PDF for Printing - Graduate School of Arts and Sciences - Columbia ...

More documents

Recommendations

Info

“You’re Being Sensitive Again...”It’s not that MESAAS is alone in these issues, Busch and the group’sorganizers stressed. Women in the sciences have been getting this levelof scrutiny for a long time. A 2008 study in the journal Perspectives onPolitics refers to the “quiet desperation” of women in academia.MESAAS students recognize that the conversations taking place in theirdepartment themselves represent a kind of privilege, since most peopleshare a similar political mind-set and vocabulary.“We think it’s really cliché to say that orientalism exists, but in a lot ofother places, it’s like, ‘Oh, that’s your opinion...You’re being sensitiveagain, brown Muslim girl.’ That sucks, and we’re lucky we don’t havethat,” Ullah said. “People are really willing to listen and engage.”Area studies comes with its own distinctive lens and curriculum biases,especially from the perspective of a woman studying the Middle East,South Asia, or Africa.“The relationship of men and women of color is often wrongly characterizedas a relationship of oppression,” Gopal said. “Like all relationships,these are dynamic and varied. As a South Asian woman, I want tospeak about my womanhood in my own terms and not through borrowedor externally imposed lenses.”A widely read piece in Foreign Policy by Mona Eltahawy asks, “Why DoThey Hate Us?” The “they” refers to Middle Eastern governments andmen while the “us” refers to Middle Eastern women. The polarizingpiece succinctly declares “We have no freedoms because they hate us”and demands that the region do better, rejecting any historical explanationor sociocultural context for the treatment of women.“There are lots of different approaches in the region with respect tofemininity. There’s the African concept of womanhood, there’s the Hindufeminine ideal, and the Islamic dialogue around women, and thesealso vary across families and communities,” Gopal explains. “There areas many expressions of womanhood as there are women in this world.Link back to contents page8 Superscript
Part of us coming together is to explore these different frameworks andchallenge them.”They’re also getting support from their curious male colleagues.”It felt like the gender dynamic in our department changed as soon asour male colleagues found out that the women were getting togetherand talking,” Gopal said.Reis added, “Our concerns are not just with male colleagues or professors;sexism and misogyny is internalized by everyone.”By creating and promotingnew narratives aboutwomen in the region, aboutwomen scholars, aboutwomen, period, they’ll startto see change.Wendell Marsh, a Ph.D. student in the department studying Africa, saidhe completely understands the need for the group, especially when heconsiders the department’s research focus.“WAFA is trying to address a lack of representation of women’s issuesin the department,” he said. “Women or women’s issues would notemerge as a prominent feature if one made a survey of departmentalscholarship, and WAFA wants to deal with this in intellectually productiveways.”The group is planning for a packed year, including hosting speakerssuch as Busch, Abu-Lughod, and Anu Rao, and aiming to coordinatesexual harassment seminars for both students and faculty. Membersare also editing a narrative book project, for which they’re solicitingsubmissions.“One of the things we’re sensitive to is the ways in which feminismshave been used purportedly to ‘save’ women of our regions from ‘theirmen,’” Ullah said. “Stories just have a way of breaking down stereotypes.”And that, Gopal added, is the point. By creating and promoting newnarratives about women in the region, about women scholars, aboutwomen, period, they’ll start to see change.“We want to create so many new stereotypes that people forget aboutthese old stereotypes and get overwhelmed by plurality.”Superscript 9Link back to contents page
Page 1 and 2: SuperscriptVolume 3, Issue 1Fall 20
Page 4 and 5: CharlesLeilaLink DickensKhaled. Pho
Page 6 and 7: shared the same themes, the same fr
Page 8 and 9: “One learns one is not alone,”
Page 12 and 13: Link back to contents page10 Supers
Page 14 and 15: But in March, Brownannounced that i
Page 16 and 17: “It’s great that women are univ
Page 18 and 19: Presidents Havel, Bollinger,and Cli
Page 20 and 21: Although Warren grew up in a union
Page 22 and 23: content or satisfied simply being a
Page 24 and 25: Link back to contents page22 Supers
Page 26 and 27: “[Fencing for Columbia] helped me
Page 28 and 29: Alumni News | Graduate School of Ar
Page 30 and 31: Alumni ProfileLouis ParksGraduate S
Page 32 and 33: On the ShelfFACULTY PUBLICATIONSThe
Page 34: On the ShelfALUMNI PUBLICATIONSIn S
Page 37 and 38: The Cultural Politics of Twentieth-
Page 39 and 40: Daniel David MacDougall. Singlemole
Page 41 and 42: Alexander Vincent Penson. Searchfor
Page 43 and 44: Teachers College: Sociology andEduc
Page 45 and 46: Joseph Woo with Provost John Coatsw
Page 47 and 48: GSAS Annual FundEach year, the Grad
Page 49 and 50: $1,000 to $2,499continuedDr. Sam H.
Page 51: Superscript 49Link back to contents

PDF for Printing - Graduate School of Arts and Sciences - Columbia ...

Create successful ePaper yourself

Delete template?

Save as template?