12.01.2015 Views

Det One - Force Recon Association

Det One - Force Recon Association

Det One - Force Recon Association

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Concept 11<br />

and due to the “naval” nature of the aviation force—<br />

not completely under Marine control— that trying to<br />

include an aviation combat element in the unit would<br />

cripple its chances to form up quickly, train, and deploy.<br />

Kyser forwarded the recommended unit structure<br />

to General Jones, who gave his assent<br />

immediately. From idea to concept to rough plan in<br />

remarkably short order, Kyser had in hand an organization<br />

he could present to SOCom.<br />

Special Operations Command Reacts<br />

Rough plan in hand, Lieutenant Colonel Kyser<br />

traveled to Special Operations Command headquarters<br />

in Tampa in late January 2002 for the first<br />

SOCom-USMC board. In front of the future concepts<br />

working group of the board, he laid out a presentation<br />

of SOCom missions and other activities and<br />

showed how, if under a reasonable assumption that<br />

its task load increased, its tasks would soon surpass<br />

its capabilities. In his words, “SOCom would run out<br />

of Schlitz.” 41 Without a pause, Kyser continued with<br />

one small step for a Marine but one giant leap for the<br />

Corps: “In the Marine Corps, we have some forces<br />

that can do some of these specific things.” “Immediately,”<br />

he said, “red star clusters went up—‘No! You’re<br />

not SOF! You can’t do these things!’” Kyser patiently<br />

answered, “Well, look, I think we can.” And he proceeded<br />

to show how.<br />

Lieutenant Colonel Kyser, Master Gunnery Sergeant<br />

Settelen, and Master Sergeant Mitchell knew the<br />

special operations world as well as the SOCom people<br />

did. They had anticipated the objections and were<br />

ready to counter each one. Kyser fired back with a<br />

counter barrage of logical arguments. His offer to<br />

provide a ready-built force that would take on four<br />

mission areas—direct action, special reconnaissance,<br />

coalition support, and foreign internal defense—and<br />

relieve other SOCom units to focus on more pressing<br />

missions proved persuasive. Arguments old and new<br />

against a Marine unit in SOCom would continue to<br />

arise during the following months, but Kyser had<br />

made his point. He had his beachhead.<br />

Both Colonel Hand at SOCom and Lieutenant<br />

Colonel Kyser at Headquarters Marine Corps drafted<br />

summaries of the minutes of the board meeting.<br />

Drafting was one thing; releasing was another. According<br />

to both officers, they wrote and rewrote their<br />

summaries several times, only to have them sat upon<br />

at SOCom. It took four months until SOCom released<br />

the executive summary in May 2002. * On a positive<br />

note, the summary specified leveraging the “unique<br />

capabilities of each organization” and pushing forward<br />

with interoperability between forward-deployed<br />

MEU (SOC)s and special operations forces based in<br />

the U.S. and overseas. On the less positive side from<br />

the Kyser/Hand point of view, the executive summary<br />

referred to the Marine force contribution as<br />

“possible,” “notional,” and “a pilot program.”<br />

In discussions that followed between Colonel<br />

Hand and Lieutenant Colonel Kyser about the nature<br />

of the Marine unit, Hand, remembering General<br />

Jones’s earlier offer of a single force reconnaissance<br />

platoon, wanted to keep the unit simple and small.<br />

He wanted to send it right out to whatever component<br />

of SOCom was going to sponsor it and get it operating,<br />

believing that the operator-level relations<br />

would be a runaway success and that a small force<br />

would be more workable. Instead, Kyser’s plan won<br />

the day; the Marine force contribution to SOCom was<br />

to be more than one platoon of reconnaissance<br />

Marines. 42<br />

Once again, Lieutenant Colonel Kyser shuttled between<br />

Headquarters Marine Corps and Special Operations<br />

Command much as he had done the previous<br />

fall. He and Colonel Hand were busy not only with<br />

selling the force contribution, but also with shepherding<br />

all the initiatives between the Marines and<br />

SOCom. As they worked trying to sell the individual<br />

service components on the potential of the Marine<br />

force contribution, Kyser still had his network of<br />

sources telling him who was saying what about the<br />

Marine unit and taking bets on when it was going to<br />

be killed off and on who would deliver the blow.<br />

The SEALs Volunteer to Help<br />

It was plain to Colonel Hand and Lieutenant<br />

Colonel Kyser that the center of gravity of opposition<br />

to any Marine force contribution was Naval Special<br />

Warfare. Some individual SEALs were receptive, but<br />

their command appeared to be institutionally opposed.<br />

43 A portion of the opposition was rooted in<br />

fierce protection of roles and missions, and therefore<br />

funding, a reaction common to every service. The<br />

SEALs had built a substantial special operations capability<br />

on their own over the course of decades and<br />

were justifiably proud of it. But protectionism was<br />

not the only factor in SEAL opposition; there also was<br />

a persistent institutional memory of the 1987 decision.<br />

According to the SEALs, the Marines did not<br />

want a part of SOCom then, and they should not be<br />

*<br />

Col Hand achieved the release through another direct personal<br />

appeal to Special Operations Command leadership. As the weeks<br />

went by and the minutes of the meeting went unsigned, he received<br />

phone calls from LtGen Bedard asking pointed questions<br />

about the document. Hand eventually went to see MajGen Eldon<br />

Bargewell and told him bluntly that not releasing the minutes was<br />

“destroying my reputation.” Hand intvw, 26Aug05 (MCHC).

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!