Dossier KIJAC ENG - Rrokum TV
Dossier KIJAC ENG - Rrokum TV
Dossier KIJAC ENG - Rrokum TV
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
RROKUM TELEVISION<br />
INVESTIGATIVE JOURNALISM SECTION<br />
November 2011
<strong>Dossier</strong> “<strong>KIJAC</strong>”<br />
It all began with two friends who were in need of money. The first one, who was<br />
going to be appointed political adviser to the first Prime Minister of independent<br />
Kosovo, Hashim Thaci, was broke yet aspired a PhD title; the second one had many<br />
years of experience in Kosovo as international staff which led him to grow a slight<br />
frustration, fortified with personal crisis at the same period. Under these<br />
circumstances, he decided he was going to play his last game in Kosovo – to make<br />
money.<br />
They opened a Journalism faculty.<br />
As if it was a movie plot, Dukagjin Gorani, currently political advisor to Prime<br />
Minister Hashim Thaci, and Willem Houwen, former senior official at the OSCE<br />
mission in Kosovo, started the biggest financial scandal in the field of journalism in<br />
post-NATO Kosovo, implying the Foreign Ministry of Norway, Cardiff University of<br />
Britain, the Kosovo Ministry of Education, Norwegian School of Journalism<br />
“Gimlekollen” and approximately - 7 million euros in funds.
From the left: Willem Houwen and Dukagjin Gorani<br />
In the article «Kosovo's Fresh Start », Kaare Melhus 1 , the name that would soon<br />
become the leading name in the launch of this project, writes « the senior advisor at<br />
the OSCE Media, Willem Houwen, believes that the training of journalists should be<br />
institutionalized. A representative from the press of NATO's forces in Kosovo,<br />
Kenneth Andresen, was also a journalism teacher at the School of Journalism and<br />
Communication Gimlekollen of Norway. Norway's Foreign Ministry was approached<br />
through Gimlekollen for funds and so they were secured for the launching of the<br />
faculty. Gimlekollen was entrusted for the role of leadership in creating <strong>KIJAC</strong> ».<br />
Hence, it was the School of Journalism and Communication Gimlekollen of Norway<br />
that generated the money from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Norway and took<br />
over the launching of this faculty, which was also often called, the Institute of<br />
Professional Journalism in Kosovo. Through the portal « Global Journalist » Mr.<br />
Melhus wrote and informed the global opinion of journalism about KIAC, « founded<br />
in 2005, the Kosovo Institute of Journalism and Communication (<strong>KIJAC</strong>) has<br />
produced 25 candidates for master's (MA) in journalism each year ».<br />
What was the role of the political advisor to the prime minister Hashim Thaci?<br />
During the five years of existence of <strong>KIJAC</strong>, Dukagjin Gorani and Willem Houwen,<br />
were the 'faces' and the public contacts of the project. Dukagjin Gorani, who had not<br />
yet succeded to obtain a degree in any faculty in Kosovo, did not aspire a Bachelor<br />
degree, neither a M.A. degree, but he wanted to ‘catapult’ himself directly to a – Ph.D<br />
degree. Mr. Kaare Melhus writes, « Dukagjin Gorani heads the <strong>KIJAC</strong> Center and is<br />
responsible for non-academic training and production of <strong>TV</strong> programs. The technical<br />
equipment also generates income. Politicians and bureaucrats from various<br />
government ministries, including the Office of the Prime Minister, receive media<br />
training paid by the United Nations Development Program... » 2<br />
1<br />
Kaare Melhus is an international director of Gimlekollen School of Journalism and Communication,<br />
at Kristiansand in Norway.<br />
http://www.globaljournalist.org/stories/2009/03/31/kosovos-fresh-start/<br />
2 http://www.globaljournalist.org/stories/2009/03/31/kosovos-fresh-start/
This idyll of two friends Gorani and Houwen, the School of Journalism Gimlekollen,<br />
the Foreign Ministry of Norway and the Government of Kosovo were crowned with a<br />
Memorandum of Understanding that was signed between UNMIK (on behalf of the<br />
Ministry of Education of Kosovo) and <strong>KIJAC</strong> (see document in annex).<br />
However, Mr Gorani was persistent in his wish to obtain a title. Thus, in an agreement<br />
that <strong>KIJAC</strong> reached with Cardiff University in Britain, one of the conditions of this<br />
cooperation was – the Ph.D. title for Dukagjin Gorani.<br />
Representatives of Cardiff University, Professor Justin Lewis and Dr. Howard Barrell,<br />
addressed a letter to the lead researcher of the <strong>KIJAC</strong> <strong>Dossier</strong>, Mehdi Mulaj, in which<br />
they confirmed that an agreement between Cardiff University and <strong>KIJAC</strong> has been<br />
reached to offer two titles, a Ph.D. (Doctor of Science) and a M.A., and that all<br />
expenses will be covered by <strong>KIJAC</strong> (see document in annex).<br />
That Dukagjin Gorani was promised to gain a Ph.D. title in order to provide to the<br />
<strong>KIJAC</strong> a governmental support or at least to assure 'an undisturbed work of this<br />
faculty', is confirmed as well in Kaare Melhus’ leter on his answers to the questions<br />
that <strong>Rrokum</strong> researchers addressed him (see document in annex.). Finally, that<br />
Dukagjin Gorani’s Ph.D. title was ‘paid’ by <strong>KIJAC</strong> is also confirmed by Mr. Gorani<br />
himself in his reaction to the address of the portal of <strong>Rrokum</strong>.<strong>TV</strong>, « My relationship<br />
with the Institute <strong>KIJAC</strong> is related to my doctoral studies, sponsored by <strong>KIJAC</strong><br />
Institute » 3 .<br />
Facsimil (see: http://www.akkks.org/2011/Qeveria_e_Republikes_se_Kosoves/Zyra_e_Kryeministrit_te_Republikes_se_Kosoves/Dukagjin_Gorani.pdf)<br />
3 http://www.rrokum.tv/?page=1,4,1757&sqr=gorani
Who launched the project officially?<br />
In response to the questions of our researchers about - "Who launched the project?",<br />
Mr. Kaare Melhus did not mention neither Williem Houwen nor Dukagjin Gorani.<br />
For him, the invitation for launching the project was sent by the OSCE mission in<br />
Kosovo.<br />
“Gimlekollen School of Journalism and Communication (GSJC) was invited by the<br />
OSCE to start <strong>KIJAC</strong>. The initial idea was to first establish it as part of the University<br />
of Pristina, but the Minister of Education Science and Technolgy, Rexhep Osmani<br />
advised us to start as an independent institution since the conditions at the UP were<br />
not suitable for the time being”, states Mr. Melhus.<br />
Mr. Melhus offered us a copy of the original document of GSJC (Gimlekollen School<br />
of Journalism and Communication) and UNMIK, who signed a Memorandum of<br />
Understanding on behalf of the Ministry of Education as an institution that was at the<br />
time considered "provisional" (see document). In this Memorandum of<br />
Understanding, Article VI among others states:<br />
- To provide the neccessary housing and accomodation facilities to establish<br />
<strong>KIJAC</strong>;<br />
- To start the procedure to fully license <strong>KIJAC</strong> upon the signing of this MoU, as<br />
well as to accredit MA degree in journalism and communication, according to<br />
the provision of the Law on Higher Education<br />
As Mr. Kaare Melhus states in his response, the Memorandum of Understanding<br />
included also provisions concerning the licensing of <strong>KIJAC</strong>, the recognition of the<br />
degree accreditation, and the finding of accommodation for the faculty. None of the<br />
provisions in this agreement are met by the Ministry of Education. However, as Mr.<br />
Melhus also says, the launching of the project started upon the suggestions of the then<br />
Minister of Education, Rexhep Osmani, who called them to start as an independent<br />
institution outside the University of Pristina. Therefore <strong>KIJAC</strong> followed this<br />
suggestion and has been launched as such.<br />
Did <strong>KIJAC</strong> ever apply to the Ministry of Education of Kosovo to be accredited<br />
as a Journalism Faculty?<br />
Osman Shahini, Director of the Departament of Private Education at the Ministry of<br />
Education, said that <strong>KIJAC</strong> never applied for accreditation as a Faculty of Journalism.<br />
« I contacted the director of the faculty, Willem Houwen, and I called them to enter<br />
the accreditation process, but it was always the same answer, ‘let me call you when I<br />
am ready for accreditation', said Osman Shahini answering the questions of researcher<br />
Mehdi Mulaj.<br />
Mr. Melhus explains how <strong>KIJAC</strong> « aborted the application procedure in 2008 because<br />
we did not meet the requirement of financial and institutional sustainability at the<br />
time ». However, there are issues to be clarified to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of<br />
Norway as a donator, to the families of the students and to the students themselves:<br />
- How did it become possible to start this project after all ?<br />
- How could it function for five years without complying with any provisions of the
Memorandum of Understanding?<br />
- Why did it not even once apply for accreditation?<br />
- How was it possible for <strong>KIJAC</strong> to act if Mr. Melhus says - « we aborted the<br />
application procedure in 2008 because we did not meet the requirement of financial<br />
and institutional sustainability at the time »?<br />
- Why were they ‘hiding’ in a village near Pristina, and why did they settle the project<br />
in that particular building?<br />
- Is there any connection with the fact that the main political adviser to Prime Minister<br />
Thaci, Dukagjin Gorani, has been one of the founders of the faculty, and therefore<br />
despite the fact that the project was lacking many aspects of normal functioning, the<br />
<strong>KIJAC</strong> project continued to act and receive donnations for 5 years?<br />
The game with the accreditation of the degree<br />
Besides the question of accreditation as a Faculty of Journalism by the Ministry of<br />
Education, <strong>KIJAC</strong> continued to face another challenge – the lack of accreditation of<br />
the <strong>KIJAC</strong> degrees.<br />
The kosovar opinion revealed that <strong>KIJAC</strong> is facing a big scandal thanks to the public<br />
reactions of some students of this faculty, who published an attention alert on the<br />
portal 'Dardamedia' and invited the competent institutions to act because - -<br />
NOBODY RECOGNISES THE <strong>KIJAC</strong> AS AN ACCREDITED FACULTY,<br />
ACCORDINGLY, NOBODY IS RECOGNISING THE RIGHT OF THE <strong>KIJAC</strong> TO<br />
ACCREDIT THE DEGREES.<br />
When <strong>KIJAC</strong> students asked the <strong>KIJAC</strong> administrators why are they not yet<br />
accredited as a private institution of higher education and why MEST refuses to<br />
recognize the <strong>KIJAC</strong> titles, the <strong>KIJAC</strong> administrators replied that « we are connected<br />
directly with Cardiff University and as such the degrees are granted by this<br />
university ».<br />
<strong>Rrokum</strong> <strong>TV</strong>’s researchers contacted the heads of Cardiff University, Mr. Justin Lewis<br />
and Professor Barrell and they received a clear and final answer that the Cardiff<br />
University does not recognize nor bears any responsibility for <strong>KIJAC</strong> degrees.<br />
« Cardiff University’s involvement in the <strong>KIJAC</strong> project was limited. Cardiff’s role<br />
was confined to contributing specialized teaching on one part of the course. Nebraska<br />
University in the United States made a similar, limited contribution. Cardiff<br />
University was willing publicly to acknowledge its input into the course to indicate<br />
the quality of instruction that <strong>KIJAC</strong> students were receiving. But Cardiff University<br />
(and that of Nebraska) had no responsibility for the leadership, management,<br />
administration, funding and staffing of the project. Cardiff also did not have any<br />
responsibility for the accreditation of the course as an academic degree. Under the<br />
agreements that lead to the establishment of <strong>KIJAC</strong>, the Government of Kosovo and<br />
the project leader that exercised executive powers, the Gimlekollen School of<br />
Journalism and Communication, held all the responsibility for the accreditation of the<br />
degree. As a matter of policy, Cardiff University does not accredit any degree unless,<br />
among other conditions, members of its own staff teach all aspects and components of
a course of study leading to the award of that degree. This condition, among others,<br />
was not met by the <strong>KIJAC</strong> project.<br />
“Cardiff University’s involvement in the <strong>KIJAC</strong> project was limited. Cardiff’s role<br />
was confined to contributing specialized teaching on part of the course. Nebraska<br />
University in the United States made a similar, limited contribution. Cardiff<br />
University was willing publicly to acknowledge its input into the course to indicate<br />
the quality of instruction that <strong>KIJAC</strong> students were receiving. But Cardiff University<br />
(like Nebraska) had no responsibility for the leadership, management, administration,<br />
funding and staffing of the project. Cardiff also did not have any responsibility for the<br />
accreditation of the course as an academic degree. Under the agreements that<br />
established <strong>KIJAC</strong>, the Government of Kosovo and the project leader that exercised<br />
executive powers, the Gimlekollen School of Journalism and Communication, took<br />
on responsibility for the accreditation of the degree. As a matter of policy, Cardiff<br />
University does not accredit any degree unless, among other conditions, members of<br />
its own staff teach all aspects and components of a course of study leading to the<br />
award of that degree. This condition, among others, was not satisfied by the <strong>KIJAC</strong><br />
project.<br />
Questions about the issue of accreditation of a <strong>KIJAC</strong> degree -- and about all matters<br />
relating to the staffing, leadership, administration, management and funding of <strong>KIJAC</strong><br />
-- should be directed to the Gimlekollen School of Journalism and Communication in<br />
Kristiansand, Norway, that led the project. The people best equipped to answer your<br />
questions at that institution are Mr. Kaare Melhus, the <strong>KIJAC</strong> project manager Kaare<br />
Melhus and Dr Lars Dahle, chairman of the board of <strong>KIJAC</strong>”, among other things<br />
said in their statement to the investigative journalism section of <strong>Rrokum</strong> Television,<br />
Professor Justin Lewis, head of Cardiff University and the university lecturer, Dr<br />
Howard Barrell.<br />
As soon as researchers forwarded the statement of the Cardiff University to Mr. Kaare<br />
Melhus, he categorically denied, saying, «While we were waiting for the official<br />
accreditation, we issued diplomas validating the quality of the education with logos<br />
and signatures from the participating institutions. The Memorandum of<br />
Understanding states clearly that the accreditation was the responsibility of MEST.<br />
The MoU clearly does not say that this is Gimlekollen’s responsibility. The Cardiff<br />
statement is wrong on this point ».<br />
These explanations regarding the verification and recognition of diplomas and<br />
certificates by <strong>KIJAC</strong>, which are becoming public and transparent only after the<br />
project ended in a scandal, made the students understand that their studies and the<br />
tuitions paid are not valid. The amount for the tuition per year was - 1000 Euros - as it<br />
is confirmed by Mr. Melhus. Mr. Melhus said they expected that the Ministry of<br />
Education was going to verify these degrees one day therefore they had temporarily<br />
issued several certificates instead of the regular degrees, with logos and signatures of<br />
participatory institutions.
Journalism nearby the Holy tomb of Sultan Murat<br />
There was another matter that followed this project from the beginning - the location<br />
where the project managers had decided to establish <strong>KIJAC</strong>.<br />
Based on the MoU, the MEST was about to find a location for this project, but, as<br />
noted above, the former Minister of Education, Rexhep Osmani, had suggested that<br />
they continue as an independent institution. Following this suggestion, the project<br />
managers decided to settle <strong>KIJAC</strong> in a facility that had once served as a storehouse of<br />
medications, 25 miles from Pristina, in the Mazgit village, which is best known for<br />
being close to a cultural monument – the Holy tomb of Sultan Murat.
The building that was selected was a large warehouse, not at all suitable for a school.<br />
This building required large investments and the location was not justified because of<br />
the long distance from the center of Pristina. However, the managers decided to make<br />
a costly investment, to convert a warehouse into a Journalism Faculty. The building<br />
was painted with 'happy' colors, pink and green, they built a <strong>TV</strong> cabinet that was<br />
almost the size of a local television, the halls were converted to auditoriums and this<br />
is how the image for this international project was constructed, launched as a major<br />
journalism project in Kosovo.<br />
The "faces" of this project were Willem Houwen, a person known in Kosovo because<br />
of a long presence as international staff, which was originally an OSBE staff but who<br />
was also involved in many other projects in Kosovo as an 'international', and, the<br />
chief political advisor to Prime Minister Hashim Thaci, Dukagjin Gorani, a journalist<br />
who had a 'problem' - he had never graduated!<br />
On the question addressed to Mr. Kaare Melhus, about why did they choose this<br />
building in Mazgit, nearby the Holy tomb of Sultan Murat, 25 miles from the center<br />
of Pristina, Mr. Melhus answered, « The MoU also states that MEST is responsible<br />
for providing <strong>KIJAC</strong> with a building. (Article VI). But MEST never did this, and<br />
being in a desperate situation, we were offered the building near Sultan Murat’s tomb,<br />
where the Ministry of Health at the time was vacating the premises ».<br />
Researchers have found that the facility where the <strong>KIJAC</strong> Faculty of Journalism was<br />
established is the compound of the company "M & B", which offered this space to the<br />
Ministry of Health as a warehouse for drugs. The owner of this company was and still<br />
is the businessman Zeqir Gashi, who happened to be as well Dukagjin Gorani’s<br />
brother in law.<br />
Researchers could not find evidence to prove the rent amount paid to "M & B"<br />
company.
What does the Norwegian Foreign Ministry say on this case<br />
Suddenly, on 19 April 2011, the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Norway, Mr. Jonas<br />
Gahr Støre, came for a first visit to Kosovo. He met with the Prime Minister Thaci,<br />
and he held a press conference after this meeting. This was a good opportunity to<br />
address a public question to Mr. Gahr Støre on the <strong>KIJAC</strong> case, which is a project<br />
funded by his Ministry. When the journalist from <strong>Rrokum</strong> Television asked the<br />
minister whether he is informed about the <strong>KIJAC</strong> project failure that his Ministry had<br />
funded, the minister replied that he does not know anything about this case and that<br />
he will immediately ask the Norwegian embassy staff in Kosovo to bring all<br />
necessary information to <strong>Rrokum</strong> Television regarding the <strong>KIJAC</strong> case.<br />
The first visit of Mr. Gahr Støre was also published on the website of the Ministry of<br />
Foreign Affairs of Norway, and it was illustrated with photographs from Kosovo<br />
press, creating the impression that his visit was successful and that it followed the<br />
general framework of the support that Kosovo was given to meet international<br />
standards and its ambition for European Union integration (see: http://www.norwaykosovo.no/News_and_events/Norwegian-Foreign-Minister-Mr-Jonas-Gahr-Storevisits-Kosovo/).<br />
Few days later, the response that <strong>Rrokum</strong> Television received from the Norwegian<br />
Embassy in Kosovo, revealed all the seismic force of a scandal that had not yet<br />
exploded in the volcano, which will affect directly the respective Ministry of Foreign<br />
Affairs.<br />
Mr. Jon Hansen, deputy chief of mission answered the questions of the investigative<br />
journalist of <strong>Rrokum</strong> <strong>TV</strong>. In the question of whether the Ministry of Foreign Affairs<br />
and the Embassy of Norway in Kosovo are informed with the <strong>KIJAC</strong> case, Mr.<br />
Hansen wrote, « The Ministry has been informed about the situation related to <strong>KIJAC</strong><br />
since the beginning of this year. The Ministry takes very seriously the allegations for<br />
financial misconduct and the failure of <strong>KIJAC</strong> to have obtained the necessary<br />
accreditation from Kosovo’s authorities for the curriculum. Therefore, the Ministry<br />
has initiated its own investigation into those allegations in order to get the facts on the<br />
table. This process is ongoing, therefore it is too early to draw any conclusions. We<br />
nevertheless hope to finalize our investigation soon».<br />
Mr. Hansen confirms to <strong>Rrokum</strong> <strong>TV</strong> that the Faculty of Journalism <strong>KIJAC</strong> has<br />
stopped its activity and that the <strong>KIJAC</strong> students thanks to an agreement with the<br />
American University in Kosovo will continue their studies to this university until they<br />
are finished.<br />
The figure that Mr. Hansen mentioned regarding the fund for the <strong>KIJAC</strong> project is<br />
different from the one that the school manager Kaare Melhus gave us. Mr. Melhus<br />
says that the Foreign Ministry of Norway donated 6 million Euros, while Mr. Hansen<br />
said that aprx. 6.25 million were donated to <strong>KIJAC</strong> for five years. 4<br />
4 “Norway disbursed a total amount of approx euro 6,25 million from 2005- 2010 to the project.”
Is <strong>KIJAC</strong> closed or not?<br />
Mr. Kaare Melhus' answer is categorically negative. «No, <strong>KIJAC</strong> is not closed. As I<br />
said in my last e-mail, we still have 59 students who are working on their<br />
dissertations. We receive about 1000 Euros per year per student, in tuition fees. In<br />
addition we did receive a modest amount of revenue through the <strong>KIJAC</strong> Center.<br />
<strong>KIJAC</strong> was also audited by the Norwegian audit company “Inter Revisjon” ».<br />
Mr. Jan Hansen, Deputy Ambassador of the Embassy of Norway in Kosovo, as well<br />
as Kaare Melhus, Norway Gimlekollen director, say that after closing <strong>KIJAC</strong>, the 59<br />
remaining students were sent in the American University in Kosovo (AUK) to<br />
continue their studies.<br />
Researchers of <strong>Rrokum</strong> <strong>TV</strong> have contacted the authorities of AUK and the remaining<br />
students of <strong>KIJAC</strong> and discovered a different reality.<br />
Dafina Paca, who worked as a lecturer in <strong>KIJAC</strong> until its closure, and who is now the<br />
coordinator for the 60 remining students (she corrects Mr. Melhus’ number of<br />
students), who are already <strong>KIJAC</strong> students on AUK, said that they are only using the<br />
AUK premises to complete their MA studies and have no other connection and<br />
cooperation with this university.<br />
« After closing the <strong>KIJAC</strong>, myself, the mentors and the students are operating at<br />
AUK, until the 60 students will complete their master degre. I am also engaged by the<br />
Norwegian government to coordinate and supervise these works, and all this is done<br />
by the Norwegian government and the fund that they created to cover the costs of<br />
teachers and students until the completion of the master », said Dafina Paca.<br />
On this issue, Ilir Ibrahimi, AUK official, said that AUK has been generous and has<br />
accepted these students in the university premises to avoid that these students remain<br />
on the streets. However, the university does not benefit anything from this situation.<br />
« AUK has been involved in this work by offering these students a space where they<br />
can work, understanding that <strong>KIJAC</strong> is now closed and there is no <strong>KIJAC</strong> building<br />
where these students can finish their studies. Given that the students have been<br />
somehow left without a solution, as an institution of higher education we felt a moral<br />
obligation to help », said Ilir Ibrahimi.<br />
He further explained the misunderstanding that was spread regarding these 60 <strong>KIJAC</strong><br />
students as allegedly incorporated at the American University of Kosovo , « These<br />
students are not included as part of AUK. We only offer them he premises as a space<br />
where they can continue to finish their master studies. At the end of their studies these<br />
60 students will receive <strong>KIJAC</strong> diplomas not the AUK degree, which explains that<br />
these students are not incorporated as students of the American University in<br />
Kosovo ». Aditionally, Mr. Ibrahim added that « after closing <strong>KIJAC</strong>, with the<br />
consent from the Norwegian government, all the devices that used to belong to<br />
<strong>KIJAC</strong>, were taken from there and are today locked in a warehouse at AUK. These<br />
devices are not being used until a solution is found for them ».<br />
Asked whether there has been an earlier agreement between <strong>KIJAC</strong> and AUK, Mr.<br />
Ibrahimi said that « there has never been an agreement between these two institutions,
even though we had received various consultations on a potential cooperation, but<br />
nothing has been ever agreed ».<br />
A <strong>KIJAC</strong> student, who wanted to remain anonymous because « it could cost you »,<br />
said that « the students who have not yet finished the master studies, were transferred<br />
to American University in Kosovo (AUK) and we were given a deadline by the end of<br />
May to complete the master. If we fail to complete it within this period, then I do not<br />
know what will happen to us, I do not know the further procedures on these issue ».<br />
Asked whether they made any extra payment, or any other obligation, the student<br />
said, « I have not paid a cent to AUK ».<br />
We have tried to get in contact with Willem Houwen, the originator and leading<br />
ideator of <strong>KIJAC</strong>, but he left Kosovo and he is not available to journalists at all.<br />
Garibaldi Street, 17<br />
Prishtina/Kosovo<br />
+381 38 222 272<br />
info@rrokum.tv<br />
www.rrokum.tv<br />
RROKUM TELEVISION’S INVESTIGATIVE JOURNALISM SECTION<br />
Researchers:<br />
Mehdi MULAJ<br />
Valentina RAFUNA<br />
The dossier is read by director of <strong>Rrokum</strong> <strong>TV</strong>, Migjen KELMENDI
ANNEX<br />
1. Facsimil of the MoU<br />
2. Facsimil from the Declaration of Assets of Mr. Gorani (Anti Corruption<br />
Agency)<br />
3. Statement from the Cardiff University<br />
4. Response from the Norwegian Embassy in Prishtina
The copy of the original document is in possesion of the respective media<br />
sector of the <strong>Rrokum</strong>.<strong>TV</strong>
Two first pages of the official public document of the Anti Corruption Agency<br />
See: http://www.akkks.org/2011/Qeveria_e_Republikes_se_Kosoves/Zyra_e_Kryeministrit_te_Republikes_se_Kosoves/Dukagjin_Gorani.pdf
Statement by the Cardiff School of Journalism, Media & Cultural Studies,<br />
Cardiff University, on its involvement in the Kosovo Institute of<br />
Journalism and Communications (Kijac)<br />
April 6 2011<br />
Between 2005 and 2010, Cardiff University allowed a small number of the<br />
academic staff from its School of Journalism, Media & Cultural Studies to teach<br />
some academic components of a course offered by the Kosovo Institute of<br />
Journalism and Communications (Kijac). The lecturers involved each spent one or<br />
two weeks a year teaching in Kosovo. This indicated the university’s commitment<br />
to the development of Kosovo, and to fostering a free and open media culture<br />
within the newest of Europe's states. Other parts of the Kijac course were taught<br />
by other institutions or by individuals with expertise in journalism skills.<br />
Cardiff University’s teaching met the highest standards – standards that make the<br />
Cardiff School of Journalism, Media & Cultural Studies one of the top three<br />
journalism studies institutions in the UK. We are proud of this contribution. Our<br />
contribution also included providing two PhD scholarships and one MA scholarship<br />
to three Kosovars whom Kijac wanted to develop as indigenous teaching staff on<br />
the project. Those Cardiff University staff who taught at Kijac part-financed these<br />
three scholarships out of the fees they were paid for their work in Kosovo.<br />
Cardiff University’s involvement in the Kijac project was limited. Cardiff’s role was<br />
confined to contributing specialised teaching on part of the course. Nebraska<br />
University in the United States made a similar, limited contribution. Cardiff<br />
University was willing publicly to acknowledge its input into the course to indicate<br />
the quality of instruction that Kijac students were receiving. But Cardiff University<br />
(like Nebraska) had no responsibility for the leadership, management,<br />
administration, funding and staffing of the project. Cardiff also did not have any<br />
responsibility for the accreditation of the course as an academic degree. Under<br />
the agreements that established Kijac, the Government of Kosovo and the project<br />
leader that exercised executive powers, the Gimlekollen School of Journalism and<br />
Communication, took on responsibility for the accreditation of the degree. As a<br />
matter of policy, Cardiff University does not accredit any degree unless, among<br />
other conditions, members of its own staff teach all aspects and components of a<br />
course of study leading to the award of that degree. This condition, among<br />
others, was not satisfied by the Kijac project.<br />
Questions about the issue of accreditation of a Kijac degree -- and about all<br />
matters relating to the staffing, leadership, administration, management and<br />
funding of Kijac -- should be directed to the Gimlekollen School of Journalism and<br />
Communication in Kristiansand, Norway, that led the project. The people best<br />
equipped to answer your questions at that institution are Mr Kaare Melhus, the<br />
Kijac project manager (kare.melhus@mediehogskolen.no), and Dr Lars Dahle,<br />
chairman of the board of Kijac (lars.dahle@mediehogskolen.no).<br />
signed:<br />
Professor Justin Lewis, Head of School, Cardiff School of Journalism, Media & Cultural<br />
Studies, Cardiff University.<br />
Dr Howard Barrell, Senior Lecturer, Cardiff School of Journalism, Media & Cultural<br />
Studies, Cardiff University.
Dear Mrs. Rafuna,<br />
Thank you for your e-mail with the questions regarding <strong>KIJAC</strong>.<br />
Please find our answers below:<br />
1) The Ministry has been informed about the situation surrounding <strong>KIJAC</strong> since<br />
the beginning of this year. The Ministry takes very seriously the allegations of<br />
financial misconduct and the confirmation that <strong>KIJAC</strong> lack the necessary<br />
accreditation from Kosovo’s authorities for the school’s curriculum.<br />
Therefore, the Ministry has initiated its own investigation into those<br />
allegations in order to get the facts on the table. This process is still ongoing<br />
so at the moment it is too early to draw any conclusions. We nevertheless<br />
hope to have finalized our investigation soon.<br />
2) The activities at <strong>KIJAC</strong> have ceased to exist and there is a possibility that the<br />
<strong>KIJAC</strong> institution will be terminated. But the Ministry have made an<br />
agreement with the American University in Kosovo (AUK) so that the<br />
remaining students from <strong>KIJAC</strong> can take their final exams at AUK. The<br />
remaining students from <strong>KIJAC</strong> are currently studying at AUK.<br />
3) When we know the facts about the situation at <strong>KIJAC</strong> from our investigations,<br />
the Ministry will decide on what steps it shall take next. This also include<br />
information to the public. It should be pointed out that the Ministry has<br />
already explained this situation and what the Ministry is doing in this case to<br />
the Norwegian press and representatives of the press in Kosovo.<br />
4) We believe the answer to this question will come from the ongoing<br />
investigation. But as mentioned above, it is too early to draw any conclusions<br />
at this point in time.<br />
5) Norway disbursed a total amount of approx euro 6,25 million from 2005-<br />
2010 to the project.<br />
6) As mentioned above, the Ministry has through the press informed the public<br />
of the seriousness of the allegations and that the Ministry is currently looking<br />
into the situation at <strong>KIJAC</strong>.<br />
I hope you will find this information useful. Please do not hesitate to contact us<br />
again if you have further questions.<br />
Best regards,<br />
Jon Hansen<br />
Jon Hansen<br />
Counsellor - Deputy Head of Mission<br />
Royal Norwegian Embassy - Prishtina<br />
Tel: + 381 38 232 111 00<br />
Fax: + 381 38 232 111 22<br />
Mob: + 386 49 201 015<br />
E-mail: jon.hansen@mfa.no<br />
www.norway-kosovo.no
From: INFO <strong>Rrokum</strong> [mailto:info@rrokum.tv]<br />
Sent: Tuesday, April 26, 2011 10:09 AM<br />
To: Hansen Jon<br />
Subject: <strong>KIJAC</strong> Case_questions<br />
On attention of Mr. Jon Hansen:<br />
Dear Sir,<br />
As his excellence, Jonas Gahr Støre, promised to answer on questions regarding<br />
<strong>KIJAC</strong> case, during his visit in Prishtina, let us address with the questions (please<br />
scroll down):<br />
Questions:<br />
1. Does Foreign Ministry, as a main donator of the <strong>KIJAC</strong> project, is informed with<br />
the latest development on <strong>KIJAC</strong> case?<br />
2. Is <strong>KIJAC</strong> finished/bankrupted as a project?<br />
3. What are the Ministry's measures to clarify and explain to Norwegian and kosovar<br />
public: what happened with <strong>KIJAC</strong> project?<br />
4. Who is responsible and accountable for <strong>KIJAC</strong> failure?<br />
5. What was the amount Foreign Ministry donated, because the investigation of the<br />
case is dealing with many ciphers? Please tell us the right cipher in order to avoid<br />
rumors?<br />
6. Why Norwegian public is kept aside and not informed with these developments?<br />
Thank you in advance!<br />
Valentina Rafuna<br />
Journalist - <strong>Rrokum</strong>.<strong>TV</strong><br />
038.222 272<br />
www.rrokum.tv