The use of hot dip galvanizing in general miningHot dip galvanized steel and miningBob Andrew, who currently practises as a value engineer, is an honorary life member of this Association and wellknown in the mining industry, sums up his view based on his extensive experience of the performance of hotdip galvanizing in the mining industry.IntroductionOne of the disadvantages of hot dipgalvanized steel is that it is mostcommonly perceived as a protectivecoating applied to steel, which it indeedis, but totally different from other typesof protective coatings. Because of this,hot dip galvanized steel is generallycompared to other forms of coatings,especially protective paint coatings.In the mining industry, whereatmospheric corrosive conditionsgenerally always occur to a greater orlesser extent, it has been proved thathot dip galvanized steel is a mostappropriate material of constructionand will generally out perform all othertypes of economically and technicallyacceptable protective coatings undervirtually all circumstances in whichcorrosive conditions are present.The only apparent disadvantage thathot dip galvanized steel has is that itsprocurement, or supply chain, is oftenperceived to be highly complex and, inthe eyes of the owner and user,problems arising during procurementthat are capable of increasing the risk tothe project in terms of schedule, budgetand quality can be unacceptableconstraints.Advantages of hot dip galvanizedsteel in miningHot dip galvanizing, affords steel withcorrosion protection, in a wide varietyof mining environments, by means ofthe presence of a surface layer of purezinc and zinc-iron alloys. In contact withzinc, steel is cathodically protected onaccount of a potential differenceforming between steel and zinc in thespecific environment. In this way, thezinc and the alloys on the steel surfaceare sacrificially attacked by theenvironment for as long as they arepresent on the surface, with the steelitself exhibiting no corrosion. Thecorrosion mechanism is enhanced bychemical reactions between zinc andoxygen or carbon dioxide in theenvironment to form various zinc oxidesor zinc carbonates that effectively sealany pores in the zinc layers. Thecathodic protection capability of thezinc or zinc alloys in contact with thesteel also provides protection at pointswhere discontinuities in the zinc layersexist. This capability provides the hotdip galvanized steel with a significantlevel of tolerance against manufacturingdefects or mechanical damages thatarise during the steel erection process.The capability is also extremely valuableat protecting the steel at coating defectsthat have arisen from mechanicaldamage during service. Anothersignificant feature of hot dip galvanizedcoatings, when compared to otherforms of zinc coatings, e.g. zinc metalspray, electroplated zinc, as well asother types of protective coatings, e.g.paint coatings, rubber linings, etc, isthat the bond between the hot dipgalvanized coating and the underlyingsteel surface is a ‘metallurgical’ ordiffusion type of bond in which zincdiffuses into the surface of the base ironas a result of the hot dip galvanizingprocess in which steel is immersed intoa bath of molten zinc. All othercommonly used protective coatingsdepend on a superficial or adhesivetype of bond.In underground mining conditions,including vertical and inclined shafts,which are probably the most corrosiveof all mining conditions, the toleranceof hot dip galvanized steel to pre- andpost- erection damage is especiallyimportant. Routine maintenance ofsteel, whether replacement orrefurbishment, is in most cases virtuallyimpossible owing to the conditionsunder which such maintenance needsto be performed, including accessibility,and the extremely limited periods thatcan be allocated to maintenance. Anymajor refurbishment or replacement ofsteel in service will undoubtedlynecessitate production downtime andeconomic losses. The ability of hot dipgalvanized steel to tolerate unavoidabledamage to the zinc coating, either byproduction circumstances or arisingfrom mechanical activities, provides hotdip galvanized steel with a valuablecapability of achieving long service liveswith minimum maintenance costs andminimum production losses.Although the conditions in surfacefacilities, like ore processing plants andmaterial handling installations, are lesscorrosive, the capability of hot dipgalvanized steel to produce minimummaintenance and production costs arestill vitally important. In most surfaceplants where hot dip galvanized steelhas not been used or cannot be used,e.g. where highly acidic liquid orgaseous conditions are present, regularrefurbishment or replacement of steelcan represent a very significant portionof the installation’s operatingexpenditure.The special characteristics of mine shaftconditions during both installation andoperation, e.g. the special stage-wiseprocesses that are required duringinstallation, the extreme difficulty incarrying out maintenance duringoperation, the long expected life of themine shaft which can often be in excessof 25 years and the highly corrosivenature of large sections of the shaft arewell accommodated by the use of hotdip galvanized steel. Test work as wellas experience has shown that hot dipgalvanized steel is both technically andeconomically superior to most otheralternative materials or corrosionprotection systems. Where hot dipgalvanized steel is used for mine shaftsteelwork, the benefits of the material6 Hot Dip Galvanizing Today Volume 3 Issue 4 2006
The use of hot dip galvanizing in general miningmake a very important contribution tothe profitability and safety of the miningoperation.Painted steelUnlike hot dip galvanized steel, paintedsteel, generally irrespective of the paintsystem used, does not tolerate damageand in corrosive mining conditions willbe highly susceptible to corrosion.Unlike other conditions where paintedsteel, or paint coatings in general, arebeneficially used, e.g. in buildings,residential homes or for roof cladding,in underground mining conditions andother mining conditions like oreprocessing plants, painted steel willrequire regular and frequentmaintenance to the coating in the formof either repair of the coating orreplacement of the coating. As statedpreviously, in these conditions,maintenance is often impractical, verycostly and, importantly, inefficient, asthe conditions are far removed fromthose optimally required for repainting.The conditions under whichmaintenance has to be performed arevery different from those under whichthe original coatings were applied. Inthe case of shaft steel, damage to thecoating can occur to erection orconstruction and accordingly corrosioncould be initiated before theinstallation has even beencommissioned. Even if a very optimisticview is taken, any calculation of lifecycle costs, which includes thepredicted future maintenance paintingroutines, if this is possible, will be highand very much higher than comparativelife cycle costs for hot dip galvanizedsteel.Local damage to protective paintcoatings will initiate localised corrosion,the final consequence of which iscorrosion pitting. Corrosion pitting,especially where relatively thin gaugesteel is used, is extremely concerning asit is difficult to monitor and negates theconcept of a ‘corrosion allowance’which assumes general or uniformcorrosion. A very good example of thisis the case of shaft buntons or hollowsections used for shaft guides. Here, hotdip galvanized steel has a major benefitin that the inner sections are zinccoated. Where welds may containdefects, or where mechanical damagecauses perforations, the subsequentingress of water to provide stagnantwater conditions are extremely harmfuland can only be efficiently protectedagainst by the interior zinc coating.Painted steel is generally not anappropriate material of construction forthe harsher mining conditions likeunderground shafts and haulages aswell as for most types of ore processingplants and material handling facilities. Ifpainted steel is used for theseconditions, the life cycle costs areusually very high as are the production,economic, safety and environmentalrisks.Procurement of hot dipgalvanized steelAs stated previously, the only apparentdisadvantage of hot dip galvanized steelin mining conditions is the perceptionby the user, owner or project manager,that the procurement process of thematerial is complex and difficult, andvery likely to cause problems inachieving project objectives.The complexity of specifying, designing,producing and transporting hot dipgalvanized steel, where this complexityrefers to the number of players in theprocess and the relationships betweenthe players does, indeed, complicatethe procurement process. Unless theprocess is properly managed andcontrolled, problems will undoubtedlyoccur, such as late delivery times,articles getting lost or misplaced,inappropriate fabrication processes thatlower the efficiency and effectiveness ofthe coating and galvanized articlesbeing severely damaged in the transportprocess. Effective management of theprocurement process is essentiallybased on ensuring that therelationships between all parties are‘open’ so as to allow an effectiveexchange of information. In most caseswhere such problems have occurred, itSpecialists inhot dip galvanizingwith quick turnaround timesHOT DIP GALVANIZINGTO APPROVED QUALITYSTANDARDS20 Dekenah StreetAlrode 1449P.O. Box 124581Alrode 1451Tel.: (011) 908-3411(011) 908-3418(011) 908-3420Fax: (011) 908-3329Volume 3 Issue 4 2006 Hot Dip Galvanizing Today 7