34Decision Tree42.Are some of<strong>the</strong> fields notintercropped?YesMaize, sorghum or milletNoDry-seasonrotation43.Would youprefer a rotation orhedgerows?44. Use S14S20, S50, S51,S55, S70,S71 or S75Hedgerows45. UseS21, S25,S58 or S8241.What are <strong>the</strong>dominantcrops?WastelandRice46.Is it uplandor paddy rice?Paddy48. Use S74S76, S78, S79,S80 or S81O<strong>the</strong>rcrops60. UseS77Upland47. UseS72 or S7338. Use S1, S2, S3,S8, S9, S18, S22,S24, S30, S52, S53,S58, S64, S69, S70,S71, S75 or S85Go to #5Vegetables& root crops50.Are <strong>the</strong>y rootcrops, vegetablesor perennials?Perennials51.Are <strong>the</strong>yirrigated orrainfed?Irrigated55. Go to #2or do someresearch.56.What are <strong>the</strong>main perennials?RainfedCoffeeOil palm,coconut,cacaoFruit trees52.Do youwant to use anintercrop or arotation?Rotation54. Use S48,S74 or S7557. UseS16, S28,or S2958. UseS26or S2759. UseS26,S37,S38, or S67Intercrop53. Use S10, S11,S42, or S43Go to #5
Decision Tree Guide35Decision Tree GuideEach of <strong>the</strong> points below refers to a numbered box in <strong>the</strong> decision tree. Each pointprovides additional information on <strong>the</strong> decision tree boxes and will assist in selectingoptions as one moves through <strong>the</strong> decision tree.1. Farmers’ priorities. If farmers do not include soil fertility or <strong>the</strong> need for fertilizersas one of <strong>the</strong>ir two or three most important problems, and don’t seem toshow much interest in working on soil fertility, go to #2. If <strong>the</strong>y do identify soilinfertility as a major problem and show a strong interest in trying to solve <strong>the</strong>problem, go to #4.2. The importance of gm/ccs. Seriously consider <strong>the</strong> possibility of not working insoil fertility. If <strong>the</strong> decision is not to work in soil fertility, go to #3. If you stillbelieve strongly that soil fertility is a major problem in <strong>the</strong> area and success intackling it is still definitely possible, go to #4.3. The end. This is <strong>the</strong> end of <strong>the</strong> program’s work in gm/ccs. Maybe something willchange (for instance, people’s soils become poorer, so <strong>the</strong>y will have more motivationto improve <strong>the</strong>m) that will make gm/ccs more attractive or easier to managein <strong>the</strong> future, but for now, gm/ccs will not be part of <strong>the</strong> program’s agenda.4. A successful system nearby? Is <strong>the</strong>re a successful gm/cc system near <strong>the</strong> projectlocation or in an area of roughly similar farming systems and ecological environment?Or do <strong>the</strong> farmers know of such a system, and are <strong>the</strong>y interested in it?Are more smallholder farmers adopting this gm/cc system, or are <strong>the</strong>y graduallyabandoning it? Are <strong>the</strong>y adopting it in <strong>the</strong> absence of any artificial subsidies orany program that is promoting it? If <strong>the</strong> answer is yes to most of <strong>the</strong>se questions,go to #5. If <strong>the</strong>re is no such system, go to #10.If <strong>the</strong>re is such a system, but you cannot answer yes to <strong>the</strong> questions, interview<strong>the</strong> farmers that are using it, being careful not to just take <strong>the</strong>ir answers at facevalue. Analyze <strong>the</strong> system’s economics and its pros and cons, both according to<strong>the</strong> farmers and according to your own analysis. If <strong>the</strong> system does not seem toprovide more benefits than costs, go to #10. If it does, go to #5.5. Field trials. Organize at least three or four trials of <strong>the</strong> technologies in question.Preferably, trials can be done on <strong>the</strong> land of <strong>the</strong> best farmer leaders, or of thosefarmers who will do <strong>the</strong> best job of managing <strong>the</strong> experiments and whose farms,if possible, are accessible. If <strong>the</strong>re is not a strong relationship with <strong>the</strong> farmers, or<strong>the</strong> farmers may not properly manage <strong>the</strong> experiments, conduct a trial on a smallplot of rented or borrowed land.Keep very close records of <strong>the</strong> costs and benefits as compared to traditional systems,being especially careful to include all labor costs. Far too often those of us