Eighth Grade Social Studies

Discussion Questions8th Grade Summer Reading Assignment1. When Alfons Heck was a young teenager, he thought that Hitler was a great hero who would save Germany. Muchlater, he realized the terrible damage that Hitler caused, both to Jewish people and to the young Germans who followedhim. Do you think people who are not fully adult should be held responsible for their decisions and actions? Do youthink that you are completely responsible for the decisions you make for yourself now?2. During the speaking tours that Helen Waterford and Alfons Heck made, audience members were sometimes angry atHelen. They believed that she should be less forgiving toward a former member of the Hitler Youth. Why do you thinkthat Helen believes so strongly that we should not hate all the members of any group? Do you agree with her?3. Near the end of World War II, even after Hitler had committed suicide, many members of the Hitler Youth fought anddied for Germany and Hitler. Why do you think they were willing to die for Germany, when it was clear that Germanywould lose the war?4. After returning to Amsterdam, Helen found her daughter, Dora. While Helen was in concentration camps, Dora hadbeen safe and happy living with another couple. When Helen took Dora to live with her, Dora had a difficult timeadjusting to living with her mother. At one point, she even said, "I wish you had never come back!" Why do you thinkthat the change was so hard for Dora? How does the author make you feel sympathy for both Helen and Dora?5. The stories of Alfons Heck and Helen Waterford have been told in separate books. Why do you think that the authorchose to tell these stories together? What does one gain by reading one chapter about Alfons followed by one aboutHelen, instead of reading their stories apart?