<strong>SpareBank</strong> 1 <strong>Gruppen</strong> is a holding company whose main owners are 15 Norwegian savings banks, together withthe Norwegian Confederation of Trade Unions (LO). The group was established in 1996 in response to strongercompetition in the Norwegian financial market. Until end-December 2009, the group has consisted of five whollyowned product companies in life insurance, non-life insurance, asset management, banking, factoring and debtcollection. Since 1st January 2010, Bank 1 Oslo has been separated from <strong>SpareBank</strong> 1 <strong>Gruppen</strong> and is nowdirectly owned by the <strong>SpareBank</strong> 1-banks and the Norwegian Confederation of Trade Unions. <strong>SpareBank</strong> 1<strong>Gruppen</strong> is also an owner in the brokerage firm <strong>SpareBank</strong> 1 Markets (97.55%).The market share of the alliance (<strong>SpareBank</strong> 1 <strong>Gruppen</strong> and member banks) has gradually improved thanks to awider and deeper product offering, increased marketing and good cross-selling, as well as new banks joining thealliance. On a reported basis, <strong>SpareBank</strong> 1 Alliance is the second-largest financial institution in Norway and has amarket share of around 20% in retail lending, c.16% in corporate lending, around 10% in equity funds,approximately 10% in non-life insurance and around 3% in life insurance.<strong>Credit</strong> Profile of Significant Subsidiaries<strong>SpareBank</strong> 1 SkadeforsikringMoody's considers the property & casualty (P&C) business to be a significant market player in the Norwegianmarket, where it has a number 4 position with a market share at YE 2012 of 10.1%. After a period of improvingprofitability in recent years, albeit driven largely by investment income in 2009 and the relatively good product risk,being focused primarily on personal motor and property risks, 2010 witnessed an increase in the overall combinedratio to 97.7%, driven in part by the severe 2010 winter, and 2011 witnessed a further deterioration to 103.5%. The2011 deterioration was driven, inter alia, by a combination of elevated flood related claims in Q2 2011, together withstorm and other large claims. More recently, the 2012 performance improved to 98.2%, reflecting, inter alia, morebenign weather conditions and lower levels of large claims than 2011 and higher revenues. This resulted in a pretaxprofit of MNOK 619 (2011: MNOK 185).Moody's also notes that there remains some degree of reserving volatility within the portfolio, particularly on thelonger tailed commercial lines business and the P&C business remains heavily dependent on a single distributionchannel, namely the owner banks.<strong>SpareBank</strong> 1 LivsforsikringFollowing significant losses in 2008 and capital injections into the life business during both 2008 and 2009, Moody'snotes the recent improvements in both profitability and capitalisation within the life business, particularly withregard to the improvement in the administration result in 2012 to MNOK -56 (2011: MNOK -66, 2010: MNOK -187)and an overall pre-tax profit of MNOK 479 (2011: MNOK 414). Whilst policyholder buffer capital remains higher(2012: 13.6% of technical provisions) and remains significantly above the 5.8% reported at YE 2008, Moody'sconsiders the life business to remain significantly exposed to investment market volatility. As with the P&Cbusiness, the life business remains heavily exposed to the Norwegian economy, lacking the geographicdiversification of larger continental life insurers.More specifically, as at YE 2012, SP1 Liv's paid up policies (poorly adapted to a Solvency II requirement) were c.NOK 4bn and the life company is expected to have some reserve strengthening need arising out of the newlongevity tables published by the FSA on the 8th March, albeit manageable in the context of the <strong>SpareBank</strong>1 Groupand its owner banks.<strong>Credit</strong> Strengths- Strong brand, which is among the most recognised financial brands in Norway- Diversified operations, including the owner banks- Relatively low risk profile of non-life insurance business- Expected high support from the owner banks reflecting its important role in the wider <strong>SpareBank</strong> 1 Alliance<strong>Credit</strong> Challenges- Improving profitability and growing business in the mature market- High competition in both the insurance and banking markets
- Volatility of investment results, particularly with the life insurance business, which necessitated capital injectionsduring the crisis- Dependence on the distribution channels of the alliance- Lower coherence in the alliance as there is no joint and several liability guarantee- Potential departure of any member bank, although this at the moment is not considered likelyWhat to Watch for:- Any deterioration in the credit profile of the owners would likely be reflected in the issuer rating of the Group.- Seasonality of profitability in the P&C business given the frequent adverse winter weather in the Nordics.- Challenge of Solvency 2 implementation, particularly for the life business which has provided products withguaranteed returns.- Treatment of Paid up Policies within the life portfolio currently remains a concern for Norwegian life insurersRating OutlookThe long-term issuer rating (Baa2 stable) was affirmed with a stable outlook at Baa2 on 18 March 2013. At thesame time, the short-term issuer rating (P-2) was affirmed. This rating action follows the publication of the newlongevity tables by the Norwegian FSA on 08th March 2013(see relevant press release for further details).What Could Change the Rating - UpNot considered likely in the short term due to the ratings being on stable outlook. However, in the longer term,positive rating action could arise in the event of:- An upgrade in one of more of the owners' ratings- If the commitment from the owner banks were to be perceived as higher, and/or- If a sustained improvement in the financial performance of the group were to occur.What Could Change the Rating - Down- A downgrade in one of more of the owners' ratings- The commitment from the owner banks were to be perceived as lower, and/or- A deterioration in the financial performance of the group.Recent ResultsAt YE 2012, the group reported a post-tax profit of NOK 443mn (YE 2011: NOK 526mn), and a return on equity of8.7% (2011: 11.1%).Capital Structure and LiquidityThe majority of the group's borrowings are made by <strong>SpareBank</strong> 1 <strong>Gruppen</strong> <strong>AS</strong>. The group's refinancing risk islimited as the outstanding term of the debt is relatively long with a mixture of perpetual instruments and post 2015maturities, although we note that there is some refinancing need in 2013. The liquidation ranking is varied withmaterial amounts of senior, subordinate and junior subordinate in issue.Financial leverage was moderate at 15% at year-end 2011. In addition, Moody's assigns equity credit to thesupplementary and security provisions, with, in particular the supplementary reserves recovering in 2010 thanks tothe relative improvement in financial markets, at least as at YE 2010, although the securities adjustment reservedeclined materially in 2011. Furthermore, policyholder reserves continue to be lower than pre-crisis levels.Earnings cover is estimated to be good at 9x in 2011 (2007-11 5 year average of 10x), in line with the healthyprofitability of the company and the relatively modest levels of financial leverage. Nevertheless, Moody's notes thesubstantial volatility of the group's operating performance could pressurise earnings cover in future quarters, as