08.06.2017 Views

w_U_201707

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

34567(& 6>5;<br />

& ˙) ˛˚)<br />

6< 68 ˚)) 6>5; ˙


˝˚B<br />

&"<br />

-\`\/1 `d1g ,\4,1k*b1Wn `*aaV*4m,*1b<br />

+S+W1yaVdp ,1abn \/Z\Yd S4 `*+\bZSV\,<br />

, q+W\Z1,\Y a*/dD<br />

˛˚#˚<br />

55= =76<br />

˛˚) <br />

9> 8;=<br />

6>5:˙˚˚˚<br />

<br />

5=> :57<br />

˙˚˝˚<br />

<br />

7<br />

&(<br />

˚˙ ˚)<br />

˙) ˝˚)<br />

,d`gSS<br />

<br />

;<br />

6< P 7˚))<br />

*V*]WS,*yb1 +\-*bab,\E<br />

V\b\`\1]\SabSZ1g1ZZ\<br />

ob\y ab*bn1 Ym \+ad/SYE V*V Sa]\Wn4\,*bn<br />

Y*b1`S*WnZm1 a`1/ab,*E hb\+m ]`S\+`1b*bn<br />

/`d41y Z* Z1+1 LdVS 5:B=MD Z1y b*V31 -\,\O<br />

`SbaqE V*V Z1 ab*bn `*+\Y *WhZ\-\ YS`* V\YY1`O<br />

gSS S V*V \b/*,*bn aWd31ZSp 1-\,1 ,a1 aSWmD<br />

<br />

56<br />

8P5> ˚))<br />

wW*hnb1 a ]W*hdkSYSx<br />

*V f`SabS*ZSZd a]`*,Sbnaq a +\Wnp \b ]\b1`S<br />

+WS4V\-\ h1W\,1V*H 1-\,* /*1b ab\Wn Z1\+f\/SO<br />

Y\1db1j1ZS1h1`14Sada*`Sab*Sf`SabS*ZaV\1<br />

a\+`*ZS1E * b*V31 a ]\Y\knp S+WSSD ob\y ab*O<br />

bn1 a\/1`3*baq a\,1bmE V\b\`m1 ]\Y\-db \+`1abS<br />

db1j1ZS1 ,a1Y aV\`+qkSYD<br />

<br />

5;<br />

55P5; ˚))<br />

\h1Yd Z*Y Zd3Z\ ,\af,*Wqbn<br />

1-\,dH<br />

58;Oy ]a*W\Y Z1\/Z\V`*bZ\ ]`S4m,*1b \3nSf<br />

aWd3Sb1W1y ,\af,*Wqbn 1-\,dD b\ 31 b*V ,]1h*bO<br />

WqW\ ]a*WY\]1,g* , 1-\,1H b,1b Ym \+ad/SY<br />

, ob\y ab*bn1D 4 Z11 Ym d4Z*1YE ]\h1Yd Z*Y b\31<br />

Zd3Z\ ,\4/*,*bn f,*Wd Z*j1Yd \-dD<br />

<br />

66<br />

5


&(<br />

˚˙ ˚)<br />

˙) ˝˚)<br />

, d`gSS<br />

˚,1V1f`SabS*Z1]`SW*O<br />

-*WS YZ\-\ daSWSyE hb\+m `*aaV*O<br />

4*bn w+W*-dp ,1abn \ g*`ab,1x V*V Y\3O<br />

Z\ +\Wnj1Yd hSaWd Wp/1y L*beD 68B58MD<br />

*/S ob\-\ Z1V\b\`m1 /*31 \b]`*,WqO<br />

WSan , /`d-S1 ab`*ZmD *VE ,\ ,`1Yq<br />

a,\Sf YSaaS\Z1`aVSf ]db1j1ab,Sy *]\aO<br />

b\W *,1W \aZ\,*b1WnZ\ ]`\]\,1/\,*W<br />

Z* b1``Sb\`SS a\,`1Y1ZZ\y d`gSSD<br />

]dabq ]`SY1`Z\ 6> ab\W1bSyE , 6>58 -\O<br />

/dE , d`gSS ]`\jW* a]1gS*WnZ*q ]`\]\O<br />

,1/ZSh1aV*q V*Y]*ZSqD *V*q d Z11 +mW*<br />

g1WnH Vb\ ]`SZqW , Z1y dh*abS1H<br />

Y\b`Sb1 +`\jp`d w\aY\b`Sb1 Z* t/\+`dp 41YWprxE<br />

ab`*ZSgm 76P77D<br />

WSa*<br />

w ˛˙˚& ˙Hx<br />

d`gSSE -/1 3S,1b \V\W\ YSWWS\Z\, h1W\,1VE<br />

,a1-\ hdbn +\Wnj1 6 > ,\4,1k*b1W1yD 'b\ 4Z*O<br />

hSbE hb\ Z* \/Z\-\ ,\4,1k*b1Wq ]`Sf\/Sbaq ]`SO<br />

+WS4Sb1WnZ\ 6< >>> 3Sb1W1yE S Y1abZmY +`*bnqY<br />

Z1 ]\/ aSWd `*aaV*4*bn +W*-dp ,1abn ,a1Y a,\O<br />

SY a\\b1h1ab,1ZZSV*YD \ob\Yd g1Wnp a]1gS*WnO<br />

Z\y ]`\]\,1/ZSh1aV\y V*Y]*ZSS +mW\ \f,*bSbn<br />

]`\]\,1/np V*V Y\3Z\ +\Wnj1 Wp/1yD `SY1`Z\<br />

99> ,\4,1k*b1W1yE -\,\`qkSf Z* bd`1gV\Y q4mV1E<br />

]`S1f*WS , d`gSp S4 `*4Zmf ab`*ZE hb\+m ,Y1ab1<br />

a Y1abZmYS +`*bnqYS S a1ab`*YS ]`SZqbn dh*abS1<br />

, ob\y V*Y]*ZSSD *VS1 ]W\/m \Z* ]`SZ1aW*H<br />

*Y]*ZSq ]`\jW* a `*4Y*f\YD `*bnq S4 a\+`*ZSq<br />

, b*Y+dW1 Z*]Sa*WSB wS/q Z*aE Wp/S a]`*jS,*O<br />

WSB t ,*a hb\ 4/1anE V*V\yOb\ al14/H d/* ZS -WqZnE<br />

,14/1 ,S/1b1WS 1-\,mIrx ,\b hb\ -\,\`SW\an<br />

, ]SanY1 S4 a\+`*ZSq , 4YS`1B wd3hSZ*E `*+\O<br />

b*,jSy Z* ab\qZV1 b*VaSE ]\/\j1W V Y1abZ\Yd ab*O<br />

`1yjSZ1 S a]`\aSWB tb\ 4/1an ]`\Saf\/SbH *V\1<br />

hd,ab,\E hb\ ,m ab*WS 1k1 *VbS,Z11rxD ˙*E V*Y]*O<br />

ZSq Z1 \ab*W*an Z14*Y1h1ZZ\y ab\`\ZZSYS Z*+WpO<br />

/*b1WqYSD<br />

1E Vb\ ]`S1f*W S4 /`d-Sf ab`*ZE +mWS ]`\ab\ , ,\aO<br />

b\`-1 \b aWd31ZSqD b1ee1Z S4 ˙*ZSS ]\/1WSWaqB<br />

w*3/my /1Zn q ,ab`1h*W b1fE Vb\ ZSV\-/* Z1<br />

aWmj*W \+ 1-\,1D q ]\ZqWE hb\ 4Z*hSb ]`\,\4O<br />

-W*j*bn SYq \-*xD ˝*ZO˙*,S/E ]`S1f*,jSyS4<br />

`*ZgSSE Z*]Sa*WB wm Z1aV\WnV\ h*a\, ]`\]\,1O<br />

/\,*WS Z* \/Z\y dWSg1D 'b\ +mW\ ]\b`qa*pk1I<br />

\WnjSZab,\ Wp/1y ZS `*4d Z1 ,ab`1h*WS ,S/1O<br />

b1W1y 1-\,mD \hbS d V*3/\y /,1`S Ym -\,\`SWS<br />

a Wp/nYSE ]\V*4m,*WS SY V*V\yOZS+d/n ,S/1\`\O<br />

WSV S \ab*,WqWS WSb1`*bd`dxD<br />

7


5 gdV\<br />

6 b1e*ZS L, g1Zb`1M<br />

7 p/S<br />

8 W1` L, g1Zb`1M<br />

9 *j*<br />

: ˛1yZ1]<br />

; 1/1`SV\<br />

< b1ee1Z<br />

5 6<br />

7 8<br />

a1-\ 4* /,1 Z1/1WS 99> ,\4,1k*b1W1y `*a]`\O<br />

ab`*ZSWS \V\W\ :> >>> ]d+WSV*gSyD 'bS gSe`m<br />

V`*aZ\`1hS,\ -\,\`qb \ b\YE a V*VSY `*4Y*f\Y<br />

]`\jW* V*Y]*ZSqD<br />

\4,1k*b1WS ab*WS aWd3Sbn 1k1 `1,Z\abZ11D 'b*<br />

V*Y]*ZSq aSWnZ\ ]\,WSqW* Z* Y1abZmf ,\4,1k*b1O<br />

W1yB YZ\-S1 4*/dY*WSan \ b\YE Z1 Z*h*bn WS SY<br />

aWd3Sbn ]\WZ\,`1Y1ZZ\D *V aW1/ab,S1E a]dabq -\/<br />

]\aW1 11 \V\Zh*ZSq hSaW\ ]S\Z1`\, , d`gSS ,\4O<br />

`\aW\ Z* 68 ]`\g1Zb*D<br />

\4,1k*b1WSE ]`S1f*,jS1 S4 /`d-Sf ab`*ZE `*aaV*O<br />

4m,*pbE hb\E ,1`Zd,jSan /\Y\yE \ZS ab*WS ]\O/`dO<br />

-\Yd aY\b`1bn Z* a,\1 aWd31ZS1D 1ab`* S4 1`Y*O<br />

ZSS ]\ SY1ZS "S`SZ Z*]Sa*W*B w`*bnq , d`gSS a<br />

W1-V\abnp ]`\]\,1/dpb Z1e\`Y*WnZ\D YZ1E ab1aO<br />

ZSb1WnZ\Yd h1W\,1VdE ob\ /*1baq a b`d/\YD /Z*V\<br />

+W*-\/*`q dh*abSp , a]1gS*WnZ\y V*Y]*ZSSE ]`SO<br />

Y1`d Y1abZmf +`*bn1, S YZ\-\hSaW1ZZmY Y\WSb,*Y<br />

q b1]1`n Y\-d /1W*bn b\E hb\ +mW\ YZ1 Z1 ]\/ aSO<br />

WdD ) /*31 ]`\]\,1/\,*W* , Y1b`\ S `*4/*,*W* b*Y<br />

+dVW1bmD 1yh*a q d31 Z1 b*V*q 4*ab1ZhS,*qE V*V<br />

`*Znj1xD<br />

,\b hb\ `*aaV*4*W \-*ZZ1a S4 1`Y*ZSSB w'b*<br />

V*Y]*ZSq V\1Oh1Yd Y1Zq Z*dhSW*D d`1gVS1 +`*bnq<br />

\h1Zn f\bqb `*aaV*4*bn SabSZd V*V Y\3Z\ +\Wnj1O<br />

Yd hSaWd Wp/1yD \ZS ]\Wn4dpbaq /Wq ob\-\ WpO<br />

+\y ,\4Y\3Z\abnpD 1`Zd,jSan , 1`Y*ZSpE q `1O<br />

jSW ]\abd]*bn b*V 31D 1yh*a q ]`\]\,1/dp +\WnO<br />

j1Yd hSaWd Wp/1yE h1Y `*Znj1xD<br />

1ab`* ]\ SY1ZS ˛1yZ1]E V\b\`*q ]`S1f*W* S4<br />

`*ZgSSE ]\/1WSW*anB w'b* V*Y]*ZSq aSWnZ\ ]\O<br />

,WSqW* Z* Y\1 aWd31ZS1D Z* ]`S/*W* YZ1 aY1W\O<br />

abS S Z*dhSW* +\Wnj1 ]\W*-*bnaq Z* 1-\,dxD<br />

\4,1k*b1WS a+WS4SWSan /`d- a /`d-\YD p+\,n S<br />

1/SZab,\E V\b\`m1 g*`SWS a`1/S +`*bn1, S a1ab1`<br />

S4 a*Ymf `*4Zmf ab`*ZE \ab*,SWS , Sf a1`/g*f Z1O<br />

S4-W*/SYmy aW1/D ˝*ZO˙*,S/E d]\YqZdbmy ,mj1E<br />

`*aaV*4*WB wm d,S/1WSE Z*aV\WnV\ Z*jS +`*bnq<br />

-\ab1]`SSYZmD ZS ]`SZqWS Z*a V*V a,\Sf /`dO<br />

41yE b*VE aW\,Z\ Ym +mWS Sf `\/ab,1ZZSV*YSD ZS<br />

\bV`mWS Z*Y /,1`S a,\1-\ /\Y*D ) 4Z*WE hb\ Z*j1<br />

+`*bab,\ Y13/dZ*`\/Z\1E S Z1 `*4 hSb*W \+ ob\Y<br />

, Z*j1y WSb1`*bd`1D /Z*V\ a1yh*a q d+1/SWaq ,<br />

8 ˝˚) ")


9 :<br />

; <<br />

ob\Y WShZ\D 1]1`n q 1k1 +\Wnj1 -\`3dan b1YE hb\<br />

]`SZ*/W13d V Z*`\/d 1-\,mE S +W*-\/*`p 1-\ 4*<br />

obd dZSV*WnZdp ,\4Y\3Z\abnxD<br />

1ab`* S4 `*ZgSS ]\ SY1ZS W1` Z*]Sa*W*B wa1<br />

Ym P Vb\ S4 ˙*ZSSE Vb\ S4 `*ZgSSE Vb\ S4 1`O<br />

Y*ZSS SWS d`gSS P +mWS \/Z\y a1Yn1yD \- aW\,O<br />

Z\ ab1` -`*ZSgm Y13/d ab`*Z*YS \-`\YZmY W*abSO<br />

V\YxD<br />

b1e*ZS S4 `*ZgSS ]\/1WSW*anB wW*-\/*`q<br />

a]1gS*WnZ\y V*Y]*ZSS Ym ]\ZqWSE hb\ Z*a \+l1/SO<br />

Zq1b Z1 VdWnbd`* SWS q4mVE * Wp+\,n V 1-\,1xD<br />

˙%E %˚ )& ˛˝˚<br />

Z\-S1 ,\4,1k*b1WSE ]`S1f*,jS1 S4 /`d-Sf ab`*ZE<br />

4*/dY*WSan Z*/ b1YE hb\+m ]1`11f*bn , d`gSpE<br />

,1/n b*Y 1k1 ]`1/ab\Sb a/1W*bn YZ\-\ `*+\bmD<br />

Z1Y*W\ +`*bn1, S a1ab1` d31 \adk1ab,SWS obd<br />

g1WnD f ]\Y\kn b`d/Z\ ]1`1\g1ZSbnD<br />

*VE , \/Z\y Z1+\Wnj\y d1/SZ1ZZ\y -`d]]1 S4 69<br />

,\4,1k*b1W1y /\W-S1 -\/m +mW b\WnV\ \/SZ ab*O<br />

`1yjSZ*D `1/ab*,nb1E V*V \+`*/\,*WSan obS +`*O<br />

bnq S a1ab`mE V\-/* , 6>59 -\/d V ZSY S4 1`Y*ZSS<br />

S S/1`W*Z/\, ]`S1f*WS j1abn ,\4,1k*b1W1yI<br />

˝˚˚ ˚˚˙•<br />

b\ -\,\`qb \ a,\1y 3S4ZS , d`gSS b1E Vb\ bd/* ]1O<br />

`11f*WH \`\y \ZS ab*WVS,*pbaq a b`d/Z\abqYSE<br />

\/Z*V\ Sf ]1`114/ ]`SZ1a SY YZ\-\ `*/\abSD \b<br />

hb\ \ZS a*YS \+ ob\Y `*aaV*4m,*pbD<br />

1/1`SV\E 31Z*bmy +`*b S4 a]*ZSSE V\b\`\Yd<br />

4* 8>E /1WSbaqB wW*-\/*`q b\YdE hb\ d Y1Zq Z1 b*V<br />

YZ\-\ ,1k1y S q V ZSY Z1 ]`S,q4*ZE q hd,ab,dp a1O<br />

+q +\W11 a,\+\/Z\ S Y\-d a\a`1/\b\hSbnaq Z*<br />

b\YEhb\,*3Z11,a1-\xD\a\,1b\,*W+m\Z/`d-SY<br />

]\1f*bn aWd3Sbn , /`d-dp ab`*ZdH w/Z\4Z*hZ\I P<br />

-\,\`Sb \ZDP \-/* ]1`1143*1jn , /`d-dp ab`*ZdE<br />

hb\+m ]\Y\-*bn Wp/qY d4Z*bn 1-\,dE bmE ]\ adO<br />

bSE ]\WZ\abnp ,,1`q1jn a1+q 1YdD bm V*V ZSV\-O<br />

/* ]`13/1 hd,ab,d1jn 1-\ 4*+\bdxD<br />

˝1Z*bmy +`*b ]\ SY1ZS p/S S4 S/1`W*Z/\,E<br />

V\b\`\Yd 4* 9>E ]\/1WSWaq a,\SYS hd,ab,*YSB w*V<br />

31 ob\ 4/\`\,\ P aWd3SbnE b*V aV*4*bnE Z* ]1`1/\O<br />

,\y S `*aaV*4m,*bn \+ SabSZ1 YZ\-SY Wp/qYE<br />

(& 6>5; 9


V\b\`m1ZSV\-/*\Z1yZ1aWmj*WSI*V]`SqbZ\,SO<br />

/1bnE V\-/* Vb\Ob\ \bVWSV*1baq Z* +W*-dp ,1abnxD<br />

`*b S4 1`Y*ZSS ]\ SY1ZS *j*E V\b\`\Yd 4*<br />

8>E aV*4*WB w*3/my `*4E Z*f\/qan , aWd31ZSSE q<br />

,ab`1h*p b1fE Vb\ aWmjSb SabSZd ,]1`,m1D `d/Z\<br />

]1`1/*bn aW\,*YSE V*V q ah*abWS,E hb\ Y\-d ]\Y\hn<br />

SY d4Z*bn 1-\,dIx<br />

˛*Yd3Zqq a1ab`* S4 )]\ZSS ]\ SY1ZS gdV\E V\O<br />

b\`\y 4* 7>E `*aaV*4*W*B w*Znj1 q f\b1W*E hb\+m<br />

`Y*-1//\Z ]`Sj1W ]\+mab`11D /Z*V\ ]\aW1 ]1O<br />

`114/* , d`gSp q Z*h*W* +W*-\/*`Sbn 1-\,d 4*<br />

b\E hb\ \Z ,a1 1k1 ]`\q,Wq1b b1`]1ZS1D 1Y +\WnO<br />

j1 q ,S3dE V*V 1-\,* Z*]`*,Wq1b a\+mbSqE b1Y<br />

+\Wnj1 YZ1 f\h1baq ab*bn V Z1Yd 1k1 +WS31xD<br />

,\baW\,*WSam S4 \aaSSE V\b\`\y Z1YZ\-\<br />

4* 7>B wWd3* 1-\,1 b*VSY \+`*4\YE q aY\-W*<br />

,VdaSbn S d4Z*bnE V*V \Z /\+`x LaD 78B


*V*]WS,*yb1 +\-*bab,\E<br />

V\b\`\1]\SabSZ1g1ZZ\<br />

w`S\+`1b*yb1 a1+1 /`d41y Z1]`*,1/ZmY +\-*bab,\Yx<br />

L 5:B=MD<br />

˚˚) oV\Z\YSh1aV*q aSab1Y* Z1a]`*,1/WS,* S +1aO<br />

]\k*/Z*D \W\/13n h*ab\ Z1 Y\31b Z*ybS `*+\bdD Z\-S1 `SO<br />

aVdpb 3S4ZnpE ]mb*qan ]1`1+`*bnaq , `*4,Sbm1 ab`*ZmD \,a1O<br />

Y1abZ\ `*a]`\ab`*Z1Z* +1/Z\abnE /*31 , ]`\g,1b*pkSf ab`*O<br />

Z*fD ]`\]*abn Y13/d +\-*bmYS S +1/ZmYS `*ab1bD \-W*aZ\<br />

Z1/*,ZSY \g1ZV*YE Y*b1`S*WnZ\1 +W*-\a\ab\qZS1 5 ]`\g1Zb*<br />

a*Ymf +\-*bmf Wp/1y YS`* a`*,ZqW\an a a\,\Vd]ZmY a\ab\qZSO<br />

1Y \ab*WnZmf == ]`\g1Zb\, 3Sb1W1y ]W*Z1bmD \bq obS /*ZZm1<br />

b`d/Z\ ]`\,1`SbnE ZSVb\ Z1 +d/1b a]\`Sbn a b1YE hb\ Z1 \/SZ<br />

YSWWS*`/ h1W\,1V 3S,1b \h1Zn +1/Z\E , b\ ,`1Yq V*V d /`d-Sf<br />

ab\WnV\ /1Z1-E hb\ Sf f,*bSW\ +m Z* YZ\-\ 3S4Z1yD Sada `SO<br />

ab\a ]\/b,1`/SW obd -\`nVdp SabSZdE aV*4*,B w1/Zm1 ,a1-/* +dO<br />

/db a ,*YSx L*`D 58B;MD h1Y ]`ShSZ* b*V\-\ Z1`*,1Zab,*H<br />

6 Sada ]\ZSY*WE hb\ ob* oV\Z\YSh1aV*q aSab1Y* Z1 S4Y1ZSbO<br />

aqE ]\V* Z1 ]`S/1b *`ab,\ \-*D WhZ*q V\YY1`h1aV*q aSab1Y*E<br />

]`1/ab*,W1ZZ*q , bV`\,1ZSS 5


7 `SabS*Z*Y ,*3Z\ *Z*WS4S`\,*bn a,\1<br />

\bZ\j1ZS1 V V\YY1`h1aV\y aSab1Y1E 4*/*O<br />

,*q a1+1 b*VS1 ,\]`\amB w*V q Y\- +m SaO<br />

]\Wn4\,*bn Y*b1`S*WnZm1 a`1/ab,*E hb\+m<br />

]\V*4*bn a,\p ,1`Z\abn \-dH *V YZ1 1k1<br />

Y1Znj1 a\]`SV*a*bnaq a YS`\Y V\YY1`O<br />

gSSH *VS1 aWdh*S ]\V*4m,*pbE hb\E 3S,q<br />

, ob\Y 31ab\V\Y S Z1a]`*,1/WS,\Y YS`1E<br />

f`SabS*Z1 ]\WZ\abnp /\,1`qpb 1-\,1Hx<br />

˚˚˙<br />

)(#˚<br />

8 ˛*hSb*y dVS 5:B5P=D `Sbh* SO<br />

ada* \ Z1]`*,1/Z\Y d]`*,Wqpk1Y Y\31b<br />

YZ\-\Yd Z*a Z*dhSbnD \aW1 b\-\ V*V<br />

ob\-\ d]`*,Wqpk1-\ \+,SZSWS , `*ab\O<br />

hSb1WnZ\abSE \Z ]`\q,SW w]`*VbSh1aVdp<br />

Yd/`\abnx S ]`S\+`1W /`d41yE hb\+m \ZS<br />

]\Y\-WS 1YdE V\-/* \Z \ab*Z1baq +14 `*+\O<br />

bmD SadaE +14daW\,Z\E Z1 ]\+d3/*W a,\O<br />

Sf dh1ZSV\, ]\abd]*bn Z1]`*,1/Z\E hb\+m<br />

V*VOb\ ]`\3Sbn , ob\Y YS`1E ,1/n b1fE Vb\<br />

b*V ]\abd]*1bE \Z Z*4,*W wamZ\,nqYS ob\y<br />

aSab1Ym ,1k1yxD \ a ]\Y\knp ob\y ]`SbO<br />

hS \Z f\b1W ]\/h1`VZdbn \/Zd ,*3Zdp<br />

YmaWnD<br />

9 Sada 4Z*WE hb\E ]\/\+Z\ d]`*,Wqpk1O<br />

YdE V\b\`my \V*4*Waq , 4*b`d/ZSb1WnZ\Y<br />

]\W\31ZSSE +\WnjSZab,\ f`SabS*Z /\WO<br />

3Zm +d/db 4*`*+*bm,*bn Z* 3S4ZnE SY1q<br />

/1W\ a Z1a]`*,1/WS,\y V\YY1`h1aV\y aSO<br />

ab1Y\yD \ob\Yd \Z ]`S4m,*W SfB w`SO<br />

\+`1b*yb1 a1+1 /`d41y Z1]`*,1/ZmY +\O<br />

-*bab,\YE hb\+mE V\-/* \Z\ SaaqVZ1bE \ZS<br />

1-\,* S Sada ]`SZqWS ,*a , ,1hZm1<br />

3SWSk*xD *V Ym Y\31Y ]`SY1ZSbn ob\b<br />

a\,1bH<br />

Sada ZSh1-\ Z1 aV*4*W \ b\YE +mW\ WS ob\ \+,SO<br />

Z1ZS1 a]`*,1/WS,mYD `1h1aV\1 aW\,\E ]1`1,1/1ZO<br />

Z\1 , dVS 5:B5 -W*-\W\Y w/\Z1aWSxE Y\31b dV*O<br />

4m,*bn Z* b\E hb\ d]`*,Wqpk1-\ \VW1,1b*WSD Sada<br />

a\a`1/\b\hSW ,ZSY*ZS1 Z1 Z* b\YE ]\h1Yd d]`*,WqpO<br />

k1-\ d,\WSWSE * Z* b\YE V*V \Z Z* ob\ \b`1*-S`\,*WD<br />

7D *VS1 ,\]`\am Ym `*aaY\b`SYH<br />

8E 9D *M V*V\Y ]\W\31ZSS \V*4*Waq d]`*,WqpO<br />

kSy S4 ]`SbhS Sada*H +M h1Yd Sada ]`S4,*W<br />

a,\Sf ]\aW1/\,*b1W1yH<br />

: \bq Sada Z1 \+lqaZSWE ]\h1Yd \Z<br />

Z*4,*W +\-*bab,\ wZ1]`*,1/ZmYxE S+WSq<br />

]\V*4m,*1bE hb\ ]\q,W1ZS1 V\YY1`h1aVSf<br />

\bZ\j1ZSy Z1 ,f\/SW\ , 4*Yma1W \-*D<br />

'/1YaV\Y a*/d 1-\,* k1/`\ /*W /*O<br />

Yd S ˚,1 ,a1E , h1Y \ZS Zd3/*WSan LmbD<br />

6B59E 5:MD V\-/* a,qb\y /df ab*W /1yab,\O<br />

,*bn Z* a\+`*ZS1 ]\Y*4*ZZmf f`SabS*Z ,<br />

]1`,\Y ,1V1E wZSVb\ ZSh1-\ S4 a,\1-\ SYdO<br />

k1ab,* Z1 Z*4m,*W a,\SY a\+ab,1ZZmYE Z\<br />

,a1 d ZSf +mW\ \+k11x L˙1qZD 8B76MD `\O<br />

`\V a*Sq ]`1/aV*4*WE hb\ Z*abd]Sb ,`1O<br />

YqE V\-/* ,a1 Wp/S +d/db Z*aW*3/*bnaq /*O<br />

`*YSE V\b\`m1 , S4\+SWSS /*ab SY 41YWq<br />

LaD 69B:P=E :9B65E 66MD ]\V* ]\aW1/\,*O<br />

b1WqY Sada* Zd3Z\ ]`\q,Wqbn w]`*VbSh1O<br />

aVdp Yd/`\abnxE hb\+m 4*`*+*bm,*bn a1+1<br />

Z* 3S4ZnE Sa]\Wn4dq wZ1]`*,1/Z\1 +\-*bO<br />

ab,\x ob\-\ YS`*E S , b\ 31 ,`1Yq d-\3/*bn<br />

\-dD<br />

˙ &˛•˚&<br />

˚˚˙% <br />

; ˛*hSb*y dVS 5:B5>P57D ]`*,WqpO<br />

kSy S4 ]`SbhS Sada* ]`S\+`1W /`d41yE<br />

]`1aW1/dq V\`mabZm1 g1WSD /Z*V\ SO<br />

ada ]`S4m,*W a,\Sf ]\aW1/\,*b1W1y ]`SO<br />

\+`1b*bn a1+1 /`d41y Z* Z1+1 S4 ]`*,SWnO<br />

Zmf ]\+d3/1ZSyD ˛*V\ZhS, `*aaV*4m,*bn<br />

]`SbhdE Sada ]\V*4*W a,q4n Y13/d b1YE<br />

V*V Ym ]\Wn4d1Yaq Z1]`*,1/ZmY +\-*bO<br />

ab,\YE S Z*j1y ,1`Z\abnp \-dD Sada f\O<br />

b1W ]\/h1`VZdbnE hb\ Ym Y\31Y +mbn<br />

w,1`ZmYS , \+`*k1ZSS a Z1]`*,1/ZmY +\O<br />

-*bab,\YxE b\ 1abn ]`*,SWnZ\ 1-\ Sa]\WnO<br />

4\,*bnD *V Ym Y\31Y ob\ /1W*bnH<br />

< /SZ S4 \aZ\,Zmf a]\a\+\, /\V*4*bn<br />

a,\p ,1`Z\abn \-dE `*a]\`q3*qan Y*b1O<br />

`S*WnZmYS a`1/ab,*YSEP ob\ 31`b,\,*bn<br />

/1Zn-S Z* ,a1YS`Z\1 /1W\ ]`\]\,1/SE \ V\O<br />

b\`\Y -\,\`SW Sada L*beD 68B58MD \/O<br />

:D \h1Yd Y\3Z\ aV*4*bnE hb\ ]\q,W1ZS1 V\YO<br />

Y1`h1aV\y aSab1Ym Z1 ,f\/SW\ , 4*Yma1W \-*H<br />

;D *V\y a\,1b a\/1`3Sbaq , dVS 5:B5>P57H<br />


Z\y /1,\hVS S4 Z/SS +mW* Y*W1ZnV*q V\O<br />

]SWV*E Vd/* \Z* SZ\-/* +`\a*W* Y\Z1bO<br />

VSD */S ob\-\ \Z* /*31 \bV*4m,*W*an \b<br />

]\Vd]VS S-`dj1VD \-/* V\]SWV* Z*]\WZSO<br />

W*anE \Z* \b/*W* ,a1 /1Zn-S Z* /1W\ ]`\O<br />

]\,1/SD /SZ +`*bE V\b\`my b\31 3S,1b ,<br />

Z/SSE ,m`*kS,*1b V\V\amD 1Y*Wdp Sf<br />

h*abn \Z 31`b,d1b , Y*W*qW*YaVSy d/*W1ZO<br />

Zmy ]1`1,\/h1aVSy \eSaD 'b\b +`*b `*aO<br />

ad3/*1b b*VB ]\aV\WnVd , \eSa ,a1 `*,Z\<br />

Zd3Z\ ]\Vd]*bn V\V\amE 31`b,\,*bn b*VSY<br />

a]\a\+\Y Wdhj1E h1Y \b/*,*bn /1Zn-SD *V<br />

\Z ]`\q,Wq1b ]`*VbSh1aVdp Yd/`\abnD \O<br />

/\+ZmY \+`*4\Y +`*bnq , `1gSS ]\ab\qZO<br />

Z\ 31`b,dpb ,1eSWnaV\y a1Yn1 \WS,V\,\1<br />

Y*aW\E am` S /`d-S1 ]`\/dVbmD<br />

= /SZ +`*b S4 "`SO*ZVSE V\b\`my<br />

a1yh*a 3S,1b , /`d-\y ab`*Z1E ]`1/\ab*O<br />

,SW a,\y /\Y S 41Y1WnZmy dh*ab\V /Wq<br />

]`\,1/1ZSq ,ab`1h a\+`*ZSq S V\Z-`1aO<br />

a\,E * b*V31 `*4`1jSWE hb\+m , /\Y1 3SWS<br />

]\WZ\,`1Y1ZZm1 aWd3Sb1WSD \bq ob\ Z1<br />

]`SZ\aSb 1Yd ZSV*V\y Y*b1`S*WnZ\y ,mO<br />

-\/mE b*V \Z \V*4m,*1b \-`\YZdp ]\Y\kn<br />

Y1abZmY ,\4,1k*b1WqYE V\b\`m1 \-`*ZSO<br />

h1Zm , a`1/ab,*fD \/Z\y S4 ab`*ZE -/1 Z*<br />

Z*jd ]`\]\,1/ZSh1aVdp /1qb1WnZ\abn Z*O<br />

W\31Zm \-`*ZSh1ZSqE +`*bnq ]\4,\WqpbE<br />

hb\+m Sf /\Y Sa]\Wn4\,*Waq V*V ˛*W *`O<br />

ab,*D W*-\/*`q ob\Yd ]S\Z1`*Y S /`d-SY<br />

,\4,1k*b1WqYE d V\b\`mf Z1 b*V YZ\-\ /1O<br />

Z1-E Z1 Zd3Z\ *`1Z/\,*bn ]\Y1k1ZS1 /Wq<br />

]`\,1/1ZSq ,ab`1h a\+`*ZSqD<br />

5> 'bS ]`SY1`m ]\V*4m,*pbE V*V aWd3SO<br />

b1WS \-* ]`\q,Wqpb ,1`Z\abn w, Y*W\YxB<br />

\ZS ]`*,SWnZ\ ]\Wn4dpbaq Y*b1`S*WnZmO<br />

YS a`1/ab,*YSE V\b\`m1 Z1 S/db ZS , V*V\1<br />

5>D *VS1 +W*-\aW\,1ZSq Ym ]\Wdh*1YE V\-/*<br />

]`\q,Wq1Y k1/`\abnH<br />

a`*,Z1ZS1 a +1ag1ZZmY /df\,ZmY +\-*bO<br />

ab,\Y LdVS 5:B5>MD b\ hd,ab,dpb /`d4nq<br />

1-\,mE S/q Z* b*VS1 31`b,mH ZS ]\ZSO<br />

Y*pbEhb\E ]`\q,Wqq k1/`\abnE \ZS \+`1b*O<br />

pb SabSZZ\1 +\-*bab,\ LdVS 5:B55MD /O<br />

Z* a1ab`*E V\b\`*q `1-dWq`Z\ 31`b,d1b Z*<br />

/1W\ *`ab,*E /1WSbaqE V*VS1 +W*-\aW\,1O<br />

ZSq \Z* ]\Wdh*1bB w* ]`\bq31ZSS W1b q<br />

]`\q,Wqp k1/`\abn , Y*b1`S*WnZ\Y ]W*O<br />

Z1D q 4*Y1bSW* SZb1`1aZdp ,4*SY\a,q4nB<br />

h1Y +\Wnj1 q 31`b,dpE b1Y +\W11 k1/O<br />

`\y q ab*Z\,Wpan , \+`*k1ZSS a /`d-SYSD<br />

1]1`n q \f\bZ11 ]`\k*pE ]`\q,Wqp b1`O<br />

]1ZS1E ]`SZSY*p a\,1bm S a]\V\yZ11 \bO<br />

Z\jdan V `*4\h*`\,*ZSqYxD Z\-S1 d+1/SO<br />

WSanE hb\ k1/`\abn \+\-*k*1b , /df\,Z\Y<br />

\bZ\j1ZSS LaD 556B9C `SbD 66B=MD<br />

55 m b*V31 ]`\q,Wq1Y w]`*VbSh1aVdp<br />

Yd/`\abnxE V\-/* Sa]\Wn4d1Y Y*b1`S*WnO<br />

Zm1 a`1/ab,*E hb\+m ]\//1`3S,*bn /`d-Sf<br />

+`*bn1,Sa1ab1`,SfaWd31ZSS\-dD1Ed<br />

V\-\ 1abn /1Z13Zm1 a`1/ab,*E Z\ V\Yd \+O<br />

ab\qb1Wnab,* Z1 ]\4,\Wqpb aWd3Sbn ]\WO<br />

Z\,`1Y1ZZ\ SWS ]1`11f*bn , /`d-dp ab`*O<br />

ZdE `*/mE hb\ a,\SYS ]\31`b,\,*ZSqYS Y\O<br />

-db a\/1yab,\,*bn /1Wd ]`\]\,1/S L`SbD<br />

5=B5;MD W*-\/*`q Z*jSY /\+`\,\WnZmY<br />

]\31`b,\,*ZSqY +W*-*q ,1abn ]`\,\4-W*O<br />

j*1baq , +1/Zmf ab`*Z*fE -/1 YZ\-S1 SZO<br />

b1`1adpbaq SabSZ\yC V`\Y1 b\-\E d Y1abO<br />

Zmf ,\4,1k*b1W1y 1abn WSb1`*bd`*D *ZnO<br />

j1 , b*VSf ab`*Z*fE V*V ˙1Y\V`*bSh1aV*q<br />

1a]d+WSV* \Z-\E */*-*aV*` S d*Z/*E<br />

+`*bnq h*ab\ ab\qWS ]1`1/ ,m+\`\YB<br />

55D *M *V 1k1 Ym Y\31Y ]`\q,Wqbn w]`*VbSh1O<br />

aVdp Yd/`\abnxH +M `S,1/Sb1 ]`SY1` b\-\E V*V<br />

, Z*`\/1 \-* `*,Z\Y1`Z\ `*a]`1/1Wqpbaq ]\O<br />

31`b,\,*ZSqD LY\b`Sb1 SWWpab`*gSp , Z*h*W1<br />

ab*bnSDM<br />

˙˚& •O˝˚˚<br />

*j* ,a1YS`Z*q +S+W1yaV*q ]`\a,1bSb1WnZ*q S -dY*ZSb*`O<br />

Z*q /1qb1WnZ\abn ]\//1`3S,*1baq /\+`\,\WnZmYS ]\31`bO<br />

,\,*ZSqYSD b\+m a/1W*bn \ZW*yZO]\31`b,\,*ZS1E 4*y/Sb1<br />

Z* a*yb jwDorg S ,ZS4d Wp+\y ab`*ZSgm Z*3YSb1 Z* aamWVd<br />

w/1W*bn ]\31`b,\,*ZS1 Z* Z*jd ,a1YS`Zdp /1qb1WnZ\abnxD


Z*V\`YSbn a1Ynp SWS Vd]Sbn S+WSpE ab\O<br />

SY\abn V\b\`\y SZ\-/* `*,ZqW*an `*4Y1O<br />

`d Z1/1WnZ\-\ SWS Y1aqhZ\-\ 4*`*+\bV*D<br />

1]1`n 31 +W*-\/*`q k1/`mY ]\31`b,\,*O<br />

ZSqY S Sf w`*,Z\Y1`Z\Yd `*a]`1/1W1ZSpx<br />

\`-*ZS4*gSq 1-\,m 4*+\bSbaq \ b\YE hb\O<br />

+m S+WSq ]1`1,\/SW*an Z* `*4Zm1 q4mVS<br />

Shb\+mV*3/myhW1Za1YnSSV*3/myS4dO<br />

h*pkSy SY1WS a\+ab,1ZZmy oV41Y]Wq`<br />

,qk1ZZ\-\ Sa*ZSqD L˛*hSb*y 6 \`SZO<br />

eqZ*Y MD<br />

58 b\+m ,1abS ]`\abdp 3S4ZnE ,*3Z\<br />

]`*,SWnZ\ \]`1/1WSbn ]`S\`Sb1bmD /Z*<br />

]*`* ,W*/1W* ]`1/]`SqbS1YE V\b\`\1 ]`SO<br />

Z\aSW\ +\Wnjdp ]`S+mWnD /Z*V\ ad]`dO<br />

-S \h1Zn f\b1WS ,\4\+Z\,Sbn ]\WZ\,`1O<br />

Y1ZZ\1 aWd31ZS1E ]\ob\Yd ]`\/*WS a,\y<br />

+S4Z1aE V*b1` S /`d-\1 SYdk1ab,\D \aO<br />

W1 ob\-\ \ZS \b]`*,SWSan /\+`\,\Wng*O<br />

YS Z* ab`\Sb1Wnab,\ ,a1YS`Z\-\ -W*,Z\O<br />

-\ d]`*,W1ZSq , \`,SV1 Ljb*b npO•\`VE<br />

"MDa\+mY+W*-\aW\,1ZS1Y/WqZSf<br />

+mW\ b\E hb\ \ZS aWd3SWS , 1eSW1 ,Y1ab1<br />

a\ a,\1y /\h1`np S 4qb1YE * Z* ]`\bq31ZSS<br />

Z1aV\WnVSf Z1/1Wn P a `\/Sb1WqYS Yd3*E<br />

V\b\`m1 b\31 b`d/SWSan , \`,SV1D ,\b<br />

/`d-\y ]`SY1`D 1ab`*O]S\Z1` S4 \W\O<br />

`*/\ L"M dab`\SW*an Z* `*+\bd , +*ZO<br />

V1 a Z1]\WZmY `*+\hSY /Z1YD *h*Wnab,\<br />

+mW\ b*V /\,\WnZ\ 11 `*+\b\yE hb\ ]`1/O<br />

W\3SW\ d,1WShSbn 11 4*`]W*bd , b`S `*O<br />

4*E 1aWS \Z* a\-W*aSbaq `*+\b*bn ]\WZmy<br />

58D * hb\ Ym /\W3Zm Z*ab`\SbnaqH `S,1/Sb1<br />

]`SY1`mD<br />

5> ˝˚) ")


1ZnD 1ab`* \bV*4*W*an \b ob\-\ 4*Y*ZhSO<br />

,\-\ ]`1/W\31ZSqE ,1/n b\-/* \Z* Z1 aY\-O<br />

W* +m ab*,Sbn aWd31ZS1 Z* ]1`,\1 Y1ab\<br />

,3S4ZSD'b\,a1-\WSjn/,*]`SY1`*b\O<br />

-\E Z* V*VS1 31`b,m S/db YZ\-S1 aWd3Sb1O<br />

WS 1-\,mD *j1 -\`qh11 31W*ZS1 SaV*bn<br />

]`13/1 *`ab,\ ]\V*4m,*1bE hb\ /`d3+d a<br />

\-\Y S /df\,Z\1 +\-*bab,\ Ym g1ZSY Z*O<br />

YZ\-\ +\Wnj1 b\-\E hb\ Y\31b ]`1/W\3Sbn<br />

Z*Y YS` V\YY1`gSSD<br />

˙ w˚˚˙˚ x<br />

)˚<br />

59 *b1`S*WnZmy /\ab*b\V Z1 \+q4*b1WnO<br />

Z\ a,S/1b1Wnab,d1b \ \3n1Y \/\+`1ZSSD<br />

1-\,* +W*-\aW\,Wq1b b1fE Vb\ ab*`*1baq<br />

w+\-*b1bn /\+`mYS /1W*YSxD L˛*hSb*y<br />

5SY\e1p :B5;P5=DM \b \/SZ ]`SY1`D<br />

4Z*,E hb\ , W+*ZSS Z1 f,*b*1b ]`\]\,1/O<br />

ZSV\,E phSqE V\b\`*q 3SW* , b*WSSE<br />

]1`11f*W* bd/* , 5==7 -\/dD Z11 Z1 +mO<br />

W\ ZSV*VSf a+1`131ZSyE S \Z* ]\WZ\abnp<br />

]\W\3SW*an Z* 1-\,dD Z* \,W*/1W* *WO<br />

+*ZaVSY q4mV\YE S +W*-\/*`q 1y +\W11<br />

:> h1W\,1V aY\-WS ]\a,qbSbn a,\p 3S4Zn<br />

1-\,1D\Z1hZ\E+\WnjSZab,\f`SabS*Z<br />

aWd3*bb*YE-/1SZb1`1aVSabSZ1Z1b*V,1O<br />

WSVD /Z*V\ ,a1Ehb\Ym/1W*1YEhb\+m]\O<br />

Y\hn /`d-SY Z*ybS ]dbn 3S4ZS S \ab*,*bnO<br />

aq Z* Z1YE \h1Zn g1ZZ\D *V Ym Z*V*]WS,*O<br />

1Y Z1]`1f\/qkS1 a\V`\,Sk* L*beD :B6>MD<br />

5: Sada aV*4*W \ Z1]`*,1/Z\Y +\-*bO<br />

ab,1B wDDDV\-/* \Z\ SaaqVZ1bxE * Z1 w1aWS<br />

\Z\ SaaqVZ1bx LdVS 5:B=MD 'V\Z\YSh1aO<br />

VS1 S +*ZV\,aVS1 V`S4SamE V\b\`m1 ab*WS<br />

\+mhZmY q,W1ZS1Y , obS ]\aW1/ZS1 /ZSE<br />

Z1 S/db ZS , V*V\1 a`*,Z1ZS1 a b1YE hb\<br />

]`\S4\y/1b ,\ ,a1Y YS`1 , +WS3*yj1Y<br />

S\-`*eSq phSS daa*Z1bb +mW* \]d+WSV\,*O<br />

Z* , 3d`Z*W1 w`\+d/Sb1anIx \b 66 SpZq 6>>7 -\/*E<br />

ab`*ZSgm 5


wW*hnb1 a ]W*hdkSYSx<br />

wb1j*yb1 /`d- /`d-* S dV`1]Wqyb1 /`d- /`d-*x<br />

L5 ˚D 9B55MD<br />

˚B =>E 555<br />

˚ %H<br />

<br />

*V 1-\,* db1j*1b a,\Sf<br />

aWd3Sb1W1yH<br />

<br />

*VS1 +S+W1yaVS1 abSfS<br />

Y\-db db1jSbn b\-\E Vb\<br />

]\b1`qW +WS4V\-\ h1W\,1V*H<br />

<br />

*V hW1Zm a\+`*ZSq Y\-db<br />

db1jSbn b1fE Vb\ aV\`+SbH<br />

w -\/ ]\aW1 aY1`bS Z*j1-\ amZ* Ym Sa]mbm,*WS<br />

Z1ab1`]SYdp +\WnxEP ]\/1WSW*an f`SabS*ZV* ]\ SY1ZS dO<br />

4SD \/SZ +`*b `*aaV*4*WE hb\E V\-/* Z1\3S/*ZZ\ dY1`W*<br />

1-\ 31Z*E \Z hd,ab,\,*W waSWnZ1yjdp eS4Sh1aVdp +\WnxD<br />

a\3*W1ZSpE obS ]`SY1`m Z1 SaVWph1ZS1D Z\-S1 f`SabSO<br />

*Z1E ,\4Y\3Z\E Z1 \3S/*WSE hb\ /\ `Y*-1//\Z* SY ]`S/1bO<br />

aq ]\b1`qbn V\-\Ob\ S4 `\/ZmfD ˚aWS ,m SWS ,*jS 4Z*V\Ym1<br />

]1`13SWS Z1hb\ ]\/\+Z\1E d ,*a Y\31b ,\4ZSVZdbn ,\]`\aB<br />

w*V ]\Y\hn b1YE Vb\ aV\`+SbE \]`*,Sbnaq \b -\`qHx<br />

6 *Y Z*,1`ZqV* 4Z*V\Y\ b*V\1 ,maV*4m,*ZS1B w`1Yq W1O<br />

hSbxD \ /1yab,Sb1WnZ\ WS ,`1Yq a*Y\ ]\ a1+1 Y\31b 4*O<br />

W1hSbn /dj1,Zm1 `*ZmH \b hb\ aV*4*W* \/Z* ,/\,*B wZ1<br />

V*31baqE ]`*,SWnZ11 +d/1b aV*4*bnE hb\ h1W\,1V* Y\31b ,mO<br />

W1hSbn b\E V*V \Z Sa]\Wn4d1b a,\1 ,`1YqxD ˚aWS b1`]1WS,\ W1O<br />

hSbn +dV,*WnZdp `*ZdE a\ ,`1Y1Z1Y \Z* 4*3S,1bD \ 31 a*Y\1<br />

Y\3Z\aV*4*bnS\/dj1,Z\y`*Z1P]\ab1]1ZZ\+\Wn\bZ11<br />

Y\31bdbSfZdbnDb\]\Y\31bb1YEVb\-\`p1b]\aW1aY1`bS<br />

+WS4V\-\ h1W\,1V*E a]`*,Sbnaq a /dj1,Z\y +\WnpH<br />

5E 6D \h1Yd Z*Y ,*3Z\ \+ad/SbnE V*V db1j*bn b\-\E Vb\ ]\b1`qW<br />

+WS4V\-\ h1W\,1V*H LY\b`Sb1 SWWpab`*gSp , Z*h*W1 ab*bnSDM<br />

56


˚ P<br />

w ) ˚"˚)x<br />

7 Z1 ,aqVSf a\YZ1ZSyE Wdhj1 ,a1-\<br />

Z*a Y\31b db1jSbn Z*j a\ab`*/*b1WnO<br />

Zmy Z1+1aZmy b1g 1-\,*D L˛*hSb*y<br />

6 \`SZeqZ*Y 5B7E 8DM 1-\,*E V\b\`my<br />

dY11b a\ab`*/*bnE V*V ZSVb\ /`d-\yE 4*O<br />

,1`q1b a,\y Z*`\/B w)E q a*Y db1j*p ,*ax<br />

LaD95B56CaD55=B9>E96E;:MD<br />

8 1-\,*E b1g a\ab`*/*ZSqE a*Y SaO<br />

]mb*W +\Wn ]\b1`SE V\-/* dY1`WS b1E V\O<br />

-\ \Z Wp+SWEP ,`**YE a**VE *V\,E<br />

\Sa1y S ˙*,S/ LSaD 56B:P


1-\E \Z ]\hd,ab,\,*W bd 31 \ab`dpE<br />

Z1ab1`]SYdp +\WnE V\b\`*q ]`\Z4SW*<br />

a1`/g1 *`SS S *`emD S/q Sf ab`*/*O<br />

ZSqE \Z Z1 ,m/1`3*W S -\`nV\ 4*]W*V*W<br />

L\*ZD 55B77P7:MD<br />

5> *V Z*Y Y\31b ]\Y\hn 4Z*ZS1 b\-\E<br />

hb\E 3S,q Z* 41YW1E Sada a\hd,ab,\,*W<br />

/`d-SY S db1j*W SfH S+WSq 4*,1`q1b<br />

Z*a , b\YE hb\ Sada Z1 S4Y1ZSWaqE \Z<br />

w,a1 b\b 31 P ,h1`*E S a1-\/ZqE S ,1hZ\x<br />

L˚,`D57BE5


58 ]\WZ1 ]\ZqbZ\E hb\ ]\`\y Ym Y\O<br />

31Y Z1 4Z*bnE hb\ aV*4*bn b\YdE Vb\ aW\YO<br />

W1Z -\`1YD /Z*V\ , S+WSS -\,\`SbO<br />

aqE hb\ wq4mV Yd/`mf Sag1Wq1bx L`SbD<br />

56B55>-\/*D<br />

58D b\ Y\3Z\ aV*4*bnE hb\+m db1jSbn b1fE<br />

Vb\ aV\`+SbH<br />

59D *V Ym Y\31Y db1jSbn /`d-SfE 1aWS<br />

Z*Y bq31W\ WShZ\ ]\-\,\`Sbn a h1W\,1V\YH<br />

LY\b`Sb1 b*V31 `*YVd w*V db1jSbn aW\,*O<br />

YSxDM<br />

5:D b\ 1k1 Y\31b \h1Zn db1jSbn /`d-SfH<br />

*V db1jSbn aW\,*YS<br />

\b hb\ Z*]Sa*WS Z1V\b\`m1 f`SabS*Z1E<br />

31W*q db1jSbn a,\Sf /`d41yB<br />

˛ w*Y b`d/Z\ Z*ybS Zd3Zm1 aW\,*E Z\ Ym<br />

f\bSY aV*4*bnE hb\ \h1Zn b1+q Wp+SYD<br />

m Z1 Y\31Y /\ V\Zg* ]\ZqbnE hb\ bm<br />

a1yh*a hd,ab,d1jnE Z\ Ym d,1`1ZmE hb\<br />

1-\,* +d/1b ]\//1`3S,*bn b1+q S /*WnO<br />

j1D \WSYaq 4* b1+q S Z*/11YaqE hb\<br />

Z*jS Y\WSb,m f\bq +m Z1YZ\-\ b1+q<br />

]\//1`3*bxD<br />

˛ w1-\,* \+q4*b1WnZ\ ]\Y\31b b1+1 ]1`1O<br />

3Sbn obd bq31Wdp db`*bdxD<br />

˛ wdabn b1+q db1j*1b YmaWn \ b\YE hb\ /\O<br />

`\-\y b1+1 h1W\,1V a1yh*a , a*Y\Y +14\O<br />

]*aZ\Y Y1ab1 P , ]*YqbS \-*E V\b\`my<br />

]\YZSb \ Z1Y *+a\WpbZ\ ,a1 S ,1`Z1b 1-\<br />

V3S4ZSxD<br />

˛ w\bE V\-\ bm Wp+SjnE +\Wnj1 ZSV\-/*<br />

Z1 ab*Z1b 31`b,\y ]\aW1/Z1-\ ,`*-* P<br />

aY1`bSD m 31 +d/1Y f`*ZSbn , ]*YqbS<br />

1-\ /1W* ,1`mE ]\V* Z1 ,ab`1bSY 1-\<br />

, `*p 3S,mY S 4/\`\,mYxD<br />

˛ w1yh*a b`d/Z\ ]1`1/*bn aW\,*YS ,ap<br />

+\Wn \b ]\b1`S b\-\E Vb\ +mW b1+1 /\`\-E<br />

Z\ Ym a Z1b1`]1ZS1Y 3/1Y ,`1Y1ZSE V\-/*<br />

aW\,*YS +d/1b b`d/Z\ \]Sa*bn ,ap `*O<br />

/\abn \b ,ab`1hS a +WS4VSY b1+1 h1W\,1O<br />

V\YE V\b\`\-\ Z*j Z1+1aZmy b1g ,1`Z1b<br />

V3S4ZSxD


aSW\y \+W*/*1b Y\WSb,*D m Y\31Y Y\O<br />

WSbnaq 4* b1fE Vb\ ]\b1`qW +WS4V\-\ h1O<br />

W\,1V*E * b*V31 ,Y1ab1 a ZSYSD \Z1hO<br />

Z\E , b*VSf Z1]`\abmf \+ab\qb1Wnab,*f<br />

SZ\-/* b`d/Z\ ,m`*4Sbn a,\S YmaWS<br />

, Y\WSb,1D \ ,*j* SaV`1ZZqq Y\Wn+*E<br />

]dabn /*31 /`\3*kSY -\W\a\YE aV,\4n<br />

aW14mE Y\31b \+W1-hSbn ab`*/*ZSq b\O<br />

-\E Vb\ aV\`+SbD ˙*WSZ /1WSbaqB w\-/*<br />

a1ab`m ]`Sf\/qb Y1Zq db1jSbnE q SZ\-O<br />

/* ]`\jd Sf ]\Y\WSbnaqD *ab\E V\-/*<br />

\ZS Z*hSZ*pb Y\WSbnaqE SY bq31W\ -\O<br />

,\`SbnE Z\ ,aV\`1 Sf -\W\a ab*Z\,Sbaq<br />

b,1`31E S \ZS ]`\S4Z\aqb ]`\ZSVZ\,1ZO<br />

Zdp Y\WSb,dD f V`1]V*q ,1`*E Wp+\,n S<br />

,ZSY*ZS1 \h1Zn dV`1]Wqpb Y\p ,1`dxD<br />

˙&˚ ˙&"˚ <br />

˚"˚)<br />

5; a1Y Wp/qY Zd3Z\ `*4Z\1 ,`1YqE<br />

hb\+m \]`*,Sbnaq ]\aW1 b`*-1/SSD Z*O<br />

h*W1 h1W\,1V*E V\b\`my ]\b1`qW +WS4O<br />

V\-\E \+mhZ\ \V`d3*pb /`d4nq S `\/abO<br />

,1ZZSVSD \ ]\b\Y SY ]`Sf\/Sbaq ,\4O<br />

,`*k*bnaq V a,\SY ]`S,mhZmY /1W*YD<br />

\ob\Yd +d/nb1 -\b\,m ]\//1`3S,*bn<br />

1-\ Z1 b\WnV\ , ]1`,m1 Z1aV\WnV\ /Z1yE<br />

Z\ S , ]\aW1/dpkS1 Y1aqgmD S+O<br />

WSS -\,\`SbaqB w*ab\qkSy /`d- Wp+Sb<br />

,\ ,aqV\1 ,`1YqE \Z +`*bE `\3/1ZZmy Z*<br />

,`1Yq +1/ab,Sqx L`SbD 5;B5;MD *Y Zd3O<br />

Z\ ]\//1`3S,*bn S db1j*bn h1W\,1V*<br />

Z* ]`\bq31ZSS ,a1-\ ,`1Y1ZSE V\-/* \Z<br />

]mb*1baq a]`*,Sbnaq a -\`1YD L˛*hSb*y<br />

5 1aa*W\ZSVSyg*Y 7B;DM<br />

5< 1 4*+m,*yb1E hb\ ]\`\y aV\`+qk1O<br />

-\ Y\31b \f,*bm,*bn aSWnZ*q +\Wn S4O4*<br />

Z*fWmZd,jSf ,\a]\YSZ*ZSyD f Y\-db<br />

,m4,*bn `*4WShZm1 -\/\,kSZmE V*V*qO<br />

b\ Y1W\/SqE 4*ZqbS1E e\b\-`*eSS S /*31<br />

4*]*fSE 4,dVS SWS ,`1Yq -\/*D \YdE Vb\<br />

]\b1`qW a]dbZSV* 3S4ZSE +m,*1b \a\O<br />

5;P5=D \h1Yd Zd3Z\ S /*Wnj1 ]\//1`3SO<br />

,*bn b1fE Vb\ ]\b1`qW +WS4V\-\ h1W\,1V*H<br />

+1ZZ\ bq31W\E V\-/* 1Yd ,]1`,m1 Zd3Z\<br />

a/1W*bn b\E hb\ \ZS /1W*WS ,Y1ab1E Z*O<br />

]`SY1` ]\ybS Z* 1h1`p ,\a]\YSZ*ZSqD<br />

\b hb\ -\,\`Sb \/SZ +`*bB w) ]`1/]\O<br />

W*-*WE hb\ Y\q ]1`,*q -\/\,kSZ* a,*/nO<br />

+m +14 31Zm ]`\y/1b \h1Zn +\W14Z1ZO<br />

Z\E S YZ1 ]`*,/* +mW\ Z1W1-V\D /Z*V\<br />

Z1aV\WnV\ Y\Sf a*Ymf +WS4VSf /`d41y<br />

]`1/W\3SWS a\+`*bnaq b1aZmY V`d-\YE<br />

hb\+m , ob\b /1Zn q Z1 \ab*,*Waq \/SZxD<br />

5= b\Sb ]\YZSbnE hb\ b\bE Vb\ ]\b1O<br />

`qW +WS4V\-\ h1W\,1V*E Zd3/*1baq , db1O<br />

j1ZSS Z1 b\WnV\ , \]`1/1W1ZZm1 /ZSD<br />

(ZSq /1WSbaqB w\-/* /`d-S1 ]\Y\-*O<br />

pb b1+1 S Z*f\/qbaq `q/\Y a b\+\y Z1<br />

b\WnV\ , V*VS1Ob\ \a\+m1 /ZSE ob\ \h1Zn<br />

]\//1`3S,*1bD ) g1Zp b*VS1 Y\Y1ZbmE<br />

\ZS ]`S/*pb YZ1 aSWxD \Z1hZ\E Z1,\4O<br />

Y\3Z\ ]\WZ\abnp S4+*,Sbn h1W\,1V* \b<br />

-\`1abZmf hd,ab, S 4*]\WZSbn \+`*4\O<br />

,*,jdpaq ]dab\bdD ,a1 31E \V*4m,*q<br />

]`*VbSh1aVdp ]\Y\kn S ]\//1`3VdE Ym<br />

Y\31Y 1-\ db1jSbn L5 \*ZD 7B5 *V 31 a\-`1,*1b Z*a YmaWn \ b\YE<br />

hb\ ,aV\`1 1-\,*E \- ,aqV\-\ db1O<br />

j1ZSqE Z*,a1-/* dab`*ZSb -\`1 S db1jSb<br />

,a1f aV\`+qkSfI 'b\ ]`\S4\y/1bE V\-O<br />

/* w,a1 Z*f\/qkS1aq , ]*YqbZmf aVW1O<br />

]*f daWmj*b 1-\ `Sab* -\W\a S ,myO<br />

/dbx L\*ZD 9B6


\h1Yd Z*Y Zd3Z\<br />

,\af,*Wqbn 1-\,dH<br />

w\af,*Wqyb1 *-I \a]1,*bn Z*j1-\ \-* ]\/ Yd4mVd P<br />

ob\ +W*-\E ob\ ]`SqbZ\ P \Z /\ab\SZ f,*Wmx LD 58;B5MD<br />

% f,*WSY /`d-Sf Wp/1yE 1aWS \ZS f\`\j\ a]`*,O<br />

Wqpbaq a\ a,\SYS 4*/*ZSqYS SWS ]`\q,Wqpb V*h1ab,*E V\b\O<br />

`m1 Z*Y \h1Zn Z`*,qbaqD *aV\WnV\ 31 +\Wnj1 d Z*a ]`ShSZ<br />

,\af,*Wqbn 1-\,dI *]`SY1`E Ym Y\31Y ,\af,*Wqbn 1-\,d<br />

4* 1-\ +14-`*ZShZdp aSWdE V\b\`*q ,S/Z* , b\YE hb\ \Z a\O<br />

4/*WE SWS 4* 1-\ -\`qhdp Wp+\,nE V\b\`dp \Z ]`\q,SWE \b/*,<br />

,31`b,d4*Z*aa,\1-\mZ*D<br />

6 ,b\` 58;O-\ ]a*WY* +mW ]\+d3/1Z ,\af,*Wqbn 1-\,dD<br />

Z b*V31 ]`S4m,*W /`d-Sf ,Y1ab1 a ZSY ,\4/*,*bn \-d f,*O<br />

WdD L˛*hSb*y a*W\Y 58;B5E ;E 56DM<br />

7 m Z1 4Z*1YE Vb\ Z*]Sa*W ob\b ]a*W\YE Z\E ,1`\qbZ\E<br />

]a*WY\]1,1g 3SW , b\ ,`1YqE V\-/* 1-\,* ,1`ZdW S4`*SWnO<br />

bqZ , 1`da*WSY S4 ,*,SW\ZaV\-\ ]W1Z* LaD 58;B6MD \3Sy<br />

Z*`\/ Y\- ,Z\,n aWd3Sbn \-d d a1+q Z* `\/SZ1E S ob\E Z1O<br />

a\YZ1ZZ\E ]\+d/SW\ ]a*WY\]1,g* ,\af,*Wqbn 1-\,dD /Z*O<br />

V\ /Wq ob\-\ d Z1-\ +mWS S /`d-S1 ]`ShSZmE V\b\`m1 \Z<br />

5P7D *M \-/*E ,1`\qbZ\E +mW Z*]Sa*Z 58;Oy ]a*W\YH +M h1Y Ym Y\O<br />

31Yd4Z*bnS458;O-\]a*WY*H<br />

˚B 9=E 7<br />

58;O• <br />

˚ DDD<br />

<br />

DDDg1ZSbn b\E hb\ 1-\,* \ ,*a<br />

4*+\bSbaqH<br />

<br />

DDDZ1 a\YZ1,*bnaq , b\YE hb\<br />

\- ]`S/1b ,*Y Z* ]\Y\knH<br />

<br />

DDDd,S/1bnE V*V 1-\,* ]\/O<br />

/1`3S,*1b a,\Sf aWd3Sb1W1y<br />

a ]\Y\knp a,\1-\ W\,*H<br />

5;


]`S,1W , a,\1Y ]a*WY1D V*VS1 ]`ShSO<br />

Zm 1abn d ,*aE hb\+m ,\af,*Wqbn 1-\,dH<br />

˚ ˚)˚<br />

"˚% ˚˙˚<br />

8 \]`\+dyb1 ]`1/ab*,SbnE V*V hd,abO<br />

,\,*WS a1+q S4`*SWnbqZ1E Z*f\/qan , ,*O<br />

,SW\ZaV\Y ]W1ZdD *,SW\ZqZ1 Z*aY1f*O<br />

WSan Z*/ ZSYSB w]\yb1 Z*Y \/Zd S4 ]1O<br />

a1Z S\Z*xD b\Yd ,`1Y1ZS 1`da*WSY<br />

W13*W , `dSZ*fE ]\ob\Yd S4`*SWnbqZ1<br />

+mWS WSj1Zm -W*,Z\y ]`ShSZmE hb\+m<br />

`*/\,*bnaq , 1-\,1 LaD 57;B5P7E :MD<br />

Y a\,a1Y Z1 f\b1W\an ]1bnD ZS +mO<br />

WS d+Sbm -\`1Y S Zd3/*WSan , db1O<br />

j1ZSSD ,\bE V*V S ]`1/aV*4*W \-E Sf<br />

\a,\+\/SW ]1`aS/aVSy g*`n S`D \aW1<br />

b\-\ V*V \Z 4*f,*bSW *,SW\ZE \Z ]`\O<br />

,\4-W*aSWB w1-\,*DDD ,1W1W YZ1 ]\ab`\O<br />

Sbn 1Yd /\Y , 1`da*WSY1DDD dabn a V*3O<br />

/mY S4 ,*aE Vb\ ]`SZ*/W13Sb V 1-\ Z*`\O<br />

/dE+d/1b1-\\-1-\,*Ddabn\ZS/1bx<br />

L6 1bD 7:B67MD *V 31 \+`*/\,*WSan S4O<br />

`*SWnbqZ1E V\-/* S` S4/*W a,\y dV*4I<br />

9 1-\,* db1jSW Z1 b\WnV\ a,\y Z*O<br />

`\/ , g1W\YE Z\ S V*3/\-\ a,\1-\ aWdO<br />

3Sb1Wq , \b/1WnZ\abSD *V 31 1-\,*<br />

]\abd]*1b S a1-\/ZqD \b hb\ ]a*WY\]1O<br />

,1g Z*]Sa*W \ \-1B wZ Sag1Wq1b a\O<br />

V`dj1ZZmf a1`/g1Y S ]1`1,q4m,*1b Sf<br />

`*Zmx LaD 58;B7MD 1-\,* ]\//1`3S,*1b<br />

b1fE Vb\ ab`*/*1b eS4Sh1aVS SWS oY\gSO<br />

\Z*WnZ\D Z ,a1-/* -\b\, db1jSbn Z*a<br />

SSag1WSbnZ*jS/dj1,Zm1`*ZmLaD<br />

78B5


S 1-\,* ]\//1`3*W ,*a a,\1y V`1]V\y<br />

`dV\yLaD85B5>E57MD\b]`SY1`a1ab`mO<br />

]S\Z1`* ]\ SY1ZS 1V\D \aW1 b\-\ V*V<br />

\Z*E ]\WdhS, Z\,\1 Z*4Z*h1ZS1E ]1`1O<br />

jW*,/`d-\1a\+`*ZS1E\Z*,]*W*,dZmO<br />

ZS1D *V 1-\,* ]\V*4*WE hb\ ]\ZSY*1b<br />

11 b`d/Z\abSH a,\1Y Z\,\Y a\+`*ZSS<br />

1V\ ]\4Z*V\YSW*an a\ YZ\-SYS +`*bnqO<br />

YS S a1ab`*YSE V\b\`m1 f\`\j\ ]\ZSY*O<br />

WS 11 hd,ab,*D Z11 +mW\ b*V\1 \kdk1O<br />

ZS1E +d/b\ 1-\,* -\,\`Sb 1yB w) Wp+Wp<br />

b1+q Z1 ]`\ab\ ]\b\YdE hb\ bm aWd3Sjn<br />

]S\Z1`\YE * ]\b\YdE hb\ bm Y\q /\hn S<br />

]\a,qbSW* YZ1 a,\p 3S4ZnD ) f\hdE hb\O<br />

+m bm `*/\,*W*an 3S4ZSE ,1/n bm Y\y<br />

,S/1b1WnIx V*V , ,*j1Y aWdh*1 a1O<br />

Y\-dkSy ]\V*4*WE hb\ ]\ZSY*1b ,*aE V*V<br />

ZSVb\ /`d-\yH<br />

˚ ˛) "<br />

˚)<br />

= ,a1f Z*a 1abn eS4Sh1aVS1 ]\b`1+O<br />

Z\abSD \4Y\3Z\E SZ\-/* Ym ]1`13S,*O<br />

1YE +d/1b WS d Z*a /\ab*b\hZ\ 1/mD /O<br />

Z*V\ 1-\,* a\b,\`SW ˛1YWp b*VE hb\<br />

\Z* ]`\S4,\/Sb ]SkdE V\b\`\y f,*b*1b<br />

Z* ,a1fD a*WY\]1,1g ]Sa*WE hb\ 11 ]\O<br />

Wdh*pb /*31 w,\`\Zqb*E V\b\`m1 ]`\aqb<br />

\Z1yxDL˛*hSb*y a*W\Y 58;B \ , ]1`,dp \h1`1/n 1-\,* 4*O<br />

+\bSbaq \ b\YE hb\+m d Z*a +mW* V`1]O<br />

V*q ,1`*E S /*1b Z*Y wYS` \3SyE V\b\O<br />

`my ]`1,\af\/Sb ,aqVdp YmaWnx LW]D<br />

8B:E ;MD \b hb\ ]`\S4\jW\ a +`*b\Y S4<br />

)]\ZSS ]\ SY1ZS dgd\ S 1-\ 31Z\yD<br />

6>55-\/dEV\-/*Z*Sfab`*Zd\+`dO<br />

jSW\an gdZ*YSE \ZS Z* a1+1 Sa]mb*O<br />

WS ]\//1`3Vd 1-\,mD Y d/*W\an ,mO<br />

3Sbn +W*-\/*`q b\YdE hb\ \ZS 4*+`*O<br />

=E 5>D *V 1-\,* ]\Y\-*1b Z*Y , ]1`,dp \h1O<br />

`1/nH *aaV*3Sb1 aWdh*yD<br />

WSan Z* V`mjd /\Y*D /Z*V\ , b\b /1Zn<br />

\ZS WSjSWSan ]`*VbSh1aVS ,a1-\ a,\O<br />

1-\ SYdk1ab,*D ZS ]`\,1WS Z\hn , f\O<br />

W\/Z\yE b1YZ\y V\YZ*b1 Z* ,b\`\Y ob*O<br />

31 a,\1-\ ]\Wd`*4`dj1ZZ\-\ /\Y*D bO<br />

`\Y \ZS ab*WS SaV*bn /df\,Zdp ]SkdE<br />

V\b\`*q Y\-W* +m Sf dV`1]SbnD a1E hb\<br />

\ZS Z*jWSEP ob\ w˚31-\/ZSV ,S/1b1O<br />

W1y 1-\,mx 4* 6>>: -\/D 4-Wq/ dgd\<br />

a`*4d 31 ]`S,W1V ]\/4*-\W\,\V w*Y\1<br />

aY1`b\Z\aZ\1 gdZ*YS , Sab\`SSxD *Y<br />

`*aaV*4m,*W\an \ 41YW1b`qa1ZSSE V\b\O<br />

`\1 ]`\S4\jW\ , 6>>8 -\/d Z* dY*bO<br />

`1D Z\ ]\`\/SW\ gdZ*YSE ]\ a,\1y aSW1<br />

Z1 SY1pk11 *Z*W\-\, , Sab\`SSD dgd\<br />

a 31Z\y ]W*V*WSE hSb*q \ b\YE hb\ `*aO<br />

aV*4m,*WS +`*bnq S a1ab`mE ]1`13S,O<br />

jS1 ob\ +1/ab,S1D d]`d-S ]\hd,ab,\,*O<br />

WS Z13Zdp 4*+\bd 1-\,mE V\b\`my /*W<br />

SY SY1ZZ\ b\E , h1Y \ZS Zd3/*WSan ,<br />

b\b Y\Y1ZbD 1-\,* b*V31 a Wp+\,np ]\O<br />

4*+\bSWaq\+SfY*b1`S*WnZmfZd3/*fD<br />

1`14 a,\Sf +`*bn1, ]\ ,1`1 \ZS ]\WdO<br />

hSWS -dY*ZSb*`Zdp ]\Y\knD \ +\Wnj1<br />

,a1-\Sf\+\/`SW\b\Ehb\Sfa\+`*ZS1<br />

]\a1bSWS +`*bnq S4 \YSb1b* eSWS*W*D<br />

dgd\ -\,\`SbB w Y1Zq +mW\ b*V\1 hd,O<br />

ab,\E hb\ 1-\,* Z*f\/Sbaq `q/\Y a V*3O<br />

/mY S4 Z*a S 4*+\bSbaq \ Z*aD *VSY 31<br />

ob\ ab*W\ db1j1ZS1YIx *V ,S/Z\E , ]1`O<br />

,dp \h1`1/n 1-\,* ]\//1`3S,*1b Z*a<br />

/df\,Z\E * 4*b1Y 4*+\bSbaq S \ Z*jSf<br />

eS4Sh1aVSf ]\b`1+Z\abqfD<br />

˙˙˚˝&<br />

55 1-\,* ,a1-/* -\b\, ,abd]Sbnaq 4*<br />

V`\bVSf S ]\//1`3*bn Sf LaD 58;B:*MD<br />

\ hb\ \3S/*1baq \b Z*aH *Y ,*3Z\ a\O<br />

f`*Zqbn a ZSY +WS4VS1 \bZ\j1ZSqD /Wq<br />

ob\-\ Z1\+f\/SY\ `*4,S,*bn V`\b\abn<br />

L\eD 6B7MD `\bVS1 b1`]1WS,\ 3/dbE ]\O<br />

V* \- ,\aab*Z\,Sb a]`*,1/WS,\abn S<br />

Sa]`*,Sb ,`1/E V\b\`my SY ]`ShSZSWSD<br />

55D b\ b`1+d1baq \b b1fE Vb\ f\h1bE hb\+m 1O<br />

-\,* SY ]\Y\-*WH<br />

(& 6>5; 5=


1-\,* \h1Zn `*/d1baqE -Wq/q Z* V`\bVSf<br />

Wp/1yD<br />

56 /`d-\yab\`\ZmE1-\,*wZ1h1abSO<br />

,mfDDD dZS3*1b /\ 41YWSx LaD 58;B:+MD<br />

*VS1 aSWnZm1 aW\,*I b\+m ]\hd,ab,\O<br />

,*bn ]`1/*ZZdp Wp+\,n 1-\,m S Z1 Z*O<br />

,W1hn Z* a1+q 1-\ -Z1,E Z*Y Zd3Z\ Z1Z*O<br />

,S/1bn b\E hb\ Z1Z*,S/Sb \Z LaD =;B5>MD<br />

*]`SY1`E ,*3Z\ Z1Z*,S/1bn a1Vad*WnO<br />

Zdp +14Z`*,ab,1ZZ\abnD ˙Wq ob\-\ Z1O<br />

\+f\/SY\ /1`3*bnaq , ab\`\Z1 \b ,a1-\E<br />

hb\ Y\31b ]\/b\WVZdbn Z*a V -`1fdE ,<br />

b\Y hSaW1 \b ]\`Z\-`*eSS LaD 55=B7;C<br />

*beD 9B6 \ \-1 -\,\`SbaqB w1 ,<br />

aSW1 V\Zq \Z Z*f\/Sb `*/\abnE Z1 , +mO<br />

ab`\b1 Z\- h1W\,1V* P d/\,\Wnab,S1xD<br />

*Y Zd3Z\ \+`*k*bnaq V 1-\,1E dY\O<br />

Wqq 1-\ \ ]\Y\kSD \bWShS1 \b Wp/1yE<br />

1-\,* ZSV\-/* Z1 dab*Z1b aWdj*bn Z*O<br />

jS ]`\an+mE /*31 1aWS Ym ]`\aSY 1-\<br />

\ ]\Y\kS ,a1 aZ\,* S aZ\,*D 1-\,d<br />

`*/dpb w+\qkS1aq 1-\E \3S/*pkS1 1-\<br />

Wp+qk1y /\+`\bmx LaD 58;B55MD m Y\O<br />

31Y Z1 a\YZ1,*bnaqEhb\ 1-\,* ]`\q,Sb<br />

V Z*Y a,\p ]`1/*ZZdp Wp+\,nD Z Z1<br />

\ab*,Sb Z*a S ]\Y\31b ]`1\/\W1bn Z*jS<br />

Z1]`*,SWnZm1 31W*ZSqD<br />

58 Z*a 1abn ,a1 \aZ\,*ZSq ,1`SbnE<br />

hb\ 1-\,* Z1 \ab*,Sb a,\y Z*`\/ , +1O<br />

/1D \b hb\ Z*]Sa*W ]a*WY\]1,1g \ ,\aO<br />

ab*Z\,W1ZSS 1`da*WSY*B wZ dV`1]SW<br />

56E 57D *M b h1-\ Z*Y Zd3Z\ /1`3*bnaq , ab\O<br />

`\Z1E 1aWS Ym f\bSY ]\WdhSbn \3np ]\Y\knH<br />

+M *VS1 Wp/S `*/dpb 1-\,dH<br />

58D h1Y +mW d+13/1Z ]a*WY\]1,1gH<br />

4*a\,m b,\Sf ,\`\bE +W*-\aW\,SW b,\Sf<br />

amZ\,1y a`1/S b1+qD Z ,a1Wq1b YS` ,<br />

b,\S ,W*/1ZSqx LaD 58;B57E 58MD *V 31<br />

db1j*W* ]a*WY\]1,g* YmaWn \ b\YE hb\<br />

\- dV`1]Sb ,\`\b* -\`\/*E hb\+m 4*kSO<br />

bSbn a,\Sf aWd3Sb1W1yI<br />

59 \`\y b`d/Z\abS WSj*pb Z*a ]\O<br />

V\qE \/Z*V\ 1-\,* Y\31b Z*/1WSbn Z*a<br />

Yd/`\abnpE hb\+m Ym a ZSYS a]`*,SO<br />

WSanD ,b\` 58;O-\ ]a*WY* Z*]Sa*WE hb\<br />

1-\,* w]\amW*1b a,\1 ]\,1W1ZS1 Z*<br />

41YWpE +mab`\ +13Sb 1-\ aW\,\xE * b*VO<br />

31 hb\ \Z w/*1b aZ1-DDD `*aam]*1b SZ1yDDD<br />

+`\a*1b VdaV*YS W1/xD ˛*b1Y ]a*WY\]1O<br />

,1g 4*/*W b*V\y ,\]`\aB w1`1/ 1-\ abdO<br />

31y Vb\ dab\SbHx Z /\+*,SWE hb\ 1-\O<br />

,* w]\amW*1b a,\1 aW\,\ S `*ab*]WS,*1b<br />

Sfx LaD 58;B59P5 ˝˚) ")


*V Z*Y ]\Y\-*1b \3n1 W\,\E V\-/* Ym ab*WVS,*1Yaq a a1`n14ZmYS b`d/Z\abqYSH<br />

LY\b`Sb1 *+4*gm 59P5;DM<br />

`*/d1b \-*D \-/* 1y +mW\ \a\+1ZZ\<br />

bq31W\E \Z* Z1]`1ab*ZZ\ Y\WSW*an 1O<br />

-\,1 S dY\WqW* 1-\ \ ]\Y\kSD Z* b*VO<br />

31 da1`/Z\ S4dh*W* S+WSpD \b hb\<br />

\Z* -\,\`Sb \+ 1-\,1B w1 +mW\ aWdO<br />

h*qE hb\+m q Z1 \kdbSW* 1-\ ]\//1`3VS<br />

S Z1 d,S/1W* 1-\ `dV\,\/ab,*xD a1 ob\<br />

]\Y\-*W\ 1y a\f`*Zqbn ]\W\3Sb1WnZmy<br />

Z*ab`\yD<br />

5< a*WY\]1,1g 4Z*WE hb\ \- ]\O\a\O<br />

5


dabn 1-\,* ]\Y\31b b1+1<br />

/\abShn ,a1f b,\Sf g1W1y<br />

w*f\/S +\Wnjdp `*/\abn , 1-\,1E S \Z Sa]\WZSb<br />

31W*ZSq b,\1-\ a1`/g*x LD 7;B8MD<br />

˚B 579E


1WS +d/db `*/\,*bnaqE * ,m +d/1b1 , abmO<br />

/1D \S aWd3Sb1WS +d/db ,\aVWSg*bn \b<br />

`*/\abS,a1`/g1xLaD:9B56P58MD\-/*<br />

f`SabS*Z1 ]`SZSY*pb ]`*,SWnZm1 `1j1O<br />

ZSqE \ZS b1Y a*YmY ]`\aW*,Wqpb 1-\,d<br />

L`SbD 6;B55MD<br />

˚E %˚ ˚˚<br />

˚ &˚<br />

7 *VS1 g1WS 1-\,* ]`1/W*-*1b b1+1<br />

]1`1/ a\+\y ]\ab*,SbnH Z a\4/*W Wp/1y<br />

b*VE hb\ /Wq ah*abnq SY Zd3Z\ d4Z*,*bn \<br />

Z1Y S ,1`Z\ 1Yd aWd3Sbn LaD 565; 67


Sfx L*beD 6MD 'b\ a*Y\1 ab\O<br />

qk11 /1W\E V\b\`\Yd Y\3Z\ ]\a,qbSbn<br />

a,\p 3S4ZnE ,1/n \Z\ ]`\aW*,Wq1b \-*D<br />

*V S , Wp+\Y /`d-\Y /1W1E b1+1 ]\Z*O<br />

/\+Sbaq ,`1YqE hb\+m ]`S\+`1abS \]mbD<br />

\b hb\ aV*4*W +`*b ]\ SY1ZS SY\bSE V\O<br />

b\`my Z*h*W aWd3Sbn ]S\Z1`\Y , 5= W1bB<br />

wZ1 Z`*,Sbaq aWd3Sbn 1-\,1 ]\WZ\O<br />

,`1Y1ZZ\D *V q Y\-d ]\V*4*bnE hb\ Wp+O<br />

Wp 1-\D 1`,\1 ,`1Yq d Y1Zq Z1 ]\Wdh*O<br />

W\an Z*h*bn +S+W1yaV\1 S4dh1ZS1E Z\ ]\O<br />

b\Y q ]1`11f*W Z* /`d-dp b1``Sb\`SpE<br />

S d31 h1`14 Y1aqg q ]`\,\/SW Z1aV\WnO<br />

V\ S4dh1ZSyD /SZ S4 b1fE a V1Y q S4dh*W<br />

S+WSpE ab*W ]`Sf\/Sbn , ˛*W *`ab,*D<br />

\aW1 /,dfY1aqhZ\-\ \+dh1ZSq , S+W1yO<br />

aV\y jV\W1 /Wq Z131Z*bmf +`*bn1, Y1Zq<br />

Z*4Z*hSWS , /`d-\1 a\+`*ZS1E S q Z*h*W<br />

b*Y h1bm`1 S4dh1ZSqD Z1 \h1Zn Z`*,SbO<br />

aq dhSbn Wp/1y SabSZ1E ]\b\Yd hb\ q ,SO<br />

3dE V*V \ZS Y1Zqpbaq ]\/ ,WSqZS1Y a,qO<br />

b\-\ /df*x L5 1aD 6B5=MD<br />

< 1V\b\`m1 Y\W\/m1 +`*bnq S a1ab`m<br />

,mdhSWS/`d-\yq4mVD\b]`SY1`˙31yO<br />

V\+* S4 \1/SZ1ZZmf "b*b\,D Z ]Sj1bB<br />

w\-/* YZ1 +mW\ a1Yn W1bE , Y\1Y VW*aa1<br />

dhSW\an YZ\-\ ,n1bZ*Yg1,D Z1 f\b1W\an<br />

`*aaV*4*bn SY \+ 1-\,1E ]\ob\Yd a]dabq<br />

V*V\1Ob\ ,`1Yq q `1jSW S4dh*bn Sf q4mVD<br />

\aZ\,Z\Y q /1W*W ob\E a`*,ZS,*q *ZO<br />

-WSyaV\1 S ,n1bZ*YaV\1 S4/*ZSq tb\`\O<br />

31,\y +*jZSrD ) b*V31 ]\/`d3SWaq a +`*O<br />

bnqYS S a1ab`*YS S4 a\a1/Z1-\ ,n1bZ*YO<br />

aV\-\ a\+`*ZSqD \-/* YZ1 Sa]\WZSW\an<br />

5


1fE Vb\ Z*hSZ*1b ]\WZ\,`1Y1ZZ\1 aWd31ZS1E 3/1b YZ\31ab,\ +W*-\aW\,1ZSy<br />

LY\b`Sb1 *+4*gm 55P57DM<br />

˚˚˙ • % <br />

˛˝˚•<br />

55 ˚abn `*4WShZm1 ,S/m aWd31ZSqD *VE<br />

YZ\-S1 Y\W\/m1 +`*bnq S a1ab`m ]\Y\O<br />

-*pb V*V /\+`\,\Wngm Z* ab`\yV1D 1\+O<br />

f\/SY\ ]\ab`\Sbn 1k1 a\bZS ˛*W\, *`O<br />

ab,*D h*abS1 , b*V\Y ab`\Sb1Wnab,1 P ob\<br />

a,qk1ZZ\1aWd31ZS1EV\b\`\1]`\aW*,WqO<br />

1b \-* S Y\31b ]`SZ1abS b1+1 \-`\YZdp<br />

`*/\abnD \/dY*y b*V31 \ b\YE V*V ]`SqbO<br />

Z\ \+k*bnaq S b`d/Sbnaq a `*4ZmYS +`*O<br />

bnqYS S a1ab`*YSD Wd3* /\+`\,\Wng1Y<br />

Z* b1\V`*bSh1aV\y ab`\yV1E bm YZ\-\Yd<br />

dhSjnaqB a\+Wp/*bn b1fZSVd +14\]*aZ\O<br />

abSE +mbn da1`/ZmY `*+\bZSV\Y S a\b`d/O<br />

ZSh*bn a b1YSE Vb\ \b,1h*1b 4* ]`\1VbD<br />

56 `*b ]\ SY1ZS 1,SZ /1WSbaqB w a*O<br />

Y\-\ /1bab,* q Y1hb*W aWd3Sbn 1-\,1<br />

]\WZ\,`1Y1ZZ\D 5= W1b q Z*V\Z1gOb\<br />

55D V*V\Y SZb1`1aZ\Y ,S/1 aWd31ZSq Y\-db<br />

dh*ab,\,*bn Y\W\/m1 f`SabS*Z1H<br />

56D *VS1 ,\4Y\3Z\abS \bV`m,*pbaq ]1`1/ b1O<br />

YSE Vb\ aWd3Sb ]S\Z1`\YH<br />

ab*W ]S\Z1`\YD ) `*+\b*W Z1]\WZmy `*O<br />

+\hSy/1Znd+`*b*EV\b\`my+mWab`\SO<br />

b1W1YD ) Z*dhSWaq V`mbn V`mjdE dab*Z*O<br />

,WS,*bn \VZ* S /,1`SD \4/Z11 q /,* -\/*<br />

`*+\b*W , +`S-*/1E V\b\`*q ]\Y\-*W* ,\aO<br />

ab*Z*,WS,*bn ˛*Wm *`ab,* S /\Y* +`*O<br />

bn1,E ]\ab`*/*,jS1 ,\ ,`1Yq d`*-*Z*D<br />

\-/* q d4Z*WE hb\ , ( b`1+dpbaq ab`\O<br />

Sb1WSE q ]\/*W 4*q,W1ZS1E S Y1Zq ]`SO<br />

-W*aSWS bd/* `*+\b*bnD ˛/1anE , e`SV1E q<br />

V*3/m1 Z1aV\WnV\ Z1/1Wn ]1`1143*pB V\-O<br />

/* 4*V*ZhS,*1baq \/Z* ab`\yV* ˛*W* *`O<br />

ab,*E q 1/d Z* aW1/dpkdpD b`\Sb1WnZ*q<br />

-`d]]* YZ1 V*V a1YnqD m ,Y1ab1 3S,1YE<br />

,Y1ab1 S4dh*1Y S+WSpE ,Y1ab1 `*+\b*1YD<br />

1k1 YZ1 \h1Zn Z`*,Sbaq V*3/dp Z1/1O<br />

Wp ]`\]\,1/\,*bn a Y1abZmYS +`*bnqYSD<br />

) /*31 Z1 ]`1/]\W*-*WE hb\ g1WSE V\b\`m1<br />

q ]\ab*,SW ]1`1/ a\+\y , /1bab,1E ]`SZ1O<br />

adb YZ1 ab\WnV\ `*/\abSxD<br />

57 1V\b\`m1 S4 b1fE Vb\ `*Znj1 +mWS<br />

57D \h1Yd ,1eSWnaV\1 aWd31ZS1 ]`SZ\aSb Y\O<br />

W\/mY f`SabS*Z*Y `*/\abnH<br />

(& 6>5; 69


]S\Z1`*YSE a1yh*a aWd3*b , 1eSW1D *O<br />

V\1 aWd31ZS1 ]`SZ\aSb YZ\-\ `*/\abSE<br />

,1/n ,a1E hb\ /1W*pb ,1eSWngmE \ZS /1W*O<br />

pb/Wq1-\,mDW*-\/*`qSfb`d/d+`*bnq<br />

Sa1ab`mE*b*V31/`d-S1Wp/SY\-db]\O<br />

Wdh*bn /df\,Zdp ]SkdD \b hb\ -\,\`Sb<br />

\/SZ ,1eSW1g ]\ SY1ZS ˙*abSZB w /1O<br />

,qbn W1b q ]\ab*,SW ]1`1/ a\+\y g1Wn P<br />

aWd3Sbn ]\WZ\,`1Y1ZZ\D V\ZhS, jV\WdE<br />

q ab*W ]S\Z1`\YD 1`14 ]\Wb\`* -\/* Y1Zq<br />

]`S-W*aSWS , 1eSWnD *Y q Z*dhSWaq `*O<br />

+\b*bn Z* ]1h*bZ\Y ab*ZV1E * ]\4/Z11 P<br />

]`\-`*YYS`\,*bnD Z1 Z`*,SbaqE hb\ , 1O<br />

eSW1 Y\3Z\ S4 ]1`,mf dab d4Z*,*bn \ b\YE<br />

V*V ]`\f\/Sb /1W\ ]\/-\b\,VS dh1ZSV\,<br />

]\ ,a1Yd YS`dD ) Wp+Wp ob\ aWd31ZS1E<br />

,1/nE ,m]\WZqq a,\p `*+\bdE Ym ]\Y\-*1Y<br />

/`d-SY Wp/qY ]`S+WS3*bnaq V 1-\,1xD<br />

˚ ˚ % ˚˚˙ •<br />

"&H<br />

58 *V b1+1 /\abShn g1WS aWd3Sbn ]\WO<br />

Z\,`1Y1ZZ\H `13/1 ,a1-\E Z1\+f\/SY\<br />

`*4,Sbn f`SabS*ZaVS1 V*h1ab,*D \ob\Yd<br />

da1`/Z\ S4dh*y \3n1 W\,\E -Wd+\V\ `*4O<br />

YmjWqy Z*/ ]`\hSb*ZZmY S ab*`*yaq \bO<br />

,1h*bn Z* ,ab`1h*f a\+`*ZSqD \V* bm<br />

dhSjnaq , jV\W1E Z*+S`*yaq \]mb* , ]`\O<br />

]\,1/ZSh1aV\Y aWd31ZSSD hSan ]`\q,O<br />

Wqbn V Wp/qY SZb1`1aB b*VbShZ\ a]`*jSO<br />

,*y Sf YZ1ZS1 S ,ZSY*b1WnZ\ Sf ,maWdjSO<br />

,*yD `\Y1 b\-\E bm Y\31jn ]`1/W*-*bn<br />

a,\p ]\Y\kn , a\+`*ZSSE Z*]`SY1` dh*O<br />

ab,\,*bn , d+\`V1 S \+aWd3S,*ZSS ˛*W*<br />

*`ab,*D ˚aWS bm ]`\q,Wq1jn aYS`1ZS1 S<br />

-\b\, ]\Y\-*bn /`d-SYE 1-\,* +d/1b `*/<br />

S /*Wnj1 4*/1yab,\,*bn b1+q , aWd31ZSSD<br />

L˛*hSb*y a*W\Y 55>B7C ˙1qZD :B5P7DM<br />

]\ab\W*,1W]`S-W*aSWSY\e1q]`SO<br />

a\1/SZSbnaq V Z1Yd , YSaaS\Z1`aV\Y aWdO<br />

31ZSSE ]\b\Yd hb\ w\ Z1Y f\`\j\ \b4m,*O<br />

WSan +`*bnqx L˙1qZD 5:B5P9MD<br />

59 +mhZ\ ]\WZ\,`1Y1ZZmY aWd3Sb1O<br />

58D *VS1 j*-S ]\Y\-db /\abShn g1WS aWd3Sbn<br />

]\WZ\,`1Y1ZZ\H<br />

59D *V ,m+`*bn ]`\e1aaSpE V\b\`*q ]\Y\31b<br />

aWd3Sbn ]\WZ\,`1Y1ZZ\H<br />

WqY Zd3Z\ a*YSY 4*`*+*bm,*bn Z* 3S4Zn<br />

L˙1qZD 5B5


*V Z1 ]*abn 31`b,\y<br />

,+Sb,14*dYm<br />

% ˙ ]`Sg1W\YD *j -W*,Zmy ,`*-E *b*Z*E Sa]\Wn4d1b ]`\bS, ,*a<br />

\h1Zn \]*aZ\1 \`d3S1D *V\1H `\]*-*Z/dD `1/Z*4Z*h1ZS1 ob\-\<br />

\`d3Sq P Z1 d+Sbn ,*aE * 4*,W*/1bn ,*jSY dY\YD<br />

]\ab\W *,1W f\`\j\ a\4Z*,*WE Z*aV\WnO<br />

V\ \]*aZ* a*b*ZSZaV*q ]`\]*-*Z/*E \/Z*V\<br />

ob\-\ Z1Wn4q +mW\ aV*4*bn \+\ ,a1f f`SabSO<br />

*Z*f , ]1`,\Y ,1V1D *VE Z1V\b\`m1 hW1Zm<br />

V\`SZeaV\-\ a\+`*ZSqE \h1,S/Z\E ab*WS a*O<br />

Y\Z*/1qZZmYSB \ZS /dY*WSE hb\ b,1`/\ ab\O<br />

qb Z* ]dbS SabSZm S ZSV\-/* Z1 d]*/db<br />

L5 \`D 5>B56MD +1a]\V\1ZZmy obSYE *,1W<br />

Z*]Sa*WB w\panE hb\+m P V*V ob\ ab*W\ a<br />

˚,\yE V\b\`dp 4Y1y a\+W*4ZSW a,\SY WdV*,O<br />

ab,\YEP ,*jS dYm Z1 `*4,`*bSWSanE \bVW\O<br />

ZS,jSan \b SaV`1ZZ\abS S hSab\bmE V\b\`mf<br />

4*aWd3S,*1b `Sab\ax L6 \`D 55B7MD<br />

W\,* *,W* ]\V*4m,*pbE hb\ Z*Y Z1Wn4q<br />

+mbn aWSjV\Y d,1`1ZZmYS , a,\Sf aSW*fD<br />

b\+mZ1]*abn31`b,\y,+Sb,14*dYmEZ1O<br />

\+f\/SY\ ]\ZSY*bnE V*Vdp \]*aZ\abn b*Sb ,<br />

a1+1 ]`\]*-*Z/*E S dY1bn a1+q 4*kSbSbnD<br />

& ˙H<br />

b\ b*V\1 ]`\]*-*Z/*H ob\y ab*bn1<br />

]\/ Z1y ]\/`*4dY1,*1baq `*a]`\ab`*Z1ZS1<br />

]`1/,4qb\y SWS Z*Y1`1ZZ\ SaV*31ZZ\y SZO<br />

e\`Y*gSS a g1Wnp 4*ab*,Sbn Wp/1y /dO<br />

Y*bn SWS ]\abd]*bn \]`1/1W1ZZmY \+`*O<br />

4\YD VZS-1 w`\]*-*Z/* S ,Zdj1ZS1x<br />

]`\]*-*Z/* ]`S`*,ZS,*1baq V\ wW3SE S4,`*O<br />

k1ZSp e*Vb\,E \+Y*ZdE Y*ZS]dWqgSSE V\ZO<br />

b`\Wp a\4Z*ZSqE ]aSf\W\-Sh1aV\y ,\yZ1xE *<br />

b*V31 a,q4m,*1baq a wZ1obShZ\yE ,`1/\Z\aO<br />

Z\y S +1ah1abZ\y b*VbSV\yx LPropaganda<br />

and PersuasionMD<br />

h1Y \]*aZ\abn ]`\]*-*Z/mH Z* /1yO<br />

ab,d1b b*V 31 Z14*Y1bZ\E V*V q/\,Sbmy -*4E<br />

Z1 SY1pkSy ZS g,1b*E ZS 4*]*f*D `\]*-*ZO<br />

/* ]`\ZSV*1b , a\4Z*ZS1 ]\ab1]1ZZ\D 'VO<br />

a]1`b , \+W*abS ]\,1/1ZSq Wp/1y oZa<br />

(& 6>5; 6;


*VV*`/ Z*]Sa*WB wZ\-SYS S4 Z*a Y*ZS]dO<br />

WS`dpbE S ob\ ]`\Saf\/Sb -\`*4/\ h*k1E h1Y<br />

Ym /dY*1YxD \ aW\,*Y \/Z\-\ dh1Z\-\E ]\/<br />

,WSqZS1Y ]`\]*-*Z/m Wp/S wa W1-V\abnp<br />

a\,1`j*WS ab`*jZm1 ,1kSE V\b\`m1 ]`\O<br />

bS,\`1h*b 4/`*,\Yd aYmaWdx P dh*ab,\,*O<br />

WS , -1Z\gS/1E ,\yZ*fE ]\//*,*WSan `*a\,\y<br />

Sab1`SSE ]`\q,WqWS `1WS-S\4Zdp Z1b1`]SO<br />

Y\abn S +mWS ,SZ\,Zm , /`d-Sf b`d/Z\O<br />

\+lqaZSYmf ]\abd]V*f LEasily Led—A History<br />

of PropagandaMD<br />

˚aWS /*31 \+mhZm1 Wp/S Y\-db Z*,q4*bn<br />

Z*Y a,\S ,4-Wq/mE hb\ b\-/* Y\3Z\ aV*4*bn<br />

\ *b*Z1HZS4dh*1b]\,1/1ZS1Wp/1yaY\O<br />

Y1Zb* Sf a\b,\`1ZSqD 1yh*a w,1an YS`x W1O<br />

3Sb , 1-\ ,W*abSD Z Y\31b ,\a]\Wn4\,*bnaq<br />

h1Y d-\/Z\ , ob\Y YS`1E hb\+m `*a]`\ab`*O<br />

Zqbn a,\p W\3n L5 \*ZD 9B5=C \*ZD


]*-*Z/*E w\h1,S/Z\E Z*S+\W11 oee1VbS,Z*<br />

b\-/*E V\-/* Wp/qYDDD Z1 /*pb YmaWSbn V`SO<br />

bSh1aVSx LMedia and Society in the Twentieth<br />

CenturyMD \ob\Yd ZSV\-/* Z1 ab\Sb aW1]\<br />

,1`Sbn ,a1YdE hb\ ,*Y -\,\`qb L`SbD 58B59MD<br />

\Wn4dyb1an /*ZZmYS ,*Y \-\Y YmaWSO<br />

b1WnZmYS a]\a\+Z\abqYS S 4*/1yab,dyb1<br />

`*4dYE hb\+m a*YSY d+1/Sbnaq , b\YE hb ‹ \<br />

1abn SabSZ* L`SbD 6B5>P59C SYD 56B5E 6MD<br />

) <br />

w˛˙˚)••x<br />

Z\-/* ,\1ZZm1 ab`*b1-S Sa]\Wn4dpb<br />

]`\]*-*Z/dE hb\+m ]\/\`,*bn +\1,\y /df<br />

]`\bS,ZSV*D 11 ]\Y\knp \ZS Y\-db ]\/O<br />

b*WVS,*bn ,`*31aVSf a\W/*b V b\YdE hb\+m<br />

\ZS Z*h*WS ,1abS +\`n+d /`d- a /`d-\Y<br />

SWS \b/1WSWSan \b \aZ\,Z\y *`YSSD \<br />

aW\,*Y \/Z\-\ Z1Y1gV\-\ -1Z1`*W*E 1`Y*O<br />

ZSq ]\b1`]1W* ]\`*31ZS1 , 1`,\y YS`\O<br />

,\y ,\yZ1 , b\Y hSaW1 ]\b\YdE hb\ w,`*31O<br />

aV*q ]`\]*-*Z/* /1yab,\,*W* Z* Wp/1yE V*V<br />

d/*, Z* V`\WSV*xD *b*Z* b\31 ]`S+1-*1b V<br />

V\,*`Z\y b*VbSV1 w`*4/1Wqy S ,W*ab,dyxD Z<br />

]mb*1baq ]\a1qbn a`1/S f`SabS*Z `*4Z\-W*O<br />

aSq SWS 4*ab*,Sbn Sf \b/1WSbnaq \b \`-*ZSO<br />

4*gSS 1-\,mE ]\+d3/*q /dY*bnE hb\ Vb\Ob\<br />

, a\+`*ZSS Sf \+S/1W SWS \+\j1Waq a ZSYS<br />

Z1a]`*,1/WS,\D<br />

1 ]\4,\Wqyb1 a1+q \+Y*ZdbnI W1/dyb1<br />

a\,1b*Y S4 \3n1-\ W\,* S a\f`*Zqyb1<br />

1/SZab,\ a +`*bnqYS S a1ab`*YSD S+WSq ]\O<br />

+d3/*1b Z*a ,1WSV\/djZ\ ]`\k*bn /`d- /`dO<br />

-* S V*V Y\3Z\ aV\`11 dW*3S,*bn `*4Z\-W*O<br />

aSq L\WD 7B57E 58C *beD 9B67E 68MD Z1y qaZ\<br />

-\,\`SbaqE hb\ Z*Y Z1Wn4q \+\a\+Wqbnaq \b<br />

a\+`*ZSq L`SbD 5


Z* ,1`Zdp aY1`bnIx b\+m obS aW\,* 4,dO<br />

h*WS +\W11 ,1a\Y\E \ZS Y\-db a\aW*bnaq Z*<br />

\jS+VSE /\]dk1ZZm1 V\Y*Z/\,*ZS1YD *b*O<br />

Z* /1yab,d1b b\hZ\ b*V 31D Z ZSV\-/* Z1<br />

\ab*,Wq1b ]\]mb\V ]\/\`,*bn Z*j1 /\,1`S1<br />

V b1YE V\Yd 1-\,* ]\`dhSW `dV\,\/Sbn a,\O<br />

SY Z*`\/\YD<br />

*V a1+q 4*kSbSbnH `1]V\ /1`3Sb1an \`O<br />

-*ZS4*gSS 1-\,m S ,1`Z\ ]\//1`3S,*yb1<br />

Z*4Z*h1ZZmf +`*bn1,E /*31 1aWS ,m 4*Y1h*1O<br />

b1 Sf Z1/\ab*bVS L5 1aD 9B56E 57MD babd]ZSO<br />

VSS/`d-S1V\,*`Zm1Wp/SY\-db]\]mb*bnO<br />

aq \aW*+Sbn ,*j1 /\,1`S1 V obSY +`*bnqYD f<br />

aW\,* Y\-db ]\V*4*bnaq ]`*,/S,mYSE Z\ Z1<br />

a]1jSb1 wV\W1+*bnaq , a,\Sf `*aad3/1ZSqfx<br />

L6 1aD 6B6C Sbd 5B5>MD W1/dyb1 a\,1bdE V\O<br />

b\`my *]\ab\W *,1W /*W SY\e1pB w`1O<br />

+m,*y , b\YE h1Yd Z*dhSWaqDDD 4Z*qE \b V\-\<br />

bm Z*dhSWaqx L6 SYD 7B58E 59MD Z*a 1abn ,a1<br />

\aZ\,*ZSq /\,1`qbn ,1`Z\Yd `*+dE V\b\`\-\<br />

1-\,* Sa]\Wn4d1b d31 \V\W\ ab* W1bE hb\O<br />

+m ]\Y\-*bn Z*Y S/bS ]db1Y SabSZm L*beD<br />

68B89P8;C ˚,`D 57B;E 5;MD<br />

˚ ˙•˚ ˚) ˛&<br />

/Z*V\ Zd3Z\ ]\YZSbnE hb\ ]`\]*-*Z/*<br />

*b*Zm Z1 ,a1-/* 4*Y*aVS`\,*Z*D Z\-/*<br />

\Z ]`S+1-*1b V 4*]d-S,*ZSpE w\/Z\y S4<br />

ab*`1yjSf e\`Y ]`\]*-*Z/mx LEasily Led—<br />

A History of PropagandaMD*VE ]\ aW\,*Y +`SO<br />

b*ZaV\-\ ]`\e1aa\`* SWS]* 1yW\`*E *aO<br />

aS`Sygm ]\/*,WqWS a,\Sf ]`\bS,ZSV\,E wSaO<br />

]\Wn4dq ]\WSbSVd b1``\`* S ]`\]*-*Z/dxD<br />

b\+m ]\/*,Sbn ,*a S 4*ab*,Sbn ,*a ]1O<br />

`1ab*bn aWd3Sbn 1-\,1E *b*Z* ]\ab*`*1baq<br />

a/1W*bn b*VE hb\+m ,*YS \,W*/1W ab`*f ]1O<br />

`1/ Wp/nYSE ]1`1/ ]`1aW1/\,*ZSqYSE ]1`1/<br />

aY1`bnp LaD *aaS`Syg1, L6 *`D<br />

5=B79MD<br />

•˚ ˙<br />

˚˙"•˚˚<br />

\4Y\3Z\E,maY\b`1WSeSWnYE,V\b\O<br />

`\Y -1`\q \+Y*Zm,*WS S Y*ZS]dWS`\,*WS<br />

SYD mE V*V 4`Sb1WnE ob\ ]\ZSY*WSE S ,*Y /*O<br />

31 f\b1W\an V`SVZdbnB w1 ,1`n ob\YdI ZS<br />

b1+1 ,`dbIx b1]1`n ]`1/ab*,nb1E hb\ *Z-1Wm<br />

b\31 V`Sh*b ,*YB w1 /*y *b*Z1 \+Y*Zdbn<br />

b1+qIx<br />

1 aWdj*yb1 a*b*ZSZaVdp ]`\]*-*Z/d<br />

L`SbD 6:B68E 69MD ZSY*yb1 b\YdE hb\ -\,\O<br />

`Sb 1-\,*E S ]\W*-*yb1an Z* Z1-\ ,\ ,a1f<br />

a,\Sf /1W*f L`SbD 7B9P;MD `SYSb1 V a1`/O<br />

gd 1-\ Sa]\WZ1ZZm1 Wp+,S aW\,*B wd/n<br />

Yd/`E amZ Y\yE S `*/dy Y\1 a1`/g1x L`SbD<br />

6;B55MD b\-/* ,m Z1 /*/Sb1 *b*Z1 \/1`O<br />

3*bn ]\+1/d , +Sb,1 4* dYmD<br />

7> ˝˚) ")


% ˚˚•<br />

\31b WS f`SabS*ZSZ f`*ZSbn d a1+q \-Z1ab`1WnZ\1 \`d3S1E<br />

Z*]`SY1` ]Sab\W1b SWS `d3n1E hb\+m 4*kSbSbn a,\p 3S4Zn<br />

, aWdh*1 Z*]*/1ZSq ]`1abd]ZSV*H<br />

ˇ `SabS*Z1 Y\-db ]`SZSY*bn `*4dYZm1 Y1O<br />

`m ]`1/\ab\`\3Z\abSE hb\+m 4*kSbSbn a,\p<br />

3S4ZnE Z\ ]`S ob\Y ,*3Z\ dhSbm,*bn +S+O<br />

W1yaVS1 ]`SZgS]mD \-W*aZ\ SYE Ym Z1 Y\O<br />

31Y Sa]\Wn4\,*bn /Wq 4*kSbm \b ]`1abd]ZSO<br />

V\, ]Sab\W1bmE `d3nq S /`d-\1 \-Z1ab`1WnZ\1<br />

\`d3S1D ˙*,*yb1 \+ad/SY Z1V\b\`m1 S4 obSf<br />

]`SZgS]\,D<br />

˙Wq 1-\,m h1W\,1h1aV*q 3S4Zn a,qk1ZZ*D<br />

a*WY\]1,1g ˙*,S/ Z*]Sa*WE hb\ d 1-\,m<br />

wSab\hZSV 3S4ZSx LaD 7:B=MD \ob\YdE 1aWS<br />

f`SabS*ZSZ f\h1b ]`1/]`SZqbn V*VS1Ob\ j*O<br />

-S /Wq 4*kSbm a1+q SWS a,\1-\ SYdk1ab,*E \Z<br />

/\W31Z a/1W*bn ,a1 ,\4Y\3Z\1E hb\+m Z1 ab*bn<br />

,SZ\,ZmY , hn1yOWS+\ aY1`bS Lb\`D 66B


Z*]*/1ZSq ,\\`d31ZZ\y -`d]]m Wp/1y LdO<br />

VS 66B96MD \-/* 1b` ,mf,*bSW Y1h S Z*]*W<br />

Z* `*+* ]1`,\a,qk1ZZSV*E Sada ,1W1W 1YdB<br />

w1`ZS a,\y Y1h Z* Y1ab\xD \aW1 ob\-\ Sada<br />

aV*4*W 1b`dB wa1E Vb\ ,\4nYdb Y1hE \b Y1h* S<br />

]\-S+ZdbxL*beD6:B95E96MD'b\\/SZS4,*3O<br />

Z1yjSf ]`SZgS]\,E V\b\`mY ]\ a1y /1Zn `dV\O<br />

,\/ab,dpbaq 1-\ ]\aW1/\,*b1WSD<br />

a\-W*aSS a Sf1q 8B7E \3nS aWd3Sb1O<br />

WS ]1`1V\,*WS wa,\S Y1hS Z* W1Y1f* S V\]nq<br />

Z* a*/\,m1 Z\3SxD 'b\b ]`SZgS]E ]\/h1`VS,*O<br />

pkSy \/Zd S4 \bWShSb1WnZmf h1`b SabSZZmf<br />

f`SabS*ZE a\-W*ad1baq a ,/\fZ\,W1ZZmYS a,mO<br />

j1 aW\,*YS *]\ab\W* *,W*B wSV\Yd Z1 ,\4O<br />

/*,*yb1 4W\Y 4* 4W\D DDD *aV\WnV\ ,\4Y\3Z\<br />

a ,*j1y ab\`\ZmE +d/nb1 , YS`1 a\ ,a1YS Wp/nO<br />

YSx LSYD 56B5;E 5C dVS :B6=MD<br />

\ Wdhj1 ,a1-\E V\Z1hZ\E ]`1/\b,`*bSbn \]*aO<br />

Zdp aSbd*gSpD ˚aWS Ym Z1 f,*ab*1Yaq a,\SY<br />

/\ab*bV\Y S Z*jS a\a1/S 4Z*pbE hb\ Ym ,SO<br />

/1b1WS 1-\,m S hb\ Ym YS`Zm1 Wp/SE Ym<br />

b\YE V*V Z1 ab*bn 31`b,\y Z*aSWnZSV*E ]Sa*W\an ,<br />

ab*bn1 w*V ob\ Y\3Z\ ]`1/\b,`*bSbnx , 3d`Z*W1 w`\O<br />

+d/Sb1anIx \b < *]`1Wq 5==7 -\/*D<br />

Y\31Y aZS4Sbn `SaV Z*]*/1ZSq L5 \*ZD 6B5:C<br />

`SbD 5MD<br />

`SabS*Z1 a d,*31ZS1Y \bZ\aqbaq V hd,O<br />

ab,*Y +`*bn1, S a1ab1` LSYD 58B65MD ˚aWS<br />

ab*Z1b S4,1abZ\E hb\ f`SabS*ZSZ f`*ZSb d a1O<br />

+q \-Z1ab`1WnZ\1 \`d3S1 Z* aWdh*y Z*]*/1O<br />

ZSq ]`1abd]ZSV\,E ob\ Y\31b j\VS`\,*bn V\O<br />

-\Ob\ S4 hW1Z\, a\+`*ZSq SWS /*31 ab*bn /Wq<br />

Z1-\ V*YZ1Y ]`1bVZ\,1ZSqD p+\,n ]\+d3/*O<br />

1b Z*a /dY*bn , ]1`,dp \h1`1/n Z1 \ a1+1E * \<br />

/`d-SfE /*31 1aWS S4O4* ob\-\ Z*Y Zd3Z\ \bV*O<br />

4*bnaq \b b\-\E Z* hb\E V*V Z*Y V*31baqE d Z*a<br />

1abn4*V\ZZ\1]`*,\L5\`D5>B76E77C57B8E9MD<br />

`SabS*Z1 ab`1Yqbaq ,1abS a1+q \+`*4g\O<br />

,\ L6 \`D 8B6C 5 1bD 9B6E 7MD ˚aWS f`SabS*ZSZ<br />

]`\/\W3*1b /1`3*bn d a1+q \`d3S1 a g1Wnp 4*O<br />

kSbm \b ]`1abd]ZSV\, /*31 ]\aW1 b\-\E V*V<br />

ab*`1yjSZm /*WS 1Yd ]\ ob\Yd ]\,\/d \aZ\O<br />

,*ZZmy Z* S+WSS a\,1bE 1-\ ]\,1/1ZS1 Z1WnO<br />

4q Z*4,*bn \+`*4g\,mYD \ob\Yd b*V\y f`SO<br />

abS*ZSZ Z1 a\\b,1bab,d1b b`1+\,*ZSqY /Wq<br />

b1fE Vb\ Sa]\WZq1b ]\h1bZm1 \+q4*ZZ\abS ,<br />

a\+`*ZSSD\b 31 ]`SZgS] ]`SY1ZSY V f`SabSO<br />

*ZSZdE V\b\`my Z\aSb \`d3S1 Z* `*+\b1D ˚Yd<br />

Wdhj1 ]\/maV*bn /`d-dp `*+\bdD<br />

\E V*VSY \+`*4\Y f`SabS*ZSZ +d/1b 4*kSO<br />

k*bn a1+qE a,\p a1Ynp SWS SYdk1ab,\E ,\<br />

YZ\-\Y q,Wq1baq 1-\ WShZmY /1W\YE b*V 31<br />

V*V S b\E -/1 S V1Y \Z `*+\b*1bD /Z*V\E ]`SO<br />

ZSY*q `1j1ZSq ]\ obSY ,\]`\a*YE ab\Sb dhSO<br />

bm,*bn +S+W1yaVS1 ]`SZgS]mE , V\b\`mf \bO<br />

`*3*1baq Yd/`\abn \-* S 1-\ Wp+\,n V Z*YD<br />

˙df\,Z\ 4`1Wm1 f`SabS*Z1E V\b\`m1 d,*3*pb<br />

obS ]`SZgS]mE Z1 ab*Zdb f`*ZSbn d a1+q \-Z1O<br />

ab`1WnZ\1\`d3S1/Wq4*kSbm\b]`1abd]ZSO<br />

V\,D ZS d,1`1Zm , b\YE hb\ b1E Vb\ ]\W*-*pbaq<br />

Z*\-*S]\abd]*pb,a\-W*aSSa+S+W1yaVSO<br />

YS ]`SZgS]*YSE , +d/dk1Y +d/db 3Sbn , YS`1<br />

S +14\]*aZ\abS LaD =;B5>C `SbD 5B77C 6B:E ;MD<br />

\Wnj1 SZe\`Y*gSS \ b\YE Y\31b WS f`SabS*ZSZ a\O<br />

-W*aSbnaq Z* `*+\bdE Z* V\b\`\y b`1+d1baq Z\aSbn \`dO<br />

3S1E Y\3Z\ Z*ybS , ,m]daV*f wb\`\31,\y +*jZSx \b<br />

5 Z\q+`q 6>>9 -\/*E ab`*ZSg* 75E S \b 5 e1,`*Wq 5=

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!