06.11.2014 Views

A Sharp Interface Cartesian Grid Method for Simulating Flows with ...

A Sharp Interface Cartesian Grid Method for Simulating Flows with ...

A Sharp Interface Cartesian Grid Method for Simulating Flows with ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

368 UDAYKUMAR ET AL.<br />

FIG. 7. (a) Computational domain, streamlines, and x-velocity contours <strong>for</strong> a cylinder oscillating in a box<br />

computed on the 270 × 270 mesh. (b) The error distribution in x-velocity <strong>for</strong> a 20 × 20 mesh. (c) The error<br />

distribution <strong>for</strong> the 60 × 60 mesh. (d) The convergence behavior of the error norms. The L ∞ and L 1 norms are<br />

shown along <strong>with</strong> the reference (dashed) line corresponding to second-order convergence.<br />

show the distribution of the local error |φ (N)<br />

j − φ (270)<br />

j | <strong>for</strong> the coarsest 20 × 20 mesh. The<br />

magnitudes of errors are labeled on a few contours and it can be observed that the errors<br />

are clearly concentrated in the region surrounding the cylinder where significant gradients<br />

exist. Figure 7c shows the error distribution <strong>for</strong> the 60 × 60 mesh. Again, the errors appear<br />

to be concentrated in the boundary layer region; however, as expected, the magnitude of<br />

the error is lower than that in Fig. 7b. Figure 7d shows the convergence behavior of the<br />

error norms <strong>for</strong> the three meshes (20 × 20, 60 × 60, 100 × 100) <strong>with</strong> respect to the finest<br />

reference mesh solution. Logs of both ε 1 and ε ∞ are plotted against log(h), where h is the<br />

grid spacing. Also plotted is a reference line <strong>with</strong> a slope of 2 corresponding to secondorder<br />

convergence. As can be noted, the convergence rate of error in the simulations is<br />

close to the reference line, indicating nearly second-order-accuracy. It should be pointed<br />

out that similar behavior in the error was observed when error was analyzed at intermediate<br />

times during the oscillation cycle. It should be noted that exact second-order-accuracy is<br />

not expected in this test primarily because the errors are not computed based on an exact

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!