Record of the Senate - Integrated Bar of the Philippines

42 TUESDAY, MAY 8, 2012Mr. Bisnar. Hindi ko na po matandaan kung mayroon man o wala.Mr. Ginez. Okay. So, wala rin kayong mga nakitang empleyado doon o mga office workersdoon, hindi po ba?Mr. Bisnar. Ang lumabas lamang po nga iyong caretaker po.Mr. Ginez. Caretaker. Ito po ba ay si Celebrada C. Pardines?Mr. Bisnar. Iyon po ang pakilala niya sa akin.Mr. Ginez. Pakilala niya, at hindi niya kilala kung sinuman, kung sino si Jose Maria BasaIII, hindi po ba?Mr. Bisnar. Pagkatanda ko po, ang sabi po niya, bihira lamang po pumunta doon, parangganoon.Mr. Ginez. At hindi taga-doon si Jose Maria Basa, sinabi niya sa inyo?Mr. Bisnar. Hindi po niya sinabi iyon.Mr. Ginez. Sheriff, hindi po ba kapag ang sinasabi ng ating Revised Rules of Court na kapagshares of stocks ang ating ii-implement or ang ating iga-garnish eh dapat susundin natin ang Rule57, Section 7, paragraph C. Basahin ko po sa inyo dahil baka hindi po ninyo naaalala. “Stocksor shares or an interest....” Basahin ko po muna ito: “Section 7. Attachment of Real and PersonalProperty Recording Thereof. Real and personal property shall be attached by the sheriff, executing thewrit in the following manner: C) Stocks or shares or an interest in stocks or shares of any corporationor company by leaving with the president or managing agent thereof, a copy of the writ and a noticestating that the stock or interest of the party against whom the attachment is issued is attached inpursuance of such writ.” Ang tanong ko muna, preliminary, Sheriff, hindi po ito ang unangpagkakataon na kayo po ay nagga-garnish ng isang shares of stocks o nagle-levy ng isang sharesof stocks, hindi po ba?Mr. Roy. Objection, Your Honor.The Presiding Officer. What is the basis?Mr. Roy. Misleading, Your Honor. The rule pertains to attachment.The Presiding Officer. What is misleading?Mr. Roy. Your Honor, the rule cited by counsel is the Rule on Attachment. The sheriff is testifyingon execution. These are two entirely different rules.Mr. Ginez. Your Honor, the Revised Rules of Court provides that if the property to be leviedis a personal property or shares of stocks. Your Honor, it specifically says that it will be attached inaccordance with the same rules that provide for the preliminary attachment. That is basic, I can citethe rule.The Presiding Officer. Objection overruled.Mr. Ginez. Thank you, Your Honor.So, may tanong po ako, Sheriff. Hindi po ito ang unang pagkakataon na kayo po ay naglevyng shares of stocks ng isang kumpanya sa loob ng inyong 16 years bilang isang sheriff?