07.12.18
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
PW OPINION PW NEWS PW LIFE PW ARTS<br />
•OPINION•<br />
BY KEVIN UHRICH<br />
BAD NEWS<br />
SURVEY SAYS NEARLY TWO-THIRDS OF PUBLIC BELIEVES THE<br />
MEDIA IS BIASED IN ITS COVERAGE<br />
Would Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh view as sacrosanct<br />
the Constitution’s orders to Congress to “make no laws respecting an<br />
establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or<br />
abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably<br />
to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances?”<br />
Or would he see such protections as a threat to the republic?<br />
As it stands now, The Press — television, radio and newspapers — is in big trouble,<br />
largely of its own making. But, of course, some of the public’s disdain for the news<br />
media must be attributed to a relentless war being waged against it by President<br />
Trump.<br />
The latest salvo was launched last week at a campaign stop for a Republican US<br />
Senate challenger in Montana. The president lit into unnamed journalists for reports<br />
on his summit with North Korean dictator Kim Jong Un, and other reports on his<br />
upcoming meeting with Russian President Vladimir Putin, calling them “fake news,”<br />
and concluding most but not all reporters are “downright dishonest,” “crooked” and<br />
“bad people.”<br />
This might have been easy to dismiss, except for the fact the president’s remarks<br />
came one week after five employees of the Capital Gazette in Annapolis Maryland<br />
were shot to death. Two others were also seriously injured after a man with a grudge<br />
against the paper entered the newsroom and opened fire with a shotgun.<br />
One day after the shooting, the president said, “Journalists, like all Americans,<br />
should be free from the fear of being violently attacked while doing their job,” CNN’s<br />
Brian Stelter reported.<br />
“But that same day,” Stelter’s report continues, “he also resumed his anti-media<br />
rhetoric. On Twitter, he called the ‘fake news’ part of the ‘opposition party;’ chastised<br />
journalists for pointing out his Twitter typos; accused the Washington Post of making<br />
up sources again; and called the Post ‘a disgrace to journalism,’ adding, ‘but then<br />
again, so are many others!’”<br />
In an interview with PBS’s Judy Woodruff, CBS reporter Lesley Stahl told of a<br />
conversation she had with Trump shortly after the election. Stahl, according to the<br />
Washington Post, said she asked the president if he planned to stop attacking the press.<br />
“I said, you know that is getting tired, why are you doing this — you’re doing it over<br />
and over and it’s boring,” Stahl said. “He said you know why I do it? I do it to discredit<br />
you all and demean you all, so when you write negative stories about me no one will<br />
believe you.”<br />
And that tactic appears to be working.<br />
A Gallup/John S. and James L. Knight Foundation survey of 1,440 people found<br />
that “US adults estimate that 62 percent of the news they read in newspapers, see on<br />
television or hear on the radio is biased. They think the news media mostly provide<br />
accurate information, but still estimate that 44 percent of what they see is inaccurate.<br />
And they believe that more than a third of the news they see in these channels is<br />
misinformation — false or inaccurate information that is presented as if it were true,”<br />
according to the foundation. On social media, “They believe 80 percent of it is biased,<br />
64 percent is inaccurate and 65 percent is misinformation.”<br />
On Wednesday, the ACLU Pasadena-Foothills chapter and the LA Progressive web<br />
magazine hosted the discussion “Press Freedoms Under Attack,” featuring comments<br />
from civil rights attorney Stephen Rohde, author and radio political talk show host<br />
Sonali Kolhatkar of KPFK 90.7 FM, and Dick Price and Sharon Kyle, publishers of LA<br />
Progressive.<br />
David Snyder, executive director of the First Amendment Coalition, said Attorney<br />
General Jeff Sessions said earlier this year that the Justice Department had tripled the<br />
number of leak investigations that were going on when President Obama left office.<br />
“The First Amendment protects not just free speech, the right to assemble, but it<br />
specifically calls out the free press,” said Snyder, speaking to Brian Day and David<br />
Cross of the Pasadena Now news website. “So written into our Constitution is the idea<br />
that the Fourth Estate, as it’s sometimes called, has a key function, and that is to help<br />
expose corruption and wrongdoing in government so that the people can understand<br />
where their government is running afoul of the law or of the goals to which the people<br />
believe the government should be focused on.”<br />
Does Judge Kavanaugh or the sitting justices think it’s OK to spy on reporters,<br />
as Presidents Bush II, Obama and now Trump have all done? Could this apparently<br />
widespread diminution of trust in the press lead to fewer journalistic freedoms with<br />
Kavanaugh on the High Court?<br />
Given the damage that the Fourth Estate is already doing to itself, in part by<br />
sometimes acting like “the opposition party,” Trump may have no need to continue<br />
criticizing a once unassailable institution that more and more people seem to trust<br />
less and less. ■<br />
6 PASADENA WEEKLY | <strong>07.12.18</strong>