DIRECT FIXATION ASSEMBLIESalmost impossible to meet both the technicaland cost targets. A high level <strong>of</strong> vibrationisolation track fastening systems has to beused. <strong>The</strong> PANDROL VANGUARD system, beingconsidered as an alterative to floating slabtrack, has been selected for these requirementson Line 5. As well as ground borne vibration,airborne noise in trains running in the tunnelalso needs to be considered.BEIJING SUBWAY LINE 5Line 5 runs north-south, beginning with threestops in the far northern suburb <strong>of</strong>Tiantongyuan in Changping District, wellbeyond the 5th Ring Road, then crossing Line13 at Lishuiqiao, and entering into the vastresidential swaths <strong>of</strong> Chaoyang District oneither side <strong>of</strong> the Yuan dynasty city wall. It skirtseast <strong>of</strong> the Temple <strong>of</strong> Earth and meets Line 2Loop at the Yonghegong, also known as theLama Temple. <strong>The</strong>n Line 5 cuts through the oldneighbourhoods <strong>of</strong> Dongcheng District and theold foreign Legation Quarter betweenDongdan and Chongwenmen. Further south,Line 5 stops at the eastern entrance to theTemple <strong>of</strong> Heaven in Chongwen District andeventually reaches Songjiazhuang in FengtaiDistrict south <strong>of</strong> the city. It takes 49 minutes tocover all the 23 stations. <strong>The</strong> Zhang ZizhongStreet station, named after a general martyredin World War Two, is the only eponymousstation on the Beijing Subway. <strong>The</strong> total length<strong>of</strong> the line is 27.6km <strong>of</strong> which 16.9kmis underground and 10.7km on the surfaceand viaduct.PANDROL VANGUARD RAILFASTENING SYSTEM AND ITSINSTALLATIONSPANDROL VANGUARD is a rail fasteningsystem in which the rail is supported by elasticwedges under its head. <strong>The</strong> wedges arein turn held in place by cast iron brackets,which are fastened to a baseplate. <strong>The</strong>baseplate is rigidly fixed down to the trackfoundation via the existing anchor inserts asshown in Figure 2. <strong>The</strong> principal advantage <strong>of</strong>the system over more conventional railfastenings is that is allows significantly greatervertical deflections under traffic withoutan unacceptable accompanying degree<strong>of</strong> rail roll and without increasing the overallrail height. A special clamping tool isused to assemble/disassemble the PANDROLVANGUARD system.Figure 2(a) Delivery <strong>of</strong> VANGUARD components andremoval <strong>of</strong> existing baseplate on Beijing Subway Line 5A special asymmetrical PANDROLVANGUARD baseplate was designed for BeijingSubway Line 5 which allows the existing anchorsystem to be used. <strong>The</strong> new baseplate is justswapped from the existing type DTVI baseplate.<strong>The</strong> PANDROL VANGUARD baseplate has thesame rail height level, super elevation andinclination so that no modification is requiredto the existing track. <strong>The</strong> track gauge and railvertical level also have the same adjustmentability.<strong>The</strong> static stiffness measured between15kN and 30kN <strong>of</strong> the PANDROL VANGUARDbaseplate designed for Beijing Subway is4.7MN/m, and the dynamic stiffness underloading at 10Hz is 6.6MN/m [2] . This very lowstiffness system reduces vibration transmissionto the supporting structure and hence intothe ground.Installation <strong>of</strong> the new PANDROLVANGUARD baseplates was made at nightduring engineering hours, with the track left atevery stage in a safe condition to run trains.In order to speed up the installation, theteam divided into two groups, with 4 clampingtools working on the both rails for eachsection at the same time. A stiffnesstransition design between the existingbaseplate and PANDROL VANGUARD usingspecial rail pads was also provided byPANDROL. <strong>The</strong> installation <strong>of</strong> the 26,000PANDROL VANGUARD baseplates over 8km <strong>of</strong>track length for the project took about 4months and finished in May <strong>2008</strong>. Figure 2shows the installation procedure includingdelivery <strong>of</strong> new baseplates, removal <strong>of</strong> theexisting baseplates, installation, and clamping<strong>of</strong> PANDROL VANGUARD assemblies,inspection and finished track.TRACK DYNAMIC DEFLECTIONPERFORMANCEIn order to check track safety issues <strong>of</strong> raildynamic deflection, a worst-case test locationwas selected on curved track with a400m radius in the southbound tunnel atkilometre post <strong>of</strong> K0+890 between Liujiayaoand Songiiazhuang stations. A vibrationperformance test was also carried out at thesame site. <strong>The</strong> existing track consists <strong>of</strong> a 60kgrail, type II clip, type DTV12 baseplate with a12mm thick rail seat pad and a 16mm thickbaseplate pad. <strong>The</strong> baseplates are anchoreddirectly onto the track slab by means <strong>of</strong> 2 <strong>of</strong>fsetbolts. <strong>The</strong> tunnel has a round section with asingle track. <strong>The</strong> traffic is 6-car trains and the4
DIRECT FIXATION ASSEMBLIESmaximum traffic frequency is 12 trains per hourduring peak hour operation. <strong>The</strong> track speedwas about 60km/h. All recordings were madeunder normal service passenger traffic with anaxle load <strong>of</strong> approximately 14 tonnes at peakoperating hours.Measurements with the existing baseplateswere made in December 2007. <strong>The</strong> PANDROLVANGUARD baseplates were installed inJanuary <strong>2008</strong> and then further trackmeasurements were made in February <strong>2008</strong>.Vertical deflection <strong>of</strong> the rail relative to the slabincreased from about 0.31mm with the existingrail fastening to 3.11mm with the PANDROLVANGUARD system under the 14 tonnes axleload on Line 5 traffic. <strong>The</strong> maximum rail headlateral movement increased from 0.50mm to0.69mm, both occur on the low rail under theleading axle. This combination <strong>of</strong> low verticalstiffness and rail roll restraint with thePANDROL VANGUARD fastening system <strong>of</strong>fersthe potential for significant reductions invibration transmission with a mechanicallyacceptable system. <strong>The</strong> railhead lateraldeflections indicated that the maximumdynamic track gauge widening for the existingfastening system and PANDROL VANGUARD isless than 1.0mm and less than 1.4mmrespectively. This meets the track maintenancespecification issued by China Ministry <strong>of</strong><strong>Rail</strong>ways in 1998, in which the dynamic trackgauge change should be within the tolerance<strong>of</strong> -6/+12mm for first class track under trainspeeds <strong>of</strong> less than 100km/h.SURFACE VIBRATIONPERFORMANCE OVER THETUNNEL WITH VANGUARD<strong>The</strong> frequency range <strong>of</strong> greatest interest forsurface vibration is from 1Hz to 80Hz. <strong>The</strong>vibration assessment is based on the ChineseNational Standards, GB10070-88 [3] andGB10071-88 [4] , in which the vibrationacceleration levels are weighted using thewindows defined in ISO2631-1 [5] . Vibration inthe vertical direction is represented in dBz.<strong>The</strong> vibration level was measured in aresidential property (145 Baimiaocun, FengtaiDistrict, Beijing) on the surface above thenorthbound tunnel on the same curved tracksite as for the track test – kilometre post <strong>of</strong>K0+890m. <strong>The</strong> approximate position <strong>of</strong> thetwo tunnels is shown in Figure 3.Accelerometers were approximately 5.2m awayfrom the centreline <strong>of</strong> the northbound tunnel.Acceleration levels from trains on both thenorthbound and southbound tracks wererecorded, and were identified and separated.Vibration measurements vary considerably fromone train pass to the next, due to the effects <strong>of</strong>speed and rail-wheel condition. Trains wereselected from the recordings that appeared togive a clean signal. All vibration measurementspresented here have been averaged acrossresults from these selected train passes. Similarresults were obtained for all <strong>of</strong> the selectedtrains within each set <strong>of</strong> data.<strong>The</strong> average background surface vibrationlevel was about 52dBz in the vertical direction.<strong>The</strong> average vertical surface vibration level was76.3dBz and 73.4dBz with BJM baseplates, and64.2dBz and 58.1dBz with PANDROLVANGUARD baseplates in the northbound andsouthbound tunnels respectively. <strong>The</strong>se indicatethat the surface vibration insertion loss was12.1dB and 15.2dB under traffic in thenorthbound and southbound tunnelsrespectively as the result <strong>of</strong> the installation <strong>of</strong>PANDROL VANGUARD system. <strong>The</strong> averageinsertion loss was about 13.7dB over thecurved track. Vertical acceleration spectra atthe surface with the existing fastening and thePANDROL VANGUARD system installed areFigure 2(b) VANGUARD clamping5