SAFER SOCIETY NEWS SAFER SOCIETYVulnerablechildren There were 31,600children on childprotection registerson 31 March 1998,according toDepartment of Healthst<strong>at</strong>istics publishedon 29 October. 8,000 (25%) of thechildren on theregisters <strong>at</strong> the endof the year were alsobeing looked after bylocal authorities. According to‘Modernising SocialServices’, in1997/98, 91 childrendied or sufferedserious injury <strong>at</strong> thehands of adultabusers. In someauthorities, as few as25% of young peopleleave care with anyeduc<strong>at</strong>ionalqualific<strong>at</strong>ion. One in fourchildren looked afteraged 14-16 do not<strong>at</strong>tend schoolregularly and manyhave been excludedand have no regulareduc<strong>at</strong>ionalplacement. According to ‘TheSchools’ Census for1998’, there were12,700 permanentexclusions fromprimary, secondaryand special schoolsin 1996/97, anincrease of 2% on theprevious year.as a cost saving measureby local authorities.’This, says the response,‘is alarming. Themajority of ordinaryfamilies continue toprovide a substantialmeasure of support totheir children until theyreach <strong>at</strong> least 18; theaverage age <strong>at</strong> whichyoung people now leavehome for independenceis estim<strong>at</strong>ed to be 22.Moreover, care leaversare likely to be r<strong>at</strong>hermore dependent thanothers <strong>at</strong> th<strong>at</strong> age inview of their personaland educ<strong>at</strong>ionalhistories.’ TheGovernment iscommitted to reversingthis trend. Research on ‘Caringfor Children Away fromHome’, published on 18November, confirmeddoubts about theefficacy of some parts ofthe residential sector.Two-fifths of the childrenin residence say theyhave been bullied in therecent past; one in sevensay they have beentaken advantage ofsexually by anotherresident; two-thirds saythey have been unhappyin the recent past andtwo-fifths say they havecontempl<strong>at</strong>ed suicide.The report containsrecommend<strong>at</strong>ions toimprove standards andtackle abuse in children’shomes.MODERNISING SOCIAL SERVICES:PROMOTING INDEPENDENCE,IMPROVING PROTECTION, RAISINGSTANDARDS is available from TheSt<strong>at</strong>ionery Office. Price £14.50and on the Internet on:http\\www.officialdocuments.co.uk\document\cm41\4169\4169.htmAn Executive Summary isavailable free from theDepartment of Health, PO Box410, Wetherby, West YorkshireLS23 7LN. The summary and a A5popular version are on theInternet on:http\\www.doh.gov.uk\scg\wpaper.htmTHE GOVERNMENT’S RESPONSETO THE CHILDREN’S SAFEGUARDREVIEW is available from TheSt<strong>at</strong>ionery Office. Price £4.50.CARING FOR CHILDREN AWAYFROM HOME - MESSAGES FROMRESEARCH is available from JohnWiley and Sons. Price £13.99.Child prostitutesto be tre<strong>at</strong>edas victimsChild prostitutes will betre<strong>at</strong>ed as victims ofabuse under joint HomeOffice and Departmentof Health guidance,published on 29December. The guidanceaims to: safeguard andpromote the welfare ofthe children; encouragethe investig<strong>at</strong>ion andprosecution of criminalactivities by those whoabuse and coercechildren in prostitution;and establish th<strong>at</strong> theprimary lawenforcement effort mustbe against abusers andcoercers. The Governmentpublished the SexualOffences (Amendment)Bill on 17 December tocre<strong>at</strong>e a new offence ofabuse of trust, whichwill apply where aperson aged 18 or over,in specifiedcircumstances, hassexual intercourse orengages in any othersexual activity with ortowards a person underth<strong>at</strong> age, if the olderperson is in a positionof trust over theyounger person.The offence is intendedto protect 16 and 17year olds in potentiallyvulnerablecircumstances,including detention orresidential care, orwhere the rel<strong>at</strong>ionshipof trust is particularlystrong, such as inschools.The Bill also equalisesthe age of consent forhomosexuals from 18 to16 in England, Walesand Scotland (and 17 inNorthern Ireland).Criminalrecord checksannouncedThe Governmentannounced plans on 14December 1998 toimplement Part V of thePolice Act 1997 whichwill mean th<strong>at</strong> allemployers will be ableto obtain the records ofjob applicants. Underthe Act, a CriminalRecords Bureau will beestablished inMerseyside under themanagement of theUnited KingdomPassport Agency. Thecore work of examiningrecords and issuingcertific<strong>at</strong>es will behandled by civilservants.This will take about twoyears to set up. Onceestablished, allemployers will be ableto find out whether jobapplicants have acriminal record, eitherby requiring theapplicants to run acheck on themselves or,in some instances, byrunning the checkdirectly.The Bureau will be selffinancing.All applicantsfor certific<strong>at</strong>es from theagency will be requiredto pay a fee which theGovernment estim<strong>at</strong>eswill vary from between£5 and £10.The Government willphase in checks. Prioritywill be given to theissue of certific<strong>at</strong>es forNACRO SAFER SOCIETY MAGAZINE FEBRUARY 1999 6
SAFER SOCIETY NEWS SAFER SOCIETYthose seeking positionswhich involve regularlycaring for, training,supervising or being insole charge of personsunder 18.Psychop<strong>at</strong>hicoffenders: newpowers neededNew legal powers areneeded to protect thepublic from offenderssuffering frompsychop<strong>at</strong>hic disordersand to care for them,according to a reportpublished by NACRO on4 November 1998.The report, ‘Risks andRights’, calls for a newreviewable sentence fordangerous offenderswith a psychop<strong>at</strong>hicdisorder who have beenconvicted of a seriousviolent or sexualoffence. At presentmany such offenders goto prison because thecourts are told bypsychi<strong>at</strong>rists th<strong>at</strong> theoffender is untre<strong>at</strong>able,while others are givenhospital orders. Thereport says th<strong>at</strong>‘psychi<strong>at</strong>rists disagreeabout tre<strong>at</strong>ability andwhether an offenderends up in prison orhospital can be a m<strong>at</strong>terof chance’.The report proposesth<strong>at</strong> offenders given thenew sentence wouldinstead be placed insepar<strong>at</strong>eaccommod<strong>at</strong>ion outsidethe current penal andhealth systems, with apositive approachaiming <strong>at</strong> rehabilit<strong>at</strong>ion.Had such a power andback up arrangementsbeen available, moreeffective and earlierintervention might havebeen possible in thecase of Michael Stone,convicted of the murderof Lynn and MeganRussell.The report stresses th<strong>at</strong>the gre<strong>at</strong> majority ofmentally disturbedpeople do not present adanger to others andth<strong>at</strong> the current legalframework for dealingwith people with asevere mental illness -as opposed to thosewith a psychop<strong>at</strong>hicdisorder - is adequ<strong>at</strong>e. Itargues, however, th<strong>at</strong>minimising the riskassoci<strong>at</strong>ed with severemental illness requiresmuch better fundedcommunity care, withswift access to back-upspecialist and hospitalservices.The report recommendscloser and better coordin<strong>at</strong>edcontact byagencies working withvulnerable mentallydisturbed people tomake sure th<strong>at</strong> they arecared for and th<strong>at</strong>urgent action is taken iftheir condition worsens.It calls for a code ofpractice on managingrisk for all agenciesdealing with mentallydisturbed people.RISKS AND RIGHTS: MENTALLYDISTURBED OFFENDERS ANDPUBLIC PROTECTION isavailable from NACRO. Price£11 including postage.Prob<strong>at</strong>ion hostelsgiven vote ofconfidenceBail and prob<strong>at</strong>ionhostels areunquestionablydemonstr<strong>at</strong>ing theirability to accommod<strong>at</strong>eand work successfullywith some of the mostdifficult, damaged andpotentially dangerousdefendants andoffenders, according toa prob<strong>at</strong>ion inspector<strong>at</strong>ereport published on 3November 1998.The report, ‘Deliveringan Enhanced Level ofCommunity Supervision’,found th<strong>at</strong> in 1997, 67%of orders or conditionsof residence weresuccessfully completed.Less than 4% ofresidents in the hostelscovered by theinspection were knownto have been chargedwith an offencecommitted during theirresidence, and themajority of these wereof a rel<strong>at</strong>ively minorn<strong>at</strong>ure. The public‘should takeencouragement fromthese findings’.DELIVERING AN ENHANCEDLEVEL OF COMMUNITYSUPERVISION: REPORT OF ATHEMATIC INSPECTION ON THEWORK OF APPROVEDPROBATION AND BAIL HOSTELSis available from the HomeOffice.Rising prisonpopul<strong>at</strong>ion‘unsustainable’In its report on‘Altern<strong>at</strong>ives to PrisonSentences’, published on10 September, the HomeAffairs Committeehighlighted a number ofprogrammes which<strong>at</strong>tempt to divert youngpeople away from crime.These include SherborneHouse in South London,which deals with youngmale offenders whowould otherwise havereceived a custodialsentence. Theseparticipants have areconviction r<strong>at</strong>e 15%lower than would bepredicted for suchoffenders.But the Committee notesthe ‘absence of rigorousresearch into theeffectiveness ofindividual communitysentences <strong>at</strong> present,and th<strong>at</strong>, until this isrectified, confidence inthem must be limited,and sentencing policy am<strong>at</strong>ter of guessworkand optimism’.Nevertheless, notingth<strong>at</strong> the current risingprison popul<strong>at</strong>ion is‘unsustainable’, theCommittee concludesth<strong>at</strong> ‘there are manypeople currentlysentenced toimprisonment who couldbe dealt with moreeffectively - and <strong>at</strong> farless expense - by a noncustodialsentence’.Among diversionaryschemes, it highlightsYouthWorks inBlackburn, one of fiveYouthWorks initi<strong>at</strong>ivesaimed <strong>at</strong> cre<strong>at</strong>ing ‘safer,high-qualityenvironments byharnessing the energiesof young people in aproductive way’.YouthWorks appears tobe achieving its aim ofreducing crime in theRoman Road Est<strong>at</strong>e areaof Blackburn, which wasnumber one in a rankingof police be<strong>at</strong>s in termsof crime committed andnow is number 14.The Committeecommend such schemesbut note th<strong>at</strong> theirfunding is err<strong>at</strong>ic. ‘Theprecarious financialsitu<strong>at</strong>ion such projectsfind themselves inmakes it difficult tomake long-term plansand takes up thevaluable time of theirworkers which could bemore usefully spent withthe young peopleconcerned ... The costeffectivenessof suchschemes is difficult toquantify and impossibleto ignore.’ALTERNATIVES TO PRISONSENTENCES: THIRD REPORT OFTHE HOME AFFAIRSCOMMITTEE SESSION 1997-98is available from The St<strong>at</strong>ioneryOffice. Price £11.50.Government7 FEBRUARY 1999 SAFER SOCIETY MAGAZINE NACRO