â2009 Equity strategyâ - Talaat Moustafa Group
â2009 Equity strategyâ - Talaat Moustafa Group
â2009 Equity strategyâ - Talaat Moustafa Group
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
“2009 <strong>Equity</strong> strategy”<br />
Prime Investment Research
TABLE OF CONTENTS<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Executive Summary 3<br />
Strategy<br />
Consequences of Global Crisis on The Region 4<br />
Sectors Outlook 5<br />
Putting It All Together (Big Picture) 6<br />
2009 Sector Outlook (Summary) 7<br />
2009 Picks<br />
Short Term Picks 8<br />
Long Term Picks 9<br />
Economic Focus 11<br />
Stock Market Focus 15<br />
Banking Sector<br />
CIB 18<br />
NSGB 20<br />
Oil & Services Sector<br />
Maridive 22<br />
Telecommunication Sector<br />
Telecom Egypt 24<br />
Mobinil 26<br />
Pharmaceuticals Sector<br />
EIPICO 28<br />
Industrial & Capital Goods Sector<br />
Orascom Construction Industries 30<br />
El Sewedy Cables 32<br />
Housing Sector<br />
TMG 34<br />
Financial Services Sector<br />
EFG-Hermes 36<br />
Stock Recommendations Guide 38<br />
Disclaimer & Contacts<br />
Please note that Market prices, trading multiples and stock performance charts are all calculated as of 9 March, 2009 closing prices.<br />
Prime Research 2
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Contagion Effect From Global Recession is Bound To Happen<br />
International financial markets continue to fluctuate with governments discovering new challenges to contain the problem from getting<br />
worse or spreading. While our main concern in this report is the Egyptian economy and the equity market in Egypt, we think it is<br />
necessary to give a quick review of the global scene since internal inadequacies per se are not the key cause behind the economic<br />
slow down faced by Egypt at the moment. In the current situation, weakened external demand constitutes a bullet hit at the heart of<br />
the Egyptian economy causing less receipts from Tourism, Suez Canal, Exports and ultimately less FDIs.<br />
Origins of The Global Crisis<br />
The global financial crisis became apparent in 2007 originating from rising housing demand at a time of low interest rates leading to<br />
overvalued housing prices ending with high interest rates and a high default ratio. Coupled with deregulation of the financial markets,<br />
increasing real estate prices led to higher appetite for risk among investors, gripping corporations such as Freddie and Fannie to guarantee<br />
more than half of USA mortgages, that were originally sub prime. In absence of the regulatory role, sub prime mortgages were<br />
pooled into Mortgage Backed Securities that enjoyed low rating leading investment banks such as Bear Sterns, Merrill Lynch and Lehman<br />
Brothers to heavily invest in them. The reputable financial institutions ended up either acquired, filed for bankruptcy, or switched<br />
to commercial banking. Moreover, commercial banks such as Indy Mach, Wachovia and Washington Mutual fell after rating agencies<br />
downgraded Investment banks, causing sharp price declines, and, hence, putting stress on the system. Tight credit took LIBOR up<br />
from 2.5% to 4%. Ultimately, high default rate, business close downs and credit dry up caused plunging demand in the USA. On the<br />
regional level, oil prices recorded historical lows grabbing commodities along, GCC budgets tightened or turned into deficit, and projects<br />
were delayed/cancelled. On the local level, with Egypt’s main trade partners being the USA and EU, a decline across Exports,<br />
Tourism, Suez canal and FDI was discounted in equities, causing equity market to act the way it is right now.<br />
We Estimate a Recovery on 2 Phases<br />
So far, governments have not fully identified the magnitude of the financial problem, however, bailout plans have been rolled out and<br />
approved in order to offer a quick fix to collapsing economies. Getting rid of toxic assets is not expected to be a simple task given the<br />
lack of data on where those assets are. We believe that once banks have completely removed toxic assets and recapitalization is<br />
achieved, probably by mid to end of 2009, a typical period of heavy regulations/low demand is expected to take place for 12 to 18<br />
months. We expect this period to be characterized by partial improvement in equity markets in the GCC and Egypt. Regionally,<br />
partial improvement of demand for oil will start to take shape leading to a price of US$50-55/barrel and ultimately resulting in<br />
higher investment. Domestically, this will correspond to a period of partial improvement in equity markets accompanied by recovering<br />
exports, tourism and Suez Canal revenues. Full recovery is expected to take place by end of 2010 at which time governments<br />
will want to sell back their stakes in recapitalized banks, with private sector regaining confidence and investing directly and indirectly<br />
following the re-regulations of the financial markets<br />
Sector Strategy and Stock Picks<br />
As we publish this note, FY08 results continue to come out, with a noticeable decline in Q4 results. Despite this, almost all stocks under<br />
our coverage offer significant value to our intrinsic prices generated from our DCF models, even after accounting for the following<br />
factors:<br />
• Lower or stagnating commodities’ prices;<br />
• Less domestic / external demand;<br />
• Pile up of high cost inventory implying weaker capital;<br />
• Expensive liquidity.<br />
Accordingly, we drafted a short-term and a long-term strategy (available in pages 8 & 9). The short-term strategy comprises stock<br />
picks for 2009, while, the long term strategy includes stocks that we believe investors can park in their money over the long term<br />
for they offer a sizeable upside potential over the long term and will benefit the most in the next upward cycle.<br />
The short term strategy targets sectors immune to the global slowdown, namely, Telecom, Pharmaceuticals, Banking as well<br />
as other non-cyclical stock. Said sectors are targeting investors with short term gain objectives in 2009 mainly generated from<br />
dividends paying stocks with stable earnings and pay out ratios due to their non-cyclical nature. Our Short Term Picks include<br />
CIB, NSGB, Maridive, Telecom Egypt, and Mobinil.<br />
The long term strategy targets sectors we view as offering significant upside potential over the long term and will benefit the most<br />
with the next impulsive cycle. We are basically attracted by long term business strategy of OCI and el Sewedy Cables due to their<br />
expansion plans as well as visible projects either privately for OCI or with the Government for Sewedy Cables. On the other side,<br />
TMGH attract us due to the relatively cheap multiples it is trading at representing almost less than half of its book value. In other<br />
words, one can argue that TMGH stock prices imply more than 70% discount to physical land market prices.<br />
Finally, we prefer EFG-Hermes due to its regional market exposure as well as the diversified investment it currently has, namely its<br />
27.8% in AUDI Bank and SODIC which the current market price of EFG-Hermes value below cost. Moreover, the company’s<br />
balance sheet is rich with LE1.2 billion cash position implying Net Investments/Mkt. cap of around 65%<br />
Prime Research 3
STRATEGY:CONSEQUENCES OF<br />
GLOBAL CRISIS ON THE REGION<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
GLOBAL EFFECT ON THE EGYPTIAN ECONOMY<br />
The Egyptian economy is currently hit by a contagion effect from the global financial crisis more than being hindered by internal<br />
weaknesses albeit the soaring real estate prices. This makes us believe that the magnitude of local economic troubles and pace of<br />
recovery is directly related to leading world economies. Thereby, we draw linkages between global forces and the Egyptian economy<br />
in an attempt to draw a picture for recovery dynamics.<br />
The global economic condition now is a result of an extended prosperity period, which led to over confidence, and lack of discipline.<br />
In the course of this period a balloon of bad and doubtful debt was created and propagated through newly invented tools (i.e. securitization).<br />
Since the US government and consequently the remaining of the world have admitted the economic crisis in early 2008, all<br />
that is being done is patching gaps that were created in the system over the last 10 or more years. During this period the global financial<br />
system has come to near halt resulting in a situation with typical recessionary symptoms in terms of residing demand and<br />
business close downs.<br />
How will the Recovery Take Place On a Global Scale?<br />
We believe that global economical ailments will undergo two phases towards full recovery. Phase one started with governments<br />
pumping life into financial institutions with high NPLs and low capitalization generated from toxic assets. This phase is expected to<br />
end once these institutions become well capitalized and funded to cover the ailments of the previous era, some time between mid to<br />
end of 2009, as most of the stimulus packages would be allocated.<br />
Phase two comprises the gradual regaining of confidence in the global financial system from regulators on one side, and from investors<br />
on the other side. Phase two is considered half way down the road towards gradual expansion in credit facilities and new investments<br />
by global funds. Subsequently, governments will gradually reduce their stakes in the previously nationalized banks through the<br />
capital markets. Main challenge of this phase is enacting an efficient set of regulations that will not deter potential growth. Phase<br />
two is expected to end in recovering demand in the west, moving to the rest of the world through the spill over effect.<br />
We expect the spill over effect of this improvement to go through another economic cycle of 12 to 18 months.<br />
Having said this, we expect phase one to go on till mid to end 2009, showing a duration period of 18 to 24 months since it started<br />
end of 2007. The recovery period or phase two is expected to reach full momentum by end of 2010 to mid 2011<br />
So what does this imply to the Middle East?<br />
Following the global trend, GCC witnessed ballooning real estate prices and indirect over exposure to toxic assets in the west. The<br />
main impact on the region, however, resulted from crude oil prices crashing from over the US$100/barrel to less than half this level.<br />
This created a sense of cash dry up and consequently led to cancellation of projects and subdued demand either for lack of confidence<br />
in the future or for government budgets becoming more tight.<br />
In our scenario, we expect that the recovery in the region will be twofold concurrent with the global recovery. The first comprises<br />
the exposure of regional players to toxic assets, while the second will depend on rebounding oil prices consequent to recovering<br />
external demand. Accordingly, pressure on regional state budgets will be elevated.<br />
So Where Does This Put Egypt?<br />
The Egyptian economy was relatively sheltered from Phase one due to overly protected banking system characterized by high excess<br />
liquidity. However, this does not shield Egypt from having to wait for the global economy to come back on track. Egypt’s economy has<br />
depended in the past years on regional fund inflows from investors and from Remittances, Tourism and Suez Canal receipts. All<br />
of which are expected to experience a crunch until the global and more importantly regional recovery materializes. Egypt also experienced<br />
a similar period of inflated asset prices (i.e. equities & land prices) due to over confidence.<br />
Inflation To Go Down<br />
Inflation is expected to go down locally driven by two reasons. Firstly, no more subsidy cuts are expected in the near future. Secondly,<br />
because we do not expect that commodity prices will reach there highs any time soon since prices were brought up in 2007<br />
driven by speculation, a prevailing pattern at the end of any upward cycle. This would mean that on average we expect oil prices to<br />
reach around US$50-55 by end of 2009 while once full recovery is achieved, we expect oil to remain at US$80/barrel.<br />
During 2006 to mid 2008 commodity prices have increased to a level that put a strain on consumers resulting in inflation levels that<br />
made any type of fixed income investment unattractive, while equity investments provided the only option that can in theory provide<br />
a return outpacing these high inflation levels.<br />
Exports are expected to decline by 25% in FY09 mainly attributed to plummeting prices of oil and semi-processed goods constituting<br />
the bulk (i.e. 62%) of Egyptian exports. Similar drastic price declines is not expected in FY10 which, together with a rebounding economy<br />
in the latter half of FY10, justifies our expectation of 6% increase in export receipts.<br />
Prime Research 4
STRATEGY-SECTORS OUTLOOK<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Tourism slowdown is imminent in 2009, while recovery is expected to show early indicators by the second half of FY10. This will<br />
lead to a 10% drop in tourist related revenues in FY09 and a 5% increase in FY10. Another segment expected to be hit is second<br />
homes for tourists requiring a large initial investment that we believe may lag another year prior to its recovery meaning by 2011.<br />
Real estate will continue to have pent up demand in low and medium income housing which will suffer a marginal drop due to the<br />
negative sentiment but will remain more robust compared to the upper end of the market which has come close to a saturation level<br />
in the previous bull wave. However, we expect another upward wave in the upper class linked to both global and more importantly<br />
the regional demand, starting in Dubai and creating euphoria of demand in another country or state and then another wave is expected<br />
to emerge in Qatar and KSA and will spill over into Egypt and other non-GCC Arab countries.<br />
Telecom sector would suffer from lower disposable income, which would marginally limit growth in 2009 and 2010. However, addressed<br />
market growth, given the fact that telecom services are now more of a necessity than a luxury, we believe it will be just a<br />
muted growth rather than a decline in earning levels.<br />
Consumer durables will be affected due to domestic decline in income levels and the negative sentiment, which will draw consumers<br />
more to saving than spending. Furthermore, we expect another wave of increasing imported goods at lower prices due to lack of<br />
global demand, which will put local goods on the defensive and will further impact margins. This would put the sector as speculative<br />
at best. However, the auto industry will witness a slowdown while the market may shift further toward lower priced vehicles, which<br />
will eventually benefit the local players marginally given the price differential.<br />
Banking sector in Egypt is different from that of the most of the world since there is no structural issues that would cause major<br />
concern about the performance of their portfolios. However, banks will remain more conscious about expanding their credit facilities<br />
which will limit the growth on their balance sheets and income. However, we expect that banks will witness steady growth since no<br />
major restructuring is required and the retail segment of the market is still underserved. Furthermore, by mid 2010 as global banking<br />
sector show signs of recovery, competition will increase again in extending credit to both corporate entities and individuals.<br />
Financial sector is mostly correlated to the capital market and thereby its slowdown and recovery will be fully correlated to that of<br />
public sentiment and risk aptitude. The stock market is expected to gradually improve anytime from the second half of 2009 to first<br />
quarter of 2010, since by that time the uncertainty of the size of the damage to the global financial sector will start to reside.<br />
Agricultural sector has been hit by falling commodity prices, which led to less aggressive approach toward utilization of fertilizers in<br />
order to cut cost. Furthermore, inventory of raw materials in fertilizer companies have been built up at relatively high prices. This<br />
would lead to around six to nine months of squeezed margins accompanied with declining revenue volume till end of Q2 2009 followed<br />
by minor growth in volumes till year end. Starting 2010, food inventories will diminish leading to gradual increase in prices and<br />
volumes.<br />
The question remains, Should equities recover, will Egypt outpace or at least equalize with other Emerging Markets upward moves?<br />
The fact remains, the correlation of the coming impulsive wave between Egypt and the remaining of the emerging markets will largely<br />
depend on structural and dormant variables in Egypt’s macro picture as well as how much discount/premium Egyptian equities<br />
will be trading at by the time Equities recover.<br />
Does Egypt have more structural changes or dormant variables that it can occur to outpace the other<br />
emerging markets another time with the next upward cycle?<br />
• If the government times the further removal of subsidies and eliminating more imbalances to the time when the emerging economies<br />
witness the extent of the recovery, these actions will have less painful effect although it will entail forsaking short term<br />
growth for a stable future outlook;<br />
• Mortgage finance, though implemented in the previous cycle, it has not yet been fully utilized. With the next round of demand<br />
spree over real estate this under utilized tool can provide the launching pad for another fast paced growth in the sector;<br />
• The financial sector have not been severely hit this time thanks to local banks still reminded by the late 90s local credit crisis and<br />
the continuous follow up of the CBE. However, the extent of the current down cycle on banks performance is yet to be established.<br />
Given that we are already half way down the road, the current indicators show that the financial sector will come out of<br />
this downward cycle with relatively minimal damage and, hence, will be in a better place to sponsor growth in the next cycle<br />
than peer countries;<br />
• Pressure from environmentalist groups in developed countries accompanied with low demand is currently taking place and will<br />
continue in 2009 and 2010 leading to more shut downs in these countries. As economic recovery takes place another phase of<br />
acquisitions of existing production facilities in emerging markets by foreign investors may seem cheaper than reopening given the<br />
carbon emission benefits. This will create an improved BOP from FDI injections.<br />
The following 2 pages will include a summary of our Global, Regional and Local view of how the recovery will happen,<br />
followed by a summary of our outlook on main sectors. The remaining of this note will be dedicated to our Economic<br />
and Stock Market Focus as well as a valuation of our Short and Long Term Stock Picks.<br />
Prime Research 5
PUTTING IT ALL TOGETHER<br />
(BIG PICTURE)
2009 SECTORS OUTLOOK (SUMMARY)<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Financial Services & Banking<br />
Banking Sector Outlook: Positive<br />
Housing & Real Estate<br />
Sectors Outlook: Negative<br />
Upside<br />
Downside<br />
Upside<br />
Downside<br />
• By law, foreign banks shall have<br />
funds in Egypt equivalent to its<br />
obligations and payables, eliminating<br />
the default risk due to<br />
external factors<br />
• Low trading Investments/total<br />
Banking Assets<br />
• Loan/Deposit ratio of 56%<br />
• Excess liquidity<br />
• Foreign exchange liquidity is<br />
highly limited<br />
Downside on Brokerage Firms<br />
• Decline in average trading value<br />
n FY09<br />
• Expected decline in M&A activity<br />
during FY09<br />
• Egypt has one of the fastest<br />
growing infrastructure sectors in<br />
the region, covering various segments;<br />
transport, tourism, commercial<br />
and industrial<br />
• Young growing population should<br />
maintain growth once the waitand–<br />
see attitude comes to an<br />
end<br />
• Unwillingness to borrow so as to<br />
buy properties after the increase<br />
in interest rates<br />
• A new tax rate is expected to be<br />
active this year<br />
• A supply gap for the housing<br />
units<br />
• A decline in steel & cement selling<br />
prices<br />
• Government encourages steel<br />
imports<br />
Petrochemicals, Chemicals & Fertilizers<br />
Sectors Outlook: Negative<br />
Food & Agriculture<br />
Sectors Outlook: Neutral<br />
Upside<br />
Downside<br />
Upside<br />
Downside<br />
• Cheap feedstock<br />
• Growing local demand<br />
• Direct relationship with food and<br />
agriculture<br />
• Local natural gas prices increased<br />
by 76% putting pressure on<br />
manufacturers’ costs<br />
• selling prices slumped dramatically<br />
• Recent decline in raw materials<br />
prices affected companies keeping<br />
expensive inventory<br />
• Population benefit<br />
• Liberalizing trade in agricultural<br />
products<br />
• Government prioritizing land<br />
reclamation<br />
• Food consumption accounts for<br />
26.8% of GDP<br />
• Absolute decline in numbers in<br />
monetary terms<br />
Telecoms<br />
Sectors Outlook: Positive<br />
Upside<br />
Downside<br />
Pharmaceuticals<br />
Sectors Outlook: Positive<br />
Upside<br />
Downside<br />
• Low penetration rate of around<br />
50%<br />
• More than anticipated decline in<br />
Mobile Sets’ Sales<br />
• Growing population<br />
• Price caps<br />
• Population bodes well for spending<br />
per subscriber<br />
• Lower available Income<br />
• Increased health awareness<br />
• TRIPS halts growth<br />
• Positive elasticity mitigates AR-<br />
PUs Decline<br />
• Prolonged recession would affect<br />
spending<br />
Tourism<br />
Sectors Outlook: Negative<br />
Upside<br />
Downside<br />
Construction / Building Materials<br />
Sectors Outlook: Negative<br />
Upside<br />
Downside<br />
• Cheaper destination when compared<br />
to other destinations such<br />
as Turkey, UAE and Morocco<br />
• Growing government investment<br />
in the sector to increase number<br />
of rooms available<br />
• Severe decline in tourist numbers<br />
• Severe Decline in tourist spending<br />
• Fall in hotel occupancy rates<br />
• Steep decline in steel/cement<br />
prices<br />
• Slowdown in construction activity<br />
• Government infrastructure projects<br />
• Prolonged recession would hit<br />
pent up demand for housing<br />
units<br />
Prime Research 7
2009 STOCK PICKS<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Short Term Picks<br />
Short-term recommendations are those for companies that are expected to perform better than average during the slow down, which<br />
would imply that they are the least exposed to the current economic downward conditions. Thereby in 2009, We overweight sectors<br />
of Telecommunication, Pharmaceuticals and banks due to the following:<br />
1) Companies in defensive Sectors / High FCF Yields<br />
2) Visible positive earnings in 2009<br />
3) Cash rich companies well positioned to withstand a recession<br />
4) Low leverage or None<br />
5) High payout Ratio<br />
6) Well branded products / services<br />
7) Strong management with a track record<br />
Short Term Stock Picks<br />
Earnings Per Share Dividends Yield Valuation Multiples<br />
RIC FY08 FY09 3Y Growth FY08 FY09 PE08 PE09<br />
EV/<br />
EBITDA08<br />
EV/<br />
EBITDA09<br />
P/B<br />
MOIL.CA 0.34 0.46 33% 9% 13% 7.74x 5.81x 6.76x 4.62x 3.30x<br />
EMOB.CA 18.60 19.60 5% 10% 11% 7.57x 7.18x 3.85x 3.46x 6.22x<br />
PHAR.CA 3.54 3.85 9% 9% 10% 7.07x 6.49x 2.92x 2.76x 1.48x<br />
ETEL.CA 1.76 1.85 5% 9% 9% 8.35x 7.98x 4.97x 4.65x 0.91x<br />
NSGB.CA* 3.52 2.76 -22% 7% 8% 4.26x 5.43x 0.00x 0.00x 0.82x<br />
COMI.CA 4.69 4.98 6% 3% 4% 7.22x 6.79x 0.00x 0.00x 1.71x<br />
1 Year Price Earning Growth Chart<br />
40%<br />
30%<br />
MOIL.CA<br />
TMGH.CA<br />
20%<br />
FY09 EPS<br />
Growth<br />
10 %<br />
0%<br />
-10%<br />
SWDY.CA<br />
CIEB.CA<br />
EGTS.CA<br />
ORTE.CA<br />
AMOC.CA<br />
PHAR.CA<br />
COMI.CA<br />
ETEL.CA<br />
EM OB.CA<br />
SUGR.CA<br />
EXPA.CA<br />
SKPC.CA<br />
-20%<br />
AUTO.CA<br />
NSGB.CA<br />
EFIC.CA<br />
HRHO.CA<br />
-30%<br />
IFA P .CA<br />
-40%<br />
PIOH.CA<br />
0x 2x 4x 6x 8x 10x 12x 14x 16x 18x 20x<br />
Price / Earnings 09<br />
*NSGB reads a –22% due to reversal of provision which if eliminated would result in a 13%<br />
Source: Prime Estimates<br />
Prime Research 8
2009 PICKS (CONT’D)<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Long Term Picks<br />
We draft our Long-term recommendations on companies that will provide the highest capital appreciation based on their fundamental<br />
value compared to current market prices in the next upward stock market cycle. In our opinion, these long term picks will approach<br />
their intrinsic values once demand rebound again and recovery takes place, moreover, they meet the following criteria:<br />
1) Strong management<br />
2) Visible ongoing Expansions<br />
3) Well positioned within market Competition<br />
4) Sustainable free cash flows<br />
5) Highest upside to their DCF values<br />
6) Currently trading on low multiples<br />
Long Term Stock Picks<br />
RIC<br />
Upside To<br />
DCF<br />
FY08<br />
Earnings Per Share Dividends Yield Valuation Multiples<br />
FY09<br />
3Y<br />
Growth<br />
FY08 FY09 PE08 PE09<br />
EV/<br />
EBITDA08<br />
EV/<br />
EBITDA0<br />
9<br />
P/Book<br />
TMGH.CA 301% 0.79 0.99 49% 0% 0% 3.28x 2.63x 2.23x 1.59x 0.23x<br />
SWDY.CA 127% 6.91 7.36 19% 0% 0% 5.67x 5.32x 5.61x 4.95x 1.46x<br />
HRHO.CA 93% 2.77 0.95 -12% 4% 1% 4.95x 14.37x 0.31x 0.31x 0.67x<br />
OCIC.CA* 202% 23.75 10.53 -30% 3% 1% 5.05x 11.38x 4.42x 6.19x 1.73x<br />
3 Year Price Earning Growth Chart<br />
40.0%<br />
COMI.CA<br />
30.0%<br />
NSGB.CA<br />
20.0%<br />
SWDY.CA<br />
M OIL.CA<br />
PIOH.CA<br />
ORTE.CA<br />
PHAR.CA<br />
10 .0 %<br />
ETEL.CA<br />
FY09 EPS<br />
Growth<br />
0.0%<br />
EXPA.CA<br />
AUTO.CA<br />
AMOC.CA<br />
CIEB.CA<br />
EM OB.CA<br />
SUGR.CA<br />
-10.0%<br />
EFIC.CA<br />
HRHO.CA<br />
-20.0%<br />
SKPC.CA<br />
-30.0%<br />
Series1<br />
IFAP .CA<br />
-40.0%<br />
0x 2x 4x 6x 8x 10x 12x 14x 16x 18x 20x<br />
Price / Earnings 09<br />
Source: Prime Estimates<br />
*OCI reads –30% over a 3 years period due to LE1.4 unusual gains of divesture of Egyptian Containers Handling<br />
Prime Research 9
2009 EQUITY STRATEGY<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
This Page has been Left Intentionally Blank<br />
Prime Research 10
ECONOMIC FOCUS<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
GDP Growth-Gains Momentum From Domestic Demand<br />
Although GDP growth is hindered by a receding global economy, momentum<br />
is gained from domestic demand. Our expectation for GDP growth<br />
hover around 4.1% growth in FY09, justified by the fact that household<br />
demand and government expenditure constitute 82% of GDP. Also,<br />
we Expect the latter half of FY10 to witness the beginning of an economic<br />
rebound to be reflected in 4.5% domestic GDP growth, basically driven<br />
by higher export, tourism and Suez Canal receipts. A close scrutiny of GDP<br />
components is provided below.<br />
High Household Consumption Driven by Wide<br />
Population Base<br />
We forecast a conservative estimate of 3.5% growth in household<br />
consumption in FY09 and FY10. Bearing in mind that population<br />
growth rate is 2%, this implies that spending patterns will increase by only<br />
1.5% in FY09. This is very much on the conservative side taking into consideration<br />
that no massive lay offs have taken place in Egypt. Q1 FY09, as<br />
well as FY08 data reveals high propensity to consume. In FY08, household<br />
consumption grew at 7.6%, a level exceeding GDP growth of 7.2%. Similarly,<br />
1Q FY09 revealed GDP growth of 5.7% y-o-y, close to the 5.8% y-o-y<br />
growth in GDP.<br />
However, we believe suppliers to change their product definition to suit B and C income groups. In this respect new cash and carry,<br />
and wholesale outlets are planned.<br />
Government Spending-Paving The Road for Future<br />
Growth<br />
In order to lubricate the economy the government pledged LE15 billion<br />
package to be spent on infrastructure as well as tax/tariff subsidies.<br />
FY08 witnessed a 2.1% growth in government spending, while Q1<br />
FY09 witnessed a 5.4% y-o-y surge. In FY09 and FY10 we expect government<br />
expenditure to grow by 4% and 3%, respectively, based on the<br />
authorities announced intentions to foster potential for economic growth<br />
through creating a developed infra structural base. The breakdown of the<br />
government stimulus package is identified as follows:<br />
• Water and waste water projects for LE5 billion<br />
• Public schools with a cost of LE150 million<br />
• Industrial areas for LE400 million<br />
• Medical centers worth LE400 million<br />
• Port development for LE200 million<br />
Moreover, LE2 billion has been allocated to subsidize custom duties and<br />
taxes on investment related goods.<br />
Budget Deficit-Financed Internally With Low Risk of Defaulting<br />
Indicator<br />
Nominal GDP (LE Billion)<br />
GDP Growth (%)<br />
Inflation Rate<br />
Exchange Rate (LE/US$)<br />
Current Account (US$ Billion)<br />
Government Deficit/GDP (%)<br />
EGP Million<br />
500,000<br />
400,000<br />
300,000<br />
200,000<br />
100,000<br />
0<br />
Main Economic Parameters<br />
FY06<br />
FY09<br />
1,067<br />
4.1%<br />
15%<br />
5.6<br />
-5.0<br />
-7.0%<br />
Government Budget<br />
FY07<br />
FY08<br />
Budget Deficit<br />
FY09f<br />
FY10<br />
1,216<br />
4.5%<br />
10%<br />
5.8<br />
-3.8<br />
-7.1%<br />
Source: Prime Estimates<br />
FY10f<br />
10.0%<br />
8.0%<br />
6.0%<br />
4.0%<br />
2.0%<br />
0.0%<br />
Revenue Expenditure Deficit/GDP<br />
Source: CBE/Prime Estimates<br />
Budget deficit deteriorated significantly in FY08 to constitute 6.8% of<br />
GDP compared to the 5.7% reported in FY07. The deterioration is<br />
caused by hiking international prices of oil and basic food items subsidized<br />
by the government. Hence, amounts devoted to subsidies witnessed<br />
a 56% increase to LE84.2 billion. On the other hand, government<br />
revenue witnessed a moderate 21% increase with income from taxes<br />
constituting 62% of total revenue.<br />
FY08 deficit was mainly financed through LE11.4 billion in external debt,<br />
LE527 million in domestic debt, and LE38.9 billion from a government<br />
contingency account. 1Q FY09, deficit amounted to LE22.8 billion financed<br />
through LE519 million in bonds, LE19 billion in bills and LE20.6<br />
billion in bank loans. LE3 billion was given in repayment of external debt<br />
in 1Q FY09. Going forward, we adjust our budget deficit upwards to<br />
settle at 7.0% and 7.1% of GDP in FY09 and FY10, respectively.<br />
We expect the banking system excess liquidity to be used in financing<br />
the budget deficit.<br />
Fiscal<br />
Account<br />
(LE bn)<br />
Total<br />
Revenues<br />
Total<br />
Expenditures<br />
Deficit/<br />
Surplus<br />
Deficit/<br />
Surplus/<br />
GDP<br />
FY06<br />
151.6<br />
207.8<br />
-56.2<br />
-9.2%<br />
FY07<br />
180.2<br />
222.0<br />
-41.8<br />
-5.7%<br />
FY08 FY09f FY10f<br />
221.4 263.7 303.2<br />
282.3 338.7 389.6<br />
-60.9 -75.0 -86.3<br />
-6.8% -7.0% -7.1%<br />
Source: CBE/Prime Estimates<br />
Prime Research 11
ECONOMIC FOCUS (CONT’D)<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
The government agenda for enhancing public financing encompass the following;<br />
• Applying the VAT in a later period in 2010 to replace the sales tax, expected to yield 2% of GDP as government revenue;<br />
• Streamlining the subsidy system through canceling in-kind food subsidies and making direct cash transfers, instead;<br />
• Undertaking a second round of privatization of state enterprises through free transfer of shares and retained ownership through<br />
holding companies for restructuring and debt settlement.<br />
Investment Friendly Environment<br />
We perceive the current economic environment in Egypt as investment friendly, as illustrated by the following;<br />
• Availability of credit that can be extended to business organizations as illustrated by a an L/D ratio of 55% as of November<br />
2008, with excess cash amounting to LE343.7 billion or 38% of GDP and more than double the budget deficit of FY09 and<br />
FY10, respectively<br />
• Expansionary monetary policy inducing interest rate cuts to 10.5% and 12.5% on overnight deposits and lending, respectively,<br />
with possible further 50 bps cut till June 2009<br />
• Government measurements aiming at lubricating investment through postponing the introduction of VAT and energy price increases<br />
until a later period in 2010. This is in addition to reinstating the free zone status for oil refineries, developing the infrastructure,<br />
and subsidizing tariffs on investment-related goods<br />
• Huge market with a high consumption potential<br />
In 2008, domestic investment represented over 60% of total investment with FDI inflows standing at around 38%. Investment in oil<br />
extraction activities, oil refining and manufacturing, transportation and communication represented 17%, 27% and 16% of total<br />
investment, respectively. The USA contributed 36% of FDI, EU 29%, Arab countries 17%, and other countries 18%.<br />
We expect a 6% growth in investment over FY09 and FY10. Announced projects and fields of foreign direct investment over<br />
the coming years are identified as follows:<br />
• Agricultural and milk projects with investment cost of LE2 billion to be injected by Saudi Investor, Soultan Ben Mohamed Ben<br />
Masoud<br />
• Industrial and tourism projects with investment cost of US$3 billion by the Kuwaiti Kharafi <strong>Group</strong><br />
• Abu Qir gas field with overall investment of US$1.3 billion by the Italian Edison SPA<br />
• A new oil field discovered in the western desert, 80 km from the borders with Libya. Production capacity is 5k b/d of oil and 4.3<br />
million cubic feet/day of gas<br />
• A steel billet factory and a mineral salt extracting project with US$2 billion investment cost by the Kuwaiti Kharafi group<br />
• A discussion of a Russian industrial zone to be established in Borg Al Arab over 5 years comprising factories for cars, airplanes,<br />
electrical tools and petroleum equipment<br />
• LNG floating terminals to ship gas produced in Egypt by Shell. The company already signed an initial multi-billion dollar contract<br />
with Iraq government to establish a similar project there<br />
• The second phase of East Port Said development project with a total investment cost of US$700 million to be completed in<br />
2011. The project aims at increasing the port’s capacity to 5.1 million containers annually from the current 2.1 million.<br />
Our main concern with regard to investment is that it is a function of fragmented, and in some cases contradicting, government decisions<br />
as opposed to being a part of an integrated plan aiming at capitalizing on the country’s resources (i.e. manpower, agricultural<br />
land … etc.) and preserving environmental resources and hence, ensuring sustainable growth. At the moment, investment opportunities<br />
capitalize on the high consumption potential in Egyptian markets while exploiting the environment, which makes economic<br />
growth in Egypt pretty unsustainable.<br />
External Linkages Posing Pressure on the<br />
External Account<br />
Lower export, Suez Canal and tourism receipts are currently<br />
perceived as the main growth hindrances. Q1<br />
FY09, however, came in strong with regard to all three items,<br />
however, the rest of FY09 is expected to reflect the repercussions<br />
of the worldwide credit crunch. A 25% decline in exports is<br />
expected in FY09 mainly attributed to plummeting prices of oil<br />
and semi-processed goods constituting the bulk (i.e. 62%) of<br />
Egyptian exports. Similar drastic price declines is not expected in<br />
FY10 which, together with a rebounding economy in the latter<br />
half of FY10, justifies our expectation of 6% increase in export<br />
receipts.<br />
Suez Canal and tourism receipts are expected to witness a<br />
decline of 8% and 10%, respectively, in FY09. FY10, however, is<br />
expected to witness a rebound of 5% and 6% in tourism and<br />
Suez Canal receipts, respectively.<br />
External Account<br />
US$(bn)<br />
Exports<br />
Imports<br />
Tourism<br />
Suez Canal<br />
Revenues<br />
Transfers<br />
Current Account<br />
FDI<br />
FY08<br />
29.4<br />
52.8<br />
10.8<br />
5.2<br />
9.3<br />
0.9<br />
13.2<br />
FY09<br />
22.1<br />
50.1<br />
9.7<br />
4.8<br />
9.8<br />
(5.0)<br />
6.5<br />
FY10<br />
23.4<br />
52.5<br />
10.2<br />
5.1<br />
10.8<br />
(3.8)<br />
7.1<br />
Source: CBE/Prime Estimates<br />
Prime Research 12
ECONOMIC FOCUS (CONT’D)<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
We expect a 5% increase in remittance inflows explained by high<br />
interest rates on deposits in Egypt relative to banks abroad, in addition<br />
to a financially secure banking system immune to the global<br />
financial turmoil.<br />
15,000<br />
External Account<br />
Exchange Rate: Pressures Towards Further<br />
Depreciation<br />
Egyptian pound depreciated to its current levels at LE5.6/US$ compared<br />
to its December resistance level at LE5.5/US$. The fall is accompanied<br />
by declining official reserves to US$33 billion in December<br />
from US$34 billion in October 2008. NIR in months of merchandise<br />
imports is roughly estimated at 7 months, using recent import<br />
data, from 7.9 months in June 2008 and 8.9 months in June 2007.<br />
Accordingly, we see pressure on the Egyptian pound to further depreciate<br />
to LE5.8/US$ by beginning of FY10. We believe the authorities<br />
will maintain a flexible exchange rate policy due to the risks<br />
entailed in managing the currency in a time of weakening balance of<br />
payment.<br />
Anticipated Immediate Slow Down of Inflationary<br />
Pressures with The Possibility of Another<br />
Wave of Grave Price Increases in The<br />
Long Run<br />
Inflation surged to 23.6% y-o-y in August 2008, following hiking<br />
international prices further aggravated by oil subsidy cut in May,<br />
2008. However, following international recessionary pressures and<br />
tightening monetary policy, inflation declined to 14% y-o-y in January<br />
2009. We expect monthly inflation rate to settle at 5% y-o-y by<br />
June 2009 since June 2008 witnessed hiking prices.<br />
Inflation surges during 2008 shed some light on inadequacies inherent in the economic system in Egypt, that we identify as follows;<br />
• Prices not reflecting the real cost (i.e. subsidies/price distortions);<br />
• Low productivity translated in low disposable personal income and resulting in reliance on subsidies;<br />
• Inefficiency of some industries turning to be unprofitable following the oil subsidy cut;<br />
• Vulnerability of the government budget to external price shocks.<br />
We believe that as the international economy rebounds another wave of inflation surges is possible that might result from external<br />
and internal factors, specified as follows;<br />
• Increasing international demand leading to fast price increases globally;<br />
• Internal economic reform towards liberalizing the economy through gradual subsidy cuts;<br />
• Rapid population growth and depleting resources illustrated by the fact that currently Egypt imports 40% of its food needs.<br />
In this respect, we emphasize the importance of encouraging investment in areas assessed to be economically viable assuming subsidy<br />
cuts are undertaken.<br />
Interest Rate Reflecting a Monetary Expansion<br />
Monetary tightening has ended with the CBE shifting its focus from inflation concerns to stagnating GDP growth. Accordingly, interest<br />
rates declined by 100 bps to 10.5% and 12.5% on overnight deposits and lending, respectively. We anticipate further interest<br />
rate cuts with a floor of 9.5% and 11.5% on overnight deposits and lending, respectively. Timing of further cuts depends on the<br />
speed by which inflation declines.<br />
USD Million<br />
CPI<br />
10,000<br />
5,000<br />
0<br />
-5,000<br />
-10,000<br />
-15,000<br />
Exchange Rate<br />
(LE/US$)<br />
Overnight Interbank<br />
Rate<br />
FY06<br />
FY06<br />
10%<br />
5.8<br />
9.5%<br />
FY07<br />
FY07<br />
15%<br />
5.5<br />
9.5%<br />
FY08<br />
Money Variables<br />
FY08<br />
12%<br />
5.5<br />
10.3%<br />
FY09e<br />
FY09<br />
11%<br />
5.7<br />
8.8%<br />
FY10f<br />
CA Balance Balance of Goods & Services Remittances<br />
`<br />
Source: CBE/Prime Estimates<br />
FY10<br />
4%<br />
5.8<br />
8.6%<br />
Source: MOF/Prime Estimates<br />
Prime Research 13
2009 INVESTMENT STRATEGY<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
This Page has been Left Intentionally Blank<br />
Prime Research 14
STOCK MARKET FOCUS<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
DISTRESSED EXTERMAL MACRO DRIVERS HIT<br />
LOCAL MARKET DYMANICS<br />
MSCI Egypt reached a peak in January 2008 where it managed to<br />
grow by 50% from Jan FY07, however, amid global worsening conditions<br />
and in line with EMEA markets, MSCI Egypt deteriorated intensively,<br />
specially after May 5 decisions which investors received<br />
bitterly on already soft volumes. Worse comes to worst with margin<br />
calls for declining asset prices and brokers closing positions on fears<br />
of declining equity values.<br />
0<br />
Tension Causing Redemptions<br />
Average daily value declined vigorously in 2009, from an average of<br />
LE1.3 billion to an average of LE500 million recorded in the beginnings<br />
of 2009. This could be attributed to change in market dynamics,<br />
namely, decline in institutional trading and lower foreign partici-<br />
Source: Prime Estimates<br />
pation. Worries from lower NAVs and less dividends from mutual funds causing asset prices to decline exponentially, despite the lack<br />
of data on AUMs available on hand with fund managers, we don’t expect less than 65% decline in assets under management.<br />
Consequently, institutional trading reached a deteriorated levels in March 2009 to 19%, down from an average of 60% recorded in<br />
January 2008. Secondly, foreign trading, including GCC fund flows, continued to deteriorate due to declining oil prices and margin<br />
calls, which also contributed negatively to lower volumes and negative sentiment. Moreover, anticipation of a weaker Egyptian pound<br />
due to weaker BOP and lower interest rates causing foreign funds to wait till the currency settle down at which time funds inflows<br />
would adjust to newer risk premium<br />
2,500<br />
2,000<br />
1,500<br />
1,000<br />
500<br />
02-01-2008<br />
14-02-2008<br />
28-03-2008<br />
MSCI Egypt<br />
12-05-2008<br />
25-06-2008<br />
07-08-2008<br />
MSCI Arabian<br />
24-09-2008<br />
06-11-2008<br />
18-12-2008<br />
02-02-2009<br />
100%<br />
90%<br />
80%<br />
Retail % Institutions %<br />
Institutions %, 86%<br />
Retail %, 75%<br />
100%<br />
90%<br />
80%<br />
Local Value<br />
Foreign Value, 51%<br />
Foreign Value<br />
60%<br />
50%<br />
70%<br />
60%<br />
70%<br />
60%<br />
40%<br />
50%<br />
50%<br />
30%<br />
40%<br />
30%<br />
20%<br />
10%<br />
0%<br />
Retail %, 14%<br />
Institutions %, 25%<br />
40%<br />
30%<br />
20%<br />
10%<br />
0%<br />
Foreign Value,<br />
6.60%<br />
20%<br />
10%<br />
0%<br />
Jan-08<br />
Feb-08<br />
Mar-08<br />
Apr-08<br />
May-08<br />
May-08<br />
Jun-08<br />
Jul-08<br />
Aug-08<br />
Sep-08<br />
Oct-08<br />
Nov-08<br />
Dec-08<br />
Jan-09<br />
Feb-09<br />
Jan-08<br />
Feb-08<br />
Mar-08<br />
Apr-08<br />
May-08<br />
May-08<br />
Jun-08<br />
Jul-08<br />
Aug-08<br />
Sep-08<br />
Oct-08<br />
Nov-08<br />
Dec-08<br />
Jan-09<br />
Feb-09<br />
Source: Prime Estimates<br />
We See Market Dynamics Improving by 2H FY09<br />
Almost 3 months are already through from 2009 with a noticeable retail buying in small caps and the market turning over around<br />
LE480 million daily with volumes starting to marginally improve to reach an average of 90 million recorded in march, up from 60 million<br />
recorded in late 2008. Accordingly, we expect market dynamics to improve gradually once the currency stabilizes and BOP starts<br />
to improve along with global improvement as discussed in the strategy part.<br />
Historical PE is Touched, Indicating that<br />
the Boom-Bust Cycle is Or Almost Over<br />
In January FY08, PAMI stocks recorded a PE of 22x, at<br />
which time the sub prime crisis continued to develop<br />
dramatically, along with May 5, 2008 decisions, panic<br />
selling dominated the market among local and foreign<br />
investors, taking PE to historical levels, as noted by<br />
values recorded in October 2008 to an average of<br />
5.6x, a 37% discount to MENA peers.<br />
24x<br />
22x<br />
20x<br />
18x<br />
16x<br />
14x<br />
12x<br />
10x<br />
8x<br />
6x<br />
PAMI P/E (1998-2009)<br />
September 2002<br />
PE 4.5x<br />
October<br />
2008<br />
PE 5.18x<br />
4x<br />
01-Jan-98<br />
09-Apr-98<br />
16-Jul-98<br />
19-Oct-98<br />
21-Jan-99<br />
02-May-99<br />
02-Aug-99<br />
02-Nov-99<br />
03-Feb-00<br />
14-May-00<br />
15-Aug-00<br />
15-Nov-00<br />
19-Feb-01<br />
31-May-01<br />
04-Sep-01<br />
04-Dec-01<br />
14-Mar-02<br />
25-Jun-02<br />
30-Sep-02<br />
05-Jan-03<br />
16-Apr-03<br />
24-Jul-03<br />
26-Oct-03<br />
03-Feb-04<br />
10-May-04<br />
10-Aug-04<br />
10-Nov-04<br />
16-Feb-05<br />
25-May-05<br />
24-Aug-05<br />
28-Nov-05<br />
05-Mar-06<br />
11-Jun-06<br />
11-Sep-06<br />
19-Dec-06<br />
28-Mar-07<br />
05-Jul-07<br />
08-Oct-07<br />
20-Jan-08<br />
21-Apr-08<br />
28-Jul-08<br />
30-Oct-08<br />
Source: Prime Estimates<br />
Prime Research 15
STOCK MARKET FOCUS (CONT’D)<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Despite Worsening Market Dynamics, Regional Multiples Favor Egypt<br />
Steep declines in equities have caused FY09 valuations multiples to turn in favor of Egypt given a dividends yield of around 8.7%,<br />
50% higher than most countries except Kuwait, while trading at 7.67x FY09 earnings, representing the lowest PER09 next to UAE<br />
which sound cheaper in this respect. However, collectively dividends yield coupled with a cheap PE would favor Egypt<br />
P/E x<br />
P/B x<br />
20<br />
18.50<br />
3.0<br />
2.76<br />
15<br />
10<br />
5<br />
10.51<br />
7.67<br />
9.77<br />
14.48<br />
5.38 5.31<br />
2.5<br />
2.0<br />
1.5<br />
1.0<br />
0.5<br />
1.80 1.88 1.78<br />
1.65<br />
0.63<br />
0.90<br />
0<br />
0.0<br />
Kuwait<br />
Egypt<br />
Saudi<br />
Arabia<br />
Bahrain<br />
Dubai<br />
Abu<br />
Dhabi<br />
Qatar<br />
Kuwait<br />
Egypt<br />
Saudi<br />
Arabia<br />
Bahrain<br />
Dubai<br />
Abu<br />
Dhabi<br />
Qatar<br />
Div Yld %<br />
10.0<br />
8.0<br />
6.0<br />
4.0<br />
2.0<br />
0.0<br />
8.25 8.73<br />
4.60<br />
5.48<br />
4.70<br />
3.98<br />
2.84<br />
Kuwait<br />
Egypt<br />
Saudi<br />
Arabia<br />
Bahrain<br />
Dubai<br />
Abu<br />
Dhabi<br />
Qatar<br />
A Selection of 30 Companies Generated a 38% Decline in EPS, While Market Prices Assume<br />
80% Decline<br />
We have slashed our forecasts for earnings across all sectors by an average of 38%, this implies a PER of 12x FY09 earnings, while<br />
market trades on PER of 7.67x FY09 earnings.<br />
We arrived at the 38% decline by the following:<br />
1) Assuming lower or stagnating commodities’ prices to new prices<br />
2) Accounting for lower domestic demand / lower exports<br />
3) Anticipating higher levels of inventory<br />
4) Accounting for more expensive liquidity.<br />
Can The Market Be right?<br />
Investors seem to be discounting worse than existing/expected economic conditions. Market pessimism seem to be disproportionate<br />
to reality, exactly as optimism was out of proportion when the market was rallying. Main factors triggering the pessimism,<br />
in our opinion, are identified as follows:<br />
1) Global uncertainties regarding equities<br />
2) Declining Oil Prices leading GCC investors to withdraw their investments<br />
3) Brokerage Companies being more conservative not extending margins to investors who already lost their positions<br />
4) Wait-to-see-attitude from investors in search for market bottoms<br />
We Strongly Refute The Likelihood of Worsening Economic Conditions Based on The Following:<br />
Source: Prime Estimates<br />
1) Expected expansionary monetary policy by the Central Bank of Egypt<br />
2) Government plan to lubricate the economy through devoting LE15 billion to infrastructure projects and tax subsidies<br />
3) Huge consumption potential attracting FDIs<br />
4) Investment friendly policies adopted by the government<br />
5) Cheap labor.<br />
Prime Research 16
2009 INVESTMENT STRATEGY<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
This Page has been Left Intentionally Blank<br />
Prime Research 17
PRIME PICK: COMMERCIAL<br />
INTERNATIONAL BANK (CIB)<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Target Price Market Price Recommendation Upside Potential Investment Grade<br />
LE40.2 LE34 Buy<br />
18.2%<br />
Value<br />
Share Data<br />
Company Short Name<br />
Sector<br />
Company Traded Market<br />
Report Reason<br />
Valuation Methodology<br />
Previous Target<br />
Exchange Rate<br />
Stock Currency<br />
Reuters Code<br />
CIB<br />
Banking<br />
EGX- LSE<br />
<strong>Equity</strong> strategy<br />
DCFE<br />
LE70.3<br />
LE5.55/US$<br />
LE<br />
COMI.CA - COMIq.L<br />
Outstanding Shares (mn) 292.5<br />
Par Value/Share (LE)<br />
Financial Year Ending<br />
LE10<br />
December<br />
Mkt. Cap (LE mn) 9,945<br />
Weight to PAMI 5.28%<br />
Av. Daily Volume (000) 820<br />
Price Low – High (LE) (52Wk.) 27.01 - 64.88<br />
Shareholders<br />
Ownership Stake<br />
Ripplewood Consortium 8.86%<br />
Bank of New York 22.2%<br />
Dubai Capital 5.24%<br />
Free Float 63.62%<br />
70<br />
60<br />
50<br />
40<br />
30<br />
20<br />
10<br />
0<br />
Jan-08<br />
Mar-08<br />
Stock Performance Chart<br />
(LE / Share)<br />
May-08<br />
Jul-08<br />
Sep-08<br />
Nov-08<br />
Jan-09<br />
Mar-09<br />
Income Statement 2008a 2009e 2010f<br />
Interest Income 3,765 4,589 5,180<br />
Interest Expense 1,967 2,306 2,643<br />
Net Interest Income 1,799 2,283 2,537<br />
Non-Interest Income 1,558 1,744 2,020<br />
Non-Interest Expenses 1,330 1,612 1,866<br />
Operating Income 2,027 2,414 2,691<br />
Provisions 411 436 441<br />
Net Profit Before Tax 1,616 1,978 2,250<br />
Tax Provisions 0 30 45<br />
Income Taxes 251 325 360<br />
NPAT 1,365 1,624 1,845<br />
Other Non Operating Items 0 0 0<br />
NPAUI 1,365 1,624 1,845<br />
Minority Interest Income -5 -6 -7<br />
Non-Appropriation Items 0 173 232<br />
Net Attributable Income 1,371 1,457 1,620<br />
Balance Sheet 2008a 2009e 2010f<br />
Cash and Cash Items 6,493 7,167 8,693<br />
Inter-bank Assets 4,552 8,451 13,961<br />
T-Bills & Gov. Securities 12,558 16,374 20,765<br />
Net Marketable Securities 3,996 4,094 4,558<br />
Net Loans and Advances 26,330 28,316 30,739<br />
Debtors & Other Debt Balances 973 1,426 1,727<br />
Subsidiaries & Direct Invst. 93 239 241<br />
Net Fixed Assets 748 765 793<br />
Other Assets 1,717 1,752 1,787<br />
Total Assets 57,462 68,583 83,264<br />
Claims on Assets<br />
Inter-bank Liabilities 229 451 757<br />
Customer Deposits 48,790 59,726 72,444<br />
Creditors & Other Cr. Balances 1,229 1,100 1,332<br />
Dividend Payable 0 546 748<br />
Other Provisions 373 469 581<br />
Bonds 109 120 132<br />
Other Liabilities 866 874 883<br />
Minority Interest 0 -6 -13<br />
Total Liabilities 51,596 63,280 76,864<br />
Tier 1 : Primary Capital 5,866 5,304 6,401<br />
Paid-In Capital 2,925 2,925 2,925<br />
Capital Surplus 0 0 0<br />
Reserves 1,444 2,458 3,555<br />
Retained Earnings 1,497 -79 -79<br />
Total Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 5,866 5,304 6,401<br />
Total Liab. & Sh. <strong>Equity</strong> 57,462 68,583 83,264<br />
Contingent Liabilities 13,291 14,886 16,672<br />
Total Footings 70,753 83,469 99,937<br />
Free Cash to <strong>Equity</strong> 2008a 2009e 2010f<br />
NAI 1,371 1,457 1,620<br />
Investment Flow: -1,679 562 -1,097<br />
Change in Assets -9,699 -11,122 -14,681<br />
Change in Liabilities 8,020 11,684 13,584<br />
Table 1<br />
Source: Bank Financials & Prime Projections<br />
<strong>Equity</strong> Cash Flow -308 2,019 523<br />
Please refer to disclaimer on last page<br />
Financial Summary (Figures in LE million)<br />
Source: Company Historical & Prime Estimates<br />
Prime Research 18
PRIME PICK: COMMERCIAL<br />
INTERNATIONAL BANK (CIB)<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Meet A Mature & Established Bank<br />
CIB is a main player in the sector in Egypt as it captures a loan market share of 6%. Despite adverse economic environment loans<br />
grew by 28.8% in FY08 leading to total L/D ratio of 57% from 55% in FY07. With regard to financial investments, the bank<br />
tripled its holding of the risk-free government securities leading to total financial investments of LE16.6 billion representing 34% of<br />
customer deposits in FY08 from 16% in FY07. Marketable securities, however, witnessed a 48% increase in marketable securities to<br />
LE3.9 billion. The bank has applied new CBE amendments with regard to valuating available for sale financial investments and held to<br />
maturity. Accordingly, earning assets expanded to LE47.3 billion demonstrating a 16% growth. The bank reported a strong equity<br />
base through a Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR) of 11.72%, perceived as protection against the global economic downturn.<br />
Projections & Valuation<br />
As a result of the economic slowdown and the global financial crisis, we expect a conservative loan growth rate of 8% and 9%<br />
over FY09 and FY10, respectively. We forecast non-interest income to grow at 12% and 16% in FY09 and FY10, respectively,<br />
compared to 38% growth in FY08 and 29% growth in FY07. In order to reflect the risk averse aptitude by investors, we raise<br />
our cost of equity to 16.3% (i.e. 9.6% risk free rate and 6.7% market risk premium).<br />
Investment Rationale<br />
We have a positive sentiment on CIB, due to the following;<br />
• Enhanced profitability as reflected in NIM standing at 3.8% from 2.9% in FY07;<br />
• Manageable risk shown by a CAR of 11.7%;<br />
• Room for growth demonstrated by L/D ratio of 57%;<br />
• Share prices demonstrate 18% upside potential, though not exceedingly high, illustrate a solid earning base.<br />
Size Items (LE millions) 2008a 2009e 2010f 2011f<br />
Total Revenues 5,323 6,332 7,201 8,639<br />
Net Banking Income 3,357 4,026 4,557 5,602<br />
Earning Assets 47,437 57,235 70,024 81,465<br />
Risk Assets. 34,879 40,861 49,259 68,802<br />
Liquid Assets 27,600 36,086 47,978 52,967<br />
Total Invested Capital 6,841 6,298 7,415 8,685<br />
Non-Performing Loans (NPLs) 840 944 1,033 1,291<br />
Specific Loan Provisions 640 945 1,278 1,695<br />
General Loan Provisions 768 834 873 923<br />
Profitability Ratios 2008a 2009e 2010f 2011f<br />
Yr/Yr Net Interest Income Growth 49.8% 26.9% 11.1% 15.1%<br />
Yr/Yr Non-Interest Income Growth 38.8% 11.9% 15.9% 32.7%<br />
Gross Earning Yield (GEY) 7.9% 8.0% 7.4% 7.3%<br />
Breakeven Earning Yield (BEY) 4.1% 4.0% 3.8% 3.7%<br />
Net Interest Margin (NIM) 3.8% 4.0% 3.6% 3.6%<br />
Cost of Funds (exc. equity) 3.9% 3.8% 3.6% 3.6%<br />
Cost of Funds (inc. equity) 5.2% 4.7% 4.6% 4.6%<br />
ROA 2.4% 2.4% 2.2% 2.4%<br />
ROE 23.3% 30.6% 28.8% 29.6%<br />
ROIC (after-tax) 20.0% 23.1% 21.8% 22.9%<br />
Asset Quality Ratios 2008a 2009e 2010f 2011f<br />
NPLs/Total Loans 3.0% 3.1% 3.1% 3.1%<br />
Specific Loan Provisions/NPLs 76.2% 100.1% 123.7% 131.2%<br />
Spe. & Gen. Loan Prov. /Tot. Loans 5.0% 5.8% 6.5% 6.3%<br />
Productivity Ratios 2008a 2009e 2010f 2011f<br />
Tot. Loans & Adv./ Tot. Deposits 57.4% 51.0% 46.0% 50.0%<br />
Tot. Bills & Bonds/Tot. <strong>Equity</strong> 276.2% 308.7% 324.4% 165.5%<br />
Liquid Assets/Total Deposits 56.6% 60.4% 66.2% 63.6%<br />
Interbank Ratio 1987.8% 1875.8% 1844.9% 2450.2%<br />
Source: Bank Financials & Prime Estimates<br />
LE mn 2009 2010 2011<br />
Old New Old New Old New<br />
Net Loans 37,188 28,316 49,021 30,739 63,725 38,496<br />
NII 2,250 2,283 2,732 2,537 3,025 2,921<br />
Net Banking Income 4,042 4,027 4,915 4,557 5,580 5,602<br />
NAI 1,882 1,457 2,392 1,620 2,743 1,988<br />
Source: Bank Financials & Prime Estimates<br />
Prime Research 19
PRIME PICK: NATIONAL SOCIETE<br />
GENERAL BANK (NSGB)<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Target Price Market Price Recommendation Upside Potential Investment Grade<br />
LE18.9 LE15.37 Buy<br />
22.9%<br />
Value<br />
Share Data<br />
Company Short Name<br />
NSGB<br />
Sector<br />
Banking<br />
Company Traded Market<br />
EGX<br />
Report Reason<br />
<strong>Equity</strong> strategy<br />
Valuation Methodology<br />
DCFE<br />
Previous Target<br />
LE52.3<br />
Exchange Rate<br />
LE5.55/US$<br />
Stock Currency<br />
LE<br />
Reuters Code<br />
NSGB.CA<br />
Outstanding Shares (mn) 302.9<br />
Par Value/Share (LE)<br />
LE10<br />
Financial Year Ending<br />
December<br />
Mkt. Cap (LE mn) 4,471.4<br />
Weight to PAMI 2.48%<br />
Av. Daily Volume (000) 133.9<br />
Price Low – High (LE) (52Wk.) 13 - 44.85<br />
Shareholders<br />
Ownership Stake<br />
Societe Generale 77.2%<br />
Free Float 22.8%<br />
Income Statement 2008a 2009e 2010f<br />
Interest Income 3,200.2 3,382.9 3,734.9<br />
Interest Expense 1,772.3 1,796.1 1,921.0<br />
Net Interest Income 1,427.9 1,586.7 1,813.9<br />
Non-Interest Income 1,178.7 1,014.9 971.1<br />
Non-Interest Expenses 1,096.6 1,190.9 1,315.6<br />
Operating Income 1,509.9 1,410.7 1,469.3<br />
Provisions 213.4 364.9 413.8<br />
Net Profit Before Tax 1,296.6 1,045.8 1,055.5<br />
Tax Provisions 0.0 73.2 105.5<br />
Income Taxes 160.2 52.3 52.8<br />
Unusual Item 0.4 - -<br />
NPAUI 1,136.9 920.3 897.2<br />
Non-Appropriation Items 71.5 84.9 81.9<br />
Net Attributable Income 1,065.4 835.4 815.3<br />
Balance Sheet 2008a 2009e 2010f<br />
Cash and Cash Items 3,102.6 3,873.4 4,183.2<br />
Inter-bank Assets 9,027.2 8,286.3 10,823.1<br />
T-Bills & Gov. Securities 2,976.4 4,415.6 4,768.9<br />
Net Marketable Securities 3,776.3 2,943.8 3,179.3<br />
Net Loans and Advances 25,011.2 26,620.3 28,233.5<br />
Debtors & Other Debt Balances 558.5 591.7 611.1<br />
Subsidiaries & Direct Invst. 40.3 (321.6) (683.5)<br />
Net Fixed Assets 729.5 772.5 817.5<br />
Other Assets 824.8 841.3 858.1<br />
Total Assets 46,046.8 48,023.3 52,791.2<br />
Stock Performance Chart<br />
(LE / Share)<br />
Claims on Assets - - -<br />
Inter-bank Liabilities 1,460.2 1,314.2 2,284.9<br />
50<br />
45<br />
40<br />
35<br />
30<br />
25<br />
20<br />
15<br />
10<br />
5<br />
0<br />
Jan-08<br />
Mar-08<br />
May-08<br />
Jul-08<br />
Sep-08<br />
Nov-08<br />
Jan-09<br />
Mar-09<br />
Customer Deposits 36,889.2 38,733.7 41,832.4<br />
Creditors & Other Cr. Balances 1,499.1 1,138.0 1,240.2<br />
Dividend Payable 0.0 449.5 491.4<br />
Other Provisions 689.3 912.4 1,168.6<br />
Long-Term Debt 49.6 71.2 78.3<br />
Total Liabilities 40,587.4 42,619.0 47,095.9<br />
Tier 2: Secondary Capital 771.9 470.0 355.3<br />
Subordinated Debt 771.9 470.0 355.3<br />
Tier 1 : Primary Capital 4,687.4 4,934.3 5,340.0<br />
Paid-In Capital 3,029.4 3,029.4 3,029.4<br />
Capital Surplus - - -<br />
Reserves 1,091.6 1,528.3 1,913.9<br />
Retained Earnings 566.4 376.6 396.7<br />
Total Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 5,459.4 5,404.3 5,695.4<br />
Total Liab. & Sh. <strong>Equity</strong> 46,046.8 48,023.3 52,791.2<br />
Contingent Liabilities 15,556.8 17,890.3 20,037.2<br />
Total Footings 61,603.6 65,913.6 72,828.4<br />
Free Cash to <strong>Equity</strong> 2008a 2009e 2010f<br />
NAI 1,065.4 835.4 815.3<br />
Investment Flow: (1,012.7) 55.1 (291.1)<br />
Change in Assets 1,356.4 (1,976.5) (4,768.0)<br />
Change in Liabilities (2,369.1) 2,031.5 4,476.9<br />
<strong>Equity</strong> Cash Flow 52.6 890.4 524.2<br />
Please refer to disclaimer on last page<br />
Financial Summary (Figures in LE million)<br />
Source: Bank Financials & Prime Projections<br />
Prime Research 20
PRIME PICK: NATIONAL SOCIETE<br />
GENERAL BANK (NSGB)<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Meet A Bank with Solid Foundation & Potential Growth<br />
We identify NSGB as the second main market player, next to CIB, holding a loan market share of 6%. In FY08, net loans witnessed<br />
a 27% increase leading to a staggering total L/D ratio of 73%, compared to 56% by year end FY07. Nonperforming<br />
loans is down to 7% from 11% in FY07 reflecting enhanced asset quality. Financial investments, however, witnessed a<br />
20% decline due to 25% decrease in government securities and 15% decline in marketable securities. Accordingly, earning assets<br />
demonstrated a 2% decline in FY08 to LE40.8 billion. The bank reported a CAR of 13% showing limited risk.<br />
Projection & Valuation<br />
Reflecting a slowing economy, we forecast a conservative annual loan growth of 6% in FY09 and FY10. Also, non-interest income is<br />
expected to witness a 14% decline in FY09 and a 4% decline in FY10, compared to a growth of 105% in FY08 and 9% in FY07. The<br />
staggering increase in non-interest income in FY08 is due to LE389 million provision reversal. We make the conservative expectation<br />
of no such reversals in the coming years. However, we believe in the efficient operations of the bank based on past performance.<br />
Investment Rationale<br />
We highly recommend the bank, due to the following;<br />
• Limited risk as indicated by CAR of 13%;<br />
• High profitability shown by a NIM of 3.5%, ROA of 2.5% and ROE of 26.5%;<br />
• Trading at a discount as demonstrated by a 23% upside potential, P/E of 4.2% and a P/B of 0.8x.<br />
Size Items LE mn 2008a 2009f 2010f 2011f<br />
Total Revenues 4,378.9 4,397.7 4,705.9 5,347.1<br />
Net Banking Income 2,606.6 2,601.6 2,784.9 3,289.2<br />
Earning Assets 40,791.0 42,266.0 47,004.8 51,884.1<br />
Risk Assets. 37,814.7 37,850.3 42,235.9 45,745.6<br />
Liquid Assets 18,882.4 19,519.1 22,954.5 24,472.9<br />
Total Invested Capital 5,508.9 5,475.5 5,773.7 6,164.2<br />
Non-Performing Loans (NPLs) 1,897.6 2,091.6 2,259.8 2,413.1<br />
Specific Loan Provisions 1,804.6 1,978.9 2,195.6 2,300.5<br />
General Loan Provisions 332.6 373.3 419.7 489.6<br />
Profitability Ratios 2008a 2009f 2010f 2011f<br />
Yr/Yr Net Interest Income Growth 20.4% 11.1% 14.3% 16.9%<br />
Yr/Yr Non-Interest Income Growth 104.7% -13.9% -4.3% 20.5%<br />
Gross Earning Yield (GEY) 7.8% 8.0% 7.9% 8.1%<br />
Breakeven Earning Yield (BEY) 4.3% 4.2% 4.1% 4.0%<br />
Net Interest Margin (NIM) 3.5% 3.8% 3.9% 4.1%<br />
Cost of Funds (exc. equity) 4.6% 4.5% 4.3% 4.2%<br />
Cost of Funds (inc. equity) 6.1% 5.9% 5.7% 5.6%<br />
ROA 2.5% 1.9% 1.7% 2.0%<br />
ROE 20.8% 17.0% 15.8% 19.6%<br />
ROIC (after-tax) 19.3% 15.3% 14.1% 17.5%<br />
Asset Quality Ratios 2008a 2009f 2010f 2011f<br />
NPLs/Total Loans 7.0% 7.2% 7.3% 6.9%<br />
Specific Loan Provisions/NPLs 95.1% 94.6% 97.2% 95.3%<br />
Spe. & Gen. Loan Prov. /Tot. Loans 7.9% 8.1% 8.4% 8.0%<br />
Productivity Ratios 2008a 2009f 2010f 2011f<br />
Tot. Loans & Adv./ Tot. Deposits 73.5% 75.0% 74.0% 76.0%<br />
Tot. Bills & Bonds/Tot. <strong>Equity</strong> 112.6% 125.3% 128.4% 159.5%<br />
Liquid Assets/Total Deposits 51.2% 50.4% 54.9% 53.2%<br />
Interbank Ratio 618.2% 630.5% 473.7% 384.0%<br />
Source: Bank Financials & Prime Estimates<br />
LE mn 2009 2010 2011<br />
Old New Old New Old New<br />
Net Loans 29,964 26,620.3 35,965 28,233.5 44,225 32,012.7<br />
NII 1,689 1,586.7 1,990 1,813.9 2,475 2,119.6<br />
Net Banking Income 2,611 2,601.6 3,127 2,784.9 3,958 3,289.2<br />
NAI 984 835.4 1,233 815.3 1,827 1,076.8<br />
Source: Bank Financials & Prime Estimates<br />
Prime Research 21
PRIME PICK: MARIDIVE AND<br />
OIL SERVICES<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Target Price Market Price Recommendation Upside Potential Investment Grade<br />
US$4.45 US$2.72 Strong Buy<br />
63.6%<br />
Value<br />
Share Data<br />
Company Short Name<br />
Sector<br />
Company Traded Market<br />
Report Reason<br />
Valuation Methodology<br />
Exchange Rate<br />
Stock Currency<br />
Reuters Code<br />
Maridive<br />
Oil & Gas services<br />
EGX<br />
<strong>Equity</strong> Strategy<br />
DCF<br />
LE5.55/US$<br />
US$<br />
MOIL.CA<br />
Outstanding Shares (mn) 256<br />
Par Value/Share (US$)<br />
Financial Year Ending<br />
0.40/share<br />
December<br />
Mkt. Cap (US$ mn) 645<br />
Av. Daily Volume 627,501<br />
Price Low – High (LE) (52Wk.) 1.8 - 7.18<br />
Shareholders<br />
Ownership Stake<br />
Eleish Family 13.20%<br />
Nadim Family 13.20%<br />
Zeid Family 13.20%<br />
Offshore Oil Services 21.39%<br />
CIB 7.11%<br />
EFG Private Company 2.91%<br />
Free Float 28.99%<br />
Stock Performance Chart<br />
(US$ / Share)<br />
Income Statement 2008a 2009e 2010f 2011f<br />
Revenues 257.1 298.4 302.8 343.6<br />
Growth -2% 16% 1% 13%<br />
COGS 125.2 145.2 151.4 167.2<br />
S,G & Admin. Expenses 23.5 27.3 33.3 31.4<br />
EBITDA 108.4 125.8 118.1 144.9<br />
Growth 1% 16% -6% 23%<br />
EBITDA Margin 42% 42% 39% 42%<br />
Depreciation 13.6 14.9 20.1 25.3<br />
Operating EBIT 94.9 110.9 98.0 119.6<br />
Interest Income 0.8 2.5 1.2 2.8<br />
Interest Expense 4.6 5.0 3.7 2.8<br />
Non-Operating Revenues 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1<br />
Pre Tax Income 92.2 109.5 96.6 120.7<br />
Income Tax 1.4 2.7 1.8 2.4<br />
Effective Tax Rate 1.5% 2.4% 1.9% 1.9%<br />
NPAT 90.8 106.9 94.7 118.4<br />
Extraordinary Items 10.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
Net Income 100.8 106.9 94.7 118.4<br />
Minority interest 13.2 13.9 12.3 15.4<br />
Net Attributable Income - NAI 87.6 93.0 82.4 103.0<br />
Growth 9% 6% -11% 25%<br />
ROS 34% 31% 27% 30%<br />
Balance Sheet 2008a 2009e 2010f 2011f<br />
Cash & Marketable Securities 78.1 149.5 86.2 166.4<br />
Trade Receivables-Net 9.4 10.9 11.1 12.6<br />
Inventory 5.6 6.5 6.6 7.5<br />
Other Current Asset 83.3 95.2 96.0 108.5<br />
Total Current Asset 176.4 262.0 199.8 295.0<br />
Net Fixed Assets 192.2 262.7 331.2 338.2<br />
Projects Under Implementation 118.3 59.1 59.1 0.0<br />
Other Assets 9.8 9.8 9.8 9.8<br />
Total Assets 496.7 593.6 599.9 643.0<br />
Short Term Bank Debt 11.8 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
CPLTD 38.5 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
Accounts Payable 17.8 20.7 21.0 23.8<br />
Dividend Payable 64.0 74.4 71.7 89.6<br />
Other Current Liabilities 29.2 33.8 34.3 39.0<br />
Total Current Liabilities 161.3 128.9 127.1 152.4<br />
Long-Term Debt 101.2 81.1 66.2 55.2<br />
Provisions for Deferred Taxes 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
Provisions 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5<br />
Total Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 231.7 381.1 404.1 432.9<br />
Total Liab.& Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 496.7 593.6 599.9 643.0<br />
8<br />
7<br />
6<br />
5<br />
4<br />
3<br />
2<br />
1<br />
0<br />
May-08<br />
Jun-08<br />
Jul-08<br />
Aug-08<br />
Sep-08<br />
Oct-08<br />
Nov-08<br />
Dec-08<br />
Jan-09<br />
Feb-09<br />
Mar-09<br />
Free Cash Flow Statement 2008a 2009e 2010f 2011f<br />
NOPLAT 93.6 108.1 96.1 117.2<br />
Non-Cash Items 13.6 14.9 20.1 25.3<br />
Gross Cash Flow 107.2 123.1 116.2 142.5<br />
Gross Investments 137.2 -35.7 76.3 -32.0<br />
Non -Operating Cash Flow 10.9 1.1 1.1 1.1<br />
Free Cash Flow -19.1 159.8 41.0 175.6<br />
Financing Flow<br />
Interest Income After-Tax -0.8 -2.5 -1.2 -2.8<br />
Investment Income After-Tax 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
Increase in Excess Cash & M. Sec. 0.0 125.6 -63.6 77.0<br />
After-Tax Interest Expense 4.5 4.8 3.6 2.7<br />
Decrease in Debt & Bonds -20.1 70.9 15.5 11.6<br />
Provisions Used -0.7 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
Dividends Paid 13.5 71.4 80.9 79.9<br />
Non-Appropriation Items 1.8 -110.4 5.8 7.2<br />
Shareholders <strong>Equity</strong> -17.4 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
Total Financing Flow -19.1 159.8 41.0 175.6<br />
Please refer to disclaimer on last page<br />
Financial Summary (Figures in US$ million)<br />
Source: Company Financials, Prime Projections<br />
Prime Research 22
PRIME PICK: MARIDIVE<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Meet An Oil Dependent Stock, Yet Immune To Oil Price<br />
Maridive <strong>Group</strong> is one of the largest companies in Middle East in terms of fleet size.<br />
Maridive operates in two segments; Offshore Construction Services (OCS) and Offshore<br />
Support Vessels (OSV). The group comprises four entities; Maridive and Oil Services,<br />
Maridive Offshore Projects, Maritide Offshore Oil Services and Valentine Maritime Ltd., all<br />
together offering a wide range of services to oil and gas Exploration and Production companies<br />
including maintenance, construction, salvaging, transport and supply of materials.<br />
Maridive diversifies its presence in various locations worldwide entering new markets to<br />
raise market share. Yet, Maridive’s fleet is operating in South East Asia, Gulf of Mexico,<br />
Australia, South America, West Africa and the Red Sea. Currently, Maridive is expanding its<br />
fleet size to reach 73 vessels by FY11 from 60 vessels in FY08<br />
Maridive FY08 consolidated financials reported a top line figure of US$257 million versus<br />
US$264 million attained in FY07, reflecting a y-o-y decline of 2.6%. The slight decline in<br />
revenues was mainly due to a loss of the barge which sank in the previous year affecting<br />
Maridive’s fleet size and due to some delayed contracts which will be reflected in Q1 FY09<br />
earnings.<br />
Maridive Fleet Expansion<br />
Year Vessels Barges<br />
2008 49 11<br />
2009 55 12<br />
2010 57 13<br />
2011 60 13<br />
Total 73<br />
Source: Maridive<br />
Projections and Valuation<br />
In FY09, we maintained utilization and daily rates for both segments (OCS & OSV) due to the fact that Maridive secures long<br />
term contracts. However, we assumed both rates to decline by 15% in FY10 due to the expected decline in global exploration<br />
spending derived by the severe decline in oil prices occurred in late 2008, as well as the cyclical nature of the industry which<br />
states that rates are negatively affected after 12 to 18 months from the oil prices’ decline. Going forward, we forecasted rates to<br />
rebound in FY11 to increase by 15%.<br />
Speaking of margins, the company was able to reduce COGS/Revenue ratio to 48.7% from 53% in FY07. As a result,<br />
OPEX declined by 5% y-o-y to stand at US$148.7 million down from US$155.9 million. We expect COGS to reach US$145 million<br />
in FY09, reflecting a y-o-y growth of 16% and thus maintaining COGS/Revenue margin at 48.7%. Going further, we projected<br />
COGS/Revenue to increase slightly in FY10 to 50% translated to a COGS figure of US$151.4 million. In FY11 and FY12, we maintained<br />
COGS/revenue at 48%, recording US$167 million and US$184 million in COGS respectively.<br />
EBITDA slightly increased by 0.6% to record US$108.4 million over US$107.8 million in FY07. EBITDA margin grew by 128 bps to<br />
42.17% up from 40.89%. We maintained the EBITDA margin in FY09. Starting FY09, we forecasted EBITDA to grow at a 3 year<br />
CAGR of 4.82% to reach US$145 million in FY11 from US$118 million. Our forecasted EBITDA margin came in slightly lower in<br />
FY10 than FY09 by 320bps to 39% from 42.2%, projected to increase back again to 42% by FY11 and maintained in FY12.<br />
We expect FY09 financials to report US$106.7 million in net income, achieving a y-o-y growth of 6% over US$100.8 million. In<br />
FY10, we project net income to decline by 12% to US$95 million. By FY11, when the cycle begins to move upward, we expect<br />
25% increase in net income to reach US$118 million.<br />
Utilizing a WACC of 12.02% and a perpetual growth of 3%, we valued Maridive’s shareholders’ value at US$1.14 billion or<br />
US$4.45/share. The target implies an upside potential of 63.6% given the prevailing market price of US$2.72/share.<br />
Investment Rationale<br />
We have a positive sentiment on the company due to:<br />
• Maridive <strong>Group</strong>’s earnings are backed by secured long term contracts vary from one to two years. Yet, Maridive has already<br />
secured contracts in FY09 and FY10 worth US$188 and US$233 million respectively.<br />
• A high barrier industry entails limited supply of offshore vessels due to insufficient funds to finance building new vessels and<br />
more than 110 vessels under construction were delayed or cancelled, Maridive is expanding its fleet size to reach 73 vessels<br />
by FY11 from 60 vessels in FY08 which will benefit its international presence and market share.<br />
• Demand on OSV vessels is supported by number of operating rigs as according to industry norms, every operating rig requires<br />
two support vessels which are considered as fixed costs for E&P companies, which is currently Maridive is capitalizing<br />
on.<br />
Prime Research 23
PRIME PICK: TELECOM EGYPT<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Target Price Market Price Recommendation Upside Potential Investment Grade<br />
LE24.02 LE14.74 Strong Buy<br />
63%<br />
Value<br />
Share Data<br />
Company Short Name<br />
Sector<br />
Company Traded Market<br />
Report Reason<br />
Valuation Methodology<br />
Previous Target<br />
Exchange Rate<br />
Stock Currency<br />
Reuters Code<br />
Stock Performance Chart<br />
(LE / Share)<br />
TE<br />
Telecommunication<br />
EGX & LSE<br />
<strong>Equity</strong> Strategy<br />
DCF<br />
LE24.87<br />
LE5.55/US$<br />
LE<br />
ETEL.CA - ETELq.L<br />
Outstanding Shares (mn) 1,707<br />
Par Value/Share (LE)<br />
Financial Year Ending<br />
LE10<br />
December<br />
Mkt. Cap (LE mn) 25,162<br />
Weight to PAMI 13.59%<br />
Price Low – High (LE) (52Wk.) 10.7 - 23.9<br />
Shareholders<br />
Ownership Stake<br />
Egyptian Government 80%<br />
Free Float 20%<br />
25<br />
Income Statement 2007a 2008e 2009f<br />
Revenues 9,993.1 10,413.2 10,710.0<br />
Growth 5.0% 4.2% 2.9%<br />
COGS 3,305.7 3,389.1 3,566.5<br />
S,G & Admin. Expenses 1,485.1 1,741.0 1,826.4<br />
Other Provisions 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
EBITDA 5,202.3 5,283.1 5,317.1<br />
Growth 2.0% 1.6% 0.6%<br />
EBITDA Margin 52.1% 50.7% 49.6%<br />
Depreciation & Amortization 2736.7 2546.8 2817.8<br />
Operating EBIT 2,465.6 2,736.3 2,499.3<br />
Interest Income 81.3 94.9 150.9<br />
Investment Income 1070.7 1222.5 1259.2<br />
Interest Expense 599.8 354.7 287.2<br />
Non-Operating Revenues 351.5 313.8 394.4<br />
Pre Tax Income 3,369.3 4,012.7 4,016.5<br />
Pre Tax Income Growth 8% 19% 0%<br />
Income Tax 513.3 662.1 679.8<br />
Effective Tax Rate 15% 17% 17%<br />
NPAT 2,856.0 3,350.6 3,336.8<br />
Growth 9.8% 17.3% -0.4%<br />
Minority 0.0 9.3 9.7<br />
Extraordinary Items (315.0) (264.7) (105.9)<br />
Net Income 2,541.0 3,076.7 3,221.2<br />
Profit Share to Employees & Board 97.3 64.6 66.4<br />
Net Attributable Income - NAI 2,443.7 3,012.1 3,154.8<br />
Growth 5.0% 23.3% 4.7%<br />
ROS 24.5% 28.9% 29.5%<br />
Balance Sheet 2007a 2008e 2009f<br />
Cash & Marketable Securities 1,302.2 2,314.5 2,381.8<br />
Trade Receivables-Net 4,792.5 4,997.0 5,396.6<br />
Inventory 508.4 529.8 544.9<br />
Other Current Asset 94.6 98.6 101.4<br />
Total Current Asset 6,697.7 7,939.8 8,424.7<br />
Net Fixed Assets 19,372.4 18,272.3 16,941.2<br />
Projects Under Implementation 843.6 847.8 852.0<br />
Other Assets 7,677.4 7,772.6 8,015.6<br />
Total Assets 34,591.1 34,832.5 34,233.5<br />
Short Term Bank Debt 1,834.5 377.4 290.8<br />
CPLTD 0.0 1,345.5 695.5<br />
Accounts Payable 130.3 135.8 125.7<br />
Dividend Payable 0.8 1.0 1.0<br />
Other Current Liabilities 3,195.9 2,997.2 2,774.4<br />
Total Current Liabilities 5,161.6 4,856.9 3,887.4<br />
Long-Term Debt 3,151.0 2,633.4 1,898.4<br />
Provisions for Deferred Taxes 170.4 170.4 170.4<br />
Provisions 324.4 421.0 520.3<br />
Total Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 25,743.9 26,701.6 27,698.2<br />
Total Liab.& Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 34,591.1 34,832.5 34,233.5<br />
20<br />
15<br />
10<br />
5<br />
0<br />
Mar-08<br />
Apr-08<br />
May-08<br />
Jun-08<br />
Jul-08<br />
Aug-08<br />
Sep-08<br />
Oct-08<br />
Nov-08<br />
Dec-08<br />
Jan-09<br />
Feb-09<br />
Free Cash Flow Statement 2007a 2008e 2009f<br />
NOPLAT 1,884.0 2,115.4 1,964.2<br />
Non-Cash Items 2,736.7 2,546.8 2,817.8<br />
Gross Cash Flow 4,620.7 4,662.2 4,782.0<br />
Gross Investments 314.4 1,958.0 2,031.8<br />
Non -Operating Cash Flow 31.0 33.4 196.5<br />
Free Cash Flow 4,337.3 2,737.7 2,946.7<br />
Financing Flow<br />
Interest Income After-Tax -80.1 -91.9 -146.1<br />
Investment Income After-Tax -1,054.4 -1,183.5 -1,219.0<br />
Increase in Excess Cash & M. Sec. 535.0 921.3 169.5<br />
After-Tax Interest Expense 508.4 241.5 195.6<br />
Decrease in Debt & Bonds 2,503.8 629.2 1,471.6<br />
Provisions Used 156.8 0.0 0.0<br />
Dividends Paid 1,716.0 2,070.5 2,167.9<br />
Non-Appropriation Items 97.3 64.6 66.4<br />
Shareholders <strong>Equity</strong> -444.2 -7.0 0.0<br />
Total Financing Flow 4,337.3 2,737.7 2,946.7<br />
Please refer to disclaimer on last page<br />
Financial Summary (Figures in LE million)<br />
Source: Company Historical & Prime Estimates<br />
Prime Research 24
PRIME PICK: TELECOM EGYPT<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
MEET THE DIVERSFIED TELECOM OPERATOR<br />
Telecom Egypt is the only fixed line operator in Egypt and the largest in the MENA region in terms of the number of subscribers<br />
which amounted to 11.33 million in September 2008. The company is 80% owned by the government and has a stake of 45% in<br />
Vodafone Egypt. Moreover, the company controls 56% of the DSL market through its TE data subsidiary.<br />
Projections & Valuation<br />
• Recently mobile operators have announced aggressive marketing schemes including a cut in calling prices to LE0.05/minutes<br />
which we believe that it will make connection costs between governorates more cheaper using mobile phones than using fixed<br />
lines which costs between LE0.08/minute to LE0.16/minute. Moreover, revenues from international calls which represented<br />
28.39% in 9M FY08 will slow down in FY09 due to the shrinkage of the Tourist activity and lay offs or salaries cuts pertaining to<br />
Egyptian expatriates.<br />
• In spite of mobile to fixed substitution, TE growth drivers still exist such as a growth in voice calls revenues should the economy<br />
dips into recession as consumers will tend to use cheaper fixed lines services,<br />
• Following the elimination of the connection tariffs during November and the first week of December, we believe that number of<br />
new subscribers will close the year at 737k subscribers compared to 421k last year.<br />
• Revenues from the undersea cable activity will enhance the bottom line going forward taking into consideration that the investment<br />
cost of the project is hovering at US$160 million but the company has managed to sign contracts with a total value<br />
hitting US$176 million by the end of 1H FY08. The TE North cable is scheduled to come into stream at the second of 2009. We<br />
believe that TE North will add LE311.8 million to aggregate revenues in FY09.<br />
• We also believe that the internet segment is another growth driver going forward with expectation for this segment to record<br />
revenues of LE480.1 million in FY08 and LE837.7 million in FY09 coupled with higher internet literacy and higher internet<br />
penetration rate and increased use of the internet by businesses.<br />
• Our latest DCF valuation for Telecom Egypt as of the 9M FY08 entails a total equity value of LE40 billion or LE24.02/share<br />
INVESTMENT RATIONALE<br />
• NTRA has postponed issuance of the 2nd fixed line license, until further notice, TE remains sole provider of fixed line services.<br />
In case of 2 player market, the second operator will have to roam on TE network till its network is completely rolled out which is<br />
hard to achieve given geographical distribution of Egypt Governorates, providing TE with additional infrastructure revenues<br />
• Internet awareness continues to increase exponentially in Egypt with number of DSL subscribers expected to grow at a CAGR of<br />
60% by FY12, allowing TE Data to capitalize on its 56% market share<br />
• Capitalizing on Egypt’s Geographical position, TE is the best choice for bandwidth traffic originating from Asia & Africa to<br />
Europe. US$70 million will be recognized in 2009 stemming from 25% utilization of the cable. Going forward, the investment will<br />
increase TE footprints to the existing transit corridor, TE will be able to capture growth in bandwidth demand in Asia without<br />
injecting more CAPEX<br />
• Should Mobinil (only listed competitor to VF) gets delisted due to the arbitration case between OTH and FT, TE will be the only<br />
access to the under penetrated Egyptian Mobile market through its 45% stake in VF.<br />
• Leading Industry in financial indicators, EBITDA margin 52%, PE 7.8x, Div Yield 8%, FCF Yield 17%<br />
Prime Research 25
PRIME PICK: MOBINIL<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Target Price Market Price Recommendation Upside Potential Investment Grade<br />
LE197 LE140.82 Strong Buy<br />
40%<br />
Value<br />
Share Data<br />
Company Short Name<br />
Sector<br />
Company Traded Market<br />
Report Reason<br />
Valuation Methodology<br />
Previous Target<br />
Exchange Rate<br />
Stock Currency<br />
Reuters Code<br />
Mobinil<br />
Telecommunication<br />
EGX<br />
<strong>Equity</strong> Strategy<br />
DCF<br />
LE209<br />
LE5.55/US$<br />
Stock Performance Chart<br />
(LE / Share)<br />
LE<br />
EMOB.CA<br />
Outstanding Shares (mn) 100<br />
Par Value/Share (LE)<br />
Financial Year Ending<br />
LE10<br />
December<br />
Mkt. Cap (LE mn) 14,080<br />
Weight to PAMI 7.60%<br />
Price Low – High (LE) (52Wk.) 87 - 243<br />
Shareholders<br />
Ownership Stake<br />
Mobinil Telecom 51%<br />
Orange 71.25%<br />
Orascom Telecom 28.75%<br />
Orascom Telecom 20%<br />
Free Float 29%<br />
250<br />
200<br />
150<br />
100<br />
50<br />
0<br />
Mar-08<br />
Apr-08<br />
May-08<br />
Jun-08<br />
Jul-08<br />
Aug-08<br />
Sep-08<br />
Oct-08<br />
Nov-08<br />
Dec-08<br />
Jan-09<br />
Feb-09<br />
Income Statement (LE mn) 2007a 2008a 2009f<br />
Revenues 8,200.5 10,002.8 11,278.7<br />
Growth 28.9% 22.0% 12.8%<br />
COGS 1,828.0 2,057.4 2,389.5<br />
S,G & Admin. Expenses 2,681.8 3,058.4 3,543.2<br />
EBITDA 3,690.7 4,886.9 5,346.1<br />
Growth 9.5% 32.4% 9.4%<br />
EBITDA Margin 45.0% 48.9% 47.4%<br />
Depreciation & Amortization 1285.9 1659.6 1988.7<br />
Other Provisions 144.1 252.0 225.9<br />
Operating EBIT 2,260.6 2,975.3 3,131.4<br />
Interest Income 29.6 40.3 12.9<br />
Investment Income 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
Interest Expense 124.0 586.6 617.2<br />
Non-Operating expenses -16.7 59.7 70.9<br />
Pre Tax Income 2,149.6 2,488.8 2,598.1<br />
Income Tax 496.4 499.0 520.9<br />
Effective Tax Rate 23.1% 20.0% 20.0%<br />
NPAT 1,653.2 1,989.9 2,077.2<br />
Growth 7.8% 20.4% 4.4%<br />
Extraordinary Items (2) (20) (1)<br />
Net Income 1,650.8 1,970.2 2,076.0<br />
Profit Share to Employees & Board 141.1 109.8 115.7<br />
Net Attributable Income - NAI 1,509.6 1,860.4 1,960.3<br />
Growth 9.1% 23.2% 5.4%<br />
ROS 18.4% 18.6% 17.4%<br />
Balance Sheet (LE mn) 2007a 2008a 2009f<br />
Total Current Asset 1,347.2 1,587.6 1,655.8<br />
Net Fixed Assets 6,060.3 7,870.0 9,022.5<br />
Projects Under Implementation 1,565.7 1,000.6 950.5<br />
Total Assets 10,053.5 13,658.0 14,507.1<br />
CPLTD 327.2 327.2 407.3<br />
Total Current Liabilities 3,937.1 4,963.3 6,523.1<br />
Long-Term Debt 3,577.3 4,848.1 4,440.8<br />
Total Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 1,751.6 2,239.6 2,381.2<br />
Total Liab.& Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 10,053.5 13,658.0 14,507.1<br />
Free Cash Flow Statement (LE mn) 2007a 2008a 2009f<br />
NOPLAT 1,616.0 2,367.4 2,436.7<br />
Non-Cash Items 1,430.0 1,911.6 2,214.7<br />
Gross Cash Flow 3,046.0 4,279.0 4,651.4<br />
Gross Investments 3,507.3 3,519.5 3,261.1<br />
Non -Operating Cash Flow -13.4 31.1 48.3<br />
Free Cash Flow -474.8 790.6 1,438.6<br />
Financing Flow<br />
Interest Income After-Tax -28.9 -39.5 -12.5<br />
Increase in Excess Cash & M. Sec. -201.1 134.3 -5.5<br />
After-Tax Interest Expense 95.4 469.0 420.3<br />
Decrease in Debt & Bonds -2,005.6 -1,276.1 399.1<br />
Provisions Used 88.8 334.0 0.0<br />
Dividends Paid 1,421.8 1,082.8 239.0<br />
Non-Appropriation Items 141.1 109.8 115.7<br />
Shareholders <strong>Equity</strong> 13.7 -23.6 282.5<br />
Total Financing Flow -474.8 790.6 1,438.6<br />
Please refer to disclaimer on last page<br />
Financial Summary (Figures in LE million)<br />
Source: Company Historical & Prime Estimates<br />
Prime Research 26
PRIME PICK: MOBINIL<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Meet The Mobile Operator<br />
Mobinil is the first GSM operator in Egypt and the largest among a tripartite industry with a market share of 48.74% by the end of<br />
2008. Mobinil’s revenues in FY08 culminated at LE10 billion, 22% more than the figure booked in FY07 with the customers base<br />
surging by 33% to 20.1 million subscribers. ARPU in contrast slumped by 17% coming in at LE47.5. On the EBITDA level, it improved<br />
from 45% in FY07 to 48.9% in FY08 as OPEX surged by only 13.4%, but as an absolute figure EBITDA moved north by<br />
32.4% to LE4.89 billion. Interest expenses meanwhile soared by 373% to LE586.58 million as the company had to increase its<br />
interest bearing debt by 30% to finance CAPEX and new expansion including the 3G license coupled with higher interest rate. In<br />
sum, net income grew by 19.2% in FY08 culminating at LE1.97 billion from FY07’s figure of LE1.65 billion.<br />
Projection and Valuation<br />
Figure In 000 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012<br />
We confide in Mobinil’s capability to seize more than 40% of the new<br />
Mobile Subscribers<br />
addition to the market in our forecast period. Yet, this will occur at<br />
41,272 49,277 55,680 60,803 64,901<br />
the expense of ARPU which is expected to slump from LE47.3 in FY08 Penetration Rate 52.72% 61.78% 68.51% 73.43% 76.84%<br />
to LE37 in FY12, which is mitigated through positive elasticity. Accordingly,<br />
this will permit the company to maintain its market share Mobinil<br />
net addition 10,672 8,004 6,403 5,123 4,098<br />
above 45.56% till the end of FY13.<br />
Subscribers 20,115 23,317 25,878 27,927 29,567<br />
New increments to the market will plummet going forward as we believe<br />
that the nearer the penetration rate to 80%, the smaller addition<br />
to the market due to high illiteracy rates, high living costs coupled with<br />
low per capita income, weaker desire of having mobile phones, concentration<br />
of Egyptian in narrow area, and the downside in the tourism<br />
sector due to the global financial turmoil. Hence, we project revenues<br />
to witness slower growth during our forecast period, locking in a 5-<br />
year CAGR of 5.28% in the top line figure.<br />
Based on the guidance of the company's management, tangible<br />
CAPEX will range between LE2.5 billion and LE3 billion in FY09<br />
versus LE3.44 billion as Mobinil will tend to depend on its internal financing<br />
sources due to the current strict borrowing and high cost of<br />
loans.<br />
Mobinil is preparing to takeover Link dot Net , a subsidiary of Orascom Telecom Holding. Link dot Net is a major ISP and internet<br />
company in Egypt, UAE, KSA, Pakistan and Qatar. Yet we haven't incorporated this takeover in our valuation, this merger in our<br />
view will in addition uphold mobile internet application in competition with Etisalat Misr and Vodafone Egypt which have similar<br />
operations. Our Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) model yielded a target price of LE197, translating into an upside potential of 39%<br />
Investment Rationale<br />
• High dividend yield of 10.91% in FY09 compared to our PGI dividend yield hovering at 5.1%. Global peers have an average<br />
dividend yield of 4.08%.<br />
• Its healthy EBITDA margin and the defensive nature of the industry during recession.<br />
market share 48.74% 47.32% 46.48% 45.93% 45.56%<br />
Vodafone<br />
Subscribers 17,611 20,813 23,374 25,423 27,063<br />
market share 42.67% 42.24% 41.98% 41.81% 41.70%<br />
Etisalat<br />
Subscribers 3,546 5,147 6,428 7,452 8,272<br />
market share 8.59% 10.45% 11.54% 12.26% 12.75%<br />
Source: NTRA and Prime Estimates<br />
• The ongoing arbitration case between OT and FT will have 2 scenarios, either one of the 2 parties will acquire Mobinil or a<br />
Status Quo.<br />
• When we think of the outcome of the arbitration and its effect on the share price, the above mentioned scenario is the most<br />
likely, at which time, a significant premium to the market price will be offered, while the second scenario would be a Status<br />
Quo which is doubled sided, from one side it will temporarily harm the share price due to a sell off from investors who were<br />
parking in their investment for an acquisition premium, and from one side it will entail that the 2 parties will focus on enhancing<br />
Mobinil core business and profitability as well as its market position given the heated competition in the highly unsaturated<br />
Egyptian market.<br />
Prime Research 27
PRIME PICK: EIPICO<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Target Price Market Price Recommendation Upside Potential Investment Grade<br />
LE39.2 LE25 Strong Buy<br />
56.8%<br />
Value<br />
Share Data<br />
Company Short Name<br />
Sector<br />
Company Traded Market<br />
Report Reason<br />
Valuation Methodology<br />
Previous Target<br />
Exchange Rate<br />
Stock Currency<br />
Reuters Code<br />
Stock Performance Chart<br />
(LE / Share)<br />
EIPICO<br />
Pharmaceuticals<br />
EGX<br />
<strong>Equity</strong> Strategy<br />
DCF<br />
LE46/Share<br />
LE5.55/US$<br />
LE<br />
PHAR.CA<br />
Outstanding Shares (mn) 72.124<br />
Par Value/Share (LE)<br />
Financial Year Ending<br />
LE10/Share<br />
December<br />
Mkt. Cap (LE mn) 1,727.4<br />
Weight to PAMI 0.96%<br />
Av. Daily Volume(000) (52Wk.) 60.5<br />
Price Low – High (LE) (52Wk.) 20 - 39.44<br />
Shareholders<br />
Ownership Stake<br />
ACDIMA 43.18 %<br />
Medical Union Investment 5.62 %<br />
Others 0.72 %<br />
Free Float 50.48 %<br />
45<br />
40<br />
35<br />
30<br />
Income Statement 2007a 2008a 2009e 2010f<br />
Revenues 850.2 910.1 979.3 1,077.3<br />
Growth 14% 7% 8% 10%<br />
COGS 380.2 559.2 474.7 484.8<br />
S,G & Admin. Expenses 104.7 21.8 124.5 137.0<br />
EBITDA 365.3 329.1 380.0 455.5<br />
Growth 15% -10% 15% 20%<br />
EBITDA Margin 43% 36.2% 39% 42%<br />
Depreciation & Amortization 59.4 53.1 18.5 18.5<br />
Other Provisions 30.2 32.9 27.5 33.1<br />
Operating EBIT 281.9 277.7 334.0 325.8<br />
Interest Income 16.3 20.0 7.0 39.5<br />
Investment Income 0.3 2.9 3.3 3.2<br />
Interest Expense 2.2 1.3 0.0 0.0<br />
Non-Operating Revenues 4.2 22.2 17.7 19.5<br />
Pre Tax Income 300.4 321.6 361.9 388.0<br />
Income Tax 63.5 59.3 57.1 61.2<br />
Effective Tax Rate 0% 0% 0% 0%<br />
NPAT 236.9 262.2 304.8 326.8<br />
Growth 17% 11% 16% 7%<br />
Extraordinary Items -5.0 -5.6 0.0 0.0<br />
Net Income 231.9 256.6 304.8 326.8<br />
Profit Share to Employees & Board 15.2 15.2 18.1 19.4<br />
Net Attributable Income - NAI 216.7 241.3 286.7 307.4<br />
Growth 19% 11% 19% 7%<br />
ROS 25% 27% 29% 29%<br />
Balance Sheet 2007a 2008a 2009e 2010f<br />
Cash & Marketable Securities 416.9 372.0 330.1 370.8<br />
Trade Receivables-Net 227.9 241.7 304.0 334.4<br />
Inventory 338.8 382.0 411.1 452.2<br />
Other Current Asset 27.5 33.3 35.8 39.4<br />
Total Current Asset 1,011.0 1,029.0 1,081.0 1,196.9<br />
Net Fixed Assets 308.3 334.1 516.1 633.9<br />
Projects Under Implementation 31.1 70.5 0.0 0.0<br />
Other Assets 256.7 238.2 219.7 201.2<br />
Total Assets 1,607.1 1,671.8 1,816.8 2,031.9<br />
Short Term Bank Debt 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
CPLTD 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
Accounts Payable 26.2 22.5 24.2 26.7<br />
Dividend Payable 137.4 0.0 181.5 194.6<br />
Other Current Liabilities 73.7 68.2 73.4 107.7<br />
Total Current Liabilities 237.2 90.7 279.1 329.0<br />
Long-Term Debt 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
Provisions for Deferred Taxes 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
Provisions 301.3 258.4 326.8 359.8<br />
Total Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 1,068.4 1,314.9 1,210.9 1,343.1<br />
Total Liab.& Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 1,607.1 1,671.8 1,816.8 2,031.9<br />
25<br />
20<br />
15<br />
Mar-08<br />
Apr-08<br />
May-08<br />
Jun-08<br />
Jul-08<br />
Aug-08<br />
Sep-08<br />
Oct-08<br />
Nov-08<br />
Dec-08<br />
Jan-09<br />
Feb-09<br />
Mar-09<br />
Free Cash Flow Statement 2007a 2008a 2009e 2010f<br />
NOPLAT 218.1 221.6 279.8 268.4<br />
Non-Cash Items 83.4 51.4 46.0 129.7<br />
Gross Cash Flow 301.5 273.0 325.9 398.0<br />
Gross Investments 120.8 274.3 31.7 230.9<br />
Non -Operating Cash Flow -0.6 13.5 14.9 16.4<br />
Free Cash Flow 180 12 309 184<br />
Financing Flow<br />
Interest Income After-Tax -15.9 -19.6 -6.9 -38.9<br />
Investment Income After-Tax -0.3 -2.9 -3.2 -3.2<br />
Increase in Excess Cash & M. Sec. 34.0 -52.1 -48.8 30.9<br />
After-Tax Interest Expense 1.8 1.0 0.0 0.0<br />
Decrease in Debt & Bonds 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
Provisions Used 15.2 75.8 -40.8 0.0<br />
Dividends Paid 129.8 129.9 163.4 175.2<br />
Non-Appropriation Items 15.2 15.2 18.1 19.4<br />
Shareholders <strong>Equity</strong> 0.2 -135.1 227.3 0.0<br />
Total Financing Flow 180 12 309 184<br />
Please refer to disclaimer on last page<br />
Financial Summary (Figures in LE million)<br />
Source: Company Historical & Prime Estimates<br />
Prime Research 28
PRIME PICK: EIPICO<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Meet The Drug Maker..<br />
Egyptian International Pharmaceutical Industries Company (EIPICO) is Egypt’s leading drug maker with local and export market<br />
shares of 7% and 25% respectively. EIPICO manufactures more than 190 products covering 23 therapeutic areas, including soft gelatine<br />
capsules, lyophilized products, gels, sprayers and effervescent tablets. It manufactures the products under license from multinationals,<br />
including Roche. Moreover, the company has a 33% stake in drug maker Universal Company in KSA which will be operational<br />
by 2H FY09 after finalizing Saudi authorities approvals. Moreover, the company is investing in its R&D department which will enable it<br />
to increase the number of generics which has higher margins than under license products. The company exports its products to most<br />
of the MENA region in order to escape price capping controls by the Egyptian governments.<br />
Projections & Valuation<br />
During our last meeting, the company’s management has confirmed that constructing the new factory has already began, and that<br />
the new factory will be fully operational by mid FY10. Accordingly, our current valuation assumes that the company will be able to<br />
double its capacity by FY10. The following table depicts EIPICO production in terms of Generics and Under license products. We expect<br />
EIPICO’s revenues to record LE979 million in FY09, growing steadily thereafter at a 5 years CAGR of 9%, while we lowered our<br />
target of LE271 million FY08 earnings to LE255 million. On the EBTIDA level, we expect an EBITDA of LE395 million, equating to an<br />
EBITDA margin of 43.5%.<br />
Drugs Produced 2007a 2008e 2009f 2010f 2011f 2012f<br />
EIPICO Production (Generics) 192 199 208 208 217 226<br />
Under license 61 61 61 61 61 61<br />
Total 253 260 269 269 278 287<br />
Table 75<br />
Source: EIPICO, Prime Forecasts<br />
Our DCF value for EIPICO has come down from LE46/share to LE39.2/share, reflecting our new risk free rate as well as new premium.<br />
Also, it is worth mentioning that the company has investment in Saudi Arabia which we have not accounted for in our valuation,<br />
but once the company reveals more details, we will revise our valuation upwards.<br />
Investment Rationale<br />
• Visible top line and bottom line growth given the industry characteristics which is defensive and immune from recession<br />
• The company has a strong focus on generics which enjoys higher margins and more cost efficient.<br />
• EIPICO opened a biotechnology centre in 2001 which will allow over the long term to harness biotech methods of producing raw<br />
materials used in its products, and to conduct pre-clinical and clinical trials.<br />
• Increased health awareness in the Egyptian market will increase Drug/capita expenditure<br />
• Sales and distribution network covering most of the MENA region, Romania in Europe, and Pakistan in Asia<br />
• Strong Export presence as well as recent expansion in Saudi Arabia which will allow it to escape strict price controls in the Egyptian<br />
market<br />
• Debt free, yet, the company still has a healthy cash flow to finance its expansions plans ( Doubling Capacity)<br />
• Dividends Yield of around 10% as well as a PE of 6x<br />
Prime Research 29
PRIME PICK: ORASCOM<br />
CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRIES<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Target Price Market Price Recommendation Upside Potential Investment Grade<br />
LE341 LE120 Strong Buy<br />
184%<br />
Value<br />
500<br />
450<br />
400<br />
350<br />
300<br />
250<br />
200<br />
150<br />
100<br />
50<br />
0<br />
Share Data<br />
Company Short Name<br />
Sector<br />
Company Traded Market<br />
Report Reason<br />
Valuation Methodology<br />
Previous Target<br />
Exchange Rate<br />
Stock Currency<br />
Reuters Code<br />
Stock Performance Chart (LE)<br />
(LE / Share)<br />
Please refer to disclaimer on last page<br />
OCI<br />
Construction/Fertilizers<br />
EGX<br />
<strong>Equity</strong> Strategy<br />
SOP DCF<br />
LE560<br />
LE5.55/US$<br />
LE<br />
OCIC.CA<br />
Outstanding Shares (mn) 215<br />
Par Value/Share (LE) 5<br />
Financial Year Ending<br />
December<br />
Mkt. Cap (LE bn) 25.75<br />
Av. Daily Volume (000) (52Wk.) 362.4<br />
Weight to PAMI 13.5%<br />
Price Low – High (LE) (52Wk.) 98.5 - 470<br />
Shareholders<br />
Ownership Stake<br />
Sawiras Family 55%<br />
Free Float 45%<br />
Mar-08<br />
Apr-08<br />
May-08<br />
Jun-08<br />
Jul-08<br />
Aug-08<br />
Sep-08<br />
Oct-08<br />
Nov-08<br />
Dec-08<br />
Jan-09<br />
Feb-09<br />
Income Statement 2007a 2008e 2009f 2010f<br />
Revenues 13,482 20,637 22,057 26,322<br />
Growth -18% 53% 7% 19%<br />
COGS 10,248 13,911 16,094 18,338<br />
S,G & Admin. Expenses 764 1,954 2,374 2,841<br />
Other provisions 85 127 147 173<br />
EBITDA 2,384 4,645 3,442 4,970<br />
Growth -46% 95% -26% 44%<br />
EBITDA Margin 18% 23% 16% 19%<br />
Depreciation & Amortization 924 340 758 1,233<br />
Operating EBIT 1,460 4,304 2,684 3,737<br />
Interest Income 323 292 170 182<br />
Investment Income 129 145 168 236<br />
Interest Expense 605 128 195 115<br />
Non-Operating Revenues (net) 161 123 (93) 17<br />
Pre Tax Income 1,469 4,737 2,735 4,057<br />
Pre Tax Income Growth -58% 223% -42% 48%<br />
Income Tax 82.0 947.3 546.9 616.5<br />
Effective Tax Rate 6% 20% 20% 15%<br />
NPAT 1,387 3,789 2,188 3,441<br />
Growth -59% 173% -42% 57%<br />
Extraordinary Items 64,786 1,413 - -<br />
Net Income 66,172 5,202 2,188 3,441<br />
Minority Interest 151 - - -<br />
Non-Appropriation Items - 78 33 52<br />
Net Attributable Income - NAI 66,021 5,124 2,155 3,389<br />
Growth 4071% -92% -58% 57%<br />
ROS 489.7% 24.8% 9.8% 12.9%<br />
Balance Sheet 2007a 2008e 2009f 2010f<br />
Cash & Marketable Securities 3,989 15,092 9,021 9,718<br />
Trade Receivables-Net 3,517 6,014 7,241 9,270<br />
Inventory 734 1,124 1,201 1,434<br />
Other Current Asset 81,499 2,691 3,113 3,547<br />
Total Current Asset 89,740 24,921 20,576 23,968<br />
Net Fixed Assets 3,473 8,526 13,959 17,137<br />
Other Assets 1,739 3,535 3,208 2,979<br />
Total Assets 94,952 36,981 37,742 44,084<br />
CPLTD 10,648 2,667 700 500<br />
Accounts Payable 5,525 9,109 10,606 13,673<br />
Dividend Payable 63,219 858 364 578<br />
Other Current Liabilities 852 2,892 3,346 4,071<br />
Total Current Liabilities 80,244 15,526 15,016 18,822<br />
Long-Term Debt 1,035 3,833 3,133 2,633<br />
Provisions for Deferred Taxes 103 103 103 103<br />
Provisions 2,307 2,435 2,582 2,755<br />
other Non current liabilities 586 0 0 0<br />
Minority interests 1,049 1,049 1,049 1,049<br />
Total Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 9,628 14,036 15,859 18,722<br />
Total Liab.& Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 94,952 36,981 37,742 44,084<br />
Free Cash Flow Statement 2007 2008 2009 2010<br />
NOPLAT 4,739 3,647 2,086 3,112<br />
Non-Cash Items 1,009 468 905 1,407<br />
Gross Cash Flow 5,748 4,115 2,991 4,518<br />
Gross Investments 69,623 (76,908) 5,651 3,155<br />
Non -Operating Cash Flow 61,320 1,229 (74) 15<br />
Free Cash Flow (2,555) 82,252 (2,734) 1,378<br />
Financing Flow<br />
Interest Income After-Tax (321) (286) (167) (180)<br />
Investment Income After-Tax (128) (142) (165) (232)<br />
Change in Excess Cash & Mkt. Sec. (1,178) 14,225 (6,099) 612<br />
Change in Subsidiaries and LT Investments 649 16 16 16<br />
After-Tax Interest Expense 571 102 156 98<br />
Change in Debt & Bonds (2,433) 5,183 2,667 700<br />
Provisions Used (1,711) - - -<br />
Dividends Paid & Minority Interest 151 63,141 826 313<br />
Non-Appropriation Items - 78 33 52<br />
Reserves Used 1,888 (0) - -<br />
Change in Paid-in Capital & Capital Surplus (42) (64) - -<br />
Total Financing Flow (2,555) 82,252 (2,734) 1,378<br />
Financial Summary (Figures in LE million)<br />
Source: Company Historical & Prime Estimates<br />
Prime Research 30
PRIME PICK: ORASCOM<br />
CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRIES<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Meet The Fertile Contractor<br />
Orascom Construction Industries is a leading construction contractor operating in Egypt with also strong presence in the MENA region<br />
and GCC countries along with Europe. Following its divesture of its cement line of business, the company has initiated operations in the<br />
lucrative fertilizers business to capitalize on the growing demand for fertilizers generated from agricultural crops and biofuel. OCI fertilizers’<br />
capacity comes from its operation via EFC, Sorfret, EBIC and Notore. The company has a total capacity of 3.8 million tons in<br />
FY08, expected to reach 4.6 million tons by FY11. EFC has a production capacity of 1.4mtpa of urea, but the 30% owned EBIC has a<br />
production capacity of 0.7 mtpa of ammonia and was expected to start operation late 2008. Notore Chemicals on the other hand, is<br />
20% owned subsidiary by OCI in Nigeria with a production capacity of 0.5 mtpa of urea/ammonia. Sofert Algeria is now the only company<br />
that has not started and will begin operation late 2010 with a sellable production capacity of 0.7 mtpa and 1.2 mtpa of ammonia<br />
and urea respectively.<br />
Projections & Valuation<br />
• We forecast a 53% growth in the top line figure in FY08<br />
culminating at LE20.6 billion, of which construction revenues<br />
will constitute around 83.8%. The rest of the value<br />
will mainly come from Egyptian Fertilizers Company<br />
(EFC). Going forward we forecast a 5-year CAGR of<br />
25.06% by the end of FY12 motivated by the rebound of<br />
the construction activities and fertilizers price. The fertilizers<br />
segment will capture 87% of aggregate revenues<br />
by FY12.<br />
• Looking ahead, EBITDA margin will slow down as the<br />
construction segment has low profit margin compared to<br />
the fertilizers segment. EBITDA margin will hover at 21%<br />
in FY12 compared to 23.1% in FY12 and will reach a<br />
minimum of 16.3% in FY09.<br />
• Our assumptions are based on an average price of<br />
US$522/ton for urea in FY08 and US$261/ton in FY09. As<br />
for ammonia, we used an average price of US$500 in<br />
FY08 and US$250/ton in FY09.<br />
• Based on the management's guidance, EBIC and Notore came into stream by the end of FY08 while Sofret Algeria in late FY10.<br />
However, we used a utilization rate of 0% in FY10 but 80% in FY11.<br />
• Net income in FY08 will be boosted by a capital gain from the divestment of the Egyptian Container Handling Company at<br />
US$255 million after all associated costs.<br />
Investment Rationale<br />
FY ending December 2008e 2009f 2010f 2011f<br />
mtpa<br />
EFC<br />
Urea<br />
Capacity 1.3 1.3 1.45 1.45<br />
Utilization 90% 70% 70% 80%<br />
Sorferet Algeria<br />
Urea<br />
Capacity 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.2<br />
Utilization 0.0% 0.0% 0% 80.0%<br />
Ammonia<br />
Capacity 0.7 0.7 0.7 0.7<br />
Utilization 0.0% 0.0% 0% 80.0%<br />
EBIC<br />
Ammonia<br />
Capacity 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8<br />
Utilization 10.0% 82.0% 85.0% 85.0%<br />
Nortre<br />
Urea<br />
Capacity 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5<br />
Utilization 50% 82% 85% 85%<br />
Source: OCI& Prime Estimates<br />
• OCI management has a track record on generating strong cash flows from its previous cement business as well as its ongoing<br />
construction business which has been growing annually at an average 20% for the past 5 years.<br />
• OCI will and have been always capitalizing on government expenditure plans of major infrastructure projects locally and in<br />
the GCC with the later projects estimated at around US$1.5 trillion<br />
• OCI is always focusing on high margin projects given its always capitalizing on its strong backlog which reached US$7 billion,<br />
up from US$4.8 billion in 2007<br />
• OCI enjoys a strong negotiation power in its construction contracts given the few number of contractors available, although someone<br />
might argue that construction slowdown would lead to lower negotiation power, yet, OCI contracts include revision clauses<br />
which will enable it to hedge against costs of raw materials<br />
• OCI presence in the fertilizers’ business will enable stronger cash flows once all capacities are in place by 2011, given that we<br />
forecast a rebound in fertilizers’ prices to average around US$320 from FY09-FY11<br />
• OCI recent acquisition of Gavilon, a major fertilizers distributor in US, will enable it to market its fertilizers’ products efficiently<br />
while achieving strong cost synergies given its fertilizer trade activity which is the largest independent importer of fertilizer into<br />
the US with 7.1 mt of fertilizer products<br />
Prime Research 31
PRIME PICK: EL SEWEDY CABLES<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Target Price Market Price Recommendation Upside Potential Investment Grade<br />
LE77 LE39.15 Strong Buy<br />
97% Value & Growth<br />
Share Data<br />
Company Short Name<br />
Sector<br />
Company Traded Market<br />
Report Reason<br />
Valuation Methodology<br />
Previous Target<br />
Exchange Rate<br />
Stock Currency<br />
Reuters Code<br />
Stock Performance Chart<br />
(LE / Share)<br />
SEWEDY<br />
Industrial<br />
EGX<br />
<strong>Equity</strong> Strategy<br />
DCF<br />
LE103<br />
LE5.55 /US$<br />
LE<br />
SWDY.CA<br />
Outstanding Shares (mn) 132<br />
Par Value/Share (LE) 10<br />
Financial Year Ending<br />
Mkt. Cap (LE mn)<br />
December<br />
LE5,168<br />
Weight to PGI 2.4%<br />
Av. Daily Volume(000) (52Wk.) 184<br />
Price Low – High (LE) (52Wk.)<br />
Shareholders<br />
LE28.5-146.4<br />
Ownership Stake<br />
El Sewedy Family 72.7%<br />
Others 2.30%<br />
Free float 25%<br />
Income Statement 2007a 2008e 2009f 2010f<br />
Revenues 9,377.5 9,690.0 6,306.0 8,824.7<br />
Growth 29.3% 3.3% -34.9% 39.9%<br />
COGS 8,118.7 8,141.6 4,644.4 6,998.4<br />
S,G & Admin. Expenses 295.0 304.9 252.2 264.7<br />
EBITDA 963.8 1,243.6 1,409.3 1,561.6<br />
Growth 47% 29% 13% 11%<br />
EBITDA Margin 10% 13% 22% 18%<br />
Depreciation & Amortization 83.3 118.5 333.2 371.6<br />
Other Provisions 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
Operating EBIT 880.5 1,125.1 1,076.2 1,190.0<br />
Interest Income 83.8 5.5 9.6 12.8<br />
Investment Income 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
Interest Expense 183.2 147.0 39.0 33.4<br />
Non-Operating Revenues 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
Pre Tax Income 781.2 983.6 1,046.8 1,169.3<br />
Income Tax 24.5 26.1 27.3 32.7<br />
Effective Tax Rate 3% 3% 3% 3%<br />
NPAT 756.7 957.5 1,019.5 1,136.6<br />
Growth 37% 27% 6% 11%<br />
Extraordinary Items 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
Net Income 756.7 957.5 1,019.5 1,136.6<br />
Minority Interest 25.4 32.3 45.0 47.9<br />
Net Attributable Income - NAI 724.3 912.5 971.6 1,083.2<br />
Growth 37% 26% 6% 11%<br />
ROS 8% 9% 15% 12%<br />
Balance Sheet 2007a 2008e 2009f 2010f<br />
Cash & Marketable Securities 982.4 1,207.8 1,021.3 1,418.2<br />
Trade Receivables-Net 1,374.1 1,384.4 1,081.1 1,815.5<br />
Inventory 2,074.9 2,616.3 2,333.2 2,823.9<br />
Other Current Asset 272.3 355.3 269.7 333.4<br />
Total Current Asset 4,703.7 5,563.9 4,705.3 6,391.0<br />
Net Fixed Assets 756.6 1,483.7 1,346.1 1,102.2<br />
Projects Under Implementation 414.2 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
Other Assets 377.7 578.0 519.4 518.1<br />
Total Assets 6,252.3 7,625.6 6,570.9 8,011.3<br />
Short Term Bank Debt 840.3 1,633.8 0.0 0.0<br />
CPLTD 1,420.7 28.5 85.7 85.7<br />
Accounts Payable 325.6 370.1 264.9 370.8<br />
Dividend Payable 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
Other Current Liabilities 182.3 13.3 8.6 12.1<br />
Total Current Liabilities 2,769.0 2,045.7 359.3 468.6<br />
Long-Term Debt 39.6 600.0 514.3 428.6<br />
Minority Interest 228.7 273.7 276.6 786.0<br />
Provisions 33.0 80.0 40.0 38.0<br />
Total Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 3,079.2 3,528.2 4,499.8 5,583.0<br />
Total Liab.& Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 6,252.3 7,625.6 6,570.9 8,011.3<br />
160<br />
140<br />
120<br />
100<br />
80<br />
60<br />
40<br />
20<br />
0<br />
M ar-08<br />
A pr-08<br />
May-08<br />
Jun-08<br />
Jul-08<br />
Aug-08<br />
Sep-08<br />
Oct-08<br />
Nov-08<br />
Please refer to disclaimer on last page<br />
Dec-08<br />
Jan-09<br />
Feb-09<br />
M ar-09<br />
Free Cash Flow Statement 2007a 2008e 2009f 2010f<br />
NOPLAT 858.7 1,095.2 1,047.9 1,156.4<br />
Non-Cash Items 83.3 118.5 333.2 371.6<br />
Gross Cash Flow 942.0 1,213.7 1,381.1 1,527.9<br />
Gross Investments 1,416.5 -223.3 -323.3 1,096.2<br />
Non -Operating Cash Flow 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
Free Cash Flow -474.5 1,436.9 1,704.3 431.8<br />
Financing Flow<br />
Interest Income After-Tax -83.6 -5.5 -9.6 -12.8<br />
Investment Income After-Tax 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
Increase in Excess Cash & M. Sec. -169.2 799.4 -74.3 270.9<br />
After-Tax Interest Expense 177.4 143.1 38.0 32.5<br />
Decrease in Debt & Bonds -326.1 38.3 1,662.3 85.7<br />
Dividends Paid 32.3 45.0 47.9 53.4<br />
Non-Appropriation Items 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
Total Financing Flow -474.5 1,436.9 1,704.3 431.8<br />
Financial Summary (Figures in LE million)<br />
Source: Company Historical & Prime Estimates<br />
Prime Research 32
PRIME PICK: EL SEWEDY CABLES<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Meet The Cable Manufacturer<br />
El Sewedy Cables is a leading power cable provider in Egypt and the second<br />
largest one in MENA. Sewedy Cables operations are basically divided into<br />
power cables , electrical appliance, comprehensive turnkey projects<br />
and wind energy projects. El Sewedy Cables market share is<br />
over 56% based on sales revenues. Sewedy Cables enjoys a vertically<br />
integrated model of producing power and special cables and cable related<br />
products and services. Operations are divided into four segments as follow:<br />
1) Wire & Cable which produces wire cables, special cables and winding<br />
wires, as well as raw materials used in cable production such as copper<br />
wire and plastic and polypropylene filler.<br />
2) Electrical Products which produces cable accessories such as modular<br />
terminators, power cable joins and transformers, as well as other<br />
products such as fiber glass and concrete poles for street lighting<br />
3) Turnkey projects which implements cable related infrastructure projects<br />
to meet the needs of major infrastructure projects.<br />
4) Latest addition is Wind energy to capitalize on the government plans<br />
if rolling out wind energy as a replacement of normal energy sources<br />
Projections & Valuation<br />
Sewedy Cables capacity is expected to increase from the current 232.6k<br />
tons/annum to 262.4k tons in 2010.<br />
• Total Revenues surged by 25% to reach LE8.9 billion in 9M FY08<br />
compared to LE7.2 billion in the comparable period last year. We expect<br />
total revenues to decline by 32% from LE9.7 billion in FY08 to<br />
LE6.3 billion in FY09. Going forward, top line figure is expected<br />
to grow at a 5 year CAGR of 3.7%.<br />
• Revenues of power cables segment contributed 81.4% of total<br />
revenues in 9M FY08. We expect revenues of power cables to reach<br />
LE6.5 billion in FY08 backed by 1) the increase in the company’s<br />
production capacity from 124k tons in FY07 to 232k tons in<br />
FY08. 2) The increase in selling prices of both copper and aluminum<br />
to record an average of US$7,000/ton and US$2,000/<br />
ton respectively in FY08. It is worth mentioning that the company’s production capacity is expected to witness an expansion in copper<br />
to reach 137.5k tons in FY08, up from 68.7k tons in FY07. In addition, aluminum production capacity is expected to increase<br />
by 79% from 35.4k tons in FY07 to 63.5k tons in FY08. We estimated that the company will operate at 85% utilization rate,<br />
therefore, total sales volume is expected to increase by 63% to reach 164k tons. Going forward, we expect that total production capacity<br />
to increase to 253k tons in FY09 and revenues of power cables and raw material segment to record LE5.1 billion. The decline in<br />
revenues of this segment can be attributed to the expected decline in selling prices of both copper and aluminum in FY09 to US$3200/<br />
ton and US$1500/ton respectively. Going forward, Revenues from this segment is expected to grow at a 5 year CAGR of approximately<br />
7%.<br />
• Revenues from Electrical products are expected to record LE858.6 million in FY08, up from LE222 million last year. Revenues from<br />
this segment are expected to decline to LE623 million in FY09. Going forward, we expect this segment to contribute approximately 9%<br />
of total revenues and to grow at a 5 year CAGR of 16.45%.<br />
• EBITDA margin is expected to increase to 12% in FY08, up from 10% in FY07. Going forward, EBITDA margin is assumed at<br />
22% in FY09 backed by the increase in production volume with the expansion plan in Libya and Qatar. Net income figure is expected<br />
to grow by 26% to reach LE912 Million in FY08. The bottom line is assumed to increase by 18% in FY09 to reach LE971 Million. Going<br />
forward, we expect net income figure to grow at a 5 year CAGR of 8.3%<br />
• Utilizing a WACC of 17.9% and growth rate of 3%, our DCF value culminate at LE77/share, illustrating 97% upside potential over the<br />
current market price of LE39.15/share.<br />
Investment Rationale:<br />
• Strong Fundamentals generated from a Sound Management with Visible business plans (Cables Expansion Capacity / Entry Wind Energy)<br />
• High Industry Barriers which will help maintain El Sewedy Market Position<br />
• El Sewedy Operations are mostly available in low competition markets<br />
Production Capacities<br />
In Tons 2008a 2009f 2010f<br />
Egypt<br />
Copper 63,600 63,600 63,600<br />
Aluminum 40,000 50,600 50,600<br />
Total 103,600 114,200 114,200<br />
y-o-y % 32.82% 10.23% 0.00%<br />
Sudan<br />
Copper 4,200 4,200 4,200<br />
Aluminum 6,000 6,000 6,000<br />
Total 10,200 10,200 10,200<br />
y-o-y % 13.33% 0.00% 0.00%<br />
Syria<br />
Copper 25,500 25,500 25,500<br />
Aluminum 3,600 3,600 3,600<br />
Total 29,100 29,100 29,100<br />
y-o-y % 70.18% 0.00% 0.00%<br />
Libya<br />
Copper 11,200 19,800 19,800<br />
Aluminum 2,400 2,400 2,520<br />
Total 13,600 22,200 22,320<br />
y-o-y % 63.24% 0.54%<br />
Saudi<br />
Copper 26,000 26,000 26,000<br />
Aluminum 7,500 7,500 7,500<br />
Total 33,500 33,500 33,500<br />
y-o-y % 0.00% 0.00%<br />
UIC<br />
Special Cables 15,600 15,600 15,600<br />
Winding Wires 16,000 16,000 16,000<br />
Total 31,600 31,600 31,600<br />
y-o-y % 53.85% 0.00% 0.00%<br />
New Cables<br />
Copper 7,000 17,500 17,500<br />
Aluminum 4,000 4,000 4,000<br />
Total 11,000 21,500 21,500<br />
y-o-y % 95.45% 8.20%<br />
El Sewedy Cables & Prime Estimates<br />
• El Sewedy long term operations will always capitalize on governments infrastructure projects which are expected to increase in order to<br />
stimulate economies<br />
• Strong Revenue Stream addition once Wind Energy revenues kick off.<br />
Prime Research 33
PRIME PICK: TALAAT MOUSTAFA<br />
GROUP (TMG)<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Target Price Market Price Recommendation Upside Potential Investment Grade<br />
LE10.27 LE2.72 Strong Buy<br />
277%<br />
Growth<br />
Share Data<br />
Company Short Name<br />
Sector<br />
Company Traded Market<br />
Report Reason<br />
Valuation Methodology<br />
Previous Target<br />
Exchange Rate<br />
Stock Currency<br />
Reuters Code<br />
Stock Performance Chart<br />
(LE / Share)<br />
TMG<br />
Housing<br />
EGX<br />
<strong>Equity</strong> Strategy<br />
DCF<br />
LE15<br />
LE5.55 /US$<br />
LE<br />
TMGH.CA<br />
Outstanding Shares (bn) 2.03<br />
Par Value/Share (LE) 10<br />
Financial Year Ending<br />
Mkt. Cap (LE bn)<br />
December<br />
LE5.5<br />
Weight to PAMI 3%<br />
Av. Daily Volume (000) (52Wk.) 9,242<br />
Price Low – High (LE) (52Wk.) LE2.3 - 13.57<br />
Shareholders<br />
TMG for Touristic and Real<br />
Estate Investment<br />
Ownership Stake<br />
49.85%<br />
Misr Insurance Company 4.43%<br />
Banque Misr 2.66%<br />
National Insurance Company of<br />
Egypt<br />
0.23%<br />
National Bank of Egypt 0.37%<br />
Other Investors 22.96%<br />
Free Float 19.50%<br />
14<br />
12<br />
10<br />
8<br />
6<br />
4<br />
2<br />
0<br />
Mar-08<br />
Apr-08<br />
May-08<br />
Jun-08<br />
Jul-08<br />
Aug-08<br />
Sep-08<br />
Oct-08<br />
Nov-08<br />
Dec-08<br />
Jan-09<br />
Feb-09<br />
Mar-09<br />
Income Statement 2007a 2008a 2009f 2010f<br />
Revenues 1,876 5,421 5,976 9,944<br />
Growth 307% 189% 10% 66%<br />
COGS 1,025 3,493 2,796 3,927<br />
S,G & Admin. Expenses 267 146 268 385<br />
EBITDA 583.7 1781.2 2911.5 5631.7<br />
Growth 9.1 2.1 0.6 0.9<br />
EBITDA Margin 31% 33% 49% 57%<br />
Depreciation & Amortization 58 103 101 119<br />
Operating EBIT 584 1,660 2,802 5,488<br />
Interest Income 78.3 128.2 59.8 49.7<br />
Investment Income 0 48 4 3<br />
Interest Expense 14 12 8 6<br />
Non-Operating Revenues 62 33 0 0<br />
Pre Tax Income 707 1,856 2,857 5,535<br />
Pre Tax Income Growth 1154% 151% 44% 89%<br />
Income Tax 46 196 463 1,007<br />
Effective Tax Rate 6% 11% 16% 18%<br />
NPAT 661 1,660 2,395 4,528<br />
Growth 1154% 151% 44% 89%<br />
Extraordinary Items 501.5 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
Net Income 1,737 1,660 2,395 4,528<br />
Profit Share to Employees & Board 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
Net Attributable Income - NAI 1,341 1,442 2,107 3,984<br />
Growth 872% 8% 46% 89%<br />
ROS 71% 27% 35% 40%<br />
Balance Sheet 2007a 2008a 2009f 2010f<br />
Cash & Marketable Securities 4465.5 1505.3 2019.1 6801.6<br />
Trade Receivables-Net 1730.6 3296.4 2465.7 4317.5<br />
Inventory 4013.8 10357.7 14976.4 15679.6<br />
Other Current Asset 716.4 3041.9 3353.5 5580.0<br />
Total Current Asset 10,960 18,203 22,816 32,380<br />
Net Fixed Assets 2555.3 3798.1 9221.7 9868.7<br />
Projects Under Implementation 284.6 384.6 697.9 802.2<br />
Other Assets 4754.4<br />
Total Assets 42,981 53,800 49,855 55,636<br />
Short Term Bank Debt 51.8 110.9 0.0 0.0<br />
CPLTD 357.1 513.5 316.7 332.5<br />
Accounts Payable 301.8 457.6 504.5 839.4<br />
Dividend Payable 0.0 2.0 0.0 0.0<br />
Other Current Liabilities 1068.8 1426.8 1284.2 1155.7<br />
Total Current Liabilities 3819.0 9876.6 8763.0 9608.9<br />
Long-Term Debt 1706.9 1296.0 950.0 633.3<br />
Provisions for Deferred Taxes 3.3 11.9 1.4 1.4<br />
Provisions 6.0 48.2 44.7 49.9<br />
Total Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 21,824 21,954 24,932 28,717<br />
Total Liab.& Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 42,981 53,800 49,855 55,636<br />
Free Cash Flow Statement 2007a 2008a 2009f 2010f<br />
NOPLAT 613.0 1476.0 2328.9 4481.0<br />
Non-Cash Items 0.1 121.5 109.3 143.7<br />
Gross Cash Flow 613.0 1597.5 2438.1 4624.7<br />
Gross Investments 19655.7 -648.9 2730.8 -1448.1<br />
Non -Operating Cash Flow 1061.3 29.7 0.0 0.0<br />
Free Cash Flow -17,981 2,276 -293 6,073<br />
Financing Flow<br />
Interest Income After-Tax -77.8 -126.9 -58.8 -48.8<br />
Investment Income After-Tax 0.0 -47.0 -3.6 -3.2<br />
Increase in Excess Cash & M. Sec. 894.4 -885.7 734.2 4983.3<br />
After-Tax Interest Expense 12.8 11.2 6.9 5.1<br />
Decrease in Debt & Bonds -642.8 195.5 653.7 300.8<br />
Dividends Paid 415.3 215.6 289.4 543.3<br />
Non-Appropriation Items 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />
Total Financing Flow -17,981 2,276 -293 6,073<br />
Please refer to disclaimer on last page<br />
Financial Summary (Figures in LE million)<br />
Source: Company Historical & Prime Estimates<br />
Prime Research 34
PRIME PICK: TALAAT MOUSTAFA<br />
GROUP (TMG)<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Meet The Developer..<br />
TMG is the largest real estate developer in Egypt with total land area of 49.6 million m2.<br />
TMG operations are broken down into Real estate projects include commercial, educational<br />
and recreational facilities, as well as Hospitality business. Total consolidated<br />
revenues recorded LE5.4 billion in FY08 compared to LE1.8 billion in FY07, with<br />
revenues from units sold recording LE4.7 billion (representing 88% of total revenues)<br />
while revenues from hotels and services activities contributed the remaining 12%. Said<br />
increase can be attributed to recognition of revenues associated with delivery of units in<br />
Madinaty project. Going forward, We expect a slow down in sales in FY09 and FY10. Top<br />
line figure is estimated to grow at a 5 year CAGR of 19%. TMG posted EBITDA margin of<br />
31% in FY08 which is expected to increase to 34% in FY09 as the increase in recognized<br />
revenues will outpace that of COGS.<br />
Projections & Valuation<br />
The slowdown in the real estate sector coupled with market saturation with regard to the<br />
high end, makes us believe that TMG will face a slowdown in the sales of its main projects<br />
namely Madinaty and Al Rehab. Therefore, we estimated total sales for Madianty and Al<br />
Rehab of LE2.4 billion and LE1.1 billion respectively in FY09.<br />
We believe that shrinking in Tourism activity will affect negatively on Hotel revenues. Accordingly,<br />
we expect a decline in average rate per room by 10% and average occupancy<br />
rate is estimated at 30% . In addition, Marsa Alam project is assumed to be postponed to<br />
FY10.<br />
The slow down in the world economy will hinder TMG’s ability to expand in the region.<br />
Therefore, Saudi Arabia Projects are expected to be postponed until the end of FY10.<br />
Our Sum of the parts (SOTP) value for TMG culminated at LE10.26/share, which<br />
illustrates upside potential of 277% compared to the last market share of LE2.72. With<br />
Madinty and Al Rehab projects contribute approximately 39% and 25%, respectively of<br />
the total value.<br />
Company Land (LE 000s)<br />
City Community & Complexes<br />
TMG Stake<br />
of Value<br />
Rabwa II 1,043,990<br />
Rehab I 6,356<br />
Rehab II 5,245,549<br />
San Stefano (Residential & Commercial)<br />
2,000,768<br />
Thabat 1,624,999<br />
Madinaty 8,202,295<br />
C&C Sum of the Part Value 18,123,957<br />
Hotels & Resorts (ICON)<br />
Four Seasons San Stefano (Hotel) 41,494<br />
Four Seasons Sharm El Sheikh 369,157<br />
Marsa Alam 152,854<br />
Four Season Nile Plaza 753,240<br />
Nile Hotel 63,552<br />
H&R Sum of the Part Value 1,380,297<br />
Alexandria Real Estate Inv.<br />
(Marketing Segment)<br />
1,336,106<br />
TMG Sum of the Part Value 20,840,360<br />
Source: Prime Estimates<br />
Revenues by Project (LE 000s) 2009f 2010f 2011f<br />
Rehab I 504,551 555,007 610,507<br />
Rehab I phase VI & Commercial 345,783 16,248 25,111<br />
Rehab II 1,908,500 1,470,345 1,128,784<br />
Madinaty 1,527,150 5,447,785 3,360,897<br />
Al Rabwa 215,771 278,578 234,891<br />
San Stefano Reseditions & Commercial 205,440 1,042,385 235,000<br />
Four Seasons San Stefano (Hotel) 71,492 109,387 237,845<br />
Four Seasons Sharm El Sheikh 588,638 311,720 377,561<br />
Marsa Alam 118,125 147,000 156,188<br />
Four Season Nile Plaza 406,382 463,626 529,241<br />
Nile Hotel 84,230 101,826 122,673<br />
Consolidated Revenue 5,976,063 9,943,906 7,018,698<br />
Source: Prime Estimates<br />
Investment Rationale<br />
Negative sentiment on real estate and Tourism slowdown, coupled with negative news on former TMG CEO, have caused sharp decline<br />
in TMG stock price to reach around LE2-3 during the last period. Now that valuations are compelling given multiples of 0.2x P/B<br />
and P/E of 2.5x FY09 earnings, we recommend TMG for the long term due to the following:<br />
• Diversification of earnings inflows among residential, commercial, recreational facilities, and hospitality business.<br />
• More negative news on former CEO is unlikely to be negative on the stock since the market has already discounted it, on the<br />
contrary, positive news would be a strong upward share driver<br />
• TMG is the only listed real estate developer offering lower to medium class housing units which is the tranche that composes<br />
most of the pent up demand<br />
• Following its IPO in August 2007, TMG share price hasn't taken its upward movement such as most of housing stocks during last<br />
upward cycle for housing , which will probably occur during the next upward cycle.<br />
Prime Research 35
PRIME PICK: EFG-HERMES<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Target Price Market Price Recommendation Upside Potential Investment Grade<br />
LE19 LE12.46 Strong Buy<br />
60.5%<br />
Value<br />
Share Data<br />
Company Short Name<br />
Sector<br />
Company Traded Market<br />
Report Reason<br />
Valuation Methodology<br />
Previous Target<br />
Exchange Rate<br />
Stock Currency<br />
Reuters Code<br />
Stock Performance Chart<br />
(LE / Share)<br />
EFG - Hermes<br />
Financial Sector<br />
EGX<br />
<strong>Equity</strong> Strategy<br />
DCF<br />
LE77/Share<br />
LE5.55/US$<br />
LE<br />
HRHO.CA<br />
Outstanding Shares (mn) 387.9<br />
Par Value/Share (LE) 5<br />
Financial Year Ending<br />
December<br />
Mkt. Cap (LE mn) 4,833<br />
Weight to PAMI 5.2%<br />
Av. Daily Volume(000) (52Wk.) 1,694<br />
Price Low – High (LE) (52Wk.) 12.5 - 61.96<br />
Shareholders<br />
Ownership Stake<br />
Dubai Financial <strong>Group</strong> 25.0%<br />
Abu Dhabi Investment Authority 8.7%<br />
EFG Employee Trust 5.0%<br />
GDRs 8.7%<br />
Free Float 15.5%<br />
Institutional & Regional Investors 37.1%<br />
70<br />
60<br />
50<br />
40<br />
30<br />
20<br />
10<br />
0<br />
Mar-08<br />
Apr-08<br />
May-08<br />
Jun-08<br />
Jul-08<br />
Aug-08<br />
Sep-08<br />
Oct-08<br />
Nov-08<br />
Dec-08<br />
Jan-09<br />
Feb-09<br />
Mar-09<br />
Income Statement 2007a 2008a 2009f 2010f<br />
Revenues 1,719.6 1,620.1 1,022.0 1,513.1<br />
Growth 91.4% -5.8% -36.9% 48.1%<br />
Other Revenues 353.6 199.4 119.5 168.0<br />
S,G & Admin. Expenses 799.1 887.5 556.8 853.6<br />
Other Provisions 109.4 42.3 27.9 40.2<br />
EBITDA 1,164.7 889.7 556.8 787.3<br />
Growth 92.8% -23.6% -37.4% 41.4%<br />
EBITDA Margin 67.7% 54.9% 54.5% 52.0%<br />
Depreciation & Amortization 22.8 130.8 76.6 91.7<br />
Operating EBIT 1,141.9 758.8 480.3 695.6<br />
Interest Income 246.3 187.1 169.4 177.1<br />
Investment Income 287.5 327.6 403.0 463.5<br />
Interest Expense 38.1 64.5 42.6 37.0<br />
Non-Operating Revenues 0.0 -116.9 -73.7 -109.1<br />
Pre Tax Income 1,637.6 1,092.3 936.4 1,190.1<br />
Pre Tax Income Growth 96% -33% -14% 27%<br />
Income Tax 210.8 101.4 86.9 110.5<br />
Effective Tax Rate 13% 9% 9% 9%<br />
NPAT 1,426.8 990.9 849.4 1,079.6<br />
Growth 95.1% -30.6% -14.3% 27.1%<br />
Extraordinary Items -33.6 2.2 0.0 0.0<br />
Minority Interest 111.9 59.6 51.0 64.8<br />
Net Income Post Minority Interest 1,281.2 933.5 798.4 1,014.8<br />
Profit Share 23.8 0.0 16.0 20.3<br />
Net Attributable Income - NAI 1,257.5 933.5 782.5 994.5<br />
Growth 81.6% -25.8% -16.2% 27.1%<br />
ROS 73.1% 57.6% 76.6% 65.7%<br />
Balance Sheet 2007a 2008a 2009f 2010f<br />
Cash & Marketable Securities 4,841.1 3,101.7 4,106.7 4,788.9<br />
Trade Receivables-Net 2,588.1 476.1 342.4 420.3<br />
Other Current Asset 461.2 739.7 454.7 575.0<br />
Total Current Asset 7,890.3 4,317.5 4,903.8 5,784.1<br />
Net Fixed Assets 135.2 168.4 164.0 187.9<br />
Other Assets 5,399.9 6,094.9 6,278.9 6,731.4<br />
Total Assets 13,426 10,581 11,347 12,703<br />
Short Term Bank Debt 0.0 0.3 0.0 0.0<br />
CPLTD 58.7 37.7 38.0 38.0<br />
Dividend Payable 387.9 186.2 95.8 223.2<br />
Other Current Liabilities 3,563.1 1,484.5 921.8 1,269.1<br />
Total Current Liabilities 4,009.6 1,708.8 1,055.6 1,530.3<br />
Long-Term Debt 131.3 91.1 72.9 58.3<br />
Provisions 169.2 153.2 181.1 221.3<br />
Other Non Current Liabilities 184.7 842.0 893.0 957.8<br />
Total Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 8,930.8 7,785.8 9,144.2 9,935.7<br />
Total Liab.& Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 13,426 10,581 11,347 12,703<br />
Free Cash Flow Statement 2007a 2008a 2009f 2010f<br />
NOPLAT 928.7 665.7 387.8 577.4<br />
Non-Cash Items 132.2 173.2 104.4 132.0<br />
Gross Cash Flow 1,061.0 838.8 492.3 709.4<br />
Gross Investments 419.8 251.0 -78.2 230.8<br />
Non -Operating Cash Flow -29.3 -104.0 -66.9 -99.0<br />
Free Cash Flow 612 484 504 380<br />
Financing Flow<br />
Interest Income After-Tax -243.1 -185.4 -167.8 -175.5<br />
Investment Income After-Tax -283.8 -324.6 -399.3 -459.2<br />
Increase in Excess Cash & M. Sec. 1,004.6 -1,523.6 1,432.4 805.5<br />
After-Tax Interest Expense 33.2 58.5 38.6 33.5<br />
Decrease in Debt & Bonds 37.4 60.8 18.3 14.6<br />
Provisions Used 7.5 58.3 0.0 0.0<br />
Dividends Paid 402.8 447.5 221.2 140.3<br />
Non-Appropriation Items 23.8 0.0 16.0 20.3<br />
Shareholders <strong>Equity</strong> -370.5 1,892.3 -655.8 0.0<br />
Total Financing Flow 612 484 504 380<br />
Please refer to disclaimer on last page<br />
Financial Summary (Figures in LE million)<br />
Source: Company Historical & Prime Estimates<br />
Prime Research 36
PRIME PICK: EFG-HERMES<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Meet The Broker’s business at FY09 P/E of 1.6x<br />
EFG Hermes is the largest Investment bank in Egypt with local and regional exposure. The company has fully fledged branches in<br />
Egypt and UAE as well as initiated operations via newly acquired brokerage licenses in Saudi Arabia and Qatar, Kuwait, and Oman.<br />
Moreover, the company has a direct stake in Audi bank and indirect stake in Egyptian real estate developer SODIC. EFG-<br />
Hermes enjoys healthy market shares in most markets it operates in. Latest market shares records a 26% in Egypt, 20% in Kuwait,<br />
24% in Oman, 26% in UAE and finally around 1.2% in Saudi Arabia.<br />
According to FY08 results, the company has hit a roadblock due to drastic market conditions originated from the credit crisis. Fee<br />
and commission income declined 5.8% to LE1.62 billion in 2008 down for LE1.72 billion in 2007. Prop. and principal<br />
trading contributed a positive LE352 million in 2007 and a negative LE84 million in 2008.<br />
Substantial decline occurred in margin trading facilities to clients from a peak of US$250 million during the year to approximately<br />
US$30 million without meaningful losses, resulting in the decline of gross receivables from LE2.6 billion in 2007 to LE958 million in<br />
2008. As of December 2008, interest earning cash stood at US$500 million, excluding investments in Banque Audi, SODIC, Nile City,<br />
seed capital in EFG-Hermes managed funds and shares purchased under the new Management Incentive Scheme or for cancellation.<br />
By 2008 year end, EFG-Hermes has taken measures to reduce total operating expenses going forward. These measures included<br />
redundancies, salary reductions for the top 200 employees, the implementation of a new expense policy and the relocation of certain<br />
functions to Egypt, all of which should lead to a meaningful decline in operating expense.<br />
Projections and Valuation<br />
2009 already started with 3 months through and average daily<br />
values have declined substantially in almost all markets. For<br />
instance, Egypt, its 32% contributor to its top line, has<br />
declined in average daily value from over LE1.3 billion to<br />
around LE800 billion. This was caused by a lot of factors as<br />
discussed in our stock market part, accordingly, we expect the company<br />
in 2009 to witness another 36% decline backed by our assumptions<br />
that average daily values will stagnate or partially<br />
improve starting Q4 FY09. On the asset management front, we<br />
expect the company, given the management previous track record, to<br />
be able to re-collect its lost AUMs due to redemptions, however,<br />
we expect no performance fees in 2009. Investment banking closed 8<br />
deals in 2008 with an average value per transaction of around LE1.6<br />
billion, we don’t expect much improvements in 2009 for investment<br />
banking due to the current market conditions, however, a re-bounce is<br />
expected by 2010 where deals in the pipe line awaiting market improvements<br />
get closed. We value EFG using SOP DCF methodology<br />
where we arrived at a total equity value of LE7.5 billion, implying<br />
LE19/share, including its investments in SODIC, Audi Bank and its<br />
Net cash position.<br />
Investment Rationale<br />
We are basically attracted to EFG-Hermes stock price due to the value<br />
it offers through its investments.<br />
EFG-Hermes has stakes in SODIC and Audi Bank, with the prevailing<br />
market prices of EFG, Audi, and SODIC, along with a Net Cash position<br />
of LE1.2 billion, investment and cash seem to be representing<br />
65% of EFG market CAP, suggesting that the market sees<br />
EFG brokerage business at LE4.2 with FY09 implied PE of<br />
1.6x, or the market thinks that EFG investments will erode EFG<br />
main business , which we refute, since we see AUDI contributing<br />
positively to EFG income statement, as well as SODIC recording sales<br />
starting 2010 and 2011. Accordingly, despite of the negative sentiment<br />
on brokerage business, we find it very cheap to buy EFG main<br />
business at a PE of 1.6x, and will probably result in a huge upside<br />
before markets rebounds given that stocks such as EFG are leading<br />
cycle players.<br />
Revenue Breakdown<br />
(LE mn)<br />
2007 2008 2009f 2010f<br />
Brokerage-Egypt 434.0 545.0 280.1 287.6<br />
growth 28.0% 25.6% -48.6% 2.7%<br />
contrib 25.2% 33.6% 27.4% 19.0%<br />
Brokerage-UAE 137.0 150.0 151.1 152.1<br />
growth 174.0% 9.5% 0.7% 0.7%<br />
contrib 8.0% 9.3% 14.8% 10.1%<br />
Brokerage-KSA 9.0 35.0 51.5 67.2<br />
growth 0 288.9% 47.0% 30.7%<br />
contrib 0.5% 2.2% 5.0% 4.4%<br />
Brokerage-Kse 0.0 40.0 20.9 21.8<br />
growth 0 0.0% -47.8% 4.5%<br />
contrib 0.0% 2.5% 2.0% 1.4%<br />
Brokerage-Oman 0.0 21.0 11.3 12.2<br />
growth 0 0.0% -46.1% 7.8%<br />
contrib 0.0% 1.0% 0.6% 0.6%<br />
Asset Mgmt (<strong>Equity</strong>) 225.00 413.24 121.18 442.44<br />
growth 309% 84% -71% 265%<br />
contrib 13.1% 25.5% 11.9% 29.2%<br />
Asset Mgmt (Money<br />
Mkt)<br />
286.00 80.76 113.67 177.88<br />
growth 1582% -72% 41% 56%<br />
contrib 16.6% 5.0% 11.1% 11.8%<br />
Inv.Banking 451 232 152 256<br />
growth 23.9% -48.6% -34.4% 68.0%<br />
contrib 26.2% 14.3% 14.9% 16.9%<br />
Private <strong>Equity</strong> 177.0 150.0 120.0 96.0<br />
growth 121% -15% -20% -20%<br />
contrib 10.3% 9.3% 11.7% 6.3%<br />
Total Revenues 1,719.0 1,620.0 1,021.9 1,513.0<br />
91.0% -5.8% -36.9% 48.1%<br />
Source: Prime Estimates<br />
Prime Research 37
2009 EQUITY STRATEGY<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
Stock Recommendation Guidelines<br />
Recommendation<br />
Target-to-Market Price (x)<br />
Strong Buy x > 25%<br />
Buy 15% < x Average LCY IBOR<br />
Quality Earnings Reflect Above Normal Risk Factor<br />
Prime Research<br />
38
2009 EQUITY STRATEGY<br />
10 March 2009<br />
Egypt<br />
PRIME EGYPT SALES TEAM<br />
Yasmine Guindy<br />
+202 3300 5666 <br />
yguindi@egy.primegroup.org<br />
<br />
Ramy El Agamy (25 lines)<br />
relagamy@egy.primegroup.org<br />
PRIME UAE SALES TEAM<br />
Shawkat Raslan +971-2-6910713 sraslan@uae.primegroup.org<br />
Sara Shaheed +971-4-4070115 sshaheed@uae.primegroup.org<br />
Ahmad Hamdi +971-2-6910701 ahamdi@uae.primegroup.org<br />
Mohamed Kamal +971-4-4070108 mkamal@uae.primegroup.org<br />
Mohamed Khaled Hafez +971-4-4070102 mkhaled@uae.primegroup.org<br />
PRIME EGYPT RESEARCH<br />
Mohamed Seddiek Senior Analyst, Acting Head +202 3300 5720 mseddiek@egy.primegroup.org<br />
Rehab Taha, CFA Senior Analyst +202 3300 5724 rtaha@egy.primegroup.org<br />
Monette Doss Senior Analyst +202 3300 5726 mdoss@egy.primegroup.org<br />
Ahmed Hindawy Analyst +202 3300 5719 aelhindawy@egy.primegroup.org<br />
Karim Osman Analyst +202 3300 5716 kosman@egy.primegroup.org<br />
Radwa Abulnaga Analyst +202 3300 5718 rabulnaga@egy.primegroup.org<br />
Hind Panicker Junior Analyst +202 3300 5727 hpanicker@egy.primegroup.org<br />
Nihal Zaki, CFTe Technical Analyst +202 3300 5725 nzaki@egy.primegroup.org<br />
Heba Monir Database Administrator +202 3300 5722 hmonir@egy.primegroup.org<br />
PRIME UAE RESEARCH<br />
Usman Rauf Senior Analyst +971-2-6910 756 urauf@uae.primegroup.org<br />
Angad Rajpal Senior Analyst +971-4-407 0119 arajpal@uae.primegroup.org<br />
Mostafa Maghraby Junior Analyst +971-4-407 0116 mmaghraby@uae.primegroup.org<br />
Dheeraj Lakhwani Junior Analyst +971-4-407 0117 dlakhwani@uae.primegroup.org<br />
Sleiman Aboulhosn Junior Analyst +971-4-407 0118 saboulhosn@uae.primegroup.org<br />
HEAD OFFICE<br />
PRIME SECURITIES S.A.E.<br />
Regulated by CMA license no. 179<br />
Members of the Cairo Stock Exchange<br />
2 Wadi El Nil St., Liberty Tower,<br />
7th-8th Floor, Mohandessin, Giza, Egypt<br />
Tel: +202 33005700/770/650/649<br />
Fax: +202 3760 7543<br />
PRIME EMIRATES LLC. (UAE)<br />
Members of the ADX and DFM<br />
Shiekh Zayed 1st Street, Khaldiyah, Abu Dhabi, UAE, PO Box 60355<br />
Tel: +971 2 6910800 Fax: +971 2 6670907<br />
Email: research@primegroup.org<br />
Disclaimer<br />
Information included in this report has no regard to specific investment objectives, financial situation, advices or particular needs of the report users.<br />
The report is published for information purposes only and is not to be construed as a solicitation or an offer to buy or sell any securities or related<br />
financial instruments. Unless specifically stated otherwise, all price information is only considered as indicator.<br />
No express or implied representation or guarantee is provided with respect to completeness, accuracy or reliability of information included in this<br />
report.<br />
Past performance is not necessarily an indication of future results. Fluctuation of foreign currency rates of exchange may adversely affect the value,<br />
price or income of any products mentioned in this report.<br />
Information included in this report should not be regarded by report users as a substitute for the exercise of their own due diligence and analysis<br />
based on own assessment and judgment criteria. Any opinions given are subject to change without notice and may significantly differ or be contrary<br />
to opinions expressed by other Prime business areas as a result of using different assumptions and criteria. Prime <strong>Group</strong> is under no obligation<br />
responsible to update or keep current the information contained herein.<br />
Prime <strong>Group</strong>, its directors, officers, employees or clients may have or have had interests or long or short positions in the securities and/or currencies<br />
referred to herein, and may at any time make purchases and/or sales in them as principal or agent.<br />
Prime <strong>Group</strong>, its related entities, directors, employees and agents accepts no liability whatsoever for any loss or damage of any kind arising from the<br />
use of all or part of these information included in this report. Certain laws and regulations impose liabilities which cannot be disclaimed. This disclaimer<br />
shall, in no way, constitute a waiver or limitation of any rights a person may have under such laws and/or regulations.<br />
Furthermore, Prime <strong>Group</strong> or any of the group companies may have or have had a relationship with or may provide or have provided other services,<br />
within its objectives to the relevant companies.<br />
Copyright 2009 Prime <strong>Group</strong> all rights reserved. You are hereby notified that distribution and copying of this document is strictly prohibited without<br />
the prior approval of Prime <strong>Group</strong>.<br />
Prime Research 39
Asset Management<br />
Investment banking<br />
securities brokerage<br />
investment research<br />
Egypt - Head Office<br />
2, Wadi El Nil St., Liberty Tower<br />
Mohandseen, Giza, Egypt.<br />
Tel: +202-33005700 - 33005770<br />
Fax: +202-33054611 - 33054569<br />
Heliopolis - Office<br />
17 Ahram st. Heliopolis,<br />
Cairo, Egypt.<br />
Tel: +202-22914260<br />
Fax: +202-22914261<br />
Abu Dhabi - Head Office<br />
Zayed1st St., - Khalidiya<br />
P.O. Box # 60355, Abu Dhabi, UAE.<br />
Tel: +9712-6910800<br />
Fax: +9712-6670907<br />
Dubai - Office<br />
Office No. 1100 Mezzanine Floor<br />
Mitsubishi Show Room<br />
Al Quoz, Sheikh Zayed Road<br />
P.O. Box # 213731, Dubai, UAE.<br />
Tel: +9714-4070100<br />
Fax: +9714-3388798