1962: The Eve of the Left Turn in China's Foreign Policy - Claude Arpi

Marxist-Leninist theory. To achieve such a victory, Mao argued that the CCP leadersshould also understand what was Marxism, and what was revisionism. 65 China’srestraint in its ideological disputes with the Soviet Union was manifested only either innot specifically mentioning the Soviet Communist Party (e.g. in the three articlescommemorating the 100th anniversary of the birth of Lenin in the spring of 1960) orthrough indirect criticism (e.g., the assessment of the 20 th Soviet Communist PartyCongress in the Moscow Declaration in 1960). Given these constraints, China couldnot possibly end the ideological dispute with the Soviet Union.Beijing and Moscow also disagreed over the Soviet dispute with Albania in thespring of 1961. Some suggested that China be cautious in the Soviet-Albanian disputeso as to avoid severely damaging the Sino-Soviet relationship. 66 The issue neverthelesssparked a further deterioration of relations with Moscow. Chinese leaders sharplycriticized the way the Soviet Union treated Albania, asserting that it did not display “asober attitude of Marxism and Leninism.” 67 The Sino-Soviet controversy over Albaniaquickly intensified during the 22 nd Soviet Communist Party Congress in mid-October1960, when Chinese leaders disagreed with Khrushchev’s policies over issues such asStalin and peaceful co-existence, and believed that the attacks on Albania by the Sovietleaders were actually aimed at a denunciation of China. 68More seriously, about sixty thousand Chinese residents in the Yili region ofXinjiang Province crossed the border and fled into Soviet territory in the spring andsummer of 1962. No evidence has emerged that Soviet leaders directly orchestratedthis incident. It is possible that the incident was related to the deterioration ofSino/Soviet relations after the 22 nd Soviet Communist Party Congress. 69 Regardless ofthe origins of the incident, one of its consequences was increased tension across the65 Shinian lunzhan, Vol.1, pp. 241-43.66 Chushi sulian banian, pp. 115-16.67 “Zhou Enlai tongzhi zai sugong ershierda daibiao dahui shang de jianghua” (Comrade Zhou Enlai’s Talk at the22 nd Soviet Union Communist Party Congress), the People’s Daily, 20 October 1960.68 “Mao Zedong huijian yindunixiyagongchandang zongshuji yaidi tongzhi de tanhua,” (Mao Zedong’s talk withGeneral Secretary of the Indonesian Communist Party Comrade Aidy), 1 January 1961.69 The most detailed examination of the “Yi-Ta incident” in recent years in China is Li Danhui, “Dui 1962 nianxinjiang yita shijian qiyin de lishi kaocha—laizi zhongguo xinjiang de dangan cailiao,” (A Historical Examinationof the Origins of the Yi-Ta Incident in Xinjiang in 1962: the archives from Xinjiang China) in Beijing yu mosik, e(Beijing and Moscow), pp. 480-509.23