6.4.4 Where the National Cricket Federation and/or <strong>Player</strong> does request a hearing in accordancewith Article 6.4.1, the matter shall proceed to a hearing in accordance with Article 7.ARTICLE 7THE DISCIPLINARY PROCEDURE7.1 Hearings under these Regulations7.1.1 Where the ICC alleges that a National Cricket Federation and/or <strong>Player</strong> has committed anoffence under these Regulations, and the National Cricket Federation and/or <strong>Player</strong> deniesthe allegation, and/or disputes the sanctions to be imposed for such offence under theseRegulations, then the matter shall be referred to the Judicial Commissioner (who shall not befrom the same country as that represented by the relevant National Cricket Federation) whoshall hear the case sitting alone.7.1.2 The Judicial Commissioner shall convene a preliminary hearing with the ICC and its legalrepresentatives, together with the National Cricket Federation and/or <strong>Player</strong> and its/his/herlegal representatives (if any). The preliminary hearing should take place as soon aspossible by telephone conference call unless the Judicial Commissioner determinesotherwise.7.1.3 The purpose of the preliminary hearing shall be to allow the Judicial Commissioner toaddress any issues that need to be resolved prior to the hearing date. In particular (butwithout limitation), the Judicial Commissioner shall:7.1.3.1 determine the date(s) upon which the full hearing shall be held. Save inexceptional circumstances or where the parties otherwise agree, the fullhearing should take place no longer than thirty (30) days after the receipt bythe National Cricket Federation and/or <strong>Player</strong> of the Notice of Charge;7.1.3.2 establish dates reasonably in advance of the date of the full hearing bywhich:(a)(b)(c)the ICC shall submit an opening brief with argument on all issuesthat the ICC wishes to raise at the hearing and a list of the witnessesthat the ICC intends to call at the hearing (and a summary of thesubject areas of the witness’s anticipated testimony), and enclosingcopies of the exhibits that the ICC intends to introduce at thehearing;the National Cricket Federation and/or <strong>Player</strong> shall submit ananswering brief, addressing the ICC’s arguments and setting outargument on the issues that it/he/she wishes to raise at the hearing,as well as a list of the witnesses that it/he/she intends to call at thehearing (and a summary of the subject areas of the witness’santicipated testimony), and enclosing copies of the exhibits thathe/she intends to introduce at the hearing; andthe ICC may (at its discretion) submit a reply brief, responding to theanswer brief of the National Cricket Federation and/or <strong>Player</strong> andlisting any rebuttal witnesses that the ICC intends to call at thehearing (and a summary of the subject areas of the witness’santicipated testimony), and enclosing copies of any other exhibitsthat the ICC intends to introduce at the hearing; and12
7.1.3.3 make such order as the Judicial Commissioner shall deem appropriate inrelation to the production of relevant documents and/or other materialsbetween the parties.7.1.4 Subject to the discretion of the Judicial Commissioner to order otherwise for good causeshown by either party, or unless otherwise agreed between the parties, hearings before theJudicial Commissioner shall: (a) take place at the ICC’s headquarters in Dubai, United ArabEmirates; and (b) be conducted on a confidential basis.7.1.5 Each of the ICC and the National Cricket Federation and/or <strong>Player</strong> (as applicable) has theright to be present and to be heard at the hearing to be represented at the hearing by legalcounsel of its/his/her own choosing. Where there is compelling justification for the nonattendanceby any party or representative at the hearing, then such party or representativeshall be given the opportunity to participate in the hearing by telephone or video conference(if available).7.1.6 Without prejudice to Article 7.2.2.2, the National Cricket Federation and/or <strong>Player</strong> maychoose not to appear in person at the hearing, but instead provide a written submission forconsideration by the Judicial Commissioner, in which case the Judicial Commissioner shallconsider the submission in its deliberations. However, the non-attendance of the NationalCricket Federation and/or <strong>Player</strong> (or its/his/her representative) at the hearing, after propernotice of the hearing has been provided, without compelling justification, shall not preventthe Judicial Commissioner from proceeding with the hearing in its/his/her absence, whetheror not any written submissions are made on its/his/her behalf.7.1.7 The procedure followed at the hearing shall be at the discretion of the JudicialCommissioner, provided that the hearing is conducted in a manner which offers the NationalCricket Federation and/or <strong>Player</strong> a fair and reasonable opportunity to present evidence(including the right to call and to question witnesses by telephone or video-conference wherenecessary), address the Judicial Commissioner and present its/his/her case.7.1.8 Save where the Judicial Commissioner orders otherwise for good cause shown by eitherparty, the hearing shall be in English, and certified English translations shall be submitted ofany non-English documents put before the Judicial Commissioner. The cost of thetranslation shall be borne by the party offering the document(s). If required by the JudicialCommissioner, the ICC shall make arrangements to have the hearing recorded ortranscribed (save for the private deliberations of the Judicial Commissioner). If requested bythe National Cricket Federation and/or <strong>Player</strong>, the ICC shall also arrange for an interpreter toattend the hearing. The costs of transcription and interpretation shall be paid by the ICC,subject to any costs-shifting order that the Judicial Commissioner may make further toArticle 7.3.3.7.2 Standard of Proof and Evidence7.2.1 The burden of proof shall be on the ICC and the standard of proof in all cases brought underthese Regulations shall be whether the Judicial Commissioner is comfortably satisfied,bearing in mind the seriousness of the allegation that is being made, that the alleged offencehas been committed. This standard of proof in all cases shall be determined on a slidingscale from, at a minimum, a mere balance of probability (for the least serious offences) up toproof beyond a reasonable doubt (for the most serious offences).7.2.2 The Judicial Commissioner shall not be bound by judicial rules governing the admissibility ofevidence. Instead, facts relating to an offence under these Regulations may be establishedby any reliable means, including admissions. The following rules of proof shall be applicableat the hearing:13