in this<br />
publication.<br />
UNV has acted widely in the physical domain, e.g. in housing<br />
and infrastructure provision and rehabilitation in different<br />
countries and regions (see text R and text S below for some<br />
examples).<br />
In addition to the fact that the physical domain of urban development<br />
includes primary human needs (such as housing and<br />
water), it acquires further importance due to the frequent<br />
incidence of natural disasters in several developing countries.<br />
Such disasters mean death or serious injury for those who<br />
do not have the proper physical protection. The assistance<br />
provided by governments, private agencies (both for-profit and<br />
not-for-profit) as well as by the international community has<br />
been limited. At the same time, there is a vast array of simple<br />
and effective solutions within the reach of low-income communities,<br />
which could prevent many disasters. Therefore, it is
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
Thematic view and illustrations<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
Thematic view and illustrations<br />
Page 60<br />
Page 61<br />
imperative to work directly with low-income communities, again<br />
highlighting the UNV’s role in such a context. In the case of<br />
mitigation of disasters, speed of response is also a crucial<br />
attribute – let alone the value of solidarity transmitted via<br />
voluntary work to help heal the traumatised group of individuals<br />
affected by a given calamity. An example of a UNV project<br />
focusing on post-disaster reconstruction – and future mitigation<br />
– is the one which entails the setting up of a university<br />
volunteer scheme in Nicaragua, presented in text G. Another<br />
similar example is a project in Guatemala, with the University of<br />
San Carlos, which focuses on disaster prevention.<br />
S --------------------------------------------<br />
Volunteer support to urban<br />
environment improvement –<br />
cases from the Philippines,<br />
Indonesia, Fiji and Botswana<br />
-----------------------------------------------<br />
UNV and the NGO Megacities<br />
enabled National UN <strong>Volunteers</strong><br />
and local volunteers in the<br />
Philippines to share with other<br />
urban poor communities of<br />
Metro Manila the waste management<br />
techniques adopted by<br />
KALAHIG, the 400-member<br />
Payatas Association of Waste<br />
Pickers. Included was a visit to<br />
Egypt in which KALAHIG garbage<br />
industry workers compared<br />
notes with Cairo’s Zabbaleen<br />
scavengers and their<br />
Environmental Development<br />
Programme. The visit galvanised<br />
research, innovation transfer,<br />
social marketing and above all,<br />
an enterprise approach.<br />
In Cipinang Besar, Jakarta,<br />
Indonesia, a UN Volunteer<br />
suggested composting the biodegradable<br />
rubbish from the<br />
market and public housing. A<br />
shed was built from junkyard<br />
scrap steel and soon three tons<br />
of compost was being produced<br />
each month. Unusually for<br />
Jakarta, the scheme is run by<br />
the community itself, providing<br />
work for twelve employees and<br />
yielding income from sales to<br />
market gardens, shrimp ponds<br />
and golf courses.<br />
International and National UN<br />
<strong>Volunteers</strong> in Fiji assisted the<br />
NGO SPACHEE (South Pacific<br />
Action Committee for Human<br />
Ecology) with environmental<br />
education, primary health care<br />
strategies, mobilising local<br />
volunteer contributions and<br />
networking. With funding from<br />
the <strong>United</strong> Kingdom Government,<br />
the pilot project tested participatory<br />
approaches to using<br />
community-level National UN<br />
<strong>Volunteers</strong> in primary environmental<br />
care in low-income<br />
urban contexts.<br />
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> in Botswana had<br />
schoolchildren conduct baseline<br />
surveys, which exposed poor<br />
environmental practices in<br />
some of the country’s settlements.<br />
A year’s promotional<br />
work followed, through the<br />
Health Ministry’s Family Welfare<br />
Educators, and handbooks<br />
were published in Setswana.<br />
The result was the contractedout<br />
construction of hundreds of<br />
latrines within the National<br />
T --------------------------------------------<br />
Cultural Heritage <strong>Volunteers</strong>:<br />
cases from Nepal and<br />
Uzbekistan<br />
-----------------------------------------------<br />
UNV has joined UNESCO and<br />
the Co-ordinating Committee<br />
on International Voluntary<br />
Service to respond to the<br />
World Commission on Culture<br />
and Development’s call for an<br />
enhanced programme of<br />
Cultural Heritage <strong>Volunteers</strong>.<br />
This joint on-going project aims<br />
to preserve or restore monu-<br />
4.5. The cultural domain<br />
The relationship between volunteerism and cultural heritage<br />
was elaborated in the first part of this paper. It explains UNV’s<br />
attention to this aspect of urban development. In addition to<br />
supporting such a relationship as a whole, UNV has specific<br />
attributes to reinforce the cultural foundations of communities,<br />
and to strengthen their bonds with the surrounding milieu. This<br />
is carried out by community motivators and instructors who<br />
raise the awareness and understanding of the communities<br />
about: (i) their cultural foundations, (ii) the importance of<br />
respecting such foundations, (iii) the relationship between the<br />
built milieu (i.e. the very neighbourhoods where they live) and<br />
culture, and (iv) the importance of preserving the built milieu.
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
Thematic view and illustrations<br />
PART II –<br />
THE UNITED NATIONS VOLUNTEERS PROGRAMME<br />
Thematic view and illustrations<br />
Page 62<br />
Page 63<br />
UNV has included the above approach in a number of projects.<br />
One example is the project with the university volunteer scheme<br />
in Nicaragua, presented before, which includes not only a focus<br />
on physical reconstruction, but also on the recuperation of the<br />
cultural heritage of the settlements. UNV also has a project<br />
with UNESCO, entitled Cultural Heritage <strong>Volunteers</strong>, which<br />
include the protection of heritage sites in Palestine, Nepal,<br />
Uzbekistan, Guatemala and India (see text T).<br />
ments and support activities to<br />
safeguard cultural heritage in<br />
other ways. The countries<br />
included in this project are<br />
Guatemala, India, Nepal,<br />
Palestine and Uzbekistan. This<br />
text includes illustrations from<br />
two of these countries.<br />
In Nepal, UNV’s involvement is<br />
part of an overall safeguarding<br />
campaign for Kathmandu Valley.<br />
The project covers seven sites<br />
with a total of 132 buildings<br />
that are in urgent need of<br />
attention. The intention is to<br />
restore the buildings and make<br />
them suitably attractive for<br />
tourism. The project’s seven<br />
sites are: Durbar Square at<br />
Bhaktapur, Durbar Square at<br />
Patan, Pashupati, Durbar<br />
Square at Bhadgaon,<br />
Changunaraian, Swayambhu<br />
and Bodanath.<br />
The specific restoration work<br />
carried out is architectural in<br />
nature, and in most cases, it<br />
includes roof repair and<br />
structural reinforcement. This<br />
has become necessary because<br />
of damage caused by earthquakes<br />
as well as uncontrolled<br />
urbanisation and demographic<br />
growth. UNV’s work in helping<br />
the local population has already<br />
started with the restoration and<br />
repair of dilapidated traditional<br />
wells and water stone spouts.<br />
Community participation,<br />
especially of women and youth,<br />
was encouraged in these<br />
restoration activities. With the<br />
help of an awareness programme<br />
and lectures, the local people<br />
began to appreciate the quality<br />
of ground water, hygiene and<br />
the importance of the use and<br />
future maintenance of the stone<br />
spouts. Other project activities<br />
likewise feature community<br />
participation activities.<br />
In Uzbekistan, the proposal has<br />
been conceived as a pilot<br />
project to provide on-the-job<br />
training to Uzbek architects in<br />
the use of modern restoration<br />
and conservation technology.<br />
The project targets sites in<br />
Shah-I-Zindah Mausoleum in<br />
Samarkand, Ismanid<br />
Mausoleum and the Buyan Kuli<br />
Khan Madrassa in Buhkara.<br />
4.6. An integrated approach<br />
As noted at the beginning of this section, urban development is<br />
a complex and multi-sectoral field. While this section divided it<br />
into five broad domains (for the sake of simplifying the presentation),<br />
it should also be noted that many of the projects<br />
presented above in fact cut across more than one domain and<br />
through different sectors of urban development. For example,<br />
the project in Port Harcourt develops a governance process<br />
while bringing concrete improvements for the children; one of<br />
the activities in Monrovia mixes income generation with garbage<br />
recycling; the project in Nicaragua mixes post-disaster reconstruction<br />
with the recuperation of cultural heritage; to mention<br />
just a few cases.<br />
The multisectoral character of urban development actually<br />
highlights a significant advantage of UNV’s contribution as a<br />
partner in development assistance. UNV’s framework of action<br />
includes volunteerism in the different sectors. Therefore, UNV<br />
is able to catalyse the synergies and complementarity between<br />
the volunteer contributions in the different sectors of the
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
CONCLUSION<br />
Page 64<br />
Page 65<br />
This paper has shown the importance of volunteerism in the<br />
development of human settlements as well as the urban agenda<br />
of UNV, noting the comparative advantages and the ability of<br />
this agency to add value. In his evaluation of a set of UNV<br />
projects, Cohen (2000: 3) noted that this agency has the<br />
distinctiveness of… ‘possessing the leverage of being located<br />
within the UN system but in many ways operating with the<br />
flexibility of an NGO’. This is a simple encapsulation of how<br />
UNV differs from other UN agencies, as well as from non-UN<br />
agencies working at the grassroots.<br />
In specific relation to work at the urban grassroots, a quotation<br />
from research conducted by UNRISD provides a good summary<br />
of its importance, as well as of the role of UNV in particular:<br />
‘The main conclusion of this study is that UNV has an important<br />
role to play in urban grassroots development, or more correctly,<br />
in fostering social cohesion and development in cities and<br />
towns. The research has confirmed earlier findings of UNV’s<br />
action research in urban communities showing that a rapidly<br />
integrating global economy is disproportionately disadvantaging<br />
vulnerable and marginalized groups, many of whom are either<br />
already in cities or on their way. Moreover, while these global<br />
forces may instigate collective action at certain points, in the<br />
long run they erode the capacity of community and volunteer<br />
organisations to respond effectively to the negative impacts’.<br />
(Westendorff, 1999: 16.)<br />
but also shortly before ‘Istanbul + 5’ (in June 2001) which will<br />
review global achievements in urban development since the<br />
‘Istanbul’ Conference of 1996 and also discuss future actions.<br />
Therefore IYV 2001 and Istanbul + 5 together constitute an<br />
excellent opportunity to discuss ways of consolidating and<br />
strengthening UNV’s value and contribution as a partner in the<br />
international effort to combat urban problems in the developing<br />
and transitional countries.<br />
While volunteerism is fundamental in human settlements, it is<br />
still overlooked as a resource. It is important, therefore, to discuss<br />
ways to expand the role of volunteerism in urban development.<br />
Cities are shaped by the sum of the innumerable daily decisions,<br />
attitudes and behaviours of individuals and groups. Many of the<br />
maladies that currently plague urban areas could be ameliorated<br />
or even abolished if such decisions, attitudes and behaviours<br />
were impregnated with a greater degree of solidarity.<br />
Volunteerism can be instrumental, among other things, to help<br />
develop norms of solidarity and reciprocity, which are essential<br />
to stable communities. Volunteerism can build the foundations<br />
for the construction of caring cities.<br />
This approach is important in order to;<br />
‘… overcome the rather instrumental use of concepts such as<br />
partnership, collaboration and participation evident in many<br />
development programmes and projects. It will also highlight the<br />
personal, cultural and locally specific contributions to social<br />
development. These are necessary antidotes to the homogenised<br />
development formulas now in vogue, which continue to leave<br />
the majority in deep poverty’. (Westendorff, 1999: 16.)<br />
UNV’s current urban agenda has been the result of thirty years<br />
of experience and learning. As noted in the introduction of this<br />
paper, it has evolved from scattered activities to systemic<br />
programming, culminating with the choice of urban development<br />
as one of the agency’s priorities. This publication has come out<br />
not only during the International Year of the Volunteer (IYV 2001)
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
Volunteering in Urban Development and the role of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Volunteer Programme<br />
REFERENCES<br />
Page 66<br />
Page 67<br />
Argyle, M. (1996) The Social Psychology of Leisure, Penguin Books.<br />
Bazan, L. and Schmitz, H. (1997) ‘Social Capital and Export Growth: An Industrial<br />
Community in Southern Brazil’ Institute of Development Studies Discussion Paper 361,<br />
August<br />
Bruhn, J. and Wolf, S. (1979), The Roseto Story, Norman: University of Oklahoma Press<br />
Cnaan, R., et al. (1998), ‘Public Perception of who is a volunteer: An examination of<br />
the net-cost approach from a cross-cultural perspective’, 27th Annual Conference<br />
Proceedings of ARNOVA, Seattle, Washington<br />
Cohen, J. (2000), ‘Review of UNV’s Involvement In Conflict Resolution and Confidence<br />
Building’; UNV Evaluation Report, mimeo<br />
Gaskin, K., and Smith, J. D. (1995), A New Civic Europe: The Extent and Nature of<br />
Volunteering in Europe, Institute for Volunteering Research<br />
Gluckman, M. (1967), The Judicial Process Among the Barotse of Northern Rhodesia,<br />
Manchester: Manchester University Press<br />
Harpham, T. (1987), ‘The worst of both worlds’, Review of Population and Development,<br />
14 (2), 6–7<br />
Harpham, T. and Blue, I. (1995), Urbanization and Mental Health in Developing<br />
Countries, Aldershot: Avebury<br />
Kahkonen, S. (1999), Does Social Capital Matter in Water and Sanitation Delivery?:<br />
A Review of the Literature, The World Bank, Social Capital Initiative Working Paper, No.9<br />
Krishna, A., and Uphoff, N. (1999), Mapping and Measuring Social Capital: A<br />
Conceptual and Empirical Study of Collective Action for Conserving and Developing<br />
Watersheds in Rajasthan, India, The World Bank, Social Capital Initiative Working<br />
Paper, No.13<br />
Moser, C. (1993), ‘Community Participation in Urban Projects in the Third World’<br />
(reference from the publication UNV, 1995)<br />
Moser, C. (1996), ‘Confronting Crisis: A Summary of Household Responses to Poverty<br />
and Vulnerability in Four Poor Urban Communities’, World Bank Environmentally<br />
Sustainable Development Studies and Monographs Series, No 7<br />
Narayan, D. (1997), Voices of the Poor: Poverty and Social Capital in Tanzania, The<br />
World Bank, Environmentally and Socially Sustainable Development Studies and<br />
Monographs Series, No. 20<br />
Narayan, D. (1999), Complementarity and Substitution: Social Capital, Poverty Reduction<br />
and the State, The World Bank, Poverty Group<br />
Putnam, R. (1993), Making Democracy Work. Civic Traditions in Modern Italy, Princeton:<br />
Princeton University Press<br />
Schneider, S. (1994), ‘Os colonos na industrial calçadista: a expansão industrial e as<br />
transformações da agricultura familiar no Rio Grande do Sul’, Masters thesis,<br />
Universidade Estadual de Campinas<br />
Smith, J. D. (1998), The 1997 National Survey of Volunteering in the UK, Institute for<br />
Volunteering Research<br />
Smith, J. D. (1999), ‘Volunteering and Social Development’, Paper prepared for UNV<br />
and presented at an Expert Group Meeting, New York, November 29–30, 1999<br />
UNCHS (<strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Centre for Human Settlements) (1996), An Urbanizing World:<br />
Global Report on Human Settlements 1996, Oxford: Oxford University Press<br />
UNDP (<strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Development Programme) (1991), ‘An Institutional Approach<br />
to Urban Informal Sector Policies in Developing Countries: Lessons from the Past;<br />
Directions for the Future’, mimeo<br />
UNDP (1998), Overcoming Human Poverty, UNDP Poverty Report<br />
UNDP (1999), ‘Cities and Sustainable Human Development’, Policy Paper, UNDP<br />
UNV (<strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> <strong>Volunteers</strong> Programme) (1995), ‘Volunteer Participation in<br />
Working with the Urban Poor’, <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> <strong>Volunteers</strong> Thematic Series<br />
Varshney, A. (1998), Civic Life and Ethnic Conflict: Hindus and Muslims in India, Yale<br />
University Press<br />
Werna, E. (1996), ‘<strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> Agencies’ Urban Policies and Health’, in Atkinson,<br />
S. Songsore, J. & Werna, E. (eds.), Urban Health Research in Developing Countries –<br />
Implications for Policy, Wallingford: CAB International<br />
Werna, E. (1997), ‘Urban small-scale production and environmental health in<br />
developing countries’, Third World Planning Review, 19 (4), 385–400<br />
Werna, E. (2000), Combating Urban Inequalities: challenges for managing cities in the<br />
developing world, Edward Elgar Publishing, Aldershot<br />
Werna, E., Dzikus, A., Ochola, L. & Kumarasuriyar, M. (1999), Implementing the Habitat<br />
Agenda: Towards Child-centred Human Settlement Development in Developing<br />
Countries, Aldershot: Ashgate<br />
Westendorff, D. (1999), ‘Volunteer Action and Local Democracy: A Partnership for a<br />
Better Urban Future’; Final Report of a UNV-UNRISD Project, mimeo<br />
Wilkinson, R. (1996), Unhealthy Societies – The Afflictions of Inequality, London:<br />
Routledge<br />
World Bank (1999), ‘A Strategic <strong>View</strong> of Urban and Local Government Issues:<br />
Implications for the Bank’, March, mimeo<br />
Salamon, L., and Anheier, H. (1998), The Emerging Sector Revisited: A Summary,<br />
The Johns Hopkins University
UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> Policy Paper<br />
‘Caring Cities’<br />
COLOPHON<br />
Page 68<br />
Text UN <strong>Volunteers</strong> ?<br />
Concept and Design<br />
this is on communication AG, Cologne<br />
Print<br />
Dfs Druck und Verlag GmbH, Marsdorf<br />
Paper<br />
Arcoprint, 300g und 100g, Cartiere Fedrigoni, Verona