THE NICHOLAS RHODES COLLECTION - COINS OF TIBET499 500499 China for Tibet, anonymous (c.1875-1908), fantasy 1- Tael, 23.86g, undated, Chineselegend: xi zang yuan Liang (“Tibet, one Liang”) (Bruce X #T1), very fine500 Tibet, Anonymous, forgery of 1-Tam Srang, 18.82g, (15-43), vertical stroke in northsymbol on reverse (YZM -, KM -), very fineThis coin appears to be a cast forgery of the scarce variant with vertical stroke in the northsymbol on reverse. It has reeded edge instead of plain edge.Note that the endless knot (7 o’clock position) on reverse is open on its upper (left) end.HK$300-450(US$40-60)HK$1,500-1,800(US$200-250)501501 Tibet, Xuan Tong, base metal forgery of 1-Tam Srang, 12.54g, 1st year, possibly acontemporary light weight forgery (YZM -; KM -), with deep toning, fine502 Tibet, Xuan Tong, forgery of Quarter-Sho, 5.66g, first year (YZM 389; KM -), very fineand scarceThis forgery struck in silver or white metal was produced in Northern India in the early1970s.502HK$750-1,000(US$100-120)HK$600-750(US$80-100)503503 Tibet, Anonymous, forgery of a 20-Tam Srang, struck in gold, 10.91g, 15-43 (YZM - ;KM -), very fine and scarcePROVENANCE:Ex. Karl Gabrisch collection, Baldwin, Ma Tak Wo, Monetarium & Gillio Auction,Hong Kong, 1 September 2005, lot 202.Although this coin was described as forgery by Karl Gabrisch (“Beiträge zur TibetischenNumismatik II: Die Tibetischen Goldmünzen und deren Fälschungen”. MünsterscheNumismatische Zeitschrift, vol. 20, no. 2, 1990, p. 1-3 and vol. 21, no. 2, 1991, p. 1-5)and again in the auction catalogue of the Gabrisch collection, it is occasionally offered asgenuine Tibetan gold coin.This forgery was most probably made by a Tibetan medical doctor in Nepal in the 1970s.HK$4,000-4,500(US$500-600)WWW.SPINK.COM
August 21, 2013 - HONG KONG504505504 China, Anonymous, Æ fantasy of 10-Cash, 6.40g, undated, legend: tong yong shi wen(10 Cash for circulation), rev. copied from a Nepalese Æ Paisa of Surendra Vir Vikram,very fineThere is a comment by Nicholas Rhodes about this piece on the following webpage:http://www.charm.ru/coins/unkn/tibet-unknown.shtmlThis is a well-known Chinese fantasy, with one side copied from a Nepalese copper Paisaof Surendra Vir Vikram (dating to c.1787 saka = 1865 AD), but with additional Chinesecharacters. The coin was probably made in Shanghai or some such place in the 1920’s or1930’s - maybe later - and has appeared in a few US auctions, if I remember correctly.Such fantasies were made only in small numbers, so it is not an easy piece to find, but hasnothing to do with Tibetan currency, and I don’t generally bother with such concoctionsunless they “fall into my lap”.Obverse: Tong Yong Shi WenReverse: Wu Zu Gong He Center; FanComment by Stephen Tai on the above-mentioned webpage:The obverse legend Tong Yong Shi Wen is translated as “10 Cashes For Circulation”. Thereverse legends is read as “Wu (five) Zu (tribe) Gong (together) He (peace or harmony),that mean “Five Tribes (Han, Manchurian, Mongolian, Islamic and Tibetian) come inpeace”. Fan is not necessary meant Foreign, in old Imperial Chinese vocabulary it also wasused to stand for Barbarian, which could indicate the uncivilized minority or foreignpeople. In this coin, it should mean the former.HK$750-1,000(US$100-140)505 Tibet, Anonymous, forgery 2½-Skar (4), dated 15-53, type KM. Y#A19 (2), one copper(YZM 681), the second in white metal, a third in copper dated 15-55, with the date 15-55 (figures 1 and 5 are connected and have “tails”), a fourth in copper with the erroneousdate 5-55, generally very fine (4)The first two most probably made in the 1990s in Lhasa. The cataloguer happened to stayin Lhasa when these forgeries appeared in the curio market; Lhasa dealers thought thatthe coins were produced in Shigatse, and curio dealers from Shigatse were adamant thatthe forgeries came from Lhasa.The last two are scarce and were most probably produced in Northern India between1960 and 1970 - in small numbers. To this date no other contemporaneous or modernforgeries of this coin type are known, hence this group of four coins represents a completeseries of the modern copies which are known.References: Anonymous (Brian Hannon and Charles Panish): “Tibetan Fake Coins HitUS; Copper 1½ , 7½ Pieces”. World Coin News, vol. 6, no. 16, April 17, 1979, pp. 3 and26.Bertsch, Wolfgang: “Some Modern Forgeries of Tibetan Coins”. ONS Newsletter, no.157, autumn 1998, p. 18-20.Semans, Scot: “Some more Forgeries”, ONS Newsletter, no. 59, August 1977.Semans, Scot: http://www.coincoin.com/TTB28F.jpgBertsch, Wolfgang:http://reviews.ebay.com/gds/forgeries-of-tibetan-coins/10000000012401474/g.htmlHK$500-600(US$70-90)119