27.12.2012 Views

dynamic gas test and afects - Roehrig Engineering

dynamic gas test and afects - Roehrig Engineering

dynamic gas test and afects - Roehrig Engineering

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

ROEHRIG ENGINEERING TECHNICAL UNDERSTANDING SERIES<br />

THE ROEHRIG GAS TEST<br />

THE DYNAMIC GAS TEST AND EFFECTS OF GAS PRESSURE<br />

Test: Used the same shock <strong>and</strong> ran it on 2” stroke, 100 F warm up at 10 in/sec using a <strong>Roehrig</strong><br />

<strong>Engineering</strong> 5VS crank type dynamometer. We collected data at three different pressures<br />

without changing anything else. For the <strong>test</strong>, we zeroed the load cell with the shock hanging<br />

from the upper crossbar, pre-loaded it 2” for the <strong>test</strong>. We ran a st<strong>and</strong>ard <strong>Roehrig</strong> <strong>Engineering</strong><br />

<strong>gas</strong> <strong>test</strong>, stopping at mid-stroke for 2 sec.<br />

One feature of <strong>Roehrig</strong> <strong>Engineering</strong>’s (REI) Shock software is the ability to measure the <strong>gas</strong><br />

force of the damper <strong>and</strong> remove its value from the data. REI does this by moving the crank to<br />

mid stroke <strong>and</strong> measuring the load cell force. We do this in both the compression <strong>and</strong> the<br />

rebound directions. We also allow the user to set how long the shock stops before measuring the<br />

load cell. This becomes very important when the shock has very little bleed.<br />

Why does <strong>Roehrig</strong> feel that this important? The main reason is that with a <strong>gas</strong> shock, there is an<br />

effect of the <strong>gas</strong> chamber on the damper. Statically, if you compress the shock by h<strong>and</strong> you are<br />

compressing the <strong>gas</strong> chamber. The pressure in the chamber pushes back against the shaft with<br />

some amount of force. The higher the <strong>gas</strong> pressure, the more force it produces on the shaft. The<br />

<strong>gas</strong> chamber acts like a spring, the more you compress it the more force it exerts on the shaft.<br />

If you put 50 psi into your shock <strong>and</strong> put it on the car, it would raise the car by a small amount<br />

because the <strong>gas</strong> force is trying to push the shaft out. If you added more pressure, say 200 psi, it<br />

would raise the car even more. Now, I am not suggesting it will raise it 1 inch, but it will raise it.<br />

What do you do then? You take rounds out of the car to get the ride heights you want.<br />

Basically, when you scale the car you take into account the effects of the <strong>gas</strong> pressure from the<br />

shock. If you add <strong>gas</strong> pressure, you re-adjust your spring heights <strong>and</strong> away you go. This is also<br />

the reason that some people use the <strong>gas</strong> pressure of the shock to act like a spring in the car, thus<br />

allowing them to run less spring in the front of the car. It is for this reason that <strong>Roehrig</strong> decided<br />

to measure the <strong>gas</strong> force <strong>and</strong> then remove it from the data. Like you do on the car, we remove the<br />

static effects of the <strong>gas</strong> chamber on the data. We only want you to look at the <strong>dynamic</strong> effects of<br />

the shock.<br />

Removing the static <strong>gas</strong> force at mid stroke allows the user of a <strong>Roehrig</strong> dynamometer to be able<br />

to compare shocks with different <strong>gas</strong> pressures <strong>and</strong> not have to worry about the static force from<br />

the <strong>gas</strong> chamber. There are some <strong>dynamic</strong> effects from the <strong>gas</strong> chamber that will show up in the<br />

data.<br />

ROEHRIG ENGINEERING INC.<br />

WWW.ROEHRIGENGINEERING.COM<br />

1-800-735-7265<br />

1


ROEHRIG ENGINEERING TECHNICAL UNDERSTANDING SERIES<br />

THE ROEHRIG GAS TEST<br />

Figure #1 shows the same shock with three different <strong>gas</strong> pressures (100, 175 <strong>and</strong> 250 psi). Each<br />

time we added <strong>gas</strong> force the graph moved up the force axis by an amount equal to the extra force<br />

on the shaft. If you did not know what changed, you might say that we added compression <strong>and</strong><br />

took away rebound. It could lead you down the wrong path. As you add more <strong>gas</strong> pressure, i.e.<br />

spring rate, you add a static force that continues to raise the overall force of the graph. You have<br />

added a force offset based on how much <strong>gas</strong> pressure is in the chamber. But, has the graph shape<br />

actually changed or does it only seem like it?<br />

Figure #1: Gas Force Kept in the Data<br />

RED TRACE: 250 PSI, BLUE TRACE: 175 PSI, GREEN TRACE: 100 PSI<br />

What happens when we remove the static <strong>gas</strong> force from each <strong>test</strong>, so that we only compare the<br />

internals of the shock <strong>and</strong> the <strong>dynamic</strong> effects of the <strong>gas</strong> chamber?<br />

ROEHRIG ENGINEERING INC.<br />

WWW.ROEHRIGENGINEERING.COM<br />

1-800-735-7265<br />

2


ROEHRIG ENGINEERING TECHNICAL UNDERSTANDING SERIES<br />

THE ROEHRIG GAS TEST<br />

The graph below shows how when you remove the static <strong>gas</strong> force, as measured by <strong>Roehrig</strong>’s<br />

<strong>gas</strong> <strong>test</strong>, the graphs line up just like you would expect. Since we did not change the internals of<br />

the shock, it makes no sense that the curves would change. Just like if you added 200 psi to the<br />

front shocks on your car, the front end would raise a small amount due to the added spring rate<br />

from the shocks. You would then, I hope, re-adjust your spring perches to get your ride height<br />

back to where you wanted it.<br />

Figure #2: Gas Force Removed<br />

RED TRACE: 250 PSI, BLUE TRACE: 175 PSI, GREEN TRACE: 100 PSI<br />

We have removed the static <strong>gas</strong> force from the shock. Are there any <strong>dynamic</strong> affects of the<br />

increased pressure?<br />

ROEHRIG ENGINEERING INC.<br />

WWW.ROEHRIGENGINEERING.COM<br />

1-800-735-7265<br />

3


ROEHRIG ENGINEERING TECHNICAL UNDERSTANDING SERIES<br />

THE ROEHRIG GAS TEST<br />

Notice how the <strong>test</strong> with 250 psi in the chamber (red trace) looks just a little stronger on<br />

compression closed side of the cycle. Figure #3 shows a close up version of the three runs. The<br />

run with the most <strong>gas</strong> pressure (red) shows extra compression force on the closing side. This is<br />

due to the effect of the <strong>dynamic</strong> addition the <strong>gas</strong> force makes. In the compression closing stage,<br />

the shock is still compressing <strong>and</strong> it is slowing down. Since it is still compressing, the <strong>gas</strong><br />

chamber is adding its spring rate to the force curve. Basically, the higher the pressure, the larger<br />

the spring rate <strong>and</strong> the larger the force offset to the curve.<br />

Figure #3: Gas Force Removed Close up View<br />

RED TRACE: 250 PSI, BLUE TRACE: 175 PSI, GREEN TRACE: 100 PSI<br />

ROEHRIG ENGINEERING INC.<br />

WWW.ROEHRIGENGINEERING.COM<br />

1-800-735-7265<br />

4


ROEHRIG ENGINEERING TECHNICAL UNDERSTANDING SERIES<br />

THE ROEHRIG GAS TEST<br />

For those of you wondering why we do it at mid stroke <strong>and</strong> not some where else, you ask a good<br />

question. The further you compress the shock, the more you compress the <strong>gas</strong> chamber <strong>and</strong> the<br />

bigger the pressure build up in the shock. Doing it at mid stroke is just a good average. Future<br />

versions of software may allow the user to do a <strong>gas</strong> <strong>test</strong> at several different stages of the stroke<br />

<strong>and</strong> compensate at each stage by removing the force. This is for the future.<br />

If you realize that depending on how your shocks are mounted on the car, the shock may be<br />

compressed more on one corner than the next corner. You also see how the <strong>gas</strong> chamber can<br />

affect the car’s behavior over time. If your right front shock was more compressed than the left<br />

front, they would each have a different static <strong>gas</strong> force, provided you put the same pressure in<br />

them to start.<br />

Another thought would be, as the temperature of the shock increases, the temperature of the <strong>gas</strong><br />

chamber increases <strong>and</strong> as a result the pressure goes up <strong>and</strong> the force exerted on the shock shaft<br />

increases. This means that during your 20 or 30 lap run on the track, the pressure in the shock is<br />

increasing because the temperature of the <strong>gas</strong> chamber is getting hotter <strong>and</strong> the increased spring<br />

rate may be affecting your car’s h<strong>and</strong>ling. Think what would happen if 20 laps into your run,<br />

you added 25 lb/in of spring rate to the front shocks, what would it do to your h<strong>and</strong>ling?<br />

We will be producing several more papers discussing temperature, adjustment <strong>and</strong> cavitation in<br />

shock absorbers. Stay tuned <strong>and</strong> keep watching the Technical info section of the website:<br />

www.roehrigengineering.com for future papers to help <strong>and</strong> maybe confuse you more. Any<br />

suggestions for technical info can be submitted to Michael@roehrigengineering.com.<br />

ROEHRIG ENGINEERING INC.<br />

WWW.ROEHRIGENGINEERING.COM<br />

1-800-735-7265<br />

5

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!