Borderline - DEAN AMORY
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
<strong>Borderline</strong><br />
Personality Disorder
BORDERLINE PERSONALITY DISORDER<br />
<strong>Borderline</strong> Personality Disorder Treatment<br />
by John M. Grohol, Psy.D. - June 22, 2007<br />
Introduction<br />
<strong>Borderline</strong> Personality Disorder is<br />
experienced in individuals in many<br />
different ways. Often, people with this<br />
disorder will find it more difficult to<br />
distinguish between reality from their own<br />
misperceptions of the world and their<br />
surrounding environment. While this may<br />
seem like a type of delusion disorder to<br />
some, it is actually related to their<br />
emotions overwhelming regular<br />
cognitive functioning.<br />
People with this disorder often see others<br />
in “black-and-white” terms. Depending<br />
upon the circumstances and situation, for<br />
instance, a therapist can be seen as being<br />
very helpful and caring toward the client.<br />
But if some sort of difficulty arises in the<br />
therapy, or in the patient’s life, the person<br />
might then begin characterizing the<br />
therapist as “bad” and not caring about the<br />
client at all. Clinicians should always be<br />
aware of this “all-or-nothing” lability most<br />
often found in individuals with this<br />
disorder and be careful not to validate it.<br />
Therapists and doctors should learn to be like a rock when dealing with a person who has<br />
this disorder. That is, the doctor should offer his or her stability to contrast the client’s lability<br />
of emotion and thinking. Many professionals are turned-off by working with people with this<br />
disorder, because it draws on many negative feelings from the clinician. These occur because<br />
of the client’s constant demands on a clinician, the constant suicidal gestures, thoughts, and<br />
behaviors, and the possibility of self-mutiliating behavior. These are sometimes very difficult<br />
items for a therapist to understand and work with.<br />
Psychotherapy is nearly always the treatment of choice for this disorder; medications<br />
may be used to help stabilize mood swings. Controversy surrounds overmedicating people<br />
with this disorder.
Psychotherapy<br />
{ INCLUDEPICTURE "http://www.borderlineselbsthilfe.de/Index/Page10357/neu_<strong>Borderline</strong>.jpg"<br />
\* MERGEFORMATINET }Like with<br />
all personality disorders, psychotherapy is the treatment of choice in helping people overcome<br />
this problem. While medications can usually help some symptoms of the disorder, they cannot<br />
help the patient learn new coping skills, emotion regulation, or any of the other important<br />
changes in a person’s life.<br />
An initially important aspect of psychotherapy is usually contracting with the person to ensure<br />
that they do not commit suicide. Suicidality should be carefully assessed and monitored<br />
throughout the entire course of treatment. If suicidal feelings are severe, medication and<br />
hospitalization should be seriously considered.<br />
The most successful and effective psychotherapeutic approach to date has been Marsha<br />
Linehan’s Dialectical Behavior Therapy. Research conducted on this treatment have shown<br />
it to be more effective than most other psychotherapeutic and medical approaches to helping a<br />
person to better cope with this disorder. It seeks to teach the client how to learn to better take<br />
control of their lives, their emotions, and themselves through self-knowledge, emotion<br />
regulation, and cognitive restructuring. It is a comprehensive approach that is most often<br />
conducted within a group setting. Because the skill set learned is new and complex, it is not<br />
an appropriate therapy for those who may have difficulty learning new concepts.<br />
Like all personality disorders, borderline personality disorder is intrinsically difficult to treat.<br />
Personality disorders, by definition, are long-standing ways of coping with the world, social<br />
and personal relationships, handling stress and emotions, etc. that often do not work,<br />
especially when a person is under increased stress or performance demands in their lives.<br />
Treatment, therefore, is also likely to be somewhat lengthy in duration, typically lasting at<br />
least a year for most.<br />
Other psychological treatments which have been<br />
used, to lesser effectiveness, to treat this disorder<br />
include those which focus on social learning theory<br />
and conflict resolution. These types of solutionfocused<br />
therapies, though, often neglect the core<br />
problem of people who suffer from this disorder —<br />
difficulty in expressing appropriate emotions (and<br />
emotional attachments) to significant people in<br />
their lives due to faulty cognitions.<br />
Providing a structured therapeutic setting is<br />
important no matter which therapy type is<br />
undertaken. Because people with this disorder<br />
often try and “test the limits” of the therapist or<br />
professional when in treatment, proper and welldefined<br />
boundaries of your relationship with the<br />
client need to be carefully explained at the onset of<br />
therapy. Clinicians need to be especially aware of<br />
their own feelings toward the patient, when the<br />
client may display behavior which is deemed<br />
“inappropriate.” Individuals with borderline personality disorder are often unfairly
discriminated against within the broad range of mental health professionals because they are<br />
seen as “trouble-makers.” While they may indeed need more care than many other patients,<br />
their behavior is caused by their disorder. Phillip W. Long, M.D. also notes that:<br />
“The therapeutic alliance should form within the patient’s real experiences with the therapist<br />
and with the treatment. The therapist must be able to tolerate repeated episodes of primitive<br />
rage, distrust, and fear. Uncovering is to be avoided in favor of bolstering of ego defenses, in<br />
order to eventually allow the patient to be less anxious about potential fragmentation and loss.<br />
The goals of therapy should be in terms of life gains toward independent functioning, and not<br />
complete restructuring of the personality.”<br />
Hospitalization<br />
Hospitalization is often a concern with people who<br />
suffer from borderline personality disorder because<br />
they so often visit hospital emergency rooms and are<br />
sometimes seen on inpatient units because of severe<br />
depression.<br />
People with this disorder often present in crisis at their<br />
local community mental health center, to their<br />
therapist, or at the hospital emergency room. While an<br />
emergency room is an immediate source of crisis<br />
intervention for the patient, it is a costly treatment and<br />
regular visits to the E.R. should be discouraged.<br />
Instead, patients should be encouraged to find<br />
additional social support within their community (including self-help support groups), contact<br />
a crisis hotline, or contact their therapist or treating physician directly. Emergency room<br />
personnel should be careful not to treat the person with borderline personality disorder in<br />
blind conjunction with another set of therapists or doctors who are treating the patient for the<br />
same problem at another facility. Every attempt should be made to contact the client’s<br />
attending physician or primary therapist as soon as possible, even before the administration of<br />
medication which may be contraindicated by the primary treatment provider. Crisis<br />
management of the immediate problem is usually the key component to effective treatment of<br />
this disorder when it presents in a hospital emergency room, with discharge to the patient’s<br />
usual care provider.<br />
Inpatient treatment often takes the form of medication in conjunction with psychotherapy<br />
sessions in groups or individually. This is an appropriate treatment option if the person is<br />
experiencing extreme difficulties in living and daily functioning. It is, however, relatively rare<br />
to be hospitalized in the U.S. for this disorder. Long-term care of the person suffering from<br />
borderline personality disorder within a hospital setting is nearly never appropriate. The<br />
typical inpatient stay for someone with borderline personality disorder in the U.S. is about 3<br />
to 4 weeks, depending upon the person’s insurance. Since this treatment is so expensive, it is<br />
getting more difficult to obtain. Results of such treatment are also mixed. While it is an<br />
excellent way of helping stabilize the client, it is usually too short a time to attain significant<br />
changes within the individual’s personality makeup.<br />
Good inpatient care facilities for this disorder should be highly structured environments which<br />
seek to expand the individual’s independence. Phillip W. Long, M.D., adds that the goals of<br />
such a treatment modality, “include decreasing acting out, clearly identifying and working
with inappropriate behaviors and feelings, accepting with the patient the magnitude of the<br />
therapeutic task, fostering more effective interpersonal relationships, and working with both<br />
real and transference relationships within the hospital.”<br />
Partial hospitalization or a day treatment program is often all that’s needed for people who<br />
suffer from borderline personality disorder. This allows the individual to gain support and<br />
structure from a safe environment for a short time, or during the day, and returning home in<br />
the evening. In times of increased stress or difficulty coping with specific situations, this type<br />
of treatment is more appropriate and more healthy for most people than full inpatient<br />
hospitalization.<br />
Medications<br />
Phillip W. Long, M.D. has noted:<br />
“During brief reactive psychoses, low doses of antipsychotic<br />
drugs may be useful, but they are usually not essential<br />
adjuncts to the treatment regimen, since such episodes are<br />
most often self-limiting and of short duration.<br />
It is, however, clear that low doses of high potency<br />
neuroleptics (e.g., haloperidol) may be helpful for<br />
disorganized thinking and some psychotic symptoms.<br />
Depression in some cases is amenable to neuroleptics.<br />
Neuroleptics are particularly recommended for the psychotic<br />
symptoms mentioned above, and for patients who show anger<br />
which must be controlled. Dosages should generally be low and the medication should never<br />
be given without adequate psychosocial intervention.”<br />
Antidepressant and anti-anxiety agents may be appropriate during particular times in the<br />
patient’s treatment, as appropriate. For example, if a client presents with severe suicidal<br />
ideation and intent, the clinician may want to seriously consider the prescription of an<br />
appropriate antidepressant medication to help combat the ideation. Medication of this type<br />
should be avoided for long-term use, though, since most anxiety and depression is directly<br />
related to short-term, situational factors that will quickly come and go in the individual’s life.<br />
Self-Help
Self-help methods for the<br />
treatment of this disorder are<br />
often overlooked by the medical<br />
profession because very few<br />
professionals are involved in<br />
them.<br />
Encouraging the individual with<br />
borderline personality disorder to<br />
gain additional social support,<br />
however, is an important aspect<br />
of treatment. Many support<br />
groups exist within communities<br />
throughout the world which are<br />
devoted to helping individuals<br />
with this disorder share their<br />
commons experiences and<br />
feelings.<br />
Patients can be encouraged to try<br />
out new coping skills and<br />
emotion regulation with people<br />
they meet within support groups.<br />
They can be an important part of<br />
expanding the individual’s skill<br />
set and develop new, healthier<br />
social relationships.
Symptoms of <strong>Borderline</strong> Personality Disorder<br />
by John M. Grohol, Psy.D. - June 22, 2007<br />
{ INCLUDEPICTURE<br />
"http://www.prosieben.de/imperia/md/images/images/02_spielfilm_serie/desperate_housewiv<br />
es/desktops/dh_desktop1_1024_768.jpg" \* MERGEFORMATINET }<br />
The main feature of borderline personality disorder (BPD) is a pervasive pattern of instability<br />
in interpersonal relationships, self-image and emotions. People with borderline personality<br />
disorder are also usually very impulsive.<br />
This disorder occurs in most by early adulthood. The instable pattern of interacting with<br />
others has persisted for years and is usually closely related to the person’s self-image and<br />
early social interactions. The pattern is present in a variety of settings (e.g., not just at work or<br />
home) and often is accompanied by a similar lability (fluctuating back and forth, sometimes in<br />
a quick manner) in a person’s emotions and feelings. Relationships and the person’s emotion<br />
may often be characterized as being shallow.<br />
A person with this disorder will also often exhibit impulsive behaviors and have a<br />
majority of the following symptoms:<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
Frantic efforts to avoid real or imagined abandonment<br />
A pattern of unstable and intense interpersonal relationships characterized by<br />
alternating between extremes of idealization and devaluation<br />
Identity disturbance: markedly and persistently unstable self-image or sense of self<br />
Impulsivity in at least two areas that are potentially self-damaging (e.g., spending, sex,<br />
substance abuse, reckless driving, binge eating)<br />
Recurrent suicidal behavior, gestures, or threats, or self-mutilating behavior<br />
Affective instability due to a marked reactivity of mood (e.g., intense episodic<br />
dysphoria, irritability, or anxiety usually lasting a few hours and only rarely more than<br />
a few days)<br />
Chronic feelings of emptiness<br />
Inappropriate, intense anger or difficulty controlling anger (e.g., frequent displays of<br />
temper, constant anger, recurrent physical fights)<br />
Transient, stress-related paranoid ideation or severe dissociative symptoms<br />
Details about <strong>Borderline</strong> Personality Disorder Symptoms<br />
Frantic efforts to avoid real or imagined abandonment.<br />
The perception of impending separation or rejection, or the loss of external structure, can lead<br />
to profound changes in self-image, emotion, thinking and behavior. Someone with borderline<br />
personality disorder will be very sensitive to things happening around them in their<br />
environment. They experience intense abandonment fears and inappropriate anger, even when<br />
faced with a realistic separation or when there are unavoidable changes in plans. For instance,<br />
becoming very angry with someone for being a few minutes late or having to cancel a lunch<br />
date. People with borderline personality disorder may believ that this abandonment implies<br />
that they are “bad.” These abandonment fears are related to an intolerance of being alone and<br />
a need to have other people with them. Their frantic efforts to avoid abandonment may<br />
include impulsive actions such as self-mutilating or suicidal behaviors.
{ INCLUDEPICTURE "http://www.siliconeer.com/past_issues/2000/feb_00_selfhelp_2.jpg"<br />
\* MERGEFORMATINET }<br />
Unstable and intense relationships.<br />
People with borderline personality disorder may idealize potential caregivers or lovers at the<br />
first or second meeting, demand to spend a lot of time together, and share the most intimate<br />
details early in a relationship. However, they may switch quickly from idealizing other people<br />
to devaluing them, feeling that the other person does not care enough, does not give enough,<br />
is not “there” enough. These individuals can empathize with and nurture other people, but<br />
only with the expectation that the other person will “be there” in return to meet their own<br />
needs on demand. These individuals are prone to sudden and dramatic shifts in their view of<br />
others, who may alternately be seen as beneficient supports or as cruelly punitive. Such shifts<br />
other reflect disillusionment with a caregiver whose nurturing qualities had been idealized or<br />
whose rejection or abandonment is expected.<br />
Identity disturbance.<br />
There are sudden and dramatic shifts in self-image, characterized by shifting goals, values and<br />
vocational aspirations. There may be suddent changes in opinions and plans about career,<br />
sexual identity, values and types of friends. These individuals may suddenly change from the<br />
role of a needy supplicant for help to a righteous avenger of past mistreatment. Although they<br />
usually have a self-image that is based on being bad or evil, individuals with borderline<br />
personality disorder may at times have feelings that they do not exist at all. Such experiences<br />
usually occur in situations in which the individual feels a lack of a meaningful relationship,<br />
nurturing and support. These individuals may show worse performance in unstructured work<br />
or school situations.<br />
{ INCLUDEPICTURE "http://www.angelfire.com/scifi2/untilthedayidie/untiltheday.jpg" \*<br />
MERGEFORMATINET }<br />
Want to learn more about these characteristics of <strong>Borderline</strong> Personality Disorder?<br />
description of these symptoms now.<br />
- Read the detailed<br />
Characteristics of <strong>Borderline</strong> Personality Disorder<br />
by John M. Grohol, Psy.D. - June 22, 2007<br />
Individuals with <strong>Borderline</strong> Personality Disorder make frantic efforts to avoid real or<br />
imagined abandonment. The perception<br />
of impending separation or rejection, or<br />
the loss of external structure, can lead to<br />
profound changes in self-image, affect,<br />
cognition, and behavior. These<br />
individuals are very sensitive to<br />
environmental circumstances. They<br />
experience intense abandonment fears<br />
and inappropriate anger even when<br />
faced with a realistic time-limited<br />
separation or when there are<br />
unavoidable changes in plans (e.g.,<br />
sudden despair in reaction to a
clinician’s announcing the end of the hour; panic or fury when someone important to them is<br />
just a few minutes late or must cancel an appointment). They may believe that this<br />
“abandonment” implies they are “bad.” These abandonment fears are related to an intolerance<br />
of being alone and a need to have other people with them. Their frantic efforts to avoid<br />
abandonment may include impulsive actions such as self-mutilating or suicidal behaviors.<br />
Individuals with <strong>Borderline</strong> Personality Disorder<br />
have a pattern of unstable and intense<br />
relationships. They may idealize potential<br />
caregivers or lovers at the first or second<br />
meeting, demand to spend a lot of time together,<br />
and share the most intimate details early in a<br />
relationship. However, they may switch quickly<br />
from idealizing other people to devaluing them,<br />
feeling that the other person does not care<br />
enough, does not give enough, is not “there”<br />
enough. These individuals can empathize with<br />
and nurture other people, but only with the<br />
expectation that the other person will “be there” in return to meet their own needs on demand.<br />
These individuals are prone to sudden and dramatic shifts in their view of others, who may<br />
alternately be seen as beneficent supports or as cruelly punitive. Such shifts often reflect<br />
disillusionment with a caregiver whose nurturing qualities had been idealized or whose<br />
rejection or abandonment is expected.<br />
There may be an identity disturbance characterized by markedly and persistently unstable<br />
self-image or sense of self. There are sudden and dramatic shifts in self-image, characterized<br />
by shifting goals, values, and vocational aspirations. There may be sudden changes in<br />
opinions and plans about career, sexual identity, va lues, and types of friends. These<br />
individuals may suddenly change from the role of a needy supplicant for help to a righteous<br />
avenger of past mistreatment. Although they usually have a<br />
self-image that is based on being bad or evil, individuals with<br />
this disorder may at times have feelings that they do not exist<br />
at all. Such experiences usually occur in situations in which<br />
the individual feels a lack of a meaningful relationship,<br />
nurturing, and support. These individuals may show worse<br />
performance in unstructured work or school situations.<br />
Individuals with <strong>Borderline</strong> Personality Disorder display<br />
impulsivity in at least two areas that are potentially selfdamaging.<br />
They may gamble, spend money irresponsibly, binge eat, abuse substances, engage<br />
in unsafe sex, or drive recklessly.<br />
Individuals with <strong>Borderline</strong> Personality Disorder may also sometimes display recurrent<br />
suicidal behavior, gestures, or threats, or self-mutilating behavior. Completed suicide occurs<br />
in 8%-10% of such individuals, and self-mutilative acts (e.g., cutting or burning) and suicide<br />
threats and attempts are very common. Recurrent suicidality is often the reason that these<br />
individuals present for help. These self-destructive acts are usually precipitated by threats of<br />
separation<br />
or<br />
rejection or by expectations that they assume increased responsibility. Self-mutilation may<br />
occur during dissociative experiences and often brings relief by reaffirming the ability to feel<br />
or by expiating the individual’s sense of being evil.
Individuals with <strong>Borderline</strong> Personality Disorder may display affective instability that is due<br />
to a marked reactivity of mood (e.g., intense episodic dysphoria, irritability, or anxiety usually<br />
lasting a few hours and only rarely more than a few days). The basic dysphoric mood of those<br />
with <strong>Borderline</strong> Personality Disorder is often disrupted by periods of anger, panic, or despair<br />
and is rarely relieved by periods of well-being or satisfaction. These episodes may reflect the<br />
individual’s extreme<br />
reactivity to interpersonal<br />
stresses.<br />
Individuals with <strong>Borderline</strong><br />
Personality Disorder may be<br />
troubled by chronic feelings<br />
of emptiness. Easily bored,<br />
they may constantly seek<br />
something to do. Individuals<br />
with <strong>Borderline</strong> Personality<br />
Disorder frequently express<br />
inappropriate, intense anger<br />
or have difficulty controlling<br />
their anger. They may<br />
display extreme sarcasm,<br />
enduring bitterness, or<br />
verbal outbursts. The anger<br />
is often elicited when a<br />
caregiver or lover is seen as<br />
neglectful, withholding,<br />
uncaring, or abandoning.<br />
Such expressions of anger<br />
are often followed by shame<br />
and guilt and contribute to the feeling they have of being evil.<br />
During periods of extreme stress, transient paranoid ideation or dissociative symptoms (e.g.,<br />
depersonalization) may occur, but these are generally of insufficient severity or duration to<br />
warrant an additional diagnosis. These episodes occur most frequently in response to a real or<br />
imagined abandonment. Symptoms tend to be transient, lasting minutes or hours. The real or<br />
perceived return of the caregiver’s nurturance may result in a remission of symptoms.
Frequently Asked Questions about <strong>Borderline</strong><br />
by John M. Grohol, Psy.D. - June 22, 2007<br />
Below are some of the most frequently asked questions, and their answers, about <strong>Borderline</strong><br />
Personality Disorder.<br />
What is <strong>Borderline</strong> Personality Disorder (BPD)?<br />
The main feature of borderline personality disorder (BPD) is<br />
a long pattern of instability in their relationships with others,<br />
and in their own self-image and emotions. People with<br />
borderline personality disorder are also usually very<br />
impulsive. The instable pattern of interacting with others has<br />
persisted for years and is usually closely related to the<br />
person’s self-image and early social interactions. The<br />
pattern is present in a variety of settings (e.g., not just at<br />
work or home) and often is accompanied by a similar
lability (fluctuating back and forth, sometimes in a quick manner) in a person’s emotions and<br />
feelings. Relationships and the person’s emotion may often be characterized as being shallow.<br />
The disorder occurs in most by early adulthood.<br />
How common is <strong>Borderline</strong> Personality Disorder?<br />
It is not very common, and is estimated to be found in 1 to 2% of<br />
the general U.S. population at any give time. It is more common<br />
amongst people seeking treatment for another mental disorder.<br />
How does <strong>Borderline</strong> Personality<br />
Disorder cause problems?<br />
Like any mental health issue, borderline personality<br />
disorder causes problems in a person’s social and life<br />
functioning by interfering with the person’s ability to<br />
reliably maintain these relationships or their everyday<br />
living. People with this disorder often cause a great amount<br />
of stress or conflict in relationships with others, especially<br />
significant others or those who are very close to the person.<br />
This can often lead to divorce, physical, sexual or<br />
emotional abuse, additional emotional problems (such as<br />
an eating disorder or depression), losing one’s job,<br />
estrangement from one’s family, and more.<br />
What is the course of <strong>Borderline</strong> Personality Disorder?<br />
There is considerable variability in the course<br />
of <strong>Borderline</strong> Personality Disorder. The most<br />
common pattern is one of chronic instability<br />
in early adulthood, with episodes of serious<br />
loss of emotion and impulsive control, as<br />
well as high levels of use of health and<br />
mental health resources. The impairment<br />
from the disorder and the risk of suicide are<br />
greatest in the young-adult years and<br />
gradually wane with advancing age. During<br />
their 30s and 40s, the majority of individuals<br />
with this disorder attain greater stability in<br />
their relationships and job functioning.
Is <strong>Borderline</strong> Personality Disorder<br />
inherited?<br />
<strong>Borderline</strong> Personality Disorder is about five times<br />
more common among first-degree biological relatives<br />
of those with the disorder than in the general<br />
population. There is also an increased familial risk for<br />
Substance-Related Disorders (e.g., drug abuse),<br />
Antisocial Personality Disorder, and Mood Disorders,<br />
like depression or bipolar disorder.<br />
Where can I go to learn more about<br />
<strong>Borderline</strong> Personality Disorder?<br />
Psych Central has a reviewed list of resources you can<br />
consult for further information about <strong>Borderline</strong><br />
Personality Disorder. We also recommend the<br />
following two books to understand more about this<br />
disorder:<br />
<br />
<br />
Stop Walking on Eggshells: Taking Your Life Back When Someone You Care about Has<br />
<strong>Borderline</strong> Personality Disorder by Paul T. Mason and Randi Kreger<br />
The Stop Walking on Eggshells Workbook: Practical Strategies for Living With Someone<br />
Who Has <strong>Borderline</strong> Personality Disorder by Randi Kreger and James Paul Shirley<br />
FOR LOVED ONES<br />
People with borderline disorder have marked difficulties with<br />
relationships, especially with the people who are closest to them,<br />
such as families, partners and friends. Episodes of anger<br />
outbursts, moodiness, and unreasonable, impulsive, and erratic<br />
behaviors, which often appear unprovoked, can result in<br />
considerable harm to these important relationships. Attempts to<br />
engage in a discussion to work out reasonable solutions to<br />
problems frequently turn into highly emotional battles.<br />
This usually results in responses from family, partners and<br />
friends that include anxiety and frustration, attempts to placate,<br />
and angry retorts when the limits of normal patience have been<br />
exceeded. Therefore, most loved ones of individuals with<br />
borderline disorder are quite relieved to learn that effective<br />
treatment is available for the disorder, and that there are ways<br />
they can help as well.<br />
Two significant advances in the area of borderline disorder have been the recent research on<br />
the effectiveness of different educational and therapeutic experiences for families, and the<br />
development of consumer and family organizations focused on the disorder.
Ten Guidelines for Families, Partners and Friends<br />
If you are a family member, partner or friend of someone with borderline disorder, you<br />
probably have developed feelings of anger and resentment towards them that conflict with<br />
your feelings of empathy and desire to help. The following are ten specific actions that you<br />
can take that will help the person with borderline disorder gain better control over her or his<br />
life, and help you in the process.<br />
1. Learn About the Disorder<br />
It is essential to understand that<br />
the person with borderline<br />
disorder is suffering from an<br />
illness that is as real as<br />
diabetes, heart disease, or<br />
hypertension. For most people,<br />
physical symptoms are easier to<br />
accept as indications of a<br />
disease than are behavioral<br />
symptoms. However, there is<br />
no reason to assume that a<br />
complex organ such as the<br />
brain is less susceptible to<br />
diseases that affect behavior<br />
than are other bodily organs that result in physical symptoms. Recently developed medical<br />
research studies demonstrate abnormal brain structure and function in patients with borderline<br />
disorder, thus confirming this conclusion.<br />
It is also helpful to realize that persons with borderline<br />
disorder did not acquire the disorder through any actions of<br />
their own, nor do they enjoy having the disorder. Imagine<br />
what it must be like to feel that you are frequently at the<br />
mercy of forces within you, over which you seem to have<br />
little control, and that cause you extreme emotional pain<br />
and significant life problems.<br />
Therefore, a critical first step in the process of helping them<br />
and you is to learn as much as you can about the symptoms<br />
and nature of borderline disorder, and the specific<br />
situational causes of acute episodes in the member of your<br />
family with the disorder.
2. Seek Professional Help<br />
Facilitate the process of obtaining optimal help.<br />
It may be necessary that you do the initial work<br />
necessary to set up the first appointment. It may<br />
also be helpful if you agree to go also. Some<br />
people with borderline disorder initially refuse<br />
to seek professional help. Provide them with a<br />
copy of my book and suggest they read the first<br />
two chapters. This may help them understand<br />
their potential problems well enough to agree to<br />
an initial appointment with a psychiatrist.<br />
Other people with borderline disorder are steadfast in their refusal of help. This, of course, is a<br />
major problem. Dr. Perry Hoffman, the founding president of the National Education Alliance<br />
for <strong>Borderline</strong> Personality Disorder (NEA-BPD) offers this advice:<br />
The best way of approaching this problem from my perspective is for one to accept that you<br />
cannot get someone into treatment. Timing is important as to when someone might be “open”<br />
to hearing the idea. But the bottom line is to free families of feeling guilty, and to understand<br />
that they are not so powerful to effect that goal. Along that line, relatives need to get help and<br />
support for themselves as they watch their loved one in the throes of the illness.<br />
3. Support the Treatment Program<br />
Once in treatment, encourage and support your loved one with borderline disorder to regularly<br />
attend therapy sessions, to take medicine as prescribed, to eat, exercise, and rest appropriately,<br />
and to engage in wholesome<br />
recreational activities. If alcohol or<br />
other drugs are a problem, strongly<br />
support their efforts to abstain<br />
completely from these substances,<br />
and encourage regular attendance<br />
in treatment programs or self-help<br />
groups, such as Alcoholics<br />
Anonymous. Remember, there is<br />
little hope of improvement of the<br />
symptoms of borderline disorder if<br />
alcohol and drugs are abused. It is<br />
very important that you remain<br />
persistent in your efforts to do<br />
everything possible to help reduce<br />
the risk of this behavior, and not<br />
enable it.<br />
4. Respond Consistently to<br />
Problematic Behaviors<br />
Develop a clear understanding (it<br />
may even be written) of the<br />
realistic consequences of recurring, problematic, destructive behaviors such as episodes of<br />
alcohol and drug abuse, physically self-damaging acts, and excessive spending and gambling.<br />
Also, agree beforehand on how best to respond to threats and acts of self-harm.<br />
These and other problematic behaviors are often triggered by stressful events that need to be
identified, and a clear plan developed for handling these events and situations more<br />
appropriately and effectively in the future. Such a<br />
plan is best developed with the help of the patient’s<br />
primary clinician.<br />
Experience has shown that responding positively to<br />
appropriate behaviors is also very important in<br />
encouraging change to new and more successful<br />
ways of handling stressful situations. Doing so also<br />
reduces the incidence of inappropriate behaviors that<br />
then cause additional problems. Issuing spontaneous<br />
ultimatums should be avoided.<br />
5. Attempt to Remain Calm<br />
Reacting desperately or angrily when there is a flare<br />
up of symptoms will often add to the existing problem. Remain calm. Acknowledge that it<br />
must be difficult to experience the expressed feelings, even if they seem out of proportion to<br />
the situation. This does not mean that you agree with these feelings, or that you think that the<br />
actions resulting from them are justified. However, it is reassuring if you listen to their<br />
feelings, the pain they are experiencing, and the difficulty they are having in dealing with this<br />
pain. Remember that you do not have to defend yourself if verbally attacked, or develop<br />
solutions to their problems. If they express thoughts of self-harm, remind them of the plan for<br />
dealing with this problem that has been worked out with their therapist.<br />
Allow and encourage the person with borderline disorder to attempt to bring their response<br />
levels in line with the situation at hand. This may require that you give them a little time alone<br />
to collect themselves. Then it may be possible to more calmly and reasonably discuss the<br />
relevant issues.<br />
In addition, do not be hesitant to express your feelings freely and openly, but with<br />
moderation. Recent research suggests that caring involvement with your loved one with<br />
borderline disorder is associated with better outcomes than a cool, disinterested approach.<br />
Stay involved.<br />
6. Remain Positive and Optimistic<br />
It is important to remain optimistic about the ultimate results of treatment, especially when the<br />
patient has a setback. The usual course of borderline disorder with optimal treatment is one of<br />
increasing periods of time when symptoms are absent or minimal, interrupted by episodes<br />
when the symptoms flare up. Over time, the specific causes of relapses can be identified,<br />
anticipated, then steps taken to develop alternative, more adaptive and effective responses.<br />
Occasional family meetings with the therapist may help clarify the causes of relapses and<br />
identify new ways of preventing them.<br />
7. Participate in Educational Experiences About <strong>Borderline</strong> Disorder<br />
It is very important that you learn as much as possible about borderline disorder and your role<br />
in the treatment process. Your participation in educational opportunities may benefit both you<br />
and your loved one with the disorder. When conducted by skilled and experienced people,<br />
such structured and informative experiences may involve both patients and family.<br />
8. Join a <strong>Borderline</strong> Disorder Consumer and Family Support Organization<br />
For information on such consumer organizations, contact the National Alliance on Mental
Illness (NAMI) or the National Education Alliance for <strong>Borderline</strong> Personality Disorder (NEA-<br />
BPD). If such an organization exists in or near your community, seriously consider joining it.<br />
You will then have available to you a large amount of new information about borderline<br />
disorder, what you can do to help the member of your family with the disorder and yourself,<br />
and compassionate and understanding support in your efforts. If there is not a group in your<br />
area, consider starting one with other family members you have met. Also consider joining<br />
one of these national consumer organizations for borderline disorder.<br />
9. Remember: the Person with <strong>Borderline</strong> Disorder Must Take Charge<br />
Remember that it is primarily the responsibility of the person with borderline disorder to take<br />
charge of her or his behavior and life. Although difficult at times, it is important for you to<br />
provide the opportunity for your family member with borderline disorder to take reasonable<br />
risks in order to try new behaviors. It is also important that you help her or him to be<br />
accountable for the consequences of old, destructive behaviors.<br />
Excessive dependency on family and friends is not helpful in the long run. Beware of the<br />
tendency of people with borderline disorder to act at the extremes. For example, the proper<br />
alternative to excessive dependency is not immediate, total independency. The more<br />
appropriate responses are to remain engaged and to gradually help move to a more balanced,<br />
mature relationship level of mutual interdependency.<br />
10. Take Care of Yourself<br />
If you take the time to meet your own needs, when your help is needed most, you will be best<br />
able to provide it. Remember that you cannot save your loved one with borderline disorder on<br />
your own.<br />
If you are the parent, there is a natural tendency to focus much of your attention on the person<br />
with borderline disorder. However, make certain that you are not neglecting your other sons<br />
and daughters who may appear to be doing well. They have need of your time and attention<br />
too, even as they grow into adulthood. You will learn from educational experiences the extent<br />
of this potential problem and how best to deal with it.
THE WORLD<br />
NEEDS PEOPLE...<br />
who cannot be bought;<br />
whose word is their bond;<br />
who put character above wealth;<br />
who possess opinions and a will;<br />
who are larger than their vocations;<br />
who do not hesitate to take chances;<br />
who will not lose their individuality in a crowd;<br />
who will be as honest in small things as in great things;<br />
who will make no compromise with wrong;<br />
whose ambitions are not confined to their own selfish desires;<br />
who will not say they do it" because everybody else does it";<br />
who are true to their friends through good report and evil report,<br />
in adversity as well as in prosperity;<br />
who do not believe that shrewdness, cunning, and hardheadedness are the best qualities<br />
for winning success;<br />
who are not ashamed or afraid to stand for the truth when it is unpopular;<br />
who can say "no" with emphasis, although all the rest of the world says "yes."<br />
Charles Swindoll.<br />
ONLINE TEST<br />
The following "test" may help you to evaluate the possibility<br />
that you or a loved one has borderline disorder. It is simply a<br />
check list of the nine criteria of borderline disorder as defined<br />
by the American Psychiatric Association in their diagnostic<br />
manual, DSM-IV-TR. However, it is reworded so that you<br />
may readily apply the criteria to your situation.<br />
Please note that you should not use the results of the test to<br />
arrive at any fixed conclusion, but rather to provide you with<br />
an estimation of the possibility that this disorder, or its traits,<br />
may exist.<br />
How to Use the <strong>Borderline</strong> Disorder Test<br />
First, read carefully about the symptoms of borderline disorder<br />
provided on this website, or as they are described in more detail in my book, <strong>Borderline</strong><br />
Personality Disorder Demystified.<br />
Next, print this page and place a check mark next to those symptoms or behaviors listed<br />
below that you believe accurately describe your condition. If you are in doubt, leave the item<br />
blank.
The <strong>Borderline</strong> Disorder Test<br />
___<br />
___<br />
___<br />
___<br />
___<br />
___<br />
___<br />
___<br />
___<br />
1) My emotions change very quickly, and I experience intense episodes of<br />
sadness, irritability, and anxiety or panic attacks.<br />
2) My level of anger is often inappropriate, intense and difficult to control.<br />
3) I suffer from chronic feelings of emptiness and boredom.<br />
4) I engage in two or more self-damaging acts such as excessive spending,<br />
unsafe and inappropriate sexual conduct, substance abuse, reckless driving,<br />
and binge eating.<br />
5) Now, or in the past, when upset, I have engaged in recurrent suicidal<br />
behaviors, gestures, threats, or self-injurious behavior such as cutting,<br />
burning or hitting myself.<br />
6) I have a significant and persistently unstable image or sense of my self, or<br />
of who I am or what I truly believe in.<br />
7) I have very suspicious ideas, and am even paranoid (falsely believe that<br />
others are plotting to cause me harm) at times; or I experience episodes<br />
under stress when I feel that I, other people or the situation is somewhat<br />
unreal.<br />
8) I engage in frantic efforts to avoid real or imagined abandonment by<br />
people who are close to me.<br />
9) My relationships are very intense, unstable, and alternate between the<br />
extremes of over idealizing and undervaluing people who are important to<br />
me.<br />
How to Score the <strong>Borderline</strong> Disorder Test<br />
Score of five or greater:<br />
If you have checked five or more items on the above list, you may have borderline disorder.<br />
In order to determine if this is the case, you will require an evaluation by a psychiatrist or<br />
mental health care clinician who is well trained and experienced in borderline disorder.<br />
Score of one to four:<br />
If you have checked one to four items on the above checklist, you may have borderline<br />
disorder traits. Depending on the level of severity of your symptoms or behaviors, and the<br />
amount of disruption that they cause you, your family, friends and others, you may require an<br />
evaluation by a psychiatrist or mental health care clinician who is well trained and<br />
experienced in borderline disorder.<br />
It is important to realize that you do not have to meet five or more criteria of borderline<br />
disorder for these symptoms to significantly disrupt your life. You may still benefit greatly<br />
from appropriate treatment.
Guidelines for the Selection of a Psychiatrist and Other Clinicians<br />
Once you have located the names of one or more clinicians, you may wish to contact them to<br />
determine if they provide the services you are looking for.<br />
The following is a list of issues that you<br />
may wish to clarify in order to determine if<br />
you have a reasonably suitable fit given<br />
your individual needs:<br />
Primary Clinician: Ideally, in most<br />
cases, you are looking for a psychiatrist<br />
with experience in borderline disorder who<br />
can serve as your primary clinician, that is,<br />
perform your initial clinical evaluation and<br />
the other tasks of someone assuming this<br />
role in your care. If such a person is not<br />
available in your community, you should<br />
ask other potential providers of care about<br />
their level of experience in the area of<br />
borderline disorder.<br />
Types of Treatment: Determine what<br />
forms of treatment they typically use for their<br />
patients with the disorder, especially<br />
medications and psychotherapies. Most psychiatrists and other clinicians do not typically<br />
provide the full range of treatments that we now know are useful for treating the disorder. In<br />
other words, you may need several people working with you, for example, one to prescribe<br />
medications, another to provide therapy, and possibly a third for group therapy work.<br />
Therefore, you will need to ask how your special needs will be met by each clinician. If you<br />
will be seeing just one person, be especially cautious if they recommend only one form of<br />
treatment for all patients with borderline disorder, for example either medications or<br />
psychotherapy, or one specific type of psychotherapy. As noted elsewhere on this site,<br />
borderline disorder affects people in many different ways. Therefore, in most cases, effective<br />
treatment plans are more complex than can be accomplished by a single type of treatment.<br />
<br />
Immediate Help: You should establish how the provider handles those times when<br />
you may need immediate help, for example who will respond to your telephone calls and<br />
under what circumstances. Also, should you require brief hospitalization, what hospital<br />
will be utilized, and who will direct your care when you are in the hospital.<br />
Communication: If you will have more than one clinician working with you, it is<br />
important to establish the degree to which they will work with you and with your family or<br />
partner, and with each other. It is important that the team communicate openly. Under most<br />
circumstances, it is essential that those people who are very important in your life are<br />
included in your treatment. The types and frequency of involvement required are best<br />
discussed prior to the onset of treatment.<br />
Finding the Right Fit: Ultimately, you are looking for clinicians who appear to be<br />
“good fits” for you and your special needs. To some degree this is a subjective quality, and<br />
cannot be easily defined further, but patients often sense when they have found the right<br />
professionals with whom to work.
Credentials: It is very appropriate to ask about the potential provider’s specific<br />
credentials: in what mental health specialty do they have their degree; are they certified<br />
properly, for example., for psychiatrists, by the American Board of Psychiatry and Neurology;<br />
are they licensed to practice in their specific clinical area; and what degree of training and<br />
experience do they have with borderline disorder.<br />
Payment Information: Finally, you should obtain their fee schedule and method of<br />
payment for different services, for example medication checks, and individual and group<br />
psychotherapy sessions. Many clinicians accept insurance with co-payments, while some<br />
require self payment.<br />
At the outset of care, remember that your doctor may not be able to determine precisely the<br />
most effective treatments for you. Therefore, it seems to me most reasonable to find a<br />
psychiatrist, and other clinicians when necessary, who know the relevant medical literature,<br />
that have open minds regarding different diagnostic possibilities and treatment approaches,<br />
and who communicate well with you and your family. Given our current level of knowledge<br />
about borderline disorder, it is likely that such professionals will give you the best help<br />
available, now and in the future.
The Diagnosis and Treatment for Depression<br />
Co-Occurring with <strong>Borderline</strong> Disorder<br />
by Robert O. Friedel, MD<br />
More than 80 percent of people with borderline disorder suffer from episodes of major<br />
depression. Treatment for depression is vital in these individuals. There are two categories of<br />
major depressive episodes, those associated with bipolar I and II disorder-depressed*, and<br />
those referred to as major depressive disorder.<br />
Therefore, if you have borderline disorder, it is important that you know and recognize the<br />
symptoms of these disorders. If they occur, you should alert your physician so that you may<br />
receive prompt treatment for depression.<br />
Symptoms of a Major Depressive Episode:<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
persistently depressed or irritable mood<br />
diminished interest or pleasure in activities<br />
significant decrease or increase in appetite, or weight loss or<br />
weight gain<br />
increased or decreased sleep<br />
decreased mental and physical activity, or increase in such activity as demonstrated by<br />
excessive worrying and agitated behavior<br />
fatigue, or loss of energy<br />
feelings of worthlessness or excessive or inappropriate guilt<br />
diminished ability to think or concentrate, or indecisiveness<br />
recurrent thoughts of death and dying, recurrent suicidal thoughts with a specific plan,<br />
or a suicide attempt<br />
Understand the differences in symptoms of <strong>Borderline</strong> Disorder, Bipolar Disorder-<br />
Depressed and Major Depressive Disorder, and learn about the various plans for treatment<br />
for depression.<br />
In order to initiate the proper treatment for depression, it is necessary to determine if you are<br />
experiencing a decrease in mood associated with borderline<br />
disorder, or if you have developed a bipolar II disorderdepressed<br />
or major depressive disorder.<br />
<br />
Depressed Mood in <strong>Borderline</strong> Disorder<br />
In borderline disorder alone, depressed mood often occurs as<br />
follows:<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
sad, depressed, and lonely feelings are frequently<br />
triggered by some life event and are often associated<br />
with strong feelings of emptiness, loneliness and fears<br />
of abandonment.<br />
symptoms readily improve if the situation causing<br />
them improves<br />
sleep, appetite and energy disturbances (if present) are<br />
usually related to an identifiable life stress and stop<br />
when the stress is managed successfully.<br />
acute suicidal thoughts and self-injurious behavior are usually the direct result of a<br />
personal problem (for example, an argument with a parent, boyfriend, spouse, or boss)
Bipolar II Disorder-Depressed*<br />
In bipolar disorder-depressed, the symptoms of a major depressive episode listed above are<br />
often characterized by:<br />
increased appetite or weight gain<br />
increased sleep and napping<br />
marked decrease in mental and physical activity<br />
marked fatigue and loss of energy<br />
Major Depressive Disorder<br />
In major depressive disorder, the symptoms<br />
of a major depressive episode listed above are<br />
often characterized by:<br />
decreased appetite or weight loss<br />
decreased sleep with early morning<br />
awakening<br />
increased mental and physical activity<br />
as demonstrated by excessive<br />
worrying and agitated behavior<br />
Treatment for Depression Cooccurring<br />
with <strong>Borderline</strong> Disorder<br />
If you think you have the symptoms of either<br />
type of depression, immediately alert your<br />
psychiatrist. If appropriate, the treatment for<br />
depression frequently involves the addition of<br />
an antidepressant, an increase in dosage if<br />
one is already being used, and/or the use of<br />
behavioral techniques.<br />
There are no controlled studies on the relative<br />
effectiveness of different antidepressants for<br />
the treatment for depression in people with<br />
borderline disorder. However, studies of these disorders in people without borderline disorder,<br />
and experience, suggest that the following initial treatment strategies may have merit:<br />
Treatment for Depression in Bipolar Disorder-Depressed<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
Bupropion (Wellbutrin®)<br />
Lamotrigine (Lamictal®)<br />
SSRIs such as fluoxetine (Prozac®) or sertraline (Zoloft®) if bupropion and<br />
lamotrigine are ineffective<br />
Treatment for Depression in Major Depressive Disorder<br />
<br />
<br />
SSRIs such as fluoxetine or sertraline<br />
Bupropion and lamotrigine if SSRIs are ineffective<br />
Note: It is important in the treatment for depression to recognize that some antidepressants<br />
may cause an episode of mania or hypomania in patients with depression who have never<br />
experienced such episodes in the past.
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy focused on treatment for depression may also prove useful to<br />
help identify thought patterns and behaviors that operate as risk factors for mood disorders,<br />
and to encourage new, more successful behaviors.<br />
Bipolar I and II, and major depressive disorders occur more commonly in patients<br />
with borderline disorder than they do in the general population. Bipolar II disorder is<br />
the most common type of bipolar disorder that occurs with borderline disorder. People<br />
with bipolar II disorder do not experience manic episodes as do those with bipolar I<br />
disorder, but do experience brief hypomanic periods and recurring episodes of<br />
depression. Depressions associated with bipolar disorder appear to be related to<br />
depressions referred to as atypical depression and seasonal affective disorder (SAD).<br />
Substance Abuse Treatment in Patients with<br />
<strong>Borderline</strong> Disorder<br />
by Robert O. Friedel, MD<br />
Two-thirds of people with borderline disorder seriously abuse alcohol, street drugs, and/or<br />
prescribed drugs. This is a major factor resulting in poor outcome of people with borderline<br />
disorder. Alcohol and drugs are abused by people with borderline disorder to temporarily<br />
relieve the severe emotional pain that they experience, especially when under stress.<br />
Predictably, this relief is short lived. Even worse, the use of these substances markedly<br />
increases many of the symptoms of borderline disorder making substance abuse treatment all<br />
the more important.<br />
It is possible that some of the genetic alterations that are risk factors in borderline disorder<br />
may also be among the group of genes that predispose people to alcoholism and drug abuse.<br />
{ INCLUDEPICTURE "http://www.thehealthcarenet.com/IMAGES/ACC_Alcohol.jpg" \*<br />
MERGEFORMATINET }<br />
DSM-IV-TR Criteria for Substance Use Disorders:<br />
There are two types of substance use disorders, substance dependence and substance abuse.<br />
Substance abuse treatment is important in both types of substance use disorders.<br />
Substance Dependence<br />
A pattern of substance use that leads to significant impairment or distress in three (or more) of<br />
the following ways:<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
tolerance, as defined by either<br />
a need for markedly increased amounts of the substance to achieve the desired effect,<br />
or a markedly diminished effect with continued used of the same amount of the<br />
substance<br />
withdrawal symptoms characteristic for the substance, or increased use to relieve or<br />
avoid withdrawal symptoms<br />
the substance is taken in larger amounts or over a longer period than intended<br />
a persistent desire or unsuccessful efforts to cut down or control substance use
much time is spent in activities to obtain the substance, use the substance, or recover<br />
from its effects<br />
important social, occupational, or recreational activities are given up or reduced<br />
the substance use is continued despite it causing a persistent or recurrent physical or<br />
psychological problem (e.g., current cocaine use despite recognition of cocaineinduced<br />
depression)<br />
Self-Injurious Behaviors and Suicidality in<br />
<strong>Borderline</strong> Disorder<br />
by Robert O. Friedel, MD<br />
{ INCLUDEPICTURE "http://www.creativescreenwriting.com/csdaily/csdart/images/2005-<br />
10-Oct/Where%20the%20Truth%20Lies%20-<br />
%20I%20felt%20a%20great%20disturbance%20in%20the%20MPAA%20(350w).jpg" \*<br />
MERGEFORMATINET }
In a recent study, approximately 75 percent of women with borderline disorder engaged in<br />
self-injurious behaviors such as cutting, burning and small drug overdoses. Cutting is by far<br />
the most common act of this type. About 9 percent of people with the disorder commit<br />
suicide. The most frequent means is by drug overdose. Both types of behavior may occur in<br />
the same individual. Cutting behaviors double the risk of suicide in people with borderline<br />
disorder.<br />
Self-Injurious Behaviors<br />
In addition to cutting and burning themselves,<br />
and taking small drug overdoses, people with<br />
borderline disorder hit themselves, pull out<br />
their hair, scratch their skin to the point they<br />
open wounds, and injure themselves in other<br />
ways. Most people with the disorder who<br />
injure themselves report that they do so<br />
mainly to decrease the intense emotional pain<br />
they experience. Remarkably, they also often<br />
report that the first time they engaged in<br />
cutting and other self injurious behaviors, the<br />
idea just came to them. Finally, they report<br />
that these acts usually do result in brief<br />
emotional relief.<br />
It is important that family and other loved<br />
ones understand that this is the main motive of<br />
self injurious behaviors, not primarily to<br />
manipulate the situation or the people around them, though this is often a secondary motive.<br />
Risk Factors for Suicidality<br />
There are a number of factors that increase the risk that a person with borderline disorder will<br />
commit suicide. Although nothing can be done to reverse some of these factors, others are<br />
highly treatable, and deserve immediate attention.<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
co-occurring disorders<br />
antisocial personality disorder (higher in males)<br />
major depression<br />
substance abuse*<br />
personality characteristics<br />
impulsive aggression<br />
poor emotional control<br />
hopelessness<br />
history and severity of childhood sexual abuse<br />
age over 30 years<br />
number of prior self-injurious behaviors and suicide attempts<br />
no prior treatment, or extensive and unsuccessful treatment history
Prevalence Across the Life Cycle:<br />
Self-injurious behaviors do not appear to decrease or “burn out” with increasing age in people<br />
with borderline disorder, as do other aggressive and impulsive behaviors<br />
Management of Self-Injurious Behaviors and Suicidality<br />
General Treatment Interventions for Self-Injurious Behaviors and Suicidality:<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
careful evaluation<br />
determine the level of intent and risk of self-injurious behaviors and suicide - overt<br />
and unstated<br />
directly involve the patient and family in the process<br />
treat at the least restrictive level of care for the shortest period of time indicated<br />
aggressively treat all co-occurring disorders<br />
modify the treatment to accommodate the significant increase in severity of borderline<br />
disorder symptoms<br />
highly structure the environment<br />
identify and promptly address precipitating events<br />
assure involvement and coordination of the entire treatment team, including the family<br />
continue to balance risk vs. reward<br />
Specific Treatment Interventions: Medications<br />
Purposes<br />
<br />
<br />
reduce or eliminate co-occurring disorders, such as major depressive episodes,<br />
substance abuse, ADHD and anxiety disorders<br />
reduce core symptoms of borderline disorder: e.g., emotional dysregulation;<br />
aggressive-impulsivity; and cognitive-perceptual impairment<br />
Specific Treatment Interventions: Psychotherapy (dialectical behavior therapy-<br />
DBT; supportive therapy)<br />
Purposes<br />
<br />
<br />
reduce self-injurious behaviors and suicidality<br />
decrease the frequency of hospitalizations<br />
* Note: If you have borderline disorder and have a tendency to abuse alcohol or drugs, it<br />
is essential that you obtain help to abstain completely from doing so.
Substance Abuse<br />
A pattern of substance use that leads to significant<br />
impairment or distress in one (or more) of the<br />
following ways:<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
a failure to fulfill major role obligations at<br />
work, school, or home<br />
recurrent substance use in situations in<br />
which it is physically hazardous<br />
recurrent substance-related legal problems<br />
continued substance use despite having<br />
persistent or recurrent social or<br />
interpersonal problems caused or worsened<br />
by the effects of the substance<br />
Consequences of Abuse of Alcohol and<br />
Street Drugs in <strong>Borderline</strong> Disorder<br />
<br />
dramatic worsening of the symptoms of<br />
borderline disorder<br />
marked decrease in the effectiveness of<br />
medications and psychotherapy.<br />
addiction to and sustained craving for these substances.<br />
Substance Abuse Treatment Interventions<br />
For all of these reasons, for substance abuse treatment purposes, I strongly advise my patients<br />
with borderline disorder to not use alcohol, to not take any street drugs, and to take prescribed<br />
medications only as ordered by their physicians. In addition, I encourage those patients who<br />
have a substance-use disorder to engage fully in a substance abuse treatment program and<br />
attend support groups (Alcoholics Anonymous or Narcotics Anonymous). I also suggest to<br />
some of them that they may benefit from a trial on a medication appropriate for their specific<br />
drug dependency, as this may help reduce craving and use.<br />
Conclusions<br />
Substance use disorders are major predictors of poor short- and long-term outcome of<br />
borderline disorder.<br />
<br />
<br />
There is little or no hope of gaining control over the symptoms of borderline disorder<br />
while alcohol and other drugs are being used, no matter how appropriate the substance<br />
abuse treatment program is otherwise.<br />
Substance abuse treatment is essential if this problem co-occurs with borderline<br />
disorder.
Anxiety and Panic Attack Symptoms Co-Occurring<br />
with <strong>Borderline</strong> Disorder<br />
by Robert O. Friedel, MD<br />
Panic Attacks<br />
Have you or a loved one been diagnosed with<br />
borderline disorder and are suffering from<br />
anxiety and panic attack symptoms?<br />
Read the following article and learn more about<br />
these symptoms and how they are treated.<br />
Anxiety and panic attack symptoms are common in<br />
people with borderline disorder. Anxiety disorders<br />
occur in almost 90% of people with the disorder.<br />
If you have borderline disorder, you may<br />
experience heightened levels of anxiety and panic<br />
attack symptoms, especially at times of stress. For<br />
example, this may occur when you feel you are<br />
personally criticized and rejected, or during<br />
periods of separation from people who are very<br />
important to you. Moderate to severe anxiety may<br />
also lead to physical symptoms, such as migraine<br />
headaches, abdominal pain and irritable bowel<br />
syndrome.<br />
A panic attack is an acute and severe form of anxiety that occurs in about 50% of people with<br />
borderline disorder. Panic attacks are characterized by a discrete period of intense fear in<br />
which four or more of the following symptoms develop abruptly and reach a peak within 10<br />
minutes:<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
palpitations, pounding heart, or increased heart rate<br />
sweating<br />
trembling or shaking<br />
sensations of shortness of breath or smothering<br />
feeling of choking<br />
chest pain or discomfort<br />
nausea or abdominal distress<br />
feeling dizzy, unsteady, lightheaded, or faint<br />
feelings of unreality or being detached from oneself<br />
fear of losing control or going crazy<br />
fear of dying<br />
numbness or tingling sensations<br />
chills or hot flushes
Symptoms can appear unexpectedly and suddenly, for no apparent reason, and disappear<br />
either rapidly or slowly.<br />
People who suffer from<br />
anxiety and panic attack<br />
symptoms may also be<br />
fearful of placing<br />
themselves in<br />
circumstances from<br />
which escape may be<br />
difficult or embarrassing<br />
such as elevators,<br />
shopping malls and<br />
movie theaters. This is<br />
referred to as<br />
agoraphobia.<br />
Treatment of Anxiety and Panic Attack Symptoms in <strong>Borderline</strong> Disorder<br />
Effective treatment of disabling anxiety and panic attack symptoms in people with borderline<br />
disorder should be initiated promptly when<br />
these disorders occur. Such treatment<br />
usually consists of the use of medications<br />
and behavioral techniques.<br />
not already prescribed.<br />
The use of medications to treat anxiety and<br />
panic attack symptoms in patients with<br />
borderline disorder must proceed with care.<br />
This is so because these disorders are<br />
commonly treated with benzodiazepines<br />
(Xanax, Klonopin, Valium, etc.), that have<br />
been found to be harmful in most patients<br />
with borderline disorder because they<br />
increase impulsivity and have addictive<br />
potential. Therefore, in borderline disorder,<br />
other classes of medications are often<br />
required, such as a temporary increase in the<br />
neuroleptic, atypical antipsychotic or<br />
antidepressant medication being used to treat<br />
the disorder. Initiating the use of an<br />
antipsychotic agent or an antidepressant may<br />
prove effective for moderate to severe<br />
anxiety and panic attack symptoms if one is<br />
In addition, a course of cognitive behavioral therapy, or of biofeedback, specifically tailored<br />
to target anxiety and panic attack symptoms are often considered as part of the long-term<br />
treatment of these problems.
The Symptoms and Treatment of Attention Deficit<br />
Hyperactivity Disorder in Patients with <strong>Borderline</strong><br />
Disorder<br />
by Robert O. Friedel, MD<br />
Background<br />
Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) occurs in about 25% of people with<br />
borderline disorder; 5 times more often than it does in the general population. The symptoms<br />
of ADHD include decreased attention and concentration, easy distractibility, difficulty in the<br />
completion of tasks, and poor management of time and the space area that you use. These<br />
symptoms of ADHD result in significantly impaired school, work and social<br />
performance, and are described in detail below.<br />
ADHD is estimated to occur in about 5% of school age children. It is more common in boys<br />
than in girls. There are subtypes associated with hyperactivity and normal activity levels. The<br />
hyperactive subtype is much more common in boys, while the inattentive subtype (the<br />
subtype with normal activity levels) is somewhat more evenly distributed among boys and<br />
girls. The symptoms of ADHD are now known to persist into adulthood in many people, and<br />
to require continued treatment. There is often a strong family history of ADHD.<br />
Identifying the symptoms of ADHD in patients with <strong>Borderline</strong> Disorder is critical for their<br />
treatment plan.<br />
Symptoms of ADHD<br />
Inattention<br />
fails to give close attention to details or makes careless mistakes in school work, work,<br />
or other activities<br />
has difficulty sustaining attention in tasks or play activities<br />
does not follow through on instructions and fails to finish school work, chores, or<br />
duties in the workplace (not due to oppositional behavior or failure to understand<br />
instructions)<br />
has difficulty organizing tasks and activities<br />
avoids, dislikes, or is reluctant to engage in tasks that require sustained mental effort<br />
(such as schoolwork or homework)<br />
loses things necessary for tasks or activities (e.g., toys, school assignment, pencils,<br />
books, or tools)<br />
is easily distracted by extraneous stimuli<br />
is often forgetful in daily activities<br />
Hyperactivity<br />
fidgets with hands or feet or squirms in seat<br />
leaves seat in classroom or in other situations in which remaining seated is expected<br />
runs about or climbs excessively in situations in which it is inappropriate (in<br />
adolescents or adults, may be limited to subjective feelings of restlessness)<br />
has difficulty playing or engaging in leisure activities quietly<br />
is often “on the go” or often acts as if “driven by a motor”<br />
talks excessively
Impulsivity<br />
blurts out answers before questions have been completed<br />
has difficulty awaiting turn<br />
interrupts or intrudes on others (e.g., butts into conversations or games)<br />
Treatment of ADHD in Patients with <strong>Borderline</strong> Disorder<br />
It is not uncommon for children,<br />
teenagers and adults with<br />
borderline disorder who have<br />
some symptoms of ADHD to be<br />
misdiagnosed with ADHD, and<br />
then receive customary<br />
treatment with stimulants such<br />
as methylphenidate or an<br />
amphetamine derivative. People<br />
with borderline disorder treated<br />
with these medications typically<br />
do not do well, and may even do<br />
worse than without these<br />
medications.<br />
If borderline disorder and<br />
ADHD co-occur, patients often<br />
do worse when treated for<br />
ADHD if they first receive a<br />
medication for the symptoms of<br />
ADHD. Under these<br />
circumstances, they may then<br />
demonstrate an increase in<br />
emotionality and aggressive<br />
impulsivity. Fortunately, clinical<br />
experience and anecdotal<br />
reports in the scientific literature<br />
suggest that this problem can be<br />
effectively managed in one of<br />
two ways.<br />
When the symptoms of ADHD are mild, behavioral treatments alone may be effective,<br />
thereby avoiding the risk of increasing the symptoms of borderline disorder with a stimulant.<br />
However, if medications are required to bring the symptoms of ADHD under optimal control,<br />
it appears to be helpful to initiate treatment with a low dose of a neuroleptic or antipsychotic<br />
agent for the symptoms of borderline disorder. Doing so then appears to permit the use of a<br />
stimulant to produce a beneficial effect on the symptoms of ADHD with a minimal risk of<br />
worsening the core symptoms of borderline disorder.
RECAP : WHAT IS BPD?<br />
<strong>Borderline</strong> personality disorder is a disturbance of certain brain functions<br />
that causes four types of behavioral disturbances:<br />
1. poorly regulated and excessive emotional responses;<br />
2. harmful impulsive actions;<br />
3. distorted perceptions and impaired reasoning; and<br />
4. markedly disturbed relationships.<br />
The symptoms of borderline personaliy disorder were first described in the medical literature<br />
over 3000 years ago. The disorder has gained increasing visibility over the past three decades.<br />
The full spectrum of symptoms of bordelrine personality disorder typically first appears in the<br />
teenage years and early twenties. Although some children with significant behavioral<br />
disturbances may develop readily diagnosable borderline disorder as they get older, it is very<br />
difficult to make the diagnosis in children.<br />
After its onset, the disorder becomes chronic. Remissions, relapses, and overall significant<br />
improvement with treatment is the most common course of the illness. <strong>Borderline</strong> disorder<br />
appears to be caused by the interaction of biological, usually genetic, and environmental risk<br />
factors, such as poor parental nurturing, and early and sustained emotional, physical or sexual<br />
abuse.<br />
Physical disorders, such as migraine headaches, and other mental disorders, such as<br />
depression, anxiety, panic and substance abuse disorders, occur much more often in people<br />
with borderline disorder than they do in the general population.<br />
TREATMENTS<br />
There are six key elements of care that directly bear on the effectiveness of the treatment you<br />
receive for borderline disorder. These include your level of commitment to treatment, locating<br />
a skilled primary clinician, determining the most appropriate level of care for you, evaluating<br />
your need for medication, and selecting the type of psychotherapy and support group that will<br />
be most effective for you.<br />
Taking Responsibility<br />
If you have borderline disorder, it is essential that you understand clearly and believe deeply<br />
that you, more than anyone or anything else, have the ability and responsibility for gaining<br />
increasing control over your life.<br />
Primary Clinician<br />
You will need help. The number and complexity of decisions involved in the proper treatment<br />
of a patient with borderline disorder requires that a highly skilled clinician assumes a central<br />
role in helping you. This person is referred to as your primary clinician, and ideally will be a<br />
psychiatrist experienced in treating borderline disorder.
Level of Care<br />
Most patients with borderline disorder are most appropriately treated as outpatients. However,<br />
there are times when acute inpatient or residential care is necessary. Under most<br />
circumstances, this decision is best made by you, your primary clinician, and your family or<br />
spouse.<br />
Medications<br />
{ HYPERLINK "http://www.bpddemystified.com/index.asp?id=21" } play three very<br />
important roles in the treatment of most patients with borderline disorder. They are effective<br />
in reducing the four major groups of symptoms of the disorder. They thereby enhance the rate<br />
and quality of improvement derived from psychotherapy. Finally, medications are effective in<br />
treating other emotional disorders that frequently are associated with borderline disorder, for<br />
example, depression, anxiety/panic attacks, and ADHD, and physical disorders such as<br />
migraine headaches.<br />
Psychotherapy<br />
Psychotherapy is also an important component of your treatment program. A number of<br />
different psychotherapeutic approaches appear to be effective in the treatment of borderline<br />
disorder. These include supportive, psychodynamic and modified psychoanalytic therapy,<br />
interpersonal therapy, dialectical behavior therapy (DBT), cognitive behavior therapy (CBT),<br />
and a variety of group and family therapies.<br />
Education and Support<br />
During the past decade, an increasing number of educational and support groups have been<br />
formed for patients with borderline disorder, and for their families. Many of these have been<br />
the result of the efforts of lay advocacy groups dedicated to increasing knowledge about, and<br />
reducing the stigma associated with borderline disorder.<br />
Patient and Family Educational Programs<br />
A growing number of educational programs are being conducted for people with borderline<br />
disorder and their families. These are often co-sponsored by community organizations<br />
working with the assistance of consumer and family organizations such as the National<br />
Education Alliance for <strong>Borderline</strong> Personality Disorder (NEA-BPD), the Treatment and<br />
Research Advancements National Association for Personality Disorder (TARA), and the<br />
National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI).<br />
A recent addition to the therapeutic opportunities for family members of people with<br />
borderline disorder has been the introduction of family educational and training programs.<br />
Family Connections<br />
The family education program, Family Connections (FC), is available in multiple locations<br />
throughout the US, and at several locations in Canada, Europe and the UK. It operates under<br />
the auspices of NEA-BPD with research funding from the National Institute of Mental Health.<br />
Experienced family members co-lead the 12-week manualized series of sessions for other<br />
families. These sessions provide participants with the most current information and research<br />
about borderline disorder, teach DBT and family coping skills, and provide an opportunity to<br />
develop a support network.<br />
Research documents a reduction in family member depression, burden, and grief and an
increase in coping skills. No registration fee is required, but in some locations a donation to<br />
cover costs of the course materials is suggested.
Family-to-Family<br />
The National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) has recently designated borderline disorder<br />
as a “priority population.” In doing so, NAMI has now extended its popular 12 week Family<br />
Education Program to include this disorder. The course is taught by trained NAMI volunteers<br />
in every state in the country. It provides a broad range of information essential to those caring<br />
for loved ones with borderline and other serious mental disorders.<br />
Family Training Workshop<br />
TARA sponsors an eight session DBT family training workshop in New York City and other<br />
cities across the country. The main goals of the program are similar to that provided by NEA-<br />
BPD. Each training cycle is limited to sixteen members, and a registration fee is required.<br />
Support Groups<br />
In some communities, groups of people with borderline disorder and family members meet on<br />
a regular basis, without a therapist or trained and skilled group leader, to help one another.<br />
Such support groups typically do not charge members a fee and can be very beneficial for the<br />
reasons cited above for therapist-assisted group therapy.<br />
There are two types of support groups:<br />
groups for the person with borderline disorder<br />
groups for their family members<br />
Although it may be helpful, participation in such groups should be approached with caution<br />
by the person with borderline disorder or family members. Considerable harm can be done if<br />
one or more individuals in the group act in an angry, manipulative, malicious, or otherwise<br />
inappropriate and destructive way toward another group member or the group as a whole.<br />
Without a skilled leader or facilitator present to step in to handle the situation promptly and<br />
properly, a member of the group, and even the group itself, may be exposed to significant<br />
trauma.<br />
Prior to joining a support group, it is wise to seek recommendations about groups in your<br />
community from your nearest NAMI Chapter, or from mental health professionals working<br />
with patients with borderline disorder. In addition, it may be helpful to request information<br />
from members of such groups before joining.<br />
Conclusion<br />
In summary, there are a number of different levels of care, medications, and individual and {<br />
HYPERLINK "http://www.bpddemystified.com/index.asp?id=22" \l "6" } approaches that can<br />
be utilized to help you gain increasing control over your life. The treatment plan that works<br />
best for another patient may not be appropriate or work well for you. Therefore, it is very<br />
important that you work closely with your psychiatrist and other mental health professionals<br />
to formulate that treatment plan that will produce the best results under your specific<br />
circumstances.