CER Letter to Minister Shabangu re MPRDA s49 - 1 Feb 2011
CER Letter to Minister Shabangu re MPRDA s49 - 1 Feb 2011
CER Letter to Minister Shabangu re MPRDA s49 - 1 Feb 2011
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Marine Protected A<strong>re</strong>a. In terms of s.14(1) as <strong>re</strong>ad with s.48 of NEMPAA,<br />
commercial prospecting and mining a<strong>re</strong> prohibited in marine protected a<strong>re</strong>as.<br />
The most <strong>re</strong>cent State of the Environment Report states that: “Despite the prog<strong>re</strong>ss<br />
al<strong>re</strong>ady made <strong>to</strong> safeguard South Africa’s coastline, the urgent need <strong>re</strong>mains <strong>to</strong><br />
protect offsho<strong>re</strong> habitats, especially in the light of the impacts of offsho<strong>re</strong> fishing<br />
and mining activities on the marine environment.” 18<br />
In addition <strong>to</strong> the purposes of declaring protected a<strong>re</strong>as as set out in the Protected<br />
A<strong>re</strong>as Act, which also apply <strong>to</strong> marine protected a<strong>re</strong>as, the designation,<br />
establishment and management of marine protected a<strong>re</strong>as is an important<br />
instrument <strong>to</strong> safeguard biodiversity and the integrity of ecological processes in the<br />
coastal and marine environment. The 2010 G<strong>re</strong>en Paper on South Africa’s Climate<br />
Change Response cur<strong>re</strong>ntly out for comment mentions that “[c]limatic changes will<br />
almost certainly disturb marine ecosystems, making them mo<strong>re</strong> susceptible <strong>to</strong><br />
invasive species from lower latitudes, so that warmer water species a<strong>re</strong> likely <strong>to</strong><br />
become mo<strong>re</strong> abundant with an overall decline in cold water indigenous species.” It<br />
also highlights the likely impacts of climate change on the fisheries sec<strong>to</strong>r, and<br />
emphasises the urgent need for <strong>re</strong>search in this field.<br />
<br />
Table Mountain Marine Protected A<strong>re</strong>a, Western Cape<br />
(Pho<strong>to</strong>: Africa Geographic)<br />
<br />
Dwesa-Cebe Marine Protected A<strong>re</strong>a, Eastern Cape<br />
3.5.4. Specially protected fo<strong>re</strong>st a<strong>re</strong>as such as the Wolkberg Wilderness in Limpopo,<br />
fo<strong>re</strong>st natu<strong>re</strong> <strong>re</strong>serves and fo<strong>re</strong>st wilderness a<strong>re</strong>as decla<strong>re</strong>d in terms of the<br />
National Fo<strong>re</strong>sts Act, 1998. In terms of s.48(1)(c) as <strong>re</strong>ad with s.9(d) of NEMPAA,<br />
commercial prospecting and mining a<strong>re</strong> prohibited in these a<strong>re</strong>as.<br />
<br />
Above we have listed a<strong>re</strong>as in which commercial prospecting and mining a<strong>re</strong> al<strong>re</strong>ady prohibited by<br />
legislation. We have done so for two <strong>re</strong>asons. Firstly, we do so <strong>to</strong> illustrate that the legislatu<strong>re</strong> has<br />
al<strong>re</strong>ady <strong>re</strong>cognised that certain geographical a<strong>re</strong>as should be off-limits <strong>to</strong> such activities.<br />
Secondly, we do so because the<strong>re</strong> have been a number of instances in which prospecting and mining<br />
rights have been granted in these a<strong>re</strong>as despite the existing statu<strong>to</strong>ry prohibition, typically as a <strong>re</strong>sult<br />
of false information submitted <strong>to</strong> the Department of Mineral Resources (DMR). This leads <strong>to</strong> the<br />
unfortunate situation of forcing inte<strong>re</strong>sted and affected parties, including donor-funded nongovernment<br />
organisations, <strong>to</strong> approach a court <strong>to</strong> set aside an inappropriate and unlawful decision,<br />
<strong>re</strong>sulting in significant legal costs being incur<strong>re</strong>d unnecessarily by organisations that can ill afford such<br />
costs. This situation must be add<strong>re</strong>ssed through improved sc<strong>re</strong>ening and verification methods, and<br />
criminal prosecution of applicants who make false or misleading statements <strong>to</strong> the DMR in their<br />
applications.<br />
<br />
18 http://soer.deat.gov.za/587.html