Download pdf - aagbi
Download pdf - aagbi
Download pdf - aagbi
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Volume 6 Number 2 September 2002 ISSN 1472-8820<br />
World Anaesthesia<br />
news<br />
In this issue<br />
Focus on Education<br />
– Training the trainers<br />
– The Beer Sheva Project<br />
Case Histories<br />
A surgeon’s experience in Tibet<br />
The management of neuroparalytic<br />
poisoning<br />
News from<br />
around the world<br />
A letter from Ethiopia<br />
Return to Cambodia<br />
40 years of Anaesthesia in Mongolia
Welcome<br />
to World Anaesthesia News<br />
The World Federation of Societies of Anaesthesiologists (WFSA) is<br />
committed to providing safe anaesthesia for all. To this end, over many<br />
years, increasing amounts of money have been spent on supporting<br />
educational activities around the globe. Training centres have been<br />
established and supported in Thailand, Israel, Ghana and Chile to<br />
provide training to anaesthetists from the surrounding countries.<br />
Visiting teachers/professors have been funded to spend varying<br />
amounts of time (weeks to months) assisting in established teaching<br />
programmes, evaluating them and acting as external examiners.<br />
Lecturers have been funded to attend meetings of National Societies<br />
and money has been given to Societies in developing countries to help<br />
them organise and run such meetings.<br />
Unfortunately, as Dr Meursing, the secretary of the WFSA, points out in her report, the<br />
supply of money to support such endeavours is drying up. The WFSA derives its income from<br />
three principal sources:<br />
● a payment from each member society that is related to the number of members that Society<br />
has – the bigger societies pay more than the small ones<br />
● profits donated by the organisers of national and international meetings and<br />
● income from investments.<br />
As Dr Meursing has pointed out, income from the latter two sources is now much<br />
reduced.<br />
The need for continuing educational activities, however, remains undiminished and as Dr<br />
Eguma shows in her article in this issue, largely unmet. It is appalling and very sad that, in her<br />
survey of anaesthetists practicing in Nigeria, 43% had never been to an educational<br />
meeting/refresher course since they qualified. In determining the educational priorities of<br />
Nigerian anaesthetists, Dr Eguma has sought to determine what are the educational<br />
requirement of each group so that scarce resources can best be used.<br />
Dr Enright, the Chair of the WFSA Education Committee, is committed to maintaining<br />
the Training Centres and continuing to support visiting teachers who can spend a significant<br />
amount of time with their host departments as these two initiatives undoubtedly offer the best<br />
value for money. It is probable that Societies that have previously received financial support for<br />
their meetings or had WFSA sponsored lecturers attend will now have to bid for a smaller share<br />
of the diminishing funds available. Their case will undoubtedly be strengthened if they can<br />
show that they have performed a needs assessment (although I hate that term) and are<br />
delivering what their members need in as cost effective a manner as possible.<br />
William F Casey<br />
The editor of World Anaesthesia<br />
News is:<br />
Dr W F Casey<br />
Popes Cottage, Cheltenham Rd,<br />
Gloucester, GL6 6TS, UK<br />
Tel: (+44) 01452 814229<br />
Fax: (+44) 01452 812162<br />
Email: wfcasey@doctors.org.uk<br />
Editorial Board<br />
Dr Dixon Tembo (Zambia)<br />
Email: dctembo@zamnet.zm<br />
Prof. Rebecca Jacob (India)<br />
Email: rebeccajacob@hotmail.com<br />
Dr Rob McDougal (Australia)<br />
Email:<br />
mcdougal@cryptic.rch.unimelb.edu.au<br />
Dr Tom Ruttmann (S.Africa)<br />
Email: ruttmann@samiot.uct.ac.za<br />
Dr Iain Wilson (UK)<br />
Email: iain.wilson5@virgin.net<br />
Dr Jeanne Frossard (UK)<br />
Email: frossie@btinternet.com<br />
Editor Emeritus<br />
Dr Roger Eltringham (UK)<br />
Email: 106147.2366@compuserve.com<br />
Submissions to World Anaesthesia News may be sent to any of the above.<br />
Contents<br />
Focus on Education<br />
Training the Trainers 1<br />
Micronesia – Anaesthetic Refresher<br />
Course 2001 3<br />
Continuing Medical Education:<br />
What do African Anaesthetists Need? 4<br />
The Beer Sheva Project 5<br />
News from around the world<br />
Anaesthesia in Rural Sudan 6<br />
Anaesthetic Experiences in<br />
Sri Lanka 7<br />
A Letter from Ethiopia 9<br />
40 years of Anaesthesia in Mongolia 10<br />
Return to Cambodia 11<br />
Anaesthesia in Naura 13<br />
Case Histories<br />
News from Otjiwarongo - Nambia 14<br />
A surgeon’s experience in Tibet 15<br />
The management of<br />
neuroparalytic poisoning 18<br />
Feature Extra<br />
PTC in the People’s Republic of<br />
China 19<br />
The Department of Anaesthesiology<br />
Calabar, Nigeria 20<br />
News and Information<br />
Useful information 22-24<br />
Anaesthetic websites to try 25<br />
The African Anaesthetist 26<br />
Working in the UK 26<br />
The WFSA in a new century 27<br />
Job Opportunity 5<br />
Diary Dates 13<br />
Book Review 21
Training the Trainers<br />
Kester Brown<br />
President, WFSA<br />
Melbourne<br />
Australia<br />
Training the trainer is important, not only<br />
because it makes the trainers job easier<br />
but also because it makes them more<br />
effective and thus gives the student a greater<br />
chance of learning well. It is a largely<br />
neglected area. People are too often<br />
appointed to academic positions without any<br />
consideration being given to their teaching<br />
ability. The trainers are often asked to teach<br />
but not given advice on how to do it. In a<br />
survey, to which over a thousand<br />
anaesthetists in Australia responded, 90 %<br />
indicated that they participated in some form<br />
of teaching.<br />
Teaching is fun and it is a challenge to<br />
do it well. Anaesthetists teach in a variety of<br />
settings – in the operating theatre, with<br />
simulators, in lecture rooms and, less<br />
formally, in tutorials and discussions. They<br />
may also develop teaching aids such as<br />
videos and electronic presentations for the<br />
student to work through, when they do not<br />
have direct contact with the student.<br />
To be a trainer it is desirable to have<br />
been well trained oneself otherwise<br />
misinformation or bad habits may be passed<br />
on. Experience is a valuable asset acquired<br />
with time that gives the teacher credibility<br />
and makes him more convincing. An<br />
experienced anaesthetist recognises or<br />
foresees problems and knows how to handle<br />
and avoid them.<br />
Good teachers inspire their students,<br />
usually by demonstrating their own<br />
enthusiasm. They can convey information<br />
simply and clearly so that it is easy to<br />
understand. They should also teach their<br />
students how to think and not to accept all<br />
they are told or read without their own<br />
critical appraisal. If a teacher can achieve<br />
this, the students will have gained a valuable<br />
asset and may themselves become good<br />
teachers.<br />
My ability as a teacher has been<br />
acquired over many years; learning from<br />
teachers who were thoughtful and easy to<br />
follow, picking up ideas and tricks from<br />
people who have worked with me and<br />
discussing things with people who are clear<br />
thinkers. Many ideas have come from<br />
comments and questions raised by students<br />
that have made me think.<br />
There are many methods and situations<br />
which the trainer can use to convey<br />
knowledge to the trainee some of which I<br />
have already mentioned. I will expand on<br />
these and also discuss the organization of<br />
courses and meetings.<br />
Lectures are useful when one has to<br />
convey information to an audience that does<br />
not have much background knowledge,<br />
especially if it is a large group. It should be<br />
used to inform the students of the overall<br />
concepts and highlight what are the key<br />
points. Students need to gain perspective<br />
and to understand the basic principles: the<br />
detail can be added later. Lectures should not<br />
try to convey too much because most people<br />
have the ability to retain only so much in a<br />
given time – too much detail will not be<br />
remembered and only serves to confuse the<br />
listener. The topic should be built up from the<br />
basic principles to more complex points. This<br />
is particularly important when lecturing to an<br />
audience with widely differing knowledge<br />
levels so that the basics can be understood<br />
by those with least knowledge and even if<br />
they cannot grasp the more complex points<br />
they will at least have learnt something.<br />
Giving a lecture is like giving an<br />
anaesthetic where we give an extra bolus of<br />
drug when the drug effect is wearing off. In a<br />
lecture most people have a limited<br />
concentration span so that the lecturer has to<br />
do something to re-awaken the audience (tell<br />
a not-too-funny joke or relevant anecdote,<br />
ask a question or show a segment of video<br />
etc) – it is like a bolus to raise the audience’s<br />
concentration. There are a few infusion<br />
lecturers who are so fascinating that the<br />
audience listens attentively throughout, even<br />
for an hour or more.<br />
Presentation is very important. A<br />
monotonous voice can quickly lead to loss of<br />
interest. Try to vary the tone and volume and<br />
put expression into it. When important points<br />
are being made, slow down and pause at the<br />
end so that the audience has time to think<br />
about the point and absorb it. Non-stop, high<br />
speed speech usually loses much of its value<br />
because the audience cannot absorb the<br />
information. It is unfortunate to hear a<br />
lecture with good information being<br />
destroyed by not adhering to these principles.<br />
Say less and say what is important if your<br />
message is to be clear.<br />
Many people use visual aids during<br />
their lectures and presentations. This is<br />
helpful especially as nearly all anaesthetists<br />
are visual rather than auditory learners.<br />
Slides should not have too much information<br />
on them, the type should be large enough to<br />
be seen at the back of the hall and it should<br />
in the middle of the slide. Colour choice is<br />
important if the slide is to be easily seen.<br />
Light colours, such as white or yellow, on a<br />
dark background-, blue or green, are easy to<br />
see. Generally red and purple do not show up<br />
well. There is a danger when generating<br />
slides on computer to fail to appreciate that<br />
the colours chosen may not show up well<br />
when projected. Fancy backgrounds produced<br />
on computers do not improve clarity or the<br />
transmission of the information.<br />
Dual projection is less common now<br />
that computer slides are more widely used<br />
which is fortunate because few people use it<br />
well. It is best when showing something on<br />
one slide and indicating what it is on the<br />
other. To have too much information on the<br />
screen at one time or to use a distracting<br />
title slide on one screen and the real<br />
information on the other are techniques to be<br />
avoided.<br />
Beware of the laser pointer. It is useful<br />
to demonstrate something but when waved<br />
around it is distracting and when used to<br />
point as the speaker reads text is<br />
unnecessary, and even insulting to an<br />
intelligent audience who learnt to read that<br />
way in Grade one or two!<br />
Why are so many 50 minute or one<br />
hour lectures given when most people only<br />
concentrate for 15-20 minutes and<br />
sometimes less, especially after lunch? At<br />
the World Congress in Sydney in 1996 only<br />
two presentations exceeded 30 minutes and<br />
yet most speakers were able to convey their<br />
message clearly in the allotted time. This<br />
should be remembered by all those<br />
3<br />
Focus on Education
Focus on Education<br />
4<br />
organizing congresses and meetings. Only<br />
when you have a rare “infusion” lecturer can<br />
one justify including a longer presentation.<br />
Tutorials are the most useful form of<br />
post-graduate teaching because the students<br />
already have some knowledge and are at a<br />
stage when they can prepare and gain more<br />
information from reading and other sources.<br />
There is, however, some skill required to run<br />
a tutorial well. Ideally the group should not<br />
be too big. Participation by all the students is<br />
essential. This may mean that the leader<br />
must diplomatically suppress anyone who<br />
has too much to say and draw out the quieter<br />
person who would not otherwise contribute.<br />
To deal with both types requires tactful<br />
handling of the individuals. The tutor should<br />
not ask questions sequentially round the<br />
class – the students will remain more alert if<br />
the order of questioning is unpredictable.<br />
Questions should be asked first, before the<br />
individual is selected to answer. If not, the<br />
person questioned will be stressed, the<br />
catecholamine levels will rise, muscle blood<br />
flow will increase with the fight or flight<br />
reaction and the trainee may have difficulty<br />
thinking of the answer, while all the others<br />
are relaxing because they have not been<br />
asked. If the question is asked first, all the<br />
group can think about the answer before the<br />
period of terror starts!<br />
I have found a very useful method<br />
when conducting tutorials is to give the<br />
students a question on the general topic to<br />
be discussed and allow them five minutes to<br />
prepare a summary answer. This way, they<br />
have time to organise their thoughts for their<br />
reply before the stressful time when they are<br />
asked to answer. Everybody has had to think<br />
and maximise their brain activity before the<br />
tutorial begins and they soon realize that<br />
they are not going to be spoon fed! The<br />
outlines can then be discussed during the<br />
tutorial, the detail filled in and a<br />
comprehensive, well organised answer<br />
produced which will be useful for written or<br />
oral examinations or just as a way of<br />
discussing the topic at any time later.<br />
How much should we teach? I have a<br />
theory which I call the 70% principle where<br />
one teaches enough for the students to reach<br />
70% in an examination. In a non competitive<br />
examination there is no need to teach more<br />
detail than that because the bright students<br />
can attain a higher standard by themselves<br />
and any student around the pass level can be<br />
helped to reach a clear pass level if you<br />
teach to 70%. This entails teaching the<br />
absolute basics well and adding some, but<br />
not too much detail. The student then clearly<br />
understands what are the important basics<br />
and not become confused by all the detail.<br />
They can fill in more detail later if they<br />
clearly understand the basic principles.<br />
Anaesthesia is a very practical field<br />
and much of the training goes on in the<br />
operating theatre and on the job. Some<br />
people can teach easily while they are<br />
working while others find that it is<br />
distracting. While practical techniques are<br />
being performed, the good teacher can<br />
explain each step as it is done. This requires<br />
some thought. If each step is analysed and<br />
the ergonomics involved are considered, then<br />
it is easy to explain and it should be easy for<br />
the trainee to follow each step. Watching the<br />
most skilful people and analysing how they<br />
perform technical procedures is a good way<br />
to learn but having it explained at the same<br />
time is even better.<br />
Video or similar presentations on film<br />
or CD that have been thought out carefully<br />
can be used as an adjunct to practical<br />
teaching and are a way that experts who are<br />
not present can be watched. It is also a way<br />
to demonstrate a technique to a wide<br />
audience. I believe it should be used as a<br />
method of presentation more often at<br />
congresses and meetings rather than being<br />
relegated to a small room that hardly<br />
anybody visits.<br />
During an operation, there is often time<br />
for discussion but it must not distract the<br />
anaesthetist from observing the patient and<br />
monitors. One of the advantages of pulse<br />
oximeters that change the tone as the<br />
saturation drops is that it is so easy to pick<br />
up the change even while one is talking. In<br />
normal conversation it is usual to look at the<br />
person being spoken to: in the operating<br />
theatre this would mean that the patient and<br />
monitors would not be observed so one has<br />
to watch these and not always look at the<br />
person being spoken to. It is also essential to<br />
keep an eye on the operation to observe<br />
what is being done, to pick up any sudden<br />
increase in bleeding or activities by the<br />
surgeon which might influence the<br />
anaesthetic.<br />
Outside the operating theatre, trainees<br />
can benefit from going round with the<br />
anaesthetist to see how they talk to their<br />
patients. Some people do this very well and<br />
valuable interpersonal skills can be learned.<br />
When visiting children, do you talk to the<br />
parents and ignore the child except when<br />
actually examining him or her or do you<br />
concentrate on the child first. I personally<br />
introduce myself to the parents and ask a<br />
couple of questions but then spend some<br />
time playing and talking with the child before<br />
examining him. The parents tend to relax if<br />
they see that you are going to be kind and<br />
friendly to their child.<br />
Simulators are still expensive but they<br />
are increasingly being used in training where<br />
they are available. They have the advantage<br />
of taking the trainee through routines which<br />
are useful, recognising and treating problems<br />
and in resuscitation. Computer modelling is a<br />
cheaper and less expensive alternative.<br />
Trainers must review the aims and<br />
objectives of training, where these exist, or<br />
be familiar with the course syllabus so that<br />
they know what has to be taught. When<br />
teaching overseas in less developed<br />
countries, it is important to teach what is<br />
relevant to that place. It is useful to teach<br />
basic science and how it applies to<br />
practical anaesthesia and to teach or<br />
demonstrate practical techniques that can<br />
be used with the drugs and equipment that<br />
is available.<br />
The ability to organize courses and<br />
meetings is useful. Various formats can be<br />
used to make them more interesting. Lectures<br />
and tutorials have been discussed. Practical<br />
workshops and demonstrations can be held<br />
for some subjects. Panels can be very lively,<br />
especially if the panellists are only allowed a<br />
brief, concise introduction to the subject<br />
followed by comments from the other<br />
panellists. The constant change of speaker<br />
prevents boredom and loss of concentration.<br />
During a course, a specialty topic such as<br />
obstetrics can be discussed by an<br />
anaesthetist and an obstetrician. This brings<br />
out different issues and points of view and<br />
has the added benefit that the two<br />
specialists may gain a better understanding<br />
of the problems from the others point of<br />
view. Some imagination and the careful<br />
selection of speakers can produce good<br />
meetings and courses.<br />
It may be useful to conduct workshops<br />
for the trainers so that they can be motivated<br />
and better informed about teaching methods<br />
available. Practice lectures using a variety of<br />
aids are extremely valuable especially when<br />
coupled with constructive criticism from<br />
fellow participants. The greatest advantage<br />
of being a trainer, however, is that one<br />
continues to learn, both in preparing the<br />
lecture and from those you teach.
Micronesia Anaesthetic Refresher Course 2001<br />
Dr. David Creasey<br />
Anaesthetic SpR<br />
Derriford Hospital<br />
Plymouth UK<br />
During my year as an anaesthetic<br />
registrar at the Royal Hobart Hospital<br />
in Tasmania I was fortunate to have been<br />
given the opportunity to participate in the<br />
annual Micronesia Anaesthetic Refresher<br />
Course that is supported by Australian<br />
Society of Anaesthetists. In 2001, this was<br />
to take place at the capital of the Federated<br />
States of Micronesia, Pohnpei. The Royal<br />
Hobart Hospital has strong links with<br />
anaesthesia in the Pacific mainly through<br />
Dr. Haydn Perndt who invited me to get<br />
involved. The course was co-ordinated by<br />
Dr Malcolm Anderson (consultant<br />
anaesthetist, Royal Hobart Hospital), Dr.<br />
Okai Johnson who hosted the course in<br />
Pohnpei and Dr. Willie Tokon, the<br />
Micronesian co-ordinator.<br />
The islands of Micronesia lie north of<br />
the equator in the Western Pacific and are<br />
the result of ancient volcanic activity.<br />
Micronesia is spread over 3 million miles of<br />
the Pacific and includes over 2000 islands.<br />
These comprise eight distinct island groups.<br />
The groups are Pohnpei, Yap, Chuuk, Kosrae<br />
(the Federated States of Micronesia) Guam,<br />
the Marianas, the Marshalls and the Republic<br />
of Palau. The distance from one end of Micronesia<br />
to the other is 2,040 nautical miles.<br />
Micronesia is a loose collection of<br />
different countries, united in their history of<br />
having been the U.S. Trust Territory of<br />
Micronesia. Although originally settled by<br />
peoples from Polynesia, a turbulent history<br />
has seen the islands come under the control<br />
of the Spanish, Germans and Japanese. After<br />
World War II, the United Nations declared<br />
Micronesia a Trust Territory, under the supervision<br />
of the United States. Today Micronesia<br />
is largely independent and self-governing<br />
So it was in October 2001, that I<br />
found myself bound for Cairns to meet<br />
with Dr. Scott Simpson, consultant<br />
anaesthetist from Townsville. After some<br />
rigorous searching in Cairns airport, we flew<br />
to Guam where we had 4 hours to hone our<br />
series of lectures surrounded by American<br />
marines with machine guns. We then flew<br />
to Pohnpei via Chuuk. We made an exciting<br />
landing at Pohnpei where the aircraft made<br />
full use of the whole length of the runway<br />
and maximum reverse engine thrust. After<br />
some more enthusiastic searching by<br />
security officials, we emerged on Pohnpei<br />
soil to be met by our host, Dr. Johnson.<br />
The day before the course we had a<br />
chance to see the island. As Dr. Johnson was<br />
running late we made a call and found out<br />
he was at the hospital but not in theatre as<br />
we first suspected, but with his wife who<br />
was in labour. Remarkably he had organised<br />
the course whilst working a 1 in 1 on-call<br />
and with a great deal happening at home.<br />
We left him to his paternal responsibilities<br />
to see Pohnpei. The island is impressive<br />
with interesting volcanic geology, scenic<br />
waterfalls and a remarkable set of ruins at<br />
Nan Madol. The latter, a 2000-year-old<br />
series of man made islands, quays &<br />
buildings made from huge granite beams, is<br />
an incredible testament to the ancient<br />
peoples who developed the site. After a<br />
packed day of exploration we collected the<br />
inimitable Dr. Willie Tokon from the<br />
airport and our faculty was complete.<br />
Dr Johnson had secured a projector<br />
for our PowerPoint presentations but we<br />
realised we could not plug our Australian<br />
laptop into Pohnpei sockets. A tour of<br />
Pohnpei’s finest hardware stores looking for<br />
an adapter proved fruitless until we returned<br />
to the first store where a very helpful chap<br />
took a pair of pliers to our plug & in seconds<br />
we were able to run on Micronesian power.<br />
Simao Nanpei, Director of Pohnpei<br />
State Health Services, opened the course<br />
which was attended by 6 participants from<br />
the Federated States of Micronesia (4 from<br />
Chuuk, 1 from Pohnpei and 1 from Yap), 1<br />
from the Marshall Islands, and 1 from<br />
Pulau. We then ran a four day course<br />
covering paediatrics, airway and trauma<br />
management, anaesthesia for the hypovolaemic<br />
patient, local anaesthesia, peripheral<br />
blocks, the management of near drowning<br />
and thoracic anaesthesia. We had practical<br />
sessions on cardiopulmonary resuscitation<br />
and peripheral blocks (Dr. Johnson gave a<br />
demonstration of ankle blocks leaving Dr.<br />
Simpson with a numb foot. Dr. Simpson<br />
demonstrated wrist blocks leaving me with a<br />
numb hand. No one seemed to want to be<br />
the patient after this.) Case reports were presented<br />
and clinical scenarios on pre-eclampsia,<br />
ectopic pregnancy and the paediatric patient<br />
with a heart murmur were discussed.<br />
The course was received with great<br />
enthusiasm by those who took part especially<br />
as the previous course, the year before, had<br />
been cancelled due to a cholera outbreak.<br />
Back Row: Dr. Okai Johnson, Dr. Willie<br />
Tokon, Akapito Edgar, Aroy Modou, Kalisto<br />
Thomas, Dr. David Creasey, Makoto Lanwi<br />
Front Row: Dr. Jay, Arthur Olap, Dr. Scott<br />
Simpson<br />
This gave the course greater significance and<br />
reinforced how important these events are<br />
to the anaesthetists of Micronesia.<br />
I feel very privileged to have had a<br />
chance to take part in this course. The<br />
anaesthetists of Micronesia do a tremendous<br />
job in difficult circumstances as the supply<br />
of drugs can be erratic and the maintenance<br />
of equipment is often neglected. Courses<br />
such as this run by the Australian Society of<br />
Anaesthetists are an important part of<br />
continuing education and training as well as<br />
presenting an opportunity for anaesthetists<br />
to discuss problems with colleagues. It was a<br />
great experience to meet these interesting,<br />
friendly doctors and I wish them all the best<br />
for their next meeting in Chuuk.<br />
5<br />
Focus on Education
Focus on Education<br />
6<br />
Continuing Medical Education: what do<br />
African Anaesthetists need?<br />
Stella A Eguma MBBS DA FWACS<br />
Department of Anaesthesia<br />
PO Box 3573<br />
Ahmadu Bello University Teaching Hospital<br />
Kaduna<br />
Nigeria<br />
Introduction<br />
Continuing Medical Education (CME)<br />
describes those educational activities<br />
undertaken by physicians after the<br />
completion of formal graduate and<br />
postgraduate training. The purpose of CME is<br />
to enable practitioners to maintain and<br />
upgrade their standards of knowledge, skills,<br />
attitude and practice. Since opportunities for<br />
medical education for anesthetists in Africa<br />
are few, it is important that the few course<br />
organised are structured so the practicing<br />
anaesthetists obtain maximum benefit from<br />
attending them. In order to run a useful and<br />
cost-effective refresher course, the learning<br />
needs of potential participants should be<br />
identified and prioritised. A learning need is<br />
the discrepancy between what a physician<br />
ought to know and what he/she actually<br />
knows. Trainee objectives can be identified<br />
for the target group and a programme<br />
consistent with the identified needs and<br />
objectives can be implemented and its<br />
effectiveness subsequently evaluated.<br />
Currently, topics for update/refresher<br />
courses are largely determined by the<br />
personal preferences of the organisers and<br />
their perception of perceived needs. These<br />
may not always accord with the needs of the<br />
participants. This survey was carried out to<br />
identify the actual learning needs of different<br />
groups of anaesthetists in a developing<br />
country, Nigeria, in the hope that its findings<br />
might help those responsible for training and<br />
education in Africa to provide more beneficial<br />
and cost-effective courses and workshops.<br />
Method<br />
Questionnaires were given to all<br />
anaesthetists (both examiners and<br />
candidates) attending the Anaesthetic<br />
Fellowship examinations of the West African<br />
College of Surgeons. The same questionnaire<br />
was given to nurse anaesthetists at various<br />
hospitals in the country. Information was<br />
sought on the respondents’ grade, place of<br />
work, number of years in anaesthetic<br />
practice, number of courses attended since<br />
starting in anaesthetic practice, reasons for<br />
non-attendance at courses and perceived<br />
areas in which the anaesthetist felt<br />
inadequately informed and in which he/she<br />
would like further training.<br />
Results<br />
Fifty three practicing anaesthetists completed<br />
the questionnaire. Forty nine (92.5%) worked<br />
in Teaching hospitals and four (7.5%) were in<br />
private practice. No replies were obtained<br />
from anaesthetists in general hospitals.<br />
Table 1. Grades of Responding<br />
Anaesthetists<br />
Category Number Percentage<br />
Consultants 8 15%<br />
Residents 20 38%<br />
DA holders 16 30%<br />
Nurses 9 17%<br />
Thirty six respondents had spent less<br />
than 10 years in practice whilst seventeen<br />
had been in practice for between 10 and 30<br />
years. The majority (88%) of the latter group<br />
were consultants or nurses.<br />
Table 2. Course attended<br />
No. of course No. of Percentage<br />
attended anaesthetists<br />
No course 23 43%<br />
10 courses 8 15%<br />
The eight anaesthetists who had<br />
attended more than ten courses in their<br />
professional life were consultants. All<br />
respondents considered update courses to be<br />
essential to their practice and, given the<br />
opportunity, would love to attend such<br />
courses regularly. The reasons given for not<br />
attending courses were:<br />
● Lack of information about suitable courses<br />
● Lack of sponsorship to attend courses<br />
● Pressure of work<br />
● Financial constraints<br />
Discussion<br />
Anaesthetists all over the world have one<br />
ultimate goal: to provide safe anaesthesia for<br />
their patients. In order to do this effectively<br />
they need not only to have been properly<br />
trained in the art and science of anaesthesia<br />
but also to keep up to date with constantly<br />
changing trends in practice. One cannot but<br />
agree with Last who wrote in 1991 that<br />
“change is one of the most striking features of<br />
our time…A large part of the medical<br />
knowledge we possess at the end of our<br />
apprenticeship in medical training has become<br />
obsolete within ten years. No specialist can<br />
remain competent without taking energetic<br />
steps to keep in touch with the growing edge<br />
of the specialty.”<br />
Anaesthetists in developing countries<br />
face a particularly difficult task in that they<br />
have to practice safe medicine with a limited<br />
range of drugs and equipment. Learning<br />
resources are scarce and opportunities to<br />
attend refresher courses are few. In addition,<br />
their workload is often so heavy that there is<br />
little time for academic activities. In spite of<br />
these difficulties, both the West African<br />
College of Surgeons and the National<br />
Postgraduate Medical College of Nigeria do<br />
manage to organise annual courses for<br />
resident doctors preparing for their<br />
professional examinations. The World<br />
Federation of Societies of Anaesthesiologists<br />
sends visiting lecturers to the annual meeting<br />
of the Society of Anaesthetists of West Africa<br />
to assist in the refresher course that is an<br />
integral part of the meeting. Other anaesthetic<br />
practitioners such as nurse anaesthetists<br />
receive no organised continuing education.<br />
Table 3. Grades of Responding Anaesthetists<br />
Consultants Residents Nurses<br />
Critical care medicine Critical care medecine Obstetric anaesthesia<br />
Pain medicine Regional anaesthesia Paediatric anaesthesia<br />
Medico-legal aspects Paediatric anaesthesia Regional anaesthesia<br />
of practice<br />
Statistics Pain control Anaesthesia and concurrent disease<br />
Telemedicine Cardiopulmonary resuscitation Local anaesthetics
Undoubtedly, the rapid and tremendous<br />
improvements in anaesthesia that have<br />
occurred in recent years have generated a<br />
need for both skill maintenance and<br />
developmental training. The need for<br />
continuing education has been realised and<br />
some efforts have been made to organise<br />
training. Specific training needs must now be<br />
identified and training geared to meet those<br />
needs. Since opportunities for continuing<br />
medical education are few, it is imperative<br />
that the courses that are organised are<br />
tailored to the needs of practicing<br />
anaesthetists.<br />
This survey suggests that all<br />
anaesthetists wish to update their knowledge<br />
and skills so as to improve their practice.<br />
Perceived learning needs, however, differed<br />
between grades of anaesthetist. While<br />
consultants were interested in learning more<br />
about the fundamentals of research and<br />
medico-legal aspects of practice, junior<br />
anaesthetists were more interested in regional<br />
and paediatric anaesthesia. Both groups were<br />
interested in critical care and pain<br />
management. The majority of anaesthetics in<br />
Nigerian are administered by junior residents<br />
and nurse anaesthetists. Both groups<br />
indicated a need for further training in<br />
paediatric and regional anaesthesia.<br />
Common to all physician anaesthetists<br />
was the desire to acquire more knowledge in<br />
critical care and pain control. This indicates<br />
that there are skill deficits in these areas that<br />
need to be addressed. Truelove has<br />
suggested that skill gaps may be due to lack<br />
of resources, lack of ability, lack of<br />
motivation or inadequate training. African<br />
anaesthetists have motivation and the ability<br />
and desire to do their best for their patients.<br />
They are constrained, however, by poor<br />
resources and inadequate training<br />
opportunities. The practice of anaesthesia in<br />
Africa cannot improve unless steps are taken<br />
to enable practitioners to keep informed of<br />
the ever-changing trends in our technologydependent<br />
speciality.<br />
New drugs, equipment and techniques<br />
are constantly introduced into practice and<br />
present new opportunities and challenges in<br />
the management of pain, obstetric,<br />
paediatric, regional anaesthesia and<br />
intensive care. Our knowledge constantly<br />
needs to be updated yet 43% of Nigerian<br />
anaesthetists have never attended a<br />
refresher course since qualifying. This study<br />
has tried to establish what our training<br />
priorities might be.<br />
The Beer Sheva Project<br />
Since 1992, an amazing project has<br />
been ongoing at Ben Gurion<br />
University of the Negev in Beer<br />
Sheva, Israel. It has been led by one man<br />
whose energy, drive and enthusiasm know<br />
no bounds, Prof. Gabriel Gurman. He<br />
recognised from his own background and<br />
experience that young anesthesiologists in<br />
Eastern Europe would benefit from<br />
experience in an academic department<br />
with modern facilities and methods.<br />
The project began in 1992 with<br />
anaesthesiologists from Romania. In<br />
1995, Hungary sent four trainees. Since<br />
then, Bulgaria, Moldova, Slovenia and<br />
Slovakia have been participating. In all, a<br />
total of 89 young anaesthesiologists have<br />
taken part in the programme spending<br />
one or two months in Soroka Medical<br />
Centre.<br />
They can choose to study anaesthesia<br />
and its subspecialties or intensive care.<br />
Beside the clinical aspects, they are also<br />
taught about the organisation and<br />
administration of the unit. Dr Mihai Sava<br />
wrote: “I am one of the Romanian<br />
anaesthesiologists who had the<br />
opportunity to train at Beer Sheva. These<br />
grants are very useful not only because we<br />
got used to modern hospital technologies<br />
but also because we learned how to<br />
efficiently manage an Anaesthesia and<br />
Intensive Care Department.”<br />
All of these young anaesthesiologists<br />
return home where they share their special<br />
skills and knowledge with their colleagues.<br />
Professor Valeriu Ghereg, President of the<br />
Society of Anaesthesia and Intensive Care<br />
of Moldova, writes “They are real<br />
promoters of new ideas in the field of<br />
health care reform. The impact of the<br />
programme is not limited only to direct<br />
participants.” The project is supported by<br />
the WFSA, Ben Gurion University and<br />
Soroka Medical Centre. It is a fine<br />
example of what can happen when groups<br />
work together. Recently, the Faculty of<br />
Health Sciences at Ben Gurion University<br />
announced a Post-doctoral Fellowship in<br />
Anaesthesiology and Related Fields. This<br />
will offer a one to two year training period<br />
to young specialists in anaesthesia from<br />
Eastern Europe, Asia, Africa and South<br />
America with guaranteed research time<br />
and training. Travel expenses and a stipend<br />
are paid. This new initiative has sprung<br />
directly from the Eastern Europe project<br />
and congratulations are due to the Dean<br />
and Faculty of the Ben Gurion University<br />
and especially Professor Gurman for<br />
developing it. It will be of great benefit to<br />
all those who participate but also to their<br />
home departments and universities.<br />
Further information about the project can<br />
be obtained from<br />
Caroline Simon<br />
Faculty of Health Science<br />
Ben Gurion University of the Negev<br />
Beer Sheva 84105, Israel<br />
Tel: 972-8-6477406<br />
Fax: 972-8-6477632<br />
Email: caroline@bgumail.bgu.ac.il<br />
Job Opportunity in Australia<br />
Locum Consultant Anaesthetist required for one year the Royal Hobart<br />
Hospital in Hobart, Tasmania. The post will commence in mid-April 2003.<br />
The Royal Hobart department has 14 full time anaesthetists and 10<br />
registrars in training. It serves a 300 bed University Tertiary Referral<br />
Teaching Hospital. All anaesthetic subspecialties are represented.<br />
Hobart is a delightful city with a population of 250,000 and is the capital<br />
of the island state of Tasmania. There are plenty of cultural and natural<br />
attractions/distractions to keep home-sickness away!<br />
For further information, contact Dr Haydn Perndt at<br />
Haydn.Perndt@utas.edu.au<br />
7<br />
Focus on Education
8<br />
Anaesthesia in Rural Sudan<br />
Paul Mwangi Iregi<br />
iregimwangi@yahoo.com<br />
Introduction<br />
Sudan, the largest country in Africa with an<br />
area of 2,500,000 sq km, gained<br />
independence from the UK and<br />
EgyptBritain in 1952. It lies north of the<br />
equator and has a climate that ranges from<br />
desertstrategically important access to<br />
tropical forest.the Red Sea. The country is<br />
potentially rich in agricultural produce and<br />
boasts the biggest cotton and sugar<br />
plantations in Africa. It also has vast<br />
unexploited mineral resources and has<br />
recently become an oil exporter.<br />
The White and Blue Nile meet at<br />
Khartoum, the capital, and the river serves<br />
as an important route for commerce and<br />
communication within the arid interior of<br />
the country. Although Arabic is the official<br />
language, English is widely spoken,<br />
especially in the South where Arabic is<br />
considered the language of the oppressor.<br />
English is also the language of instruction at<br />
the second oldest medical school on the<br />
continent, in Khartoum, the Gordon<br />
School of Medicine in Khartoum, called<br />
after the colonial administrator who was<br />
famously killed in the Mahdi’s rebellion.<br />
The country has been embroiled in a<br />
civil war since 1984. Simplistically, the war<br />
is between the Islamic north and the<br />
Christian/animist south but the southern<br />
forces are divided into different factions.<br />
Rumbek Regional Hospital<br />
I started working as a non-physician<br />
anaesthetist in Southern Sudan in 1997.<br />
What infrastructure had survived years of<br />
neglect, drought and famine had been<br />
largely destroyed by aerial bombing. I was<br />
employed by a NGO and asked to try and<br />
establish an anaesthetic service at Rumbek<br />
Regional Hospital.<br />
The hospital was in need of major<br />
reconstruction but as sufficient funds were<br />
not available, priority was given to restoring<br />
the operating theatre and the surgical wards.<br />
Much of the essential building work was<br />
done within a month and we were also able<br />
to acquire a generator and some basic<br />
equipment including an oxygen<br />
concentrator, Ambu bags, a suction<br />
machine, laryngoscopes and endotracheal<br />
tubes. Although we were now able to<br />
undertake minor surgery, before progressing<br />
to major surgery, I set out to:<br />
● Improve operating theatre nurse training<br />
● Introduce training on pre- and postoperative<br />
management<br />
● Teach basic life saving techniques<br />
● Obtain more basic equipment and drugs<br />
● Train one or two dedicated anaesthetic<br />
assistants.<br />
Within one year, encouraging progress<br />
had been made: we had established a quality<br />
service with a low mortality and had a<br />
substantial number of well trained nurses<br />
with more in training.<br />
Anaesthesia<br />
As few monitors were available, ketamine<br />
was my preferred agent for induction and<br />
maintenance of anaesthesia. If intubation<br />
was required, suxamethonium and<br />
pancuronium were used and all patients,<br />
both adults and children, were ventilated<br />
manually with an Ambu bag. Reversal of<br />
muscle relaxation was achieved with<br />
atropine and neostigmine. Supplementary<br />
oxygen was administered from our donated<br />
oxygen concentrator.<br />
Spinal anaesthesia was frequently practiced<br />
as it was safe and inexpensive to perform.<br />
Hyperbaric bupivacaine 0.5% was employed<br />
for long operations such as the repair of<br />
recto-vaginal fistulae whilst 5% hyperbaric<br />
lidocaine was used for shorter procedures.<br />
Ephedrine was always readily available for<br />
manage hypotension but, as I routinely pretreated<br />
all patients with at least one litre of<br />
crystalloid, it was not usually needed. Postdural<br />
headaches were rare as I used fine<br />
spinal needles, preferring a 26g if available.<br />
I had a supply of 1% and 2%<br />
lidocaine for performing local infiltration<br />
and regional blockade. I could confidently<br />
perform foot blocks, digital blocks, Bier’s<br />
block and brachial plexus block (axillary<br />
approach) with little risk of failure.<br />
Blood<br />
Because of inadequate laboratory facilities, it<br />
was impossible to perform safe homologous<br />
blood transfusion. We were, however, able<br />
to perform autologous transfusions. If the<br />
need for transfusion was foreseen, the<br />
patient was bled immediately preoperatively<br />
and the volume replaced with<br />
crystalloid and colloid. This method works<br />
well for fit patients who are likely to need a<br />
limited amount of blood as only a blood<br />
bag containing anticoagulant is needed.<br />
Alternatively, blood can be taken over<br />
several days pre-operatively, but to do that<br />
you need a reliable fridge! Both methods<br />
avoid the risk of transmitting AIDS.<br />
Paul Mwangi Iregi is a non-physician<br />
anaesthetist who has worked in Sudan and<br />
Somalia since 1997 and is currently working<br />
in Sierra Leone.
Anaesthetic Experiences in Sri Lanka<br />
(January 2001 – June 2001)<br />
Background<br />
Since the early 1980’s, there has been a<br />
protracted conflict between the Sri Lankan<br />
Government and the Liberation Tigers of Tamil<br />
Eelam (LLTE). It has resulted in over 60,000<br />
deaths and many more people have been<br />
displaced from their homes. An area in the<br />
north of Sri Lanka is currently controlled by the<br />
LTTE and is claimed by them as a separate<br />
Tamil state. (Editorial Note: Earlier this year,<br />
a ceasefire was agreed and peace negotiation<br />
are continuing)<br />
In conjunction with the Sri Lankan<br />
Ministry of Health, Medecins Sans Frontiere<br />
(MSF) has an established programme that<br />
provides medical personnel and supplies to the<br />
Government Hospital in Mallavi, a town of<br />
40,000 inhabitants. The hospital also acts as a<br />
referral centre for a wider population of up to<br />
400,000.<br />
Getting there<br />
I wasn’t sure how difficult it was going to be to<br />
fulfil my long held desire to practise medicine,<br />
and in particular anaesthetics, in a developing<br />
country. I had explored the possibilities a<br />
couple of years earlier, but all doors appeared<br />
closed until I had gained the FRCA and a<br />
minimum of 5 years experience. Now I met<br />
these basic requirements and had no more<br />
excuses. I applied to a couple of organisations<br />
that I knew ran surgical programmes and<br />
waited for their reply. Meanwhile, I spoke to<br />
the person that mattered most on my specialist<br />
registrar rotation: the Regional Advisor. I was<br />
fortunate that he had done similar work in the<br />
past and he was very enthusiastic about<br />
allowing me time to work abroad.<br />
I applied to MSF, a voluntary<br />
organisation that has projects in a number of<br />
countries around the world. They asked me to<br />
attend an interview at the end of October<br />
2000. The interview was an informal affair<br />
principally discussing how I would cope as the<br />
only anaesthetist on a placement and the<br />
problems of dealing with difficult situations. At<br />
the end of the interview things looked hopeful<br />
but the nature of the organisation means that<br />
available positions are often difficult to confirm<br />
until the very last minute. The realisation of<br />
what I was about to embark on began to sink<br />
in.<br />
For the next few weeks, I was left in<br />
limbo. I had not been allocated a post for the<br />
next 6 months of my training rotation but had<br />
no definite alternative job. There was a<br />
suggestion that I might be offered a post in<br />
Sri Lanka starting in April. Meanwhile, I<br />
attended a course in Bristol on anaesthesia<br />
in difficult circumstances that was excellent<br />
and enabled me to meet people who had<br />
previously worked in similar circumstances.<br />
Unfortunately, putting an Ether EMO<br />
vaporiser back together after taking it apart<br />
Our surgical workload was<br />
largely determined by how<br />
much equipment was<br />
available at a given time.<br />
The average was about 110<br />
cases per month but we<br />
sometimes had to stop all<br />
elective procedures when<br />
supplies were running low.<br />
didn’t seem to be my forte but I did gain a lot<br />
of information about anaesthesia in<br />
developing countries.<br />
Meanwhile discussions were under<br />
way with the Royal College of Anaesthetists<br />
to clarify whether what I was planning to do<br />
would count towards my specialist<br />
accreditation. The main stumbling block was<br />
that I would be a lone anaesthetist with no<br />
consultant supervision. It was decided that I<br />
should have a distant supervisor with whom I<br />
would regularly correspond by E-mail. This<br />
had not been done before by the College.<br />
Just before Christmas 2000, I received<br />
a telephone call to say that my services were<br />
required in Sri Lanka from the end of January.<br />
This fitted in perfectly with the end of my<br />
existing job. My remaining time was a<br />
whirlwind of being on-calls, finishing an audit<br />
project, sorting out my finances and saying<br />
goodbye to family and friends.<br />
Mallavi Hospital:<br />
I arrived in Sri Lanka to the humidity of<br />
Colombo airport, jet lagged and nervous<br />
about what awaited me. Twenty four hours<br />
later, I found myself in the northern town of<br />
Mallavi. I had had little sleep for 2 days and<br />
had crossed numerous army check points to<br />
eventually find myself in the Tamil Tiger<br />
Territory better known as the Vanni. I was<br />
immediately on call.<br />
The following day I was able to get a<br />
better picture of the hospital itself. The<br />
surgical ward consisted of a thatched 50<br />
bedded unit. Multicoloured mosquito nets<br />
were tied back in the daytime to reveal old<br />
stained mattresses. The obstetric and labour<br />
ward seemed more crowded and attracted a<br />
greater number of flies than anywhere else.<br />
There was one operating theatre with an<br />
attached scrub room. I looked with<br />
trepidation at the anaesthetic machine. It<br />
was a basic Boyle’s machine with a<br />
halothane vaporiser attached. The breathing<br />
circuit was home made from an Ambu bag<br />
and tubing. It was held together with tape<br />
and it was impossible to tell how much<br />
oxygen, halothane or air was actually being<br />
given. The only monitoring equipment was a<br />
blood pressure cuff and a slightly unreliable<br />
pulse oximeter.<br />
The drugs available were actually more<br />
extensive than I expected. However, I was<br />
soon to learn that as supplies were brought<br />
into Vanni on a monthly basis from the south<br />
of the country, deliveries were often delayed<br />
and availability was erratic and depended on<br />
the political situation at the time. The drugs<br />
were also often very close to their expiry<br />
date. Oxygen supply was a major problem. A<br />
large J size cylinder was present but we<br />
never knew with certainty when it would be<br />
replaced and there was no oxygen<br />
concentrator available. Hence, I had to<br />
quickly learn the art of giving anaesthesia<br />
without supplemental oxygen, which seemed<br />
contrary to all I had previously learned in my<br />
training.<br />
There were a limited supply of sterile<br />
gloves, needles, syringes and so they were<br />
used sparingly. All equipment for spinal<br />
anaes-thesia and surgical procedures was<br />
sterile.<br />
There were few other trained medical<br />
personnel in Mallavi: a couple of doctors<br />
took care of the medical patients while the<br />
surgical ward was managed by 4 trained<br />
nurses who never complained about working<br />
long shifts. There were a similar number of<br />
midwives and in the theatre were 5 “OT<br />
boys”, as they were affectionately known.<br />
The latter were unqualified but very helpful<br />
9
10<br />
staff responsible for all aspects of scrubbing,<br />
cleaning and autoclaving. They also worked<br />
in the minor theatre where suturing and<br />
dressing changes were performed as well as<br />
acting as anaesthetic assistants.<br />
Operating theatre<br />
Our surgical workload was largely<br />
determined by how much equipment was<br />
available at a given time. The average was<br />
about 110 cases per month but we<br />
sometimes had to stop all elective<br />
procedures when supplies were running low.<br />
The average age of our surgical patients was<br />
29 years. Except true emergencies, all<br />
patients were reliably starved from 4am and<br />
brought to theatre after the morning ward<br />
round. I attended this with the surgeon and it<br />
was satisfying to review all our patients from<br />
the previous day’s surgery.<br />
Pre-operative assessments were<br />
limited despite having a nurse translator.<br />
Fortunately there were very few patients with<br />
chronic medical problems – the most<br />
common was hypertension. All patients were<br />
weighed and had their blood pressures taken<br />
prior to coming to theatre. The only<br />
investigations available were red cell counts,<br />
ESR, malaria screening and urine testing.<br />
There were no facilities for estimating urea<br />
and electrolyte level or performing ECGs. X-<br />
ray examinations were possible in another<br />
hospital an hour’s drive away once a week.<br />
There were a significant number of<br />
children to be anaesthetised and I soon<br />
realised trying to gain intravenous access in<br />
a child without pre-treatment with topical<br />
local anaesthesia is very difficult! Gaseous<br />
induction of anaesthesia with the equipment<br />
available was equally challenging and I soon<br />
found the best method of inducing<br />
anaesthesia was a quick intramuscular<br />
injection of ketamine (8-10mg/kg) into the<br />
buttock. Within a few minutes, I was able to<br />
insert an intravenous cannula in a now<br />
relaxed child and allow the operation to<br />
proceed. Ketamine became my best friend in<br />
the world of anaesthesia. My previous<br />
experience with the drug had been limited to<br />
using minimal doses in elderly patients<br />
having their fractured hips repaired but I soon<br />
discovered the benefits of having a drug that<br />
allowed patients to maintain a patent airway<br />
and did not cause them desaturate despite<br />
receiving no added oxygen.<br />
I found there were large differences in<br />
doses required to induce and maintain<br />
anaesthesia in my patients: often they<br />
appeared to need far more than the 1-2mg/kg<br />
300 Sex of patients<br />
250<br />
200<br />
150<br />
100<br />
50<br />
0<br />
300<br />
250<br />
200<br />
150<br />
100<br />
50<br />
0<br />
intravenously quoted in the literature.<br />
Sometimes they would seem awake and I<br />
was concerned that they might be aware but<br />
I was reassured by a survey I carried out. The<br />
patients all seemed to be quite happy with<br />
their anaesthetic and had no recollection of<br />
their operation. They seemed to laugh off,<br />
almost inappropriately, any dreams they had.<br />
This may have reflected the nature of the<br />
culture and the difficult environment in which<br />
they lived.<br />
Spinal anaesthesia was my other major<br />
technique and was indicated for any<br />
operation below the waist. As most of my<br />
patients were very thin, my biggest problem<br />
was avoiding puncturing the dura with the<br />
introducer needle. During my time in Sri<br />
Lanka, I performed 250 spinals and had one<br />
definite spinal headache that resolved with<br />
fluids and bed rest.<br />
I always worried when we had to do a<br />
laparotomy or other case that required<br />
intubation. I would use a standard rapid<br />
sequence induction with thiopentone and<br />
suxamethonium and intubate the patient<br />
using whatever endotracheal tubes were<br />
available. I then maintained anaesthesia with<br />
140<br />
120<br />
100<br />
80<br />
60<br />
40<br />
20<br />
0<br />
Spinal<br />
Males<br />
Age of patients<br />
61<br />
Years
there was little happening, we were able to<br />
relax in the hammocks and try to keep cool in<br />
the sweltering heat. Bicycle rides to a local<br />
reservoir at the end of the day through the<br />
beautiful surroundings were a great joy in our<br />
lives – a two-way radio taking the place of<br />
my usual bleep. Sunday nights were spent<br />
watching movies at the UN compound and<br />
hoping that we would not get called away<br />
mid-film for a Caesarean Section. Getting<br />
used to living within the limitations of<br />
Mallavi was a challenge in itself. Our only<br />
contact with outside world was via a convoy<br />
on Tuesdays and Fridays that brought in E-<br />
mails, letters and other provisions.<br />
At times, it was quite easy to forget<br />
that we were in the middle of a war zone<br />
until a patient would be brought in with half<br />
their foot blown off from a land mine – the<br />
temptation of collecting coconuts from just<br />
beyond the barbed wire having proved too<br />
much. At other times, the shelling would<br />
pound away in the distance sounding like<br />
faint thunder or the locals would get very<br />
excited by over flying aircraft.<br />
Back to reality<br />
Now that I am back working for the NHS, I<br />
appreciate all the facilities and benefits we<br />
have and take for granted. The difficulty of<br />
finding an available intensive care bed<br />
contrasts with having no critical care beds at<br />
all. My work here is certainly busier and<br />
poses different anaesthetic challenges but I<br />
think I learnt many things from being the sole<br />
anaesthetist in Mallavi and I am sure my<br />
experiences will benefit me in my every day<br />
work. The local people who appreciated<br />
whatever we did for them, no matter how<br />
difficult their circumstances, more than<br />
compensated for the frustrations I<br />
encountered.<br />
I feel I was very fortunate to have been<br />
able to go and work in Sri Lanka with MSF.<br />
Getting there was certainly much easier and<br />
less complicated than I was led to believe. It<br />
isn’t a job that would suit everybody and<br />
certainly the minimal pay and basic living<br />
conditions need to be taken into<br />
consideration when considering such jobs. I<br />
am sure that the time I spent in Sri Lanka will<br />
benefit both my future career and my<br />
personal development.<br />
Total number of cases = 431<br />
Editorial Apology: I’m afraid I have lost the<br />
name and address of the author of this paper.<br />
He/she appears to be a trainee anaesthetist<br />
in the UK and I would be grateful if he/she<br />
would contact me.<br />
A letter from Ethiopia<br />
Tefera Alemu<br />
Department of Anaesthesiology<br />
PO Box 18728<br />
Addis Ababa<br />
Ethiopia<br />
Dear Dr Eltringham,<br />
Thank you for sending me the package of books. All arrived safely except for one<br />
that had some damage to its cover caused, I think, by our domestic postal service. I<br />
really appreciate your interest in spending you time, energy and money in sending<br />
material to help us.<br />
Perhaps I can tell you and your colleagues a little more about our department her in<br />
Addis Ababa:<br />
● The School of Anaesthesia was established in 1982 and since then has produced<br />
203 nurse anaesthetists, most of whom are still practicing in Ethiopia.<br />
● Currently we have 24 students who are reaching the end of their two year course. At<br />
the start of the new academic year in September, we expect to enrol 25 new students.<br />
Because of the constraints of space, particularly in the operating theatres, and to<br />
maintain standards and safety, we cannot accept greater numbers of students for<br />
training.<br />
● We teach the theoretical aspects of anaesthesia in the classroom and then<br />
introduce practical experience in the operating rooms of various hospitals. As<br />
there are few teachers, our workload is considerable.<br />
● Our students work in ten different government hospitals enabling them to gain<br />
experience in different aspects of anaesthetic practice and develop appropriate<br />
skills. Since we use so many different hospitals, I can only guess at the number<br />
of patients our students anaesthetise.<br />
● Our students learn general anaesthesia using intravenous and inhalational agents<br />
and the use of muscle relaxants and endotracheal intubation. They also learn safe<br />
spinal anaesthesia and a number of regional blocks.<br />
The major problems we face every day are:<br />
● A shortage of local anaesthetic agents for spinal anaesthesia especially 5%<br />
lidocaine and 0.5% bupivacaine. Because of the poor state of our economy we<br />
are unable to import modern anaesthetic agents such as isoflurane, atracurium,<br />
vecuronium and etomidate.<br />
● We are also short of laryngoscopes, endotracheal tubes, airways and monitors<br />
such as oximeters and even ECGs.<br />
Although we work under many constraints, we try to the maximum of our<br />
knowledge and capacity to produce well qualified and competent nurse anaesthetists<br />
for our country.<br />
With best regards,<br />
Tefera Alemu<br />
If you would like to donate books or journals for use in a developing country, please<br />
contact Dr Roger Eltringham (+44) 07774 276284 or<br />
106147.2366@compuserve.com<br />
11
12<br />
40 years of Anaesthesia in Mongolia:<br />
a Conference and Refresher Course report<br />
Dr David Pescod FANZCA,<br />
Staff Specialist in Anaesthesia<br />
Northern Hospital<br />
Melbourne<br />
Victoria<br />
Australia<br />
In October 2001, I spent nine days in<br />
Mongolia as a WFSA visiting lecturer<br />
and guest of the Mongolia Anaesthesia<br />
Society. I was involved in four days of<br />
teaching and a two-day conference<br />
celebrating 40 years of anaesthesia in<br />
Mongolia.<br />
Mongolia is a landlocked country of<br />
some 1,565,000 square kilometres in<br />
Eastern Asia. It consists of semi-desert and<br />
desert plains with mountains in the West<br />
and South West and the Gobi Desert in the<br />
South East. The average altitude above sea<br />
level is 1,580m. The summers are mild and<br />
the winters long and cold.<br />
Mongolia has a high rate of<br />
population growth, estimated at 1.45% in<br />
1999. The 2000 census reported a total<br />
population of 2.38 million with 35%<br />
estimated to be less than 15 years of age.<br />
However the demography is in transition<br />
with declining fertility and mortality rates<br />
which will increase the demands on both<br />
adult and elderly health services.<br />
Until the 1940s Mongolia had neither<br />
industry nor settled agriculture, with the<br />
vast majority of people living a nomadic,<br />
subsistence agricultural existence. After<br />
1940, there was a rapid increase in<br />
urbanization, industrialization and<br />
education. However because of the<br />
geographical conditions and very low<br />
population density, there were significant<br />
shortages of basic foodstuffs, electricity,<br />
clean water and sewerage disposal. These<br />
shortages also exist today in Ger settlements<br />
in urbanized areas. An estimated 60,000<br />
people live in Ger camps around Ulaan<br />
Baatar, the capital.<br />
Modern health services began in<br />
1921. After Mongolia came under the<br />
influence of the USSR in the 1940s they<br />
rapidly developed, with strong central<br />
planning following the Soviet model. This<br />
emphasis on medical specialisation and<br />
hospital based services continued until<br />
1990s. In 1997 Mongolia had an estimated<br />
407 hospitals with 18,436 beds.<br />
Life expectancy is estimated as 63.6<br />
years for males and 67 years for females.<br />
Infant mortality rate was approximately 35<br />
per 1000 live births and maternal mortality<br />
157 per 100,000 live births in 1998.<br />
Mortality among under 5 year olds is 47 per<br />
1000 live births due to respiratory infections<br />
along with parasitic diseases, birth trauma<br />
and gastrointestinal illnesses. Crude death<br />
rate in 1997 was 7.2. This represents a<br />
marked change in the last 30 years with<br />
decreased mortality from infectious,<br />
parasitic and respiratory disease but an<br />
increase in mortality from neoplasia,<br />
circulatory disease, trauma and poisoning.<br />
In 1998 the commonest sites of<br />
cancer were the liver (40%) stomach (18%)<br />
and lung (12%). Cardiovascular disease<br />
including hypertension, stroke, ischaemic<br />
heart disease and rheumatic heart disease is<br />
now the leading cause of death.<br />
Communicable disease such as viral<br />
hepatitis, TB, brucellosis and shigellosis<br />
remain a major health problem. The<br />
incidence of other communicable diseases<br />
such as tetanus, polio, pertussis and measles<br />
has been markedly reduced whilst others<br />
such as Hepatitis C and AIDS are emerging.<br />
Mongolian health delivery is divided<br />
into four levels. Level one provides basic<br />
medical and public health services for the<br />
nomadic population, often in remote areas.<br />
Level two includes general practice<br />
physicians in larger communities with level<br />
three including towns and small cities. Level<br />
four provides a full range of health services<br />
and is limited to the capital city.<br />
The restructuring of Mongolia’s health<br />
system from a centralised to a devolved<br />
structure has resulted in major social upsets.<br />
Vigorous efforts are being made to improve<br />
the management of health facilities but<br />
minimal economic wealth and isolation<br />
makes progress difficult.<br />
Anaesthesia training is conducted in<br />
Mongolia’s only university. Facilities, as in<br />
all areas of health and education, are<br />
limited. Textbooks are available but the<br />
donation of several selected specialist texts<br />
would greatly improve the library facilities.<br />
Similarly the provision of handbooks of<br />
anaesthesia for anaesthetists in training<br />
would be a simple and cost effective action.<br />
Anaesthetic educators would appreciate<br />
supplies of basic educational aids such as<br />
overhead projector transparencies.<br />
Anaesthetic equipment/supplies and<br />
hence anaesthetic practice varies between<br />
hospitals. Although a few centres have new<br />
equipment, most rely on old and even pre-<br />
Soviet machines and monitoring. Few<br />
anaesthetic drugs are available. Little<br />
equipment is “disposable”.<br />
Mongolia has 138 anaesthetists, of<br />
whom 43 attended the seminars and conference.<br />
Seminar topics included regional anaesthesia,<br />
obstetric anaesthesia, advanced airway<br />
management and trauma management.<br />
There are many areas of anaesthetic<br />
practice where guidance would markedly<br />
increase anaesthetic skills and improve<br />
patient care. Mongolia has a wealth of<br />
dedicated health professionals and the<br />
countries anaesthetists would welcome and<br />
appreciate further support and assistance.
Return to Cambodia<br />
Dr Gillian Davies<br />
London, UK<br />
Gd407@btinternet.com<br />
Cambodia, the land of the white crocodile,<br />
is situated in the heart of Indo-China<br />
bordered by Thailand, Vietnam and Laos.<br />
It has maintained a uniquely Khmer culture<br />
although there is still much evidence of the<br />
French colonial presence from 1864 to 1953.<br />
Since then civil war, Pol Pot and the Khmer<br />
Rouge and continuing political instability have<br />
made it one of the poorest countries in South<br />
East Asia.<br />
International aid organizations have<br />
been welcomed back to Cambodia since the<br />
1991 Paris Peace Accords and in 1993-94 I<br />
worked with the Red Cross in the North West<br />
province of Banteay Meanchey and on the<br />
Thai-Cambodian border. More recently, I have<br />
been privileged to work in two very different<br />
anaesthetic projects, each for 5 months. From<br />
July 2000, I worked for Emergency in<br />
Battambang and in 2001 at the Sihanouk<br />
Hospital, Phnom Penh with BESO (British<br />
Executive Service Overseas).<br />
Emergency Hospital, Battambang<br />
Batttambang, Cambodia’s second city is<br />
situated 295 Km NW of Phnom Penh has a<br />
population of 90,000. It is in the centre of a<br />
rich agricultural plain where much rice and fruit<br />
is grown and it has the best preserved French<br />
colonial era architecture in the country. The<br />
surrounding province has a population of 1.5<br />
million and is the most heavily mined area in<br />
the country. Nationwide, about 150 new mine<br />
injuries occur each month peaking during the<br />
dry season, (December–May) when rice is<br />
planted. In March 2001, a record 103 mine<br />
injuries were recorded in Battambang province<br />
alone and it is estimated that some 6 million<br />
mines remain undiscovered.<br />
Eighty five percent of the Cambodian<br />
population live in the countryside and are<br />
engaged in subsistence farming earning less<br />
than US$ 0.8/day. The Government can only<br />
afford to spend US$ 2 per person/year on<br />
health care so malaria, TB and HIV remain<br />
uncontrolled, infant mortality is 90/1000 and<br />
life expectancy is only 54 years.<br />
I worked for Emergency, an Italian NGO<br />
that has been active in Cambodia since July<br />
1998. It aims to provide surgical care and<br />
rehabilitation to the victims of war, those with<br />
mine injuries and related musculo-skeletal<br />
problems due to cerebral palsy, polio and<br />
burns. The Emergency hospital was an<br />
attractive 100 bed facility with 2 operating<br />
theatres, dedicated to an Italian journalist, Ibria<br />
Alpi, who had been killed in Somalia. It was<br />
staffed by 138 Cambodians and 7 expatriates<br />
and treated over 3000 in- and out-patients<br />
annually. The facilities were low tech but<br />
sufficient to perform about 90 operations a<br />
month. Anaesthesia was administered by 5<br />
nurses who had been “trained on the job” by<br />
my predecessors. I tried to encourage them to<br />
use what was available more appropriately, to<br />
teach them spinals and other regional blocks<br />
and to pay greater attention to the recovery<br />
area so that they could work safely without<br />
expatriate supervision.<br />
There was not a great amount of<br />
anaesthetic equipment available: one OMV<br />
and one Fluotec Mark 2 vaporiser each<br />
attached to inaccurate flow meters. Although<br />
there was a notional ventilator for the postoperative<br />
ward, all ventilation is done by hand<br />
using an Ambu bag held together with<br />
elastoplast. The paediatric circuits leaked and<br />
were in short supply and there was a limited<br />
range of endotracheal tubes that were<br />
constantly reused. There was one combined<br />
defibrillator, oximeter and ECG machine that<br />
was moved about as required and we had 2<br />
oxygen concentrators, an Innosar Simo-plus<br />
and a New Life Airsep that generally worked<br />
well but were dependent on an unreliable<br />
town electricity supply. Oxygen was also<br />
supplied in large cylinders from Phnom Penh<br />
during the dry season but not during the rainy<br />
season when the road became almost<br />
impassable. Disposable equipment such as<br />
syringes, needles, cannulae and size 22 spinal<br />
needles were usually available but we lacked a<br />
reliable suction pump.<br />
Core anaesthetic drugs, ketamine,<br />
thiopentone, diazepam, halothane, suxamethonium,<br />
atropine and norcuronium were available<br />
but there were recurrent shortages of bupivacaine,<br />
neostigmine and ephedrine. Pentazocine,<br />
tramadol andacetaminophen/<br />
paracetamol were our analgesics. Hyperbaric<br />
bupivacaine was not available.<br />
We worked in two spacious operating rooms<br />
using:<br />
● Thiopentone induction only<br />
● Ketamine for induction, maintenance and<br />
as an infusion and also as an adjunct to<br />
local blocks<br />
● Halothane for induction and/or<br />
maintenance during spontaneous<br />
ventilation with a face mask or with IPPV<br />
● Suxamethonium for intubation and<br />
intermittently for short cases. Norcuronium<br />
was used if longer muscle relaxation was<br />
required<br />
● Diazepam for sedation and with local<br />
anaesthetic blocks<br />
● Regional techniques including spinal<br />
anaesthesia (the incidence of headache<br />
was 15% and the failure rate 2%). Supraclavicular<br />
and axillary brachial plexus<br />
blocks, ankle and wrist block were all<br />
introduced in August 2000.<br />
● Intravenous regional anaesthesia<br />
(IVRA/Bier’s block) with lidocaine<br />
Table 1 – Anaesthetics Administered<br />
Total War related: War related Recon<br />
Emergency Elective strutive<br />
430 46 182 203<br />
290 patients were male, 141 female and<br />
92 children under 12. Ketamine was the most<br />
frequently used agent, either alone or in<br />
combination, as shown in the following chart<br />
Patients were being sent from the<br />
theatre, down a long corridor to wards that<br />
had no resuscitation facilities when I arrived.<br />
Subsequently we used an area in ITU next to<br />
the theatre. ITU nurses came to theatre to<br />
learn about anaesthesia and airway<br />
management so that post-operative care was<br />
greatly improved.<br />
There was a 10 bed intensive care/high<br />
dependency ward where the patients needing<br />
extra nursing such as those with recent mine<br />
injuries, those who have had a laparotomy,<br />
tracheostomy or chest drains and children who<br />
have undergone complex orthopaedic<br />
13
14<br />
procedures were cared for. There was no<br />
special monitoring and artificial ventilation was<br />
not possible.<br />
Sihanouk Hospital, Phnom Penh<br />
Phnom Penh is a bustling city of 1.3 million at<br />
the junction of the Bassac, Tonle Sap and<br />
Mekong rivers and has been the capital of<br />
Cambodia since 1865. Although it was French<br />
designed with wide tree lined boulevards,<br />
pagodas, temples and colonial villas, all the<br />
infrastructure was destroyed when the entire<br />
population was forcibly removed by Pol Pot in<br />
1975. There are no skyscrapers with most<br />
buildings being 4-6 stories high but it is again<br />
a thriving city with a National Museum<br />
containing Ankor sculptures, an Art Gallery,<br />
Royal Palace and Silver Pagoda.<br />
Sihanouk Hospital, Centre of<br />
Hope opened in December 1996 and<br />
is staffed and managed by Hope<br />
Worldwide, a NGO founded in1991. It<br />
is the best equipped and managed<br />
hospital I have seen on any of my<br />
visits to Cambodia and its aim is to<br />
train health care professionals to give<br />
first class free medical care to the<br />
poor and needy 24 hours a day. It has<br />
a large out-patient department that<br />
treats 5000 patients a month, half of<br />
whom come from outlying villages.<br />
There are 22 medical and surgical beds<br />
with 2 operating theatres where<br />
approximately five general surgical or<br />
orthopaedic procedures are undertaken<br />
each day. No out-of-hours emergency<br />
surgery and no paediatrics is<br />
undertaken. The hospital has 26<br />
Cambodian doctors selected, on<br />
rotation, from the national hospitals,<br />
assisted by 14 expatriate medical staff.<br />
There is one physician anaesthetist and<br />
three anaesthetic nurses, all Frenchtrained,<br />
in Phnom Penh.<br />
The two well-equipped<br />
operating rooms had Boyle’s type<br />
continuous flow anaesthetic machines<br />
fitted with a halothane vaporiser and flow<br />
meters for air, nitrous oxide and oxygen<br />
although only the latter was used. Co-axial<br />
circuits were used with soda lime. There was<br />
no mechanical ventilator in the theatre but<br />
there was an Eagle Marquette automatic<br />
monitor for BP, pulse, ECG, O2 and CO2. There<br />
was a reliable supply of disposable circuits,<br />
needles, syringes, intravenous cannulae, 26g<br />
spinal needles with introducers and a variety<br />
of endotracheal tubes including flexometallic,<br />
RAE and Rusch double lumen for chest surgery.<br />
Anaesthetic drugs included fentanyl,<br />
morphine, meperidine/pethidine, midazolam,<br />
spinal lidocaine and tetracaine (US donated).<br />
Shortages of fentanyl and neostigmine<br />
occurred but there was tramadol and<br />
pentazocine for post-operative analgesia.<br />
Diazepam was not used. Although there were<br />
plentiful supplies of intravenous fluids, careful<br />
forward planning was needed to obtain enough<br />
blood from relatives for elective surgery as the<br />
HIV Rate is 4% and 56% of HIV positive<br />
patients are under 25 years old.<br />
A range of anaesthetic techniques were<br />
used especially muscle relaxation and IPPV.<br />
Spontaneous respiration with halothane +/-<br />
analgesia was not used before my visit nor<br />
were ketamine or diazepam, even when<br />
500 Anaesthetics given<br />
400<br />
300<br />
200<br />
100<br />
0<br />
150<br />
120<br />
90<br />
60<br />
30<br />
0<br />
Total<br />
Emerg<br />
War rel<br />
Anaesthetics given<br />
Reconstr<br />
IPPV<br />
Hal<br />
General<br />
Orthop<br />
GA, IPPV<br />
Hal<br />
Ketamine<br />
Spinal<br />
Ketamine<br />
Spinal<br />
Marcaine<br />
Pontoc<br />
indicated.<br />
There was a comprehensively equipped<br />
recovery area immediately adjacent to the<br />
theatre with space for 3 beds. It was staffed by<br />
a trained anaesthetic nurse on six month<br />
rotation with colleagues and a theatre nurse.<br />
During my stay, 230 surgical procedures<br />
were performed of which 105 were<br />
orthopaedic including tendon transfers, the<br />
fixation of fractures and the revision of<br />
amputations and 125 general surgical<br />
procedures mostly thyroidectomy, mastectomy,<br />
cholecystectomy, gastric ulcer surgery and<br />
ovarian cystectomies. One hundred and six<br />
general anaesthetics were given; 98 patients<br />
were ventilated and only 8 breathed<br />
spontaneously. Ninety five patients received<br />
spinals of which 3 failed (2.8%) and 17<br />
received local anaesthesia/sedation.<br />
Hyperbaric tetracaine +/-adrenaline was used<br />
for 47 of the spinals, bupivacaine either plain<br />
or mixed with dextrose at the time of injection<br />
for 40 and pre-mixed hyperbaric lidocaine for<br />
nine.<br />
Anaesthetics Given<br />
The Ministry of Health has run an Anaesthetic<br />
Nurse Training School in Phnom Penh since<br />
1991 with support from MSF and French<br />
universities. A two year course is run for<br />
fifteen nurses and aims to ensure that<br />
there is an adequately trained<br />
anaesthetic nurse working in each of<br />
the countries 21 provinces. Some<br />
doctors are also trained as specialists<br />
in Phnom Penh in a programme run by<br />
the Ministry of Health and the<br />
Universities of Paris and Bordeaux.<br />
They have an opportunity to spend<br />
some time in France for practical<br />
training but few go to work in the<br />
provinces when they return. All<br />
anaesthetic staff at the Sihanouk<br />
hospital had completed one of these<br />
courses but were still anxious to learn<br />
more and improve their standard of<br />
practice.<br />
To this end, as well as teaching<br />
in the operating theatre, I conducted<br />
pre- and post-operative teaching rounds<br />
and held weekly tutorials for the<br />
anaesthetic and recovery room staff. At<br />
their request, I also used Mike<br />
Dobson’s book “Anaesthesia in the<br />
District Hospital” to teach surgical<br />
trainees the basics of anaesthesia as<br />
they recognised that if they were<br />
working in district hospitals, they would<br />
have to supervise and be responsible<br />
for the conduct of anaesthesia.<br />
It was gratifying to see the dedication<br />
and enthusiasm of all the Cambodian doctors<br />
and nurses and the improving standards of<br />
treatment given to the countries patients who<br />
often present late with advanced disease after<br />
having tried traditional/herbal medicine. The<br />
staff’s wish to improve their own knowledge<br />
and skills for the benefit of their future patients<br />
is a delight to see as is their search for the<br />
education we, in the West, so often take for<br />
granted.
Anaesthesia in the Republic<br />
of Nauru<br />
Dr Serupepeli Goneyali<br />
SMO Anaesthetist<br />
Republic of Nauru<br />
Background<br />
The Republic of Nauru is a twenty-one<br />
square mile coral island in the central<br />
Pacific Ocean, 42 kilometres south of the<br />
equator and 1287 kilometres west of the<br />
International Date Line. It has a<br />
population of 12,000 and enjoys a<br />
sunny, tropical climate with monsoons<br />
from November to February. It was a<br />
dependency of Australia from the time of<br />
World War I until it gained<br />
independence in 1968 with a democratic<br />
presidential system of government. The<br />
main source of income is phosphate<br />
mining but as the phosphate deposits are<br />
becoming depleted, off-shore financial<br />
services are being encouraged<br />
Health Institutions<br />
The island has two hospitals, the Nauru<br />
General Hospital and the Republic of<br />
Nauru Hospital (formerly administered<br />
by the Phosphate Mining Company) that<br />
are managed by the Ministry of Health.<br />
Recently the General Hospital has been<br />
renovated to become a base for nurse<br />
training and for public health activities.<br />
The Republic of Nauru hospital has a<br />
three-man recompression facility and is<br />
currently undergoing the necessary<br />
structural changes to cope with its<br />
expanding clinical load. A total of nine<br />
doctors, a dentist, twenty five nurses and<br />
thirteen paramedical staff provide the<br />
qualified and skilled expertise to serve<br />
our population. Tertiary medical care is<br />
provided by visiting specialists and by<br />
referral to hospitals in Australia.<br />
Health Status<br />
Despite their isolation, Nauruans are not<br />
immune from the illnesses of the 21st<br />
century and its impact on their lifestyle.<br />
Abandoning tradition ways, changing<br />
living standards, an altered diet together<br />
with other social and economic factors<br />
and modern air travel have contributed<br />
to an altered pattern of illness. Diabetes<br />
and its complications have increased<br />
enormously and are the main cause of<br />
morbidity and mortality. Road traffic<br />
injuries occupy second place. Although<br />
infant mortality is 10 per 1,000, life<br />
expectancy is only 61 years with 40% of<br />
the population aged under 14 years and<br />
less than 2% over 65 years.<br />
Anaesthetic Practice<br />
Anaesthetic services are basic and<br />
support essential first-line and emergency<br />
care such as appendicectomies, Caesarean<br />
sections, simple orthopaedic<br />
manipulations and the diabetic limb<br />
debridement and amputations. Patients<br />
requiring major elective surgery and<br />
those with complex trauma are evacuated<br />
to Australia. Drugs and medical gases are<br />
obtained through the government<br />
pharmacy service and come by regular air<br />
and sea transport from Australia.<br />
Thiopentone, suxamethonium,<br />
vecuronium, ketamine and halothane<br />
are available as are oxygen, nitrous<br />
oxide, carbon dioxide and nitrogen.<br />
Morphine, fentanyl, pethidine and<br />
pentazocine are available as required.<br />
We have lidocaine and bupivacaine in<br />
the usual concentration for regional and<br />
intrathecal anaesthesia. Visiting<br />
specialists bring other drugs together<br />
with endotracheal tubes and LMAs.<br />
Intensive Care/High Dependancy<br />
Unit<br />
A single room, one-bedded unit is<br />
reserved for very ill patients and those<br />
who require mechanical ventilation.<br />
Available equipment includes a Bird<br />
ventilator (Mk VI), a LifePac Physio<br />
Control ventilator and a Hewlett<br />
Packard combined ECG/pulse/oxygen<br />
saturation monitor. Whilst more<br />
sophisticated equipment would be<br />
useful, we lack the infrastructure and<br />
expertise to manage and service it.<br />
Some six years ago, a Bear 5<br />
ventilator was purchased but has never<br />
been used. It transpires that at least a<br />
further twelve parts and a supply of<br />
compressed air is necessary before it can<br />
be operated. Advice on the purchase<br />
and maintenance of appropriate<br />
technology equipment is sorely needed<br />
and would be much appreciated.<br />
Diary Dates<br />
7th Biennial Congress<br />
Asian & Oceanic Society of Regional<br />
Anesthesia and Pain Medicine<br />
5-8 November 2003<br />
Bangkok, Thailand<br />
Lectures, Symposia/Panel Discussions,<br />
Workshops<br />
Further information: AOSRA Secretariat<br />
39 Pradipat 10 (Phaholyothin 11)<br />
Phyathai, Bangkok 10400, Thailand<br />
Tel: +66 (0) 2615 7301<br />
Fax: +66 (0) 2615 7309<br />
Mobile: +66 (01) 836 1368<br />
Email: cdm@cdmthailand.com<br />
http://www.cdmthailand.com<br />
Annual Scientific Meeting<br />
Hong Kong College of Anaesthesiologists<br />
& Society of Anaesthetist of Hong Kong<br />
1-3 November 2002<br />
Sheraton Hotel and Towers, Hong Kong<br />
Tel: (+852) 2821 3520<br />
Fax: (+852) 2866 7530<br />
Email: grace.chu@fmshk.com.hk<br />
5th South Asian Congress of<br />
Anaesthesiology & 1st South<br />
Asian Regional Pain Society<br />
Congress<br />
18-20 February 2003<br />
Dhaka, Bangladesh<br />
Chairman, Organising Committee:<br />
Prof K M Iqbal<br />
Secretary, Organising Committee:<br />
Dr Lutful Aziz<br />
Bangladesh Society of Anaesthesiologists<br />
Email: kmi@bdcom.com<br />
krahman@agni.com<br />
SITUATION WANTED<br />
Veteran anaestestist with 36 years<br />
experiance, 28 years in Africa, available<br />
for teaching and training anaestetic<br />
personnel.<br />
Setting up and running a modern<br />
anaestetic management<br />
team/department<br />
Contact Dr. G.S Raju<br />
Flat No. 2, Jain Building<br />
16 Navratan Bagh, Indore 452001<br />
Madhya, Pradesh (India)<br />
Tel: (0091-731) 497536<br />
Email: hemaravi@botsnet.bw<br />
15
Case histories<br />
16<br />
NEWS from Otjiwarongo-Namibia<br />
Dr Sikota Zeko<br />
PO Box 1378<br />
Otjiwarongo State Hospital<br />
Otjiwarongo<br />
Namibia<br />
Email: zeko@ iway.na<br />
Namibia: an overview<br />
Situated on the south-western coast of Africa,<br />
Namibia is truly a land of remarkable contrasts.<br />
With a land surface of 824,269 square kilometres,<br />
it is nearly four times the size of Great<br />
Britain. Despite its size, its one of the most<br />
sparsely populated countries in Africa with an<br />
estimated population of about 1.7 million<br />
people. The north-central part of the country is<br />
the most densely populated area with an<br />
average population density of 26 people per<br />
square kilometre. The small population is<br />
largely due to the fact that Namibia is the most<br />
arid country south of the Sahara.<br />
Namibia’s people are diverse; ranging<br />
from the pastoral Himba in the northwest, to<br />
the San (Bushmen) in the east. The San no<br />
longer pursue an exclusively hunter-gatherer<br />
existence, but are struggling to adapt to a new<br />
way of life. The other major population groups<br />
are the Owambo, the Kavango, Damara, Nama<br />
and Herero. Smaller groups include the<br />
Basters, Tswana, coloured and whites of<br />
European descent.<br />
During the Namibian winter (May to<br />
September), temperatures in the interior range<br />
from 18 to 25 degrees Celsius during the day.<br />
Below freezing temperatures and ground frost<br />
are common at night. Summer (October to<br />
April) temperatures in the interior range from<br />
20 to 34 degrees Celsius during the day.<br />
Temperatures above 40 degrees Celsius are<br />
often recorded in the extreme north and south<br />
of the country. The coast, influenced by the<br />
cold Benguela current, boasts a relatively<br />
stable range of 15 to 25 degrees Celsius. Thick<br />
fog is fairly common at night. Humidity is<br />
generally very low in most parts of Namibia,<br />
but can reach as high as 80% in the extreme<br />
north during summer. The average annual<br />
rainfall varies from less than 50mm along the<br />
coast to 350mm in the central interior and<br />
700mm in the extreme northeast.<br />
The economy centres on agriculture<br />
(mainly stock farming), fishing and mining, the<br />
country’s most important earner of foreign<br />
exchange. Namibia is one of the top diamondproducing<br />
countries in the world, while<br />
uranium, tin, copper, lead and zinc are other<br />
important minerals. The agricultural, fishing<br />
and mining industries account for more than<br />
25% of GDP, while tourism is a major economic<br />
growth area.<br />
Namibia currently has one doctor per<br />
3,650 people and this is one of the best doctor/<br />
patient ratios in Africa. All major centres have<br />
state run hospitals. In Windhoek (the capital),<br />
there are three international standard privately<br />
run hospitals and two State hospitals, each<br />
with fully equipped and maintained intensive<br />
care units. In addition to the usual range of<br />
specialties, the latter are able to undertake<br />
plastic surgery and thoracic and neurosurgical<br />
procedures when surgeons from South Africa<br />
visit. There are State hospitals in virtually all<br />
major towns in Namibia whilst in the smaller<br />
towns, villages and rural settlements, there are<br />
well-equipped and staffed clinics and health<br />
care centres operated by the Ministry of Health<br />
and Social Services.<br />
Anaesthetic services are available in<br />
most major towns in both state hospitals and<br />
private hospitals but Intensive Care facilities<br />
only exist in Windhoek (state and private<br />
hospitals). A basic anaesthetic training course,<br />
lasting six weeks, is run for doctors working in<br />
rural district hospitals at the main State<br />
hospital in Windhoek. This equips them to<br />
administer anaesthesia for caesarean section,<br />
laparotomies and minor procedures.<br />
Case History<br />
A 17 year old male was admitted to<br />
Otjiwarongo District hospital, 250km north of<br />
Windhoek, in October 2001. He had a short<br />
history of fever, left sided abdominal pain,<br />
painful micturition and had vomited several<br />
times. He had no significant past medical<br />
history but had been stabbed in the left chest<br />
wall one year previously. He had made a full<br />
recovery from this incident and had no<br />
respiratory sequelae.<br />
On examination, he had mild dehydration<br />
but no pallor or jaundice. BP 110/70, RR<br />
12/min, PR 96/min, Temp 36 degrees Celsius.<br />
He was tender in the left hypochondrium and<br />
renal angle but with no evidence of peritonism.<br />
Laboratory investigations including a full<br />
blood count, urea and electrolyte estimations<br />
and liver function tests were normal. Urinalysis<br />
revealed modest proteinuria and so he was<br />
given antibiotics for a presumed urinary tract<br />
infection.<br />
A few days later, he developed localised<br />
signs of peritonitis with well-defined mass in<br />
right iliac fossa extending to the suprapubic<br />
area. Needle aspiration of the swelling<br />
revealed pus. His temperature had risen to 39<br />
degrees Celsius, BP 120/80, PR 80/min, RR<br />
20/min. Laboratory tests showed a white cell<br />
count of 16.4 x 109 /l with 83.3% neutrophils.<br />
A chest X ray showed the remnant of a knife<br />
blade in the left infrascapular area (Fig.1 & 2).<br />
The patient required emergency surgery<br />
to drain the intra-abdominal abscess but, in<br />
view of the incidental finding on the chest X<br />
ray, it was thought wisest to refer the patient<br />
to the Central hospital in Windhoek for further<br />
evaluation and management. There an<br />
uneventful laparotomy was performed later the<br />
same day.<br />
The patient was referred back to<br />
Otjiwarongo hospital two weeks later with the<br />
piece of knife still in his chest and made an<br />
uneventful recovery.
A Surgeon’s experience of an Interplast<br />
visit to the roof of the world, Tibet<br />
Peter & Pat Brown<br />
Canberra<br />
Australia<br />
Peter Brown. (pbbrown@webone.com.au)<br />
It was in January 2000 that I received an<br />
invitation from Prof Paolo Morselli, a<br />
Plastic & Reconstructive Surgeon from<br />
Bologna Italy, to join a voluntary<br />
international Interplast1 team to work in<br />
Lhasa, Tibet during their northern summer.<br />
This was an opportunity not to be<br />
missed. My theatre sister wife, Pamela and I<br />
had previously worked in Saigon in the early<br />
1970’s and later with Interplast Australia2<br />
in the southwest Pacific, Papua New Guinea<br />
and Southeast Asian countries. Not only<br />
was this an opportunity to help the Tibetan<br />
people but also an opportunity to work<br />
with an international team in plastic and<br />
reconstructive surgery.<br />
The Interplast team was thirteen in<br />
number, 3 Plastic Surgeons (Italy, USA and<br />
Australia), 3 Anaesthetists (Canada, Italy<br />
and Germany), 1 Paediatrician (USA) and 6<br />
Nurses (USA, Italy, Holland and Australia).<br />
Thus three Continents were represented,<br />
Australia, Europe and North America; it<br />
was truly an international team that came<br />
together in Kathmandu, Nepal to travel on<br />
Back: Dr Bai, Dr Song, Elsa Gerritsen<br />
(Netherlands), Dr Stuart Neil(Canada), Dr<br />
Paul Schueller (Germany)<br />
Front: Dr JJ Keyser(USA), Dr Da Wa, Dr<br />
Paolo Morselli(Italy), Dr Lu Xiang, Dr<br />
Den Zin , Interpreter Margrit Elliot(USA),<br />
Monica Bargani(Italy), Dr Lorena<br />
Pasnini(Italy), Dr MJ Pionk(USA), Sandra<br />
Dore(USA), Pamela Brown(Australia), Dr<br />
Peter Brown(Australia)<br />
to Lhasa, in order to bring our expertise in<br />
plastic & reconstructive surgery to those in<br />
need (Fig 1). Travel into Tibet and entry<br />
visas were arranged for us by a Nepalese<br />
tour operator who also organised two buses<br />
to get to the airport: one for us and one for<br />
our luggage.. Our luggage weighed about<br />
250 Kg more than allowed but the tour<br />
operator had influence and excess charges<br />
were waived.<br />
The flight to Lhasa from Kathmandu<br />
took about one and a half hours by China<br />
Southwest Airlines and a fine view of the<br />
Himalayas could be seen from the aircraft.<br />
Lhasa airport is situated on the bank of the<br />
Brahmaputra river between steep mountains<br />
a long way outside the city. On arrival we<br />
were herded across the tarmac to the<br />
terminal, constantly being exhorted by the<br />
military not to take photographs. When the<br />
Customs officials saw the quantity of<br />
luggage we had, they decided that it was too<br />
much to examine immediately and told us<br />
to take it all to the hospital and that they<br />
would come and inspect it “next week”. The<br />
team was then greeted by the senior Chinese<br />
surgeon in Lhasa bundled into a small bus<br />
for the trip into the city. The road followed<br />
the river and the scenery was spectacular<br />
with high mountain ranges on either side.<br />
The mountains were devoid of vegetation<br />
and had evidence of multiple large landslips<br />
due to the extreme temperatures during<br />
winter.<br />
Our hotel in Lhasa was directly<br />
opposite the Jokhang Monastery that dates<br />
back to AD 539. The Monastery is in the<br />
old Tibetan area known as the Barkhor and<br />
is the home of several hundred monks. A<br />
stream of chanting Tibetans constantly<br />
circled the building in a clockwise direction<br />
with prayer wheels spinning or prostrated<br />
themselves on the ground to pray.<br />
As Lhasa is some 12,000 ft above sealevel,<br />
we were all interested in the effects of<br />
altitude and each member was affected to a<br />
greater or lesser degree. Out of interest, on<br />
arrival, we measured our oxygen saturations<br />
with a portable oximeter and found that the<br />
readings were 88-90% and they remained at<br />
this level until our departure. There was<br />
some debate as to whether Diamox was of<br />
any help in combating the effects of the<br />
altitude. Some members of the team had<br />
already started taking 250mgm per day and<br />
after a few sleepless nights, we all started to<br />
take it. Diamox on its own did not solve the<br />
problem of obtaining a good night’s sleep<br />
but was essential if one was to be able to do<br />
a full day’s operating.<br />
Our work was to be at the Lhasa<br />
Municipal People’s Hospital, a hospital of<br />
about 300 beds and one of three in Lhasa.<br />
After a formal welcome for the team from<br />
Dr Lu Xiang, the President (Chief<br />
Administrator) of the Hospital and an<br />
oncologist who was fluent in English as he<br />
had spent some time in Australia, we got<br />
down to work. The room was turned into a<br />
clinic and we started examining the patients<br />
that had been assembled for us. This was<br />
done with the help of two Chinese interns<br />
who interpreted for us. The patient was first<br />
examined by the surgeons. A history, the<br />
findings on clinical examination and the<br />
proposed operation, if indicated, was<br />
recorded. Then a Polaroid photograph was<br />
taken and stapled to the patient’s notes. A<br />
number was allocated to the patient and put<br />
on a wristband as we had no hope of<br />
identifying them from their name either in<br />
Chinese or Tibetan. The patient then went<br />
to the paediatrician (as most were children)<br />
for screening and from there to the<br />
anaesthetists. The case-records were then set<br />
aside for scheduling of operation. This<br />
system worked extremely well and it was a<br />
methodical way of organising our workload<br />
when communication with our patients was<br />
a major problem. During the first two days<br />
we examined 140 patients and 84 were<br />
selected for surgery. The operating lists were<br />
then scheduled to take place throughout the<br />
rest of the visit. Most of the patients had<br />
cleft lips or palates or were children with<br />
joint deformities due to post-burn<br />
contractures.<br />
The senior Chinese surgeon, Dr Tang,<br />
informed us that he would like our help<br />
with a breast reconstruction on a patient on<br />
whom he proposed to perform a Halsted<br />
radical mastectomy. The patient had<br />
advanced breast cancer with skin and nodal<br />
involvement and chemotherapy had been<br />
commenced. Breast reconstruction was<br />
unlikely to be feasible but we offered help<br />
with closure of the surgical defect after<br />
mastectomy. There was much negotiation<br />
about the best time to carry this out. The<br />
second week suited us best but he wanted it<br />
17<br />
Case histories
Case histories<br />
18<br />
done earlier. Finally it was decided to<br />
schedule it for the second week of our visit -<br />
or so we thought.<br />
In the meantime, the anaesthetists and<br />
nurses had prepared the operating theatre: a<br />
large room with two tables sharing a single<br />
ceiling mounted light, the main light for<br />
one table and the smaller satellite light for<br />
the other table (Fig 2). Fortunately we had<br />
brought with us a small autoclave, as local<br />
sterilising facilities were limited. Other<br />
equipment and supplies included anaesthetic<br />
and diathermy machines, supplies of<br />
anaesthetic drugs, antibiotics and dressings,<br />
disposable surgical drapes and gowns.<br />
The Lhasa Operating Room<br />
The first operating day was a Monday.<br />
It always takes time to get going on the first<br />
day and for everyone to find their feet in a<br />
strange environment. Surgery continued<br />
until 7.00 p.m. which was quite late enough<br />
as we were all suffering, to a greater or lesser<br />
extent, from the effects of the altitude. Most<br />
days we operated for ten to twelve hours.<br />
With two tables but three surgeons and<br />
three anaesthetists, it was possible to rest a<br />
surgeon and anaesthetist while the other<br />
two teams worked. The Chinese interns<br />
assisted with all operations but it was<br />
disappointing that the older Chinese<br />
surgeons did not involve themselves in the<br />
theatre work.<br />
On the second operating day, we were<br />
greeted on arrival by the senior Chinese<br />
surgeon who advised us that he had his<br />
patient for a Halsted mastectomy ready on<br />
the operating table. We told him that there<br />
was some mistake as we had agreed we<br />
would help him with closure of the<br />
mastectomy defect the following week. He<br />
was not to be deterred so we rescheduled<br />
our day’s patients. After some delay, he<br />
performed a very radical Halsted mastectomy<br />
and we were presented with a 20 x<br />
15cm chest defect to close. We were able to<br />
do this with a latissimus dorsi flap, fortunately<br />
without further incident and the patient<br />
made a good recovery. The Chinese surgeon<br />
was genuinely grateful for our help in treating<br />
his patient and we considered the goodwill<br />
gained was an important aspect of our visit.<br />
We had come prepared to give lectures<br />
on Plastic & Reconstructive surgery,<br />
Anaesthesia and Paediatrics. A lecture<br />
afternoon had been arranged and an<br />
interpreter booked: unfortunately he did<br />
not have a good grasp of English let alone<br />
medical terminology but we discovered that<br />
much information could be transferred<br />
visually. A laptop computer had been<br />
brought by Paolo Morselli to demonstrate<br />
nasal reconstruction. Stuart Neil, assisted by<br />
M. J. Pionk gave a masterly demonstration<br />
on pre-operative selection of patients with<br />
the use of simple diagrams and then<br />
proceeded to demonstrate monitoring<br />
equipment using his colleague, Paul<br />
Schueller as the patient. With the help of a<br />
35mm slide projector provided by the<br />
Hospital, I spoke on the use of pedicle flap<br />
repairs in various parts of the body and J. J.<br />
Keyser spoke on the management of hand<br />
infections. The audience displayed keen<br />
interest and we think understood the<br />
content of the lecture despite the problems<br />
with translation. There is always a lack of<br />
audiovisual equipment in developing countries<br />
and this needs to be remembered when<br />
preparing any teaching. It is often necessary<br />
to bring your own equipment and be<br />
prepared to improvise if the electricity fails.<br />
The younger doctors and nurses were<br />
also keen to learn or improve their English.<br />
Two members of our team conducted<br />
English classes each morning from 8-9am.<br />
These classes were well attended and, judged<br />
by the noise and laughter, thoroughly<br />
enjoyed by the teachers and pupils.<br />
The weekends provided an<br />
opportunity to see some of the country. On<br />
the first Sunday, the hospital administrator<br />
invited us to tour the Potala Palace, the<br />
home of all the Dalai Lamas since 1649.<br />
This spectacular building is very important<br />
to the Tibetans and is still occupied by<br />
monks but they seemed to be strictly<br />
supervised. No photography was permitted<br />
inside the Palace and the Potala police<br />
enforced this rigorously when we were<br />
conducted through numerous chapels and<br />
mausoleums for the deceased Dalai Lamas.<br />
On the second Sunday, we were<br />
invited to a picnic at a sacred lake by the<br />
name of Yamdrok-Tso. Imagining that we<br />
were going to a lake near the river, not far<br />
away, we set off in the hospital minibus. We<br />
met another hospital vehicle, the<br />
ambulance, containing all the Chinese<br />
doctors with their wives and children at a<br />
refuelling stop. We continued in convoy<br />
past the airport and began to climb through<br />
a steep ravine. Our driver seemed to be in a<br />
hurry and overtook every vehicle in sight as<br />
we climbed higher and higher through the<br />
clouds, negotiating hundreds of hair-pin<br />
bends cut into the side of the mountain.<br />
There was no marking on the edge of the<br />
road and a brief look down revealed a sheer<br />
drop of 700 to 1,000 feet. After an hour of<br />
hard driving, we reached the top and our<br />
destination, the sacred lake, could be seen<br />
some 500 feet below on the other side.<br />
At the lake edge, we were led to a<br />
barge with a diesel engine bolted to the<br />
stern. The boatman smoked constantly and,<br />
once the team were aboard, decided to refuel<br />
from an open can of diesel fuel. In<br />
order to start the motor a piece of cloth was<br />
held in a pair of pliers, dipped into the<br />
diesel fuel and then ignited with a cigarette<br />
lighter. One crewman then cranked the<br />
engine while the burning wick was held<br />
over the air intake. Eventually, the engine<br />
fired and the barge headed across the lake, a<br />
journey of 30 minutes. There were no<br />
lifebelts to be seen. The surrounding<br />
mountains reached into the clouds, for we<br />
were now at 15,000 feet above sea level.<br />
Interestingly, the extra 3,000 feet did not<br />
trouble the team members but the Chinese<br />
doctors were all complaining of headache.<br />
The whole mountainside was silent but<br />
covered with wild flowers: there was no<br />
noise from human activity and no birdsong<br />
- just the sound of water lapping at the<br />
lake’s edge. The Chinese had brought lunch<br />
but the weather had deteriorated and most<br />
of the lunch was eaten by a group of young<br />
children who had appeared from nowhere,<br />
like a pack of jackals. The boat was<br />
successfully restarted and an uneventful<br />
journey made back to the other side of the<br />
lake. By now it was raining and the return<br />
journey appeared even more frightening in<br />
prospect.<br />
At the top of the mountain, before the<br />
start of our descent, the driver stopped the<br />
vehicle, took out several white scarves and<br />
ran to a small shrine where there were many<br />
other scarves and flags. He placed his scarves<br />
there and offered a short prayer for a safe<br />
return journey! He drove back, tail-gating<br />
the vehicle ahead and overtaking other
vehicles, generally passing on the outside<br />
edge of the road. The passengers closed their<br />
eyes and hoped that the rear wheels<br />
remained on terra firma. On arrival back to<br />
safety, we commented on the dangerous<br />
nature of the road to the local doctors.<br />
Their reply was that many vehicles went off<br />
the road each year and there were never any<br />
survivors.<br />
At the end of the first week a young<br />
boy with a severe neck contracture from a<br />
burn was referred for treatment (Figs 3 &<br />
Above: Tibetan boy with burn contracture<br />
(frontal). Below: Tibetan boy with burn<br />
contracture (lateral)<br />
His neck contracture posed not only a<br />
surgical, but also an anaesthetic challenge.<br />
Fortunately we had the expertise to deal<br />
with both. It was clear that blood<br />
replacement might be needed for any<br />
operation. Not being certain of the<br />
availability and compatibility of blood in<br />
Lhasa, a member of the French educational<br />
team who had brought the boy to us offered<br />
to donate blood for him as she was O Rh<br />
negative and therefore a universal donor. A<br />
plan for relieving the neck contracture was<br />
made and anaesthesia induced. A laryngeal<br />
mask was used during the initial release of<br />
the contracture. Two of us then worked on<br />
his neck and division of the neck<br />
contracture from ear to ear through the<br />
dense scar tissue was begun. Gradually the<br />
contracture was released and his neck<br />
extended, the distance between his lower lip<br />
and upper chest gradually increasing until a<br />
normal neck contour appeared. His airway<br />
was then maintained by withdrawing the<br />
laryngeal mask and replacing it with an<br />
endotracheal tube. The next problem was<br />
how to repair the large skin defect that now<br />
measured about 20 cm in vertical length<br />
from lower lip to upper chest. Our preoperative<br />
plan was to use a long skin flap,<br />
from each side of the neck extending down<br />
to the shoulder tip, to be brought across to<br />
the midline to resurface the neck. This now<br />
appeared feasible and was accomplished<br />
with viable skin flaps covering the anterior<br />
neck but leaving a large chest, lower lip and<br />
chin defects to be covered (Fig 5). Large<br />
confidence. He will be able to stand upright<br />
and look another of his height in the eye. If<br />
we had done no other surgery, helping this<br />
young Tibetan boy and improving his<br />
quality of life would have made the trip<br />
worthwhile.<br />
Our last day was fully occupied with a<br />
review of each case, removing sutures and<br />
giving instructions on future management.<br />
We were all inundated with white prayer<br />
shawls given to us by patients as a gesture of<br />
thanks. The last night in Lhasa was a team<br />
dinner in a restaurant at the foot of the<br />
Potala and a time to reflect on the work<br />
done and the friends we had made. The<br />
team of professionals from six different<br />
countries had come together voluntarily to<br />
do what they could to help those in need in<br />
Tibet. These people are always special and it<br />
was interesting to see how each performed<br />
so well in their own discipline and<br />
functioned together as a team. There was<br />
satisfaction that, after nearly three weeks of<br />
working together, we had seen 142 patients<br />
and operated on 84 with no complications.<br />
The quality of life of those treated had been<br />
improved and the local doctors and nurses<br />
had seen what could be achieved.<br />
Case histories<br />
4). A French educational team had come<br />
across him living in a secluded village and as<br />
he could not attend school, his future was<br />
grim. The French team took a photo of him<br />
and sent it to Paris in the hope someone<br />
there might be able to help him.. The photo<br />
was sent to London and eventually found its<br />
way back to Paolo Morselli in Lhasa. The<br />
boy’s plight was extreme; the contracture<br />
caused his neck to be fixed in flexion to<br />
such a degree that his lower lip was fixed to<br />
his upper chest and the remainder of his<br />
chest scarred from shoulder to shoulder<br />
down to his upper abdomen. There was no<br />
expertise in Tibet to treat him and the<br />
possibility of him being treated elsewhere in<br />
China or overseas was remote.<br />
Tibetan boy with with graft in situ<br />
sheets of skin grafts were taken from his<br />
thighs to complete the repair of these areas.<br />
Enough blood had been transfused to<br />
replace what had been lost and his<br />
condition remained good throughout the<br />
operation. At the time of our departure, he<br />
was making an uncomplicated recovery. No<br />
doubt there will be need of further surgery<br />
in the future, but the major part of the<br />
correction had been achieved and he should<br />
be able to look to the future with more<br />
Peter & Pamela Brown with prayer wheels<br />
in the background<br />
The Tibet Interplast International<br />
team (Fig 6). had finished their work and it<br />
was to be one of the more memorable visits<br />
we have made to any countries. It was not<br />
the easiest because of the altitude and<br />
because of the dominance of the Chinese in<br />
Tibet but our patients were mostly Tibetans<br />
and they appreciated the help we were able<br />
to offer.<br />
1. Interplast is an international organisation<br />
but functions on a national basis. Its purpose is<br />
to provide Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery<br />
Continued on the next page<br />
19
Case histories<br />
to the citizens of developing countries<br />
throughout the world. Surgeons, anaesthetists<br />
and nurses work in a voluntary capacity and<br />
the organisation is funded by donation from<br />
sources such as Rotary International, some<br />
specific government funding and corporate<br />
and private donors. Interplast Australia is a<br />
non-profit aid organisation that has been in<br />
existence since 1983 and sends voluntary<br />
teams to 50 destinations in countries in the<br />
Southwest Pacific and Southeast Asia. The<br />
teams generally consist of 2 plastic and<br />
reconstructive surgeons, 1 anaesthetist and one<br />
theatre sister. The duration of the visits is two<br />
weeks. Apart from surgery, teaching is undertaken<br />
with the aim that the hospital staff will<br />
become proficient in the techniques used.<br />
2. Ever since their time in Saigon, Peter and<br />
Pam Brown have taken their skills in plastic<br />
and reconstructive surgery to many countries<br />
in the Far East. It is therefore very appropriate<br />
that their efforts have been formally recognised<br />
by the Australian Government. Peter Brown<br />
has been awarded the Australian Medal for<br />
service to medicine, particularly in the field of<br />
plastic and reconstructive surgery, and to<br />
overseas medical aid programmes and they<br />
have both received formal certificates from the<br />
Australian Government for their contributions<br />
towards assisting developing countries to reduce<br />
poverty and achieve sustainable development<br />
signed by the Prime Minister and the Minister<br />
for Foreign Affairs.<br />
Neostigmine-Glycopyrrolate and Antisnake Venom<br />
for Management of Neuroparalytic Poisoning<br />
20<br />
Drs Shashi Kiran, Balbir Chhabra & Preeti Goyal<br />
Department of Anaesthesiology and Critical Care<br />
Post-Graduate Institute of Medical Sciences<br />
Rohtak-124001, Haryana<br />
India<br />
Gupta3@vsnl.com<br />
goyalpreeti@hotmail.com<br />
Introduction<br />
Envenomation by snakes of the Elapidae family,<br />
commonly found in India, is characteristically<br />
neuroparalyic in nature. The interesting<br />
similarity of its electrophysiological features to<br />
myasthenia gravis and the limited availability of<br />
antisnake venom have prompted interest in the<br />
use of anticholinesterese therapy.<br />
Case Report<br />
A 30 year old man presented in the Accident<br />
and Emergency Department after being bitten<br />
on the dorsum of his right foot by a snake. His<br />
blood pressure was 160/100. pulse rate 92<br />
beats per minute and respiratory rate 14 breaths<br />
per minute with a good tidal volume. He had<br />
dilated pupils, ptosis, generalised muscle<br />
weakness and difficulty in swallowing but a<br />
good cough reflex.<br />
After first aid and the transfusion of<br />
antisnake venom, he was admitted to the<br />
Intensive Care Unit for observation. Within two<br />
hours of admission, his respiration became<br />
shallow and blood gas analysis showed a<br />
respiratory acidosis. He was intubated and<br />
artificial ventilation started. He was given<br />
fifteen vials of antisnake venom over 12 hours<br />
and neostigmine 2mg every four hours together<br />
with glycopyrrolate 0.2mg. Over the next day,<br />
his condition gradually improved and it was<br />
possible to wean him from the ventilator after<br />
72 hours. His muscle weakness resolved<br />
completely, he was able to swallow, had a good<br />
cough reflex and his pupil size returned to<br />
normal.<br />
Discussion<br />
Envemonation by members of the Elapidae<br />
family results in neuroparalytic features due to<br />
the curare-like action of the venom. Ptosis is<br />
usually the earliest paralytic manifestation<br />
followed by involvement of the muscles of the<br />
palate, jaw, tongue larynx and the muscles of<br />
swallowing. The chest muscles and diaphragm<br />
are involved later and cause respiratory failure<br />
as occurred in our patient.<br />
As well as general care and respiratory<br />
support, antisnake venom (ASV) is generally<br />
administered. ASV is a neurotoxin-specific<br />
immunoglobulin that accelerates dissociation of<br />
the neurotoxin/acetylcholine receptor complex.<br />
Unfortunately there is no consensus on the<br />
effective dose of ASV or indeed if it is of any<br />
value whatsoever. In several trials, there has<br />
been little or no change in morbidity or mortality<br />
after ASV was used and there appears to be no<br />
correlation between the dose of ASV<br />
administered and the size or site of the snake<br />
bite or the species of snake.<br />
As snake venom can cause<br />
pathophysiological features similar to<br />
myasthenia gravis, neostigmine has been<br />
suggested as an alternative therapy. Pandey et<br />
al. first added neostigmine to conventional<br />
treatment with ASV in 1969. They observed a<br />
dramatic improvement in neuroparalytic<br />
symptoms in 65 patients and recommended that<br />
it should be administered to all patients with<br />
paralytic symptoms. Moreover, Bomb et al have<br />
recently condemned the use of ASV and<br />
suggested that anticholinesterese drugs and<br />
good supportive care are all that is necessary.<br />
Neostigmine can be given as 50-100<br />
micrograms/kg four hourly or as a continuous<br />
infusion. Edrophonium has also been used in<br />
doses of 10mg in adults and 0.25mg/kg in<br />
children as a test and, if a positive response<br />
occurs, converting to the longer acting<br />
neostigmine. As there is no consensus on the<br />
optimum treatment, we elected to use<br />
neostigmine 2mg four hourly together with ASV.<br />
Although atropine is often used before<br />
neostigmine to counteract its muscarinic effects,<br />
as it is a tertiary ammonium compound it<br />
crosses the blood brain barrier. This can result in<br />
a central anticholinergic syndrome with<br />
confusion and prolonged muscle weakness. We,<br />
therefore, decided to use glycopyrrolate as<br />
unlike atropine, it does not cross the blood brain<br />
barrier.<br />
We are not sure whether ASV or<br />
neostigmine resulted in the early favourable<br />
outcome for our patient but their coadministration<br />
certainly resulted in a rapid<br />
neurological recovery. Therefore, we<br />
recommend glycopyrrolate-neostigmine with<br />
ASV for the management of patients with<br />
neuroparalytic symptoms following snake-bite.
Introducing Primary Trauma Care (PTC) to the<br />
Peoples’ Republic of China May 19 - 31 2002<br />
Stephen Swallow<br />
Specialist Anaesthetist<br />
Hobart<br />
Tasmania<br />
PTC in China<br />
The Peoples’ Republic of China is one of<br />
the two most populous countries in the<br />
world and one that is undergoing a period<br />
of rapid economic and industrial<br />
development. The rising number of traffic<br />
accidents and workplace injuries is placing<br />
an increasing burden on medical facilities<br />
particularly in rural and remote areas. This<br />
impression is confirmed both by anecdotal<br />
comments by experienced medical<br />
practitioners and also by data from studies<br />
such as the Global Burden of Disease<br />
study1 and ‘the Neglected Epidemic’: Road<br />
Traffic Injuries in Developing Countries2.<br />
Our decision to introduce the Primary<br />
Trauma Care (PTC) courses into the<br />
Peoples’ Republic of China was based on a<br />
fortuitous coincidence of events. Following<br />
a meeting of the Australian and New<br />
Zealand College of Anaesthetists (ANZCA)<br />
in Hong Kong in May 2001, there was a<br />
satellite meeting in Beijing. I spoke about<br />
PTC at that meeting and with the assistance<br />
of Dr T W Lee, President of the Hong<br />
Kong College of Anaesthesiology, we staged<br />
a demonstration trauma scenario.<br />
Dr T W Lee has been a strong supporter<br />
of the Primary Trauma Care programme<br />
in mainland China. At the Beijing meeting<br />
Professor Lize Xi’ong, Head of Department<br />
of Anaesthesia and Intensive Care, Xijing<br />
Hospital in Xi’an invited me to speak in more<br />
detail about PTC at an Intensive Care Meeting<br />
in Xi’an in September 2001 and has<br />
been instrumental in introducing the concept<br />
of PTC to the Peoples’ Republic of China.<br />
The PTC Programme in China<br />
In May 2002, we ran a two day instructor<br />
course in Hong Kong where we inducted a<br />
group of 14 emergency medicine,<br />
anaesthetic and intensive care specialists<br />
from Hong Kong and 2 specialists from<br />
Xi’an into the methodology of PTC. Many<br />
of the Hong Kong instructors were already<br />
experienced ATLS or APLS instructors.<br />
We divided these doctors into four<br />
groups of four that went to Xi’an, Beijing,<br />
Shanghai and Kunming. The course<br />
directors were Douglas Wilkinson (UK) in<br />
Shanghai, Tim Gray - emergency medicine<br />
physician, Royal Melbourne Hospital, in<br />
Beijing and Stephen Swallow (myself) in the<br />
other venues. Mrs. Diane Wilkinson was<br />
the educationalist for the courses. Professor<br />
Peter Cameron, currently Professor of<br />
Emergency Medicine at the Prince of Wales<br />
Hospital, Hong Kong on sabbatical leave<br />
from the Royal Melbourne Hospital,<br />
instructed on the programme in Xi’an.<br />
The Plan<br />
The plan was to run a two day trauma<br />
course followed by a one day instructor<br />
course for 16-24 experienced medical<br />
practitioners in each venue. The doctors<br />
that we inducted into the methodology of<br />
PTC would then form a local committee<br />
which, with appropriate support, would<br />
then run courses in the more remote parts<br />
of their provinces in China.<br />
The Reality<br />
Xi’an<br />
On the way from the airport to the hotel,<br />
on the evening before the course, we were<br />
advised that there would be ‘a few extra<br />
people’ perhaps between 100 and 200. On<br />
the first morning, there were 160 delegates<br />
from all over China. We modified the first<br />
two days so there were more<br />
demonstrational elements. Small group<br />
teaching with groups of 40 was interesting!<br />
The instructor course ran with 20<br />
participants along the lines that we had<br />
proposed and we ended up with a strong<br />
local PTC committee willing to organize<br />
and run future PTC courses.<br />
Shanghai and Beijing<br />
We met with only limited success in these<br />
two cities for several reasons: Professor Lize<br />
Xi’ong in Xi’an, my primary PTC contact<br />
in China is unusual amongst anaesthetists in<br />
China in that he has strong interests in<br />
Intensive Care and major trauma<br />
resuscitation. His anaesthetic colleagues in<br />
Beijing and Shanghai confine their sphere of<br />
influence to activities within the operating<br />
theatre and to anaesthetic research. We had,<br />
therefore, recruited representatives from the<br />
wrong specialty to effectively promote PTC.<br />
Emergency medicine is just starting to<br />
develop as a specialty in its own right in<br />
China. Directors of emergency<br />
departments in the principle cities of China<br />
face an enormous task to develop good<br />
emergency medicine systems for their whole<br />
province. There is a significant drop in<br />
staffing levels, expertise and resources once<br />
one leaves the major cities and ventures into<br />
the countryside.<br />
The director of the Beijing Chaoyang<br />
Hospital is anxious to develop a programme<br />
of post graduate education in emergency<br />
medicine and is keen to promote PTC.<br />
There is a recognition that when the<br />
Olympic Games come to Beijing in 2008,<br />
21<br />
Feature Extra
Feature Extra<br />
Beijing’s’ ability to look after foreign visitors<br />
who are accidentally injured will come<br />
under close scrutiny.<br />
We plan a return visit to Beijing in<br />
October 2002.<br />
Kunming<br />
By a happy chance, the primary contact in<br />
Kunming was Dr Xu Wang Bin. He has<br />
worked for 6 years in specialist anaesthetic<br />
and intensive care practice. A year ago, he<br />
was one of two specialists given the position<br />
of Director of the Emergency Department.<br />
He is committed to improving the standards<br />
of emergency care particularly in rural<br />
Yunnan province.<br />
The programme in Kunming ran<br />
smoothly and we trained 24 emergency<br />
medicine doctors. The PTC committee in<br />
Kunming includes Dr Xu, a senior Army<br />
doctor in charge of 17 trauma centres and<br />
the medical director of the ambulance<br />
service in Kunming.<br />
Issues<br />
PTC, ATLS and a lack of surgical<br />
representation<br />
It is not the intention of PTC to<br />
exclude surgeons and it was unfortunate<br />
that the one surgical instructor from Hong<br />
Kong that we were able to recruit was<br />
unable to take part as a result of other<br />
commitments. We view the PTC and ATLS<br />
programmes as mutually complementary.<br />
The target audience for PTC is junior<br />
doctors, registered nurses or health officers<br />
working in a small remote hospital with<br />
inadequate facilities whilst that for ATLS is<br />
surgical, anaesthetic and emergency<br />
medicine trainees and specialists in the<br />
teaching hospitals of the larger cities. We<br />
encourage ATLS to develop a programme in<br />
mainland China.<br />
Scenarios and small group teaching<br />
These methods of teaching were unfamiliar<br />
to our Chinese audience although they were<br />
interested to use these techniques in the<br />
future.<br />
The future for PTC in China<br />
We are optimistic that PTC is a useful<br />
programme for the Peoples’ Republic of<br />
China. We have gained strong acceptance<br />
in Xi’an and Kunming and a level of<br />
interest in Shanghai and Beijing.<br />
The teaching material, slides, manuals<br />
and instructor manuals have all been<br />
translated into Chinese script and our<br />
instructors in Hong Kong and at our<br />
regional office in Australia will be the key<br />
workers who will continue to support PTC<br />
in China.<br />
It is clear that emergency medicine is<br />
the specialty that will take ownership of<br />
PTC in China and a joint Australasian and<br />
Chinese emergency medicine and PTC meeting<br />
is planned for Beijing in October 2002.<br />
Conclusion<br />
We received lavish hospitality wherever we<br />
went in China and were made to feel most<br />
welcome. There is no doubt that modern<br />
China is an outward looking country with<br />
much to contribute to the rest of the world.<br />
It is important that we develop friendships<br />
with doctors in the Peoples’ Republic of<br />
China. My three visits to China over the<br />
last year have given me a much improved<br />
knowledge and understanding of this large<br />
and important country. I strongly<br />
encourage other anaesthetists, who have not<br />
done so to visit and teach in China.<br />
Acknowledgements<br />
This project was financed by the Australian<br />
Society of Anaesthetists. Abbott Australasia<br />
also provided financial support for the<br />
preliminary visits to China in 2001.<br />
References<br />
The Global Burden of Disease Study.<br />
Lancet 1997<br />
The Neglected Epidemic: road traffic<br />
injuries in developing countries. Vionand<br />
M, Nantulga and Michael R Reich. BMJ<br />
324, 11 May 2002, 1139-1141<br />
22<br />
The Department of Anaesthesiology,<br />
University of Calabar, Nigeria<br />
Dr Ini Abasi Ilori<br />
Dr Sylvia G Akpan<br />
University of Calabar Teaching Hospital<br />
Nigeria<br />
The city of Calabar on the south east coast<br />
of Nigeria has given its name to a<br />
variation of filariasis known as the<br />
Calabar swelling (loa loa) and the poisonous<br />
Calabar bean (Physostigma venenosum). The<br />
latter was first described in 1846 by the<br />
Scottish missionary, Dr William Freeman<br />
Daniel, and was used for trial by ordeal. Its<br />
local name is Esere, hence eserine for the<br />
phyostigmine alkaloid.<br />
Calabar is a quiet and tidy seaport with<br />
only one access/exit road through the<br />
surrounding mangrove swamps. It was at one<br />
time the capital of Nigeria and has one of the<br />
oldest secondary schools in the country. The<br />
dominant local language is Efik and Efik<br />
women have a reputation for being alluring<br />
and lovable. The traditional dish they cook of<br />
vegetables and dried fish is said to intoxicate<br />
men such the Calabar is also known as the city<br />
to Come And Live And Be At Rest.<br />
The University of Calabar is one of the<br />
third generation Nigerian universities. Although<br />
the Teaching Hospital was formally established<br />
in 1982 it grew out of St Margaret’s Hospital<br />
that was founded in 1897. The hospital now<br />
serves the 320,000 population of the city as<br />
well as acting as a referral centre for the entire<br />
Cross River and Awka Ibom states as well as<br />
West Cameroon (formerly part of Nigeria). The<br />
hospital has 508 beds and is managed by the<br />
Federal Ministry of Health. From the main<br />
theatre one can view the surrounding<br />
mangroves and the Atlantic Ocean.<br />
The Department of Anaesthesiology<br />
serves the specialties of general surgery,<br />
otorhinolaryngology, ophthalmology, burns and<br />
plastic surgery, maxillo-facial surgery, urology,<br />
orthopaedics and trauma surgery as well as<br />
obstetrics and gynaecology. Unfortunately, as<br />
the supply of water, electricity and medical<br />
gases can be erratic we do not practice hi-tech<br />
anaesthesia! Although we often have to<br />
improvise, we practice subarachnoid and<br />
epidural anaesthesia as well as 3-in-1 and<br />
sciatic blocks to minimise blood loss. Ketamine<br />
is frequently used for total intravenous<br />
anaesthesia. We use a variety of muscle<br />
relaxants but only have one volatile agent,<br />
halothane. We have a 3-bedded intensive care<br />
unit but it is only occasionally used. Our two<br />
Blease ventilators, donated by the<br />
Hammersmith Hospital, cannot be used due to<br />
lack of spare parts. When we have to ventilate
critically ill patients we have to do so manually<br />
with a self-inflating bag. A simply battery<br />
operated ventilator suitable for both adults and<br />
children would be tremendously useful in our<br />
hospital.<br />
(Editorial note: Perhaps they would find<br />
the Glostavent described in World Anaesthesia<br />
Vol. 6, No. 1 useful).<br />
Our department is staffed by<br />
consultants, residents and nurse anaesthetists.<br />
The Faculty of Anaesthetists of the National<br />
Postgraduate Medical College of Nigeria<br />
regulates training in anaesthesia. Training lasts<br />
4-5 years and candidates for the Fellowship<br />
have to pass a three part (primary, parts 1 and<br />
11) examination. Our department is accredited<br />
to undertake part of this training but trainees<br />
have to move to Lagos, Ibaden or Enugu to<br />
gain experience in cardiothoracic and neuroanaesthesia.<br />
We have successfully trained two<br />
consultants. The first Nigerian trainee to spend<br />
time with Dr Roger Eltringham in the UK came<br />
from Calabar and is now a fellow of the West<br />
African College of Surgeons and is training<br />
anaesthetists at a Teaching Hospital in<br />
northern Nigeria. The second spent time with<br />
Prof. Rocke as a WFSA trainee in South Africa,<br />
is a fellow of the National Postgraduate<br />
Medical College and is now a consultant in<br />
Calabar.<br />
We enjoy the services of two<br />
consultants from the Nigerian military: one is a<br />
senior naval officer currently attached to the<br />
naval base at Calabar; the other is a retired<br />
army colonel. The foundation professor of<br />
anaesthesia in this department has recently<br />
returned home after working overseas and,<br />
although retired, has donated funds towards<br />
developing our teaching infrastructure. We<br />
have seven residents at various stages in their<br />
training; five have already gained the Diploma<br />
in Anaesthesia.<br />
As elsewhere in Nigeria, we have<br />
difficulty attracting new entrants to the<br />
specialty as anaesthesia is not as financially<br />
rewarding as other specialties. However, we<br />
feel that if we can provide the necessary<br />
training aids, books and journals so that our<br />
residents can pass their examinations at the<br />
first attempt, we will be able to attract and<br />
keep the young doctors who rotate through our<br />
department on their national youth service<br />
year. We, therefore, hope to be able to twin<br />
with an anaesthetic department is a developed<br />
English-speaking country so that we can offer<br />
our trainees 3-6 months of exposure to modern<br />
anaesthetic practice. If you can help, please<br />
contact us.<br />
Email: bidemiilori@yahoo.com<br />
Feature Extra<br />
Book Review<br />
Oxford Handbook of Anaesthesia<br />
Allman KG & Wilson IH Oxford University Press, pp 1139<br />
This book assumes a basic knowledge of<br />
anaesthesia and aims to offer practical advice<br />
and guidance to the practicing anaesthetist. It<br />
has some forty major contributors, all now<br />
working in the UK although many have had<br />
considerable previous experience elsewhere.<br />
The first section, chapters 1-12, covers<br />
pre-operative assessment and considers the<br />
anaesthetic implications of pre-existing<br />
medical conditions. Sections II (chapters 13-33)<br />
considers anaesthesia for the major surgical<br />
specialties with sections III and IV covering<br />
obstetrics and paediatrics respectively. Section<br />
V is concerned with the management of<br />
anaesthetic emergencies. Section VI (chapters<br />
37-48) usefully considers a number of practical<br />
issues such as blood transfusion, the<br />
management of inoculation injury and death on<br />
the table. Acute pain management is discussed<br />
in section VII and regional anaesthesia in section<br />
VIII. The book concludes with a drug formulary, a<br />
series of suggested infusion regimes and lists<br />
of normal values. Also included are an<br />
apparatus checklist, a list of anaesthetic web<br />
sites and, on the flysheets, protocols for<br />
advanced life support, failed intubation and the<br />
management of anaphylaxis.<br />
Although not a book to attempt to read<br />
from cover to cover, it is very reader friendly<br />
with a comprehensive index. The chapter authors<br />
attempt to offer, based on their experience<br />
and normal practice, guidance to the reader on<br />
the management of a variety of everyday and<br />
sometimes very unusual scenarios. Each<br />
section is clearly set out so that it is easy for<br />
the reader to find the information they seek.<br />
Inevitably, there are omissions, even in a<br />
book of over one thousand pages of small print,<br />
and one might wonder if grafting a section on<br />
regional anaesthesia on to the text would be of<br />
any value: it is. This book offer sensible and<br />
readily accessible advice to anaesthetists<br />
facing a problem they rarely encounter and is a<br />
valuable resource for anyone asked to prepare<br />
a lecture at short notice.<br />
As it says on its cover, this book is a<br />
concise yet comprehensive guide for all<br />
anaesthetists. In developed countries, both<br />
trainees and established practitioners should<br />
find it a useful vade-mecum and for<br />
anaesthetists in developing countries who<br />
have to manage every situation with minimal<br />
resources and no super-specialist to advise and<br />
support them, it will be invaluable.<br />
At less than £20 (approx. $30 or € 30),<br />
this book is spectacular value for money. We<br />
suggest you order a copy immediately.<br />
Carola Andrick, Consultant Anaesthetist<br />
Mbarara University Hospital, Uganda<br />
William Casey<br />
UK<br />
23
Useful Information<br />
Useful Information<br />
World Federation of Societies of<br />
Anaesthesiologists (WFSA)<br />
7th Floor, Imperial house<br />
15-19 Kingsway<br />
London<br />
WC2B 6TH,<br />
United Kingdom<br />
Tel: (+44) 020 7836 5652<br />
Fax: (+44) 020 7836 5616<br />
Email: office@wfsa-office.org<br />
info@wfsa-office.org<br />
Courses in Anaesthesia for the<br />
developing world.<br />
Oxford (UK): July (annually).<br />
Contact: Dr. M. Dobson<br />
Department of Anaesthesia<br />
John Radcliffe Hospital<br />
Headley Way,<br />
Headington,<br />
Oxford,<br />
OX3 9DU, UK<br />
Tel: (+44) 01865 221589.<br />
E-mail: michael.dobson@ndm.ox.ac.uk<br />
Bristol (UK): December (annually).<br />
Contact: Dr. Claire Jewkes<br />
Department of Anaesthesia<br />
Frenchay Hospital,<br />
Bristol,<br />
BS16 ILE,<br />
UK<br />
Tel: (+44) 01179 701212.<br />
Remote Situations, Difficult<br />
Circumstances, Developing<br />
Country Anaesthesia<br />
Hobart or Launceston (alternate years),<br />
Tasmania, Australia<br />
Contact: Dr Haydn Perndt<br />
Royal Hobart Hospital<br />
GPO Box 1061-L,<br />
Hobart,<br />
TAS 7001<br />
Australia<br />
Email: haydn.perndt@utas.edu.au<br />
Primary Trauma Care Foundation<br />
The foundation exists to improve the<br />
management of trauma in the developing<br />
world. It has organised training courses in<br />
the South Pacific, Asia, Africa and South<br />
America.<br />
Contact: Dr Douglas Wilkinson<br />
313 Woodstock Road<br />
Oxford<br />
OX2 7NY<br />
UK<br />
Email: PTC@nda.ox.ac.uk<br />
Equipment collection and distribution<br />
to the developing world<br />
Contact: ECHO<br />
Ullswater Crescent<br />
Coulsdon,<br />
Surrey,<br />
CR3 2HR,<br />
UK<br />
Tel: (+44) 020 8660 2220<br />
Carelift International Inc.<br />
185 Walnut Street (Floor 22)<br />
Philadelphia P.A. 19103,<br />
USA<br />
Tel: (+1) 215 535 3590<br />
Dr. William Rosenblatt<br />
REMEDY<br />
Dept. of Anaesthesia<br />
Yale University School of Medicine<br />
333 Cedar Street,<br />
New Haven<br />
CT 06510,<br />
USA<br />
Book Aid International<br />
39-41 Coldharbour Lane<br />
Camberwell,<br />
London,<br />
SE5 9NR,<br />
UK<br />
Tel: (+44) 020 7733 3577<br />
The organisation is interested in receiving<br />
recent complete sets of journals and newish<br />
text books. These are collected free and<br />
distributed by Rotarians.<br />
Society for Education in<br />
Anaesthesia<br />
International members are invited to join this<br />
Society that promotes techniques and<br />
excellence in the teaching of Anaesthesia.<br />
520N Northwest Highway<br />
Park Ridge,<br />
Illinois 60069-2573,<br />
USA<br />
Tel: (847) 825 5586<br />
Fax: (847) 825 5658<br />
Email: sea@asahq.org<br />
Web: www.seahq.org<br />
The TOKTEN Project<br />
Expatriate nationals returning to their country of<br />
origin are invited to apply for the post of project<br />
expert. Each project is sponsored by the United<br />
Nations who would meet the cost of international<br />
travel and pay a subsistence allowance ($90/day).<br />
Applications should be made to the Minister of<br />
Health of the host developing nation.<br />
Technical Assistance at Low Cost (TALC)<br />
Books, videos etc at low cost<br />
Contact: PO Box 49<br />
St Albans<br />
Herts<br />
AL1 5TX<br />
UK<br />
Tel: (+44) 1727 853869<br />
Fax: (+44) 1727 846852<br />
www.talcuk.org<br />
Douleurs Sans Frontieres (DSF)<br />
Goals<br />
1. To participate, to create or to encourage any<br />
structure involved in the treatment of pain and<br />
suffering (cancer pain, AIDS, acute pain etc).<br />
2. To search for therapeutic methods, to provide<br />
training and to propagate knowledge about<br />
pain and suffering especially in developing<br />
countries<br />
For further information contact:<br />
Docteur Alain Serrie<br />
Hôpital Lariboisière<br />
2, rue Ambroise Paré,<br />
75010 Paris, France<br />
Tel: (+33) 1 49 95 81 77<br />
Fax: (+33) 1 49 95 69 98<br />
Email: alain.serrie@lrb.ap-hop-paris.fr<br />
24
or Docteur Jacques Meynadier<br />
Centre Oscar Lambret<br />
BP 307-59020 Lille cedex,<br />
France<br />
Tel: (+33) 3 20 29 59 89<br />
Fax: (+33) 3 20 29 59 97<br />
Email: j-meynadier@o-lambret.fr<br />
The International Committee of<br />
the Red Cross (ICRC)<br />
The ICRC acts to help all victims of war and<br />
internal violence, attempting to ensure<br />
implementation of humanitarian rules<br />
restricting armed violence.<br />
Contact: ICRC,<br />
Recruitment Division<br />
19 Ave. de la Paix,<br />
CH-1202<br />
Geneva,<br />
Switzerland<br />
or your local society.<br />
Email: http://www.icrc.ch<br />
Overseas Doctors Training Scheme<br />
(UK)<br />
Anaesthetists seeking recognised training<br />
posts in the UK should apply to:<br />
Bemard Johnson, Adviser<br />
Royal College of Anaesthetists<br />
8 Russell Square,<br />
London<br />
WC1B 4JX,<br />
UK<br />
Tel: (+44) 020 7637 4104<br />
Emain: info@rcoa.ac.uk<br />
www.rcoa.ac.uk<br />
The SOROS Foundation<br />
will consider applications from anaesthetists<br />
in Eastern and Central Europe for support for<br />
limited periods of study in the UK.<br />
Applications should be made in advance to<br />
the branch office of their country of origin<br />
whose address may be obtained from:<br />
The Soros Foundation<br />
400 West 59th Street<br />
New York,<br />
NY 10019,<br />
USA<br />
Tel: (+1) 212 548 0600<br />
Fax: (+1) 212 548 4600.<br />
E-mail: osnews@sorosny.org<br />
Teaching Videos:<br />
The following titles are available at £5 each:<br />
1. Servicing the EMO & Tri-Service vaporisers<br />
2. The oxygen concentrator<br />
3. The Manley multivent/Glostavent<br />
4. Servicing the anaesthetic machine<br />
Contact: Dr. R Eltringham<br />
Gloucestershire Royal Hospital<br />
Gloucester,<br />
GLI 3NN,<br />
UK<br />
Tel: (+44) 01452 394786/394194<br />
Fax: (+44) 01452 394485<br />
E-mail: 106147.2366@compuserve.com<br />
Job opportunities in the<br />
developing world<br />
These are listed in a bimonthly magazine<br />
produced by the International Health Exchange.<br />
Contact: Ms Isobel McConnan<br />
8-10, Dryden Street<br />
London,<br />
WC2E 9NA,<br />
UK<br />
Tel: (+44) 020 7836 5833<br />
Fax: (+44)020 7379 1239<br />
E-mail:<br />
health exchange@compuserve.com<br />
www.ihe.org.uk<br />
US volunteers wishing to spend<br />
periods working in developing<br />
countries<br />
Contact: Dr. Lena Dohlman<br />
Health Volunteers Overseas<br />
c/o Washington Station, PO.<br />
Box 65157<br />
Washington DC 20035-5157,<br />
USA<br />
Tel: (+1) 202 296 0928<br />
Fax: (+1) 202 296 8018<br />
Committee Chair<br />
Overseas Teaching Program<br />
American Society of Anesthesiologists<br />
520 N. Northwest Highway<br />
Park Ridge,<br />
IL 60068-2573,<br />
USA<br />
World Anaesthesia<br />
This organisation works to improve standards<br />
of anaesthesia throughout the world. In<br />
conjunction with the WFSA, it produces two<br />
publications, World Anaesthesia News and<br />
Update in Anaesthesia* (an add-on textbook)<br />
published twice-yearly. The annual subscription<br />
is £10. For further information<br />
Contact: Dr. C Collins<br />
Department of Anaesthesia<br />
Royal Devon and Exeter Hospital<br />
Barrack Road,<br />
Exeter,<br />
Devon<br />
EX2 5DW,<br />
United Kingdom<br />
Tel: (+44) 01392 411611<br />
* also available on:<br />
http://www.nda.ox.ac.uk/wfsa<br />
Courses on Anaesthetic Equipment<br />
Maintenance<br />
One week residential courses for anaesthetic<br />
technicians are organised at the NHS training and<br />
conference centre. Applications should be sent to:<br />
Geoffrey Dillow<br />
Conference Centre,<br />
Wotton under Edge<br />
Gloucester,<br />
GLI2 8DA,<br />
UK.<br />
Association for International<br />
Development of Anaesthesia<br />
(A.I.D.A.)<br />
Contact: Professor Stanley Samuels<br />
Department of Anesthesia<br />
Stanford University Medical Centre<br />
Stanford,<br />
California,<br />
USA<br />
Tel: (+1) 415 723 6411<br />
Fax: (+1) 415 723 8544<br />
Email: Samuels@Ieland.stanford.edu<br />
Useful Information<br />
25
Useful Information<br />
26<br />
Useful Information continued<br />
Commonwealth Medical Awards<br />
Available to citizens of Commonwealth<br />
countries for limited periods of postgraduate<br />
study within the UK. Applications should be<br />
addressed to:<br />
The Medical Awards Administrator<br />
Commonwealth Scholarship Commission<br />
36 Gordon Square<br />
London<br />
WC1H IPE,<br />
UK<br />
Medecins Sans Frontieres (MSF)<br />
offers assistance to populations in distress,<br />
to victims of natural and man-made disasters<br />
and to victims of armed conflict. They require<br />
volunteers for both long and short-term<br />
projects. If you are interested in obtaining<br />
more information, contact them at:<br />
MSF<br />
124-132 Clerkenwell Road<br />
London<br />
ECIR 5DL,<br />
UK<br />
Tel: (+44) 020 7713 5600<br />
Fax: (+44) 020 7713 5004 or<br />
11 East 26th St.<br />
Suite 1904<br />
New York NY 10010,<br />
USA<br />
Tel: (+1) 212 679 6800.<br />
Email: http://www.msf.org or<br />
http://www.dwb.org<br />
Merlin<br />
5-13 Trinity Street<br />
London<br />
SE1 1DB<br />
Tel: (+44) 20 7378 4888<br />
www.merlin.org.uk<br />
WHO Liaison Officer<br />
Dr M Dobson<br />
Nuffield Department of Anaesthetics<br />
The John Radcliffe Hospital<br />
Headley Way<br />
Headington<br />
Oxford,<br />
OX3 9DU,<br />
UK<br />
Tel: (+44) 01865 221589/741166<br />
Fax: (+44) 01865 221593/453266.<br />
E-mail: michael.dobson@ndm.ox.ac.uk<br />
If you wish to advertise your organisation on<br />
this page (free-of-charge), please contact:<br />
The Editor Dr W F Casey<br />
Popes Cottage,<br />
Cheltenham Road,<br />
Painswick,<br />
Gloucester,<br />
GL6 6TS,<br />
UK<br />
Tel: (+44) 01452 814229<br />
Fax: (+44) 01452 812162<br />
Email: wfcasey@doctors.org.uk<br />
Produced and Distributed by:<br />
Media Publishing Company<br />
Media House,<br />
41 Crayford Way,<br />
Crayford,<br />
Kent<br />
DA1 4JY,<br />
UK<br />
Tel: (+44) 01322 558029<br />
Fax: (+44) 01322 558524<br />
E-mail: MediaPublishers@aol.com<br />
Electronic Publication<br />
of “Update in<br />
Anaesthesia”<br />
● “Update in Anaesthesia” is an<br />
education journal produced by “World<br />
Anaesthesia”, widely distributed and<br />
acclaimed in many developing<br />
countries.<br />
● An electronic version of “Update”<br />
including back issues is now available –<br />
you can read it on your computer<br />
screen (using suitable free software),<br />
and download and/or print all or part<br />
of it for reference.<br />
● If you have an Internet connection you<br />
can access “Update” at<br />
http://www.nda.ox.ac.uk/wfsa It can be<br />
viewed with either a graphical browser<br />
(looks prettier) such as Netscape or a<br />
text-only browser such as Lynx.<br />
● If you don’t have Internet access but do<br />
have a computer, we can post you the<br />
same material on floppy disk with<br />
instructions on use. (N.B. This only<br />
applies to developing countries.)<br />
● You do not need the latest and most<br />
expensive computer to make use of<br />
Electronic Update: a 286-PC should be<br />
adequate. If you need technical advice,<br />
please write to Dr Mike Dobson,<br />
Nuffield Department of Anaesthetics,<br />
John Radcliffe Hospital, Oxford, OX3<br />
9DU, UK., or send an Email request<br />
to: michael.dobson@ndm.ox.ac.uk<br />
● An electronic version of “World<br />
Anaesthesia Newsletter” (incorporating<br />
“Anaesthesia Worldwide”) including<br />
back issues in similar format is also<br />
now available at the same Internet site.
Anaesthetic web sites to try<br />
Resources<br />
Anaesthesia & Critical Care Resources on the Internet<br />
(AACRI)<br />
Anesthesia Web<br />
Anesthesia International<br />
Audio Digest Foundation<br />
Australian Society Overseas Aid<br />
Bandolier (Evidence-based medicine)<br />
Echocardiography<br />
Gaseous anomaly<br />
GASNet Anesthesiology Home Page<br />
International Anesthesia Research Society<br />
Illustrated Regional Anesthesia<br />
Medical World Search<br />
Primary Internet resources for anaesthetists<br />
Primary Trauma Care Foundation<br />
Society for Education in Anaesthesia<br />
The National Library of Medicine<br />
The Trauma Organisation<br />
University of Chicago<br />
Virtual Anaesthetic Machine<br />
Virtual Anaesthesia Textbook<br />
Virtual Museum of Anesthesiology<br />
World Anaesthesia Online<br />
http://www.eur.nl/cgi-bin/accri.pl<br />
http://www.anesthesiaweb.com/<br />
http://www.geocities.com/anestint<br />
http://www.audio-digest.org<br />
http://www.asa.org.au/committess/oseasaid<br />
http://www.jr2.ac.uk/Bandolier<br />
http://www2.umdnj.edu/shindler/echo.html<br />
http://www.anaesthesia.ml.org<br />
http://gasnet.med.vale.edu<br />
http://www.anaesthesia-analgesia.org<br />
http://weber.u.washington.edu/~aelizaga/regional/welcome<br />
http:/.mwsearch.com/<br />
http:/gasnet.dundee.ac.uk:1081/mirror/vat/MajRes.html<br />
http:/www.nda.ox.ac.uk/wfsa/dl/html/pages/ptc.htm<br />
http:/www.www.seahq.org<br />
http://www.nsbi.nlm.nih.gov/PubMed/<br />
http://www.trauma.org/<br />
http://www.airway.bsd.uchicago.edu<br />
http://www.ufl.anest.edu/van<br />
http://www-usvd.edu.au/su/anaes/VAT/VAT.html<br />
http://umdas.med.miami.edu/aha/vma<br />
http://www.nda.ox.ac.uk/wfsa<br />
Websites to try<br />
Journals:<br />
African Anaesthetist<br />
Anaesthesia<br />
Anaesthesia and Analgesia<br />
Anaesthesia and Intensive Care<br />
Anesthesiology<br />
British Journal of Anaesthesia<br />
JAMA<br />
NEJM<br />
Science<br />
The Internet Journal of Anaesthesia<br />
http:/www.africananaes@lycos.com<br />
http://www.blackwell-science.com/ana<br />
http:/anaesthesia-analgesia.org<br />
http://www.aaic.net.au/home.html<br />
http://www.anesthesiology.org<br />
http://bja.oupjournals.org<br />
http://www.ama-assn.org/public/joumals/jama/jamahome-html<br />
http://www.nejm-org/content/index.asp<br />
http://www.sciencemag.org/<br />
http://www.ispub.com/journals/ja.htm<br />
Associations:<br />
American Society of Anaesthesiologists (ASA)<br />
http://asahq.org<br />
Anaesthetic Research Society<br />
http://www.ars.ac.uk<br />
Armenian Society of Anaesthesiologists<br />
http://freenet.am/~armanest<br />
Association of Anaesthetists of Great Britain & Ireland<br />
http://www.<strong>aagbi</strong>.org<br />
European Academy of Anaesthesiology<br />
http://www.eaa.euro-anaesthesiology.org/<br />
International Society for the Study of Pain http://www.halcyon.com /iasp<br />
International Trauma Anaesthesia & Critical Care Society http://www.trauma.itaccs.com<br />
National Confidential Enquiry Peri-operative Deaths<br />
http://www.ncepod.org.uk<br />
Obstetric Anaesthetists Association<br />
http://oaa-anaes.ac.uk<br />
Royal College of Anaesthetists<br />
http://www.rcoa.ac.uk/<br />
Society for Ambulatory Anaesthesia<br />
http://www.sambahq.org<br />
Society for Critical Care Medicine<br />
http://www.sccm.org<br />
Society for Computing and Technology in Anaesthesia http://www.scata.orh.uk/programs/list.html<br />
Society for Education in Anesthesia<br />
http://anesthesia.ccf.org:8080/sea/index.htm<br />
Society for Obstetric Anesthesia & Perinatology (SOAP) http://www.soap.org<br />
Society for Paediatric Anaesthesia<br />
http://www.uams.edu/spa<br />
South African Society of Anaesthesiologists<br />
http://www.sasaweb.com<br />
World Federation of Societies of Anaesthesiologists<br />
www.anaesthesiologists.org<br />
The editor would be delighted to hear of other sites that might be of interest and to learn of any site addresses that are incorrect or no<br />
longer function<br />
27
News and Information<br />
The African Anaesthetist<br />
Dr. David Nekyon<br />
Dept. of Anaesthesia<br />
Mulago Hospital<br />
Kampala<br />
Uganda<br />
How often has someone wanted to contact<br />
an anaesthetic society or a department of<br />
anaesthesia in Africa and not known<br />
where to start! If I wanted to attend the<br />
annual conference of an African society in,<br />
say, Cameroon I would not have a clue on<br />
how to find out when and where it would<br />
be held.<br />
It was because of such frustration<br />
that I have started the ‘African<br />
Anaesthetist’ website. After teaching<br />
myself HTML codes and messing around<br />
with Dreamweaver software on Sunday<br />
afternoons it is finally ready.<br />
The website consists of several pages<br />
and includes links to web pages that I have<br />
found interesting and helpful as they are<br />
practical and often appropriate for my<br />
situation. Lecture notes, tutorials and<br />
practice manuals are all easy to find.<br />
The list of links is quite extensive<br />
and constantly being updated. Links may<br />
take you to whole websites or more often<br />
just to particular parts of a site, thus bypassing<br />
a lot of unnecessary preambles and<br />
making it less likely that the surfing<br />
anaesthetist will get lost!<br />
There is a discussion group where<br />
fellow anaesthetists can drop comments<br />
and hopefully engage in lively debate. A<br />
chat room will be added if the demand for<br />
it is high enough. There is an African<br />
survey in which you can vote and instantly<br />
see the results. The current survey is<br />
looking at the availability of an assistant to<br />
apply cricoid pressure during an obstetric<br />
anaesthetic.<br />
You will also find a link to a website<br />
that offers online MCQ exams and gives<br />
you your results as well as one to an online<br />
clinical game called ‘surgeons and dragons’<br />
that should test your clinical judgment.<br />
There is also slowly growing list of<br />
addresses of academic departments and<br />
societies of anaesthesia in Africa. This<br />
should hopefully help overcome the<br />
difficulties we face in trying to contact<br />
each other. If your country’s address is<br />
missing just get in touch and it will be<br />
added immediately<br />
(africanaes@lycos.com).<br />
I have also included a diary of<br />
conferences in Africa and some<br />
international ones that may be of interest<br />
to African anaesthetists. Please contact me<br />
and tell me about your meetings.<br />
The website is designed so that even<br />
the most techno-phobic African<br />
anaesthesiologist should be able to<br />
navigate his way around and find what he/<br />
she is looking for. I hope the site will<br />
become a useful resource for both the<br />
working anaesthetist and the specialist<br />
trainee enabling them to increase their<br />
knowledge.<br />
The website address is<br />
http://africananaesthetist.tripod.com<br />
Contact the Editor: africanaes@lycos.com<br />
Working in the UK<br />
28<br />
We frequently receive requests from<br />
doctors in the developing world for<br />
information about working in the<br />
UK. They request help with registering with<br />
the General Medical Council, sponsorship,<br />
finding jobs and taking (or avoiding the need<br />
to take) the Professional and Linguistic<br />
Assessment Board (PLAB) exam.<br />
It is difficult to give accurate advice as<br />
the rules are complex and constantly<br />
change. To work in the UK, you need to<br />
register with the General Medical Council. If<br />
you qualified in the UK or from a medical<br />
school in Australia, New Zealand or the<br />
West Indies, certain universities in Hong<br />
Kong, Singapore and South Africa or the<br />
University of Malaysia before December<br />
1987 you should have no difficulty obtaining<br />
full registration. Likewise, if you graduated<br />
from a medical school in another European<br />
Economic Area (EAA) state and are a<br />
national of an EAA state or have right of<br />
abode in the EAA, you will have no<br />
problems. If you do not have right of abode<br />
in the EEA but qualified from a medical<br />
school listed in the WHO list of approved<br />
medical schools, you have rather more<br />
hurdles to clear before you can be<br />
registered. You will need to obtain<br />
information about visa requirements and<br />
passing the Professional and Linguistic<br />
Assessment Board examinations (PLAB &<br />
IELTS). If your medical school does not<br />
appear on the WHO list, contact the GMC<br />
before trying to proceed.<br />
Recently, the UK government has<br />
encouraged the recruitment overseas of<br />
doctors and others with skills that are in<br />
short supply in the UK (the Highly Skilled<br />
Migrant Programme). Slightly different rules<br />
apply to this group but anaesthetists are not<br />
currently among those being recruited<br />
There are now a number of websites<br />
that provide accurate and up-to-date advice<br />
that you may find helpful. You should find<br />
much of the information you require at:<br />
The General Medical Council:<br />
www.gmc-uk.org<br />
The National Advice Centre for Postgraduate<br />
Medical Education:<br />
www.britishcouncil.org/health/nacpe<br />
Professional and Linguistic Assessment<br />
Board (PLAB)<br />
www.britishcouncil.org./health/nacpme/<br />
plab.htm<br />
International English Language Testing<br />
Scheme<br />
www.ielts.org<br />
The Department of Health:<br />
www.doh.gov.uk/medicaltrainingintheuk<br />
www.doh.gov.uk/internation-recruitment<br />
The Royal College of Anaesthetists<br />
www.rcoa.ac.uk<br />
The World Health Organisation<br />
www.who.int/health-servicesdelivery/med_schools/<br />
UK Foreign Office<br />
www.fco.gov.uk/ukvisas<br />
UK Immigration Service<br />
www.ukimmigration.com/hsmp<br />
UK National Health Service<br />
www.nhs.uk
The WFSA in a new century<br />
The world at large – not only in<br />
anaesthesia – has changed more<br />
than usual in the past year. We<br />
seem to have moved away from dialogue,<br />
debate and argument to more and more<br />
dramatic violence. The events of<br />
September 11, 2001 were the ultimate and<br />
disastrous demonstration. On a smaller<br />
scale though, around the world, suicide<br />
bombings for other –sometimes<br />
incomprehensible - causes took place.<br />
Imagine: your child goes to school<br />
in the morning, never to return, because<br />
one of her fellow students was not<br />
allowed to sit an exam and decided to kill<br />
the responsible teachers. Your child was<br />
in the way. Your husband, a fireman in<br />
New York goes to work in the morning,<br />
never to return because of the<br />
inconceivable event of a hijacked<br />
aeroplane crashing into the World Trade<br />
Centre. In horror and disgust, all of us<br />
around the world were listening to our<br />
radios and glued to the TV screens. We<br />
mourn all the victims of this senseless,<br />
useless violence, and convey our<br />
sympathy to all the relatives, colleagues<br />
and friends. May it change our own<br />
attitude and behaviour in life so that at<br />
least some good comes out of these<br />
horrific events; if all of us brought a little<br />
peace around us in our world, maybe - in<br />
the end it could have a roll on effect.<br />
Another remarkable change is the<br />
emphasis on money making and the lack<br />
of it at the moment. Anything – even in<br />
health care or education - must be cost<br />
effective at least, or preferably make<br />
money, otherwise it is not considered<br />
useful. For the past three to four World<br />
Congresses, it was generally accepted that<br />
any surplus facilitated the educational and<br />
publication efforts of the World<br />
Federation of Societies of<br />
Anaesthesiologists. We, the organisers,<br />
were proud of having contributed to the<br />
world of anaesthesia at large. Being cost<br />
conscious during and prior to the World<br />
Congress, and with the help of industry<br />
and the registering delegates, it became<br />
possible to establish training centres in<br />
countries where no training was available.<br />
The organisers of the last World<br />
Congress in Canada, despite being very<br />
successful in attracting a large attendance<br />
and providing excellent scientific content,<br />
met with a grumbling industry and some<br />
less than willing invited speakers.<br />
Nevertheless, they managed to make a<br />
significant contribution towards the<br />
training programmes in Thailand, Ghana,<br />
Israel and Chile. Until now being invited<br />
to address the delegates of the World<br />
Congress had been considered an honour:<br />
now some speakers demand first class<br />
airfares, accommodation and a fee.<br />
Industry, faced with mergers<br />
(becoming bigger and wealthier as they<br />
merge but fewer in number), are reluctant<br />
to commit themselves to the next World<br />
Congress in Paris. Yes, the economy has<br />
been less buoyant and yes, we all have to<br />
tighten the belt, but do anaesthesiologists<br />
have to contribute to the widening of the<br />
economic gap between us and our<br />
colleagues of the less affluent world?<br />
Would it not be possible for all the<br />
anaesthesiologists in the well-to-do world<br />
to donate from their own personal money<br />
US$100, £100 or € 100 per year? That is<br />
two units of each currency per week that<br />
means one daily newspaper less, or half a<br />
bottle of wine, or... ? With such money,<br />
WFSA could establish Anaesthesia Schools<br />
in all those less affluent parts of the world<br />
and we could truly serve to -<br />
Make available the highest<br />
standards of anaesthesia,<br />
resuscitation and pain relief to<br />
all peoples of the world<br />
Michael Rosen, the chairman of<br />
WFSA Foundation, has found willing ears<br />
in the Association of Anaesthetists of<br />
Great Britain and Ireland. They will<br />
launch an appeal in their September<br />
Newsletter, asking for a voluntary<br />
donation from their members with the<br />
regular subscription to the Association.<br />
The Australian Society has done this for<br />
years for their projects in the Pacific<br />
Ocean. Which of our National Societies<br />
is going to follow these examples? Yes, of<br />
course we need transparent and clear<br />
budgets for all these exercises. We will<br />
know however where our donations go.<br />
This ought to be an effort of no more<br />
than ten to twenty years. We may even<br />
see it to completion in our own lifetime.<br />
Eventually there will be enough<br />
anaesthesiologists trained to provide safe<br />
anaesthesia and pain relief to their own<br />
people.<br />
National Member Societies<br />
Both Ruth Hooper and Rose Zawazawa<br />
are energetic in their endeavour to make<br />
the WFSA database of national member<br />
societies correct and up to date. Please<br />
note a number of changes in the address<br />
list. New applications for membership<br />
have been received from Surinam, West<br />
Indies, Netherlands Antilles, Mozambique,<br />
Ethiopia, Botswana, and Brunei.<br />
Executive Committee and Officers<br />
Just two weeks after September 11, most<br />
of us managed to attend a very successful<br />
2nd All Africa Anaesthesia Congress in<br />
Durban, South Africa. Both the African<br />
Regional Section as well as the South<br />
African Society of Anaesthetists is warmly<br />
congratulated on a successful meeting,<br />
both scientifically as well as socially. We<br />
look forward to the next meeting in<br />
Tunisia (2005). The members of the<br />
Executive Committee studied closely the<br />
(negative) budget as accepted in Montreal,<br />
Canada. They requested the Treasurer and<br />
Finance Committee to revise this to a<br />
budget which would be in balance from<br />
2003 onwards. All administrative costs<br />
have been brought down to less than 50<br />
% of the total budget. It was also decided<br />
that those societies that paid dues in 2003<br />
would be in good standing to attend the<br />
General Assembly in 2004.<br />
Standing Committees<br />
The Education Committee has now<br />
established and actively supports four<br />
training centres. All the members of the<br />
Education Committee are active within<br />
their region. More than twenty countries<br />
were visited by teachers or instructors on<br />
refresher courses, mostly Asia, Africa and<br />
South America. Eastern Europe is also<br />
being well supported by Confederation of<br />
European National Societies of<br />
Anaesthesiologists. Douglas Wilkinson<br />
29<br />
News and Information
News and Information<br />
and his Primary Trauma Care Team have<br />
captured the interest and blessing of the<br />
World Health Organisation with the<br />
Primary Trauma Course. We extend our<br />
warmest congratulations and apologise for<br />
the unfortunate omission of news of their<br />
activities in the previous annual report.<br />
The Publication Committee, quietly<br />
and unassuming go their way and<br />
distribute anaesthesia literature in both<br />
printed and electronic form. Update has<br />
an ever-increasing number of daily hits, in<br />
September there were 70,598 visitors to<br />
their web-site from 131 countries, an<br />
average of over 90 ‘hits’ per day! We look<br />
forward to seeing the same success to the<br />
WFSA web-site!<br />
The Statutes and Bylaws committee<br />
is studying how the process of the<br />
credentialling before the General Assembly<br />
can be streamlined. The confusion and<br />
chaos just before such a meeting is<br />
disturbing for everyone. Unfortunately,<br />
the bylaws allow delegates to register up to<br />
24 hours prior to the General Assembly:<br />
when they have managed to come and<br />
attend, we do not wish to refuse to allow<br />
them to participate. Additionally, not all<br />
delegates of a National Society are aware<br />
whether they are one of their society’s<br />
official delegates or an alternative delegate.<br />
It is of the utmost importance that<br />
delegates names are handed to the WFSA<br />
secretariat in good time to facilitate the<br />
workings of all our committees.<br />
Specialist Committees<br />
The Pain Relief Committee has developed<br />
both a basic and an advanced course in<br />
Pain Management which were run for<br />
participants following the 11th Asian<br />
AustralAsian Congress in Kuala Lumpur<br />
in July of this year and subsequently run<br />
in several other places in the region.<br />
The Paediatrics Committee is active<br />
with training scholarships in Paediatric<br />
Anaesthesia in South America. The<br />
European arm (FEAPA) held successful<br />
courses in Germany and Slovenia.<br />
The Obstetrics Committee is<br />
supporting a postgraduate course in<br />
obstetric anaesthesia in Malawi this year<br />
and investigating the possibility of<br />
extending this in the East African region<br />
in 2003.<br />
The Safety and Quality of Practice<br />
Committee has elected a new chairman::<br />
Prof Alan Merry has taken over from Prof<br />
Klaus Geiger, whom we thank for his<br />
efforts in this task. Prof. Merry hopes to<br />
embark on an international monitoring<br />
study and has planned a teleconference in<br />
the near future with his committee<br />
members.<br />
It is hoped that all specialist<br />
committees may be able to develop<br />
courses accompanied by a distance<br />
learning programme, and contribute these<br />
programmes to the WFSA Schools of<br />
Anaesthesia. This would surely be an<br />
example for the medical world at large!<br />
Office and Administration<br />
WFSA has tightened its belt like<br />
everybody else in the world. We have<br />
moved to a smaller office on the 7th floor<br />
of the same building (same phone and fax<br />
numbers, same address), and we reduced<br />
the administrative staff to one in London<br />
(Ruth Hooper) and one in Malawi (Rose<br />
Zawazawa). I am very grateful to Michael<br />
Vickers (Immediate Past President) who<br />
volunteered to help in the London Office.<br />
His background knowledge of WFSA<br />
affairs has been a great help to Ruth and<br />
myself.<br />
WFSA is going electronic: you will<br />
therefore find this annual report in<br />
electronic form in your e-mail or, if we do<br />
not have your e-mail address, on a floppy<br />
Oxford Instructors Course<br />
Primary Trauma Care<br />
7-8th February 2003<br />
diskette by post. You may save it or print<br />
as many copies as you like. By the time<br />
you receive this annual report, the WFSA<br />
web-site will have been launched in early<br />
August, 2002<br />
www.anaesthesiologists.org<br />
Your comments will be appreciated!<br />
Next World Congress of<br />
Anaesthesiologists - Paris 2004<br />
In two years time, we will meet in Paris.<br />
The President, Honorary Secretary and<br />
Administrative Co-ordinator were warmly<br />
welcomed in Paris last May. To organise a<br />
World Congress in these more difficult<br />
financial times, and to maintain the vision<br />
of a truly world congress with speakers<br />
from all around the world, is not an easy<br />
task. Our French colleagues are leading<br />
the way by electronic communication and<br />
they have many other firsts:<br />
● This will be the first World Congress<br />
to be combined with an Annual<br />
Meeting of a Society, in this case the<br />
French;<br />
● The book of abstracts will only be<br />
available on CD-ROM (no more<br />
excess luggage on the way home!);<br />
● Slides will be replaced by computer<br />
presentations: those who want to<br />
present with slides will have to have<br />
their slides scanned in locally.<br />
We wish our French colleagues<br />
under the wise guidance of Phillippe<br />
Scherpereel, Claude Martin and Michel<br />
Pinaud and their professional congress<br />
organiser, Colloquium, success with their<br />
impressive efforts to make this 13th World<br />
Congress, almost our fiftieth birthday a<br />
soaring and unforgettable success. Please<br />
register on the web-site:<br />
www.wca2004.com and book the dates in<br />
your diary: 17 – 23 April 2004.<br />
Anneke E.E. Meursing, Netherlands /<br />
Malawi, July 2002.<br />
Registration Fee £175.00<br />
Further information may be obtained from ptc@nda.ox.ac.uk<br />
30
✃<br />
World Anaesthesia Database<br />
Why not join World Anaesthesia today for the modest fee of £20 (or equivalent) if you work in a first world country? Membership is free to<br />
those working in developing countries. Just complete the form below and forward it to the Secretary with your cheque.<br />
Name: ................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
Address: ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
Institution: ....................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
Telephone: Work: ......................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
Home: ..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
World Anaesthesia Database<br />
Fax: ......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
E-mail address: ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
Job Title: ..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
Speciality: ........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
Grade: ..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
Age: ................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
Male ■ Female ■<br />
Experience overseas:<br />
Please list the countries where you have worked (other than your home country). Please add: the places in those<br />
countries, the dates and the type of work you were engaged in. (e.g. Disaster Relief, Support for refugees, Area of<br />
War/Conflict, Longer term medical missionary or secular relief agency work). Continue on a separate sheet if<br />
necessary:<br />
................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
31
✃<br />
Clinical Investigations<br />
World Anaesthesia Database continued<br />
Particular interests:<br />
(e.g. subspecialities of anaesthesia/care of the critically ill, education, distance learning, appropriate research writing,<br />
disaster relief, conflict situations, medical missionary, long term secular:<br />
..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
Languages spoken: ....................................................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
Availability:<br />
Are you happy to answer enquiries relevant to your experience/expertise? ■ Yes ■ No<br />
Are you able to write for WA publications? ■ Yes ■ No<br />
Are you available for working visits abroad? ■ < 1 month ■ 1 to 6 months<br />
How much notice do you require? ■ 2 weeks ■ 2 months ■ 6 months ■ > 6<br />
Any comments: ..........................................................................................................................................................<br />
..................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
..................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
..................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
..................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
..................................................................................................................................................................................<br />
Please complete this form as accurately as possible and return to:<br />
Dr. C. Collins, Secretary, World Anaesthesia<br />
Dept. Anaesthesia, Royal Devon and Exeter Hospital (Wonford), Barrack Road, Exeter, Devon EX2 5DW<br />
United Kingdom Tel: (+44) 01392 411611<br />
32