23.11.2012 Views

section 1 energy conversion engineering

section 1 energy conversion engineering

section 1 energy conversion engineering

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

SECTION 1<br />

ENERGY CONVERSION<br />

ENGINEERING<br />

Combustion Calculation Parameters 1.1<br />

Coal Fuel Combustion in a Furnace 1.1<br />

Percent Excess Air while Burning Coal 1.4<br />

Fuel Oil Combustion in a Furnace 1.5<br />

Natural Gas Fuel Combustion in a<br />

Furnace 1.7<br />

Wood Fuel Combustion in a Furnace 1.11<br />

Combustion CalCulation Parameters<br />

Combustion Analysis by the Molal<br />

Method 1.13<br />

Estimating the Temperature of the Final<br />

Products of Combustion 1.15<br />

Determination of the Savings Produced by<br />

Preheating Combustion Air 1.16<br />

Combustion Calculations Using the Million<br />

Btu (1.055 MJ) Method 1.17<br />

The focus in this <strong>section</strong> of the handbook is on external combustion of fossil fuels—such as in a boiler<br />

furnace. A large portion of fossil-fuel <strong>energy</strong> use takes place in the form of external combustion to<br />

generate steam for power generation and space heating. Internal combustion of fossil fuels—such as<br />

in gas turbines, and diesel and gas engines—is discussed within <strong>section</strong>s 3 and 4 of this handbook.<br />

In today’s world the greatest emphasis is on complete combustion to reduce greenhouse gases<br />

and the ensuing pollution when such gases are emitted into the atmosphere. Thus, in the midwestern<br />

United States, combustion of coal in steam power plants produces some 210 lb (95.3 kg) of CO 2 per<br />

million Btu (1.055 MJ) of coal used in a steam boiler. Contrast this with 120 lb (54.4 kg) of CO 2<br />

produced per million Btu (1.055 MJ) of natural gas used in a steam boiler.<br />

On the basis of power generated, 1.9 lb (0.86 kg) of CO 2 is produced per kWh generated by a<br />

coal-fired boiler and turbine. With natural-gas firing of a steam boiler, 1.25 lb (0.57 kg) of CO 2 is<br />

produced per kWh generated. These statistics indicate that more efficient combustion of fossil fuels<br />

reduces greenhouse gases and operating costs. Hence design and operating engineers are making<br />

strenuous efforts to improve combustion efficiency to comply with ever stricter regulations while<br />

reducing plant operating costs.<br />

As indicated later in this <strong>section</strong> of the handbook, some states and countries are considering banning<br />

coal-fired power plants unless they meet much more stringent emission requirements. At this writing,<br />

the Environmental Protection Agency seeks to establish ozone levels of 0.060 to 0.070 ppm.<br />

Coal Fuel Combustion in a FurnaCe<br />

A coal fuel has the following ultimate analysis (or percent by weight): C = 0.8339; H 2 = 0.0456;<br />

O 2 = 0.0505; N 2 = 0.0103; S = 0.0064; ash = 0.0533; total = 1.000 lb (0.45 kg). This coal is burned<br />

in a steam-boiler furnace. Determine the weight of air required for theoretically perfect combustion,<br />

the weight of gas formed per pound (kilogram) of coal burned, and the volume of flue gas,<br />

at the boiler exit temperature of 600°F (316°C) per pound (kilogram) of coal burned; air required<br />

with 20 percent excess air, and the volume of gas formed with this excess; the CO 2 percentage in<br />

the flue gas on a dry and wet basis.<br />

1.1


1.2 SECTION 1<br />

Calculation Procedure:<br />

1. Compute the weight of oxygen required per pound (kilogram) of coal<br />

To find the weight of oxygen required for theoretically perfect combustion of coal, set up the following<br />

tabulation, based on the ultimate analysis of the coal:<br />

Element ×<br />

C; 0.8339<br />

H 2 ; 0.0456<br />

O 2 ; 0.0505; decreases external O 2 required<br />

N 2 ; 0.0103 is inert in combustion and is<br />

ignored<br />

S; 0.0064<br />

Ash 0.0533 is inert in combustion and is<br />

ignored<br />

×<br />

×<br />

×<br />

Molecular-weight<br />

ratio =<br />

32 /12<br />

16 /2<br />

32 /32<br />

=<br />

=<br />

=<br />

=<br />

lb (kg) O 2<br />

required<br />

2.2237 (1.009)<br />

0.3648 (0.165)<br />

−0.0505 (0.023)<br />

0.0064 (0.003)<br />

Total 1.0000<br />

lb (kg) external O 2 per lb (kg) fuel = 2.5444 (1.154)<br />

Note that of the total oxygen needed for combustion, 0.0505 lb (0.023 kg), is furnished by the fuel<br />

itself and is assumed to reduce the total external oxygen required by the amount of oxygen present<br />

in the fuel. The molecular-weight ratio is obtained from the equation for the chemical reaction of<br />

the element with oxygen in combustion. Thus, for carbon C + O 2 → CO 2 , or 12 + 32 = 44, where 12<br />

and 32 are the molecular weights of C and O 2 , respectively.<br />

2. Compute the weight of air required for perfect combustion<br />

Air at sea level is a mechanical mixture of various gases, principally 23.2 percent oxygen and<br />

76.8 percent nitrogen by weight. The nitrogen associated with the 2.5444 lb (1.154 kg) of oxygen<br />

required per pound (kilogram) of coal burned in this furnace is the product of the ratio of the nitrogen<br />

and oxygen weights in the air and 2.5444, or (2.5444)(0.768/0.232) = 8.4228 lb (3.820 kg).<br />

Then the weight of air required for perfect combustion of 1 lb (0.45 kg) of coal = sum of nitrogen<br />

and oxygen required = 8.4228 + 2.5444 = 10.9672 lb (4.975 kg) of air per pound (kilogram) of<br />

coal burned.<br />

3. Compute the weight of the products of combustion<br />

Find the products of combustion by addition:<br />

Products of combustion<br />

Fuel constituents + Oxygen → lb kg<br />

C; 0.8339 + 2.2237 → CO 2 = 3.0576 1.387<br />

H; 0.0465 + 0.3648 → H 2 O = 0.4104 0.186<br />

O 2 ; 0.0505; this is not a product combustion<br />

N 2 ; 0.0103; inert but passes through furnace = 0.0103 0.005<br />

S; 0.0064 + 0.0064 → SO 2 = 0.0128 0.006<br />

Outside nitrogen from step 2 = N 2 = 8.4228 3.820<br />

lb (kg) of flue gas lb (kg) of coal burned = 11.9139 5.404<br />

4. Convert the flue-gas weight to volume<br />

Use Avogadro’s law, which states that under the same conditions of pressure and temperature, 1 mol<br />

(the molecular weight of a gas expressed in lb) of any gas will occupy the same volume.


ENERGY CONVERSION ENGINEERING 1.3<br />

At 14.7 lb/in 2 (abs) (101.3 kPa) and 32°F (0°C), 1 mol of any gas occupies 359 ft 3 (10.2 m 3 ).<br />

The volume per pound (kilogram) of any gas at these conditions can be found by dividing 359<br />

by the molecular weight of the gas and correcting for the gas temperature by multiplying the<br />

volume by the ratio of the absolute flue-gas temperature and the atmospheric temperature. To<br />

change the weight analysis (step 3) of the products of combustion to volumetric analysis, set up<br />

the calculation thus:<br />

Weight<br />

Molecular<br />

Volume at<br />

Products lb kg weight Temperature correction 600°F, ft3 316°C, m3 CO 2 3.0576 1.3869 44 (359/44)(3.0576)(2.15) = 53.6 1.518<br />

H 2 O 0.4104 0.1862 18 (359/18)(0.4104)(2.15) = 17.6 0.498<br />

Total N 2 8.4331 3.8252 28 (359/28)(8.4331)(2.15) = 232.5 6.584<br />

SO 4 0.0128 0.0058 64 (359/64)(0.0128)(2.15) = 0.15 0.004<br />

ft 3 (m 3 ) of flue gas per lb (kg) of coal burned = 303.85 8.604<br />

In this calculation, the temperature correction factor 2.15 = absolute flue-gas temperature, °R/absolute<br />

atmospheric temperature, °R = (600 + 460)/(32 + 460). The total weight of N 2 in the flue gas is<br />

the sum of the N 2 in the combustion air and the fuel, or 8.4228 + 0.0103 = 8.4331 lb (3.8252 kg).<br />

The value is used in computing the flue-gas volume.<br />

5. Compute the CO 2 content of the flue gas<br />

The volume of CO 2 in the products of combustion at 600°F (316°C) is 53.6 ft 3 (1.158 m 3 ), as computed<br />

in step 4, and the total volume of the combustion products is 303.85 ft 3 (8.604 m 3 ). Therefore,<br />

the percent CO 2 on a wet basis (i.e., including the moisture in the combustion products) = ft 3 CO 2 /<br />

total ft 3 = 53.6 / 303.85 = 0.1764, or 17.64 percent.<br />

The percent CO 2 on a dry, or Orsat, basis is found in the same manner, except that the weight of<br />

H 2 O in the products of combustion, 17.6 lb (7.83 kg) from step 4, is subtracted from the total gas<br />

weight. Or, percent CO 2 , dry, or Orsat basis = (53.6)/(303.85 − 17.6) = 0.1872, or 18.72 percent.<br />

6. Compute the air required with the stated excess flow<br />

With 20 percent excess air, the air flow required = (0.20 + 1.00)(air flow with no excess) = 1.20<br />

(10.9672) = 13.1606 lb (5.970 kg) of air per pound (kilogram) of coal burned. The air flow with no<br />

excess is obtained from step 2.<br />

7. Compute the weight of the products of combustion<br />

The excess air passes through the furnace without taking part in the combustion and increases the<br />

weight of the products of combustion per pound (kilogram) of coal burned. Therefore, the weight of<br />

the products of combustion is the sum of the weight of the combustion products without the excess<br />

air and the product of (percent excess air)(air for perfect combustion, lb); or, given the weights from<br />

steps 3 and 2, respectively, = 11.9139 + (0.20)(10.9672) = 14.1073 lb (6.399 kg) of gas per pound<br />

(kilogram) of coal burned with 20 percent excess air.<br />

8. Compute the volume of the combustion products and the percent CO 2<br />

The volume of the excess air in the products of combustion is obtained by converting from the weight<br />

analysis to the volumetric analysis and correcting for temperature as in step 4, using the air weight<br />

from step 2 for perfect combustion and the excess-air percentage, or (10.9672)(0.20)(359/28.95)<br />

(2.15) = 58.5 ft 3 (1.656 m 3 ). In this calculation the value 28.95 is the molecular weight of air. The<br />

total volume of the products of combustion is the sum of the column for perfect combustion, step 4,<br />

and the excess-air volume, above, or 303.85 + 58.5 = 362.35 ft 3 (10.261 m 3 ).<br />

By using the procedure in step 5, the percent CO 2 , wet basis = 53.6/362.35 = 14.8 percent. The<br />

percent CO 2 , dry basis = 53.8/(362.35 − 17.6) = 15.6 percent.<br />

Related Calculations. Use the method given here when making combustion calculations for any<br />

type of coal—bituminous, semibituminous, lignite, anthracite, cannel, or cooking—from any coal


1.4 SECTION 1<br />

field in the world used in any type of furnace—boiler, heater, process, or waste-heat. When the air<br />

used for combustion contains moisture, as is usually true, this moisture is added to the combustionformed<br />

moisture appearing in the products of combustion. Thus, for 80°F (26.7°C) air of 60 percent<br />

relative humidity, the moisture content is 0.013 lb/lb (0.006 kg/kg) of dry air. This amount appears<br />

in the products of combustion for each pound of air used and is a commonly assumed standard in<br />

combustion calculations.<br />

Fossil-fuel-fired power plants release sulfur emissions to the atmosphere. In turn, this produces<br />

sulfates, which are the key ingredient in acid rain. The federal Clean Air Act regulates sulfur dioxide<br />

emissions from power plants. Electric utilities which burn high-sulfur coal are thought to produce<br />

some 35 percent of atmospheric emissions of sulfur dioxide in the United States.<br />

Sulfur dioxide emissions by power plants have declined some 30 percent since passage of the<br />

Clean Air Act in 1970, and a notable decline in acid rain has been noted at a number of test sites.<br />

In 1990 the Acid Rain Control Program was created by amendments to the Clean Air Act. This<br />

program further reduces the allowable sulfur dioxide emissions from power plants, steel mills, and<br />

other industrial facilities.<br />

The same act requires reduction in nitrogen oxide emissions from power plants and industrial<br />

facilities, so designers must keep this requirement in mind when designing new and replacement<br />

facilities of all types which use fossil fuels.<br />

At the time of this writing, there are a number of states and countries considering phasing out<br />

coal-burning power plants at the end of their useful commercial lives if they do not install means to<br />

capture carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases. These entities are also urging a shift to naturalgas<br />

fuel. Further, combined-cycle natural-gas-fueled power plants are being urged as replacements<br />

of coal-fired power plants.<br />

PerCent eXCess air WHile burninG Coal<br />

Calculation Procedure:<br />

A certain coal has the following composition by weight percentages: carbon 75.09, nitrogen 1.56,<br />

ash 3.38, hydrogen 5.72, oxygen 13.82, sulfur 0.43. When burned in an actual furnace, measurements<br />

showed that there was 8.93 percent combustible in the ash pit refuse and the following Orsat<br />

analysis in percentages was obtained: carbon dioxide 14.2, oxygen 4.7, carbon monoxide 0.3. If<br />

it can be assumed that there was no combustible in the flue gas other that the carbon monoxide<br />

reported, calculate the percentage of excess air used.<br />

1. Compute the amount of theoretical air required per lb m (kg) of coal<br />

Theoretical air required per pound (kilogram) of coal, w ta = 11.5C′ + 34.5[H′ 2 − O′ 2 /8)] + 4.32S′,<br />

where C′, H′ 2 , O′ 2 , and S′ represent the percentages by weight, expressed as decimal fractions,<br />

of carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, and sulfur, respectively. Thus, w ta = 11.5(0.7509) + 34.5[0.0572 −<br />

(0.1382/8)] + 4.32(0.0043) = 10.03 lb (4.55 kg) of air per lb (kg) of coal. The ash and nitrogen are<br />

inert and do not burn.<br />

2. Compute the correction factor for combustible in the ash<br />

The correction factor for combustible in the ash, C 1 = (w t C f − w r C r )/(w f × 100), where the amount<br />

of fuel, w f = 1 lb (0.45 kg) of coal; percent by weight, expressed as a decimal fraction, of carbon<br />

in the coal, C f = 75.09; percent by weight of the ash and refuse in the coal, w r = 0.0338; percent<br />

by weight of combustible in the ash, C r = 8.93. Hence, C 1 = [(1 × 75.09) − (0.0338 × 8.93)]/<br />

(l × 100) = 0.748.<br />

3. Compute the amount of dry flue gas produced per lb (kg) of coal<br />

The lb (kg) of dry flue gas per lb (kg) of coal, w dg = C 1 (4CO 2 + O 2 + 704)/[3(CO 2 + CO)], where<br />

the Orsat analysis percentages are for carbon dioxide, CO 2 = 14.2; oxygen, O 2 = 4.7; carbon


ENERGY CONVERSION ENGINEERING 1.5<br />

monoxide, CO = 0.3. Hence, w dg = 0.748 × [(4 × 14.2) + 4.7 + 704)]/[3(14.2 + 0.3)] = 13.16 lb/lb<br />

(5.97 kg/kg).<br />

4. Compute the amount of dry air supplied per lb (kg) of coal<br />

The lb (kg) of dry air supplied per lb (kg) of coal, w da = w dg – C 1 + 8[H′ 2 − (O′ 2 / 8)] − (N′ 2 / N),<br />

where the percentage by weight of nitrogen in the fuel, N′ 2 = 1.56, and “atmospheric nitrogen”<br />

in the supply air, N 2 = 0.768; other values are as given or calculated. Then, w da = 13.16 − 0.748 +<br />

8[0.0572 − (0.1382 / 8)] − (0.0156 / 0.768) = 12.65 lb / lb (5.74 kg/kg).<br />

5. Compute the percent of excess air used<br />

Percent excess air = (w da − w ta ) / w ta = (12.65 − 10.03) / 10.03 = 0.261, or 26.1 percent.<br />

Related Calculations. The percentage by weight of nitrogen in “atmospheric air” in step 4 appears in<br />

Principles of Engineering Thermodynamics, 2nd edition, by Kiefer et al., John Wiley & Sons, Inc.<br />

Fuel oil Combustion in a FurnaCe<br />

Calculation Procedure:<br />

A fuel oil has the following ultimate analysis: C = 0.8543; H 2 = 0.1131; O 2 = 0.0270; N 2 = 0.0022;<br />

S = 0.0034; total = 1.0000. This fuel oil is burned in a steam-boiler furnace. Determine the weight<br />

of air required for theoretically perfect combustion, the weight of gas formed per pound (kilogram)<br />

of oil burned, and the volume of flue gas, at the boiler exit temperature of 600°F (316°C), per pound<br />

(kilogram) of oil burned; the air required with 20 percent excess air, and the volume of gas formed<br />

with this excess; the CO 2 percentage in the flue gas on a dry and wet basis.<br />

1. Compute the weight of oxygen required per pound (kilogram) of oil<br />

The same general steps as given in the previous calculation procedure will be followed. Consult that<br />

procedure for a complete explanation of each step.<br />

Using the molecular weight of each element, we find<br />

Element × Molecular-weight ratio = lb (kg) O 2 required<br />

C; 0.8543 × 32 / 12 = 2.2781 (1.025)<br />

H2 ; 0.1131<br />

O2 ; 0.0270; decreases external O2 required<br />

N2 ; 0.0022 is inert in combustion<br />

and is ignored<br />

× 16 /2 =<br />

=<br />

0.9048<br />

− 0.0270<br />

(0.407)<br />

(− 0.012)<br />

S; 0.0034 × 32 / 32 = 0.0034 (0.002)<br />

Total 1.0000<br />

lb (kg) external O 2 per lb (kg) fuel = 3.1593 (1.422)<br />

2. Compute the weight of air required for perfect combustion<br />

The weight of nitrogen associated with the required oxygen = (3.1593)(0.768 / 0.232) = 10.458 lb<br />

(4.706 kg). The weight of air required = 10.4583 + 3.1593 = 13.6176 lb / lb (6.128 kg/kg) of oil<br />

burned.


1.6 SECTION 1<br />

3. Compute the weight of the products of combustion<br />

As before,<br />

Fuel constituents + Oxygen = Products of combustion<br />

C; 0.8543 + 2.2781 = 3.1324 = CO 2<br />

H 2 ; 0.1131 + 0.9148 = 1.0179 = H 2 O<br />

O 2 ; 0.270; not a product of combustion<br />

N 2 ; 0.0022; inert but passes through furnace = 0.0022 = N 2<br />

S; 0.0034 + 0.0034 = 0.0068 = SO 2<br />

Outside N 2 from step 2 = 10.458 = N 2<br />

lb (kg) of flue gas per lb (kg) of oil burned = 14.6173 (6.578)<br />

4. Convert the flue-gas weight to volume<br />

As before,<br />

Weight<br />

Molecular<br />

Volume at<br />

Products lb kg weight Temperature correction 600°F, ft3 316°C, m3 CO 2 3.1324 1.4238 44 (359 / 44)(3.1324)(2.15) = 55.0 1.557<br />

H 2 O 1.0179 0.4626 18 (359 / 18)(1.0179)(2.15) = 43.5 1.231<br />

N 2 (total) 10.460 4.7545 28 (359 / 28)(10.460)(2.15) = 288.5 8.167<br />

SO 2 0.0068 0.0031 64 (359 / 64)(0.0068)(2.15) = 0.82 0.023<br />

ft 3 (m 3 ) of flue gas per lb (kg) of oil burned = 387.82 10.978<br />

In this calculation, the temperature correction factor 2.15 = absolute flue-gas temperature, °R/<br />

absolute atmospheric temperature, °R = (600 + 460)/(32 + 460). The total weight of N 2 in the flue<br />

gas is the sum of the N 2 in the combustion air and the fuel, or 10.4580 + 0.0022 = 10.4602 lb<br />

(4.707 kg).<br />

5. Compute the CO 2 content of the flue gas<br />

CO 2 , wet basis = 55.0/387.82 = 0.142, or 14.2 percent. CO 2 , dry basis = 55.0/(387.2 − 43.5) = 0.160,<br />

or 16.0 percent.<br />

6. Compute the air required with stated excess flow<br />

The pounds (kilograms) of air per pound (kilogram) of oil with 20 percent excess air = (1.20)<br />

(13.6176) = 16.3411 lb (7.353 kg) of air per pound (kilogram) of oil burned.<br />

7. Compute the weight of the products of combustion<br />

The weight of the products of combustion = product weight for perfect combustion, lb + (percent<br />

excess air)(air for perfect combustion, lb) = 14.6173 + (0.20)(13.6176) = 17.3408 lb (7.803 kilogram)<br />

of flue gas per pound (kilogram) of oil burned with 20 percent excess air.<br />

8. Compute the volume of the combustion products and the percent CO 2<br />

The volume of excess air in the products of combustion is found by converting from the weight to<br />

the volumetric analysis and correcting for temperature as in step 4, using the air weight from step 2<br />

for perfect combustion and the excess-air percentage, or (13.6176)(0.20)(359/28.95)(2.15) = 72.7 ft 3<br />

(2.058 m 3 ). Add this to the volume of the products of combustion found in step 4, or 387.82 + 72.70 =<br />

460.52 ft 3 (13.037 m 3 ).<br />

By using the procedure in step 5, the percent CO 2 , wet basis = 55.0/460.52 = 0.1192, or 11.92 percent.<br />

The percent CO 2 , dry basis = 55.0/(460.52 − 43.5) = 0.1318, or 13.18 percent.


ENERGY CONVERSION ENGINEERING 1.7<br />

Related Calculations. Use the method given here when making combustion calculations for any<br />

type of fuel oil—paraffin-base, asphalt-base, Bunker C, no. 2, 3, 4, or 5—from any source, domestic<br />

or foreign, in any type of furnace—boiler, heater, process, or waste-heat. When the air used for<br />

combustion contains moisture, as is usually true, this moisture is added to the combustion-formed<br />

moisture appearing in the products of combustion. Thus, for 80°F (26.7°C) air of 60 percent relative<br />

humidity, the moisture content is 0.013 lb/lb (0.006 kg/kg) of dry air. This amount appears in the<br />

products of combustion for each pound (kilogram) of air used and is a commonly assumed standard<br />

in combustion calculations.<br />

natural Gas Fuel Combustion in a FurnaCe<br />

Calculation Procedure:<br />

A natural gas has the following volumetric analysis at 60°F (15.5°C): CO 2 = 0.004; CH 4 = 0.921;<br />

C 2 H 6 = 0.041; N 2 = 0.034; total = 1.000. This natural gas is burned in a steam-boiler furnace.<br />

Determine the weight of air required for theoretically perfect combustion, the weight of gas formed<br />

per pound (kilogram) of natural gas burned, and the volume of the flue gas, at the boiler exit temperature<br />

of 650°F (343°C), per pound (kilogram) of natural gas burned; air required with 20 percent<br />

excess air, and the volume of gas formed with this excess: CO 2 percentage in the flue gas on a dry<br />

and wet basis.<br />

1. Compute the weight of oxygen required per pound of gas<br />

The same general steps as given in the previous calculation procedures will be followed, except that<br />

they will be altered to make allowances for the differences between natural gas and coal.<br />

The composition of the gas is given on a volumetric basis, which is the usual way of expressing a<br />

fuel-gas analysis. To use the volumetric-analysis data in combustion calculations, they must be converted<br />

to a weight basis. This is done by dividing the weight of each component by the total weight<br />

of the gas. A volume of 1 ft 3 (1 m 3 ) of the gas is used for this computation. Find the weight of each<br />

component and the total weight of 1 ft 3 (1 m 3 ) as follows, using the properties of the combustion<br />

elements and compounds given in Table 1:<br />

Density<br />

Component weight =<br />

column 1 × column 2<br />

Component Percent by volume lb/ft 3 kg/m 3 lb/ft 3 kg/m 3<br />

CO 2 0.004 0.1161 1.859 0.0004644 0.007<br />

CH 4 0.921 0.0423 0.677 0.0389583 0.624<br />

C 2 H 6 0.041 0.0792 1.268 0.0032472 0.052<br />

N 2 0.034 0.0739 0.094 0.0025026 0.040<br />

Total 1.000 0.0451725 0.723<br />

Percent CO 2 = 0.0004644/0.0451725 = 0.01026, or 1.03 percent<br />

Percent CH 4 by weight = 0.0389583/0.0451725 = 0.8625, or 86.25 percent<br />

Percent C 2 H 6 by weight = 0.0032472/0.0451725 = 0.0718, or 7.18 percent<br />

Percent N 2 by weight = 0.0025026/0.0451725 = 0.0554, or 5.54 percent<br />

The sum of the weight percentages = 1.03 + 86.25 + 7.18 + 5.54 = 100.00. This sum checks the<br />

accuracy of the weight calculation, because the sum of the weights of the component parts should<br />

equal 100 percent.


1.8<br />

TABLE 1 Properties of Combustion Elements*<br />

Heat value, Btu (kJ)<br />

Nature<br />

At 14.7 lb / in2 (abs) (101.3 kPa),<br />

60°F (15.6°C)<br />

Per ft3 (m3 ) at<br />

14.7 lb/in2 (abs)<br />

(101.3 kPa), 60°F<br />

(15.6°C) Per mole<br />

Per lb (kg)<br />

Gas or<br />

solid Combustible<br />

Volume, ft3 /lb<br />

(m3 /kg)<br />

Weight, lb/ft3 (kg/m3 )<br />

—<br />

0.0053 (0.0849)<br />

—<br />

0.0739 (1.183)<br />

0.0423 (0.677)<br />

0.0686 (1.098)<br />

0.0739 (1.183)<br />

0.0792 (1.268)<br />

0.0844 (1.351)<br />

0.0739 (1.183)<br />

0.0765 (1.225)<br />

0.1161 (1.859)<br />

0.0475 (0.760)<br />

Molecular<br />

weight<br />

Element or compound Formula<br />

174,500<br />

123,100<br />

129,600<br />

122,400<br />

384,000<br />

562,000<br />

622,400<br />

668,300<br />

—<br />

325 (12,109)<br />

—<br />

323 (12,035)<br />

1,012 (37,706)<br />

1,483 (55,255)<br />

1,641 (61,141)<br />

1,762 (65,650)<br />

14,540 (33,820)<br />

61,000 (141,886)<br />

4,050 (9,420)<br />

4,380 (10,187)<br />

24,000 (55,824)<br />

21,500 (50,009)<br />

22,200 (51,637)<br />

22,300 (51,870)<br />

Yes<br />

Yes<br />

Yes<br />

Yes<br />

Yes<br />

Yes<br />

Yes<br />

Yes<br />

S<br />

G<br />

S<br />

G<br />

G<br />

G<br />

G<br />

G<br />

G<br />

G<br />

G<br />

G<br />

G<br />

—<br />

188 (11.74)<br />

—<br />

13.54 (0.85)<br />

23.69 (1.48)<br />

14.58 (0.91)<br />

13.54 (0.85)<br />

12.63 (0.79)<br />

11.84 (0.74)<br />

13.52 (0.84)<br />

13.07 (0.82)<br />

8.61 (0.54)<br />

21.06 (1.31)<br />

12<br />

2.02 †<br />

32<br />

28<br />

16<br />

26<br />

28<br />

30<br />

32<br />

28<br />

29<br />

44<br />

18<br />

C<br />

H2 S<br />

CO<br />

CH4 C2H2 C2H4 C2H6 O2 N2 —<br />

CO2 H2O Carbon<br />

Hydrogen<br />

Sulfur<br />

Carbon monoxide<br />

Methane<br />

Acetylene<br />

Ethylene<br />

Ethane<br />

Oxygen<br />

Nitrogen<br />

Air ‡<br />

Carbon dioxide<br />

Water<br />

*P. W. Swain and L. N. Rowley, “Library of Practical Power Engineering” (collection of articles published in Power).<br />

† For most practical purposes, the value of 2 is sufficient.<br />

‡ The molecular weight of 29 is merely the weighted average of the molecular weight of the constituents.


TABLE 2 Chemical Reactions<br />

ENERGY CONVERSION ENGINEERING 1.9<br />

Next, find the oxygen required for combustion. Since both the CO 2 and N 2 are inert, they do not<br />

take part in the combustion; they pass through the furnace un changed. Using the molecular weights<br />

of the remaining components in the gas and the weight percentages, we have<br />

Compound × Molecular-weight ratio = lb (kg) O 2 required<br />

CH 4 ; 0.0718<br />

C 2 H 6 ; 0.0718<br />

lb (kg) external O 2 required<br />

per lb (kg) fuel<br />

×<br />

×<br />

64/16<br />

112/30<br />

=<br />

=<br />

=<br />

3.4500 (1.553)<br />

0.2920 (0.131)<br />

3.7420 (1.684)<br />

In this calculation, the molecular-weight ratio is obtained from the equation for the combustion<br />

chemical reaction, or CH 4 + 2O 2 = CO 2 + 2H 2 O, that is, 16 + 64 = 44 + 36, and C 2 H 6 + 7/2O 2 =<br />

2CO 2 + 3H 2 O 2 , that is 30 + 112 = 88 + 54. See Table 2 from these and other useful chemical<br />

reactions in combustion.<br />

Combustible substance Reaction Mols lb (kg)*<br />

Carbon to carbon monoxide C + ½O 2 = CO 1 + ½ = 1 12 + 16 = 28<br />

Carbon to carbon dioxide C + O 2 = CO 2 1 + 1 = 1 12 + 16 = 28<br />

Carbon monoxide to carbon dioxide CO + ½O 2 = CO 2 1 + ½ = 1 28 + 16 = 44<br />

Hydrogen H 2 + ½O 2 = H 2 O 1 + ½ = 1 2 + 16 = 18<br />

Sulfur to sulfur dioxide S + O 2 = SO 2 1 + 1 = 1 32 + 32 = 64<br />

Sulfur to sulfur trioxide S + 3/2O 2 = SO 3 1 + 2/2 = 1 32 + 48 = 80<br />

Methane CH 4 + 2O 2 = CO 2 + 2H 2 O 1 + 2 = 1 + 2 16 + 64 = 44 + 36<br />

Ethane C 2 H 6 + 7/2O 2 = 2CO 2 + 3H 2 O 1 + 7/2 = 2 + 3 30 + 112 = 88 + 54<br />

Propane C 3 H 8 + 5O 2 = 3CO 2 + 4H 2 O 1 + 5 = 3 + 4 44 + 160 = 132 + 72<br />

Butane C 4 H 10 + 13/2O 2 = 4CO 2 + 5H 2 O 1 + 12/2 = 4 + 5 58 + 208 = 176 + 90<br />

Acetylene C 2 H 2 + 5/2O 2 = 2CO 2 + H 2 O 1 + 5/2 = 2 + 2 26 + 80 = 88 + 18<br />

Ethylene C 2 H 4 + 3O 2 = 2CO 2 + 2H 2 O 1 + 3 = 2 + 2 28 + 96 = 88 + 36<br />

*Substitute the molecular weights in the reaction equation to secure lb (kg). The lb (kg) on each side of the equation must balance.<br />

2. Compute the weight of air required for perfect combustion<br />

The weight of nitrogen associated with the required oxygen = (3.742)(0.768/0.232) = 12.39 lb (5.576 kg).<br />

The weight of air required = 12.39 + 3.742 = 16.132 lb/lb (7.259 kg/kg) of gas burned.<br />

3. Compute the weight or the products of combustion<br />

Products of combustion<br />

Fuel constituents + Oxygen = lb kg<br />

CO2 ; 0.0103: inert but passes<br />

through the furnace<br />

= 0.010300 0.005<br />

CH4 ; 0.8625<br />

C2H6 ; 0.003247<br />

N2 ; 0.0554; inert but passes<br />

through the furnace<br />

+<br />

+<br />

3.45<br />

0.2920<br />

=<br />

=<br />

=<br />

4.312500<br />

0.032447<br />

0.055400<br />

1.941<br />

0.015<br />

0.025<br />

Outside N2 from step 2<br />

lb (kg) of flue gas per lb (kg) of<br />

natural gas burned<br />

=<br />

=<br />

12.390000<br />

16.800347<br />

5.576<br />

7.562


1.10 SECTION 1<br />

4. Convert the flue-gas weight to volume<br />

The products of complete combustion of any fuel that does not contain sulfur are CO 2 , H 2 O, and<br />

N 2 . Using the combustion equation in step 1, compute the products of combustion thus: CH 4 + 2O 2 =<br />

CO 2 + H 2 O; 16 + 64 = 44 + 36; or the CH 4 burns to CO 2 in the ratio of 1 part CH 4 to 44/16 parts CO 2 .<br />

Since, from step 1, there is 0.03896 lb CH 4 per ft 3 (0.624 kg/m 3 ) of natural gas, this forms (0.03896)<br />

(44/16) = 0.1069 lb (0.048 kg) of CO 2 . Likewise, for C 2 H 6 , (0.003247)(88/30) = 0.00952 lb (0.004<br />

kg). The total CO 2 in the combustion products = 0.00464 + 0.1069 + 0.00952 = 0.11688 lb (0.053<br />

kg), where the first quantity is the CO 2 in the fuel.<br />

Using a similar procedure for the H 2 O formed in the products of combustion by CH 4 , we find<br />

(0.03896)(36/16) = 0.0875 lb (0.039 kg). For C 2 H 6 , (0.003247)(54/30) = 0.005816 lb (0.003 kg). The<br />

total H 2 O in the combustion products = 0.0875 + 0.005816 = 0.093316 lb (0.042 kg).<br />

Step 2 shows that 12.39 lb (5.58 kg) of N 2 is required per lb (kg) of fuel. Since 1 ft 3 (0.028 m 3 ) of<br />

the fuel weights 0.04517 lb (0.02 kg), the volume of gas which weighs 1 lb (2.2 kg) is 1/0.04517 =<br />

22.1 ft 3 (0.626 m 3 ). Therefore, the weight of N 2 per ft 3 of fuel burned = 12.39/22.1 = 0.560 lb (0.252 kg).<br />

This, plus the weight of N 2 in the fuel, step 1, is 0.560 + 0.0025 = 0.5625 lb (0.253 kg) of N 2 in the<br />

products of combustion.<br />

Next, find the total weight of the products of combustion by taking the sum of the CO 2 , H 2 O, and<br />

N 2 weights, or 0.11688 + 0.09332 + 0.5625 = 0.7727 lb (0.35 kg). Now convert each weight to ft 3 at<br />

650°F (343°C), the temperature of the combustion products, or:<br />

Weight<br />

Molecular<br />

Volume at<br />

Products lb kg weight Temperature correction 650°F, ft3 343°C, m3 CO 2 0.11688 0.05302 44 (379/44)(0.11688)(2.255) = 2.265 0.0641<br />

H 2 O 0.09332 0.04233 18 (379/18)(0.09332)(2.255) = 4.425 0.1252<br />

N 2 (total) 0.5625 0.25515 28 (379/28)(0.5625)(2.255) = 17.190 0.4866<br />

ft 3 (m 3 ) of flue gas per ft 3 (m 3 ) of natural-gas fuel = 23.880 0.6759<br />

In this calculation, the value of 379 is used in the molecular-weight ratio because at 60°F (15.6°C)<br />

and 14.7 lb/in 2 (abs) (101.3 kPa), the volume of 1 lb (0.45 kg) of any gas = 379/gas molecular weight.<br />

The fuel gas used is initially at 60°F (15.6°C) and 14.7 lb/in 2 (abs) (101.3 kPa). The ratio 2.255 =<br />

(650 + 460)/(32 + 460).<br />

5. Compute the CO 2 content of the flue gas<br />

CO 2 , wet basis = 2.265/23.88 = 0.947, or 9.47 percent. CO 2 , dry basis = 2.265/(23.88 − 4.425) = 0.1164,<br />

or 11.64 percent.<br />

6. Compute the air required with the stated excess flow<br />

With 20 percent excess air, (1.20)(16.132) = 19.3584 lb of air per lb (8.71 kg/kg) of natural gas, or<br />

19.3584/22.1 = 0.875 lb of air per ft 3 (13.9 kg/m 3 ) of natural gas. See step 4 for an explanation of<br />

the value 22.1.<br />

7. Compute the weight of the products of combustion<br />

Weight of the products of combustion = product weight for perfect combustion, lb + (percent excess<br />

air) (air for perfect combustion, lb) = 16.80 + (0.20)(16.132) = 20.03 lb (9.01 kg).<br />

8. Compute the volume of the combustion products and the percent CO 2<br />

The volume of excess air in the products of combustion is found by converting from the weight to<br />

the volumetric analysis and correcting for temperature as in step 4, using the air weight from step 2 for<br />

perfect combustion and the excess-air percentage, or (16.132/22.l)(0.20)(379/28.95)(2.255) = 4.31 ft 3<br />

(0.122 m 3 ). Add this to the volume of the products of combustion found in step 4, or 23.88 + 4.31 =<br />

28.19 ft 3 (0.798 m 3 ).<br />

By the procedure in step 5, the percent CO 2 , wet basis = 2.265/28.19 = 0.0804, or 8.04 percent.<br />

The percent CO 2 , dry basis = 2.265/(28.19 − 4.425) = 0.0953, or 9.53 percent.


ENERGY CONVERSION ENGINEERING 1.11<br />

Related Calculations. Use the method given here when making combustion calculations for any<br />

type of gas used as a fuel—natural gas, blast-furnace gas, coke-oven gas, producer gas, water gas,<br />

sewer gas—from any source, domestic or for eign, in any type of furnace—boiler, heater, process, or<br />

waste-heat. When the air used for combustion contains moisture, as is usually true, this moisture is<br />

added to the combustion-formed moisture appearing in the products of combustion. Thus, for 80°F<br />

(26.7°C) air of 60 percent relative humidity, the moisture content is 0.013 lb/lb (0.006 kg/kg) of dry<br />

air. This amount appears in the products of combustion for each pound of air used and is a commonly<br />

assumed standard in combustion calculations.<br />

WooD Fuel Combustion in a FurnaCe<br />

Calculation Procedure:<br />

The weight analysis of a yellow-pine wood fuel is: C = 0.490; H 2 = 0.074; O 2 = 0.406; N 2 = 0.030.<br />

Determine the weight of oxygen and air required with perfect combustion and with 20 percent excess<br />

air. Find the weight and volume of the products of combustion under the same conditions, and the<br />

wet and dry CO 2 . The flue-gas temperature is 600°F (316°C). The air supplied for combustion has a<br />

mois ture content of 0.013 lb/lb (0.006 kg/kg) of dry air.<br />

1. Compute the weight of oxygen required per pound (kilogram) of wood<br />

The same general steps as given in earlier calculation procedures will be followed; consult them for<br />

a complete explanation of each step. Using the molecular weight of each element, we have<br />

Element × Molecular-weight ratio = lb (kg) O 2 required<br />

C; 0.490 × 32 /12 = 1.307 (0.588)<br />

H 2 ; 0.074 × 16 / 2 = 0.592 (0.266)<br />

O 2 ; 0.406; decreases external O 2 required = −0.406 (−0.183)<br />

N 2 ; 0.030 inert in combustion<br />

Total 1.000<br />

lb (kg) external O 2 per lb (kg) fuel = 1.493 (0.671)<br />

2. Compute the weight of air required for complete combustion<br />

The weight of nitrogen associated with the required oxygen = (1.493)(0.768 / 0.232) = 4.95 lb (2.228 kg).<br />

The weight of air required = 4.95 + 1.493 = 6.443 lb / lb (2.899 kg / kg) of wood burned, if the air is<br />

dry. But the air contains 0.013 lb of moisture per lb (0.006 kg / kg) of air. Hence, the total weight of<br />

the air = 6.443 + (0.013)(6.443) = 6.527 lb (2.937 kg).<br />

3. Compute the weight of the products of combustion<br />

Use the following relation:<br />

Fuel constituents + Oxygen = Products of combustion, lb (kg)<br />

C; 0.490 + 1.307 = 1.797 (0.809) = CO 2<br />

H 2 ; 0.074 + 0.592 = 0.666 (0.300) = H 2 O<br />

O 2 ; not a product of combustion<br />

N 2 ; inert but passes through the furnace = 0.030 (0.014) = N 2<br />

Outside N 2 from step 2 = 4.950 (2.228) = N 2<br />

Outside moisture from step 2 = 0.237 (0.107)<br />

lb (kg) of flue gas per lb (kg) of wood burned = 7.680 (3.458)


1.12 SECTION 1<br />

4. Convert the flue-gas weight to volume<br />

Use, as before, the following tabulation:<br />

Weight<br />

Molecular<br />

Volume at<br />

Products lb kg weight Temperature correction 600°F, ft3 316°C, m3 CO 2 1.797 0.809 44 (359/44)(1.797)(2.15) = 31.5 0.892<br />

H 2 O (fuel) 0.666 0.300 18 (359/18)(0.666)(2.15) = 28.6 0.810<br />

N 2 (total) 4.980 2.241 28 (359/28)(4.980)(2.15) = 137.2 3.884<br />

H 2 O (outside air) 0.837 0.377 18 (359/18)(0.837)(2.15) = 35.9 10.16<br />

Cu ft (m 3 ) of flue gas per lb (kg) of oil 233.2 6.602<br />

In this calculation the temperature correction factor 2.15 = (absolute flue-gas tem perature, °R)/<br />

(absolute atmospheric temperature, °R) = (600 + 460)/(32 + 460). The total weight of N 2 is the sum<br />

of the N 2 in the combustion air and the fuel.<br />

5. Compute the CO 2 content of the flue gas<br />

The CO 2 , wet basis = 31.5/233.2 = 0.135, or 13.5 percent. The CO 2 , dry basis = 31.5/(233.2 − 28.6 −<br />

35.9) = 0.187, or 18.7 percent.<br />

6. Compute the air required with the stated excess flow<br />

With 20 percent excess air, (1.20)(6.527) = 7.832 lb (3.524 kg) of air per lb (kg) of wood burned.<br />

7. Compute the weight of the products of combustion<br />

The weight of the products of combustion = product weight for perfect combustion, lb + (percent<br />

excess air)(air for perfect combustion, lb) = 8.280 + (0.20)(6.527) = 9.585 lb (4.313 kg) of flue gas<br />

per lb (kg) of wood burned with 20 percent excess air.<br />

8. Compute the volume of the combustion products and the percent CO 2<br />

The volume of the excess air in the products of combustion is found by converting from the weight<br />

to the volumetric analysis and correcting for temperature as in step 4, using the air weight from step 2<br />

for perfect combustion and the excess-air per centage, or (6.527)(0.20)(359/28.95)(2.15) = 34.8 ft 3<br />

(0.985 m 3 ). Add this to the volume of the products of combustion found in step 4, or 233.2 + 34.8 =<br />

268.0 ft 3 (7.587 m 3 ).<br />

By using the procedure in step 5, the percent CO 2 , wet basis = 31.5/268 = 0.1174, or 11.74 percent.<br />

The percent CO 2 , dry basis = 31.5/(268 − 28.6 − 35.9 − 0.20 × 0.837) = 0.155, or 15.5 percent. In<br />

the dry-basis calculation, the factor (0.20)(0.837) is the outside moisture in the excess air.<br />

Related Calculations. Use the method given here when making combustion calculations for any<br />

type of wood or woodlike fuel—spruce, cypress, maple, oak, sawdust, wood shavings, tanbark,<br />

bagesse, peat, charcoal, redwood, hemlock, fir, ash, birch, cottonwood, elm, hickory, walnut,<br />

chopped trimmings, hogged fuel, straw, corn, cottonseed hulls, city refuse—in any type of furnace—<br />

boiler, heating, process, or waste-heat. Most of these fuels contain a small amount of ash—usually<br />

less than 1 percent. This was ignored in this calculation procedure because it does not take part in<br />

the combustion.<br />

Industry is making greater use of discarded process waste to generate electricity and steam by<br />

burning the waste in a steam boiler. An excellent example is that of Agrilectric Power Partners Ltd.,<br />

Lake Charles, LA. This plant burns rice hulls from its own process and buys other producers’ surplus<br />

rice hulls for continuous opera tion. Their plant is reported as the first small-power-production facility<br />

to operate on rice hulls.<br />

By burning the waste rice hulls, Agrilectric is confronting, and solving, an environmental nuisance<br />

often associated with rice processing. When rice hulls are disposed of by being spread on land<br />

adjacent to the mill, they often smolder, cre ating continuous, uncontrolled burning. Installation of<br />

its rice-hull burning, electric-generating plant has helped Agrilectric avoid the costs associated with<br />

landfilling and disposal, as well as potential environmental problems.


ENERGY CONVERSION ENGINEERING 1.13<br />

The boiler supplies steam for a turbine-generator with an output ranging from 11.2 to 11.8 MW.<br />

Excess power that cannot be used in the plant is sold to the local utility at a negotiated price. Thus,<br />

the combustion of an industrial waste is produc ing useful power while eliminating the environmental<br />

impact of the waste. The advent of PURPA (Public Utility Regulatory Policies Act) requiring local<br />

utilities to purchase power from such plants has been a major factor in the design, devel opment, and<br />

construction of many plants by food processors to utilize waste ma terials for combustion and power<br />

production.<br />

Combustion analYsis bY tHe molal metHoD<br />

Calculation Procedure:<br />

A coal fuel has this ultimate analysis: C = 0.8339; H 2 = 0.0456; O 2 = 0.0505; N 2 = 0.0103; S = 0.0064;<br />

ash = 0.0533; total = 1.000. This coal is completely burned in a boiler furnace. Using the molal method,<br />

determine the weight of air required per lb (kg) of coal with complete combustion. How much air<br />

is needed with 25 percent excess air? What is the weight of the combustion products with 25 percent<br />

excess air? The combustion air contains 0.013 lb of moisture per lb (0.006 kg/kg) of air.<br />

1. Convert the ultimate analysis to moles<br />

A mole of any substance is an amount of the substance having a weight equal to the molecular weight<br />

of the substance. Thus, 1 mol of carbon is 12 lb (5.4 kg) of carbon, because the molecular weight<br />

of carbon is 12. To convert an ultimate anal ysis of a fuel to moles, assume that 100 lb (45 kg) of the<br />

fuel is being considered. Set up a tabulation thus:<br />

Weight<br />

Ultimate analysis, % lb kg Molecular weight Moles per 100-lb (45-kg) fuel<br />

C = 0.8339 83.39 37.526 12 6.940<br />

H 2 = 0.0456 4.56 2.052 2 2.280<br />

O 2 = 0.0505 5.05 2.678 32 0.158<br />

N 2 = 0.0103 1.03 0.464 28 0.037<br />

S = 0.0064 0.64 0.288 32<br />

Ash = 0.0533 5.33 2.399 Inert<br />

Total 100.00 45.407 9.435<br />

2. Compute the mols of oxygen for complete combustion<br />

From Table 2, the burning of carbon to carbon dioxide requires 1 mol of carbon and 1 mol of oxygen,<br />

yielding 1 mol of CO 2 . Using the molal equations in Table 2 for the other elements in the fuel, set<br />

up a tabulation thus, entering the product of columns 2 and 3 in column 4:<br />

(1)<br />

Element<br />

(2)<br />

Moles per 100-lb<br />

(45-kg) fuel<br />

(3)<br />

Moles O 2 per 100-lb<br />

(45-kg) fuel<br />

(4)<br />

Total moles O2 C 6.940 1.00 6.940<br />

H 2 2.280 0.5 1.140<br />

O 2 0.158 Reduces O 2 required −0.158<br />

N 2 0.037 Inert in combustion<br />

S 0.020 1.00 0.020<br />

Total moles of O 2 required — — 7.942


1.14 SECTION 1<br />

3. Compute the mols of air for complete combustion<br />

Set up a similar tabulation for air, thus:<br />

(1)<br />

Element<br />

(2)<br />

Moles per 100-lb<br />

(45-kg) fuel<br />

(3)<br />

Moles air per 100-lb<br />

(45-kg) fuel<br />

(4)<br />

Total moles air<br />

C 6.940 4.76 33.050<br />

H 2 2.280 2.38 5.430<br />

O 2 0.158 Reduces O 2 required −0.752<br />

N 2 0.037 Inert in combustion<br />

S 0.020 4.76 0.095<br />

Total moles of air required — 37.823<br />

In this tabulation, the factors in column 3 are constants used for computing the total moles of air<br />

required for complete combustion of each of the fuel elements listed. These factors are given in the<br />

Babcock & Wilcox Company—Steam: Its Generation and Use and similar treatises on fuels and<br />

their combustion. A tabu lation of these factors is given in Table 3.<br />

TABLE 3 Molal Conversion Factors<br />

Mol/mol of combustible for complete combustion;<br />

no excess air<br />

For combustion Combustion products<br />

Element or compound O 2 N 2 Air CO 2 H 2 O N 2<br />

Carbon,* C 1.0 3.76 4.76 1.0 — 3.76<br />

Hydrogen, H 2 0.5 0.188 2.38 — 1.0 1.88<br />

Oxygen, O 2<br />

Nitrogen, N 2<br />

Carbon monoxide, CO 0.5 1.88 2.38 1.0 — 1.88<br />

Carbon dioxide, CO 2<br />

Sulfur,* S 1.0 3.76 4.76 1.0 — 3.76<br />

Methane, CH 4 2.0 7.53 0.53 1.0 2.0 7.53<br />

Ethane, C 2 H 6 3.5 13.18 16.68 2.0 3.0 13.18<br />

*In molal calculations, carbon and sulfur are considered as gases.<br />

An alternative, and simpler, way of computing the moles of air required is to convert the required<br />

O 2 to the corresponding N 2 and find the sum of the O 2 and N 2 . Or, 376O 2 = N 2 ; N 2 + O 2 = moles of<br />

air required. The factor 3.76 converts the required O 2 to the corresponding N 2 . These two relations<br />

were used to convert the 0.158 mol of O 2 in the above tabulation to moles of air.<br />

Using the same relations and the moles of O 2 required from step 2, we get (3.76)(7.942) = 29.861<br />

mol of N 2 . Then 29.861 + 7.942 = 37.803 mol of air, which agrees closely with the 37.823 mol computed<br />

in the tabulation. The difference of 0.02 mol is traceable to roundings.<br />

4. Compute the air required with the stated excess air<br />

With 25 percent excess, the air required for combustion = (125/100)(37.823) = 47.24 mol.


ENERGY CONVERSION ENGINEERING 1.15<br />

5. Compute the mols of combustion products<br />

Using data from Table 3, and recalling that the products of combustion of a sulfur-containing fuel are<br />

CO 2 , H 2 O, and SO 2 , and that N 2 and excess O 2 pass through the furnace, set up a tabulation thus:<br />

(1)<br />

Moles per 100-lb (45-kg) fuel<br />

(2)<br />

Mol/mol of<br />

combustible<br />

(3)<br />

Moles of combustion<br />

product per 100-lb<br />

(45-kg) fuel<br />

CO 2 ; 6.940 1 6.940<br />

H 2 O; 2.280 + (47.24)(0.021 + 0.158) — 3.430<br />

SO 2 ; 0.020 1 0.202<br />

N 2 ; (47.24)(0.79) — 37.320<br />

Excess O 2 ; (1.25)(7.942) − 7.942 — 1.986<br />

Total moles, wet combustion products = 49.878<br />

Total moles, dry combustion products = 49.878 − 3.232<br />

= 46.646<br />

In this calculation, the total moles of CO 2 is obtained from step 2. The moles of H 2 in 100 lb (45 kg) of<br />

the fuel, 2.280, is assumed to form H 2 O. In addition, the air from step 4, 47.24 mol, contains 0.013 lb<br />

of moisture per lb (0.006 kg/kg) of air. This moisture is converted to moles by dividing the molecular<br />

weight of air, 28.95, by the molecular weight of water, 18, and multiplying the result by the moisture<br />

content of the air, or (28.95/18)(0.013) = 0.0209, say 0.021 mol of water per mol of air. The product<br />

of this and the moles of air gives the total moles of moisture (water) in the combustion products per<br />

100 lb (45 kg) of fuel fired. To this is added the moles of O 2 , 0.158, per 100 lb (45 kg) of fuel, because<br />

this oxygen is assumed to unite with hydrogen in the air to form water. The nitrogen in the products of<br />

combustion is that portion of the moles of air required, 47.24 mol from step 4, times the proportion of<br />

N 2 in the air, or 0.79. The excess O 2 passes through the furnace and adds to the combustion products<br />

and is computed as shown in the tabulation. Subtracting the total moisture, 3430 mol, from the total (or<br />

wet) com bustion products gives the moles of dry combustion products.<br />

Related Calculations. Use this method for molal combustion calculations for all types of fuels—<br />

solid, liquid, and gaseous—burned in any type of furnace—boiler, heater, process, or waste-heat.<br />

Select the correct factors from Table 3.<br />

estimatinG tHe temPerature oF tHe Final<br />

ProDuCts oF Combustion<br />

Calculation Procedure:<br />

Pure carbon is burned to carbon dioxide at constant pressure in an insulated cham ber. An excess air<br />

quantity of 20 percent is used and the carbon and the air are both initially at 77°F (25°C). Assume<br />

that the reaction goes to completion and that there is no dissociation. Calculate the final product’s<br />

temperature using the following constants: Heating value of carbon, 14,087 Btu/lb (32.74 × 10 3 kJ/kg);<br />

constant-pressure specific heat of oxygen, nitrogen, and carbon dioxide are 0.240 Btu /lb m (0.558 kJ/kg),<br />

0.285 Btu/lb m (0.662 kJ/kg), and 0.300 Btu/lb (0.697 kJ/kg), respectively.<br />

1. Establish the chemical equation for complete combustion with 100 percent air<br />

With 100 percent air: C + O 2 + 3.78N 2 → CO 2 + 3.78N 2 , where approximate molecular weights are:<br />

for carbon, MC = 12; oxygen, MO 2 = 32; nitrogen, MN 2 = 28; carbon dioxide, MCO 2 = 44. See the<br />

Related Calculations of this procedure for a general description of the 3.78 coefficient for N 2 .<br />

2. Establish the chemical equation for complete combustion with 20 percent excess air<br />

With 20 percent excess air: C + 1.2O 2 + (1.2 × 3.78)N 2 → CO 2 + 0.2O 2 + (1.2 × 3.78)N 2 .


1.16 SECTION 1<br />

3. Compute the relative weights of the reactants and products of the combustion process<br />

Relative weight = moles × molecular weight. Coefficients of the chemical equation in step 2 represent<br />

the number of moles of each component. Hence, for the reactants, the relative weights are: for C =<br />

1 × MC = 1 × 12 = 12; O 2 = 1.2 × MO 2 = 1.2 × 32 = 38.4; N 2 = (1.2 × 3.78)MN 2 = (1.2 × 3.78 × 28) = 127.<br />

For the products, relative weights are: for CO 2 = 1 × MCO 2 = 1 × 44 = 44; O 2 , = 0.2 × MO 2 =<br />

0.2 × 32 = 6.4; N 2 = 127, unchanged. It should be noted that the total relative weight of the reactants<br />

equal that of the products at 177.4.<br />

4. Compute the relative weights of the products of combustion on the basis of a per unit relative<br />

weight of carbon<br />

Since the relative weight of carbon, C = 12 in step 3; hence, on the basis of a per unit relative<br />

weight of carbon, the corresponding relative weights of the products are: for carbon dioxide, wCO 2 =<br />

MCO 2 /12 = 44/12 = 3.667; oxygen, wO 2 = MO 2 /12 = 6.4/12 = 0.533; nitrogen, wN 2 = MN 2 /12 =<br />

127/12 = 10.58.<br />

5. Compute the final product’s temperature<br />

Since the combustion chamber is insulated, the combustion process is considered adiabatic. Hence,<br />

on the basis of a per unit mass of carbon, the heating value (HV) of the carbon = the corresponding<br />

heat content of the products. Thus, relative to a temperature base of 77°F (25°C), 1 × HVC =<br />

[(wCO 2 × c pCO 2 ) + (wO 2 × c p O 2 ) + (wH 2 + c p N 2 )](t 2 − 77), where the heating value of carbon, HVC =<br />

14,087 Btu/lb m (32.74 × 10 3 kJ/kg); the constant-pressure specific heat of carbon dioxide, oxygen,<br />

and nitrogen are c p CO 2 = 0.300 Btu/lb (0.697 kJ/kg), cpO 2 = 0.240 Btu/lb (0.558 kJ/kg), and c p N 2 =<br />

0.285 Btu/lb (0.662 kJ/kg), respectively; final product temperature is t 2 ; other values as before. Then,<br />

1 × 14,087 = [(3.667 × 0.30) + (0.533 × 0.24) + (10.58 × 0.285)(t 2 − 77)]. Solving, t 2 = 3320 + 77 =<br />

3397°F (1869°C).<br />

Related Calculations. In the above procedure it is assumed that the carbon is burned in dry air. Also,<br />

the nitrogen coefficient of 3.78 used in the chemical equation in step 1 is based on a theoretical composition<br />

of dry air as 79.1 percent nitrogen and 20.9 percent oxygen by volume, so that 79.1/20.9 = 3.78.<br />

For a more detailed description of this coefficient see Section 3 of this handbook.<br />

Determination oF tHe saVinGs ProDuCeD bY<br />

PreHeatinG Combustion air<br />

Calculation Procedure:<br />

A 20,000 ft 2 (1858 m 2 ) building has a calculated total seasonal heating load of 2,534,440 MBH (thousand<br />

Btu) (2674 MJ). The stack temperature is 600°F (316°C) and the boiler efficiency is calculated<br />

to be 75 percent. Fuel oil burned has a higher heating value of 140,000 Btu/gal (39,018 MJ/L). A preheater<br />

can be purchased and installed to reduce the breeching discharge combustion air temperature<br />

by 250°F (139°C) to 350°F (177°C) and provide the burner with preheated air. How much fuel oil will<br />

be saved? What will be the monetary saving if fuel oil is priced at $1.10 per gallon?<br />

1. Compute the total combustion air required by this boiler<br />

A general rule used by design engineers is that 1 ft 3 (0.0283 m 3 ) of combustion air is required for<br />

each 100 Btu (105.5 J) released during combustion. To compute the combustion air required, use<br />

the relation CA = H/100 × Boiler efficiency, expressed as a decimal, where CA = annual volume of<br />

combustion air, ft 3 (m 3 ); H = total seasonal heating load, Btu/yr (kJ/yr). Substituting for this boiler,<br />

CA = (2,534,400)(1000)/100 × 0.75 = 33,792,533 ft 3 /yr (956.329 m 3 /yr).<br />

2. Calculate the annual <strong>energy</strong> savings<br />

The <strong>energy</strong> savings, ES = (stack temperature reduction, deg F)(ft 3 air per year)(0.018), where the<br />

constant 0.018 is the specific heat of air. Substituting, ES = (250)(33,792,533)(0.018) = 152,066,399<br />

Btu/yr (160,430 kJ/yr).


ENERGY CONVERSION ENGINEERING 1.17<br />

With a boiler efficiency of 75 percent, each gallon of oil releases 0.75 × 140,000 Btu/gal =<br />

105,000 Btu (110.8 jk). Hence, the fuel saved, FS = ES/usable heat in fuel, Btu/gal. Or, FS =<br />

152,066,399/105,000 = 1448.3 gal/yr (5.48 m 3 /yr).<br />

With fuel oil at $1.10 per gallon, the monetary savings will be $1.10 (1448.3) = $1593.13. If the<br />

preheater cost $6000, the simple payoff time would be $6000/1593.13 = 3.77 years.<br />

Related Calculations. Use this procedure to determine the potential savings for burning any type<br />

of fuel—coal, oil, natural gas, landfill gas, catalytic cracker offgas, hydrogen purge gas, bagesse,<br />

sugar cane, etc. Other rules of thumb used by designers to estimate the amount of combustion air<br />

required for various fuels are: 10 ft 3 of air (0.283 m 3 ) per 1 ft 3 (0.0283 m 3 ) of natural gas; 1300 ft 3<br />

of air (36.8 m 3 ) per gal (0.003785 m 3 ) of No. 2 fuel oil; 1450 ft 3 of air (41 m 3 ) per gal of No. 5 fuel<br />

oil; 1500 ft 3 of air (42.5 m 3 ) per gal of No. 6 fuel oil. These values agree with that used in the<br />

above computation—i.e. 100 ft 3 per 100 Btu of 140,000 Btu per gal oil = 140,000/100 = 1400 ft 3<br />

per gal (39.6 m 3 /0.003785 m 3 ).<br />

This procedure is the work of Jerome F. Mueller, P.E. of Mueller Engineering Corp.<br />

Combustion CalCulations usinG tHe million btu<br />

(1.055 mJ) metHoD<br />

Calculation Procedure:<br />

The <strong>energy</strong> absorbed by a steam boiler fired by natural gas is 100-million Btu/h (29.3 MW). Boiler<br />

efficiency on a higher heating value (HHV) basis is 83 percent. If 15 percent excess air is used,<br />

determine the total air and flue-gas quantities produced. The approximate HHV of the natural gas<br />

is 23,000 Btu/lb (53,590 kJ/kg). Ambient air temperature is 80°F (26.7°C) and relative humidity<br />

is 65 percent. How can quick estimates be made of air and flue-gas quantities in boiler operations<br />

when the fuel analysis is not known?<br />

1. Determine the <strong>energy</strong> input to the boiler<br />

The million Btu (1.055 MJ) method of combustion calculations is a quick way of estimating air and<br />

flue-gas quantities generated in boiler and heater operations when the ultimate fuel analysis is not<br />

available and all the engineer is interested in is good estimates. Air and flue-gas quantities determined<br />

may be used to calculate the size of fans, ducts, stacks, etc.<br />

It can be shown through comprehensive calculations that each fuel such as coal, oil, natural gas,<br />

bagasse, blast-furnace gas, etc. requires a certain amount of dry stoichiometric air per million Btu<br />

(1.055 MJ) fired on an HHV basis and that this quantity does not vary much with the fuel analysis.<br />

The listing below gives the dry air required per million Btu (1.055 MJ) of fuel fired on an HHV<br />

basis for various fuels.<br />

Combustion Constants for Fuels<br />

Fuel<br />

Blast furnace gas<br />

Bagasse<br />

Carbon monoxide gas<br />

Refinery and oil gas<br />

Natural gas<br />

Furnace oil and lignite<br />

Bituminous coals<br />

Anthracite coal<br />

Coke<br />

Constant, lb dry air per million Btu<br />

(kg/MW)<br />

575 (890.95)<br />

650 (1007.2)<br />

670 (1038.2)<br />

720 (1115.6)<br />

730 (1131.1)<br />

745 − 750 (1154.4 − 1162.1)<br />

760 (1177.6)<br />

780 (1208.6)<br />

800 (1239.5)


1.18 SECTION 1<br />

To determine the <strong>energy</strong> input to the boiler, use the relation Q f = (Q s )/E h , where Q f = <strong>energy</strong> input<br />

by the fuel, Btu/h (W); Q s = <strong>energy</strong> absorbed by the steam in the boiler, Btu/h (W); E h = efficiency<br />

of the boiler on an HHV basis. Substituting for this boiler, Q f = 100/0.83 = 120.48 million Btu/h on<br />

an HHV basis (35.16 MW).<br />

2. Estimate the quantity of dry air required by this boiler<br />

The total air required T a = (Q f )(Fuel constant from list above). For natural gas, T a = (120.48)(730) =<br />

87,950 lb/h (39,929 kg/h). With 15 percent excess air, total air required = (1.15)(87,950) = 101,142.5 lb/h<br />

(45,918.7 kg/h).<br />

3. Compute the quantity of wet air required<br />

Air has some moisture because of its relative humidity. Estimate the amount of moisture in dry air in<br />

M lb/lb (kg/kg) from M = 0.622 (p w )/(14.7 − p w ), where 0.622 is the ratio of the molecular weights<br />

of water vapor and dry air; p w = partial pressure of water vapor in the air, psia (kPa) = saturated<br />

vapor pressure (SVP) × relative humidity expressed as a decimal; 14.7 = atmospheric pressure of<br />

air at sea level (101.3 kPa). From the steam tables, at 80°F (26.7°C), SVP = 0.5069 psia (3.49 kPa).<br />

Substituting, M = 0.622 (0.5069 × 0.65)/(14.7 − [0.5069 × 0.65]) = 0.01425 lb of moisture/lb of dry<br />

air (0.01425 kg/kg).<br />

The total flow rate of the wet air then = 1.0142 (101,142.5) = 102,578.7 lb/h (46,570.7 kg/h).<br />

To convert to a volumetric-flow basis, recall that the density of air at 80°F (26.7°C) and 14.7 psia<br />

(101.3 kPa) = 39/(480 + 80) = 0.0722 lb/ft 3 (1.155 kg/m 3 ). In this relation, 39 = a constant and the<br />

temperature of the air is converted to degrees Rankine. Hence, the volumetric flow = 102,578.7/<br />

(60 min/h)(0.0722) = 23,679.3 actual cfm (670.1 m 3 /min).<br />

4. Estimate the rate of fuel firing and flue-gas produced<br />

The rate of fuel firing = Qf / HHV = (120.48 × 106 )/23,000 = 5238 lb/h (2378 kg/h). Hence, the total<br />

flue gas produced = 5238 + 102,578 = 107,816 lb/h (48,948 kg/h).<br />

If the temperature of the flue gas is 400°F (204.4°C) (a typical value for a natural-gas fired<br />

boiler), then the density, as in step 3, is: 39/(400 + 460) = 0.04535 lb/ft 3 (0.7256 kg/m 3 ). Hence, the<br />

volumetric flow = (107,816)/(60 min/h × 0.04535) = 39,623.7 actual cfm (1121.3 m 3 /min).<br />

Related Calculations. Detailed combustion calculations based on actual fuel gas analysis can be<br />

performed to verify the constants given in the list above. For example, let us say that the natural-gas<br />

analysis was: methane = 83.4 percent; ethane = 15.8 percent; nitrogen = 0.8 percent by volume. First<br />

convert the analysis to a percent weight basis.<br />

Fuel Percent volume MW Col. 2 × Col. 3 Percent weight<br />

Methane 83.4 16 1334.4 72.89<br />

Ethane 15.8 30 474 25.89<br />

Nitrogen 0.8 28 22.4 1.22<br />

Note that the percent weight in the above list is calculated after obtaining the sum under Column 2 ×<br />

Column 3. Thus, the percent methane = (1334.4)/(1334.4 + 474 + 22.4) = 72.89 percent.<br />

From a standard reference, such as Ganapathy, Steam Plant Calculations Man ual, Marcel<br />

Dekker, Inc., find the combustion constants, K, for various fuels and use them thus: For the air<br />

required for combustion, A c = (K for methane)(percent by weight methane from above list) +<br />

(K for ethane)(percent by weight ethane); or A c = (17.265)(0.7289) + (16.119)(0.2589) = 16.76 lb/lb<br />

(16.76 kg/kg).<br />

Next, compute the higher heating value of the fuel (HHV) using the air constants from the<br />

same reference mentioned above. Or HHV = (heat of combustion for methane)(percent by<br />

weight methane) + (heat of combustion of ethane)(percent by weight ethane) = (23,879)(0.7289) +<br />

(22,320)(0.2589) = 23,184 Btu/lb (54,018.7 kJ/kg). Then, the amount of fuel equivalent to<br />

1,000,000 Btu (1,055,000 kJ) = (1,000,000)/23,184 = 43.1 lb (19.56 kg), which requires, as<br />

computed above, (43.1)(16.76) = 722.3-lb dry air (327.9 kg), which agrees closely with the value<br />

given in step 1, above.


ENERGY CONVERSION ENGINEERING 1.19<br />

Similarly, if the fuel were 100 percent methane, using the steps given above, and suitable constants<br />

from the same reference work, the air required for combus tion is 17.265 lb/lb (7.838 kg/kg)<br />

of fuel. HHV = 23,879 Btu/lb (55,638 kJ/kg). Hence, the fuel in 1,000,000 Btu (1,055,000 kJ) =<br />

(1,000,000)/(23,879) = 41.88 lb (19.01 kg). Then, the dry air per million Btu (1.055 kg) fired =<br />

(17.265) (41.88) = 723 lb (328.3 kg).<br />

Likewise, for propane, using the same procedure, 1 lb (0.454 kg) requires 15.703-lb (7.129-kg) air<br />

and 1 million Btu (1,055,000 kJ) has (1,000,000)/21,661 = 46.17-lb (20.95-kg) fuel. Then, 1 million<br />

Btu (1,055,000 kJ) requires (15.703)(46.17) = 725-lb (329.2-kg) air. This general approach can be<br />

used for various fuel oils and solid fuels—coal, coke, etc.<br />

Good estimates of excess air used in combustion processes may be obtained if the oxygen and<br />

nitrogen in dry flue gases are measured. Knowledge of excess-air amounts helps in performing<br />

detailed combustion and boiler efficiency calculations. Percent excess air, EA = 100(O 2 − CO 2 )/<br />

[0.264 × N 2 – (O 2 – CO/2)], where O 2 = oxygen in the dry flue gas, percent volume; CO = percent<br />

volume carbon mon oxide; N 2 = percent volume nitrogen.<br />

You can also estimate excess air from oxygen readings. Use the relation, EA = (constant from<br />

list below)(O 2 )/(21 − O 2 ).<br />

Constants for Excess-Air Calculations<br />

Fuel Constant<br />

Carbon 100<br />

Hydrogen 80<br />

Carbon monoxide 121<br />

Sulfur 100<br />

Methane 90<br />

Oil 94.5<br />

Coal 97<br />

Blast furnace gas 223<br />

Coke oven gas 89.3<br />

If the percent volume of oxygen measured is 3 on a dry basis in a natural-gas (methane) fired boiler,<br />

the excess air, EA = (90)[3/(21 – 3)] = 15 percent.<br />

This procedure is the work of V. Ganapathy, Heat Transfer Specialist, ABCO Industries.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!