2012 Report on Istanbul - Sciences Po

Istanbul <strong>2012</strong> - Governing the Large Metropolis
0+*% 6C#S6#,'6$% #(% &'(,*=.'+0+4% 0+,#$,#&%
.+0&,#&*$%#(%N$,0(C6/:%%%%
T),*+% ,"#$% #(,+'86&,#'(5% ,"*% $.*0-*+%
/06(&"*8% 0% KM7=#(6,*% *R,+0&,% )+'=% 0%
8'&6=*(,0+4% '(% ,"*% &#,4% ')% N$,0(C6/_%
G&A=*('.'/#$:% !"#$% *R&*+.,% 8#$./04*8%
&'(,*=.'+0+4%6+C0(%&"0//*(J*$%#(% N$,0(C6/5%
.0+,#&6/0+%0+'6(8% ,"*%#$$6*% ')%"'6$#(J:% !"*%
8'&6=*(,0+4% $.*&#Q#&0//4% "#J"/#J",*8% ,"*%
&'(,+0$,% C*,9**(% J0,*8% &'==6(#,#*$% 0(8%
"#J"/4%#($*&6+*%&'==6(#,#*$:%%%%
?'$,%')%,"*%=**,#(J%9#,"%?#$$%@A(0/%0&,60//4%
,''-%,"*%)'+=%')%0(%#(,*+3#*9%C4%)'&6$#(J%'(%
$,68*(,$% S6*$,#'($:% d'+% "*+5% ,"*+*% #$% ('%
!6+-#$"%0+,#$,% 9"'% #$%(',%#(3'/3*8% #(%0%-#(8%
')% 0&,#3#$=% ,"+'6J"%"#$n"*+% 0+,:% T+,#$,$% 0+*%
6$60//4% 3*+4% &'==#,,*8% ,'% &6++*(,% *3*(,$%
C*&06$*%,"*+*%0+*%/',$%')%#$$6*$%,'%C*%$'/3*8%
0(8% ,"*+*% #$% 0/904$% $'=*,"#(J% J'#(J% '(:%
\*$#8*$% 0+,#$,$5% $&"'/0+$5% $,68*(,$5% 0(8%
0&,#3#$,$%0+*%0/$'%.0+,%')%.6C/#&% *(J0J*=*(,%
,"0,%0#=$%0,% )'+&#(J% ,"*%J'3*+(=*(,%,'% $,'.%
&'(,+'3*+$#0/% .'/#&#*$% $6&"%0$% ,"'$*% 0+'6(8%
"'6$#(J:% G3*(% #)% ,"*% J'3*+(=*(,% 8'*$% (',%
$**=% ,'% 088+*$$% ,"*$*% &/0#=$5% 0&,#3#$=%
C*&'=*$% ='+*% 0(8% ='+*% .'9*+)6/% #(%
N$,0(C6/:% Y'9*3*+5% ,"*% 0+,% &'==6(#,4% 8'*$%
(',% +*&*#3*% 0(4% .+*$$6+*% )+'=% ,"*%
J'3*+(=*(,:% T&&'+8#(J% ,'% ?#$$% @A(0/5% ,"*%
.+*$$6+*% #$% &'=#(J% ='+*% )+'=% (0,#'(0/#$,%
.*'./*% '+% )+'=% ,"*% (*#J"C'+"''8:% !"*%
(*9$.0.*+5% T-#,% `)'+=*/4% -('9(% 0$% m0-#,a%
0/$'% .6,$% .+*$$6+*% '(% I*.'_% #,% #$% '),*(%
0J0#($,% $'=*% *R"#C#,#'($% `*$.*&#0//4% '(*$%
&+#,#&#]#(J% .'/#,#&0/% N$/0=a5% 0(8% #,% '(&*%
'C/#J*8% ,"*% &'==6(#,4% ,'% ='8#)4% $6&"% 0(%
*R"#C#,#'(:
P6+% $.*0-*+% C*/#*3*8% ,"*+*% ,'% C*% 0% +#$-% ')%
*R,+*=*% &6/,6+0/% &'(&*(,+0,#'(% #(% N$,0(C6/:%
D"*%*R./0#(*8%,"0,%*3*+4,"#(J%&6/,6+0/%,0-*$%
./0&*%#(%!0-$#=:%\*$#8*$5%='$,%0+,#$,$%/#3*%#(%
,"*%&#,4%&*(,*+%')%N$,0(C6/:%T&&'+8#(J%,'%"*+5%
,"*+*% #$% ('% $.0&*% )'+% 0+,% ,'% 8*3*/'.%
#(8*.*(8*(,/4% #(% !6+-*4% ,'804V% =0(4%
J0//*+#*$% &'(&*(,+0,*%#(% '(*%.0+,#&6/0+%0+*05%
(',%'(/4%#(%N$,0(C6/%C6,% 0/$'%#(%,"*% &'6(,+4:%
?'+*'3*+5% ='$,% ')% ,"*% &6/,6+0/% ./0&*$% #(%
N$,0(C6/%0+*%/'&0,*8%#(%0+*0$%')%&'($6=.,#'(%
7% ,"*+*% #$% 0/='$,% ('% #(8*.*(8*(,% 0+,#$,#&%
./0&*5% 0$% 0+,% #$% ='$,/4% 8#$./04*8% #(%
)'6(80,#'($% )6(8*8% C4% &0.#,0/% '+% #(% $=0//%
&'==*+&#0/%J0//*+#*$:% @A(0/%+*&'J(#]*8% ,"0,%
,"*% 3*+4% .+*$*(&*% ')%,"*% &6/,6+0/% &*(,*+% #(%
,"*%&*(,+0/%0(8%3*+4% 84(0=#&%(*#J"C'+"''8%
')% !'."0(*%#$% .0+,% ')%0% J*(,+#)4#(J%.+'&*$$:%
!"*% =6(#&#.0/#,45% "'9*3*+5% 9*/&'=*$% ,"*%
&6/,6+0/%&*(,*+%#(%,"#$%0+*0%C*&06$*%#,%C+#(J$%
$'=*%&6/,6+0/%&0.#,0/:
T&&'+8#(J% ,'% ?#$$% @A(0/5% ,"*+*% #$% ('%
+*/#J#'6$% &'(,*=.'+0+4% 0+,%C6,%$'=*% 0+,#$,$%
6$*%+*/#J#'6$% $4=C'/$% #(%,"*#+%9'+-5% ='$,/4%
N$/0=#$,%$4=C'/$:%!"*+*%0+*%$'=*%9'+-$%,"0,%
&+#,#&#]*% N$/0=#$=% C6,% ,"*$*% 0+*% ='+*%
J*(*+0/% &+#,#&#$=$% ')% ,"*% .'/#,#&#]0,#'(% ')%
N$/0=%,"0(%0%&/0#=%0J0#($,%,"*%+*/#J#'(%#,$*/):
!"*+*%#$%('%8*='&+0,#]0,#'(%')%,"*%&6/,6+*%#(%
!6+-*4%$#(&*%&0.#,0/%#$%$,#//%0%C0++#*+%0J0#($,%
,"0,_%#)%0(%0+,#$,%#$%(',%=0+-*,0C/*5%"*%'+%$"*%
&0((',%*R"#C#,%"#$%'+%"*+%9'+-:%d6+,"*+='+*5%
,"*%J'3*+(=*(,% 8'*$% (',%J#3*%0(4% Q#(0(&#0/%
$6..'+,% )'+% &'(,*=.'+0+4% 0+,5% 0$% #,%
&'(&*(,+0,*$% #,$% C68J*,% 0+'6(8% ,+08#,#'(0/%
0+,5%&#(*=05%'+%,"*0,*+:
G3*(% #)% T$*(0% @A(0/% )'&6$*8% "*+% 8#$&'6+$*%
'(% ,"*% 0&,#3#,#*$% ')% ,"*% &6/,6+0/% &*(,*+5% 9*%
9*+*% *3*(,60//4% 0C/*% ,'% $-*,&"% '6,% $'=*%
)*0,6+*$% ')% ,"*% &6++*(,% J'3*+(0(&*% ')%
N$,0(C6/% 0,% ,"*% *(8% ')% ,"*% =**,#(J:%
PC$*+3#(J%,"*%-#(8%')%0+,9'+-$%8#$./04*8%#(%
,"*%&*(,*+5% 9*%J+0$.*8%,"*%=0#(%&'(&*+($%')%
!6+-#$"% 0+,#$,$5% +*3*0/#(J% ,"*#+% '.#(#'(% '(%
,"*%=0(0J*=*(,% ')%30+#'6$% 6+C0(% #$$6*$% #(%
N$,0(C6/:% d'+% *R0=./*5% ,"*% ."','$% ,0-*(% C4%
E'=0% -#8$% ')% ,"*% E'=0% &'==6(#,4%
#=./#&#,/4%+*)*+%,'%,"*%"'6$#(J%.'/#&4%0,%$,0-*%
#(% N$,0(C6/:% \*&06$*%')% ,"*%#=.+'3*=*(,% ')%
$'=*% (*#J"C'+"''8$% 0(8% ,"*% +#$*% #(% ,"*%
.+#&*% ')% +*(,$5% ,"*% 6..*+7=#88/*% &/0$$% #$%
.+'J+*$$#3*/4% +*./0&#(J% ,"*% 9'+-#(J% &/0$$%
0(8% =#J+0(,$% 9"'% 6$*8% ,'% /#3*% #(% &*(,+0/%
0+*0$%')%N$,0(C6/%0(8%9"'%0+*%('9%/#=#,*8%,'%
='3#(J% ,'% ,"*% '6,$-#+,$% ')% ,"*% &#,4:% !"#$%
+*0/#,45% &'(3*4*8%C4% $*3*+0/% ."','$5% +*3*0/$%
,"*% =0$$#3*% 8#$./0&*=*(,% ,0-#(J% ./0&*% #(%
N$,0(C6/%&'(&*+(#(J%"'6$#(J:%Z*%6(8*+$,''8%
,"0,%,"*%J*(,+#Q#&0,#'(%.+'&*$$%#$%#(,*($#)4#(J%
44