13.11.2014 Views

“2009 Equity strategy” - Talaat Moustafa Group

“2009 Equity strategy” - Talaat Moustafa Group

“2009 Equity strategy” - Talaat Moustafa Group

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

“2009 <strong>Equity</strong> strategy”<br />

Prime Investment Research


TABLE OF CONTENTS<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Executive Summary 3<br />

Strategy<br />

Consequences of Global Crisis on The Region 4<br />

Sectors Outlook 5<br />

Putting It All Together (Big Picture) 6<br />

2009 Sector Outlook (Summary) 7<br />

2009 Picks<br />

Short Term Picks 8<br />

Long Term Picks 9<br />

Economic Focus 11<br />

Stock Market Focus 15<br />

Banking Sector<br />

CIB 18<br />

NSGB 20<br />

Oil & Services Sector<br />

Maridive 22<br />

Telecommunication Sector<br />

Telecom Egypt 24<br />

Mobinil 26<br />

Pharmaceuticals Sector<br />

EIPICO 28<br />

Industrial & Capital Goods Sector<br />

Orascom Construction Industries 30<br />

El Sewedy Cables 32<br />

Housing Sector<br />

TMG 34<br />

Financial Services Sector<br />

EFG-Hermes 36<br />

Stock Recommendations Guide 38<br />

Disclaimer & Contacts<br />

Please note that Market prices, trading multiples and stock performance charts are all calculated as of 9 March, 2009 closing prices.<br />

Prime Research 2


EXECUTIVE SUMMARY<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Contagion Effect From Global Recession is Bound To Happen<br />

International financial markets continue to fluctuate with governments discovering new challenges to contain the problem from getting<br />

worse or spreading. While our main concern in this report is the Egyptian economy and the equity market in Egypt, we think it is<br />

necessary to give a quick review of the global scene since internal inadequacies per se are not the key cause behind the economic<br />

slow down faced by Egypt at the moment. In the current situation, weakened external demand constitutes a bullet hit at the heart of<br />

the Egyptian economy causing less receipts from Tourism, Suez Canal, Exports and ultimately less FDIs.<br />

Origins of The Global Crisis<br />

The global financial crisis became apparent in 2007 originating from rising housing demand at a time of low interest rates leading to<br />

overvalued housing prices ending with high interest rates and a high default ratio. Coupled with deregulation of the financial markets,<br />

increasing real estate prices led to higher appetite for risk among investors, gripping corporations such as Freddie and Fannie to guarantee<br />

more than half of USA mortgages, that were originally sub prime. In absence of the regulatory role, sub prime mortgages were<br />

pooled into Mortgage Backed Securities that enjoyed low rating leading investment banks such as Bear Sterns, Merrill Lynch and Lehman<br />

Brothers to heavily invest in them. The reputable financial institutions ended up either acquired, filed for bankruptcy, or switched<br />

to commercial banking. Moreover, commercial banks such as Indy Mach, Wachovia and Washington Mutual fell after rating agencies<br />

downgraded Investment banks, causing sharp price declines, and, hence, putting stress on the system. Tight credit took LIBOR up<br />

from 2.5% to 4%. Ultimately, high default rate, business close downs and credit dry up caused plunging demand in the USA. On the<br />

regional level, oil prices recorded historical lows grabbing commodities along, GCC budgets tightened or turned into deficit, and projects<br />

were delayed/cancelled. On the local level, with Egypt’s main trade partners being the USA and EU, a decline across Exports,<br />

Tourism, Suez canal and FDI was discounted in equities, causing equity market to act the way it is right now.<br />

We Estimate a Recovery on 2 Phases<br />

So far, governments have not fully identified the magnitude of the financial problem, however, bailout plans have been rolled out and<br />

approved in order to offer a quick fix to collapsing economies. Getting rid of toxic assets is not expected to be a simple task given the<br />

lack of data on where those assets are. We believe that once banks have completely removed toxic assets and recapitalization is<br />

achieved, probably by mid to end of 2009, a typical period of heavy regulations/low demand is expected to take place for 12 to 18<br />

months. We expect this period to be characterized by partial improvement in equity markets in the GCC and Egypt. Regionally,<br />

partial improvement of demand for oil will start to take shape leading to a price of US$50-55/barrel and ultimately resulting in<br />

higher investment. Domestically, this will correspond to a period of partial improvement in equity markets accompanied by recovering<br />

exports, tourism and Suez Canal revenues. Full recovery is expected to take place by end of 2010 at which time governments<br />

will want to sell back their stakes in recapitalized banks, with private sector regaining confidence and investing directly and indirectly<br />

following the re-regulations of the financial markets<br />

Sector Strategy and Stock Picks<br />

As we publish this note, FY08 results continue to come out, with a noticeable decline in Q4 results. Despite this, almost all stocks under<br />

our coverage offer significant value to our intrinsic prices generated from our DCF models, even after accounting for the following<br />

factors:<br />

• Lower or stagnating commodities’ prices;<br />

• Less domestic / external demand;<br />

• Pile up of high cost inventory implying weaker capital;<br />

• Expensive liquidity.<br />

Accordingly, we drafted a short-term and a long-term strategy (available in pages 8 & 9). The short-term strategy comprises stock<br />

picks for 2009, while, the long term strategy includes stocks that we believe investors can park in their money over the long term<br />

for they offer a sizeable upside potential over the long term and will benefit the most in the next upward cycle.<br />

The short term strategy targets sectors immune to the global slowdown, namely, Telecom, Pharmaceuticals, Banking as well<br />

as other non-cyclical stock. Said sectors are targeting investors with short term gain objectives in 2009 mainly generated from<br />

dividends paying stocks with stable earnings and pay out ratios due to their non-cyclical nature. Our Short Term Picks include<br />

CIB, NSGB, Maridive, Telecom Egypt, and Mobinil.<br />

The long term strategy targets sectors we view as offering significant upside potential over the long term and will benefit the most<br />

with the next impulsive cycle. We are basically attracted by long term business strategy of OCI and el Sewedy Cables due to their<br />

expansion plans as well as visible projects either privately for OCI or with the Government for Sewedy Cables. On the other side,<br />

TMGH attract us due to the relatively cheap multiples it is trading at representing almost less than half of its book value. In other<br />

words, one can argue that TMGH stock prices imply more than 70% discount to physical land market prices.<br />

Finally, we prefer EFG-Hermes due to its regional market exposure as well as the diversified investment it currently has, namely its<br />

27.8% in AUDI Bank and SODIC which the current market price of EFG-Hermes value below cost. Moreover, the company’s<br />

balance sheet is rich with LE1.2 billion cash position implying Net Investments/Mkt. cap of around 65%<br />

Prime Research 3


STRATEGY:CONSEQUENCES OF<br />

GLOBAL CRISIS ON THE REGION<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

GLOBAL EFFECT ON THE EGYPTIAN ECONOMY<br />

The Egyptian economy is currently hit by a contagion effect from the global financial crisis more than being hindered by internal<br />

weaknesses albeit the soaring real estate prices. This makes us believe that the magnitude of local economic troubles and pace of<br />

recovery is directly related to leading world economies. Thereby, we draw linkages between global forces and the Egyptian economy<br />

in an attempt to draw a picture for recovery dynamics.<br />

The global economic condition now is a result of an extended prosperity period, which led to over confidence, and lack of discipline.<br />

In the course of this period a balloon of bad and doubtful debt was created and propagated through newly invented tools (i.e. securitization).<br />

Since the US government and consequently the remaining of the world have admitted the economic crisis in early 2008, all<br />

that is being done is patching gaps that were created in the system over the last 10 or more years. During this period the global financial<br />

system has come to near halt resulting in a situation with typical recessionary symptoms in terms of residing demand and<br />

business close downs.<br />

How will the Recovery Take Place On a Global Scale?<br />

We believe that global economical ailments will undergo two phases towards full recovery. Phase one started with governments<br />

pumping life into financial institutions with high NPLs and low capitalization generated from toxic assets. This phase is expected to<br />

end once these institutions become well capitalized and funded to cover the ailments of the previous era, some time between mid to<br />

end of 2009, as most of the stimulus packages would be allocated.<br />

Phase two comprises the gradual regaining of confidence in the global financial system from regulators on one side, and from investors<br />

on the other side. Phase two is considered half way down the road towards gradual expansion in credit facilities and new investments<br />

by global funds. Subsequently, governments will gradually reduce their stakes in the previously nationalized banks through the<br />

capital markets. Main challenge of this phase is enacting an efficient set of regulations that will not deter potential growth. Phase<br />

two is expected to end in recovering demand in the west, moving to the rest of the world through the spill over effect.<br />

We expect the spill over effect of this improvement to go through another economic cycle of 12 to 18 months.<br />

Having said this, we expect phase one to go on till mid to end 2009, showing a duration period of 18 to 24 months since it started<br />

end of 2007. The recovery period or phase two is expected to reach full momentum by end of 2010 to mid 2011<br />

So what does this imply to the Middle East?<br />

Following the global trend, GCC witnessed ballooning real estate prices and indirect over exposure to toxic assets in the west. The<br />

main impact on the region, however, resulted from crude oil prices crashing from over the US$100/barrel to less than half this level.<br />

This created a sense of cash dry up and consequently led to cancellation of projects and subdued demand either for lack of confidence<br />

in the future or for government budgets becoming more tight.<br />

In our scenario, we expect that the recovery in the region will be twofold concurrent with the global recovery. The first comprises<br />

the exposure of regional players to toxic assets, while the second will depend on rebounding oil prices consequent to recovering<br />

external demand. Accordingly, pressure on regional state budgets will be elevated.<br />

So Where Does This Put Egypt?<br />

The Egyptian economy was relatively sheltered from Phase one due to overly protected banking system characterized by high excess<br />

liquidity. However, this does not shield Egypt from having to wait for the global economy to come back on track. Egypt’s economy has<br />

depended in the past years on regional fund inflows from investors and from Remittances, Tourism and Suez Canal receipts. All<br />

of which are expected to experience a crunch until the global and more importantly regional recovery materializes. Egypt also experienced<br />

a similar period of inflated asset prices (i.e. equities & land prices) due to over confidence.<br />

Inflation To Go Down<br />

Inflation is expected to go down locally driven by two reasons. Firstly, no more subsidy cuts are expected in the near future. Secondly,<br />

because we do not expect that commodity prices will reach there highs any time soon since prices were brought up in 2007<br />

driven by speculation, a prevailing pattern at the end of any upward cycle. This would mean that on average we expect oil prices to<br />

reach around US$50-55 by end of 2009 while once full recovery is achieved, we expect oil to remain at US$80/barrel.<br />

During 2006 to mid 2008 commodity prices have increased to a level that put a strain on consumers resulting in inflation levels that<br />

made any type of fixed income investment unattractive, while equity investments provided the only option that can in theory provide<br />

a return outpacing these high inflation levels.<br />

Exports are expected to decline by 25% in FY09 mainly attributed to plummeting prices of oil and semi-processed goods constituting<br />

the bulk (i.e. 62%) of Egyptian exports. Similar drastic price declines is not expected in FY10 which, together with a rebounding economy<br />

in the latter half of FY10, justifies our expectation of 6% increase in export receipts.<br />

Prime Research 4


STRATEGY-SECTORS OUTLOOK<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Tourism slowdown is imminent in 2009, while recovery is expected to show early indicators by the second half of FY10. This will<br />

lead to a 10% drop in tourist related revenues in FY09 and a 5% increase in FY10. Another segment expected to be hit is second<br />

homes for tourists requiring a large initial investment that we believe may lag another year prior to its recovery meaning by 2011.<br />

Real estate will continue to have pent up demand in low and medium income housing which will suffer a marginal drop due to the<br />

negative sentiment but will remain more robust compared to the upper end of the market which has come close to a saturation level<br />

in the previous bull wave. However, we expect another upward wave in the upper class linked to both global and more importantly<br />

the regional demand, starting in Dubai and creating euphoria of demand in another country or state and then another wave is expected<br />

to emerge in Qatar and KSA and will spill over into Egypt and other non-GCC Arab countries.<br />

Telecom sector would suffer from lower disposable income, which would marginally limit growth in 2009 and 2010. However, addressed<br />

market growth, given the fact that telecom services are now more of a necessity than a luxury, we believe it will be just a<br />

muted growth rather than a decline in earning levels.<br />

Consumer durables will be affected due to domestic decline in income levels and the negative sentiment, which will draw consumers<br />

more to saving than spending. Furthermore, we expect another wave of increasing imported goods at lower prices due to lack of<br />

global demand, which will put local goods on the defensive and will further impact margins. This would put the sector as speculative<br />

at best. However, the auto industry will witness a slowdown while the market may shift further toward lower priced vehicles, which<br />

will eventually benefit the local players marginally given the price differential.<br />

Banking sector in Egypt is different from that of the most of the world since there is no structural issues that would cause major<br />

concern about the performance of their portfolios. However, banks will remain more conscious about expanding their credit facilities<br />

which will limit the growth on their balance sheets and income. However, we expect that banks will witness steady growth since no<br />

major restructuring is required and the retail segment of the market is still underserved. Furthermore, by mid 2010 as global banking<br />

sector show signs of recovery, competition will increase again in extending credit to both corporate entities and individuals.<br />

Financial sector is mostly correlated to the capital market and thereby its slowdown and recovery will be fully correlated to that of<br />

public sentiment and risk aptitude. The stock market is expected to gradually improve anytime from the second half of 2009 to first<br />

quarter of 2010, since by that time the uncertainty of the size of the damage to the global financial sector will start to reside.<br />

Agricultural sector has been hit by falling commodity prices, which led to less aggressive approach toward utilization of fertilizers in<br />

order to cut cost. Furthermore, inventory of raw materials in fertilizer companies have been built up at relatively high prices. This<br />

would lead to around six to nine months of squeezed margins accompanied with declining revenue volume till end of Q2 2009 followed<br />

by minor growth in volumes till year end. Starting 2010, food inventories will diminish leading to gradual increase in prices and<br />

volumes.<br />

The question remains, Should equities recover, will Egypt outpace or at least equalize with other Emerging Markets upward moves?<br />

The fact remains, the correlation of the coming impulsive wave between Egypt and the remaining of the emerging markets will largely<br />

depend on structural and dormant variables in Egypt’s macro picture as well as how much discount/premium Egyptian equities<br />

will be trading at by the time Equities recover.<br />

Does Egypt have more structural changes or dormant variables that it can occur to outpace the other<br />

emerging markets another time with the next upward cycle?<br />

• If the government times the further removal of subsidies and eliminating more imbalances to the time when the emerging economies<br />

witness the extent of the recovery, these actions will have less painful effect although it will entail forsaking short term<br />

growth for a stable future outlook;<br />

• Mortgage finance, though implemented in the previous cycle, it has not yet been fully utilized. With the next round of demand<br />

spree over real estate this under utilized tool can provide the launching pad for another fast paced growth in the sector;<br />

• The financial sector have not been severely hit this time thanks to local banks still reminded by the late 90s local credit crisis and<br />

the continuous follow up of the CBE. However, the extent of the current down cycle on banks performance is yet to be established.<br />

Given that we are already half way down the road, the current indicators show that the financial sector will come out of<br />

this downward cycle with relatively minimal damage and, hence, will be in a better place to sponsor growth in the next cycle<br />

than peer countries;<br />

• Pressure from environmentalist groups in developed countries accompanied with low demand is currently taking place and will<br />

continue in 2009 and 2010 leading to more shut downs in these countries. As economic recovery takes place another phase of<br />

acquisitions of existing production facilities in emerging markets by foreign investors may seem cheaper than reopening given the<br />

carbon emission benefits. This will create an improved BOP from FDI injections.<br />

The following 2 pages will include a summary of our Global, Regional and Local view of how the recovery will happen,<br />

followed by a summary of our outlook on main sectors. The remaining of this note will be dedicated to our Economic<br />

and Stock Market Focus as well as a valuation of our Short and Long Term Stock Picks.<br />

Prime Research 5


PUTTING IT ALL TOGETHER<br />

(BIG PICTURE)


2009 SECTORS OUTLOOK (SUMMARY)<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Financial Services & Banking<br />

Banking Sector Outlook: Positive<br />

Housing & Real Estate<br />

Sectors Outlook: Negative<br />

Upside<br />

Downside<br />

Upside<br />

Downside<br />

• By law, foreign banks shall have<br />

funds in Egypt equivalent to its<br />

obligations and payables, eliminating<br />

the default risk due to<br />

external factors<br />

• Low trading Investments/total<br />

Banking Assets<br />

• Loan/Deposit ratio of 56%<br />

• Excess liquidity<br />

• Foreign exchange liquidity is<br />

highly limited<br />

Downside on Brokerage Firms<br />

• Decline in average trading value<br />

n FY09<br />

• Expected decline in M&A activity<br />

during FY09<br />

• Egypt has one of the fastest<br />

growing infrastructure sectors in<br />

the region, covering various segments;<br />

transport, tourism, commercial<br />

and industrial<br />

• Young growing population should<br />

maintain growth once the waitand–<br />

see attitude comes to an<br />

end<br />

• Unwillingness to borrow so as to<br />

buy properties after the increase<br />

in interest rates<br />

• A new tax rate is expected to be<br />

active this year<br />

• A supply gap for the housing<br />

units<br />

• A decline in steel & cement selling<br />

prices<br />

• Government encourages steel<br />

imports<br />

Petrochemicals, Chemicals & Fertilizers<br />

Sectors Outlook: Negative<br />

Food & Agriculture<br />

Sectors Outlook: Neutral<br />

Upside<br />

Downside<br />

Upside<br />

Downside<br />

• Cheap feedstock<br />

• Growing local demand<br />

• Direct relationship with food and<br />

agriculture<br />

• Local natural gas prices increased<br />

by 76% putting pressure on<br />

manufacturers’ costs<br />

• selling prices slumped dramatically<br />

• Recent decline in raw materials<br />

prices affected companies keeping<br />

expensive inventory<br />

• Population benefit<br />

• Liberalizing trade in agricultural<br />

products<br />

• Government prioritizing land<br />

reclamation<br />

• Food consumption accounts for<br />

26.8% of GDP<br />

• Absolute decline in numbers in<br />

monetary terms<br />

Telecoms<br />

Sectors Outlook: Positive<br />

Upside<br />

Downside<br />

Pharmaceuticals<br />

Sectors Outlook: Positive<br />

Upside<br />

Downside<br />

• Low penetration rate of around<br />

50%<br />

• More than anticipated decline in<br />

Mobile Sets’ Sales<br />

• Growing population<br />

• Price caps<br />

• Population bodes well for spending<br />

per subscriber<br />

• Lower available Income<br />

• Increased health awareness<br />

• TRIPS halts growth<br />

• Positive elasticity mitigates AR-<br />

PUs Decline<br />

• Prolonged recession would affect<br />

spending<br />

Tourism<br />

Sectors Outlook: Negative<br />

Upside<br />

Downside<br />

Construction / Building Materials<br />

Sectors Outlook: Negative<br />

Upside<br />

Downside<br />

• Cheaper destination when compared<br />

to other destinations such<br />

as Turkey, UAE and Morocco<br />

• Growing government investment<br />

in the sector to increase number<br />

of rooms available<br />

• Severe decline in tourist numbers<br />

• Severe Decline in tourist spending<br />

• Fall in hotel occupancy rates<br />

• Steep decline in steel/cement<br />

prices<br />

• Slowdown in construction activity<br />

• Government infrastructure projects<br />

• Prolonged recession would hit<br />

pent up demand for housing<br />

units<br />

Prime Research 7


2009 STOCK PICKS<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Short Term Picks<br />

Short-term recommendations are those for companies that are expected to perform better than average during the slow down, which<br />

would imply that they are the least exposed to the current economic downward conditions. Thereby in 2009, We overweight sectors<br />

of Telecommunication, Pharmaceuticals and banks due to the following:<br />

1) Companies in defensive Sectors / High FCF Yields<br />

2) Visible positive earnings in 2009<br />

3) Cash rich companies well positioned to withstand a recession<br />

4) Low leverage or None<br />

5) High payout Ratio<br />

6) Well branded products / services<br />

7) Strong management with a track record<br />

Short Term Stock Picks<br />

Earnings Per Share Dividends Yield Valuation Multiples<br />

RIC FY08 FY09 3Y Growth FY08 FY09 PE08 PE09<br />

EV/<br />

EBITDA08<br />

EV/<br />

EBITDA09<br />

P/B<br />

MOIL.CA 0.34 0.46 33% 9% 13% 7.74x 5.81x 6.76x 4.62x 3.30x<br />

EMOB.CA 18.60 19.60 5% 10% 11% 7.57x 7.18x 3.85x 3.46x 6.22x<br />

PHAR.CA 3.54 3.85 9% 9% 10% 7.07x 6.49x 2.92x 2.76x 1.48x<br />

ETEL.CA 1.76 1.85 5% 9% 9% 8.35x 7.98x 4.97x 4.65x 0.91x<br />

NSGB.CA* 3.52 2.76 -22% 7% 8% 4.26x 5.43x 0.00x 0.00x 0.82x<br />

COMI.CA 4.69 4.98 6% 3% 4% 7.22x 6.79x 0.00x 0.00x 1.71x<br />

1 Year Price Earning Growth Chart<br />

40%<br />

30%<br />

MOIL.CA<br />

TMGH.CA<br />

20%<br />

FY09 EPS<br />

Growth<br />

10 %<br />

0%<br />

-10%<br />

SWDY.CA<br />

CIEB.CA<br />

EGTS.CA<br />

ORTE.CA<br />

AMOC.CA<br />

PHAR.CA<br />

COMI.CA<br />

ETEL.CA<br />

EM OB.CA<br />

SUGR.CA<br />

EXPA.CA<br />

SKPC.CA<br />

-20%<br />

AUTO.CA<br />

NSGB.CA<br />

EFIC.CA<br />

HRHO.CA<br />

-30%<br />

IFA P .CA<br />

-40%<br />

PIOH.CA<br />

0x 2x 4x 6x 8x 10x 12x 14x 16x 18x 20x<br />

Price / Earnings 09<br />

*NSGB reads a –22% due to reversal of provision which if eliminated would result in a 13%<br />

Source: Prime Estimates<br />

Prime Research 8


2009 PICKS (CONT’D)<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Long Term Picks<br />

We draft our Long-term recommendations on companies that will provide the highest capital appreciation based on their fundamental<br />

value compared to current market prices in the next upward stock market cycle. In our opinion, these long term picks will approach<br />

their intrinsic values once demand rebound again and recovery takes place, moreover, they meet the following criteria:<br />

1) Strong management<br />

2) Visible ongoing Expansions<br />

3) Well positioned within market Competition<br />

4) Sustainable free cash flows<br />

5) Highest upside to their DCF values<br />

6) Currently trading on low multiples<br />

Long Term Stock Picks<br />

RIC<br />

Upside To<br />

DCF<br />

FY08<br />

Earnings Per Share Dividends Yield Valuation Multiples<br />

FY09<br />

3Y<br />

Growth<br />

FY08 FY09 PE08 PE09<br />

EV/<br />

EBITDA08<br />

EV/<br />

EBITDA0<br />

9<br />

P/Book<br />

TMGH.CA 301% 0.79 0.99 49% 0% 0% 3.28x 2.63x 2.23x 1.59x 0.23x<br />

SWDY.CA 127% 6.91 7.36 19% 0% 0% 5.67x 5.32x 5.61x 4.95x 1.46x<br />

HRHO.CA 93% 2.77 0.95 -12% 4% 1% 4.95x 14.37x 0.31x 0.31x 0.67x<br />

OCIC.CA* 202% 23.75 10.53 -30% 3% 1% 5.05x 11.38x 4.42x 6.19x 1.73x<br />

3 Year Price Earning Growth Chart<br />

40.0%<br />

COMI.CA<br />

30.0%<br />

NSGB.CA<br />

20.0%<br />

SWDY.CA<br />

M OIL.CA<br />

PIOH.CA<br />

ORTE.CA<br />

PHAR.CA<br />

10 .0 %<br />

ETEL.CA<br />

FY09 EPS<br />

Growth<br />

0.0%<br />

EXPA.CA<br />

AUTO.CA<br />

AMOC.CA<br />

CIEB.CA<br />

EM OB.CA<br />

SUGR.CA<br />

-10.0%<br />

EFIC.CA<br />

HRHO.CA<br />

-20.0%<br />

SKPC.CA<br />

-30.0%<br />

Series1<br />

IFAP .CA<br />

-40.0%<br />

0x 2x 4x 6x 8x 10x 12x 14x 16x 18x 20x<br />

Price / Earnings 09<br />

Source: Prime Estimates<br />

*OCI reads –30% over a 3 years period due to LE1.4 unusual gains of divesture of Egyptian Containers Handling<br />

Prime Research 9


2009 EQUITY STRATEGY<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

This Page has been Left Intentionally Blank<br />

Prime Research 10


ECONOMIC FOCUS<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

GDP Growth-Gains Momentum From Domestic Demand<br />

Although GDP growth is hindered by a receding global economy, momentum<br />

is gained from domestic demand. Our expectation for GDP growth<br />

hover around 4.1% growth in FY09, justified by the fact that household<br />

demand and government expenditure constitute 82% of GDP. Also,<br />

we Expect the latter half of FY10 to witness the beginning of an economic<br />

rebound to be reflected in 4.5% domestic GDP growth, basically driven<br />

by higher export, tourism and Suez Canal receipts. A close scrutiny of GDP<br />

components is provided below.<br />

High Household Consumption Driven by Wide<br />

Population Base<br />

We forecast a conservative estimate of 3.5% growth in household<br />

consumption in FY09 and FY10. Bearing in mind that population<br />

growth rate is 2%, this implies that spending patterns will increase by only<br />

1.5% in FY09. This is very much on the conservative side taking into consideration<br />

that no massive lay offs have taken place in Egypt. Q1 FY09, as<br />

well as FY08 data reveals high propensity to consume. In FY08, household<br />

consumption grew at 7.6%, a level exceeding GDP growth of 7.2%. Similarly,<br />

1Q FY09 revealed GDP growth of 5.7% y-o-y, close to the 5.8% y-o-y<br />

growth in GDP.<br />

However, we believe suppliers to change their product definition to suit B and C income groups. In this respect new cash and carry,<br />

and wholesale outlets are planned.<br />

Government Spending-Paving The Road for Future<br />

Growth<br />

In order to lubricate the economy the government pledged LE15 billion<br />

package to be spent on infrastructure as well as tax/tariff subsidies.<br />

FY08 witnessed a 2.1% growth in government spending, while Q1<br />

FY09 witnessed a 5.4% y-o-y surge. In FY09 and FY10 we expect government<br />

expenditure to grow by 4% and 3%, respectively, based on the<br />

authorities announced intentions to foster potential for economic growth<br />

through creating a developed infra structural base. The breakdown of the<br />

government stimulus package is identified as follows:<br />

• Water and waste water projects for LE5 billion<br />

• Public schools with a cost of LE150 million<br />

• Industrial areas for LE400 million<br />

• Medical centers worth LE400 million<br />

• Port development for LE200 million<br />

Moreover, LE2 billion has been allocated to subsidize custom duties and<br />

taxes on investment related goods.<br />

Budget Deficit-Financed Internally With Low Risk of Defaulting<br />

Indicator<br />

Nominal GDP (LE Billion)<br />

GDP Growth (%)<br />

Inflation Rate<br />

Exchange Rate (LE/US$)<br />

Current Account (US$ Billion)<br />

Government Deficit/GDP (%)<br />

EGP Million<br />

500,000<br />

400,000<br />

300,000<br />

200,000<br />

100,000<br />

0<br />

Main Economic Parameters<br />

FY06<br />

FY09<br />

1,067<br />

4.1%<br />

15%<br />

5.6<br />

-5.0<br />

-7.0%<br />

Government Budget<br />

FY07<br />

FY08<br />

Budget Deficit<br />

FY09f<br />

FY10<br />

1,216<br />

4.5%<br />

10%<br />

5.8<br />

-3.8<br />

-7.1%<br />

Source: Prime Estimates<br />

FY10f<br />

10.0%<br />

8.0%<br />

6.0%<br />

4.0%<br />

2.0%<br />

0.0%<br />

Revenue Expenditure Deficit/GDP<br />

Source: CBE/Prime Estimates<br />

Budget deficit deteriorated significantly in FY08 to constitute 6.8% of<br />

GDP compared to the 5.7% reported in FY07. The deterioration is<br />

caused by hiking international prices of oil and basic food items subsidized<br />

by the government. Hence, amounts devoted to subsidies witnessed<br />

a 56% increase to LE84.2 billion. On the other hand, government<br />

revenue witnessed a moderate 21% increase with income from taxes<br />

constituting 62% of total revenue.<br />

FY08 deficit was mainly financed through LE11.4 billion in external debt,<br />

LE527 million in domestic debt, and LE38.9 billion from a government<br />

contingency account. 1Q FY09, deficit amounted to LE22.8 billion financed<br />

through LE519 million in bonds, LE19 billion in bills and LE20.6<br />

billion in bank loans. LE3 billion was given in repayment of external debt<br />

in 1Q FY09. Going forward, we adjust our budget deficit upwards to<br />

settle at 7.0% and 7.1% of GDP in FY09 and FY10, respectively.<br />

We expect the banking system excess liquidity to be used in financing<br />

the budget deficit.<br />

Fiscal<br />

Account<br />

(LE bn)<br />

Total<br />

Revenues<br />

Total<br />

Expenditures<br />

Deficit/<br />

Surplus<br />

Deficit/<br />

Surplus/<br />

GDP<br />

FY06<br />

151.6<br />

207.8<br />

-56.2<br />

-9.2%<br />

FY07<br />

180.2<br />

222.0<br />

-41.8<br />

-5.7%<br />

FY08 FY09f FY10f<br />

221.4 263.7 303.2<br />

282.3 338.7 389.6<br />

-60.9 -75.0 -86.3<br />

-6.8% -7.0% -7.1%<br />

Source: CBE/Prime Estimates<br />

Prime Research 11


ECONOMIC FOCUS (CONT’D)<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

The government agenda for enhancing public financing encompass the following;<br />

• Applying the VAT in a later period in 2010 to replace the sales tax, expected to yield 2% of GDP as government revenue;<br />

• Streamlining the subsidy system through canceling in-kind food subsidies and making direct cash transfers, instead;<br />

• Undertaking a second round of privatization of state enterprises through free transfer of shares and retained ownership through<br />

holding companies for restructuring and debt settlement.<br />

Investment Friendly Environment<br />

We perceive the current economic environment in Egypt as investment friendly, as illustrated by the following;<br />

• Availability of credit that can be extended to business organizations as illustrated by a an L/D ratio of 55% as of November<br />

2008, with excess cash amounting to LE343.7 billion or 38% of GDP and more than double the budget deficit of FY09 and<br />

FY10, respectively<br />

• Expansionary monetary policy inducing interest rate cuts to 10.5% and 12.5% on overnight deposits and lending, respectively,<br />

with possible further 50 bps cut till June 2009<br />

• Government measurements aiming at lubricating investment through postponing the introduction of VAT and energy price increases<br />

until a later period in 2010. This is in addition to reinstating the free zone status for oil refineries, developing the infrastructure,<br />

and subsidizing tariffs on investment-related goods<br />

• Huge market with a high consumption potential<br />

In 2008, domestic investment represented over 60% of total investment with FDI inflows standing at around 38%. Investment in oil<br />

extraction activities, oil refining and manufacturing, transportation and communication represented 17%, 27% and 16% of total<br />

investment, respectively. The USA contributed 36% of FDI, EU 29%, Arab countries 17%, and other countries 18%.<br />

We expect a 6% growth in investment over FY09 and FY10. Announced projects and fields of foreign direct investment over<br />

the coming years are identified as follows:<br />

• Agricultural and milk projects with investment cost of LE2 billion to be injected by Saudi Investor, Soultan Ben Mohamed Ben<br />

Masoud<br />

• Industrial and tourism projects with investment cost of US$3 billion by the Kuwaiti Kharafi <strong>Group</strong><br />

• Abu Qir gas field with overall investment of US$1.3 billion by the Italian Edison SPA<br />

• A new oil field discovered in the western desert, 80 km from the borders with Libya. Production capacity is 5k b/d of oil and 4.3<br />

million cubic feet/day of gas<br />

• A steel billet factory and a mineral salt extracting project with US$2 billion investment cost by the Kuwaiti Kharafi group<br />

• A discussion of a Russian industrial zone to be established in Borg Al Arab over 5 years comprising factories for cars, airplanes,<br />

electrical tools and petroleum equipment<br />

• LNG floating terminals to ship gas produced in Egypt by Shell. The company already signed an initial multi-billion dollar contract<br />

with Iraq government to establish a similar project there<br />

• The second phase of East Port Said development project with a total investment cost of US$700 million to be completed in<br />

2011. The project aims at increasing the port’s capacity to 5.1 million containers annually from the current 2.1 million.<br />

Our main concern with regard to investment is that it is a function of fragmented, and in some cases contradicting, government decisions<br />

as opposed to being a part of an integrated plan aiming at capitalizing on the country’s resources (i.e. manpower, agricultural<br />

land … etc.) and preserving environmental resources and hence, ensuring sustainable growth. At the moment, investment opportunities<br />

capitalize on the high consumption potential in Egyptian markets while exploiting the environment, which makes economic<br />

growth in Egypt pretty unsustainable.<br />

External Linkages Posing Pressure on the<br />

External Account<br />

Lower export, Suez Canal and tourism receipts are currently<br />

perceived as the main growth hindrances. Q1<br />

FY09, however, came in strong with regard to all three items,<br />

however, the rest of FY09 is expected to reflect the repercussions<br />

of the worldwide credit crunch. A 25% decline in exports is<br />

expected in FY09 mainly attributed to plummeting prices of oil<br />

and semi-processed goods constituting the bulk (i.e. 62%) of<br />

Egyptian exports. Similar drastic price declines is not expected in<br />

FY10 which, together with a rebounding economy in the latter<br />

half of FY10, justifies our expectation of 6% increase in export<br />

receipts.<br />

Suez Canal and tourism receipts are expected to witness a<br />

decline of 8% and 10%, respectively, in FY09. FY10, however, is<br />

expected to witness a rebound of 5% and 6% in tourism and<br />

Suez Canal receipts, respectively.<br />

External Account<br />

US$(bn)<br />

Exports<br />

Imports<br />

Tourism<br />

Suez Canal<br />

Revenues<br />

Transfers<br />

Current Account<br />

FDI<br />

FY08<br />

29.4<br />

52.8<br />

10.8<br />

5.2<br />

9.3<br />

0.9<br />

13.2<br />

FY09<br />

22.1<br />

50.1<br />

9.7<br />

4.8<br />

9.8<br />

(5.0)<br />

6.5<br />

FY10<br />

23.4<br />

52.5<br />

10.2<br />

5.1<br />

10.8<br />

(3.8)<br />

7.1<br />

Source: CBE/Prime Estimates<br />

Prime Research 12


ECONOMIC FOCUS (CONT’D)<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

We expect a 5% increase in remittance inflows explained by high<br />

interest rates on deposits in Egypt relative to banks abroad, in addition<br />

to a financially secure banking system immune to the global<br />

financial turmoil.<br />

15,000<br />

External Account<br />

Exchange Rate: Pressures Towards Further<br />

Depreciation<br />

Egyptian pound depreciated to its current levels at LE5.6/US$ compared<br />

to its December resistance level at LE5.5/US$. The fall is accompanied<br />

by declining official reserves to US$33 billion in December<br />

from US$34 billion in October 2008. NIR in months of merchandise<br />

imports is roughly estimated at 7 months, using recent import<br />

data, from 7.9 months in June 2008 and 8.9 months in June 2007.<br />

Accordingly, we see pressure on the Egyptian pound to further depreciate<br />

to LE5.8/US$ by beginning of FY10. We believe the authorities<br />

will maintain a flexible exchange rate policy due to the risks<br />

entailed in managing the currency in a time of weakening balance of<br />

payment.<br />

Anticipated Immediate Slow Down of Inflationary<br />

Pressures with The Possibility of Another<br />

Wave of Grave Price Increases in The<br />

Long Run<br />

Inflation surged to 23.6% y-o-y in August 2008, following hiking<br />

international prices further aggravated by oil subsidy cut in May,<br />

2008. However, following international recessionary pressures and<br />

tightening monetary policy, inflation declined to 14% y-o-y in January<br />

2009. We expect monthly inflation rate to settle at 5% y-o-y by<br />

June 2009 since June 2008 witnessed hiking prices.<br />

Inflation surges during 2008 shed some light on inadequacies inherent in the economic system in Egypt, that we identify as follows;<br />

• Prices not reflecting the real cost (i.e. subsidies/price distortions);<br />

• Low productivity translated in low disposable personal income and resulting in reliance on subsidies;<br />

• Inefficiency of some industries turning to be unprofitable following the oil subsidy cut;<br />

• Vulnerability of the government budget to external price shocks.<br />

We believe that as the international economy rebounds another wave of inflation surges is possible that might result from external<br />

and internal factors, specified as follows;<br />

• Increasing international demand leading to fast price increases globally;<br />

• Internal economic reform towards liberalizing the economy through gradual subsidy cuts;<br />

• Rapid population growth and depleting resources illustrated by the fact that currently Egypt imports 40% of its food needs.<br />

In this respect, we emphasize the importance of encouraging investment in areas assessed to be economically viable assuming subsidy<br />

cuts are undertaken.<br />

Interest Rate Reflecting a Monetary Expansion<br />

Monetary tightening has ended with the CBE shifting its focus from inflation concerns to stagnating GDP growth. Accordingly, interest<br />

rates declined by 100 bps to 10.5% and 12.5% on overnight deposits and lending, respectively. We anticipate further interest<br />

rate cuts with a floor of 9.5% and 11.5% on overnight deposits and lending, respectively. Timing of further cuts depends on the<br />

speed by which inflation declines.<br />

USD Million<br />

CPI<br />

10,000<br />

5,000<br />

0<br />

-5,000<br />

-10,000<br />

-15,000<br />

Exchange Rate<br />

(LE/US$)<br />

Overnight Interbank<br />

Rate<br />

FY06<br />

FY06<br />

10%<br />

5.8<br />

9.5%<br />

FY07<br />

FY07<br />

15%<br />

5.5<br />

9.5%<br />

FY08<br />

Money Variables<br />

FY08<br />

12%<br />

5.5<br />

10.3%<br />

FY09e<br />

FY09<br />

11%<br />

5.7<br />

8.8%<br />

FY10f<br />

CA Balance Balance of Goods & Services Remittances<br />

`<br />

Source: CBE/Prime Estimates<br />

FY10<br />

4%<br />

5.8<br />

8.6%<br />

Source: MOF/Prime Estimates<br />

Prime Research 13


2009 INVESTMENT STRATEGY<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

This Page has been Left Intentionally Blank<br />

Prime Research 14


STOCK MARKET FOCUS<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

DISTRESSED EXTERMAL MACRO DRIVERS HIT<br />

LOCAL MARKET DYMANICS<br />

MSCI Egypt reached a peak in January 2008 where it managed to<br />

grow by 50% from Jan FY07, however, amid global worsening conditions<br />

and in line with EMEA markets, MSCI Egypt deteriorated intensively,<br />

specially after May 5 decisions which investors received<br />

bitterly on already soft volumes. Worse comes to worst with margin<br />

calls for declining asset prices and brokers closing positions on fears<br />

of declining equity values.<br />

0<br />

Tension Causing Redemptions<br />

Average daily value declined vigorously in 2009, from an average of<br />

LE1.3 billion to an average of LE500 million recorded in the beginnings<br />

of 2009. This could be attributed to change in market dynamics,<br />

namely, decline in institutional trading and lower foreign partici-<br />

Source: Prime Estimates<br />

pation. Worries from lower NAVs and less dividends from mutual funds causing asset prices to decline exponentially, despite the lack<br />

of data on AUMs available on hand with fund managers, we don’t expect less than 65% decline in assets under management.<br />

Consequently, institutional trading reached a deteriorated levels in March 2009 to 19%, down from an average of 60% recorded in<br />

January 2008. Secondly, foreign trading, including GCC fund flows, continued to deteriorate due to declining oil prices and margin<br />

calls, which also contributed negatively to lower volumes and negative sentiment. Moreover, anticipation of a weaker Egyptian pound<br />

due to weaker BOP and lower interest rates causing foreign funds to wait till the currency settle down at which time funds inflows<br />

would adjust to newer risk premium<br />

2,500<br />

2,000<br />

1,500<br />

1,000<br />

500<br />

02-01-2008<br />

14-02-2008<br />

28-03-2008<br />

MSCI Egypt<br />

12-05-2008<br />

25-06-2008<br />

07-08-2008<br />

MSCI Arabian<br />

24-09-2008<br />

06-11-2008<br />

18-12-2008<br />

02-02-2009<br />

100%<br />

90%<br />

80%<br />

Retail % Institutions %<br />

Institutions %, 86%<br />

Retail %, 75%<br />

100%<br />

90%<br />

80%<br />

Local Value<br />

Foreign Value, 51%<br />

Foreign Value<br />

60%<br />

50%<br />

70%<br />

60%<br />

70%<br />

60%<br />

40%<br />

50%<br />

50%<br />

30%<br />

40%<br />

30%<br />

20%<br />

10%<br />

0%<br />

Retail %, 14%<br />

Institutions %, 25%<br />

40%<br />

30%<br />

20%<br />

10%<br />

0%<br />

Foreign Value,<br />

6.60%<br />

20%<br />

10%<br />

0%<br />

Jan-08<br />

Feb-08<br />

Mar-08<br />

Apr-08<br />

May-08<br />

May-08<br />

Jun-08<br />

Jul-08<br />

Aug-08<br />

Sep-08<br />

Oct-08<br />

Nov-08<br />

Dec-08<br />

Jan-09<br />

Feb-09<br />

Jan-08<br />

Feb-08<br />

Mar-08<br />

Apr-08<br />

May-08<br />

May-08<br />

Jun-08<br />

Jul-08<br />

Aug-08<br />

Sep-08<br />

Oct-08<br />

Nov-08<br />

Dec-08<br />

Jan-09<br />

Feb-09<br />

Source: Prime Estimates<br />

We See Market Dynamics Improving by 2H FY09<br />

Almost 3 months are already through from 2009 with a noticeable retail buying in small caps and the market turning over around<br />

LE480 million daily with volumes starting to marginally improve to reach an average of 90 million recorded in march, up from 60 million<br />

recorded in late 2008. Accordingly, we expect market dynamics to improve gradually once the currency stabilizes and BOP starts<br />

to improve along with global improvement as discussed in the strategy part.<br />

Historical PE is Touched, Indicating that<br />

the Boom-Bust Cycle is Or Almost Over<br />

In January FY08, PAMI stocks recorded a PE of 22x, at<br />

which time the sub prime crisis continued to develop<br />

dramatically, along with May 5, 2008 decisions, panic<br />

selling dominated the market among local and foreign<br />

investors, taking PE to historical levels, as noted by<br />

values recorded in October 2008 to an average of<br />

5.6x, a 37% discount to MENA peers.<br />

24x<br />

22x<br />

20x<br />

18x<br />

16x<br />

14x<br />

12x<br />

10x<br />

8x<br />

6x<br />

PAMI P/E (1998-2009)<br />

September 2002<br />

PE 4.5x<br />

October<br />

2008<br />

PE 5.18x<br />

4x<br />

01-Jan-98<br />

09-Apr-98<br />

16-Jul-98<br />

19-Oct-98<br />

21-Jan-99<br />

02-May-99<br />

02-Aug-99<br />

02-Nov-99<br />

03-Feb-00<br />

14-May-00<br />

15-Aug-00<br />

15-Nov-00<br />

19-Feb-01<br />

31-May-01<br />

04-Sep-01<br />

04-Dec-01<br />

14-Mar-02<br />

25-Jun-02<br />

30-Sep-02<br />

05-Jan-03<br />

16-Apr-03<br />

24-Jul-03<br />

26-Oct-03<br />

03-Feb-04<br />

10-May-04<br />

10-Aug-04<br />

10-Nov-04<br />

16-Feb-05<br />

25-May-05<br />

24-Aug-05<br />

28-Nov-05<br />

05-Mar-06<br />

11-Jun-06<br />

11-Sep-06<br />

19-Dec-06<br />

28-Mar-07<br />

05-Jul-07<br />

08-Oct-07<br />

20-Jan-08<br />

21-Apr-08<br />

28-Jul-08<br />

30-Oct-08<br />

Source: Prime Estimates<br />

Prime Research 15


STOCK MARKET FOCUS (CONT’D)<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Despite Worsening Market Dynamics, Regional Multiples Favor Egypt<br />

Steep declines in equities have caused FY09 valuations multiples to turn in favor of Egypt given a dividends yield of around 8.7%,<br />

50% higher than most countries except Kuwait, while trading at 7.67x FY09 earnings, representing the lowest PER09 next to UAE<br />

which sound cheaper in this respect. However, collectively dividends yield coupled with a cheap PE would favor Egypt<br />

P/E x<br />

P/B x<br />

20<br />

18.50<br />

3.0<br />

2.76<br />

15<br />

10<br />

5<br />

10.51<br />

7.67<br />

9.77<br />

14.48<br />

5.38 5.31<br />

2.5<br />

2.0<br />

1.5<br />

1.0<br />

0.5<br />

1.80 1.88 1.78<br />

1.65<br />

0.63<br />

0.90<br />

0<br />

0.0<br />

Kuwait<br />

Egypt<br />

Saudi<br />

Arabia<br />

Bahrain<br />

Dubai<br />

Abu<br />

Dhabi<br />

Qatar<br />

Kuwait<br />

Egypt<br />

Saudi<br />

Arabia<br />

Bahrain<br />

Dubai<br />

Abu<br />

Dhabi<br />

Qatar<br />

Div Yld %<br />

10.0<br />

8.0<br />

6.0<br />

4.0<br />

2.0<br />

0.0<br />

8.25 8.73<br />

4.60<br />

5.48<br />

4.70<br />

3.98<br />

2.84<br />

Kuwait<br />

Egypt<br />

Saudi<br />

Arabia<br />

Bahrain<br />

Dubai<br />

Abu<br />

Dhabi<br />

Qatar<br />

A Selection of 30 Companies Generated a 38% Decline in EPS, While Market Prices Assume<br />

80% Decline<br />

We have slashed our forecasts for earnings across all sectors by an average of 38%, this implies a PER of 12x FY09 earnings, while<br />

market trades on PER of 7.67x FY09 earnings.<br />

We arrived at the 38% decline by the following:<br />

1) Assuming lower or stagnating commodities’ prices to new prices<br />

2) Accounting for lower domestic demand / lower exports<br />

3) Anticipating higher levels of inventory<br />

4) Accounting for more expensive liquidity.<br />

Can The Market Be right?<br />

Investors seem to be discounting worse than existing/expected economic conditions. Market pessimism seem to be disproportionate<br />

to reality, exactly as optimism was out of proportion when the market was rallying. Main factors triggering the pessimism,<br />

in our opinion, are identified as follows:<br />

1) Global uncertainties regarding equities<br />

2) Declining Oil Prices leading GCC investors to withdraw their investments<br />

3) Brokerage Companies being more conservative not extending margins to investors who already lost their positions<br />

4) Wait-to-see-attitude from investors in search for market bottoms<br />

We Strongly Refute The Likelihood of Worsening Economic Conditions Based on The Following:<br />

Source: Prime Estimates<br />

1) Expected expansionary monetary policy by the Central Bank of Egypt<br />

2) Government plan to lubricate the economy through devoting LE15 billion to infrastructure projects and tax subsidies<br />

3) Huge consumption potential attracting FDIs<br />

4) Investment friendly policies adopted by the government<br />

5) Cheap labor.<br />

Prime Research 16


2009 INVESTMENT STRATEGY<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

This Page has been Left Intentionally Blank<br />

Prime Research 17


PRIME PICK: COMMERCIAL<br />

INTERNATIONAL BANK (CIB)<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Target Price Market Price Recommendation Upside Potential Investment Grade<br />

LE40.2 LE34 Buy<br />

18.2%<br />

Value<br />

Share Data<br />

Company Short Name<br />

Sector<br />

Company Traded Market<br />

Report Reason<br />

Valuation Methodology<br />

Previous Target<br />

Exchange Rate<br />

Stock Currency<br />

Reuters Code<br />

CIB<br />

Banking<br />

EGX- LSE<br />

<strong>Equity</strong> strategy<br />

DCFE<br />

LE70.3<br />

LE5.55/US$<br />

LE<br />

COMI.CA - COMIq.L<br />

Outstanding Shares (mn) 292.5<br />

Par Value/Share (LE)<br />

Financial Year Ending<br />

LE10<br />

December<br />

Mkt. Cap (LE mn) 9,945<br />

Weight to PAMI 5.28%<br />

Av. Daily Volume (000) 820<br />

Price Low – High (LE) (52Wk.) 27.01 - 64.88<br />

Shareholders<br />

Ownership Stake<br />

Ripplewood Consortium 8.86%<br />

Bank of New York 22.2%<br />

Dubai Capital 5.24%<br />

Free Float 63.62%<br />

70<br />

60<br />

50<br />

40<br />

30<br />

20<br />

10<br />

0<br />

Jan-08<br />

Mar-08<br />

Stock Performance Chart<br />

(LE / Share)<br />

May-08<br />

Jul-08<br />

Sep-08<br />

Nov-08<br />

Jan-09<br />

Mar-09<br />

Income Statement 2008a 2009e 2010f<br />

Interest Income 3,765 4,589 5,180<br />

Interest Expense 1,967 2,306 2,643<br />

Net Interest Income 1,799 2,283 2,537<br />

Non-Interest Income 1,558 1,744 2,020<br />

Non-Interest Expenses 1,330 1,612 1,866<br />

Operating Income 2,027 2,414 2,691<br />

Provisions 411 436 441<br />

Net Profit Before Tax 1,616 1,978 2,250<br />

Tax Provisions 0 30 45<br />

Income Taxes 251 325 360<br />

NPAT 1,365 1,624 1,845<br />

Other Non Operating Items 0 0 0<br />

NPAUI 1,365 1,624 1,845<br />

Minority Interest Income -5 -6 -7<br />

Non-Appropriation Items 0 173 232<br />

Net Attributable Income 1,371 1,457 1,620<br />

Balance Sheet 2008a 2009e 2010f<br />

Cash and Cash Items 6,493 7,167 8,693<br />

Inter-bank Assets 4,552 8,451 13,961<br />

T-Bills & Gov. Securities 12,558 16,374 20,765<br />

Net Marketable Securities 3,996 4,094 4,558<br />

Net Loans and Advances 26,330 28,316 30,739<br />

Debtors & Other Debt Balances 973 1,426 1,727<br />

Subsidiaries & Direct Invst. 93 239 241<br />

Net Fixed Assets 748 765 793<br />

Other Assets 1,717 1,752 1,787<br />

Total Assets 57,462 68,583 83,264<br />

Claims on Assets<br />

Inter-bank Liabilities 229 451 757<br />

Customer Deposits 48,790 59,726 72,444<br />

Creditors & Other Cr. Balances 1,229 1,100 1,332<br />

Dividend Payable 0 546 748<br />

Other Provisions 373 469 581<br />

Bonds 109 120 132<br />

Other Liabilities 866 874 883<br />

Minority Interest 0 -6 -13<br />

Total Liabilities 51,596 63,280 76,864<br />

Tier 1 : Primary Capital 5,866 5,304 6,401<br />

Paid-In Capital 2,925 2,925 2,925<br />

Capital Surplus 0 0 0<br />

Reserves 1,444 2,458 3,555<br />

Retained Earnings 1,497 -79 -79<br />

Total Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 5,866 5,304 6,401<br />

Total Liab. & Sh. <strong>Equity</strong> 57,462 68,583 83,264<br />

Contingent Liabilities 13,291 14,886 16,672<br />

Total Footings 70,753 83,469 99,937<br />

Free Cash to <strong>Equity</strong> 2008a 2009e 2010f<br />

NAI 1,371 1,457 1,620<br />

Investment Flow: -1,679 562 -1,097<br />

Change in Assets -9,699 -11,122 -14,681<br />

Change in Liabilities 8,020 11,684 13,584<br />

Table 1<br />

Source: Bank Financials & Prime Projections<br />

<strong>Equity</strong> Cash Flow -308 2,019 523<br />

Please refer to disclaimer on last page<br />

Financial Summary (Figures in LE million)<br />

Source: Company Historical & Prime Estimates<br />

Prime Research 18


PRIME PICK: COMMERCIAL<br />

INTERNATIONAL BANK (CIB)<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Meet A Mature & Established Bank<br />

CIB is a main player in the sector in Egypt as it captures a loan market share of 6%. Despite adverse economic environment loans<br />

grew by 28.8% in FY08 leading to total L/D ratio of 57% from 55% in FY07. With regard to financial investments, the bank<br />

tripled its holding of the risk-free government securities leading to total financial investments of LE16.6 billion representing 34% of<br />

customer deposits in FY08 from 16% in FY07. Marketable securities, however, witnessed a 48% increase in marketable securities to<br />

LE3.9 billion. The bank has applied new CBE amendments with regard to valuating available for sale financial investments and held to<br />

maturity. Accordingly, earning assets expanded to LE47.3 billion demonstrating a 16% growth. The bank reported a strong equity<br />

base through a Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR) of 11.72%, perceived as protection against the global economic downturn.<br />

Projections & Valuation<br />

As a result of the economic slowdown and the global financial crisis, we expect a conservative loan growth rate of 8% and 9%<br />

over FY09 and FY10, respectively. We forecast non-interest income to grow at 12% and 16% in FY09 and FY10, respectively,<br />

compared to 38% growth in FY08 and 29% growth in FY07. In order to reflect the risk averse aptitude by investors, we raise<br />

our cost of equity to 16.3% (i.e. 9.6% risk free rate and 6.7% market risk premium).<br />

Investment Rationale<br />

We have a positive sentiment on CIB, due to the following;<br />

• Enhanced profitability as reflected in NIM standing at 3.8% from 2.9% in FY07;<br />

• Manageable risk shown by a CAR of 11.7%;<br />

• Room for growth demonstrated by L/D ratio of 57%;<br />

• Share prices demonstrate 18% upside potential, though not exceedingly high, illustrate a solid earning base.<br />

Size Items (LE millions) 2008a 2009e 2010f 2011f<br />

Total Revenues 5,323 6,332 7,201 8,639<br />

Net Banking Income 3,357 4,026 4,557 5,602<br />

Earning Assets 47,437 57,235 70,024 81,465<br />

Risk Assets. 34,879 40,861 49,259 68,802<br />

Liquid Assets 27,600 36,086 47,978 52,967<br />

Total Invested Capital 6,841 6,298 7,415 8,685<br />

Non-Performing Loans (NPLs) 840 944 1,033 1,291<br />

Specific Loan Provisions 640 945 1,278 1,695<br />

General Loan Provisions 768 834 873 923<br />

Profitability Ratios 2008a 2009e 2010f 2011f<br />

Yr/Yr Net Interest Income Growth 49.8% 26.9% 11.1% 15.1%<br />

Yr/Yr Non-Interest Income Growth 38.8% 11.9% 15.9% 32.7%<br />

Gross Earning Yield (GEY) 7.9% 8.0% 7.4% 7.3%<br />

Breakeven Earning Yield (BEY) 4.1% 4.0% 3.8% 3.7%<br />

Net Interest Margin (NIM) 3.8% 4.0% 3.6% 3.6%<br />

Cost of Funds (exc. equity) 3.9% 3.8% 3.6% 3.6%<br />

Cost of Funds (inc. equity) 5.2% 4.7% 4.6% 4.6%<br />

ROA 2.4% 2.4% 2.2% 2.4%<br />

ROE 23.3% 30.6% 28.8% 29.6%<br />

ROIC (after-tax) 20.0% 23.1% 21.8% 22.9%<br />

Asset Quality Ratios 2008a 2009e 2010f 2011f<br />

NPLs/Total Loans 3.0% 3.1% 3.1% 3.1%<br />

Specific Loan Provisions/NPLs 76.2% 100.1% 123.7% 131.2%<br />

Spe. & Gen. Loan Prov. /Tot. Loans 5.0% 5.8% 6.5% 6.3%<br />

Productivity Ratios 2008a 2009e 2010f 2011f<br />

Tot. Loans & Adv./ Tot. Deposits 57.4% 51.0% 46.0% 50.0%<br />

Tot. Bills & Bonds/Tot. <strong>Equity</strong> 276.2% 308.7% 324.4% 165.5%<br />

Liquid Assets/Total Deposits 56.6% 60.4% 66.2% 63.6%<br />

Interbank Ratio 1987.8% 1875.8% 1844.9% 2450.2%<br />

Source: Bank Financials & Prime Estimates<br />

LE mn 2009 2010 2011<br />

Old New Old New Old New<br />

Net Loans 37,188 28,316 49,021 30,739 63,725 38,496<br />

NII 2,250 2,283 2,732 2,537 3,025 2,921<br />

Net Banking Income 4,042 4,027 4,915 4,557 5,580 5,602<br />

NAI 1,882 1,457 2,392 1,620 2,743 1,988<br />

Source: Bank Financials & Prime Estimates<br />

Prime Research 19


PRIME PICK: NATIONAL SOCIETE<br />

GENERAL BANK (NSGB)<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Target Price Market Price Recommendation Upside Potential Investment Grade<br />

LE18.9 LE15.37 Buy<br />

22.9%<br />

Value<br />

Share Data<br />

Company Short Name<br />

NSGB<br />

Sector<br />

Banking<br />

Company Traded Market<br />

EGX<br />

Report Reason<br />

<strong>Equity</strong> strategy<br />

Valuation Methodology<br />

DCFE<br />

Previous Target<br />

LE52.3<br />

Exchange Rate<br />

LE5.55/US$<br />

Stock Currency<br />

LE<br />

Reuters Code<br />

NSGB.CA<br />

Outstanding Shares (mn) 302.9<br />

Par Value/Share (LE)<br />

LE10<br />

Financial Year Ending<br />

December<br />

Mkt. Cap (LE mn) 4,471.4<br />

Weight to PAMI 2.48%<br />

Av. Daily Volume (000) 133.9<br />

Price Low – High (LE) (52Wk.) 13 - 44.85<br />

Shareholders<br />

Ownership Stake<br />

Societe Generale 77.2%<br />

Free Float 22.8%<br />

Income Statement 2008a 2009e 2010f<br />

Interest Income 3,200.2 3,382.9 3,734.9<br />

Interest Expense 1,772.3 1,796.1 1,921.0<br />

Net Interest Income 1,427.9 1,586.7 1,813.9<br />

Non-Interest Income 1,178.7 1,014.9 971.1<br />

Non-Interest Expenses 1,096.6 1,190.9 1,315.6<br />

Operating Income 1,509.9 1,410.7 1,469.3<br />

Provisions 213.4 364.9 413.8<br />

Net Profit Before Tax 1,296.6 1,045.8 1,055.5<br />

Tax Provisions 0.0 73.2 105.5<br />

Income Taxes 160.2 52.3 52.8<br />

Unusual Item 0.4 - -<br />

NPAUI 1,136.9 920.3 897.2<br />

Non-Appropriation Items 71.5 84.9 81.9<br />

Net Attributable Income 1,065.4 835.4 815.3<br />

Balance Sheet 2008a 2009e 2010f<br />

Cash and Cash Items 3,102.6 3,873.4 4,183.2<br />

Inter-bank Assets 9,027.2 8,286.3 10,823.1<br />

T-Bills & Gov. Securities 2,976.4 4,415.6 4,768.9<br />

Net Marketable Securities 3,776.3 2,943.8 3,179.3<br />

Net Loans and Advances 25,011.2 26,620.3 28,233.5<br />

Debtors & Other Debt Balances 558.5 591.7 611.1<br />

Subsidiaries & Direct Invst. 40.3 (321.6) (683.5)<br />

Net Fixed Assets 729.5 772.5 817.5<br />

Other Assets 824.8 841.3 858.1<br />

Total Assets 46,046.8 48,023.3 52,791.2<br />

Stock Performance Chart<br />

(LE / Share)<br />

Claims on Assets - - -<br />

Inter-bank Liabilities 1,460.2 1,314.2 2,284.9<br />

50<br />

45<br />

40<br />

35<br />

30<br />

25<br />

20<br />

15<br />

10<br />

5<br />

0<br />

Jan-08<br />

Mar-08<br />

May-08<br />

Jul-08<br />

Sep-08<br />

Nov-08<br />

Jan-09<br />

Mar-09<br />

Customer Deposits 36,889.2 38,733.7 41,832.4<br />

Creditors & Other Cr. Balances 1,499.1 1,138.0 1,240.2<br />

Dividend Payable 0.0 449.5 491.4<br />

Other Provisions 689.3 912.4 1,168.6<br />

Long-Term Debt 49.6 71.2 78.3<br />

Total Liabilities 40,587.4 42,619.0 47,095.9<br />

Tier 2: Secondary Capital 771.9 470.0 355.3<br />

Subordinated Debt 771.9 470.0 355.3<br />

Tier 1 : Primary Capital 4,687.4 4,934.3 5,340.0<br />

Paid-In Capital 3,029.4 3,029.4 3,029.4<br />

Capital Surplus - - -<br />

Reserves 1,091.6 1,528.3 1,913.9<br />

Retained Earnings 566.4 376.6 396.7<br />

Total Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 5,459.4 5,404.3 5,695.4<br />

Total Liab. & Sh. <strong>Equity</strong> 46,046.8 48,023.3 52,791.2<br />

Contingent Liabilities 15,556.8 17,890.3 20,037.2<br />

Total Footings 61,603.6 65,913.6 72,828.4<br />

Free Cash to <strong>Equity</strong> 2008a 2009e 2010f<br />

NAI 1,065.4 835.4 815.3<br />

Investment Flow: (1,012.7) 55.1 (291.1)<br />

Change in Assets 1,356.4 (1,976.5) (4,768.0)<br />

Change in Liabilities (2,369.1) 2,031.5 4,476.9<br />

<strong>Equity</strong> Cash Flow 52.6 890.4 524.2<br />

Please refer to disclaimer on last page<br />

Financial Summary (Figures in LE million)<br />

Source: Bank Financials & Prime Projections<br />

Prime Research 20


PRIME PICK: NATIONAL SOCIETE<br />

GENERAL BANK (NSGB)<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Meet A Bank with Solid Foundation & Potential Growth<br />

We identify NSGB as the second main market player, next to CIB, holding a loan market share of 6%. In FY08, net loans witnessed<br />

a 27% increase leading to a staggering total L/D ratio of 73%, compared to 56% by year end FY07. Nonperforming<br />

loans is down to 7% from 11% in FY07 reflecting enhanced asset quality. Financial investments, however, witnessed a<br />

20% decline due to 25% decrease in government securities and 15% decline in marketable securities. Accordingly, earning assets<br />

demonstrated a 2% decline in FY08 to LE40.8 billion. The bank reported a CAR of 13% showing limited risk.<br />

Projection & Valuation<br />

Reflecting a slowing economy, we forecast a conservative annual loan growth of 6% in FY09 and FY10. Also, non-interest income is<br />

expected to witness a 14% decline in FY09 and a 4% decline in FY10, compared to a growth of 105% in FY08 and 9% in FY07. The<br />

staggering increase in non-interest income in FY08 is due to LE389 million provision reversal. We make the conservative expectation<br />

of no such reversals in the coming years. However, we believe in the efficient operations of the bank based on past performance.<br />

Investment Rationale<br />

We highly recommend the bank, due to the following;<br />

• Limited risk as indicated by CAR of 13%;<br />

• High profitability shown by a NIM of 3.5%, ROA of 2.5% and ROE of 26.5%;<br />

• Trading at a discount as demonstrated by a 23% upside potential, P/E of 4.2% and a P/B of 0.8x.<br />

Size Items LE mn 2008a 2009f 2010f 2011f<br />

Total Revenues 4,378.9 4,397.7 4,705.9 5,347.1<br />

Net Banking Income 2,606.6 2,601.6 2,784.9 3,289.2<br />

Earning Assets 40,791.0 42,266.0 47,004.8 51,884.1<br />

Risk Assets. 37,814.7 37,850.3 42,235.9 45,745.6<br />

Liquid Assets 18,882.4 19,519.1 22,954.5 24,472.9<br />

Total Invested Capital 5,508.9 5,475.5 5,773.7 6,164.2<br />

Non-Performing Loans (NPLs) 1,897.6 2,091.6 2,259.8 2,413.1<br />

Specific Loan Provisions 1,804.6 1,978.9 2,195.6 2,300.5<br />

General Loan Provisions 332.6 373.3 419.7 489.6<br />

Profitability Ratios 2008a 2009f 2010f 2011f<br />

Yr/Yr Net Interest Income Growth 20.4% 11.1% 14.3% 16.9%<br />

Yr/Yr Non-Interest Income Growth 104.7% -13.9% -4.3% 20.5%<br />

Gross Earning Yield (GEY) 7.8% 8.0% 7.9% 8.1%<br />

Breakeven Earning Yield (BEY) 4.3% 4.2% 4.1% 4.0%<br />

Net Interest Margin (NIM) 3.5% 3.8% 3.9% 4.1%<br />

Cost of Funds (exc. equity) 4.6% 4.5% 4.3% 4.2%<br />

Cost of Funds (inc. equity) 6.1% 5.9% 5.7% 5.6%<br />

ROA 2.5% 1.9% 1.7% 2.0%<br />

ROE 20.8% 17.0% 15.8% 19.6%<br />

ROIC (after-tax) 19.3% 15.3% 14.1% 17.5%<br />

Asset Quality Ratios 2008a 2009f 2010f 2011f<br />

NPLs/Total Loans 7.0% 7.2% 7.3% 6.9%<br />

Specific Loan Provisions/NPLs 95.1% 94.6% 97.2% 95.3%<br />

Spe. & Gen. Loan Prov. /Tot. Loans 7.9% 8.1% 8.4% 8.0%<br />

Productivity Ratios 2008a 2009f 2010f 2011f<br />

Tot. Loans & Adv./ Tot. Deposits 73.5% 75.0% 74.0% 76.0%<br />

Tot. Bills & Bonds/Tot. <strong>Equity</strong> 112.6% 125.3% 128.4% 159.5%<br />

Liquid Assets/Total Deposits 51.2% 50.4% 54.9% 53.2%<br />

Interbank Ratio 618.2% 630.5% 473.7% 384.0%<br />

Source: Bank Financials & Prime Estimates<br />

LE mn 2009 2010 2011<br />

Old New Old New Old New<br />

Net Loans 29,964 26,620.3 35,965 28,233.5 44,225 32,012.7<br />

NII 1,689 1,586.7 1,990 1,813.9 2,475 2,119.6<br />

Net Banking Income 2,611 2,601.6 3,127 2,784.9 3,958 3,289.2<br />

NAI 984 835.4 1,233 815.3 1,827 1,076.8<br />

Source: Bank Financials & Prime Estimates<br />

Prime Research 21


PRIME PICK: MARIDIVE AND<br />

OIL SERVICES<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Target Price Market Price Recommendation Upside Potential Investment Grade<br />

US$4.45 US$2.72 Strong Buy<br />

63.6%<br />

Value<br />

Share Data<br />

Company Short Name<br />

Sector<br />

Company Traded Market<br />

Report Reason<br />

Valuation Methodology<br />

Exchange Rate<br />

Stock Currency<br />

Reuters Code<br />

Maridive<br />

Oil & Gas services<br />

EGX<br />

<strong>Equity</strong> Strategy<br />

DCF<br />

LE5.55/US$<br />

US$<br />

MOIL.CA<br />

Outstanding Shares (mn) 256<br />

Par Value/Share (US$)<br />

Financial Year Ending<br />

0.40/share<br />

December<br />

Mkt. Cap (US$ mn) 645<br />

Av. Daily Volume 627,501<br />

Price Low – High (LE) (52Wk.) 1.8 - 7.18<br />

Shareholders<br />

Ownership Stake<br />

Eleish Family 13.20%<br />

Nadim Family 13.20%<br />

Zeid Family 13.20%<br />

Offshore Oil Services 21.39%<br />

CIB 7.11%<br />

EFG Private Company 2.91%<br />

Free Float 28.99%<br />

Stock Performance Chart<br />

(US$ / Share)<br />

Income Statement 2008a 2009e 2010f 2011f<br />

Revenues 257.1 298.4 302.8 343.6<br />

Growth -2% 16% 1% 13%<br />

COGS 125.2 145.2 151.4 167.2<br />

S,G & Admin. Expenses 23.5 27.3 33.3 31.4<br />

EBITDA 108.4 125.8 118.1 144.9<br />

Growth 1% 16% -6% 23%<br />

EBITDA Margin 42% 42% 39% 42%<br />

Depreciation 13.6 14.9 20.1 25.3<br />

Operating EBIT 94.9 110.9 98.0 119.6<br />

Interest Income 0.8 2.5 1.2 2.8<br />

Interest Expense 4.6 5.0 3.7 2.8<br />

Non-Operating Revenues 1.1 1.1 1.1 1.1<br />

Pre Tax Income 92.2 109.5 96.6 120.7<br />

Income Tax 1.4 2.7 1.8 2.4<br />

Effective Tax Rate 1.5% 2.4% 1.9% 1.9%<br />

NPAT 90.8 106.9 94.7 118.4<br />

Extraordinary Items 10.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

Net Income 100.8 106.9 94.7 118.4<br />

Minority interest 13.2 13.9 12.3 15.4<br />

Net Attributable Income - NAI 87.6 93.0 82.4 103.0<br />

Growth 9% 6% -11% 25%<br />

ROS 34% 31% 27% 30%<br />

Balance Sheet 2008a 2009e 2010f 2011f<br />

Cash & Marketable Securities 78.1 149.5 86.2 166.4<br />

Trade Receivables-Net 9.4 10.9 11.1 12.6<br />

Inventory 5.6 6.5 6.6 7.5<br />

Other Current Asset 83.3 95.2 96.0 108.5<br />

Total Current Asset 176.4 262.0 199.8 295.0<br />

Net Fixed Assets 192.2 262.7 331.2 338.2<br />

Projects Under Implementation 118.3 59.1 59.1 0.0<br />

Other Assets 9.8 9.8 9.8 9.8<br />

Total Assets 496.7 593.6 599.9 643.0<br />

Short Term Bank Debt 11.8 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

CPLTD 38.5 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

Accounts Payable 17.8 20.7 21.0 23.8<br />

Dividend Payable 64.0 74.4 71.7 89.6<br />

Other Current Liabilities 29.2 33.8 34.3 39.0<br />

Total Current Liabilities 161.3 128.9 127.1 152.4<br />

Long-Term Debt 101.2 81.1 66.2 55.2<br />

Provisions for Deferred Taxes 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

Provisions 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5<br />

Total Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 231.7 381.1 404.1 432.9<br />

Total Liab.& Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 496.7 593.6 599.9 643.0<br />

8<br />

7<br />

6<br />

5<br />

4<br />

3<br />

2<br />

1<br />

0<br />

May-08<br />

Jun-08<br />

Jul-08<br />

Aug-08<br />

Sep-08<br />

Oct-08<br />

Nov-08<br />

Dec-08<br />

Jan-09<br />

Feb-09<br />

Mar-09<br />

Free Cash Flow Statement 2008a 2009e 2010f 2011f<br />

NOPLAT 93.6 108.1 96.1 117.2<br />

Non-Cash Items 13.6 14.9 20.1 25.3<br />

Gross Cash Flow 107.2 123.1 116.2 142.5<br />

Gross Investments 137.2 -35.7 76.3 -32.0<br />

Non -Operating Cash Flow 10.9 1.1 1.1 1.1<br />

Free Cash Flow -19.1 159.8 41.0 175.6<br />

Financing Flow<br />

Interest Income After-Tax -0.8 -2.5 -1.2 -2.8<br />

Investment Income After-Tax 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

Increase in Excess Cash & M. Sec. 0.0 125.6 -63.6 77.0<br />

After-Tax Interest Expense 4.5 4.8 3.6 2.7<br />

Decrease in Debt & Bonds -20.1 70.9 15.5 11.6<br />

Provisions Used -0.7 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

Dividends Paid 13.5 71.4 80.9 79.9<br />

Non-Appropriation Items 1.8 -110.4 5.8 7.2<br />

Shareholders <strong>Equity</strong> -17.4 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

Total Financing Flow -19.1 159.8 41.0 175.6<br />

Please refer to disclaimer on last page<br />

Financial Summary (Figures in US$ million)<br />

Source: Company Financials, Prime Projections<br />

Prime Research 22


PRIME PICK: MARIDIVE<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Meet An Oil Dependent Stock, Yet Immune To Oil Price<br />

Maridive <strong>Group</strong> is one of the largest companies in Middle East in terms of fleet size.<br />

Maridive operates in two segments; Offshore Construction Services (OCS) and Offshore<br />

Support Vessels (OSV). The group comprises four entities; Maridive and Oil Services,<br />

Maridive Offshore Projects, Maritide Offshore Oil Services and Valentine Maritime Ltd., all<br />

together offering a wide range of services to oil and gas Exploration and Production companies<br />

including maintenance, construction, salvaging, transport and supply of materials.<br />

Maridive diversifies its presence in various locations worldwide entering new markets to<br />

raise market share. Yet, Maridive’s fleet is operating in South East Asia, Gulf of Mexico,<br />

Australia, South America, West Africa and the Red Sea. Currently, Maridive is expanding its<br />

fleet size to reach 73 vessels by FY11 from 60 vessels in FY08<br />

Maridive FY08 consolidated financials reported a top line figure of US$257 million versus<br />

US$264 million attained in FY07, reflecting a y-o-y decline of 2.6%. The slight decline in<br />

revenues was mainly due to a loss of the barge which sank in the previous year affecting<br />

Maridive’s fleet size and due to some delayed contracts which will be reflected in Q1 FY09<br />

earnings.<br />

Maridive Fleet Expansion<br />

Year Vessels Barges<br />

2008 49 11<br />

2009 55 12<br />

2010 57 13<br />

2011 60 13<br />

Total 73<br />

Source: Maridive<br />

Projections and Valuation<br />

In FY09, we maintained utilization and daily rates for both segments (OCS & OSV) due to the fact that Maridive secures long<br />

term contracts. However, we assumed both rates to decline by 15% in FY10 due to the expected decline in global exploration<br />

spending derived by the severe decline in oil prices occurred in late 2008, as well as the cyclical nature of the industry which<br />

states that rates are negatively affected after 12 to 18 months from the oil prices’ decline. Going forward, we forecasted rates to<br />

rebound in FY11 to increase by 15%.<br />

Speaking of margins, the company was able to reduce COGS/Revenue ratio to 48.7% from 53% in FY07. As a result,<br />

OPEX declined by 5% y-o-y to stand at US$148.7 million down from US$155.9 million. We expect COGS to reach US$145 million<br />

in FY09, reflecting a y-o-y growth of 16% and thus maintaining COGS/Revenue margin at 48.7%. Going further, we projected<br />

COGS/Revenue to increase slightly in FY10 to 50% translated to a COGS figure of US$151.4 million. In FY11 and FY12, we maintained<br />

COGS/revenue at 48%, recording US$167 million and US$184 million in COGS respectively.<br />

EBITDA slightly increased by 0.6% to record US$108.4 million over US$107.8 million in FY07. EBITDA margin grew by 128 bps to<br />

42.17% up from 40.89%. We maintained the EBITDA margin in FY09. Starting FY09, we forecasted EBITDA to grow at a 3 year<br />

CAGR of 4.82% to reach US$145 million in FY11 from US$118 million. Our forecasted EBITDA margin came in slightly lower in<br />

FY10 than FY09 by 320bps to 39% from 42.2%, projected to increase back again to 42% by FY11 and maintained in FY12.<br />

We expect FY09 financials to report US$106.7 million in net income, achieving a y-o-y growth of 6% over US$100.8 million. In<br />

FY10, we project net income to decline by 12% to US$95 million. By FY11, when the cycle begins to move upward, we expect<br />

25% increase in net income to reach US$118 million.<br />

Utilizing a WACC of 12.02% and a perpetual growth of 3%, we valued Maridive’s shareholders’ value at US$1.14 billion or<br />

US$4.45/share. The target implies an upside potential of 63.6% given the prevailing market price of US$2.72/share.<br />

Investment Rationale<br />

We have a positive sentiment on the company due to:<br />

• Maridive <strong>Group</strong>’s earnings are backed by secured long term contracts vary from one to two years. Yet, Maridive has already<br />

secured contracts in FY09 and FY10 worth US$188 and US$233 million respectively.<br />

• A high barrier industry entails limited supply of offshore vessels due to insufficient funds to finance building new vessels and<br />

more than 110 vessels under construction were delayed or cancelled, Maridive is expanding its fleet size to reach 73 vessels<br />

by FY11 from 60 vessels in FY08 which will benefit its international presence and market share.<br />

• Demand on OSV vessels is supported by number of operating rigs as according to industry norms, every operating rig requires<br />

two support vessels which are considered as fixed costs for E&P companies, which is currently Maridive is capitalizing<br />

on.<br />

Prime Research 23


PRIME PICK: TELECOM EGYPT<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Target Price Market Price Recommendation Upside Potential Investment Grade<br />

LE24.02 LE14.74 Strong Buy<br />

63%<br />

Value<br />

Share Data<br />

Company Short Name<br />

Sector<br />

Company Traded Market<br />

Report Reason<br />

Valuation Methodology<br />

Previous Target<br />

Exchange Rate<br />

Stock Currency<br />

Reuters Code<br />

Stock Performance Chart<br />

(LE / Share)<br />

TE<br />

Telecommunication<br />

EGX & LSE<br />

<strong>Equity</strong> Strategy<br />

DCF<br />

LE24.87<br />

LE5.55/US$<br />

LE<br />

ETEL.CA - ETELq.L<br />

Outstanding Shares (mn) 1,707<br />

Par Value/Share (LE)<br />

Financial Year Ending<br />

LE10<br />

December<br />

Mkt. Cap (LE mn) 25,162<br />

Weight to PAMI 13.59%<br />

Price Low – High (LE) (52Wk.) 10.7 - 23.9<br />

Shareholders<br />

Ownership Stake<br />

Egyptian Government 80%<br />

Free Float 20%<br />

25<br />

Income Statement 2007a 2008e 2009f<br />

Revenues 9,993.1 10,413.2 10,710.0<br />

Growth 5.0% 4.2% 2.9%<br />

COGS 3,305.7 3,389.1 3,566.5<br />

S,G & Admin. Expenses 1,485.1 1,741.0 1,826.4<br />

Other Provisions 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

EBITDA 5,202.3 5,283.1 5,317.1<br />

Growth 2.0% 1.6% 0.6%<br />

EBITDA Margin 52.1% 50.7% 49.6%<br />

Depreciation & Amortization 2736.7 2546.8 2817.8<br />

Operating EBIT 2,465.6 2,736.3 2,499.3<br />

Interest Income 81.3 94.9 150.9<br />

Investment Income 1070.7 1222.5 1259.2<br />

Interest Expense 599.8 354.7 287.2<br />

Non-Operating Revenues 351.5 313.8 394.4<br />

Pre Tax Income 3,369.3 4,012.7 4,016.5<br />

Pre Tax Income Growth 8% 19% 0%<br />

Income Tax 513.3 662.1 679.8<br />

Effective Tax Rate 15% 17% 17%<br />

NPAT 2,856.0 3,350.6 3,336.8<br />

Growth 9.8% 17.3% -0.4%<br />

Minority 0.0 9.3 9.7<br />

Extraordinary Items (315.0) (264.7) (105.9)<br />

Net Income 2,541.0 3,076.7 3,221.2<br />

Profit Share to Employees & Board 97.3 64.6 66.4<br />

Net Attributable Income - NAI 2,443.7 3,012.1 3,154.8<br />

Growth 5.0% 23.3% 4.7%<br />

ROS 24.5% 28.9% 29.5%<br />

Balance Sheet 2007a 2008e 2009f<br />

Cash & Marketable Securities 1,302.2 2,314.5 2,381.8<br />

Trade Receivables-Net 4,792.5 4,997.0 5,396.6<br />

Inventory 508.4 529.8 544.9<br />

Other Current Asset 94.6 98.6 101.4<br />

Total Current Asset 6,697.7 7,939.8 8,424.7<br />

Net Fixed Assets 19,372.4 18,272.3 16,941.2<br />

Projects Under Implementation 843.6 847.8 852.0<br />

Other Assets 7,677.4 7,772.6 8,015.6<br />

Total Assets 34,591.1 34,832.5 34,233.5<br />

Short Term Bank Debt 1,834.5 377.4 290.8<br />

CPLTD 0.0 1,345.5 695.5<br />

Accounts Payable 130.3 135.8 125.7<br />

Dividend Payable 0.8 1.0 1.0<br />

Other Current Liabilities 3,195.9 2,997.2 2,774.4<br />

Total Current Liabilities 5,161.6 4,856.9 3,887.4<br />

Long-Term Debt 3,151.0 2,633.4 1,898.4<br />

Provisions for Deferred Taxes 170.4 170.4 170.4<br />

Provisions 324.4 421.0 520.3<br />

Total Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 25,743.9 26,701.6 27,698.2<br />

Total Liab.& Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 34,591.1 34,832.5 34,233.5<br />

20<br />

15<br />

10<br />

5<br />

0<br />

Mar-08<br />

Apr-08<br />

May-08<br />

Jun-08<br />

Jul-08<br />

Aug-08<br />

Sep-08<br />

Oct-08<br />

Nov-08<br />

Dec-08<br />

Jan-09<br />

Feb-09<br />

Free Cash Flow Statement 2007a 2008e 2009f<br />

NOPLAT 1,884.0 2,115.4 1,964.2<br />

Non-Cash Items 2,736.7 2,546.8 2,817.8<br />

Gross Cash Flow 4,620.7 4,662.2 4,782.0<br />

Gross Investments 314.4 1,958.0 2,031.8<br />

Non -Operating Cash Flow 31.0 33.4 196.5<br />

Free Cash Flow 4,337.3 2,737.7 2,946.7<br />

Financing Flow<br />

Interest Income After-Tax -80.1 -91.9 -146.1<br />

Investment Income After-Tax -1,054.4 -1,183.5 -1,219.0<br />

Increase in Excess Cash & M. Sec. 535.0 921.3 169.5<br />

After-Tax Interest Expense 508.4 241.5 195.6<br />

Decrease in Debt & Bonds 2,503.8 629.2 1,471.6<br />

Provisions Used 156.8 0.0 0.0<br />

Dividends Paid 1,716.0 2,070.5 2,167.9<br />

Non-Appropriation Items 97.3 64.6 66.4<br />

Shareholders <strong>Equity</strong> -444.2 -7.0 0.0<br />

Total Financing Flow 4,337.3 2,737.7 2,946.7<br />

Please refer to disclaimer on last page<br />

Financial Summary (Figures in LE million)<br />

Source: Company Historical & Prime Estimates<br />

Prime Research 24


PRIME PICK: TELECOM EGYPT<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

MEET THE DIVERSFIED TELECOM OPERATOR<br />

Telecom Egypt is the only fixed line operator in Egypt and the largest in the MENA region in terms of the number of subscribers<br />

which amounted to 11.33 million in September 2008. The company is 80% owned by the government and has a stake of 45% in<br />

Vodafone Egypt. Moreover, the company controls 56% of the DSL market through its TE data subsidiary.<br />

Projections & Valuation<br />

• Recently mobile operators have announced aggressive marketing schemes including a cut in calling prices to LE0.05/minutes<br />

which we believe that it will make connection costs between governorates more cheaper using mobile phones than using fixed<br />

lines which costs between LE0.08/minute to LE0.16/minute. Moreover, revenues from international calls which represented<br />

28.39% in 9M FY08 will slow down in FY09 due to the shrinkage of the Tourist activity and lay offs or salaries cuts pertaining to<br />

Egyptian expatriates.<br />

• In spite of mobile to fixed substitution, TE growth drivers still exist such as a growth in voice calls revenues should the economy<br />

dips into recession as consumers will tend to use cheaper fixed lines services,<br />

• Following the elimination of the connection tariffs during November and the first week of December, we believe that number of<br />

new subscribers will close the year at 737k subscribers compared to 421k last year.<br />

• Revenues from the undersea cable activity will enhance the bottom line going forward taking into consideration that the investment<br />

cost of the project is hovering at US$160 million but the company has managed to sign contracts with a total value<br />

hitting US$176 million by the end of 1H FY08. The TE North cable is scheduled to come into stream at the second of 2009. We<br />

believe that TE North will add LE311.8 million to aggregate revenues in FY09.<br />

• We also believe that the internet segment is another growth driver going forward with expectation for this segment to record<br />

revenues of LE480.1 million in FY08 and LE837.7 million in FY09 coupled with higher internet literacy and higher internet<br />

penetration rate and increased use of the internet by businesses.<br />

• Our latest DCF valuation for Telecom Egypt as of the 9M FY08 entails a total equity value of LE40 billion or LE24.02/share<br />

INVESTMENT RATIONALE<br />

• NTRA has postponed issuance of the 2nd fixed line license, until further notice, TE remains sole provider of fixed line services.<br />

In case of 2 player market, the second operator will have to roam on TE network till its network is completely rolled out which is<br />

hard to achieve given geographical distribution of Egypt Governorates, providing TE with additional infrastructure revenues<br />

• Internet awareness continues to increase exponentially in Egypt with number of DSL subscribers expected to grow at a CAGR of<br />

60% by FY12, allowing TE Data to capitalize on its 56% market share<br />

• Capitalizing on Egypt’s Geographical position, TE is the best choice for bandwidth traffic originating from Asia & Africa to<br />

Europe. US$70 million will be recognized in 2009 stemming from 25% utilization of the cable. Going forward, the investment will<br />

increase TE footprints to the existing transit corridor, TE will be able to capture growth in bandwidth demand in Asia without<br />

injecting more CAPEX<br />

• Should Mobinil (only listed competitor to VF) gets delisted due to the arbitration case between OTH and FT, TE will be the only<br />

access to the under penetrated Egyptian Mobile market through its 45% stake in VF.<br />

• Leading Industry in financial indicators, EBITDA margin 52%, PE 7.8x, Div Yield 8%, FCF Yield 17%<br />

Prime Research 25


PRIME PICK: MOBINIL<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Target Price Market Price Recommendation Upside Potential Investment Grade<br />

LE197 LE140.82 Strong Buy<br />

40%<br />

Value<br />

Share Data<br />

Company Short Name<br />

Sector<br />

Company Traded Market<br />

Report Reason<br />

Valuation Methodology<br />

Previous Target<br />

Exchange Rate<br />

Stock Currency<br />

Reuters Code<br />

Mobinil<br />

Telecommunication<br />

EGX<br />

<strong>Equity</strong> Strategy<br />

DCF<br />

LE209<br />

LE5.55/US$<br />

Stock Performance Chart<br />

(LE / Share)<br />

LE<br />

EMOB.CA<br />

Outstanding Shares (mn) 100<br />

Par Value/Share (LE)<br />

Financial Year Ending<br />

LE10<br />

December<br />

Mkt. Cap (LE mn) 14,080<br />

Weight to PAMI 7.60%<br />

Price Low – High (LE) (52Wk.) 87 - 243<br />

Shareholders<br />

Ownership Stake<br />

Mobinil Telecom 51%<br />

Orange 71.25%<br />

Orascom Telecom 28.75%<br />

Orascom Telecom 20%<br />

Free Float 29%<br />

250<br />

200<br />

150<br />

100<br />

50<br />

0<br />

Mar-08<br />

Apr-08<br />

May-08<br />

Jun-08<br />

Jul-08<br />

Aug-08<br />

Sep-08<br />

Oct-08<br />

Nov-08<br />

Dec-08<br />

Jan-09<br />

Feb-09<br />

Income Statement (LE mn) 2007a 2008a 2009f<br />

Revenues 8,200.5 10,002.8 11,278.7<br />

Growth 28.9% 22.0% 12.8%<br />

COGS 1,828.0 2,057.4 2,389.5<br />

S,G & Admin. Expenses 2,681.8 3,058.4 3,543.2<br />

EBITDA 3,690.7 4,886.9 5,346.1<br />

Growth 9.5% 32.4% 9.4%<br />

EBITDA Margin 45.0% 48.9% 47.4%<br />

Depreciation & Amortization 1285.9 1659.6 1988.7<br />

Other Provisions 144.1 252.0 225.9<br />

Operating EBIT 2,260.6 2,975.3 3,131.4<br />

Interest Income 29.6 40.3 12.9<br />

Investment Income 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

Interest Expense 124.0 586.6 617.2<br />

Non-Operating expenses -16.7 59.7 70.9<br />

Pre Tax Income 2,149.6 2,488.8 2,598.1<br />

Income Tax 496.4 499.0 520.9<br />

Effective Tax Rate 23.1% 20.0% 20.0%<br />

NPAT 1,653.2 1,989.9 2,077.2<br />

Growth 7.8% 20.4% 4.4%<br />

Extraordinary Items (2) (20) (1)<br />

Net Income 1,650.8 1,970.2 2,076.0<br />

Profit Share to Employees & Board 141.1 109.8 115.7<br />

Net Attributable Income - NAI 1,509.6 1,860.4 1,960.3<br />

Growth 9.1% 23.2% 5.4%<br />

ROS 18.4% 18.6% 17.4%<br />

Balance Sheet (LE mn) 2007a 2008a 2009f<br />

Total Current Asset 1,347.2 1,587.6 1,655.8<br />

Net Fixed Assets 6,060.3 7,870.0 9,022.5<br />

Projects Under Implementation 1,565.7 1,000.6 950.5<br />

Total Assets 10,053.5 13,658.0 14,507.1<br />

CPLTD 327.2 327.2 407.3<br />

Total Current Liabilities 3,937.1 4,963.3 6,523.1<br />

Long-Term Debt 3,577.3 4,848.1 4,440.8<br />

Total Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 1,751.6 2,239.6 2,381.2<br />

Total Liab.& Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 10,053.5 13,658.0 14,507.1<br />

Free Cash Flow Statement (LE mn) 2007a 2008a 2009f<br />

NOPLAT 1,616.0 2,367.4 2,436.7<br />

Non-Cash Items 1,430.0 1,911.6 2,214.7<br />

Gross Cash Flow 3,046.0 4,279.0 4,651.4<br />

Gross Investments 3,507.3 3,519.5 3,261.1<br />

Non -Operating Cash Flow -13.4 31.1 48.3<br />

Free Cash Flow -474.8 790.6 1,438.6<br />

Financing Flow<br />

Interest Income After-Tax -28.9 -39.5 -12.5<br />

Increase in Excess Cash & M. Sec. -201.1 134.3 -5.5<br />

After-Tax Interest Expense 95.4 469.0 420.3<br />

Decrease in Debt & Bonds -2,005.6 -1,276.1 399.1<br />

Provisions Used 88.8 334.0 0.0<br />

Dividends Paid 1,421.8 1,082.8 239.0<br />

Non-Appropriation Items 141.1 109.8 115.7<br />

Shareholders <strong>Equity</strong> 13.7 -23.6 282.5<br />

Total Financing Flow -474.8 790.6 1,438.6<br />

Please refer to disclaimer on last page<br />

Financial Summary (Figures in LE million)<br />

Source: Company Historical & Prime Estimates<br />

Prime Research 26


PRIME PICK: MOBINIL<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Meet The Mobile Operator<br />

Mobinil is the first GSM operator in Egypt and the largest among a tripartite industry with a market share of 48.74% by the end of<br />

2008. Mobinil’s revenues in FY08 culminated at LE10 billion, 22% more than the figure booked in FY07 with the customers base<br />

surging by 33% to 20.1 million subscribers. ARPU in contrast slumped by 17% coming in at LE47.5. On the EBITDA level, it improved<br />

from 45% in FY07 to 48.9% in FY08 as OPEX surged by only 13.4%, but as an absolute figure EBITDA moved north by<br />

32.4% to LE4.89 billion. Interest expenses meanwhile soared by 373% to LE586.58 million as the company had to increase its<br />

interest bearing debt by 30% to finance CAPEX and new expansion including the 3G license coupled with higher interest rate. In<br />

sum, net income grew by 19.2% in FY08 culminating at LE1.97 billion from FY07’s figure of LE1.65 billion.<br />

Projection and Valuation<br />

Figure In 000 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012<br />

We confide in Mobinil’s capability to seize more than 40% of the new<br />

Mobile Subscribers<br />

addition to the market in our forecast period. Yet, this will occur at<br />

41,272 49,277 55,680 60,803 64,901<br />

the expense of ARPU which is expected to slump from LE47.3 in FY08 Penetration Rate 52.72% 61.78% 68.51% 73.43% 76.84%<br />

to LE37 in FY12, which is mitigated through positive elasticity. Accordingly,<br />

this will permit the company to maintain its market share Mobinil<br />

net addition 10,672 8,004 6,403 5,123 4,098<br />

above 45.56% till the end of FY13.<br />

Subscribers 20,115 23,317 25,878 27,927 29,567<br />

New increments to the market will plummet going forward as we believe<br />

that the nearer the penetration rate to 80%, the smaller addition<br />

to the market due to high illiteracy rates, high living costs coupled with<br />

low per capita income, weaker desire of having mobile phones, concentration<br />

of Egyptian in narrow area, and the downside in the tourism<br />

sector due to the global financial turmoil. Hence, we project revenues<br />

to witness slower growth during our forecast period, locking in a 5-<br />

year CAGR of 5.28% in the top line figure.<br />

Based on the guidance of the company's management, tangible<br />

CAPEX will range between LE2.5 billion and LE3 billion in FY09<br />

versus LE3.44 billion as Mobinil will tend to depend on its internal financing<br />

sources due to the current strict borrowing and high cost of<br />

loans.<br />

Mobinil is preparing to takeover Link dot Net , a subsidiary of Orascom Telecom Holding. Link dot Net is a major ISP and internet<br />

company in Egypt, UAE, KSA, Pakistan and Qatar. Yet we haven't incorporated this takeover in our valuation, this merger in our<br />

view will in addition uphold mobile internet application in competition with Etisalat Misr and Vodafone Egypt which have similar<br />

operations. Our Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) model yielded a target price of LE197, translating into an upside potential of 39%<br />

Investment Rationale<br />

• High dividend yield of 10.91% in FY09 compared to our PGI dividend yield hovering at 5.1%. Global peers have an average<br />

dividend yield of 4.08%.<br />

• Its healthy EBITDA margin and the defensive nature of the industry during recession.<br />

market share 48.74% 47.32% 46.48% 45.93% 45.56%<br />

Vodafone<br />

Subscribers 17,611 20,813 23,374 25,423 27,063<br />

market share 42.67% 42.24% 41.98% 41.81% 41.70%<br />

Etisalat<br />

Subscribers 3,546 5,147 6,428 7,452 8,272<br />

market share 8.59% 10.45% 11.54% 12.26% 12.75%<br />

Source: NTRA and Prime Estimates<br />

• The ongoing arbitration case between OT and FT will have 2 scenarios, either one of the 2 parties will acquire Mobinil or a<br />

Status Quo.<br />

• When we think of the outcome of the arbitration and its effect on the share price, the above mentioned scenario is the most<br />

likely, at which time, a significant premium to the market price will be offered, while the second scenario would be a Status<br />

Quo which is doubled sided, from one side it will temporarily harm the share price due to a sell off from investors who were<br />

parking in their investment for an acquisition premium, and from one side it will entail that the 2 parties will focus on enhancing<br />

Mobinil core business and profitability as well as its market position given the heated competition in the highly unsaturated<br />

Egyptian market.<br />

Prime Research 27


PRIME PICK: EIPICO<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Target Price Market Price Recommendation Upside Potential Investment Grade<br />

LE39.2 LE25 Strong Buy<br />

56.8%<br />

Value<br />

Share Data<br />

Company Short Name<br />

Sector<br />

Company Traded Market<br />

Report Reason<br />

Valuation Methodology<br />

Previous Target<br />

Exchange Rate<br />

Stock Currency<br />

Reuters Code<br />

Stock Performance Chart<br />

(LE / Share)<br />

EIPICO<br />

Pharmaceuticals<br />

EGX<br />

<strong>Equity</strong> Strategy<br />

DCF<br />

LE46/Share<br />

LE5.55/US$<br />

LE<br />

PHAR.CA<br />

Outstanding Shares (mn) 72.124<br />

Par Value/Share (LE)<br />

Financial Year Ending<br />

LE10/Share<br />

December<br />

Mkt. Cap (LE mn) 1,727.4<br />

Weight to PAMI 0.96%<br />

Av. Daily Volume(000) (52Wk.) 60.5<br />

Price Low – High (LE) (52Wk.) 20 - 39.44<br />

Shareholders<br />

Ownership Stake<br />

ACDIMA 43.18 %<br />

Medical Union Investment 5.62 %<br />

Others 0.72 %<br />

Free Float 50.48 %<br />

45<br />

40<br />

35<br />

30<br />

Income Statement 2007a 2008a 2009e 2010f<br />

Revenues 850.2 910.1 979.3 1,077.3<br />

Growth 14% 7% 8% 10%<br />

COGS 380.2 559.2 474.7 484.8<br />

S,G & Admin. Expenses 104.7 21.8 124.5 137.0<br />

EBITDA 365.3 329.1 380.0 455.5<br />

Growth 15% -10% 15% 20%<br />

EBITDA Margin 43% 36.2% 39% 42%<br />

Depreciation & Amortization 59.4 53.1 18.5 18.5<br />

Other Provisions 30.2 32.9 27.5 33.1<br />

Operating EBIT 281.9 277.7 334.0 325.8<br />

Interest Income 16.3 20.0 7.0 39.5<br />

Investment Income 0.3 2.9 3.3 3.2<br />

Interest Expense 2.2 1.3 0.0 0.0<br />

Non-Operating Revenues 4.2 22.2 17.7 19.5<br />

Pre Tax Income 300.4 321.6 361.9 388.0<br />

Income Tax 63.5 59.3 57.1 61.2<br />

Effective Tax Rate 0% 0% 0% 0%<br />

NPAT 236.9 262.2 304.8 326.8<br />

Growth 17% 11% 16% 7%<br />

Extraordinary Items -5.0 -5.6 0.0 0.0<br />

Net Income 231.9 256.6 304.8 326.8<br />

Profit Share to Employees & Board 15.2 15.2 18.1 19.4<br />

Net Attributable Income - NAI 216.7 241.3 286.7 307.4<br />

Growth 19% 11% 19% 7%<br />

ROS 25% 27% 29% 29%<br />

Balance Sheet 2007a 2008a 2009e 2010f<br />

Cash & Marketable Securities 416.9 372.0 330.1 370.8<br />

Trade Receivables-Net 227.9 241.7 304.0 334.4<br />

Inventory 338.8 382.0 411.1 452.2<br />

Other Current Asset 27.5 33.3 35.8 39.4<br />

Total Current Asset 1,011.0 1,029.0 1,081.0 1,196.9<br />

Net Fixed Assets 308.3 334.1 516.1 633.9<br />

Projects Under Implementation 31.1 70.5 0.0 0.0<br />

Other Assets 256.7 238.2 219.7 201.2<br />

Total Assets 1,607.1 1,671.8 1,816.8 2,031.9<br />

Short Term Bank Debt 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

CPLTD 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

Accounts Payable 26.2 22.5 24.2 26.7<br />

Dividend Payable 137.4 0.0 181.5 194.6<br />

Other Current Liabilities 73.7 68.2 73.4 107.7<br />

Total Current Liabilities 237.2 90.7 279.1 329.0<br />

Long-Term Debt 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

Provisions for Deferred Taxes 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

Provisions 301.3 258.4 326.8 359.8<br />

Total Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 1,068.4 1,314.9 1,210.9 1,343.1<br />

Total Liab.& Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 1,607.1 1,671.8 1,816.8 2,031.9<br />

25<br />

20<br />

15<br />

Mar-08<br />

Apr-08<br />

May-08<br />

Jun-08<br />

Jul-08<br />

Aug-08<br />

Sep-08<br />

Oct-08<br />

Nov-08<br />

Dec-08<br />

Jan-09<br />

Feb-09<br />

Mar-09<br />

Free Cash Flow Statement 2007a 2008a 2009e 2010f<br />

NOPLAT 218.1 221.6 279.8 268.4<br />

Non-Cash Items 83.4 51.4 46.0 129.7<br />

Gross Cash Flow 301.5 273.0 325.9 398.0<br />

Gross Investments 120.8 274.3 31.7 230.9<br />

Non -Operating Cash Flow -0.6 13.5 14.9 16.4<br />

Free Cash Flow 180 12 309 184<br />

Financing Flow<br />

Interest Income After-Tax -15.9 -19.6 -6.9 -38.9<br />

Investment Income After-Tax -0.3 -2.9 -3.2 -3.2<br />

Increase in Excess Cash & M. Sec. 34.0 -52.1 -48.8 30.9<br />

After-Tax Interest Expense 1.8 1.0 0.0 0.0<br />

Decrease in Debt & Bonds 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

Provisions Used 15.2 75.8 -40.8 0.0<br />

Dividends Paid 129.8 129.9 163.4 175.2<br />

Non-Appropriation Items 15.2 15.2 18.1 19.4<br />

Shareholders <strong>Equity</strong> 0.2 -135.1 227.3 0.0<br />

Total Financing Flow 180 12 309 184<br />

Please refer to disclaimer on last page<br />

Financial Summary (Figures in LE million)<br />

Source: Company Historical & Prime Estimates<br />

Prime Research 28


PRIME PICK: EIPICO<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Meet The Drug Maker..<br />

Egyptian International Pharmaceutical Industries Company (EIPICO) is Egypt’s leading drug maker with local and export market<br />

shares of 7% and 25% respectively. EIPICO manufactures more than 190 products covering 23 therapeutic areas, including soft gelatine<br />

capsules, lyophilized products, gels, sprayers and effervescent tablets. It manufactures the products under license from multinationals,<br />

including Roche. Moreover, the company has a 33% stake in drug maker Universal Company in KSA which will be operational<br />

by 2H FY09 after finalizing Saudi authorities approvals. Moreover, the company is investing in its R&D department which will enable it<br />

to increase the number of generics which has higher margins than under license products. The company exports its products to most<br />

of the MENA region in order to escape price capping controls by the Egyptian governments.<br />

Projections & Valuation<br />

During our last meeting, the company’s management has confirmed that constructing the new factory has already began, and that<br />

the new factory will be fully operational by mid FY10. Accordingly, our current valuation assumes that the company will be able to<br />

double its capacity by FY10. The following table depicts EIPICO production in terms of Generics and Under license products. We expect<br />

EIPICO’s revenues to record LE979 million in FY09, growing steadily thereafter at a 5 years CAGR of 9%, while we lowered our<br />

target of LE271 million FY08 earnings to LE255 million. On the EBTIDA level, we expect an EBITDA of LE395 million, equating to an<br />

EBITDA margin of 43.5%.<br />

Drugs Produced 2007a 2008e 2009f 2010f 2011f 2012f<br />

EIPICO Production (Generics) 192 199 208 208 217 226<br />

Under license 61 61 61 61 61 61<br />

Total 253 260 269 269 278 287<br />

Table 75<br />

Source: EIPICO, Prime Forecasts<br />

Our DCF value for EIPICO has come down from LE46/share to LE39.2/share, reflecting our new risk free rate as well as new premium.<br />

Also, it is worth mentioning that the company has investment in Saudi Arabia which we have not accounted for in our valuation,<br />

but once the company reveals more details, we will revise our valuation upwards.<br />

Investment Rationale<br />

• Visible top line and bottom line growth given the industry characteristics which is defensive and immune from recession<br />

• The company has a strong focus on generics which enjoys higher margins and more cost efficient.<br />

• EIPICO opened a biotechnology centre in 2001 which will allow over the long term to harness biotech methods of producing raw<br />

materials used in its products, and to conduct pre-clinical and clinical trials.<br />

• Increased health awareness in the Egyptian market will increase Drug/capita expenditure<br />

• Sales and distribution network covering most of the MENA region, Romania in Europe, and Pakistan in Asia<br />

• Strong Export presence as well as recent expansion in Saudi Arabia which will allow it to escape strict price controls in the Egyptian<br />

market<br />

• Debt free, yet, the company still has a healthy cash flow to finance its expansions plans ( Doubling Capacity)<br />

• Dividends Yield of around 10% as well as a PE of 6x<br />

Prime Research 29


PRIME PICK: ORASCOM<br />

CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRIES<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Target Price Market Price Recommendation Upside Potential Investment Grade<br />

LE341 LE120 Strong Buy<br />

184%<br />

Value<br />

500<br />

450<br />

400<br />

350<br />

300<br />

250<br />

200<br />

150<br />

100<br />

50<br />

0<br />

Share Data<br />

Company Short Name<br />

Sector<br />

Company Traded Market<br />

Report Reason<br />

Valuation Methodology<br />

Previous Target<br />

Exchange Rate<br />

Stock Currency<br />

Reuters Code<br />

Stock Performance Chart (LE)<br />

(LE / Share)<br />

Please refer to disclaimer on last page<br />

OCI<br />

Construction/Fertilizers<br />

EGX<br />

<strong>Equity</strong> Strategy<br />

SOP DCF<br />

LE560<br />

LE5.55/US$<br />

LE<br />

OCIC.CA<br />

Outstanding Shares (mn) 215<br />

Par Value/Share (LE) 5<br />

Financial Year Ending<br />

December<br />

Mkt. Cap (LE bn) 25.75<br />

Av. Daily Volume (000) (52Wk.) 362.4<br />

Weight to PAMI 13.5%<br />

Price Low – High (LE) (52Wk.) 98.5 - 470<br />

Shareholders<br />

Ownership Stake<br />

Sawiras Family 55%<br />

Free Float 45%<br />

Mar-08<br />

Apr-08<br />

May-08<br />

Jun-08<br />

Jul-08<br />

Aug-08<br />

Sep-08<br />

Oct-08<br />

Nov-08<br />

Dec-08<br />

Jan-09<br />

Feb-09<br />

Income Statement 2007a 2008e 2009f 2010f<br />

Revenues 13,482 20,637 22,057 26,322<br />

Growth -18% 53% 7% 19%<br />

COGS 10,248 13,911 16,094 18,338<br />

S,G & Admin. Expenses 764 1,954 2,374 2,841<br />

Other provisions 85 127 147 173<br />

EBITDA 2,384 4,645 3,442 4,970<br />

Growth -46% 95% -26% 44%<br />

EBITDA Margin 18% 23% 16% 19%<br />

Depreciation & Amortization 924 340 758 1,233<br />

Operating EBIT 1,460 4,304 2,684 3,737<br />

Interest Income 323 292 170 182<br />

Investment Income 129 145 168 236<br />

Interest Expense 605 128 195 115<br />

Non-Operating Revenues (net) 161 123 (93) 17<br />

Pre Tax Income 1,469 4,737 2,735 4,057<br />

Pre Tax Income Growth -58% 223% -42% 48%<br />

Income Tax 82.0 947.3 546.9 616.5<br />

Effective Tax Rate 6% 20% 20% 15%<br />

NPAT 1,387 3,789 2,188 3,441<br />

Growth -59% 173% -42% 57%<br />

Extraordinary Items 64,786 1,413 - -<br />

Net Income 66,172 5,202 2,188 3,441<br />

Minority Interest 151 - - -<br />

Non-Appropriation Items - 78 33 52<br />

Net Attributable Income - NAI 66,021 5,124 2,155 3,389<br />

Growth 4071% -92% -58% 57%<br />

ROS 489.7% 24.8% 9.8% 12.9%<br />

Balance Sheet 2007a 2008e 2009f 2010f<br />

Cash & Marketable Securities 3,989 15,092 9,021 9,718<br />

Trade Receivables-Net 3,517 6,014 7,241 9,270<br />

Inventory 734 1,124 1,201 1,434<br />

Other Current Asset 81,499 2,691 3,113 3,547<br />

Total Current Asset 89,740 24,921 20,576 23,968<br />

Net Fixed Assets 3,473 8,526 13,959 17,137<br />

Other Assets 1,739 3,535 3,208 2,979<br />

Total Assets 94,952 36,981 37,742 44,084<br />

CPLTD 10,648 2,667 700 500<br />

Accounts Payable 5,525 9,109 10,606 13,673<br />

Dividend Payable 63,219 858 364 578<br />

Other Current Liabilities 852 2,892 3,346 4,071<br />

Total Current Liabilities 80,244 15,526 15,016 18,822<br />

Long-Term Debt 1,035 3,833 3,133 2,633<br />

Provisions for Deferred Taxes 103 103 103 103<br />

Provisions 2,307 2,435 2,582 2,755<br />

other Non current liabilities 586 0 0 0<br />

Minority interests 1,049 1,049 1,049 1,049<br />

Total Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 9,628 14,036 15,859 18,722<br />

Total Liab.& Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 94,952 36,981 37,742 44,084<br />

Free Cash Flow Statement 2007 2008 2009 2010<br />

NOPLAT 4,739 3,647 2,086 3,112<br />

Non-Cash Items 1,009 468 905 1,407<br />

Gross Cash Flow 5,748 4,115 2,991 4,518<br />

Gross Investments 69,623 (76,908) 5,651 3,155<br />

Non -Operating Cash Flow 61,320 1,229 (74) 15<br />

Free Cash Flow (2,555) 82,252 (2,734) 1,378<br />

Financing Flow<br />

Interest Income After-Tax (321) (286) (167) (180)<br />

Investment Income After-Tax (128) (142) (165) (232)<br />

Change in Excess Cash & Mkt. Sec. (1,178) 14,225 (6,099) 612<br />

Change in Subsidiaries and LT Investments 649 16 16 16<br />

After-Tax Interest Expense 571 102 156 98<br />

Change in Debt & Bonds (2,433) 5,183 2,667 700<br />

Provisions Used (1,711) - - -<br />

Dividends Paid & Minority Interest 151 63,141 826 313<br />

Non-Appropriation Items - 78 33 52<br />

Reserves Used 1,888 (0) - -<br />

Change in Paid-in Capital & Capital Surplus (42) (64) - -<br />

Total Financing Flow (2,555) 82,252 (2,734) 1,378<br />

Financial Summary (Figures in LE million)<br />

Source: Company Historical & Prime Estimates<br />

Prime Research 30


PRIME PICK: ORASCOM<br />

CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRIES<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Meet The Fertile Contractor<br />

Orascom Construction Industries is a leading construction contractor operating in Egypt with also strong presence in the MENA region<br />

and GCC countries along with Europe. Following its divesture of its cement line of business, the company has initiated operations in the<br />

lucrative fertilizers business to capitalize on the growing demand for fertilizers generated from agricultural crops and biofuel. OCI fertilizers’<br />

capacity comes from its operation via EFC, Sorfret, EBIC and Notore. The company has a total capacity of 3.8 million tons in<br />

FY08, expected to reach 4.6 million tons by FY11. EFC has a production capacity of 1.4mtpa of urea, but the 30% owned EBIC has a<br />

production capacity of 0.7 mtpa of ammonia and was expected to start operation late 2008. Notore Chemicals on the other hand, is<br />

20% owned subsidiary by OCI in Nigeria with a production capacity of 0.5 mtpa of urea/ammonia. Sofert Algeria is now the only company<br />

that has not started and will begin operation late 2010 with a sellable production capacity of 0.7 mtpa and 1.2 mtpa of ammonia<br />

and urea respectively.<br />

Projections & Valuation<br />

• We forecast a 53% growth in the top line figure in FY08<br />

culminating at LE20.6 billion, of which construction revenues<br />

will constitute around 83.8%. The rest of the value<br />

will mainly come from Egyptian Fertilizers Company<br />

(EFC). Going forward we forecast a 5-year CAGR of<br />

25.06% by the end of FY12 motivated by the rebound of<br />

the construction activities and fertilizers price. The fertilizers<br />

segment will capture 87% of aggregate revenues<br />

by FY12.<br />

• Looking ahead, EBITDA margin will slow down as the<br />

construction segment has low profit margin compared to<br />

the fertilizers segment. EBITDA margin will hover at 21%<br />

in FY12 compared to 23.1% in FY12 and will reach a<br />

minimum of 16.3% in FY09.<br />

• Our assumptions are based on an average price of<br />

US$522/ton for urea in FY08 and US$261/ton in FY09. As<br />

for ammonia, we used an average price of US$500 in<br />

FY08 and US$250/ton in FY09.<br />

• Based on the management's guidance, EBIC and Notore came into stream by the end of FY08 while Sofret Algeria in late FY10.<br />

However, we used a utilization rate of 0% in FY10 but 80% in FY11.<br />

• Net income in FY08 will be boosted by a capital gain from the divestment of the Egyptian Container Handling Company at<br />

US$255 million after all associated costs.<br />

Investment Rationale<br />

FY ending December 2008e 2009f 2010f 2011f<br />

mtpa<br />

EFC<br />

Urea<br />

Capacity 1.3 1.3 1.45 1.45<br />

Utilization 90% 70% 70% 80%<br />

Sorferet Algeria<br />

Urea<br />

Capacity 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.2<br />

Utilization 0.0% 0.0% 0% 80.0%<br />

Ammonia<br />

Capacity 0.7 0.7 0.7 0.7<br />

Utilization 0.0% 0.0% 0% 80.0%<br />

EBIC<br />

Ammonia<br />

Capacity 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8<br />

Utilization 10.0% 82.0% 85.0% 85.0%<br />

Nortre<br />

Urea<br />

Capacity 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5<br />

Utilization 50% 82% 85% 85%<br />

Source: OCI& Prime Estimates<br />

• OCI management has a track record on generating strong cash flows from its previous cement business as well as its ongoing<br />

construction business which has been growing annually at an average 20% for the past 5 years.<br />

• OCI will and have been always capitalizing on government expenditure plans of major infrastructure projects locally and in<br />

the GCC with the later projects estimated at around US$1.5 trillion<br />

• OCI is always focusing on high margin projects given its always capitalizing on its strong backlog which reached US$7 billion,<br />

up from US$4.8 billion in 2007<br />

• OCI enjoys a strong negotiation power in its construction contracts given the few number of contractors available, although someone<br />

might argue that construction slowdown would lead to lower negotiation power, yet, OCI contracts include revision clauses<br />

which will enable it to hedge against costs of raw materials<br />

• OCI presence in the fertilizers’ business will enable stronger cash flows once all capacities are in place by 2011, given that we<br />

forecast a rebound in fertilizers’ prices to average around US$320 from FY09-FY11<br />

• OCI recent acquisition of Gavilon, a major fertilizers distributor in US, will enable it to market its fertilizers’ products efficiently<br />

while achieving strong cost synergies given its fertilizer trade activity which is the largest independent importer of fertilizer into<br />

the US with 7.1 mt of fertilizer products<br />

Prime Research 31


PRIME PICK: EL SEWEDY CABLES<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Target Price Market Price Recommendation Upside Potential Investment Grade<br />

LE77 LE39.15 Strong Buy<br />

97% Value & Growth<br />

Share Data<br />

Company Short Name<br />

Sector<br />

Company Traded Market<br />

Report Reason<br />

Valuation Methodology<br />

Previous Target<br />

Exchange Rate<br />

Stock Currency<br />

Reuters Code<br />

Stock Performance Chart<br />

(LE / Share)<br />

SEWEDY<br />

Industrial<br />

EGX<br />

<strong>Equity</strong> Strategy<br />

DCF<br />

LE103<br />

LE5.55 /US$<br />

LE<br />

SWDY.CA<br />

Outstanding Shares (mn) 132<br />

Par Value/Share (LE) 10<br />

Financial Year Ending<br />

Mkt. Cap (LE mn)<br />

December<br />

LE5,168<br />

Weight to PGI 2.4%<br />

Av. Daily Volume(000) (52Wk.) 184<br />

Price Low – High (LE) (52Wk.)<br />

Shareholders<br />

LE28.5-146.4<br />

Ownership Stake<br />

El Sewedy Family 72.7%<br />

Others 2.30%<br />

Free float 25%<br />

Income Statement 2007a 2008e 2009f 2010f<br />

Revenues 9,377.5 9,690.0 6,306.0 8,824.7<br />

Growth 29.3% 3.3% -34.9% 39.9%<br />

COGS 8,118.7 8,141.6 4,644.4 6,998.4<br />

S,G & Admin. Expenses 295.0 304.9 252.2 264.7<br />

EBITDA 963.8 1,243.6 1,409.3 1,561.6<br />

Growth 47% 29% 13% 11%<br />

EBITDA Margin 10% 13% 22% 18%<br />

Depreciation & Amortization 83.3 118.5 333.2 371.6<br />

Other Provisions 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

Operating EBIT 880.5 1,125.1 1,076.2 1,190.0<br />

Interest Income 83.8 5.5 9.6 12.8<br />

Investment Income 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

Interest Expense 183.2 147.0 39.0 33.4<br />

Non-Operating Revenues 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

Pre Tax Income 781.2 983.6 1,046.8 1,169.3<br />

Income Tax 24.5 26.1 27.3 32.7<br />

Effective Tax Rate 3% 3% 3% 3%<br />

NPAT 756.7 957.5 1,019.5 1,136.6<br />

Growth 37% 27% 6% 11%<br />

Extraordinary Items 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

Net Income 756.7 957.5 1,019.5 1,136.6<br />

Minority Interest 25.4 32.3 45.0 47.9<br />

Net Attributable Income - NAI 724.3 912.5 971.6 1,083.2<br />

Growth 37% 26% 6% 11%<br />

ROS 8% 9% 15% 12%<br />

Balance Sheet 2007a 2008e 2009f 2010f<br />

Cash & Marketable Securities 982.4 1,207.8 1,021.3 1,418.2<br />

Trade Receivables-Net 1,374.1 1,384.4 1,081.1 1,815.5<br />

Inventory 2,074.9 2,616.3 2,333.2 2,823.9<br />

Other Current Asset 272.3 355.3 269.7 333.4<br />

Total Current Asset 4,703.7 5,563.9 4,705.3 6,391.0<br />

Net Fixed Assets 756.6 1,483.7 1,346.1 1,102.2<br />

Projects Under Implementation 414.2 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

Other Assets 377.7 578.0 519.4 518.1<br />

Total Assets 6,252.3 7,625.6 6,570.9 8,011.3<br />

Short Term Bank Debt 840.3 1,633.8 0.0 0.0<br />

CPLTD 1,420.7 28.5 85.7 85.7<br />

Accounts Payable 325.6 370.1 264.9 370.8<br />

Dividend Payable 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

Other Current Liabilities 182.3 13.3 8.6 12.1<br />

Total Current Liabilities 2,769.0 2,045.7 359.3 468.6<br />

Long-Term Debt 39.6 600.0 514.3 428.6<br />

Minority Interest 228.7 273.7 276.6 786.0<br />

Provisions 33.0 80.0 40.0 38.0<br />

Total Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 3,079.2 3,528.2 4,499.8 5,583.0<br />

Total Liab.& Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 6,252.3 7,625.6 6,570.9 8,011.3<br />

160<br />

140<br />

120<br />

100<br />

80<br />

60<br />

40<br />

20<br />

0<br />

M ar-08<br />

A pr-08<br />

May-08<br />

Jun-08<br />

Jul-08<br />

Aug-08<br />

Sep-08<br />

Oct-08<br />

Nov-08<br />

Please refer to disclaimer on last page<br />

Dec-08<br />

Jan-09<br />

Feb-09<br />

M ar-09<br />

Free Cash Flow Statement 2007a 2008e 2009f 2010f<br />

NOPLAT 858.7 1,095.2 1,047.9 1,156.4<br />

Non-Cash Items 83.3 118.5 333.2 371.6<br />

Gross Cash Flow 942.0 1,213.7 1,381.1 1,527.9<br />

Gross Investments 1,416.5 -223.3 -323.3 1,096.2<br />

Non -Operating Cash Flow 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

Free Cash Flow -474.5 1,436.9 1,704.3 431.8<br />

Financing Flow<br />

Interest Income After-Tax -83.6 -5.5 -9.6 -12.8<br />

Investment Income After-Tax 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

Increase in Excess Cash & M. Sec. -169.2 799.4 -74.3 270.9<br />

After-Tax Interest Expense 177.4 143.1 38.0 32.5<br />

Decrease in Debt & Bonds -326.1 38.3 1,662.3 85.7<br />

Dividends Paid 32.3 45.0 47.9 53.4<br />

Non-Appropriation Items 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

Total Financing Flow -474.5 1,436.9 1,704.3 431.8<br />

Financial Summary (Figures in LE million)<br />

Source: Company Historical & Prime Estimates<br />

Prime Research 32


PRIME PICK: EL SEWEDY CABLES<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Meet The Cable Manufacturer<br />

El Sewedy Cables is a leading power cable provider in Egypt and the second<br />

largest one in MENA. Sewedy Cables operations are basically divided into<br />

power cables , electrical appliance, comprehensive turnkey projects<br />

and wind energy projects. El Sewedy Cables market share is<br />

over 56% based on sales revenues. Sewedy Cables enjoys a vertically<br />

integrated model of producing power and special cables and cable related<br />

products and services. Operations are divided into four segments as follow:<br />

1) Wire & Cable which produces wire cables, special cables and winding<br />

wires, as well as raw materials used in cable production such as copper<br />

wire and plastic and polypropylene filler.<br />

2) Electrical Products which produces cable accessories such as modular<br />

terminators, power cable joins and transformers, as well as other<br />

products such as fiber glass and concrete poles for street lighting<br />

3) Turnkey projects which implements cable related infrastructure projects<br />

to meet the needs of major infrastructure projects.<br />

4) Latest addition is Wind energy to capitalize on the government plans<br />

if rolling out wind energy as a replacement of normal energy sources<br />

Projections & Valuation<br />

Sewedy Cables capacity is expected to increase from the current 232.6k<br />

tons/annum to 262.4k tons in 2010.<br />

• Total Revenues surged by 25% to reach LE8.9 billion in 9M FY08<br />

compared to LE7.2 billion in the comparable period last year. We expect<br />

total revenues to decline by 32% from LE9.7 billion in FY08 to<br />

LE6.3 billion in FY09. Going forward, top line figure is expected<br />

to grow at a 5 year CAGR of 3.7%.<br />

• Revenues of power cables segment contributed 81.4% of total<br />

revenues in 9M FY08. We expect revenues of power cables to reach<br />

LE6.5 billion in FY08 backed by 1) the increase in the company’s<br />

production capacity from 124k tons in FY07 to 232k tons in<br />

FY08. 2) The increase in selling prices of both copper and aluminum<br />

to record an average of US$7,000/ton and US$2,000/<br />

ton respectively in FY08. It is worth mentioning that the company’s production capacity is expected to witness an expansion in copper<br />

to reach 137.5k tons in FY08, up from 68.7k tons in FY07. In addition, aluminum production capacity is expected to increase<br />

by 79% from 35.4k tons in FY07 to 63.5k tons in FY08. We estimated that the company will operate at 85% utilization rate,<br />

therefore, total sales volume is expected to increase by 63% to reach 164k tons. Going forward, we expect that total production capacity<br />

to increase to 253k tons in FY09 and revenues of power cables and raw material segment to record LE5.1 billion. The decline in<br />

revenues of this segment can be attributed to the expected decline in selling prices of both copper and aluminum in FY09 to US$3200/<br />

ton and US$1500/ton respectively. Going forward, Revenues from this segment is expected to grow at a 5 year CAGR of approximately<br />

7%.<br />

• Revenues from Electrical products are expected to record LE858.6 million in FY08, up from LE222 million last year. Revenues from<br />

this segment are expected to decline to LE623 million in FY09. Going forward, we expect this segment to contribute approximately 9%<br />

of total revenues and to grow at a 5 year CAGR of 16.45%.<br />

• EBITDA margin is expected to increase to 12% in FY08, up from 10% in FY07. Going forward, EBITDA margin is assumed at<br />

22% in FY09 backed by the increase in production volume with the expansion plan in Libya and Qatar. Net income figure is expected<br />

to grow by 26% to reach LE912 Million in FY08. The bottom line is assumed to increase by 18% in FY09 to reach LE971 Million. Going<br />

forward, we expect net income figure to grow at a 5 year CAGR of 8.3%<br />

• Utilizing a WACC of 17.9% and growth rate of 3%, our DCF value culminate at LE77/share, illustrating 97% upside potential over the<br />

current market price of LE39.15/share.<br />

Investment Rationale:<br />

• Strong Fundamentals generated from a Sound Management with Visible business plans (Cables Expansion Capacity / Entry Wind Energy)<br />

• High Industry Barriers which will help maintain El Sewedy Market Position<br />

• El Sewedy Operations are mostly available in low competition markets<br />

Production Capacities<br />

In Tons 2008a 2009f 2010f<br />

Egypt<br />

Copper 63,600 63,600 63,600<br />

Aluminum 40,000 50,600 50,600<br />

Total 103,600 114,200 114,200<br />

y-o-y % 32.82% 10.23% 0.00%<br />

Sudan<br />

Copper 4,200 4,200 4,200<br />

Aluminum 6,000 6,000 6,000<br />

Total 10,200 10,200 10,200<br />

y-o-y % 13.33% 0.00% 0.00%<br />

Syria<br />

Copper 25,500 25,500 25,500<br />

Aluminum 3,600 3,600 3,600<br />

Total 29,100 29,100 29,100<br />

y-o-y % 70.18% 0.00% 0.00%<br />

Libya<br />

Copper 11,200 19,800 19,800<br />

Aluminum 2,400 2,400 2,520<br />

Total 13,600 22,200 22,320<br />

y-o-y % 63.24% 0.54%<br />

Saudi<br />

Copper 26,000 26,000 26,000<br />

Aluminum 7,500 7,500 7,500<br />

Total 33,500 33,500 33,500<br />

y-o-y % 0.00% 0.00%<br />

UIC<br />

Special Cables 15,600 15,600 15,600<br />

Winding Wires 16,000 16,000 16,000<br />

Total 31,600 31,600 31,600<br />

y-o-y % 53.85% 0.00% 0.00%<br />

New Cables<br />

Copper 7,000 17,500 17,500<br />

Aluminum 4,000 4,000 4,000<br />

Total 11,000 21,500 21,500<br />

y-o-y % 95.45% 8.20%<br />

El Sewedy Cables & Prime Estimates<br />

• El Sewedy long term operations will always capitalize on governments infrastructure projects which are expected to increase in order to<br />

stimulate economies<br />

• Strong Revenue Stream addition once Wind Energy revenues kick off.<br />

Prime Research 33


PRIME PICK: TALAAT MOUSTAFA<br />

GROUP (TMG)<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Target Price Market Price Recommendation Upside Potential Investment Grade<br />

LE10.27 LE2.72 Strong Buy<br />

277%<br />

Growth<br />

Share Data<br />

Company Short Name<br />

Sector<br />

Company Traded Market<br />

Report Reason<br />

Valuation Methodology<br />

Previous Target<br />

Exchange Rate<br />

Stock Currency<br />

Reuters Code<br />

Stock Performance Chart<br />

(LE / Share)<br />

TMG<br />

Housing<br />

EGX<br />

<strong>Equity</strong> Strategy<br />

DCF<br />

LE15<br />

LE5.55 /US$<br />

LE<br />

TMGH.CA<br />

Outstanding Shares (bn) 2.03<br />

Par Value/Share (LE) 10<br />

Financial Year Ending<br />

Mkt. Cap (LE bn)<br />

December<br />

LE5.5<br />

Weight to PAMI 3%<br />

Av. Daily Volume (000) (52Wk.) 9,242<br />

Price Low – High (LE) (52Wk.) LE2.3 - 13.57<br />

Shareholders<br />

TMG for Touristic and Real<br />

Estate Investment<br />

Ownership Stake<br />

49.85%<br />

Misr Insurance Company 4.43%<br />

Banque Misr 2.66%<br />

National Insurance Company of<br />

Egypt<br />

0.23%<br />

National Bank of Egypt 0.37%<br />

Other Investors 22.96%<br />

Free Float 19.50%<br />

14<br />

12<br />

10<br />

8<br />

6<br />

4<br />

2<br />

0<br />

Mar-08<br />

Apr-08<br />

May-08<br />

Jun-08<br />

Jul-08<br />

Aug-08<br />

Sep-08<br />

Oct-08<br />

Nov-08<br />

Dec-08<br />

Jan-09<br />

Feb-09<br />

Mar-09<br />

Income Statement 2007a 2008a 2009f 2010f<br />

Revenues 1,876 5,421 5,976 9,944<br />

Growth 307% 189% 10% 66%<br />

COGS 1,025 3,493 2,796 3,927<br />

S,G & Admin. Expenses 267 146 268 385<br />

EBITDA 583.7 1781.2 2911.5 5631.7<br />

Growth 9.1 2.1 0.6 0.9<br />

EBITDA Margin 31% 33% 49% 57%<br />

Depreciation & Amortization 58 103 101 119<br />

Operating EBIT 584 1,660 2,802 5,488<br />

Interest Income 78.3 128.2 59.8 49.7<br />

Investment Income 0 48 4 3<br />

Interest Expense 14 12 8 6<br />

Non-Operating Revenues 62 33 0 0<br />

Pre Tax Income 707 1,856 2,857 5,535<br />

Pre Tax Income Growth 1154% 151% 44% 89%<br />

Income Tax 46 196 463 1,007<br />

Effective Tax Rate 6% 11% 16% 18%<br />

NPAT 661 1,660 2,395 4,528<br />

Growth 1154% 151% 44% 89%<br />

Extraordinary Items 501.5 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

Net Income 1,737 1,660 2,395 4,528<br />

Profit Share to Employees & Board 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

Net Attributable Income - NAI 1,341 1,442 2,107 3,984<br />

Growth 872% 8% 46% 89%<br />

ROS 71% 27% 35% 40%<br />

Balance Sheet 2007a 2008a 2009f 2010f<br />

Cash & Marketable Securities 4465.5 1505.3 2019.1 6801.6<br />

Trade Receivables-Net 1730.6 3296.4 2465.7 4317.5<br />

Inventory 4013.8 10357.7 14976.4 15679.6<br />

Other Current Asset 716.4 3041.9 3353.5 5580.0<br />

Total Current Asset 10,960 18,203 22,816 32,380<br />

Net Fixed Assets 2555.3 3798.1 9221.7 9868.7<br />

Projects Under Implementation 284.6 384.6 697.9 802.2<br />

Other Assets 4754.4<br />

Total Assets 42,981 53,800 49,855 55,636<br />

Short Term Bank Debt 51.8 110.9 0.0 0.0<br />

CPLTD 357.1 513.5 316.7 332.5<br />

Accounts Payable 301.8 457.6 504.5 839.4<br />

Dividend Payable 0.0 2.0 0.0 0.0<br />

Other Current Liabilities 1068.8 1426.8 1284.2 1155.7<br />

Total Current Liabilities 3819.0 9876.6 8763.0 9608.9<br />

Long-Term Debt 1706.9 1296.0 950.0 633.3<br />

Provisions for Deferred Taxes 3.3 11.9 1.4 1.4<br />

Provisions 6.0 48.2 44.7 49.9<br />

Total Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 21,824 21,954 24,932 28,717<br />

Total Liab.& Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 42,981 53,800 49,855 55,636<br />

Free Cash Flow Statement 2007a 2008a 2009f 2010f<br />

NOPLAT 613.0 1476.0 2328.9 4481.0<br />

Non-Cash Items 0.1 121.5 109.3 143.7<br />

Gross Cash Flow 613.0 1597.5 2438.1 4624.7<br />

Gross Investments 19655.7 -648.9 2730.8 -1448.1<br />

Non -Operating Cash Flow 1061.3 29.7 0.0 0.0<br />

Free Cash Flow -17,981 2,276 -293 6,073<br />

Financing Flow<br />

Interest Income After-Tax -77.8 -126.9 -58.8 -48.8<br />

Investment Income After-Tax 0.0 -47.0 -3.6 -3.2<br />

Increase in Excess Cash & M. Sec. 894.4 -885.7 734.2 4983.3<br />

After-Tax Interest Expense 12.8 11.2 6.9 5.1<br />

Decrease in Debt & Bonds -642.8 195.5 653.7 300.8<br />

Dividends Paid 415.3 215.6 289.4 543.3<br />

Non-Appropriation Items 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0<br />

Total Financing Flow -17,981 2,276 -293 6,073<br />

Please refer to disclaimer on last page<br />

Financial Summary (Figures in LE million)<br />

Source: Company Historical & Prime Estimates<br />

Prime Research 34


PRIME PICK: TALAAT MOUSTAFA<br />

GROUP (TMG)<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Meet The Developer..<br />

TMG is the largest real estate developer in Egypt with total land area of 49.6 million m2.<br />

TMG operations are broken down into Real estate projects include commercial, educational<br />

and recreational facilities, as well as Hospitality business. Total consolidated<br />

revenues recorded LE5.4 billion in FY08 compared to LE1.8 billion in FY07, with<br />

revenues from units sold recording LE4.7 billion (representing 88% of total revenues)<br />

while revenues from hotels and services activities contributed the remaining 12%. Said<br />

increase can be attributed to recognition of revenues associated with delivery of units in<br />

Madinaty project. Going forward, We expect a slow down in sales in FY09 and FY10. Top<br />

line figure is estimated to grow at a 5 year CAGR of 19%. TMG posted EBITDA margin of<br />

31% in FY08 which is expected to increase to 34% in FY09 as the increase in recognized<br />

revenues will outpace that of COGS.<br />

Projections & Valuation<br />

The slowdown in the real estate sector coupled with market saturation with regard to the<br />

high end, makes us believe that TMG will face a slowdown in the sales of its main projects<br />

namely Madinaty and Al Rehab. Therefore, we estimated total sales for Madianty and Al<br />

Rehab of LE2.4 billion and LE1.1 billion respectively in FY09.<br />

We believe that shrinking in Tourism activity will affect negatively on Hotel revenues. Accordingly,<br />

we expect a decline in average rate per room by 10% and average occupancy<br />

rate is estimated at 30% . In addition, Marsa Alam project is assumed to be postponed to<br />

FY10.<br />

The slow down in the world economy will hinder TMG’s ability to expand in the region.<br />

Therefore, Saudi Arabia Projects are expected to be postponed until the end of FY10.<br />

Our Sum of the parts (SOTP) value for TMG culminated at LE10.26/share, which<br />

illustrates upside potential of 277% compared to the last market share of LE2.72. With<br />

Madinty and Al Rehab projects contribute approximately 39% and 25%, respectively of<br />

the total value.<br />

Company Land (LE 000s)<br />

City Community & Complexes<br />

TMG Stake<br />

of Value<br />

Rabwa II 1,043,990<br />

Rehab I 6,356<br />

Rehab II 5,245,549<br />

San Stefano (Residential & Commercial)<br />

2,000,768<br />

Thabat 1,624,999<br />

Madinaty 8,202,295<br />

C&C Sum of the Part Value 18,123,957<br />

Hotels & Resorts (ICON)<br />

Four Seasons San Stefano (Hotel) 41,494<br />

Four Seasons Sharm El Sheikh 369,157<br />

Marsa Alam 152,854<br />

Four Season Nile Plaza 753,240<br />

Nile Hotel 63,552<br />

H&R Sum of the Part Value 1,380,297<br />

Alexandria Real Estate Inv.<br />

(Marketing Segment)<br />

1,336,106<br />

TMG Sum of the Part Value 20,840,360<br />

Source: Prime Estimates<br />

Revenues by Project (LE 000s) 2009f 2010f 2011f<br />

Rehab I 504,551 555,007 610,507<br />

Rehab I phase VI & Commercial 345,783 16,248 25,111<br />

Rehab II 1,908,500 1,470,345 1,128,784<br />

Madinaty 1,527,150 5,447,785 3,360,897<br />

Al Rabwa 215,771 278,578 234,891<br />

San Stefano Reseditions & Commercial 205,440 1,042,385 235,000<br />

Four Seasons San Stefano (Hotel) 71,492 109,387 237,845<br />

Four Seasons Sharm El Sheikh 588,638 311,720 377,561<br />

Marsa Alam 118,125 147,000 156,188<br />

Four Season Nile Plaza 406,382 463,626 529,241<br />

Nile Hotel 84,230 101,826 122,673<br />

Consolidated Revenue 5,976,063 9,943,906 7,018,698<br />

Source: Prime Estimates<br />

Investment Rationale<br />

Negative sentiment on real estate and Tourism slowdown, coupled with negative news on former TMG CEO, have caused sharp decline<br />

in TMG stock price to reach around LE2-3 during the last period. Now that valuations are compelling given multiples of 0.2x P/B<br />

and P/E of 2.5x FY09 earnings, we recommend TMG for the long term due to the following:<br />

• Diversification of earnings inflows among residential, commercial, recreational facilities, and hospitality business.<br />

• More negative news on former CEO is unlikely to be negative on the stock since the market has already discounted it, on the<br />

contrary, positive news would be a strong upward share driver<br />

• TMG is the only listed real estate developer offering lower to medium class housing units which is the tranche that composes<br />

most of the pent up demand<br />

• Following its IPO in August 2007, TMG share price hasn't taken its upward movement such as most of housing stocks during last<br />

upward cycle for housing , which will probably occur during the next upward cycle.<br />

Prime Research 35


PRIME PICK: EFG-HERMES<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Target Price Market Price Recommendation Upside Potential Investment Grade<br />

LE19 LE12.46 Strong Buy<br />

60.5%<br />

Value<br />

Share Data<br />

Company Short Name<br />

Sector<br />

Company Traded Market<br />

Report Reason<br />

Valuation Methodology<br />

Previous Target<br />

Exchange Rate<br />

Stock Currency<br />

Reuters Code<br />

Stock Performance Chart<br />

(LE / Share)<br />

EFG - Hermes<br />

Financial Sector<br />

EGX<br />

<strong>Equity</strong> Strategy<br />

DCF<br />

LE77/Share<br />

LE5.55/US$<br />

LE<br />

HRHO.CA<br />

Outstanding Shares (mn) 387.9<br />

Par Value/Share (LE) 5<br />

Financial Year Ending<br />

December<br />

Mkt. Cap (LE mn) 4,833<br />

Weight to PAMI 5.2%<br />

Av. Daily Volume(000) (52Wk.) 1,694<br />

Price Low – High (LE) (52Wk.) 12.5 - 61.96<br />

Shareholders<br />

Ownership Stake<br />

Dubai Financial <strong>Group</strong> 25.0%<br />

Abu Dhabi Investment Authority 8.7%<br />

EFG Employee Trust 5.0%<br />

GDRs 8.7%<br />

Free Float 15.5%<br />

Institutional & Regional Investors 37.1%<br />

70<br />

60<br />

50<br />

40<br />

30<br />

20<br />

10<br />

0<br />

Mar-08<br />

Apr-08<br />

May-08<br />

Jun-08<br />

Jul-08<br />

Aug-08<br />

Sep-08<br />

Oct-08<br />

Nov-08<br />

Dec-08<br />

Jan-09<br />

Feb-09<br />

Mar-09<br />

Income Statement 2007a 2008a 2009f 2010f<br />

Revenues 1,719.6 1,620.1 1,022.0 1,513.1<br />

Growth 91.4% -5.8% -36.9% 48.1%<br />

Other Revenues 353.6 199.4 119.5 168.0<br />

S,G & Admin. Expenses 799.1 887.5 556.8 853.6<br />

Other Provisions 109.4 42.3 27.9 40.2<br />

EBITDA 1,164.7 889.7 556.8 787.3<br />

Growth 92.8% -23.6% -37.4% 41.4%<br />

EBITDA Margin 67.7% 54.9% 54.5% 52.0%<br />

Depreciation & Amortization 22.8 130.8 76.6 91.7<br />

Operating EBIT 1,141.9 758.8 480.3 695.6<br />

Interest Income 246.3 187.1 169.4 177.1<br />

Investment Income 287.5 327.6 403.0 463.5<br />

Interest Expense 38.1 64.5 42.6 37.0<br />

Non-Operating Revenues 0.0 -116.9 -73.7 -109.1<br />

Pre Tax Income 1,637.6 1,092.3 936.4 1,190.1<br />

Pre Tax Income Growth 96% -33% -14% 27%<br />

Income Tax 210.8 101.4 86.9 110.5<br />

Effective Tax Rate 13% 9% 9% 9%<br />

NPAT 1,426.8 990.9 849.4 1,079.6<br />

Growth 95.1% -30.6% -14.3% 27.1%<br />

Extraordinary Items -33.6 2.2 0.0 0.0<br />

Minority Interest 111.9 59.6 51.0 64.8<br />

Net Income Post Minority Interest 1,281.2 933.5 798.4 1,014.8<br />

Profit Share 23.8 0.0 16.0 20.3<br />

Net Attributable Income - NAI 1,257.5 933.5 782.5 994.5<br />

Growth 81.6% -25.8% -16.2% 27.1%<br />

ROS 73.1% 57.6% 76.6% 65.7%<br />

Balance Sheet 2007a 2008a 2009f 2010f<br />

Cash & Marketable Securities 4,841.1 3,101.7 4,106.7 4,788.9<br />

Trade Receivables-Net 2,588.1 476.1 342.4 420.3<br />

Other Current Asset 461.2 739.7 454.7 575.0<br />

Total Current Asset 7,890.3 4,317.5 4,903.8 5,784.1<br />

Net Fixed Assets 135.2 168.4 164.0 187.9<br />

Other Assets 5,399.9 6,094.9 6,278.9 6,731.4<br />

Total Assets 13,426 10,581 11,347 12,703<br />

Short Term Bank Debt 0.0 0.3 0.0 0.0<br />

CPLTD 58.7 37.7 38.0 38.0<br />

Dividend Payable 387.9 186.2 95.8 223.2<br />

Other Current Liabilities 3,563.1 1,484.5 921.8 1,269.1<br />

Total Current Liabilities 4,009.6 1,708.8 1,055.6 1,530.3<br />

Long-Term Debt 131.3 91.1 72.9 58.3<br />

Provisions 169.2 153.2 181.1 221.3<br />

Other Non Current Liabilities 184.7 842.0 893.0 957.8<br />

Total Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 8,930.8 7,785.8 9,144.2 9,935.7<br />

Total Liab.& Shareholders' <strong>Equity</strong> 13,426 10,581 11,347 12,703<br />

Free Cash Flow Statement 2007a 2008a 2009f 2010f<br />

NOPLAT 928.7 665.7 387.8 577.4<br />

Non-Cash Items 132.2 173.2 104.4 132.0<br />

Gross Cash Flow 1,061.0 838.8 492.3 709.4<br />

Gross Investments 419.8 251.0 -78.2 230.8<br />

Non -Operating Cash Flow -29.3 -104.0 -66.9 -99.0<br />

Free Cash Flow 612 484 504 380<br />

Financing Flow<br />

Interest Income After-Tax -243.1 -185.4 -167.8 -175.5<br />

Investment Income After-Tax -283.8 -324.6 -399.3 -459.2<br />

Increase in Excess Cash & M. Sec. 1,004.6 -1,523.6 1,432.4 805.5<br />

After-Tax Interest Expense 33.2 58.5 38.6 33.5<br />

Decrease in Debt & Bonds 37.4 60.8 18.3 14.6<br />

Provisions Used 7.5 58.3 0.0 0.0<br />

Dividends Paid 402.8 447.5 221.2 140.3<br />

Non-Appropriation Items 23.8 0.0 16.0 20.3<br />

Shareholders <strong>Equity</strong> -370.5 1,892.3 -655.8 0.0<br />

Total Financing Flow 612 484 504 380<br />

Please refer to disclaimer on last page<br />

Financial Summary (Figures in LE million)<br />

Source: Company Historical & Prime Estimates<br />

Prime Research 36


PRIME PICK: EFG-HERMES<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Meet The Broker’s business at FY09 P/E of 1.6x<br />

EFG Hermes is the largest Investment bank in Egypt with local and regional exposure. The company has fully fledged branches in<br />

Egypt and UAE as well as initiated operations via newly acquired brokerage licenses in Saudi Arabia and Qatar, Kuwait, and Oman.<br />

Moreover, the company has a direct stake in Audi bank and indirect stake in Egyptian real estate developer SODIC. EFG-<br />

Hermes enjoys healthy market shares in most markets it operates in. Latest market shares records a 26% in Egypt, 20% in Kuwait,<br />

24% in Oman, 26% in UAE and finally around 1.2% in Saudi Arabia.<br />

According to FY08 results, the company has hit a roadblock due to drastic market conditions originated from the credit crisis. Fee<br />

and commission income declined 5.8% to LE1.62 billion in 2008 down for LE1.72 billion in 2007. Prop. and principal<br />

trading contributed a positive LE352 million in 2007 and a negative LE84 million in 2008.<br />

Substantial decline occurred in margin trading facilities to clients from a peak of US$250 million during the year to approximately<br />

US$30 million without meaningful losses, resulting in the decline of gross receivables from LE2.6 billion in 2007 to LE958 million in<br />

2008. As of December 2008, interest earning cash stood at US$500 million, excluding investments in Banque Audi, SODIC, Nile City,<br />

seed capital in EFG-Hermes managed funds and shares purchased under the new Management Incentive Scheme or for cancellation.<br />

By 2008 year end, EFG-Hermes has taken measures to reduce total operating expenses going forward. These measures included<br />

redundancies, salary reductions for the top 200 employees, the implementation of a new expense policy and the relocation of certain<br />

functions to Egypt, all of which should lead to a meaningful decline in operating expense.<br />

Projections and Valuation<br />

2009 already started with 3 months through and average daily<br />

values have declined substantially in almost all markets. For<br />

instance, Egypt, its 32% contributor to its top line, has<br />

declined in average daily value from over LE1.3 billion to<br />

around LE800 billion. This was caused by a lot of factors as<br />

discussed in our stock market part, accordingly, we expect the company<br />

in 2009 to witness another 36% decline backed by our assumptions<br />

that average daily values will stagnate or partially<br />

improve starting Q4 FY09. On the asset management front, we<br />

expect the company, given the management previous track record, to<br />

be able to re-collect its lost AUMs due to redemptions, however,<br />

we expect no performance fees in 2009. Investment banking closed 8<br />

deals in 2008 with an average value per transaction of around LE1.6<br />

billion, we don’t expect much improvements in 2009 for investment<br />

banking due to the current market conditions, however, a re-bounce is<br />

expected by 2010 where deals in the pipe line awaiting market improvements<br />

get closed. We value EFG using SOP DCF methodology<br />

where we arrived at a total equity value of LE7.5 billion, implying<br />

LE19/share, including its investments in SODIC, Audi Bank and its<br />

Net cash position.<br />

Investment Rationale<br />

We are basically attracted to EFG-Hermes stock price due to the value<br />

it offers through its investments.<br />

EFG-Hermes has stakes in SODIC and Audi Bank, with the prevailing<br />

market prices of EFG, Audi, and SODIC, along with a Net Cash position<br />

of LE1.2 billion, investment and cash seem to be representing<br />

65% of EFG market CAP, suggesting that the market sees<br />

EFG brokerage business at LE4.2 with FY09 implied PE of<br />

1.6x, or the market thinks that EFG investments will erode EFG<br />

main business , which we refute, since we see AUDI contributing<br />

positively to EFG income statement, as well as SODIC recording sales<br />

starting 2010 and 2011. Accordingly, despite of the negative sentiment<br />

on brokerage business, we find it very cheap to buy EFG main<br />

business at a PE of 1.6x, and will probably result in a huge upside<br />

before markets rebounds given that stocks such as EFG are leading<br />

cycle players.<br />

Revenue Breakdown<br />

(LE mn)<br />

2007 2008 2009f 2010f<br />

Brokerage-Egypt 434.0 545.0 280.1 287.6<br />

growth 28.0% 25.6% -48.6% 2.7%<br />

contrib 25.2% 33.6% 27.4% 19.0%<br />

Brokerage-UAE 137.0 150.0 151.1 152.1<br />

growth 174.0% 9.5% 0.7% 0.7%<br />

contrib 8.0% 9.3% 14.8% 10.1%<br />

Brokerage-KSA 9.0 35.0 51.5 67.2<br />

growth 0 288.9% 47.0% 30.7%<br />

contrib 0.5% 2.2% 5.0% 4.4%<br />

Brokerage-Kse 0.0 40.0 20.9 21.8<br />

growth 0 0.0% -47.8% 4.5%<br />

contrib 0.0% 2.5% 2.0% 1.4%<br />

Brokerage-Oman 0.0 21.0 11.3 12.2<br />

growth 0 0.0% -46.1% 7.8%<br />

contrib 0.0% 1.0% 0.6% 0.6%<br />

Asset Mgmt (<strong>Equity</strong>) 225.00 413.24 121.18 442.44<br />

growth 309% 84% -71% 265%<br />

contrib 13.1% 25.5% 11.9% 29.2%<br />

Asset Mgmt (Money<br />

Mkt)<br />

286.00 80.76 113.67 177.88<br />

growth 1582% -72% 41% 56%<br />

contrib 16.6% 5.0% 11.1% 11.8%<br />

Inv.Banking 451 232 152 256<br />

growth 23.9% -48.6% -34.4% 68.0%<br />

contrib 26.2% 14.3% 14.9% 16.9%<br />

Private <strong>Equity</strong> 177.0 150.0 120.0 96.0<br />

growth 121% -15% -20% -20%<br />

contrib 10.3% 9.3% 11.7% 6.3%<br />

Total Revenues 1,719.0 1,620.0 1,021.9 1,513.0<br />

91.0% -5.8% -36.9% 48.1%<br />

Source: Prime Estimates<br />

Prime Research 37


2009 EQUITY STRATEGY<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

Stock Recommendation Guidelines<br />

Recommendation<br />

Target-to-Market Price (x)<br />

Strong Buy x > 25%<br />

Buy 15% < x Average LCY IBOR<br />

Quality Earnings Reflect Above Normal Risk Factor<br />

Prime Research<br />

38


2009 EQUITY STRATEGY<br />

10 March 2009<br />

Egypt<br />

PRIME EGYPT SALES TEAM<br />

Yasmine Guindy<br />

+202 3300 5666 <br />

yguindi@egy.primegroup.org<br />

<br />

Ramy El Agamy (25 lines)<br />

relagamy@egy.primegroup.org<br />

PRIME UAE SALES TEAM<br />

Shawkat Raslan +971-2-6910713 sraslan@uae.primegroup.org<br />

Sara Shaheed +971-4-4070115 sshaheed@uae.primegroup.org<br />

Ahmad Hamdi +971-2-6910701 ahamdi@uae.primegroup.org<br />

Mohamed Kamal +971-4-4070108 mkamal@uae.primegroup.org<br />

Mohamed Khaled Hafez +971-4-4070102 mkhaled@uae.primegroup.org<br />

PRIME EGYPT RESEARCH<br />

Mohamed Seddiek Senior Analyst, Acting Head +202 3300 5720 mseddiek@egy.primegroup.org<br />

Rehab Taha, CFA Senior Analyst +202 3300 5724 rtaha@egy.primegroup.org<br />

Monette Doss Senior Analyst +202 3300 5726 mdoss@egy.primegroup.org<br />

Ahmed Hindawy Analyst +202 3300 5719 aelhindawy@egy.primegroup.org<br />

Karim Osman Analyst +202 3300 5716 kosman@egy.primegroup.org<br />

Radwa Abulnaga Analyst +202 3300 5718 rabulnaga@egy.primegroup.org<br />

Hind Panicker Junior Analyst +202 3300 5727 hpanicker@egy.primegroup.org<br />

Nihal Zaki, CFTe Technical Analyst +202 3300 5725 nzaki@egy.primegroup.org<br />

Heba Monir Database Administrator +202 3300 5722 hmonir@egy.primegroup.org<br />

PRIME UAE RESEARCH<br />

Usman Rauf Senior Analyst +971-2-6910 756 urauf@uae.primegroup.org<br />

Angad Rajpal Senior Analyst +971-4-407 0119 arajpal@uae.primegroup.org<br />

Mostafa Maghraby Junior Analyst +971-4-407 0116 mmaghraby@uae.primegroup.org<br />

Dheeraj Lakhwani Junior Analyst +971-4-407 0117 dlakhwani@uae.primegroup.org<br />

Sleiman Aboulhosn Junior Analyst +971-4-407 0118 saboulhosn@uae.primegroup.org<br />

HEAD OFFICE<br />

PRIME SECURITIES S.A.E.<br />

Regulated by CMA license no. 179<br />

Members of the Cairo Stock Exchange<br />

2 Wadi El Nil St., Liberty Tower,<br />

7th-8th Floor, Mohandessin, Giza, Egypt<br />

Tel: +202 33005700/770/650/649<br />

Fax: +202 3760 7543<br />

PRIME EMIRATES LLC. (UAE)<br />

Members of the ADX and DFM<br />

Shiekh Zayed 1st Street, Khaldiyah, Abu Dhabi, UAE, PO Box 60355<br />

Tel: +971 2 6910800 Fax: +971 2 6670907<br />

Email: research@primegroup.org<br />

Disclaimer<br />

Information included in this report has no regard to specific investment objectives, financial situation, advices or particular needs of the report users.<br />

The report is published for information purposes only and is not to be construed as a solicitation or an offer to buy or sell any securities or related<br />

financial instruments. Unless specifically stated otherwise, all price information is only considered as indicator.<br />

No express or implied representation or guarantee is provided with respect to completeness, accuracy or reliability of information included in this<br />

report.<br />

Past performance is not necessarily an indication of future results. Fluctuation of foreign currency rates of exchange may adversely affect the value,<br />

price or income of any products mentioned in this report.<br />

Information included in this report should not be regarded by report users as a substitute for the exercise of their own due diligence and analysis<br />

based on own assessment and judgment criteria. Any opinions given are subject to change without notice and may significantly differ or be contrary<br />

to opinions expressed by other Prime business areas as a result of using different assumptions and criteria. Prime <strong>Group</strong> is under no obligation<br />

responsible to update or keep current the information contained herein.<br />

Prime <strong>Group</strong>, its directors, officers, employees or clients may have or have had interests or long or short positions in the securities and/or currencies<br />

referred to herein, and may at any time make purchases and/or sales in them as principal or agent.<br />

Prime <strong>Group</strong>, its related entities, directors, employees and agents accepts no liability whatsoever for any loss or damage of any kind arising from the<br />

use of all or part of these information included in this report. Certain laws and regulations impose liabilities which cannot be disclaimed. This disclaimer<br />

shall, in no way, constitute a waiver or limitation of any rights a person may have under such laws and/or regulations.<br />

Furthermore, Prime <strong>Group</strong> or any of the group companies may have or have had a relationship with or may provide or have provided other services,<br />

within its objectives to the relevant companies.<br />

Copyright 2009 Prime <strong>Group</strong> all rights reserved. You are hereby notified that distribution and copying of this document is strictly prohibited without<br />

the prior approval of Prime <strong>Group</strong>.<br />

Prime Research 39


Asset Management<br />

Investment banking<br />

securities brokerage<br />

investment research<br />

Egypt - Head Office<br />

2, Wadi El Nil St., Liberty Tower<br />

Mohandseen, Giza, Egypt.<br />

Tel: +202-33005700 - 33005770<br />

Fax: +202-33054611 - 33054569<br />

Heliopolis - Office<br />

17 Ahram st. Heliopolis,<br />

Cairo, Egypt.<br />

Tel: +202-22914260<br />

Fax: +202-22914261<br />

Abu Dhabi - Head Office<br />

Zayed1st St., - Khalidiya<br />

P.O. Box # 60355, Abu Dhabi, UAE.<br />

Tel: +9712-6910800<br />

Fax: +9712-6670907<br />

Dubai - Office<br />

Office No. 1100 Mezzanine Floor<br />

Mitsubishi Show Room<br />

Al Quoz, Sheikh Zayed Road<br />

P.O. Box # 213731, Dubai, UAE.<br />

Tel: +9714-4070100<br />

Fax: +9714-3388798

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!