12.07.2015 Views

not speaking a language that is mine - National Translation Mission

not speaking a language that is mine - National Translation Mission

not speaking a language that is mine - National Translation Mission

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS
  • No tags were found...

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Not Speaking A Language That Is Mine 33the face-to-face intimacy of Miyaanwali, articulate theiraspirations to Standard Punjabi's urbane inflections. Dialecthas a strange meeting with <strong>language</strong> in the domestic spacewhere Puj andi 's rustic Miyaanwaali utterances are greeted withStandard Punjabi responses. Instead of res<strong>is</strong>ting it, the dialectgives in to Punjabi's unifying space in the construction ofmodernity. The erasure of dialectal differences in StandardPunjabi enables the imagining of a unified Punjabi community.Standard Punjabi's modernity writes its difference from theclosed space of local dialects, which circumscribe identity inrigid kinship structures of belonging.Anderson's point about the homogenizing impact ofprint <strong>language</strong>s on speech communities <strong>is</strong> illustrated by thenatural death of the dialect in the evolution of modem Indianprint <strong>language</strong>s. The development of modem Punjabi opens upnew identity routes on which the nation's myth might beengraved. But the inscription of the nation in modem Indian<strong>language</strong>s, be it Punjabi or Bengali, reveals a markeddivergence from the unifying script the Indian nation sought toinscribe itself in. The adoption of modem Punjabi by educatedspeakers in Lahore and Lyallpur <strong>is</strong> a move away from smalldialect-based identifications towards the beginnings of amodem Punjabi kaum. Speakers of different dialectscongregate in the public sphere of a standardized Punjabi toconstruct a unified lingu<strong>is</strong>tic space, which will be seen toreveal a deep communal cleavage.The imagining of the nation in the Punjabi <strong>language</strong>produces slippages of religion translating into separat<strong>is</strong>tdemands for two pure lands, Pak<strong>is</strong>tan and Khal<strong>is</strong>tan. Thoughthe latter <strong>is</strong> also couched as a lingu<strong>is</strong>tic demand, the Hindu

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!