Social Success Stories - Amazon Web Services
Social Success Stories - Amazon Web Services
Social Success Stories - Amazon Web Services
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
<strong>Social</strong> <strong>Success</strong> <strong>Stories</strong><br />
Marketing Lessons from Industry Leaders<br />
JULY 2012<br />
1
<strong>Social</strong> <strong>Success</strong> <strong>Stories</strong><br />
Marketing Lessons from Industry Leaders<br />
Introduction<br />
Best <strong>Social</strong> Engagement in Retail<br />
Leading Retail Facebook Brand: Converse<br />
Leading Retail Twitter Brand: Whole Foods<br />
Key Takeaways/Best Practices for Retail<br />
Best <strong>Social</strong> Engagement in Sports<br />
Leading Sports Facebook Brand: NBA<br />
Leading Sports Twitter Brand: ESPN<br />
Key Takeaways/Best Practices for Sports<br />
Best <strong>Social</strong> Engagement in <strong>Services</strong><br />
Leading <strong>Services</strong> Facebook Brand: Farmers<br />
Leading <strong>Services</strong> Twitter Brand: American Express<br />
Key Takeaways/Best Practices for <strong>Services</strong><br />
Conclusion<br />
Additional Resources<br />
About Awareness Inc. 23<br />
2<br />
3<br />
4<br />
5<br />
7<br />
9<br />
10<br />
11<br />
13<br />
15<br />
16<br />
17<br />
19<br />
21<br />
22<br />
22
<strong>Social</strong> <strong>Success</strong> <strong>Stories</strong><br />
Marketing Lessons from Industry Leaders<br />
INTRODUCTION<br />
When it comes to social marketing, some brands seem to have an innate knack for doing it right.<br />
Don’t be fooled; this success did not happen overnight. As the social landscape evolves, the best<br />
brands dedicate time and resources to their social presence. And we know there’s always something<br />
to learn from the best.<br />
To help you optimize your social experience, Awareness Inc. analyzed the top social brands in retail,<br />
services and sports to identify and share their best-in-class strategies for success. We reviewed<br />
their social presence and analyzed the content strategies used by social marketing leaders such as<br />
Converse, Whole Foods, NBA, ESPN, Farmers Insurance, and American Express, on the two most<br />
popular social networks, Facebook and Twitter. We left no strategy unturned – and we share the<br />
answers to the following questions: What do these successful brands post? How often? What kind of<br />
imagery supports their brand? What content makes their audience tune in and take action?<br />
Based on this analysis, we have distilled our findings into actionable best practices that every brand<br />
and marketer can follow to improve their company’s social efforts. After reading this paper, marketers<br />
will be equipped with a new arsenal of best practices to help them achieve and sustain meaningful<br />
relationships with their audience.<br />
BACKGROUND<br />
To crack the code to the leading brands’ social media success, Awareness consulted the rankings<br />
of the most popular brands on The Fan Page List, dubbed as the social media directory of official<br />
accounts of your favorite brands, celebrities, movies, TV shows and sports teams. We focused on<br />
three industry sectors - retail, services and sports - and reviewed the top ten brands in each of those<br />
categories on Facebook and Twitter, using the size of their fan base as a starting point. We then dove<br />
into some of top leaders’ engagement metrics and strategies. For the retail sector we focused on<br />
Converse and Whole Foods, for sports – NBA and ESPN, and for services – Farmers Insurance and<br />
American Express.<br />
When analyzing the engagement for each of the leaders in our three categories, we used two types of<br />
metrics:<br />
Facebook Engagement Ratio:<br />
This is a point in time metric, as the number of people talking about a brand frequently fluctuates.<br />
Twitter Engagement Ratio:<br />
# of people talking about a brand<br />
Total # fans of that brand<br />
Total # of Tweets<br />
Total # followers of that brand<br />
Our analysis for each industry sector starts with a top 10 chart of the most popular brands, with their<br />
total number of fans at the time of this report’s publication, and their engagement ratio for Facebook<br />
and Twitter. We then dig deeper into the marketing practices of specific market leaders by category to<br />
showcase how they use their social profiles, what content they post, and how well they integrate their<br />
social and digital presences.<br />
3
<strong>Social</strong> <strong>Success</strong> <strong>Stories</strong><br />
Marketing Lessons from Industry Leaders<br />
Converse<br />
Victoria’s Secret<br />
Walmart<br />
Zara<br />
Target<br />
Burberry<br />
Levi’s<br />
H&M<br />
Lacoste<br />
Nike<br />
Best <strong>Social</strong> Engagement in Retail<br />
In this section, we examine the top 10 retail brands on Facebook and<br />
Twitter. The Facebook leaders in this category are Converse, the brand<br />
with the most Facebook followers in our set, and our choice for a deep<br />
engagement dive, followed by Victoria’s Secret, Walmart, Zara, Target,<br />
Burberry, Levi’s, H&M, Lacoste and Nike. The retail leaders on Twitter<br />
are Whole Foods, the brand with the most Twitter followers and our<br />
choice for a deep engagement dive, followed by Zappos, Etsy, Toms<br />
Shoes, Cake Wrecks, H&M, Burberry, Victoria’s Secret, Marc Jacobs and<br />
Forever 21.<br />
How do the winners achieve success? The best performing retail brands carefully balance<br />
promotional posts with more neutral content – whether that is video, pictures or contests. <strong>Success</strong>ful<br />
brands also look for opportunities to include their communities – by showcasing user photos, running<br />
polls, and having fill-in-the-blank style submissions.<br />
Top Ten Retail Brands on Facebook and Twitter<br />
Brand Fans Fans<br />
Talking<br />
About<br />
Brand<br />
30,996,009<br />
18,741,656<br />
16,431,023<br />
13,562,553<br />
13,392,590<br />
12,914,216<br />
12,215,819<br />
11,208,321<br />
9,781,674<br />
9,322,892<br />
257,582<br />
178,777<br />
480,031<br />
110,092<br />
316,798<br />
60,220<br />
120,599<br />
109,820<br />
70,237<br />
93,563<br />
Engagement<br />
Ratio<br />
0.83%<br />
0.95%<br />
2.92%<br />
0.81%<br />
2.36%<br />
0.47%<br />
0.99%<br />
0.98%<br />
0.72%<br />
1.00%<br />
Brand Followers Total<br />
Posts<br />
Whole Foods<br />
Zappos<br />
Etsy<br />
Toms Shoes<br />
Cake Wrecks<br />
H&M<br />
Burberry<br />
Victoria’s Secret<br />
Marc Jacobs<br />
Forever 21<br />
Source: Data from The Fan Page List, as of June 19th, 2012.<br />
4<br />
2,675,347<br />
2,390,382<br />
1,640,477<br />
1,622,849<br />
1,233,044<br />
1,217,143<br />
1,040,725<br />
883,532<br />
638,632<br />
570,792<br />
32,838<br />
2,272<br />
15,868<br />
233,021<br />
4,577<br />
4,897<br />
1,980<br />
3,185<br />
8,878<br />
5,827<br />
Followers<br />
Per Post<br />
81.47<br />
1052.10<br />
103.38<br />
6.96<br />
269.40<br />
248.54<br />
525.61<br />
277.40<br />
71.93<br />
97.96
PROFILE ELEMENTS<br />
CONTENT<br />
<strong>Social</strong> <strong>Success</strong> <strong>Stories</strong><br />
Marketing Lessons from Industry Leaders<br />
Leading Retail Facebook Brand: Converse<br />
Profile/Cover Photo<br />
Converse uses their<br />
signature shoe as their<br />
profile picture. It stands<br />
out against a vibrant cover<br />
image showcasing artistic<br />
photos of Converse shoes<br />
in action. Page visitors<br />
can quickly determine<br />
Converse’s brand<br />
personality: fun, classic<br />
and well-loved.<br />
Converse is known as ‘the Biggest Little Sneaker Brand’ on<br />
Facebook. Despite not being the biggest shoe brand, they dominate<br />
the sneaker category. How do they do it? Glad you asked…<br />
Tabs: With the introduction of timeline, brands may now only show four tabs directly on their home<br />
page. For all others, visitors must click on a drop-down menu. Converse shows Photos, Likes,<br />
Events, and Videos on their homepage. Their extended tabs include a live video stream, Notes, and a<br />
Beirut Block Party. Converse’s Block Party hooks fans up with music downloads.<br />
Frequency: Post one to three times per day.<br />
Top Sites: Promoted Converse.com, YouTube, Promotional<br />
Partners when running co-branded campaigns.<br />
<strong>Social</strong> Content Approach Converse uses content wisely, with a<br />
special focus on photography. Converse has over 50 photo albums.<br />
They have an iconic and easily recognizable product. They use photos<br />
to showcase new and old styles, special collections, and to share<br />
sneak peeks of upcoming product lines.<br />
For example, this photo of the Converse Americana Collection has<br />
over 11,230 ‘Likes’ and comments.<br />
Sharing the brand’s history also increases fan engagement. A photo<br />
posted of the 1934 Chuck Taylor All Star generated over 35,000<br />
interactions.<br />
5
<strong>Social</strong> <strong>Success</strong> <strong>Stories</strong><br />
Marketing Lessons from Industry Leaders<br />
Leading Retail Facebook Brand: Converse (cont.)<br />
Music is a natural complement to Converse. Converse has a lengthy history with independent<br />
musical artists. In fact, Converse opened a music studio in New York, which offers free studio time<br />
to musicians. So it’s no surprise then that they frequently offer exclusive downloads of songs, having<br />
previously supported bands like the Gorillaz and Beirut.<br />
Contes:ts: Converse uses contests to keep levels of fan engagement high. One campaign, “Show<br />
Me Yours: All Natural” generated over 20,000 social interactions with fans. Converse regularly posts<br />
short challenges, encouraging fans to snap and send a shot of their shoes. Converse has featured<br />
“Show Me Yours: Blue” in support of World Autism Day, “Show Me Yours in Your Neighborhood” and<br />
“Show Me Yours: Dirty”. Converse then posts the best user-submitted photos in an album.<br />
<strong>Web</strong>s:ite Integration While<br />
there is limited promotion of<br />
social channels on the Converse<br />
website, they do embed sharing<br />
on each individual product<br />
page. Converse connects with<br />
Facebook, Myspace, Twitter,<br />
Blogspot and Tumblr.<br />
How <strong>Social</strong> Leads: to Revenue Converse represents more than a product, rather a<br />
lifestyle, which includes supporting musical artists and activities such as skateboarding and creative<br />
design. Converse shoes and apparel are portraying themselves as the unofficial uniform of this<br />
lifestyle.<br />
6
PROFILE ELEMENTS<br />
CONTENT<br />
<strong>Social</strong> <strong>Success</strong> <strong>Stories</strong><br />
Marketing Lessons from Industry Leaders<br />
Leading Retail Twitter Brand: Whole Foods<br />
Followers: 2,675,216<br />
Following 558,636<br />
– consisting of fans of<br />
Whole Foods, chefs, and<br />
likeminded companies.<br />
Background The Whole<br />
Food’s background is a<br />
soothing solid green, with a<br />
bit of information to help a<br />
user find their local Whole<br />
Foods store on Twitter.<br />
Whole Foods is known for being an early trailblazer on social media.<br />
Their goal is to interact with their customers on their customers’ turf.<br />
Frequency: Whole Foods posts between 10-20 original tweets per day, not including customer<br />
replies.<br />
Ratio of Pos:ts: to Replies: Whole Foods is incredibly active in conversations with fans and store<br />
visitors. For example, they frequently respond to customers who share their lunch orders. The daily<br />
ratio of replies to posts is roughly 50:15.<br />
Frequently: dis:cus:s:ed topics: include<br />
• Recipes. Whole Foods posts recipes and cooking ideas on their website and blog.<br />
• Current events. Whole Foods shares special events and informs their users when various<br />
organizations are being recognized (i.e. 3rd Annual Hemp History Week).<br />
Contes:ts: Whole Foods occasionally offers<br />
contests, like $250 gift certificates for the<br />
best berry recipe or a $50 gift card randomly<br />
awarded for a retweet.<br />
Dis:cus:s:ions: Whole Foods frequently<br />
comments on the purchases of Whole Foods<br />
visitors. Whole Foods always takes a friendly<br />
and helpful approach, creating genuine<br />
engagement with their users.<br />
7
<strong>Social</strong> <strong>Success</strong> <strong>Stories</strong><br />
Marketing Lessons from Industry Leaders<br />
Leading Retail Twitter Brand: Whole Foods (cont.)<br />
Cus:tomer s:ervice Whole Foods practices excellent customer service on Twitter, always<br />
interacting with their customers – fixing compliants, chatting about food and just generally acting as a<br />
friend.<br />
Frequently: us:ed has:htags: Whole<br />
Foods commits to a hashtag for the<br />
duration of a contest or promotion. For<br />
most of June, they used #WFMfish<br />
nearly exclusively for their Fishmonger<br />
Face-Off competition, and #WFMdish<br />
for fish recipes. The Fishmonger Face-<br />
Off “will highlight its fishmongers who<br />
work daily to help educate shoppers<br />
about responsibly-caught seafood<br />
choices and cooking tips.” Before that,<br />
they used #Foodiechats.<br />
<strong>Web</strong>s:ite Integration The website includes social links, but does not integrate a social feed. They<br />
also include a page dedicated to helping hungry and interested fans find all official accounts. Whole<br />
Foods syncs with Facebook, Twitter and Pinterest to allow users to share recipes with their social<br />
networks.<br />
How <strong>Social</strong> Leads: to Revenue Whole Foods has chosen to focus on the ingredients<br />
that make food great. By doing this, they are associating their brand with those ingredients, so the<br />
next time their customer is in the mood for an heirloom tomato and basil salad, they will think of Whole<br />
Foods.<br />
8
<strong>Social</strong> <strong>Success</strong> <strong>Stories</strong><br />
Marketing Lessons from Industry Leaders<br />
Key Takeaways/Best Practices for Retail Brands<br />
1. Know Your Audience! – We cannot stress this enough. As<br />
Converse’s chief marketing officer, Geoff Cottrill, says their success can<br />
be attributed to letting the fans lead and “acting like a party guest.” Listen<br />
to your followers; let them post on your wall. Study how your competitors<br />
interact with them. Capitalize on opportunities that align your brand with<br />
your customer’s other interests – like Converse and music. Converse<br />
has seen success from being flexible and relevant and adding to the<br />
conversation where possible.<br />
2. Offer Exclus:ive Content – Your fans are important. Make that clear. Offer them<br />
exclusive content, sneak peaks at new products, or, as Converse did, a free download of a new song.<br />
Give your fans a reason to pay attention to your News Feed. What can you offer them? How can you<br />
be helpful?<br />
3. Tell a Story: with Photos: – Create albums and photo-sharing contests that motivate<br />
your users to showcase their usage of your product or service.<br />
4. Develop Continuity: – Although only one person posts for Whole Foods at a time, that<br />
person is not identified by name on the account. Rather, Whole Foods focuses on strengthening their<br />
brand, which keeps professionalism high and grants continuity in case a different person steps in. Any<br />
loyalty remains with Whole Foods and not the account’s author.<br />
5. It’s: not a 9-5 – The current author behind the Whole Foods voice, Michael Bepko, spends<br />
a third of his day on Twitter, but often checks it during off hours and weekends. Customers always<br />
have complaints or queries that need to be answered. Without a high level of commitment, the brand<br />
could face frustrated fans.<br />
6. Get Local – While the main Whole Foods Twitter account is ideal for answering general<br />
complaints, it may not help a local store visitor with a timely question. Many of the individual<br />
stores have their own Twitter accounts manned by store employees. This allows for more targeted<br />
interactions, as well as local promotions, and relationship-building with local stores.<br />
9
<strong>Social</strong> <strong>Success</strong> <strong>Stories</strong><br />
Marketing Lessons from Industry Leaders<br />
Best <strong>Social</strong> Engagement in Sports<br />
In this section, we examine the top 10 sports brands on Facebook and<br />
Twitter. The Facebook leaders in this category are the NBA with the most<br />
Facebook followers in this set, and our choice for a deep engagement<br />
dive. Nike, WWE, UFC, ESPN, PUMA, NFL, Fox Racing, Foot Locker<br />
and The North Face round out the top 10. On Twitter, the sports leaders<br />
are the NBA, ESPN — our choice for a deep engagement dive — NFL,<br />
MLB, WWE, NHL, FIFA, UFC, Sports Illustrated, and FIFA World Cup<br />
2014.<br />
Sports companies tend to focus on their users’ top interests – game stats, players and scores. With<br />
only two days a year without a sporting event, sports brands and organizations are generally flush<br />
with content. In this section, we’ll share how the NBA uses their Facebook presence and how ESPN<br />
approaches Twitter.<br />
Top Ten Sports Brands on Facebook and Twitter<br />
Brand Fans Fans<br />
Talking<br />
About<br />
Brand<br />
NBA<br />
Nike<br />
WWE<br />
UFC<br />
ESPN<br />
PUMA<br />
NFL<br />
Fox Racing<br />
Foot Locker<br />
The North Face<br />
13,430,916<br />
9,322,892<br />
9,218,074<br />
8,738,461<br />
7,526,675<br />
7,441,829<br />
5,626,332<br />
3,428,525<br />
3,036,974<br />
2,470,290<br />
345,958<br />
93,563<br />
238,514<br />
121,367<br />
227,321<br />
32,426<br />
82,768<br />
26,251<br />
78,499<br />
46,009<br />
Engagement<br />
Ratio<br />
2.58%<br />
1.00%<br />
2.59%<br />
1.39%<br />
3.02%<br />
0.44%<br />
1.47%<br />
0.77%<br />
2.58%<br />
1.86%<br />
Brand Followers Total<br />
Posts Followers<br />
Per Post<br />
NBA<br />
ESPN<br />
NFL<br />
MLB<br />
WWE<br />
NHL<br />
FIFA<br />
UFC<br />
Sports Illustrated<br />
10<br />
5,294,694<br />
4,315,609<br />
3,448,186<br />
2,146,286<br />
1,251,727<br />
1,231,530<br />
820,510<br />
649,256<br />
370,212<br />
FIFA World Cup 2014 257,754<br />
29,708<br />
40,821<br />
14,933<br />
36,608<br />
22,026<br />
32,681<br />
9,530<br />
26,142<br />
35,976<br />
9,592<br />
178.22<br />
105.72<br />
230.91<br />
58.63<br />
56.83<br />
37.68<br />
86.10<br />
24.84<br />
10.29<br />
26.87<br />
Source: Data from The Fan Page List, as of June 19th, 2012.
PROFILE ELEMENTS<br />
CONTENT<br />
<strong>Social</strong> <strong>Success</strong> <strong>Stories</strong><br />
Marketing Lessons from Industry Leaders<br />
Leading Sports Facebook Brand: NBA<br />
Profile/Cover<br />
Photo The NBA puts<br />
a year-round focus on<br />
the NBA Finals. After<br />
Facebook introduced<br />
Timeline, the NBA<br />
featured a photo of the<br />
2011 NBA Finals Trophy,<br />
held up by the hands of<br />
the victors. When the<br />
2012 NBA Finals began,<br />
the cover was changed<br />
to a snapshot of Game<br />
One’s tip-off.<br />
The NBA, the organization with the most Facebook followers at the time<br />
of this paper’s publication, also has a highly engaged audience, not<br />
surprisingly, as our analysis coincided with the NBA Finals, one of the most<br />
active periods for the league.<br />
Tabs: Of the four visible tabs, the NBA chooses to show: photos (to the tune of 364 albums), a<br />
Virtual Stadium, Shaker NBA Finals – an app that keeps fans up-to-date with upcoming games<br />
and offers trivia, prizes and the chance to chat with other fans to get ready for the game, and their<br />
<strong>Social</strong> Media Awards – a never-been-held-before celebration honoring 12 players for their social<br />
media adoption. For instance, the Best in Game (BIG) Award was given to the player who best<br />
utilizes social media across all platforms including Facebook and Twitter. The Laugh Out Loud (LOL)<br />
Award was awarded to the team or player with the most shared and ‘Liked’ blooper from the regular<br />
season. Awards were announced on June 20th. The expanded tabs include the NBA shop, events,<br />
total ‘Likes’, FanCam, Twitter, and Spanish NBA.<br />
Frequency: 7-10 posts per day<br />
Top Sites: Promoted NBA.com, NBA Store, NBA.com News, YouTube, TwitVid, Partner sites<br />
(like Spalding), and charities with whom the NBA has a relationship, like the American Diabetes<br />
Association.<br />
11
<strong>Social</strong> <strong>Success</strong> <strong>Stories</strong><br />
Marketing Lessons from Industry Leaders<br />
Leading Sports Facebook Brand: NBA (cont.)<br />
<strong>Social</strong> Content Approach<br />
• Updates: The NBA features a lot of game clips, stats<br />
and action shots – and rightfully so. Fans can relive<br />
favorite moments, discuss their favorite games and<br />
dispute the outcomes. The post (shown) that announced<br />
the Oklahoma City Thunder’s advancement to the NBA<br />
Finals had over 15,000 ‘Likes’ and comments.<br />
• Polls: The NBA frequently solicits the opinion of its<br />
viewers. This poll (shown) in anticipation of the Eastern<br />
Conference winner totaled over 30,000 votes.<br />
Giveaway:s:/Contes:ts: The NBA hosts regular contests in partnership with sponsors. A contest<br />
in early June awarded one fan a trip to the 2013 All-Star Game. In order to enter the contests, fans<br />
must share their contact information and opt-in to receive NBA-related emails.<br />
<strong>Web</strong>s:ite Integration The NBA is all about integrating social media activity in real time. Aside from<br />
the typical embedded Twitter feed, their website lists the Top Ten Trending Players with real-time<br />
analytics on total mentions across the social web per hour. LeBron James is number one with 2,015<br />
mentions per hour and 1,629,734 total mentions at the time of this paper’s publication. In addition, a<br />
dedicated section of the NBA website, the <strong>Social</strong> Spotlight, brings fans real time tweets from leading<br />
sports analysts, columnists and bloggers. Additionally, on each player page, a visitor has the option<br />
to ‘Like’ the page on Facebook. Their various blogs connect with Facebook, Twitter and Google+<br />
with typical social sharing buttons. The NBA photo gallery connects with Twitter for social sharing.<br />
How <strong>Social</strong> Leads: to Revenue A more engaged social audience is more likely to<br />
watch NBA games. More viewers increase the NBA’s leverage and allow them to command more<br />
money for broadcasting rights. Additionally, the NBA does have a Shop NBA Facebook tab for direct<br />
sales through social.<br />
12
PROFILE ELEMENTS<br />
CONTENT<br />
<strong>Social</strong> <strong>Success</strong> <strong>Stories</strong><br />
Marketing Lessons from Industry Leaders<br />
Leading Sports Twitter Brand: ESPN<br />
Followers: 4,352,450<br />
Following 335 — consisting<br />
of mainly ESPN employees,<br />
reporters and players.<br />
Background At publication,<br />
ESPN’s background is an<br />
image of a NBA court, in<br />
support of the NBA Finals with<br />
their logo as the profile image.<br />
ESPN’s Twitter and TV strategy aren’t terribly dissimilar. Their goal is<br />
to bring their followers all sports news all the time. As a sport-agnostic<br />
channel, users see updates on everything from pro-hockey games to the<br />
national spelling bee championship.<br />
Frequency: Between 5-15 original Tweets per day, not including retweets.<br />
Ratio of Pos:ts: to Replies: ESPN does not respond to anyone. They do, however, retweet their<br />
fans. ESPN posts roughly 10-15 retweets per day.<br />
Frequently: dis:cus:s:ed topics: include<br />
• Stats/Articles. ESPN posts news<br />
stories and game stats with regularity<br />
– that’s what their followers care most<br />
about.<br />
• Photos: ESPN brings their Twitter<br />
channel to life by adding pictures to<br />
relevant tweets.<br />
• Videos & Live Streams: ESPN shares<br />
videos of games and makes live<br />
streams available on their website.<br />
• Live Tweeting: For big games, like<br />
Game 7 of the NBA Eastern Conference<br />
finals, ESPN live tweets to keep the<br />
excitement level high.<br />
• Affiliated Content: ESPN regularly relies on affiliated ESPN-partners, be that ESPN reporters<br />
and niche ESPN-accounts to bolster their social stream.<br />
13
<strong>Social</strong> <strong>Success</strong> <strong>Stories</strong><br />
Marketing Lessons from Industry Leaders<br />
Leading Sports Twitter Brand: ESPN (cont.)<br />
Cus:tomer s:ervice ESPN does not support customer service activities on Twitter.<br />
Frequently: us:ed has:htags: ESPN integrates hashtags regularly. They frequently reference a<br />
team, player, sport or series by hashtags (#Euro2012, #LSU, #PacBradley, #boxing), which helps<br />
keep track of sports conversations. They also use inspirational hashtags like #ChampionsRISE to<br />
keep fans hyped.<br />
Advertis:ing ESPN uses<br />
Promoted Tweets as part of<br />
their marketing mix. ESPN and<br />
Twitter recently announced a<br />
partnership to take advantage<br />
of the volume of sports-related<br />
tweets. #GameFace during the<br />
NBA Finals is the first example of<br />
this partnership, which features<br />
tight TV integration. Fans<br />
tweet their best #GameFace to<br />
ESPN and they’ll show of the<br />
best ones on TV (ESPN and<br />
partner channels like ABC).<br />
This partnership aims to make<br />
channel integration stronger and<br />
easier than ever before.<br />
<strong>Web</strong>s:ite Integration The homepage does not include Twitter integration; sub-properties like ESPN<br />
NFL and others do include on-page Twitter integration. ESPN, like many big brands, have several<br />
highly visible sub-properties, all with their own social accounts as well. On each article published,<br />
ESPN includes ‘share socially buttons’ for Twitter and Facebook. They also have Facebook <strong>Social</strong><br />
Sharing, a service that automatically posts to Facebook when you read an article.<br />
How <strong>Social</strong> Leads: to Revenue Similar to the NBA, an engaged ESPN audience<br />
is likely to turn to them for their sports news needs. Just as important is the distribution of their web<br />
articles via Twitter. This increases traffic to their website, and more visitors creates more ad revenue<br />
for their site.<br />
14
<strong>Social</strong> <strong>Success</strong> <strong>Stories</strong><br />
Marketing Lessons from Industry Leaders<br />
Key Takeaways/Best Practices for Sports Brands<br />
1. Stay: Relevant — Post timely updates to keep fans updated<br />
and give them a reason to check their news feed.<br />
2. Be Cons:is:tent — Fans in a crunch need to know whom<br />
they can depend on for up-to-date news, and other vital information.<br />
Offer them what they are looking for, and they’ll keep coming back.<br />
3. Relis:h Victories: — Post easy-to-read snapshots of key<br />
events – the NBA keeps their fans updated with final scores and<br />
highlights.<br />
4. Incorporate Channel Integration — ESPN promotes its many Twitter profiles well<br />
on their website, but what they do even better is the combination of social media with traditional<br />
media. While playing a highlight from a basketball game of a great dunk, they had reactions from<br />
other athletes on Twitter showing on TV. Rather than keep their online presence separate from their<br />
TV presence, ESPN understands the benefit in integrating them, such as when they use Twitter as a<br />
news source or to boost the views on their stories.<br />
5. Create a Cons:is:tent Brand Identity: — ESPN requires employees to use Twitter<br />
only in a business capacity for discussing sports. Curbing personal branding may seem counterintuitive<br />
for social media, but by branding all of writers as ESPN writers, they establish continuity,<br />
which is strengthened by fostering a professional social media approach. No bloopers here!<br />
6. Cons:ider Advertis:ing — Explore the advertising platforms on social channels to grow<br />
following, spread awareness and/or make a sale.<br />
15
<strong>Social</strong> <strong>Success</strong> <strong>Stories</strong><br />
Marketing Lessons from Industry Leaders<br />
Top 10 <strong>Services</strong> Brands on Facebook and Twitter<br />
American Express<br />
Farmers Insurance<br />
DirecTV<br />
Live Nation<br />
Visa<br />
Ticketmaster<br />
UPS<br />
Ancestry.com<br />
24 Hour Fitness<br />
Accenture<br />
Best <strong>Social</strong> Engagement in <strong>Services</strong><br />
2,464,693<br />
2,334,713<br />
1,279,217<br />
809,691<br />
875,106<br />
547,165<br />
368,804<br />
322,572<br />
227,982<br />
118,429<br />
In our last section, we’ll examine the top 10 services brands on<br />
Facebook and Twitter based on their following. In the services section,<br />
we chose the number two and number three brands for our deep<br />
analysis dive to spice it up a bit. The Facebook leaders in this category<br />
are American Express, Farmers Insurance – our choice for a deep dive,<br />
DirecTV, Live Nation, Visa, Ticketmaster, UPS, Ancestry.com, 24 Hour<br />
Fitness, and Accenture rounding out the top 10. On Twitter, the leaders<br />
are CME Group, CBOE, American Express – our deep dive choice,<br />
Tepco, Live Nation, Ticketmaster, Vanguard, Comcast Digital Care<br />
Center, DirecTV and Accenture.<br />
Brands in the services industry register much smaller followings than their counterparts in retail and<br />
sports. This is not a huge shock; there is less up-to-the-minute excitement occurring for some of the<br />
brands below. In this section, we’ll share how the Farmers Insurance connects with their audience on<br />
Facebook and how American Express builds strong connections on Twitter.<br />
The services brands with the largest followings may have fewer than our other categories, but that<br />
hasn’t impacted their engagement rates. By and large, they are consistent with the others.<br />
Brand Fans Fans<br />
Talking<br />
About<br />
Brand<br />
5,694<br />
4,431<br />
26,430<br />
11,235<br />
118,330<br />
10,531<br />
7,120<br />
4,088<br />
1,760<br />
1,566<br />
Engagement<br />
Ratio<br />
0.23%<br />
0.19%<br />
2.07%<br />
1.39%<br />
13.52%<br />
1.92%<br />
1.93%<br />
1.27%<br />
0.77%<br />
1.32%<br />
Brand Followers Total<br />
Posts<br />
CME Group<br />
CBOE<br />
American Express<br />
TEPCO<br />
Live Nation<br />
Ticketmaster<br />
Vanguard<br />
Comcast Digital<br />
Source: Data from The Fan Page List, as of June 19th, 2012.<br />
16<br />
Care Team<br />
DirecTV<br />
Accenture<br />
754,740<br />
730,686<br />
470,930<br />
256,166<br />
185,785<br />
73,356<br />
61,768<br />
57,835<br />
55,162<br />
48,354<br />
19,396<br />
6,153<br />
13,809<br />
2,805<br />
8,949<br />
9,891<br />
4,808<br />
52,446<br />
21,636<br />
4,176<br />
Followers<br />
Per Post<br />
38.91<br />
118.75<br />
34.10<br />
91.32<br />
20.76<br />
7.41<br />
12.85<br />
1.10<br />
2.55<br />
11.58
PROFILE ELEMENTS<br />
CONTENT<br />
<strong>Social</strong> <strong>Success</strong> <strong>Stories</strong><br />
Marketing Lessons from Industry Leaders<br />
Leading <strong>Services</strong> Facebook Brand: Farmers<br />
Profile/Cover<br />
Photo At the time<br />
of this paper’s<br />
publication, Farmers<br />
used their cover<br />
photo to promote a<br />
marketing event, in<br />
which winners earn<br />
two free tickets to<br />
attend a Rascal Flatts<br />
concert and meet the band. However, the cover image does not clearly define how one enters the<br />
contests, the terms and conditions, or when winners will be announced.<br />
Tabs: Farmers displays their photos with 11 albums, the summer Rascal Flatts concert promotion,<br />
their products, and a weather alert on their main page. For the additional tabs, they have integrated<br />
YouTube and an insurance quote generator. Some older tabs, though visible, are no longer<br />
supported.<br />
Frequency: 1-3 posts per week.<br />
Top Sites: Promoted Farmers rarely promotes other sites.<br />
<strong>Social</strong> Content Approach Farmers connects with its audience through small gestures and big<br />
campaigns. Besides the Rascal Flatts summer concert giveaway, they previously ran a campaign in<br />
conjunction with the release of summer blockbuster The Avengers, in which users were encouraged<br />
to make their own Farmers Agent superhero costumes.<br />
One post that struck a chord with Farmers fans was spontaneous. The author of the account posted<br />
a photo from a community baseball field that speaks to parents. It starts “He’s just a little boy” and<br />
reminds parents to keep perspective. It spread like wildfire on Facebook, generating nearly 15,000<br />
interactions, almost half of which were shares (and shares increase EdgeRank). Farmers seized<br />
the opportunity to capitalize on its popularity and created follow-up posts offering to buy up to 1,500<br />
posters for interested fans. The four total posts amounted to 27,663 social interactions.<br />
17
<strong>Social</strong> <strong>Success</strong> <strong>Stories</strong><br />
Marketing Lessons from Industry Leaders<br />
Leading <strong>Services</strong> Facebook Brand: Farmers (cont.)<br />
Farmers also hosts “Like” Donations for charities. For instance, they gave $1,000 for every 100,000<br />
views their mockumentary “The Lost Love”. By offering to donate $10 per fan to the March of Dimes,<br />
they increased their fan base by 2,500.<br />
One of Farmers most enduring qualities is their positivity and sense of humor. They are always<br />
driving ‘Likes’ by poking fun at themselves through jingle remixes, photos, and comments.<br />
Giveaway:s:/Contes:ts: Farmers also uses campaigns to grow engagement. They recently held<br />
their Star for a Day giveaway, where fans enter to win two tickets to any Rascal Flatts concert and go<br />
backstage to meet the band. To enter the competition, one must like the page and provide contact<br />
information.<br />
<strong>Web</strong>s:ite Integration Currently, Farmers isn’t integrating social channels on their website. They<br />
simply have a link to their social properties on the homepage. They could add their Facebook posts<br />
and Twitter stream to keep the home page vibrant and updated.<br />
In the near future, expect to see Farmers Insurance catch up to other leading brands – they are<br />
actively searching for a social media agency to help them grow their presence and engagement.<br />
How <strong>Social</strong> Leads: to Revenue Insurance isn’t the sexiest – Farmers is using<br />
Facebook to portray the brand as humorous, trustworthy, and ‘human.’ Ideally, this trust will translate<br />
into sales when their fans search for insurance. In fact, the page does have an “Our Products” tab<br />
that allows for direct conversions.<br />
18
PROFILE ELEMENTS<br />
<strong>Social</strong> <strong>Success</strong> <strong>Stories</strong><br />
Marketing Lessons from Industry Leaders<br />
CONTENT<br />
Leading <strong>Services</strong> Twitter Brand: American Express<br />
Followers: 470,426<br />
Following 18,143, with<br />
no apparent specific follow<br />
strategy.<br />
Background AmEx has<br />
a simple, on-brand, solid<br />
blue background.<br />
Frequency: Between 5-20 original Tweets per day, not including retweets and mentions. The record<br />
high was 35 tweets, occurring during an AmEx-sponsored Usher concert.<br />
Ratio of Pos:ts: to Replies: For a highly regulated industry, AmEx replies to fans often. Often,<br />
they send as many replies as tweets in a day.<br />
<strong>Social</strong> Content Approach<br />
AmEx is on the cutting edge of social media. They recently announced<br />
a partnership with Twitter that allows card members to sync their cards<br />
with the social media channel to redeem couponless offers.<br />
Member Benefits: AmEx frequently offers their card-holders additional rewards, designated by a<br />
#MembershipRewards hashtag.<br />
Contes:ts:/Giveaway:s: AmEx leverages their sizeable network and premium partnerships to bring<br />
members excellent contests and giveaways, like a chance to win a cruise.<br />
19
<strong>Social</strong> <strong>Success</strong> <strong>Stories</strong><br />
Marketing Lessons from Industry Leaders<br />
Leading <strong>Services</strong> Twitter Brand: American Express (cont.)<br />
Spons:ored Events: American Express puts on concerts and other high-profile events.<br />
#AmExUNSTAGED are AmEx-sponsored concerts.<br />
Cus:tomer Service AmEx congratulates members on purchases and solves customer<br />
complaints. In fact, fans regularly state they receive faster support on Twitter than by more traditional<br />
routes.<br />
Frequently: Us:ed Has:htags:<br />
AmEx generously uses hashtags,<br />
generally divided into two camps.<br />
The first is specific to events<br />
they are sponsoring or hosting,<br />
such as #InsideTheDream<br />
and #AmExUNSTAGED. They<br />
also regularly use hashtags to<br />
boost fan engagement such<br />
as #MembershipRewards, and<br />
#MembershipEffect.<br />
One particularly fun hashtag<br />
is #AmExmademytrip where<br />
cardholders share stories of their<br />
travels made easier with an AmEx<br />
card.<br />
<strong>Web</strong>s:ite Integration AmEx<br />
has low website integration. The<br />
homepage includes links to their<br />
main social channels. On all<br />
product offers, American Express<br />
offers social sharing on Twitter and<br />
Facebook.<br />
How <strong>Social</strong> Leads: to Revenue AmEx does a masterful job of highlighting (but not<br />
over-promoting) the many benefits that are exclusively for cardholders, such as advance tickets.<br />
20
<strong>Social</strong> <strong>Success</strong> <strong>Stories</strong><br />
Marketing Lessons from Industry Leaders<br />
Key Takeaways/Best Practices for <strong>Services</strong> Brands<br />
1. Strengthen Brand Pres:ence through<br />
Promotions: — American Express has done a great job at using<br />
Twitter to drive conversations (and benefitting while doing so). AmEx<br />
launched their Sync service, in partnership with Twitter, earlier in the<br />
year to allow cardholders to save money at shops and restaurants by<br />
tweeting a hashtag, and found the service used by millions. Because<br />
of this innovative program, AMEX was one of the most talked about<br />
companies at SXSW Interactive.<br />
2. Excel at Cus:tomer Service — Many large companies struggle with customer<br />
service. Complaints may be frequent, complicated, and pressing at all hours of the day. American<br />
Express has done a great job at using Twitter to alleviate those complaints. If a customer is having<br />
trouble getting a response or reaching a representative, @AskAmEx is readily available to help. A<br />
negative customer situation can easily be turned into a positive one with a quick Twitter reply.<br />
3. Lis:ten to Your Fans: — Pay attention to what your audience likes and which posts<br />
receive attention. These can lead to great opportunities to keep the social momentum going. If a<br />
posts receives a lot of likes, what else can you do to add to the conversation?<br />
4. Share Your Story: — In the service industry you need to make a strong connection<br />
with your customers. Farmers Director of <strong>Social</strong> Media, Ryon Harms, shares that he wasn’t using<br />
Facebook to tell people what they sell, but rather who they are.<br />
5. Stay: Light — Post positive content, and be able to laugh at yourself.<br />
21
<strong>Social</strong> <strong>Success</strong> <strong>Stories</strong><br />
Marketing Lessons from Industry Leaders<br />
Conclusion<br />
All of the best practice examples we have highlighted above adhere to several basic tenets: 1)<br />
Know your customers, 2) Engage them in new and creative ways, and 3) Listen and monitor postengagement.<br />
<strong>Social</strong> media allows companies to understand their customers deeply and then<br />
effectively engage them. And by listening and monitoring responses, you come to know your<br />
customers even better, and drive even more effective engagement. And so the cycle continues.<br />
One of the most beautiful things about social media is the speed at which this feedback loop of<br />
customer insight and action can take place. It can now happen faster than ever before. We hope<br />
these best practices enable you to better prosper from the new social landscape.<br />
Additional Resources<br />
The Fan Page List<br />
Check out more brands and their social statistics on the Fan Page List site.<br />
Five Killer Strategies to Dominate <strong>Social</strong> Media’s Big 3: Facebook, Twitter and YouTube<br />
Even with the increasing number of social networks, most experts still recognize that successful social<br />
marketing revolves around the Big 3: Facebook, Twitter and YouTube.<br />
How to Audit Your <strong>Social</strong> Marketing Efforts<br />
Learn how to evaluate the effectiveness of your current social marketing strategy. Identify new ways to<br />
improve the return on your social marketing investment.<br />
<strong>Social</strong> Engagement: How to Crack the Code of <strong>Social</strong> Interaction<br />
Engagement is the enduring effect of content to motivate an audience to do something; motivate your<br />
audience with data proven best practices.<br />
<strong>Social</strong> Commerce Lessons: The 6 <strong>Social</strong> Principles that Increase Sales<br />
Learn more about content strategies and driving sales.<br />
Actionable <strong>Social</strong> Analytics<br />
A detailed guide on how to approach your social analytics process.<br />
2102 <strong>Social</strong> Media and New Media Predictions<br />
This free e-book is full of insights on big data and other trending topics in social media. Hear from 32<br />
social media experts, including David Meerman Scott, Brian Solis, and Erik Qualman.<br />
The <strong>Social</strong> Funnel: Driving Business Value with <strong>Social</strong> Marketing<br />
For a detailed discussion on how to effectively measure your social marketing initiatives, download our<br />
free e-book.<br />
The State of <strong>Social</strong> Media Marketing: Top Areas For <strong>Social</strong> Marketing Investment and Biggest<br />
<strong>Social</strong> Marketing Challenges in 2012<br />
Learn how leaders allocate resources, discover the top social platforms and social media management<br />
tools they use, social marketing investment priorities, and the practices companies will adopt in 2012.<br />
22
<strong>Social</strong> <strong>Success</strong> <strong>Stories</strong><br />
Marketing Lessons from Industry Leaders<br />
About Awareness<br />
Awareness Inc. is the leading provider of enterprise-class, on-demand social marketing management<br />
software (SMMS) for marketers to publish and manage social content, engage with their audience<br />
and measure the effectiveness of their social media activities across multiple social media channels.<br />
The Awareness <strong>Social</strong> Marketing Hub is built upon Awareness’ expertise with some of the world’s<br />
leading brands and marketing agencies including MLB, Sony Pictures, Comcast, Likeable Media,<br />
Associated Press, Cox Communications, Mindjumpers and American Cancer Society.<br />
The Awareness <strong>Social</strong> Marketing Hub is built to address the challenges marketers face managing<br />
multiple social channels. The <strong>Social</strong> Marketing Hub is the first enterprise-class application for serious<br />
marketers who want to plan, implement and measure meaningful social media strategies across the<br />
organization.<br />
Get Connected:<br />
Follow us on Twitter<br />
@awarenessinc<br />
Join us on Facebook<br />
• <strong>Social</strong> Media Marketing Best Practices<br />
• <strong>Social</strong> Media Marketing Mavens<br />
Join our LinkedIn Group<br />
<strong>Social</strong> Media Marketing Mavens Group<br />
Check out our Blog<br />
Follow us on Pinterest<br />
23