Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Opinion THE<br />
SHERIDAN <strong>Press</strong> Friday,<br />
Rioting in France<br />
retreat from reality<br />
and hard decisions<br />
that reality requires<br />
Riots that began on the outskirts of Paris have<br />
spread into the center of the French capital and to other<br />
communities in other parts of the country.<br />
Thousands of cars have been set on fire and the police<br />
and even medical personnel have been shot at.<br />
Like many other riots, whether in France or elsewhere,<br />
this one started over an incident that just happened<br />
and was then seized upon to rally resentments<br />
and unleash violence. Two local boys in a predominantly<br />
Muslim neighborhood tried to escape the police<br />
by hiding in a facility that transmitted electricity —<br />
and accidently electrocuted themselves.<br />
This was the spark that ignited volatile emotions.<br />
But those emotions were there,<br />
ready to be ignited, for a long<br />
time.<br />
A substantial Muslim population<br />
lives in France but is not<br />
really of France. Much of that<br />
population lives in social isolation<br />
in housing projects<br />
away from the center of Paris,<br />
as unknown to many Parisians<br />
as to tourists.<br />
Like housing projects in<br />
Thomas<br />
Sowell<br />
Columnist<br />
America, many of these are<br />
centers of social degeneration,<br />
lawlessness and violence.<br />
Three years ago, profound<br />
British social critic <strong>The</strong>odore<br />
Dalrymple wrote of “burned-out and eviscerated carcasses<br />
of cars everywhere” in these projects, among<br />
other signs of social degeneration. This was in an<br />
essay titled “<strong>The</strong> Barbarians at the Gates of Paris” that<br />
is reprinted in his insightful book, “Our Culture,<br />
What’s Left of It.”<br />
While Dr. Dalrymple called this Muslim underclass<br />
“barbarians,” a French minister who called the rioters<br />
“scum” provoked instant outrage against himself,<br />
including criticism from at least one member of his<br />
own government. This squeamishness in word and<br />
deed, and the accompanying refusal to face blatant<br />
realities is also a major part of the background for the<br />
breakdown of law and order and the social degeneration<br />
that follows.<br />
None of this is peculiar to France. It is a symptom<br />
of a common retreat from reality, and from the hard<br />
decisions that reality requires, not only in Europe but<br />
also in European offshoot societies like Canada,<br />
Australia, New Zealand — and the United States of<br />
America.<br />
European countries especially have thrown their<br />
doors open to a large influx of Moslem immigrants<br />
who have no intention of becoming part of the cultures<br />
of the countries to which they immigrate but to recreate<br />
their own cultures in those countries.<br />
In the name of tolerance, these countries have<br />
imported intolerance, of which growing antisemitism<br />
in Europe is just one example. In the name of respecting<br />
all cultures, Western nations have welcomed people<br />
who respect neither the cultures nor the rights of<br />
the population among whom they have settled.<br />
During the last election, some campus Republicans<br />
who were holding a rally for President Bush at San<br />
Francisco State University were harassed by Middle<br />
Eastern students, including a woman who walked up<br />
to one of these Americans and slapped his face. <strong>The</strong>y<br />
knew they could do this with impunity.<br />
In Michigan, a Muslim community loudly sounds<br />
their calls to prayer several times a day, without regard<br />
to whether that sound bothers the original inhabitants<br />
of the community.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Dutch were shocked when one of their filmmakers<br />
was assassinated by a Muslim extremist for<br />
daring to have views at variance with what the extremists<br />
would tolerate.<br />
No one should have been shocked. <strong>The</strong>re are people<br />
who will not stop until they get stopped — and<br />
much of the media, the political classes, and the cultural<br />
elites of the West cannot bring themselves to<br />
even criticize, much less stop, the dangers or degeneracy<br />
among groups viewed sympathetically as underdogs.<br />
Not all Muslims, nor necessarily a majority of<br />
Moslems, are either a cultural or a physical danger.<br />
But even “moderate” Muslim organizations in the<br />
West who deplore violence and try to discourage it<br />
nevertheless encourage their followers to remain foreigners<br />
rather than become part of the countries they<br />
live in.<br />
So do our own intelligentsia and political and cultural<br />
elites. Balkanization has been glorified as “diversity”<br />
and diversity has become too sacred to defile<br />
with anything so gross as hard facts. But reality is not<br />
optional. Our survival may in the long run be as menaced<br />
by degeneration within — from many sources<br />
and in many ways — as was that of the Roman<br />
Empire.<br />
To find out more about Thomas Sowell and read<br />
features by other Creators Syndicate columnists and<br />
cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate Web page at<br />
www.creators.com.<br />
Thomas Sowell is a senior fellow at the Hoover<br />
Institution, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305.<br />
His Web Site is www.tsowell.com.<br />
COPYRIGHT 2005 CREATORS SYNDICATE INC<br />
Letters<br />
Would like to see rebate for<br />
Wyomingites over 18 years old<br />
Editor:<br />
In Saturday’s paper (Nov. 5), Patrick Murphy wrote an<br />
in-depth editorial on the subject of a rebate for Wyoming<br />
residents as proposed by Rep. David Miller of Riverton.<br />
This $2,000 rebate would come as a result of the budget<br />
surplus generated from our abundant energy resources.<br />
This is very similar to a proposal I suggested back in<br />
September to Rep. Rosie Berger of Big Horn. However,<br />
my proposal contained certain criteria for receiving such a<br />
rebate.<br />
Even though we are an energy-producing state, we will<br />
still feel the effects of higher energy costs for gasoline and<br />
home heating.<br />
I proposed that a $1,000-$2,000 rebate be given to<br />
every citizen over 18 years of age. (Children are not paying<br />
those heating bills.)<br />
In addition to this criterion, a stipulation should be<br />
made concerning residency. For example, a one-year<br />
proof of residency like that required by Game and Fish for<br />
a state game license might be a requirement in order to<br />
receive this rebate.<br />
Some term is necessary in order to eliminate people<br />
moving into the state for a few months just to receive the<br />
rebate.<br />
As a concerned citizen of Wyoming, I would want my<br />
government to continue to be fiscally responsible with our<br />
budget surpluses.<br />
That is why my proposal, which puts limitations on<br />
who receives the rebate, would make the amount much<br />
less than the forecast $1 billion.<br />
As we all know, such talk of rebates is purely hypothetical<br />
unless the Legislature enacts a change in our<br />
state’s constitution. However, if you are interested in the<br />
possibility of a rebate, contact your representative about it<br />
before the budget session in February.<br />
Even a one-time rebate would be a boost to the morale<br />
and pocketbook of most citizens of Wyoming.<br />
Jay M. Manthei<br />
<strong>Sheridan</strong><br />
“I don’t know of course,” I said to Willie, “but if<br />
the reports are right, the police just needed to keep<br />
him bottled up so he couldn’t hurt anybody and wait<br />
him out.”<br />
“That seems reasonable,” Willie grumped. “But<br />
iffen the guy was shootin’<br />
’round, that’s a different story.”<br />
“Well,” I said, “they used<br />
some tear gas to try to get him<br />
out. And that didn’t work.”<br />
“Likely made him mad,”<br />
Willie grumped. “That’s nasty<br />
stuff. But I don’t know that he<br />
was hurtin’ anybody but his<br />
self. So what was the push ta<br />
C.L.<br />
Tibbets<br />
Columnist<br />
make him come out?<br />
“Sure, he shot up some windows<br />
an’ some pots an’ pans.<br />
Not too big a loss as compared<br />
ta a life. An’ he talked<br />
to a number of folks what was tryin’ ta get him ta surrender.<br />
Near as I know, he didn’t threaten any o’<br />
them.”<br />
Address <strong>The</strong> <strong>Press</strong><br />
Write: <strong>The</strong> <strong>Sheridan</strong> <strong>Press</strong>, Box 2006, <strong>Sheridan</strong>, WY 82801<br />
Letters must be signed and include the address and telephone number of the author, which<br />
are used for verification only. Unsigned letters will not be printed. Letters should not exceed<br />
400 words. Longer letters are printed at the discretion of <strong>The</strong> <strong>Sheridan</strong> <strong>Press</strong>. Letters are<br />
edited for length, taste, grammar, clarity and possible libelous material. E-mail to<br />
editor@thesheridanpress.com<br />
Today’s Iraq compared<br />
to state of England in 1942<br />
Editor:<br />
<strong>The</strong> Iraqi people recently voted and passed a<br />
constitution.<br />
As Winston Churchill said on Nov. 10, 1942, as<br />
England, much as Iraq is now, was fighting for its<br />
democratic life, “Now this is not the end. It is not<br />
even the beginning of the end. But it is, perhaps, the<br />
end of the beginning.”<br />
One would hope so.<br />
And what is Iraq’s future? Churchill himself in a<br />
1939 radio broadcast wondered about Russia: “I<br />
cannot forecast to you the action of Russia. It is a<br />
riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an enigma.”<br />
To me this statement sums up Iraq’s future in<br />
spite of assertions of confidence from our leaders.<br />
But how shall we pay for this war? In September<br />
your guest columnist Daniel Kline said, “Lower taxes<br />
and you have economic growth; raise taxes and<br />
everything shrinks.”<br />
And the economic growth Kline so stoutly<br />
defends comes from gifts to the rich, the very rich,<br />
who have had to share less of their exorbitant<br />
wealth through lower taxes and thus stimulate the<br />
economy and through their increased wealth lower<br />
the deficit.<br />
Makes sense to me, I think. It’s like a car seller<br />
saying to you, “We’re going to cut your payments<br />
about 15 percent, and, by the way, don’t worry<br />
about the interest, because the Chinese and Japanese<br />
are loaning us lots of money.”<br />
It was a question last election of two candidates:<br />
one who would spend money on his war and not<br />
raise taxes, and the other candidate who would perhaps<br />
raise taxes and then spend the money on<br />
“social programs.” Simple choice for Wyoming.<br />
But in 2000 with a Republican Congress and a<br />
Democratic president, the U.S. government budget<br />
was balanced. Remember?<br />
Willie & Sunshine<br />
“He was breaking the law,” I said. “Probably a<br />
number of them.”<br />
“Ain’t no doubt ’bout that,” Willie agreed. “But the<br />
cure fer that was purty hard. An’ I’d surely hate ta be<br />
shot at ever’ time I broke a law. <strong>The</strong>y’d be lots o’<br />
shootin’ fer folks breakin’ the law speedin’.”<br />
“This is more serious than a speeding violation,” I<br />
answered. “<strong>The</strong> man was armed and shooting. He<br />
might have just been a lousy shot, but he was shooting”<br />
“Could be,” Willie agreed again. “But generally iffen<br />
ya got a gun, ya kin figger which end is dangerous,<br />
an’ iffen he was shootin’ at me, there would be a tendency<br />
ta shoot back. But the question is still what was<br />
the rush?<br />
MALLARD FILMORE by Bruce Tinsley<br />
4<br />
November 11, 2005<br />
<strong>The</strong> year 2004, according to Harper’s Index, was<br />
ranked first “among the most fiscally reckless years<br />
in U.S. history, according to the comptroller general.”<br />
It comes down to the legacy we are leaving those<br />
Americans who follow. George Bush has had about<br />
five years to deliver deficit reduction with his tax<br />
breaks aimed mostly at his rich compatriots.<br />
Someday our country will have to pay its debts,<br />
won’t it? How? And at the same time keep those<br />
services which government, believe it or not, does<br />
better than the private sector — build highways,<br />
provide Social Security, perhaps even health care,<br />
defend the country, put out fires, and help hurricane<br />
victims — those kinds of things.<br />
Well, what do you think? Or do you care? OK, let<br />
our children, grandchildren and their grandchildren pay<br />
off the deficit and curse us, rightly.<br />
William (Mick) Anderson<br />
<strong>Sheridan</strong><br />
Asks citizens to donate<br />
extra Halloween candy<br />
Editor:<br />
In my experience the people in <strong>Sheridan</strong> County<br />
have shown themselves to be loving parents as well as<br />
generous, caring and concerned community members.<br />
<strong>The</strong>refore, I am asking the community to donate<br />
“extra” Halloween candy to Sister Delores for the little<br />
children she teaches on the Lame Deer reservation. <strong>The</strong><br />
candy is given to the children at Christmastime.<br />
Please bring donated candy to Holy Name Catholic<br />
School, 121 S. Connor St. Sister Delores will pick it up<br />
on her day off. May God bless you and your family for<br />
your generosity.<br />
Toni Wendt<br />
Holy Name School Principal<br />
I’d hate to be shot every time I broke the law<br />
“Accordin’ ta some o’ the witnesses, the building<br />
was completely surrounded. He was still talkin’ to<br />
some people, so why the rush?”<br />
“Maybe things changed ,” I offered. “Things do<br />
change, you know.”<br />
“Yeah,” Willie replied, “but I’m seein’ this rush-tacapture<br />
thin’ all over the country. Someplace —<br />
Montana, I think — a high-speed chase wound up with<br />
either the officer or the suspect gettin’ killed.<br />
“Jest a couple weeks ago one of our officers rolled<br />
his patrol car givin’ chase, rolled his police car an’<br />
broke his shoulder. Ya read about it regular where a<br />
high-speed chase gets somebody hurt or killed.<br />
“Some chases is justified, but high speed is dangerous<br />
to ever’one in the area. An’ it don’t make much<br />
sense ta bruise up the neighborhood for an’ offense that<br />
is less dangerous than the cost o’ the chase.<br />
“This deal cost a life, an’ I don’t think it should<br />
have.”<br />
Willie tried his coffee and found it cold.<br />
“Thin’ is,” he said sourly, “this is sup’osta be a<br />
serve-protect fer all o’ us. So far it looks like this guy<br />
come up short.”<br />
That may be hard to argue with.