13.07.2015 Views

13 Titles - Viola da Gamba Society

13 Titles - Viola da Gamba Society

13 Titles - Viola da Gamba Society

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

Carl Hugo ÅgrenDiatonic Fingering on Treble and Pardessus ViolsChelys, vol. <strong>13</strong> (1984), pp. 61-76Music ReviewsChelys, vol. <strong>13</strong> (1984), pp. 77-82Book ReviewsChelys, vol <strong>13</strong> (1984), pp. 83-102Pearce WrightStradivarius 'Discovery' put to the test – Science report, TheTimes, 2 nd March 1984Chelys, vol. <strong>13</strong> (1984), p. 103EDITORIALThis issue of Chelys, with the exception of the major review of Meyer's EarlyEnglish Chamber Music by Christopher Field, avoids the area which so far hasserved as the central concern of the <strong>Society</strong> - English music of the earlyseventeenth century.Instead we move towards other areas geographically - to Germany wherePeter Holman considers the influence in England of Thomas Baltzar as aforeign virtuoso on the violin; and to France, where Adrian Rose highlights theimportance of Charpentier as a composer for the treble viol. The issue alsomakes a departure in its emphasis on different performance styles.It is becoming increasingly important to question the desirability ofattempting to arrive at historical accuracy, both in terms of producinghistorical copies of instruments, and in matters of performance-practice. Theaim of the scholar is the pursuit of truth; but in matters of style and taste,which concern the maker and the performer, this goal is necessarily elusive.Neither in the presentation of a critical edition with its atten<strong>da</strong>nt textualvariants (such as our Supplementary Publications), nor in the wide variety ofperformance styles (such as are presented in the articles by Alison Crum andCarl Hugo Agren), is it possible to arrive at a definitive answer. Is there notsome truth in the words of Kipling?:There are nine and sixty ways of constructing tribal lays,And-every-single-one-of-them-is-right!I should like to thank Stewart McCoy for preparing the prodigious numberof musical examples required in this issue.WENDY HANCOCK

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!