07.02.2017 Views

FK - FS paper Rome 140604

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

law, and function as a transmission channel by greatly<br />

facilitating the import of the new international law into<br />

national law.<br />

European Union law is a body of law with supranational<br />

characteristics and therefore with a higher degree of<br />

penetration in national law than classical international law.<br />

There can be no question that the national laws of each of the<br />

Member States of the European Union will be profoundly<br />

affected by the Constitution, which, when adopted, will be at<br />

the top of their hierarchy of legal norms. Whereas the role<br />

of constitutional rights-based litigation has so far remained<br />

limited, it can be advanced with a high degree of certainty<br />

that the Constitution, for the various reasons explained<br />

above, will be an engine for expansion of this type of<br />

litigation.<br />

Such a “constitutional common law” approach will offer<br />

extraordinary opportunities for the importation and<br />

transmission of the new international law, which the Union<br />

will “strictly observe”. In practice, it will become<br />

sufficient for a court to refer to some human right (a<br />

“fundamental international right") to render obsolete any<br />

provision of national law, even a posterior legislative act.<br />

The scope and the undefined and vague nature of many new human<br />

rights lead to a loss of power and legal authority by the<br />

political branches of government in favor of this<br />

international legal order.<br />

If courts and tribunals can be pulled into the dynamics<br />

between the "international community" and "civil society", the<br />

alliance between international bodies and NGO's, this new<br />

legal, and eventually also political, order can be made<br />

dominant. Such a development will inevitably extend into and<br />

12

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!