House of Representatives
2h0s7Ad
2h0s7Ad
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Thursday, 1 December 2016 HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES 25<br />
Stanley, AM<br />
Swanson, MJ<br />
Thistlethwaite, MJ<br />
Watts, TG<br />
Wilson, JH<br />
NOES<br />
Swan, WM<br />
Templeman, SR<br />
Vamvakinou, M<br />
Wilkie, AD<br />
Zappia, A<br />
Question agreed to.<br />
The SPEAKER (11:16): The original question was that the requested amendments be not made. To this the<br />
honourable member for Adelaide has moved as an amendment:<br />
That all the words after "That" be omitted with a view to substituting the following words:<br />
"the <strong>House</strong> calls on the Government to recommend an appropriation from the Governor-General consistent with the request<br />
from the Senate".<br />
The question now is that that amendment be agreed to.<br />
Dr ALY (Cowan) (11:17): As someone who has worked in the vocational education and training sector—<br />
The SPEAKER: The member for Cowan will resume her seat. The Leader <strong>of</strong> the <strong>House</strong>?<br />
Mr PYNE (Sturt—Leader <strong>of</strong> the <strong>House</strong> and Minister for Defence Industry) (11:17): I move:<br />
That the question be now put.<br />
A division having been called and the bells being rung—<br />
Dr Aly interjecting—<br />
The SPEAKER: The member for Cowan does not have the call. No-one can hear you. Resume your seat.<br />
There is a division.<br />
An opposition member interjecting—<br />
The SPEAKER: Whoever that was, I can remind you that there is still 30 seconds to be ejected under 94(a).<br />
The question is that the question be now put.<br />
The <strong>House</strong> divided. [11:18]<br />
(The Speaker—Hon. Tony Smith)<br />
Abbott, AJ<br />
Andrews, KJ<br />
Banks, J<br />
Broad, AJ<br />
Buchholz, S<br />
Christensen, GR (teller)<br />
Coleman, DB<br />
Crewther, CJ<br />
Dutton, PC<br />
Evans, TM<br />
Fletcher, PW<br />
Frydenberg, JA<br />
Gillespie, DA<br />
Hartsuyker, L<br />
Hawke, AG<br />
Hogan, KJ<br />
Hunt, GA<br />
Joyce, BT<br />
Laming, A<br />
Laundy, C<br />
Ley, SP<br />
Marino, NB<br />
McVeigh, JJ<br />
Morton, B<br />
O'Brien, T<br />
O'Dwyer, KM<br />
Pitt, KJ<br />
Prentice, J<br />
Ayes ...................... 74<br />
Noes ...................... 73<br />
Majority ................. 1<br />
AYES<br />
Alexander, JG<br />
Andrews, KL<br />
Bishop, JI<br />
Broadbent, RE<br />
Chester, D<br />
Ciobo, SM<br />
Coulton, M<br />
Drum, DK<br />
Entsch, WG<br />
Falinski, J<br />
Flint, NJ<br />
Gee, AR<br />
Goodenough, IR<br />
Hastie, AW<br />
Henderson, SM<br />
Howarth, LR<br />
Irons, SJ<br />
Keenan, M<br />
Landry, ML<br />
Leeser, J<br />
Littleproud, D<br />
McCormack, MF<br />
Morrison, SJ<br />
O'Brien, LS<br />
O'Dowd, KD<br />
Pasin, A<br />
Porter, CC<br />
Price, ML<br />
CHAMBER
Change language