Saugeen District Secondary School - Bluewater District School Board
Saugeen District Secondary School - Bluewater District School Board
Saugeen District Secondary School - Bluewater District School Board
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Prepared by:<br />
A Vision for the Retrofit Potential of <strong>Saugeen</strong> <strong>District</strong> <strong>Secondary</strong> <strong>School</strong><br />
Submitted to the A.R.C. of the B.W.D.S.B.<br />
February 2011<br />
Environment & Resource Management Class (CGR 4M) – (2008 & 2010-11)<br />
Specialist High Skills Major Energy Students<br />
Members of the Planeteers/ Eco<strong>School</strong> Team
Introduction<br />
A. Energy<br />
i. Heating and Cooling<br />
ii. Electricity<br />
B. Water Consumption<br />
C. Products<br />
D. Exterior and Interior Landscaping<br />
Conclusion<br />
Funding Sources<br />
Suppliers<br />
Works Cited<br />
Appendices<br />
Table of Contents<br />
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1<br />
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3<br />
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7<br />
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12<br />
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15<br />
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16<br />
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20<br />
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21<br />
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22<br />
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25<br />
Provided to the Chair of the<br />
Accommodation Review Committee
We are aware that the global environment is fragile… and ‘many people have begun to question the<br />
ability of the planet to support the growing population if our present ways continue. The result is<br />
that, while twenty years ago most people would not have given the environment more than a passing<br />
thought,: today many people are taking a keen interest in environmental problems.<br />
(Dunlop et al, 1997, 2)<br />
<strong>Saugeen</strong> <strong>District</strong> students, be they members of the Energy Specialist High Skills Major program and/or the<br />
Planeteers/ Eco<strong>School</strong> Team, as students enrolled in the Grade 12 Environment and Resource Management class<br />
(CGR 4M) have collectively worked to “examine ecological processes, the principles of sustainability, and strategies<br />
for resource management, with a focus on the challenges [and successes] of environmental degradation and<br />
resource depletion” (Ministry of Education, 2009, http://www.edu.gov.on.ca/eng/curriculum/secondary/canworld1112curr.pdf 104 of<br />
265). Their goal was the submission of this report on the exciting opportunities available to the school population, the<br />
community of <strong>Saugeen</strong> Shores, and the <strong>Bluewater</strong> <strong>District</strong> <strong>School</strong> <strong>Board</strong>, as the future of S.D.S.S. is considered.<br />
A starting point is the consideration of the rights and responsibilities that go along with this opportunity:<br />
Rights<br />
We have a right to consume resources to support our growth and development, but rights must be balanced with<br />
responsibilities.<br />
Shelter<br />
� We must take the opportunity to reduce our reliance on non-renewable sources of electricity, incorporating<br />
renewable energies into the design of S.D.S.S.<br />
� Where we can source eco-friendly alternatives in construction, we should make every effort to do so.<br />
Water<br />
� We need to reflect on the impact we have on our water resources and then consider alternatives to:<br />
� Reduce our water consumption within the building and on the school grounds.<br />
� Minimize our contribution to pollution of our water resources.<br />
Transportation<br />
� Students arrive at school by a variety of means – by both necessity and choice. The impact of modes of<br />
transportation can reduced by:<br />
� Encouraging students and staff to consider alternatives to driving (e.g. walking, biking, etc.).<br />
� Adhering to the No-Idling Policy.<br />
� Make wise choices when it comes to the extensive surfaces of parking lots.<br />
Food<br />
� Consideration of the ecological and health benefits/ risks of food being served in the building are to be taken into<br />
consideration. For example:<br />
� Can it be locally-sourced?<br />
� Are the livestock and land treated in a humane and sustainable manner?<br />
� What can we do to maximize the use of the school grounds (e.g. a small herb garden exists in the Heritage<br />
Garden)?<br />
� Are the materials used for serving biodegradable?<br />
Consumer Goods<br />
� As citizens of the developed world, we must be more conscious of our impact on the lives and livelihood of<br />
others. For products, we should consider:<br />
� The content of the materials (e.g. cotton, organic cotton, green cleaning products, etc.)<br />
� Where it was made?<br />
� Under what kind of conditions?<br />
1
Based on these basic rights and responsibilities, each person needs to make their own decisions about how<br />
to preserve the environment for the future generations. The responsibility lies not in following some set of<br />
“Golden Rules,” but rather in being knowledgeable and well-informed by researching all available options<br />
and to act upon that knowledge. The redesign of S.D.S.S, therefore, goes beyond the physical aspects. It is<br />
hoped that through the process, staff and students will:<br />
� Educate themselves and each other about environmental issues<br />
� Be willing to change lifestyle practices to improve environmental sustainability<br />
� Be creative and try to come up with new solutions<br />
Certainly, there are different viewpoints regarding environmental preservation and sustainability; a sampling<br />
are provided here:<br />
Positive Negative<br />
� The Earth needs to be saved – it’s the only one we<br />
have<br />
� There’s no problem<br />
� Needs to be preserved at all cost<br />
� It’s too hard to change our ways<br />
� I want to do something, but where do I start?<br />
� Someone else will fix it<br />
� I’ll take it one step at a time, someday it will make a<br />
drastic difference<br />
� I don’t know how to change my ways<br />
� I’ll buy the resources from local businesses<br />
� It’ll cost too much money<br />
Regardless of viewpoint, all human systems affect the environment. We are products of our planet and so, all<br />
choices we make affecting the environment then, ultimately, come back to us. In this way, we need to make smart,<br />
ecologically friendly choices that are based on sustainability. It starts with new ways of seeing the world and putting<br />
systems and structures in place that will help us cope with difficulties.<br />
Students employed geo-technologies and skills of geographic inquiry to explain and evaluate measures they would<br />
like to see incorporated in to the new building, but have also investigated future net savings (including potential<br />
savings with respect to energy and water, along with maintenance costs) to offset the initial costs. This report is<br />
divided into 4 main sections – Energy, Water, Products and Exterior & Interior Landscaping - based on S.D.S.S.’s<br />
impact on the environment. Practises and systems that reduce impact on the environment encourage a healthy<br />
ecosystem, and therefore a healthy population. What better place to start than with our school?!<br />
Teachers and administrators have the weighty task of raising the youth of each generation to be valuable<br />
contributors to our society. Increasingly, the importance of the environment to our society is being recognized: in<br />
industry, technology, business and in individual homes. It is also being taught in our schools, as many educators<br />
recognize that the value of a healthy environment must be embraced by our youth. Students are taught the<br />
importance of making environmental choices as it affects all areas of health, economy and ecology. Now it is time to<br />
practice what is preached. The technology is available to build green schools, with smaller ecological footprints.<br />
With a purpose in building a stronger society, the <strong>Bluewater</strong> <strong>District</strong> <strong>School</strong> board can lead the way by building<br />
‘green’ to preserve our future.<br />
2
A. ENERGY<br />
i. Heating and Cooling<br />
How is our school heated?<br />
Most of our school is heated by burning natural gas, a non-renewable resource (Figure 1). Our school uses a<br />
boiler system, were the natural gas is burned to heat the water. That water is then sent through the school and the<br />
heat is transferred into our class rooms via radiators. The secondary way we heat our school is though our<br />
ventilation. We send cool air past the hot water tubes coming out of the boilers, thus heating the air which is then<br />
circulated through our school’s vents.<br />
Gas Consumption, Cubic Meters<br />
50000<br />
45000<br />
40000<br />
35000<br />
30000<br />
25000<br />
20000<br />
15000<br />
10000<br />
5000<br />
0<br />
Feb-09<br />
37860<br />
Mar-09<br />
35100<br />
Apr-09<br />
28860<br />
May-09<br />
11250<br />
Jun-09<br />
9900<br />
Jul-09<br />
Figure 1: Natural Gas Consumption<br />
5700<br />
Gas Consumption<br />
SDSS 2009-2010<br />
Aug-09<br />
5400<br />
Sep-09<br />
5400<br />
Oct-09<br />
14400<br />
Nov-09<br />
Date<br />
Year Totals: 367 950m 3 at 21.5 cents/ m 3 = $79 109.25<br />
(Union Gas, Bills provided by J. McTeer, BWDSB)<br />
How do we cool our school?<br />
Our school has several (5) A/C units positioned above the school that use electricity to remove the heat from<br />
the air, thus making the air cool. The cool air is then sent back into (most of) the school’s ventilation system.<br />
The New Wing:<br />
In our school’s new wing we have heat pumps that both heat and cool the school. The heat pump: A device<br />
that transfers heat from a hot location to a cold location. The pump is supplied with hot water from the boilers.<br />
20910<br />
Dec-09<br />
29760<br />
Jan-10<br />
46500<br />
Feb-10<br />
41250<br />
Mar-10<br />
30750<br />
Apr-10<br />
22650<br />
May-10<br />
17010<br />
Jun-10<br />
2850<br />
Jul-10<br />
2400<br />
3
Rationale for Taking the Opportunity to Make Changes at S.D.S.S.:<br />
To provide some perspective as to the importance and value of considering non-traditional energy sources, the<br />
following figure illustrates the timing of production peaks and contribution of energy sources over time.<br />
(Chefurka, 2007, http://www.paulchefurka.ca/WEAP/WEAP.html )<br />
Currently, fossil fuels are the 3 most important contributors to the world energy mix, but they are all in rapid decline<br />
by the second half of the century. Even alternative energy resources that become dominant provide a fraction of the<br />
millions of tonnes of oil equivalent (Mtoe) relied upon at present. The overall message that is delivered here is that<br />
we must reduce our energy consumption through efficiency and conservation, and the following proposals show the<br />
way.<br />
An Autocad illustration of the school provides a visual for the placement of several of the following energy features.<br />
(Appendix A)<br />
4
How Advantages Cost Savings<br />
Cross/ Stack-Ventilation “Warm air rises through the upper<br />
levels, encouraging lower level<br />
opening to s admit cooler,<br />
refreshing replacement air.”<br />
Geothermal Heating &<br />
Cooling<br />
Tubes are buried underground that<br />
allows water to be pumped though<br />
them heating or cooling the water<br />
with the heat from the ground.<br />
� Cooling the building using the forces of nature,<br />
reducing A/C costs.<br />
� Naturally heated or cooled water reduces the<br />
amount of heat that is required from electricity or<br />
another costly source by 50 to 70 percent.<br />
� The pre-heating is renewable, always reliable and<br />
always free unlike more conventional methods.<br />
� The pipes are buried underground so they can be<br />
placed anywhere on the property.<br />
� ~ $90 000<br />
� The cost to complete this will be<br />
repaid over the first 4 years<br />
after completion.<br />
� The savings are also in the<br />
environmental impacts that the<br />
energy savings will have on the<br />
environment<br />
Green/ Living Roof (See Landscaping) (See Landscaping) (See Landscaping)<br />
Natural Wool Insulation (See Products) (See Products) (See Products)<br />
Passive Solar Heating and A concept of building design, taking � Sun’s energy harnessed to increase indoor<br />
(A combination of<br />
Cooling<br />
advantage of the ample energy<br />
temperature in the winter and to promote cooler attributes<br />
available from the Sun that can be temperatures in the summer<br />
discussed within<br />
integrated into virtually any type of<br />
architecture.<br />
Includes windows, awnings, thermal<br />
mass and vegetation to conduct and<br />
store heat energy.<br />
�<br />
this report).<br />
Reflective Roof<br />
High albedo of the paint lowers the � Bonds directly to original roof<br />
Approximately � Actual saving varies according<br />
Snow Roof® Premium White cost of cooling. (Used on roof area � Reduces temperature up to 45°C<br />
$30/ can<br />
to climate, situation, and<br />
Roof Coating<br />
above the gym as it’s span is too � Can save up to 25% on cooling costs<br />
region.<br />
wide to support a green roof). � Reduces the rate at which roof deteriorates “Coverage per � Potential savings of 25% on<br />
� Flows to seal cracks and damages.<br />
gallon:<br />
cooling costs, and substantial<br />
� Protects against snow, rain, hail, etc.<br />
Metal (corrugated) amounts on roofing installation<br />
� 10 year warranty<br />
80 sq.ft./gal.<br />
and repairs.<br />
Metal (smooth) � Repairs simply require touch-<br />
100 sq.ft./gal.<br />
Foam / Mod. Bit.<br />
50 sq.ft./gal.<br />
Concrete* 50<br />
sq.ft./gal.<br />
Bonded Tar &<br />
Gravel/BUR 50<br />
sq.ft./gal.”<br />
ups of paint<br />
5
How Advantages Cost Savings<br />
Solar Panels Photovoltaic cells are made of<br />
semiconductors such as silicon.<br />
When light hits the cell some of it is<br />
absorbed by the semiconductor<br />
allowing the electrons to flow freely.<br />
We harness this current by placing<br />
metal contacts on both sides of the<br />
cell. The cells produce DC and a<br />
converter is needed to convert it to<br />
A/C.<br />
Need 175 to offset our electrical<br />
needs.<br />
Tankless Water Heater These heated coils would be<br />
installed at various locations<br />
across the school, where hot<br />
water is needed<br />
Wind Turbine One roof mounted vertical axis<br />
turbine. (Vbine®)<br />
One wind turbine mounted on a<br />
ground-based standard (Skystream<br />
3.7 ®)<br />
� Panels are flexible and can be installed almost<br />
anywhere.<br />
� Power can still be generated on cloudy days<br />
� Provides and endless supply of non-polluting<br />
power<br />
� If in the height of the schools electricity demands<br />
(June) the total consumption is 119 099.5 kWh,<br />
and our solar panels produced 35 kW we could<br />
potentially produce 126000kWh, which would<br />
more than offset our total energy needs.<br />
� Feed-in-tariff provides a source of revenue (see<br />
Savings)<br />
� Replaces the hot water tank<br />
� hot water on demand”<br />
� This technology doesn’t require the energy<br />
to keep a tank of water hot all the time. It<br />
rather heats the water needed when it is<br />
needed<br />
� Operates with even low wind speed, from<br />
any direction<br />
� Low noise<br />
� Safe for the environment (birds and bats)<br />
� No maintenance (2 sealed bearings expected<br />
to last 20 years)<br />
� Can feed into the grid<br />
175 panels<br />
$140 000<br />
Installation<br />
~$200 000<br />
Inverter<br />
$35 000<br />
Total Cost<br />
$375 000<br />
Each unit costs<br />
approx.. $500<br />
� They will pay themselves off<br />
within 20-25 years.<br />
� Entering into a 20 year contract<br />
with the government yields<br />
$0.80/KW for all the energy<br />
generated<br />
�<br />
Will provide up to a 40% saving<br />
in hater hating costs.<br />
At the Dr. David Suzuki Public<br />
<strong>School</strong> the VWAT roof-mounted<br />
turbine, “taking into account<br />
energy losses and varying wind<br />
speed, the expected annual<br />
electricity savings generated from<br />
the wind turbine are 4,000kWh”<br />
(DeCoppel et al, 2008, Report)<br />
(Avery et al, 2011, Report)<br />
(Dr. David Suzuki Public <strong>School</strong>, 2011, http://www.suzukipublicschool.ca/building-features/renewable-energy/wind/skystream.html)<br />
(Dr. David Suzuki Public <strong>School</strong>, 2011, http://www.suzukipublicschool.ca/building-features/renewable-energy/wind/skystream.html )<br />
(Gibb, 2008, e-mail)<br />
(Stansfield et al, 2011, Report)<br />
6
ii. Electricity<br />
<strong>Saugeen</strong> <strong>District</strong> <strong>Secondary</strong> <strong>School</strong> consumption of approximately 940 400 kWh per annum, @ 0.1078 cents/ kWh<br />
(Fig. 2), provides a clear opportunity for more sustainable methods of power (Reany et al, 2010, Report).<br />
Energy Comsumption, kWh<br />
140000<br />
120000<br />
100000<br />
80000<br />
60000<br />
40000<br />
20000<br />
0<br />
Feb-09<br />
122400<br />
Mar-09<br />
92400<br />
Apr-09<br />
112800<br />
May-09<br />
124800<br />
Jun-09<br />
100800<br />
108000<br />
Jul-09<br />
Electricity Consumption<br />
SDSS 2009-2010<br />
Aug-09<br />
94800<br />
Sep-09<br />
103200<br />
Oct-09<br />
117600<br />
Nov-09<br />
55200<br />
Dec-09<br />
Figure 2: Electricity Consumption<br />
Year Total: 1 940 400kWh @ 0.1078 Cents/kWh = $209 175.12<br />
(Westario Power, Bills provided by J. McTeer, BWDSB)<br />
Some opportunities for greater efficiency are detailed below:<br />
Doors<br />
Energy Efficient Power<br />
Bars<br />
Date<br />
Where Advantages Cost Savings<br />
Depends on<br />
recommendations<br />
after the doors have<br />
been tested.<br />
� Computer labs<br />
� Family Studies<br />
� Cafeteria<br />
� Tech rooms<br />
� Reduce heat loss<br />
Firing proof retardant<br />
available for steel door<br />
42000<br />
Jan-10<br />
� Consumes energy only<br />
when something is<br />
operating.<br />
� Eliminates ghost or idle<br />
current.<br />
� Convenience of leaving<br />
things plugged in<br />
without the struggle of<br />
trying to unplug them<br />
121200<br />
Feb-10<br />
97200<br />
Mar-10<br />
117600<br />
Apr-10<br />
118800<br />
May-10<br />
$380-$500 plus<br />
installation<br />
Martin Steel Door<br />
from Georgian Bay<br />
Windows and<br />
Doors<br />
~ $35 dollars but<br />
depending on the<br />
quality and size the<br />
price fluctuates.<br />
(This is about ten<br />
dollars more than<br />
an equivalent that<br />
is not as energy<br />
efficient).<br />
108000<br />
Jun-10<br />
94800<br />
98400<br />
Jul-10<br />
Aug-10<br />
110400<br />
Determined after all doors<br />
currently in place should be<br />
tested for by an energy auditor.<br />
� The use of electricity will be<br />
reduced and that will save<br />
money and will pay for the<br />
cost of the new bars quickly<br />
depending on what is<br />
plugged into them.<br />
7
Energy Efficient Vending<br />
Machines<br />
Motion Detecting Light<br />
Switch<br />
Where Advantages Cost Savings<br />
� Common Area Energy Star machines have<br />
more efficient<br />
compressors, fan motors,<br />
and lighting.<br />
The low power mode<br />
option allows the machine<br />
to only use a little power<br />
when in standby mode or<br />
inactive.<br />
More efficient lighting and<br />
power off times when not<br />
in use to eliminate constant<br />
current.<br />
� Classrooms<br />
� Offices<br />
� Washrooms<br />
� Some hallways<br />
(With a few<br />
intermittent lights<br />
that are<br />
constantly on, so<br />
the safety of the<br />
students isn’t<br />
compromised)<br />
Outdoor Lighting Modifications to the<br />
existing lights on the<br />
school property:<br />
� 6 lights on<br />
standards<br />
� 32 lights attached<br />
to the walls<br />
� 9 lamp posts<br />
Power Controlling Device � Best on<br />
appliances made<br />
in the 1990s<br />
� Eliminates lights being<br />
left on and consuming<br />
energy when the<br />
spaces are vacant.<br />
� As life becomes more<br />
convenience-based<br />
they will be very<br />
practical<br />
� Half the wattage of the<br />
old lights<br />
� Dark sky friendly<br />
� Environmentally<br />
friendly – entire light is<br />
recyclable and there is<br />
no Mercury<br />
� Very little maintenance<br />
� Average lifespan of<br />
17.5 years<br />
� New technology would<br />
attract school publicity<br />
� Motor adjusts the 60<br />
cycle sine wave from<br />
the utility to match<br />
changes in the load on<br />
the motor, allowing it<br />
to operate at its peak<br />
efficiency and at a<br />
cooler temp..<br />
The new<br />
components in the<br />
machine that cost<br />
about 200 dollars<br />
will save around<br />
150 dollars per<br />
year<br />
~ $15 dollars<br />
Not every room<br />
would benefit from<br />
these since some<br />
require having the<br />
lights on at all<br />
times like the<br />
larger rooms, such<br />
as the common<br />
room and<br />
gymnasium, so<br />
these would be<br />
best simply in class<br />
rooms and not the<br />
larger rooms.<br />
Hallways can be a<br />
possibility.<br />
Installation:<br />
� ~$75/light<br />
fixture for<br />
standards<br />
(total cost ~<br />
$2,925)<br />
� Wall lights:<br />
$414.19 per<br />
light (total cost<br />
~ $13 254.08)<br />
� Parking lot<br />
lights:<br />
$555.45/ light<br />
(~ $3 888.15)<br />
$30-60 with a<br />
warranty from 10-<br />
15 years<br />
� The lighting of the machine<br />
accounts for 35 percent of<br />
the energy and the actual<br />
refrigeration at 65 percent<br />
so reducing the unnecessary<br />
energy will reduce the<br />
overall consumption.<br />
� (Regular vending machines<br />
will consume about 2,500<br />
kilowatt hours (kWh) to<br />
4,400 kWh of energy per<br />
year, which cost about $200<br />
to $350<br />
� Depending on the number<br />
of light switches that are<br />
being converted will<br />
determine the amount of<br />
savings. (Est. of $4000/yr)<br />
� Estimated reduction of 11.5<br />
metric tonnes of GHG/yr<br />
� The more switches that are<br />
converted will have a<br />
greater impact and for sure<br />
outweigh the costs<br />
extremely quickly.<br />
� The company is will to sell<br />
their lights at cost<br />
� After 2.5 years, savings<br />
would pay off the cost of<br />
the lights<br />
� Payback time is dependent<br />
on: line, voltage, age/<br />
condition, cost of device,<br />
cost of utility electricity.<br />
8
Where Advantages Cost Savings<br />
Skylights � Interior rooms � Reduces consumption<br />
of electricity to create<br />
light.<br />
� Allow natural light into<br />
interior rooms<br />
� Reduces eye strain and<br />
has a calming effect.<br />
� Students have better<br />
attendance,<br />
concentration and<br />
improved test scores.<br />
� Use of blinds can<br />
provide insulation,<br />
trapping heat in the<br />
winter.<br />
Solar Light Tubes � Several in the<br />
gymnasium,<br />
throughout the<br />
upper hallways<br />
and storage/<br />
mechanical rooms<br />
Energy Star Windows � Window to floor<br />
area 1:10<br />
� Triple glazing with<br />
sealed insulating<br />
glass unite<br />
� Low-e glass (low<br />
emissivity)<br />
� Argon or krypton<br />
in sealed unit<br />
� Low-conductivity<br />
spacer bars<br />
� Insulated<br />
fiberglass frames<br />
� airtight<br />
� As above (no blinds<br />
however)<br />
� In addition, they<br />
provide light, not heat<br />
– a benefit in the<br />
summer months<br />
� Easy installation<br />
� Heating and cooling<br />
cost savings<br />
� Airtight<br />
� Increased comfort<br />
� Higher humidity<br />
without condensation<br />
� Lower sound<br />
transmission<br />
� More daylight<br />
� Increased passive solar<br />
potential<br />
$200 to 2000,<br />
depending on the<br />
size and design.<br />
The more that are<br />
added will decrease<br />
the demand for<br />
electricity more<br />
30’’ by 48’’<br />
� Thermopane<br />
Clear, R 2.4,<br />
Double Glaze:<br />
$331.97/unit<br />
� Thermopane R+,<br />
Double Glaze, R<br />
3.2: $357.56/unit<br />
� Thermopane Star<br />
+, Double Glaze.<br />
R 4.2, Low-E-<br />
Argon: $368.62<br />
� Thermopane R3+,<br />
Triple Glaze, 12-5<br />
Warm edge spacer,<br />
Low-E-Argon:<br />
$460.26 Ultimate<br />
Recommendation<br />
� Georgian Bay<br />
Windows and<br />
Doors: R8.1<br />
Tripling Glazing<br />
� The saving will relate to the<br />
amount of skylights put in<br />
� Several in the gymnasium,<br />
throughout the upper<br />
hallways and storage/<br />
mechanical rooms<br />
� Window: floor area 1:10<br />
(Reany et al, 2011, Report)<br />
(Sutcliffe et al, 2008, Report)<br />
9
What the students are most excited about…<br />
� The fact that we can combine different energy sources and be off grid; renewable energy is a possibility.<br />
Sarah Szabo<br />
� I see the geothermal heating and cooling being feasible and realistic. This technology has built a name for its self, and has<br />
proven to be reliable and worthwhile. Though, the technology that I am most excited about is hydrogen storage and<br />
transportation (see below). However this technology is still very new, expensive and hasn’t made a reputation.<br />
J. Kononiuk<br />
� To see the changes that these different ideas will have on the school and energy costs – that small changes can have a big<br />
effect overall. And these changes aren’t just on energy costs, but that they will raise awareness and other changes are<br />
surely to follow with the outlook of the staff and students.<br />
� Seeing how many ideas the board will actually like and what they reject, and for what reasons. It will be interesting to see<br />
how sustainable the school is; seeing what works and what is not as good as anticipated in a few years after the initial<br />
construction. And to see how much revenue can be produced after all the projects are paid off and the rest is revenue. I<br />
would like to see that money used to continue to help with the environment.<br />
K. MacGregor<br />
iii. Future Considerations?<br />
Hydrogen Surplus Storage/<br />
Transportation<br />
Landfill Gas Converting to<br />
Energy<br />
� Port Elgin and Southampton<br />
Landfills<br />
� Power Station on school<br />
grounds<br />
“1 million tons of municipal solid<br />
waste in a landfill typically<br />
generates 300 cubic foot per<br />
minute (cfm) of landfill gas that<br />
could then generate 7 000 000<br />
kilowatt hours per year and 7 000<br />
000 kWh is enough energy to<br />
power 700 homes for a year”<br />
Advantages Cost Savings<br />
� Making hydrogen at night<br />
when the cost of electricity<br />
is low, and storing it for<br />
later.<br />
� In the day, when energy<br />
needs are greater and cost<br />
has increased, the<br />
hydrogen can be converted<br />
to energy.<br />
� Less strain on the electricity<br />
grid in peak times, and<br />
saves money.<br />
� The fuel cell also produces<br />
heat that can be captured.<br />
� Projects generate<br />
renewable energy,<br />
offsetting the use of nonrenewables.<br />
� Reduces local air pollution<br />
� Helps to eliminate methane<br />
- a potent heat-trapping<br />
gas. “Methane is a green<br />
house gas that has 21 times<br />
the heating effect as carbon<br />
dioxide...”<br />
� “About 70% of the<br />
recovered gas is used as<br />
energy”<br />
� Involves citizens, the<br />
government and other<br />
organizations<br />
� Projects create jobs,<br />
revenues, and cost savings<br />
� Potential to become leading<br />
school board in renewable<br />
energy; leader and example<br />
for all<br />
� A hydrogen fuel cell is<br />
about $90 000<br />
� An equivalent hydrogen<br />
producer would also cost<br />
about $80 000<br />
� And, large holding tanks,<br />
$16 000<br />
� The cost of maintenance<br />
and operation of this<br />
system is about $4500 per<br />
year<br />
� It would take 3-4 years to<br />
pay off the system with the<br />
saving that it provides.<br />
� Unknown<br />
� Could enter into<br />
partnership with the<br />
municipality.<br />
� We use and average of $132<br />
110.60 of electricity<br />
annually<br />
� If we can store all the<br />
energy we need at night<br />
during low cost, we can save<br />
$67 161.49 in power<br />
annually.<br />
� That is a 50% decrease in<br />
cost.<br />
� For the Port Elgin site, with<br />
energy harvested based on<br />
2007’s cubic metres of waste,<br />
~500,000 kWh (equivalent to<br />
49 homes)<br />
� For the Southampton site,<br />
with energy harvested based<br />
on 2009’s cubic metres of<br />
waste, ~600,000 kWh<br />
(equivalent to 57 homes)<br />
� Total savings of energy<br />
needs, based on the<br />
Southampton site = ~$61,000<br />
10
Transportation � 20 buses going to and from<br />
school each day<br />
� Each bus travels approx.<br />
77.0 km / day, and with a<br />
bus efficiency of 105 000 L<br />
of fuel for all the buses for a<br />
year, we produce 77<br />
056.164 kg of CO 2 emission,<br />
annually, from buses.<br />
� Therefore we would<br />
preventing 77 056.164 kg of<br />
CO 2 emissions annually.<br />
Advantages Cost Savings<br />
� The cost of a hydrogen<br />
power bus is 2.1 million<br />
dollars, about 4 times that<br />
of a regular bus.<br />
� We will be fuelling our buses<br />
essentially with electricity<br />
(in the form of hydrogen)<br />
(Reany et al, 2011, Report)<br />
Figure 3: The Energy Team and a working model of their proposals for SDSS Redesigned.<br />
From left to right: Jake Kononiuk, Avery Reany, Sean Tenbergen, Kirk MacGregor and designer Sarah Szabo.<br />
11
B. WATER CONSUMPTION<br />
Rationale for Taking the Opportunity to Make Changes at S.D.S.S.:<br />
Imagine our world 25 years from now. The majority of people would think of new technology, more job<br />
opportunities, and a better and healthier lifestyle. The reality, though, is that within 25 years it is predicted that<br />
humans will be facing a huge water crisis - globally.<br />
Humans today are consuming water at such a rate where we are actually using more freshwater than can be<br />
replenished through the environment naturally. This, of course, is a huge issue. Many people seem to be in denial<br />
about the limited amount of freshwater left on our Earth, as people fail to implement water conservation ideals in<br />
their daily routines. The fact is, is that we as humans need to work together to make a change to our lifestyles that<br />
will benefit the conservation of water in the future. If we do not do it now, then there might not be any water in the<br />
future to worry about.<br />
Appendix B provides a listing of current water features at S.D.S.S., while Figure 4 provides some indication as to<br />
where we may go to reduce our water consumption. Recommendations follow.<br />
Total Liters Used<br />
3000000<br />
2500000<br />
2000000<br />
1500000<br />
1000000<br />
500000<br />
0<br />
Water Consumption / Sewer Usage<br />
SDSS 2010<br />
2478254<br />
May-July<br />
Time of year (2 Months)<br />
Figure 4: Water Consumption<br />
(Town of <strong>Saugeen</strong> Shores Water/Sewer, Bills provided by J. McTeer, BWDSB)<br />
1456885<br />
Nov-Jan<br />
12
Dishwasher<br />
(Whirlpool ®<br />
DU1055XTVB or<br />
GU2475XTVQ)<br />
Electric Dryer<br />
(Frigidaire ® 5.8 Cu. Ft.)<br />
Faucet<br />
(Sloan Soils)<br />
Front Load Washer<br />
(Frigidaire ® 3.1 Cu. Ft.)<br />
Where Advantages Cost Savings<br />
DU1055XTVB in<br />
� DLC<br />
� Family Studies<br />
GU2475XTVQ in:<br />
� Kitchen<br />
� Family Studies<br />
� DLC<br />
� Custodial<br />
3 main washrooms—<br />
the courtyard, the<br />
upstairs common area,<br />
and the washrooms by<br />
the English office<br />
� Family Studies<br />
� DLC<br />
� Custodial Room<br />
Grey Water A commercial grey<br />
water recycling system<br />
would mean that<br />
extensive construction<br />
would be required.<br />
Rainwater Harvesting On the roof, with<br />
storage in cisterns on<br />
the ground if necessary<br />
Water Efficient Toilet Replacing the 49 toilets<br />
throughout the school<br />
Water-Free Urinal<br />
(Sloan ® WES-5000 or<br />
Falcon®)<br />
Halsey Taylor HVRGRN8<br />
Water Fountain<br />
� Replacing the 18<br />
urinals throughout<br />
the school<br />
Incorporate additional<br />
fountains throughout<br />
the school, as it is not<br />
convenient to use<br />
fountains at present.<br />
� Energy Star qualified<br />
(DU1055XTVB)<br />
� Sanitization option<br />
� Control lock disables certain<br />
buttons so that unintentional<br />
use/cycle changes do not occur<br />
� Uses 320 KW/year<br />
(GU2475XTVQ)<br />
� Sani-rinse (powerful, NSF certified)<br />
� Powerful jets provide great rinse<br />
action<br />
� Uses 320 KW/year<br />
� Energy Star Qualified<br />
� Precision dry moisture sensor which<br />
detects when clothes are dry,<br />
therefore using the least amount of<br />
electricity as possible<br />
� Sensor detects when hands are<br />
underneath the tap; only the<br />
necessary amount of water will be<br />
used at a time<br />
� More sanitary - no knobs to turn<br />
� Aerates water<br />
� Energy Star qualified<br />
� Only uses 14-18 gallons/load<br />
compared to 44 gallons/load and<br />
more which non energy star<br />
qualified uses<br />
� Front load efficiency reduces energy<br />
and annual costs by nearly 70%<br />
� Reduces fresh water use<br />
� Recharges ground water<br />
� Enhances soil fertility<br />
� Reduces strain on water treatment<br />
plant<br />
� An alternative to local water needs,<br />
reducing dependence on municipal<br />
water<br />
� Naturally soft-water does not cause<br />
scaling<br />
� Treatment of storm water is<br />
reduced<br />
� Low consumption dual flush<br />
� Full flush 6.0Lpf/1.3gpf<br />
� Partial flush 3.0Lpf/0.66gpf<br />
� Zero water consumption<br />
� Odour free<br />
� Touch free for improved hygiene<br />
� Vandal-free<br />
� Clean, cold water supply to<br />
eliminate bottled water<br />
� Produced from 60% recycled<br />
content<br />
� Resists corrosion<br />
� Low flow bubbler for aeration and<br />
reduction in water usage<br />
(DU1055XTVB)<br />
$549.00 ea.<br />
Total: $1,098.00<br />
(GU2475XTVQ)<br />
$749.00<br />
Total: $749.00<br />
$400.00<br />
Total: $1,200.00<br />
$439.99<br />
$549.00<br />
Total: $1,647.00<br />
Expensive<br />
system—no set<br />
cost could be<br />
found.<br />
Building the<br />
catchment and<br />
conveyance and<br />
storage systems<br />
$249.99<br />
Total: $12,250<br />
$232.99<br />
Total : $4,560<br />
$645<br />
+ $60 shipping<br />
(+ removal of<br />
current fountains<br />
from washrooms<br />
for hygiene and<br />
accessibility).<br />
� 30% water<br />
reduction<br />
compared to<br />
standard<br />
machine<br />
�<br />
� 70% reduction<br />
in energy use<br />
� 36-50%<br />
reduction in<br />
water<br />
consumption<br />
� It would pay<br />
itself off within<br />
ten years of<br />
(new)<br />
construction.<br />
� The costs will be<br />
returned in 1-2<br />
years.<br />
� 54-77%<br />
reduction in<br />
water<br />
consumption<br />
� 100% savingson<br />
water<br />
consumption<br />
� Reduces<br />
consumption by<br />
2,725,496 L of<br />
water per year<br />
� ~40% reduction<br />
in water<br />
consumption<br />
� More than 50%<br />
energy efficient<br />
� 8% reduction in<br />
refrigerant<br />
13
(Alexander et al, 2011, Report)<br />
(DeCoppel et al, 2008, Report)<br />
(Sutcliffe et al, 2008, Report)<br />
What the students are most excited about…<br />
� The replacement of the common bathroom and kitchen fixtures as a very reasonable and realistic option, in part because<br />
they require no additional installation procedures (i.e. running gas lines, electricity, installation of tanks, etc.).<br />
J. Kononiuk<br />
� The task of redesigning a whole school is a huge process that takes a lot of work and effort to plan out. While researching<br />
this project, we discovered a lot of new technology that we did not even know existed. One of the things that we found very<br />
interesting and what we are most excited about is the water-free urinals that we hope to install in the future. … We both<br />
would definitely love to see a new SDSS that included water-free urinals, as they would be more efficient in both means of<br />
money and water conservation. Karissa Finlayson & Krisinda Alexander<br />
14
C. PRODUCTS<br />
i. Construction Materials<br />
Advantages Cost<br />
Clay Paint � No VOC content<br />
� Absorbs odours in the air<br />
� Numerous laquers do not have to be applied to keep paint form chipping<br />
� Does not release toxic chemicals into the air<br />
Green Linoleum � Made from all natural materials including linseed oil, wood flour, cork flour and<br />
limestone<br />
� No toxic materials<br />
� 25-40 year lifespan<br />
� Recyclable at end of life<br />
� Adhesives 100% solvent free<br />
Milk Paint � All natural pigments<br />
� No VOC<br />
� Fast drying time (1/2 – 4 hours)<br />
� Can be sprayed<br />
� Paint is non-hazardous for easily disposal<br />
Natural Sheep’s Wool<br />
Insulation<br />
Wheat/ Straw <strong>Board</strong><br />
(in lieu of drywall)<br />
ii. Products<br />
Bradley ® Plastic Lockers<br />
iii. Consumables<br />
Newspaper Pencils<br />
Recycled Multi-Purpose<br />
Paper<br />
� Uses sheep’s wool – a renewable resource<br />
� Wool absorbs natural condensation in the air draws moisture out of wood and<br />
prevents against mould-related illnesses<br />
� When installing, no protective covering is needed<br />
� Treated with boron salts to repel insects and<br />
� Its life-span ranges for hundreds of years without losing moisture retention or<br />
flexibility<br />
� Biodegradable and reusable<br />
� Produced from compressed straw; the by-product of wheat production<br />
� Better moisture resistance than wood<br />
� No formaldehyde is used<br />
� MDI emits lower VOC levels than other chemical binders<br />
‘BioShield” brand<br />
costs $189.00 for<br />
19 litres<br />
$3.39/ ft 2<br />
$46/ gallon<br />
(Almost same<br />
price as paint<br />
currently used).<br />
$57.60 for 24” roll<br />
?<br />
(Cronin et al, 2008, Report)<br />
(Wrightson, 2010, Report)<br />
Advantages Cost<br />
� Made of 30% recycled plastic / 100% recyclable material post consumer<br />
$305.69/ locker<br />
� Shipped fully assembled<br />
� Resists scratches, dents, and never needs to be repainted<br />
� 20 year warranty against rust and delamination<br />
� No fumes or toxic chemicals will be realised form repainting<br />
(Wrightson, 2010, Report)<br />
Advantages Cost<br />
� Non-toxic chemicals are used to bind the graphite to the pencil<br />
� pencils are better protected and graphite won’t break as easy; when dropped<br />
� No automated or machinery is used in the process; all hand rolled<br />
� Can be customized to have a unique look<br />
� Certified 100% recycled , chlorine-free<br />
� No chlorine or chlorine containing compounds<br />
� FSC certified – saves 17 trees per one tonne<br />
288 pencils for<br />
$70.00<br />
$49.95 for 20lb<br />
box (5000 sheets)<br />
(Wrightson, 2010, Report)<br />
What the students are most excited about…<br />
� I would like to see environmentally friendly paints being used for any work being done during the renovations. J. Kononiuk<br />
� There are several aspects not considered here, that The Planeteers/ Eco<strong>School</strong> Team is investigating, such as biodegradable lunch dishes,<br />
along with green cleaners..<br />
15
D. EXTERIOR AND INTERIOR LANDSCAPING<br />
Rationale for Taking the Opportunity to Make Changes at S.D.S.S.:<br />
Land management that protects the integrity of biodiversity, soil, and the water cycle increases the productivity of the land. This, in the long run, protects<br />
the health of the people. Practises and systems that reduce impact on the environment encourage a healthy ecosystem, and therefore a healthy population.<br />
In 2001, the Heritage Garden Project was established, creating first an extensive garden with walkways at the front of the school, the purpose being to<br />
“beautify and naturalize the school grounds of <strong>Saugeen</strong> <strong>District</strong> <strong>Secondary</strong> <strong>School</strong>, enhancing local biodiversity while demonstrating the value of ecological<br />
restoration.” (HGP, 2001, Mission Statement) Later, a tree-lined allee was planted, complete with the formal construction of a pathway up the western<br />
slope. In addition, smaller scale projects have resulted in greening of the grounds in pockets. Years later, these gardens:<br />
� contribute to biodiversity<br />
� aid in keystone species’ survival<br />
� improve the local biome<br />
� create opportunities for courses of study, be they Art, English, Geography, Science, or in use as outdoor classroom space<br />
� have aesthetic appeal and social benefit<br />
This following work proposes additional opportunities for the greening of S.D.S.S.<br />
Bioswales<br />
(See Appendix C)<br />
Advantages Cost Savings<br />
� Groundwater recharge if infiltration is high.<br />
� Reduces run off volume, 25% of total rainfall from a typical road.<br />
� Reduces erosion. Vegetation helps stabilize soil - a problem with other<br />
traditional draining methods such as open ditches.<br />
� Removal of approximately 20-40% s of sediment and pollutants, through<br />
filtering by vegetation and soils. Plants slow the flow of water causing particles<br />
to settle, allowing bacteria in the soil to decompose carbon-based pollutant<br />
such as motor oil.<br />
� Improves water quality by filtering out pollutants such as oil, greases, metals<br />
and sediments.<br />
� Using check dams can improve pollutant removal and infiltration<br />
� Less maintenance, water & fertilizer than turf.<br />
� Native species are chosen they resist local pest and diseases.<br />
� Maintenance is similar to that for ditches: inspect banks for slumping and<br />
erosion, replanting any bare patches and maintaining vegetation.<br />
� Storm water flood control, slowing and storing run-off, allowing it to infiltrate<br />
the ground.<br />
� Good vegetation survival when plants selected are non-invasive, low<br />
maintenance and suited to moisture levels.<br />
� Preserves native vegetation and provide habitat for wildlife.<br />
� Cost to be<br />
determined on a site<br />
to site basis.<br />
� Low cost but can vary<br />
raging from less than<br />
$0.10 to $0.50 per<br />
cubic foot depending<br />
on size, plants and<br />
site considerations.<br />
� Labour could be<br />
provided by the<br />
construction,<br />
geography &<br />
greenhouse classes,<br />
along with the<br />
Planeteers/ Eco<strong>School</strong><br />
Team.<br />
� In general they are less expensive<br />
than underground piping.<br />
� Lower infrastructure and utility<br />
costs<br />
� Substantial cost savings in<br />
comparison to conventional curb<br />
and gutter systems. In a Chicago<br />
suburb there were estimated<br />
savings of $800 per residence<br />
16
Gazebos<br />
.<br />
Ground Cover of Eco-Lawn<br />
mixed with Clover<br />
� Already successfully<br />
incorporated in the Heritage<br />
Garden Project in front of S.D.S.S.<br />
Advantages Cost Savings<br />
� Place for students and teachers to eat lunch<br />
� May provide a sort of outdoor classroom<br />
� Shade from the sun<br />
� Construction of gazebos could be done by the construction class<br />
� Both grow successfully in our sandy soil<br />
� Aesthetically pleasing<br />
� Requires little watering & are drought-tolerant<br />
� Clover roots decay into nitrogen rich humus and leave tunnels for aeration<br />
and irrigation<br />
Green/ Living Roof � Increases thermal insulation values, reducing heating and cooling costs<br />
� Controls water run-off<br />
� Protects the roof membrane from UV radiation, reducing maintenance<br />
� Better air quality- the vegetation removes the particulate from the air, giving<br />
us cleaner air to breath<br />
Living Wall<br />
� Improved air quality- the vegetation of the living wall removes the particulate<br />
from the air giving us cleaner air to breath<br />
� Carbon dioxide and oxygen exchange- helps to create cleaner air<br />
� Reduction of heating and cooling- the living wall creates an insulation just as<br />
the living roof does, which helps moderate the temperature of the building<br />
� Storm water management on the exterior wall, - the plants from the living wall<br />
use the rainwater and runoff, which reduces the amount that goes into the<br />
storm sewers<br />
� Sound insulation- the vegetation creates an insulator to absorb the sound<br />
� Increases the appeal of the school<br />
� Natural vegetation acts as mood enhancers<br />
� $4000-5000<br />
� Labour would be<br />
provided by the<br />
construction class.<br />
� Cost of lumber and<br />
hardware<br />
� Clover<br />
� 50 lb bag of Eco-<br />
Lawn (covers 10,000<br />
ft 2 ) costs $299.95<br />
� Xero Flor 12$ per<br />
square foot to install,<br />
which includes one<br />
year for<br />
maintenance.<br />
� The remaining roof<br />
space (after solar<br />
heating tubes, solar<br />
and reflective gym<br />
roof is ~49,000 ft 2<br />
Total Cost: ~$588,000<br />
� Indoor Living Wall<br />
(NEDLAW $ )<br />
� $1000 for 50 single<br />
woolly pockets<br />
(woolly pockets are<br />
what the plants will<br />
be planted in; they<br />
are small pockets<br />
which will be<br />
mounted to the wall<br />
and the plants will be<br />
planted in them)<br />
� 50% less time<br />
� 85% less money<br />
� 50% less fuel<br />
� 85% less fertilizer<br />
� 100% less water<br />
� Air conditioning costs can be<br />
reduced 25%<br />
� Energy savings can be reduced up<br />
to 4.15kWh/ m 2 /yr<br />
� Demand load reduction<br />
0.0023kWh/m 2 at the peak.<br />
� Megan<br />
17
Advantages Cost Savings<br />
Permeable Parking Lot � Prevents soil erosion<br />
� Acts as a natural on-site storm water retention system<br />
� Made out of recycled plastic waste<br />
� Reduces heat emissions<br />
� Allows the planting of vegetation around (or closer to) the paved areas around<br />
the school<br />
� Easy to maintain<br />
� Resists movement or breakage from vehicle turning stresses and torsional<br />
loads<br />
Rain/ Bioretention Garden<br />
(See Appendix C)<br />
Vegetation<br />
� Includes extensive planting of<br />
trees, and the addition of<br />
plants to attract more<br />
hummingbirds and butterflies<br />
(See Appendix D)<br />
� Controls storm water runoff<br />
� Improves infiltration<br />
� Reduces contaminates in storm water, removing up to 90% of nutrients and<br />
chemicals and 80% of sediments. (70% of all water pollution occurs from<br />
pollutants carried by rainwater runoff)<br />
� Vegetation and percolation help to filter out pollutants, such as dirt, fertilizer,<br />
chemicals, oil, garbage, and bacteria<br />
� Allow 30% more water to soak into the ground than a lawn, recharging<br />
groundwater aquifers<br />
� Habitat for birds and butterflies<br />
� Preserves native vegetation which does not require fertilizer or pesticides.<br />
� After the first year maintenance is usually minimal. The garden will only<br />
requires occasional watering and plants for the fist year or two. Occasional<br />
watering may be required during dry periods.<br />
� Opportunity for student involvement (Construction, Geography & Greenhouse<br />
classes, along with The Planeteers/ Eco<strong>School</strong> Team)<br />
� Will provide shade for students who wish to sit outside on a nice day to eat<br />
lunch, or during their spares –reducing likelihood of skin cancer in later years<br />
� Learning experience for everyone (how to plant trees, learning about stages of<br />
growth, greenhouse class, science, etc).<br />
� Carbon sink<br />
� Will promote more biodiversity and wildlife in the area<br />
� Aesthetically pleasing<br />
� If placed around the parking lot, can cool internal temperature of cars<br />
� Opportunity for student involvement (Construction, Geography & Greenhouse<br />
classes, along with The Planeteers/ Eco<strong>School</strong> Team)<br />
Pavement removal will<br />
cost roughly $2.50 -$3.50<br />
per ft 2 = ~$400 000<br />
Cost to Implement:<br />
Green Innovations<br />
$28.44 per m 2<br />
= $396 567.36<br />
Presto Geosystems<br />
$10-12 per ft 2 for 3.5”<br />
depth =$1 500 932.16<br />
EcoGrid $3.10 per ft 2<br />
= $465 288.96<br />
� Determined on a siteby-site<br />
basis which<br />
depends on the soil<br />
type, size of drainage<br />
area and plants<br />
chosen.<br />
� If self installed,<br />
approximate cost<br />
between $3 to $5 per<br />
square foot, for plants<br />
and soil amendments,<br />
and $10 to 15$ if<br />
working with a<br />
landscaping company<br />
� Maintenance costs.<br />
� A ten-foot potted tree<br />
costs about $150<br />
� A cubic metre of<br />
mulch runs at about<br />
$50 (enough for 6-8<br />
trees)<br />
� Cost of maintenance,<br />
watering, etc.<br />
� Will not need to repave the<br />
pavement<br />
� Resists movement or breakage<br />
from vehicle turning stresses and<br />
torsional loads<br />
�<br />
In Maplewood, Minnesota rain<br />
gardens were used instead of<br />
constructing new storm sewers to<br />
manage stormwater problems. It is<br />
estimated that a conventional street<br />
repaving and storm water<br />
construction project would have cost<br />
approximately 30% more than the rain<br />
garden project.<br />
� If planted on the northern and<br />
western sides of the school,<br />
energy consumption may be<br />
reduced by up to 25%.<br />
(deCoppel et al, 2008, Report)<br />
(Gibb, 2008, e-mail)<br />
(Stansfield et al, 2011, Report)<br />
(Sutcliffe et al, 2008, Report)<br />
18
What students are most excited about…<br />
� I am most excited that we are influencing the direction our school takes and that little changes we can make will make<br />
a huge difference to the environment. Our changes can have a huge impact! J. Larson<br />
� I’m excited to see more trees and places to eat and sit in the shade because I think it will make the school grounds<br />
more user-friendly. I’m also really excited for the green roof, if it happened, because I think it would be very cool to<br />
have a green space on the roof… K. Nutt<br />
� I would like to see the living wall, as it would be healthy, as well as, a statement to the people walking through the<br />
school that we are making a difference. We are the people of the future and we’re going green. J. Kononiuk<br />
� I am most excited just to have a greener school, where I can be happy to come to school and be in an environment I<br />
enjoy. I'm also excited to see a place where we as students can just hang out. M. Stansfield<br />
19
In Conclusion<br />
Along with this work by the Grade 12 CGR 4M class, information from the website for the landmark Dr. David Suzuki<br />
<strong>School</strong>, will provide a vision for the retrofit of <strong>Saugeen</strong> <strong>District</strong> <strong>Secondary</strong> in Port Elgin.<br />
Members of the Planeteers/ Eco<strong>School</strong> Team, students enrolled in the Grade 12 CGR 4M class and/ or the Energy<br />
Specialist program had plans to travel to see, first-hand, the Dr. David Suzuki <strong>School</strong>, but due to conflicts and then<br />
inclement weather, have had to put it off the spring. Knowing that <strong>Saugeen</strong> <strong>District</strong> <strong>Secondary</strong> <strong>School</strong> was to<br />
undergo extensive changes, the intent of the trip was to see first-hand the possibilities in reducing the school’s<br />
ecological footprint – through energy use, water consumption, waste minimization and landscaping.<br />
Dr. David Suzuki Public <strong>School</strong> has been designed to be a demonstration project, intended to inform and inspire the<br />
future of other educational, institutional, commercial and private building initiatives. (Dr. David Suzuki Public <strong>School</strong>, 2011,<br />
http://www.suzukipublicschool.ca/overview/about-earth-keepers/about-earth-keepers.html)<br />
When it opened in September 2010, Dr. David Suzuki Public <strong>School</strong> was the first LEED platinum<br />
school building in Canada, one of a select few in North America, and a magnet for architects,<br />
planners, designers, educational facility developers and others interested in learning about the<br />
newest and most effective energy and environmental green building systems.<br />
(Ibid, http://www.suzukipublicschool.ca/overview/about-earth-keepers/about-earth-keepers.html)<br />
Certainly, we would like S.D.S.S. to incorporate technologies utilized in the building of the Dr. David Suzuki <strong>School</strong>,<br />
but ultimately we are hoping to set our own course, following the principles of LEED construction:<br />
� sustainable site development<br />
� water efficiency<br />
� energy efficiency<br />
� materials selection<br />
� indoor environmental quality<br />
(Canada Green Building Council, N.A., http://www.cagbc.org/AM/Template.cfm?Section=LEED)<br />
In the process of planning a school with sustainability in mind, students have considered energy efficiency, water<br />
conservation, materials with a small ecological footprint, as well as effective land use. Taking into consideration the<br />
benefits, disadvantages, costs and savings of all aspects students desire to be incorporated into our school, we<br />
aimed, ultimately, to minimize our impact on our environment – both locally and globally.<br />
In a follow-up e-mail to the presentations made by students in the 2008 CGR 4M class, Al Gibb, BWDSB’s Manager of<br />
Plant Services and Administration stated, “You have demonstrated the value of a collaborative effort with this project<br />
and the learning opportunities.” It is the hope of the students submitting this report the <strong>Bluewater</strong> <strong>District</strong> <strong>School</strong><br />
<strong>Board</strong> will give serious consideration to the work of the students, providing feedback and following our vision for<br />
an ‘SDSS Redesigned’ that is both sustainable in nature and offers wonderful teaching opportunities.<br />
20
FUNDING OPPORTUNITIES<br />
The sources are all hyper-linked; an electronic-copy of this document can be forwarded upon request.<br />
A. Energy<br />
Canadian Industry Program for Energy Innovation<br />
Energy audits<br />
Energy Innovators Initiative<br />
Energy retrofits<br />
Environment Canada: EcoAction<br />
Since 1995, Environment Canada's EcoAction Community Funding Program has provided financial support to community groups for<br />
projects that have measurable, positive impacts on the environment. Funding support can be requested for projects that have an<br />
action focus, a community capacity building focus, or a combination of both objectives.<br />
Federation of Canadian Municipalities<br />
FCM's Green Municipal Fund offers grants to develop sustainable community plans. Plans must consider environmental, social and<br />
economic objectives and include specific targets for environmental performance<br />
Ontario Helps <strong>School</strong>s Invest in Green Technology “Grants from the<br />
Ontario Ministry of Education for the installation of renewable energy solutions … These funds are for projects that reduce heating,<br />
cooling and electrical costs in schools by installing sustainable technologies. … All projects are to be completed by August 2011.”<br />
B. Water<br />
Environment Canada: EcoAction<br />
Funding support can be requested for projects that have an action focus, a community capacity building focus, or a combination of<br />
both objective, with measurable, positive impacts on the environment.<br />
Resources for Thinking- Project Flow<br />
R4R Water Action Projects and the comprehensive water action plan, can receive up to $500 and $3000, respectively.<br />
D. Exterior and Interior Landscaping<br />
Communities in Bloom Ontario<br />
Awards for community environmental projects<br />
Earth Day Canada (EDC) Community Environment Fund<br />
Provides grants to support local environmental programs<br />
Federation of Canadian Municipalities<br />
FCM's Green Municipal Fund offers grants to develop sustainable community plans. Plans must consider environmental, social and<br />
economic objectives and include specific targets for environmental performance<br />
Metro Green Apple <strong>School</strong> Program<br />
Grant to get schools started on initiatives to help the environment<br />
TerraCycle<br />
Waste collection programs<br />
Toyota Evergreen Learning Grounds<br />
Funding to create outdoor classrooms<br />
WWF Green Community <strong>School</strong> Grants Program<br />
Grants to help reduce the impact a community has on the environment, starting at the school level<br />
21
SUPPLIERS<br />
Students have made every effort to incorporate products produced locally, for several reasons:<br />
� Environmental sustainability concerns<br />
� To keep dollars in the local economy<br />
� To support diversity in economic enterprise<br />
� Locally-owned businesses support their communities<br />
A. ENERGY<br />
Product Company e-mail or Web Address<br />
Telephone<br />
Geothermal South-Port Geothermal geothermal@bmts.com<br />
519-832-2665<br />
Light Switches Home Depot 1-800-628-0525<br />
Outdoor lighting Canada City Lighting<br />
Corporation<br />
Snow Roof®<br />
Premium White Roof<br />
Coating<br />
Sherwin-Williams<br />
http://www.canadacitylighting.com/<br />
info@canadacitylighting.com<br />
403-455-8689<br />
Sky Lights &<br />
Georgian Bay Windows and 519-934-2690<br />
Windows<br />
Doors<br />
estimates@georgianbaywindowanddoor.com<br />
Solar Light Tubes Solatube http://www.solatube.com/commercial/index.php<br />
888-765-2882<br />
Solar panels/solar<br />
heating and more<br />
Grey Bruce Solar Technologies 519-764-4576<br />
Windows & Doors Georgian Bay Windows and estimates@georgianbaywindowanddoor.com<br />
Doors<br />
519-934 -2690<br />
Wind Turbines<br />
Skystream 3.7<br />
VAWT<br />
Rona - Southampton<br />
Grey-Bruce Computer and<br />
Solar Technologies<br />
Vbine Energy<br />
519-797-3245<br />
www.greybrucesolar.com<br />
519 -794-0433<br />
http://www.vbine.com/contact<br />
306.435.3777<br />
B. WATER CONSUMPTION<br />
Product Company e-mail or Web Address<br />
Telephone<br />
Dishwasher<br />
(Whirlpool ®<br />
DU1055XTVB &<br />
GU2475XTVQ)<br />
Electric Dryer<br />
(Frigidaire ® 5.8 Cu.<br />
Ft.)<br />
Faucet<br />
(Sloan Soils)<br />
Front Load Washer<br />
(Frigidaire ® 3.1 Cu.<br />
Ft.)<br />
Square Deal Neal’s http://www.squaredealneils.ca/<br />
519-797-3905<br />
Square Deal Neal’s http://www.squaredealneils.ca/<br />
519-797-3905<br />
Port Elgin Home Hardware www.homehardware.ca/<br />
519-832-2466<br />
Square Deal Neal’s http://www.squaredealneils.ca/<br />
519-797-3905<br />
22
Product Company e-mail or Web Address<br />
Telephone<br />
Water Efficient Toilet Carson’s Plumbing Supply www.carsonsupply.com<br />
519- 389-6245<br />
Water-Free Urinal<br />
(Sloan ® WES-5000 or<br />
Falcon®<br />
Or alternate:<br />
Water Fountain -<br />
Halsey Taylor<br />
HVRGRN8<br />
Port Elgin Home Hardware<br />
Dobbin Sales Ltd<br />
Carson’s Plumbing Supply<br />
www.homehardware.ca/<br />
519-832-2466<br />
www.dobbinsales.com<br />
1-800-565-8515<br />
Fax: 1-800-606-7636<br />
www.carsonsupply.com<br />
519- 389-6245<br />
Limpia Water http://www.drinking-fountain.net/<br />
1-877-645-6044<br />
C. PRODUCTS<br />
Product Company e-mail or Web Address<br />
Telephone<br />
Clay Paint BioShield 1-800-621-2591<br />
Bradley ® Plastic Sustainable Supply Company sales@sustainablesupply.com<br />
Lockers<br />
303-325-7547<br />
Green Linoleum ? ?<br />
Milk Paint ? ?<br />
Natural Sheep’s Wool<br />
Insulation<br />
Eco Building Products 231-668-6361<br />
Newspaper Pencils Tree Smart sales@treesmart.com<br />
503-722-9593<br />
Recycled Multi-<br />
Purpose Paper<br />
Wheat/ Straw <strong>Board</strong><br />
(in lieu of drywall)<br />
GreenLine Paper Company inof@greenlinepapercompany.com<br />
1-800-641-1117<br />
Panel Source mlinden@mckillican.com<br />
1-877-464-7246<br />
? Information not available at time of printing<br />
23
D. EXTERIOR AND INTERIOR LANDSCAPING<br />
Product Company e-mail or Web Address<br />
Telephone<br />
Clover Sprucedale Agromart http://www.sprucedale.com/<br />
Ltd.<br />
519-934-2340<br />
Eco-Lawn Wildflower Farm<br />
http://www.wildflowerfarm.com/index.php?p=product&id=257&parent=4<br />
Company<br />
1 866 GRO WILD ( 1 866 476 9453)<br />
Living Wall NEDLAW Living Walls http://www.naturaire.com/index.php<br />
519-648-9779<br />
Woolly Pocket Garden http://www.woollypocket.com/<br />
Co. Inc.<br />
877-796-6559<br />
Permeable Parking Lot Terra Firm Enterprises http://www.terrafirmenterprises.com/<br />
(Ecogrid)<br />
1-866-934-7572<br />
Permeable Parking Lot<br />
(FilterPave)<br />
Permeable Parking Lot<br />
(Porous Paving and<br />
Garden Grid)<br />
Vegetation Acorus Restoration<br />
Presto Geosystems http://www.prestogeo.com/<br />
Cory.Schneider@Reynoldspkg.com<br />
1-800-548-3424<br />
Green Innovations http://www.greeninnovations.ca/<br />
walter@greeninnovations.ca<br />
888-725-7524<br />
http://www.ecologyart.com/content/view/2/3/<br />
519-586-2603<br />
Beagle Run Nursery &<br />
Orchard<br />
A Sense of Place<br />
Sweet Grass Gardens<br />
beaglerun@bmts.com<br />
519-896-3073<br />
http://www.goldbook.ca/brantford-on/nurseries/sweet-grass-gardens-sixnations-reserve-40620/<br />
519-445-4828<br />
24
Works Cited<br />
Alexander, Krisinda and Karissa Finlayson. (13-Jan-11). Sustainable SDSS. A report submitted for CGR 4M @ S.D.S.S., Port Elgin, ON.<br />
Canada Green Building Council. (n.d.). Funding and Loans. (Online), January 14, 2011.<br />
http://www.cagbc.org/AM/Template.cfm?Section=Resources#FAQs<br />
Canada Green Building Council. (n.d.). Introduction to LEED. (Online), January 19, 2011.<br />
http://www.cagbc.org/AM/Template.cfm?Section=LEED<br />
Cherfurka, Paul. (2007). World Energy and Population to 2010. (Online), November 20, 2010.<br />
http://www.paulchefurka.ca/WEAP/WEAP.html<br />
Cronin, Jamie-Lee, H., Jordan, McCready, Kailagh and Sarah Pitzen. (2008). S.D.S.S. Designed with Sustainability in Mind. A report<br />
submitted for CGR 4M @ S.D.S.S., Port Elgin, ON.<br />
DeCoppel, Jeryn, Glass, Sarah, Shular, Graham and Emily Vollett. (2008). S.D.S.S. Designed with Sustainability in Mind: CGR 4M<br />
Summative Activity. A report submitted for CGR 4M @ S.D.S.S., Port Elgin, ON.<br />
Dr. David Suzuki Public <strong>School</strong>. (2011). About Earth Keepers. (Online), January 14, 2011.<br />
http://www.suzukipublicschool.ca/overview/about-earth-keepers/about-earth-keepers.html)<br />
Dr. David Suzuki Public <strong>School</strong>. (2011). LEED Product Requirements. (Online), January 14, 2011.<br />
http://www.suzukipublicschool.ca/overview/construction-of-the-school/leed-construction-process/leed-productrequirements.html<br />
Dr. David Suzuki Public <strong>School</strong>. (2011). Skystream. (Online), January 23, 2011. http://www.suzukipublicschool.ca/buildingfeatures/renewable-energy/wind/skystream.html<br />
Dr. David Suzuki Public <strong>School</strong>. (2011). VWAT. (Online), January 23, 2011. http://www.suzukipublicschool.ca/buildingfeatures/renewable-energy/wind/vawt.html<br />
Dunlop, Susan and Jackson, Michael. (1997). Understanding our Environment. Oxford University Press: Don Mills, ON, Canada.<br />
Gibb, Al. (25-Jan-2008). Re: SDSS Redesigned Presentations. E-mail received January 25, 2008 @ S.D.S.S., Port Elgin, ON.<br />
Ministry of Education. (2009). The Ontario Curriculum Grades 11 & 12 Canadian & World Studies. (Online), July 26, 2010.<br />
http://www.edu.gov.on.ca/eng/curriculum/secondary/canworld1112curr.pdf 104 of 265)<br />
Reany, Avery, Kononiuk, Jake, MacGregor, Kirk and Sarah Szabo, (13-Jan-11). SDSS Redesigned – Energy. A report submitted for CGR<br />
4M @ S.D.S.S., Port Elgin, ON.<br />
Stansfield, Megan, Nutt, Kailyn, Larson, Jessica and Taylor McElwain. SDSS Redesigned – Land. A report submitted for CGR 4M @<br />
S.D.S.S., Port Elgin, ON.<br />
Sutcliffe, Alyce, Cleaver, Alexandra, Sabina, S. and Kyla Vanderzwet. (2008-01-06). SDSS Redesigned. A report submitted for CGR 4M<br />
@ S.D.S.S., Port Elgin, ON.<br />
Turner, Chris. (2007). The Geography of Hope. Random House of Canada Ltd.<br />
Wrightson, Amanda. (2011), Sustainable SDSS. A report submitted for CGR 4M @ S.D.S.S., Port Elgin, ON.<br />
25
Appendices<br />
Hard copy provided to the Chair of the Accommodation Review Committee<br />
A. Blueprint of S.D.S.S<br />
B. An inventory of appliances that consume water<br />
C. Bioswales<br />
D. Landscape suggestions<br />
E. Recommendations for Trees<br />
A Vision for the Retrofit Potential of <strong>Saugeen</strong> <strong>District</strong> <strong>Secondary</strong> <strong>School</strong><br />
by<br />
Environment & Resource Management Class (CGR 4M) – (2008 & 2010-11)<br />
Specialist High Skills Major Energy Students<br />
Members of the Planeteers/ Eco<strong>School</strong> Team<br />
26