23.10.2014 Views

by Jean DERMINE. * Associate Professor of Finance, INSEAD ...

by Jean DERMINE. * Associate Professor of Finance, INSEAD ...

by Jean DERMINE. * Associate Professor of Finance, INSEAD ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

"DEPOSIT INSURANCE, CREDIT RISK<br />

AND CAPITAL ADEQUACY: A NOTE"<br />

<strong>by</strong><br />

<strong>Jean</strong> <strong>DERMINE</strong>.<br />

N° 92/I9/FIN<br />

* <strong>Associate</strong> <strong>Pr<strong>of</strong>essor</strong> <strong>of</strong> <strong>Finance</strong>, <strong>INSEAD</strong>, Boulevard de Constance,<br />

Fontainebleau 77305 Cedex, France.<br />

Printed at <strong>INSEAD</strong>,<br />

Fontainebleau, France


DEPOSIT INSURANCE, CREDIT RISK AND CAPITAL ADEQUACY, a Note<br />

<strong>by</strong> <strong>Jean</strong> Dermine*<br />

<strong>INSEAD</strong>,Fontainebleau<br />

March 1992<br />

*Research undertaken while the author was Visiting Fellow at New York University<br />

Salomon Center. The author acknowledges the insightful comments <strong>of</strong> Mark Flannery,<br />

Itzhak Swary and participants <strong>of</strong> the University <strong>of</strong> Florida (Gainsville) <strong>Finance</strong> Seminar and<br />

<strong>of</strong> the Seminario de Economia Financiera <strong>of</strong> the Fundacion Banco Bilbao Vizcaya,<br />

Barcelona.


Abstract<br />

DEPOSIT INSURANCE, CREDIT RISK AND CAPITAL ADEQUACY, a Note<br />

Previous research on deposit insurance and capital adequacy has modeled the bank<br />

as a corporate firm with risky assets and insured liabilities. No attempt was made to analyze<br />

explicitly the risk characteristics <strong>of</strong> bank assets. The purpose <strong>of</strong> this paper is to model bank<br />

lending and calculate credit-risk sensitive insurance premia. The lending function <strong>of</strong> banks<br />

creates the need to model equity as a 'capped' call option. Previous estimates <strong>of</strong> insurance<br />

premia which are based on a 'naked' call assumption could be biased. Moreover, it is shown<br />

that the Modigliani-Miller capital structure irrelevance theorem implies the ineffectiveness<br />

<strong>of</strong> bank capital regulations.


1<br />

The seminal work <strong>by</strong> Black and Scholes (1973) on the valuation <strong>of</strong> options has led<br />

to four applications in the banking literature : Pricing <strong>of</strong> deposit insurance (Merton<br />

(1977,1978), Pennacchi (1987), Allen and Saunders (1990)), design <strong>of</strong> capital requirement<br />

(Pyle (1986), Ronn and Verma (1989)), risk premium evaluation on bank subordinated debt<br />

(Gorton and Santomero,1990), and determination <strong>of</strong> examination schedules (Kuester and<br />

O'Brien, 1991). Applied papers <strong>by</strong> Marcus and Shaked (1984), Ronn and Verma<br />

(1986,1987), and Giammarino, Schwartz and Zechner (1990) elicit from observable market<br />

data the necessary parameters to evaluate deposit insurance premia. A constant in these<br />

papers is that the role <strong>of</strong> banks as financial intermediaries is not modeled explicitly. The<br />

bank is considered as a corporate firm with insured liabilities and risky assets that follow<br />

a Wiener process. Equity, subordinated debt, deposits or deposit insurance liability are<br />

priced as contingent claims on the assets <strong>of</strong> the bank. Equity is equivalent to a call option,<br />

while the deposit insurance liability is modeled as a put option. Two exceptions in this<br />

literature are McCulloch (1984) and Crouhy and Galai (1986, 1991) who model explicitly<br />

the maturity transformation role <strong>of</strong> banks and who calculate interest-sensitive risk premia.<br />

The purpose <strong>of</strong> this paper is to provide an analysis <strong>of</strong> credit-risk sensitive insurance premia.<br />

The motivation is tw<strong>of</strong>old. First, lending is an essential function <strong>of</strong> banks. A FDIC study<br />

(1983) reports that the prime cause <strong>of</strong> bank failure is credit risk in 75 % <strong>of</strong> the cases. An<br />

explicit formulation <strong>of</strong> credit risk should provide more information on the underlying<br />

exposure <strong>of</strong> deposit insurers. Secondly, the empirical studies <strong>by</strong> Marcus-Shaked (1984),<br />

Ronn-Verma (1986) and King-O'Brien (1991) yield a positive correlation between the<br />

market capitalisation-to-deposit ratio <strong>of</strong> banks and the variance <strong>of</strong> asset returns. Strongly<br />

capitalized banks would hold riskier assets. One does wonder whether this result can be<br />

caused <strong>by</strong> a misspecification <strong>of</strong> the valuation functions.<br />

The results are as follows. Firstly, the lending function <strong>of</strong> banks creates specific risk<br />

characteristics and the necessity to model the equity <strong>of</strong> a bank as a call option which is


2<br />

being capped. Previous empirical estimates <strong>of</strong> insurance premia that are based on a 'naked'<br />

call assumption could be biased. Highly leveraged banks in the Ronn-Verma sample appear<br />

to hold riskier assets, increasing substantially the liability <strong>of</strong> the deposit insurer. Secondly,<br />

the depositors are protected <strong>by</strong> two equity cushions : Those <strong>of</strong> the bank and <strong>of</strong> the<br />

borrowers. It is shown that the Modigliani-Miller capital structure irrelevance theorem<br />

implies the ineffectiveness <strong>of</strong> bank capital regulations.<br />

The paper is organized as follows. The theoretical valuation model is developed in<br />

Section One. The ineffectiveness <strong>of</strong> bank capital regulations in a Modigliani-Miller world<br />

is proven in Section Two. A numerical analysis <strong>of</strong> the effect <strong>of</strong> misspecification on the<br />

market-based estimation <strong>of</strong> insurance premia follows in Section Three.<br />

SECTION ONE : THE VALUATION MODEL<br />

The standard contingent claim approach is applied to a bank-borrower situation. A<br />

firm is funding an asset (market value =A E) with a bank loan (Lf) and equity (E r). The bank<br />

funds the loan with insured deposits (D b) and equity (Eb). The promised payments on the<br />

zero coupon loan and deposits, L and D respectively, are set in a perfectly competitive<br />

market. Loans and deposits have a maturity T. The balance sheets <strong>of</strong> the firm and <strong>of</strong> the<br />

bank are as follows :<br />

Af<br />

Lf (L) Db (D)<br />

Ef<br />

Eb<br />

The Firm The Bank'<br />

The market value <strong>of</strong> the asset <strong>of</strong> the firm varies continuously over the time interval<br />

(0,T) according to the stochastic process<br />

'The balance sheet <strong>of</strong> the bank does not include the fixed insurance premium which has<br />

been paid upon receipt <strong>of</strong> the deposits.


3<br />

dAt = pAtd, + oAtdWt,<br />

where p is the instantaneous expected rate <strong>of</strong> return on the asset, a is the instantaneous<br />

standard deviation <strong>of</strong> the return and W t is a Wiener process. The stochastic process implies<br />

that the value <strong>of</strong> the asset A, will follow a lognormal distribution.<br />

As is well known from option theory (Black and Scholes,1973), the market value <strong>of</strong><br />

the equity <strong>of</strong> the bank (MVE) is a call option on the asset <strong>of</strong> the bank, that is<br />

MVE = Call (Value <strong>of</strong> loan, D)<br />

= Call (L-Put(A, L), D),<br />

i.e., the ability to buy the asset <strong>of</strong> the bank at an exercise price D. The value <strong>of</strong> the asset<br />

<strong>of</strong> the bank is the promised payment on the loan (L) reduced <strong>by</strong> a put option given to the<br />

borrower who can sell his end-<strong>of</strong>-period asset A at a price L. Applying the Put-Call-Parity<br />

theorem to the value <strong>of</strong> the asset <strong>of</strong> the bank, one obtains :<br />

e'rTL-Put (A,L) = Call(L-Put(A, L), D) + D.e -rT -Put(L-Put( A, L), D) (1).<br />

The asset <strong>of</strong> the bank is equal to the equity (the call), plus the discounted value <strong>of</strong><br />

the exercise price (D) minus the liability <strong>of</strong> the insurer (the put). This allows to write the<br />

market value <strong>of</strong> the equity <strong>of</strong> the bank (MVE) as follows :<br />

MVE = Call = - Put(A, L)) - D.er + Put(L-Put(A, L), D)<br />

= + Put(A, D) (2).<br />

The simplification <strong>of</strong> the insurance liability occurs because the put on the asset <strong>of</strong> the bank<br />

will only be exercised when the bank defaults, that is when the borrower defaults and hands<br />

his assets A to the bank2.<br />

2The assumption <strong>of</strong> equal maturity for deposits and loans permits this simplification.<br />

Otherwise, the value <strong>of</strong> bank assets, at the deposit maturity date, would be equal to L-<br />

Put(A,L).


4<br />

Graphically, the value <strong>of</strong> the equity <strong>of</strong> the bank can be represented as follows :<br />

MVE<br />

L—D<br />

D b D L f<br />

L A f<br />

A<br />

Lb<br />

Ef<br />

Figure One : The Market Value <strong>of</strong> the Bank's Equity<br />

The value <strong>of</strong> the equity <strong>of</strong> the bank is bounded upward <strong>by</strong> a cap, the promised loan<br />

payment (L) net <strong>of</strong> the deposit (D). It is bounded downward <strong>by</strong> the put received from the<br />

deposit insurer. The upward sloping segment represents the borrower's default case with the<br />

bank holding the end-<strong>of</strong>-period asset A. At the beginning <strong>of</strong> the period, the asset Af is equal<br />

to the sum <strong>of</strong> deposits and equities <strong>of</strong> the bank and <strong>of</strong> the borrower. An alternative way to<br />

interpret the risk characteristics is to observe that the deposits and equity <strong>of</strong> the bank are<br />

equivalent to a senior claim and subordinated debt on the assets <strong>of</strong> the borrower. The<br />

depositors are protected <strong>by</strong> a double cushion coming from the equity <strong>of</strong> the borrower and<br />

<strong>of</strong> the bank. The bank shareholders received a fixed payment when the borrower is solvent,<br />

and hold the borrower's asset when he defaults.<br />

In this model, the liability <strong>of</strong> the deposit insurer is modeled as a put on the asset <strong>of</strong><br />

the borrower,<br />

Deposit Insurance Liability = Putins = Put(A, D) (3).<br />

Applying the Risk Neutral Valuation methodology 3 and denoting <strong>by</strong> N(.) the<br />

3A detailed application <strong>of</strong> the Risk Neutral Valuation method to subordinated debt is<br />

available in Black and Cox (1976), and Smith (1980).


cumulative normal distribution and <strong>by</strong> r the risk free interest rate, one obtains :<br />

5<br />

MVE=AI N(<br />

in(<br />

, 02<br />

f<br />

D )+(e+ 2 —)T<br />

ovy,<br />

02<br />

In(-9+(r--)T<br />

e -"D N( D 2<br />

aft<br />

A, 02 A, n2<br />

ln()+(r+-)T In(--2)+(r--=)T<br />

L 2 L 2<br />

- Al N(<br />

)+e -"L N( ) (4).<br />

=. g--<br />

°IT <strong>of</strong>t<br />

Equation (4) can be interpreted as the value <strong>of</strong> a call on the asset A <strong>of</strong> the borrower<br />

at an exercise price D, net <strong>of</strong> a call given to the borrower on the same asset at an exercise<br />

price L The last two terms represent the loss <strong>of</strong> value resulting from the cap. It is a<br />

decreasing value <strong>of</strong> the loan repayment, going to zero as L goes to infinity. The case<br />

analyzed in the literature (the 'naked' call) is a limit case <strong>of</strong> the 'capped' valuation.<br />

The liability <strong>of</strong> the deposit insurer is valued as follows :<br />

A, n2 A, n2<br />

+(r+=-)T<br />

2<br />

PUTIns = e-"D(1-N( )-441(1-N( D2 )) (5).<br />

a vt<br />

The valuation <strong>of</strong> the insurance liability is similar to the put option discussed in the<br />

literature, except that the underlying asset is the one <strong>of</strong> the borrower.


Moreover, the variance <strong>of</strong> the bank equity return is given <strong>by</strong>`<br />

6<br />

2<br />

A, °<br />

In—t-+(r+z—)T --z In--L+(r+=—)T<br />

A<br />

2.rw 2 2<br />

)-N(<br />

I 4<br />

f xo2A (6).<br />

)(Vs v<br />

mv E<br />

The variance <strong>of</strong> equity returns differs significantly from the one <strong>of</strong> a naked call. It<br />

can be seen that it is an increasing function <strong>of</strong> L, equal to the variance <strong>of</strong> a 'naked' call as<br />

L goes to infinity.<br />

The explicit analysis <strong>of</strong> bank lending and credit risk has two implications. Firstly, the<br />

equity <strong>of</strong> the bank is equivalent to a 'capped' call. In 'good' economic states, the value <strong>of</strong><br />

equity cannot exceed the promised payment on the loan net <strong>of</strong> the deposit repayment. This<br />

observation is independent <strong>of</strong> the maturity <strong>of</strong> the loan. Secondly, the liability <strong>of</strong> the deposit<br />

insurer is directly related to the risk on the borrower's asset, the maturity <strong>of</strong> the deposit and<br />

a leverage defined as the deposits to borrower's asset ratio. In the next section, it is shown<br />

that the Modigliani-Miller capital structure irrelevance theorem implies the ineffectiveness<br />

<strong>of</strong> bank capital regulations.<br />

*This follows from equation (2) and the expression for the random return on a put<br />

option (P) on an asset (A) :<br />

A xr r .6x—<br />

put p A<br />

where 6 is the standard delta on a put option and r A is the random return on the underlying<br />

asset (Galai and Masulis,1976).


7<br />

SECTION TWO : THE INEFFECTIVENESS OF BANK CAPITAL REGULATIONS<br />

Let us first assume that an increase in bank equity (AEI) is compensated <strong>by</strong> a deposit<br />

reduction <strong>of</strong> an equivalent amount. The market value <strong>of</strong> the bank equity becomes :<br />

MVE=Lr(De -'T- AEb)+Put(A,D- AEbel) (7).<br />

The change in the market value is the difference between equations (7) and (2) :<br />

AMY E. A E b-(Put(A,D)-Put(A,D- AEber7)).<br />

The increase in market value is equal to the increase in equity less the reduction in the<br />

deposit insurance liability5. Since the increase in market value is less than the issue <strong>of</strong><br />

equity, the stock price would go down. A possible way to retain the deposit insurance<br />

subsidy is to keep constant the volume <strong>of</strong> deposits and increase the amount lent to finance<br />

the asset Af <strong>by</strong> AEb. The promised reimbursement on the loan, L., is calculated to increase<br />

the value <strong>of</strong> the loan <strong>by</strong> AE b. In this case, the market value <strong>of</strong> the bank equity becomes :<br />

MVE = (Lt + AEb) - Db Put(A,D)<br />

= (re-'r - Put(A,L.)) - Db Put(A,D) (8).<br />

The bank keeps the insurance subsidy and, with respect to equation (2), the change in the<br />

market value <strong>of</strong> the bank equity becomes AE b, leaving the price per share constant. It<br />

remains to be shown under which circumstances the borrower would accept such lending<br />

terms. In a 'Modigliani-Miller capital structure irrelevance' world, an increase in the bank<br />

5For expository convenience,we have assumed that the insurance premium is<br />

independent <strong>of</strong> the volume <strong>of</strong> deposits.If this was not the case,part <strong>of</strong> the proportional<br />

insurance premium paid to the insurer would be returned to the bank.


8<br />

loan (ALI = AEb) would be fully compensated <strong>by</strong> a decrease in equity ( A -Ef)and the value <strong>of</strong><br />

the borrower's assets (and price per share) would remain constant. The capital structure<br />

irrelevance theorem implies the ineffectiveness <strong>of</strong> bank capital regulations.<br />

This straightforward proposition that an increase in bank capital can be <strong>of</strong>fset <strong>by</strong> an<br />

increase in the leverage <strong>of</strong> the borrower has not received much attention in the theoretical<br />

literature, although it is well recognized that bank capital regulations can be defeated <strong>by</strong> an<br />

increase in the variance <strong>of</strong> return on assets (Kareken,1987)6. The sources <strong>of</strong> wealth transfers<br />

from deposit insurance to banks are similar to those found in the literature (Li. Furlong and<br />

Kealey, 1989), except that attention is paid explicitly to the risk characteristics <strong>of</strong> the<br />

borrower. An increase in the variance <strong>of</strong> asset return, or an increase in the bank leverage<br />

increases the value <strong>of</strong> the bank equity. Indeed from equation (2) and keeping constant the<br />

current value <strong>of</strong> the loan, L1 , one has :<br />

a AIVE a Put<br />

amvE<br />

0Put<br />

> 0 = - 1 + — > - 1 .<br />

a 02<br />

a a' ap, ap b<br />

ADeiti-Ebi<br />

Similarly, increasing the borrower leverage (A -A 1<br />

= A.E1, ADb = AEb = AL1 = 0), or increasing<br />

simultaneously the leverage <strong>of</strong> the borrower and <strong>of</strong> the bank<br />

( 1A-E1 AilDb, AAf = AEb = 0) transfer wealth to the bank shareholders :<br />

amvE ()Put amv 8Put<br />

< 0 ; > O.<br />

8D b no<br />

a41 ilDetaf Efi b<br />

In the next section, we assess the impact <strong>of</strong> misspecification on the market-based<br />

estimates <strong>of</strong> deposit insurance premia .<br />

6One will observe that the international regulations on bank capital implemented <strong>by</strong> the<br />

Bank for International Settlements or the European Community make no reference to the<br />

leverage <strong>of</strong> borrowers.<br />

'Full information is assumed, so that the terms <strong>of</strong> the loan, C, are adjusted to keep<br />

constant the current value <strong>of</strong> the loan.


9<br />

SECTION THREE : MISSPECIFICATION AND INSURANCE PREMIUM<br />

ESTIMATES<br />

It has been shown that the lending function <strong>of</strong> banks creates a specific risk structure<br />

and the necessity to model the equity <strong>of</strong> banks as 'capped' call options. Ronn-Verma (1986)<br />

have used market-based data and the assumption <strong>of</strong> a 'naked' call option to estimate fair<br />

insurance premia. One can wonder whether a cap would alter their estimates significantly.<br />

An additional motivation is that their empirical results yield an (unreported) positive<br />

correlation <strong>of</strong> 0.43 between the estimated variance <strong>of</strong> bank assets and the market<br />

capitalization-to-deposit ratio. In an earlier study <strong>by</strong> Marcus and Shaked (1984), the<br />

correlation is even higher, 0.73. Strongly capitalized banks appear to hold riskier assetss.<br />

An exlanation consistent with the option-based model is that a high variance <strong>of</strong> asset return<br />

increases the subsidy derived from deposit insurance and the capitalised market value <strong>of</strong><br />

banks. However, this line <strong>of</strong> reasoning is not validated empirically. Indeed, the correlation<br />

between the estimated variance <strong>of</strong> asset return and an 'adjusted' capitalised value (observed<br />

capitalised value net <strong>of</strong> a fair deposit insurance premium) remains positive. An alternative<br />

explanation is that a mispecification in the valuation model could bias the estimate <strong>of</strong> the<br />

variance <strong>of</strong> asset return.<br />

Two tests <strong>of</strong> the robustness <strong>of</strong> deposit insurance premium estimates are reported. In<br />

the first one, we provide numerical examples to test the sensitivity <strong>of</strong> insurance premium<br />

estimates to the existence <strong>of</strong> caps and to assess the direction <strong>of</strong> the biases. In the second<br />

one, we test the robustness <strong>of</strong> the Ronn-Verma estimates.<br />

The sensitivity <strong>of</strong> insurance premia. a numerical exercise<br />

The numerical exercise is designed as follows. Starting from a set <strong>of</strong> assumptions on<br />

alCuester and O'Brien (1991) report a positive Spearman rank correlation coefficient<br />

between asset return standard deviation and market capitalisation-to-asset ratio.


10<br />

the value <strong>of</strong> the asset <strong>of</strong> a borrower, the variance <strong>of</strong> its return, the size <strong>of</strong> the loan and the<br />

bank equity-to-asset ratio, we calculate the market value <strong>of</strong> the bank equity, the standard<br />

deviation <strong>of</strong> its return and the insurance premium which are consistent with equations (4)<br />

to (6). In a second step, we apply the Ronn-Verma methodology 9 to the 'observable'<br />

computed values obtained for the bank equity and the variance <strong>of</strong> its return. A 'naked 'call<br />

methodology is applied in a 'capped' world to assess the extent <strong>of</strong> the bias.<br />

In the first example, we consider an asset <strong>of</strong> 100 with variance <strong>of</strong> 0.1 financed with<br />

a loan <strong>of</strong> 70. We let the bank equity-to-asset ratio fluctuate between 1 % and 10 %. It is<br />

assumed that a competitive risk free interest rate <strong>of</strong> 7 % is paid on bank deposits and that<br />

the loan is priced in a perfectly competitive market, that is the terms <strong>of</strong> the loan are such<br />

that its market value is equal to its book value L 1°. In line with the literature, we assume<br />

a short maturity <strong>of</strong> one year for deposits".<br />

Insert Table One.<br />

As expected, the (q) ratio <strong>of</strong> the market value <strong>of</strong> the equity <strong>of</strong> the bank to its book<br />

value increases sharply with leverage as the bank extracts a rent from the deposit insurance<br />

agency. The 'q' ratio jumps from 1.11 to 3.27 as the equity-to-asset ratio decreases from<br />

9Ronn and Verma (1986) solve for the value <strong>of</strong> bank asset (V) and its variance a<br />

system <strong>of</strong> two non-linear equations<br />

MVE=Call(V,D)=VN(C-De'N(c12)<br />

a mv, - ExN(d )xo v<br />

MV<br />

1<br />

02<br />

where di=((inVID)+ (r )7)/0 [T<br />

2<br />

d2=di-og<br />

The value and variance <strong>of</strong> the assets are used to calculate the risk insurance premium.<br />

1°A discussion on the sharing <strong>of</strong> the insurance rent is available in Ronn and Verma<br />

(1986). The cumulative normal approximation discussed in Figlewski, Silber and<br />

Subrahmanyam (1990) is used for the calculations.<br />

"From the point <strong>of</strong> view <strong>of</strong> a deposit insurer,the effective maturity <strong>of</strong> deposits could be<br />

longer,if a poor marketability <strong>of</strong> bank loans forces the insurer to refinance the portfolio for<br />

a longer period.


11<br />

10 % to 1 %. The last three columns report the 'Ronn-Verma' estimates for the market<br />

value <strong>of</strong> asset, the variance and the insurance premium. Three observation stand out. The<br />

first is an undervaluation <strong>of</strong> the asset <strong>of</strong> the borrower <strong>by</strong> an order <strong>of</strong> 30 % and an<br />

undervaluation <strong>of</strong> the variance <strong>of</strong> the asset return <strong>by</strong> a factor <strong>of</strong> 10. Secondly, these biases<br />

affect the estimate <strong>of</strong> the insurance premium in opposite ways. The undervaluation <strong>of</strong> the<br />

assets backing deposits raises the premium, while the undervaluation <strong>of</strong> variance lowers it.<br />

In this numerical example, the net effect is an undervaluation <strong>of</strong> the insurance premium as<br />

long as the bank equity-to-asset ratio exceeds 2 %. Finally, the bias in the estimates <strong>of</strong> the<br />

variance and the asset are the largest, the lowest the bank equity to asset ratio12.<br />

In Table Two, we consider a higher degree <strong>of</strong> leverage for the borrower (90 %) and<br />

various degrees <strong>of</strong> bank leverage. As in Table One, the biases in the estimates <strong>of</strong> assets and<br />

variance are the largest for the highly leveraged bank cases, but the variance is<br />

overestimated so that the bias in the insurance premium is always positive. Finally, in Table<br />

Three, we consider a constant leverage for the bank (8%), but the leverage <strong>of</strong> the borrower<br />

is increased from 30 to 90 %. The bank 'q' ratio increases from 1 to 1.68, while the bias in<br />

the insurance premium goes from an undervaluation for a low level <strong>of</strong> indebtness to an<br />

overvaluation <strong>of</strong> in the highly leveraged situation.<br />

Insert Table Two and Three<br />

The main results <strong>of</strong> the numerical exercises are to show that the biases resulting from<br />

the application <strong>of</strong> the Ronn-Verma methodology in a 'capped' world can be significant and<br />

that the direction <strong>of</strong> the bias cannot be signed. It depends on the financial structures <strong>of</strong> the<br />

bank and <strong>of</strong> the borrower.<br />

In the final part <strong>of</strong> the paper, we investigate to what extent the Ronn-Verma<br />

estimates are robust with respect to alternative specifications.<br />

12With reference to the ineffectiveness <strong>of</strong> bank capital regulation discussed in Section<br />

Two,it can easily be shown that an increase in bank equity from 8 to 10 % (a 25 % relative<br />

increase) necessitates an increase in the loan from 70 to 71.55 ( a relative increase <strong>of</strong> 5 %<br />

in the borrower equity-to-asset ratio) to keep the insurance-based subsidy constant.


12<br />

The robustness the Ronn-Verma estimates<br />

The application <strong>of</strong> the 'capped' methodology to real world data raises an interesting<br />

issue. Indeed, one could argue that the assumption <strong>of</strong> a normal distribution for the return<br />

on bank assets is justified <strong>by</strong> a Central Limit Theorem applying to a sum <strong>of</strong> independent<br />

assets or <strong>by</strong> the fact that factors other than credit risk affect the value <strong>of</strong> bank assets, such<br />

as interest rate fluctuations. The Central Limit Theorem argument is doubtful for the<br />

following reason. Recent research on credit risk (Chirinko-Gui11,1991) reports a large<br />

correlation between the activity levels <strong>of</strong> industries so that one can not rely on a sum <strong>of</strong><br />

independent variables to describe credit risk. Presumably, in good states <strong>of</strong> the economy,<br />

loan losses are small and the assets <strong>of</strong> the bank are capped <strong>by</strong> the sum <strong>of</strong> promised<br />

payments, while in bad states, there are many defaults and banks end up owning the assets<br />

<strong>of</strong> borrowers. The effect <strong>of</strong> interest rate fluctuations on the value <strong>of</strong> bank assets is a more<br />

powerful criticism, but it has been reported that interest rate risk is small relative to credit<br />

risk (FDIC,1983). Moreover, interest rates are bounded downward at zero, so that the value<br />

<strong>of</strong> bank assets is limited upward <strong>by</strong> the sum <strong>of</strong> promised cash flows.<br />

In the analysis that follows, we assume that the value <strong>of</strong> the bank assets, which<br />

follows a lognormal distribution, is capped at some level. This assumption hides complex<br />

issues <strong>of</strong> aggregation <strong>of</strong> loans <strong>of</strong> different maturities granted to various industries. It<br />

attempts to reflect the fact that the assets <strong>of</strong> banks are capped <strong>by</strong> the promised repayments<br />

in good states <strong>of</strong> the economy, while their value fluctuate much more in bad states. The<br />

unbounded distribution assumed <strong>by</strong> Ronn-Verma is a limit case and the sensitivity <strong>of</strong><br />

insurance premia estimates with respect to the caps becomes an empirical issue. Following<br />

Ronn-Verma, we take the observed market value <strong>of</strong> the equity and the variance <strong>of</strong> equity<br />

return to estimate the value <strong>of</strong> bank assets, the variance and the deposit insurance premium.<br />

We use the 1983 (quarter IV) data provided in Ronn-Verma (1986) to test the sensitivity<br />

<strong>of</strong> their estimates to various cap assumptions. A major difficulty arises in this exercise.<br />

Whereas Ronn and Verma have a two-equation systems to evaluate two unknowns, the asset<br />

and the variance, we have two equations to evaluate three parameters : The asset, the<br />

variance and the cap. In other words, the existence <strong>of</strong> a cap does not allow to evaluate the


13<br />

insurance premia using market based data 13. What can be done is a test the sensitivity <strong>of</strong><br />

the insurance premium estimates to various cap assumptions.<br />

Insert Table Four<br />

The robustness <strong>of</strong> the Ronn-Verma estimates is evaluated for two sets <strong>of</strong> four heavily<br />

leveraged and strongly capitalized banks. As reported in Table Four, the Ronn-Verma<br />

estimates <strong>of</strong> the standard deviation <strong>of</strong> asset return are the highest for the strongly<br />

capitalized banks, such as Wachovia or JP Morgan. To test the robustness <strong>of</strong> their estimates,<br />

the 'capped' valuation model is applied. The cap on the asset <strong>of</strong> the leveraged banks has<br />

been set to allow the capitalisation value <strong>of</strong> the bank to increase <strong>by</strong> 200 %. As the market<br />

value <strong>of</strong> leveraged banks is very low, this assumption could penalize those banks. So in a<br />

second case, we allow the capitalisation value <strong>of</strong> leveraged banks to reach the book value<br />

<strong>of</strong> equity, while the return on well capitalized banks is limited to 25 %. As is shown in Table<br />

Four, the caps raise the insurance premium <strong>of</strong> the highly leveraged banks considerably. For<br />

instance, the insurance premium <strong>of</strong> First Pennsylvania is raised from 0.5 % to 8.5 %. The<br />

increase results from a substantially higher estimate <strong>of</strong> the variance <strong>of</strong> asset return. As<br />

concerns the strongly capitalized banks, the Ronn-Verma estimates for the insurance<br />

premium are shown to be robust with respect to various caps, 200 % increase in<br />

capitalisation value or a restrictive 25 . Whatever the caps, the insurance premium<br />

remains close to zero.<br />

The main conclusion <strong>of</strong> the test <strong>of</strong> robustness <strong>of</strong> the Ronn-Verma estimates is that<br />

the low insurance premium reported for the highly leveraged banks is highly dependent on<br />

the assumption <strong>of</strong> an unbounded distribution. Caps raise the insurance premium estimates<br />

quite substantially. However, the 'zero premium' estimates obtained for the strongly<br />

capitalized institutions are quite robust with respect to alternative specifications. The<br />

observation that highly leveraged banks hold riskier assets seems reasonable. These banks<br />

130ne has to be reminded that the variance <strong>of</strong> assets cannot be evaluated directly.The<br />

value <strong>of</strong> assets is unobservable since it depends on the insurance premium.


14<br />

hold a large portfolio <strong>of</strong> doubtful loans the value <strong>of</strong> which is closely dependent on the assets<br />

<strong>of</strong> the borrowers. In the case <strong>of</strong> strongly capitalized banks, the portfolio <strong>of</strong> doubtful loans<br />

is smaller so that the value <strong>of</strong> bank assets is less dependent on the assets <strong>of</strong> the borrowers<br />

because <strong>of</strong> the cap on the promised payments.<br />

As the two-equation system does not allow the simultaneous estimation <strong>of</strong> the cap,<br />

one will have to rely on judgment or additional information to evaluate the relevance <strong>of</strong> the<br />

cap assumption for the highly leveraged banks.<br />

The objective <strong>of</strong> the paper is to show that bank lending and credit risk create a<br />

specific stochastic process for the asset <strong>of</strong> a bank. Equity is isomorphic to a 'capped' call and<br />

the leverage relevant for the insurer is the deposits to borrower's asset ratio. It has been<br />

shown that 'call' evaluations <strong>of</strong> insurance premia could be biased when credit risk is the<br />

significant risk factor. A bias is likely to arise for highly leveraged banks, but appear to be<br />

small for strongly capitalized ones. Furthermore, a straightforward policy conclusion is that<br />

capital regulation can be <strong>of</strong>fset <strong>by</strong> a relatively small increase in the leverage <strong>of</strong> the<br />

borrowers. To be efficient, capital adequacy regulations must take into account the leverage<br />

<strong>of</strong> borrowers.


15<br />

REFERENCES<br />

Allen,Linda and Anthony Saunders : "Forbearance and Valuation <strong>of</strong> Deposit Insurance as<br />

a Callable Put", mimeo, New York University, 1990.<br />

Black,Fischer and Myron Scholes :"The Pricing <strong>of</strong> Options and Corporate Liabilities",<br />

Journal <strong>of</strong> Political Economy, 81, May-June 1973,637-659.<br />

Black, Fischer and John C. Cox : "Valuing Corporate Securities, Some Effects from Bond<br />

Indentures", Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Finance</strong>, 31, May 1976,351-367.<br />

Chirinko Robert S. and Gene D. Guill : "A Framework for Assessing Credit Risk in<br />

Depository Institutions : Toward Regulatory Reform", Journal <strong>of</strong> Banking and <strong>Finance</strong>, 15,<br />

September 1991, 785-804.<br />

Crouhy,Michel and Dan Galai :"An Economic Assessment <strong>of</strong> Capital Requirement ", Journal<br />

<strong>of</strong> Banking and <strong>Finance</strong> 10, June 1986,231-242.<br />

Crouhy,Michel and Dan Galai :"A Contingent Claim Analysis <strong>of</strong> a Regulated Depository<br />

Institution", Journal <strong>of</strong> Banking and <strong>Finance</strong> 15, 1991, 73-90.<br />

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation : Deposit Insurance in a Changing Environment<br />

(Washington : Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation,april 15,1983).<br />

Galai, Dan and Ronald Masulis : 'The Option Pricing Model and the Risk Factor <strong>of</strong> Stock",<br />

Journal <strong>of</strong> Financial Economics , 33, January/March 1976, 53-81.<br />

Figlewski, Stephen, William L. Silber and Marti G. Subrahmanyam (eds): Financial<br />

Options.from Theory to Practice.1990 (Business One Irwin : Homewood).<br />

Furlong Frederick T. and Michael C. Keeley : "Capital Regulation and Bank-Risk Taking,<br />

a Note", Journal <strong>of</strong> Banking and <strong>Finance</strong> 13, November 1989,883-891.<br />

Giammarino, R., Eduardo Schwartz and Joseph Zechner : "Market Valuation <strong>of</strong> Bank<br />

Assets and Deposit Insurance in Canada", Canadian Journal <strong>of</strong> Economics, 22, 1989,109-127.<br />

Gorton, Gary and Anthony M. Santomero :" Market Discipline and Bank Subordinated<br />

Debt", Journal <strong>of</strong> Money.Credit and Banking, February 1990, 22,119-128.<br />

Kareken, John : "The Emergence and Regulation <strong>of</strong> Contingent Commitment Banking",<br />

Journal <strong>of</strong> Banking and <strong>Finance</strong> 11, June 1987,359.


16<br />

Kuester, Kathleen A. and James M. O'Brien : "Market-Based Risk-Adjusted Examination<br />

Schedules for Depository Institutions", Journal <strong>of</strong> Banking and <strong>Finance</strong>,15, September<br />

1991,955-974.<br />

Kuester, Kathleen A. and James O'Brien : "Market-Based Deposit Insurance Premiums, an<br />

Evaluation", Federal Reserve Board, January 1991.<br />

Marcus, Allan and Israel Shaked: 'The Valuation <strong>of</strong> Deposit Insurance Using Option Pricing<br />

Estimates", Journal <strong>of</strong> Money. Credit and Banking, 16, November 1984,446-460.<br />

Merton, Robert C. :"On the Cost <strong>of</strong> Deposit Insurance When There Are Surveillance Costs",<br />

Journal <strong>of</strong> Business, July 1987,439-476.<br />

Merton, Robert C. :"An Analytic Derivation <strong>of</strong> the Costs <strong>of</strong> Deposit Insurance and Loan<br />

Guarantees", Journal <strong>of</strong> Banking and <strong>Finance</strong> 1, June 1977,3-11.<br />

McCulloch, Huston :"Interest-Risk Sensitive Deposit Insurance Premium", Journal <strong>of</strong><br />

Banking and <strong>Finance</strong>, 9, March 1985,137-156.<br />

Pennacchi,George : "A Reexamination <strong>of</strong> the Over- (or -Under) Pricing <strong>of</strong> Deposit<br />

Insurance", Journal <strong>of</strong> Money. Credit and Banking. 19,340-360.<br />

Pyle,David H. : "Capital Regulation and Deposit Insurance", Journal <strong>of</strong> Banking and<br />

<strong>Finance</strong>, 10, June 1986,189-201.<br />

Ronn, Ehud I. and Avinash K. Verma :"Pricing Risk-Adjusted Deposit Insurance,an Optionbased<br />

Model", Journal <strong>of</strong> <strong>Finance</strong>. 41, September 1986,871-895.<br />

Ronn, Ehud I. and Avinash K. Verma :"A Multi-Attribute Comparative Evaluation <strong>of</strong><br />

Relative Risk for a Sample <strong>of</strong> Banks ", Journal <strong>of</strong> Banking and <strong>Finance</strong>, 11, September<br />

1987,499-523.<br />

Ronn,Ehud I. and Avinash Verma : "Risk-Based Capital Adequacy Standards for a<br />

Sample <strong>of</strong> 43 Major Banks", Journal <strong>of</strong> Banking and <strong>Finance</strong>, 13, March 1989,21-29.<br />

Smith, Clifford W. :"On the Theory <strong>of</strong> Financial Contracts ,the Personal Loan Market",<br />

Journal <strong>of</strong> Monetary Economics July 1980, 333-358.


17<br />

BANK<br />

EQUITY<br />

(% <strong>of</strong> Loan)<br />

q RATIO' INSURANCE'<br />

(MV/iEb) (% <strong>of</strong> DEPOSITS)<br />

RONN-VERMAb<br />

ASSET VARIANCE PREMIUM<br />

(% OF DEPOSITS)<br />

10 1.11 1.26 70.49 .00815 0.49<br />

8 1.17 1.46 70.47 .00780 0.74<br />

6 1.26 1.67 70.40 .0075 1.10<br />

4 1.46 1.91 70.20 .0069 1.60<br />

2 2.06 2.16 69.90 .0062 2.30<br />

1 3.27 2.29 69.62 .0059 2.85<br />

Table One : Robustness with respect to Bank Leverage<br />

Asset =100,Loan =70, Variance =0.1,Interest Rate = 0.07,Maturity= 1 year<br />

a.The market value and insurance premium have been computed with equations (4) and (5).<br />

b.The Ronn-Verma methodology discussed in footnote 8 is applied to the market value and variance computed with<br />

equations (4) and (6).


18<br />

RONN-VERMAb<br />

BANK q RATIO' INSURANCE' ASSET VARIANCE PREMIUM<br />

EQUITY (MVpiEb) (% <strong>of</strong> DEPOSITS) (% <strong>of</strong> DEPOSITS)<br />

(% <strong>of</strong> Loan)<br />

10 1.48 5.28 82.6 .147 14.39<br />

8 1.68 5.85 81.4 .154 16.28<br />

6 2.27 6.46 80.0 .159 18.24<br />

4 2.70 7.09 78.6 .166 20.34<br />

2 4.80 7.75 76.9 .172 22.60<br />

1 9.02 8.08 76.2 .173 23.60<br />

Table Two : Robustness with respect to Bank Leverage<br />

Asset =100,Loan =90, Variance =0.1,1nterest Rate =0.07,Maturity=1 year<br />

a.The market value and insurance premium have been computed with equations (4) and (5).<br />

b.The Ronn-Verma methodology discussed in footnote 8 is applied to the market value and variance computed with<br />

equations (4) and (6).


19<br />

LOAN<br />

(% <strong>of</strong> Asset)<br />

q RATIO' INSURANCE'<br />

(MVp/Eb) (% <strong>of</strong> DEPOSITS)<br />

RONN-VERMAb<br />

ASSET VARIANCE PREMIUM<br />

(% <strong>of</strong> DEPOSITS)<br />

30 1.00 0.00 30.0 0.0000 0.00<br />

40 1.00 0.00 40.0 0.0001 0.00<br />

50 1.02 0.10 50.1 0.0015 0.00<br />

60 1.06 0.50 60.2 0.0015 0.01<br />

70 1.17 1.46 70.47 0.0078 0.74<br />

80 138 3.23 78.5 0.0390 5.23<br />

90 1.68 5.85 81.4 0.1540 16.28<br />

Table Three : Robustness with respect to Borrower Leverage<br />

Asset =100,Equity =8 %, Variance =0.1,1nterest Rate =0.07,Maturity =1 year<br />

a.The market value and insurance premium have been computed with equations (4) and (5).<br />

b.The Ronn-Verma methodology discussed in footnote 8 is applied to the market value and variance computed with<br />

equations (4) and (6).


20<br />

Ronn-Verma Estimate? Cap on MVE =<br />

200 % increase"<br />

MVE/D A<br />

a A Premium<br />

(%)<br />

Ab a A Premium<br />

(%)<br />

Cap on MVE =<br />

Book Value"<br />

A a A Premium<br />

(%)<br />

First Pennylvania 0.28 3857 0.99 0.51 4100 44 15 3550 7.07 8.5<br />

Crocker National 0.9 15247 1.43 0.56 15700 44 16 14600 8.4 5.6<br />

Continental Illinois 1.14 22829 0.98 0.16 22300 1.41 0.19 22180 2.4 0.75<br />

Wells Fargo 1.4 22200 1.08 .087 22200 1.7 0.21 22160 2.2 0.44<br />

Ronn-Verma Estimates' Cap on MVE =<br />

200 % increase"<br />

MVE/D A<br />

on Premium<br />

(%)<br />

A aA Premium<br />

(cX)<br />

Cap on MVE =<br />

25 % increase"<br />

A a A Premium<br />

(%)<br />

Republic NY Corp. 9.7 4225 2.21 0 4225 2.21 0 4360 5.92 .04<br />

Irving bank 6.5 10326 1.25 0 10326 1.25 0.01 10350 2 0<br />

Wachovia 8.0 6807 1.70 0 6807 1.7 0 6819 2 .01<br />

Morgan J•P. 7.1 28913 1.71 0 28913 1.71 0 28900 4 0<br />

Table Four : Robustness <strong>of</strong> Ronn-Verma Estimates<br />

a.Estimates reproduced from Ronn and Verma (1986).<br />

b.Values <strong>of</strong> A and aA <strong>by</strong> solving equations (4) and (6). Premium computed with equation (5) and estimates <strong>of</strong> A and 0A.


1NSEAD WORKING PAPERS SERIES<br />

88/12 Spyros MAKRIDAKIS "Business firms and managers in the 21st<br />

century", February 1988<br />

1988<br />

88/01 Michael LAWRENCE and "Factors affecting judgemental forecasts and<br />

Spyros MAKRIDAKIS confidence intervals", January 1988.<br />

88/13 Manfred KETS DE VRIES "Alexilhymia in organizational life: the<br />

organization man revisited", February 1988.<br />

88/14 Alain NOEL "The interpretation <strong>of</strong> strategies: a study <strong>of</strong><br />

the impact <strong>of</strong> CEOs on the<br />

corporation", March 1988.<br />

88/02 Spyros MAKRIDAKIS "Predicting recessions and other turning<br />

points", January 1988.<br />

88/03 James TEBOUL "De-industrialize service for quality", January<br />

1988.<br />

88/04 Susan SCHNEIDER "National vs. corporate culture: implications<br />

for human resource management", January<br />

1988.<br />

88/05 Charles WYPLOSZ "The swinging dollar: is Europe out <strong>of</strong><br />

step?", January 1988.<br />

88/15 Anil DEOLALIKAR and "The production <strong>of</strong> and returns from<br />

Lars-Hendrik ROLLER<br />

industrial innovation: an econometric<br />

analysis for a developing country", December<br />

1987.<br />

88/16 Gabriel HAWAWINI "Market efficiency and equity pricing:<br />

international evidence and implications for<br />

global investing", March 1988.<br />

88/17 Michael BURDA "Monopolistic competition, costs <strong>of</strong><br />

adjustment and the behavior <strong>of</strong> European<br />

employment", September 1987.<br />

88/06 Reinhard ANGELMAR "Les conflits dans les canaux de<br />

distribution", January 1988.<br />

88/07 Ingemar DIERICKX "Competitive advantage: a resource based<br />

and Karel COOL perspective", January 1988.<br />

88/08 Reinhard ANGELMAR "Issues in the study <strong>of</strong> organizational<br />

and Susan SCHNEIDER cognition", February 1988.<br />

88/09 Bernard SINCLAIR- "Price formation and product design through<br />

DESGAGNE bidding", February 1988.<br />

88/10 Bernard SINCLAIR- "The robustness <strong>of</strong> some standard auction<br />

DESGAGNE game forms", February 1988.<br />

88/11 Bernard SINCLAIR- "When stationary strategies are equilibrium<br />

DESGAGNE<br />

bidding strategy: The single-crossing<br />

property". February 1988.<br />

88/18 Michael BURDA "Reflections on "Wait Unemployment" in<br />

Europe", November 1987, revised February<br />

1988.<br />

88/19 M.J. LAWRENCE and "Individual bias in judgements <strong>of</strong><br />

Spyros MAKRIDAKIS confidence", March 1988.<br />

88/20 <strong>Jean</strong> <strong>DERMINE</strong>,<br />

Damien NEVEN and<br />

"Portfolio selection <strong>by</strong> mutual funds, an<br />

equilibrium model", March 1988.<br />

J.F. THISSE<br />

88/21 James TEBOUL "De-industrialize service for quality", March<br />

1988 (88/03 Revised).<br />

88/22 Lars-Hendrik ROLLER "Proper Quadratic Functions with an<br />

Application to AT&T", May 1987 (Revised<br />

March 1988).


88/23 Sjur Didrik FLAM "F.quilibres de Nash-Cournot dans le march4<br />

and Georges ZACCOUR europden du gaz: un cas oh les solutions en<br />

boucle ouverte et en feedback coincident",<br />

Mars 1988.<br />

88/34 Mihkel M. TOMBAK "Flexibility: an important dimension in<br />

manufacturing", June 1988.<br />

88/35 Mihkel M. TOMBAK "A strategic analysis <strong>of</strong> investment in flexible<br />

manufacturing systems", July 1988.<br />

88/24 B. Espen ECKBO and "Information disclosure, means <strong>of</strong> payment,<br />

Herwig LANGOHR and takeover premia. Public and Private<br />

tender <strong>of</strong>fers in France", July 1985, Sixth<br />

revision. April 1988.<br />

88/25 Everette S. GARDNER "The future <strong>of</strong> forecasting", April 1988.<br />

and Spyros MAKRIDAKIS<br />

88/26 Sjur Didrik FLAM "Semi-competitive Cournot equilibrium in<br />

and Georges ZACCOUR multistage oligopolies", April 1988.<br />

88/27 Murugappa KRISHNAN "Entry game with resalable capacity",<br />

Lars-Hendrik ROLLER April 1988.<br />

88/28 Sumantra GHOSHAL and<br />

C. A. BARTLETT<br />

"The multinational corporation as a network:<br />

perspectives from interorganizational<br />

theory", May 1988.<br />

88/36 Vikas TIBREWALA and "A Predictive Test <strong>of</strong> the NBD Model that<br />

Bruce BUCHANAN Controls for Non-stationarity", June 1988.<br />

88/37 Murugappa KRISHNAN "Regulating Price-Liability Competition To<br />

Lars-Hendrik ROLLER Improve Welfare", July 1988.<br />

88/38 Manfred KETS DE VRIES "The Motivating Role <strong>of</strong> Envy : A Forgotten<br />

Factor in Management", April 88.<br />

88/39 Manfred KETS DE VRIES "The Leader as Mirror : Clinical<br />

Reflections", July 1988.<br />

88/40 Josef LAKONISHOK and "Anomalous price behavior around<br />

Theo VERMAELEN repurchase tender <strong>of</strong>fers", August 1988.<br />

88/41 Charles WYPLOSZ "Assymetry in the EMS: intentional or<br />

systemic?", August 1988.<br />

88/29 Naresh K. MALHOTRA,<br />

Christian PINSON and<br />

Arun K. JAIN<br />

"Consumer cognitive complexity and the<br />

dimensionality <strong>of</strong> multidimensional scaling<br />

configurations", May 1988.<br />

88/30 Catherine C. ECKEL "The financial fallout from Cherno<strong>by</strong>l: risk<br />

and Theo VERMAELEN<br />

perceptions and regulatory response", May<br />

1988.<br />

31 Sumantra GHOSHAL and "Creation, adoption, and diffusion <strong>of</strong><br />

Christopher BARTLETT<br />

innovations <strong>by</strong> subsidiaries <strong>of</strong> multinational<br />

corporations", June 1988.<br />

88/32 Kesre FERDOWS and "International manufacturing: positioning<br />

David SACKRIDER plants for success", June 1988.<br />

88/33 Mihkel M. TOMBAK "The importance <strong>of</strong> flexibility in<br />

manufacturing". June 1988.<br />

88/42 Paul EVANS "Organizational development in the<br />

transnational enterprise", June 1988.<br />

88/43 B. SINCLAIR-DESGAGNE "Group decision support systems implement<br />

Bayesian rationality", September 1988.<br />

88/44 Essam MAHMOUD and "The state <strong>of</strong> the art and future directions<br />

Spyros MAKFUDAKIS in combining forecasts", September 1988.<br />

88/45 Robert KORAJCZYK "An empirical investigation <strong>of</strong> international<br />

and Claude VIALLET<br />

asset pricing", November 1986, revised<br />

August 1988.<br />

88/46 Yves DOZ and "From intent to outcome: a process<br />

Amy SHUEN framework for partnerships", August 1988.<br />

88/47 Alain BULTEZ,<br />

Els GUSBRECHTS,<br />

"Asymmetric cannibalism between substitute<br />

items listed <strong>by</strong> retailers", September 1988.


Philippe NAERT and<br />

Piet VANDEN ABEELE<br />

88/59 Martin KILDUFF<br />

"The interpersonal structure <strong>of</strong> decision<br />

making: a social comparison approach to<br />

organizational choice", November 1988.<br />

88/48<br />

Michael BURDA<br />

"Reflections on 'Wait unemployment' in<br />

Europe, 11", April 1988 revised September<br />

1988.<br />

88/60 Michael BURDA<br />

"Is mismatch really the problem? Some<br />

estimates <strong>of</strong> the Chelwood Gate II model<br />

with US data", September 1988.<br />

88/49<br />

Nathalie DIERKENS<br />

"Information asymmetry and equity issues",<br />

September 1988.<br />

88/61 Lars-Hendrik ROLLER<br />

"Modelling cost structure: the Bell System<br />

revisited", November 1988.<br />

88/50<br />

Rob WEITZ and<br />

"Managing expert systems: from inception<br />

Arnoud DE MEYER<br />

through updating", October 1987.<br />

88/62 Cynthia VAN HULLE,<br />

"Regulation, taxes and the market for<br />

88/51<br />

Rob WEITZ<br />

"Technology, work, and the organization:<br />

Theo VERMAELEN and<br />

Paul DE WOUTERS<br />

corporate control in Belgium", September<br />

1988.<br />

the impact <strong>of</strong> expert systems", July 1988.<br />

88/63 Fernando NASCIMENTO<br />

"Strategic pricing <strong>of</strong> differentiated consumer<br />

88/52<br />

Susan SCHNEIDER and<br />

Reinhard ANGELMAR<br />

"Cognition and organizational analysis:<br />

who's minding the store?", September 1988.<br />

and Wilfried R.<br />

VANHONACKER<br />

durables in a dynamic duopoly: a numerical<br />

analysis", October 1988.<br />

88/53<br />

Manfred KETS DE VRIES<br />

"Whatever happened to the philosopherking:<br />

the leader's addiction to power,<br />

88/64 Kasra FERDOWS<br />

"Charting strategic roles for international<br />

factories", December 1988.<br />

September 1988.<br />

88/65 Arnoud DE MEYER<br />

"Quality up, technology down", October 1988<br />

88/54<br />

Lars-Hendrik ROLLER<br />

"Strategic choice <strong>of</strong> flexible production<br />

and Kasra FERDOWS<br />

and Mihkel M. TOMBAK<br />

technologies and welfare implications",<br />

October 1988<br />

88/66 Nathalie DIERKENS<br />

"A discussion <strong>of</strong> exact measures <strong>of</strong><br />

88/55<br />

Peter BOSSAERTS<br />

"Method <strong>of</strong> moments tests <strong>of</strong> contingent<br />

information assymetry: the example <strong>of</strong> Myers<br />

and Mailuf model or the importance <strong>of</strong> the<br />

and Pierre HILLION<br />

claims asset pricing models", October 1988.<br />

asset structure <strong>of</strong> the firm", December 1988.<br />

/67 88/56 Pierre HILLION<br />

"Size-sorted portfolios and the violation <strong>of</strong><br />

Paul S. ADLER and<br />

the random walk hypothesis: Additional<br />

Kasra FERDOWS<br />

88/57<br />

Wilfried VANHONACKER<br />

and Lydia PRICE<br />

empirical evidence and implication for tests<br />

<strong>of</strong> asset pricing models", June 1988.<br />

"Data transferability: estimating the response<br />

effect <strong>of</strong> future events based on historical<br />

analogy", October 1988.<br />

1989<br />

89/01 Joyce K. BYRER and<br />

Tawfik JELASSI<br />

"The chief technology <strong>of</strong>ficer", December<br />

1988.<br />

"The impact <strong>of</strong> language theories on DSS<br />

dialog", January 1989.<br />

88/58<br />

B. SINCLAIR-DESGAGNE<br />

and Mihkel M. TOMBAK<br />

"Assessing economic inequality", November<br />

1988.<br />

89/02 Louis A. LE BLANC<br />

and Tawfik JELASSI<br />

"DSS s<strong>of</strong>tware selection: a multiple criteria<br />

decision methodology", January 1989.


89/03 Beth H. JONES and<br />

"Negotiation support: the effects <strong>of</strong> computer<br />

89/13 Manfred KETS DE VRIES<br />

"The impostor syndrome: a disquieting<br />

Tawfik JELASSI<br />

intervention and conflict level on bargaining<br />

phenomenon in organizational life", February<br />

outcome", January 1989.<br />

1989.<br />

89/04 Kasra FERDOWS and<br />

"Lasting improvement in manufacturing<br />

89/14 Reinhard ANGELMAR<br />

"Product innovation: a tool for competitive<br />

Amoud DE MEYER<br />

performance: In search <strong>of</strong> a new theory",<br />

advantage", March 1989.<br />

January 1989.<br />

89/15 Reinhard ANGELMAR<br />

"Evaluating a firm's product innovation<br />

89/05 Martin KILDUFF and<br />

"Shared history or shared culture? The<br />

performance", March 1989.<br />

Reinhard ANGELMAR<br />

effects <strong>of</strong> time, culture, and performance on<br />

institutionalization in simulated<br />

89/16 Wilfried VANHONACKER,<br />

"Combining related and sparse data in linear<br />

organizations", January 1989.<br />

Donald LEHMANN and<br />

regression models", February 1989.<br />

Fareena SULTAN<br />

89/06 Mihkel M. TOMBAK and<br />

"Coordinating manufacturing and business<br />

B. SINCLAIR-DESGAGNE<br />

strategies: I", February 1989.<br />

89/17 Gilles AMADO,<br />

Claude FAUCHEUX and<br />

"Changement organisationnel et Oath&<br />

culturelles: contrastes franco-ainericains",<br />

89/07 Damien J. NEVEN<br />

"Structural adjustment in European retail<br />

Andrd LAURENT<br />

March 1989.<br />

banking. Some view from industrial<br />

organisation", January 1989.<br />

89/18 Srinivasan BALAJC<br />

"Information asymmetry, market failure and<br />

RISHNAN and<br />

joint-ventures: theory and evidence",<br />

89/0B Arnoud DE MEYER and<br />

Hellmut SCHOTTE<br />

"Trends in the development <strong>of</strong> technology<br />

and their effects on the production structure<br />

in the European Community", January 1989.<br />

Mitchell KOZA<br />

89/19 Wilfried VANHONACKER,<br />

March 1989.<br />

"Combining related and sparse data in linear<br />

Donald LEHMANN and<br />

regression models", Revised March 1989.<br />

89/09 Damien NEVEN,<br />

"Brand proliferation and entry deterrence",<br />

Fareena SULTAN<br />

Carmen MATUTES and<br />

February 1989.<br />

Marcel CORSTJENS<br />

89/20 Wilfried VANHONACKER<br />

"A rational random behavior model <strong>of</strong><br />

and Russell WINER<br />

choice", Revised March 1989.<br />

89/10 Nathalie DIERKENS,<br />

"A market based approach to the valuation<br />

Bruno GERARD and<br />

<strong>of</strong> the assets in place and the growth<br />

89/21 Arnoud de MEYER and<br />

"Influence <strong>of</strong> manufacturing improvement<br />

Pierre HILLION<br />

opportunities <strong>of</strong> the firm", December 1988.<br />

Kasra FERDOWS<br />

programmes on performance", April 1989.<br />

89/11 Manfred KETS DE VRIES<br />

"Understanding the leader-strategy interface:<br />

89/22 Manfred KETS DE VRIES<br />

"What is the role <strong>of</strong> character in<br />

and Alain NOEL<br />

application <strong>of</strong> the strategic relationship<br />

and Sydney PERZOW<br />

psychoanalysis?" April 1989.<br />

interview method", February 1989.<br />

89/23 Robert KORAJCZYK and<br />

"Equity risk premia and the pricing <strong>of</strong><br />

89/12 Wilfried VANHONACKER<br />

"Estimating dynamic response models when<br />

Claude VIALLET<br />

foreign exchange risk" April 1989.<br />

the data are subject to different temporal<br />

aggregation", January 1989.<br />

89/24 Martin KILDUFF and<br />

Mitchel ABOLAFIA<br />

"The social destruction <strong>of</strong> reality:<br />

Organisational conflict as social drama"<br />

zApril 1989.


89/25 Roger BETANCOURT and<br />

"Two essential characteristics <strong>of</strong> retail<br />

David GAUTSCHI<br />

markets and their economic consequences"<br />

89/36 Martin KILDUFF<br />

"A dispositional approach to social networks:<br />

March 1989.<br />

the case <strong>of</strong> organizational choke", May 1989.<br />

89/26 Charles BEAN,<br />

"Macroeconomic policies for 1992: the<br />

89/37 Manfred KETS DE VRIES<br />

"The organisational fool: balancing a<br />

Edmond MAL1NVAUD,<br />

transition and after", April 1989.<br />

leader's hubris", May 19119.<br />

Peter BERNHOLZ,<br />

Francesco GIAVAllI<br />

89/38 Manfred KETS DE VRIES<br />

"The CEO blues", June 1989.<br />

and Charles WYPLOSZ<br />

89/39 Robert KORAICZYK and<br />

"An empirical investigation <strong>of</strong> international<br />

89/27 David KRACKHARDT and<br />

"Friendship patterns and cultural<br />

Claude VIALLET<br />

asset pricing", (Revised June 1989).<br />

Martin KILDUFF<br />

attributions: the control <strong>of</strong> organizational<br />

diversity", April 1989.<br />

89/40 Balaji CHAKRAVARTHY<br />

"Management systems for innovation and<br />

productivity", June 1989.<br />

89/28 Martin KILDUFF<br />

"The interpersonal structure <strong>of</strong> decision<br />

making: a social comparison approach to<br />

89/41 B. SINCLAIR-DESGAGNE<br />

"The strategic supply <strong>of</strong> precisions", June<br />

organizational choice", Revised April 1989.<br />

and Nathalie D1ERKENS<br />

1989.<br />

89/29 Robert GOGEL and<br />

"The battlefield for 1992: product strength<br />

89/42 Robert ANSON and<br />

"A development framework for computer-<br />

<strong>Jean</strong>-Claude LARRECHE<br />

and geographic coverage", May 1989.<br />

Tawfik JELASSI<br />

supported conflict resolution", July 1989.<br />

89/30 Lars-Hendrik ROLLER<br />

"Competition and Investment in Flexible<br />

89/43 Michael BURDA<br />

"A note on firing costs sad severance benefits<br />

and Mihkel M. TOMBAK<br />

Technologies", May 1989.<br />

in equilibrium unemployment", June 1989.<br />

89/31 Michael C. BURDA and<br />

"Intertemporal prices and the US trade<br />

89/44 Balaji CHAKRAVARTHY<br />

"Strategic adaptation in multi-business<br />

Stefan GERLACH<br />

balance in durable goods", July 1989.<br />

and Peter LORANGE<br />

firms", June 1989.<br />

89/32 Peter HAUG and<br />

"Application and evaluation <strong>of</strong> a multi-<br />

89/45 Rob WEITZ and<br />

"Managing expert systems: a framework and<br />

Tawfik JELASSI<br />

criteria decision support system for the<br />

Amoud DE MEYER<br />

case study", June 1989.<br />

dynamic selection <strong>of</strong> U.S. manufacturing<br />

locations", May 1989.<br />

89/46 Marcel CORSTJENS,<br />

"Entry Encouragement", July 1989.<br />

Carmen MATUTES and<br />

89/33 Bernard SINCLAIR-<br />

"Design flexibility in monopsonistic<br />

Damien NEVEN<br />

DESGAGNE<br />

industries", May 1989.<br />

89/47 Manfred KETS DE VRIES<br />

"The global dimension in leadership and<br />

89/34 Sumantra GHOSHAL and<br />

"Requisite variety versus shared values:<br />

and Christine MEAD<br />

organization: issues and controversies", April<br />

Nittin NOHRIA<br />

managing corporate-division relationships in<br />

1989.<br />

the M-Form organisation", May 1989.<br />

89/48 Damien NEVEN and<br />

"European integration and trade flows",<br />

89/35 <strong>Jean</strong> <strong>DERMINE</strong> and<br />

"Deposit rate ceilings and the market value<br />

Lars-Hendrik ROLLER<br />

August 1989.<br />

Pierre BILLION<br />

<strong>of</strong> banks: The case <strong>of</strong> France 1971-1981",<br />

May MCI


89/49 <strong>Jean</strong> <strong>DERMINE</strong> "Home country control and mutual<br />

recognition", July 1989. 89/62 Arnoud DE MEYER<br />

(TM)<br />

89/50 <strong>Jean</strong> <strong>DERMINE</strong> "The specialization <strong>of</strong> financial institutions,<br />

the EEC model", August 1989. 89/63 Enver YUCESAN and<br />

(TM) Lee SCHRUBEN<br />

89/51 Spyros MAKRIDAKIS "Sliding simulation: a new approach to time<br />

series forecasting", July 1989. 89/64 Enver YUCESAN and<br />

(TM) Lee SCHRUBEN<br />

89/52 Arnoud DE MEYER "Shortening development cycle times: a<br />

manufacturer's perspective", August 1989. 89/65 Soumitra DUTTA and<br />

(TM, Piero BONISSONE<br />

89/53 Spyros MAKRIDAKIS "Why combining works?", July 1989.<br />

AC, FIN)<br />

"Technology strategy and international R&D<br />

operations", October 1989.<br />

"Equivalence <strong>of</strong> simulations: A graph<br />

approach", November 1989.<br />

"Complexity <strong>of</strong> simulation models: A graph<br />

theoretic approach", November 1989.<br />

"MARS: A mergers and acquisitions<br />

reasoning system", November 1989.<br />

89/54 S. BALAKRISHNAN "Organisation costs and a theory <strong>of</strong> joint 89/66 B. SINCLAIR-DESGAGNE<br />

and Mitchell KOZA ventures", September 1989. (TM.EP)<br />

"On the regulation <strong>of</strong> procurement bids",<br />

November 1989.<br />

89/55 H. SCHUTTE "Euro-Japanese cooperation in information 89/67 Peter BOSSAERTS and<br />

technology", September 1989. (FIN) Pierre HILLION<br />

89/56 Wilfried VANHONACKER<br />

and Lydia PRICE<br />

89/57 Taekwon KIM,<br />

Lars-Hendrik ROLLER<br />

and Mihkel TOMBAK<br />

"On the practical usefulness <strong>of</strong> meta-analysis<br />

results", September 1989.<br />

"Market growth and the diffusion <strong>of</strong><br />

1990<br />

multiproduct technologies", September 1989. 90/01<br />

TM/EP/AC<br />

B. SINCLAIR-DESGAGNE<br />

"Market microstructure effects <strong>of</strong><br />

government intervention in the foreign<br />

exchange market", December 1989.<br />

"Unavoidable Mechanisms", January 1990.<br />

89/58 Lars-Hendrik ROLLER "Strategic aspects <strong>of</strong> flexible production 90/02 Michael BURDA<br />

(EP,TM) and Mihkel TOMBAK technologies", October 1989. EP<br />

89/59<br />

(OH)<br />

Manfred KETS DE VRIES,<br />

Daphne ZEVADI,<br />

Alain NOEL and<br />

Mihkel TOMBAK<br />

"Locus <strong>of</strong> control and entrepreneurship: a<br />

three-country comparative study", October<br />

1989.<br />

90/03<br />

TM<br />

Arnoud DE MEYER<br />

"Monopolistic Competition, Costs <strong>of</strong><br />

Adjustment, and the Behaviour <strong>of</strong> European<br />

Manufacturing Employment", January 1990.<br />

"Management <strong>of</strong> Communication in<br />

International Research and Development",<br />

January 1990.<br />

89/60 Enver YUCESAN and "Simulation graphs for design and analysis <strong>of</strong> 90/04 Gabriel HAWAWINI and<br />

(TM) Lee SCHRUBEN discrete event simulation models", October FIN/EP Eric RAJENDRA<br />

1989.<br />

"The Transformation <strong>of</strong> the European<br />

Financial Services Industry: From<br />

Fragmentation to Integration", January 1990.<br />

89/61 Susan SCHNEIDER and "Interpreting and responding to strategic 90/05 Gabriel HAWAWINI and<br />

(AB) Arnoud DE MEYER issues: The impact <strong>of</strong> national culture",<br />

FIN/EP Bertrand JACQUILLAT<br />

October 1989.<br />

"European Equity Markets: Toward 1992<br />

and Beyond", January 1990.


90/06 Gabriel HAWAWINI and "Integration <strong>of</strong> European Equity Markets:<br />

FIN/EP Eric RAJENDRA Implications <strong>of</strong> Structural Change for Key<br />

Market Participants to and Beyond 1992",<br />

January 1990.<br />

90/17<br />

N<br />

Nathalie DIERKENS<br />

"Information Asymmetry and Equity Issues",<br />

Revised January 1990.<br />

90/18 Wilfried VANHONACKER "Managerial Decision Rules and the<br />

90/07 Gabriel HAWAWINI "Stock Market Anomalies and the Pricing <strong>of</strong> MKT Estimation <strong>of</strong> Dynamic Sales Response<br />

FIN/EP<br />

Equity on the Tokyo Stock Exchange",<br />

Models", Revised January 1990.<br />

90/08<br />

TM/EP<br />

Tawfik JELASSI and<br />

B. SINCLAIR-DESGAGNE<br />

January 1990.<br />

"Modelling with MCDSS: What about<br />

Ethics?", January 1990.<br />

90/19 Beth JONES and "The Effect <strong>of</strong> Computer Intervention and<br />

TM Tawfik JELASSI Task Structure on Bargaining Outcome",<br />

February 1990.<br />

90/09 Alberto GIOVANNINI "Capital Controls and International Trade 90/29 Tawfik JELASSI, "An Introduction to Group Decision and<br />

EP/FIN and Jae WON PARK <strong>Finance</strong>", January 1990. TM Gregory KERSTEN and Negotiation Support", February 1990.<br />

90/10 Joyce BRYER and "The Impact <strong>of</strong> Language Theories on DSS<br />

Stanley ZIONTS<br />

TM Tawfik JELASSI Dialog", January 1990. 90/21 Roy SMITH and "Reconfiguration <strong>of</strong> the Global Securities<br />

FIN Ingo WALTER Industry in the 1990's", February 1990.<br />

90/11 Enver YUCESAN "An Overview <strong>of</strong> Frequency Domain<br />

TM Methodology for Simulation Sensitivity 90/22 Ingo WALTER "European Financial Integration and Its<br />

90/12 Michael BURDA "Structural Change, Unemployment Benefits<br />

Analysis", January 1990. FIN Implications for the United States", February<br />

1990.<br />

EP and High Unemployment: A U.S.-European 90/23 Damien NEVEN "EEC Integration towards 1992: Some<br />

90/13 Soumitra DUTTA and "Approximate Reasoning about Temporal<br />

Comparison", January 1990. EP/SM Distributional Aspects", Revised December<br />

TM Shashi SHEKHAR Constraints in Real Time Planning and 90/24 Lars Tyge NIELSEN "Positive Prices in CAPM", January 1990.<br />

Search", January 1990.<br />

FIN/EP<br />

1989<br />

90/14<br />

TM<br />

90/15<br />

TM<br />

Albert ANGEHRN and<br />

Hans-Jakob LUTHI<br />

Amoud DE MEYER,<br />

Dirk DESCHOOLMEESTER,<br />

Rudy MOENAERT and<br />

"Visual Interactive Modelling and Intelligent<br />

DSS: Putting Theory Into Practice", January<br />

1990.<br />

"The Internal Technological Renewal <strong>of</strong> a<br />

Business Unit with a Mature Technology",<br />

January 1990.<br />

90/25<br />

FIN/EP<br />

Lam Tyge NIELSEN<br />

"Existence <strong>of</strong> Equilibrium in CAPM",<br />

January 1990.<br />

90/26 Charles KADUSHIN and "Why networking Fails: Double Binds and<br />

OB/I1P Michael BRIMM the Limitations <strong>of</strong> Shadow Networks",<br />

February 1990.<br />

Jan BARBE 90/27 Abbas FOROUGHI and "NSS Solutions to Major Negotiation<br />

90/16 Richard LEVICH and "Tax-Driven Regulatory Drag: European<br />

TM Tawfik JELASSI Stumbling Blocks", February 1990.<br />

FIN Ingo WALTER Financial Centers in the 1990's", January 90/28 Arnoud DE MEYER "The Manufacturing Contribution to<br />

1990. TM Innovation", February 1990.


90/40 Manfred KETS DE VRIES "Leaders on the Couch: The case <strong>of</strong> Roberto<br />

90/29 Nathalie DIERKENS "A Discussion <strong>of</strong> Correct Measures <strong>of</strong> OB Calvi", April 1990.<br />

FIN/AC Information Asymmetry", January 1990.<br />

90/30 Lars Tyge NIELSEN "The Expected Utility <strong>of</strong> Portfolios <strong>of</strong><br />

90/41<br />

FIN/EP<br />

Gabriel HAWAWINI,<br />

Itzhak SWARY and<br />

"Capital Market Reaction to the<br />

Announcement <strong>of</strong> Interstate Banking<br />

FIN/EP Assets", March 1990. Ik HWAN JANG Legislation", March 1990.<br />

90/31 David GAUTSCHI and "What Determines U.S. Retail Margins?", 90/42 Joel STECKEL and "Cross-Validating Regression Models in<br />

MKT/EP Roger BETANCOURT February 1990. MKT Wilfried VANHONACKER Marketing Research", (Revised April 1990).<br />

90/32 Srinivasan BALAK- "Information Asymmetry, Adverse Selection 90/43 Robert KORAJCZYK and "Equity Risk Premix and the Pricing <strong>of</strong><br />

SM<br />

RISHNAN and<br />

Mitchell KOZA<br />

and Joint-Ventures: Theory and Evidence",<br />

Revised, January 1990.<br />

FIN Claude VIALLET Foreign Exchange Risk", May 1990.<br />

90/33 Caren SIEHL, "The Role <strong>of</strong> Rites <strong>of</strong> Integration in Service 90/44 Gilles AMADO, "Organisational Change and Cultural<br />

OB David BOWEN and Delivery", March 1990. OB Claude FAUCHEUX and Realities: Franco-American Contrasts", April<br />

Christine PEARSON Andre LAURENT 1990.<br />

90/45 Soumitra DUTTA and "Integrating Case Based and Rule Based<br />

90/34<br />

FIN/EP<br />

<strong>Jean</strong> <strong>DERMINE</strong><br />

"The Gains from European Banking<br />

Integration, a Call for a Pro-Active<br />

TM Piero BONISSONE Reasoning: The Possibilistic Connection",<br />

May 1990.<br />

Competition Policy", April 1990.<br />

90/46 Spyros MAJCRIDAKIS "Exponential Smoothing: The Effect <strong>of</strong><br />

90/35 Jae Won PARK "Changing Uncertainty and the Time- TM and Michele HIBON Initial Values and Loss Functions on Post-<br />

El'<br />

Varying Risk Premia in the Tenn Structure<br />

Sample Forecasting Accuracy".<br />

<strong>of</strong> Nominal Interest Rates", December 1988,<br />

Revised March 1990. 90/47 Lydia PRICE and<br />

"Improper Sampling in Natural<br />

MKT Wilfried VANHONACKER Experiments: Limitations on the Use <strong>of</strong><br />

90/36 Amoud DE MEYER "An Empirical Investigation <strong>of</strong> Meta-Analysis Results itt Bayesian<br />

TM Manufacturing Strategies in European Updating", Revised May 1990.<br />

Industry", April 1990.<br />

90/48 Jae WON PARK "The Information in the Term Structure <strong>of</strong><br />

90/37 William CATS-BARIL<br />

"Executive Information Systems: Developing<br />

EP<br />

Interest Rates: Out-<strong>of</strong>-Sample Forecasting<br />

TM/OB/SM<br />

an Approach to Open the Possibles", April<br />

Performance", June 1990.<br />

1990.<br />

90/49 Soumitra DUTTA "Approximate Reasoning <strong>by</strong> Analogy to<br />

90/38 Wilfried VANHONACKER "Managerial Decision Behaviour and the TM Answer Null Queries", June 1990.<br />

MKT<br />

90/39<br />

TM<br />

Louis LE BLANC and<br />

Tawfik JELASSI<br />

Estimation <strong>of</strong> Dynamic Sales Response<br />

Models", (Revised February 1990). 90/50 Daniel COHEN and "Price and Trade Effects <strong>of</strong> Exchange Rates<br />

Charles WYPLOSZ<br />

Fluctuations and the Design <strong>of</strong> Policy<br />

"An Evaluation and Selection Methodology<br />

Coordination", April 1990.<br />

for Expert System Shells", May 1990.


90/51 Michael BURDA and "Gross Labour Market Flows in Europe: 90/63 Sumantra GHOSHAL and "Organising Competitor Analysis Systems",<br />

EP Charles WYPLOSZ Some Stylized Facts", June 1990. SM Eleanor WESTNEY August 1990<br />

90/52 Lars Tyge NIELSEN "The Utility <strong>of</strong> Infinite Menus", June 1990. 90/64 Sumantra GHOSHAL "Internal Differentiation and Corporate<br />

FIN SM Performance: Case <strong>of</strong> the Multinational<br />

90/53 Michael Burda "The Consequences <strong>of</strong> German Economic<br />

Corporation", August 1990<br />

El' and Monetary U ", June 1990. 90/65 Charles WYPLOSZ "A Note on the Real Exchange Rate Effect <strong>of</strong><br />

90/54 Damien NEVEN and "European Financial Regulation: A<br />

El' German Unification", August 1990<br />

El' Colin MEYER Framework for Policy Analysis", (Revised 90/66 Soumitra DUTTA and "Computer Support for Strategic and Tactical<br />

90/55 Michael BURDA and "Intertemporal Prices and the US Trade<br />

90/56<br />

Stefan GERLACH<br />

Damien NEVEN and<br />

Lars-Hendrik ROLLER<br />

May 1990). 111/SE/FIN Piero BONISSONE Planning in Mergers and Acquisitions",<br />

Balance", (Revised July 1990).<br />

90/67<br />

TM/SE/FIN<br />

Soumitra DUTTA and<br />

Piero BONISSONE<br />

September 1990<br />

"Integrating Prior Cases and Expert Knowledge In<br />

a Mergers and Acquisitions Reasoning System",<br />

"The Structure and Determinants <strong>of</strong> East-West<br />

September 1990<br />

Trade: A Preliminary Analysis <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Manufacturing Sector", July 1990 90/68 Soumitra DUTTA "A Framework and Methodology for Enhancing the<br />

TM/SE<br />

Business Impact <strong>of</strong> Artificial Intelligence<br />

90/57 Lars Type NIELSEN Common Knowledge <strong>of</strong> a Multivariate Aggregate Applications", September 1990<br />

FIN/EP/ Statistic", July 1990<br />

TM 90/69 Soumitra DUTTA "A Model for Temporal Reasoning in Medical<br />

90/58 Lars Tyge NIELSEN "Common Knowledge <strong>of</strong> Price and Expected Cost<br />

FIN/EP/TM in an Oligopolistic Market", August 1990 90/70<br />

90/59 <strong>Jean</strong> <strong>DERMINE</strong> and "Economies <strong>of</strong> Scale and<br />

TM Expert Systems", September 1990<br />

TM<br />

Albert ANGEHRN<br />

"'Triple C': A Visual Interactive MCDSS",<br />

September 1990<br />

FIN Lars-Hendrik ROLLER Scope in the French Mutual Funds (SICAV) 90/71 Philip PARKER and "Competitive Effects in Diffusion Models: An<br />

Industry", August 1990 MKT Hubert GATIGNON Empirical Analysis", September 1990<br />

90/60 Pen IZ and "An Interactive Group Decision Aid for 90/72 Enver YUCESAN "Analysis <strong>of</strong> Markov Chains Using Simulation<br />

TM Tawfik JELASSI Multiobjective Problems: An Empirical TM Graph Models", October 1990<br />

Assessment", September 1990<br />

90/61 Pankaj CHANDRA and "Models for the Evlauation <strong>of</strong> Manufacturing<br />

90/73<br />

114<br />

Amoud DE MEYER and<br />

Kasra FERDOWS<br />

"Removing the Barriers in Manufacturing",<br />

October 1990<br />

TM Mihkel TOMBAK Flexibility", August 1990<br />

90/62 Damien NEVEN and "Public Policy Towards TV Broadcasting in the 90/74 Sumantra GHOSHAL and "Requisite Com plexity: Organising Headquarters-<br />

EP Menno VAN DLIK Netherlands", August 1990 SM Nitin NOHRIA Subsidiary Relations in MNCs", October 1990


90/75<br />

MKT<br />

Roger BETANCOURT and<br />

David GAUTSCH1<br />

'The Outputs <strong>of</strong> Retail Activities: Concepts,<br />

Measurement and Evidence", October 1990<br />

9087<br />

FIN/EP<br />

Lars Tyge NIELSEN<br />

"Existence <strong>of</strong> Equilihriuut in CAPIN: Further<br />

Results', December 1990<br />

90/76 Wilfried VANHONACKER "Managerial Decision Behaviour and the Estimation 90/88 Susan C. SCHNEIDER and "Cognition in Organisational Analysis: Who's<br />

MKT<br />

<strong>of</strong> Dyaarsic Sales Response Models",<br />

OIUMKT Reinhard ANGEL/AR Wading the Store?" Revised, December 1990<br />

Revised October 1990<br />

90/89 Manfred F.R. KETS DE VRIES *The CEO Who Couldn't Talk Straight and Other<br />

90/77 Wilfried VANHONACKER "Testing the Koyck Scheme <strong>of</strong> Sales Response to OH Tales from the Board Room; December 1990<br />

MKT<br />

Advertising: An Aggregation-ludepeodeut<br />

Aulacerreiahon Test", October 1990 90/90 Philip PARKER 'Price Elasticity Dynamics over the Adoption<br />

MKT Lifecycle: An Empirical Study,' December 1990<br />

tons Michael BURDA and "EscImage Rate Dynamics and Currency<br />

EP Stefan GERLACH Unification The Ostmark - DM Rate•<br />

October 1990<br />

90,19 Anil GABA 'Inferences ni gh no Unknown Noise Level is<br />

TM Berman/1i Process", October 1990<br />

90/110 Anil GABA and "Wog Survey Data in Inferences about Purchase<br />

TM Robert WINKLER Behaviour•, October 1990 1991<br />

TM<br />

Tawfik JELASSI<br />

'Du Pretreat as Fedor: Wan et Orientations des<br />

Systtoses toteractifs d'Aide h la DOOM,'<br />

October 1990<br />

91/01<br />

TM/S14<br />

904.2 Charles WYPLOSZ "Monetary Union and Fiscal Policy Discipline,'<br />

EP November 1990 91/02<br />

TM/gt4<br />

Luk VAN WASSENHOVE, •Operetimal Research Can Do More for Managers<br />

Leonard FORTUIN and<br />

Than They MOM;<br />

Paul VAN BEER January 1991<br />

Luk VAN WASSENHOVE,<br />

Leonard FORTUIN and<br />

°Operational Research and &ointment;<br />

January 1991<br />

90/113 Natalie DIERKENS and "beformatios Asymmetry and Corporate Paul VAN BEEK<br />

FIN/TM Bernard SINCLAIR-DESGAGNE Communication: Results <strong>of</strong> • Pilot Study',<br />

November 1990 9100 Pekka HIETALA and •AA Implicit Dividend Increase in Rights Issues:<br />

FIN Time LOYITYNIEMI Theory and Evidence," January 1991<br />

90/114 Philip M. PARKER nu Effect <strong>of</strong> Advertising on Price and Quality:<br />

MKT nee Optometric Industry Revisited." 91/04 Lars Tyge NIELSEN "Two-Fred Separation, Factor Structure and<br />

December 1990 FIN Robastm; January 1991<br />

90/115 Avijit GHOSH and 'Optimal Tuning and Location in Competitive 91/05 Susan SCHNEIDER "Managing Itmadasies in Organisations;<br />

MKT Vika. TIBREWALA Markets," November 1990 OR January 1991<br />

90/$6<br />

EP/TAM<br />

Olivier CADOT and<br />

Bernard SINCLAIR-DESGAGNE<br />

'Prudence and Success he Politics,' November 1990 91/06<br />

OR<br />

Manfred KEFS DE VRIES, •Lloderstaodiog the Leader-Strategy !Medico<br />

Danny MILLER and<br />

Application <strong>of</strong> the Strategic Relationship Interview<br />

Akin NOEL Method,' January 1990 ($9/11, revised April 1990)


91/07 Olivier CADOT "Lending to Insolvent Countries: A Paradoxical<br />

EP Story," January 1991 91/19<br />

MKT<br />

Vikas TIBREWALA and "An Aggregate Test <strong>of</strong> Purchase Regularity",<br />

Bruce BUCHANAN March 1991<br />

91/08 Charles WYPLOSZ "Post-Reform East and West: Capital<br />

EP Accumulation and the Labour Mobility 91/20 Darius SABAVALA and "Monitoring Short-Run Changes in Purchasing<br />

Constraint," January 1991 MKT Vikas TIBREWALA Behaviour", March 1991<br />

91/09 Spyros MAKRIDAKIS "What can we Learn from Failure?", February 1991 91/21 Sumantra GHOSHAL, "Intermit Communication within MNCs: The<br />

TM SM Harry KORINE and Influence <strong>of</strong> Formal Structure Versus Integrative<br />

91/10 Luc Van WASSENHOVE and "Integrating Scheduling with Hatching and<br />

Gabriel SZULANSKI Processes", April 1991<br />

TM C. N. POTTS Lot-Sizing: A Review <strong>of</strong> Algorithms and 91/22 David GOOD, *EC Integration and the Structure <strong>of</strong> the Franco-<br />

91/11 Luc VAN WASSENHOVE et al. "Multi-Item Lotsizing in Capacitated Multi-Stage<br />

Complexity", February 1991 EP Lars-Hendrik ROLLER and American Airline Industries: Implications for<br />

Robin SICKLES Efficiency and Welfare", April 1991<br />

TM Serial Systems", February 1991 91/23 Spyros MAKRIDAKIS and "Exponential Smoothing: The Effect <strong>of</strong> Initial<br />

TM<br />

Michele HIBON Values and Loss Functions or Post-Sample<br />

91/12 Albert ANGEHRN "Interpretative Computer Intelligence: A Link Forecasting Accuracy", April 1991 (Revision <strong>of</strong><br />

TM<br />

91/13<br />

EP<br />

Michael BURDA<br />

between Users, Models and Methods in DSS",<br />

February 1991<br />

"Labor and Product Markets in Czechoslovakia and<br />

the Ex-GDR: A Twin Study", February 1991<br />

91/14 Roger BETANCOURT and "The Output <strong>of</strong> Retail Activities: French SM/TM Charles J. CORBETT<br />

MKT David GAUTSCHI Evidence", February 1991<br />

91/15<br />

OB<br />

Manfred F.R. KETS DE VRIES<br />

"Exploding the Myth about Rational Organisations<br />

and Executives", March 1991<br />

90/46)<br />

91/24 Louis LE BLANC and "An Empirical Assessment <strong>of</strong> Choice Models for<br />

TM Tawfik JELASSI S<strong>of</strong>tware Evaluation and Sdaction", May 1991<br />

91/25 Luk N. VAN WASSENHOVE and "Trade-Offs? What Trade-Offs?" April 1991<br />

91/26 Luk N. VAN WASSENHOVE and "Single Machine Scheduling to Minimize Total Late<br />

TM C.N. POTTS Work", April 1991<br />

91/27 Nathalie DIERKENS "A Discussion <strong>of</strong> Correct Measures <strong>of</strong> Information<br />

91/16 Arnoud DE MEYER and "Factories <strong>of</strong> the Future: Executive Summary <strong>of</strong> FIN Asymmetry: The Example <strong>of</strong> Myers and Wiles<br />

TM Kasra FERDOWS et.al. the 1990 International Manufacturing Futures<br />

Survey", March 1991<br />

Model or the Importance <strong>of</strong> the Asset Structure <strong>of</strong><br />

the Finn", May 1991<br />

91/17 Dirk CATTRYSSE, "Heuristics for the Discrete Lotsizing and 91/28 Philip M. PARKER "A Note on: 'Advertising and the Price and Quality<br />

TM<br />

Roel<strong>of</strong> KUIK,<br />

Scheduling Problem with Setup Times", March 1991 MKT <strong>of</strong> Optometric Services', June 1991<br />

Marc SALOMON and<br />

Luk VAN WASSENHOVE 91/29 Tawfik JELASSI and "An Empirical Study <strong>of</strong> an Interactive, Session-<br />

TM<br />

Abbas FOROUGHI Oriented Computerised Negotiation Support System<br />

91/18 C.N. POTTS and "Approximation Algorithms for Scheduling a Single (NSS)", June 1991<br />

TM Luk VAN WASSENHOVE Machine to Minimize Total Late Work",<br />

March 1991


91/30 Wiltried R. VANHONACKER and "Using Meta-Analysis Results in Bayesian Updating:<br />

MKT Lydia J. PRICE The Empty Cell Problem", June 1991 91/43 Sumantra GHOSHAL and "Building Transnational Capabilities: The<br />

SM Christopher BARTLETT Management Challenge", September 1991<br />

91/31 Rezaul KABIR and "Insider Trading Restrictions and the Stock<br />

FIN Theo VERMAELEN Market", June 1991 91/44 Sumantra GHOSHAL and "Distributed Innovation in the 'Differentiated<br />

SM Nitin NOHRIA Network' Multinational", September 1991<br />

91/32 Susan C. SCHNEIDER "Organisational Sensemaking: 1992", June 1991<br />

011 91/45 Philip M. PARKER "The Effect <strong>of</strong> Advertising on Price and Quality:<br />

MKT<br />

An Empirical Study <strong>of</strong> Eye Examinations, Sweet<br />

91/33 Michael C. BURDA and "German Trade Unions after Unification - Third Lemons and Self-Deceirers", September 1991<br />

EP Michael FUNKE Degree Wage Discriminating Monopolists?",<br />

91/34 <strong>Jean</strong> <strong>DERMINE</strong> "The BIS Proposal for the Measurement <strong>of</strong> Interest<br />

lune 1991 91/46 Philip M. PARKER "Pricing Strategies in Markets with Dynamic<br />

MKT Elasticities", October 1991<br />

FIN Rate Risk, Some Pitfalls", June 1991 91/47 Philip M. PARKER "A Study <strong>of</strong> Price Elasticity Dynamics Using<br />

MKT<br />

Parsimonious Replacement/Multiple Purchase<br />

91/35<br />

FIN<br />

<strong>Jean</strong> <strong>DERMINE</strong><br />

"The Regulation <strong>of</strong> Financial Services in the EC,<br />

Centralization or National Autonomy?" June 1991<br />

Diffusion Models", October 1991<br />

91/48 H. Landis GABEL and "Managerial Incentives and Environmental<br />

91/36 Albert ANGEHRN "Supporting Multicriteria Decision Making: New EP/TM Bernard SINCLAILDESGAGNE Compliance", October 1991<br />

TM Perspectives and New Systems", August 1991<br />

91/49 Bernard SINCLAIR-DESGAGNE "The First-Order Approach to Multi-Task<br />

91/37 Ingo WALTER and "The Introduction <strong>of</strong> Universal Banking in Canada: TM Principal-Agent Problems", October 1991<br />

EP Hugh THOMAS An Event Study", August 1991<br />

91/50 Luk VAN WASSENHOVE and "How Green is Your Manufacturing Strategy?"<br />

91/38 Ingo WALTER and "National and Global Competitiveness <strong>of</strong> New York SM/TM Chides CORBETT October 1991<br />

EP Anthony SAUNDERS City as • Financial Center", August 1991<br />

91/39<br />

EP<br />

91/40<br />

TM<br />

91/41<br />

TM<br />

Ingo WALTER and<br />

Anthony SAUNDERS<br />

"Reconfiguration <strong>of</strong> Banking and Capital Markets<br />

in Eastern Europe", August 1991<br />

91/51 Philip M. PARKER "Choosing Among Diffusion Models: Some<br />

MKT Empirical Guidelines", October 1991<br />

91/52 Michael BURDA and *unman Capital, Investment and Migration in an<br />

Luk VAN WASSENHOVE, "A Set Partitioning Heuristic for the Generalized<br />

El' Charles WYPLOSZ Integrated Europe", October 1991<br />

Dirk CATTRYSSE and<br />

Assignment Problem", August 1991<br />

Marc SALOMON 91/53 Michael BURDA and "Labour Mobility and German Integration: Some<br />

El' Charles WYPLOSZ Vignettes", October 1991<br />

Luk VAN WASSENHOVE, "A Fully Polynomial Approximation Scheme for<br />

M.Y. KOVALYOU and<br />

Scheduling a %ogle Machine to Minimize Total 91/54 Albert ANGEHRN "Stimulus Agents: An Alternative Framework for<br />

C.N. POTTS Weighted Late Work", August 1991 TM Computer-Aided Decision Making", October 1991<br />

91/42 Rob R. WEITZ and "Solving A Multi-Criteria Allocation Problem:<br />

TM Tawfik JELASSI A Decision Support System Approach",<br />

August 1 99 1


91/55 Robin HOGARTH,<br />

EP/SM Claude MICHAUD,<br />

Yves DOZ and<br />

"Longevity <strong>of</strong> Business Firms: A Four-Stage<br />

Framework for Analysis", November 1991<br />

92/03<br />

OB<br />

Manfred F.R. KETS DE VRIES<br />

"The Family Firm: An Owner's Manual",<br />

January 1992<br />

Ludo VAN DER HEYDEN 92/04 Philippe HASPESLAGH and "Making Acquisitions Work", January 1992<br />

91/56 Bernard SINCLAIR-DESGAGNE<br />

TM/EP<br />

"Aspirations and Economic Development",<br />

SM<br />

David JEMISON<br />

November 1991 92/05 Xavier DE GROOTE "Flexibility and Product Diversity in Lot-Sizing<br />

TM<br />

Models", January 1992 (revised)<br />

91/57 Lydia 1. PRICE "The Indirect Effects <strong>of</strong> Negative Information on<br />

MKT Attitude Change", November 1991 92/06 Theo VERMAELEN and "Financial Innovation: Self Tender Offers in the<br />

FIN Kees COOLS U.K.", January 1992<br />

91/58 Manfred F. R. KETS DE VRIES "Leaders Who Go Crazy", November 1991<br />

OB 92/07 Xavier DE GROOTE "The Fledbility <strong>of</strong> Production Processes: A<br />

TM<br />

General Framework", January 1992 (revised)<br />

91/59 Paul A. L. EVANS<br />

OB<br />

"Management Development as Glue Technology",<br />

November 1991<br />

92/08<br />

TM<br />

Luk VAN WASSENHOVE,<br />

Leo KROON and<br />

91/60 Xavier DE GROOTE<br />

"Flexibility and Marketing/Manufacturing<br />

Marc SALOMON<br />

TM<br />

Coordination", November 1991 (revised)<br />

92/09 Luk VAN WASSENHOVE,<br />

91/61 Arnoud DE MEYER "Product Development in the Textile Machinery<br />

TM<br />

Roel<strong>of</strong> KUM and<br />

TM Industry", November 1991 Mare SALOMON<br />

"Exact and Approximation Algorithms for the<br />

Operational Fixed Interval Scheduling Problem",<br />

January 1992<br />

"Statistical Search Methods for Lotsizing<br />

Problems", January 1992<br />

91/62 Philip PARKER and "Specifying Competitive Effects in Diffusion 92/10 Yves DOZ and "Regaining Competitiveness: A Process <strong>of</strong><br />

MKT Hubert GATIGNON Models: An Empirical Analysis", November 1991 SM Heinz THANHEISER Organisational Renewal", January 1992<br />

91/63 Michael BURDA "Some New Insights on the Interindustry Wage 92/11 Enver YUCESAN and "On the Intractability <strong>of</strong> Verifying Structural<br />

EP<br />

Stricture from the German Socioeconomic Panel",<br />

December 1991<br />

TM Sheldon JACOBSON Properties <strong>of</strong> Discrete Event Simulation Models",<br />

February 1992<br />

91/64 <strong>Jean</strong> <strong>DERMINE</strong><br />

FIN<br />

"Internationalisation <strong>of</strong> Financial Markets,<br />

Efficiency and Stability", December 1991<br />

92/12<br />

FIN<br />

Gabriel HAWAWINI<br />

"Valuation <strong>of</strong> Cross-Border Mergers and<br />

Acquisitions", February 1992<br />

1992 92/13 Spyros MAKRIDAKIS and "The M2-Competition: A Budget Related<br />

92/01 Wilfried VANHONACKER "CONPRO•DOGIT: A New Brand Choice Model<br />

TM Michele HIBON et.al. Empirical Forecasting Study", February 1992<br />

MKT/EP/TM Incorporating a Consideration Set Formation 92/14 Lydia PRICE "Identifying Cluster Overlap with NORMIX<br />

Process". January 1992 MKT Population Membership Probabilities",<br />

92/02 Wilfried VANHONACKER "The Dynamics <strong>of</strong> the Consideration Set Formation<br />

MKT/EP/TM<br />

Process: A Rational Modelling Perspective and<br />

Some Numerical Results", January 1992<br />

February 1992


92/15 Vikaa TIBREWALA,<br />

MKT Peter LENK and<br />

Ambar RAO<br />

"Nonstationary Conditional Trend Analysis: An<br />

Application to Scanner Panel Data", February 1992<br />

92/16 Xavier DE GROOTE and<br />

TM Yu-Sheng ZHENG<br />

"A Sensitivity Analysis <strong>of</strong> Stochastic Inventory<br />

Systems", March 1992<br />

92/17 Xavier DE GROOTE and<br />

TM Evan L. PORTEUS<br />

"An Approach to Single Parameter Process<br />

Design", March 1992<br />

92/18 Xavier DE GROOTE<br />

TM<br />

"Information Disclosure and Technology Choice",<br />

March 1992

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!