sammlung- sine qua non - Munich Wine Company
sammlung- sine qua non - Munich Wine Company
sammlung- sine qua non - Munich Wine Company
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Robert Parker<br />
From To Judgement<br />
96 100 extraordinary<br />
90 95 outstanding<br />
80 89 above average to very good<br />
70 79 average<br />
60 69 below average<br />
50 59 deemed to be unacceptable<br />
<strong>Wine</strong>spectator<br />
From To Judgement<br />
95 100 classic; a great wine<br />
90 94 outstanding; superior character<br />
and style<br />
80 89 good to very good; wine with<br />
special <strong>qua</strong>lities<br />
70 79 average; drinkable wine, may have<br />
minor flaws<br />
60 69 below average; drinkable<br />
but not recommended<br />
50 59 poor; undrinkable, not recommended<br />
Michael Broadbent<br />
Score Judgement<br />
***** outstanding<br />
**** very good<br />
*** good<br />
** moderately good<br />
* not very good but not bad<br />
no stars poor<br />
Clive Coates<br />
Score Judgement<br />
20 grand vin<br />
19 very fine indeed<br />
18 fine plus<br />
17 very good indeed<br />
16 very good<br />
15 good<br />
14 quite good<br />
13 not bad<br />
Alan Winkelman<br />
From To Judgement<br />
9,0 10,0 outstanding to extraordinary<br />
8,0 8,9 very good to outstanding<br />
7,0 7,9 good to very good<br />
6,0 6,9 average to good<br />
5,0 5,9 drinkable to average<br />
Gambero Rosso<br />
Score Judgement<br />
3 Gläser premium wine<br />
2 Gläser very good wine<br />
1 Glas good wine<br />
0 Gläser correct wine<br />
WINE SCORING SYSTEMS<br />
John Platter<br />
Score Judgement<br />
***** Cape classic<br />
**** excellent<br />
*** characterful and appealing<br />
** pleasant drinking<br />
* plain and simple<br />
Rene Gabriel<br />
21/20<br />
Legends<br />
20/20<br />
Vintage wine<br />
of the century<br />
19/20<br />
Top<br />
18/20<br />
Outstanding<br />
17/20<br />
Remarkable<br />
16/20<br />
Very good<br />
15/20<br />
Good<br />
14/20<br />
Satisfactory<br />
13/20<br />
Below average<br />
12/20<br />
Unsatisfactory<br />
11/20<br />
Poor<br />
10/20<br />
Unacceptable<br />
Reserved for wines which are beyond the<br />
scale, like the 37 d'Yquem or the 47<br />
Château Cheval Blanc.<br />
Every aspect is perfect. Only very few wines,<br />
and only in great vintages.<br />
Former vintage wines of the century on<br />
their descending journey and young<br />
aspirants for the vintage wine of the century.<br />
Around 130 wines every year are rated<br />
19/20 in Bordeaux, about half of them<br />
older than 30 years.<br />
Outstanding in blind degustations. They<br />
show strength, concentration nuances and<br />
a personal character. The price is irrelevant<br />
for the point evaluation from this level on.<br />
A very good wine with independent<br />
character but missing the touch of greatness.<br />
Around 400 every year in Bordeaux<br />
for example.<br />
A very good wine is fun to drink even for<br />
wine-lovers. Often the best wines from<br />
small vintages or the prestigious losers<br />
from good vintages. Very often good value<br />
for the price.<br />
For certain wines just the word -good -<br />
comes to mind. Nothing special, but simply<br />
good.<br />
Satisfactory wine, the lowest <strong>qua</strong>lity level for<br />
some praise.<br />
Below average for the vintage and below<br />
comparable wineries. Useful for standard<br />
cooking.<br />
Not good enough to be sold by a <strong>qua</strong>lity<br />
label. Destined for a<strong>non</strong>ymous mass-wine<br />
sales.<br />
Only produced by a very <strong>non</strong> ambitious<br />
wine maker.<br />
Industrial alcohol standard.
Change language