BusinessDay 22 Mar 2018
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Thursday <strong>22</strong> <strong>Mar</strong>ch <strong>2018</strong><br />
Investor<br />
Helping you to build wealth & make wise decisions<br />
C002D5556<br />
BUSINESS DAY<br />
19<br />
PZ Nigeria: Stock outlook hazy after<br />
parent company’s earnings warning<br />
…Cordros Capital favours ‘sell’ rating; FBNQuests retains ‘underperform’ rating<br />
IHEANYI NWACHUKWU<br />
PZ Cussons Plc, the<br />
parent company<br />
of PZ Nigeria Plc<br />
said in a trading<br />
update released<br />
<strong>Mar</strong>ch 15 that it now expects<br />
its profit for the year ending<br />
May <strong>2018</strong> will fall short<br />
of expectations. In 2017,<br />
the shares of PZ Nigeria<br />
appreciated by 42percent in<br />
line with the broad market.<br />
In the earnings warning,<br />
the parent company<br />
mentioned that intense<br />
competition is resulting in<br />
lower prices and margins,<br />
but “noticeably in the milk<br />
category”.<br />
The Group said it has<br />
initiated some remedial<br />
actions in Nigeria, including<br />
a (1) reassessment of the<br />
structure of its operating<br />
model to further reduce<br />
the overhead base, (2)<br />
review of product costs with<br />
a focus on areas such as<br />
packaging reduction, and (3)<br />
re-prioritisation of the new<br />
product pipeline to focus<br />
on fewer, bigger projects<br />
requiring lower levels of<br />
complexity.<br />
When clearly executed,<br />
analysts believe these<br />
efficiency measures will<br />
be potentially positive for<br />
margins.<br />
No doubt, the parent<br />
company’s earnings warning<br />
made good some analysts<br />
earlier depressing outlook<br />
for the stock which was<br />
priced at N23.55 kobo last<br />
Monday.<br />
In their January <strong>22</strong><br />
note to investors, Uwadiae<br />
Osadiaye-led team of<br />
analysts at Lagos-based<br />
FBNQuest said, “Looking<br />
ahead, we note that the<br />
business environment is<br />
becoming more competitive<br />
and consumer demand<br />
remains soft following<br />
significant cost inflation in<br />
recent quarters.”<br />
Following FBN<br />
Quest research analyst’s<br />
discussions with PZ Nigeria<br />
Plc management, the<br />
analysts believe that PZ’s<br />
White Goods segment and<br />
sales of bulk milk due to<br />
pricing pressures are likely<br />
to continue to struggle in the<br />
near-term.<br />
“We also understand<br />
that naira credit availability<br />
which was tight in first-half<br />
(H1) <strong>2018</strong> (end Nov) may<br />
persist through the year.<br />
However, we expect already<br />
rolled-out initiatives at<br />
the start of H2 <strong>2018</strong> (end-<br />
May), which is PZ’s peak<br />
season, such as distribution<br />
expansion and new product<br />
launches will help to improve<br />
performance during the<br />
period.<br />
“We forecast sales<br />
growth of 21percent y/y<br />
to N96.1billion. However,<br />
we forecast earnings per<br />
share (EPS) decline of circa<br />
53percent y/y to N1.69 in<br />
<strong>2018</strong>E due to the adverse<br />
impact coming through from<br />
FX-related losses this year”,<br />
said FBNQuest analysts.<br />
“PZ posted FX-related<br />
losses of N2.6billion in H1<br />
<strong>2018</strong> alone. Excluding FXrelated<br />
losses, EPS growth<br />
was 36percent y/y. Our new<br />
price target of N20.5 is up<br />
24percent and implies a<br />
downside potential. Our<br />
new PT is driven by marketreflective<br />
adjustments to our<br />
risk-free rate and equity risk<br />
premium assumptions.<br />
“While we lowered the<br />
former by 150basis bps to<br />
14percent we cut the latter<br />
by 50bps to 6percent. We<br />
have also rolled forward<br />
our valuation to 2019. We<br />
retain our Underperform<br />
rating on the stock. PZ shares<br />
are trading on a <strong>2018</strong>E P/E<br />
multiple of 13.0x for average<br />
EPS growth of 5epercent y/y<br />
over the 2019-2021E period”,<br />
FBNQuest analysts further<br />
stated.<br />
Meanwhile in their<br />
<strong>Mar</strong>ch 16 note on valuation<br />
following PZ Cussons<br />
earnings warning, Cordros<br />
Capital said, “We have a ‘Sell’<br />
recommendation for PZ<br />
Nigeria.” The analysts target<br />
price for the share is N15.19,<br />
with YtD return of 12percent.<br />
PZ Nigeria Plc is valued at<br />
N93.504billion with shares<br />
outstanding of 3.970billion<br />
units.<br />
The stock price has<br />
gained 14.3percent this<br />
year, surpassing the NSE<br />
All Share Index (ASI) which<br />
stood at circa 10percent in<br />
same period, according to<br />
Nigerian Stock Exchange<br />
(NSE) trading data. PZ<br />
Nigeria Plc stock price had<br />
reached a 52-week low of<br />
N13.30 and a 52-week high<br />
of N27.30.<br />
Trading conditions<br />
in Nigeria and UK were<br />
unfavourable in first-half<br />
(H1), and apparently, the<br />
usual peak season uplift has<br />
not occurred to the expected<br />
level thus far in second-half<br />
(H2), according to Cordros<br />
Capital in their recent note<br />
to investors.<br />
“In our note published on<br />
20 February, we estimated<br />
that PZ Nigeria <strong>2018</strong>E net<br />
profit will be lower by<br />
7percent versus 2017FY.<br />
But the tone of the parent<br />
company’s communication<br />
of this earnings warning has<br />
raised concern for us that<br />
the decline might be bigger.<br />
The guidance provided by PZ<br />
Cussons is for 18-23percent<br />
decline in Group <strong>2018</strong>E<br />
Profit Before Tax (PBT)<br />
versus 2017FY”, the analysts<br />
said.<br />
“We update on PZ<br />
following recent meeting<br />
with management.<br />
Feedback is that the<br />
operating environment has<br />
been more challenging than<br />
expected since December,<br />
and could impact the<br />
group’s performance in the<br />
traditionally strong second<br />
half, and indeed, <strong>2018</strong>F”,<br />
Cordros analysts said in<br />
their February 20 note to<br />
investors.<br />
“There is actually<br />
sales pressure in “Naija”.<br />
The management of the<br />
Nigerian subsidiary<br />
actually confirmed to us in<br />
February that the operating<br />
environment has been<br />
more challenging than<br />
expected since December<br />
2017, and could impact the<br />
group’s performance in the<br />
traditionally strong second<br />
half, and indeed, <strong>2018</strong>F. The<br />
Personal Care {-5percent<br />
year-on-year (y/y) volume<br />
in H1} and Electrical<br />
(-20percent y/y volume in<br />
H1) divisions remain under<br />
pressure, while Home Care<br />
(+7percent y/y volume in<br />
H1) has been resilient.<br />
“In essence, the 23percent<br />
y/y revenue growth in H1-18<br />
was entirely price-driven.<br />
Revenue growth should<br />
moderate to 8percent in H2,<br />
by our estimate”, Cordros<br />
stated.<br />
Morison raises N502.2m new equity funds<br />
Mo r i s o n<br />
Industries<br />
P l c h a s<br />
successfully<br />
raised N502.2million in new<br />
equity funds, providing the<br />
healthcare company with<br />
the much-needed boost to<br />
reposition its operations.<br />
The company had late last<br />
year launched a new capital<br />
raising for about N502.2<br />
million in new equity funds<br />
through new share sale<br />
to existing shareholders.<br />
Morison Industries offered a<br />
rights issue of 836.98 million<br />
ordinary shares of 50 Kobo<br />
each at 60 Kobo per share on<br />
the basis of 11 new ordinary<br />
shares for every two ordinary<br />
shares of 50 Kobo held as at<br />
August 25, 2017.<br />
GTI Securities Limited<br />
acted as the stockbroker<br />
to the supplementary<br />
share issuance while GTI<br />
Capital Limited was the<br />
issuing house. Both GTI<br />
Securities and GTI Capital<br />
are members of the GTI<br />
Group-a leading financial<br />
services group that owns the<br />
largest private trading floor<br />
in Sub Saharan Africa (SSA).<br />
The allotment results for<br />
the rights issue approved by<br />
the Securities and Exchange<br />
Commission (SEC) showed<br />
that the rights issue was<br />
oversubscribed by 1.12<br />
million ordinary shares as<br />
shareholders took up their<br />
rights and demanded for<br />
additional shares. As against<br />
836.98 million shares placed<br />
on offer, shareholders placed<br />
orders for 838.11 million<br />
ordinary shares.<br />
“The success of the rights<br />
issue has further confirmed<br />
GTI Capital’s pedigree of<br />
packaging companies to<br />
raise capital, irrespective<br />
of the macroeconomic and<br />
market conditions. GTI<br />
Capital worked with the<br />
directors and management<br />
of Morison Industries to<br />
convince shareholders on<br />
the prospects of the 63 year<br />
old healthcare company”,<br />
said Kehinde Hassan, Chief<br />
Operating Officer, GTI<br />
Capital.<br />
“We were able to get<br />
many shareholders to<br />
subscribe to the shares due<br />
to our extensive research<br />
on the prospects of the<br />
company. Many subscribers<br />
were also impressed by<br />
the fact that all offers that<br />
we had handled in the<br />
past usually turned into<br />
goldmines, and the facts<br />
are out there. So the trust in<br />
GTI Capital positively rubs<br />
off on the exciting prospects<br />
of a recapitalised Morison<br />
Industries,” Hassan said.<br />
He reiterated the<br />
commitment of GTI Capital<br />
Group to supporting the<br />
growth of indigenous<br />
economy by providing<br />
amenable debt and equity<br />
capital and other advisory<br />
services to Nigerian<br />
companies, adding that with<br />
its international presence,<br />
GTI Capital Group is wellpositioned<br />
to handle private<br />
and public fund raisings for<br />
companies in Nigeria and<br />
beyond.<br />
“The new equity funds<br />
would be deployed to<br />
improve working capital and<br />
finance the restructuring of<br />
the company. With the new<br />
equity funds, shareholders<br />
can be well assured of a new<br />
era of growth for Morison<br />
Industries adding that the<br />
directors of the company will<br />
work with all stakeholders to<br />
achieve its growth targets”,<br />
said Nwabueze Oputa,<br />
Managing Director, Morison<br />
Industries Plc.<br />
Oputa commended the<br />
professionalism of GTI<br />
Capital in concluding the<br />
rights issue successfully<br />
and as scheduled, pointing<br />
out that GTI Capital has<br />
reinforced his confidence in<br />
the capabilites of Nigerian<br />
capital market operators.<br />
Morison Industries was<br />
incorporated in Nigeria<br />
in June 1955. Morison<br />
Industries is engaged in the<br />
production and marketing<br />
of pharmaceuticals, hygiene<br />
products and the importation<br />
and distribution of medical,<br />
surgical and hospital<br />
equipment, instruments and<br />
consumables. The company<br />
also provides its production<br />
facilities to third party for<br />
contract manufacturing<br />
arrangements.