19.01.2013 Views

D R A F T

D R A F T

D R A F T

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

This is an unapproved Kinectrics International Draft Report, subject to change<br />

To: HES Hacilar Electrik San. Ve Tic.<br />

Erciyes Mah. HES Cad.<br />

No: 22 38210 Hacilar, Kayseri<br />

Turkey<br />

1.0 INTRODUCTION<br />

D R A F T<br />

KINECTRICS INTERNATIONAL INC. TEST REPORT<br />

FOR HES HACILAR ELEKTRIK SAN. VE TIC.<br />

(Ref. Stress-Strain Test on PHEASANT ACSR Conductor)<br />

Kinectrics International Inc. Report No.: K-419148-RC-0002-R00<br />

December 22, 2009<br />

C. Dimnik<br />

Transmission and Distribution Technologies Business<br />

A Stress-Strain Test was performed on a conductor manufactured by HES Hacilar Elektrik San.<br />

Ve Tic. of Turkey. The outside diameter of the conductor is 35.11 mm and is designated<br />

1272 MCM PHEASANT ACSR. The data sheet for this conductor is included in Appendix A.<br />

The cable was received in good condition. The test was performed on December 3 and 4, 2009<br />

by Kinectrics North America Inc. personnel at 800 Kipling Avenue, Toronto, Ontario, M8Z 6C4,<br />

Canada according to Kinectrics Quotation DIM-419-0910-068-R02 dated October 1, 2009.<br />

DRAFT<br />

The testing was videotaped and reviewed by Mr. Asim Mercan of HES.<br />

A copy of Kinectrics ISO 9001 Certificate is included in Appendix C.<br />

PRIVATE INFORMATION<br />

Contents of this report shall not be disclosed without authority of the client.<br />

Kinectrics North America Inc., 800 Kipling Avenue, Toronto, Ontario M8Z 6C4.<br />

Page 1 of 20 K-419148-RC-0002-R00


This is an unapproved Kinectrics International Draft Report, subject to change<br />

2.0 TEST OBJECTIVE AND STANDARD<br />

The objective of the test is to provide the stress-strain characteristics of the conductor to be<br />

used in the calculation of sags and tensions during the design of overhead transmission lines.<br />

The test was performed in general compliance to IEC 61089 Round wire concentric lay<br />

overhead electrical stranded conductors, Annex B; and BS EN 50182:2001 Conductors for<br />

overhead lines – Round wire concentric lay stranded conductors, Annex C.<br />

3.0 TEST SET-UP – for Whole Conductor and Steel Core<br />

The set-up for the Stress-Strain Tests is shown schematically in Figure 1. A whole conductor<br />

sample 13.95 m in length was terminated using epoxy-resin dead-ends. A steel core sample<br />

14.97 m in length was also terminated using epoxy-resin dead-ends. The prepared sample was<br />

installed in a hydraulically-activated horizontal tension test facility. During the initial set-up and<br />

pre-loading steps, the sample was supported along its length to keep the sample as straight as<br />

possible and to minimize the axial stress and sag. A pull-wire potentiometer was fixed to the<br />

sample to measure elongation over a gauge length of about 10 m, centered midway between<br />

the dead-ends. The actual gauge length for the test was measured at the first pre-load step. A<br />

load cell located at the hydraulic end of the sample measured the tension. A photo of a typical<br />

test sample installed in the test facility is shown in Figure 2.<br />

A thermocouple was installed on the conductor and core samples during the test, outside the<br />

gauge length.<br />

The test was carried out in a temperature-controlled laboratory at 20ºC ± 2ºC.<br />

Instrumentation and Data Acquisition<br />

The conductor elongation and tension, as measured by the pull wire potentiometer and load cell<br />

respectively, were monitored continuously using a digital data logging system. The data logging<br />

rate during loading was every one (1) second and during holds every ten (10) seconds.<br />

DRAFT<br />

Temperature measurements were manually recorded at the end of each hold period.<br />

The measuring instruments and equipment used in this test are listed in Appendix B.<br />

Page 2 of 20 K-419148-RC-0002-R00


This is an unapproved Kinectrics International Draft Report, subject to change<br />

4.0 TEST PROCEDURE<br />

The conductor was subjected to the loading schedule outlined in IEC 61089 Annex B.<br />

Step 1 – Whole Conductor<br />

The conductor was tensioned according to the loading schedule on the following table. The<br />

loads were applied at a rate of 3,054 kg/minute (6,732 lb/minute). This is based on achieving<br />

30% of RTS in two (2) minutes.<br />

Whole Conductor RTS= 20,357 kgf<br />

Step % RTS kgf lbf<br />

Hold<br />

(minutes)<br />

preload 2% 407 898<br />

1 30% 6,107 13,464 30<br />

2 2% 407898 1<br />

3 50% 10,179 22,440 60<br />

4 2% 407 898 1<br />

5 70% 14,250 31,415 60<br />

6 2% 407898 1<br />

7 85% 17,303 38,147 60<br />

8 2% 407 898 1<br />

The completion of Step 8 of the above loading schedule marked the completion of the Stress-<br />

Strain Test. The pull wire potentiometer was removed from the conductor, and the load<br />

reapplied at a rate of 4,071 kg/minute (8,976 lb/minute) until the conductor failed. The breaking<br />

load of the conductor was recorded.<br />

Step 2 – Steel Core<br />

The stress-strain test on the steel core was also performed according to IEC 61089 Annex B.<br />

The procedure was similar as for the whole conductor except the tension levels for Steps 1, 3<br />

and 5 for the steel core were determined by the elongation at the beginning of each hold period<br />

obtained on the whole conductor at 30%, 50%, 70% and 85% RTS, respectively. That is, for<br />

each load step, the tension was increased in the steel core until the % elongation was the same<br />

as the whole conductor for the corresponding load step. This meant that the stress-strain test<br />

must be performed on the whole conductor before the steel core. The steel core was tensioned<br />

according to the loading schedule on the following table. The loads were applied at a rate of<br />

3,054 kg/minute (6,732 lb/minute).<br />

DRAFT<br />

Page 3 of 20 K-419148-RC-0002-R00


This is an unapproved Kinectrics International Draft Report, subject to change<br />

Step<br />

Whole Conductor RTS=<br />

20,357 kgf<br />

Whole Conductor<br />

Elongation, mm kgf lbs<br />

Hold<br />

(minutes)<br />

preload 0 407 898<br />

1 11.79 - - 30<br />

2 - 407 898 1<br />

3 21.78 - - 60<br />

4 - 407 898 1<br />

5 35.95 - - 60<br />

6 - 407 898 1<br />

7 51.49 - - 60<br />

8 - 407 898 1<br />

The completion of Step 8 of the above loading schedule constituted the completion of the<br />

Stress-Strain Test.<br />

5.0 TEST RESULTS<br />

The strain data for the conductor and core have been corrected because the elongation<br />

measurement was taken to be zero at the preload. Using a straight-line regression of the stressstrain<br />

data while loading up to 30% RTS it was calculated that the corrected strain at preload was<br />

+0.0032% for the conductor and +0.0291% for the steel core. After accounting for these<br />

corrections, the data was extrapolated to the Y-axis to zero. The corrected data was the actual<br />

conductor’s behaviour because the conductor will have zero elongation only when it is under zero<br />

tension.<br />

Figures 3a and 3b show load (i.e. tension) plotted against all strain data for the whole conductor<br />

and steel core, respectively.<br />

Figures 4a and 4b show stress plotted against strain (%) for only those points that contribute to the<br />

stress-strain curve for the whole conductor and steel core, respectively.<br />

DRAFT<br />

Figure 5 shows the stress-strain curve for the PHEASANT ACSR conductor showing the plots for<br />

the whole conductor, the aluminium layers, and the steel core.<br />

The area of the conductor was 726.79 mm 2 according to the cable data sheet, included in<br />

Appendix A.<br />

The stress-strain curve for the aluminium layers is calculated by subtracting corresponding data<br />

points of the steel core from the whole conductor.<br />

The Modulus of Elasticity (MOE) of the conductor can be determined from the Stress-Strain<br />

curve. The MOE is the slope of the unloading segment of the 85% RTS curve. The MOE for<br />

the conductor is approximately 72,973 MPa.<br />

Similarly, the MOE of the steel core can also be determined from the unloading curve on the<br />

core only Stress-Strain curve. The MOE for the steel core (based on the area of the steel core<br />

only) is approximately 187,471 MPa. The MOE for the steel core (based on the area of the<br />

whole conductor) is approximately 21,077 MPa.<br />

Page 4 of 20 K-419148-RC-0002-R00


This is an unapproved Kinectrics International Draft Report, subject to change<br />

The MOE of the aluminum layers is calculated from the difference between the whole conductor<br />

and steel core, from the unloading at 85% to their intersection (knee-point). The MOE for the<br />

aluminum layers (based on the area of the aluminum only) is approximately 60,779 MPa. The<br />

MOE for the aluminum layers (based on the area of the whole conductor) is approximately<br />

53,946 MPa.<br />

The whole conductor failed at 22,286 kgf or 109.5% of the Rated Tensile Strength of the<br />

conductor.<br />

The key results for the Stress-Strain Tests are shown in Tables 1, 2, and 3.<br />

The general form of the equation of the loading curve for each of the whole conductor, steel<br />

core and outer aluminum layers is:<br />

y = AX3 +BX2 +CX+D<br />

This equation is generated from a 3 rd order polynomial least-squares curve-fit based on the data<br />

points at the end of each hold period. This is the formula used by the Alcoa Sag10 program.<br />

Table 1 Summary of Stress-Strain Test Results for PHEASANT ACSR<br />

Whole Conductor<br />

Whole Conductor<br />

Polynomial Coefficients<br />

(MPa)<br />

A= +4.0623 E+08<br />

B= -8.3710 E+06<br />

C= +7.5030 E+04<br />

D= -1.0032 E-01<br />

Final Modulus of<br />

Elasticity<br />

MPa<br />

(before Knee-point)<br />

** The knee-point is extracted from the 85% unloading curve.<br />

The R-squared value for this curve-fit was R 2 = 1.0000.<br />

Estimated<br />

Knee-point Load<br />

kN **<br />

Breaking Load<br />

kgf<br />

72,973 46.5 22,286<br />

Table 2 Summary of Stress-Strain Test Results for PHEASANT ACSR<br />

Steel Core<br />

Steel Core<br />

Polynomial Coefficients<br />

(MPa)<br />

A= -2.3788 E+07<br />

B= -4.3890 E+05<br />

C= +2.2588 E+04<br />

D= +6.8298 E-03<br />

Final Modulus<br />

of Elasticity<br />

(based on area of<br />

Steel Only)<br />

MPa<br />

The R-squared value for this curve-fit was R 2 = 1.0000.<br />

DRAFT<br />

Final Modulus<br />

of Elasticity<br />

(area corrected for<br />

Consolidated Conductor)<br />

MPa<br />

187,471 21,077<br />

Page 5 of 20 K-419148-RC-0002-R00


This is an unapproved Kinectrics International Draft Report, subject to change<br />

Table 3 Summary of Stress-Strain Test Results for PHEASANT ACSR<br />

Aluminum Layers<br />

Aluminum<br />

Polynomial Coefficients<br />

(MPa)<br />

A= +4.2684 E+08<br />

B= -7.8971 E+06<br />

C= +5.2329 E+04<br />

D= -2.3784 E-03<br />

Final Modulus<br />

of Elasticity<br />

(based on Area of<br />

Alum Only)<br />

MPa<br />

The R-squared value for this curve-fit was R 2 = 1.0000.<br />

6.0 ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA<br />

Final Modulus<br />

of Elasticity<br />

(area corrected for<br />

Consolidated Conductor)<br />

MPa<br />

60,779 53,946<br />

As stated in IEC 61089 and BS EN 50182:2001, there are no acceptance criteria for the Stress-<br />

Strain test.<br />

As stated in IEC 61089 and BS EN 50182:2001, the breaking strength of the conductor shall<br />

withstand, without fracture of any wire, not less than 95% of the rated tensile strength.<br />

7.0 CONCLUSION<br />

The primary purpose of the Stress-Strain Test is to provide stress-strain characteristics of the<br />

conductor to be used in sag-tension calculations.<br />

The conductor, as tested, met the requirements for the Tensile Test as specified in IEC 61089<br />

and BS EN 50182:2001.<br />

DRAFT<br />

Page 6 of 20 K-419148-RC-0002-R00


Prepared by:<br />

Reviewed by:<br />

Approved by:<br />

CD:CJP:RL<br />

This is an unapproved Kinectrics International Draft Report, subject to change<br />

C. Dimnik<br />

Engineer<br />

Transmission and Distribution Technologies Business<br />

C.J. Pon<br />

Principal Engineer<br />

Transmission and Distribution Technologies Business<br />

R. Lings<br />

General Manager<br />

Transmission and Distribution Technologies Business<br />

DRAFT<br />

DISCLAIMER<br />

Kinectrics International Inc. (KII) has taken reasonable steps to ensure that all work performed meets<br />

industry standards as set out in KII Quality Manual, and that, for the intended purpose of this report, is<br />

reasonably free of errors, inaccuracies or omissions. KII DOES NOT MAKE ANY WARRANTY OR<br />

REPRESENTATION WHATSOEVER, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, WITH RESPECT TO THE<br />

MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PARTICULAR PURPOSE OF ANY INFORMATION<br />

CONTAINED IN THIS REPORT OR THE RESPECTIVE WORKS OR SERVICES SUPPLIED OR<br />

PERFORMED BY KNAI. KII does not accept any liability for any damages, either directly, consequentially<br />

or otherwise resulting from the use of this report.<br />

�<br />

� Kinectrics International Inc., 2009<br />

Page 7 of 20 K-419148-RC-0002-R00


Page 8 of 20 K-419148-RC-0002-R00<br />

Cylinder Mount<br />

Fixed to Strong Floor<br />

This is an unapproved Kinectrics International Draft Report, subject to change<br />

Hydraulic Cylinder<br />

Load Cell<br />

Epoxy Deadend<br />

ACSR ACS Conductor<br />

Displacement<br />

Transducer<br />

Gauge length<br />

DRAFT<br />

Data Aquisition System<br />

Figure 1 Set-up for Stress-Strain Test<br />

Stationary End<br />

Fixed to Strong Floor


DRAFT<br />

Figure 2 Photo of Typical Test Sample Installed in Stress-Strain Test Facility.<br />

Page 9 of 20 K-419148-RC-0002-R00


Page 10 of 20 K-419148-RC-0002-R00<br />

Conductor Tension, kN<br />

180<br />

160<br />

140<br />

120<br />

100<br />

80<br />

60<br />

40<br />

20<br />

Stress-Strain Test for HES Hacilar Elektrik San. Ve Tic. (Ref. PHEASANT ACSR Conductor)<br />

DRAFT<br />

0<br />

0.00% 0.05% 0.10% 0.15% 0.20% 0.25% 0.30% 0.35% 0.40% 0.45% 0.50% 0.55% 0.60%<br />

Conductor Strain, %<br />

Figure 3a Load (tension) vs. Conductor Strain<br />

46.5 kN Knee Point


Page 11 of 20 K-419148-RC-0002-R00<br />

Core Tension, kN<br />

80<br />

70<br />

60<br />

50<br />

40<br />

30<br />

20<br />

10<br />

Stress-Strain Test for HES Hacilar Elektrik San. Ve Tic. (Ref. PHEASANT ACSR Conductor)<br />

DRAFT<br />

0<br />

0.00% 0.05% 0.10% 0.15% 0.20% 0.25% 0.30% 0.35% 0.40% 0.45% 0.50% 0.55% 0.60%<br />

Core Strain, %<br />

Figure 3b Load (tension) vs. Steel Core Strain


Page 12 of 20 K-419148-RC-0002-R00<br />

Conductor Stress, MPa<br />

250<br />

200<br />

150<br />

100<br />

50<br />

Stress-Strain Test for HES Hacilar Elektrik San. Ve Tic. (Ref. PHEASANT ACSR Conductor)<br />

Conductor area = 726.79 mm²<br />

0.1276%, 82.45 MPa<br />

0.2390%, 137.41 MPa<br />

0.4018%, 192.35 MPa<br />

DRAFT<br />

0.5842%, 233.58 MPa<br />

0<br />

0.00% 0.10% 0.20% 0.30% 0.40% 0.50% 0.60%<br />

Conductor Strain, %<br />

Figure 4a Stress vs. Conductor Strain for Only Those Points That Contribute to the Stress-Strain Curve


Page 13 of 20 K-419148-RC-0002-R00<br />

Core Stress, MPa<br />

120<br />

100<br />

80<br />

60<br />

40<br />

20<br />

Stress-Strain Test for HES Hacilar Elektrik San. Ve Tic. (Ref. PHEASANT ACSR Conductor)<br />

Conductor area = 726.79 mm²<br />

0.1472%, 32.26 MPa<br />

0.2487%, 53.06 MPa<br />

0.3950%, 80.94 MPa<br />

DRAFT<br />

0.5567%, 108.04 MPa<br />

0<br />

0.00% 0.10% 0.20% 0.30% 0.40% 0.50% 0.60%<br />

Core Strain, %<br />

Figure 4b Stress vs. Steel Core Strain for Only Those Points That Contribute to the Stress-Strain Curve


Page 14 of 20 K-419148-RC-0002-R00<br />

Stress, MPa<br />

250<br />

200<br />

150<br />

100<br />

50<br />

Stress-Strain Test for HES Hacilar Elektrik San. Ve Tic. (Ref. PHEASANT ACSR Conductor)<br />

Conductor area = 726.79 mm²<br />

Core Area = 81.71 mm²<br />

Final Steel<br />

0<br />

0.00% 0.10% 0.20% 0.30% 0.40% 0.50% 0.60%<br />

Unit Strain, %<br />

Initial Steel<br />

Initial Composite<br />

DRAFT<br />

Figure 5 Composite Stress-Strain Curve<br />

Final Composite<br />

Initial Aluminum<br />

Final Aluminum


APPENDIX A<br />

DESCRIPTION OF HES HACILAR ELEKTRIK SAN. VE TIC. CONDUCTOR<br />

(Ref. 1272 mcm, 726.79 mm 2 , PHEASANT ACSR Conductor)<br />

DRAFT<br />

Page 15 of 20 K-419148-RC-0002-R00


PHEASANT<br />

CONDUCTOR 1272 MCM<br />

Stranding Direction Right<br />

Conductor OD mm 35.11<br />

Total Cross Section mm² 726.79<br />

Construction 1(St)+6(St)+12(St)+12(Al)+18(Al)+24(Al)<br />

Conductor Weight kg/km 1783.8<br />

Conductor Tensile Strength kgf 20,357<br />

Aluminum Cross Section mm² 645.08<br />

Aluminum Weight kg/km 1783.8<br />

Steel Core Diameter mm 11.7<br />

Steel Core Cross Section mm² 81.71<br />

Steel Core Weight kg/km 639.7<br />

A.C. Resistance at 25 ° C, 50 Hz ohm/km 0.00475<br />

Xa at 50 Hz ohm/km 0.231<br />

X'a at 50 Hz Megaohm.km 0.1363<br />

GMR 14.2<br />

Conductor E-modulus (First) kg/mm² 5000<br />

Conductor E-modulus (Final) kg/mm² 6000<br />

Linear Thermal Coefficient / °C 19,3*10 -6<br />

Current Carrying Capacity A 1160<br />

Drum Length m 1600<br />

Aluminum Wires<br />

Nominal OD mm 3.9<br />

Nominal Cross Section mm² 11.93<br />

Tensile Strength(min) kg/mm² 16.5<br />

DC Resistivity at 20 ° C (Max) n.ohm.m 28.264<br />

Linear Thermal Coefficient / °C 23*10 -6<br />

Steel Wires<br />

CONDUCTOR PROPERTIES<br />

DRAFT<br />

Nominal OD mm 2.34<br />

Nominal Cross Section mm² 4.29<br />

Tensile Strength After Stranding kg/mm² 138<br />

Tensile Strength at 1% Elongation (Min.) kg/mm² 128<br />

Zinc Coating Weight g/m² 230<br />

Page 16 of 20 K-419148-RC-0002-R00


Page 17 of 20 K-419148-RC-0002-R00<br />

ISO-9001<br />

Form: QF11-1<br />

Rev 0, 97-10<br />

APPENDIX B<br />

INSTRUMENT SHEET<br />

HES Hacilar Elektrik San. Ve Tic. (Ref. PHEASANT ACSR Conductor)<br />

Test Description: Stress-Strain Test Test Start Date: December 3, 2009<br />

Project Number: K-419148 Test Finish Date: December 4, 2009<br />

TEST<br />

DESCRIPTION<br />

Stress-Strain<br />

Test<br />

EQUIPMENT<br />

DESCRIPTION<br />

Datalogger<br />

Load Cell (MTS)<br />

Load Cell<br />

Conditioner<br />

Displacement<br />

Transducer<br />

Conditioner<br />

MAKE MODEL<br />

ASSET # or<br />

SERIAL #<br />

National<br />

Instruments PCI-6036E - B<br />

Lebow<br />

3156<br />

17356-0<br />

MTS<br />

Ametek<br />

Trans-tek<br />

493.01DC<br />

PT-10AT-HT<br />

1002-000F<br />

10000686-0<br />

KIN-00658<br />

PWP #2<br />

Measuring Tape Stanley FatMax (34-813) KIN-00723<br />

Digital Meter<br />

Thermocouple<br />

Fluke<br />

Fluke<br />

51<br />

TC-K<br />

ACCURACY<br />

CLAIMED<br />

CALIBRATION<br />

DATE<br />

CALIBRATION<br />

DUE DATE<br />

TEST<br />

USE<br />

±0.1% of<br />

Reading June 25, 2009 June 25, 2010 Data Acquisition<br />

±1.0% of<br />

reading May 29, 2009 May 29, 2010<br />

Stress Strain,<br />

Breaking Load<br />

19698-0 ±0.1 mm October 7, 2009 October 7, 2010 Cable Strain<br />

DRAFT<br />

17616-0<br />

KIN-00613<br />

< 0.05% of<br />

Reading October 2, 2008 October 2, 2010<br />

±0.9 degree C<br />

±0.5 degree C<br />

March 18, 2009<br />

March 19, 2009<br />

March 18, 2010<br />

March 19, 2010<br />

Cable and<br />

Gauge Length<br />

Cable<br />

Temperature


APPENDIX C<br />

KINECTRICS ISO 9001 QUALITY MANAGEMENT SYSTEM REGISTRATION<br />

CERTICATE<br />

DRAFT<br />

Page 18 of 20 K-419148-RC-0002-R00


DRAFT<br />

Page 19 of 20 K-419148-RC-0002-R00


DISTRIBUTION<br />

Mr. Asim Mercan (2) HES Hacilar Elektrik San. Ve Tic.<br />

Erciyes Mah. HES Cad.<br />

No: 22 38210 Hacilar, Kayseri<br />

Turkey<br />

Telephone: 90 352 207 45 00<br />

Email: amercan@hes.com.tr<br />

C. Dimnik (1) Transmission and Distribution Technologies – KB223<br />

DRAFT<br />

Page 20 of 20 K-419148-RC-0002-R00

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!