24.05.2015 Views

Slope with ponded water.pdf - GEO-SLOPE International Ltd.

Slope with ponded water.pdf - GEO-SLOPE International Ltd.

Slope with ponded water.pdf - GEO-SLOPE International Ltd.

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

<strong>GEO</strong>-<strong>SLOPE</strong> <strong>International</strong> <strong>Ltd</strong>, Calgary, Alberta, Canada www.geo-slope.com<br />

1 Introduction<br />

<strong>Slope</strong> <strong>with</strong> Ponded Water<br />

The purpose of this illustrative example is to show how the stability of a partially submerged slope can be<br />

modeled <strong>with</strong> <strong>SLOPE</strong>/W. Features of this simulation include:<br />

• Entry and Exit slip surface<br />

• Partial submerged slope<br />

• Pore-<strong>water</strong> pressures modeled <strong>with</strong> a piezometric line<br />

• How to alter the unit weight of <strong>water</strong> of the <strong>ponded</strong> <strong>water</strong> layer<br />

• Hand calculation of some slice forces<br />

2 Configuration and setup<br />

Figure 1 shows the geometry of the partial submerged slope. The <strong>water</strong> layer is 3 m high, and a<br />

piezometric line is used to specify the pore <strong>water</strong> pressure condition of the slope.<br />

Figure 1 Geometry of the partial submerged slope<br />

3 Changes to how <strong>water</strong> is modeled in <strong>SLOPE</strong>/W Version 7.1<br />

In Version 7.1, the historic option to define <strong>water</strong> as a no-strength material has been removed from<br />

<strong>SLOPE</strong>/W. Any file created in an earlier version that modeled <strong>water</strong> as a no-strength material will<br />

automatically be updated the first time you open the file in Version 7.1 to use the new approach.<br />

If the weight of the <strong>water</strong> was modeled in earlier files using a pressure boundary, you will see a warning<br />

message when you open the file in Version 7.1 suggesting that the pressure line may be redundant and<br />

need to be removed. This error message will only occur if the pressure line was drawn to correspond<br />

<strong>with</strong>in a specified tolerance of the piezometric line. If the pressure line was drawn at a different elevation<br />

<strong>SLOPE</strong>/W Example File: <strong>Slope</strong> <strong>with</strong> <strong>ponded</strong> <strong>water</strong>.doc (<strong>pdf</strong>) (gsz) Page 1 of 7


<strong>GEO</strong>-<strong>SLOPE</strong> <strong>International</strong> <strong>Ltd</strong>, Calgary, Alberta, Canada www.geo-slope.com<br />

for some reason, the warning message will not appear. Please note that pressure lines are now referred to<br />

as surcharge loads in Version 7.1, which is more accurate.<br />

The new approach that has been implemented in Version 7.1 computes the stabilizing weight of the <strong>water</strong><br />

acting on the ground surface by looking at the positive pore-<strong>water</strong> pressures that exist along the ground<br />

surface. This approach will work for piezometric lines, pressure heads defined using a spatial function or<br />

finite element computed heads. The presence of positive pore-<strong>water</strong> pressures on the ground surface line<br />

will be visually represented by a shaded area showing the extent of the <strong>ponded</strong> <strong>water</strong> and <strong>with</strong> arrows<br />

indicating the direction that the <strong>water</strong> force will be acting on the free body. Water forces will act normal<br />

to the ground surface line.<br />

Pore-<strong>water</strong> pressures at the base of each slice will be computed differently depending on the method used.<br />

For piezometric lines, the vertical distance from the base of the slice up to the relevant piezometric line<br />

multiplied by the unit weight of <strong>water</strong> as defined under SET: Units and Scale, will determine the pore<strong>water</strong><br />

pressures that exist at the base. For pressure heads developed using a pressure head spatial function,<br />

the pore-<strong>water</strong> pressures will be determined using a numerical process called Kriging. For finite element<br />

generated pore-<strong>water</strong> pressures, the location of the base of the slice, relative to the nearest finite element<br />

nodes, will be determined and the pore-<strong>water</strong> pressures will be interpolated from the finite element<br />

computed results.<br />

For the example being described in this article, a piezometric line has been created and assigned to both<br />

the foundation and embankment materials. Accordingly, the stabilizing weight of the <strong>water</strong> will be<br />

applied in the analysis and is represented <strong>with</strong> a shaded zone and arrows.<br />

3.1 Case 1 – Water layer modeled <strong>with</strong> a piezometric line<br />

In this case, the <strong>ponded</strong> <strong>water</strong> is modeled <strong>with</strong> a piezometric line. Note that the piezometric line is drawn<br />

across the anticipated surface of the <strong>ponded</strong> <strong>water</strong> where pressure equals zero (P = 0). The area between<br />

the ground surface line and the piezometric line has been shaded to indicate the extent of positive pore<strong>water</strong><br />

pressures and arrows have also been painted along the ground surface to indicate the direction that<br />

the <strong>water</strong> force is acting.<br />

The global unit weight of <strong>water</strong> under SET: Units and Scale has been defined as 9.807 kN/m 3 as shown in<br />

Figure 2. This is the value that will be used together <strong>with</strong> the vertical height of the piezometric line to<br />

compute the correct pore-<strong>water</strong> pressure at the base of each slice. This is also the unit weight that will be<br />

used to compute the <strong>water</strong> force acting on the ground surface. If you want to use a different value, you<br />

can change the global value and then do a quick hand-calculation to confirm to yourself that the unit<br />

weight being used is what you have input.<br />

<strong>SLOPE</strong>/W Example File: <strong>Slope</strong> <strong>with</strong> <strong>ponded</strong> <strong>water</strong>.doc (<strong>pdf</strong>) (gsz) Page 2 of 7


<strong>GEO</strong>-<strong>SLOPE</strong> <strong>International</strong> <strong>Ltd</strong>, Calgary, Alberta, Canada www.geo-slope.com<br />

Figure 2: Set Units and Scale dialogue box where you can define the global unit weight of <strong>water</strong><br />

Figure 3 shows the critical slip surface and the factor of safety of the partially submerged slope. The<br />

factor of safety is 1.127.<br />

Figure 3 Critical slip surface and factor of safety of the partial submerged slope when modeled<br />

<strong>with</strong> a piezometric line.<br />

Figure 4 shows the free body diagram and the force polygon of slice #4, which is located half way down<br />

the submerged portion of the slope. Note the line load acting on the top of the slice which represents the<br />

resultant <strong>water</strong> force (F) contributed from the <strong>water</strong> layer.<br />

<strong>SLOPE</strong>/W Example File: <strong>Slope</strong> <strong>with</strong> <strong>ponded</strong> <strong>water</strong>.doc (<strong>pdf</strong>) (gsz) Page 3 of 7


<strong>GEO</strong>-<strong>SLOPE</strong> <strong>International</strong> <strong>Ltd</strong>, Calgary, Alberta, Canada www.geo-slope.com<br />

Figure 4 Free body diagram and force polygon of slice #1<br />

The resultant <strong>water</strong> force (F) contains both the vertical and horizontal <strong>water</strong> force components, which are<br />

computed as being the <strong>water</strong> pressure acting over the vertical or horizontal area of the slice (assuming a<br />

unit depth).<br />

Figure 5 Schematic submerged slice showing the parameters used in the <strong>water</strong> force calculation<br />

Referring to the single schematic slice shown in Figure 5, the resultant force (F) can be spot-checked by<br />

calculating the horizontal and vertical weight components as shown below:<br />

<strong>SLOPE</strong>/W Example File: <strong>Slope</strong> <strong>with</strong> <strong>ponded</strong> <strong>water</strong>.doc (<strong>pdf</strong>) (gsz) Page 4 of 7


<strong>GEO</strong>-<strong>SLOPE</strong> <strong>International</strong> <strong>Ltd</strong>, Calgary, Alberta, Canada www.geo-slope.com<br />

The vertical and horizontal forces acting on a submerged slice can be computed as:<br />

where:<br />

FV = (γ x Hw) x bV x unit depth<br />

FH = (γ x Hw) x bH x unit depth<br />

γ = unit weight of <strong>water</strong><br />

Hw = height of the <strong>water</strong> at the top, centre of the slice<br />

bv = width of the slice as given in the slice force information<br />

bH = bv* tan(α)<br />

For slice #4, <strong>with</strong> a <strong>water</strong> depth of 1.5m, a slice width (bV) of 0.43787 m and a slope angle (α) of 45-<br />

degrees, the vertical and horizontal <strong>water</strong> forces would be:<br />

Fv = (9.807 x 1.5) x 0.43787 m x 1 m = 6.441 kN<br />

FH = (9.807 x 1.5) x [0.43787 m x tan(45)] = 6.441 kN*<br />

* which is the same as the vertical component since the slope is at 45 – degrees.<br />

The resultant force is therefore computed as:<br />

F 2 = √(FH 2 + FV 2 ) = √(6.441 2 + 6.441 2 ) = 9.1 kN<br />

The small difference between the computed F value and the line load acting on the top of the slice is due<br />

to numerical round-off in the hand-calculations.<br />

3.2 Case 2 – Water weight modified <strong>with</strong> a surcharge load<br />

By default, the weight of the <strong>water</strong> and the pore-<strong>water</strong> pressures at the base of the slice will both be<br />

computed using the global weight of <strong>water</strong>. However, there may be a time where you want to use one unit<br />

weight to compute the pore-<strong>water</strong> pressure at the base of the slice and a different unit weight to compute<br />

the <strong>water</strong> force acting on the submerged slices. To do this, you would define the unit weight of <strong>water</strong> for<br />

the pore-<strong>water</strong> pressure computation using SET: Units and Scale, as shown in Figure 2. The global value<br />

would also be used to compute the weight of the slice, but you could modify this value by defining a<br />

surcharge load <strong>with</strong> either a positive or negative unit weight to add or subtract load as desired.<br />

In the second analysis in this detailed example, the global unit weight of <strong>water</strong> has been left at the default<br />

value of 9.807 kN/m 3 , and a surcharge load <strong>with</strong> a positive unit weight of 0.1 kN/m 3 . In defining this<br />

value, the <strong>water</strong> force will essentially be computed as if the unit weight of <strong>water</strong> was defined as 9.907<br />

kN/m 3 .<br />

Figure 6 shows the surcharge load defined overtop of the shaded area representing <strong>ponded</strong> <strong>water</strong> between<br />

the piezometric and the ground surface lines.<br />

<strong>SLOPE</strong>/W Example File: <strong>Slope</strong> <strong>with</strong> <strong>ponded</strong> <strong>water</strong>.doc (<strong>pdf</strong>) (gsz) Page 5 of 7


<strong>GEO</strong>-<strong>SLOPE</strong> <strong>International</strong> <strong>Ltd</strong>, Calgary, Alberta, Canada www.geo-slope.com<br />

Figure 6 A surcharge load used to modify the global weight of <strong>water</strong> for the <strong>water</strong> force acting on<br />

the submerged slope<br />

The critical slip surface and the factor of safety of the partially submerged slope is shown in Figure 7. The<br />

factor of safety is 1.129. The small increase in factor of safety is due to the slight heavier <strong>ponded</strong> <strong>water</strong><br />

which gives additional resisting force against the slide mass.<br />

Figure 7 Critical slip surface and factor of safety <strong>with</strong> the <strong>water</strong> weight modified using a<br />

surcharge load<br />

<strong>SLOPE</strong>/W Example File: <strong>Slope</strong> <strong>with</strong> <strong>ponded</strong> <strong>water</strong>.doc (<strong>pdf</strong>) (gsz) Page 6 of 7


<strong>GEO</strong>-<strong>SLOPE</strong> <strong>International</strong> <strong>Ltd</strong>, Calgary, Alberta, Canada www.geo-slope.com<br />

The free body diagram and the force polygon of slice #4 is shown in Figure 8. Note that the load of<br />

9.0026 kN acting on the top of the slice has increased slightly from the computed value shown in Figure<br />

4, due to the slightly more dense <strong>water</strong> acting on the submerged slope.<br />

Figure 8 Free body diagram and force polygon of slice #4<br />

<strong>SLOPE</strong>/W Example File: <strong>Slope</strong> <strong>with</strong> <strong>ponded</strong> <strong>water</strong>.doc (<strong>pdf</strong>) (gsz) Page 7 of 7

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!