26.11.2014 Views

complete packet

complete packet

complete packet

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Villa<br />

Essential Document<br />

(Please Keep All Year)<br />

English 11


Annotative Steps to Reading:<br />

1. Number the paragraphs. Before you read, take a moment and number the paragraphs.<br />

Then circle the number.<br />

2. Circle: (Paper should have many circles)<br />

A. Key terms: (• key concepts • lesson-based content vocabulary • concept-based vocabulary)<br />

B. Cited authors or names: (• names of people • names of historical events)<br />

C. Other essential words or numbers: (• words that signal relationships (e.g. This led to… or As a result )•<br />

dates • numbers • theories • experiments • repeated • anything relevant to one’s reading purpose)<br />

3. Underline the author’s claims and other information relevant to the reading:<br />

Relevant information might include: • central claims • evidence • details relating to a theology, philosophy, theory<br />

or ideology • facts about a person, place, thing, or idea • descriptions of a person, place, thing, or idea • cause<br />

and effect relationships • data • example • methods • descriptions • facts • or anything else that backs up the<br />

author’s assertion<br />

Things you should know:<br />

• A claim may appear anywhere in the text (beginning, middle, or end).<br />

• A claim may not appear explicitly in the argument, so the reader must infer what it is<br />

• Often, an author will make several claims throughout his or her argument.<br />

• An author may signal his or her claim, letting you know that this is his or her position.<br />

4. Write in the margins: While making connections, clarifying information, or doing other work defined on<br />

this page, write down your thoughts in the margins of the text.<br />

There are 6 strategies for writing in the margins: (Do at least 3 of the 6)<br />

A. Visualizing what authors say will help you clarify complex concepts and ideas.<br />

Ask yourself:<br />

•What does it look like?<br />

•What visual and/or symbol best represents this idea?<br />

B. Summarize paragraphs or sections of the text in order to keep track<br />

C. Clarify or translate complex ideas presented in the text.<br />

D. Connect to your own life or other readings or sections in the reading.<br />

•How does this relate to me?<br />

•How does this idea relate to other ideas in the text?<br />

E. Respond to ideas in the text. Readers often respond to interesting ideas, emotional arguments, provocative<br />

statements, author’s claims, and facts or ideas. You may include any rhetorical devices and/ or strategies<br />

(see other handout)<br />

F. Question both the ideas and your own understanding of the text. Ask good questions to become more<br />

critical readers.<br />

Ask yourself:<br />

• What is the author saying here? • What is the author doing? • What do I understand so far?<br />

• What is the purpose of this section? • What do I agree/disagree with?<br />

**• Who is …? • What is the word…? • When did…? • Where is /or Where was….? • Why is the author…?<br />

How come…?<br />

5. Say, Do, Mean: Answer the following questions somewhere at the bottom of the text.<br />

A. What does the author say? (What is the text about?)<br />

B. What does the author do? (What rhetorical devices or strategies does the author use?)<br />

C. What does the text mean? (What is significant about the text? What is the greater meaning? Or the deeper<br />

understanding?)


Poetry Analysis Steps<br />

Villa<br />

1. Read the poem several times.<br />

2. Define any unknown words<br />

3. Identify: (Pick 2 from any category)<br />

a. Sound Devices: the rhyme scheme, alliteration, consonance, assonance<br />

b. Figurative Language: metaphors, simile, hyperbole, personification<br />

c. Other Poetic Devices: symbolism, irony, allusion<br />

4. Identify the tone of the poem. What diction supports your answer?<br />

5. Identify: Who is the speaker(s) of the poem? Who is the audience?<br />

6. What is taking place in the poem? (action or ideas)<br />

7. What is the central purpose of the poem? (theme)<br />

Early Assessment Program (EAP)<br />

E- explain the author’s argument<br />

A- agree or disagree with the argument<br />

P- provide examples to support your point of view<br />

EAP tips:<br />

1. State your opinion about the topic in your thesis.<br />

2. Analyze / evaluate the main points of the argument.<br />

a. What was the major claim the author makes?<br />

b. What are the strongest claims? What are the wekest?<br />

c. What appeals does the authors use? (Methods of Appeal)<br />

3. Be aware of your audience; take your audience into consideration.<br />

4. Choose evidence that supports your thesis statement.<br />

5. Anticipate opposing points of view (counterclaim)<br />

6. Find some common ground.<br />

7. Maintain a reasonable tone.<br />

8. Organize your essay so that it presents you opposition as effectively as possible.<br />

Introduction:<br />

Background info.<br />

Introduction to subject<br />

Statement of your opinion<br />

Body: (@ least 2<br />

Paragraphs)<br />

Common ground (Topic)<br />

Supporting Evidence: Logical<br />

& Emotional<br />

Address opposing points of<br />

view<br />

Conclusion:<br />

Restatement of opinion<br />

Call for action or agreement<br />

Respond to opposing points<br />

of view


Villa<br />

Alliteration: the repetition of similar sounds in a sequence of words<br />

11 th Grade Literary Terms list<br />

Allusion: In literature, this is a reference to another work. (In the Police song “Wrapped Around Your Finger” Sting writes, “trapped between the<br />

Scylla and Charybdis” in reference to Homer’s Oddyssey.)<br />

Anecdote: A very short story that is told to make a point.<br />

Assonance: repetition of identical or similar vowel sounds, usually those found in stressed syllables that are close to each another (3 examples<br />

are shown in this line: “What large, dark hands are those at the window/ grasping in the golden light”)<br />

Consonance: repetition of the final consonant sounds following different vowel sounds in words close to each other (His blade was stained with<br />

blood.)<br />

Connotation: the association(s) suggested by a word, different from what it literally describes, often referred to as the implied meaning of a word<br />

Denotation: a direct and specific meaning, often referred to as the dictionary meaning of a word Detail: facts, observations, and incidents that<br />

are used to develop a topic<br />

Flashback: a scene in a short story, a novel, a narrative poem, or a play that interrupts the action to show an event that happened earlier.<br />

Foreshadowing: the use of hints or clues in a narrative to suggest what action is to come. Writers use foreshadowing to create interest and build<br />

suspense<br />

Hyperbole: an exaggeration of fact used either for serious or comic effect. (“Her eyes opened wide as saucers.”)<br />

Imagery: words used to create or suggest pictures in the reader’s mind – what we see, hear, smell, feel, or taste. (“The pungent fragrance of<br />

orange blossoms sweetly drifted through the air.” “The stunning blue waters sparkled with brilliant clarity.”)<br />

Irony: A contrast or an incongruity between what is stated and what is meant or between what is expected to happen and what actually happens.<br />

The three kinds of irony are:<br />

verbal irony, in which a writer or speakers says one thing and means something entirely different (Mercutio: “If you look for me<br />

tomorrow, you shall find me a grave man.”)<br />

dramatic irony, in which a reader or an audience knows something that a character in the story or play does not know (readers know<br />

Romeo and Juliet will die)<br />

irony of situation, in which the writer shows a discrepancy between the expected result of some action or situation and its actual result<br />

(It is ironic that the marriage counselor got a divorce.)<br />

Metaphor: a comparison that is only suggested or implied, with no clear indication of a relation between the two items. (“Her face is a wrinkled<br />

leaf.”)<br />

Motif: a reoccurring feature, such as a name, an image, or a phrase, in a work of literature. A motif generally contributes in some way to the<br />

theme of a short story, novel, poem, or play.<br />

Onomatopoeia: the use of a word in which the sound imitates or suggests its meaning. (Hiss, clang, snap, buzz.)<br />

Oxymoron: a phrase where two or more words are <strong>complete</strong>ly opposed. (Sweet sorrow, wise fool, honest thief, short eternity)<br />

Parallel structure: the use of grammatically similar constructions in writing; words, phrases, sentences, paragraphs. (His audition required<br />

singing, dancing, and memorizing a passage)<br />

Personification: a figure of speech in which something nonhuman is given human qualities.(“Grey mist on the sea’s face”)<br />

Satire: A kind of writing that holds up to ridicule or contempt the weaknesses and wrongdoings of individuals, groups, institutions, or humanity<br />

in general. The aim of satire is to set a moral standard for society, and to attempt to persuade the reader to see their point of view through the<br />

force of laughter.<br />

Simile: a figure of speech comparing two essentially unlike things through the use of words “like” or “as” (My love is like a rose)<br />

Symbol: any object, person, place, or action that has a meaning in itself and that also stands for something larger than itself, such as a quality, an<br />

attitude, a belief, or a value. (as a rose is often a symbol of love).<br />

Soliloquy: a monologue in which the character in a play is alone and speaking only to himself or herself; usually shows a significant conflict in<br />

thoughts<br />

Syntax: the way words are arranged to form phrases, clauses and sentences; syntax encompasses word order, sentence length, sentence focus, and<br />

punctuation.<br />

Tone: the author’s attitude toward the book, play or poem’s subject and theme; tone is conveyed through diction and detail.


Angry<br />

Paranoid<br />

Sarcastic<br />

Pleading<br />

Sweet<br />

Numb<br />

Harsh<br />

Cynical<br />

Cheerful<br />

Facetious<br />

Pleasant<br />

Hating<br />

Sharp<br />

Nervous<br />

Disgusted<br />

Loving<br />

Haughty<br />

Condescending<br />

Soothing<br />

Enthusiastic<br />

Melancholic<br />

Snooty<br />

Depressed<br />

Dreamy<br />

Ecstatic<br />

Lighthearted<br />

Agitated<br />

Humble<br />

Sympathetic<br />

Instructive<br />

Seductive<br />

Disinterested<br />

Hollow<br />

Uninterested<br />

Humorous<br />

Cheery<br />

Passive<br />

Manipulative<br />

Persuasive<br />

TONE<br />

Contradictory<br />

Afraid<br />

Aggravated<br />

Tired<br />

Serious<br />

Happy<br />

Calm<br />

Disappointed<br />

Proud<br />

Dejected<br />

Apathetic<br />

Excited<br />

Encouraging<br />

Desperate<br />

Consoling<br />

Superficial<br />

Friendly<br />

Sad<br />

Loud<br />

Artificial<br />

Apologetic<br />

Authoritative<br />

Appreciative<br />

Surprised<br />

Joyful<br />

Ironic<br />

Villa<br />

Miserable<br />

Content<br />

Vibrant<br />

Hurt<br />

Confused<br />

Questioning<br />

Informative<br />

Arrogant<br />

Coarse<br />

Romantic<br />

Upset<br />

Cheerful<br />

Transition Words<br />

Words that can be used to show location:<br />

above behind by near throughout<br />

across below down off to the right<br />

against beneath in back of onto under<br />

along beside in front of on top of<br />

among between inside outside<br />

around beyond into over<br />

Words that can be used to show time:<br />

while first meanwhile soon then<br />

after second today later next<br />

at third tomorrow afterward as soon as<br />

before now next week about when suddenly<br />

during until yesterday finally<br />

Word that can be used to compare two things:<br />

likewise also while in the same way<br />

like as similarly<br />

Words that can be used to contrast two things:<br />

but still although on the other hand<br />

however yet otherwise even though<br />

Words that can be used to emphasize a point:<br />

again truly especially for this reason<br />

to repeat in fact<br />

to<br />

emphasize<br />

Words that can be used to conclude or summarize:<br />

finally as a result to sum up in conclusion<br />

lastly therefore all in all because<br />

Words that can be used to add information:<br />

again another for instance for example<br />

also and moreover additionally<br />

as well besides along with other<br />

next finally in addition<br />

Words that can be used to clarify:<br />

that is for instance in other words


Villa<br />

List of Words to Describe an Author’s Tone<br />

This is a list of words that could be used while examining an author’s tone. Students can use this list when<br />

completing the rhetorical précis or while doing similar work.<br />

Tone<br />

Meaning<br />

apologetic<br />

Sorry<br />

appreciative<br />

grateful; thankful<br />

concerned<br />

worried or interested<br />

critical<br />

finding fault<br />

curious<br />

wanting to find out more<br />

defensive<br />

defending<br />

direct<br />

straightforward; honest<br />

disappointed<br />

discouraged; unhappy because something went wrong<br />

encouraging<br />

optimistic<br />

enthusiastic<br />

excited; energetic<br />

formal<br />

respectful, appropriate behavior<br />

frustrated<br />

angry because of not being able to do something<br />

hopeful<br />

looking forward to something; optimistic<br />

humorous<br />

funny<br />

informal<br />

not formal; relaxed<br />

inspirational<br />

encouraging; reassuring<br />

ironic<br />

different from what is expected or the opposite of what is meant<br />

judgmental<br />

judging others; critical<br />

lighthearted<br />

happy, carefree<br />

mocking<br />

scornful; ridiculing; making fun of someone<br />

negative<br />

unhappy; pessimistic<br />

neutral<br />

neither good nor bad; neither for nor against<br />

nostalgic<br />

thinking about the past; wishing for something from the past<br />

objective<br />

without prejudice; without discrimination; fair<br />

optimistic<br />

hopeful; cheerful<br />

pessimistic<br />

seeing the bad side of things<br />

sarcastic<br />

scornful; mocking; ridiculing<br />

satirical<br />

making fun of something to show its weakness or teach a lesson<br />

sentimental<br />

thinking about feelings, especially when remembering the past<br />

sincere<br />

honest; truthful; earnest<br />

sympathetic<br />

compassionate; understanding of how someone feels<br />

urgent<br />

insistent; saying something must be done soon<br />

Verb List<br />

High-Frequency Charting Verbs<br />

Analyzing Connecting Discussing Illustrating Questioning<br />

Arguing Defining Developing Introducing Stating<br />

Asserting Debating Extending Listing Suggesting<br />

Comparing Clarifying Explaining Offering Summarizing<br />

Contrasting Concluding Interpreting Proving Questioning<br />

Medium-Frequency Charting Verbs<br />

Acknowledging Distinguishing Justifying<br />

Challenging Establishing Predicting<br />

Compiling Generalizing Qualifying<br />

Differentiating Incorporating Substantiating<br />

Use this space to add charting verbs that are not listed above.<br />

Taken from AVID Critical Reading 10.9 and 8.2


Villa<br />

Adjectives to use:<br />

Appearance<br />

Adjectives<br />

adorable<br />

beautiful<br />

clean<br />

drab<br />

elegant<br />

fancy<br />

glamorous<br />

handsome<br />

long<br />

magnificent<br />

old-fashioned<br />

plain<br />

quaint<br />

sparkling<br />

ugliest<br />

unsightly<br />

wide-eyed<br />

Color Adjectives<br />

red<br />

orange<br />

yellow<br />

green<br />

blue<br />

purple<br />

gray<br />

black<br />

white<br />

Condition<br />

Adjectives<br />

alive<br />

better<br />

careful<br />

clever<br />

dead<br />

easy<br />

famous<br />

gifted<br />

helpful<br />

important<br />

inexpensive<br />

mushy<br />

odd<br />

powerful<br />

rich<br />

shy<br />

tender<br />

uninterested<br />

vast<br />

wrong.<br />

Feelings (Bad)<br />

Adjectives<br />

angry<br />

bewildered<br />

clumsy<br />

defeated<br />

embarrassed<br />

fierce<br />

grumpy<br />

helpless<br />

itchy<br />

jealous<br />

lazy<br />

mysterious<br />

nervous<br />

obnoxious<br />

panicky<br />

repulsive<br />

scary<br />

thoughtless<br />

uptight<br />

worried<br />

Feelings (Good)<br />

Adjectives<br />

agreeable<br />

brave<br />

calm<br />

delightful<br />

eager<br />

faithful<br />

gentle<br />

happy<br />

jolly<br />

kind<br />

lively<br />

nice<br />

obedient<br />

proud<br />

relieved<br />

silly<br />

thankful<br />

victorious<br />

witty<br />

zealous<br />

Shape Adjectives<br />

broad<br />

chubby<br />

crooked<br />

curved<br />

deep<br />

flat<br />

high<br />

hollow<br />

low<br />

narrow<br />

round<br />

shallow<br />

skinny<br />

square<br />

steep<br />

straight<br />

wide.<br />

Size Adjectives<br />

big<br />

colossal<br />

fat<br />

gigantic<br />

great<br />

huge<br />

immense<br />

large<br />

little<br />

mammoth<br />

massive<br />

miniature<br />

petite<br />

puny<br />

scrawny<br />

short<br />

small<br />

tall<br />

teeny<br />

teeny-tiny<br />

tiny<br />

Sound Adjectives<br />

cooing<br />

deafening<br />

faint<br />

hissing<br />

loud<br />

melodic<br />

noisy<br />

purring<br />

quiet<br />

raspy<br />

screeching<br />

thundering<br />

voiceless<br />

whispering<br />

Time Adjectives<br />

ancient<br />

brief<br />

early<br />

fast<br />

late<br />

long<br />

modern<br />

old<br />

old-fashioned<br />

quick<br />

rapid<br />

short<br />

slow<br />

swift<br />

young<br />

Taste/Touch<br />

Adjectives<br />

bitter<br />

delicious<br />

fresh<br />

greasy<br />

juicy<br />

hot<br />

icy<br />

loose<br />

melted<br />

nutritious<br />

prickly<br />

rainy<br />

rotten<br />

salty<br />

sticky<br />

strong<br />

sweet<br />

tart<br />

tasteless<br />

uneven<br />

weak<br />

wet<br />

wooden<br />

yummy<br />

Touch Adjectives<br />

boiling<br />

breeze<br />

broken<br />

bumpy<br />

chilly<br />

cold<br />

cool<br />

creepy<br />

crooked<br />

cuddly<br />

curly<br />

damaged<br />

damp<br />

dirty<br />

dry<br />

dusty<br />

filthy<br />

flaky<br />

fluffy<br />

freezing<br />

hot<br />

warm<br />

wet<br />

Quantity Adjectives<br />

abundant<br />

empty<br />

few<br />

full<br />

heavy<br />

light<br />

many<br />

numerous<br />

sparse<br />

substantial


Villa<br />

Rhetoric Analysis Steps<br />

1) Read the non-fiction article several times.<br />

2) Define any unknown words<br />

3) Identify: (Pick at least 2 Devices and provide the concrete detail that supports your<br />

answer)<br />

a. Testimonials (personal or “outside” figures)<br />

b. Examples/Statistics/Data<br />

c. Questions: Open (designed to cause the reader to ponder possibilities,<br />

connections and draw conclusions)/ Rhetorical (designed to cause the reader to<br />

concur with the writer. Worded in such a way as to elicit one obvious response)<br />

d. Anecdotes (often used for ethos appeal): a short narrative of an incident<br />

e. Syntax (varied sentence structure): periodic sentence, multi-layered, emphatic<br />

sentence, rhetorical question, parallel structure, repetition, punctuation<br />

f. Figurative Language: simile, metaphors, hyperbole, personification, litote/<br />

understatement, paradox, imagery, allusion, irony, sarcasm<br />

4) Identify: (Pick at least 2 Strategies and explain the reasoning)<br />

a. Claims about: meaning, value, consequences, policy<br />

b. Methods of appeal: Logos (logic), Pathos (feelings/emotions), Ethos<br />

(ethics/character/reputation)<br />

c. Reasoning: Deductive, Inductive (see handout)<br />

5) Identify the tone of the article. What diction supports your answer?<br />

6) What is the overall content of the article?<br />

7) What is the author’s central purpose? (message)<br />

8) What are the overriding devices? (please list)<br />

9) What are the overriding strategies? (please list)


Villa<br />

Rhetoric/Argumentation Terms and Definitions<br />

Argument: Attempts to convince an audience by means of careful reasoning that a specific claim/ proposition is true<br />

(supporting evidence/a ”rational appeal”)<br />

Persuasion: Attempts to move the reader to a course of action, to reform a group’s feelings, opinions, and beliefs<br />

(Argument is always present/an “emotional appeal”)<br />

Rhetorical/Argumentative Devices: These are the tools the writer uses in developing the rhetorical/argumentative<br />

strategies and are found throughout the essay<br />

Testimonials – personal or “outside” figures<br />

Examples<br />

Statistics/Data<br />

Questions<br />

Open- Designed to cause the reader to ponder possibilities, connections and draw conclusions<br />

Rhetorical – Designed to cause the reader to concur with the writer. Worded in such a way as to elicit<br />

one obvious response<br />

Anecdotes (Often used for pathos appeal)<br />

Connotative Language - Diction (charged words) that helps to establish the writer’s tone<br />

Syntax – Writer’s use of varied sentence structures for a purpose<br />

• Periodic Sentence– subject at the end of the sentence<br />

• Multi-layered Sentence – many dependent clauses linked to central meaning<br />

• Emphatic Sentence – short sentence among longer sentences used for emphasis<br />

• Rhetorical Question<br />

• Parallel Structure- using the same pattern of words to show that 2 or more ideas have the same<br />

level of importance<br />

• Repetition<br />

• Punctuation<br />

Figurative Language<br />

• Such as: Simile, Metaphor, Imagery, Allusion, Personification, Irony, Sarcasm<br />

• Hyperbole- an exaggeration of fact used either for serious or comic effect. (“Her eyes opened wide<br />

as saucers.”)<br />

• Litotes – a deliberate understatement (downplaying one’s accomplishments in order to gain an<br />

audience favor (“ethos appeal”)<br />

• Paradox- A statement that reveals a kind of truth, although it seems at first to be self-contradictory<br />

and untrue.<br />

Rhetorical/Argumentative Strategies:<br />

1.Claims – These are the assertions writer is making; they formulate/connect to the argument’s central purpose.<br />

Claims about Meaning: What is X? (Propositions that center on how we define/interpret something. i.e.<br />

Is a defendant “sane” enough to stand trial?) Defining<br />

Claims about Value: Is X good or bad, right or wrong? (Ethical evaluations based on clear/consistent<br />

criteria i.e. Is capital punishment morally wrong?) Morality- good and bad/right and wrong<br />

Claims about Consequences: What will happen as a result of X? (Examination of the causal patterns<br />

involved in certain ideas/actions – usually an “if X, then Y format” i.e. “If capital punishment was<br />

abolished, then more murders would be committed.”)<br />

Claims about Policy: What should be done about X? Stated in the form of a proposal using “should and<br />

ought” i.e. “Gun control ought to be mandatory in every state.”) Why not? Law or Deciding factor<br />

Many extended arguments depend upon a mixture of all of them.<br />

2. Methods of Appeal:<br />

Logos: Appeal to the logic and good sense. (Offering a clear, reasonable central idea and developing it<br />

with appropriate reasoning, examples or details)<br />

Pathos: Appeal to feelings/emotions, a nonintellectual response. (Drawing on the emotions /interests of<br />

the audience so it will be sympathetically inclined to accept the central argument. Anger, fear, frustration,<br />

contentment, patriotism, religious feelings, social acceptance, morality are often targets.)<br />

Ethos: Appeal based on the speaker’s personal presence, character and reputation. (Offers evidence that<br />

speaker is credible, knows important/relevant information about the topic and is a good, person who has<br />

the audience’s best interest in mind.)<br />

**Extended arguments blend all three appeals.<br />

3. Reasoning – Argument is backed up by reasoning.<br />

Deductive – arguments proceed from the general to the particular<br />

Ex. “All dogs are carnivorous; Fido is a dog; therefore Fido is carnivorous. A deductive argument<br />

leads to a necessary conclusion. Once we accept the premises as true and the connection to the<br />

conclusion, then we must accept the truth of the conclusion.<br />

Inductive Reasoning – arguments proceed from the particular to the general. This does not<br />

yield logically necessary conclusions. Generalization is based on a limited number of instances. Ex<br />

Fido is carnivorous, Prince is carnivorous, Spot is carnivorous, all dogs are carnivorous.<br />

4. Organization – the heart of the argument<br />

Series of Independent Reasons: Strongest reason followed by weaker reasons and ending with a<br />

strong summarizing reason. Utilizes transition words to reconnect each independent reason to central<br />

purpose.<br />

Chain Structure –A set of interdependent points not arranged according to strength but according to<br />

their logical sequence: the conclusion of one becomes the premise of the next.


Villa<br />

Rhetorical Précis Worksheet<br />

A rhetorical précis differs from a summary in that it is a less neutral, more analytical condensation of both the<br />

content and method of the original text. If you think of a summary as primarily a brief representation of what a text<br />

says, then you might think of the rhetorical précis as a brief representation of what a text both says and does.<br />

Although less common than a summary, a rhetorical précis is a particularly useful way to sum up your understanding<br />

of how a text works rhetorically.<br />

The Structure of a Rhetorical Précis<br />

Sentence One: Name of the author, genre, and title of work, date in parentheses; a rhetorically active verb; and a<br />

THAT clause containing the major assertion or thesis in the text.<br />

Sentence Tw o: An explanation of how the author develops and supports the thesis.<br />

Sentence Three: A statement of the author’s apparent purpose, followed by an “in order to” phrase.<br />

Sentence Four: A description of the intended audience and/or the relationship the author establishes with the<br />

audience.<br />

Rhetorical Précis Sentence Starters<br />

Sentence One (What?)<br />

____________________________ in the _________________________, _________________________,<br />

(Author) (A) (Title)<br />

______________________________________ that ___________________________________________<br />

(B)<br />

_____________________________________________________________________________________<br />

Sentence Two (How?)<br />

____________________________ supports his/her _________________ by ______________________<br />

(Author’s Last Name) (B) (C)<br />

_____________________________________________________________________________________<br />

_____________________________________________________________________________________<br />

Sentence Three (Why?)<br />

The author’s purpose is to<br />

_____________________________________________________________________________________<br />

(D)<br />

________________________________ in orderto / so that ____________________________________<br />

_____________________________________________________________________________________<br />

Sentence Four (To Whom?)<br />

The author writesin a ______________________tone for ______________________________________<br />

(E)<br />

(audience)<br />

A B C D E<br />

article,<br />

book review,<br />

essay,<br />

column,<br />

editorial<br />

argues, argument,<br />

asserts, assertion,<br />

suggests, suggestion,<br />

claims, questions,<br />

explains, explanation<br />

comparing,<br />

contrasting<br />

telling, explaining,<br />

illustrating,<br />

demonstrating,<br />

defining, describing,<br />

listing<br />

show<br />

point out<br />

suggest<br />

inform<br />

persuade<br />

convince<br />

formal<br />

informal<br />

sarcastic<br />

humorous<br />

contemptuous


Natalia Leyva<br />

Villa<br />

Professor Beach<br />

ED 200<br />

11 September 2017<br />

Rhetorical Précis<br />

In the article “End Homework Now” (2001), Etta Kralovec and John Buell claim that the<br />

practice of assigning homework is not an effective teaching method because its negative effects<br />

outweigh its benefits. Kralovec and Buell support their claims by providing examples of how<br />

homework disrupts families, overburdens children and limits learning and by dispelling myths<br />

about the benefits of homework and providing alternative practices that would lead to<br />

improvement in student achievement. The authors’ purpose is to make the reader question a<br />

practice that is a trademark of the U.S. education system and decide whether it is conducive to<br />

creating a “smarter” student. They seem to be speaking to the entire educational community:<br />

administrators, teachers, students and parents.<br />

Rhetorical Précis Worksheet and Paragraph Taken from: http://www.lanzbom.org/


Villa<br />

What is “AXES”?<br />

A good AXES-paragraph contains each of these elements plus more!<br />

A<br />

Assertion: An assertion is your claim for the paragraph. Although<br />

sometimes it is referred to as a topic sentence, an assertion goes<br />

beyond stating a topic; an assertion takes a stand or makes a claim<br />

about an issue. An assertion should not be obvious or self- explanatory.<br />

X<br />

Example: An example is the evidence required to support your<br />

assertion. Most often an example is a quote or passage from the<br />

readings that proves or confirms your assertion.<br />

E<br />

Explanation: The explanation reveals how the example actually<br />

supports or proves the assertion. The explanation should be clear and<br />

specific. Explanation should never repeat or “translate” the quoted<br />

example.<br />

S<br />

Significance: Every paragraph should include a statement that tells<br />

the reader what makes your assertion important. As part of an essay,<br />

the significance reveals how the paragraph supports the paper’s thesis.<br />

It may also show how your assertion connects to real-life human<br />

experience. In literary analysis, your significance may explore the<br />

author’s purpose in writing the text, or show a connection between the<br />

text and modern human experience.


Name:___________________________ Period:_____<br />

Topic:_______________________________<br />

Points<br />

Understanding the<br />

assignment concrete<br />

details/ evidence<br />

Organization; quality<br />

and clarity of thought<br />

Outstanding<br />

5<br />

Evidence of exceeding the<br />

requirements; use of 2 or<br />

more concrete details;<br />

thorough and perceptive<br />

explanation of context and<br />

significance; outstanding<br />

evidence of quality work;<br />

impressive statement of<br />

relevance<br />

Creative and engaging<br />

introduction; extensive<br />

body with detailed<br />

discussion of the topic;<br />

impressive conclusion<br />

Analytical Paragraph/Essay Scoring Guide<br />

Excellent<br />

Very Good<br />

4<br />

3<br />

Clear identification of Clear but brief<br />

understanding the<br />

identification of<br />

assignment; use of 2 understanding the<br />

concrete details; thorough assignment; use of 1-2<br />

explanation of context and concrete details; clear<br />

significance; outstanding and adequate explanation<br />

evidence of quality work; of context and<br />

clear statement of<br />

significance; good<br />

relevance.<br />

evidence of attention to<br />

producing quality work;<br />

clear but brief statement<br />

Effective introduction with<br />

clear identification of<br />

purpose; thorough body<br />

with discussion of the<br />

topic; clear conclusion<br />

of relevance<br />

Adequate introduction<br />

with identification of the<br />

purpose; <strong>complete</strong> body<br />

with discussion of the<br />

topic; adequate<br />

conclusion.<br />

Fair<br />

2<br />

Brief identification of the<br />

understanding the<br />

assignment; use of only 1<br />

source; brief explanation of<br />

context, significance; some<br />

evidence of attention to<br />

producing quality work;<br />

some statement of relevance.<br />

Adequate, but brief<br />

introduction; simple<br />

identification of purpose;<br />

<strong>complete</strong> but thin body with<br />

discussion of topic; scant<br />

conclusion<br />

Poor<br />

1<br />

Sketchy identification of<br />

the assignment; use of only<br />

1 source; sketchy<br />

explanation of context,<br />

significance; little evidence<br />

of attention to producing<br />

quality work; little or no<br />

statement of relevance<br />

Inadequate or simplistic<br />

introduction; in<strong>complete</strong><br />

identification of purpose;<br />

sketchy discussion of the<br />

topic; inadequate<br />

conclusion<br />

Style and writing<br />

conventions<br />

Excellent command of<br />

sentence variety,<br />

transitions, and structure<br />

Eloquent diction mastery<br />

of punctuation, spelling<br />

and grammar<br />

Standards Assessed: R2.4, R2.5, W1.1, W2.3, ELC1.1, ELC1.2<br />

Comments:<br />

Strong command of<br />

sentence variety,<br />

transitions, and structure<br />

effective diction few<br />

punctuation, spelling,<br />

grammar errors.<br />

Some sentence variety,<br />

transitions, and some<br />

errors in sentence<br />

structure<br />

Appropriate diction<br />

Some punctuation,<br />

spelling and grammar<br />

errors that do not interfere<br />

with meaning.<br />

Limited sentence variety<br />

and transitions.<br />

Many errors in sentence<br />

structure<br />

Basic/Unsophisticated use<br />

of diction<br />

Some punctuation, spelling<br />

and grammar errors that<br />

may distract reader<br />

No sentence variety; nor<br />

transitions<br />

Many errors in sentence<br />

structure<br />

Diction is elementary an/or<br />

inappropriate serious and<br />

persistent errors that<br />

severely interferes with<br />

meaning<br />

Key: check means you did the following, circle with a strike through means you didn’t do it!<br />

□ Proper Heading □ Page Requirements □ Font Size □ Spacing/Margins □ AXES format □ other: _________________________________________________________

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!