06.07.2015 Views

Volume 10 Issue 7 - April 2005

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

tackled Swedish folk and classical<br />

songs, music of Elvis Costello as well<br />

as plethora of operatic roles and traditional<br />

lieder. She is, to my knowledge,<br />

the only mezzo-soprano to<br />

record a song by ... ABBA and make<br />

it a revelation. In ;, Music for a<br />

While", it's early baroque music that<br />

receives the "von Otter" treatment.<br />

Frescobaldi. Caccini, Monteverdi,<br />

Purcell and Dowland of course do<br />

not present a challenge for von Otter.<br />

It's her versatility that makes this<br />

remarkable disc less than perfect.<br />

Her beautifol and powerful voice<br />

does not easily conform to the strict<br />

standard of the epoque. Rather than<br />

throw a vocal dart at the notes, von<br />

Otter brushes over them with broader<br />

strokes, allowing for a round, unrestrained<br />

sound. This minor quibble<br />

aside, the disc is a beautiful collection<br />

of great performances.<br />

As mentioned before, we do not<br />

really know what the singers of the<br />

Baroque sounded like. Just as the<br />

entire period performance ·movement,<br />

the "baroque singing" is a<br />

conjecture, albeit based on meticulous<br />

musicological research. One<br />

can only hope that Bach, Haendel<br />

and Monteverdi had the benefit of<br />

singers as talented as these three<br />

remarkable vocalists.<br />

Robert Tomas<br />

Bach - Mass in B Minor<br />

The King's Consort; Robert King<br />

Hyperion CDD22051<br />

Judging by his extensive program<br />

notes Robert King is intimately familiar<br />

with the breadth and sonority<br />

of this inspirational masterpiece by<br />

Bach. Using a men-and-boys choir<br />

in this 1996 recording, he follows<br />

historical precedents as Bach did not<br />

use women's voices in any of his sacred<br />

compositions. As to be expected,<br />

there are a few moments that are<br />

somewhat less refined or graceful<br />

as a result, but still the brilliant tone<br />

of the•boy sopranos and altos of the<br />

Tolzer Knabenchor offers great<br />

clarity and definition to the counterpoint.<br />

The listener is also compensated<br />

with disciplined, freshly enthusiastic<br />

and astonishingly mature performances<br />

from these young fellows.<br />

The tiuid lyricism of tenor Anthony<br />

Rolfe Johnson and the bold baso<br />

of Michael George were perfectly<br />

suited for their respective solos.<br />

Carefully conceived in every<br />

phiase, nuance, and dynamic, maestro<br />

King has crafted a beautifully<br />

detailed performance in which the<br />

dancing lilt of the Gloria in excels is<br />

Deo, the sobbing mournful Crucijixus,<br />

the triumphant Et resurrexit,<br />

even the break-neck tempo of Cum<br />

Sancto Spiritu, seemed to make perfect<br />

sense. If Bach heard this, I think<br />

he would have approved.<br />

Frank Nakashima<br />

Mozart: La finta semplice<br />

Helen Donath, Teresa Berganza,<br />

Anthony Rolfe-Johnson,<br />

Thomas Moser<br />

Mozarteum-Orchester<br />

Salzburg; Leopold Hager<br />

Brilliant 92345<br />

Mozart: La finta giardiniera<br />

Elzbieta Szmytka, Joanna<br />

Kozlowska, Marek Torzewski<br />

Orchestre du Theatre Royal de<br />

la Monnaie; Sylvain Cambreling<br />

Brilliant 92348<br />

Mozart: Lucio Silla<br />

Lella Cuberli, Ann Murray,<br />

Christine Barbeaux, Anthony<br />

Rolfe-Johnson<br />

Orchestre du Theatre Royal de<br />

la Monnaie; Sylvain Cambreling<br />

Brilliant 92343<br />

Mozart: Mitridate, re di ponto<br />

Francine van der Hayden, Cecile<br />

van de Sant, Johannette Zomer,<br />

Marcel Reijans<br />

Musica ad Rhenum; Jed Wentz<br />

Brilliant 92344<br />

Mozart: Ascanio in Alba<br />

Nicola Wemyss, Claron<br />

McFaddon, Claudia Patacca,<br />

Maaike Beekman, Tom Allen<br />

Vocaal Ensemble Coqu;<br />

Musica ad Rhenum; Jed Wentz<br />

Brilliant 92347<br />

Mozart: II re pastore<br />

Johannette Zomer, Francine<br />

van der Hayden, Alexei<br />

Grigorev, Marcel Reijans<br />

Musica ad Rhenum; Jed Wentz<br />

Brilliant 92342<br />

Mozart: II sogno di scipione<br />

Claron McFadden, Claudia<br />

Patacca, Franc;ois Soons,<br />

Marcel Reijans<br />

Capella Amsterdam;<br />

Musica ad Rhenum; Jed Wentz<br />

Brilliant 92346<br />

There is enough splendid music in<br />

these early operas alone to count<br />

Mozart as a great operatic .composer.<br />

Recordings cai;i be hard to<br />

find and expensive. But you can buy<br />

all three discs in the budget label<br />

Brilliant's Mitridate for less that the<br />

price of a single disc in Rousset's<br />

star-studded recording.<br />

La finta semplice, written when<br />

Mozart was twelve, is a light-hearted<br />

comedy about a woman pretending<br />

to be a simpleton. The experi,,.<br />

enced Leopold Hager leads some top<br />

Mozart singers of the day in a delightfully<br />

stylish, if unexciting, reissue<br />

from 1983. Recitatives are stilted,<br />

and the orchestra plays down the<br />

character of the score. But there<br />

is some terrific singing, especially<br />

from.Helen Donath as the 'feigned<br />

simpleton' of the title, Anthony Rolphe-Johnson<br />

as the real simpleton<br />

and Teresa Berganza as the vivacious<br />

love-interest who drives the<br />

very silly plot.<br />

The plot of La jinra giardiniera<br />

is even sillier. Mozart was ten<br />

when he wrote it. But it is studded<br />

with gorgeous arias like "Crudeli<br />

fermate", sung here with fiery intensity<br />

by Joanna Kozlowska as the<br />

'feigned garden girl' of the title. She<br />

is pursuing her lover, who has<br />

stabbed her and run off, leaving her<br />

for dead. As the playfully appealing<br />

servant-girl, Elzbieta Szmytka is<br />

charming in her mood changes from<br />

poignant despair to hope. But the men<br />

here are an unexciting lot in this live<br />

performance made in 1989 at La<br />

Monnaie in Brussels with their expert<br />

orchestra under a responsive Sylvain<br />

Cambreling.<br />

Lucio Silla was recorded at La<br />

Monnaie under Cambreling four<br />

years earlier with the same sensitive<br />

pacing, but unfortunately the<br />

same intrusive stage noise and<br />

coughing. Again the cast is uneven,<br />

with some sublime singing. The<br />

duet "D'Ellisio in sen" with the lovely<br />

Ann Murray and a scintillating<br />

Lella Cuberli is one of the highlights<br />

of this whole group of discs.<br />

The four recordings led by Jed<br />

Wentz are recent. Wentz uses his<br />

OTE CO<br />

On location recordings of jazz and classical music<br />

Twenty years of live recording for public radio<br />

William Van Ree<br />

phone: 416 694 3505<br />

97 Highview Avenue<br />

cell: 416 452 6623<br />

Scarborough ON<br />

www.williamvanree.com<br />

M1N2H6<br />

william@williamvanree.com<br />

DIGITAL EDIT.ING<br />

•<br />

CD MASTERING<br />

.<br />

·OPE N REEL TRANSFERS·<br />

96/24 CAPABILITY<br />

CONTACT: KARL MACHAT<br />

416 503 3060 OR 647 227 KARL<br />

MISTERS.MASTERS@SYMPATtCO.CA<br />

APRIL 1 - MAY 7 <strong>2005</strong> WWW. THEWHOLENOTE.COM

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!